


Gregory Forth discusses his long-running anthropological research on Flores Island, focusing on two ideas: (1) the fossil hominin Homo floresiensis (“Flores hobbit”), and (2) local reports from the Leo region of a still-existing “Leo ape man” (lihoa/“lihor,” also linked by locals to terms like abugogo). He connects these stories to the fossil record, especially the timing of Homo sapiens on Flores and evidence about what Homo floresiensis ate.
Gregory Forth is a cultural anthropologist who began field research on Flores in 1984, returning repeatedly for decades. He investigated local languages and beliefs, then later (especially after 2003) pursued the lihoa/abugogo reports more intensively, interviewing dozens of people and writing about them in books.
Local sightings are concentrated in eastern Flores (Leo region), mostly in mountainous, forested areas away from settlements. Forth argues the descriptions match the “ape man” concept and are not merely misidentified monkeys, noting Flores lacks native apes and has limited monkey fauna. He also argues that Homo floresiensis likely ranged beyond a single discovery site given the long survival window (tens of thousands of years). He suggests Komodo dragons may have killed many pygmy stagodons, with Homo sapiens possibly overlapping later.
Nage-region folklore about abugogo being wiped out 200–300 years ago; reports of lihoa sightings in high-altitude Leo forests; a 2019 account from two British hikers; and comparisons to “orang pendek” in Sumatra (where no fossil evidence exists).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Explore the discovery of the Homo floresiensis and its implications.
“Yeah, so it's like flora and then siencis.”
Learn about Gregory's early research and local legends regarding small hominids.
“And what is fascinating about your work is that you were on that island quite a bit before that.”
Discussion on potential distinct species and local claims about hominids.
“But then subsequent to that visit, I began to hear about similar creatures further to the east in a place called Leo.”
Delve into findings related to ancient hominids and their tools.
“There has been discovered after a deliberate search by paleoanthropologists, if you'll appreciate that distinction, also in the central part of Flores.”
Examine the evidence and implications of coexistence between species.
“And are these stone tools clearly formed like an arrowhead or a spearhead or are they ambiguous?”
Discuss the myths surrounding creatures similar to Homo floresiensis.
“Which would leave – yeah, although, again, if I've got this right and if I'm up to date on this, I'm not sure that there are clear evidence.”
Discover the unique characteristics and myths surrounding the Orang Pendek and Floresiensis.
“It was kind of gobsmacking than would be, he said, the discovery of a space alien.”
Discuss the food chain on Flores, including the dragons and their prey.
“But if you're a 10-foot-long poisonous lizard, it's going to be hard to sustain that mass just on rats unless they're overpopulated with rats.”
Explore the legend of the Abugogo, creatures said to live in caves and interact with villagers.
“Yeah, you get narrative themes entering, including two escaping the extermination.”
Hear about firsthand encounters with the Leo ape men and the excitement of discovery.
“Yeah, there are other stories told soon thereafter.”
Understand the analysis of credibility in reported sightings of the Leo ape men.
“So as we were saying, you had this encounter with someone who explained that they had seen one in the flesh.”
Discuss the resources and expertise needed for a thorough search for the Leo ape men.
“And so in total, yeah, it was well over 120, 130 people I think I talked to in all.”
Learn about the different types of expertise required for exploration in rugged areas.
“You'd need people who are young and fit.”
Discussion about Les Stroud's belief in Bigfoot and potential exploration.
“But yeah, so I'm expecting him on Friday the 13th, actually, so just in, what, nine, ten days' time.”
Delve into the physical challenges faced in research and the role of technology.
“Well, you know, coincidences do happen, including remarkable ones, so maybe that's it.”
Understand the importance of local knowledge in discovering new species.
“So, yeah, those would come into play as well.”
Hear about recent encounters and reports from hikers in Flores Island.
“Not the kind of place where you'd expect to find rabbits or hares perhaps.”
Examine a specific encounter reported by British visitors and its significance.
“after doing, one of them in particular, found my name after doing an internet search concerning apes and monkeys on Flores Island.”
Discussion on various sightings of ape-like creatures in Indonesia.
“I might mention 2019 was well before the 22 book came out, so that's a factor as well.”
Detailed exploration of the Homo floresiensis and its implications for anthropology.
“It is not present or wasn't at one time present also on other islands around and about.”
Theories on how ancient species migrated to Flores and the tools they used.
“So we don't really know because it's so difficult to make a fossil.”
Exploration of how various species arrived on islands, with a focus on the mechanisms and evidence of sea travel.
“it's reckoned that they well they wouldn't have had like sea craft no land bridges by the way that anybody knows about so they would have to come somehow by sea.”
Discussion about the wildlife on islands, the introduction of species by humans, and the historical context of these changes.
“There's evidence for this kind of thing happening.”
Insight into the discovery and characteristics of Homo floresiensis, a small hominin species, and the debates surrounding their classification.
“There is a book in which I've written about all this stuff, but I can't remember now.”
Exploration of the cultural and behavioral aspects of Homo naledi and other hominins, including burial practices and tool use.
“Yeah, there's a similar remains in Luzon Island.”
A deep dive into the ongoing debates among paleoanthropologists regarding the classification of ancient hominins, particularly Homo floresiensis.
“Because it makes you think, like, well, what else did they have?”
Explore the complexity of human evolution and the misconceptions in the linear model.
“I mean, one suggestion was that, you know, this thing is so recent, bearing in mind that one specimen was reckoned to be only 12 ,000, 13 ,000 years old at the time.”
Discuss the resistance within the scientific community to change long-held beliefs.
“Rather that the suggestion was that the view now seems to be that the human tree, family tree as it were, is bushy.”
Learn about the modern people's experiences on Flores Island and their beliefs in supernatural beings.
“I mean, they ruined this guy's reputation.”
Investigate the substances consumed by the local population and their effects on perception.
“All I'm trying to say, and my focus, of course, is on the people, the modern people of Florey's Island and their experiences and, you know, how they think, what they say and all that kind of stuff.”
Examine the traditional uses of substances like beetle nut and tobacco among the locals.
“But are the, so is that the only documented substance that these people are taking on this island?”
Delve into the myths surrounding local creatures and their origins in reality.
“You were smoking cigarettes on the island by yourself?”
Explore how local myths may arise from misinterpretations of real animals and their behaviors.
“that seemed to be something that was fiction?”
Explore the origins and myths surrounding civet coffee and the perceptions of exotic animals.
“You think that you're drinking coffee that came out of a civet's butt.”
Discuss the ethical dilemmas of capturing and studying potentially discovered species.
“But it gets to the point where if you have enough of them and they're so similar and then you have bones and then you don't just have bones there, but you have bones in the Philippines.”
Examine the best practices for studying new or rare species in the wild.
“But if they captured one of them, like, boy, I would feel bad.”
Delve into eyewitness accounts and anthropological anecdotes of mysterious small beings.
“But there's quite a few credible reports of sightings.”
Learn about the existence and characteristics of pygmoid populations in New Guinea.
“In fact, I had some difficulty preparing for this interview because I'm working on the proofs, the final proofs and the index.”
Investigate legends of Sasquatch and the cultural significance of these accounts in Native American folklore.
“Where else are these credible witness accounts of people experiencing these kind of little tiny ape-like creatures?”
Explore the cultural significance and historical accounts of Sasquatch sightings.
“I don't know which one it is, but Daniel Boone.”
Discuss the tension between scientific skepticism and belief in Bigfoot.
“Again, I don't know much of the details of that.”
Analyze the similarities and differences in Sasquatch-like myths across cultures.
“If you start saying you believe in Bigfoot, you're immediately put into the Coupé category.”
Examine historical evidence and accounts of potential Sasquatch sightings.
“If you look at general knowledge, then you do start to get kind of fantastic features, right?”
Delve into the story of Jacko, a supposed Sasquatch captured in British Columbia.
“Maybe Forrest would be interested in doing it.”
Explore the credibility of Sasquatch sightings in North America.
“Now, I think it had longish head hair as well.”
Learn about the historical context regarding the public's knowledge of great apes.
“The mountain gorilla I think was the 20th century was it?”
Hear about personal accounts of Bigfoot sightings and the challenges of the environment.
“And she said she saw this thing, and she, for a half a second, she goes, that's a gorilla.”
Delve into historical exhibitions of people and the myths surrounding them.
“I guess, but then you have to ask, why would anybody like that want to be running through the woods, you know, in some remote place, presumably naked?”
Learn about the perspectives on witchcraft and its cultural significance.
“But before that, Europeans thought that pygmies were a myth, that there was no such thing, that this was a product of Greek mythology, especially.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On The Joe Rogan Experience, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This episode is presented by Searchlight Pictures' Wild Horse 9. Shortly before Chile's 1973 coup, two CIA agents, played by John Malkovich and Sam Rockwell, find their mission on Easter Island, spiraling into a web of conspiracies, unexpected alliances, and chaos. Wild Horse 9, only in theaters Friday. Get tickets now. All your favorite NBA players are back. And DraftKings Sportsbook, an official sports betting partner of the NBA, is the place to bet on NBA stars this season. Follow your favorite NBA stars, get excited about the biggest matchups, and lock in on those buzzer-beating moments. Plus, new customers get three months of NBA League Pass on us so you can catch more NBA action anytime, anywhere.
0:50Download the DraftKings Sports app today and use code ROGAN. New DraftKings customers spend$5 and get$200 in total bonuses, plus three months of NBA League Pass on us. That's CodeRogan in partnership with DraftKings. The crown is yours.
1:24Bonus bets expire seven days after issuance. For additional terms and responsible gaming resources, see sportsbook.draftkings.com slash promos. NBA League Pass auto renews until canceled. Limited time offer. This episode is brought to you by ZipRecruiter. Hook up a better speaker to your TV and your home theater experience is immediately 10 times better. Or add a little extra treat to your dog's food. They get so happy at dinnertime. Sometimes it's worth it to go that extra step. to find people who will do that for your business. Check out ZipRecruiter. Try it for free at ziprecruiter.com slash rogan.
2:02ZipRecruiter has what you need to find great candidates fast, like powerful matching technology to help sort through thousands of resumes and a feature that puts people who are the most interested and most qualified first. Try ZipRecruiter and meet great candidates who'll go the extra step for your job. Four out of five employers who post on ZipRecruiter get a quality candidate within the first day. Try it for free today at ZipRecruiter.com slash Rogan. That's ZipRecruiter.com slash Rogan. ZipRecruiter. Meet your match on ZipRecruiter. Joe Rogan podcast. Check it out. The Joe Rogan experience.
2:45Train by day, Joe Rogan podcast by night, all day. Thank you very much for being here. I'm really excited to talk to you. I am fascinated by this little hobbit creature, this Homo floriensis. Am I saying it right? Floresiensis. Floresiensis. Floresiensis. Yeah, so it's like flora and then siencis. Right. I've been fascinated from 2003 when it was announced. Well, when was it announced? They discovered it in 2003? September 2003, announced October 2004. So for people that don't know what we're talking about is the supposed hobbit people from the island of Flora. It's a very small, tiny. It's in the homo genus, right?
3:33That's right. That's where it's been put. A relative of human beings. That's the little fella right there. Fair enough, yeah. Quite good. And what is fascinating about your work is that you were on that island quite a bit before that. And you were investigating the possibility of this existing a long time before that. Yeah, no, that's correct. I first began field research on Flores as an anthropologist, a cultural anthropologist in 1984. I was interested in the people and the culture and the languages generally. but quite early in my stay in fact in 1984 during my first visit I heard about these small hominoid human-like creatures which were known locally actually at that time I was working right in the central part of the island a place called Nage and the Nage people according to the Nage people there were a group of these used to live close by in a cave high up on a nearby volcano.
