Is Jane Goodall Fighting a Losing Battle?

0:05Ryan Knutson:This week, leaders from around the world poured into New York City for the United Nations General Assembly. Among them was Jane Goodall, one of the world's most well-known environmentalists. Goodall is best known for her work with chimpanzees. In 1960, at just 26, she moved to what is now the Gombe National Park in Tanzania. She became one of the first scientists ever to study chimps in the wild and was the first person to observe them using tools and discovered they have complex social relationships. Her observations fundamentally changed our understanding of primates forever. Goodall went on to found the Jane Goodall Institute, which continues to study chimps and runs conservation and educational programs throughout the world.

0:51Ryan Knutson:Today, at the age of 91, Goodall is not slowing down. She travels 300 days a year to give talks, meet with world leaders, and push for green causes. But the planet continues to warm. Forests continue to be cut down. The list of endangered species keeps getting longer. And earlier this week, President Trump called climate change a con job. Goodall has said we're living in dark times. And earlier this week, I had a chance to ask her, does she feel like she's fighting a losing battle? Welcome to The Journal, our show about money, business, and power. I'm Ryan Knudsen. It's Friday, September 26th.

1:35Ryan Knutson:Coming up on the show, a conversation with Jane Goodall.

1:54Ryan Knutson:Advertising operations fall out of sync. Everything else follows. Spotify and Accenture are working together to reinvent the rhythm of ad sales. Using automation, analytics, and smarter workflows to simplify campaign delivery and access better data across the business. The result? Less time spent on operations. More time connecting brands with the moments and fandoms that matter most. Learn more at Accenture.com slash Spotify. For adults with Crohn's disease or ulcerative colitis symptoms, every choice matters. Tremphaya offers self-injection or intravenous infusion from the start. Tremphaya is administered as injections under the skin or infusions through a vein every four weeks, followed by injections under the skin every four or eight weeks.

2:41Ryan Knutson:If your doctor decides that you can self-inject Tremphaya, proper training is required. Tremphaya is a prescription medicine used to treat adults with moderately to severely active Crohn's disease and adults with moderately to severely active ulcerative colitis. Serious allergic reactions, increased risk of infections or lower ability to fight them and liver problems may occur. Before treatment, get checked for infections and tuberculosis. Tell your doctor if you have an infection, flu-like symptoms or need a vaccine. Explore what's possible. Ask your doctor about Tremphaya today. Call 1-800-526-7736 to learn more or visit Tremfierradio.com.

3:26Thank you so much, everybody, for being here.

3:37Ryan Knutson:Thank you, Jane Goodall, for joining us today. I wanted to start out by having you tell us about your special guest that you brought with us. Well, Mr. H, given to me 35, all right, these people at the back, it's given to me 35 years ago by a man who lost his eyesight in the U.S. Marines when he was 21, decided to become a magician, was told it was impossible. Children don't know he's blind. Anyway, he thought he was giving me a stuffed chimpanzee, and I made him hold the tail. He said, never mind, take him where you go. And he's been 64 countries, and he's my example of the indomitable human spirit.

4:19Ryan Knutson:I also brought with me a stuffed monkey. He's not as well-traveled as yours, but this was my favorite stuffy as a boy. and I think he may have the same problem because he has a tail which chimpanzees do not that's right but would you like to know what I named him what did you name it monkey not very creative well so I wanted to talk about what is going on in our world right now what you've referred to as the dark times you've dedicated your life to conservation saving endangered species more recently combating climate change but my but by many measures things aren't looking so good right now by your own estimate the population of chimpanzees has fallen by more than half in the last century many experts believe we're in a sixth mass extinction event largely as a result of human activity the planet continues to warm do you feel like you're losing the fight well i think and i'm not alone, fortunately, that we have a window of time.

5:24It's not a very big window of time when if we get together, and I'm talking about, you know, ordinary people and corporations, business leaders, and you know, we know what we can do to slow down climate change and loss of biodiversity. We know the sort of things that are making things worse and worse, like industrial agriculture and you know fossil fossil fuel burning and people are seldom talking about it but the effect on the climate of these terrible wars is

5:58Ryan Knutson:enormous so if we know the solutions why aren't we solving the problems is because unfortunately there is an idea that continued economic development must come before the environment. And, you know, it's crazy because, first of all, we're on a planet with finite natural resources, growing human and livestock populations. And if we don't change the way that we do things, the way that we develop economically, then it will be too late. I mean, we will reach tipping points. One of the reasons that the world is moving in this direction is also because of politics and what governments choose to prioritize.

6:43Ryan Knutson:The Trump administration is doing many things right now that run counter to your mission, expanding oil and gas drilling, cutting funding for foreign aid, cutting funding for renewable energy. During his speech in front of the UN this week, President Trump called climate change a con job. And the European countries are, quote, on the brink of destruction because of the green energy agenda. How do you react when you hear the president of the United States talking this way? Well, I find it very strange that somebody can say climate change is a con job. When you think what's happening just in this one country alone, the frequency and intensity of hurricanes, flooding, droughts, heat waves, fires, and all of this, you know, why are we going through all of this?

