Man United In CRISIS & Gary Neville’s FIRST Kiss! | The Good, The Bad & The Football

15 Sep 2025 · 1 h 16 min · 27 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Manchester United’s crisis under Amorim-style football, why the team is predictable and lacks aggression/legs, plus goalkeeper recruitment (Donnarumma) and derby culture. The episode also includes stories about hard tackles, Gary Neville’s first kiss, and goal/volley memories.

Guests and backgrounds

Luke (former Premier League player; played in Manchester derbies and discusses midfield/formation issues). Nicky (former player; talks about derby mentality and academy influence). Gary Neville is referenced as the host/figure, with Neville’s “first kiss” story told by the guests.

Key claims

  1. United are easy to plan against because their system/philosophy is consistent and opponents know how they’ll play.
  2. The main issue isn’t just formation; midfield lacks athletic “legs” and aggression, so Bruno Fernandes’ role breaks down versus elite teams.
  3. Recruitment has neglected key areas (especially goalkeeper and midfield balance), leaving United without the spine needed to win multiple ways.
  4. Derby games feel “wrong” when a team gets battered yet no one is booked—suggesting a lack of physical fight.
  5. Donnarumma is a major upgrade: a top-level goalkeeper can save 15–20 points per season.

Notable examples

  • Amorim/United vs Pep/City tactical adjustment (Doku moving inside creates 3v2).
  • Derby anecdotes: stud marks, respect via tough challenges, and Neville’s first kiss on the lips during a match context.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Remembrances of Ricky Hatton

0:59 to 1:21

Hosts share heartfelt memories and reflections about Ricky Hatton.

“Getting help from one of State Farm's 19 ,000 local agents when you choose to bundle home and auto.”

Remembrances of Ricky Hatton

2:15 to 6:42

Hosts share heartfelt memories and reflections about Ricky Hatton.

“all three of us have known him throughout the years we've been in his company numerous times any memories of spending a bit of time with a great man?”

Manchester Derby Discussion

6:42 to 7:09

Hosts analyze the recent Manchester Derby and its implications.

“a way to start the podcast by the way the Manchester Derby, now as a football fan and I've no skin in the game with City and United I was watching it and this sort of Amerind's philosophy he won't bend it for anyone.”

Coaching Philosophy and Player Performance

7:09 to 9:24

Discussion on coaching styles and player capabilities in football.

“What are you thinking when you hear him speak after a game?”

Midfield Dynamics and Player Roles

9:24 to 10:34

Analysis of midfield roles and player responsibilities in teams.

Recruitment Issues at Manchester United

10:34 to 14:00

Hosts critique Manchester United's recruitment strategies and team construction.

“I think the big question will be about Bruno and his position, I think.”

The Decline of Manchester United's Derby Rivalry

14:00 to 18:12

A discussion about the current state of Manchester United's derby matches and the lack of excitement compared to the past.

“But you think about recruitment, Nick, going right back to May.”

The Importance of Local Players in Football

18:12 to 22:40

The hosts talk about the value of having local players on a team and how it affects their performance and passion.

“I don't know if my eyes accept that anymore.”

Goalkeeper Recruitment Mistakes at Manchester United

22:40 to 28:00

Analysis of Manchester United's goalkeeper situation and the consequences of poor recruitment decisions.

“It's on to going behind from the keeper.”

Goalkeeper Challenges at Manchester United

28:00 to 29:09

Discussion on the importance of having a reliable goalkeeper for Man United and the challenges faced in recruitment.

“And you need a goalkeeper who's going to, as Nicky said, save you 15 points or win you 15 points a season.”
Show all 27 chapters

Reflections on Manchester Derbies

29:10 to 30:52

Hosts share their personal experiences and memorable moments from past Manchester derbies.

“But you still knew he was going to be good because he'd been at a big club at 18 years of age.”

The Competitive Nature of Derby Matches

30:53 to 34:21

Exploration of the physicality and competitiveness in derby matches, along with shared anecdotes.

“Now, I know on this podcast, this is our first one, I'll be hammering you both with questions.”

Kissing and Masculinity in Football

34:22 to 37:14

A lighthearted discussion about the norms and experiences of physical affection among male footballers.

“It does get you into it, no matter what level you play, you're like, oh, we're in here now.”

Remarkable Goals and Techniques

37:15 to 38:39

Analysis of spectacular goals scored in football and the skill involved in executing them.

Memorable Moments from European Football

38:40 to 42:00

Discussion on iconic goals and players from European football history, focusing on specific memorable matches.

“Bang, you were a good header at the ball, weren't you?”

Legendary Goals and Iconic Players

42:00 to 43:30

Discussing unforgettable football moments and legendary players like Van Basten and Zidane.

“oh he was not diving header wasn't it yeah Holland and the World Cup I think.”

The Electric Atmosphere of St. James' Park

43:30 to 45:00

Exploring the thrill of playing at St. James' Park and the passionate Newcastle fans.

Training with Legends: Sir Bobby and Mick Utnell

45:00 to 46:30

Anecdotes about training alongside football legends and the memorable experiences shared.

“I remember once he walked out to the stadium looked round the stadium and I went this is me this is a bit of me.”

The Influence of Celebrities in Football

46:30 to 48:20

Discussion on the impact of celebrity presence in football training sessions and its implications.

Social Media's Double-Edged Sword for Players

48:20 to 54:40

Debating the pros and cons of social media involvement for modern footballers.

“And to be fair, you can understand why he's with Miss World, because he's a real handsome chap.”

The Pressure of Transitioning to Bigger Clubs

54:40 to 56:02

Exploring the challenges players face when moving to larger clubs and adapting their game.

“And again, when you're older, no one likes seeing anything bad about them, but you can kind of go, no bad.”

The Pressure of Transitions in Football

56:02 to 58:44

Discussion on the impact of transferring to a bigger club on player performance.

“It's hard to explain I suppose I suppose look is it Aston Villa is the big fish innit yeah all of a sudden he's going to a City winning the Premier League and they've got 20 players probably as good as him.”

Family Involvement in Football

58:45 to 1:00:01

Exploration of how family dynamics influence young players' careers.

“I'm going to start doing things that I'm not capable of.”

The Pressure of Young Footballers

1:00:02 to 1:02:30

Insights into the pressures faced by young players and their families in football.

“And when you talk about pressure as well, if you're signing because a family member's advised you to do it because they're benefiting, you might be going to a club that doesn't suit you.”

Financial Pressures and Young Talent

1:02:31 to 1:05:18

Discussion on financial expectations and their effects on young footballers.

“Because when I was at school, my identity wasn't Nicky Butt.”

Pro-Am Golf Experiences and Anecdotes

1:05:19 to 1:10:01

Light-hearted anecdotes about experiences in a pro-am golf tournament.

“Firstly, I've got to say, I'm not feeling the new player videos.”

Comparing Sports Difficulties

1:10:01 to 1:14:40

Discuss the comparative difficulty of various sports skills, including darts and snooker.

“Even if you're at your old club and there's a couple of people still watching you.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:01This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome? That's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required, compatibility and availability varies 18+. class it up with crocs you know back to school is coming in fast so why wait to find your new fave footwear step into a local croc store and step into your new look try it style it make it yours because the right pair doesn't just show up it shows off first day fits handled walk out ready for whatever's next.

0:51Visit your nearest croc store today. This episode is brought to you by State Farm. Listening to this podcast instead of doom scrolling? Smart move. Another smart move? Getting help from one of State Farm's 19 ,000 local agents when you choose to bundle home and auto. Bundling, just another way to save with the personal price plan. Prices are based on rating plans that vary by state. Coverage options are selected by the customer. Availability, amount of discounts and savings, and eligibility vary by state. Well, look at the price he's paid for. What's the price? 20 million euros. Look, it tells me he's not a top ballkeeper.

1:26Yeah, straight away. Is that the training session when Sir Bobby got knocked out? Jesus Christ, this is some training session. Are we allowed to swear on it, by the way? Are we allowed to swear on it? Yeah.

1:39Welcome to the good, the bad and the football. Your new home for the beautiful game hosted by Footballing Royalty. We've got Premier League winners, Champions League winners and Soccer Aid's most capped player. And I think they missed the R out of cap though. How are we lads, all right? All good, mate, you? Yeah, yeah, nice and bonny. Luke, before we, it's a brand new podcast, but before we get into it, it'll be remiss of us not to talk about the great man Ricky Atton. Obviously, really sad news and our thoughts go out to Ricky's family. but just while we're here all three of us have known him throughout the years we've been in his company numerous times any memories of spending a bit of time with a great man?

2:25Paddy McGuinness:Yeah I think like we were speaking before off air I think it's literally we've known him through the years since growing up you bump into each other he's obviously a big big City fan but the connection of him and Manchester in general is massive and the news was heartbreaking it really was but such a great bloke real lad's lad real people's person and obviously talent was there for everyone to see, but for me, I'd rather speak about the lad. Every time I met him, he was a gen, he'd have a beer with you, he'd have a laugh and a joke, and had time for everybody, and I think that's what's touched everyone's hearts, is that you had time for the normal people.