4:42But they had become extinct about 200, 300 years previously. So in that particular area, that particular part of Flores, they weren't supposed to be around anymore. But then subsequent to that visit, I began to hear about similar creatures further to the east in a place called Leo. and those are the ones I write about in the book. Yeah, in the book you discuss two distinct, at least possible different species. Yeah. One of them being Homo floresiensis and the other one being this one from Leo. No. Well, in a way you could say that. I mean, there's Homo floresiensis, which lived on the island of Flores for a long time and must have lived in places other than the single discovery site.
5:41And then there are the claims, the descriptions offered by Leo people about creatures they say are still around, rare, but still present in their territory in which some people claim to have seen and have given quite vivid descriptions of. And they seem very similar. If I may just expand a bit. There has been discovered after a deliberate search by paleoanthropologists, if you'll appreciate that distinction, also in the central part of Flores. In fact, in a place where decades ago there were discovered stagodons, kind of primitive elephant bones in large numbers. And there was evidence that something had, if not killed these things, these stagodons had at least eaten them, eaten their carcasses.
6:44A very long intensive study was done in what, the 2000s into the 20-teens, looking for some kind of human, some kind of hominid remains. And finally, after a concentrated effort, they found pieces of jaw, pieces, oh right, teeth, that belonged to something far older than Floresiensis, going back about 700 ,000 years ago. and contemporaneous with what would take to be stone tools, which is what kind of set them in motion in the first place, which were even smaller than Floresiensis. And it is kind of presumed that these are possible ancestors of Floresiensis. Again, going back further, hundreds of thousands of years.
7:51700 ,000, 600, 700 ,000, something in that. But there's also stone tool evidence or stones taken to be possible tools that takes us back even further to like a million years ago, maybe even earlier. I mean, there's still a big mystery as to how these things ever got on the island. Right. Yeah. And are these stone tools clearly formed like an arrowhead or a spearhead or are they ambiguous? Some of them, you know, this is not my area. I should confess straight away. But some of them are ambiguous. There have been different interpretations. Some authorities in paleoanthropology, archaeology would suggest that they're not artifacts at all.
8:44They're not things that have been made by any hominin. So here's, Jamie pulled up some examples from Indonesia. Yeah. And this is some potential tools that they believe Homo floresiensis used. And you can see they are tool-like, but it's a little odd. It's hard to say. Could be just flakes of chips of stone. Well, to mention right away there is that there was some overlap between Floresiensis and ourselves, Homo sapiens. And it is a well-known generalization, certainly in that part of the world, that you can't distinguish species on the basis of stone tool industries, as they're called. In other words, you need skeletal evidence in close association with anything that is a stone tool or might be to say what species probably made these things.
9:49So, yeah, none of these can we securely attribute to Homo phrysiansis. There have been some fascinating recent studies actually on stagodon bones close to the location of the discovery site. Is that a pygmy elephant? Is that a small elephant? Yeah. Those would have been the ones that they preyed on or scavenged. Yeah, a pygmy stagodon but the size of a cow. So if you can think of an elephant the size of a cow. Still pretty formidable if you're only three feet, three and a half feet tall. Or four, yeah. But then again, I mean, the recent interpretations, analysis has suggested that these stagodons, which may have been consumed by floresiensis, were killed, not by floresiensis, not hunted, by floresiensis, but instead were killed by Komodo dragons, which is the world's largest lizard, growing up to 10 feet long and a formidable animal.
11:09Venom glands, terrifically sharp teeth and a deadly tail. So they were probably scavenging or potentially scavenging what was left. That's the idea. And anything that could be taken for a cut mark, well, the bones that have been studied, they show marks, but mostly from dragon's teeth, Komodo dragon teeth. Komodo monitor teeth, to use another name. Those that don't look like Komodo dragon teeth marks have been interpreted as, yeah, possible stone tool marks used by Floresiensis, but merely to scrape meat off the bones, not to kill the animal. But were there humans living on the island of Flores at the same time?
12:04If I'm not mistaken, well, when Floresiensis was discovered, the oldest date for Homo sapiens on the island was 11 ,000 years ago. Oh, wow. Whereas now, I think that's been pushed back to 50 ,000 or so. So there was overlap. So this overlap, is it possible that it was humans that were predating on these pygmy elephants? That's certainly possible, yeah. Which would leave – yeah, although, again, if I've got this right and if I'm up to date on this, I'm not sure that there are clear evidence. There's clear evidence from Bones that any of the elephants were killed by Homo sapiens. Right, like spear marks on the rib cage.
12:59Well, cut marks when you're butchering. That sort of is the big – yeah. So it's more like something smaller and smaller tools just scraping meat away. Yeah. Which would indicate the little animals. So the date of the actual – the group that they found that was in that cave, was it 50 ,000, 60 ,000 years old? How old were they? That's – well, of course, initially it was reckoned they were only 12 ,000, 13 ,000 years old. The youngest ones. Right, right, right. But that was a big problem for the paleos. That was a big problem. They said so as well. Well, it would be a real big problem if they found a live one today.
13:40Well, yeah, no, you're certainly correct there. although one of the senior investigators, the original find, said memorably that just the discovery of something like Homo floresiensis that, you know, 12, 13 ,000 years ago, or even a bit older, was more surprising. It was kind of gobsmacking than would be, he said, the discovery of a space alien. So that just shows you how out of the blue this paleontological discovery was. Well, it is pretty crazy that this myth has gone on for so long all over the world, or all over that part of the world, I should say, like the Orang Pendek. Yeah. Right? That one's what?
14:35Is that Vietnam or is that? Orang Pendek is in… Malaysia? …mostly southern Sumatra. Sumatra. So very close to Malaysia. And it's a very similar description. Yeah, on the whole, I would say so. I've written a bit about that as well. But the difference, I guess, well, a couple of differences with floresiensis is that with floresiensis, we have fossil evidence for something that could have survived until much more recently. Whereas in Sumatra, the fossil evidence for orang pendic is not there. And also, of course, on Sumatra, you have all kinds of primates that could be, shall we say, mistaken or taken for a very small human.
15:31Orangutans, for one thing. But Flores does not. Flores has only one species of monkey and no apes. And the monkey, a macaque, a long-tailed macaque, was introduced by humans thousands, just a few thousands of years ago. So no native apes, no native monkeys either. So these people, when you first went in the 1980s, how frequent were their sightings? And were they in a very specific area? And what did they say the encounters were like? Well, the sightings have been entirely or nearly entirely in the Leo region towards the eastern end of the island,
16:25mostly in high altitudes, mountainous areas, mountain forest, and thus well away from human settlements for the most part. How frequently? It's difficult to say. I mean, I recorded over 30 reports of encounters, some of them not terribly credible, others, you know, a dozen or so much more interesting. Can I ask you this? When you say not entirely credible, were there aspects of it that seemed like mythological? Like what was not entirely credible? Not necessarily mythological, but it sounded like they could well have been identifying monkeys. Well, one reason for that was what they described. Another reason was that a lot of those less credible ones were in circumstances when you wouldn't expect a human to encounter anything like Floresiensis.
17:37And largely close to the coast, where most people live and have lived for a long time, Whereas, yeah, all indications are that the lihoa, as they're called, the local hominoids, are much higher up in unsattled parts of the mountains. So that would indicate that there's a food supply for them up there. Yeah. And are they primarily vegetarian? They seem to be very much so, yeah. I mean, the dentition on the type specimen, the skull, the teeth, suggests a vegetarian, a herbivore, if you will. The best specimen, the type specimen, as it's called, doesn't really show any definite canines. molars are fine in great shape by the way for the age but yeah so I'm not saying they didn't have pronounced canines as do chimpanzees for example even though chimpanzees are also largely vegetarian largely but they apparently prefer to eat monkeys oh yeah no that's Well, like humans, I mean, humans during most of our history have of necessity eaten grains and vegetables and so on because they couldn't afford the meat.
19:19But nevertheless, meat has usually been a prized food. Yeah. Well, we're clearly omnivores. Yeah. But if you were a creature that lived in this mountainous terrain, there's probably not a wide variety of mammals, right? And if they didn't really have weapons, they had very small stone tools. There seems to be no indication they have anything they could throw or anything along those lines. They could throw stones, throw rocks. Stones. They're pretty strong. Good luck being successful at killing a deer, throwing rocks. It'll take you a long time to get one. Deer are also a recent import. Oh, is it?
20:08In fact, flores is mammal poor. The only indigenous native mammals are bats, as you would expect, because they can fly freely to the island, and rodents. So what are the dragons eating? The dragons were— Because they're huge. Well, it's interesting because at one time they were eating the godons, certainly. You think they made them extinct, perhaps, because it's a small island? Well, they could have contributed to that, yeah, along with other factors. But besides dragons, there are other large rats. Oh, that's right. They have one very aggressive tree rat, right? Now, that guy is still around, as I know.
20:56Oh, really? I've got photos of, yeah. That thing's huge, right? It is a huge rat. A couple feet long? It's at least, I think, in terms of metrics. Oh, that's what it looks like? Oh, there is. The size of that sucker. Yeah, no, that's great. Mostly or largely tail is a lot of animals, but it is big, as you can see. That lady looks like she's got one as a pet. I'm not sure if that's the same creature. I don't think it is. Oh, okay. But, yeah, now that looks more like it. Yeah. Yeah. This episode is brought to you by the farmer's dog, which is exactly what I feed my own dogs. And you know why? It's real food that can make a real difference in their long-term health, and it's totally backed by science.
21:47Every meal is developed by board-certified nutritionists, made to human-grade safety standards, and is backed by published research that shows it supports healthy aging. And my dogs love it. I want my dogs to live as long as possible, and I want them to be healthy. So the fact that fresh food from the farmer's dog actually helps reduce the formation of harmful compounds associated with age-related decline is a huge win. Get 50 % off your first box of the farmer's dog at thefarmersdog.com slash Rogan. Plus, you can now add their human-grade crunchy biscuit treats to any plan. Try them today. Papagomis.
22:29But if you're a 10-foot-long poisonous lizard, it's going to be hard to sustain that mass just on rats unless they're overpopulated with rats. Well, I've got to say that once, you know, extinction dates for Pygmy Stagodon or any Stagodon. Well, I can't recall the current figures, but they're always changing, by the way. But as soon as you had humans on the island, you had pigs and dogs. And some of the pigs quite quickly, I think, became feral, which they were wild. Yes. So, and, yeah, and then, you know, deer at one point were introduced by humans. So certainly deer and pigs and not to mention domesticates like goats.
23:25Even, you know, young buffalo and horses are prey to dragons at present. So in a sense, it could be Homo sapiens that's kept that creature alive. Yeah. So they could have wiped out the pygmy elephants and then we could have probably maybe come in at a very opportune time with a bunch of domesticated animals, pigs, dogs. Yeah. And then they started eating those. I should say also the little ape man, the Leo, for example, described also reputed occasionally to steal chickens or very small piglets. Yeah. So, yeah, not to deny that they wouldn't eat meat if they could get it. So when you went there, was it 84 was the first time you went?
24:15That was the first time, but, you know, I kept going back sometimes every year. But when you first went, did you go looking for this specific creature? No. No, I went because there were parts of Flores, including Nage Country, right in the center where I first... Pull that microphone up. Research. Sorry. It's okay. It moves around a little bit. You can stay where you're sitting. No, that's fine. No, the reason I went was to visit the people and find out how they lived and what they believed in. Because they were kind of blank on the cultural anthropological map. And it was just incidentally, you know, by accident you might say.
