In short
The Mario Rosenstock Podcast - Episode Summary
Episode Title
REPOST: Nicola Tallant on Why She Chose a Life in Crime
Episode Description In this holiday special of The Mario Rosenstock Podcast, Mario revisits one of the most popular episodes featuring Nicola Tallant, a prominent Irish crime journalist. Tallant discusses her career in crime journalism, her interest in criminal characters, and shares humorous anecdotes. The episode also includes comedic segments surrounding current events.
---
Key Themes
The Nature of Crime Journalism
- Unique Career: Tallant describes crime journalism as a unique and challenging field that involves engaging with dangerous individuals while aiming to inform the public about criminal activities.
- Fascination with Crime: Tallant reveals her fascination with the narratives behind criminal lives and societal issues that lead individuals to crime.
Notable Criminal Figures
- Profiled Characters: The discussion includes infamous figures in Irish crime, such as the Kinahan and Hutch gangs, and how their stories captivate public interest.
- Societal Context: The podcast explores how environment, family background, and societal neglect contribute to criminal behavior.
Personal Insights and Experiences
- Role of Resilience: Tallant discusses the emotional toll of covering crime, emphasizing the development of resilience and the challenges of maintaining empathy in personal life.
- Impulsiveness: Tallant shares her tendency toward impulsiveness and the excitement that comes with her profession.
The Business of Crime
- Crime as Entertainment: The episode touches upon the growing popularity of crime-related content across various media and the public’s fascination with real-life criminal stories.
- Financial Motivations: Tallant explains how crime journalism has transitioned into a profitable business model, with high audience interest leading to more production of crime-related media.
---
Key Takeaways
- Personal Connection to Crime: Nicola Tallant shares how her initial curiosity evolved into a career that allows her to tell impactful stories.
- Understanding Criminality: The episode highlights the complexities of criminal behavior, emphasizing that many criminals come from marginalized backgrounds.
- Public Fascination: The dialogue sheds light on why figures like the Kinahans draw public intrigue, illustrating the blend of criminality with elements of charisma and media portrayal.
- Cultural Reflection: The podcast suggests that crime narratives reflect broader societal issues, prompting discussions on intervention and support for at-risk communities.
---
Comedy Segment Highlights
- Rory McIlroy’s Master Victory: Mario humorously depicts a voicemail segment where various public figures congratulate Rory McIlroy on his Masters win, showcasing his comedic style.
- Lighthearted Exchanges: The episode balances serious discussions with humorous impressions and playful banter, characteristic of Mario Rosenstock’s comedic approach.
---
Conclusion This episode serves as both an insightful exploration of crime journalism through the lens of Nicola Tallant and a comedic break during the holiday season. It underscores the ongoing dialogue about crime, media, and the society that both shapes and is shaped by these narratives.
---
Additional Notes
- Upcoming Events: Mention of the 25th anniversary show of Gift Grub Live at 3Arena Dublin.
- Audience Engagement: Mario encourages listeners to share the podcast with others to broaden its reach.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOIntroduction to Nicola Tallant
0:45 to 1:55
Mario introduces crime journalist Nicola Tallant and her work.
“Nicola is, of course, one of Ireland's best known crime journalists.”
The Fascination with Crime
1:55 to 2:52
Discussion on why Nicola Tallant chose a career in crime journalism.
“So you're in a courtroom and there's this sort of famous criminal, I suppose, John Gilligan, but you're within touching distance of him.”
The Reality of Crime Reporting
2:52 to 4:23
Exploring the realities of reporting on crime and the personalities involved.
“As you'd expect, his phone has been hopping and people from all over the world are leaving him messages of congrats.”
Personal Reflections on Crime
4:23 to 5:30
Nicola shares her personal insights and experiences in crime journalism.
“You know, you really did nearly mess it up, which would have been horrifying.”
The Thrill of the Job
5:30 to 7:27
Discussion on the thrills and dangers of being a crime journalist.
“As I am imposing a 100 % tariff on European golfing scores Meaning any player from Europe, Asia, or China Now, we like China.”
The Edge of Criminal Life
7:27 to 8:27
Nicola talks about the excitement of being close to criminal events.
“he came as my plus one no he didn't by the way Daniel Kinahan was just up in the gods he was in the gods right yeah ready all the pot top criminals were at my show But yeah, it was nice.”
Impulsiveness in Life Choices
8:27 to 10:23
Nicola discusses her impulsive nature and how it affects her decisions.
“I mean it's such like a niche and unusual thing.”
The Impulsiveness of Adventure
14:01 to 15:20
Explore the nature of impulsivity and the balance of saying yes to experiences.
“It's just like, you know you're doing this.”
The Dark Humor in Crime Journalism
15:21 to 17:00
Delve into the blend of humor and darkness in the crime journalism industry.
“has been outside of the journalism I came up with who would have ever thought crime journalism would become a live stage show and that kind of thing.”
Why Crime Captivates Audiences
17:01 to 19:30
Understand the fascination with crime stories and their appeal to audiences.
“Look, usually criminals are pretty interesting individuals with pretty interesting stories.”
Show all 30 chapters
The Sociological Aspects of Crime
19:31 to 21:10
Examine the societal factors that contribute to criminal behavior.
“weird person, you're interested in the whole panoply of characters which are in a milieu a place, a socioeconomic thing.”
The Impact of Environment on Criminal Development
21:11 to 23:15
Learn how childhood environments influence paths to crime and redemption.
“Ger Redmond, the older brother, was actually on a trajectory to a fantastic football career at the time.”
The Nature of Good and Bad in Society
23:16 to 24:43
Discuss the complexities of labeling individuals as 'good' or 'bad'.
“Now lots of people also grow up in that environment.”
The Psychology of Violent Offenders
24:44 to 27:26
Investigate the mindset and characteristics of violent criminals, particularly paedophiles.
“So are there people, have you seen, have you seen evidence that there are people who are not bad, but become bad, right?”
Building Resilience in Dark Professions
27:27 to 28:00
Understand how professionals cope with the trauma of working in crime-related fields.
“Do you ever feel trauma on their behalf?”
Building Resilience in Crime Journalism
28:00 to 29:50
Explore how resilience affects crime journalists and their personal lives.
“I think you build a resilience and there is a resilience and I think it's not only like crime journalists, I think people like counsellors, how do counsellors and social workers do it?”
The Intelligence of Criminals
29:50 to 33:02
Discuss the intelligence and strategic thinking of successful criminals.
“Now, if you don't have any resilience, you end up probably in treatment in a hospital.”
Ambition and the Kinahan Family
33:02 to 37:48
Examine the ambitious nature of the Kinahan family and their global connections.
“So you just have to be completely, you know, show no weakness.”
Striving for More: A Double-Edged Sword
37:48 to 42:00
Analyze the balance between ambition and contentment in life choices.
“Have you always felt that or is that more?”
The Enigma of Conor McGregor
42:00 to 43:00
Discussing Conor McGregor's complex public persona and associations.
