In short
The episode draws on BBC Witness History to cover (1) Norwegian teacher resistance to Nazi propaganda during WWII, (2) Ireland’s 1981 Stardust nightclub fire and its aftermath, (3) how cable modem technology enabled home internet, (4) India’s rise in remote call centers, plus shorter segments on Paralympian Trisha Zorn-Hudson and the San Jose shipwreck discovery.
Guests/backgrounds
Tim O’Callaghan (BBC guide to Norway story); Dr Rachel Pistol (WWII historian, University of Southampton); Antoinette Keegan (Stardust survivor, speaking to Jen Dale); Ruzbe Yassini (inventor of early cable modem system, speaking to Guy Kilty); Pramod Bhasin (call-center pioneer, speaking to Rebecca Kesby); Trisha Zorn-Hudson (American Paralympic swimmer, speaking to Matt Pintus); Rachel Naylor (San Jose story, speaking to BBC).
Key claims/notable examples
Norway’s teachers refused Nazi education demands; 12,000 of 14,000 refused Quisling’s union; some were beaten and jailed. Stardust: 48 died; 2024 jury found “unlawfully killed,” citing electrical fault in a hot press, flammable bar décor, failed emergency lighting, and unprepared staff. Yassini: used existing coax cable to enable two-way data; first success shown via “dove” file transfer. Bhasin: early call centers used cardboard partitions and saris; overcame unreliable phone lines via a satellite link; accent/cultural training for US/Europe customers.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VONorwegian Teacher Resistance in WWII
3:15 to 12:05
Explore how Norwegian teachers resisted Nazi propaganda during the occupation.
“when it was occupied by Nazi Germany during the Second World War.”
Women in WWII Resistance
12:06 to 16:19
Discuss the significant role of women in resistance efforts during WWII.
“Dr Rachel Pistol is a historian specialising in the Second World War from the University of Southampton in the UK and is with us now.”
Transition to Stardust Nightclub Tragedy
16:19 to 16:33
A brief introduction to a significant tragedy in Ireland's history.
“And don't forget that there is a wealth of Nazi resistance stories included in our Second World War collection on the website.”
Survivor's Account of the Stardust Fire
16:33 to 22:39
Hear the harrowing story of Antoinette Keegan, a survivor of the Stardust Nightclub fire.
“Next, we reflect on a tragedy which has reverberated across the decades in Ireland.”
The Aftermath and Inquest
22:39 to 24:38
Discussing the consequences of the Stardust fire and the subsequent investigations.
“Two empty beds, two empty chairs in the kitchen, and then the yogurts that Mary loved.”
Technological Milestone in Connectivity
26:37 to 28:00
A look into how an engineer's innovation brought internet access to homes in the US.
“But first, we have a significant milestone in the evolution of the technology which has resulted in our highly interconnected digital world.”
Roosberg's Journey in Telecommunications
28:00 to 35:18
Learn about Roosberg's transition from aspiring doctor to tech innovator.
“No country had contributed to the civilization and mankind before 19th century more than Persia in Iran.”
Introduction to Future Topics
35:18 to 35:30
A segue into the next segment focusing on the impact of telecom advances.
“that people could use from their home and it was just a beautiful moment for all of us.”
Pramod's Pioneering Call Center
35:30 to 42:04
Explore the inception and growth of India's outsourcing call center industry.
“And Ruzbe's inventive ideas on telecommunication lead us nicely into our next item.”
The Impact of Call Centers on Indian Economy
42:04 to 43:54
Explore how call centers transformed the Indian economy and society.
“If I say, hello, this is Pramod, they don't know who the hell that is.”
Show all 20 chapters
Introduction to Sporting Witness
43:54 to 44:18
Transition to the segment about a decorated Paralympian.
“He was speaking to Rebecca Kesby in 2019.”
Trisha Zorn-Hudson: A Paralympic Legend
44:18 to 46:00
Learn about the achievements of swimmer Trisha Zorn-Hudson.
“The 1988 Paralympics have opened in Seoul.”
Overcoming Challenges: Trisha's Journey
46:00 to 48:04
Hear how Trisha faced obstacles and achieved greatness in swimming.
“Trisha Zorn-Hudson was born in Orange, Southern California in 1964.”
The Rise of a Champion
48:04 to 49:38
Discover Trisha's remarkable medal haul and legacy in sports.
“Tricia's success continued as she won a further six medals four years later at the 1984 New York Paralympics.”
Advocacy and Change in Paralympic Sports
49:38 to 52:07
Uncover Trisha's efforts to improve conditions for para-athletes.
“Tricia decided to try and use her success in Nepal to help lobby for more support for her fellow para-athletes.”
Trisha's Career Reflections
52:07 to 52:42
Reflect on the bittersweet aspects of Trisha's impressive career.
“Yes, it was frustrating, but, you know, there is the right time and the right place for things to happen.”
Transition to Shipwreck Discovery
52:42 to 53:07
Shift focus to the tale of a significant shipwreck discovery.
“Finally this week, we're in the ever fascinating world of the shipwreck.”
The Hunt for the San Jose Shipwreck
53:07 to 56:00
Explore the captivating story behind the search for the San Jose shipwreck.
“It's September 2011 and Colombian President Juan Manuel Santos is at a reception at the Colombian Embassy in New York.”
The Discovery of the San Jose Galleon
56:00 to 1:01:03
Learn about the discovery of the San Jose Galleon and the controversies surrounding it.
“and so they started searching with some submarines.”
The Global Story Preview
1:02:49 to 1:03:19
Preview of an upcoming interview with financial guru Dave Ramsey.
“Delivery available on qualifying orders.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.
0:30up at Whole Foods Market. A beautifully designed Squarespace website is the difference between thinking about photography school and selling your portraits online. It's the difference between giving away those cookies you just made for free and running your cookie empire. A beautifully designed Squarespace website is the difference between having a movie reviewing hobby and a movie reviewing career. Squarespace, because no matter what you're into, a website makes it real. Use offer code DIFFERENCE for 50 % off select plans. Terms and conditions apply. Imagine being here. Scientists have made the atomic bomb.
1:08The first one was dropped on a Japanese city this morning. Here. During the meeting, Mr. Mandela was informed of the government's decision regarding his release. And here. Witnesses have spoken of a wall of water that swept coastlines in Sri Lanka, Indonesia, Thailand. Hear from the people who were there. He heard me praying while he was shooting and he just stopped. He said, I'm not going to. I'm going to leave you here to tell the story. Knowing that you have a spy and that you're following a spy, it doesn't get any cooler than that. Witness History brings you first-hand accounts. Merkel gets up and says, I'm going.
