1. Podcasts
  2. The Interview
  3. Michael Freeman, forensic medicine expert: Why I dispute official ruling on Epstein’s death
The Interview

20 Nov 2026 · 23m · 7 chapters

Episode artwork

Michael Freeman, forensic medicine expert: Why I dispute official ruling on Epstein’s death

In short

Forensic medicine expert Michael Freeman, interviewed by BBC’s Victoria Derbyshire, argues he disputes the official ruling that Jeffrey Epstein died by suicide in a New York prison cell in 2019. Freeman says he reviewed Epstein’s autopsy records and photographs and believes the injuries are inconsistent with self-inflicted hanging, claiming signs of assault/ligature strangulation from behind, with the same ligature later used to suspend the body. He highlights alleged omissions and lack of follow-up: no DNA swabbing (including fingernails), no scene-of-crime evidence collection, and no photographs of the body with the ligature in place. He questions the guard’s account of how Epstein was found and says crucial evidence (e.g., fabric/ligature details) was not recovered or reassessed. Background: Freeman is a forensic medicine expert; he says Mark Epstein provided confidential photos but did not pay him.

Notable examples

deep hemorrhage to Epstein’s left shoulder, facial blunt-force trauma, and purported fingernail marks above the ligature.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:50

Introducing Michael Freeman and Epstein's Case

Michael Freeman discusses Epstein's death and his belief it was homicide.

“and contends Epstein's death in prison was the result of homicide rather than suicide.”
3:55

Inconsistencies in Epstein's Autopsy

Freeman details the inconsistencies in the autopsy report and investigation.

“There's only one remaining explanation then, and that is that the death was as a result of a homicide.”
6:20

The Evidence Suggesting Homicide

Freeman outlines the physical evidence that indicates homicide over suicide.

“But I have the photographs of the external examination, of the internal examination, of the anthropological examination of the bone in the neck that was fractured and of the cartilage that was fractured.”
8:10

Discussions on the Medical Examination

A deep dive into the medical examiner's findings and their implications.

“why did you leave out the part where you described a deep hemorrhage to his left shoulder?”
10:50

Claims About the Scene and Evidence

Freeman addresses the claims made by guards and the absence of crucial evidence.

“What are you saying is the new evidence?”
14:27

Analyzing Epstein's Death: A Forensic Perspective

Michael Freeman discusses the inconsistencies in the ruling on Epstein's death.

“As I listened really carefully to what Michael Freeman was telling me, and having read the official reports compiled into Epstein's death, I was also thinking about some of the women Epstein exploited and abused.”
21:58

The Role of Emotions in Forensic Analysis

Freeman explains the importance of objectivity in forensic investigations.

“That would indicate that he's not suicidal by the time that this, what was ultimately deemed to be a suicide by the medical examiner occurred.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The Interview, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

0:30all in one place, so you can invest your way. Visit schwab.com to learn more. You've considered advancing your education or pursuing a new career. Rasmussen University has a seat saved for you. And with over 50 online programs, you can take a seat in your kitchen, your kids' soccer practice, your commute home, or wherever your busy schedule takes you. Plus, with a team dedicated to supporting you every step of the way, you may be online, but you'll never be alone. Find the program that fits your goals at rasmussen.edu. BBC World Service. This episode of The Interview contains details of death and injury and discussion of suicide.

1:14Hello, I'm Victoria Derbyshire and this is The Interview from the BBC World Service. The best conversations coming out of the BBC. People shaping our world from all over the world. I want to get freedom. I like that freedom. A gender equal world would be a better world for men too. We need this is fire. We need healing. We need trust. These companies don't really, they don't care what governments do. This is a war. The first thing that we want is the war to end. For this episode, I speak to forensic medicine expert Michael Freeman, who says he's reviewed Jeffrey Epstein's autopsy records and contends Epstein's death in prison was the result of homicide rather than suicide.