“I mean, I certainly wouldn't sleep straight in bed at night waiting for the any day or when will it?”
The Downfall of a Fighting Icon
43:00 to 44:10
Exploring the transformation of McGregor from a clean image to controversial behavior.
“Anyway, he's done that and it's sitting somewhere on the cutting floor.”
The Story of 'The Witness'
44:10 to 47:50
Nicola shares the compelling story of a young boy drawn into crime and his journey to redemption.
“And you kind of, I don't try and avoid it if I have to cover it, but it just results in such a pile on.”
Turning Real Stories into Media
47:50 to 50:40
Discussing the process of turning 'The Witness' story into different media formats.
“It was a young boy who was groomed into a drug gang very early in his life and had a horrendous time.”
A Love for Crime Dramas
50:40 to 52:30
Exploring Nicola's passion for crime-related movies and series.
“When we started really being offered these offerings from those streamers, you know, Netflix and stuff.”
Comedy and Crime: The Monk Sketch
52:30 to 54:40
The comedic approach to discussing crime through sketches involving real-life figures.
“My God, I think I've just come up with a great sketch.”
An Inside Look at the Podcast with The Monk
54:40 to 56:00
A behind-the-scenes perspective on interviewing a notorious criminal for the podcast.
“There's problems with gangs around here.”
The Kinnaghan-Hutch Feud Insights
56:00 to 57:55
Explore the details surrounding the Kinnaghan-Hutch feud and its impact.
The Impact of Podcasting on Politics
57:55 to 59:30
Discuss the influence of a podcast on political dynamics and public perception.
“And he was going, listen, it's looking like he might be getting in.”
Exploring Charisma in Crime Figures
59:30 to 1:00:59
Analyze the charisma of crime figures and their public personas.
“Maybe I should appear on Crime World the next time, the Minister for Finance.”
Messages and Strategies in Crime
1:00:59 to 1:04:24
Learn about the subtle messages conveyed by crime figures and their strategies.
“He has that thing though that a few of them have which is charisma.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00Happy Christmas from everybody at the Mario Rosenstock podcast. I'm Mario Rosenstock and you are welcome to these Tide You Over podcasts for the holiday period. Coming up, one of my favourite podcasts of recent times. I hope you're having a great Christmas, a great break and I'll see you in the new year. Play. Coming up on this episode of the Mario Rosenstock podcast. I mean, it was a brilliant picture and he had a ridiculous hat on. Yeah. All this sort of stuff and Happy New Year on it, OK? But Daniel Kinahan sent his hit men to kill him on New Year's Eve. OK. And that's a message. I'm here that not everybody gets but I get that it was a subliminal message I'm still here yeah wow you know interesting they're always about two steps ahead of you
0:52Well as far as careers go let's face it being a crime journalist is up there with one of the most let's say interesting out there you're constantly dealing with dangerous people that do terrible things And not only that, your job is to make as many people as possible aware of those people and the awful crimes that they commit. I mean, who'd want a job like that? I have an answer for that. Nicola Talentwood. Nicola is, of course, one of Ireland's best known crime journalists. After years writing about crime, she then started talking about it on a podcast she created called Crime World, which is now one of the most listened to podcasts in the country.
1:24She also does live stage shows, writes a book every year and regularly appears in the media. But why? What is it about this macabre subject that fascinates Nicola? Well, that's what this episode of the Mario Rosenstock podcast is all about. Nicola reveals why she chose this career in crime and is so ambitious about continuing it and growing it. She also talks openly and honestly about those characters we all seem to find compelling, like Christy and Daniel Kinahan, Jerry the Monkutch and Conor McGregor. You do not want to miss this one. So you're in a courtroom and there's this sort of famous criminal, I suppose, John Gilligan, but you're within touching distance of him.
2:01You have this front seat at this arena that everybody else gets to listen to. Sports journalists will say that to you, that, you know, they get the seats, they get the best seats at these things. And it's a similar kind of a thing. Most people kind of come from situations where there is no parenting or problems and trauma, addiction. They might be living in areas where everything is surrounding them. They might be the kids that are left out in the street at night that nobody's roaring for them to come in. There mightn't be anywhere for them to go into. They want to be part of something. Some of them are extremely bright.
2:34You just have to look at the top of the tree at those Ginehans and realise that they are now dealing with the Iranian regime and Putin and they are moving drugs for them and mixing with royalty in the United Arab Emirates. That is extraordinary. We do have to take a minute and go, how did they make their way up that ladder into the arena of global politics? Thank you Nicola Maybe I should appear on Crime World the next time The Minister for Finance I've committed some very grievous crimes With the budget 2024 That was horrific I robbed everybody blind I practically went up and took the wallets out of their pockets So I'm ready to confess My full chat with Nicola Talent coming up in just a few minutes time But let's face it The story of the week has to be the ongoing fallout as we all bask in the glow of Rory McIlroy's amazing, man of the moment performance in Augusta, winning the Augusta Masters and completing the Grand Slam, the only ever Irish golfer to do so and only the sixth golfer in history to do so.
3:37What a performance. As you'd expect, his phone has been hopping and people from all over the world are leaving him messages of congrats.
3:46Yeah, hi, you've reached Rory McIlroy, Masters Champion 2025 Oh god It started again Just leave a message I'm so happy How are you Rory? It's Bertie Ahern here Listen a fantastic performance in the golf at Augusta Dera I haven't seen crying like that since I did that interview with Brian Dobson on RT1 By the way if anyone asks they might have a thing coming up about the presidency but I put 47 ,000 euro on you to win that's where I'm after getting a few quid recently if they're asking just to corrupt back me up on that one there thanks Rory nice one Rory, Brendan O 'Connor here listen, you're an absolute legend but like I'd love to give you a full hour of the show this Saturday I know you've been talking so much about how great the performance was but you almost did, you know, choke.
4:49You know, you really did nearly mess it up, which would have been horrifying. I'm interested in exploring the horror of what it could have been like had you just completely ruined your life again. I mean, how bad could it have got? Would we be looking at, like, you know, certifiable sort of depression, maybe electric shock treatment or something, or lifetime of medication maybe? You know, get in touch. Rory, this is President Donald J. Trump. Congratulations on a fantastic performance Amazing, fantastic performance I had a 63 at Augusta only two weeks ago They said, sir, no president has ever scored three hole-in-ones in one round Amazing, I was incredible But, Arori, from now on, Europe will no longer be able to win the Masters As I am imposing a 100 % tariff on European golfing scores Meaning any player from Europe, Asia, or China Now, we like China.
5:44They're smart. They're smart, and we like smart, but the tariffs are going on their golf. Every golfer that is not American will start at 11 over bar. Thank you for your attention in this matter, Rory. Rory, this is Mary Lou McDonald on show. I wanted to congratulate you, but also to ask you if you would deliver the keynote speech at the Sinn Féin Ardèche. We're up seven points in the latest poll. And I think you could be the secret to unlocking a united Ireland in the future, bearing in mind what you have done. Give us a call. Colgardicus, August, whatever they say. Good luck. An exclusive comedy every week, of course, on the Mario Rosenstock podcast.
