1. Podcasts
  2. The Information's TITV
  3. How Nvidia Shapes Policy in Washington, Midterms Affecting Data Centers, Apple Sales Cool
The Information's TITV

3 Nov 2026 · 46m · 19 chapters

Episode artwork

How Nvidia Shapes Policy in Washington, Midterms Affecting Data Centers, Apple Sales Cool

In short

A tech-sector election-day roundup covering (1) Nvidia’s influence on Washington export-control policy, (2) which U.S. midterm races could change data-center rules, and (3) Apple’s slowing growth plus Marvell’s $80B acquisition of Lumentum.

Guests and backgrounds

Barton Crockett, senior research analyst at Rosenblatt Securities (Apple results, services/App Store). Torrey Svonberg, managing director and senior semiconductor analyst at Stifel (Marvell-Lumentum deal). Leo Schwartz, tech and politics reporter at The Information (data-center politics; Nvidia policy story). Shane Burke, senior data journalist at The Information (governor races and data-center development). Phoebe Liu, Nvidia reporter at The Information (Nvidia influence, think tanks, export controls).

Key claims + notable examples

Apple revenue growth slowed to 12% (forecast 7–10%); services decelerated due to App Store gaming weakness and Google search licensing pressure from AI overviews. Marvell will buy Lumentum to combine networking chips with optical lasers for next-gen AI “scale” networks; deal faces antitrust review; transceiver overlap is <10% of revenue. Data-center policy likely varies more at state level: Georgia (moratorium vs pro-regulation), Texas (Abbott pause vs stricter controls), Alaska (moratorium dynamics; land/cooling). Nvidia’s Jensen Huang is portrayed as a “chip allocator” using government affairs, think-tank pressure, and Hill allies (including via Defense Authorization Act export-control fights) to shape export-control outcomes; sources cite Slack/internal fears at OpenAI about angering Nvidia.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:48

Apple's Quarterly Results Overview

Discussion on Apple's quarterly results and performance under John Ternus.

“It's going to be a great show, so let's get right on into it.”
2:10

Challenges Faced by Apple

Analysis of the memory cost challenges impacting Apple's gross margins.

“and I think they're in a bit of a lull right now in some of their tertiary products in terms of the wearables and a couple of headwinds and services.”
3:43

Apple's Inventory Strategy

Exploration of Apple's strategy in managing memory inventory amid rising costs.

4:39

Services Revenue Slowdown

Detailed look at the slowing services revenue and factors affecting it.

“And that wraps into this whole, you know, search is it secularly challenged at some level that came out of Google's most recent earnings report.”
5:55

Gaming App Profitability and Consumer Behavior

Discussion on the profitability of gaming apps and consumer spending behavior changes.

“But, you know, but that's something that Apple's been calling out.”
7:56

Apple's AI and Robot Ambitions

Exploration of Apple's AI capabilities and potential in the robotics space.

“I'm thinking about, you know, Microsoft's Xbox business, for example.”
12:35

Marvell and Lumentum Acquisition Announcement

Introduction to Marvell's acquisition of Lumentum and its implications.

“But, you know, if I was to bet on their disruptive innovation to be more on the hardware side than on the AI kind of software front.”
13:14

Technical Overview of Marvell and Lumentum

Analysis of the technologies involved in Marvell and Lumentum's operations.

“Here to offer some analysis is Torrey Svonberg, Managing Director and Senior Semiconductor Analyst at Stifel.”
14:06

The Future of AI Infrastructure

Learn about the evolving technology and strategies in AI networking and optical connections.

“So by combining the two under one house, Marvell sees the opportunity of this sort of extreme code design to develop some of the best solutions for all the four networks within AI infrastructure.”
18:04

Market Reactions to the Merger

Explore the implications and market reactions surrounding the Marvell-Lumentum deal.

“But I do believe that by bringing these two competencies under one house, Marvell should be able to address next generation AI infrastructure in a much better way than what they are today.”
Show all 19 chapters
23:51

Election Impact on Data Centers

Discover how key Senate and governor races could impact data center policies and development.

“So let's talk about the data center build out.”
28:00

Candidates' Platforms on Data Centers

Discussion on how candidates are addressing data center regulations.

“What we're seeing is that that's more at the state level.”
29:50

AI Regulation and Political Landscape

Analyzing the impact of midterm elections on AI regulation.

“Leo, so Shane mentioned voluntary, and it kind of brings me back to the discussion you and I have had about the AI regulation, more on the federal level, how the agencies are thinking about this.”
32:50

Introduction to NVIDIA's Political Influence

Overview of how Jensen Huang has built political capital.

“They've spent over$100 million on this already.”
33:30

NVIDIA's Strategic Positioning

Exploring NVIDIA's approach to maintaining its chip dominance.

“I want to bring on Leo Schwartz and Phoebe Liu to share more about their reporting.”
37:10

Influence in D.C. Through Think Tanks

The role of think tanks in NVIDIA's political strategies.

“And, you know, that's not abnormal for companies to do, but NVIDIA became the richest and I guess now the second richest company in the world.”
40:40

Shifting Power Dynamics in AI

Discussion on the changing power balance between NVIDIA and its customers.