2:58Paddy McGuinness:You knew you had your superstar friends, but you'd only be with the same group of lads having a pint and having a chat in the local pub. So for me, it's very, very sad news, and like you say, thoughts go out to everybody. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, look, it was awful news, wasn't it? You don't so much wake up, I think it was mid-morning, but you just hope it's not true when you hear about it. As Nicky said, you bump into him all the time and you just never think it was possible that this kind of thing was happening because he was such a character, really, just a great character. He used to come up to Upper Mill quite a bit, to the village where I live, for a drink and the amount of nights I've had with him, just having a few drinks, he's always with his same mates, he never forgot his roots, he always lived in the same area and with it, the ability as well.

3:42He was probably one of the best boxers Britain has ever produced. I'll always remember his fan base more than anything. Everyone just went to Vegas, 15 ,000, 20 ,000. Now, we have to look away from the city part of it, do you know what I mean? Because a lot of United fans get a bit funny about it. But proper Manchester person and somebody we were all proud of. I just feel now for his family, two young girls, grandkids, his boy as well. It's just so sad. I feel, I thought it was a really lovely touch by the United fans in the Derby game as well. You know, giving him, you know, and that shows you how loved he was in the city.

4:19And you're right, Nick, he's like a man of the people. You know, he's one of them blokes where, I remember, you know, he was up, when we were out in Vegas, he was like in this box with like Beckham and Brad Pitt, Tom Cruise come up. And then like, I'm with my mates and he treated them exactly the same. He was like, get them in here. you know just a great lad but there's loads of stories about him and loads of different things and I think for me personally uh one that always it makes me smile when I think about this was uh and this is Ricky all over it was 2010 soccer head I think you played in that and um and uh I was right back and he was right wing but we were on the bench no surprise and uh and Giggsie were playing and Figo so they're over that side so half decent and whoever was on that right hand side was getting absolutely murdered and Harry Redknapp in his infinite wisdom thought I'll bring the big guns on McGuinness and Atten so we go on and I'm behind Ricky and we've been playing for about 10 or 15 minutes absolutely blowing and I bought someone Someone got injured, a ball went out for a minute or whatever it were.

5:36The game stopped. And he went, Ricky goes, Paddy, Paddy. And I thought, right, here we go. World champion, champion's mindset. This is a little pep talk now. Get us through this. And I ran over to him and I went, yeah, Ricky. He went, we're fucked. I went, yeah, we are, haven't we? And he went, he said, you kick him, I'll punch him. and you know when I think about that I can still see like Old Trafford packed out and just his face and I just thought but just how he was like that it just relaxes you he was like that all the time he's almost like a comedian in some ways there's nothing ever serious in his life you felt and it just goes to show what happens behind clothes you just don't know when you see such a happy person all the time and then exactly that but his legacy will live on and that's the main thing so thoughts and prayers with his family and God bless you Ricky wherever you are pal Right, what a way to start the podcast by the way the Manchester Derby, now as a football fan and I've no skin in the game with City and United I was watching it and this sort of Amerind's philosophy he won't bend it for anyone.

7:01Even me as a neutral, I'm going, surely he's got to adapt and change something. You two have played the game at the highest level. What are you thinking when you hear him speak after a game? Oh, God, where do you start with it? You talk about his philosophy, don't you, and his style of play, the way he wants to play. Now, there's so many clever coaches these days in England and all around the world and they work it out quite easily. They know exactly the way Manchester United are going to play every single week. I remember when we were younger in the first team and the team sure always came through an hour before the game or something, was it?

7:41An hour and a half might be. And you always look to the players and the manager always looks like, I wonder how they're going to play today. I wonder what they'll do. Trying to work out if they're going to play five at the back, four at the back. With Amorim, they know. With Manchester, everybody knows. So it's easy to play against and easy to work out because the coaches are that clever. Now, with regards to that, I'm not sure, even if he changed it, if he did play a 4-3-3, I just don't think the players are quite good enough. That seems to be the thing, doesn't it, what's going around at the minute.

8:13They say no matter what the formation, no matter what he does, he hasn't got the players.

8:17Paddy McGuinness:Yeah, for me, it's not so much the formation. I don't like the formation thing because you move 10 yards, 15 yards. so for instance the five at the back if the right back moves high 15 yards you become a back four anyway and you go three into midfield it's quite when we played we played four footer every week but you'd always end up with three in midfield a winger would always get tucked in it's just I don't believe in that but the thing with Amarin for me is if you look at Pep on the other hand he's got a philosophy of football that is probably the best that anyone's ever seen even as a Man United fan it's the best football I've ever seen at Barcelona at Man City a couple of years ago it's the best but even he changes a little bit so yesterday like Scrooge is saying everyone knows where Man United are going to play.

8:57Paddy McGuinness:So he just brought Doku off the left-hand side and brought him close into the middle. And straight away, it's 3-4 v2. You're getting absolutely devastated. And I think, for me, forget the system. The players are just not at the level that Man United need to get them anywhere near where they are. They're not aggressive enough. They're not quick enough. They've not got their legs in midfield. They're playing two lads in midfield, Bruno and Ugarte. They've not got their legs to do it in a three, let alone in a two. So they're struggling. so if they want to get results and he wants to keep his job in the long run he's going to have to bite the bullet and change a little bit and if he doesn't they're going to keep losing games and also as well I think no matter what level of football you play even if you play Sunday League if there's a game going a certain way you're on that pitch as a player you're going to work it out amongst yourselves but it seems as though they don't know whether to stick a twist when they're on there yeah exactly and I think that it comes from experience we had many a player when we were coming through experience you almost didn't need a manager at times did you?

9:58We had managers on the pitch you think of Rikeen Brian Robson we're great players there's nobody on there to take responsibility and there is some experienced players around now you think of Dillard the club's easy they don't get a grip of it You're right

10:11Paddy McGuinness:because literally we played in midfield together a lot of the time and even when I was playing with Roy or I played with Scolzi or Scolzi and Roy were in there together we'd always feel like we'd get an outrun and then we played in Europe there's always three and you'd be like what's going on here but we'd pull we're always moaning we're always moaning we're getting out we're getting out but we're just you just like you pull the winger in and go come in for 10 minutes let's get a grip on this game and then when we get a grip on the game you can go back out but they don't they're like robots and it's weird but the bigger thing for me as well is it's a derby game nowadays you get booked for just touching someone a tiny missed time tackle touched like that you're booked derby game getting beat 3-0 the fans are all laying at 80 minutes and not one player has been booked I'm not saying go and break people's legs or kick anybody I'm really not saying that what I'm saying is it's a derby game you know you're getting the piss took out you're basically it's 3-0 and there's all laying and there's not a tackle gone in that's missed times you get a booking there's something fundamentally wrong in that football that was the first five minutes I went out of a big derby game and I fucking get so into these you'll have a goal back then when you could do it now you can't touch anybody about getting booked but there's no bookings I'm not trying to make out go and boot anybody or break like I'm not saying that What I'm saying is, it's a physical game and you have to get about people, especially in a derby game, especially when you're getting battered, especially when it's like 3-0 away from your rivals.

11:29I think the big question will be about Bruno and his position, I think. Having him as one of the central midfielders, look, he's United's best player, there's no doubt about it. On the ball, he's brilliant. But going to Manchester City against a Pep Guardiola team, playing that position, it took me years to adjust to that position. because I was always a centre forward and I needed somebody next to me who was an athlete and knew the position brilliantly. That could be Nicky, it could be Roy, it could be Michael Carrick because I wasn't great at that. All of a sudden you're playing, you get away with it in most games.

12:02I'd say 80 % of games you get away with it and all of a sudden you play against the best teams and you don't know where you are thinking, fuck's sake. Phil Foden's just running behind me. Docu, as you said, coming in behind me. You don't know that position so you don't do it and that's what Bruno Fernandes is like. He's lost a little bit. You know, also, sorry, with Fernandes as well, what's mad with how he's got in play now is, we were talking before we came on about FPL and fantasy football. Fernandes was always in the team because you know he's going to be a bank run. No, even that, it's not working.

12:35Paddy McGuinness:I was going to say that. He's our best player last season. If it weren't for him, we'd be a lot worse off last season. He scores goals. he's the only shining light of the last six to eight months at Man United in a team and now he's lost that because he brought him back into a city midfielder it's madness they almost need two Brunos the one who can play midfield and get on the ball they need one up front he tries to do too much it's taken away his quality I think you have to go back to recruitment for that as well you think over the summer they bought two number 10s did they need two number 10s in Cunha and Bueno to play in them positions well why did you need that we've got Mason Mount that goes back to what he wants to play the box in midfield that goes back to that he wants to play that box in midfield and that's what he's recruiting for as well but that it pigeonholes him it kills the manager because then if he wants to change it who's going to put we keep saying you know we can't play with two but who's going to play in there no one's got legs none of them got legs in midfield that can get about a football pitch box to box and especially when it gets spread and you've got two people in midfield if you spread a game from box to box it's alright when you're tight and compact but you spread a game box to box in like the 30 minute when a game opens up or you've got a goal down you could put anybody in there you're not covering that ground I don't actually think Legs was that much of a problem yesterday because if you look at the stats man you had more possession they had more passes it's mad for against a City team that usually happens I thought it was more quality yesterday more than anything but it's always quality at the minute but my thing with Legs is wanting to get that 10 yards to get against you and get a tackle and then once that ball's gone behind you and Foden's running off you you've got to get the legs to get from there back 15, 20 yards again and you can't do it.