6:33I love doing the voicemails. OK, it's time to cross straight over to the Go Loud studios and meet my special guest on this episode Nicola Tallon she of the Sunday World the Crime World podcast the Witness in His Own Words podcast several books and live shows and so much more but with all that going on she managed to find time to come and see me at my recent live show at the Three Arena I even did an impression of her The last time I saw you you were at my show Amazing It was so good I was so blown away that like that that venue you must have just been The Three Arena Yeah I just saw you coming out on the stage at the end of it and you were just taking it all in I was because it doesn't happen every no time you stand on a stage is it that you sell out that big and that sort of a no wasn't it a great atmosphere oh it was a brilliant atmosphere yeah and I was having a good look at the crowd I was just wondering who goes all ages people who grew up with you people who are new yeah that's right we're all ages yeah good mix Monk was in the third row from the back yeah he was with me he came as my plus one no he didn't by the way Daniel Kinahan was just up in the gods he was in the gods right yeah ready all the pot top criminals were at my show But yeah, it was nice.
7:37It was families there, couples and then just kind of people out for the night and everything. Good mix. Yeah. And I did you as well, didn't I? Yes, you did. I wasn't expecting that. I knew you were there because you've got a well to do voice. So it reminds me a little bit of imagine if Joanne McNally did just talk about murders the whole time instead of funny. It's that South Dublin thing, which people find very irritating, don't they? Yeah, people. Some people do. Like I remember Joanne McNally, right. I used to love listening to her voice because when she started as a comedian, because I remember thinking she's really owning this.
8:11Yeah. She owns this posh voice. Yeah. To the extent that she just totally overdoes it. And then a couple of curses in the middle of it work. Yeah. Yeah. The accent, don't they? Yeah. And then some people say I sound like Mary Lou MacDonald as well. She has that same boring sort of. No, no, no, no, no. We're still friends. No, I know what you're saying. she has a kind of holy child voice alright you know the nuns Holy Child West Dublin maybe yeah yeah but no you just have a kind of well brought up sort of voice and come here listen I mean like I'll make this more of a profile piece in a way right I mean like I never asked you how you got into all this sort of stuff like was it journalism that got you in do you mean podcasting and all that sort of stuff no I meant the crime.
9:00I meant crime. Yeah. I mean it's such like a niche and unusual thing. I mean for years I was doing Paul Williams on the radio and I had him on the podcast as well and all his nicknames. Viper Tosser and all this. And I used to make up nicknames for people like the librarian and stuff. Really innocent nicknames for people. But like how do you get into crime? You kind of are in the office one day and you're sent on a story like when back in the day when you were young and you used to be sent out of offices. Nowadays most of them are sitting on you know computers and rewriting stuff maybe and all the rest.
9:38We are always out when I was younger. We were always sent out on whatever was happening. Physically sent. This is what Jumbo Cairns was telling me. Do you know what? It was him. Was it? Him. I worked with him. For people who want to listen back, Jumbo is a legend. Jumbo is a legend in journalistic circles and he told me all about this and being sent out and that's the way journalism used to be and you learn your trade being sent out, yeah. You do, like, and actually I was working with him in the Mirror at the time and those Gilligan trials were on. So they were the big story of the day and I was sort of sent down to them very green and not knowing really a huge amount about it all but it was exciting and then I suppose, yeah, like I suppose it was a news reporter but then you start doing crime and you get sort of pushed into that arena because you know a little bit about it and then, because I found it interesting maybe I didn't bulk and look to go to the sort of other areas.
10:30Yeah. You say you found it, like you used the word exciting there. Let's go deeper into that. Like you knew that something was going on inside your head, inside your body even when you were tuning into this. It excited you. It just something, it made something work within you, didn't it? Yeah, I was just interested in it. I mean, initially sort of almost voyeuristically, I think you could say, because I didn't really understand the fabric around it and what was happening really to get people. So you're in a courtroom and there's this sort of famous criminal, I suppose, John Gilligan, but you're within touching distance of him.
11:03You have this front seat at this arena that everybody else gets to listen to. Sports journalists will say that to you, that, you know, they get the seats, they get the best seats at these things. And it's a similar kind of a thing. So you're there for these moments, these big moments. And also then outside of court, we used to be sent a lot around the country. if there was a murder you'd actually be in your car going down to try and gather bits and before really you could send a photograph electronically you had to get a photograph in somebody's kitchen, sit and have tea and wait until the biscuit tin came down and these photographs of maybe a victim came out and it was a very sort of good training ground to learn how to communicate with people in pretty bad circumstances you know and then you'd have to drive back with the photograph and write the story around a victim and whatever.
11:51So all of this kind of stuff then I just found pretty fascinating. Sometimes you'd be sent out to speak to the homeless population to kind of, you know, keep an eye on some street dealing, all of this. And as I went on with it and continued on with it, I think I started to understand the fabric around it, what created this, that these people weren't just to be spied upon and, you know, photographed you know, from the back of a surveillance van. They had a story. there was a reason they were there and that I wasn't. You know, because any of us could be in their shoes, really. I believe now at this stage that it's really just the look of birth and your parents, really, and your education and certain things happen in your life that send you the right direction rather than the wrong.
12:36But bring yourself back to your teenage years when you knew it all. And if you're in a different environment, I certainly think I might have gone for the flashy life, to be honest with you. So in other words, even yourself, it could have happened to. Indeed. Because of the kind of the excitement of it. Yeah, I think so. Living on the edge. Yeah, I think so. So in a way, legally, you are living legally on the edge, covering these, but from just slightly the other side. Slightly the other side. And maybe now, I suppose, with the advantage of age, with a little bit more of an understanding of it.
13:10So when I do speak about it, I like to hope that I am not judgmental and I'm sort of, you know, delving a little bit into society and the reason that these people end up, you know. You find it exciting. I'm sticking on this for a minute. You find it exciting. It does something. It works with you and your personality. Is that reflected in any other area of your personality? So, for example, you can take the question for what it is. But, you know, for example, have you ever found you really like a flutter, for example? Oh, yeah. Oh, you do? Oh, gotcha. So that would tally as well. Yeah. And I would also tend to be somebody that I sort of would dive in.
13:52I wouldn't think about things. I don't overthink anything. If a kind of a scenario comes up, do you want to do this? And it might be something slightly off the, I'll go for it. Yes, very much so. And willfully impulsive. You know you're being impulsive. Yeah, absolutely. You're not just being kind of reckless. It's just like, you know you're doing this. But I'd be disappointed with myself if I didn't say yes to things. Give me an example of the type of thing that you'd easily say yes to on a regular basis. A friend of yours goes, will we just feck off to Belgium for the weekend? Oh, for sure. That kind of thing.