25:04And with these people, what kind of life are they living? A subsistence lifestyle? Are they hunter-gatherers? Are they? Certainly in the 1980s, yeah. They were still largely subsistence cultivators, small farmers who would feed themselves from what they grew. Also hunters, however. The men very much value hunting, although not a lot of their food supply comes from that activity. And are they hunting animals that have been introduced, like the deer species and pigs? Deer and pigs are the two prized types, most valued types of game. But they'll also kill monkeys, wild cats, feral cats. Feral house cats?
25:54Yeah. Well, that sounds like what they are. I don't think there's any indigenous. Right. Right. But although some people in the past have thought they were, including Alfred Wallace, who you may know. Sure. But, yeah, but also things like, well, the giant tree rats that you mentioned. They hunt those. They hunt those. I have said in one or two places, by the way, that it's rather unlikely that floresiensis would have been able to hunt the tree rats because they're very difficult to hunt. They're vicious as hell. Really? Yeah. So you need, well, from what I'm told, what I am told often, was told often by the nage, for example, is that you need more than one person, dogs.
26:50You need dogs. You need dogs to hunt the rats? You need a kind of a prod to knock them out of the tree and so on. And it's often reported that people are injured from the teeth of these damn things dropping down from trees. Well, you saw how big it was. Yeah. Well, that's a great meal, though. If you're a three-foot-tall human-like creature and you eat a two-foot rat, that's a good catch. Yeah. Mind you, at the same time, let's talk about floresiensis,
27:23would possibly have been able to catch smaller rodents, nation birds. Yeah. Sure. So when you first went there, what was the first story that you heard about these little hairy people that live in the woods? Yeah. The first story I heard in the Nage region that I've mentioned was a kind of local legend about how they were wiped out by the ancestors of the Nage. And it's a story that whatever the basis in fact has clearly been embellished, embroidered. Yeah, you get narrative themes entering, including two escaping the extermination. And this is an old plot line. and moving to another territory where they, sister and brother, as you said, where they incestuously managed to maintain their species.
28:28But yeah, that was the first story. I mean, according to that one, these were creatures called abugogo, is a term you may have come across. They were in their habit, it said, of they lived in a cave high on the mountain, But they were in the habit of coming down a bit lower, downslope, and joining in feasts and dancing of villagers. And they were given food by their reluctant hosts. But they did odd things. Like, yeah, they would certainly eat the food, but then they'd start biting into the plates, which were made of, well, traditionally made of sort of pumpkin skin, dried pumpkin skin. So, yeah, you can break them with your teeth.
29:23I'm sure that a human can eat them or want to. So they were just confused as to where the food ended. Well, this is the idea. That particular category of creature, a bugogo, always interpreted as or represented as being stupid. Right. Yeah, very stupid. So they couldn't tell the difference between food and a plate. They were made drunk. They'd given copious amounts of palm wine, palm gin. And then, of course, eventually they wanted to go back to their cave to sleep it off. And what was the timeline for these supposed interactions? Well, as far as one can tell from local genealogies, family histories, that sort of thing, yeah, we'd be talking at least 200, 300 years ago.
30:11So this was like folklore or at least like legend that they would tell the stories of these people? And so this was the first story that you heard of these creatures? That was the first one. Yeah, there are other stories told soon thereafter. But so this was the first one where you were explained that at least at one point in time there was supposedly a small, hairy, human-like creature that lived on the island. Yeah, that's exactly right. People are very insistent. The storytellers are very insistent that these things weren't like forest spirits or anything. It was an actual animal. It was an actual animal, exactly.
30:55And when did you talk to someone that had had an encounter?
31:02First of all, that was when I visited the Leo region. which is the main topic of the book, as I said. Yeah, and that was in the early 2000, 2001, 2003. So you'd had this in your mind for a couple of decades at that point. Yeah. So what was it like to hear that there was a possibility that these things were still on the island? And if people haven't seen the Island of Flores before, it's incredibly dense, mountainous. Very mountainous, yeah. Very difficult to get to. There's not like a real, like, is there a road structure that allows you to get from one side of the island to the other? There's a Dutch colonials back in the, what?
31:49Is it a coastal road or does it just go through the middle? It goes wherever it can go because it's so mountainous. There's virtually no straight stretches. Right. So it kind of snakes all over the place. A lot of it goes through the, yeah, a lot of it along the coast, but other parts in more central areas. Can you see if we can get a photo? I'm looking at the map. I'm just trying to find the road. Yeah. Well, it's an insanely dense jungle. So this is what we're looking at. It's just a 3D topographical. Okay, yeah. I mean, we're looking at it from above. and this if you get a photograph of what it looks like because I've seen some drone photos of the island that are really spectacular because you know they're above the tree line and you go okay anything could be out there it's just it's like parts of the Amazon where you look at it and you go well this is so dense yeah just incredibly dense and people are not regularly traveling to this area, certainly not Westerners who are there exploring and doing anthropological work.
33:01They're not traveling. A few tourists these days, but - Yeah. Okay. So this is a good representation. It's just incredibly dense, mountainous, beautiful, but wildly uncharted, not uncharted necessarily, because we actually know where everything is, but people aren't going and making an audit of all the different animals that are there. So it is possible that something could... If you looked at it, you're like, well, maybe. Well, yeah, I mean, there have been studies by zoologists of certain parts of the local wildlife, local animal life. But, yeah, none explicitly in search of something like Floresiensis or the Leo ape men, as I call them.
33:54So when you first had someone explain to you an encounter, how far was that from the actual discovery of the bones? Because you had the conversations with people that were telling you that they had encountered one prior to them discovering these bones, correct? Yeah. Certainly prior. Not very long before, a couple of months. But certainly, yeah, well, every year before the plurisensis discovery was announced in the media, including the scientific press. That must have been incredibly exciting to hear these stories and go, wow, I've been talking to people about these things for 20 years now. And now this guy tells me he saw one.
34:44And then a couple of months later, they're finding bones. You had to be like, wow, this is a real thing. I was quite staggered, yeah. I actually find it kind of hot in here. Can I take my jacket off? Yeah, absolutely. Of course. Yeah. Take your jacket off. So as we were saying, you had this encounter with someone who explained that they had seen one in the flesh. And then just a few months later, they find these bones. That had to be incredibly exciting. Because you had, especially in the early, when they were saying it might potentially only be 10 ,000 plus years old. Yeah. No, I felt extremely lucky.
35:22Right. And I mean, if I'd first heard about these things a year or two later, well, I probably wouldn't have written the book, and I wouldn't have taken it much further. I would have thought, well, there is a possibility, however slim, that somebody's seen a reconstruction of Floresiensis in a newspaper or on television. But no, yeah, so I was fortunate. One thing I subsequently discovered is that the name Laihoa is in fact recorded in a Leo language dictionary, Leo German, as a matter of fact, which was research for that went on in the 1920s, and not long after the establishment of a Dutch colonial administration written by a German missionary.
36:25And it finally was published in 1933, and there were mentions of Lai Hoa, and some of information, which came from sample sentences of the language, were consistent with what people generally were telling me about the Leo ape man. So that was another strong indication that the whole notion of these creatures hadn't come from the fossil discovery. Was there any encounters or descriptions from ancient missionaries that had visited? No, not that I've been able to discover. I've looked for that kind of thing, obviously, but no. So they had only documented stories? Yeah, it's quite remarkable. The man I knew for quite a long time, a Dutchman in the Nage region, a missionary, Catholic missionary who'd been there for ages.
37:32And he'd never heard of the Obugogo, which are the Nage ape men. And which, you know, stories about these, like the ones I just described, are pretty widely known. in the region near the village where his inhabitants were supposed to wipe them out hundreds of years ago. But the missionary, he never heard it. I was surprised, and I'm sure he was being honest. Now, when you first got the initial report from someone that had encountered one of these in real life, did you then start looking for other stories from other people? to get more confirmation? I did, but not so much in that particular year.
38:27That was, as I said, summer 2003. And, yeah, because I had to return to Canada, I think. It was in the June, and I had to return in the July or early August, something like that. So I didn't have a lot of time in that year. But after hearing about floresiensis, of course, I did initiate a new project which enabled, gave me funds to go back and talk about a bunch of things, not just the hominoids. But certainly to pay much more attention to Leo, the Leo region, and to these creatures than I'd done previously. And how many reports of encounters had you had? Like how many different people? I interviewed, well, to answer your question, somewhere in the 30s, 32, I think.
39:27Wow. But I talked to more people than that just about, you know, these hominoids in general, what they'd heard from their parents or, you know, from whoever, to get, you know, a good idea of the kind of local knowledge there was about them. And so in total, yeah, it was well over 120, 130 people I think I talked to in all. That it had encounters? No, no. No, 30 that had encounters. They knew something about, knew what a li-hor was. But if you talked to 120 people and 30 of them had encounters, that seems like a lot. I guess it does, yeah. But then there were a lot of people besides who knew virtually nothing about a li-hor.
40:15Oh, they didn't want to talk to me or they were scared or whatever. Right, right, right. Now, did they all have similar descriptions? Yeah. I mean, one thing I show in my analysis, and it's been four years now, so I think I got this right, is that the sightings are both the clearest, most detailed, in other words, most credible sighting reports. reports, seem more accurate, more in line with the standard image of ape men than, you know, others. And even, as I said, even among the sighting reports, there were some that I was inclined to dismiss as being, you know, mistaken monkeys or, yeah. Right.
41:08Right. So at least a few of them possibly could have been this actual creature. Yeah. If they're being honest. That's right. And it just takes one out of 30-odd. Yeah. I mean, if you have that many, and also you have bones, and then also you have a history of these things. It's just, what would be required to comb the forest to try to find these things? Have you ever thought about what kind of resources would be required, how many people would be involved, camera traps, like various technologies that you could use to potentially find these things? Yeah. Not so much forests, although forests included, but higher slopes of mountains, of which there are many, and certainly in Leo territory and neighboring districts as well.
42:07You'd need people who are young and fit. And quite a few of them. Yeah, you'd need different sorts of expertise. I mean, certainly people who could handle the terrain. Maybe also people who, well, primatologists, shall we say.
42:30People specializing in the study of apes and monkeys. that would be helpful zoologists working in that area as well you mentioned camera traps, that would be a good idea in fact I'm working I think you could say at present with a man in the Netherlands who is very keen on doing the sort of thing you've just described. And he has visited one area in particular, and there's a story about that, but I won't backtrack just yet. He has, yeah, visited one volcano and placed traps, taken lots of photos and so on. He wasn't there for very long. He wants to go back, I think late next year, but with a team.
43:36And he's asked me to investigate people with experience of, you know, rugged country and that kind of search. In fact, he even recommended I talk to you about it, but I don't know if we want to go about it. Well, not you, but maybe somebody in your team, somebody you could recommend. end. Some explorer type? Yeah. But in the meantime, quite recently, in fact, I've been asked for an interview by Les Stroud. Sure, Survivor Man. Yeah, exactly. He's a big believer in Bigfoot. Well, yeah. But yeah, so I'm expecting him on Friday the 13th, actually, so just in, what, nine, ten days' time. And I think he would be the kind of person to consult on that.
44:30Well, he could live up there for a few months by himself. Yeah, well, maybe I can get him interested. Yeah, he would figure out, like, that would be a great idea for a series. Because, you know, he's done quite a few episodes looking for Bigfoot, to no avail. Shocking. Never found it. But this would be, I think, probably more likely than finding Bigfoot. First of all, it's an island. Yeah. It's not just an entire, like, coastline, like if you're in the Pacific Northwest or wherever you're searching for Bigfoot. Yeah. And the other thing being that, you know, a guy like Les going solo, because he does everything solo.