14:10But you think about recruitment, Nick, going right back to May. This is the same midfield as he's had last year. He knew he didn't have legs in there. Address it. He had to address it somehow. And they've gone with the forward players. OK, three forward players. We don't really know how good they're going to be yet. We think they're good players. Obviously, two of them we know. They're Premier League proven. But what's behind them just isn't working and it hasn't worked for a long time. As a new try, I used to love watching City United because I was like, like you said, oh, here we go, this is going to be tasty.

14:40Do you think it's lost its luster now, especially with the players as well? Like, I kind of look forward, really. If I'm watching, I love watching football, I love watching all games, but for me now, I watched the derby, I enjoyed it as a neutral, but when you've got teams like Arsenal, Leeds, Liverpool, City, all these games that you used to look forward to watching United playing in now, Where are you ranking the City game now, the Derby? Because it just didn't seem to have anything.

15:12Paddy McGuinness:Now I don't think it's what it used to be. I would never say a footballer has ever gone on a football pitch and tried and tossed it off. I would never say that. I can't imagine ever... You don't pride in what you do well. But let's be perfectly honest. If you get somebody from Portugal, which is brilliant, to go and get the best in the world and bring them in, into your group is what footballers, or best footballers, all about. but there's no one there whose parents are sported the club grandparents they're great-grandparents they've not been to a school in the area they don't know their hatred on a Monday on a Monday after getting beat three-nil on a Sunday they don't know that I'm not saying they won't try hard and it's any different when you go on a football pitch but surely God if you've got four or five lads that are in the Academy that I've come through glad you all said about Phil folding yesterday yeah if you've got them in your squad loves the club There's no way that can't be better for your club.

16:04Paddy McGuinness:Because they know, they run for a brick wall, they play for free for that football club on a derby day. It's natural, it will happen. It's safe in any world. Look at Barcelona's team back in the day, Real Madrid's team back in the day. They've all come through the academy. Now, you still go and get five, six, seven players like we had in our day. That come from outside and you ingrain yourself into that tradition and you learn about it. But at the minute, it looks like to me there's no one on that football pitch. Remember when we were playing at derby? I knew if the best of the 11 back at 99 example when Scoles was suspended if I'm honest I knew most of the time in a big game I probably wouldn't play but I knew for a fact when a derby game came up I was playing because of the background the way I was brought up the philosophy my love for the club reminds me he was clever he would always put the local boys on he'd always put the local boys on in a derby game and you saw the difference sorry Patrick you saw the difference like you mentioned Phil Foden he looked like I've quite missed Phil Fogler for the last year what a player and a great lad as well lovely lad I don't know the lad but I just love watching the kid play football even though he plays for them and you saw it in him you saw him going around to people giving up fire saying well done you could just see that in him when he's on at the start of that game and you look at him and he's running exactly what you say you can see that in him now again when you talk about the academy he brings Maynou on and I thought he's not got that look in his eye so has that been knocked out of him I don't think he's been respected the way he should have been Cobby he's a young boy I get that he's well off the boil a little bit I get that but he's 90 he's flew onto the scene he's playing for England he's a top top player any club would want him and he's been pushed to the side now his mindset might be you're bringing me on in a derby where we're getting battered and I'm on my own on this football pitch he was actually quite good when he came on I don't get that he's been questioning about his legs and stuff but he's got it's not always about legs you know what I mean he's got a brain to play that position I remember a couple of weeks I think Amarim said didn't he he's in competition with Bruno so after a couple of the games that you've seen Bruno not do quite well why is he not going so he said knocking on his door so I'm pretty sure Bruno's not been great will that be going up behind the scenes don't know I don't know what Cobby's like but I'm not so sure players go and knock on managers' doors anymore?

18:26Paddy McGuinness:I don't know if my eyes accept that anymore. I think some of the managers say, I don't want to speak to you about it. It's my decision. That's what I do. Kobe Marner, especially Nick, today, Monday morning, he should go and knock on the door. He said, I should be playing now. I got told off my dad when I was 18, go and knock on managers' doors. And it was the worst, honestly, at 18, to go and knock on Sir Alex Ferguson's doors. It was the worst thing. I was like knocking on like that. And I go, Gaff, why am I not playing? And as soon as I said it, I thought, I'm dead. Yeah, like, why? Because he used to get a book, but I know for a fact, and I think he wrote it in his book, like, he used to expect you to go and ask, if you didn't ask the question, the next time it comes round, you're the easy one to get dropped.

19:05Paddy McGuinness:Oh, I'm going to drop him, because it's either me or Scores are getting dropped. Yeah. Right? Well, I'll drop, I'll drop Butty because he's going to keep his mouth shut, but Scores will knock on my door for the next six weeks, so he's easier to, them little things like that must go in people's heads. But also as well with someone like Amren, and I'm only speaking from what I see, if you look at, I don't know he went about it the wrong way going actually with being unhappy but is that kind of a sign of going well Luke if you challenge the manager or knock on his door you're gone yeah well it could be that might be something that scares might be we don't know also and that's a good point Paddy that's alarming for a Man United person like people like us because if you want to leave Man United that easily it's not the club it used to be because no one left Man United nobody obviously Betts left but there's a reason why he left there's a reason why Roy left there's a reason why Van Nistel Roy Stam left he didn't just wake up one morning and go I don't like this football I call I want to leave he never did and it's now you're seeing people leave left right it's not the club we know though is it it's not the club we played for it's totally different it's a shit and like you say just as a football fan you don't want to see that like a club like United massive club world football Champions Leagues just just renowned and now I think like you know teams like Bournemouth's goal to Old Trafford were, no disrespect to Bournemouth, but every team that goes now, you go in, oh, probably turn them over.

20:28Paddy McGuinness:There's no fear factor at all. We used to play, and it's not a Man United thing, this. It happened at Barcelona, Real Madrid, Liverpool with Gerard Carragher, Fowler, Mike Lund. You bring people through an academy and bring in the best available to bring into that. It is the best ingredient you'll ever get. And now you're right, we used to look across the tunnel and we was lining up to go out. you look at the faces of the people you're lying up next to and you look at who you're stood next to and you're thinking honestly these have not got a chance you have to cross the line and that's arrogant I know but back in the day you just know they might beat us 1-0 luckily it might happen once a season but it never happened like I said it's just not there anymore you look across there and you think any team can beat us any team in that league can come and beat us and I also brought up sorry Paddy I also brought up I think when you're playing football and going back to Amarin's philosophy on football you have to be a if you're going to be a top top player at a top top club forget Maniaid in general every club that's a top club that wants to challenge for trophies you've got to be able to win in four or five different ways you can't just win one way you've got to be able to outrun them out fight them out play them out pass them and then win the games and you know it comes from you when you're young you know you might go and play a game we just play against a team called Marine a Scouts team yeah men yeah open age when we sit and they'd leather us.

21:48Paddy McGuinness:Yeah, yeah. And all the cocky Man United kids coming up to Liverpool trying to take a load of blokes on. And you had to learn how to run and out fight them. Yeah. But then you'd go and play against Liverpool, for example, at the academy on a nice pitch and we'd have to outplay them. And like I say, I'm not looking through rose-tinted glasses here. That didn't always work always perfect. But you learn different ways of playing. That team right now can't win anyway. Yeah. And when they do win, it's the same way of playing every time and going back to what's called. As I said, people just know the script that's coming to them before they met.

22:14Paddy McGuinness:It's character building as well, that kind of stuff, isn't it? You know what I mean? Yeah, as Nicky said, people probably look at our team and think we battled everyone 5-0 every week. It just wasn't like that. Do you know what I mean? There were some times when we were rubbish and got outplayed at times. But as Nicky said, you find a way to win. You fight your way to a win, whether it's a 1-0 win or scoring last-minute goals. It wasn't a fluke. It happened because that was the character of people. Best team do it as well, don't they? Look at City. Look at Liverpool. Let's see Liverpool going back.

22:44Paddy McGuinness:It's on to going behind from the keeper. They're going behind. Now in time you see Liverpool, Edison kick it in behind, you've got the keepers going behind, then the score goes. It's not always one way of playing, but you have this thing that everyone thinks you've got to play from the back now, from the six-yard box, and play all your way out, all the way into their box, and tap it in. It's the dream world. Yeah. Pace Checkout is offered by your banks and credit unions. So when you shop online at participating merchants, Your cards appear in one place, ready to use and kept up to date. And the best part, your actual card number isn't shared when you check out.

23:17Because boundaries are healthy, like no work emails after six. One small step for boundaries, one big leap for checkout. Pays, it checks out. Activation required. See Pays.com to learn more. Terms and conditions apply. Chronic migraine is 15 or more headache days a month, each lasting four hours or more.