14:20Absolutely. Belgium, I've never been there. Great, let's do it. Belgium doesn't sound too exciting. We could have found maybe somewhere a little bit more edgy, maybe Vegas or something. But yes, I'm always sort of up for things. Right. And I'm always sort of... Have you ever got married in a Vegas shop? No, not quite. But it sounds like you nearly could. It sounds like I could. It sounds like something, your life's not over yet. Britney Talent. Shotgun weddings. She shaved her head. Would you shave your head? Maybe not. No, not now. I might have at another period of my life when it would grow back quicker.
14:47But I would be very impulsive like that and it would just be for the laugh and to maybe sit the photograph and then you might kind of regret things afterwards. Have you ever regretted being impulsive? I don't think I have. I think I would have always regretted had I not gone and tried it and done it and you know but then you know sometimes and maybe it's an Irish thing saying yes you have to learn how to say no as well don't you because sometimes then you overwhelm yourself with the amount of things you're doing and things go a little bit out of control and you find yourself spreading yourself a little bit too thin like a lot of the stuff I've done in recent years has been outside of the journalism I came up with who would have ever thought crime journalism would become a live stage show and that kind of thing.
15:34Mine on a much smaller basis than yours and you probably, your career was always bringing you that way anyway. But it was the last thing you'd expect to put on a stage and to try and entertain people and to give them a night out and make them laugh and that sort of opportunity came up. And interesting you say making people laugh because in fact you can make people laugh with this subject. It's dark. But that's what you have to do. People don't come out to go home in tears. They come out for maybe learn a little bit to have a little bit of entertainment and just be a little bit interested. But anything with such dark edges to it is only very close to the humour anyway.
16:09For sure. We're all dark. The whole crime thing, right, is a tsunami in podcasting, literature, TV. I mean, I suppose murder and crime was always part of the cinema genre. But now it's taken over podcasting. And you're kind of at the forefront, the apex of this thing. I mean, you're so well known for what you do. You interview all the top criminals. It's like as if they're pop stars. It's like you interview all the top criminals and you have the live shows and everything. So what is it about crime do you think that makes people that monetises it. Why is crime so sellable? Why is it so sellable?
17:01Look, usually criminals are pretty interesting individuals with pretty interesting stories. They've had pretty interesting experiences. They haven't sat in an office, you know, behind a screen and they've really experienced life in a way and they do have a lot to say. There's different sort of types of crime. You talk about the podcast and all that, and particularly in the podcast arena, There's a huge amount of influencer type people who are interested in crime and who have podcasts where they tell stories about crime, but they don't have any intimacy with it. And they're all they're doing well.
17:36And there's a whole amount of people that are interested in the stories of serial killers who don't really exist anymore. but they're still interested in that and they're interested in these sort of unsolved cases that are pretty fascinating they're all a rarity. The stuff I do is more the real stuff it's like you know what is actually happening out there and your greater risk is probably you know to get burgled than to be killed by a stranger but that sort of stuff is still fascinating and there's a huge amount of content around that I don't know the crime world stuff is almost like nearly a news show like we follow some of the breaking stories we follow some of the trials that are of interest to people, we can really see, like I'm sure you can you can see what's interesting people and if you see it, because we see the figures all the time in real time there's actually like screens all over our newsroom showing what everyone is watching and what they're looking at so we are actually, we always said as a media we were sort of serving the people what they want.
18:42Now we actually are because we can see what they want. I would do about 10 podcasts a week. I can see the stories, the characters, the individuals that they really are interested in because the figures go up as basic as that. And then I would tell sort of more longer form stories over 10 parts. Some of them are cold case murders, some of them are gangland hits and you get really down into the weeds of those stories and who's who and who are the characters around it, what has happened, what are the chances of solving it. One of the things that came across what she said there is there's a societal element to what's going on with you.
19:20So rather than somebody being obsessed with Ted Bundy, the serial killer, which may be a person who is voyeuristically interested in that particular weird person, you're interested in the whole panoply of characters which are in a milieu a place, a socioeconomic thing. There's a sliding doors moment as you talked about. Why did that person become? So you're interested in that whole thing. Isn't that right? Yes, which is a little bit more, yeah, it's more kind of looking at where society sits within this as well and where areas of Dublin and where deprivation and all those other elements come into it and I like to delve back rather than just give someone a nickname and call them a baddie.
20:06I like to delve back into why they became that. And there are some really fascinating, sad stories about why people become and why they're standing there. When you say fascinating and sad, give me one who stands out in your mind. Yeah, well, there's a brother and sister currently in jail and they've been convicted and they're called, they're both Redmond, Rue Redmond and Sister Rachel for different offences. Rue Redmond in particular for a murder. He's had a long history in gangland. But they have another brother called Ger Redmond, who was also involved in criminality, but while in prison and after he had a child, had a road to Damascus moment, essentially, and is now a very intriguing, interesting, amazing character that's giving back to the community.
20:53and he works with kids and he tries to direct them away from it. But when you go back to their childhood, you see a very, very dysfunctional home where their own father committed a crime, an arson attack, which resulted in the killing of a young baby. And he was put away in jail for manslaughter. Ger Redmond, the older brother, was actually on a trajectory to a fantastic football career at the time. He'd been picked to go to Scotland. and he was, you know, he had a career basically, possibly in the premiership. And because of that incident, he had to come back and try and rear four young siblings and feed them.
21:31And something there was missed by social services, by education, by the state. And, you know, this child is trying to rear children. He turns to crime to feed them. And because it's all around him, he does get out of that and come back and give back to the community. but the brother and sister are now in jail. I think that's a really sad story. You know, very tough childhood. Not to take from the victims that are there within their stories but it's a really tough childhood. And I wonder would I be Ger or would I be Rachel or Rue? Would I have the strength of character to come back from that and to have that moment and give back?
22:14Yeah. What about, just on that point, do you think from what your experience has seen that criminals are created by their environment and if they are created by the environment is it at a young age especially so and is it to do with abuse I think most of them like there is a kind of a few and actually funny enough Christy Kinahan Senior you know he's actually the cuckoo in the nest because he's from a middle class family he's educated he's everything That's fascinating. And he chooses it. He actually goes out and finds it and chooses it. But most people kind of come from situations where there is no parenting or problems and trauma, addiction.
23:01They might be living in areas where everything is surrounding them. They might be the kids that are left out in the street at night that nobody's roaring for them to come in. there mightn't be anywhere for them to go into or it might be going into more troubled environment than they find in the streets and they want to be part of something and they become part of a gang. Now lots of people also grow up in that environment. When you say part of a gang is that them finding a family? Yes. 100 % they're finding safety they're finding a place. An identity. An identity. And you think back as a teenager that's really what teenage life is about finding an identity outside your home.
23:34But loads of people then at the same time will grow up in that environment and they won't go into that. They'll manage to manoeuvre their way out and maybe they have a skill set that others don't. But we have left those communities become that you know through I suppose all we've tried to do is police it, put people in jail and the same funds haven't gone into those community groups that take longer and take you know more money really to steer a kid the right way. And look some of them you know like all human beings are different and some of them will maybe go the wrong way anyway no matter what you throw at them but I think a lot of people more people could be saved if there was interventions there younger and I really dislike when people who have all the education and everything and have had that and that they judge you know and just think it's just because they're bad.