45:08He doesn't bring a big camera crew. It would be a smaller footprint. Yeah. Probably less likely to make a lot of noise and disturb things. Yeah. That's a good feature. Yeah. Yeah. And if he found something, boy, that would be exciting. That would be one of the most exciting things that's ever happened in all of anthropology. Yeah. Yeah. No, indeed. And I think, you know, I'm not a firm believer in anything, really, you might say. Good for you. But I was a bit skeptical. But the evidence in this case, the coincidence that we were talking about a minute ago between the discovery, the reconstruction of Floresiensis and what Leo people and others were describing to me, you know, the match.
46:04Right. It is so remarkable that, you know, unless there's been some huge, well-hidden conspiracy designed entirely to fool little old me, I just can't imagine it. Well, you know, coincidences do happen, including remarkable ones, so maybe that's it. But even so, I think, yeah, it's worth further exploration. I mean, back in 2005, when I began to look at the LIHOR hominoids in earnest, I was already approaching 60 years. I've never been particularly athletic. And, you know, by the time I left, left off this piece of research back in 2018, yeah, I was already in my 70s. So, you know, and you've seen the country.
47:01I mean, there's no way I'm going to be scrambling up a mountainside. Dangerous, too. Yeah, I won't go into the particulars of my present physical condition. But, you know, it's a bit of a challenge going anywhere these days, I must confess. So, yeah, no, the research is worth, well, not, you know, guaranteeing success of any sort. Now, what about potential use of technology? Are they going to use drones or anything along those lines? Because they've gotten incredibly good. That's right. Yeah. Yeah. Well, yeah, no, this is on the sort of bucket list for this colleague of mine. A young guy, financially successful, who has the time to do this kind of thing.
47:58Yeah, I think drones are certainly on the list. So, yeah, those would come into play as well. Yeah. And so how much of the area where they find them, how much of a piece of land are we talking about? What is the square kilometers? The Leo region. Can I just grab a—I'm getting very dry here. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Well, there's water in there, that glass right there. I'll take a bit of this. And there's coffee in here if you'd like some coffee. Oh, that's great. How big is the area where—I mean, is it centrally located where they keep finding these same sightings? Is it all in the same particular area or is it spread out?
48:49Yeah, well, I've worked mostly in a place called East Leo.
48:59But there's no clear indication of the bounds of knowledge of this kind of creature. So they go, yeah, to the east and to the west. They're just mostly avoiding people. Yeah, well, certainly the creatures are. But, you know, the fact is that different people, their knowledge of local wild animals is different from, you know, maybe their neighbors or people at another end of the island. There is in western Indonesia, in Sumatra, possibly on parts of the Malay Peninsula close by as well, there is a kind of wild rabbit or hare. Not the kind of place where you'd expect to find rabbits or hares perhaps.
49:57But this animal was unknown to most of the local people. It was discovered by Western, many Dutch, I think, naturalists, and given a scientific name and all that kind of stuff. Local people didn't have a local name for it. Interesting. Yeah, and in fact, it's now known mostly, and so far as people are aware of it, where the national Indonesian name, Kalinchi, which refers to rabbits that were imported by the Dutch as food a couple of centuries ago. So... Is that, I think, the source of these particular wild rabbits on the island? No. No, this would be quite a separate species. Okay. That they would be indigenous, yeah.
50:45Right. But again, local people or lots of local groups didn't know about them. Reasonable, they're forest-dwelling, and they're, you know, quite rare. Right. So no great surprise, but if I may, something that I was going to say with regard to my friend who plans to go back to Flores with an expanded search. he became very interested in this particular locality particular mountain in fact because of reports I received out of the blue about three years ago from two British visitors hikers, outdoorsmen taking a break on floreys and doing scuba diving and hiking a bit of mountain climbing, this kind of thing.
51:49They, I have to think about the details of this because it was, yeah, like three years back. They finally found their name, my name, I should say, after doing, one of them in particular, found my name after doing an internet search concerning apes and monkeys on Flores Island. and I came across my name in connection with a creature, Central Flores creature called Obugogo. And one of them, yeah, he wrote to me, he contacted me first of all across LinkedIn and asked me about monkeys on the island and I told him and he described to me what he and his friend, both of them at the same time, had seen.
52:43on the highest slopes of this particular mountain. And he said, I think in his first communication, that it sounds like you're a bugogo. So naturally I followed this up and had some more conversations by phone and email with these two young men. And there's nothing they told me to kind of disabuse me of that possibility. Now, I should stress that I can't go into all the details or the circumstances of our communications, but all indications are that they'd never heard of my writings or never read my writings on Flores Apeman before. So they just had an encounter and sought out an expert? They had an encounter.
53:32They thought it was some kind. Well, it's interesting because I managed to interview them subsequently separately, which is a good thing. And one of them, in fact, the main contact, described what he saw as something very much like a Leo ape man, you know, a little man, a little human, but, you know, monkey-like. Bipedal. Bipedal, yes. That was his impression. The other man described it as looking more like, you know, or another sort of primate. In fact, he described it as a monkey, but a very big one, an unusually big one. And it's interesting because those two opinions, those two interpretations, very much align with the range of descriptions that I recorded from local people.
54:25You know, some descriptions had it more monkey-like, others more human-like. And, of course, naturally there were variations in the estimated size of what people were seeing. What's the highest? The highest comes from a second-hand report of the LIHOR. And that would have been about 1.4 meters, which is, yeah, bigger than four feet. It's getting on there, getting four feet, yeah. Yeah. Yeah, you're right. So this encounter that these gentlemen had, this was only three years ago? Well, actually, the encounter was in 2019 in March. And, you know, they hadn't followed this. They hadn't thought about it.
55:11And then for some reason they met. This is it. I think they were separated for some time, these two guys. And they met and, you know, over a drink, started to reminisce about their visit to Flores. Now they'd like to go back. and one said to the other, well, you know, God, do you remember that huge monkey we saw? And, you know, went on to discuss that. And then one of them,
55:43he, yeah, he took some time to kind of follow this up by looking for information on the internet and it was that way that he finally came across my name and contact details. So is that one of the only Westerners, or at least groups of Westerners that spotted these things? This episode is brought to you by the movie Ghost Soldier. Jim Caviezel plays Fitz, a former American Special Forces soldier and advanced weapons developer. As a military veteran, Fitz has a strong code of justice and a natural instinct to protect a vulnerable community from a powerful corporation. Here's the trailer.
56:29Listen carefully. You made the mistake of thinking you're safe behind money and guns. But this land doesn't belong to you. I've been paid to end wars and dismantle regimes. I'm the man they send to erase problems.
56:47And tonight, you're the problem.
56:54Now that doesn't sound like a guy you want to mess with. Ghost Soldier is a fun action film that demands to be seen in theaters, which opens nationwide on Veterans Day, November 11. Rated PG-13. There are two of them, of course. No, not quite. I might mention 2019 was well before the 22 book came out, so that's a factor as well. No, not the only two. Well, there was a man, not Western but Asian. I won't give any more details of that because he didn't want me to mention this in the book. But he came across something in the dark, trekking back towards Upslope, a village he was staying in. He got a bit lost, actually, and managed to find his way.
57:50and he saw something which was described, certainly interpreted by local people as having been one of these ape men. That would go back to, I guess, yeah, the last century, 1990s maybe. But he's a person I know quite well. But also, well, somebody who became a friend of mine sadly passed away a few years ago was working on the neighboring island he was an anthropologist
58:27he was working on the neighboring island called Sambawa which is immediately east of Flores another big island lots of mountains and so on and he had a similar sighting back in the similar experience I should say back in the 1980s and was very open about the whole thing and gave me detailed descriptions on more than one occasion. Now, that he did allow me to mention in the book, in fact, in more than one book. And did he describe the same type of creature, the same type of experience? Big monkey standing upright, no tail, about three feet or more tall. Yeah, there was more than one of them that he saw at the end of a kind of a...
59:25A grown over area, sort of a tunnel that had been created by vegetation. He was trekking through jungle. And he came across these things. And he turned back. Actually, he wanted to find there was a site with certain stone monuments that he'd heard about. And, you know, villagers down below had sort of pointed him in the right direction. and he followed the trail they had indicated. And he was still in his 20s at this time. He was in pretty good shape. And then he came to this area which was grown over, grown over to the extent that he had to go on all fours to continue climbing. And it was at the end of this tunnel where there was some light, of course, a sunny day, where he saw several of these creatures, mostly kind of silhouettes, you know, given the lighting conditions.
1:00:34They made sounds which were unlike local monkeys.
1:00:41And there you have it. But he wrote it up in his field notes, which he showed me. Wow. Much tidier than my field notes, I can tell you. And what he'd written at that time accorded with what he told me. So again, talk about Floresiensis. I mean, there's no reason that that species or something very much like it It is not present or wasn't at one time present also on other islands around and about. And this – so his depiction of it was before you had ever had your first description of it given to you. Yeah. You can say that. We weren't qualification. My first research in Indonesia was done in the 1970s.
1:01:38Oh. As a doctoral student. And you'd never heard any of these stories then? Well, I was working on the island of Sumba, which is not the same as Flores, a big island to the south. Not to be confused with Sumbawa, but this is just Sumba. And there, there is a tradition of, well, something sounds more like the Sasquatch, actually, or the Bigfoot. Because, yeah, these are sort of, you know, half human, half ape. standing on two legs, but they're much bigger than us, certainly much bigger than local people. So they're talking about two to three meters in height. And I must say the evidence for them is not as good as for my Flores ape men.
1:02:33So I'd heard about this. Also, I might mention that I did my first degree in Vancouver at Simon Fraser University, my undergraduate degree at Simon Fraser in the late 60s and into the 70s. And this is a time when there was a lot of interest locally in British Columbia, in Bigfoot. It was also at that time, yeah, late 60s, very late 60s, that there was the film supposedly made in Northern California. Oh, the Patterson-Gimlin footage? Patterson-Gimlin, exactly, yeah. Yeah, there's a new documentary out that kind of shows that had been rehearsed. Yeah, yeah. Oh, yeah, there's a lot of suspicion. Pre-fake.
1:03:23Although at the time, it's interesting. I know there were a number of, or a few, primatologists and so on who thought it credible. But there's that film, and then of course there's the phenomenon as a whole. But anyway, from that kind of thing going on in the late 60s, early 70s, I became interested. Well, I was studying anthropology at the time, including, you know, prehistory and paleoanthropology and a lot of talk about the possibility of this kind of thing. And, yeah, so I was just studying human evolution and all the rest of it. And I became aware at that point that there were reports of things still alive that kind of looked like, you know, Homo erectus or some of these physically primitive forms of Homo, of humans.
1:04:24Well, it's an incredibly fascinating idea. And we know from what we know about the fossil record, the fossil record is so incomplete because it's so difficult to make a fossil. So when we find new things like the Denisovans, which is very recent discovery, we go, oh, well, there's a totally different branch. And they were larger than people. This is really interesting. So we don't really know because it's so difficult to make a fossil. That's right. In fact, it's infinitesimally remote, a possibility of a species, just a whole species, not just an individual animal being, you know, surviving, being preserved, being fossilized.
1:05:14That's why it's so crazy to try to get an understanding or a map of the past with fossils. Well, it's always changing. Right. It's always changing. They find a new one, throws a monkey wrench into the whole thing. You're like, oh, well, look at this. Now we know there's this kind. And now we know Homo Juliensis and Homo, you know, there's a whole series of them. The Denisovans. Yeah. No. And, you know, if we don't kill ourselves off in the near future, it's likely there'll be more of these discoveries. No, they're made, you know, quite by chance. The likelihood of anybody finding these things is remote.
1:05:54So the sample of fossil hominins is certainly not representative. I mean, it's really needles in a haystack. It seems to be constantly expanding our understanding of how many there were. Yeah, well, because research continues. That's why. But even so, there are lots of places where people could look. And, yeah, we don't know with any species that is declared extinct. We don't know exactly when it died out. We know the most recent date. Right. Well, that's what's really interesting. And we know the earliest date. When it came into being as well, we don't know. And when you find something that's 60 ,000 years old, like those bones that they found in the cave, the odds of those being the last ones that existed are very small.