23:37Paddy McGuinness:Botox on a botulinum toxin A prevents headaches in adults with chronic migraine before they start it's not for those with 14 or fewer headache days a month it prevents on average eight to nine headache days a month versus six to seven for placebo prescription Botox is injected by your doctor effects of Botox may spread hours to weeks after injection causing serious symptoms alert your doctor right away as difficulty swallowing speaking breathing eye problems or muscle weakness can be signs of a life-threatening condition patients with these conditions before injection are at highest risk. Side effects may include allergic reactions, neck and injection site pain, fatigue, and headache.

24:10Allergic reactions can include rash, welts, asthma symptoms, and dizziness. Don't receive Botox if there's a skin infection. Tell your doctor your medical history, muscle or nerve conditions, including ALS Lou Gehrig's disease, myasthenia gravis, or Lambert-Eaton syndrome, and medications, including botulinum toxins, as these may increase the risk of serious side effects. Why wait? Ask your doctor, visit BotoxChronicMigraine.com, or call 1-800-44-BOTOX to learn more. Tomorrow morning is knocking Stock your fridge now How about a creamy mocha frappuccino drink Or a sweet vanilla Smooth caramel maybe Or a white chocolate mocha Whichever you choose Delicious coffee awaits Find Starbucks frappuccino drinks Wherever you buy your groceries It's as much as I want to carry on Talking about the Derby And we'll do some Because I've got the vibes That we might have to bring a councillor in Let's just take a little bit of a turn But talking about a subject That's very close to my heart goalkeepers so Anana Edison out Lehmanns Donnarumma in firstly let's speak about the United keeper brings him in doesn't start him incredible yeah you think well look at the price he's paid for him what's the price 20 million euros look it tells me he's not a top goalkeeper straight away and if he is a top goalkeeper it's a goalkeeper bang he's playing yeah he's straight into the big game because we know United have got big big problems in goal haven't they absolutely Tom Marouna did it, didn't he?

25:32He's going straight in. Yeah, I'm straight in. Exactly, and that's the problem. You think about, I keep going back to recruitment, but you think about the summer, we needed a top-class goalkeeper, top-class midfield player. Both areas have been neglected, really. Did it really take them to that Grimsby game to realise that Anana's not good enough for Man United? Yeah. Really? That seems to be when the panic happened to try and get Martinez out of Villa. Yeah. what was it 35, 40 million you should have bought him but this Donnarumma one is the biggest mistake I can see as soon as that man became available go on game drive to Paris go on game give him whatever he wants he could be easily the best goalkeeper in the world for the next 10 years and you saw it yesterday and goalkeepers are positioned as well where if you're paying money for a player defender, midfield, forward wherever they are you can understand sometimes right not going to start it's like look at Izak at Liverpool you know give him time get used to how we're playing but a keeper it's a keeper you know what you're doing so you can go into sort of any team really and play and I watched him in the next Donna Roma and I was like firstly Jesus Christ the size of the fucker

26:48Paddy McGuinness:where'd you hit are we allowed to swear on it by the way are we allowed to swear on it the size of the fucker where'd you hit is it that big that's what I mean where's the space it reminds me of Peter Schmeichel we grew up with Peter Schmeichel coming in as first team players doing shooting practice how the fuck am I going to score? a good goalkeeper saves you 15-20 points a season I keep going about when he played boring people but even when it was one on one and the following went through a Schmeichel I still fancied Pete all day long but when you saw that yesterday yeah he's got a goal when he went through hard it's a goal but I mean fundamentally the best teams in the world have a spine right down the middle and it'll be a goalkeeper, centre-back, midfielder, forward.

27:31Paddy McGuinness:If that spine's good and top, top level, the rest fit into place. Keeper is absolutely huge. And going back to the philosophies again, you look at the best, probably the best manager, well, definitely the best manager for a long, long time, Pep. His philosophy when he come in and he sold Joe Hart, didn't he? Because, I know if the chat was, he wasn't good enough with his feet. So he went and bought keepers with his feet. Don Maroon is not great with his feet but he knows he needs a top top goalkeeper to get City at starting getting back where he was and he's gone and done it that's the difference with him and Amerind he's gone he's gone needs must so needs must we need a goalkeeper who can stop that ball going in the net and we'll get him better with his feet and we'll get there like Scogler said the next three because he's a 10 year keeper this lad we don't Man United don't do that I cannot I just hope there were conversations with him and he said no I don't want to come to United I hope that happened because if Man United if that head of recruitment wasn't in for him I think that's a criminal offence which way does Amarin have over the head of recruitment because I want that I have no idea I don't know that but what we've seen with the last few managers they've always blamed recruitment when they've left I didn't want him I didn't want him but you go back to the goalkeeper for Manchester United the goalkeeping position is massive because of the way historically they play because they are going to give chances away We try and entertain, we try and score goals.

28:56And you need a goalkeeper who's going to, as Nicky said, save you 15 points or win you 15 points a season. We had that with Peter Schmeichel. Then they couldn't replace him. It took a while, it took ages. Until you got to Van der Sar. Brilliant, great goalkeeper, same again. Then De Gea. Did De Gea come after Edwin, didn't he?

29:13Paddy McGuinness:Yeah. Yeah, De Gea comes in after Edwin. Brilliant. Took a bit of time to settle in. David took ages to settle in. But you still knew he was going to be good because he'd been at a big club at 18 years of age. I think he was captain of Cane Athletic. But it was a massive club, so you knew there was something there. Now, from that point on, they've just neglected it and they can't find a keeper to replace the great ones. And he was perfect. I can't stress enough how ideal he was for Manchester United. He seems like a character as well. Character personality. You see, when he makes a save, he's fucking high-fiving everyone.

29:46Paddy McGuinness:I think he's more a Man United goalkeeper than a city. Absolutely. Because Peter wasn't the best of his feet. Yeah. And all the players that you're talking about, a key goalkeeper they're not having brilliant with their feet but they're unbelievable goalkeepers but I think City's got an absolute well they've got it for 10 years I wrote it on my Instagram I think that's a sign of the transfer window I was going to say obviously Pep's doing a little bit of rejigging with the squad but does Donnarumma's signing get them the title no not this year I still think they're a couple of years away I think what it does spell out for me sorry schools is that everyone knows who the boss up Man City isn't it Pep he gets where he wants so if he wants that goalkeeper he gets that goalkeeper I'm not sure that happens I still think they're in a little bit of transition I don't think I think Rodri will still he's going to get battered obviously he's been injured for a long time and he will in the next few weeks but I still think there are a few doubts about City I think the right back left back for example I don't think I'm not 100 % on both centre-halves either they are in a little bit of a period I don't think they'll get to the level of Arsenal and Liverpool this year but it won't be long before the back.

30:53Yeah. Now, I know on this podcast, this is our first one, I'll be hammering you both with questions. I love hearing your insights, but we do a little bit of the old rose-tinted spectacles as well. Now, going back to when you two played in the Manchester derbies, any sort of things that sort of stick out in your mind straight away where you go, oh, I remember that game and I remember this happening, or if it was a belting game or you come off, you might have could have done better. there's a few there could have got a little better I played in the one at City where we got beat 4-1 wasn't a great experience the one where Gary at Main Road made a mistake Sean Gota some bad experience a lot of them were good don't get me wrong I don't know what our record is at them but I'm pretty sure I left I'm pretty sure we did alright I left when we had all-in games

31:44Paddy McGuinness:when I was at Newcastle I didn't see the really great times at City against Man United great for City should I say I only lost one derby at Main Road did you really? I do remember one in particular we were talking about tackling before I remember in the first few I absolutely smashed Adam Johnson and I felt like it was and all the crowd going mad because he was right in front of the crowd in the far corner and we weren't playing great but I felt then it just set a tone and that was the way it should be I think we ended up winning 1-0 but I did score quite a few goals in the Dabble one of the famous ones is obviously Keenan Harlan Senior yes which by the way now Luke you play with Roy Keane I've only sort of been in Roy's company a few times Soccer Aid that other podcast thing they do and I really like him right he's a lot more chilled he's got a great sense of humour but I remember he came out after that challenge or he said it in his book or something he went ah karma I'm like that's not karma someone's having a bit of a go at you with the verbals isn't like oh I'll break his leg that's karma I think what got right was it was he was having a bad serious injury on the floor at Leeds wasn't it he said he were faking it didn't he he was always faking him yeah and obviously knowing Roy like we do he didn't break his leg though didn't he he was always going to go back It was a studs-up job.

Read the full transcript

33:18I think he did. Did he break his... No.

33:21Paddy McGuinness:Right. No, he blamed his retirement on that injury, but he played about 30 times more after it, so I think it did. Oh, did he really? What Harlan did? Harlan blamed that tackle on his retirement, but after that tackle, he played about 35, 38 games. Do you know what, that's the way it was then. If someone got you, you got them back, yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I'm not sure that happens now, but I still remember people, now that I've still got to get back. Yeah. Do you know what I mean? But you're never going to be able to do it. It's funny, you know, but I love it when the memes do the round and they were going, talk about that challenge, it's a pity he didn't do it in his bollocks.