7:31It's because the climate is changing, that the planet is warming, sea levels are rising. And we're on the brink of disaster. So I find it disturbing when presidents make statements like this.

7:49Ryan Knutson:You got involved in the 2024 election. You created the Vote for Nature initiative to try to encourage people to vote for green candidates and candidates to support the environment. Why do you think that message lost? I don't know and it was you know it was governments around the world really because there were many elections last year. It lost for the reasons I've said that people are putting their own personal economic development before thinking about future generations. And you know if you tackle people and say but you let me tell a story here. I was talking to a group of CEOs in Singapore, and one of them came up to me afterwards and he said, Jane, I want to promise you that for the last eight years I've been doing everything I can to make my business more sustainable and less heavy footprint on the environment for three reasons.

8:45One, I saw the writing on the wall that we're using up natural resources in some places faster than nature can replenish them, and sometimes nature can't. Two, consumer pressure. People are beginning to ask questions about what they buy. How was it made? Did it harm the environment? But he said, what really tipped the balance for me was my little girl of eight, and she came home from school one day. She said, Daddy, they're telling me that what you're doing is hurting the planet. That's not true, is it, Daddy? Because it's my planet.

9:21Ryan Knutson:It's human nature, though, to think about your own situation and whether or not you have food on the table can provide your family before you can start thinking about how to help others. For many people, as this is the case, how do you get people to care about the environment when many people in this world and in this country feel like their livelihoods are at stake? Well, absolutely. So our Jane Goodall Institute method of conservation is working to alleviate poverty because that is one, you know, on the one hand, you get overconsumption, you get unsustainable lifestyles, like probably everyone in this room, including me.

9:57And on the other hand, you get poverty where people either, if they're rural, destroy the environment to get some money from timber or destroying the landscape for growing some crop just to survive. And if they're in a city, they buy the cheapest junk food, which clearly has been made in the cheapest way possible and harmed the environment. So unless you alleviate poverty and reduce our unsustainable lifestyle and have a different way of thinking about things, we differ from other animals mostly by the development of this intellect. So we are without question the most intellectual creatures to ever walk the planet, even though we know animals are way, way, way more intelligent than was thought.

10:44But we may be intellectual, we may have brilliant brains, but we're not intelligent because intelligent creatures don't destroy their only home. And unless you believe there's going to be rockets that will take us off to some other planet like Mars, which I personally don't believe, then we need to protect this planet and think about the future. But as we have these intellects, if enough people who care come together and use the intellect, surely we can find a way. Because if we don't, that's the end of our species. Humans are not exempt from extinction.

11:27Ryan Knutson:I want to, because you mentioned someone who wants to put humans on rockets to potentially colonize Mars, I'm really curious to know what you think of Elon Musk.

11:40Well, okay, he's the only person who's ever attacked me on social media. Twice. And basically, he said the second time that I was guilty of wanting genocide. And why? Why? Because I always say one of the problems we face is, you know, a growing number of humans on a planet with finite natural resources. That's it. I don't say more than that.

12:09Ryan Knutson:And he thinks that humanity will collapse because of population decline. He's encouraging people to have more children. Yes, I know. But he is a complicated figure in many ways because he's done a lot to further the advancement of electric vehicles and green energy technology and battery technology. And yet he also put a great deal of his wealth behind President Donald Trump, who's now advancing many policies that run directly counter to your mission. And he stopped USAID. He froze it. We lost five and a half million dollars a year for the next four years for our program, which was improving the lives of people, giving children a chance of going to school, protecting the environment.

12:52That money just gone.

12:54Ryan Knutson:Which do you think has had a bigger impact, the work that he's done for electric vehicles and green energy technology or his political work? I think without any question, his political work has caused immense harm. There's no question. Tell me more about the impact that it's had on your organization. Because you did, as you mentioned, you had some funding cut. What was cut and what will the impact of that be? Well, the impact is we've had to lay off people who are really good people. We've had to search very hard for alternative sources of funding to fill in the gaps, move towards perhaps more stable corporate partnerships that will last through the years.

13:35And also, of course, we need to build up an endowment.

13:38Ryan Knutson:Are there any conflicts of interest that are coming in from the new sources of funding that you're noticing? Well, we have to say no to some, which is tough. What ones have you had to say no to? offering, well, somebody offered me a private shirt. I had to say no to that. You had to say no to that? Not everybody says no to that. No, but if you're ethical, you do, if you care about the environment. And also, you know, other things like an oil company that's terribly, terribly polluting and not doing anything about it, except a bit of greenwashing. And they want to give you money. Why? Because the Jane Goodall Institute has a good name and they want to be tied up with us, then we have to say no.

14:25Ryan Knutson:Coming up, Jane Goodall on what she calls Jane Magic.

14:40This episode is brought to you by Optum. Healthcare doesn't always work great. If you ever waited on a refill or couldn't schedule an appointment, you get it.