2:00Epstein was a wealthy American financier and convicted sex offender, with links to prominent figures around the world. He died in a New York prison in 2019, while awaiting trial on charges of sex trafficking underage girls. His death was ruled a suicide by New York City's medical examiner. A subsequent FBI investigation found no evidence of criminal activity connected to his death, while the US Justice Department's Inspector General also concluded there was no evidence of foul play. But Freeman disputes those conclusions. He believes Epstein was assaulted and strangled, most likely from behind, and argues that the injuries documented in the autopsy are inconsistent with the official account.

2:46He also raises serious questions about the original investigation, arguing that crucial evidence was overlooked and that important aspects of the case were not properly examined. If the DOJ interviewer had had the autopsy report, that interviewer could have asked, why did you leave out the part where you described a deep hemorrhage to his left shoulder? If you say there was no debris under the fingernails, what else did you look for? did you swab the fingernails, which was not done. There was no swabbing for DNA on any part of the body. And so there are a lot of unexplained findings from the autopsy that unfortunately the interviewers didn't follow up on.

3:29Dr. Barbara Sampson, chief medical examiner of New York City at the time of Epstein's autopsy, who ruled that Epstein's death was a suicide, has previously said, I stand firmly behind our determination of the cause and manner of death for Mr. Epstein. The cause is hanging, the manor is suicide. The BBC has approached Dr Sampson for comment. Welcome to the interview from the BBC World Service with Michael Freeman. Well, in looking at the circumstances and how his body was described as being found when it was taken down from the suspension by the guard who found him, and comparing that to the injuries that were found during the autopsy and that I've been able to review in the autopsy evidence, the injuries and the way the body was found don't match up.

4:16There's only one remaining explanation then, and that is that the death was as a result of a homicide. And that would have been a homicide that included strangling, most likely from behind. So the definition of homicide is the killing of one person by another, intentionally or unintentionally. I want to ask you, can you describe to us in plain English then what you think happened, what you believe happened in that cell? Well, the evidence that we see is that there are signs indicating an insult. There is a deep muscular hemorrhage to the left shoulder. There are injuries to the face that appear to be consistent with blunt force trauma being struck in the face.

4:57There are even fingernail marks or the appearance of fingernail marks above the level of where the ligature is at the neck, which would be consistent with strangulation, particularly from behind, and the attempt by the victim to try to remove the ligature from the neck. Can you describe what you think happened in that cell? What you believe happened in that cell? I believe that the evidence is most consistent with an assault, a ligature strangulation from behind, and then most probably using that same ligature to suspend the body from the bunk bed. That's quite an extraordinary claim to make. You're saying that someone else killed him.

5:36Well, what I'm saying as a certainty is he didn't get all of those injuries from self-inflicted hanging, that just the hanging alone cannot explain the injuries. And by a process of elimination, he didn't die from a natural cause. He didn't die from old age in his cell, and he die from an accident. So the only option that we have is that he died as a result of a homicide. Or that he died by taking his own life, which is what the official reports say. And you've reached that conclusion because you've looked at photographs. Is that right? I have all of the evidence from the autopsy. The only thing I wasn't able to do was be present for the autopsy.

6:20But I have the photographs of the external examination, of the internal examination, of the anthropological examination of the bone in the neck that was fractured and of the cartilage that was fractured. So I have all of the evidence the medical examiner had, plus I have the evidence that the medical examiner didn't have, which is the account from the guard who found the body. There was no account of how the body was found at the time that the autopsy was done. there was actually no indication that there was a hanging other than what that guard said. And then that guard refused to talk to anybody for two years.

7:01What you haven't looked at is the body. I have not looked at the body. Which, of course, the medical examiner did look at diligently and carefully because that's their job. Of course. And from the medical examiner who looked at the body, we know from the official DOJ, Office of the Inspector General, report into the US Bureau of Prisons Care and Custody of Epstein, it says the medical examiner who performed the autopsy told the Office of Inspector General that Epstein's injuries were consistent with suicide by hanging and that there was no evidence of defensive wounds that would be expected if his death had been a homicide.

