The Big Business of Holding Back Eighth-Graders

0:05— All right, next group! Are you set? Your bars are clear! Good! Remove busting! Legs up! Ready? Go! — Let's go! Push this up! Let's go!

0:16Ryan Knutson:— This is the sound of finals at a middle school in Southern California. — Let's go, Chance! — Ah! Go, Timberley! — And at this school, their finals aren't just on paper. They're also in the gym. They're being tested for their speed, their strength. Here, they're doing pull-ups.

0:41Ryan Knutson:This middle school is called the Together Ship. And as you may have guessed, it isn't a typical school. It's a private school, where a major part of the curriculum is athletics. There are classes like weightlifting and speed training. And they also have classes for specific sports, like the football players who work on running routes and throwing mechanics. Ready to go? Yeah, running routes, routes on air. And the soccer players trying to score goals on each other. Get finished! You have to go, Cork! The basketball students practicing their layups.

1:24Ryan Knutson:The school was founded by a man named Devin Quinn Each day they have four classes two academic, two athletic but they alternate, they'll have so like all these kids that are in academic class right now they will be in an athletic class their next period and then after that back to an academic class and the last period for them would be athletic The together ship is part of a new phenomenon a growing multi-million dollar cottage industry of private schools across the country that emphasize athletics. Another thing that makes these schools unusual is that they offer to hold students back a year in middle school, specifically so they can get better at sports.

2:03And so if we can get this one more year to prepare them and get them set up so that they enter high school fully prepared, it's a really big advantage.

2:14Ryan Knutson:Welcome to The Journal, our show about money, business, and power. I'm Ryan Knudsen. It's Thursday, June 18th.

2:27Ryan Knutson:Coming up on the show, the big business of holding back eighth graders.

2:40This episode of The Journal is brought to you by Harvey, an AI platform designed for legal and professional services. Built and tested by lawyers, Harvey is trusted by more than 60 % of the AMLA 100. The platform dramatically reduces time spent on research, drafting, and document review without sacrificing quality, all while meeting the highest industry standards for security and compliance. Harvey. AI tailored for law. Visit Harvey.ai to learn more and request a demo. This episode is brought to you by Optum. Healthcare doesn't always work great. If you ever waited on a refill or couldn't schedule an appointment, you get it.

3:22That's what Optum is changing. They're using data and technology to integrate patient care, pharmacy, and everything else. So healthcare is connected. Not complicated. That means cheaper prescriptions that are easier to get and care that looks at the whole person how you need it. Optum is making healthcare work as one for everyone. Learn more at business.optum.com.

3:49Ryan Knutson:Holding kids back isn't a new thing. But historically, it's only been done for academic or behavioral reasons. And it often comes with negative connotations. Here's our colleague Harriet Ryan, an investigative reporter. I mean, getting held back when I was a child meant like you did not learn to read that year. You couldn't sit still. And they thought they're going to give you another crack at third grade. But that's not what this holdback is. Yeah. I mean, certainly I remember back in school, like that would be a way to tease someone. Yeah, that one kid who's like a foot taller than everybody else in the class.

4:21Yeah.

4:21Ryan Knutson:And if you did it specifically for sports, that was pretty fringe. Those parents were seen as somewhat insane. Even by people who had their kids playing, you know, elite sports, they thought, like, well, somebody who would do that's kind of crazy. And I will point to no greater source than the movie Varsity Blues, which was about overbearing football parents in Texas. Yep, gonna hold our toy back a year. Still be bigger for frost triads. Eighth grade ain't so bad, is it, son? This started to change a few years ago when college athletes suddenly were able to get paid. After a historic ruling by the NCAA, collegiate athletes across the country have a newfound freedom, freedom to make money.

5:04Well, what allows college athletes to get paid for their name, image, and likeness in what can be lucrative NIL deals? NIL, that's name, image, and likeness, so the Supreme Court decision that made it possible to compensate amateur athletes, that just rolled everything back about when you have to start thinking about becoming really good at sports if you want to get paid. So before it was like, you know, the money's in the pros, you need to start planning when you're in college. Now the money's in college, you need to start planning when you're in high school or even middle school.

5:34Ryan Knutson:And like not that many people can make it to the pros and everybody kind of has a good sense of that. You know, there's like, I don't know, like around 450 roster spots in the NBA, so you probably don't have a chance, but college and NIL money, like maybe we could get that. Right.

5:52Ryan Knutson:Devin from The Together Ship says NIL deals are definitely something he and the families are thinking about. The NIL has really became a factor. And now all of a sudden it speeds it up where kids are getting able to make money off this starting, you know, senior year, freshman year of college. And so I would say that that has now become a pretty big factor in it. but originally it was not part of the reasoning at all, but it definitely is a bigger factor now. And to increase their odds of getting an NAL deal, which can be worth millions of dollars for the best athletes, parents and students are looking for any advantage they can get.