1:06:42Very small. Yeah, that's way in the – oh, that's a question of yours I didn't answer. I think that way in the eastern – sorry, the western end of Flores Island is the discovery site, whereas I'm working mostly towards the eastern end, central or east-central Flores. So quite a distance away. But no, and let's remember as well that the evidence suggests that what's called homophoreziensis survived for at least 50 ,000 years, which is quite a stretch of time. Especially when we don't really know how they got there. We don't know how they got there. there is evidence for something much earlier. It's 700 ,000 years ago that could possibly be ancestral to Floresiensis.
1:07:35Now, in that space of time, the notion that they're restricted to one small neighborhood is just not credible. They must have been all over the map of Flores. What is the evidence of the one that's 100 ,000 plus? The 700 ,000 plus, excuse me. Oh, 700 ,000. Oh, sorry, the floresiensis. There's a number of specimens in Liangboa Cave. The most recent were initially reckoned to be 12 ,000, 13 ,000. That date was pushed back in a kind of interesting way to 50 ,000 or 60 ,000. Well, how was the pushback? Was it radiocarbon dating? Various methods were applied. I can't recall the details. details. But yeah, I mean, the point is, Joe, that this 12 ,000, 13 ,000 date was found to be a big problem.
1:08:34And so a lot of energy was put into retesting the geological situation in the cave. So is the current dating a certainty? No, nothing's a certainty. Right. So is it possible that it's earlier or it's newer rather? I think it is, simply because we only know one site, a site not much bigger, if any bigger, than this building on an island of that size. So it's interesting, the follow-up research, looking for ancestors to Homo floresiensis, which turned up the 700 ,000-year-old fossils, that was all focused on finding something older. Not something more recent or younger. Is that Flores as well? On Flores also, but in the central part on a large plain.
1:09:37Well, that's even crazier, right? So how did they get there 700 ,000 years ago? Well, there is evidence in the form of possible stone tools, let's just say stone tools, that something was making those artifacts a million years ago. So how did they get there? They – or what did whatever it was that was living a million years ago look like? it's reckoned that they well they wouldn't have had like sea craft no land bridges by the way that anybody knows about so they would have to come somehow by sea. Lower sea level though correct? Particularly during the ice age. Lower sea levels but not not a
1:10:27land bridge I mean the stagodons swam over Whoa. From how far away? Not that far Probably from the east or the north. Maybe they rode the elephants. Well, I guess somebody suggested that, but not likely. Imagine you're in a boat and you see a bunch of weird-looking monkey people riding elephants. Yeah. No, you would check your diet. I'd definitely pull my iPhone out. Yeah. Take a video. Yeah, but it is possible for creatures like Floresiensis apparently to kind of sail over accidentally on great clumps of foliage. I'm looking for a term now. Okay, like driftwood, like some sort of a log or something.
1:11:21How many miles or kilometers? There's a clump of earth that had been dug up by a tsunami and driven out to sea. There's evidence for this kind of thing happening. So, yeah, you would need, of course, more than one of them to get to floreys, and they'd have to be opposite sexes as well. But it's all possible, given the time scale involved. Yeah, that's the thing that they do when they talk about human populations. that they find on these islands that are problematic in age, when they get really, really long ago, before they thought people were sea traveling, they go, okay, how many had to get out here in order to develop a population?
1:12:00So there's a mathematical equation to that, right? Yeah, yeah, no, for sure. As there are estimates of how many members of a population you'd need for it to be able to survive, continue, breed, and so on. So if it's such a small island that it's not possible that they evolved there?
1:12:22Well, I mean, it suggests they did part of their evolution once on the island. Yeah, but once on the island. But how did everything else get there? Like, how did the dragons get there? How did the rats get there? Like, what is the origin of all these various life forms? It's very diverse, right? Well, yeah. I mean, rats seem to be able to get it everywhere. Yeah. Except Alberta, by the way. we have mice but no rats we're trying to keep them out as well you guys have wolves though we have wolves and all kinds of things grizzly bears black bears a lot of black bears mountain lions moose big deer, huge deer, elk you guys have everything up there so called antelope as well it is a beautiful part of the world of course we've got the two national parks which are full of protected wildlife.
1:13:19But, yeah, no, let me say about the dragons. The so-called dragons, like Komodo monotors. Great swimmers. Really? I mean, now they swim between islands regularly. Ugh. Yeah. That's terrifying. So they would have no problem getting there. Right. So they probably just went wherever they smelled food. Yeah. They probably smelled something dead over there and just took a hop into the water. So all these various animals, The elephants could swim. The dragons could swim. The rats could figure out a way to get there. Birds, obviously, could fly. Lots of bats. They can fly. And the monkeys came on boats.
1:13:54No, the monkeys were introduced like a lot of other animals. I mean, they're only mammals there, sizable mammals, a various species of mice and rats. And then there's a giant rat. You've got, what, pigs. Right, we talked about all this. We talked about pigs, yeah. that are introduced by people. Yeah, a lot of them were introduced by people. What year was this where they started getting introduced by people? It varies, and it's controversial. I mean, there's like dogs, for example. There's some evidence that suggested that they haven't been there very long, several hundred to a thousand years, but it seems likely to me they've been there longer.
1:14:39Pigs. There is a book in which I've written about all this stuff, but I can't remember now. details. Anyway, yeah, you know, they're monkeys porcupines. There are porcupines that were introduced from Western, and they're a game animal. Really? Yep. Oh, for sure. They're ultimately rodents like rats. If you're going to eat giant rats, a porcupine is certainly also on the menu. Interesting. But, yeah, you've got to know how to cook them and butcher them probably. Yeah, and kill them without getting jammed. Again, you need dogs for that. Oh, poor dogs. And they have a special, special method. Well, the dogs have to be clever if they're not going to get injured.
1:15:28I've seen pictures of dogs with porcupine quills all over their face. It's so sad. Yeah. Well, that can happen with tigers in India, of course. I've seen that as well. Look at this poor dog. Oh, this poor dude. Yeah. Well, it's interesting you should be able to produce those straight away. Oy, oy, oy. Yeah. So the point is there's a lot of wildlife, and a lot of it came from somewhere else, including the monkeys. And we have no idea if these little hobbit people, we don't have any idea when they got there or how they got there. But it's not just there. But isn't there some evidence or at least some stories of them from the Philippines as well?
1:16:11Yeah, there's a similar remains in Luzon Island. Oh, how long ago was this discovered? It was discovered after Floresiensis. Oh, so it's fairly recent. Yeah, Luzonensis. That's called Homo Luzonensis. And it's a separate branch? It's a different animal? It's a different species, yeah. Wow. But then there are, I'm not sure of the present state of interpretation on this one, but in China as well, in a place called Red Deer Cave, there's evidence for small hominoids living in the same region as Homo erectus, which was much bigger there, a bigger hominin. And then in Africa, you've got, again, since the discovery of a small species called Homo naladi.
1:17:15That goes back about 200 ,000 years. But that apparently is small. But they're an interesting one, right? Because they buried their dead. Yeah. Yeah, now that's right. They had a kind of an unusually elaborate, you know, for their circumstances, symbolic culture, evidently. Yes. Yeah, nothing like that for Floresiensis. And evidence of stone tool use, too, correct? Yeah, I believe so. Yeah. And so weren't there the ones that had a specific area in a cave where they would deposit their bodies? Yeah, yeah, that's right. Yeah. Fascinating story. Really interesting stuff. Because it makes you think, like, well, what else did they have?
1:17:59Like, how long ago? And they were tiny, right? Yeah. Well, similar to Floresiensis. So there's evidence that this particular type of creature existed all over the world, or at least in many parts of the world, I should say. Parts of Asia and Africa with Naladi, yeah. Of course, the whole of the New World, South and North America, there's no evidence there for any kind of human or primate except for South American monkeys. Do we know if South American monkeys were indigenous? They came from the Old World originally. I can't remember exactly how. I mean, this was, I guess, at a time when, you know, world geography was a bit different.
1:18:48So they were introduced as well? Yeah, not by humans, though, but they managed to get there. And they're quite different in many respects from old world monkeys. Well, the main difference, I guess, is the prehensile tail. They can actually use the tail as a hand of a hole, an extra limb, Whereas no old world monkey can do that. Really? Yeah. The whole story of these creatures, to me, it is so captivating. I really can't get enough of it. And what I also thought was really interesting was that when they first found these bones of Homo floresiensis, there was a lot of dismissing of it. And a lot of people thought that it was maybe humans that had some genetic abnormality.
1:19:40That's right. Very good. Yeah. Yeah. No. Somebody's done your research. Oh, you've done your research. I'm obsessed. No. I'm obsessed with this. No, that's right. I'll tell you, paleoanthropologists themselves can be interesting characters. Yeah. They can be very contentious to fight among themselves. Yeah, for sure. There are a few other academics that are like that. Yeah. But the, yeah, no, you're right. There was a member of the Indonesian, well, no, he wasn't a member of the Indonesian team, but a very senior Indonesian prehistorian archaeologist who was resentful of the fact he wasn't on the team and he wasn't, you know, consulted early.
1:20:28but anyway he he dismissed this as a new floresiensis as a new species and he claimed that these what they'd found were one or more humans who were suffering from a brain condition called, well there are a couple of different possibilities, one's called microcephaly I think Yeah. So very small craniums, small brains. But this is an abnormality and people in this condition, you know, they don't, as individuals, they don't survive. Adamantly rejected the notion that these were a different species. Has been. There was also the problem that these things are, yeah, the floresiensis, of course, were small, small bodied, which doesn't correlate with microcephaly, which just concerns the head.
1:21:24Right. And, yeah, no, I mean, I don't think there's many people who support this. There is another bone of contention there, so to speak, and that has to do with the classification of Homo floresiensis as Homo or not. And most paleoanthropologists still seem to support Homo, but there are some including
1:21:57a guy called Chris Stringer at the National History Museum in London who I very much respect mainly because what he says agrees with what I think but no he suggested that for his instance it's something much much more primitive physically and that it derives from something much older, a separate branch, going back to somewhere in the region of Australopithecine, so pre-homo. And, you know, a lot of stuff, a lot of features of the fossils, not least of all the brain size, which is about that of a chimpanzee, so pretty small, body size and all the rest the lack of evidence for anything in the way of culture, all of these things suggest something that is a different kettle of fish altogether.
1:22:58And in fact, there was a senior member of the team that discovered and analyzed and interpreted the Floresiensis fossils. a guy called Peter Brown, an Australian anatomist, who proposed a different name for Homo phoresiensis. He gave it a new genus. He put it into a new genus, which he named, he gave the suggested name Sundanthropus, which would mean something like man-like being from the Sunda region, which refers to those islands. And this was rejected on... Yeah, I mean, that there were... You know, it was a Zaregubal kind of stuff. But some of the reasons put forward were not particularly credible, I found.
1:24:02I mean, one suggestion was that, you know, this thing is so recent, bearing in mind that one specimen was reckoned to be only 12 ,000, 13 ,000 years old at the time. but this speech was too recent so recent that it had to be Homo this betrays a very kind of linear progressive view of not progressive in a political sense but in a time sense of human or hominin evolution really, I mean it's ironic because, yeah, it was the discovery of Floresiensis that threw your monkey wrench into that whole picture of human evolution. I mean, it was evidence in favor of a view which had been around a little bit already by that time that you didn't have a single line of evolution where something bigger and better, more developed.
