In short
Scholes and Nicky Butt debate Manchester United’s 0-1 Manchester Derby defeat to Manchester City, focusing on the offside goal and a controversial red card, plus broader issues around United’s squad-building and performance under interim/managerial pressure.
Guests
James Milner, former Premier League midfielder (debut 2002; retired 2026), played for clubs including Leeds, Newcastle, Liverpool, and others; known for longevity and elite professionalism. He discusses VAR changes, derby intensity, training standards, and player development.
Key claims
- The offside was “obviously” offside because it interfered with a player.
- The red card decision was “ridiculous”/soft; they argue it should have been both red or both yellow.
- After City went down to 10 men, United failed to press or attack; they sat back, had no shots on goal, and let City control the middle third.
- VAR/official review is criticized for missing a clear Bruno incident (a kick/boot), with the implication that the wrong outcome changed the derby’s balance.
- United’s recruitment approach is questioned: they may be building “in sections” (attack/midfield first) rather than starting from the back with a top goalkeeper/defensive spine.
Notable examples
- City’s high-level passing after the sending off; Elliot Anderson praised for energy and quality.
- Milner’s personal derby highlights: Leeds’ 6-1 vs City and Liverpool’s 7-0 vs United (and other heavy defeats he experienced).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOJames Milner Reflects on His Football Career
0:04 to 0:26
James discusses his long career and the changes in football over the years.
“It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks.”
James Milner Reflects on His Football Career
1:50 to 2:55
James discusses his long career and the changes in football over the years.
“In all those 24 years, what's the biggest change you've seen in the game?”
Subscriber Question and Ribena Story
2:55 to 4:14
The hosts discuss a light-hearted question about James celebrating a win.
“We've got a question in from one of our subscribers, Pete in Nuneaton, who's a Villa fan.”
Analysis of Manchester Derby
4:14 to 7:42
The panel analyzes the recent Manchester Derby and key moments.
“Do you want to talk about the sending off?”
Referee Decisions and VAR Controversies
7:42 to 10:20
Discussion about controversial referee decisions during the match.
“You two mentioned this last season when Michael was interim manager and obviously he was flying and everyone was saying, well, he's got to get the job.”
Fan Reactions and Team Strategy Discussion
10:20 to 14:01
Examining fan frustration and the team's strategic choices post-match.
“I just feel like, you know, we've gone too far one way where you're in danger of losing that and, you know, you don't want to be seeing players sent off a complete change to a full derby and things like that.”
Refereeing Controversies and Team Recruitment Issues
14:01 to 16:46
Discussing the impact of refereeing decisions and Manchester United's recruitment strategy.
“But fundamentally, just on that decision, you can understand why people get really pissed off with it because I just don't...”
Analyzing Defensive Strategies in Modern Football
16:46 to 18:10
Examining the importance of building a team from the back and the current defensive issues at Manchester United.
“Martins is still at the top of his game.”
Young Talent Development at Brighton
18:10 to 19:13
Exploring how Brighton develops young players and how this affects their transition to larger clubs.
“He bursts in the game, bursts forward with it.”
Memorable Derby Experiences
19:13 to 21:07
Sharing experiences and memories from notable derby matches and their emotional impact.
“amazing club, done incredible, like, the last few, the last 15 years or whatever, their journey.”
Show all 34 chapters
The Thrill of Being Part of a Successful Team
21:07 to 23:24
Discussing the excitement and atmosphere surrounding teams on the verge of success.
“I thought the next game I don't know I don't know obviously I think we got a fine for it but I think we just changed the tops but it was just one of them days It was nothing to do with the kid.”
Jurgen Klopp's Coaching Philosophy
23:24 to 24:55
Delving into Klopp's coaching style and its impact on player performance and team culture.
“What would you like Klopp to play for and just as a bloke in general?”
Jurgen Klopp's Coaching Philosophy
24:58 to 25:51
Delving into Klopp's coaching style and its impact on player performance and team culture.
“It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks.”
Fun Manchester Trivia Game
26:27 to 28:00
Engaging in a light-hearted trivia game focused on Manchester-related facts.
“Of the built different index Football's alternative league table Today's alternative Manchester derby Is Paul Scholes Versus Nicky to see who knows the most about Manchester.”
Football Quiz Fun Begins
28:00 to 29:40
The hosts engage in a light-hearted football quiz, sharing trivia about players and clubs.
“no Coronation Street yeah I know it's Coronation Street that's the question I just told you that I don't even remember that I'm going to have a little YouTube of that Corey I've got to say Is this a quiz or what?”
More Quiz Questions and Banter
29:40 to 31:30
The quiz continues with humorous exchanges and more questions about football culture.
“What is the name of the drink created in Manchester in 1908 that was originally a herbal tonic designed to give...”
Debating Football Success
31:30 to 34:20
The hosts discuss the most successful football teams in Manchester, debating club loyalties and successes.
“If you wanted to get a tattoo, a record, or some second-hand clothes...”
Debating Football Success
34:22 to 34:38
The hosts discuss the most successful football teams in Manchester, debating club loyalties and successes.
“not like the old school bookies, quick to use, simple to navigate, no messing about.”
The Life of a Professional Footballer
34:38 to 38:05
A discussion on the lifestyle and career longevity of professional footballers, focusing on diet and commitment.
“This lad plays 658 Premier League games.”
The Mindset of Top Athletes
38:05 to 42:00
Exploring the mindset and work ethic required to be a top-level footballer, using examples like Ronaldo and Salah.
“Do you ever go back and watch games at Leeds because I know you're a Leeds fan, Leeds boy and that's where you started but you've had a big career at other clubs.”
The Importance of Self-Obsession for Top Players
42:00 to 43:20
Discover how self-obsession can drive elite footballers to greatness.
Arteta's Unconventional Methods at Arsenal
43:20 to 45:00
Explore Mikel Arteta's psychological strategies to gain an edge with the Arsenal squad.
“Yeah Yeah of course Just I want to touch a little bit on Arsenal here, lads.”
Weird Managerial Tactics in Football
45:00 to 45:50
Hear anecdotes about unusual tactics employed by football managers.
“And you're looking around and you look down to the pitch where he was training and there was four speakers in each, a speaker in each corner, so obviously four, and then Big Sam's there with his mic on.”
Big Sam's Unique Training Sessions
45:50 to 48:00
Learn about Big Sam's unconventional training methods and their humorous aspects.
“He was like shouting to the IT guy sort of speakers out and it was good echoing Remember Mark the duke was a great block.”
First Football Memories and Experiences
48:00 to 50:50
Relive the hosts' first memories of watching football and their experiences as fans.
“It was mental for all the people, you know, doing all the commercial stuff and that.”
The Journey from Youth to Professional Football
50:50 to 52:33
Explore the transition from playing football as a child to pursuing it as a career.
“And I had like three or four mates that were a lot older than me.”
The Journey from Youth to Professional Football
52:50 to 54:42
Explore the transition from playing football as a child to pursuing it as a career.
“Lads, I know we had the big thing about the boiled eggs, but I've got you a little gift here to elevate your cooking game.”
James Milner's Career Moves
56:31 to 58:20
James discusses the options he had during his career, particularly regarding Manchester United and Liverpool.
“James, as we've got you on, pal, the mods have come up with something here called Who Wants to Quiz a Millie on Earth?”
Life in Spain and Bilingual Kids
58:20 to 1:00:50
James shares his experience learning Spanish and teaching his kids.
“I go over there a lot and was impressed when people could speak two languages.”
Balotelli's Antics in the Dressing Room
1:00:50 to 1:03:25
Anecdotes about Mario Balotelli's unpredictable behavior while at Manchester City.
“Is it fireworks in his house or something?”
Injuries and Tough Days in Football
1:03:25 to 1:06:00
James reflects on some of the hardest moments he faced due to injuries and training incidents.
“driving behind him so if he got tired he could put his car on.”
Being Called Out by Coaches
1:06:00 to 1:08:10
James recounts times he faced criticism from coaches and the lessons learned.
“Jürgen was having a go and said a couple of things back and he smashed his hand down on the thing in the middle of the dressing room and said, will you shut the fuck up?”
Death Row Meals and Fun Food Talk
1:08:10 to 1:10:00
A lighthearted discussion about favorite meals and food preferences.
“I thought he was playing and he was going knock on his door.”
Death Row Meals and Dessert Preferences
1:10:00 to 1:16:48
The hosts lightheartedly discuss their ideal death row meals and dessert preferences, highlighting their humor and camaraderie.
“Did you used to make the bird's trifle in the box?”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:01This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome? That's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required, compatibility and availability varies 18+. Nationwide is so much more than a great insurance company. They're one of America's largest financial services companies.