6:35Ryan Knutson:And an extra year of school definitely helps. For boys, the dream that's kind of sold to parents is that in this year, your kid is going to just sprout up, grow three inches, six inches, eight inches. And they're going to become more coordinated. They're going to bulk up. Which means they might get faster, stronger, and overall better at their sport. And for the next year, they'll also build confidence and maturity. And so they'll go into high school and be a force. Instead of playing freshman football or JV, they will start on varsity. And they will have four great years to showcase their abilities to colleges.

7:21That is the idea behind it.

7:24Ryan Knutson:But what is the rule on this? I mean, can students just be held back for whatever reason the parents want? Most public schools will not let you hold back for an athletic reason alone. If a child is, you know, struggling academically or socioemotionally, they might allow a student to repeat a year. But if the parents are just like, this is for sports, no, they don't let you do that. And that's why there's been this proliferation of private holdback academies, because they are serving a need that the vast majority of public schools will not do. So the schools are saying, no, you can't do this. But like, hey, there's a private school down the street that says, if you pay us, we'll hold them back for a year.

8:04Ryan Knutson:Yes. One of those private schools down the street is the together-ship. The growth that I saw in that one year, I knew was special, or like, there was really something there. Devin started off working with students who did a holdback year through homeschooling. And the parents of those kids encouraged him to start his own school. And so I always joke, like, I don't know if I love or hate those moms who said, hey, you have something here, like, this is a school for athletes that you basically are running. and so they were the ones that kind of pushed me to really pursue it and make it into a real structured school.

8:43Ryan Knutson:He opened the Together Ship in 2020. So here's our science room. Hi. What grade is this? This is seventh grade. Seventh grade? Yeah. Hi there. I'm Christine. Pierce at the Wall Street Journal. Oh, hi. Our producer Pierce Singe visited the school recently. Its co-ed costs about$20 ,000 a year and has grades 6 through 8, plus one more, the Hold Back program. Yeah, so we call it HSP, high school prep. The Together Ship is in San Clemente, California, an affluent area of Orange County. Its campus sits on a hill overlooking the ocean. She's got an ocean view in there. She's got an ocean view. If you stand over here...

9:30Ryan Knutson:Each student has a sports focus. Right now, the school offers football, basketball, baseball, soccer, volleyball, and lacrosse. But they have regular classes, too. Playing Family Feud with mythology. All right, next up. Pierce visited one class while it was doing a trivia game. All right, gentlemen, who is Kronos' wife? Rhea. Yes, sir. Excellent, excellent. Some students were also testing how fast their sprints were. Let's go, Lana. Let's go, Lana. Let's go, Lana. Let's go, Lana. 1-5-5. There you go. And the school's food options, if you pay extra for it, is also tailored to athletes with high-protein meals.

10:15Ryan Knutson:Eggs and bacon. Some protein shakes and then also some oatmeal or overnight oats. 2 ,800 calories of mostly protein. Yeah, yeah, really protein-dominated. And really just trying to make sure that they're getting enough fuel in their body for, you know, they're doing two workouts here. And then after school, a lot of times they'll have practice as well. So it's a lot of energy expended throughout.

10:45Ryan Knutson:The protein will help with the gains in the weight room. But does holding back a year help with the gains in life? That's after this recess. Thank you.

11:26culture, and technology. Today, it's the foundation for AI systems that learn from real-world data to generate insights. Visit progressforai.com to learn more. One of the biggest drivers of American innovation is something you've probably never heard of, fair use. This legal principle lets people use copyrighted works to learn, research, or create something new. And for nearly 200 years, it's let innovators build on existing ideas, powering breakthroughs in medicine, agriculture, and technology. Today, it's the foundation for AI systems that learn from real-world data to generate insights. Visit progressforai.com to learn more.

12:13Ryan Knutson:AJ DeBonsa is projected to be one of the top picks in this year's NBA draft. And he did a holdback year. So once I got an extra year of work, It was like, yeah, I'm ready. Like, I can go hoop with anybody. Here he is talking on a podcast about it. Because that made hoops circuit. Like, when I play eighth grade, I won it because I had confidence. And I was like, yeah, I can play high school. Just don't call it getting held back to his face. AJ, just a quick follow-up question with that. So you said that you got held, you did eighth grade twice. I know that's a fun fact. I actually was held back in eighth grade.

12:45See, did you get held back because of your grades? No. Reclassify. Are we changing the term? I did not get held back. I reclassed. Let's fix that. Okay. Because held back is like, you know, your grades are wrong. You didn't pass. I passed.

12:59Ryan Knutson:Many students want to reclassify so that they can be like A.J. DeBonsa. But many of the families Harriet spoke to were also interested in this type of education, especially after those years of online school during the pandemic. People in this area of Orange County are very concerned about academics as well as athletics. They want their kids to get into good colleges. academically as well as athletically. I think when I've talked to people about this story, everyone wants me to say like, oh, I met a lot of crazy people that have crazy ideas about their kids. And no, I met like normal people who were like, I looked at, did my research, talked to coaches, looked around my travel team, looked around my club team, and this is the right option for my kid.