1:42And Tusk says, I'm locking the door. Nobody's leaving. You're reaching a compromise or you're not leaving this room. Was it shopping carts that made you rich? Well, they didn't make me poor. Listen now. Search for Witness History wherever you get your BBC podcasts.
2:06Hello and welcome to the History Hour from the BBC World Service with me, Max Pearson, the past brought to life by those who were there. This week, as we take you back through the stories which are featured on Witness History, a tragedy which shocked Ireland in the 1980s, the Stardust nightclub fire. The last thing that I remembered was the smoke was so thick, it was actually born in our throat, it couldn't breathe, and the fumes actually knocked the whole of us out. Also the discovery of the San Jose, one of the most sought-after shipwrecks of all time. Plus the man who connected the world by inventing the cable modem.
2:44The bankers, the cable industry said, you're crazy. Nobody's going to solve those problems. And even if you solve it, nobody cares because who wants to have data connected at their home? And how increased connectivity led to India becoming a powerhouse in the business of remote call centers. The first call center experiment was again done in tiny room. Barriers made of cardboard between phones, separators made with saris. That's all coming up later. But we're starting in Norway, when it was occupied by Nazi Germany during the Second World War. There was resistance in the form of fighting and sabotage, but Tim O 'Callaghan has the story of how Norwegian teachers aided their country's resistance by refusing to teach Nazi propaganda to their pupils.
3:32I remember the early morning of that day in April 1940 when the Germans attacked us. That's the voice of Norwegian schoolteacher Mr Rolf Hansen, speaking to the BBC in 1944. Norway was still under occupation at this point but he had managed to escape and was living in the United Kingdom. Before we hear more from him, here is some background for you. The German invasion of Norway began on the 9th of April 1940. This is the BBC Home Service. As listeners to our early morning bulletins will have heard, Norway is at war with Germany.
4:13Norway had tried to stay out of the war up to this point and was caught completely by surprise by the invasion, with the capital Oslo falling to the Nazis almost immediately. Reuter reports that the Norwegian government has left Oslo and is going to Hama in central Norway, and the Oslo radio announces that general mobilisation has been ordered in Norway. Mr Rolf Hansen remembers standing outside his school that day and watching Norway's anti-aircraft guns attempting to bring down German bombers. Three or four boys were standing about in the deserted schoolyard. They came up to me rather bewildered.
4:50Teacher, isn't there going to be any school today? I couldn't help smiling at their diffident devotion to duty and I told them they could go home. As the Nazis invaded, the leader of Norway's largely unsuccessful fascist party, Vidkun Kvisling, saw an opportunity. Russian women and Russian men. I'm going to take this explanation I read at about 8.30. Rushing to the studios of the country's national radio station, he ordered all resistance against the Nazi invaders to stop and declared himself the leader of a new national government. However, this was news to the Germans, who sent Nazi official Joseph de Boven to serve as the head of a new occupying government.
5:33Quisling did manage to retain some influence. By the end of 1940, he was serving as an acting prime minister under Terboven, and many members of the cabinet were from his party. When I let my thoughts go back to those first days of the German occupation, it's like recalling a remote and naive childhood. I didn't know the Germans then. I didn't realise how little place schools, in the ordinary civilised sense of the word, would have in Hitler's new order. It didn't start at once. It wasn't in the autumn of 1940, after Quislinger got one of his men recognized as Minister of Church and Education, that German-inspired circulars began to pile up on the writing desk of our headmaster.
6:18One of them demanded that Quislinger's portrait should be hung up in the schools. One day, when my pupils and I were trying to clear up some of the intricacies of English grammar, one of the local Quisling stormtroopers suddenly barged into the room. Under his arm he had a large-scale photo of Quisling and he proceeded to climb onto a desk and nail it up on the wall. I knew the boy. He was an old pupil of mine and a difficult one at that. We went on with our grammar as if it didn't exist. He stood on the desk beside the portrait of Quisling for a while scowling at the faces of my boys and girls before he jumped down again.
6:57Just you wait and see, he bawled. Quisling was seen as a traitor by many Norwegians. When the door had slammed behind him, one of the girls got up. We can't have that picture here, she said indignantly. Father says Quisling is a traitor and crack brain too. I just nodded and said I'd better speak to the other teachers about it so that we didn't muddle things up by acting each in his own way. but when I came back to the same classroom for the next lesson the picture wasn't there anymore. Some days later the caretaker told me he'd seen it in the dustbin. Quisling eventually achieved the aim of his initial coup attempt and was appointed the head of a puppet government at the start of February 1942.
7:40Mr. Rolf Hansen said there was a concerted effort by Quisling and the German occupiers to force Norwegian schools to change the way they taught. I shall never forget the day when a certain Quisling County propaganda leader came to give all the children of my school a lecture on the rotten state of affairs in our decayed democracy. We'd only just been given a new Quisling headmaster, a little nincompoop who had got the old headmaster arrested and wangled himself into the job to make up for as many miserable girls as teacher in classes he couldn't discipline. When the lecture started, he had cautiously taken up his position at the back of the room.
8:19He stood watching us with eyes not yet quite sober after last night's revelling in some German mess. At one of the numerous climaxes in his lecture, the propaganda leader bellered out over our heads. We don't want decadent democracy. We want leaders, and our leaders are the able men, the strong men. At these words, boys and girls spontaneously turned round and looked at the new headmaster. The words of the propaganda leader were drowned in laughter, and soon after the meeting had completely broken down. The Quisling government believed that Norway would embrace Nazi ideology if the education system was controlled.
8:58The authorities wanted us to adopt what they called a positive national policy, which meant that we should slander our king, prove to our pupils that our constitution was no good and extol Quisling. We never did. Quisling did his best to crush our resistance. In February 1942, he issued a decree ordering all Norwegian teachers to be members of the Quisling Union of Teachers and assist at the activities of the compulsory Quisling Youth Service. 12 ,000 of Norway's 14 ,000 teachers refused point blank to have anything to do with the union. A month later, more than 1 ,000 teachers were knocked about in concentration camps by German policemen.
9:39Some of the teachers held in the camps were forced to work in the remote parts of Norway and Finland for the German war machine. Wages were also withheld and many were expelled from their jobs, but it made no difference to the teachers' resistance. When these teachers came back to their homes half a year later and were released, they had won a victory over Quisling. They are still not members of his union of teachers and his youth service has been a complete failure. One thing is certain, by his action against the teachers, Quisling had, as usual, achieved exactly the opposite of what he intended.