0:32Just like I'm so much more than quarterback Peyton Manning. I'm also Peyton Manning. Insurance and financial services together, it's a masterpiece. Peyton Manning does it again. For your insurance and financial needs, Nationwide is on your side. Nationwide Investment Services Corporation, member FINRA, Columbus, Ohio. Star Wars, The Mandalorian and Grogu is now streaming on Disney+. What are you waiting for? Hop on. The must-see galactic adventure comes home on Disney+. This is the way. Our only chance is to work together. I like this kid. Always wear your seatbelt. Star Wars The Mandalorian and Grogu Now streaming on Disney Plus Read PG-13 Welcome to the good, the bad and the football Sponsored by Midnight The betting app that's built different Today folks, wow We are in for a treat We've got a player on who made his debut Before the iPhone Was even released Facebook didn't exist And Nicky Butt are dreadlocks.
1:48James Milner, welcome, pal. Thanks for having me. Great to see you. What a career. You started in 2002, retired in 2026. In all those 24 years, what's the biggest change you've seen in the game? Just talking about probably VAR. Yeah, I mean, there's loads of changes. I think I feel fortunate I sort of feel like I played in the old school and then the new school, if you like. I played across two sort of different eras of football, I feel like, you know, when I first started and how it was and the training and, you know, pretty brutal at times. You had to grow up quick and you got walloped in the air, first tackle from behind, and it was just a warning.
2:34And then obviously now there's players going out there and not wearing any shin pads. So there's lots of change, obviously, but I just, you know, I feel lucky I've played across such a span and experienced it all, really. Unbelievable, that 24 years. Just the physicality of that amazes me, just keeping going. But before we get into the football chat, and we are going to talk about the Manchester Derby lads. Come get comfy for this. We've got a question in from one of our subscribers, Pete in Nuneaton, who's a Villa fan. he said James is it true you celebrated winning the Champions League by drinking Ribena it's not true no but it was basically I think it was a semi-final and we played in Rome and you know I think the the guy said are you gonna have a glass of red wine and I'm there first thing that came into it now I'll have a I've been and that was it the amount of bottles of right being over the mods over there hey get James don't get some right being and I don't know if this is true lads but hey I've got to say right being a though and the people downstairs from midnight will be loving this the money they've put into this podcast and we're here with a bottle of right drink right being a you saw the cartons in Yeah.
3:55Cartons all the time. They're still knocking about them. I don't know. I've not had a drink of that. I've not had a rabbi for ages. Do you know what I've got out of? Cordial. You used to always have cordial when you were a kid. Vimto were the main one. You used to love a Vimto. An orange squash. Let's get into the football chat, lads. Man United 0, Manchester City 1. Why do you say that so happily, Paddy? I'm just reading out the results. He does smile on his face. No, I, listen There's nothing wrong with a bit of You keep thinking of this 1-0 Very nice You didn't go though, no I was working, I was up in Scotland DJing Now this game, regardless of the result Quite a controversial one What do you want to talk about first?
4:46Do you want to talk about the goal? Do you want to talk about the sending off? The field is yours I think for me, I think if you've got to take, well, me and Scully have to take our Man United love out of the way of it. It was quite obviously an offside because he's interfering with the player, but anyone likes it or not. I think we've admitted that now, aren't we, the referees panel? Yeah. The big thing for me is the red card is ridiculous. He's either got to give both a red card or both nothing or both yellow cards. So that's just papering over the cracks for me as a Man United fan. I think the performance from Man City after that they went to 10 men was was really really high level you know with 10 players passing out from the back they look like they've got more players than Man United and I just think that it was very disappointing for Man United fans to be playing at Old Trafford against your arch rivals with 10 men and you're not going flat out to go and try and kill them I mean it should have been a high press, should have gone all out high up, we sat back we didn't have a shot on goal, I think it was 40 minutes after 40 minutes.
5:46Does the 10 men make a difference? I was going to say, you say a high press. When you're 11 against 10, you shouldn't really, you should have the ball all the time. Well, you should, but when you've not got it, at least go and try and get it back. We didn't even try and do that. We sat back and then let them come into our middle third. And you're literally like, what are you doing? I would say, though, if there's any team, I think 99 % of teams in the world, when a man gets sent off, you fancy yourself to beat them. Now, City are probably one of the teams where you think it's still going to be hard, because they're so good on the ball.
6:18Technically, they're brilliant. I thought Elliot Anderson was unbelievable. He was like, you talk about having 10 men. He was like two players. The energy of him and his quality on the ball, I thought he was brilliant. When you've been playing the game and you're up against a team that's gone down to 10 men, does the manager instantly get an instruction to you or do you just figure it out yourselves? Depends on the team you're playing in and what your make-up is, I suppose. When you've got more senior players, you can probably take it on yourselves on the pitch. But, you know, I think coming more into it as well, teams might coach that.
6:51What do we do when we're going out of 10? What do we do when playing against 10? And I think, like Scald said, it's probably a bit different playing against City. They're probably a bit better than most when they've got 10 men. But, you know, maybe you need to change your game plan at this point and say, let's get after them. They're still good on the ball. We respect that. But we have got a man extra, so you press them and win the ball back. And you would hope you had the majority of the ball, I think. And it's the amount of time, because when did they get us on it? After 20 minutes or something?
7:1520 minutes. So there's still 70 minutes to go. Keep the ball. That's what you've got to do. If you give the ball away, especially against a team like that, it's very difficult to get it back. Whether they've got nine men, ten men, eleven men, it's so hard to get it back. You tie them out. Now, look, you might not be bombarding the goal because City are a good team. But still, at some point, you're going to commit one another. Just keep the ball off them. You don't give them a kick of the ball. And eventually, you are having a great chance. Of course you are with the players you've got. I also think he could have probably I don't know how much confidence he's got on his back four to bring a defender off and bring an extra attacking player on it seemed to take a while for him to want to do that like I say you can get that I thought City's sub and I was very good when he came on as well on the right side because all of a sudden you've got a player who can probably go and create a golf out of nothing for himself now look he didn't have many chances but the energy he carried the ball the energy was there he gets the ball up the pitch and they're valuable players.
8:13You two mentioned this last season when Michael was interim manager and obviously he was flying and everyone was saying, well, he's got to get the job. What is it with this curse of the interim manager? As soon as they get the rubber stamp going, right, you are no the gaffer. Feels like the wheels come off a little bit. Like four points from four games. Look, it's not a great start. It's still early. Man United, with that team, they're going to win a lot of games of football. But what we both said here before, and we never expect them to go and challenge for the league, they're just not good enough to do that at this point.
8:52When Michael took the job last year, he couldn't lose really because the team were playing that badly. And don't get me right, he did brilliant to get him to where he did in the end, obviously, Champions League football. But at the start of the season, that's when the job becomes real. This is a time now where you've got to go and win them games again to put yourself in a place to challenge maybe for the league I don't look I don't think they're there and you'd have expected a better start but I've I've seen it over the years many teams and we were fighting against teams like Liverpool not when James there before James was there before Christmas they're struggling a bit and they're your biggest rivals yeah so by November December time they're out of the league they're probably 10-15 points behind I mean, probably where United are going to be when it comes to November, December.
9:43And then after Christmas, because the pressure's off a little bit, you put a load of wins together. Now, that's not the important time. The important time is now to get you in a position up to Christmas. Then you hopefully have a finish to go and challenge for the league. And just talking about the Ford and Bruno incident, James, you just said at the beginning, I said, you know, what's the biggest change you were saying about VAR and all the rest of it. when you're playing in a game like that and say an incident like that happens and you watch it back and they've got the decision totally wrong what's the vibe around the group like are you talking to each other is there an official complaints process what happens I think the clubs normally deal with that if there's a decision you're not used to but I just feel like you know the games are passionate it's a passionate sport derbies things like that I just feel like you know back in my day and when I started and stuff you felt like the referees reffed a bit more with common sense and stuff and I know there's so many cameras and VR but like you're going to get flash points in a game and if the referee takes care of it early in a way which is like no more of that next time it happens or whatever you know like you can keep players on the pitch and the game tempo is set from that point but now it's obviously nobody wants to see things like that but it is part of the game or it should be part of the game and putting your physical stamp in that midfield area, especially in derbies and things like that.
11:07I just feel like, you know, we've gone too far one way where you're in danger of losing that and, you know, you don't want to be seeing players sent off a complete change to a full derby and things like that. You want tackles, you want that passion. Yeah, nothing stupid, but I think there's a line as well where you can bring it back a bit and keep that in the game. One thing I will say about the referee, he did it very quickly. You know, you're thinking a lot of people are moaning about referees not refereeing but he went in straight whether it's right or wrong is probably wrong at the end of it but he went in very quickly and you're thinking as James said, the passioners, sometimes there are going to be flash points especially in the first 20 minutes of a big Manchester derby so you think maybe just take a step back and then we can have a look at it.
11:51It was one of them where you probably do wait and just have a little look at it. I think the referees' jobs are so hard now I think they probably dislike it as much. Am I making a decision? Am I leaving for VA? I think their jobs are so difficult as well so I'd never put anything on them I think it's making their life a nightmare a bit as well obviously all of us when you're watching from the comfort home you're watching the replays and everything else I do think there's a lot of pressure on refs but do you think there's certain refs going to games already thinking right I'm just going to nail some of the cards straight away and set it odd I'm just going to let it go a little bit I'm not going on about like the Mike Dean stuff studying the in centre circle for 20 minutes I'm going to pick now no I don't think they go into games like that do they?