13:40Ryan Knutson:One of those families is the cancellaries. 15 years old, Carter Cancellary, San Clemente. I'm going into freshman year, just finished up eighth grade. Carter Canceleri did a holdback year at the Together Ship, where he focused on baseball. His dream is to play baseball in college, and then professionally, hopefully for the San Diego Padres. He spoke to our producer, Pierce. One of the reasons that people talk about doing these holdback years is also gives a chance for your body to mature physically also. Is that something that you've seen? 100%. I've always been undersized, and going in that holdback year, I was much smaller, shorter, weighed, not a lot.

14:24And then this whole year I've gained weight. I've gone bigger, faster, stronger, taller. So everything in that extra year has matured and gone up.

14:33Ryan Knutson:Well, what's your favorite thing like on the field? Like what do you like doing the most? Probably hitting. Hitting is, I enjoy that the most, for sure. Here's Carter's dad, Michael. The holdback part of this was being driven by Carter. He is a very dedicated, focused kid. He wanted to be able to perform the best that he could. He was pretty focused on the type of high school or the league that he wanted to go to in the area. And he has always known, like, there were certain steps to kind of get there. And if this gave him a better opportunity to kind of reach some of those goals, then he was all for it.

15:11Ryan Knutson:Next year, Carter will be attending a private school in the Trinity League. an athletic conference in Southern California that's known for elite athletics. It's competitive a league you will get in the country in any sport. The football programs are, you know, amazing. The women's boys, every kind of athletic activity at those schools is just hyper, hyper competitive. In parts of the country where sports are especially competitive, like Southern California where Carter lives, Michael says it's starting to feel like a disadvantage not to hold your kid back. especially at the top schools, this has become much, much more prevalent.

15:50So yeah, I think that it can be a disadvantage if you're not kind of taking advantage of this. It may make it more challenging.

16:02Ryan Knutson:Where do you think this trend is heading? I mean, do you think that this is going to create a situation where just more and more and more schools and kids across the country are being held back a year, it's going to become more common? You know, I think what will happen eventually, and if this hasn't already happened, it's that everybody who is like a D1 boy competitive athlete is going to have been reclassed or held back. I think some experts believe like, okay, that's where we're going. And once we're there, it's not an advantage anymore, but you know, but not doing, it sure is a disadvantage.

16:38I think there is a belief among some parents, they know their kid is not going to get a college scholarship or NIL money. they want them to have the opportunity to play in high school. And where they live, they look around and everybody's doing this. And so their kid who doesn't do it is going to, like, be deprived, in their view, of the opportunity just to play on their high school team. How does affluence play a factor in this?

17:03Ryan Knutson:I mean, is this an opportunity that really is only available to wealthier families? I talked to a woman who runs a homeschool program. So she's basically like sort of a concierge for parents who want to homeschool their kids. And she helps them like figure out what their state requirements are and how to fill out the paperwork. She charges her basic packages$650 a year. And she said she's getting a ton of athletic families. And she said they are middle class or a little bit lower than that. And they cannot afford a private school for their kids. They can afford to do this. And they are doing it.

17:39Ryan Knutson:I mean, I got to be honest. Like, it sounds kind of appealing to me. Thinking back to my own high school experience, which I loved, you know, but like the idea that I could spend more time studying basketball, which is my main sport, you know, and like learning how to get better. Doesn't sound so bad. A little bit less time sitting and looking at a book. I mean, all the parents I talked to said there are literally no drawbacks. they fight with the kids less about homework because the kid's a year older in high school. They are more coordinated. They are more able to be self-starters. Some people told me, like, even if my kid wasn't an athlete, I would hold them back because boys are so difficult to deal with in high school.

18:24And if they were all just a year older, things would be better. So there's definitely a contingent that thinks there's no drawback at all.

18:32Ryan Knutson:There are people who think the holdback year could have potential drawbacks. For instance, Harriet talked to one coach who said that sometimes it's good for players to be smaller than everyone else because it teaches them how to deal with adversity. He was a basketball player. He played professionally in Europe. And he said a really defining moment in my life was being a gangly freshman who was not good and got run over by everybody. And that gave me ambition and a work ethic and grit. and I use that to become better and better and better. And he said, you know, I think for all players now, I just wonder whether they are going to be able to meet adversity, not having just dealt with it through the natural course of life.

19:14Ryan Knutson:Across the country, some states still think it's unfair. In Pennsylvania, if a student holds back a year for sports, the state will take a year of high school sports eligibility from them. But others are giving in. Other states have sort of just been like, this is a battle we don't want to fight anymore. So Louisiana used to have these pretty tough rules. They would penalize coaches, they would penalize schools who were involved in any way, and they just got rid of those rules in 2023. And in Orange County, where the together ship is, the largest school district there, Capistrano Unified, will start offering its own holdback program this upcoming fall.

19:51Paid for by taxpayers. Like, people in that district will be paying for kids to repeat eighth grade.