1:25:11and so on replaced something more primitive in a single line of development. Rather that the suggestion was that the view now seems to be that the human tree, family tree as it were, is bushy. So something like a Jewish menorah, the thing with the candles, you've got these things coming up side by side and, you know, terminating at the same point. We have that in everything else. It happens in all other sorts of animals. The idea that we would be isolated. Well, we are, as humans, so used to thinking of ourselves as special, right? I mean, everything in our culture, our history, religion as well suggests that.
1:26:01But, no, so it's kind of ironic that you still find traces of this progressive linear view. in certain statements made quite recently by paleoanthropologists. Well, I think it's part of the problem with this. They adopt an idea, start saying that this is the fact, and then are very reluctant to change their position, especially if they've been teaching it, if they're professors, if they've written books. Look what the Clovis first thing. I forget the gentleman's name who found the stones that indicated that there was people in the Americas far earlier than that. Oh, yes. He was destroyed. I mean, they ruined this guy's reputation.
1:26:45They viciously attacked him. It turns out he was correct. Yes. No, this does happen. He wasn't just correct. He was correct by a long shot. Like they found evidence of things that were 10 ,000 years or close to it, 22 ,000 years, the White Sands, New Mexico footprints. Right, right. Yeah. Yeah, that date keeps being pushed further and further. Further and further. Going further. Right. This is other weird evidence of it looks like someone had broken apart mastodon bones or mammoth bones. That's over 100 ,000 years ago. Yeah. No, you're quite right. I want to say something in defense of science and scientists.
1:27:26I mean, they are conservative. You're right. And they probably should be. Exactly. Exactly, what I was about to say. Yeah. Yeah. So, you know, I mean, there's a lot of uncertainty, obviously, in this field of endeavor that you can't rule out anything as being correct, including the prevailing view. At least for the time being. And it does take a lot to change things. I think on the whole, quite rightly, I, yeah, I mean, with regard to what I've written, I don't argue, I don't attempt to argue that floresiensis or something deriving from floresiensis, you know, is definitely still around. I'm not going to make a statement of conviction like that.
1:28:27All I'm trying to say, and my focus, of course, is on the people, the modern people of Florey's Island and their experiences and, you know, how they think, what they say and all that kind of stuff. So what I need to explain as an ethnologist, a cultural anthropologist, is the basis of some of their claims about things, about creatures, about beings. Right. Some of those beings, I'm sure, are supernatural. They don't exist. I mean, I'm thinking of things like forest spirits, various varieties of forest spirits, which have their names and characteristics. But they are not like animals or modern humans because they can't be perceived.
1:29:23Certainly, they can't be seen. They're invisible. And people say this. So there is a difference between them on that ground alone and homophoresiensis. With what I am showing is that there is a possibility that when Leo people make these reports about their ape men, that their reports are accurately based on some actual experience that individuals, a few individuals at any rate have had. Yes. So when you're talking to these people, is there evidence of psychedelic drug use amongst these people? You know what I mean? For the forest spirits and stuff like that. I thought you were going to ask me if there's any evidence for my use of such substances in the field.
1:30:10I'll ask that off air. But when you hear people talking about forest spirits, you start thinking about people in the jungle that have psychedelic rituals, like in the Amazon with ayahuasca. Yeah, well, for one thing, rarely are these things the forest spirits of sea. And you get the odd, well, you get a category of people, healers in part. Shamans. Shamans is not a bad description, yeah, who claim an ability to see things that other people can't. But do they have a history of psychedelic drug use? Nothing? No. Because most cultures have some method of perturbing their consciousness. Yeah. Are they using fermented fruits and making any kind of alcohol?
1:30:59Oh, yeah, making alcohol for sure. Okay. Palm wine, palm gin, very powerful stuff. Right. Good drink. Right. Now, are they drunk when they're seeing these forest spirits? No evidence that they are or were. Right. Right. But are the, so is that the only documented substance that these people are taking on this island? Is there any particular plants that have any sort of hallucinogenic properties? Well, certainly traditionally, not so much nowadays among the men. But until quite recently, they would regularly, habitually, excuse me, chew what's called beetle nut. No, it's not actually a nut. There's an areca nut.
1:31:42There's a palm nut. And beetle, which is either a leaf or a sort of pepper from a vine, together with slaked lime. And this is mildly narcotic. I mean, yeah. I consumed it regularly when I was on Sumba in the 1970s. What was that like? It was pleasant. It turned my teeth black, as it does with the local people. It's kind of like, I don't know, smoking too many cigars in a row. Okay, so it's like a strong stimulant. Yeah, I never became physically ill in the stomach. But it makes you feel good, like a lot of other things. I wasn't hallucinating. And, yeah, so there's that in addition to that. You said slick lime.
1:32:40What is that? Slake lime. Slake lime? Yeah. What is that exactly? It has to do with the way it's produced. I mean, it comes out as a... Here, Janie, just pulled it up. It's calcium hydroxide powder or paste. Yeah, I was going to say it comes out as a kind of a white powder, like talcum powder. Yeah. And you take a dab of that with your beetle pepper or leaf and your Eureka nut. Chew it all up. it becomes red. I mean, the plant materials are green. It's the fourth most commonly used addictive substance in the world after alcohol, nicotine, and caffeine. Isn't that wild? I can believe that. That's wild.
1:33:26Yeah. I don't think I became addictive even though I had a red mouth a lot of the time. Did it mess up your teeth? It made them black. That's it? You could brush them off? Oh, wow, look at these people. Oh, that's nasty. I'll tell you this so you may not believe it, but, I mean, I rarely brush my teeth for two years on Sumba. Wow. I was very intent. What was your breath like? My, my, my smoking as well. Oh, boy. You know, whatever. And I'm still alive at the age of nearly 80, so there you go. You were smoking cigarettes on the island by yourself? How'd you get them there? Oh, there were cigarettes for sale.
1:34:04Oh, they have them? Not very good ones, yeah. Okay. And they make their own as well. or they grow their own tobacco. Okay. So there's nothing, my point was, there's nothing that causes hallucinations. That's a part of their culture. I hope my insurance agent isn't listening to this. Sorry, what was the question? Are you still smoking? A small cigar, maybe five or six times a week. Okay. Yeah. After lunch only. I get it. No more than one a day. Some days, none. I haven't had one since Monday. And no, I enjoy smoking cigars. I do as well. But that was my point. Like if there was something that would cause them to see things that maybe wouldn't be available under normal consciousness.
1:34:54No, not really. And there's no delay. Yeah, I mean, with some shamans, people called shamans in other parts of the world, you have them making deliberate efforts to dissociate, to alter their consciousness. Through ritual? Well, it can be through percussion, drumming. Chanting. Chanting, yeah. It can be through substances, as you've described. rigorous sex even. Rigorous? Yeah. But there's not like psychedelic mushrooms or anything that grows there? On flores, no. Not that I'm aware of, no. I'm sure I'd have heard about them if there were. No. There are, of course, in other parts of the world and used by sharmons as well.
1:35:48Of course. So that was just my point with this because you were talking about how there's things that they saw that clearly seemed to be mythological or just fiction. The spirits, yeah. But then they also saw things that match up with these hobbit people. Yeah, I must say, I mean, the Leo people certainly have these religious figures, if you want to call them that. and I tended to dismiss their accounts, which were often a bit towards the fantastic ends of things. Did they have other fantastic accounts, not of primates, but of other things other than forest spirits that also existed that seemed to be something that was fiction?
1:36:38Seemed to be fiction, yeah. Yeah, I mean, one case I go into, again, in the recent book, is a creature that we are told is very good at climbing trees. That's not fantastic, but it has multiple testicles, they tell us. The females as well as the males. Females. They come in two sexes. and it grows an extra pair every year. Whoa. When it's reached a limit, which I think is a dozen, two times six, it will climb a tree, wail all night, and be dead by the morning, or drop dead in the following morning. Now, that sounds pretty fantastic, I think you'd say. Yeah, especially testicles on the ladies. It turns out to be the palm civet, which is a well-known animal and with some interpretation, you know, has features that accord with all these exaggerated claims.
1:37:51Have you ever had that coffee that they make out of the civet dung? Oh, yes. Yes, indeed. Kopi luwak. Luwak. That's exactly the species, yeah. I've had that. Yeah. It's a remarkably smooth coffee, but it's disconcerting. You think that you're drinking coffee that came out of a civet's butt. I guess so. But I guess there's a weirder things that people eat, I think. Certainly. Or consume. Yeah, no, the species name is hermaphroditus. Really? Which relates to certain glands both sexes possess, which can be mistaken for testicles. Oh, okay. Okay, so that's the origin of the myth. That's the origin of the idea.
1:38:36I mean, I later discovered that this fantastic, well, I was pretty sure beforehand, but it later became clear that people put out, here's one of those. And it was a palm civet. Right, so then you have to take into consideration what other things are they seeing that is either getting exaggerated or getting incorporated into the folklore, right? Like if they see just a particularly large monkey and maybe at a distance and maybe through thick brush and then they decide – because monkeys will occasionally be bipedal for brief periods of time. Chimpanzees as well. Yeah. Apes, of course. Yes. Our closest relative.
1:39:15Yes. So it gets to the point where you go, okay, if you have 30 people that have these stories that seem credible, at least a few of those have to be BS. But it gets to the point where if you have enough of them and they're so similar and then you have bones and then you don't just have bones there, but you have bones in the Philippines. You have bones in China. And you start – and in Africa, you start going, hey, maybe this is a real thing. And the real problem is what's the ethical considerations if they captured one? Like if they capture a monkey, you can put the monkey in the zoo. Yeah. It gets real squirrely if they captured one of these things and then they have to decide what to do with it.
1:40:06Because like what is that? It's not quite a monkey and it's not quite a person. Yeah. No. It's well between ape and human. Yeah. Using human in the sense of – I would feel very bad if one of those was in a zoo. I feel bad when I see monkeys in a zoo. Well, especially chimpanzees, sort of the higher apes. They look like they're in hell. Yeah. Yeah. No, I agree with you. I'm very torn myself on this point. I mean, obviously, you know, I'd partly like something like that to be discovered. I mean, it would— From a scientific perspective, it would be incredible. From a scientific perspective, it would be incredible.
1:40:48It would also kind of vindicate me, I guess. Right. But you might say, but on the other hand, I think it would be much better if they still exist to leave them alone. Right. But you would have to prove it. And how would you prove that they exist? And especially in this day and age with AI video, it's almost impossible at this point to discern what's real and what's not. Very right. Yeah. But if they captured one of them, like, boy, I would feel bad. Like, especially if it started making noises that sounded like a language, you know? Oh, well, then it would be kind of easier, I guess, to – yeah, you definitely wouldn't put them in a zoo.
1:41:28Right. Well, not only that, what are you going to do even in terms of studying them? Like do you decide to dart them for a short period of time and sedate them? And also there's complications to that. To sedate – who knows what they're allergic to. You could potentially kill them accidentally while studying them. I mean that's an issue as well. But I would say the best way to study them would be through field research, primatological field research, a la Jane Goodall and various other ladies, including the one that lived with mountain gorillas. and long enough so they become habituated to you and so on.
1:42:19Yeah, probably would be better if a slightly built female took on that role. Something non-threatening that would allow them to come into their community. Yeah, but they're not chimpanzees or they weren't. And so, I don't know. Gosh, it really – I mean we are used to dealing with all these conceptual boundaries, right? Like human and animal and so on. And this would – yeah, this would present a real philosophical problem, a real conundrum. Yeah, so Forrest Gallant was telling me about a contemporary account of a woman who was an anthropologist who was – I just cannot remember where the village was.