14:49Ryan Knutson:That's what Optum is changing. They're using data and technology to integrate patient care, pharmacy, and everything else. So healthcare is connected, not complicated. That means cheaper prescriptions that are easier to get and care that looks at the whole person, how you need it. Optum is making healthcare work as one for everyone. Learn more at business.optum.com. This episode is brought to you by United for Business. United connects you to more of the world than any U.S. airline. and United for Business can get your company where you need to go. Whether you're growing a business or managing travel for thousands, they offer solutions to fit your needs.

15:26Ryan Knutson:Track expenses, create reports, and manage traveler perks. Plus, employees earn mileage plus miles while your company saves on travel. Get started with no minimum spend or flight requirements. Visit business.united.com slash the journal.

15:46Ryan Knutson:There are a lot of young people in the United States and throughout the world that have swung toward the right. There was a big switch among young people toward Trump in the 2024 election. Have you noticed a change among young people and where their values are? No, I'm probably not meeting those young people.

16:07and if I do meet them they seem to kind of fall under a spell

16:14Ryan Knutson:say more about what you mean it's called jade magic oh I see so you think that you can change their minds I hope I can at least start to change their minds because I've seen it happen how do you change their minds what do you say stories stories, children and adults. If I'm talking to somebody who, for example, is a climate change denier, I don't try and argue. There's no point. But if you can tell a story to reach the heart, like that CEO and the little girl. How do you think the message needs to change? We talked about your vote for nature campaign, but what needs to change about the message that progressives and people who care about the environment are telling in order to have more success in elections?

17:10Well, I don't know about more success in elections, but I think in general, people need to understand and so many people don't, that what they do makes a difference. Each one of us, everyone in this room, everyone who listens to this it's a podcast or whatever we're doing multiple things at once yeah yes so everybody every day that we live we make an impact on the planet and we can choose what sort of impact we make and people come to me depressed and saying well the world's a mess and you know there's nothing I can do about it I'm just one person But I say to them, think of your own community.

17:53What can you do there? What do you care about? Start doing something to make it better. Get other people to help you. You will see you make a difference. That makes you feel good. Then you want to do more. Then you inspire more people. So then you dare think globally.

18:11Ryan Knutson:How do you balance? There's obviously a tension, as we've been talking about, in conservation projects between the environment and people's economic situation? You mentioned poverty being an important thing to fight, but how do you think about that tension when you want to do something that you think will protect a forest or animals but also has a tradeoff and that it might mean that there are then fewer jobs for people that live in that area? Well, first of all, the example we have is our method of community-led conservation around Gombe National Park, where, by the way, the chimp research, we just celebrated our 65th anniversary of research in that area.

18:54Yes, thank you.

18:58And the reason I left Gombe and the forest and chimps that I love was at a big conference that I actually helped put together. And by that time, when we brought the people studying chimps, there were six other chimp study sites. and it was basically to find out about chimp behavior changing, but we had a session on conservation and it was a shock. Forests being cut down, chimpanzee numbers dropping. So I left the conference having gone as a scientist, as an advocate, I don't know what you want to call me, but I knew I had to do something. I had no idea what to do, so I got some money from Geographic to visit the different study sites and while I was learning the problems faced by chimps like habitat destruction, the increasing bush meat trade and so on, I was also learning about the problems facing so many African people living in and around the forest habitats of the chimps.

19:59And that's when it hit me. These people are struggling to survive. They're living in crippling poverty. and unless we can help them find ways of making a living without cutting down trees for making money from charcoal or timber or clearing space for growing food to eat or to sell then we can't save chimpanzees forest or anything else so that's when we began our community-led conservation program it began with 12 villages around the park now it's in 41 throughout chimp range in Tanzania and people are understanding that saving the environment isn't just for wildlife. It's for their own future.

20:44Ryan Knutson:You have spent a lot of time with humanity's closest relative, the chimpanzee, with whom we share a common ancestor. What do you think are the best qualities that we share with chimps and what are the worst? Well, the best altruism, of course we can be more better altruists than chimps. Chimps respond to an immediate situation of a child falls in the water and the chimp jumps in after it. But we can take altruism to a whole new level, knowing that by helping we may damage ourselves. We're seeing some of that today in the political arena, people daring to stand up, therefore or losing their jobs and their livelihood.

21:28The worst? Brutality. War. Chimpanzees are capable of killing, and between neighboring communities, there's a kind of primitive warfare, and one community may annihilate another.

21:44Ryan Knutson:There are people who think that we are creating the next phase of evolution right now with artificial intelligence, that the computers and chatbots will be the next intelligent species to dominate the earth. If that is true, what do you think would be the best qualities of humanity that you hope AI inherits from us? Well, first of all, I'm glad I'm 91. I won't live to see that day. Who knows? I mean, there's new technology out there now. So, well, I would hope that these intelligent, whatever they are, robots, I don't know what they'll be, that it's pushed into them altruism, compassion, love, respect, wanting to help, wanting to make this a better world, understanding that animals are thinking, feeling beings.