33:55Yeah. After yesterday. It had stopped. It had stopped the big man

34:00Paddy McGuinness:absolutely terrorising United, the premier league. Flippin' heck. You got sent off, didn't you, in Derby? Yeah. Tabaletto was a bad tackle. Yeah, bad tackle, yeah. Yeah, but you expect that in a Derby game. You don't expect that in any game, I would, anyway. Yeah. I would never get up and start whinging at someone for kicking me because you're expecting. I loved it. I enjoyed it, didn't you? Yeah, it's like a pat on your back. Come on, fucking brilliant. It does get you into it, no matter what level you play, you're like, oh, we're in here now. And it's a sign of respect. It's a sign of respect.

34:32Paddy McGuinness:I'm telling you, if you're playing against someone, they're getting into it, you know that they're worried about you. Yeah. So it's a sign of respect. And people in the best squads over the years, all different clubs will say, probably the hardest games they'd have, unless you're playing against your title rivals, is in training. You're playing against the likes of Scolzi, Keeney, all these great players, Giggsie, Bex, Yap, all these unbelievable world-class players. And you go into a game, it's easier. But then obviously you go against your rivals and it was tough games. But I think if you're getting hit all the time, and sometimes it pisses you off a little bit when someone's just rattling your legs all the time.

35:05Paddy McGuinness:But it is a sign of respect, I'm telling you. I loved it, man. I did. It got me going. It livened you up a little bit. So, all right, go on, is it going to be like that? even Sunday League when you're having a shower after it lads and you go oh look at that you know stud marks down there you can't it sort of gives you a little bit of an adrenaline rush doesn't it down the boozer after you're like I love all that showing them your stud marks yeah yeah absolutely there's one where did Gaz give you a kiss on the lips in one of them games you know he did that was Nev's first kiss that that was his first kiss he was 28 tickling me with his little trash he was oh god I don't expect it You kissed him back What do you want me to do?

35:49I don't want you snogging him I've got to say though It's a funny one isn't it with kissing blokes at football Because it's almost like Weirdly The most macho thing you can ever do Because I've kissed a few lads And I've been kissed by a few lads There you go There's the Mail Online's headline But weirdly In the context of a fully aggressive game, it kind of felt like the thing to do. I remember over the week, I played in a PGA golf tournament, which I won. No, I don't like to talk about it. I've got to have not brought the trophy from here. I'll bring it on the next one. But I was playing with tubes, and we were all buzzing after, and me and him kissed each other on the lips, and it was only like, about a couple of minutes, I thought, I've just kissed him on the lips.

36:34But it felt like the most natural thing to do. No, the lips is weird. I know. I'm not really a kisser. No, I'm not. No, you meet people. Not even on the cheek. And during a game, after a game, well played. Do you know what? Maybe on the cheek every now and again, but... Is that your missus? I haven't got one. Join the club. But on the lips is weird. Yeah. So when he came towards you, were you thinking, hang on, he's going for the lips here? Yeah, I had no idea what he was going to do. But do you know what? I'm going to say I love it. No, I love seeing the picture of it because of what happened before it.

37:10Do you know what I mean? Gary's emotional Gary's passionate he's just the way he is who was it was it Barthez who used to kiss Barthez on the head Laurent Blanc Blanc that was it yeah was it before every game that was because he won the World Cup

37:22Paddy McGuinness:remember he did it all the way through the World Cup he'd become like a superstition thing I'm all for it I don't mind it now and again it's testosterone I'm going down a cul-de-sac move on yeah move on talk to me about Zubamendi's volley Scolesque or burlesque Burlesque That's a bit different I was kissing boys now he's burlesque what's going on here Kissing boys Men Kissing men Yeah It was a man Yeah In prison Brilliant wasn't it and he's not really known for scoring goals really and especially he scored twice actually he scored a header as well it was something he probably needed to add to his game I saw him at Real Sociedad had last year against United top good player just keeps things ticking over the modern day my field player doesn't really go over the half way line but controls play and then adding that to his game it was brilliant some goal two things as a fan goals I like seeing I like seeing a crisp volley and an absolute bullet header those are two to see two of them go in I love that a bit like a bullet header but like Forden's one you say sorry Sorry to remind you of it again.

38:42But just neck, wallop. Loved that. Stiff neck, wasn't it? Yeah. Bang, you were a good header at the ball, weren't you? I scored a few headers, yeah. You had a leap on you, didn't you?

38:50Paddy McGuinness:I scored a good goal in Wembley against Newcastle, actually. Yeah, Chariot Shield. Yeah. Diving header. But scores with a volley, man. Yeah. Turn that way, you talk about volleys. I didn't score that many volleys. Turn that way. Have you ever played in a game where someone scored at an absolute world of a volley, not on your opponent, and you've gone, Oh, my God. Rivaldo. Rivaldo. Old red kick at Barcelona. Chested it up. Yeah, shit, yeah. Old red kick, right, and it's like, yeah, he's a real player. Yeah. I can't remember that. Can't remember too many follies, no. He were close to signing for Bolton, him at one stage.

39:23Yeah, back end of his career. Yeah. He was, this is like, I don't know if it's an exclusive, but a mate of mine was a football agent, and the rumours were going round, and he sent me a picture of him at the hotel. De Vere's at Bolton so that's how close he was and it just for whatever reason it never happened it wouldn't surprise you with Sam Norton yeah as you say a jockey a coach a coach yeah I know I know I'll tell you about that one at Bradford everyone was saying it was an amazing goal that day and I thought I've got a chance of winning goal of the season it was only February or March I've got a chance the day after Paolo Di Canio scored that scissor kick volley oh remember that one it couldn't ride over the very day after and fucking won it Yeah, I forgot all about that one.

40:10Yeah, I took it back, that was a better one. Fuck you, that didn't last long. Is it a play, is that something you think about? It's funny you should say that. Do you go goal and see, do you think them things?

40:19Paddy McGuinness:No, I mean, I was younger in the youth team. I used to be quite a marauder in midfield to score goals. I mean, he was a forward playing a number 10 or a number 9. I used to bet every year he scored the most goals. Really? Every year, didn't we? I pissed it every year. Pissed it every year, yeah. I know we're going to put a link up But he scored Well almost scored The best overhead kit we've ever seen It's a thing of legend Legend of what didn't go in Didn't score But it was fucking brilliant Saved it though In my eyes that's as good as a goal There's two big volleys I remember Van Persie's when we won the league against Aston Villa Rooney's pass And the other one was Rooney's against Newcastle I played against him I was playing Did you play him?

41:06Paddy McGuinness:Yeah, was you? I think I let him run off me Yeah It's some weighing up in like 30 seconds of football because the camera's on him he's going mad at the referee moaning and all of a sudden the ball comes up and he turns and he's like oh what a ball he's smashed it was it past Shea Gibbon? Well Shea yeah but I will now because you forget about goals I'm rubbish at remembering goals and stuff but I'd have to say Vampirza because of the way it come over his head from Rooney's pass Oh it's better than mine now? Yeah only because if you ever when you play football you know a ball coming over your head there and you try to connect with it Keeper was dodging it wasn't it yeah it didn't go in the corner it's just because you didn't win goal this season don't be having a go at me I wanted to win goal at a moment from goal of the season where did Van Persie I'm sure one I don't know if it was an international game or when he were at United did one not come over his head like that and he went foot header yeah it was about 20 oh he was not diving header wasn't it yeah Holland and the World Cup I think.

42:04Paddy McGuinness:It's amazing. Van Basten, yeah. You forget about Van Basten. Van Basten. It was just legendary. That kit. 1998. The kit he had on as well. It was cool. It was like proper football. What a goal. Yeah. Zidane must have scored a few. Left foot goal. Yeah. Hamden Park. Hamden Park. Leverkusen. Didn't do him in crap games, did he? No. Was that like a bit of a scissor kick? Left foot. Left foot, wasn't it? on the side way. Just when you were saying about European football then and what have you. Just talking about European games from back in the day. Obviously, Newcastle are going to be playing Barcelona soon, but the game, 1997, as Spriller-Attrick.

42:45I mean, that for me, again, as a neutral, I loved him as a player. I like players that were a bit naughty. And what I mean by that is you've got a bit of personality. You just go, what are you going to get with them today? I remember seeing him when he first sat I'm sure he like did he rock up with that massive big chinchilla for a couple of those I was like I like this guy I like this guy if you score an act trick against Barcelona for me that's like right retiring done I think

43:22Paddy McGuinness:I was at Newcastle for six years five years and literally that night against Barcelona it'll be unbelievable the atmosphere there will be electric it'll be a proper game to go and watch it's a great place to play football if it's going well and the night that they scored the at-trick that would have been electric and like you say if you do well up there they idolise you they just absolutely adore you up there it is worth going just for what you've experienced it proper but it's worth going it's a one city club so it's nice Champions League nights against the best against the Barcelona that would be brilliant I remember playing in the Nou Camp I was only 18 and we got beat 5-1 I think 4-1 Romario Stoichkov Oh I've never been happier to be a subbing Ronald Koeman Guardiola played Did he?

44:13Paddy McGuinness:Yeah we got absolutely battered and one of my I know Scorsese one of Scorsese heroes because he was an olden fan one of my favourite players was Dennis Irwin because of his character the way he is just under-assuming unbelievable footballer always 8 out of 10 every single game yeah he got done off stoichkoff and i was like i was gobsmacked he was like he gives stoichkoff 10 yards starts giving him 10 yards quick and dennis was quick and stoichkoff caught him got the ball and pinged it across the right of picture romario's feet yeah and he was he was he was i was and when you go to the new camp you walk down and there's a church right at the bottom of the stairs before you go back up in the chapel chapel the chapel wow so basically before you go out and you get absolutely murdered you say a few prayers hope for the best just stay in the chapel I remember I was 18 and when you're younger you're confident you're younger you think I'm ready I'm ready I was not I should have I should have been put down after that game yeah it was like a bit of a light bulb yeah you're way off we were very young you must have been 18 starting that game but I only started because of the five foreign rule remember the five foreign rule after a game like that though where you're saying you go that's the sort of point where you go right benchmark these levels are you what did Sir Alex say to you after a game does he just let that one settle and go Luke we got hammered or does he come in and start digging you out a bit he went mad at Incy he went mad at Incy did he yeah because Incy was always having to go back and it was always they were always like love hate bang bang bang and I remember sitting there and again we was only we was only kids we were just a year and a half out of school and to see the two big personalities going to each other like that and I mean going to each other do you remember what happened that night it was the night before I've got a lot of training that something happened.

45:54I remember once he walked out to the stadium looked round the stadium and I went this is me this is a bit of me. Oh. And the manager brought the hope after the game.

46:04Paddy McGuinness:Was that the training session when Sir Bobby got knocked out? No I don't think so. Was that not the one? I think that was later yeah. Jesus Christ this is some training session. No Sir Bobby used to come and train with us at the European Games. No way. He used to train at 60 years of age. No. So one night there's a picture of us playing at the new camp stadium training the night before in a box Sir Bobby Charlton's there and Mick Utnell Mick Utnell we had some beauties training with us Mick Utnell training with us Sir Bobby how's that happening in any professional game I don't think that was at the same time I think that was like one year there's a picture of it if you google it there's a picture of Mick Utnell Sir Bobby and I think it's me and I think you remember we used to have our own younger box and he was in with us Mick Utnell used to bring like Miss World on the bus with him as well yeah Mick Utnell what a time to play football but surely Gaffer would be going well you can't join in training in case you crock someone the Gaffer's mate the Gaffer's the one that brought them in he wasn't a great footballer Mick Wocknell was he no Sir Bobby could have played with that Sir Bobby was brilliant he's a join in training Sir Bobby I'm not joking 60 years of it he was phenomenal wasn't he obviously he couldn't run around a bit like Man United now can't run around I think someone had a shot though and smacked him on the head didn't he Brian McClare Brian McClare Brian McClare probably did it on purpose he hit a volley Brian McClare from about 10 yards straight into Sir Bobby's face and he's got boxed down and he must be thinking well the biggest legend of Man United survived the Munich Air disaster and then Brian McIntyre killed him in the volley you think how good that was though Paddy for young players like us oh Sir Bobby I think the people we had around the club Brian Robson Nobby Stiles Brian Kidd amazing that's why I said the club isn't as we know it now it almost with players like you're almost you've almost won a game before you've you know because when you see them players like that you're kind of going oh I'm a part of this but I've got to say and I'm lucky enough to know a lot of ex-pros and current pros and spoke to them about all kinds of stuff and I'm always getting into someone tell me about this tell me about that never heard anyone say they played in a training session with Mick Ucknell or any non-player well better than that he had his missus with the night before Miss World she was sat at the table So my claim to fame is I've had dinner with Miss World.

48:22Paddy McGuinness:Oh, what a treat. It was very good. And to be fair, you can understand why he's with Miss World, because he's a real handsome chap. He looked really good in his United kit as well. Legs look magnificent. Has that ever happened before? Have you ever heard of any other team having a pop star or actor, anyone joining a training session before a European game? You think about it now, the press have gone mad. wouldn't he? He'd gone mental wouldn't he? He'd been absolutely crucified. Are you taking this serious? You've got fucking Simply Red training with, do you know what I mean? I think he did the box didn't he, to be fair.

48:55Paddy McGuinness:He did the box and then jumped out the little possession box. I just remember training, I remember Donkeys years ago, a mate of mine he was at Bolton on the coach and I said, come down and have a session with lads and I remember going, oh no, no. Because I thought to myself, firstly I thought I'd be absolutely embarrassed here by him. But secondly I just thought, if I go in on anyone and crock him, it's my name, and he's like, him, he's ruined it. They wouldn't be allowed now because insurance would say... Yeah, you wouldn't be allowed. Even the coaches now can't join in because of the fact that if you're not insured and you do some money, the amount of money in their contracts are not insured, so who's going to get the liability for that?

49:37Got a Sam's Cafe pizza order up. You know the best part about this spicy Italian sausage? I voted for this topping. Yeah, just another perk of being a member. Come join us. Sam's Club. When you were talking about, like you said, the coaches joined in, Popstars, Sir Bobby Charlton, which is just mind-blowing for me. When you look at the modern player, right, and all those things back in the day, and I get the game moves on and, you know, sometimes for the better, sometimes for the worse. Do you think the modern footballer should be as involved with things like social media as they are. I see that as a mistake.

50:22Paddy McGuinness:I think if you do that, fair play to them, because financially your career is short, and I know they make millions, I'm not saying that, but if you do it and you're making money out of it, and the flip side is you can't expect any privacy when you're going out and stuff. So you can't be both ways. I think if you're going down that line, you take all that comes with it, or you do what probably scholars would have been a bit quiet and reserved, not many interviews, not social media, and doesn't want to be infected about his private life. So I think it swings him round about it. I don't blame him for doing it, if he do it, because as you know, it's very rewarding if he gets to a certain amount of followers.

50:53Paddy McGuinness:But you can't then say, oh, I'm getting forward here, I'm getting told to do that, I'm going to press it outside my house. Because if you bring it in, you've got to take it off. It's not even just that for me. I think like, you know, regardless, we know what it's like, you know, when you're working in a job where you're public facing, if you like, that comes with a job, negativity online. Everyone's kind of used to that a little bit. But I just think if I'm a player, like, interestingly, when they interviewed Phil Forden after the game and he were talking about stuff he'd seen, and, you know, he said, I've seen the negatives.

51:27And I'm kind of thinking, I'd want to just not read anything. I'd want the blinkers on. Yeah, I was just going to say that. Because I think it can affect you, you know, regardless of what you're doing for them. If someone says, you're shit, or that's not good enough, and you're reading that, and then you're going out there.

51:42Paddy McGuinness:We went to the World Cup in 2002, and I remember, we never knew what was going on at home. we never knew it there was no papers anywhere obviously back then it worked social media so even if you're getting slagged off and it oh the flip side if you're doing great and you're getting pat on your back you don't get too carried away with yourself yeah i think there's like i say it's a better way but it's never gonna happen we were always so in the manager don't read the papers it was the papers when he was younger yeah yeah but now now i don't know how you cope with it now i don't know how you'd i don't know how cold being a player with all your screw to like you said, I'd have to stay away from it, but it'd be so hard to stay away from people just saying you're shit and stuff like that.

52:20How do you deal with stuff like that? How can you not come back at them? And also when you lot played back in the day, you'd expect to hear that from the crowd. The crowd, yeah. And it's part of the game, isn't it really? But you leave then and that's it. It's in the moment. You're not still reading about it. I should imagine a lot of young players, It's like, say, any young person these days, it's part of their life now, social media. There's no two ways about it. And you're not telling me a lot of these players aren't sat on the phone at night. And, you know, it's seducing to kind of, when they're saying good things about you, when you start seeing the bad things, it's going to affect you.

52:59Of course, even look back to what we were doing on Thursday and then it goes on social media. You can't help but just have a little look at it. Yeah, yeah. Oh, not them two. Oh, nice one. Really? We've not even done anything yet. which is the one that our picture took. Them two boring bastards again. I've not read Manor Dance. No, that's what I mean. What does he know? You're sorry you actually clicked the button to read it. Yeah, yeah. And that's what it must be like for a footballer. Even you look at it when you do well, and I think, nah, just leave it for both. But we weren't brought up like that,

53:30Paddy McGuinness:so we wouldn't know. These younger players are brought up with it, so they're experiencing it. I would imagine they know how to use it, how not to use it. It's probably as well, I think, the clubs weirdly probably encourage it now because it's because it's a you know football it's the beautiful game but it's a massive global money making game and I think if you're a club and you've got a star player who's got well look at Ronaldo you know what I mean hundred and odd million probably more than that the revenue that's going to bring you into the club so weirdly these days I think football clubs it's a 50-50 because you want to protect the player but you want to well if an Arsenal player for example leaves Arsenal and they've got 30 million followers and they go to Man United straight away there's 30 million people following them and Man United fans more now so you're right it's a different world and it's something I don't understand if I'm honest with you I don't understand it I'm on a little bit of it I got on it just for a joke with my daughter and I said when I wake up in the morning I think I can have more followers than you so that's all I did it for so it's a bit of fun with them but yeah I think it's just if you're going to get in that world, you've got to be able to set the rough and smooth, I think.

54:41Yeah, and I think like you just saying about you read stuff about what you're going to do, but we're lucky in a sense that all three of us, from our walks of life and whatever we did job-wise and the creativity, we came through it when that wasn't a thing, and we've sort of seen it develop and grown into it. And again, when you're older, no one likes seeing anything bad about them, but you can kind of go, no bad. Yeah. You move on. if you're 20 year old you're playing top level Premier League football or whatever league you're playing in and you're reading about someone going you're a wanker or you're shit or whatever if I were 20 I'd have crumbled on the other side of that I don't know about Nick but I quite liked it when people did have a go at me when they did slug me off it gave you a bit of motivation I think you're playing you mean

55:30Paddy McGuinness:yeah but I think the deeper thing is you know when you're 18, 19, 20 you're acne, you've got spots, you've got a girlfriend that's in the paper. There's a lot of personal things out there. But personal stuff's different, of course it is. But I'm talking about when it was football. That's fine, yeah. I'll show you. The way you were brought up, it's like sink or swim, fight or flight, go and show them what you've got. And that's pretty much what we all were like, really. Something I wanted to ask, and a slight bit of a tangent, but it's something that I think about a lot, right? As a fan of football, never played the game at the highest level, when I look at players who have, say, a club, and they've come through the ranks, the star player, and then the big, big teams come in from, like, for instance, Grealish, Villa to City, how does a player, literally more or less overnight, lose that kind of pizzazz and that sort of that flair and that ability because you see it with you know they'll join a club and they just almost crumble is it you know if you look at Grealish at City with Pep who's arguably world's greatest manager that's ever been when it comes to football how does that happen?

56:53It's hard to explain I suppose I suppose look is it Aston Villa is the big fish innit yeah all of a sudden he's going to a City winning the Premier League and they've got 20 players probably as good as him. Now all of a sudden he's not standing out so he still might be performing okay but he's not at that level above his teammates do you know what I mean? He's still part of a team but Aston Villa he was by far the best player. He was brilliant.

57:20Paddy McGuinness:I think Aston Villa as well I'd imagine about seeing any of the stats and anything he'd probably get the ball eight minutes of time. So if you average ten dribbles and four, five get taken off you, the five or six that he's done well will be on match at day. Your confidence goes up. Whereas if he's getting it three or four times at City and he's losing it twice, you're losing it 50 % of the time. I just think that's a big thing. And some people do like being the big fish. They do like it. I didn't, he didn't, you don't want to be that. It's a bit more reserved. But literally, some people thrive on being the big fish.

57:52Paddy McGuinness:Mike Scrooge is quite right what he's saying. He went there and didn't get him off the ball. He didn't get the ball. if I'm pretty sure the manager would have said at Villa get the ball give it Jack get in the box that's probably what would have happened which is what Moise has done I was just going to say that's what it feels like it's happened to him now and all of a sudden bang I'm the main man again player of the month he's been brilliant it's hard to us to explain that because we never did that we never really had a big move to a bigger club we were already at the best club so it's difficult to probably explain that one thing I will say with a price tag Jack had and I was not the big fish.

58:29Paddy McGuinness:I wasn't ever that. But when I went to Newcastle, I felt I had to do more than what I did at United. So at United, I was a box-to-box footballer, get the ball, give it to better players. I was defensive, spoiler alert if you like. I went to Newcastle and I thought, right, well, I need to show these how good I am. I'm going to start doing things that I'm not capable of. So I started trying to do 50, 60 yards passes, giving the ball away. And I got to a point where I was getting booed off the fans. I weren't having a good relationship with the fans. and I remember my dad who was like my hero growing up he looked up at me everywhere playing football Terry the Fish yeah he basically just said to me listen just stick two fingers up to them and show them what you can do in your own game and I think that might have happened with Jack I don't know you have to ask him obviously but I think Jack's going there a hundred and a million he's going to have to go that's a big price on your shoulders you're then going to go I need to go and show how good I am and maybe do things that you weren't doing and I think you lose a bit of confidence you get a little bit of injury niggles here and there you just drop right down the pecking order can I also explain yeah we used to know Nicky's obviously because your parents used to go to the game and he was called Terry obviously we was out one night weren't we and I got a taxi on I said have you been out I said I've just brought up Nicky and the lad said how's Terry the fish why the fuck is Terry the fish he said Nicky's dad Terry bought Terry the fish he works at the fish market Terry the fish but that's what he's like then wasn't it everyone had a nickname didn't they yeah Nick the Sig Nick the Sig Billy, they all will not talk about how he got there but it's it's funny you say about Nicky's dad there and what have you another thing like I see in the modern game is whenever there's a big transfer on now it seems to be a lot more family members mums, dads cousins yeah it's brothers yeah look at Garnaccio and it kind of yeah yeah and it feels as though as an outsider it's not it's not the way to do things but money I think there will be a few of them that are good at the job and keep it in the family and I get that why am I giving all the money to this sort of person I don't know I'll give it my family I get that but if they're not capable of doing it then it's the wrong thing or if they go in he'll sign it but I want a yacht yeah that's what they do it's what parents do of kids who are trying to go to big clubs it's ridiculous yeah Get me a house.

1:00:55Get me a job in a club. It's stupid just to sign the sun. And when you talk about pressure as well, if you're signing because a family member's advised you to do it because they're benefiting, you might be going to a club that doesn't suit you. Exactly, yeah, but they don't care about that. Especially younger players.

1:01:13Paddy McGuinness:It's tough, honestly. I'm sure social media will be slagging me off for saying this, but football's the best job in the world. It is that you get paid very good money, you get idolised and you're playing football like you do for free and you can keep him fit every day of the week it's the best job in the world but there's things that come along with that that's not nice so the crap you get when you were your kids you can't go out at certain times you don't have a Christmas and I wouldn't change my life I'm not saying it's wrong but as a young player if you're 16, 15, 16, 17 whether it's right or wrong you start taking the weight of your whole family on your shoulders not because they're asking my family never asked me for anything my mum, my dad never asked me for anything but you feel like you want to provide.

1:01:53Paddy McGuinness:So if you're a young player and you've got all the weight on your shoulders as well as trying to be a footballer, as well as getting all the stick, it can just knock... I was lucky I had a great family behind me but it can knock some people off the pedestal. You can see that happening with a lot of young players. Our families, probably when we grew up, we just stayed in the background. Now, families are desperate for their kids to be a footballer. I think just purely for their lifestyle. I mean, there should be a rule with the FA as well, going off tangent a little bit here because obviously when I was an academy manager as well, I'd seen it all at United.

1:02:26Paddy McGuinness:The FA should make a rule that if a young player signs for a club and they're under 16, no one can put it on social media. Because when I was at school, my identity wasn't Nicky Butt. It was a footballer. Paul Scores' identity as a young boy at three point was a footballer. Not a 16, 15, I mean. But literally, your identity is that. So if you all of a sudden get released at 15 or 16, you're embarrassed. your friends are laughing at you everyone wants to knock you down and I just think going off telling you again a little bit is that when they're that age and the young players they shouldn't be putting it all over this or their parents but like Scully said they can see the bigger picture if this boy my son does well here all our lives are set and also as well if you're a manager or whatever and someone's being a bit heavier like that I'd be going we don't want him because I can see there's going to be problems in the future because of this behaviour definitely put people off definitely It is crazy that.

1:03:24It's because your family are there for you, but once money starts creeping in, not everyone, because obviously, like Nicky said, and you, Paul, you've got a good family behind you, and that's the rock, that's everything. But if you get a few little, actually, they'll get us an house if we do this,

1:03:44Paddy McGuinness:and a car or whatever. But their mindset also is, I'm not taking it off my brother or my son or me. I'm taking it off the club. Well, you're not. Yeah, exactly. You're not because the club will have a pot. And however that pot gets divvied up, the club won't care how long they get the player. Yeah. So basically that pot isn't changing. So if that pot's£10 and they're giving£3 of that to the agent, brother, whoever it might be, that's still coming out of the player's money because that's it. The other thing as well, when family are involved, say your brother or he's your agent or your mum's involved, seeing one kid, I'm pretty sure his mum's involved doing his deal.

1:04:19They then know what money you're earning. So they're thinking, I should get a bit of that. You should be looking after me. When I was growing up, even from 16 years of age, being an apprentice on£28.50 a week, £40 for your mum's cheque that we got, that was probably the only time my mum and dad knew what I was on. Me too. They never knew. They didn't have a clue what eight wages I was earning. They didn't care about it. now they're almost entitled to a bit of his wages.

1:04:47Paddy McGuinness:A lot of them now, up to the age of 18, 19, 20, they don't have access to the money. They get spending money. Wow. Which is a good thing if it's been invested in the right way, but it's a controlling thing as well. I don't mind that, because if someone gave me 50 grand a week when I was 19, 20, I'd have spunked it right off the wall. Had my career ever lasted about a year tops, I'd have been on scrap. It would have been a good year. Yeah, it would have been the best year ever. A couple of things just to finish off a bit more light-hearted. Firstly, I've got to say, I'm not feeling the new player videos.

1:05:26You know now, if a player signs for a club, it's like a fucking pop video. And I'm like, what is going on? Yeah, they've gone a bit stupid. I didn't mind Eze walking out at the Emirates, and that were lovely. But all the... It's a bit... No, it's getting a bit much.

1:05:41Paddy McGuinness:Yeah, it's a bit too much. I remember when Pogba signed at United, remember when he'd come back? Yeah. Pogba'd come back, they set a studio up in the big gym and took over the whole gym for three days. No one could go and use a gym. None of the academy players could go and use a gym because it was a set for him to come back. Yeah. And you're going, wow, yeah, it's just a total different world. Again, that's social media though, isn't it? Yeah. Videos for Instagram, Twitter. Imagine how much money Adidas and Man Utd made out of it. I get why it happens. It's just, it used to be back in the day, I always think of Shearer at Newcastle, scarf loads of people out forter lovely stuff suit you think of the suit I remember Rio and his white suit oh yeah let's get really down to the nitty gritty though talk us about your win you a day Paddy oh the BMW PGA biggest pro-am in the country that one oh yeah I don't really want to talk about it but you know if you're asking we've asked never done a pro-am in my life now you two I will talk to you about your handicap so firstly I wouldn't go out with you two far too good a player so I'm 14 and they asked me to play in it and I said to them I said look I'm 14 I think that's about the cut off in a pro hand any more they're on the iron I don't think it matters that much you know please so anyhow I get there and I'm playing with Tubes who used to do soccer AM they do golf life now and his brother Ange and our pro's Marco Penge brilliant what a player now honestly firstly, shitting bangers on first tee.

1:07:15Topped it. Topped it.

1:07:16Paddy McGuinness:Was the line right down there? It was the seventh at Wentworth and it's kind of like over a load of scrubland. It's not as straightforward. It's like over a bit of scrubland. It's a slight dogleg ride. It's a horrendous haul to start on. Everyone's out. I'd gone down to the driving range before. Started at my 52 all the way up to my driver. Creaming it, I bet you were. Beautiful. I couldn't wait to get to the tee. I was like, get me. And I'm looking around, he's all pro. I'm like, yeah, you're seeing this. First tee, topped it. Then second shot, shanked it. It took me about three or four holes to start playing how I'd kind of normally play.

1:07:58And chews were the same. Luckily, Ange were just in the zone. We just couldn't get into it. And then once we settled and realised, hang on a minute, he hits it that far Penj like 300 and odd yards ridiculous that if you just play a normal how you'd normally play you've always got a shot on yeah so once we settled we were like up there all the time you can use his tee shot all the time you can use his tee shot so that's that was another thing that took the pressure off yeah because you're trying to hit the world's best tee shot yeah and it's just it's just not happening um but weirdly I never knew this during that pro-am you can get your pro to take one shot right whenever it like is a joker yeah and um and we will kept trying to use him in marco's going on save it lads this isn't all coming up in a bit i forget which one it is at wentworth but it's um the 18th yeah it's par five eight second shot over the water greens up there yeah so we're saving for that so we're all up there we've got a shot on but it's a it's a hard you You know, it's like, whatever, we're 180 yards off a summit.

1:09:05Luke's further. We're like, right, Marco? Here we go. And in our clubs, put everyone in the fucking water. Literally. Tell you what, the freebies. Brilliant. Clothing. Sunglasses, shoes, everything. It was like doing a trolley dash at fucking Selfridges. I was... To Lindenburg. Lindenburg, I went down there. And it's good gear as well. If you're watching. And G4, lovely shoes. But I was like, in the end, because I had my caddy with me, he used me coach at our club, and I'm loading him up as well. And in the end, we go, we're going to have to stop. We fucking know what, put anything. Because you can't, they tell you not to bring anything with you.

1:09:51So I'd know next year, I'll be bringing one of my fucking old arms. Take a van with you. Take a van. There's two things, I think, in the sporting world. which people crumble with, regardless of where you're playing. One's a tee shot. Even if you're at your old club and there's a couple of people still watching you. And the other one's penalties, where you just go, oh, God. Let's not talk about penalties. But it is. Those are the two things. I think if you have a go at darts or tennis, you can sort of... I can't think of anything in those sports where you go, that's the moment. Because there's nothing in dark light.

1:10:33Obviously, you've got to finish on your doubles and trebles and bullseye and all that. But it doesn't feel like there's a moment in something like tennis. Golf intimidates you. Do you know when you see the players? Go back to the Icon series. It's a par five to finish at about 120 yards. There's loads of people around the back of the green. It's only a picture, I just remember. And there's only two people I can see out of 500 people. It's Sergio Garcia and Lee Westwood. there's the two fucking in amongst everyone but there's two people who say fucking I don't know if I top it what if it's left what if I fat it yeah it's just it's so intimidating with that in mind I want you to put these in order of difficulty right 1-4-7 snooker 9-darter finish all in one only one you can get lucky with all in one most impressive

1:11:23Paddy McGuinness:yeah all in one most impressive got to be 1-4-7 because you're having yeah was it how many balls is it 12 reds is it 12 reds and you've got 12 colours that's 24 and you've got the colour again you're looking at like 30 32 33 shots yeah and you've got to get back to the black to position every single time I've got to say you know you should be on fucking countdown literally I was like this is impressive a couple of balls out there I think literally I just think that's like a lot of shots I think nine darts obviously nine yeah all in one a bit of luck yeah all in one anyone can more or less do you've got a chance at it and you can hit one all along the floor and yeah yeah I couldn't split the litter really yeah I'm with Nicky I think one four sevens most difficult then I go the nine data same and then I go the only thing so yeah same no I can't because the both the skill level of that is incredible for both of them don't you think absolutely but when you've been in the pub over the years playing darts right and I'm not listen have you ever had a 9 darts I've never had a 9 darts but I've never once I've never been to a snooker club I've never been to a snooker club and had a 20 break you know what I mean where I've got treble 20s in pubs yeah a few times have you ever got a 180 though I have no I've had a 140 a few times yeah he's played a lot at Newcastle with the lads at all the time but you've never got anywhere near a 147 and again if it was just potting all the balls I'd probably them go and nine dart but the fact he's got to get back to the black spot or position on the black every single time that's why I would go the one thing I would say about about darts which again watching it on the telly over the years and I've seen it live at the I still call it the Reebok with Phil Taylor what surprised me I was at one once and they were setting it up and they went go on you can have a little go like the hockey the pros player Jesus Christ you need a javelin I was literally I was like that with a dart and it was dropping under the three it's higher than you think is it it's so far away so actually that does put it up the difficult but I've got to say yeah the 147 you see I think you see nine darters more than 147s as well yeah you do yeah that's a good point and to it's fair the talent of it so Ronnie obviously the best ever that's ever lived but the amount of times he's not done a 147 on purpose because he won't pay the right cheque have you seen that if you remember they used to give you 147 grand but he stopped doing them didn't he he'd get to like an easy black and miss the easy black I thought it was brilliant I wasn't having that I remember that happening and I as a sports fan I was fuming I get whatever the protest we were doing but I'm going everyone's paid the money someone's grafting all week coming down watching you you're the hero put it in for God's Imagine you two going up for a penalty and going, nah, I want an extra£50 ,000 away.

1:14:28You've got penalties all the time, you've missed them all, I've scored. I missed them on purpose. It's like Ronnie. It is, yeah, so we're going 1-4-7, 9-darter. All in one. All in one. Yeah. Bosh. Thanks for joining us for The Good, The Bad and The Football. We'll be here every Monday from 6 o 'clock. You can watch us on YouTube, Spotify, Apple, wherever you get your podcasts, basically. Make sure to like and subscribe to the video. and please do that so we can get a smile out of Scolzi. He's got a face like a smacked arse.

1:15:13That refresh you've been putting off until the right deal came along? It's here! Wayfair's Black Friday in July sale is happening now so you can finally get the style you've been waiting for for less. Get up to 80 % off area rugs and up to 60 % off outdoor and bedroom furniture. Shop Wayfair's huge selection of styles and find the piece to fit your style, budget, and space. Plus, free shipping. Black Friday in July ends July 27th. Shop today at Wayfair.com. Wayfair, every style, every home.

From the publisher

Welcome to the first episode of The Good, The Bad and The Football with Paul Scholes, Nicky Butt and Paddy McGuinness.

Naturally, the boys have a debrief on United’s 3-0 defeat at Manchester City: they get into where it went wrong at the Etihad and Scholesey reveals what he thinks was the biggest mistake the club made this summer.

They also discuss football’s greatest volleys after Martin Zubimendi’s banger at the weekend, recall the night United got a chasing at the Nou Camp and Paddy reveals how Bolton nearly signed a Brazilian World Cup legend and remembers a funny moment he shared with the late Ricky Hatton.

You can watch Nicky's overhead kick from the 1992 FA Youth Cup Final here: https://youtu.be/HSUqmK3eKhA?t=46

If you want to ask the guys anything about football email them at: questions@goodbadfootball.co.uk.

Follow The Good, The Bad & The Football:

YouTube: www.youtube.com/@goodbadfootballpod

Instagram: @goodbadfootballpod

X/Twitter: @goodbadftblpod

TikTok: goodbadfootballpod

Facebook: www.facebook.com/goodbadfootballpod

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from The Good, The Bad & The Football

All 59 episodes
Man United In CRISIS & Gary Neville’s FIRST Kiss!The Good, The Bad & The Football · 1 h 16 min
Listen in VO