24:35Yes. Yeah, well, let's talk about that. Let's talk about bad. I mean, it's not easy even to categorise, but for the purposes of simplifying the argument, maybe we'll attempt to. So are there people, have you seen, have you seen evidence that there are people who are not bad, but become bad, right? Then there are people who are just bad and follow through on being bad. You do see that, but do you not think we see evidence of that in normal society as well? I mean, there's some bad people you meet and they're just bad. Yeah, I do. And they're just nasty and they're doing things they mightn't ever be caught, you know, committing a crime.
25:19They are. They're doing them. They're doing them. And I mean, the ones that really, really sort of make, creep me out are definitely the paedophiles. I mean, there's something about them that I think people who work with them can always say they can nearly tell them when they walk into a room there's something there, there's some sort of a, I mean it's shocking what they do and you don't even want to you want to go home and wash when you're near them it's just so unforgivable and that's in them that's not something that's usually created. Yeah one of the things I find about, from the reports I've read to do with paedophilia is that a lot of paedophiles completely absolutely know what they're doing.
26:00And they seem to be almost rational and sane. So they don't fall into this. He had nothing to live for fucking psychopath Tony Montana. Fucking I'm going down. So I might as well take the whole boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, world with me. It's nothing to do with that. It's like rational. They know what it is. And they actually, that's pretty as close to suppose evil as you can think. Yeah, it is. It's pretty. I mean, I remember being called into this particular individual who had been accused and he was living. A lot of paedophiles hoard things. And like, as you come to the door, you know, there's something good that they hoard cars, they hoard dirty things, they hoard magazines, they hoard.
26:41I'm not saying all hoarders, by the way, are paedophiles, but a lot of them have that. And I happened to be in this house and I didn't know where to sit. I was like, oh, God. And started asking this man about some of the allegations that I was putting to him. and he I was talking to him about having sex with children and he said but lots of people have that hobby so he had sort of like he was trying to deny everything and then he came out with that as a defence and I said but lots of people wouldn't call that a hobby in fact most people wouldn't call that a hobby and they just yeah there's something wrong about them they're so outside what you expect a human being to be like and that's they're a completely different breed really of of you know predator than what I usually thankfully What about your own soul when you you alluded to a minute ago about feeling dirty sometimes you feel you need to go home and wash when you're with some of the some of that kind of person I just wonder how that rubs off on you just generally generally the idea of constantly being in the arena of of people who are transgressing the law and hurting other people and you have thought of that presumably Yeah and also being with victims who have been through horrendous things and having to sit down and listen and see some of the results of the stuff.
27:57Do you ever feel trauma on their behalf? I think you build a resilience and there is a resilience and I think it's not only like crime journalists, I think people like counsellors, how do counsellors and social workers do it? How do they do it? I know. People working in the ambulance services and the hospitals, you're seeing all that. Police. So you build this or you have this resilience. So you have to have it. So you have to have resilience. And that works for you because you're able to deal with this stuff and whatever you're doing with it. I'm only trying to sort of be a conduit to tell it on.
28:33But that resilience then I think can sometimes affect the way you deal with people in your personal life because you maybe have less empathy if they're not as resilient and you have to kind of check yourself. I understand what you're saying. You have to be a little bit more realistic that not everybody's as resilient. I'll be slightly trite here, but I'm trying to think of an example. And one of them was, I was watching The Jackal, right? The Day of the Jackal, the recent series, which was really well produced and everything. But the black girl in it, the police officer, she was very interesting because she was dealing with like out there murderers and everything.
Read the full transcript
29:11She was following the jackal, but then she'd come home to her husband and the kids and she'd be cold. because she's completely switched on. And he'd be there like saying, you know, you haven't seen the daughter and your daughter, our daughter in three days and she's doing her leaving like her GCSEs. And she's then, oh shit, sorry. And then she tries to go into empathy mode, but it doesn't come naturally to her. Yeah. Because she's toughened up. She's got this shell that she's developed. Mm-hmm. And I think you kind of, you've thought with yourself as well because you don't, I suppose resilience stops you processing things.
29:46Right. So then if you stop processing things and then you try to just screw that up, you're not able for that. Now, if you don't have any resilience, you end up probably in treatment in a hospital. Do you know what I mean? So resilience is usually good. It's probably most of it is good. But some of it then is you have to have a little bit of kindness towards yourself and others. And, you know, I mean, I have to stop myself. I'm sure my kids say that I'm constantly telling them about. they actually do impressions of me you'd love it they're sitting at breakfast and there's no milk or something and then I go do you not know what's happening in Ukraine?
30:23Like you know what I mean I sort of always bring things to that level of ridiculousness almost and you know You go into sixth gear Yeah because it's like you have this feeling like do you not know how privileged you are but I feel that more for myself I think that you feel you can't I don't know process a lot of things probably Well it was interesting to somebody in your position who go I would wonder sometimes do you feel it hard to open up to somebody and to be vulnerable with people on the basis that your inner brain is telling me what kind of a fucking psycho am I dealing with here potentially?
30:58Well there's definitely a bit of that because like you know in what I do if you show weakness it's the worst thing you can do you can never show weakness you have to just constantly keep looking at them in the eye because criminals always try and threaten you and undermine you and they try and get at you and they try and claim to know little things about you which they just don't. Are criminals intelligent? Oh, mostly. You know, any of them are successful. Probably the ones who are... So like any area that are... They've risen to the top. They have used... They demonstrate intelligence. Oh, they have a brain and they can work systems and they can...
31:31Are some of them very bright? Some of them are extremely bright. Extremely bright. Who do you think is bright? Names that we might know. Well, I mean, you just have to look at the top of the tree at those Kinehans and realise that they're now dealing with the Iranian regime and Putin and they are moving drugs for them and they are, you know, they're working, they're in trouble with the Americans because they've been helping fund Hezbollah essentially. How do they get from Oliver Bond to mixing with that and with royalty in the United Arab Emirates? That is extraordinary. Like, we do have to take a minute and go, how did they do that?
32:07How did they make their way up that ladder into the arena of politics, of world global politics? So I suppose how I'm asking you then, and I'm trying to maybe guess then, you do it by, well, you must demonstrate enormous cunning. You must demonstrate, you must surely demonstrate the ability to think strategically as well, though. But I mean, they've languages. I mean, I couldn't be a little bit of French. They might have eight languages. They've learned about the world. They haven't just stayed in their own little lane. They have learned that they're better than that in a way. And they've gone out and they have trotted the world and they have realized where the weaknesses in countries that I hardly know exist are.
32:49And that's extraordinary. and I suppose if they had gone into legitimate business they would be the likes of the Microsoft heads. So yes they are very intelligent. They're just working in a parallel universe. Yes. But like the kind of the there's only a finite amount of people in the world get to that position top of the tree but mostly they will be sort of scammers fraudsters this kind of thing but they'll also if they want to deal with you because a lot of it is they're having a bit of fun and they will always try and suggest they know where you live or they know this or the other. So you just have to be completely, you know, show no weakness.
33:32When you say show no weakness, I mean, you must almost feel no weakness. Hold your ground. I don't know what you'd call it. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. You learn how to do that. So then does that kind of go into probably, you know, when I meet people first, I'm probably a little bit standoffish and trying to work out. Are they actually some sort of a psychopath? Are they okay? I know. But trying to have a couple of drinks on the street with you at Christmas is a bloody nightmare. I mean, my defences are down, Nicola. You know, and you're there. I'm just working you out. Right, you might be on your third gin and tonic, but I've got you figured out, Rosenstock.
34:09Yeah, there you are. Looking all sort of cheery and smiley and kios in South Down Street. But why are you here really, Rosenstock? Just for my listeners, we had a few drinks together at Christmas and we met some people and I bumped into Nicola during the evening and we had a great royal time. We had a really good, we were all on good Christmas cheer. Absolutely. And I was taking the piss out of people and you were in good top form as well. We were kind of running the crowd for a while there in Kios, I think. We were, yeah, we were putting on a mini podcast. People were gathering around. It was a little mini podcast.
34:40That was funny. So interesting, so interesting. So a couple of other, like the Kinahans, you said the Daniel Kinahan there, that he's a fascinating character. Is he more, is he of Christie or is he even beyond Christie? Is he like, you know, completely outdoing his father? Or is he trying to? I don't know. Or is he trying to? Maybe. Do they have a relationship? Yeah. Yeah. Father-son relationship? Yeah. And, you know, funny, there's some creepy little things that you hear about. he people who would know him would always say he's sort of his sort of baby-like to the father on the phone and stuff and yet you know he's ordering murders like they're pizzas yeah peculiar character the father was definitely is a peculiar character and he is too Is the father alive?
35:29Yeah yeah 80s, 90s? No no he would be only in his 60s now Really? So he obviously had the son very young He had them well they're 40s you see They feel like they're around forever, don't they? So, yeah, he's in his 60s, but still very much, you know, and resolved to, up until recently, take over the shipping routes of, you know, the world. Like, I mean, the ambition knows no end. You know, buying planes from the Israelis and moving cocaine up through Africa during COVID and air ambulances and things like this. The brain never stops. Highly intelligent. he is supposed to have been a member of Mensa the father Daniel Kinahan for me when you look at his achievements I look at Tyson Fury I knew nothing about boxing at all I can tell you from South County Dublin it wasn't a sport I would have known anything about but it is an amazing sport and very interesting I only know about it through my crime work but he did take Tyson Fury from the scrap heap and he you know brought him back to become the heavyweight champion of the world which is an extraordinary thing to do.
36:39Even though the accusation is in the background he was using, you know, his influence and probably dirty money to make things happen. But even without that, to have done that, to have had that one achievement in life and it's never enough. There's never enough. So no matter how intelligent people are, I always envy people in life who are satisfied with their lot. I think that is happiness. When people are just satisfied. They mightn't have a huge amount, but they're satisfied in their home with their partner, with their kids, with everything around them. They don't constantly strive for more because that's an irritant when you're like that.
37:19You can never just totally relax when you're constantly striving for more. And, you know, it's illogical. What are you striving for when you have really everything that matters at the end of the day? I see it slightly differently. I mean, I do understand exactly what you're saying, but I think there's more to striving for more than striving for more material gain. I think there is striving because you want to deliver. Like, I'm not a religious person at all, but I do have a kind of a, I do have a spiritual belief in the idea of be thankful for the talent you were given and honour it. Honour it.
38:00Have you always felt that or is that more? It's something that's grown in me, this idea that it's a sense of privilege, luck that I feel I've been given. And I see people who are laughing at things that I do and I feel so gifted and blessed that I can do it. And then I feel I've got to deliver on this. I've got to keep working on my talent to almost honour the fact, don't let it lie fallow. Keep at it like more, more, more, more, not for more money or for more fame or adulation. it's definitely to keep honouring the thing that you have been lucky enough to be given because so many people are just so in you know I mean you said it there a minute ago Ukraine and the vast majority of people don't even have fresh water to drink you know and I have this thing that I've been given to make people happy and laugh honour it honour it I get that it's like that thing and did you ever see Chariots of Fire and the guy who was very religious and he said God gave him speed and he must honour God he must honour God and deliver on it.
39:01But anyway, it's an interesting one. And haven't you luck if you've found what you're good at early on? Oh, it's a fluke, total fluke. That is a kind of a very, you know, you see people who are still in careers going, oh, I don't really know what I want to do. Well, you said people who are satisfied. There are a lot of people who settle for things and they appear satisfied. But they're the people I worry about because they're the people that later in life, a lot of the resentment surfaces. Maybe, yeah. And, you know, you go, oh, right, like, so I have no relationship with the kids and I broke up with the wife when I was there.
39:30And why? Well, because there was something there the whole time that you never itched the scratch. You never scratched the itch, you know? But anyways, but I do broadly understand what you're saying. I'm fascinated by this, you know, now that we're on the Cainahans thing. So the father is still working away. The son is trying to emulate maybe the father and go beyond him. He's an international player of Ronaldo or Messi-like levels. He's sanctioned by the Americans. he's doing business with the Iranians and the Putin and the Russians running drugs all over the world. Do you know where he is? He's in Dubai.
40:06Yeah. And what do the Dubai authorities, they know where he is. Yeah, this is where it gets complex because so we're putting together a file. The Americans obviously have a bounty on his head. The Emirates are playing a game, a political game. They're signing treaties and they're saying, oh yes, yes, we'll hand them once. The paperwork is there. But it's a long time happening now. All these things that are a long time happening end very quickly and swiftly. I mean, I've seen it before, these people that are untouchable and, you know, very, you know, within a few days they're behind bars and that's where they're staying and it's all over for them.
40:46But it feels like certainly this political games. I do know that Daniel Kinahan has a very good friend who's one of these sort of bratty younger royals. and he probably got into mixing with him through the boxing. I think their connections with that part of the world started way back around the early 2000s when they were on the racetracks in the UK, kind of period forgotten nearly. They were dipping in to try and see how much money they could launder through horse racing, which is a brilliant way of laundering money. And there's a lot of very rich people that own horses and that are mixing and mingling in that world.
41:26And I think they made strong connections there. They have some protections. At the same time, there's very few people who appear on a wanted poster, you know, for the DEA, for the US Treasury, who actually live out to see the retirement. You know, they look untouchable until they're not. Yeah. And, you know, cops would always say to you, the criminals have to be lucky every day. We just have to be lucky once. And it's a kind of a little thing that come out. Do you think he moves around between Russia and Japan? No, no. No, I think he stayed in the Emirates. I think he's afraid to move. I think he's protected somewhat there.
41:59And, you know, I mean, what would life be like? I mean, I certainly wouldn't sleep straight in bed at night waiting for the any day or when will it? Will they come for me? Will they not? He has a confidence. He has gone to ground with the social media stuff. He did pop up really heavily in around 22 after Tyson Fury. He was on social media. Yes. And he was being photographed. He was being spoken about. He actually made a big long podcast with a guy called James English in the UK, which has never seen the light of day. Never? No, it never got out. It was three hours. Have you ever been allowed to do three hours in a podcast?
42:37You would be, but... I wouldn't. They'd edit me. They'd chop me down. Well, we edit ourselves here. Well, I would edit myself. Sorry, rather Patrick would edit it. Patrick would tell you to wrap it up if it went on for three hours. Well, he'd let me do three hours with you and then... He'd wrap it up. Well, he'd possibly go, I thought that was so interesting we'll do it in three episodes. Yeah, well. Well, I mean, Joe Rogan does three hour podcasts with Elon Musk and people like that and anybody. Anyway, he's done that and it's sitting somewhere on the cutting floor. I don't know, but he was very much coming out and then the sanctions and he's gone back to ground.
43:09Just sorry, jumping completely. Have you any interest in, have you had any interest in covering Conor McGregor? Well, Conor McGregor sits in a kind of a complex position because obviously we covered the trial, the civil trial. He's appealed that now and waiting decision on what's going to happen with that. He floats beside a lot of people that we're talking about. Adjacent. He knows a lot of the kind of the Cunningham cartel from growing up with them. And a lot of them were involved in boxing, which, you know, in that kind of industry, they love going, they always went and went to the Conor McGregor fights and all the rest of it.
43:49And he would have been photographed with them and that. But there's, as we have to constantly remind ourselves and say, to keep ourselves clean, he's no involvement in organised crime. He just knows these people and he's floating around with them and he doesn't mind hanging out with them. He's moving into an arena now that is very political and far right. And you kind of, I don't try and avoid it if I have to cover it, but it just results in such a pile on. Do you find him an interesting character? Or is he in your world? Or not so much? Personally, just I don't. I find him quite abhorrent, to be honest with you.
44:30No, I didn't mean that. He makes my lip curl. Yeah, but so do a lot of these people. So do a lot of people you have to deal with. But I suppose he's not, he's coming onto my radar as somebody on the periphery. He's not actually doing anything that's illegal. He's making his money legally. He's mixing with interesting people, I suppose. So I have the same attitude to him probably that a normal, you know, anybody would have. Yes. He's done a big interview that'll be probably out by this. Tucker Carlson, yeah. Tucker Carlson. I'll probably tune in to listen to what he has to say and just, you know, curl my lip at it.
45:05But yeah, he's moving into strange arena, isn't he? Yeah, he is. And definitely there's going to be a reduction in sales of those cloth caps. Has he disconnected from reality? and that does happen funny enough to a lot of people that live in that world where they're completely surrounded they've too much money really My opinion? Utterly completely divorced from reality Yeah Yeah I think so too So he hasn't a clue what's going on And those around him as well Yeah but it's the same as Trump in the sense of it's the yes people It's totally People who won't say no to you Yeah Yeah And you know anyway he's he's not a proud son of this city maybe is he and yet he wants to Yeah Yeah, it's a pity because he could have been Muhammad Ali.
45:48He could have been, yeah, he could have been somebody that we would have. Well, I remember when he first emerged on the scene, I mean, he used to talk about, I never have a drink, I never have a drink, that kind of, you know, that voice, that thing, I don't have a drink, I'm clean, I'm pure Buddhist, the Buddhist mentality, I am only in the... Did he always talk as if he was from a foreign country and was speaking English? No, no, no, no, no, no, no, that's a Dublin thing. that thing no that's a Dublin thing that thing of it's almost a trade union thing of I have educated educated myself into the institutionalisation and colonialisation of you and I pronounce my I-N-G's yes I am ing ing ing I'm not the normal Dubliner I don't say in in like I'm throwing I would throwing throwing you know because my father was a member of the ITGWU and I fought for the unions this thing you know but then he does this thing as well like nice to meet you my friend it's very good assholes do that we've all had an asshole friend who's visited feckin Spain for the weekend and he comes back going hey Ming what the fuck and you're there Tony you're from Rant Mines yeah yeah but he's doing it yeah no it is it is bizarre yeah but he could have been because he used to talk about how this is like back to 2015 how his body was clean and how he believed in training and almost like I just said a minute ago honouring the Lord with the grace with good grace and being good to yourself and being honouring your opponent.
47:12Because this is, of course, in real martial arts, you honour your opponent. Four years later, he's saying dance, dance, dance boy, dance to Floyd Mayweather in one of the lowest racial slurs you can do. He's throwing chairs at a window at Khabib on a bus. He's... Spitting in people's faces. Yeah, no, he's... It's just disgusting. So something went completely wrong in his life. And that's what happened. So what about The Witness? Tell me about The Witness because Eamon has been on this podcast before and I know you're doing with Jane Gogol. Tell me all about that. So The Witness was a story of redemption in a way.
47:53It was a young boy who was groomed into a drug gang very early in his life and had a horrendous time. Was forced to go out and sell drugs, deliver drugs and was abused also by a very dark character called Brian Kenney. and he, Kenny then commits a murder along with Thomas Hinchin and he comes back to where he's living with Joey O 'Callaghan and he asks him to go hide the gun, hide the get rid of the motorbike, blow it up burn the leathers but Joey escapes, goes to the police and becomes a witness and his evidence along with some other evidence puts these two guys away for life and he goes into witness protection programme, disappears he's expected to set up a new life and to live as if he never came from Dublin, never had a family, never had friends.
48:44He's given a backstory and he's 19 and it doesn't work out like that. He's too young. He's got no support system. So he sort of came back and in a bad way and I met him actually. And we sort of forged this, what is now a really good, strong friendship. We wrote a book together. We went on to do a podcast, The Witness in His Own Words, which was just Joey talking really and I suppose showing people maybe why I believed him because he's very genuine he's very articulate at telling a story and hopefully now that story is going to move into the next medium of film drama which is very exciting but for me it's always been the project that has been non I suppose financial it's the one that I really was worth doing it was worth helping Joey tell his story get it out I think it's a really valid I still get an email practically every day from somebody a teacher or something saying they've just stumbled upon the podcast or the book and they really think this should be in the schools and kids should be you know taught this story you know told this story not taught it but certainly exposed to it maybe you know all of this happened quite some time ago but it's still very relevant in modern society it's the story of how a child can be lured into a situation and then feel they've no way out and yet they do find the strength then to become ultimately a man who can who can become a very strong character and a very strong voice and it's going to go to it's going to be made into a film certainly the is there script being written at the moment yeah it's great to see something get to that place you know like I would write books every nearly a year at the moment but anyway I'll slow down with that but you sort of you know I'll write the book but that one I really had I really wanted to tell someone else's story I wanted him to tell his story he didn't have the ability to write or to put it together I did and I sort of sat in the middle of that thing and we brought it to life Do you like movies about criminals?
