1. Podcasts
  2. The Journal.
  3. The Most Expensive Midterms Ever
The Journal.

27 Oct 2026 · 20m · 9 chapters

Episode artwork

The Most Expensive Midterms Ever

In short

The episode examines how the 2026 midterms are becoming the most expensive ever, focusing on record ad spending, the rise of super PACs and “dark money,” and weaker enforcement by the Federal Election Commission (FEC) amid new online and AI-driven influence tactics.

Guests and backgrounds

Maggie Severance, a Wall Street Journal colleague who follows campaign finance and ultra-wealthy donors; Ryan Knudsen (host).

Key claims

TV ad spending is projected to exceed $1 billion in the final two weeks; total election-cycle ad spending tops $11 billion. Spending is rising while federal oversight declines because the FEC lacks a quorum (since April 2025). Dark money: nearly $400 million went to super PACs this cycle. Influencers and AI create disclosure gaps.

Notable examples

Elon Musk reportedly spent about $440 million, targeting Texas Senate via support for James Tallarico against Ken Paxton. Crypto group Fairshake spent about $50 million to oppose Democrat Sherrod Brown in Ohio. George Soros, Michael Bloomberg ($80M), and Gaza/anti-AIPAC-linked new progressive donors are cited.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

2:55

Sponsor Introduction

Introduction of the sponsors Accenture and Indeed with their services.

4:44

Big Money in the Midterms

Discussion on the overwhelming financial contributions to the midterms from various donors.

“This is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs.”
10:09

The Role of Super PACs and Regulation

Exploring the influence of super PACs on elections and the regulatory challenges faced.

“Because super PACs are supposed to be independent of a candidate, right?”
12:28

Emerging Issues in Campaign Finance

Discussion on the evolving landscape of campaign finance including influencers and AI.

“All right, Maggie, introduce us to the cop on the beat here when it comes to campaign spending.”
14:01

The Regulatory Gray Area of Campaign Financing

Explore the ambiguous regulations around campaign financing and AI's role in elections.

“There's no rule that you have to put a disclosure on it and say, you know, this was paid for by Ryan for president.”
15:11

Congress and the Failure to Act

Discussing Congress's inaction on campaign finance reforms and voter appetite for change.

“I think the other side of this is that we haven't talked about as much as Congress, right?”
16:01

The Impact of Citizens United

Analyzing how the Citizens United decision has changed the landscape of campaign finance.

“Citizens United, which happened 16 years ago, it now has its driver's license roaming around town, was kind of like the beginning of like lifting regulations on campaign finance.”
16:57

The Effectiveness of Campaign Spending

Understanding the relationship between campaign spending and electoral outcomes.

“The Trump administration and the FEC didn't return requests for comment.”
17:38

Frustrations of Big Donors

Exploring the frustrations and challenges faced by major political donors.

“They have more friends and allies now than they did when they first started doing this.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The Journal., what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:05Ryan Knutson: There's just one week to go until the midterm elections. Odds are, you've been seeing campaign ads everywhere. Online, on TV, getting texts to your phone. And that's because spending is off the charts.

0:23Maggie Severns: People are projecting it might be the most expensive political cycle ever.

0:29Ryan Knutson: Our colleague Maggie Severance follows the money that funds election campaigns.

0:32Maggie Severns: It'll definitely be the most expensive midterms ever. And that tends to be a trend, right? Like every cycle seems to get more and more expensive. In the last two weeks of this election, it's estimated that people are going to see over a billion dollars in TV commercials. Just in the last two weeks? Just in the last two weeks. Wow. That's been booked, arranged. So it's a lot of money. It's a lot of money that's going around.

0:58Ryan Knutson: According to one estimate, ad spending in this election cycle alone totals more than$11 billion.

1:07Ryan Knutson: How does that amount of money strike you as somebody who covers election and campaign finance?

1:14Maggie Severns: You know, it's funny because I started really tracking this stuff probably around 10 years ago. You know, not too long before Trump ran for president. And every time the amount of money seems like a lot, like you hear about someone giving$10 million and you might think to yourself, oh my gosh,$10 million. I've never seen money like that in my life. That is so much money. And then all of a sudden we're talking about a$50 million donation and then$100 million donation.

1:43Ryan Knutson: In her reporting about ultra-wealthy donors, Maggie's heard about a new logic for the never-ending upward spiral of money. The thinking goes, given how important government regulations are, maybe we're not spending enough.

1:56Maggie Severns: Why are we cutting a$50 ,000 check when we could pour$50 million and get a whole new slate or try and get a whole new slate of regulations? This hasn't necessarily worked in kind of the one-to-one, you cut a check, you get results way that I think that some people were hoping. But you have industries like cryptocurrency, increasingly AI, who are dumping huge amounts of money into elections. And then you have on kind of a completely different interest side, you have AIPAC that spent a lot of money to try and defend candidates who are pro-Israel. And while all this spending has gone up, the level of federal oversight has gone down.

2:38Maggie Severns: For some people, there's a sense this cycle that things are just reaching this point where they're going kind of off the rails or things are getting, the numbers are getting so big that it feels crazy to people.

2:54Ryan Knutson: Welcome to The Journal, our show about money, business and power. I'm Ryan Knudsen. It's Tuesday, October 27th.

3:07Ryan Knutson: coming up on the show the midterms money madness

3:22Maggie Severns: this episode of the journal is presented to you by Accenture behind this podcast and the music you listen to Spotify has a sophisticated advertising business Accenture is deeply embedded in that business, working with Spotify to reinvent the rhythm of ad sales, building, maintaining, and optimizing. Accenture finds the friction and builds the systems that make things run smoother and faster. The result? Less time spent on operations, more time connecting brands with the moments and fandoms that matter most. Learn more at Accenture.com slash Spotify. This episode is brought to you by Indeed. Running a business means dealing with the dreaded hiring process.

3:58Maggie Severns: And the stakes are high when the right hire could make or break your business strategy. But good news. Indeed Sponsored Jobs is here to make things less painful and nerve wracking. It gives your job post a boost to reach quality talent faster. Plus, it can help put your job in front of exactly who you're looking for based on criteria you set. Like if you need certain skills or certifications. And it works. Sponsored jobs posted directly on Indeed are 95 % more likely to report a higher than non-sponsored jobs. So spend less time searching and more time actually interviewing candidates who check all your boxes.

4:33Maggie Severns: Listeners of this show will get a$75 sponsored job credit at indeed.com slash podcast. That's indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Need a hiring hero? This is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs.

4:56Ryan Knutson: No one has thrown more money at this election than Elon Musk.

5:00Maggie Severns: And Elon in particular has been funneling money to be spent on the Texas Senate race, which is a big one. Hypocrite James Tallarico will do anything to push his radical agenda, even if it leaves families broke and jobless.

5:16Ryan Knutson: I'm Ken Paxton and I approve this message.

5:19Maggie Severns: You have James Tallarico, the Democrat, up against Ken Paxton, who's a Republican who has great history with Trump.

5:27Ryan Knutson: Paxton won a bruising primary, and he's faced some serious controversies, which have been hurting him in the polls.

5:33Maggie Severns: And, you know, Elon has a home in Texas, lives there quite a bit of the time, so I think it is a particularly big deal for him to keep Texas in red hands. So we've seen him just dumping huge amounts of money.

5:46Ryan Knutson: Musk has reportedly spent upwards of$440 million on Republican races this midterm cycle. Then there's a Democratic side.

5:55Maggie Severns: I'm Troy Jackson. I approve this message, and I'd be honored to have your vote. I'm Dr.

6:00Ryan Knutson: Abdul-Alsaid. I approve this message because honesty matters.

6:03Maggie Severns: My name is Angie Nixon, and I'm running for U.S. Senate because change can't wait.

6:10Ryan Knutson: For Democrats, many of their biggest donors have been players for decades.

6:15Maggie Severns: You always have someone like George Soros, who has a lot of kind of theories on political giving. He's been giving a lot. Michael Bloomberg recently poured$80 million to help Democrats. So there are some really late in the game, huge checks. Bloomberg is someone who we didn't really see around for most of the election. And Democrats have been kind of hurting for money from people like him. And he kind of came in. And in the most recent disclosures, there he was.

6:43Ryan Knutson: Democrats have also been getting a surge of money from a big crop of new donors, mainly backing progressives.

6:49Maggie Severns: And it's kind of the first time that we've seen people who are super motivated by the war in Gaza as an issue. So these are people who saw AIPAC, saw what AIPAC was doing.

7:01Ryan Knutson: AIPAC is the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, which lobbies for Israel.

7:04Maggie Severns: And decided they wanted to give money to, in some cases, a group that's really billing itself as an anti-AIPAC. and will spend around$10 million. So not very much money compared to what we're seeing others, but it's interesting to see new people and new excitement on the left.

7:24Ryan Knutson: It seems like a lot of this money that we are talking about is going to individual campaigns or candidates rather than, say, like the Republican or Democratic Party, their national committees. Is that new?

7:37Maggie Severns: I think that particularly among Democrats, there's been a real interest in funding individual candidates. So one thing that we have written about is how people have been hesitant to help the DNC this cycle, but they've been really excited about someone like Tellurico, the Texas Senate candidate. They're really excited about John Ossoff. They're really thinking about 2028. So all the 2028 candidates are also out there handshaking, and some of them are running for office. And so it's an interesting moment where people, I think, are a little disillusioned by Washington, disillusioned by institutions, but they see a lot of kind of bright stars out there.

8:17Ryan Knutson: How are you seeing industries line up during this election cycle? Are there clear lines about which parties certain industries are donating to?

8:24Maggie Severns: There are some very clear examples of industries deciding to spend against candidates. So a really good example is crypto with Sherrod Brown.

8:36Ryan Knutson: Brown is a Democrat running for the U.S. Senate in Ohio.

8:40Maggie Severns: There is a pro-cryptocurrency super PAC called Fairshake, and it has a couple affiliates. And Fairshake decided to pour around$50 million into the Ohio Senate race to spend against Democrat Sherrod Brown, the candidate there, because they think that Brown's opponent, John Husted, will be better on their issues. He voted to raise the gas tax by 30 percent and give Social Security benefits to illegals. Ask yourself whose side Senator Sherrod Brown is really on.

9:09Ryan Knutson: John Husted has voted for crypto-friendly legislation in the past. I know that the 2010 Supreme Court decision Citizens United helped pave the way for the existence of super PACs, but can you just help me understand how it's possible for people to give seemingly unlimited amounts of money now? I get a little tangled up over what the actual rules are.

9:31Maggie Severns: If you are going to go give to a candidate, you're limited in the low thousands of dollars. And most of the time when we talk about people wanting to help candidates, what we're talking about is people giving to super PACs and other kind of outside efforts where a political consultant will say, hey, I'm raising money. I am going to raise money for Ryan's campaign. And how about you come and give me a million dollars and it will be spent on Ryan's campaign? He's running for Congress in New York. You know, this is a fictional campaign I'm making up.

10:02Ryan Knutson: Ryan for president, actually, 2028. Go big or go home.

10:06Maggie Severns: Yeah, Ryan for president. And, you know, when I started covering this about 10 years ago, there were a lot of taboos in place. Because super PACs are supposed to be independent of a candidate, right? They're not allowed to speak and coordinate with the candidate. and there were all these taboos in place where you had to seem, if you were a super PAC, very independent of a candidate or a campaign. And that's one of those things that normatively we've just seen slide. Now, Ryan, if you were running for president, you can't solicit checks for your super PAC. You can't say like, here, give me$10 million and I'll give it to the super PAC.

10:45Maggie Severns: That's not allowed. But we could throw a nice fundraiser and you could come to the fundraiser and you could talk to everyone. And then, you know, me, your fundraiser, could walk around 10 minutes later and say like, okay, so the, you know, donation for this event was$500 ,000.

11:02Ryan Knutson: Have you paid up yet? During the most expensive midterms ever, the public knows less about where all this money is coming from. One, because so many donations these days are shrouded by layers and layers of different business entities.

11:15Maggie Severns: So one example of a problem that's been changing kind of and growing slowly over time is dark money being given to super PACs, right? So like we'll see a disclosure showing how much money a super PAC has raised, but a bunch of the spenders aren't people. They're these random LLCs or other things that you've never heard of.

11:34Ryan Knutson: One recent analysis found that nearly$400 million of dark money went to super PACs for both Democrats and Republicans this cycle.

11:42Maggie Severns: So there's tons of other kind of dark money floating around there, but that's$400 million that just came from places where we don't know. You know, it's just an anonymous giver.

11:53Ryan Knutson: There is a government watchdog with the authority to investigate where all this dark money is coming from. But Maggie says that regulator can't really do its job right now.

12:04Maggie Severns: We're at a moment when voters are really hungry for ethics reform and a more honest Washington. And I think that there's real irony in the fact that not only has the cop on this beat been basically out of commission for the last 18 months, there's also very little appetite to change things on Capitol Hill right now.

12:27Ryan Knutson: That's next.

12:39Ryan Knutson: All right, Maggie, introduce us to the cop on the beat here when it comes to campaign spending.

12:44Maggie Severns: So the cop on the beat when it comes to campaign finance is this like Nixon era regulator, the Federal Election Commission.

12:53Ryan Knutson: The Federal Election Commission is designed to be a panel with three Republicans and three Democrats.

12:58Maggie Severns: And they hear cases, they hear challenges, they vote, and they make decisions. That is how it is supposed to work.

13:07Ryan Knutson: But thanks to a very basic problem, the FEC hasn't been working that way for a while.

13:12Maggie Severns: In order to actually vote and make decisions, the FEC, which is supposed to be a six-member panel, needs to have at least four people. And since about a year and a half ago, they've had two. There are still lawyers that work at the FEC. There are still some things that get done, but basically it's becoming kind of a clearinghouse for self-reported information about spending. It hasn't been a strong regulator in a long time, but now it's a regulator that literally can't do its job.