12:36they can't do I think referees like to think they're honest and they just see and react to what they see same with football when we play you react to it you give a ball away you don't mean to do it but you do and mistakes happen now for me the biggest thing with that flashpoint isn't the fact that he went and sent him off because he reacted I think it was a bit soft but he did react and he can't do that nowadays the biggest thing is when it goes to VAR how can they not see the kick from Bruno as a Man United fan I don't want Bruno sent off. But how can they not see that and go, he's booted him in the backside.
13:06And then we were talking off there with James before, and if you react, which you shouldn't do, but you do, you react and you get punished for it. And it started... So it's the biggest reactor, isn't it? No, but it started with Bruno was the aggressor, wasn't it? And whether you like it or not, he was the aggressor. So he's hard, but then look at VR. But at that time, the ref could have missed that, his angle like it was at. But once it goes to TV, and I don't know how many people are in VR, is it two, three people? How can they not see how can you not see that and then basically the other say look they both need sending off or the both staying on Yeah, and that's it then there's 10 beat 10 or it's 11 v 11 and it's a great derby That with that in mind when you say the look at that because you can't blatantly see him kicking him but it happened the other week with Gabriel with Yeah, yeah Boots him straight in the face Yeah, it's unbelievable.
13:55I think that's what gets fans' backs up. And again, as a Man United fan, I'm not papering over the cracks of the performance and how well City played. But fundamentally, just on that decision, you can understand why people get really pissed off with it because I just don't... I understand referees missing things because it's human error and you make mistakes on a football pitch. Players do, referees do. It's all 100 mile an hour. Once it goes to that screen and it's slowed down, and what did it take them? Two and a half minutes? And they didn't... Sorry, that was the offside goal, was it? Two and a half minutes?
14:23It must have been at least a minute and 90 seconds of looking at that. You can see it straight away, what's happened. It's crazy, isn't it? It's absolute madness. It is bonkers, and that's what you're saying, that's what gets all the fans' backs up. And I suppose they're playing the game as well. Now, this is another one. You look at United's, well, I say recruitment, but crying out for a new left-back. Shaw's injured now. is it surely Michael's pulling his ear out going Again we've said this haven't we been over this haven't we with Krim I think they're doing it in sections well that's what it looks like they saw the forwards out last year and the forwards look alright still probably need a top class centre forward I'm not sure how much confidence they have in Sesko although I think he has got better and it looks like they did the midfield this year and it feels like the defence will probably come next year Now whether that's the right way of doing it, I don't know.
15:21But at this moment in time, defensively, I struggle. They're always going to concede goals in that team. If you were setting up a team, you had the checkbook, and you were like, right, I've got to sort this team out. Is it not better to start from the back first? Yeah, which is why we thought that was strange, because that is normally what happens. You probably start with a... What team have you seen win the Premier League without a top-class goalkeeper? Yeah. Now, look, Le Mans might be that. I don't know. I think the jury's probably still out on that. And then you build from the back of four.
15:57Like Arsenal, it's the way Arsenal started three or four years ago. Defensive, they have been absolutely brilliant. And you need a top-class goalkeeper. You think of Liverpool's team with Alisson and City's teams with... Raya, Arsenal. Raya, Arsenal. Man United with Peter Schmeichel, Edwin van der Sar. They've all got brilliant, brilliant goalkeepers. You start from the back, of course you do. Whether Michael's just got to be patient and wait for that, I don't know. He obviously thought with the Luke Shaw thing and a left-back that Dogu would be okay. Now, look, I don't know if he is going to be okay.
16:33He was signed as a wing-back, won't he for Amarim's system? So we'll have to wait and see. But when you're saying about that then, about if he's patient and what have you, but I think in the modern game, if you're a manager, you don't really get much patience. I think that's all well and good saying they're doing it in sections from the from the club and the recruitment But if you're a manager you're thinking well the forwards they think are sorted I don't think they are I think we need us at number nine and out and out number nine Then they've gone and sorted the midfield without which Debatable I think they've done a decent job with that But it could be Michael could not even get to the net transfer window It could be going well I've lost my job and you're not giving me the tool to go and do my job with a back four Because certainly, whatever you say about that back four, Harry Maguire has been an unbelievable player.
17:18Top, top player. But he's getting to a certain age now. And he is getting older. We've all been there, haven't we? You get older and you slow up. You're not as quick as us. Martins is still at the top of his game. He's still a really good player. Luke's, in my opinion, I love Luke Shaw. When he's fit and playing, he's one of the best in Europe. But it's a fact that he gets a lot of injuries. The right backs, I don't believe either of them are good enough. So you're looking as a manager or as a coach, and you're going, well, I'm desperate to get some players in the back forward. Then you've got, it looks like the recruitment team and the powers that beat United are going, no, that's our next phase and that might happen in January.
17:50It might even happen next. We're going to be really hard or it'll probably be happening in the summer. That doesn't help a manager. That doesn't help the coach. I think Michael's probably banking on with his new midfielder and that might help protect him a little bit because they've obviously brought a couple of defensive midfielders in and a lad from Chelsea Santos and Belieber. Well, I was just going to ask James about Belieber because you've played with him. What do you think he'll bring to United? Yeah, I mean, he's still very young. Physical quality is outstanding. He bursts in the game, bursts forward with it.
18:18Can dominate areas, but he's still young. Growing into that physicality to be able to do it for 90 minutes. You know, Brighton's one of the best places to be for young players to learn the trade. The amount of, you know, the recruitment's obviously great, but the amount of time the manager and the coach is putting on. Well-run club Brighton, isn't it? Yeah, and the amount, as a young player, like I say, the amount of coaching they get, you know, you get to the top clubs and play start. You're expected to come in. You know what you're doing. You play, you get left alone. You're expected to do your job and obviously at Brighton, the manager every year loses his best players and the young one's coming again.
18:53You've got to start again but the amount of effort they're putting to, you know, the individual meetings, the meetings for positions, time after training, one-on-one sessions, video sessions, so good at developing those players and obviously it's a step up for Carlos then going to a club like Man United, size difference compared to Brighton. No disrespect to Brighton, obviously, like, say, amazing club, done incredible, like, the last few, the last 15 years or whatever, their journey. Amazing club, but Man United's a whole different ball game. You've played in pretty much all the big derbies, but I've always wanted to ask you, was it, which was the best?
19:33Was it beating United 6-1 with City, or 7-0 with Liverpool? Let's start at Leeds Plays at Liverpool, plays at City He's battered us everywhere he's been Who chooses these guys? That's probably the best question I've ever been asked Is it the 6-1 with City or the 7-0 with Liverpool? Both incredible, obviously Being a Leeds fan and growing up as a Leeds lad I had to separate but I think the City one was obviously massive because it was I think the first year we won the league it was early in the season and I think it probably gave us that belief to go on and win the league for the first time so you can't really separate them but I'd say that in terms of having that belief to go and knock them off the perch was the saying at the time wasn't it You've been in quite a few games with United where you've been on the winning side haven't you?
20:33I think there's a start beaten by 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7 I think somewhere Can you believe that lads? I was at both of them games The Liverpool game horrendous Did you hear that? 1, 2, 3 He's beat us 1, 2, 3 Try to ignore it What a stat that is I had that tattoo in the arm Flipping heck What's it like What's the biggest When you two I don't think I don't like We got really pumped In Europe We did I got pumped we got pumped against Barcelona is it four or five new camp for one and the three was it six to one with the kit yeah yeah so basically we had the great kit on and it was boiling like you couldn't see anywhere the sun but obviously there was a new kit and the minds you just I think you're just looking for an excuse
21:37space
21:44Still got bait so yeah
21:50Think you could change your kit during the game. I thought the next game I don't know I don't know obviously I think we got a fine for it but I think we just changed the tops but it was just one of them days It was nothing to do with the kid. Oh the going back to what James said then about City winning that game the derby game And it's something Arsenal didn't really do over the last three or four years when they didn't win the league Beating one of your main rivals for the league is big Mmm, then you know I mean that then gives you the belief you can actually go and win the league and especially control traffic and doing it in the way they did.
22:24I could imagine that gave you a massive depleting right. This is our time now. And we could feel it's coming. Do you know what I mean? I think it was only three points in it, but like you say, it's just that belief in it and that feeling. Yeah. It must be great being part of a team that's just on the cusp of doing that, winning the league and the excitement and managers come in. What's the feeling like around those places? I think that was a major decision when we go in there I could have gone, I think it was maybe Chelsea when I went to City. The appeal was they hadn't won anything for a long time and it was being part of something that started.
23:01So that was a big draw. It was similar to when I went to Liverpool as well, really. It was a big decision to leave City, but Liverpool, a hugely successful club, huge club, but not won loads in the recent history. And to go there and try and start a new era of success and win that first Premier League title, obviously so many league tiles but not wanna a Premier League at that point was mental really for the size of that club yeah you you went seem to went to them clubs at the right time really it was a little bit of a risk because they hadn't won anything but in both instances both team if you knew they were coming yeah so we've seen City for three or four years and Jesus Christ these are gonna be good obviously with the money they spent the players quality player that was going there and then Liverpool exactly the same yeah you could feel with Jurgen Klopp that he's going to be dangerous.