10:17Children, parents and teachers all over the country were now united against him. In Mr. Rolf Hansen's class, there was one boy who joined the youth service, which was intended to be similar to the Hitler youth in Germany. He was completely isolated and boycotted by his classmates. Sometimes when we studied English institutions, he would bring out astonishing bits from German propaganda about the English-Jewish-Marxian-Plutocratic democracy. Otherwise, he hadn't much to contribute. He kept a notebook where he wrote down things I said that he thought were offensive to his party or to the Germans.
10:53To teach in the class with a quizzing youth boy gave me my own small share of the Gestapo nightmare which has now pressed Europe since 1941. Norway was liberated on the 8th of May 1945 as Nazi forces surrendered to the Allies across Europe. Our cameraman was scarcely able to film the scenes of welcome. So great was the delirious reception given to our men. For five years, the free spirit of Norway has never failed or faltered. Quisling was then arrested and sentenced to death. He was killed by firing squad in October 1945. Ahead of that liberation, Mr. Rolf Hansen, speaking in 1944, reflected with pride on the resistance that he and his fellow teachers put up against their invaders.
11:41The Germans conquered the whole of southern Norway in four weeks. But our schools have waged another war against the Germans for four years and have stood our ground all the time. Mr. Rolf Hansen was speaking to the BBC in 1944 and Tim O 'Callaghan was our guide through the story of Norwegian resistance in the Second World War with the help of the BBC archives. Dr Rachel Pistol is a historian specialising in the Second World War from the University of Southampton in the UK and is with us now. So resistance to Nazi occupation in various European countries was a feature of the Second World War and in some cases the occupation was particularly brutal.
12:23I'm thinking of the Warsaw Ghetto but even there resistance was mounted against terrible odds. Absolutely and I'm sure many people will be familiar with the violent uprising that happened in the Warsaw Ghetto. But another act of resistance was the actual documentation of the conditions within the archive. And this is a really strong effort that was made by the Polish Jewish historian and communal organiser Emanuel Ringelblum. And he set up this organisation called Oneg Shabbat, which is Yiddish for joy of the Sabbath. And we estimate that around 50 or 60 people gathered to secretly record information.
13:06They had journalists, economists, teachers, writers, rabbis, and they were collecting diary entries, essays, photos, drawings, official documents, any testimony that showed what was happening in the ghetto and also what was happening to Jews outside the ghetto to try and preserve this historical record for posterity. So documenting what was happening, even amid terrible scenes, was an act of resistance? Absolutely. This is them trying to counter Nazi propaganda and working with other resistance organisations to smuggle this information out. They're also trying to preserve humanity and dignity because they're aware that it's very likely that they will die, but they want to make sure that it's not the Nazis that have the last word, that they actually get to preserve their humanity by pointing out exactly what they had to live through.
13:55Often the story of war is told in terms of fighting men, But to what extent were women integral to resistance to Nazi occupation across Europe? Well, if we take the Special Operation Executive, which was an organisation set up in Britain to try and encourage people to go behind Nazi lines and sabotage radio and telegraph communication, etc. A lot of their agents were actually women. And this is because they were able to travel freely. They weren't expected to work during the day. And there were still so many gender stereotypes at the time that helped keep women above suspicion because the Nazis didn't believe that women would be spies necessarily.
14:41And so this ability to remain conspicuous was a great asset to them as they were parachuted into France and other countries to communicate with the British about what was going on. Is it possible to quantify, though, what difference resistance made in terms of the outcome of the Second World War? Because clearly it would be good for morale of the occupied country to know that there was resistance. But was it pivotal? Well, I'd say it was. If we take the example of Czechoslovakia, you had the Czech government in exile in the UK and a sort of Czech army that was being trained up. And two individuals were taken from that and trained up to do Operation Anthropoid, which was all about assassinating Deputy Reich Protector Reinhard Heydrich, who was the man known for the organisation of Kristallnacht and the final solution.
15:35And he was particularly brutal in Czechoslovakia. He crushed the resistance. He took away any opportunity to express Czech culture. And so you had these two individuals who were sent, Josef Gabczyk and Jan Kubitsch, who were sent in to assassinate Heydrich. And they were successful and they paid for it with their lives. And actually there was a really brutal suppression of two villages that they felt were associated with this. But it was also really positive, ultimately, in terms of helping Czechoslovakia know that they weren't alone in terms of combating the evil of the Nazis. That's Dr Rachel Pistol from the University of Southampton.
16:22And don't forget that there is a wealth of Nazi resistance stories included in our Second World War collection on the website. Find them by going to bbc.com slash witness history. Next, we reflect on a tragedy which has reverberated across the decades in Ireland. For this, we're heading back 45 years to what's widely considered to be the country's deadliest fire. It happened in 1981 at the Stardust Nightclub in Dublin. Jendale has been hearing from a survivor. For these past few days, Ireland has been united, united in its shock and its grief at an appalling loss of life, A loss of life made all the more tragic by the youthfulness of the people who died.
17:06The smoke was so tick and the heat was intense. I remember my last words was, right, oh God, help us. In 1981, Antoinette Keegan is a fun-loving 18-year-old living in Koolock, a suburb in the north of Dublin. She comes from a large family with seven siblings and is very close to sisters Mary, who's 19, and 16-year-old Martina. Martina really wants to go to the Stardust Nightclub on Friday the 13th of February to meet up with her boyfriend ahead of Valentine's Day. She pleaded with my parents for her to go and they said no, that she's too young, but I promised my mother and father I'd look after her.
17:44So the girls get dressed up. Martina even lends Antoinette a white silk blouse to go with her wine-coloured skirt. The Stardust Nightclub is in nearby Artane. It's a two-storey brown brick building with a white facade at the entrance and semi-circular red cloth canopies above the lower floor windows. It was all lit up with stardis on the main entrance. It was like a real fancy building we thought was the best place that you could go to. Inside there are several bars, tiered cinema seating, as well as tables and chairs surrounding the large dance floor. The venue's packed with more than 800 people enjoying a disco competition.
18:23but in the early hours of the 14th of February around 1.30am shortly after the winners are announced Antoinette spots something At one stage one of the songs that was being played was Born To Be Alive and that's when I actually noticed the smoke dripping across the ceiling and I actually thought it was like the DJ had to let off the dry ice effect like the special effects that you do in a disco and then my friend said to me look over there so I looked over where she was pointing and I just saw a small fire, approximately, I'd say, three foot, four foot high. Within minutes, the fire has spread.
19:04When the music stopped and it went in pitch dark, you could hear people screaming, oh, I'm dying, I'm dying, get me out, get me out, and wherever it was coming from, the ceiling, it was dripping, it was like molten, like you would turn a candle upside down and it's like wax falling on you. It was falling onto your face and actually burning into your skin. At this stage, the fire was right across the whole ceiling and the ceiling was starting to collapse. We tried to get to exit 5 and we seen a lot of people panicking and pushing the door and kicking it and they couldn't open it. As chaos ensued, chains across fire escapes impeded their exit.
19:42Fire services found the bodies of some huddled around the locked doors. in the chaos staying close to each other Antoinette and her two sisters try to escape so then we decided we'd hold hands and walk down to the next exit which was exit floor in pitch dark with the smoke and fire all over us we got say about six foot away from the door and then with the panic of everyone rushing and pushing and trying to get out we were pushed to the floor and we were trampled on and we couldn't get up next to all I just seen a fireball coming towards us. So I remember putting my right hand up to try and push it away from hitting us and my right hand got severely burned.
20:26And then the last thing that I remembered was like the smoke was so thick, it was actually burning our throat, it couldn't breathe. And the fumes actually knocked the whole of us out. And that was the last I remember then of being inside the stardust. Antoinette loses consciousness. When she wakes, she's outside the venue, someone has pulled her out but in doing so has wrenched her free from martina who she'd been clutching on to an ambulance man came up and he said you've got to get into the ambulance i said no i can't they said i've defined miriam martina and he said everyone has gone they're all gone to the hospital he said you have to get in the ambulance there would have been approximately i'd say probably 10 other survivors or victims facing me and i was remember looking at their faces and their bones and their hands and everything and saying oh my god they got badly born.
21:16But little at the time that I know, right, I look the same as they did. Antonette suffered a collapsed lung and severe burns. Her parents don't even recognise her when they visit her in hospital. They're told she has a 50-50 chance of survival. The doctors also advise them not to break the news to Antonette that Mary and Martina haven't survived. I had no idea that Mary and Martina had being killed because my mother and father was changing from their morning clothes like the black tie and the black shirt to ordinary clothes right and coming up to see me and i'd always say to her how's mary and she'd say oh she's grand and how's martina she's grand it's only when a priest visits antonette that she finds out the truth that's right he said your two sisters was killed and i said no no they weren't i said they weren't killed and he said no no he said they're dead they're dead, they're dead and buried.
22:09And I said, no, they're not, they're not. And I kept saying, no, they're not. My mother and father told me they're alive. And then he said, I'm sorry about that, he said, and then he left. 48 young people died in the Stardust fire. The average age of the victims was 19. Here in Dublin, the first of the funerals are being held of some of the people who died in the tragedy.
22:35After several weeks in hospital, Antoinette is allowed back home. Two empty beds, two empty chairs in the kitchen, and then the yogurts that Mary loved. My mother was still continuing to buy them every week. It was just hard. It's hard to accept. Caused an awful lot of arguments in the house. My father was saying to my mother, you were the dancer. They wouldn't have been dancers only for you. And then my mother would say, will you let them go? So it was kind of a blame game. It's sad, it's like it just literally ripped every family that lost and loved them, ripped them apart. The family's grief was also ripped apart by what happened following the tragedy.
23:14An original inquest didn't reference the circumstances of the fire and a tribunal found the cause to be probable arson. This was rejected by many victims, families and survivors and the ruling was dismissed in 2009. After years of campaigning, fresh inquests were granted in 2019. They were reported to be the largest and longest in Irish history. In April 2024, a new verdict was returned. The 12-person jury told the families of the 48 young people who died in the Stardust fire that their loved ones had been unlawfully killed. The whole courtroom erupted with a round of applause and people cheered and said, thank God, thank God.
23:58It was just absolutely amazing. The jury found that it was an electrical fault in a hot press of the bar that started the fire and the materials used to decorate the bar caused the fire to spread rapidly. The jury also found the failure of the emergency lighting system and lack of preparedness of staff played a part in the disaster. And I kept looking up right towards heaven and my hands crossed right and saying, thanks, ma, thanks, dad, thanks, God. At last we have that they have an unlawful killing. They also received an official apology from the Taoiseach, the Irish Prime Minister, Simon Harris.
24:35The institutions of this state let you down. We should have been by your side. We should have worked with you. We were not. We did not. And for that, we are truly sorry. Today, we honour the 48 children who never came home. Today, we apologise to the families, to the survivors, to those who were denied the truth for too long. Antoinette has a poignant reminder of that tragic night, the Valentine's card that her sister Martina took with her to the club to give her boyfriend. That was found outside floating around, and I have that card. I have it in a big frame. The two of them died together. Valentine's Day has never, ever been the same for me or my family since 1981.
25:18Antoinette Keegan continues to campaign for survivors. She was speaking to Jen Dale. The safety failures identified after the fire, locked emergency exits, steel grills over the windows and flammable materials were all addressed in subsequent legislation. The Irish government is now implementing a compensation scheme for those affected by the tragedy.
25:42September's always busy. Whole Foods Market can help. Their September Stock Up event makes it easy to load your pantry and freezer with flavorful, nourishing food. Even better, there are hundreds of sales. Get dinner going with canned soups and veggies. Lean on frozen pizzas, pastas, and seafood everyone loves. Their Build Your Own Family Meals feeds four for just$35. Stock up at Whole Foods Market. A beautifully designed Squarespace website is the difference between thinking about photography school and selling your portraits online. It's the difference between giving away those cookies you just made for free and running your cookie empire.
26:22A beautifully designed Squarespace website is the difference between having a movie reviewing hobby and a movie reviewing career. Squarespace, because no matter what you're into, a website makes it real. Use offer code DIFFERENCE for 50 % off select plans. Terms and conditions apply. Still to come, how India became a world leader in the field of remote call centres and the story behind the discovery of the San Jose, a legendary shipwreck loaded with treasure, as told by a former president of Colombia. I said, oh my God, I was thrilled. I knew that it was big news. many of my predecessors had tried.
Read the full transcript
27:03But first, we have a significant milestone in the evolution of the technology which has resulted in our highly interconnected digital world. In 1991, a small company, led by an Iranian-born engineer called Ruzbe Yassini, created a system which enabled millions of homes across the US to access the internet. Guy Kilty has been hearing how he used the existing cable TV infrastructure to kickstart a digital revolution. The bankers, the cable industry and any investor said, you're crazy, nobody's going to solve those problems. And even if you solve it, nobody cares because who wants to have data connected at their home?
27:44Before he moved to the US to develop the technology that would change the world, Ruzbeth's life began in the Middle East. I was born in Tehran, Iran, which was the capital, a beautiful country with 7 ,000 plus years of the civilization. No country had contributed to the civilization and mankind before 19th century more than Persia in Iran. And Iranian peoples are global citizens of the world who have always contributed to the betterment of the humanity. So I was raised there. I went to school and learned from my parents the integrity of the study heart and be a good person. He may well be a legend in the tech world now, but Roosberg didn't think he'd even work in the industry when he first moved to America.
28:34My interest originally was in medical school, and I wanted to be a medical doctor. So when I came to the United States, I didn't have enough money to go to medical school because they're expensive and cost a lot of money. So I said, I'll go to electrical engineering and biomedical, and through there I jumped back to the medical school. And what happens during my last two years in West Virginia University, I had a number of great professors, and I learned from them that telecommunication, just like medical, has no boundary. It's just as unknown to the mankind as the medical is. And because of their skills and expertise, and because of the number of the projects I had in my junior year and senior year in the university, I changed direction.
29:19instead of going to medical school after I graduated from electrical engineering, I decided to stay with the telecommunication field and pursue my challenge there. And guess what? It's really proven to be just as exciting as medical school would have been. After university, Roosberg worked for a couple of tech firms building his skills. During that time, he learned the key things that would power the technological breakthroughs to come. From 1981 to 1986, I was working for General Electric and I learned how the TV system works, how the cable TV system works, how the audio-video entertainment works.
29:571987 in time frame, I worked for a high-speed data company called Proteon in the data networking. I learned from them how high-speed data works. My vision was that I could put high-speed data over cable infrastructures. Working out how to transfer data using wires connecting homes and buildings was a big challenge in the 1980s, and many assumed a whole new set of wires would be needed. The dream of the technologies was, let's go big, let's do a fiber connection, which is fantastic, it's not a problem, except the cost associated with that. At that time, the United States had about 56 million homes already connected.
30:37So to bring new cable and new labors and new work was extraordinary. To try and get around that cost of installing a whole fiber network, Roosbeau was convinced he could work out a way to use the existing cable TV infrastructure, known as coax cables, to transfer the data both ways. Up to then, the cables had just been used to transfer data to homes in the form of cable TV shows. The hard part would be allowing data to go back the other way. Eventually, Roosberg took his idea to management. I went to the founder of the company I was working with. I said, hey, did you know we really could get these high-speed data networking to every home via COACs?
31:20And his view was that, well, if anybody wanted to do that, they had already done it. And plus, who cares about the homes being connected? Who would ever use computers and the networking from the home? Despite that rejection, Roosberg didn't give up, eventually getting the system up and running at an army base called Rock Island Arsenal. The big challenge remained, though. Could this system work not just in closed networks of government buildings, but across millions of homes in villages, towns and cities? To find out, Roosberg created his own company in 1990 and set his sights on testing out the technology in a real place with real houses.
32:00After a few failed attempts, a small town in Massachusetts called Stowe where a couple of other technology companies were based, seemed open to the idea. We went to the local commercial residential cable company and we told them, hey, we have this crazy idea, we have tested it here and we like to kind of play with your system. The gentleman there was really actually half high techs, half cable guys. I said, sure, I'll give you a channel to play, see how it goes. Things didn't go well to start with. In our first trial, we figured out that cable industry's residential was so noisy that we couldn't even find our signal.
32:40Instead of calling it signal-to-noise ratio, we called it noise-to-signal ratio. It was very horrible. And we failed miserably to be able to get working over residential cable. Over time, things started to improve, until eventually they set up another test to transfer a file from a residential address to a company's office. The file that was transferred each time was a picture of a dove in flight. After resolving all the issues that we had discovered, they initiated the file transfer, and guess what? Everything was flying for them as perfectly as it should with that old residential cables, and they called me enthusiastically with yelling and screaming, saying the dove is flying now over that network infrastructure.
33:28Finally, the technology worked. Roosbe and his team were ecstatic. But instead of trying to make billions from it, he decided to license it to the telecommunications industry royalty-free. You know, everybody asks me that entrepreneurs go make money and then donate a little bit of money here and there to be famous. Why did I do exactly the reverse of that? I come from a country where I noticed that the majority of the problem our country has faced and the area in the Middle East space was since invention of the oil. And I've always been in the mindset that what if we had a telecommuting system that could do health care at the time and educations and all the other good things bring and take its dependency of the oil that not also protect the planet Earth from pollutions that we have, but also provides a freedom for the people in that area that they can enjoy a democratic society and all it brings in.
34:25So for that purpose, I thought donating my technology free without royalties that becomes a global standard was really a cornerstone of my vision at the time, which worked very well. After successfully creating the technology that allowed data transfer between millions of homes, Roosbeck went on to create a mass-market cable modem designed specifically for domestic use. By 1995, his modems accounted for a significant proportion of the market in America. And just a year later, his company was acquired for tens of millions of dollars. Looking back, Roosbert feels immense pride at the technology he and his team created.
35:07This was a dream that created by 13 peoples and seven advisors, 20 of us got together. and we drove our visions to execution and we drove our execution to the useful tools that people could use from their home and it was just a beautiful moment for all of us. Ruzbe Yassini, he was speaking to Guy Kilty. And Ruzbe's inventive ideas on telecommunication lead us nicely into our next item. For this, we're in the late 1990s when the world was on the brink of a revolution that would change the course of modern commerce. With the advances in telecoms, it's possible for a company in any part of the world to outsource back office services to places where labor is less expensive.
35:53In 2019, Rebecca Kesby spoke to a businessman who was one of the first people to spot the opportunity. You know, I wish I could tell you there was a eureka moment. There wasn't. It was quite a simple idea, but it grew in complexity and potential as we thought about it because it seemed so obvious. that it was almost surprising nobody had thought of it earlier.
36:19Pramod Basin had been working abroad in the US and Britain for General Electric for more than 20 years. When, in his mid-40s, he headed home to India, he saw an opportunity to build a new company, and one that would change India's employment market forever. I had the ability, worth, to understand what US businesses wanted, but also the excitement of starting up a new business venture in India. So for me, it was an enormously exciting time, both from a career perspective as well as the joy of coming home and being able to do something new and different. The caliber of people we could attract at that time and now in India was phenomenal.
37:01And the costs at which you could hire people were incredibly low compared to international salaries for the same qualification. Not quite the same qualification, roughly the same qualification. So, you know, you could hire a graduate at that time pretty much for$3 ,000 a year. You could hire a chartered accountant for$14 ,000,$15 ,000. You could hire a master's degree for$5 ,000,$6 ,000. And I could see that they were as good as anybody I'd worked with anywhere in the world. English speaking was another one. Once we advertised and we needed to fill 20 spots, and we got 8 ,000 applications out of which 4 ,000 were totally acceptable, I knew I had an avalanche coming at me.
37:41And literally at that point in time, you realise you were sitting on a gold mine. It didn't hit us till that point in time. The early days of Pramod's pioneering call centre were rather basic. The first call centre experiment was again done in tiny room, 25 feet by 25 feet. barriers made of cardboard between phones, separators made with saris. We didn't have soundproof stuff. We didn't know how to do that. So we brought saris and curtains. And so we went there. It was a shambles. There were wires everywhere, there were saris, there were calls going on, and just starting to experiment.
38:22But appropriate office space wasn't going to be the biggest challenge to overcome. India's notoriously unreliable phone network would be the first major stumbling block. You know in those days we all had three phone lines at home or two phone lines because one was down all the time. So calling my bosses up and telling them how I was going to do all their processing for all their mission critical processes on our phone lines was considerably challenged because the phone line would drop as I would tell them this. And so this used to happen quite a lot. When we went to the telecom authority of course they laughed at us and said are you Are you kidding?
38:57We're going to let you put phone lines so that you can dial people all over the world? Are you trying to set up a phone company? It's not going to happen, right? But outside this building, if you go, is a true landmark of India. It's a giant satellite dish. It was like we had found Nirvana when they put that satellite dish up there. And there's a picture of all of us crowded under that dish. because that was our first private link allowed in India to a private company to dial out. It had a waiting time, so there was a lag. There was a time lag when you talk to people, which was a pain, so we worked hard to reduce that.
39:34We had lots of issues with it, but it was a huge landmark for us. Getting that big satellite dish in place was the start, I think, in some respects, of the entire revolution. Technological problems could be overcome, but the next major challenge would be customer expectation, and that proved to be far harder to satisfy. Whilst all the employees at Pramod's call centre had excellent qualifications and good English, their Indian accents were not so warmly received by customers calling in from the US and Europe. The amount here is$128. Would you like to make a check over the phone? I can post it in the check also.
40:16Yes, they met hostility quite often because either people were saying, where are you calling from? Or sometimes they couldn't understand them. What is this funny accent kind of wondering where the hell this call is coming from? We had accent correction training going on, right? One of the rather bad areas which we didn't excel at was appliances. You know, when appliance owners would call us in with a broken down appliance and our people had never seen a washing machine before. So they're calling them and saying, my washing machine, you know that thing at the back which is leaking away? I'm like, what?
40:51So we triple-checked everything to prove that our quality was excellent. We had double backups on phone lines, on everything possible. You know, because in those days, the risk of error was high. And any problem would have been an India problem, not a problem of the process. It would have been, India won't work, India can't work. Workers were encouraged to study the cultures of the countries they were phoning to familiarise themselves with the football premiership or the National Hockey League to watch the soap operas, even to sound more like the people they were calling. All the trainers seemed to have American accents, so our employees started picking up American accents.
41:29And then as you're talking to Americans all the day, your accent gets more pronounced. So that entire change, that cultural change that was happening, is why I get so terribly excited when I come back to this office, because I could see these young people getting transformed. We were trying to train them in things like the weather in the U.S. If you're calling Arizona, you might as well know whether there's a thunderstorm or snow or ice. You might as well try and get a little more familiar with sports, big events that are happening around that point in time so that you don't, July 4th, you don't call everybody up and not know which day it is.
42:03And then figuring out, you know, what do we call ourselves? If I say, hello, this is Pramod, they don't know who the hell that is. If I say, hello, this is Pete, it's better. While trades unions in Europe questioned the ethics of outsourcing jobs to India, where staff were paid considerably less, worked excruciatingly long hours, often at night, and were even encouraged to change their own names, Pramod argues the call centres did offer great opportunities to their employees and even changed the Indian economy. You know, I think when you're in the throes of it, you don't realise what you've got.
42:36And what we had was a tiger by the tail. I don't think we realized what a huge industry this would become. And even if we did, it was beyond belief to some extent because it's almost beyond what certainly our imagination was at that time. But you know, it's built our cities in many ways. It's built Gurgaon. It's built Hyderabad, Jaipur. Many cities have been built around this industry because these are young kids and you look at them. They have money. They're going to spend it. it gives rise to restaurants, malls, shops, car sales, homes, everything, right, all the stuff. But fast. The biggest element is just what it's done to the people.
43:16You know, 50 % of our employees are women. Men and women working together in a way that doesn't happen in India that much. You know, it was quite liberating, I think, at some level. Economically, very empowering for them. Now, many people can criticize the job, and I think quite rightly. Some of it is very boring. But, you know, it's changed their lives. There are kids here who financed homes, colleges for their relatives. You know, there was an air of excitement and adventure. You look at it every day and say, my God, what did we spawn here? Pramod Basim. In 2011, he left the call center company he founded.
43:54He was speaking to Rebecca Kesby in 2019. Nearly three decades on, India remains one of the world's major call center hubs. Now it's time for this week's Sporting Witness and the story of the most decorated Paralympian of all time. In a career spanning three decades, the swimmer Trisha Zorn-Hudson won a remarkable 55 medals across seven games. She spoke to Matt Pintus in 2024. The 1988 Paralympics have opened in Seoul. Thousands were in the Olympic Stadium to hear the South Korean president welcome disabled competitors from around the world. Seoul, Korea was the first Paralympic Games that we were able to compete in the same venues as the Olympic Games.
44:38That's American Paralympian Trisha Zorn-Hudson. It was monumental because the IPC, International Paralympic Committee, had said that if you were to bid for the Olympic Games, you were to take on the Paralympic Games as well. Tricia is Team USA's star para-athlete. At just 24 years old, she already has 17 swimming gold medals to her name. She's never lost a race, and the winning feeling is something she never tires of. You envision that moment, and when that moment came, it's just like this huge relief of being able to say that you've accomplished your goal that you set out to do and representing your country.
45:27Not everybody can state that. So it's an amazing moment being able to do it for others and yourself pretty special. What made Seoul particularly special to you? It was amazing because we are the same athletes. We train just as hard as Olympic athletes. And from Seoul on to be able to compete in the same venues and everything two weeks after was a huge step for the whole movement of the Paralympic Games. Trisha Zorn-Hudson was born in Orange, Southern California in 1964. She was born with a condition called aniridia, where a person's iris isn't fully developed. In Trisha's case, that meant blindness.
46:16I was the only one in my family that has the genetic eye condition. I did everything that my sibling did. I tried everything. So we spent a lot of time at the beach in the summers. And at the time, my parents were taking me over to a swim club that was starting in the local town. Trisha's promise and talent in the pool was evident from an early age. And at just 16, despite her eye condition, She was on the cusp of qualifying for the Olympic Games. I had always competed with people without disabilities, and so I had just missed the Olympic team by 1-100th in the 200 backstroke. There was a local paper that had done an article, and at that time every state in the United States had an organization for blind athletes, and a director of the California chapter had reached out to me and wanted to know if I would go to their national championships to try and make the Paralympic team.
47:33And make that Paralympic team she did. Tricia made the ultimate splash in the Games in Arnhem, the Netherlands, winning all the events she entered. I had no expectations, so I had no idea about what was going to happen or what I was going to bring home. So when I did get the seven gold medals in my first gaze, I think that set a precedent. I mean, I'm always glad to be setting the bar higher for just on myself, but for others. I was always taught when I was younger, you need to have a level head and be very humble and just let your swimming or whatever you're setting out to do, let that speak for who you are.
48:19Tricia's success continued as she won a further six medals four years later at the 1984 New York Paralympics. But life as a Paralympian wasn't easy. It was far from the glitz and glamour of the Olympics. Every country is different, the way they treat Paralympic athletes and what the support that they give them. And at the time, we were having to pay for our own uniforms. You had to do fundraisers in order to get those expenses for certain parts of a trip. I was fortunate. I was the first here in the United States. I was the first physically disabled athlete to earn a full athletic scholarship to Division I college.
49:05So my college was being paid for because of the scholarship. That alleviated some of the stressors. At the 1988 Games in Seoul, Korea, Trisha continued her winning ways with 10 gold medals. And she set 10 world record times in the process. Her form continued into the next games in Barcelona, where she won even more goals. In fact, she was so dominant that she didn't lose a race for the first 12 years of her career. Tricia decided to try and use her success in Nepal to help lobby for more support for her fellow para-athletes. And ahead of the 2000 Olympics in Sydney, she spearheaded a pilot, allowing Paralympians to live and train in the United States Olympic Training Centre for the first ever time.
49:57It was a massive moment in disability sport, but it didn't come without a few initial teething problems. We went to the pool and they had it as 25 yards. You're training 50 metres. They had lifeguards all over and we're like, what are you doing? We had a coach there and they're like, why is the pool this way? And like, well, we didn't know if they could swim this far. So we just had to laugh. I remember the conversation, too, that they were worried about how we'd go through the cafeteria and what changes they would have to make. And we didn't ask for any changes. We asked just that we'd have the free access to the pool, to the weight room, to all the other facilities that Olympic athletes had.
50:46But that just goes back to my point of training and the whole purpose of education. Tricia went on to compete in seven Paralympic Games across three decades. But just how many medals did she actually win? 41 gold, 9 silver and 5 bronze. And her most memorable medal? Her last one, a bronze in Athens. My mom had passed away in June before the Games. She'd always been to all my Games. I think that was a culmination, knowing that I was going to be retiring after those Games and knowing that this is going to be the end. And I think just not having my mom there and knowing that she would want me to compete at those games.
51:37And it was probably the most memorable event that I did. In 2012, she was inducted into the International Paralympian Hall of Fame. And 20 years on from her retirement, Tricia has mixed emotions about her career. There's a bunch of corporate sponsors of Olympic athletes that Paralympic athletes have now. And yeah, it's bittersweet, but you know what? That was the whole purpose of making the movement and trying to move the needle forward is to be able to have these young athletes who were behind us to be able to have those opportunities. Yes, it was frustrating, but, you know, there is the right time and the right place for things to happen.
52:27And what's happening now is the Paralympics are in a good place. Trisha Zorn-Hudson now works as a legal professional for the Department of Veterans Affairs in the US. She was speaking to Matt Pintus in 2024. Finally this week, we're in the ever fascinating world of the shipwreck. And this is the story of what was considered to be the holy grail of shipwrecks, which was eventually discovered off the coast of Colombia. Treasure on board is thought to be worth an estimated$18 billion. But there's still an international dispute over who owns it. Rachel Naylor has the story of the San Jose. It's September 2011 and Colombian President Juan Manuel Santos is at a reception at the Colombian Embassy in New York.
53:14He's approached by a mysterious white-bearded man. He claims to have found the legendary San Jose shipwreck, which has been famous in Colombia since it sank 300 years ago. He looks a bit like a hippie. I thought he was, oh, another treasure hunter and I didn't want to see him. After all, he's not the first to say he knows where it is. But there's something intriguing about him. So the president reluctantly agrees to speak to him. with a condition that he would not take more than three minutes of my time. He talks very, very fast, and he's very knowledgeable, but a bit strange. He said, I've been searching for the San Jose almost all my life.
54:03This is my passion, this is my life. And I discovered that there is a key called the Admiral's Key near Cartagena. that did not appear in any map that I had previously studied. And if that is true, if that key exists, then I know where the San Jose is. The man making this bold claim is Roger Dooley, a Cuban-American maritime archaeologist. He says he found this antique map in the world's biggest library, the Library of Congress in Washington, D.C. Roger shows the president a copy where four tiny X's mark the spot It sounds too good to be true but why is he telling the president? He cuts to the chase He needs funding as well as the government's permission The president sends him to speak to his culture minister Mariana Gars says who is also dubious but she looks into it and says You know for the first time I think this is serious I think he has very important information and that he is for real.
55:11This is huge news. The San Jose and its booty of gold, silver and emeralds worth billions of dollars had been missing since it sank in 1708.
55:25The Spanish galleon was sailing from Colombia to Spain when a British warship intercepted it and attempted to seize her treasure. But they fired a cannonball into the gunpowder stores by mistake. The San Jose blew up and sank within minutes. More than 300 years later, the president authorises Roger to lead an expedition to find it, with help from the Colombian Navy and American experts who helped discover the Titanic. The search starts in June 2015 in the Baru Peninsula, using a yellow unmanned underwater vehicle shaped like a torpedo. They made an area where it could possibly be, and so they started searching with some submarines.
56:07means they went through half this area and didn't find anything. That is until months later, on the 27th of November, when the president is working in Paris. He gets a phone call to say they found the San Jose. I said, oh my God, I was thrilled. I knew that it was big news. Many of my predecessors had tried. But at the same time, I said, don't get very excited. think about the correct way to proceed. And where was it found? It was found not very far from where the president of Colombia has a small island to go and rest called the Tesoro Island near Cartagena. Tesoro, coincidentally, means treasure.
57:00But the exact coordinates remain a state secret. A week later, the president returns to Colombia and announces the discovery on Twitter, writing, Gran noticia, encontramos el Galeón San José. Well, great news, we found the San José Galeón. The day after, he holds a press conference.
57:22307 years after it was sunk, we have found, without any shadow of a doubt, the San José Galeón. El Galeón San José. I told the world what we had found, and we showed some of the pictures that were taken, which were very clear, very interesting. As a matter of fact, one of the proofs that it was the San Jose was some kind of seal that one of the canyons had. And you could see it in the picture. The news and the images of her bronze guns cast with dolphins make headlines around the world, including on CBS in the U.S. Treasure hunters have called it the holy grail of shipwrecks, and now it's been found.
58:06Colombia says it has located the Spanish galleon San Jose and its cargo, sunken treasure that could be worth billions. Now the Colombian and Spanish governments, as well as a U.S. salvage company, are fighting over who has legal claim to all that loot. The Spanish have always said that these galleons are from Spain. But I started asking around experts and the easiest interpretation of who owns it, the person who finds it, it's his. So that was the position that we took. But not everyone agrees. Not only did the Spanish say it was theirs, some historians said the shipwreck shouldn't be recovered at all.
58:47They argued that the San Jose should be treated like a graveyard as around 600 people drowned when the ship went down. There was a big discussion here in Colombia. Some of them said, no, no, leave it there. It's the only way to preserve it is to not touch it. Which we thought, well, it's a bit illogical. With such a discovery, not to do anything. The president felt so strongly about this, he even passed a law saying as such, the Submerged Patrimony Law, which defines sunken ships in Colombian waters as national heritage. Today, it's not just Colombia and Spain who are fighting over it. A US salvage company claimed they found the San Jose in the 1980s and have launched a lawsuit against Colombia.
59:31Indigenous groups from Bolivia and Peru have also waded in, saying they're entitled to some of the treasure as it was mined by the forced labour of their ancestors. But 11 years and three presidents later, the San Jose remains 600 metres below the surface on the seabed. Last year, despite the ongoing dispute, the first objects were recovered, including a cannon, three coins and a porcelain cup. They are now in a conservation laboratory run by the Colombian government. It's supposed to be the galleon that had the most amount of richness that any galleon has had in the history of the world. So we have said, and I have said, this in fact belongs to humanity and we should recover it.
1:00:17The plan was to build a museum in Cartagena for the people of the world to go and see. How do you feel about it being discovered during your presidency? Now I brag about it. Now I say, well, we discovered the San Jose, but it was, in a way, pure luck. The sense of Roger Dooley appearing and my meeting with him in New York and getting the right people. When I look back and people tell me, well, your legacy, and I say, well, the peace in Colombia, the Nobel Peace Prize, we brought down poverty. But I always say that we discovered the San Jose. I now mention it as an achievement. I do want and I dream of seeing the San Jose recovered.
1:01:12and then I can look back and say that was discovered during my government and that would give me a lot of satisfaction. It would be a good thing for my ego. A life in politics put into perspective by the discovery of a sunken galleon. Juan Manuel Santos was president of Colombia between 2010 and 2018. He was speaking to Rachel Naylor. And that's it for this edition of the History Hour. We'll be opening another chest full of glittering treasures in the form of real-life stories from the past next week. So until then, this is Max Pearson. From all of us here, thanks for listening. Goodbye. Sporting Witness takes you to the events that have shaped the sports world through the eyes of the people who were there.
1:01:55We weren't going to ask permission. We were just going to do it. It was such an amazing feeling. It was incredible. He started to write a story about how he came up with the idea for the red and yellow cars. I got to go. We cried a bit. We laughed a bit. It was wonderful. There's a magic during those moments that carries your soul. We were truly blessed to be a part of history. Sporting Witness. Subscribe wherever you get your BBC podcasts.
1:02:23Shop the Sherwin-Williams Fall Sale and get 35 % off paints and stains September 15th through the 21st with prices starting at$29.86. Whether you're refreshing your interior or exterior, we've got the colours to bring your vision to life. And with delivery, getting everything to your door is easier than ever. Shop online to have it delivered or visit your neighborhood Sherwin-Williams store. Click the banner to learn more. Retail sales only. Some exclusions apply. See store for details. Delivery available on qualifying orders.
1:02:54Can politicians improve our economic fortunes? Dave Ramsey says no. I'm Tristan Redmond from The Global Story, and I've been speaking to the massively popular U.S. money guru who says if there's a financial crisis, it's on us. When you borrow on credit cards and take out a$1 ,200 car payment on a freaking Range Rover, you've destroyed your life, not the president. For the full interview, listen to The Global Story on bbc.com or wherever you listen.
From the publisher
Max Pearson presents a collection of the week's Witness History episodes from the BBC World Service.
We hear how Norwegian teachers resisted peddling Nazi propaganda during the German occupation of the Second World War and our guest, Dr Rachel Pistol, talks us through other examples of resistance around Europe.
Plus, the Stardust nightclub fire in Dublin in 1981, the Iranian engineer who connected homes to the internet using cable TV and the birth of India's call centre industry.
Finally, this week's Sporting Witness - the most successful Paralympian and the discovery of the 'holy grail' of shipwrecks.
Contributors: Mr Roll Hansen - Norwegian teacher. Dr Rachel Pistol - a historian specialising in the Second World War, from the University of Southampton. Antoinette Keegan - survivor of the Stardust nightclub fire. Rouzbeh Yassini - father of the cable modem. Pramod Bhasin - businessman who set up India’s first call centre. Trischa Zorn-Hudson - the most successful Paralympian. Juan Manuel Santos - former President of Colombia.
(Photo: German troops marching through Oslo in occupied Norway during World War Two in 1940. Credit: European / FPG / Getty Images)