13:42Ryan Knutson: The stalemate is happening at a time when the way people try to influence elections is changing by moving online.

13:48Maggie Severns: I've covered influencers a lot. Influencers are getting paid millions of dollars from campaigns. We don't know exactly who's getting paid or how. We know we see money going to management firms. But there aren't rules if you want to post about a candidate and get paid for that. There's no rule that you have to put a disclosure on it and say, you know, this was paid for by Ryan for president.

14:13Ryan Knutson: Plus, there's a ton of new questions about the use of AI.

14:17Maggie Severns: There are a bunch of people who have asked the FEC, like, can AI make robocalls? Can AI send texts? Like, that's the kind of thing that they should be thinking through, right? And instead, there's no quorum.

14:33Maggie Severns: It feels like you can, if you have a novel idea, why not try it? Because unless you are literally breaking federal law, unless someone will take you to court. But if you're in kind of a gray area, like, hey, I want to pay a fancy person$500 ,000 to make a bunch of online posts about my campaign, like, push the limit, see where it goes, and maybe at some point we'll have regulators that are interested.

15:01Ryan Knutson: The FEC hasn't had a quorum since April of 2025. The Trump administration has nominated two potential commissioners, but the Senate hasn't taken them up.

15:11Maggie Severns: I think the other side of this is that we haven't talked about as much as Congress, right? Like, you have lawmakers who are constantly running on this idea that they're going to clean up Washington. And whoever's in charge, these priorities tend to fall away or they get kind of poisoned by things that keep the bills from passing. So I think we can blame the FEC for large amounts of this problem. But, like, ultimately, this is something that Congress should be doing, right? There is huge, huge appetite among voters to clamp down and clean up in Washington. And yet both parties have been in charge.

15:48Maggie Severns: Well, I think that appetite's there and we haven't seen anything happen.

15:52Ryan Knutson: This, coupled with the Citizens United decision, which found the campaign spending should be treated more like speech, has really let the guardrails off campaign finance. it sort of feels like in some ways Citizens United, which happened 16 years ago, it now has its driver's license roaming around town, was kind of like the beginning of like lifting regulations on campaign finance. And now what we're seeing at the FEC is sort of just like a continuation of like less. Less. You know, less rules, less enforcement, like just wild west.

16:29Maggie Severns: Yeah, and I think that people, you know, I talk about this sometimes with former lawyers, people who have worked at the FEC, and it's hard when something has been such a slow change to pinpoint. Like, when did things really fall apart? You know, some people say, like, this is the cycle when things are really falling apart. Like, they're not even pretending anymore. They used to at least do a few things. But, you know, it's been an agency that people have been very disillusioned with for a long time.

16:57Ryan Knutson: The Trump administration and the FEC didn't return requests for comment.

17:06Ryan Knutson: Do you have a sense of how, I mean, ultimately, you know, these, all this spending, the goal is to affect the outcome of elections. But does it always work that way? I mean, it's not always the case that the more money you spend, you know, it's not a guarantee for victory.

17:22Maggie Severns: No, it's not. Money is not everything in these elections, right? Right. So like cryptocurrency is actually a pretty good example. They've spent hundreds of millions of dollars on elections and they're still having problems getting the legislation they want passed through Congress. Right. They have more friends and allies now than they did when they first started doing this. They've managed to drive some critics off Capitol Hill. Like I'm not saying that they have been ineffective, but it's not like everyone saw the cryptocurrency industry coming in and immediately lined up and did exactly what they wanted.

17:55Maggie Severns: Right. Like there are a lot of different things at play in politics and a lot of different things can happen. It must be frustrating, frankly, if you're if you're someone who's out like 100 million dollars and and nothing happens. Yeah.

18:13Ryan Knutson: I mean, they should put it toward Ryan for president 2028. Then we'll see results.

18:18Maggie Severns: Now open.

18:20Ryan Knutson: Um, just kidding. We won't need money because it's going to be entirely grassroots organic movement.

18:27Maggie Severns: There you go.

18:37Ryan Knutson: That's all for today, Tuesday, October 27th. The Journal is a co-production of Spotify and The Wall Street Journal. I'm Ryan Knudsen, and I approve this message. See you tomorrow.

From the publisher

The 2026 midterm cycle is the most expensive election in American history. At a time when huge sums of campaign money are flowing into races across the country, federal oversight has weakened. WSJ’s Maggie Severns explains where the influx of election cash is coming from and why the regulator charged with monitoring campaign funding is struggling to do its job. Ryan Knutson hosts.

Further Listening:

- Red, White and Who? The Swing Voters in South Texas

- Red, White and Who? The Inflation Election

Sign up for WSJ’s free What’s News newsletter.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from The Journal.

All episodes