23:48What would you like Klopp to play for and just as a bloke in general? Yeah, I think the great thing about Jurgen is probably what you see is what you get. You know, some people are very different behind the camera, in front of the camera and behind the camera. I think he was, what you see is what you get. Plenty of energy, demanded high standards, everything you do. I remember like one time, I think his first Christmas party and we'd lost to Watford, I think, away and come now I was in the mood and says this is for all the staff, whatever we do, we do well. If we're training, we're training well.
24:20If we're playing, we're playing well. And if we're partying, we're partying well. And that was like everything. No, exactly. I wasn't allowed to get on the dance floor sort of thing. Yeah, so his standards were great. Infectious, obviously. And sessions were really tough when he first came in. You wouldn't believe people throwing up at side at pitch. Yeah, yeah. It was ruthless. How was Pep and Klopp different? I didn't work with Pep. I missed Pep. Yeah, no, I was Mancini and Pellegrini, yeah. So I missed Pep by a year. Pellegrini, bloody hell. This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome, that's new.
25:00It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required compatibility and availability varies 18+. Nationwide is so much more than a great insurance company. They're one of America's largest financial services companies. Just like I'm so much more than quarterback Peyton Manning. I'm also Peyton Manning. Insurance and financial services together, it's a masterpiece.
25:39Peyton Manning does it again. For your insurance and financial needs, Nationwide is on your side. Nationwide Investment Services Corporation, Ember Finra, Columbus, Ohio. Star Wars, The Mandalorian and Grogu is now streaming on Disney+. What are you waiting for? Hop on. The must-see galactic adventure comes home on Disney+. This is the way. Our only chance is to work together. I like this kid. Always wear your seatbelt. Star Wars The Mandalorian and Grogu Now streaming on Disney Plus Read PG-13 Now it's time for a game Powered by our friends at midnight The betting app that's built different This is midnight's home Of the built different index Football's alternative league table Today's alternative Manchester derby Is Paul Scholes Versus Nicky to see who knows the most about Manchester.
26:45Firstly, before we get into it, who do you think has got the bragging rights when it comes to Manchester facts? I think it depends what the facts are. We're talking about some... Coronation. Good point. Yeah, but like Coronation Street. I have no idea. I never watched it. It can be anything and everything to do with the city of Manchester. I think Nick is more of a Manchester lad than me. You know what I've noticed about Paul Scholes Every time we do these quizzes He does this And then we get about three questions in And he's like He's already marking them down in his head And he's going that's half a point And that's So he gets quite competitive Hustling me, isn't he?
27:23Question one Derived from rhyming slang What part of your body does Newton's Nicky Bult That was me It was me, wasn't it? No, he was in the Newton Heath's teeth Correct Correct. One point to Nicky. Question two. What was the name of Chesney's dog in Coronation Street? Oh, the Big Great Dane, wasn't it? No, it was an Alsatian, wasn't it? No, it was a Big Great Dane. That was EastEnders, wasn't it? Schmeichel. Yeah. When you said Great Dane, I thought, how did you not got that straight away? One, one, whoa. What was the one at EastEnders? Wellard, wasn't it? Wellard. Little Willie. What? That was on EastEnders, Little Willie.
28:09extra factoid for you Peter Schmeichel made a cameo as a background Coronation Street you told him that answer before though I'm right this is not a fucking question I'm just giving you a fact Peter Schmeichel made a cameo as a background extra in the show in 1999 did you remember him doing that? no Coronation Street yeah I know it's Coronation Street that's the question I just told you that I don't even remember that I'm going to have a little YouTube of that Corey I've got to say Is this a quiz or what? What we're doing here? Is that a question? Am I allowed to just No That's the question Next questions please Bob Bob Question three Which former Manchester United player did Liam Gallagher tell to sit down Gary Neville Wrong To sit down your little farts on Twitter during the Manchester Derby in 2016?
Read the full transcript
29:14I'll give you a clue. He's in this room. Scolsy. Fucking hell, well you've already gone. Yes, you, Paul Scolz. Do you know that? Fucking hell. 50, isn't it? Fucking hell. Well, the reason why I said he's in this room, I was willing him to say Nicky. I was like, no, you. Question four. But I've got to say, lads, going well this. Great show. What score is it, by the way? Fuck no. Two on to you. Right. Question four. What is the name of the drink created in Manchester in 1908 that was originally a herbal tonic designed to give... Yes? Vimto. I was going to say Vimto. Great show. It was designed to give drinkers vim and vigour.
30:04Right. Vim We told you Manchester's Oh Hey I never knew that With Vimso Very northern Salford had a sponsorship Didn't they Yeah Did they Question five What five letter word Can mean stingy Or fake Oh you got me the fake Tight No Very tight but It's not fake is it Five letter word Can mean stingy And fake I'd think more towards the fake snide correct start means yeah yeah uh proper man question six what is chuddy that was me that was me that was tight that was tight that was tight yes chris well done how do you know that because you can't That's your opinion. I want to see the replay. I was going to say, I was going to say, Chewing Gum.
31:05The main thing is, they're not competitive, and that's the main thing. Just a bit of fun quiz. Chewing Gum is right, Paul Scholes. Nick, here it's me. Nick, the thing is, yours' sound is more prominent than mine. There we go. It went up, didn't it? I did go up and knocked that. I fucking know. That's if you're covering the speaker on your leg like that, you div. Is anyone keeping these quotes? Because I'm not right, God, right. Three, two. Three, all, that. Honestly, seriously, Try and not cover that. Right. Leave it there like that. If you wanted to get a tattoo, a record, or some second-hand clothes...
31:39Oh, yes. Affleck's Palace. Oh, he's straight in. Affleck's Palace. Yeah, I knew that. Or a piercing from one place in Manchester. Where would you go? Affleck's Palace. Question eight. What do you call a narrow alley? Ginnall. He's in. And I like how he's holding the buzzer now. Here we go. I think we might be drawing so far. What's good, is it? 4-0. I still want that VAR looking at, Jack. 4-0, two questions left. How old are you playing for? What time would you have your dinner?
32:2512 o 'clock. Correct, midday. is your tea what sort of fucking question is that because your tea everyone has to dinner at different times dinner's posh dinner's dinner time isn't it lunch isn't it and your tea is your dinner tea's like half three till six I know what the fuck it is well where were you on the buzzer clearly you don't so half three till six you're in the kitchen knocking trifles up it proves my point your tea's half three till six so your dinner can be from half eleven till half two no no your dinner's twelve innit It's 12 o 'clock dinner. I'm right out of paddy. Right, it's all on this to take us to a time break.
33:05No, you can't. It could go to a time break. You just made me want to go along you. Well, it's fucking 5-4, so it's obvious if he gets this right. I can't get over that question. It's fucking Carol Vorderman. Work that out. That question's fucking stupid. Question Sam. Who are the most successful football team based in the city of Manchester?
33:26Man United. That is incorrect. The answer is Manchester City Oh wait wait You've got to pass it across There's only fucking two clubs No he's not How can I pass it across I don't know It's a bit amateur You've already won But how Manchester United Are in Greater Manchester But Old Trafford Is located outside The city limits And is in Trafford Yeah you're right The fuck's that Got to do with it Well the question is Who's the most successful Football team Based in the city of Manchester. Chris, have you done this quiz? Of course he has. It's fucking shit. I won. I won. You don't see much of that, do you, on QI?
34:11This is fucking shit. But there you have it. That was the alternative Manchester derby, powered by Midnight, built for no, not like the old school bookies, quick to use, simple to navigate, no messing about. Just search Midnight Built Different Index for more information. You do have to be 18 or older and please gamble responsibly. What's on James Milner's playlist? Everything, to be fair. I can listen to my stuff. Yeah, I like it. A bit of an eclectic mix. Yeah, yeah, I'm pretty. What's on yours? He doesn't. Oh, he doesn't. I'll tell you what it is. Fucking silence. This lad plays 658 Premier League games.
34:57you're asking about fucking music. Oh, is it not nice to know the person as well? No, it doesn't always have to be muck and bullets, does it? Is it 658? We were talking about steaming eggs a few podcasts back. That is unbelievable. I don't think you understand how good that is. No, I do. That's what I'm saying. I'm not sure you do. You talk about fucking music. It's nice to know the person as well. It's nice to know the person behind the football shit, Paul. This is what he doesn't understand. It's about communicating and building up a rapport. 600-odd games. What do you think it is, with you personally as a player?
35:38What's your favourite song? Wow. He's fucking murdering him. What is it that, like, makes you go for so long and other players not? Is it all just down to injuries? Is it down to do players lose interest? It's something special mentally for me. Mentally, physically, especially. Yeah, I think you need luck for sure. You need a bit of luck in terms of staying fit, but also you need to do the side that everything to not get injured. So I think you're looking at diet details. Obviously, that's changed a lot since I first started, and the more people around the club and take advantage of that, the nutritionist, the gym stuff, you know, you start doing maybe a few gym sessions a week at Newcastle or whatever, and then it gets more, and then you're in the gym half an hour before training.
36:22and then every day after training, depending on his legs, upper-fing core, injury prevention. But, yeah, I think I always just tried to do everything right and do every day and be the best I could, I suppose, and never really cut corners. There's no days off in terms of, you know, you have your rest days, but, I mean, no days off in thinking about it. This is what I love about James. It's like for any young people watching who want to get into this game, there's no shortcuts. It's hard work. It's commitment. When you think of an example of how to live your life and how to be a professional footballer for 24 years, there's no better example.
37:01It sounds like a daft question, this has been spoken about 24 years within football, but are you actually a football nut? Would you go and watch games, are you obsessed with football? Because for me, from a distance as well, it's like you're more obsessed than you personally, now you're going to be professionalised. I don't see you around football at the minute, I don't see you at any games. is it your football no I'm not I don't watch loads of football I really don't you bang on to be fair I think early in my career I was for sure watching everything and I think it was about you know yourself and pushing out probably the last five six years was about my team obsessed with my team how can I and obviously become a senior player it's not about you it's about the team how can I help the lads and speaking at the manager a lot and involved in those coaches conversation so you're thinking about the bigger picture of the team so I'm obsessed with my team rather than watching other teams and that's probably where it's been and then you know since I've retired you know I'm watching games here and there but you know I'm doing other things and spending a bit of time with the family and stuff like that so I'm not a football nut yeah I'm obsessed with what I'm doing and if I'm doing something I'm fully all in I suppose so it's been you're right really that journey of that and you get to a point in your career because I started so young I felt probably like a senior player a lot earlier than you know I was probably 24 and I felt a bit like a senior player because I played eight years at that point so I had quite a long time of thinking about the bigger picture rather than yourself sort of thing.
38:22Do you ever go back and watch games at Leeds because I know you're a Leeds fan, Leeds boy and that's where you started but you've had a big career at other clubs. It's hard to say you've always got a love for City, a love for Liverpool. Do you ever go back to Leeds and go I want to watch a game? It's a funny story you know. I went to Newcastle obviously and I was more than happy staying at Leeds, wanted to stay at Leeds but it it was best for the club so they needed the money so I went to Newcastle fine and they got to the playoff final that first year after I'd gone to Newcastle so I contacted the club wanted to go watch him at Wembley said can I come and watch the game yeah yeah no problem can get you some tickets just let us know you want to pay for them and all this
39:00and that was it yes I am Vincent really that is just it's when you two have said stuff about United and tickets it blows my mind Honestly, it left the club to help the club I mean obviously I was 18 at times it wasn't gonna save the club I gave up why I was out and stuff. Yeah, you know I don't have any hard feelings against club. I love the club. I mean it's people who are in charge at the time Yeah, yeah, it's one of them. Yeah, and I've just not been Enjoy the most being up and that's probably a tough question. It is tough. I think um obviously leeds being a leeds fan liverpool was incredible um individual like say villa i was there twice and i think that was when i had my best individual time i've loved them all really city city was only you know they hated me when i left there's some bizarre stories about i've said this about the club and that and you know quotes have apparently said and you know i got booed when you back, which is sad.
40:03You got booed when you went back? Yeah, I used to get booed. Still now, really. But, you know, I enjoy my time, so I've got nothing bad to say. Everyone speaks very highly of you, how you were as a professional, how you looked after yourself. What was Moore like? Was he one of those kind of players who was always last on the training pitch, putting the hours in? He was obsessed again, but yeah, for sure. Obsessed with it and was humble to ask questions and opinions and then make his own mind up, but he'd always be looking, how can I get the edge, whether it was recovery, fitness, in the gym all the time, finishing, penalties.
40:38We had so many conversations on penalties and things like that. Humble enough to ask questions, but then he'd make the decision and things like that. I think that's a sign of someone who's elite, I think, doesn't have that ego that I know best. He would go around and get as much information or he'd see things or read things that someone's doing it and the next thing he's got a bike in his swimming pool at home and he's doing his recovery and things like that. Or he's going back to the training ground at 3 o 'clock in the morning after a game to do an Australian. I've seen bikes in swimming pools in Bolton.
41:08I say swimming pools, canals. Have you got a bike in your pool at home? Have you? That's a very simple question. Lads, we keep having this discussion on the podcast. I'm not an ex-Premier League footballer. There's no swimming pools in our... I've got a blow-up paddling pool in the backyard. Have you got a bike in it? I've got a bike wheel. Yeah, I've just missed the rest of it. I think what you're saying about Mo Salah there then, every top player, and again, this is, I think, if you're a young person, you think, oh, I want to get into football. The examples for me that I've seen throughout the years is all the top, top players, you've got to have that ability, but they've all had a work ethic.
41:52I mean, you look at Ronaldo when people talk about him. but graft do you know what I mean hours and hours of like extra training you know they put it in how they live diet everything that's what I was asking James before I think the misconception from people that have not been in football think that to be a top top top player you have to be obsessed with football I think you've got to be obsessed with yourself and making the best of yourself so Ronaldo is a pivot example Ronaldo great lad loves himself he wants to be the best physical specimen he can be he does the scores, he was like that when he came in he wants to be the best footballer there is and then that transpires into being one of the best teammates you can have, and I do think that's a massive thing with top, top, top players, it's like obviously they enjoy the game they want to be the best they can be, but to be as high level as Mo Salah, Millie these players, they have to be they have to be obsessed with how they are themselves, they want to look in the mirror and go I really like what I'm seeing here I really want to be I did the last No I never No but they do If you look at Ronaldo Don't look at his trousers I look at that Ronaldo I'm telling you Is obsessed with himself Yeah And that's not a slant name at all It is looking at how he can be The best specimen he can be To be the best footballer he can be And I think all the top players I think to be in that Very elite bracket When you're talking about The best in the world The top four or five You have to be selfish Yeah You have to have that Yeah Yeah of course Just I want to touch a little bit on Arsenal here, lads.
43:26This one, Arteta has revealed this week he deliberately sabotages the Arsenal squad, but with random stuff, because he feels as though psychologically it gives them the edge. That might be like going the wrong way to a game, or to training, or is it like he has people pickpocketing? Yeah, he did that last year, didn't he? Look, if he thinks it's the extra 1 % that gets you results. Not sure if your iPhone nicked makes you a better player, does it? Really? He's got a method in his madness. Who are we to argue with? He just won the Premier League. He seems to be working. On our bus, our coach, when he was younger and some pickpocket comes and starts nicking everyone's phones.
44:14You've been knocking it out, haven't you? You've been knocking it out. I'm trying to nick Yapstam's phone off him. no the manager told me to do it sorry Yap the manager's paying me what's the weirdest thing you've seen a manager do throughout your careers like that where you go this is you know where they've gone we're just going to try this today because I saw some last season I had Tesser Adamo passing a cable run with a lightbulb on the end and he was giving some speech I actually watched that programme on Netflix I don't know if any views have seen it where they followed Arsenal I actually quite liked him I thought he was good like his light bulb team talk and some of the things I thought it was really good.
44:54Now this is a couple of years ago and obviously you haven't been as successful now but looking back we were talking about it before so I will talk about it again for the audience but when we signed it when Sam came to Newcastle and obviously you knew Sam's background at Bolton and what he did was amazing but how he did it was very together and it was a team spirit and it was like there's no superstars although he went and bought a few it was always very team spirit so at Newcastle you come out of the building and you go down a couple of steps and you'd be on the pitch and then as we got out onto the grass, you just hear this heavy breathing like Darth Vader, and you're thinking, what the fuck, what's this?
45:28And you're looking around and you look down to the pitch where he was training and there was four speakers in each, a speaker in each corner, so obviously four, and then Big Sam's there with his mic on. And he's thinking, what the fuck? And he's walking out and you just hear him start talking and because he was running around putting cones out, he's heavy breathing and honestly, it was one of the funniest things ever. And then he'd be saying like Millie get to the ball ball ball ball He was like shouting to the IT guy sort of speakers out and it was good echoing Remember Mark the duke was a great block.
46:05You know him a lot better Dukes as calmest nicest guy ever and he just went not for me this not for me not for me this it was what Sam did I imagine at Bolton and we had so much success there he was going to go to the next club and do exactly the same thing isn't he we had like a few where the managers just get obsessed with certain things like Mancini was so superstitious it was a joke so before we played you in the semi-final I think it was in 2010 I think semi and we went the wrong way from the hotel went the wrong way took us Forever again, I think we only got there 45 minutes for kickoff and I'm 15-1 So what did we have to do stayed at the same hotel to take the same route for the final?
46:56But one now yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah was it the one of the famous skulls tackles it wasn't great Guess we're murder skulls, isn't it? The only other one... What did it go away with? It didn't go away with it. Come on, James. No, it was just... Jürgen was one where we had... When we used to go to the Far East, we went on tour time. So we wouldn't be on their time. We wouldn't be on English time. We'd be somewhere in the middle, so the jet lag wasn't as bad. Yeah. Tour time. Tour time. So the tour time turned out that we were up straight away for a running session before breakfast, which tour time made 12.30, 1 o 'clock in the afternoon.
47:35I've never heard that before. Hottest part of the day. So we're doing this run around this track. Hottest part of the day. It's like 1 ,000 degrees. Got on the bus and he wouldn't let us have aircon on. Oh, my God. So we've had to go like half an hour stuck in traffic. Like, everyone's melting. No aircon. I don't know if it was because we thought we were going to get colds or something else. Yeah, so we had like 45 minutes back to the hotel. Everyone's dying. That's unbelievable. Imagine that. I've never done a tour time, have you? I've heard stay on English time. Yeah, stay on English time. It was mental for all the people, you know, doing all the commercial stuff and that.
48:05They're working off the time for local time. I want to organise that. Tour time, England. It was insane. It was great. What a work. Yeah. Brilliant. That prize guy are back again, and we're doing our own giveaway completely free for one lucky winner. Do you want the true GBF experience? Trust me, I'm here every Monday. You don't. You're better off being on that side of the camera. It's too stressful in here. Well, we're giving away a GBF Weekender. Two tickets to watch United vs Spurs on Saturday 10th October, two nights in hotel football,£500 spending money and the exclusive chance to come and watch us record GBF in person on Monday 12th October.
48:58So the prize is about watching football. I'm going to ask you a little bit about your experiences of watching football because obviously, lads, you've been there in the midst of the game, but I'm taking you back to when you were fans of the game. What's your first memory of watching football? What was the first game? Was it live or was it on the telly? Well, it probably would have been the telly, wouldn't it? But I think as far as the live one, I was a Man United fan. My dad took me to United probably once maybe. We couldn't afford to go. And I think it was against Chelsea. and you remember the tunnel underneath?
49:31It used to go out, it was packed and it kicked off. It was all fighting. There was a lot of hooliganism around at the time. I remember my dad picking me up and sprinting off. My shoes fell off. Didn't have any shoes. Brilliant. Trainers fell off and that was probably my first experience. How quickly did he pick you up for your trainers to come off? It was a bit quick. Remember Chelsea? He was a big fan. He was a size 10 at the time, his trainers. Probably cheap. Chelsea's were the headhunters. Yeah, the hooligans. and under that tunnel at United it was like cramped parts and I was a kid it's mad isn't it when you think back to football I don't remember the game don't remember the game what was yours?
50:10again I remember it being match of the day and watching it on TV but the first time I went to a game I went with my cousin took me to Old Trafford I can't remember if it was a game but I just remember it being like when you get hooked on something but I was never one for going to matches when I was a kid I was more I loved playing football with my mates I'd like playing for your school team, play for your Sunday league team. And it was always out of our price range going to Old Trafford. It was never... Did you ever go in that bit in the Stratford and like the top bit? I'm pretty sure you used to have like a little seated section at the top.
50:42I can't remember. I'll tell you where I used to go quite a bit. I used to go to watch City quite a bit as well because I had a lot of friends that were older than me. Well, basically, you used to go where you could get to. Yeah. And I had like three or four mates that were a lot older than me. So they were like three or four years older than me. So they were allowed out and I weren't allowed to go anywhere on my own without them. So I got dragged to Main Road quite a few times. What was the point when you were playing the game, just local teams and all the rest of it, where you thought, oh, I might give this a will?
51:13I think it's just something that's been better than you. I mean, I've no school, your dad played football, my dad played football, and your uncles do. You just get dragged to Sunday League games, then you go to the pub to have a Coke and some Chris, then go on. It becomes your lifestyle, And then obviously you start playing yourselves and you realize it's, and I say to my kids when they were younger, it's not about being great at something. I think team sport is massive for friendships and building relationships. And when you get into a, we were fortunate enough to obviously meet when we were young and grow up together and win things.
51:44But that was like the pinnacle, but being part of a team and playing football as a kid at school and Manchester boys, and there's nothing better really. Probably not until your 15, 16, where you think you might have a chance to play football. and still that is very young but that's when you're leaving school and it's your job. Are you aware of the grown-ups around you going, he's going to be all right or were you oblivious to all that? No, I don't think I listened to that. Yeah. I think back in our day, I think it might have changed a bit now but we was always put down as kids. Yeah. I don't remember ever, my dad ever saying he was brilliant today.
52:17Never. I don't think he's ever said that to me. Don't be too big-headed. Yeah, you get in the car. You think you've made it. No, you haven't. You get off the bus and you go and meet your dad and they go, you're rubbish today. Tough love. Tough love. Yeah, so I just think we never had that. So for a chance, for all those lovely goodies, head over to thatprizeguy.co.uk forward slash competitions forward slash good bad football weekender to enter our free GBF weekender giveaway. This episode is brought to you by Xclad. Lads, I know we had the big thing about the boiled eggs, but I've got you a little gift here to elevate your cooking game.
52:56The old X-Cod pans. Now, oh, I've got some of these home-weighty. Look at that. Beautiful, that, innit? Paul, feel the weight of that. Cook you a duck all around in there. Oh, that's like a NASA pan to me. NASA. Look at the engineering on that, lads. It's got a lovely curve there. Do you know what's brilliant about these and all? Proper non-stick. Non-stick, yeah. You can flip a pancake in them. no trouble whatsoever so they're ex-clad pans you've got the performance of a stainless steel pan but with the convenience of a non-stick what a time to be alive lads you get a lovely sear sear oh what's that you flick it inside and pull it back like that that looked uncomfortable though do you use a pan like that?
53:45yes no there's no way he does that I'm telling you There's no way you do that. Do you do that? Everyone does that. Who holds a pan like that? Only on an omelette. So you're at your house and you're like that. No, that's what you do. That's more like you. Oh, it's really sour sauce. Snog in this pan of beans. However, all joking aside, going to make me some a lovely dinner tonight with this. And what's brilliant about these, dishwasher safe, metal utensil safe, and even oven safe too, lads. They're a triple threat, these pans. And they come with a lifetime warranty. Hey, new season, new pans. Get the pans that work as hard as you do.
54:28And if you upgrade to the Xclads, and this is a treat. For a limited time, our listeners get 10 % off with our exclusive link. Upgrade to Xclad and make everyday cooking easier. Paul, give them the code. Head to xclad.co.uk forward slash good bad football. That's Hexclad H-E-X-C-L-A-D Dot co dot UK Forward slash good bad football That's G-O-O-V Ha ha ha ha Ha ha ha ha Offer excludes bundles and other items Already on sale Support our show and let them know we sent you This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome You think you know a browser But Gemini and Chrome, that's new It can help you with practically anything on the web like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks.
55:24Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required. Compatibility and availability varies 18+. Nationwide is so much more than a great insurance company. They're one of America's largest financial services companies, just like I'm so much more than quarterback Peyton Manning. I'm also Peyton Manning. insurance and financial services together, it's a masterpiece. Peyton Manning does it again. For your insurance and financial needs, Nationwide is on your side. Nationwide Investment Services Corporation, Amber Finra, Columbus, Ohio.
56:05Star Wars, The Mandalorian and Grogu is now streaming on Disney+. What are you waiting for? Hop on. The must-see galactic adventure comes home on Disney+. This is the way. Our only chance is to work together. I like this kid. Always wear your seatbelt. Star Wars The Mandalorian and Grogu. Now streaming on Disney+. Read PG-13.
56:36James, as we've got you on, pal, the mods have come up with something here called Who Wants to Quiz a Millie on Earth? Exactly. very creative that's what we're dealing with James that's the level we aspire to on this podcast not bad yeah not bad that's us right this is where our viewers we've given the opportunity to ask you some questions so this is from David first he's a Manchester United fan and Paul and Nicky feel free to interject on any of these did United ever make a move for yourself and if they did, would you have joined? They did, to be fair, yeah. When I was leaving City. But obviously not.
57:23No, I wouldn't have entertained it. Did you speak to them? Not really. No, I just... Not really? Well, no. Yeah, I didn't. Yeah, I think I did make my mind up about Liverpool. Yeah, I just... I mean, you talk about a Leeds player, City player. Obviously, you haven't been to Liverpool then, but then going to United is... Yeah, that's... That's a tricky one, isn't it? Yeah. Right, okay. I just couldn't. Respect the club, obviously, but just Leeds fans through and through and dislike them. What about when Smudgy won? Smudgy did it, yeah. Smudgy did, yeah. They hated him for it, didn't they? Did they?
57:55They hated him, yeah. I think there's still a massive... Can you get a ticket? For what he did for Leeds, I think. This is from Chris. He's a Brighton fan. Is it true that James only speaks to his kids in Spanish? for the first three years of the life I did, yeah. Is that real? When I saw that, I thought it was a fucking nonsense. What were that? Well, I just learned Spanish because, you know, I go over there a lot and was impressed when people could speak two languages. So when I was at City, I had a tutor and did it every week and learned the language and then, yeah, got like kids books in Spanish and English and just did it in Spanish.