1:43:12But this person had encountered something – Dude, I bet this woman's name. Yeah, here it is. I've got it. So a woman named Sabine Coogler who wrote this book called Child of the Jungle. Her parents were German missionaries in a super remote area of western Papau. So it was in New Guinea. He did an interview with her, and she said that she had seen these little people. And then she woke up in camp more than one time, and they were looming over her and around camp. And she's a very sane academic, he's saying, not like a jungle person who believes in third world superstitions, he says. And this woman who is a very sane literary author, cutting edge scientist, and she swears that she saw these little people and she told the exact story.
1:44:10And so he says he actually has a recorded Zoom call that he could send me of this encounter. Yeah. But this is a woman who was just like completely stunned encountering these tiny little people in New Guinea. So are there accounts in New Guinea that are similar? If I may ask, she was quite young at the time? I don't know. I mean, it's just something that Forrest sent me. He's a wildlife biologist and he does a lot of work trying to find extinct species as well. He's looked for the thylacine multiple times. The thylacine. Yeah. Oh, yeah. Yeah. Interesting case, that one. Right. So we have video of the last supposed thylacine that was alive in a zoo.
1:44:57Yeah, 1936. But there's quite a few credible reports of sightings. Yeah, there are sightings. And if people aren't actually seeing them, there's that bigger, more fascinating problem of what they are seeing or where this all comes from. The point is that this is Forrest's history. This is what he does. He has a great YouTube channel, by the way. Yeah. And he documents his journeys. I think I've heard of the name. Really great. I'm not particularly familiar. He may follow that up. Fascinating guy. But the point is, like, this woman told him the story. This story is, like, insane. She actually encountered these.
1:45:35So is there a history of them in New Guinea as well? I might just point out, not to appear too defensive, but I myself have been told similar stories by Flores Islanders. And I don't want to – I want to make clear that, you know, to my mind, that there's not as much difference as you would think between Flores Islanders and Westerners who report similar experiences. But you said New Guinea, Papua New Guinea, I think. Yeah. Well, there are, again, in the highlands of that very big island, there are what are or used to be called human pygmies, pygmoid populations.
1:46:27who, yeah, there have been reports of those people showing up in sort of odd places and walking through human settlements as well. You know, also from reported by credible witnesses. And witches. I'm writing a book on witches. Are you really? Yeah. No, that's another thing. In fact, I had some difficulty preparing for this interview because I'm working on the proofs, the final proofs and the index. And I did pieces recently on Halloween. Oh, wow. That was just a Freudian slip. Oh, no worries. Witnesses, I meant. So what are the descriptions? Are they human, like careless? They are human. So they're just like tiny pygmies.
1:47:20You know, it's interesting. They don't wear a lot of clothes. There's a lot of people in New Guinea don't or didn't. So whether bodily hair shows up more than it might do otherwise, can't recall those details, but they are small and they are dark, like most New Guineans. Well, to be classified as pygmoid, They have to be, the average male height has to be less than 1.5 meters, which is like, you know, well, less than five feet or four foot 11, that kind of. So, these are. So, there is more. I like African pygmies. But these are people. These are modern humans. This is very different. These are extraordinarily different.
1:48:07Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Not to confuse with floresiensis or anything. Maybe what this woman encountered. So that might be that they live. Very possible. We'd need more details of what she remembers. Are these documented populations? Yes. So this is something that we know exists currently? Oh, for sure. I mean, there are detailed ethnographic, cultural, anthropological details of their socioeconomic systems and everything else. This is a totally different kind of thing. Yeah, of course. They speak languages like the rest of us. Okay. So as far as little tiny hairy creatures, you said Sumatra, the Philippines, Indonesia.
1:48:49Where else? Where else are these credible witness accounts of people experiencing these kind of little tiny ape-like creatures? Yeah, well, my first inclination is to say, well, you know, Flores and I guess Sumbawa, neighboring Ireland, and Sumatra as well, the Orang Pendek. But there are reports from North America by native North Americans. Something sounds familiar, similar. Nothing terribly detailed. but I know I did some research for another book years back on the Bigfoot or Sasquatch in the Pacific Northwest. And I think the Bella Coola Indians, the Bella Bella Indians, in British Columbia, coastal British Columbia, had a category of the name of creatures which sounded like small, somewhat hairy folk.
1:50:14The lai hoa, of course, in Flores, there are various reports of how much bodily hair they have. And, you know, according to some, they're not terribly hairy, not like a gorilla or a bear. So that's another kind of variable. But then, you know, if you just have the description hairy, then, you know, if you don't take that any further and, you know, investigate more, you don't know what that means. I mean, hairy can mean, well, like the lady in the picture up there. Right. It can refer specifically to mainly to the head hair. But anyway, yeah, no, there are, well, there's one report I was talking about Sasquatch, which I find fascinating, from 1884.
1:51:08It even appeared in an early newspaper in that neck of the woods about a creature that was given the name Jacko. And I can send references to that if you're interested. but that sounded fairly genuine. Say it again. What is the name of it? The creature? What is it called? It was called Jacko. It's just kind of a nickname, which is sometimes a nickname for human beings, like Jack. Yeah. So Daniel Boone had a description in his memoirs of an encounter that he had with a giant creature that he wound up killing. Do you know that story? Probably. I know. Daniel Boone or David Crockett was supposed to have killed a bear when he was only three.
1:52:03I don't know which one it is, but Daniel Boone. This was a song on the radio when I was about five years old. He had an encounter supposedly that he documented with him and his son where they had shot and killed a giant human-like creature. and it was, I believe it was over eight feet tall or nine feet tall, some enormous thing that had a different anatomy than humans. Like instead of having a rib cage, it had like a large plate of bone over its chest area. I mean, apparently, I sent this to my friend Steve Rinella and he said Boone also had some tall tails. So I don't know. I don't know how much of this is true or not true.
1:52:44But the whole Sasquatch thing has always fascinated me because of the amount of different names that Native Americans had for this particular creature. And they didn't have a lot of fake creatures. They didn't have descriptions of things that just didn't exist. And they had a lot of names for a wild man that lives in the woods that's very tall and hairy. Yeah. No, you're right. In fact, there was a rather interesting paper written on that very issue by a guy. He's at the University of Washington. Meldrum? Not Meldrum, no. His name is long gone now. His name was Wayne Suttles. You'd be interested in the article.
1:53:27Just looking at the different names and their derivations and all that kind of thing. No, Meldrum, not another person who's passed. Yes. Yeah. No, I sort of was acquainted with him for a while. He was a true believer. Yeah, but at the same time, he was, you know, his arguments, whatever the basis, are pretty solid. He was a serious physical anthropologist. Well, you know who really believed in it, at least at one point she did, was Jane Goodall. Yes, so I understand. Again, I don't know much of the details of that. She gave interviews where she was saying that she's certain it exists. This was quite a long time ago.
1:54:13Yeah. Who knows? I don't know. She's gone now. Yeah, but before she died, I don't know if she changed her opinion or she's probably tired of talking about it because that might have been the only thing people wanted to talk about. Tell me more about Bigfoot. Yeah, yeah. No, I mean, there's a number of other primatologists and people who study primates in the field who have also subscribed to, if not Bigfoot, then the Yeti, a guy called Vern Reynolds, who was at Oxford at one time, I think. And a guy called John Napier who wrote a very interesting book called, I guess, Bigfoot back in, I don't know, the early 70s.
1:54:59It largely partly focused on the Patterson film. Yeah. Yeah. So, you know, I mean, it's not the case that all scientists, to use that broad category, you know, dismiss immediately. And in fact, I know paleoanthropologists, biologists as well, who find my arguments credible. But it's very interesting, you know, they'll never say so in print. No. No, because, and again, you know, I talk about conservatism and so on. Somewhat understandably, they like to keep this, you know, in a separate kind of compartment. Completely understandably, especially if you're an academic. If you start saying you believe in Bigfoot, you're immediately put into the Coupé category.
1:55:56Well, there's that, but more practically speaking, I guess your funding will quite rapidly dry up. Yeah, there's a fine line between eccentric and foolish. Yeah. Yeah. Well, however eccentric I might be, I'm pleased to report that I never had, as a cultural anthropologist, particularly studying other people's experiences, beliefs, values, all this kind of thing, I never had that problem from my colleagues. I may have been more ignored than I would have been otherwise, but I've never had to put up with what— Well, it's fascinating. What Meldrum did. Well, Meldrum was like a full believer. I asked him if you could chop one of your fingers off to find out the Bigfoot was real, would you do it?
1:56:40He said yes. I was like, oh, my God, man.
1:56:46But the point is it's like as a cultural anthropologist, it is absolutely, at least the mythology of these things, is absolutely a part of culture. And a fascinating aspect of it because there's so many stories and they're so uniform. It's all like eight foot plus, nine foot tall, enormous, hairy, ape-like creature that seems to be very human in a lot of ways. It doesn't have the arm length and leg length of an ape. It seems to be built more like a large, hairy person. Yeah. Well, I would agree with you, except for one particular. These details, well, talking about flores. Mm-hmm. These details don't show up so much in what we call mythology or myths or even legends to make that distinction.
1:57:39The naturalistic descriptions come from, well, mostly from supposed eyewitness encounters. Right. If you look at general knowledge, then you do start to get kind of fantastic features, right? And also second-hand accounts. They pass from hand to hand. They kind of tend more in the supernatural direction, which in itself is fascinating. is a kind of evidence for the eyewitnesses, especially having had an actual experience and referring to an actual creature. And, of course, that's where the similarities between the different accounts become remarkable. And not just that, of course, but the match with reconstructions of fossils of Homo floresiensis.
1:58:41Yes. Yeah. If they had found that in North America, like if they had found a Bigfoot evidence, it would change the whole conversation. Then the conversation would be, is this an extinct? Like imagine if they had found some Bigfoot jawbone in a cave somewhere that was an unknown primate that is 8 ,000 plus years old. Yeah. Then you'd have to go, OK, now what are we talking about? Are we talking about something that's extinct or are we talking about a very small population of intelligent creatures that has thus far evaded being captured on film? Yeah. Yeah. No, I mean that would – I mean it would get a lot more publicity than Floresiensis.
1:59:27Oh my goodness. Happening in the modern West and in the U.S. or even Canada. It would have the same coverage. Well, the problem is unlike Homo florensis or floresiensis, there is so many hoaxes in America. There's so many gods like, I found Bigfoot. He's in my freezer. And like a big frozen doll. There's like so many kooks that have said and so many people have done it for stories and, you know, just to create a hoax. Yeah. Well, this is something that I – well, it's the first thing, one of the first things I discuss in the book. is the different cultural context, circumstances of, on the one hand, people in florries, ordinary, you know, villagers, reporting what, you know, they once saw.
2:00:26The culture, the circumstances, all that kind of stuff, on the one hand, and the culture, the socioeconomic system in which people who claim to have observed Bigfoot live, different kinds of interests. I mean, nobody on flores thinks they're going to become famous by telling me what they've seen, whatever it may have been. Right. Whereas with Bigfoot in North America, then, you know, you become rich and famous. I don't know about rich. Maybe not rich, but famous. You might be able to parlay it. I mean, look, you could get on Finding Bigfoot. I mean, how many seasons did they do a Finding Bigfoot?
2:01:16They never found Bigfoot. Never did. Spoiler alert. No. You watch a lot of hours long television waiting for them to find it, and they never find it. Well, that's an excellent point because, you know, there's never been such a search on Flores. Right. And no local interest in such a thing either. That's probably pure. It's probably better that they don't do it that way. I think but a real true scientific search, not a reality show search, would be absolutely fascinating. Yeah. Maybe Forrest would be interested in doing it. He's fascinated by the subject. Worth doing as well. Certainly worth doing.
2:01:53Now, when you were doing this whole investigation of Bigfoot, did you find any evidence or anything, any stories, anything that you thought was compelling? Well, I mentioned the 1884 report that was actually published in one of the few newspapers in British Columbia. This is a wild frontier, right? In fact, this thing that was seen was actually...