7:39Epstein did not have marks on his hands. He didn't have broken fingernails. He didn't have debris under them. He didn't have contusions to his knuckles that would of evidence to fight. Or, other than an abrasion on his arm, he didn't have bruising on his body. And that official report was then reviewed and approved by the first deputy chief medical examiner. Well, I guess if the DOJ interviewer had had the autopsy report, that interviewer could have asked, why did you leave out the part where you described a deep hemorrhage to his left shoulder? If you say there was no debris under the fingernails, what else did you look for?

8:25Did you swab the fingernails? Which was not done. There was no swabbing for DNA on any part of the body. And so there are a lot of unexplained findings from the autopsy that unfortunately the interviewers didn't follow up on. The medical examiner gave answers, and the answers were not even consistent with what was described in the autopsy report. You say they're unexplained. Even if that's true, and the official reports contradict that, that doesn't mean it was homicide, does it? That is still a leap for a person like yourself who is trained in forensic pathology, but doesn't practice it, and who didn't see the body.

9:03Well, seeing the body didn't add any information that we don't have outside of what's in the medical examiner's report. How do you know? And the photographs. How can you know that? Because nothing's described in the report or shown in the photographs that you can't see. The whole point of an autopsy, the word autopsy means to see for yourself. You document everything that you see. There are extensive photographs of everything that was seen. And the most critical thing to see is what the shape and the nature of the ligature mark is. Looking at it in person isn't going to look any different than looking at it in the 30-plus photographs that we have of it.

9:40That's not going to change anything. So there's nothing that the medical examiner said during the interview that said, well, only I could see, only I could see this one thing that told me this must be a suicide, but you can't see it in the photographs, and I didn't write it down in the autopsy report. That's not what you're supposed to do in forensic pathology. You're supposed to document everything. So if you see something, and it's something that's unique, that actually dictates what your determination is, then it has to be documented. But there's nothing like that. There's nothing here that says this must be a suicide.

10:15The only reason we believe this man might have been hanged is because a guard who said that he found him hanging from his bunk bed two years later said, well, that's how I found him. But we don't have any evidence. It was uncorroborated. If the body had been found flat on his back with the ligature mark, everyone would look at it and say this guy was probably strangled. And so the fact that the determination has been made doesn't mean the determination is correct. And now that we have new information, we have to go back and we have to revisit it. And that's something the medical examiner never did.

10:49Lots of things to unpack there. What are you saying is the new evidence? The new evidence is how the body was positioned, where the ligature was anchored, and what kind of injuries we would expect from the way the body was positioned at the time that it was found. So we know from the official report that the guard who found Epstein, Michael Thomas, entered the cell, I'm quoting from the report, and saw Epstein hanged. He immediately yelled for guard number two to get help. The alarm was activated, signaling a medical emergency. Michael Thomas said, and I'm quoting, He immediately ripped the orange sheet or shirt away from the bunk bed and Epstein's body dropped to the ground.

11:35Thomas said he then lowered the entire body to the floor and began chest compressions until other medical staff arrived. So the guard who found Epstein explained what happened. Guard number two was calling for help. No photographs were taken at that moment because they were trying to save Epstein's life. Are you not accepting that? Are you saying they're lying about that? No, I think that they're telling the truth, actually. I think what the guard is saying is telling the truth. We then couldn't find out more from the guard about what is it that he was hanging from? What was around his neck? That was never found.

12:17That was never recovered from the cell. We've got photographs of that in the official report. No, no. There was photographs of a sheet that the medical examiner says wasn't what the body was hanging from. And it was a sheet that was picked up by an EMT, a responder who put it on the gurney when they carried the body out. There was no investigation at the scene to try to figure out what of all the different pieces and scraps of fabric that were in the room. Figure 5.5 in the official report, a photo of a piece of orange cloth tied into a noose recovered from Epstein's cell after his death. Which the medical examiner said wasn't the ligature probably, that it was a different photograph.