“again, to show how they were influencing these policy discussions that were happening in D.C.”
42:00

NVIDIA's Evolving Influence in Washington

Discussion on NVIDIA's changing stance and influence in export control policies.

“leverage in that they are explicitly making their own chips, which could kind of sway the policy balance of power as well.”
43:56

Impact of Midterms on Export Control Bills

Analysis of how bipartisan export control bills may be affected by midterm elections.

“And sorry, Leo, just to confirm, those three packages, the bills that I guess we are waiting to see if they go through, are those bipartisan?”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The Information's TITV, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:13Welcome everyone to The Information's TI TV. My name is Akash Pasricha. It is Tuesday, November 3rd. It is Election Day. We're going to get to that shortly and talk about the midterm races that you should be watching as it relates to the tech sector. We'll talk about the data center story at the center of this election, along with the California billionaire's tax. Before we get there, we've got some analysis on Apple's quarterly results for you. We're also going to break down Marvell's agreement to buy Lumentum. And we also have some new reporting on Jensen Huang's influence in Washington, D.C.

0:48It's going to be a great show, so let's get right on into it. Apple reported its quarterly results last night, the first under John Ternus. The company says total revenue growth slowed to 12%, the slowest in a year, and it also forecasts a further slowdown to 7 % to 10 % in the current quarter. I want to bring on Barton Crockett, senior research analyst at Rosenblatt Securities, for his view on all of this. Barton, welcome back to the show. It's great to have you here. Great. Thank you. Thanks for having me. So it was Ternus' first kick at the can. How do you think he did? I mean, I think he did just fine, given the hand he's dealt.

1:27I mean, he's presiding over an Apple that is doing a tremendous job with the most important product for them, which is the iPhone family. I think a terrific launch of the Duo in terms of the product capabilities. It would be great if it was more available, but certainly they've got a great product that they've designed and they're giving to consumers. Of course, the iPhone cycle is holding up remarkably well versus very difficult compares to a very strong iPhone cycle last year. So those are great. The Mac is doing great because it's hitting the sweet spot in AI. But the things that it can't control are really, I think, issues that are taking a little bit of the luster off of this opening report.

2:09And that is the memory cost challenge is hitting gross margins. and I think they're in a bit of a lull right now in some of their tertiary products in terms of the wearables and a couple of headwinds and services. So, you know, nothing's, it's not perfect, but, you know, I think you can't blame that on Ternus. I think he's doing, you know, as good a job as you would hope for at the start here. So maybe we'll come back to Ternus here broadly, but you mentioned some of the results here. So is it all outside of Apple's control, Do you think is there anything they could be doing better in terms of execution?

2:49You know, I think it's hard, right? I mean, because you've got some, you know, big players now in the same room with you fighting for memory in terms of the AI CapEx. You know, Apple used to be the big kid on the block and they used to get their way and they don't anymore. um and um you know the memory guys uh are in a position where they can take price they'll probably be in that position for um some you know number of years couple of years probably at least um and so the gross margin pressure you see from memory um seems like something that's not going to abate um you know in the next couple of years at a minimum so and there's not much they can do about it i don't know what they can do to stop anthropics demand for memory or open ai's demand for memory or meta or everyone else um you know they're just uh a victim of the circumstance right now which has turned a bit against them um in the world at large well we've talked on the show about how nvidia has has uh taken some measures here to protect itself against uh oscillating memory prices has apple taken those same measures i imagine to lock in some of those long-term prices at least well i mean they've done some things around uh you know around the margin you know not to use uh you know the word there too much but um yeah they bought you know they didn't inventory a bit more kind of um memory uh than perhaps they would have under cook and that um is probably the right thing to do because uh you know maybe if prices are going up that helps you kind of hedge that um and then it also helps you make sure you ensure supply so you don't lose sales because you can't you know get what you need when you need it um and it's probably harder to do that now than it was a couple of years ago so you know those are helpful but they don't solve the problem they um you know help uh help keep it from getting worse than it is but it doesn't make it go away okay and and what about services here what did they say last night on the call about why services is slowing because this was i mean this is the higher margin category for them this is uh this is a category that i i think i mean i was it growing 30 ish percent at one point a couple a couple years ago quarters ago i can't even remember maybe it was 20 plus but this is this is slow right yeah yeah i mean that they're slowing to um kind of a very high single digit range in the guide um and you know there's a little bit of currency kind of pressure around the deceleration uh fractional deceleration from the quarter they just reported into the quarter that they're guiding um but part of what is really more meaningful here is um you know they're they're the game cycle uh in the app store is not what it was um and then we're also seeing pressure on the license fees that they get from Google mainly tied to search.

5:34And that wraps into this whole, you know, search is it secularly challenged at some level that came out of Google's most recent earnings report. We're seeing, you know, they're not monetizing the AI overviews as well as they did the search surface. And that's showing up to a degree in Apple's deceleration and services. can you explain both of those in in a little more detail here both the gaming cycle and then the the search component i just want to unpack those yeah i mean look i mean games are one of the most profitable they're probably the biggest and most profitable element of the app store um and um you know the consumer is just not downloading they're not monetizing like they were you know perhaps that's a reflection of you know just some challenges on the consumer um and you know Perhaps they're spending, you know, a little bit more of their money in some other things like, you know, AI subscriptions.

6:27But, you know, but that's something that Apple's been calling out. And, you know, that's an important part of the App Store, which is an important part of services. In terms of search, you know, we've seen, you know, Alphabet had a slight disappointment in search revenue growth in the September quarter, decelerated a little bit. and you know and that's as people are using ai overviews they're not getting as many of the 5 10 blue links that you used to get not clicking on them like they used to and that's a bit of a headwind for revenues and you know it's not clear how quickly that turns around i mean i think that you know google is very hopeful that they can monetize ai overviews better over time but that's tbd because that's a very different form factor where you're not just clicking to purchase, but you are kind of getting educated and maybe there's fewer things to click on, but higher intent when you go through.

7:22So it's a very different sale process. And there's more competition for that as well because people are using OpenAI and others. So they called this out last night? They called this headwind out? They called out licensing. They said licensing had decelerated and that's the Google search license fee. Got it. Got it. And I want to get back to Terrence here in a second, but on the gaming front, so is this a category headwind that gaming altogether is facing? You mentioned sort of the state of the consumer. I'm thinking about, you know, Microsoft's Xbox business, for example. I mean, are these two separate stories here or is it one and the same?

8:04Yeah, I mean, Xbox is, you know, your game console. I think you're talking about apps, right? Your gaming apps that you're downloading. Yeah, yeah. I just wondered if maybe people were gaming less here, if they were tied together. Yeah, I mean, apparently, on the iPhone, they're seeing pressure in the app store from that category. And so, yeah, so that's a headwind. I think that that is not clear 100 % in my mind what is behind that. But, you know, we do see a consumer that is stretched in many ways. I mean, they have new toys to play with in terms of AI, and they have a lot of pressures in terms of inflation.

8:42And, you know, this is a highly discretionary, obviously, you know, clicking around on a stupid game on your iPhone. Pretty discretionary, and people do that when they're looking to kill time, and they don't worry about spending a couple of bucks. But if you're more worried about a couple of bucks, and maybe you're spending more time on something else, you know, that seems to be pressured. so turnus made the decision last night to bring on the coo for part of the conference call and he also took a fair share of the questions i saw as well with the cfo kevin park what did you make of that decision well i think he's highlighting um you know a talented executive has been promoted into a more prominent position um and this is um you know i think great i mean i think that they, you know, should highlight him.

9:31I think the answers were very helpful. And, you know, and I applaud it. I think it's a great thing to do. Did you, and, you know, I'm just asking here, did you see it at all as, you know, a change in the way he runs the company? Or maybe, you know, you could make the argument too, perhaps that he was not so much in, as much in the details as perhaps the COO was in terms of in so far as how he answered the questions. Did you see that come across at all? Well, I mean, you know, certainly, you know, the chief operating, you know, Apple has, you know, vast operational exposures. And, you know, and Tim Cook kind of came up through that operational side and Ternus came up through the product side.

10:16So, you know, I think if that's the gist of your question, I think it makes sense. I mean, they're, you know, Ternus has his strengths and he's bringing up someone beside him who also has great strengths that are complementary. So put them all on the call. And I think that's great. Why not? Right. And last question for you, Barton. So we had the story this week about Apple's robot ambitions. And this is another category that they are likely to try to expand in. What do you make of that? And also, where are we on sort of the AI headwinds that we talked about with Apple and Siri, you know, they, they seems to, it, it's not the first thing that people talk about anymore, although it was them being behind on AI.

11:00So, um, have we weathered that storm and does that tell us anything about how their robot ambitions might go? Well, look, I, you know, I think they're, they're two separate things. I mean, I would say in terms of their AI execution, clearly they were dead in the water and now, you know, they're, they're, uh, treading water, um, you know, and And they're certainly not in the race. Their capabilities are not leading edge, but at least they have something that's credible. And they did that in part by working with Alphabet and in part by changing their team around. And that's helpful that they're making progress there.

11:39I think the real question for Apple is, what is the next big thing that really accelerates growth? And this is a stock you love to own when they're coming up with some disruptive new innovation. Obviously, they did that with iPhone. They did that to a smaller degree with the watch. And what could that next thing be? Maybe it's robots. Not based on the form factors we're seeing in HomeView or anything related to that. But they have skills all around that. Maybe in coming years, they could come up with something that is exciting. And an Apple robot running around your home could be pretty cool. Maybe they do that in AR glasses, you know, where Meta's been showing some traction, you know, and maybe they are able to innovate better in AI.

12:23And we're certainly seeing, you know, Meta innovate with their Muse and, you know, and there is every reason to think that Apple could do that. I'm not sure they've shown the skill to do it. But, you know, if I was to bet on their disruptive innovation to be more on the hardware side than on the AI kind of software front. But we're looking for something. And, you know, and one of those things maybe is it. Right. Well, Barton, I want to thank you for coming on. That is Barton Crockett from Rosenblatt Securities here on TI TV. Marvell agreed to buy Lumentum, a market leader in lasers and optics technology used in data centers.

13:03I'll read here at The Information. The deal comes to around$80 billion. Marvell shareholders will own two-thirds of the new company. Lumentum shareholders will own one-third. That is, assuming that the deals go through after what is likely to be a careful antitrust review. Here to offer some analysis is Torrey Svonberg, Managing Director and Senior Semiconductor Analyst at Stifel. Torrey, welcome to the show. It's great to have you here. Yes, thank you for having me on. Appreciate it. Okay, so we'll get to the price here in a second because the valuation is really interesting. Just remind us, though, Marvell and Lumentum, what type of chips, what type of lasers exactly do they do?

13:41How does their technology intersect with each other even before this acquisition? Yeah, so if you think about Marvell, they are a networking semiconductor company. They do serve both optical and copper connections. But as I'm sure you know, optical connections are becoming more and more important. And, you know, Lamentum, of course, they sell optical components and lasers. So by combining the two under one house, Marvell sees the opportunity of this sort of extreme code design to develop some of the best solutions for all the four networks within AI infrastructure. So just to be clear, these are the chips, these are the lasers that they connect different chips together within a server.

14:28They connect different servers together. They also connect different data centers together. Is that right? Yeah. So when you think about the four AI networks, there's basically scale across, scale out, scale up and scale in. Today, most of the AI infrastructure is in scale out and scale across, and those do use optical connections today. However, the next generation networks are going to be scale up and scale in. Those are based on copper connections today. But because the speeds are expanding so exponentially, that's where optical technology is now set to solve some major issues. Right. And the idea here, just to recap for folks, I mean, scale out and scale across, this is between servers and then between different data centers.

15:18Scale in and scale up is basically within the chip and then up inside the servers. All right. Exactly. So scale out is about connecting the racks together. Scale across is basically connecting data centers together. Scale up would be basically looking at racks that are quite large, quite tall. And then scale in would be millimeter type connections between compute and all the other various components within an AI rack, such as NIC cards, storage, memory, and so on and so forth. and so lumentum they play largely in that more uh like the the more microscopic uh scale in uh category is that right no so scale in today is all copper connections okay but next generation scale is gonna is gonna be based on optical so today lamentum plays predominantly in scale out and scale across which is where optical technology is used today.

16:21But as I mentioned before, as speeds continues to move higher and higher, copper runs out of steam as a connectivity medium, and therefore you are going to need optical connections. Got it. Okay. So now let's talk about the strategic logic then for this deal from Marvell. Sounds like Lumentum has some pretty forward-thinking technology here that is going to become important. Do you think that this is a good deal for marvell and ultimately we're going to get to the price what do you think of what they paid for it yeah so first of all today uh semiconductor companies and optical companies are not one on the same you know they have different capabilities different ip um but what's happening is that with the convergence of electrical signals and optical signals or in this case semiconductors and photonics, I think Marvell sees an opportunity to bring it all under one house and therefore be able to deliver some better architectures, some better products, and certainly some better performance solutions to their customers.

17:31As far as the price tag, yes, I mean, people look at the headlines like it's quite staggering. I mean, this is one of the biggest deals in semiconductor history. But let's not forget what's at stake here, right? I mean, we're talking about AI infrastructure, which is probably the place to be in technology over the next five to seven years. And what they are bringing to bear here is, you know, some of the most complex solutions you can find. I do understand for investors it's confusing again because, you know, we haven't really seen anything like this before. I think we're all used to thinking, you know, in verticals.

18:05But I do believe that by bringing these two competencies under one house, Marvell should be able to address next generation AI infrastructure in a much better way than what they are today. What do you think Lumentum shareholders are reacting to here? Because, I mean, look, typically a deal gets announced, the target, right? I mean, those investors get excited and the acquirer, those shareholders get nervous. Here, it was both of them getting nervous. So Lumentum's anxiety is what exactly? Yeah, I mean, I think this has more to do with, you know, the length of, you know, when this deal is going to close, right?

18:44So it's not going to close until 1st of the 28th. There is going to be some regulatory scrutiny. So I think what Lumentum investors are worried about is, you know, could this deal actually go through? Will it get approved? and given the timeframe, how long this is gonna last, could that cause some disruption to their business model? Could competitors come in? Could customers get nervous? So I think that's what Lomentum investors are basically worried about. Do you think it'll go through? I personally think it will go through. There's no regulatory reasons why this wouldn't go through. Certainly if you just use the laws out there and the legality, There's no reasons why this should cause any antitrust anxiety.

19:31But keep in mind, this is going to need both China and US approval. As you know, politically, there's been some concerns there. But again, just purely from an antitrust perspective, I think the deal is going to go through. And as you think about this from a competitive perspective, so Marvell, obviously, Broadcom is another big networking chip competitor for it. Does it help compete against that company? And we're going to talk as well about something you called out in your note, which is the competition that its customers might see it waging against it with this deal. Yeah. So again, if you think about what I just mentioned before, you know, sort of this convergence between semiconductor technology and optical technology, there's very few companies that have all of that in-house under one umbrella.

20:18Broadcom does. So, you know, they certainly had the same vision, the same view. and now Marvell obviously is going to be the second one. I think the alternative is still to buy discrete components from either side, but I think that's also one of the reasons why Lumentum decided to sell because they themselves, I think, were also looking at potentially bringing semiconductor technology into their house. That would have required obviously buying a lot of different smaller companies. I think that in itself would probably be a very long and tiring process. But the reality is that, yeah, now you only have two big players here that have the capabilities both in-house.

20:58Okay. And what about the point you called out in your note here, the customer perspective on this? I mean, Marvell, I guess some of their customers compete with them on this stuff? Yeah. So the one thing that we pointed out as potential being a risk to this transaction is that basically Marvell is buying one small customer that does optical transceivers? And does that basically mean Lamentum's competitors who also buy from Marvell, would they get cold feet and look for alternative sources? Our understanding is that with this combination, the transceiver business would be less than 10 % of revenue.

21:41So while we thought that would be a bigger risk initially when you put it into numbers and it's less than 10%, it does become less of a risk. But that's certainly something to keep an eye out here as this merger plays out. Okay, and last question for you. What do you think of the price that they paid? I know that depending on which share price you take, at what point in the story, you either get closer to$115 billion or closer to$80 billion. You called this out as well last night. So whatever it is, What do you think of the valuation broadly, the per share price that they've put on it? Yeah, I mean, this is an all stock deal.

22:22So at the end of the day, these two stocks are now tight at the hip, right? So, you know, whatever Marvell stock does, Lamentum will follow. And I think that explains why both stocks were down yesterday, because they are now officially tight at the hip. That obviously also then dictates eventually, you know, what the enterprise value is going to be, you know, when the deal actually closes. You know, we'll just have to wait and see. But I think, you know, when it comes to these deals, especially this size, I think investors do worry about the dilution because Marvell is offering quite a bit of shares here.

22:56And I get it. But I think given the strategic rationale for this acquisition, I also think that this deal makes a lot of sense. And by the way, the CEO, Marvell, Matt Murphy, he has a track record of doing some really, really good deals and delivering a lot of value over time. And I think with this one, I think we'll see tremendous amount of value being created. Great. Well, Torrey, I want to thank you for coming on. That is Torres Fonberg from Stiefel here on TI TV. It is election day, and between AI data centers and the California billionaire tax ballots, the tech sector has been one of the newsiest parts of this election cycle.

23:35Joining us now to break down what to watch tonight are tech and politics reporter, Leo Schwartz and senior data journalist Shane Burke, who is tracking key governor races and their implications for data center development. Welcome to you, both of you. It is great to have you here. Hey, Kaj. Thanks for having me. Leo, I want to start with you. So let's talk about the data center build out. Which Senate races specifically are you watching tonight with respect to that. I'm going to be a boring politics reporter and say, unfortunately, I don't think anything's really going to change that much based on tonight's results, especially in federal Senate races.

24:16That being said, as you said, it has been a major theme in races. I think probably the most emblematic one of that has been in Ohio with John Husted and Sherrod Brown, a former senator, where Sherrod Brown has been accusing his opponent of being the face of data senators. Although at the same time, what you see in a lot of these races is that when it comes down to brass tacks, the views aren't actually that different. I think every candidate realizes that data centers and AI more broadly has been largely unpopular with voters and have taken sort of similar policy approaches to it. I mean, John Husted even was trying to advance rate payer protection legislation in the Senate.

24:56So even though it has been a big point of rhetoric, whether it will actually lead to different policy changes based on who gets elected is pretty unlikely, I think. So, well, let's go to the governor races then, Shane. I mean, this is kind of the ones that I think are more interesting. You did some great reporting on this and some number crunching in a piece that we will link in the show notes. Which governor races specifically should we be paying attention to from your perspective? Yeah, so the governor's races are interesting to look at because it has been governors who have been able to enact moratoriums or pauses on larger scales.

25:38I'd say the three races I'm most interested in looking at right now, Georgia is really close, and there's a candidate, the Democrat wants to put a moratorium on data centers, and the Republican is much more free with regulation and stuff. So I think that is a close one that could have a lot of differences. Texas, there's a kind of similar story, although Abbott, the incumbent, has put a pause on data centers. His opponent wants stricter controls. And then the third one, I find Alaska's race really interesting. There are four candidates, like the Democrat is maybe going to pull off an upset or change the way it's been.

26:24And that also is a data center moratorium versus not a candidate situation. And I think Alaska could be an interesting market in the future for data centers. They've got a lot of land and a lot of cooling. I was going to say, yeah, it makes the cooling issue a little bit easier if you're building it up there. Although the Alaska results, I think those are the ones that'll take longest to come in from what I was tracking this morning. Yeah, they've also got like a ranked voting system. It's interesting. Different. Yeah. So, Leo, what about some of these? I mean, so you talked about the Senate race in Ohio just now.

27:01What about the governor race in Ohio? And, you know, some of the other data center hotspots, Virginia is another one. I wonder if that's one that we should be paying attention to or if it's kind of spoken for. I mean, Texas is certainly Shane alluded to it. But what about the other ones? Yeah, I mean, I would just say, as Shane has done some really great reporting on this, a lot of the battles over data center has happened not only at the state, but at the local level. And there are states like New Mexico, Virginia, where this has been such a battleground that I do think that's more interesting to watch.

27:36at the federal level, they're really, I mean, A, the chance of real legislation passing is always incredibly slim, but there also aren't necessarily that strong of policy differences between the right and the left, at least in the Senate and the House on this issue. A lot of the support has actually come from the Trump administration, and you continue to see policy coming out of the Trump administration incentivizing data center build out. So if there is strong pushback. What we're seeing is that that's more at the state level. Shane, one of the things that you called out in your story on Sunday was the idea that moratoriums and pauses are one axes to look at these candidates at.

28:16There's also stuff like how they're looking at water, how they're looking at tax breaks. What are the different sort of vectors on which these candidates have been running their platforms? Because some of them have more nuanced takes on whether or not there should be a moratorium, whether or not we should conserve the water use and stuff like that. Yeah, totally. I would say most of the candidates now have some sort of restriction on data centers or on energy, which can be like a proxy for data centers. So first and most popular is ratepayer protections. Those are making sure that costs of data centers, whether it's the buildout or surges in demand, don't end up going to like household customers.

29:05And I'd say there's also a range there of protections. Some people have signed like a voluntary pledge and you have to ask what that will mean, you know, if it's just voluntary. And then there's also environmental protections that people are putting into or they're proposing tests on air quality, water quality, like closed water systems so the water won't go out into the environment. And like siting on environmental remediation sites or brownfields, that's another thing. Yeah, there's just a bunch of different policies people are putting into place or want to put into place. Yeah. Leo, so Shane mentioned voluntary, and it kind of brings me back to the discussion you and I have had about the AI regulation, more on the federal level, how the agencies are thinking about this.

30:06And that's I think, you know, that is almost the faster moving part of the story in some ways insofar as how it gets regulated. Or I guess as I say that it's also not moving fast enough because we know that these executive orders just kind of drag on. Will any of what happens tonight or this week, will it at all affect the regulation that you have been reporting on with the agencies and with, you know, the task forces and the model reviews? Is any of that going to change at all? Well, this is the more maybe sober-minded and less exciting analysis that I would provide, which is that even in the best-case scenario for Democrats, where they win a bunch of seats in the Senate, they take over the House, they still have the glaring issue that Trump is the president.

30:54Obviously, he has veto power. Overcoming a veto is very difficult. So are they going to be able to pass their own legislation without bipartisan support, without Trump support, that seems very unlikely. Of course, there are vehicles for that to be done, must pass bills like the Defense Authorization Act, which will actually likely be done before the next Congress comes in in January. There likely will be AI provisions in that. But at the same time, whether you see a real challenge to Trump's authority over AI regulation and all of this lack of clarity we've been seeing at the agency and executive level through new legislation, the Democrats that still faces the same steep or impossible odds of actually passing.

31:38What will happen if Democrats are able to win one or both houses is just a lot of oversight hearings. They'll have subpoena power likely to bring some CEOs who have cozy relationships with Trump to Capitol Hill. But if anything, that will just cause more embarrassment for the companies than have actual consequences. Right. And one more question for you, Leo. So Prop 40 is the other ballot that has been getting a lot of attention in California. We saw it come up with Meta's stock split as well, because, again, we didn't expect this to have been a repercussion of it. But Mark Zuckerberg is saying, if you want me to stick around in California, you know, you've got to let me sort of pay for this somehow.

32:23What's the latest on the way the Prop 40 ballot is looking? Are there any twists and turns this might go for? What do you think? Yeah, it seemed for a while like this had a real chance of passing. I think polling on propositions in California is always sort of a fool's errand and pretty unscientific. At the same time, it seemed like it had a real chance of passing. But the no side, the billionaire side, has outspent the yes side, I think, 250 to one. They've spent over$100 million on this already. It does seem like the polls are shifting to the proposition failing, but we'll find out tomorrow.

33:01Great. Well, I want to thank you both for coming on. Leo, stick around for a minute as well, because I want to talk about a story that you published as well today. That is Shane Burke, our senior data journalist here at The Information, and Leo Schwartz, our tech and politics reporter here in our newsroom. Awesome. Thanks, guys. Whichever way the midterms go, Jensen Huang will still be pushing hard to keep his relationship sharp with everyone in Washington, D.C. Several reporters in our newsroom joined forces on a new feature story that highlights how Jensen has built such a strong political capital behind the scenes.

33:37I want to bring on Leo Schwartz and Phoebe Liu to share more about their reporting. Welcome to the both of you. It is great to have you here. Phoebe, I want to start with you because, you know, you and our colleagues did a ton of great reporting here on this issue from all different angles. There's the policy angle. There's the NVIDIA angle. There's the think tank angle. There's also the open AI angle. And the story starts with a Slack exchange that you and our colleagues got a hold of. What was this Slack message that really perked our ears here at The Information? Yeah. So last month, senior OpenAI research scientist, Noam Brown, sent another news article around kind of a perception that OpenAI had softened its stance on chip exports, specifically advanced AI chip exports to China, and kind of asked, what is our policy on export controls?

34:35And kind of the response to that was a little bit tenuous, kind of pointing at previous things that OpenAI had published saying, okay, the company supports export controls generally, but not specifying like certain hardware or certain countries like China. And our colleague Steph had some reporting basically also saying that internally some open AI policy people had said, oh, like we've maybe softened some of our stances on export controls maybe for fear of angering NVIDIA and specifically its CEO, Jensen Huang. And so this is kind of interesting because the fear of Jensen Huang is kind of the through line here that is what we really reported on.

35:23And so I wonder if you could talk a little bit about that. I mean, why – what's going on here? Why are they – I mean, they just want chips? Is that the idea? I mean, NVIDIA's biggest lever, of course, is its ability to decide who gets how many chips. because everyone wants more chips from NVIDIA than they can get. NVIDIA, of course, has over many, many occasions denied that they kind of explicitly use this as a lever, but that doesn't mean the fear is not still there. Like anything that a company can do to even create the perception that they might be able to get more chips from NVIDIA is a good thing.

36:04And I think that effectively gives NVIDIA even more sway over its biggest customers and partners. And, I mean, Leo, as you think about this, there's sort of the interviews that Jensen gives in which he's quite loud about this, but then there's sort of what he's doing behind the scenes, I guess. And this was some of the more interesting reporting we did. How has he been sort of waging this power behind the scenes? Yeah, I mean, this was a fun story because we really got to trace the history of NVIDIA becoming a DC company. And, you know, I think people forget that just a few years ago, it was a much smaller gaming chip company before it became the chief allocator of the AI revolution.

36:49So during the early Biden years, in the early Biden years, in the Biden years before the export controls, NVIDIA didn't have that much of a presence in D.C. But then when Biden started doing these export controls on ships to China, NVIDIA built up its government affairs team in D.C. and started getting a reputation for having very sharp elbows within the Biden administration, on the Hill, in think tanks, really exerting its influence. And, you know, that's not abnormal for companies to do, but NVIDIA became the richest and I guess now the second richest company in the world. So obviously was able to hold more attention than I think other companies who tried the same game.

37:29Right. And, you know, I, Phoebe, when you look at this, I mean, this is kind of interesting because NVIDIA is at this point now where it's actually not as favorited, I guess, as you could say. I guess in the last couple of weeks, we've seen maybe some government officials, including the president, maybe soften his his unconditional support, at least a little bit for the company. Just walk us through a little bit what's going on here. Yeah, so last week the New York Times published a very well-reported story saying that Jensen had a close relationship with this Chinese business executive who had at some point been affiliated with an NVIDIA customer in Singapore that was under investigation for potentially skirting export controls and smuggling advanced NVIDIA chips to China.

38:25and the Times reported that the government had found or believed that that relationship possibly had a direct line into Beijing and thought that Jensen might be the target of some kind of spy plot. It's unclear if any information actually did pass. That would be pretty crazy. If so, we don't have evidence of that. But I think that's kind of a piece of the broader picture, kind of undergirding all of this. and as far as Trump's comments go over the weekend he was basically saying like okay like I still have full faith in him right now like previously I'd been briefed on this thing and like didn't take any action and this time around it seemed to suggest that he was going to look into it again he was like I have full faith in Jensen like unless or until we find something to the contrary right right leo another stakeholder in this is how nvidia has been um working with think tanks i guess on these uh advocacy advocacy groups what do we know about those relationships yeah i mean we kept hearing in the course of this reporting that nvidia in response to expert controls that limited powerful advanced ai chips going to china would have different arguments one that the Chinese chips didn't really have that different of capability or that chip smuggling wasn't actually that much of an issue.

39:54One of the most powerful players in the DC world is think tanks, which put out their own scholarship, but they often have a blurred line with donors like NVIDIA who provide finance to them. Like publications, think tanks often purport to have editorial independence. But what we found out and kept hearing examples of was scholars at these think tanks putting out policy papers that were very in favor of export controls and then the think tank getting very angry emails from nvidia's government affairs staff critiquing uh the the papers or dangling the threat of their funding and their donations uh so we have a lot of reporting about that in the story about how nvidia would express the displeasure and sometimes tie that with the money that they were giving to the think tank, again, to show how they were influencing these policy discussions that were happening in D.C.

40:47around export controls. Okay, so Phoebe, as I read this story, you know, one of the through lines that came through to me was, as Leo mentioned, you know, Jensen has occupied this role now of chief allocator, I guess. He's got the money, he's got the goods, he's got everything that everyone wants, and he has amassed so much power because of that. My read on this story, and I'm asking if this resonates with you, is people seem to be maybe getting a little bit tired of Jensen having all of this power and sort of calling the shots in the way that he does, because this is advocacy groups, this is politicians, this is open AI now also saying, hey, well, can't we have our own opinions about this is that sort of your read on on nvidia's current uh position in in the ai um political uh jungle of all this yeah i mean i think in both leo's conversations with sources and mine like the word tired came up like we're tired of their tactics or whatnot um several times so i think yes that is kind of the general sentiment among some policy makers in dc that said i think a lot of mvd's biggest customers are also starting to get a little bit more leverage in that they are explicitly making their own chips, which could kind of sway the policy balance of power as well.

42:08On top of that, I think NVIDIA has made some new hires like Bruce Andrews and others that may be a sign that its kind of stance in Washington is softening or kind of changing in some way or another to not be as sharp elbowed of like a staunch supporter of export controls in the way that it has in the last year, year and a half. And Leo, what's your read on this from the D.C. angle to all this? Yeah, I think our reporting, it came up again and again that the real peak of this was last year. Jensen obviously found a huge ally in Trump. And when there was these legislative debates last year as part of the Defense Authorization Act around export control bills, it was really able to throw its weight around on the hill, employing David Sachs, former AI czar within the Trump administration, who is an NVIDIA ally, to make sure that those bills didn't pass.

43:05We're seeing this again. This will come up after the midterms today. There's a different round of potential export control bills. And we kept hearing that it seems like NVIDIA will not be as strong-armed or might not have as much of an impact as they did last year. So this is really the race to watch, is there are three big export control bills as part of this broader package being considered. If they are able to advance, it would show NVIDIA's winning influence, whether that's a factor of, like Phoebe said, them bringing in new people who have more of a soft approach on the Hill, or because a lot of legislative offices are just getting tired of NVIDIA, or maybe because the Trump administration itself is souring on NVIDIA.

43:47We'll see, But there is this big policy debate that's about to happen, and I think the results of it will be very telling. And sorry, Leo, just to confirm, those three packages, the bills that I guess we are waiting to see if they go through, are those bipartisan? Do they fall on partisan lines? I'm just trying to understand how the midterms could affect that. So they're bipartisan, but they'll likely be debated and passed before the new Congress. So this will happen during the lame duck session after the elections today and before January. And this is another interesting dynamic, which is that, you know, China hawks are not really limited to one party.

44:28You see it often cross partisan lines. And that's why I think this expert control bill discussion will be very telling, which is, will NVIDIA be able to win back allies on both sides of the aisle? Well, and also, if it's going to happen during the lame duck session, then, you know, some of these politicians have nothing to lose. and so that you might actually see some of their very honest opinions on this matter come out, which I think might be very telling. I want to thank you both for coming on. That is Phoebe Liu, our NVIDIA reporter, and Leo Schwartz, our tech and politics reporter here at The Information.

45:03Thanks. That does it for today's show. A reminder, we are on the stream Monday through Friday at 10 a.m. Pacific, 1 p.m. Eastern. If you can't make it then, episodes are available on TheInformation.com, on our YouTube channel, or wherever you get your podcasts. Make sure to follow us on social media on X, on Instagram, on TikTok, and on LinkedIn. I am already excited for our next show tomorrow. Have a great rest of your Tuesday. Bye-bye for now.

From the publisher

Rosenblatt Securities Senior Research Analyst Barton Crockett talks with TITV Host Akash Pasricha about Apple’s slowing revenue growth, pressure on services and John Ternus’s first earnings call as CEO. We also talk with Stifel Managing Director and Senior Semiconductor Analyst Tore Svanberg about Marvell’s proposed acquisition of Lumentum, optical networking for AI data centers and regulatory scrutiny. The Information’s Leo Schwartz and Shane Burke discuss the midterm races that could shape data center development and California’s Proposition 40. Lastly, Nvidia reporter Phoebe Liu and tech and politics reporter Leo Schwartz unpack The Information’s reporting on Jensen Huang’s influence over chip-export policy and Washington think tanks.


Articles discussed in today’s show:

- Apple Sales Cool: https://www.theinformation.com/briefings/apple-sales-cool

- Marvell to Buy Lumentum: https://www.theinformation.com/briefings/marvell-buy-lumentum-115-billion-all-stock-deal

- Candidates Backing Data Center Pauses Could Win in Up to 15 Governor’s Races: https://www.theinformation.com/articles/candidates-backing-data-center-pauses-win-15-governors-races

- How Nvidia Uses Its Soft Power to Influence Customers and Shape Policy: https://www.theinformation.com/articles/nvidia-uses-soft-power-influence-customers-shape-policy


Subscribe:

- YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@theinformation

- The Information: https://www.theinformation.com/subscribe_h


Sign up for the AI Agenda newsletter: https://www.theinformation.com/features/ai-agenda


TITV airs weekdays on YouTube, X and LinkedIn at 10AM PT / 1PM ET. Or check us out wherever you get your podcasts.


Follow us:

X: https://x.com/theinformation

IG: https://www.instagram.com/theinformation/

TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@titv.theinformation

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/theinformation/


Chapters:

01:13 - Introduction and Apple’s earnings

13:56 - Marvell’s Lumentum acquisition

24:24 - Midterms and data center policy

34:20 - Nvidia’s influence in Washington

45:40 - Closing


More from The Information's TITV

All episodes