2:02:21Yeah, no, it was reputedly captured alive. That's right. But it was when the Canadian Pacific Railway was going through. And this was about 100-odd miles from the coast in a place called Yale, as a matter of fact, near a place called Yale. It was small. One reason why I mentioned it wasn't a giant. I know that subsequent commentators have suggested it was an infant Bigfoot. How small was it? I think it was maybe 4 '2". So it's similar in size to Homo floresiensis. A bit bigger. A little bigger. Yeah. But certainly small for a modern human or for an Neanderthal for that matter. But there are North American or Native American tribes that have stories of small, hairy people that live in the woods as well.
2:03:18There are. Well, just the one, at any rate, that I mentioned earlier. So, yeah, obviously by comparison with the Indonesian stuff. What did they wind up doing with this? Because photography existed at the time, right? It did, but I'm not sure how many cameras were available. And so no pictures were taken. He's got it here. Jacket, there he is. It's a story of a potential... Oh, four foot seven. I was wrong. Okay. Anyway, shorter than five feet. So a young ape-like creature of Sasquatch allegedly captured alive near Yale, British Columbia, Canadian Pacific Railway crew. First published in the Daily British Colonist newspaper on July 4th, 1884.
2:04:03The story is widely considered by modern historians and cryptozoologists to be a work of historical journalistic fiction. A newspaper hoax. which is very possible too because they did a lot of those back then. Huh. Yeah. Maybe. Who knows? So there's that. But is there anything else that you thought was interesting?
2:04:25Yeah, certainly there were some writers on Bigfoot like John Green, who's a newspaper man, in fact, in the Fraser Valley there. He was not quite so dismissive. The main reason I think the cryptos would dismiss Jacko is because he wasn't big enough for a Bigfoot. Well, also because newspapers would routinely make up stories. They would, yeah. But, you know, the eyewitnesses were all named, including one of the top bosses of the CP Railway. so if he'd want to stick his neck out so far, or indeed, you know, why he would want to do it. Whatever became of it is a mystery. It sort of disappeared. I know there's a book published a couple of decades back by a guy whose name escapes me.
2:05:31It's a physical anthropologist, and the book is called Bigfoot Debunked. I mean he's sort of virulently opposed to any suggestion that anything like this could exist and the best he could do with Jacko is conclude that it was a chimpanzee that had escaped from a circus or a zoo. A four foot seven chimpanzee? Well there you are. Now, I think it had longish head hair as well. But anyway. Really? Yeah. But it was, by all indications, naked, although this was not mentioned in the report, kind of interestingly. Bearing in mind this was the height of the Victorian era, you know, where you didn't mention such a thing.
2:06:24But, yeah, no, the best this author, recent author could do is say that it was an escaped chimpanzee. You know, I mean, one thing one can be pretty certain of, very certain of, is that there were no circuses or zoos in that area. I don't think there was a zoo anywhere in British Columbia. Very remote. Maybe. Well, yeah, it was a brand new, it was a colony at that time. Yeah. It wasn't part of, well, I guess it had just become, had it? And that area, British Columbia in particular, has a lot of those Sasquatch sightings. Well, this is kind of the classic domain of these things. Yeah. I've got to say no circuses either.
2:07:13No, no circuses. So do you think that there's a possibility that something like that, at least at one point in time, existed in North America? I don't want to rule it out. But as I say, the Flores ape men are much more credible because of the fossil evidence. and the whole kind of ecosystem and the region of the world where they are, existence of other primates. If not on the island, then pretty close by. The whole evolutionary history of that region. And again, not only are there fossils, but there's a close match between what the fossils indicate and what my colleagues in the field, Leo Villagers indicate so yeah you've got to keep a bit of an open mind don't you?
2:08:03Yes well it's also my problem with Bigfoot is that it's fun it's fun to believe yeah and so I start looking at my own judgment and going stop yeah being silly you're wasting time yeah no I I don't I don't find Bigfoot credible and again I've said so in print in an earlier book it's interesting that 1884 I mean that was the time when great apes gorillas and chimpanzees were becoming widely known to a western public whereas they hadn't been before but the discovery of mountain apes by westerners wasn't until the late 19th century right? The mountain gorilla I think was the 20th century was it? Yeah and And the other, the Lerland guerrilla as well, was relatively recent.
2:08:58Yeah, they were thought to be a myth, which is quite hard for us to imagine today. Well, yes and no. I mean, if you look at the culture history and so on, the historical setting and all the rest of it. Don't forget Darwin, his ideas only became current in 1859. But I was going to say with regard to, you know, kind of general knowledge about apes, these were something new. And, you know, they reached people through, I guess, you know, the popular press, such as it was mainly at the time. Some people would have read books about them, but they would have been probably a minority. So, you know, people had only a vague kind of idea of what they looked like.
2:10:00Anybody seeing, I don't know, a very shaggy dog or maybe a small bear in British Columbia at that time might have made a mistake or, you know. That's the part of the problem. It created it, yeah. Bears also sometimes walk bipedally. Yeah, if you see them in the distance, if it's dusk, if it's very, yeah. If it's very dense woods, it's very difficult to discern what you're actually looking at. And then the mind plays tricks on you and you start. Indeed. I did a show with my friend Duncan where we went up into the Pacific Northwest to go looking for Bigfoot. And we were hanging out with Bigfoot hunters.
2:10:38And, you know, most of them just seemed like guys that are looking for a hobby. But there's one woman that I talked to, one woman who had an encounter. and I don't know what she saw, obviously, but she was very, at least the way she was communicating, felt very rational, very sane. She was a smart person. She wasn't stupid. And she knew the area. She lived in the area. And she said she saw this thing, and she, for a half a second, she goes, that's a gorilla. Like, why is there a gorilla in the forest? And she said she only saw it for less than a minute. it was moving through the trees but she said she goes i know what a bear looks like she goes i know what she goes it did not look like a bear i think it was a sasquatch and i think they're real yeah the problem also with the pacific northwest and that particular area we're talking about like mount rainier it's so dense that the the trees the way i describe it it's like a box of q-tips you know like it's just it's insanely dense you can't see anything no and it's the forest floor is filled with pine needles and leaves that have like landed and compacted over and over and over.
2:11:48So you're not going to get any footprints. No. No, indeed. And these things can walk quietly because the ground is very soft and everything's wet because it's just this tremendous rainforest. It's incredibly rich with life. And you're there and you go, okay, I can see how something could hide in here. Like you're not going to find things. Like you could only – like even if you had a team of people, first of all, you'd be making so much noise. They would smell you a mile away. I'd say smell would be a factor as well. Smell you a mile away. Yeah. And it's so dense. Like the kind of forest up there is so incredibly dense that seeing something in the distance would be virtually impossible if you're actually in the woods.
2:12:29Yeah. Yeah. But the question is like if it's something – look at that guy. Have you seen this guy before? Oh, yes, indeed. In fact – Jojo the dogface boy, he was around 1880s. Some of those pictures are in an earlier book I wrote, yeah. Yeah, there's people that have that condition today. Yeah, hypertrichosis. I stumbled across this guy from this. This is Julia Pastrana. She was around from 1860 and died in 1865 in Moscow, but is from Sinaloa, Mexico. Yeah. And was studied left and right by all sorts of people. So she was from Mexico. Look at her features. That's crazy. the hair all over her face yeah that's wild small was a performer whoa her body is still being displayed somewhere oh yeah uh but as i'm like hearing all these descriptions i'm like this this would pass for that description you're saying kind of in some sure sure if you saw that if she was tiny and she was running through the woods a bigfoot you mean yeah or you know yeah uh any sort of forest person in some of these other places.
2:13:35I guess, but then you have to ask, why would anybody like that want to be running through the woods, you know, in some remote place, presumably naked? You know, how would they get there? How would they get home after a time? She was supposedly sold by her uncle after her mother died. Yeah, I know there's some unfortunate stories attached to these. well didn't they put a man in the Bronx Zoo there was a man that they put in the Bronx Zoo who was I think he was a pygmy and they literally had him in the zoo like for observation so people could see him it's not impossible I know there were same time period yeah there were pygmies pygmy families who were exhibited at was it a World's Fair Somewhere in, where the heck was that, Chicago?
2:14:29Uh-huh. St. Louis? Somewhere in the United States. Yeah. It was the same one. St. Louis Welfare. Yeah, same guy. Oh, yes. Booties. One group of so-called pygmies. Let me tell you about pygmies. One hesitates a bit because the name is no longer politically correct. But we're talking about fully modern humans. Their brains and heads are not as small as their bodies. Okay, so their brain size would be comparable to anybody else. So quite different from something like Homo pharisiensis. But the point I wanted to make was that before a guy called Schweinfurth, a German explorer, was able to document the actual existence of African pygmies around the middle of the 19th century.
2:15:34I think it was 1847, so exactly 100 years before I was born. He actually bought one, if you can believe that. Horrible, as that sounds. But, you know, some pygmies were kept as slaves by taller Africans at that time. But before that, Europeans thought that pygmies were a myth, that there was no such thing, that this was a product of Greek mythology, especially. And, of course, it's from there that the name pygmy comes. So, yeah, comparable to our knowledge of or anybody's knowledge of gorillas, for example, the pygmies we discovered a bit before. It's fascinating we think of like how little people knew about the natural world just a couple of hundred years ago.
2:16:30Yeah. Well, no, indeed, that's a good point. I want to just correct myself. I said before guerrilla were discovered. They were well known to local people in Africa. Right. Discovered by the Western world. With a very ethnocentric approach, which, again, is a matter of habit, right? Yep. I didn't mean to say that. And, yeah, likewise with conservative scientists, you get into modes of thought that are not easy to alter. Yeah. Well, listen, I really enjoyed talking to you. And I'd love to talk to you about witches when that book is done too. That's another very fascinating subject. April Fool's Day.
2:17:09First of April is when there's an official publication date that you can order copies now. What is it called? It's called The Wicked Witch. And then there's a subtitle which is Origins of an Enduring Worldwide Belief. Because one of my main aims is to show that there are very few cultures anywhere that don't have a belief that corresponds. very closely, even in the smallest particulars, to what we understand by witches in the West. And I would immediately point out that I don't believe in witches. Whatever I might think about homophlorisians or present-day descendants that might exist, no, a witchcraft exists in accusations people accuse, have accused, still accused, as a matter of fact, in many places, including in the West, other people of being able to, of being evil, of being able to harm other people maliciously, wantonly through supernatural means.
2:18:15But there's a lot of other things I've discovered about witches in that journey, which actually began a very long time ago when I first started to teach anthropology. But I think it's something that would be of interest to your listeners. 100%. So let's plan on doing that again. We'll do another podcast sometime after the book is out. Yeah, okay. We'll talk about that. Okay. Alright. Next time, make sure you get me a flight to Austin that gives me more connection time from Houston because I missed my flight yesterday. Oh, did you? Oh, sorry. Yeah. Okay, we'll do that. Thank you very much. Really appreciate it.
2:18:51It was a really fun conversation. Yeah, no, it's been extremely enjoyable and I I'm very impressed by your question. Oh, thank you. I'm very impressed by your work. Thank you. Perfect. All right. Bye, everybody. Bye.
Gregory Forth, DPhil, is an anthropologist, Fellow of the Royal Society of Canada, and author of "Between Ape and Human: An Anthropologist on the Trail of a Hidden Hominid."www.pegasusbooks.com/books/between-ape-and-human-9781639361434-hardcoverwww.gregoryforth.com
Perplexity: Download the app or ask Perplexity anything at https://pplx.ai/rogan.
50% off your first box at https://www.thefarmersdog.com/rogan!
Ghost Soldier exclusively in Theatres This Tuesday
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices