1. Podcasts
  2. The Journal.
  3. How A24 Keeps Making Hit Films
The Journal.

28 Oct 2026 · 20m · 8 chapters

Episode artwork

How A24 Keeps Making Hit Films

In short

The episode argues that A24’s success comes from combining small-budget risk-taking with a social-media-driven marketing strategy that builds strong youth brand loyalty. It spotlights the documentary You Can See Everything, made by A24, which followed Elizabeth Holmes and Billy Evans in the 34 days before Holmes went to prison and continued after sentencing; it was kept secret during a three-year production (known to fewer than 10 A24 staff) and premiered to 650 phone-locked attendees.

Key claims

A24 harnesses social media “counterculturally,” turns surprise into marketing currency, and converts brand equity into box office.

Notable examples

Moonlight, The Witch, Hereditary, Midsommar, Backrooms, and a flop Misty Green ($160,000).

Guests

Ben Fritz, entertainment-industry journalist and colleague; Ryan Knudsen hosts.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

3:02

Sponsor: Accenture

Accenture's role in Spotify's advertising business and optimization.

“Coming up on the show, you can hear everything about A24.”
3:26

The Secret of You Can See Everything

Exploration of the secrecy surrounding the documentary about Elizabeth Holmes.

“Behind this podcast and the music you listen to, Spotify has a sophisticated advertising business.”
6:01

Crafting the Documentary with A24

How A24 became involved in the documentary and its unique approach.

“which for a documentary, particularly one that doesn't have any music stars in it, is really extraordinary.”
10:23

A24's Unique Business Model

Discussion on A24's founding, marketing strategy, and film focus.

“This is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs.”
11:48

A24's Rise and Breakthroughs

Examination of A24's significant films and their cultural impact.

“So for a new studio to launch with a focus on that business seemed very unusual.”
13:16

A24's Hits and Misses

Overview of A24's track record with films and box office performance.

“But it was a commercial and critical failure.”
14:00

A24's Success and Challenges

Explore how A24 has established a strong brand and navigates industry challenges.

“that were not cheap, shocking, and exploitative, that were actually really smart horror movies.”
17:14

Maintaining A24's Cool Factor

Discuss the challenges A24 faces in maintaining its unique brand identity as it grows.

“And inevitably, as you get bigger, you just become more corporate.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The Journal., what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:06You're not going to deceive me today, right, Ben? I don't have anything to deceive you on. Of course I'm not deceiving you. I'm engaging with you as a human being. You're being real right now. I'm always being real.

0:24I am not Elizabeth Holmes. I'm not out to deceive anybody. I specifically became a journalist, not an actor. That's our colleague Ben Fritz. He writes about the entertainment industry. And he, like so many of us, has recently seen the new documentary, You Can See Everything. On its surface, it is about the last few weeks before Elizabeth Holmes went to prison, during which Nathan Fielder and the filmmaker Lance Oppenheim spent 34 days with Holmes and her partner and their two young children documenting everything about their lives and talking to her about whether she really was guilty of the crimes that she was convicted of, which of course she believes she is not.

1:09So where did things get lost? Like, how are you where you are right now? I wish I knew. I don't know. I don't feel like I understand that. And then the film continues after she goes to prison in some, what can I say, some very surprising and bizarre ways. I guess I would say that the film gets very meta. The movie was made by A24. The independent studio is having an exceptionally good year. From the Gen Z horror movie backrooms to Oscar contenders like Primetime and The Invite, A24 has done something incredible. Make critically acclaimed movies, make money, and get young people excited about Hollywood again.

1:57A24 is by far the most successful independent film company in the entertainment industry right now. And most importantly, they've created a brand that is really meaningful for young audiences. A lot of people go to see A24 movies because they are A24 movies. It's become kind of a brand that's as powerful for young fans of indie cinema as like Disney is for families.

2:27How surprising is it what A24 has built? It's pretty shocking. You know, I mean, I think a decade ago, everybody thought that young people were losing interest in the movies. And it was all about social media, short form video, video games, etc. But what A24 has done really remarkably is they've harnessed social media. And in a kind of countercultural way, A24 has made film cool again for at least a certain set of young adults.

2:57Welcome to The Journal, our show about money, business, and power. I'm Ryan Knudsen. It's Wednesday, October 28th.

3:10Coming up on the show, you can hear everything about A24.

3:25This episode of The Journal is presented to you by Accenture. Behind this podcast and the music you listen to, Spotify has a sophisticated advertising business. Accenture is deeply embedded in that business, working with Spotify to reinvent the rhythm of ad sales, building, maintaining, and optimizing. Accenture finds the friction and builds the systems that make things run smoother and faster. The result? Less time spent on operations, more time connecting brands with the moments and fandoms that matter most. Learn more at Accenture.com slash Spotify.

4:02I want to start by talking about how this movie, You Can See Everything, was so top secret for a while. How secret was it? And can you tell me the story of how it came to light for the first time? The existence of this film all through production, which was three years, was barely known to anybody outside of the tiny crew and fewer than 10 people who work at A24. and there are something like 300 people who work there. So that's really remarkable. I mean, Hollywood is the most gossipy industry in the world. So the fact that they kept it so secret, even within their own company, was extraordinary.

4:36And at first, it was part of the project. It was like kind of necessary for them as they figured out what this film was going to be. And then as it got closer to completion, 824 kind of realized that the secrecy would actually be a really effective marketing tool. So they didn't even announce it was coming until literally the first step was in June. An executive at A24 texted the director of the Telluride Film Festival and just told her, and we actually have seen the text, that all this text said was, have something of note to talk to you about. The director of the Telluride Film Festival agreed to show the movie without revealing what it was.

5:14And so then in early September, a month and a half before the film came out, like about 650 people went into a theater, They all had to lock their phones in a yonder pouch. And did any of the people that went to this premiere, this 650 people, did they know what they were about to see? No, they did not know what it was. And it turned out to be, you can see everything. And that started the unbelievable buzz that, you know, kind of built up over about six weeks and with really a brilliantly executed marketing plan because the buzz really reached its crescendo just as the film opened. Mm-hmm. And so how has it opened since it hit theaters?

5:48It's done remarkably well. Its opening weekend was$15.6 million. Its second weekend was$19.5 million. It's, of course,$45 million so far as of the time we're recording this, which for a documentary, particularly one that doesn't have any music stars in it, is really extraordinary. I mean, this is on track to be one of, if not the highest-grossing non-music documentaries ever.

6:18so tell me the story of how this movie got made how did it end up at 824 well what's really interesting is that elizabeth holmes and her partner billy evans they actually reached out to 824 they were interested in making a documentary and they knew enough about 824 to think this is a company that they wanted to work with at first 824 passed because they were like you know you can imagine if Elizabeth Holmes and Billy Evans were initiating it, they thought this would be maybe like a pretty puffy documentary that they controlled. This is not the kind of thing A24 would do. They really care about working with prestige filmmakers or promising young filmmakers they believe in.

6:56And since there were not even any filmmakers attached, A24 decided they didn't want to do it initially. But rumor of the pitch soon made its way to the comedian Nathan Fielder and a young, acclaimed documentary filmmaker, Lance Oppenheim. Last month, after a screening, Oppenheim talked about the origin of the film. It started when he was with Fielder at a magic club in LA. A magician asked the audience for the name of a celebrity, and someone yelled Elizabeth Holmes. And then the magic show ended. I was like, it's so interesting, Elizabeth Holmes. And Nathan's like, what's interesting? And I was like, well, I just heard that she, I heard that she was looking for someone to document her life and that she had reached out to A24, which I thought was strange.

7:38And so they talked to A24, and next thing you know, there's a seven-person film crew in the rental home where Elizabeth Holmes and Billy Evans and their kids were living, starting about 34 days before she went to prison. One of the strangest things about this movie is the pairing of Fielder, a deadpan comedian who leans into the uncomfortable, and Holmes, the disgraced founder of Theranos. Fielder was not a household name, but A24 took a bet on his creative talents, Something the studio has a reputation for. Nathan Fielder is not a serious documentary maker at all. He makes nonfiction programming that's very meta, right?

8:19Like, Nathan, for you, was about him coming in and running businesses that he had no idea how to run. But it's about deep-seated things and the way humans deal with each other and the way our society runs. And, you know, he is a very quirky personality, to say the least. So he was never going to make a straight-ahead documentary at all. I will say, A24 is a studio that takes a lot of risks. You know, they make a lot of, like, bizarre movies you didn't see coming. You know, they were the ones who took an internet meme and turned it into backrooms. You know, just for one example, they had a movie called The Drama this year that mixes the threat of mass shootings with a wedding, and it's a comedy, if you can believe it.

9:00So they make unusual movies, and basically, if they believe in a filmmaker, or they're willing to take a bet. And they believe in both Fielder and Oppenheim. And at first, you know, it was very cheap, right? They're just sending a small crew to Holmes and Evans' house, and they weren't even sure they'd get a movie out of it. They were like, let's just see what we get and see if there's a movie here. Coming up, the business model behind A24.

9:32This episode is brought to you by Indeed. Running a business means dealing with the dreaded hiring process. And the stakes are high when the right hire could make or break your business strategy. But good news. Indeed Sponsored Jobs is here to make things less painful and nerve wracking. It gives your job post a boost to reach quality talent faster. Plus, it can help put your job in front of exactly who you're looking for based on criteria you set. Like if you need certain skills or certifications. And it works. Sponsored jobs posted directly on Indeed are 95 % more likely to report a hire than non-sponsored jobs.

10:07So spend less time searching and more time actually interviewing candidates who check all your boxes. Listeners of this show will get a$75 sponsored job credit at Indeed.com slash podcast. That's Indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Need a hiring hero? This is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs.

10:35A24 was a startup founded in 2012 by three people, Daniel Katz, David Finkel, and John Hodges. Katz secured seed money from the investment firm Guggenheim Partners, where it used to work. And the idea was that they could help fill the hole in what was in an already dwindling independent film market by focusing on social media marketing, which would cost a lot less, of course, than TV ads and which reaches a younger audience than, like, print newspaper ads, I'm sorry to say. A key part of their strategy was to make movies with smaller budgets, unlike the blockbusters that dominated Hollywood at the time.

11:15How counterintuitive was this idea at the time? Like, what was happening in Hollywood around 2012? Well, the whole independent film business was withering. It had been really big in the 1990s. Think of, like, The Rise of Miramax. think of films like Little Miss Sunshine. Those movies were not doing as well. Disney had sold Miramax by this point. Everybody was really excited about franchise movies at this time, you know, like Marvel and Fast and Furious were taking over the film business. And little independent movies that came out of Sundance or something were just, they were losing attention.

11:46They were losing market share. It was becoming a worse and worse business. So for a new studio to launch with a focus on that business seemed very unusual. It didn't make sense on its face. And then their marketing playbook was unusual because the idea for independent film had always been, well, if you want to reach a prestige audience, it's all about getting good reviews in newspapers and magazines, getting the critics to like it, running print ads in those papers where, like, high-end affluent moviegoers find what they want to watch. And maybe if your film is breaking out enough, you start buying some TV ads.

12:19Social media was pretty young at that point. And the idea of marketing on it was a bit of a novelty. So for a studio to launch and for that to be their focus was an entirely new thing for Hollywood.

12:34So A24 kind of reinvented how to market a film using social media, but also the films they were making were good. Absolutely. Yes. A24 really became known for, I would say, unusual twists on something you think you know. They identified a lot of emerging filmmakers who went on to become big. The first movie A24 distributed was called A Glimpse Inside the Mind of Charles Swan III. It had all the trappings of an A24 movie today. A buzzy director and Roman Coppola. A slightly off-the-wall surrealist plot. And a talented cast, including Bill Murray and Patricia Arquette. But it was a commercial and critical failure.

13:18I don't want to be with you anymore. I can't concentrate. I think of her every minute. A24 had a big breakout moment with the movie Moonlight, which won Best Picture at the Oscars in 2017. And you might remember this was the time they accidentally announced the wrong movie. This is not a joke. Moonlight has won Best Picture.

13:39Moonlight. Best Picture. They made films that were simultaneously well-respected by critics and eventually by the Oscars, but were also actually seemed cool and interesting to young people because they weren't the most down-the-middle, obvious, like, Oscar-bait films at all. And they started making horror movies that were not cheap, shocking, and exploitative, that were actually really smart horror movies. There was The Witch. What's thou like to live deliciously? There was Hereditary. Don't you ever raise your voice in me! I am your mother! There was Midsommar. Welcome and happy Midsommar. Skol!

14:24And actors followed suit, wanting to work with in-demand directors at the edgy studio. Robert Pattinson, for instance, has made six A24 movies. A24 is not invincible, though, I assume. What's its actual batting average when it comes to hits versus flops? I mean, it's actually, it's good, but it is not extraordinary. A24 has had plenty of flops. They just released a Chris Rock movie that I'm sure you haven't heard of called Misty Green. Nope. Yep. Literally, let's see here if I can find what it's grossed. It came out right around the same time as you can see everything. It's grossed$160 ,000. I'm sorry,$160 ,000?

15:10That's it. Yep, that's it. That's everything. That's all the ticket sales they've had. Wow. I'm sure it didn't even pay for the catering on the movie. and they have their share of flops, but their flops are usually at least interesting. You know, they're not making like just really lame, lame cash-in attempts that fail. But there are two things that made it stand out. One is that even amongst their share of hits and flops, they built this brand. They built a brand that is meaningful. And if you're a, you know, private equity and venture capital backed company, which A24 is, having a brand that has real equity in it is so meaningful because that means the value of the company is not just the cash flow from its films.

15:48There's real brand equity there.

15:54Lots of people are loyal to the A24 brand. The studio has a robust merch shop on its website, with vinyl editions of movie soundtracks and things like mugs from the fictional businesses in the movie Backrooms. There's even a Robert Pattinson nesting doll. I think we've started to see this sort of virtuous cycle where the more known and respected their brand is, the better their films do, because people know what A24 means, and they want to see a movie because it's A24 movie. A24 is now moving beyond the silver screen. It has a growing TV business, but the show's euphoria and beef. It's branching into fashion with a partnership with Dior.

16:34It's got a music business. It bought an off-Broadway theater in New York, and it's expanding internationally. They already have a UK office, and they've had talks with potential partners in other countries. The idea is to find emerging A24-style filmmakers in other countries so they could eventually expand globally. And in the past, I would say indie studios that succeed like A24, usually the playbook is you then get bought by a major studio. But A24 and its investors seem like that's not what they're going for. They're going for global expansion. How hard do you think it will be for A24 to maintain this cool?

17:13It's going to be a challenge because the more they grow, the more opportunities there are for them to whiff. And inevitably, as you get bigger, you just become more corporate. It's very hard to avoid that. One example of that is a recent deal A24 made with Google to do research together on AI filmmaking tools. There was a lot of fan blowback. I would say it's kind of the worst PR event that A24 has had in its history. People online were calling them AI24 and, you know, saying that they were betraying the artists and betraying their artistic integrity. So they've had plenty of hits since then, so it didn't destroy the company, but it was a dent in their armor, for sure.

17:52The A24 partner who oversees technology said the new tools won't look anything like the, quote, type of AI that people feel uncomfortable with. These days, there's a lot of hand-wringing in Hollywood about dwindling ticket sales and stale franchises. But Ben says that A24 is kind of a beacon, especially when it comes to younger audiences. It's not just about the quality of the film. It's about, really, can you build a brand and a marketing machine that's really effective online, that speaks to young people where they are? And in order to do that, you have to have a brand that they care about and trust.

18:30And, you know, I would say surprise is kind of the currency of social media, right? And if you can do that in films, you actually can get people to come out. So it proves that film at least could have a much healthier future than a lot of people feared, but that it kind of takes a new playbook.

18:53Okay. All right. Good chat. Okay. It was good to chat with you, Ryan. I've been completely honest with you about everything I've said because I have no reason to deceive you.

19:11That's all for today. Wednesday, October 28th. The Journal is a co-production of Spotify and The Wall Street Journal. Additional reporting in this episode by John Jergensen.

19:25Thanks for listening. See you tomorrow.

19:32When it comes to my policy, Farmers gives it to me straight, so there's no surprises. It's your coverage. You should never be confused. You hear that? An insurance provider with a conscience. We're a choir, but yes, we have that too. Straightforward coverage you can literally understand. That's what you get when you have farmers. Bum, bum, bum, bum, bum, bum. Learn more at Farmers.com. Underwritten by Farmers Truck or Fire Insurance Exchanges or Affiliate. Products not available in every state.

From the publisher

The studio behind the documentary “You Can See Everything” is A24. It’s an independent company with a reputation for critically acclaimed movies that fills theaters. Young audiences trust that an A24 release will be as relevant for them as a Disney movie is for families. WSJ’s Ben Fritz explains why. Ryan Knutson hosts.

Further Listening:

- These Movies Finally Got Gen Z Into Theaters

- Why Hollywood Can't Find Good Scripts

Sign up for WSJ’s free What’s News newsletter.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from The Journal.

All episodes