13:01It was a piece of fabric that was never recovered. It was just, we have no idea where it went.

13:09You're listening to The Interview from the BBC World Service with me, Victoria Derbyshire.

13:19you've considered advancing your education or pursuing a new career Rasmussen University has a seat saved for you and with over 50 online programs you can take a seat in your kitchen your kids soccer practice your commute home or wherever your busy schedule takes you plus with a team dedicated to supporting you every step of the way you may be online but you'll never be alone find the program that fits your goals at rasmussen.edu you. Running a business shouldn't feel like surviving a software group project. One app for accounting, another for inventory, another for sales. And somehow, none of them talk to each other.

13:57That's where Odoo comes in. An all-in-one business management software that brings every part of your business together. From sales and accounting to inventory and marketing, all in one powerful platform. No messy integrations, no bouncing between tabs, And best of all, no spreadsheets. Stop managing software and start managing your business with one unified system. Try for free today at odoo.com. That's O-D-O-O dot com.

14:27As I listened really carefully to what Michael Freeman was telling me, and having read the official reports compiled into Epstein's death, I was also thinking about some of the women Epstein exploited and abused. They have fought for years to get the authorities to take seriously what they said Epstein did to them. And they're still fighting. Some have also told me they don't believe Epstein took his own life in jail. OK, let's return to my conversation with Michael Freeman. You've mentioned a couple of times that the guard number one, as I'm calling him, Michael Thomas, didn't do an interview for two years.

15:04That can be explained, surely, by the circumstances. He was under investigation by the FBI because he hadn't done the regular monitoring of the cells in that area that he should have been doing. So he falsified records. He admitted that. He's not going to do an interview because he's being investigated by the FBI. He did eventually do an interview. Yes. So does it matter that two years passed before he did that interview? Well, it matters that the medical examiner said, this death is undetermined. I want to talk with the guard. never talked with the guard, and four days later said, it's a suicide.

15:39And then the guard finally gave information two years later, and that information was never reassessed. So it matters from that perspective, yes. The medical examiner was interviewed by the U.S. Department of Justice in May 2022. We've got the transcript from the Epstein files. She says she would have liked to speak to the guard and visited the cell, but it wasn't possible. but she was also clear that was simply in the interests of Thorinus and it was still a pretty clear-cut suicide. Well, I know that she doubled down on the idea that it was a suicide. She didn't explain how the injuries, which were inconsistent with her description, actually occurred, however, and she omitted numerous injuries that were consistent with a struggle.

16:26Are you able to say who you think could have killed Epstein if your theory is accurate and why? I have no idea. That is not something I have an opinion about. That isn't any part of any investigation that I've done. My investigation is purely to see whether these injuries are possibly explained by a suicidal hanging, which is what the medical examiner said. And the injuries are impossible if you look at the scenario and how the body was found. I mean, that's really emphatic. You say it's impossible. You're absolutely sure. And yet you haven't seen the body. And there are three official reports that have ruled that Epstein killed himself.

17:08The New York City Medical Examiner's Office, a separate FBI investigation that found no crimes associated with the death and the U.S. Justice Department's watchdog, the Office of Inspector General, who found no evidence of foul play. Repeating something that's erroneous doesn't make it more correct over time. All of those determinations are based on the original determination that this was a suicide. We have one person who is evaluating a body that is said to have been found in a cell hanging. We're missing almost every element we would have in a highly investigated, you would expect, death. because what we have is an internationally known multi-millionaire sex trafficker who dies under what are reasonably considered suspicious circumstances.

17:58We have video that doesn't work. We have a roommate who has been transferred out of the cell on the same day. We have all sorts of things going on in the room, in the cell itself, that possibly indicative of a struggle, hard to say, but there are blankets and sheets and there's an extra mattress in the room. There's all sorts of things. So what? With respect, at this point, you are sounding, if I may, more like a conspiracy theorist than somebody trained in forensic pathology. Well, let me finish my answer real quick. There's all sorts of things that are unusual and suspicious. We are missing the elements that we normally have for an investigation of a hanging in custody.

18:39We don't have a photograph of the body as it was suspended. If someone is found hanging, you don't stop to take a photograph, do you? You try and save their life. And we have the guard telling the official report that they were shouting, breathe, Epstein, Epstein, breathe. We have inmates who are around who could hear that going on. I'm not faulting anybody for taking the body down from how it was found. As the guard describes it, it's appropriate to try to resuscitate the body. The body was cold by this time. The body had been dead for hours. Nothing was going to happen. That was quite clear.

19:15The body never regained any kind of heartbeat or had any sign that it could be resuscitated. The guard didn't know all that. Understood. I'm not faulting the guard. I'm talking about the fact that we then don't have a picture of the body, with the ligature in place. We have somebody with a camera in the room, but we have no pictures of the body with the ligature in place. In fact, the person who is... Someone with a camera in the room after the event. Yes. Not right there and then. Well... Because the body has been taken to hospital because they're trying to save his life. No, no, you're missing out on the evidence.

19:49There is no treating of this room like it might be a crime scene. It's never closed. People are in and out of it. There's no scene of crime investigation. There's no fingerprinting. There's no DNA swabbing. There's no DNA swabbing on the body. I mean, the medical examiner talked about the fact that there was no sign of a struggle because he didn't have broken fingernails. That would be very atypical, particularly for a man with very closely trimmed fingernails, which is what he had. I mean, atypical does not lead to necessarily homicide. It just means it's atypical? What's atypical, the circumstances of how this suicidal hanging was investigated, that's what's atypical.

20:32That doesn't mean that it's a homicide. However, if you find injuries that cannot be explained by the theory that is put forth by the medical examiner, which is that this is a suicidal hanging and there is no evidence that there has been any kind of struggle, there are no other injuries except for a little scratch on the arm, omitting the injuries on the shoulder, omitting the injuries in the face, omitting what appear to be fingernail marks above the ligature. Fingernail marks above the ligature or any injury above the ligature are impossible in a suicidal hanging. We know Epstein was suicidal.

21:07He tried to take his own life two weeks earlier. The official report into his death says he'd been found the previous month with an orange cloth around his neck, and Epstein's cellmate told officers he had tried to hang himself. Medical staff examined him. They found friction marks and superficial reddening around his neck, and they placed him on suicide watch. So according to that report, his mental health was deteriorating. I have no comment about that. I can't tell you that any of those findings are valid or invalid. I've not investigated it. Right. I know... But there's no reason to suggest they're invalid though, is there?

21:47Well, he was taken off suicide watch a week and a half later. I'm not sure why that happened. I'm not going to comment on how the prison was being run, but he was taken off suicide watch. That would indicate that he's not suicidal by the time that this, what was ultimately deemed to be a suicide by the medical examiner occurred. But I can't tell you that he was suicidal. He wasn't. I have spoken to his brother. His brother says that he doesn't believe he was suicidal. I don't have any kind of opinion about that. It's not something I've evaluated. Well, talking of Jeffrey Epstein's brother, it's Mark Epstein has long believed his brother was murdered.

22:27He gave you the file of these confidential photographs showing the body of Epstein to analyze. Is your analysis independent? Completely independent. Do you mind if I ask, has Mark Epstein paid you? I don't mind if you ask, and no, he hasn't. That would not be appropriate in any way whatsoever. I would mention, by the way, that the entire file that I received from Mark Epstein will be uploaded at the time of my lecture so that there will be general access to it. Unlike the medical examiner, I have the luxury of being able to say, don't take my word for it, let everybody look at it. If you think I'm still a conspiracy theorist because I'm looking at something that looks like a strangulation and say, I think it is a strangulation and I don't think it could be a hanging, show me where I got it wrong.

23:17I'm wide open to that. I'm an academic. I'm quite happy to hear people's theories on things that are informed. We've talked about conspiracy theories. Are you adding to them, do you think, with this work, potentially? You mean by saying that I've done a scientific analysis of the forces and the effects of the described hanging and looked at the consistency with the marks on the body and the injuries on the body. No, I think I'm doing what should have been done in the first place. I think that that hopefully does something to clarify the issue. That's my goal. There's a reason that the files are being released at the same point in time.

23:54I think people should see what's going on here. This is a topic of great public interest. It certainly is. And on Newsnight, I have interviewed many survivors of Epstein's sexual abuse. have they been in your mind as you have been doing this work? Frankly, no, and not because of the fact that what's happened to them hasn't been terrible. It's because it doesn't help me do what I'm trying to do. I really can't have that information in my head because maybe that makes me want to think one way or think the other. I'm trying to look at what the evidence shows and see how that comports with the other evidence of the circumstances.

24:36Thank you for listening to The Interview. For more compelling conversations, search for The Interview wherever you get your BBC podcasts. You'll find my conversations with survivors of Jeffrey Epstein, as well as interviews with film director Christopher Nolan and Google CEO Sundar Pichai, among many others. Until the next time, bye for now. If you've been affected by some of the issues that have come up in this interview, you could speak to a health professional or an organisation that offers support. There are details of help available in many countries at Befrienders.org. Innovation has always kept the world moving forward, but it also comes with risk.

25:22As technology and AI evolve, AXA XL is facing into risk. As a leading global insurer, we constantly push the boundaries to protect your data and network from cyber risks. AXA XL, facing into risk for a future to be imagined. This advertisement doesn't constitute an offer or solicitation nor a description of any products or services of AXA XL. Balance your trading strategy by adding futures. CME Group helps you manage risk and capture opportunities in all market environments. Capitalize on around-the-clock access to highly liquid global futures and options markets across all major asset classes.

26:00Visit your online broker and get started. See what adding futures can do for you at cmegroup.com forward slash podcast. Derivatives are not suitable for all investors and involve the risk of losing more than the amount originally deposited and any profit you might have made. This is not a recommendation or offer to buy, sell, or attain any specific investment or service.

From the publisher

“By a process of elimination, he didn't die from a natural cause. He didn't die from old age in his cell, and he didn't die from an accident. So the only option that we have is that he died as a result of a homicide.” BBC Newsnight presenter Victoria Derbyshire speaks to forensic medicine expert Michael Freeman, who says he's reviewed Jeffrey Epstein's autopsy records and contends Epstein's death in jail was the result of homicide rather than suicide.

Epstein was a wealthy American financier and convicted sex offender, with links to prominent figures around the world. He died in a New York jail in 2019 while awaiting trial on charges of sex trafficking involving underage girls.

His death was ruled a suicide by New York City's medical examiner. A subsequent FBI investigation found no evidence of criminal activity connected to his death, while the US Department of Justice’s Inspector General also concluded there was no evidence of foul play.

In an interview with BBC Newsnight, Freeman challenges these conclusions. He argues Epstein was assaulted and strangled, most likely from behind, and contends that the injuries documented in the autopsy are inconsistent with the official account of his death.

Dr Barbara Sampson, Chief Medical Examiner of New York City at the time of Epstein's autopsy, has previously said: “I stand firmly behind our determination of the cause and manner of death for Mr. Epstein. The cause is hanging, the manner is suicide”.

This episode of the interview contains details of death and injury and discussion of suicide.

The Interview brings you conversations with people shaping our world, from all over the world. The best interviews from the BBC, including episodes with Sundar Pichai and Julia Gillard. You can listen on the BBC World Service on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays at 0800 GMT. Or you can listen to The Interview as a podcast, out three times a week on BBC Sounds or wherever you get your podcasts. Presenter: Victoria Derbyshire Producer: Osman Iqbal Editor: Farhana Haider

(Image: Michael Freeman. Credit: BBC)

More from The Interview

All episodes