58:34Can your kids speak Spanish now? No, they do it at school, yeah. My daughter was brilliant and she could understand everything, but she never spoke it. Yeah. And me lad was lazy and he'd go, what? I'm speaking English. And they do Spanish at school, so I'm hoping it's in there and it'll come out. But yeah, my daughter, she couldn't speak at that point. She was probably like 14 months or something. She could walk and not speak or something. And I asked her to do something in Spanish, didn't point or anything, and she did it. So she understood everything, but she just never spoke it. Was it always in your head?
59:05Was it just because of your teammates? You thought, you know what, actually, I'll show a bit of will in here with some of the lads I've played with. Or did you always have in the back of your mind you might have played in Spain? Yeah, I think that was a possibility. I like Spain, spend a lot of time out there. And it's a good skill to have, obviously. Yeah, I think I was never against it never happened in the end. I always had a good option in England where I thought it was the right move and hopefully I always chose the right move. But yeah, it was always something that I fancied playing abroad for sure.
59:34Joe, Man United fan. When did James become aware of the boring James Milner account on Twitter? And what's the most boring thing you actually do? This account, by the way, it's got a life of its own. I remember seeing that myself. Have you seen this account? I don't see it twice. It's someone who's saying they're James Milner. It's a parody account, but it's all like, got up today but can't you get that taken down if it's not you no I don't think anyone believes it's actually James Osden did they at the beginning maybe I think people thought it was me I think it was like we were pre-season with City so that's how long ago it's been like 13 14 years and there was a boring Barry at the start as well so that's why I didn't know if he would want it lads but we never found out it was I think Mika Richards contacted to find out yeah a bit of fun did you ever read any in like some of them yeah I mean they got pretty repetitive I mean we're 13 years in now there's only time so many times to protect bins out and stuff like that ain't it until bins out today and you know yeah brush the dog hair and whatever but yeah okay Luke Man City fan what was it like sharing a dressing room with Balotelli yeah it was it was like having a 11, 12 year old in there maybe too old like if we If, say, we were a group of lads in dressing room just having a chat and he was in there and no attention was in, he'd just do something completely stupid just to people look at him, make a noise, like, do something random, smash something up, just so he got, like, attention.
1:01:17That's, yeah, just completely... Is it fireworks in his house or something? Fireworks. Oh, yeah. The old Carrington training ground, there was, like, a window at the top where there was a dartboard and the gym was below and he'd be throwing darts at people as they're walking through the gym and stuff like that. Oh, my God. Do you think he ever reached his full potential? Nah. No. How good was he? Yeah, he was. I mean, yeah, he could finish. He's probably one of the best penalty takers I've seen, to be fair. I've never seen him miss one in training for years. Because he was one of the first to really watch the keeper.
1:01:50And if someone does that well, you can't stop it, can you? If the keeper moves, he's going the other way. If he don't move, he's got a hard enough shot. Is he a stutter or is he a straight places? No, he just walked and looked at the keeper. and if the keeper moved, he put it in the other corner. If the keeper didn't move, he had a hard enough side foot that the keeper was never getting it. And then he actually moved to Milan, I think, and he missed his first penalty. I couldn't believe it. But Harty must have been in net for about a thousand penalties to him. I think he saved two. It must have been frustrating for you at the time.
1:02:21He was a nightmare. Because so much attention went on him and things like that. And distractions that you didn't need at times, critical times. he'd come in in a camouflaged Bentley, which he actually backed into my car and I watched him do it and then denied it in front of me. But yeah, you know, to be fair, I found him all right. Like he was all right with me. Like if I ever gave it out to him or anything like that, he could say I was doing what I was asking him to do. So he didn't really complain. To be fair, I always got on with him. Okay, he was crazy, but scored some important goals for City and famous, obviously, the famous assist, isn't he?
1:03:00He's the only assist he got. Yeah. And I think Mancini had a little bit of an understanding with him, didn't he? A little bit. They had a fight there. Yeah, I was going to say. Yeah, but I think it was like one of them love-hate things with them two. Yeah, 100%. Do you know what I mean? It wasn't like he wasn't having him. Oh, no, yeah. Did Mancini used to go into working on a bike? He did, yeah. But then I think he had his personal assistant driving behind him so if he got tired he could put his car on. Really? That is golden, isn't it? How great is that? Just in case I get knackered. Oh, Ryan's died there.
1:03:37Just follow me. My favourite Balotelli thing I'd heard is he got pulled over by the police in Manchester and he had a massive wad of money on him and they went, hey, what are you doing with all that money on you? And he went, I'm rich.
1:03:56It's like, fair enough. I'm rich. It's a bell said that, isn't it? Harry, Arsenal fam. What was the worst day you had in football, excluding match day?
1:04:14Worst day? Yeah, I've got an example here. I don't know if Harry's put this in. He says, was it when Colo Torre put you through a fence? Ah, yeah, I had broken ribs at the time. yeah two broken ribs I've been playing with them for like a few months and lads all knew and he just decided to wallop me in training and like yeah straight I was getting injections for games and that lasted for about an hour and then it wore off and you've done well playing with broken ribs that is the worst yeah it's horrible I brought my white out of lane at the whole end I brought my newcastle is it in a challenge yeah I couldn't I just thought I couldn't breathe I couldn't I couldn't breathe I was like no you're going like never tell you when you're getting shooting pains laugh or sneeze you're in big trouble but it was the same guy, we played a game at City and I think I had six stitches in my head, broke two ribs and then I was waiting for my car after the game, they bring cars down and I was there a bit and I was like, surely it's mine now, I've been waiting a while there, I thought something's not right here and the person who brought it down had ploughed it into a bollard
1:05:20that was a bad day got a few more of these Adam Celtic fan what's the biggest bollocking you ever got erm oh I don't know tough one that I think I remember one I can't imagine you getting bollocked not much I remember one you might have been playing actually when Glenn Roder gave me one Glenn Roder yeah Glenn Roder gave me one erm for being lazy and I was thinking afterwards and I was like doesn't sound like me that and then he pulled me the day after and said erm sorry erm I just had to dig one and someone out to like put a bit of presence on it and obviously didn't want to dig out any big guys.
1:05:58So I ended up getting it. So that was one. And then I remember Jürgen. Jürgen was having a go and said a couple of things back and he smashed his hand down on the thing in the middle of the dressing room and said, will you shut the fuck up? Was you an answer backer? No, not normally. Not normally, I'd take it. But I think if it was a point, it's not just like, you know sometimes if it's like whatever there's not to answer that but if it's a tactical yeah or if there's a reason behind it I wasn't just I'd never just go back because you can't say anything to me I'm never wrong it wasn't one of them it was like I believe whatever it was I believe this was happening because of this there are some players who like that though aren't there they're never ever wrong no it's never their fault really do you want to name any?
1:06:44Peter Schmeichel Peter Schmeichel I was going to say no he's coming out from a similar part of the world I played with at Villa and they were the same never them it was never our fault yeah as a leader the amount of times I used to get as well I used to get off the mind you you was an arguer as well you put one more word out of you and you sold and I'd go fucking fucking fucking you was never wrong I was always wrong but I used to I used to get bollocks every single week just to come from I just look at you I just get eye contact but is it like what James said though he knew there were certain players that he could put it on to show the others no it wasn't with me it was because he brought us up from 12.
1:07:22He thought he could just bollock us and he wanted to really. I got a bollocking off Eric Harrison who was like one of our heroes. I'll never forget it. He brought me off an A-team game at the Cliff and I scored two goals. He brought me off. I said, you, you're coming off. The lights are on but no one's in. He said to me, bollocking me. And I'm thinking, I've just scored two goals. Next morning, a bit like James, get brought in to his office. I'm thinking, here we go. and he wouldn't answer Eric back at 16 and he said I'm really sorry I thought you was Simon Davis you got him mixed up you got him mixed up you got him mixed up one of the players I was like oh right because I remember at the night time my dad's saying well you must have done because like back in then days the parents used to always think the coaches or teachers were always right and it was like well you must have done something wrong he brought you up I said I don't know what I've done wrong I was thinking I was playing well we had some bollocking bollocking stuff Eric he chased me on a pitch once in Switzerland on the 16th tournament Speaking about Wrong player Kiddo He obviously Now Well he brought Wrong player off When he was Assistant at City Didn't he Yeah Mancini was sat there And they've done sub And he's like Must have been off Talking to a player And he's come and sat down And I can't remember Was it Nasri or something And he's come over And he's like Triple take And what the hell Are you doing here Kiddo's like This fumbling Too late To talk about it Wrong player off Kiddo's best fumblers When you know You used to get We used to have A little sitting room In the Like the players lounge Before the games And you'd be having a coffee and stuff waiting for an hour and a half to get there too early and you just they come down thinking they shout Nicky the manager once you know you're dropped or you're not playing on the scores and on the way out Kido will go out to him it's a joke this you should be playing you should be having a word with him he'll be winding you all up to go into it the best one was actually in a dressing room where the team Kido knows the team he knows who's playing so the manager names the team and you look over at Kido no I'm not playing I can't believe that I thought he was playing behind the gaffer's fucking bed.
1:09:19I thought he was playing and he was going knock on his door. He's like that, knock on his fucking door, knock on his door. You fucking bastard. Here's one Matthew, Southampton fan. What's your death row meal? Oh, good question. Start of Maine's dessert. Start, tempura prawns. Oh, maybe. Sweet chilli sauce on the side. Yeah, I'll say, yeah. Maine would have to be a decent burger. like you know like not a crappy burger like a proper burger yeah it sounds good um and chips never heard burger on someone's death row me no like one of them's where it's like triple pate cheese good solid yeah good fries and what's the dessert uh apple crumble and custard oh yeah in fact just the crumble eat the fucking apple you're not a steak eat the apple oh I'm I used to do my head in that you know you'd go up for desserts and like
1:10:24what's yours what death row meal i don't know well i'll tell you what i'll come back What did I say last week? I said something last week in the food. This is probably fucking chips and egg. Sunday roast. Spam and egg. Oh, we did that in the quiz. It reminded me of Sunday roast. Yeah, I don't mind the roast. What's your starter? Prong cocktail. Oh, I'm a prawn cocktail as well. I like a bit of soup. Soup and a bread roll. What flavour? Tomato. Tomato? Cream of? Can't have tomato. Cream of, yeah. Death round meal, can't you? No, I wouldn't. Can't have a bit of orange skulls. I know. Don't worry about that.
1:10:58There's plenty of them. Roast beef dinner. and then pudding jam roly poly no apple oh my god that's good I like trifle though as well do you like trifle I love a trifle but the one with two lady fingers in the bottom I don't like the fucking fruit I like the sponge in the bottom you know what I mean yeah the old sponge fingers weirdly the cheaper the better for me same with prawn cocktails like them with them is there any fucking need for that there's fucking socks as well you put socks on next time for fuck's sake how's me asking a lovely question You turn into a fucking personal attack. Even you've jumped in.
1:11:34You won't do that at the fucking thing. Did you used to make the bird's trifle in the box? Did you make that one? No, I just buy that cheap one from supermarket. Ready to go, peel the lid off. Yeah, that's what that was. What was? The bird's trifle. No, you fucking made a bird's trifle yourself. Yeah. Yeah, I'm saying you buy one when it's a go. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Listen, there's no way on God's green earth you're making a bird's trifle. You've never made a bird's trifle in your life. I fucking made loads of Burstrifles Have you? I have made loads of Burstrifles The best trifles, Marks and Spencers I don't care what anyone says It's unbelievable Do you like the Madagascan vanilla and all that?
1:12:13No, that's what they do at Marks It's the proper good gear They call it probably the best trifle ever Yeah I have made a Burstrifle, I've made loads Alright No one's saying anything, go So you obviously get the cubes of jelly, don't you? so you have to separate them, put them in the bottom of your glass bowl, hot water, so I don't know about that much maybe, wait for it to set, and while you're waiting for it to set, you're doing the custard and you're mixing the green topping. He's missed the fingers. Oh, sorry, yeah, the sponge, you had to break them off, remember? What sponge are you using?
1:12:48It's in the packet, what do you mean? The fingers are packets. No, they're not. Yes, they are. In a bird's triangle, it's the custard powder and then the cream powder, isn't it? Yeah. You still get the fingers? You still get the fingers? In the box? No, I never knew that. You live and learn. Of course you do. You don't buy it separately, do you? I don't like trifle. You don't like fucking trifle? That's what I say. You don't like breathing. What do you put on top, though? Hundreds and thousands? Always. Hundreds and thousands. I've got one fiscal. That's how you make it. Trust me. Instead of putting them fingers in it.
1:13:18I've not done it for years, lad. Put Twix in it. A Twix. Oh, Nicky. I'm telling you. Fucking hell are you doing this? I'm a Twix. You put Twix in a fucking trifle? Is there any spongy things that I'm making? No, that's weird. Just try it. That's horrific. Try it. No, it's horrific. It doesn't even work. I always used to struggle getting the consistency right of the dream topping. Mary Berry over there. It's dead hard to do it. It's getting thick enough. And you had to whisk it for ages. You didn't have like electric whisk. Do you know what? At first I thought he would take your piss, but I think he does other things.
1:13:46I think he does me. What was your death row one? Prawn cocktail, cheap one. Orange sauce. Orange sauce? Orange sauce. Duck a little orange. Prawn cocktail? Yeah. Not orange. Orange sauce. It's Mary Rose sauce. What's it called? Yeah, that's what it's called. I can't fucking believe. Where have you been all your life? You two. What have you been eating? Oh, you're wrong, mate. You're wrong again. No, no, Prong Cocktail sauce isn't pink. It's orange. It's pink. Have you seen the jars of the Foz and Island dressing? Pink. Have you seen it? What colour is that? Pink. That's not Mary Rose sauce. No, that's still pink.
1:14:17It's orange. It's pink. Google that. Mods. I'd say pink. Yeah, we'd all say pink apart from you. Well James You lost me when you said What colour is that there? Fucking orange Which one? What's that? Pink That's fucking orange By the way The only one with glasses on is trying to tell us what we can see That's fucking orange That's pink You need to go back to the opticians The prawn's orange and the sauce is pink Prawns are red aren't they Anyhow prawn cocktail right leave the colour leave the colour it's causing too much controversy with buttered white bread for dipping in brown bread brown bread in triangles yeah triangles yeah shredded iceberg lettuce yes and then main on with Nicky roast dinner mash roasties you can't have mash on a roast dinner you can yeah you don't have mash on a roast dinner we've had this conversation before you don't you have roast potato you don't have mash You think you know someone.
1:15:23You don't have both. You don't have double spuds. You don't have that. No, you do. You don't. I can't believe you can call yourself a fucking northerner. I love mashed potatoes, but you don't have it on a Sunday, don't you? It's too much. It's too much. I'll find you a Sunday roast. Probably have at some point, but I'd probably say roast. Yeah, it's roast, yeah. You're right. Just roast potatoes. Yeah, roast potatoes, carrots, parsnips. As long as you've got Yorkshire pudding on there. Bit of white cabbage on there. Yorkies, Yorkies are the ones. I've been in Yorkshire for a start as well. Big one.
1:15:49Yeah. do you make your own pigs in blankets I'm used to it oh fantastic pigs in blankets I love a pig in a blanket you can keep them parsnips you've had a few of them haven't you no need for that and same as apple crumble and custard although when he said jam roly poly sticky toffee pudding that was not do you know who does a good jam roly poly that Aunt Bessie yeah she does she works her fingers to the fucking bone I don't know the Yorkshire puddings as well I've got them stocked up at home but Ant Bessie's Jan Rolly Polly with Ambrosia Death and Custard we've lost James we've lost him fucking shit fuck are these three on about anyway I don't like trifle we've been fucking arguing for five minutes when they were kicking me up in air all those years playing for United I never thought I'd be talking to them about trifle I must admit Life, eh?
1:16:49It's a funny one. Hey, James, an absolute pleasure. Thanks for joining us. I love your company. It's been amazing. James, if you could regale our subscribers with please watch The Good, The Bad and The Football in Spanish. Por favor, puedes ver el bueno, el mal y el fútbol en español.
1:17:11We're clapping that. Could have said anything. you could be working for Gary Neville's lot whatever you do don't watch that El Overlap por favor that's it for this week's The Good, The Bad and The Football powered by Midnight the betting app that's built different
1:17:44Nationwide is so much more than a great insurance company. They're one of America's largest financial services companies, just like I'm so much more than quarterback Peyton Manning. I'm also Peyton Manning. Insurance and financial services together, it's a masterpiece. Peyton Manning does it again. For your insurance and financial needs, Nationwide is on your side. Nationwide Investment Services Corporation, member FINRA, Columbus, Ohio.
From the publisher
Paul, Nicky & Paddy welcome James Milner onto the show to react to the controversial Manchester derby, while James discusses the brilliance of Jurgen Klopp & Mohamed Salah, sharing a dressing room with Mario Balotelli and other incredible stories from his career.
The Good, The Bad & The Football is sponsored by Midnite, the betting app that's built different: https://www.midnite.com/
18+, please gamble responsibly.
─────────────────────────────
🏆 LINKS
Enter for the chance to win a GBF Weekender FOR FREE: https://thatprizeguy.co.uk/competitions/goodbadfootballweekender
Check out other prize giveaways at https://thatprizeguy.co.uk
Find your forever cookware @hexclad and get 10% off at hexclad.co.uk/GoodBadFootball Offer excludes bundles and other items already on sale. #hexcladpartner
______________________________________________
📩 GOT A QUESTION FOR THE LADS?
Email the team at: questions@goodbadfootball.co.uk
─────────────────────────────
📑CHAPTERS
─────────────────────────────
📲 FOLLOW THE GOOD, THE BAD & THE FOOTBALL
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@goodbadfootballpod
IG: https://www.instagram.com/goodbadfootballpod
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/goodbadfootballpod
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@goodbadfootballpod
─────────────────────────────
#football #premierleague #footballpodcast #manchesterunited #goodbadfootball #paulscholes #nickybutt #paddymcguinness
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