50:57Oh my god yeah Do you? Oh my god I mean go to bed at 10 o 'clock I can't if it starts and even on oh yeah yeah Talk to me because I love movies Oh my god I'd watch anything For example The Godfather is that that's Yeah I re-watched that every now and then I actually re-watched Love Hate which is something if anybody hasn't done that in the last decade or whatever we're talking about go do it again I love re-watching those re-watching The Sopranos The Wire some of those things Breaking Bad Yeah I loved Breaking Bad So many good series. When we started really being offered these offerings from those streamers, you know, Netflix and stuff.
51:37I would say you love ones which involve double crossing and moles. Like Donnie Brasco, I think, is one. Love that. Yeah. Isn't Johnny Depp? Yes. Johnny Depp is the mole. Is the mole. I love really intriguing stuff. But I will also watch some of those crappy kind of documentary things that, you know, of a crime in Scotland. where I've never heard it before. I love a lot of the Nordic stuff, the dramas. I pretty much watch absolutely anything and I'll know in the first 10 minutes if I'm going to get to the end of it. If I like the characters, if they've... Yeah. I mean, I'd say now... Nicola Talent says this is class.
52:17You're a good reviewer for this. Yeah. So, not Dancing with the Stars then? Not Dancing with the Stars. Unless they're all criminals. I love that. This week on Dancing... It's Dancing Daniel Kinahan doing the rumba. And here is the monk with his foxtrot. That would be grass. He probably would as well. My God, I think I've just come up with a great sketch. He'd probably be game for that. Dun, dun, dun, dun, dun. Get out of it. You're a dirty old bee. Paul Reynolds, get out of it. Paul Reynolds? You're a buzzing wasp. Match the two of them. Yeah. Paul Reynolds dancing with the monk. With the monk.
52:51That would be something, yeah. We'd all tune in for that. Have you been in touch with the monk recently? Yeah, be in touch a bit, yeah. he had an interesting experience didn't he nearly getting into power or into the Dáil at least and I sort of He did we had from my point of view we had some interesting times as well we did some sketches on him Yeah and I kind of it was a little tricky getting it over the line with the guys Yeah and I appreciate where my team Ian Dempsey and Charlie and my producer Right what were they worried about him? No no it was more like because we hadn't done a sketch on the monk So basically we were deciding to do a funny sketch on a known criminal.
53:34All right. Yeah. So that means that takes it to a different level. So that means you're making fun, if you like, of a potentially very dangerous person who has been involved in violent crime. And so that was a moment where we all have to kind of decide, well, where do we stand on this? And I guess I would have been pushing to do the sketch on the basis that he's really out there. and now he's in the public arena where the public are voting on him. Yeah. And so that brings him into my arena, if you like. Yeah. The democracy thing, you know. He's now entered our world. And so we did a few sketches on him and they went down really well.
54:13And he would totally get that, by the way. Oh, I understand he would get it. He enjoys the bit of fun that goes on with it. One of the things was he came to the door, sorry, just a woman and a husband were at the door, just they're normal people. And they go, Jesus, Gerry. there's a figure at the door. And I said, who is it? I don't know, it's a dodgy looking figure. And they go, I'll go out to him. And they open the door and it's the monk. And he's standing there with his polling card going, how are you doing, I'm the monk. Yes. Just be there around the yard here. I noticed there's things going wrong.
54:49Are there any complaints to yourself? There's a lot of complaints. There's problems with gangs around here. And you go, gangs, that's dreadful. No, that's awful to hear. that's gang G-A-N gang's all right anything else well there's some you know people burglars and stuff oh that's absolutely terrible terrible terrible terrible okay thank you I appreciate your vote goodbye so shut the door and they kind of went it wasn't too bad next thing they said wrong on the door it's Pascal Dunne get the fuck out of it you scumbag criminal yeah that was the end of the sketch in other words I suppose the motto of the thing was even Monk was regarded as halfway decent in comparison into the crowd that are in there.
55:28And you know, you've just hit the nail on the head because that's why he got so many votes. Exactly that was the attitude. They thought he was better. It was this kind of like, I had an interesting experience with the whole thing, to be honest with you. So he agrees to do the podcast, which is like brilliant, but I'm not telling anyone he's coming into the building because I look for forgiveness afterwards. so we bring him in at night in the basement and up the lifts and everything and he comes in and there's very little planning in this done but he sort of says he'll tell, I wasn't really interested in his politics because I didn't think he had any I wanted him to tell me first hand about this Kinnaghan-Hutch feud, I wanted him to tell me about meeting Daniel Kinnaghan, doing a deal, the double cross how he was nearly shot in Lanzarote this was my thing you know and of course he did it all he did it all and you know we challenged him on various things you're not going to actually you know do a Paul Reynolds on it are you in a podcast studio because someone's just going to get up and walk out certainly different journalism you're not doorstepping them and shouting allegations at them you need them to talk to create something and also he's a really interesting character and he hasn't sat down and done an interview like this ever so that was all great and then we put it out in three parts yeah it was one of those it was worth a few hours it goes off the scale absolutely like the biggest ever listened to and watched podcast I think ever made in Ireland just unbelievable yeah really figures are mental yeah about 1.5 million on YouTube alone you know 1.5 million that's kind of views on YouTube but as in that's watching it that's listening to it and watching it that's just watching it that's before you hit your audio you know figures so this is off the scale this thing you know and he went out then and he, because I think he people hadn't really heard him talk like that and I think people realised well maybe they could approach him and could say hello to him, people start kind of greeting him warmly, now he's known within a part of the North Inner City but he found that warmth elsewhere and people waving at him, doing selfies with him, going down the street, it's all gone down very positively for him and he's clever enough like his team behind him sort of suggested to him that he didn't do any more interviews because he was up there and shut your mouth say no more going forward which was probably a clever political strategy in fairness so anyway we go on and you can nobody expects him to get anywhere and then the election and then the polls are coming in and by the saturday night he was i think almost a shoe in yeah and niall who's my my co-host rings me now i was actually out you know and a couple of glasses of wine in and he had been in the newsroom and he could feel the tide turning and a lot of kind of whispers about that podcast and, you know, hmm.
58:25And he was going, listen, it's looking like he might be getting in. And I'm going, great, no problem. We'll deal with it tomorrow, it'll be grand. So then the next morning I wake up and I'm going, oh my God, he's going to get in. Oh my goodness me, this is going to be, you know, stand your ground here. Because a lot of criticism was coming then about him getting a platform, about, you know, other politicians didn't get the same. platform. There was a lot of this kind of, you know, RTE talk shows and all this sort of stuff and then he didn't get in. But this sort of wave of almost cancellation came.
59:02I just had to put my head down. It was interesting. It was interesting and there was this kind of like, nobody really wanted to quite say it, but they were going around it. But I mean, you're talking, Simon Harris, everybody was, everyone who's been interviewed was talking about the platform he got. and of course he only got one platform. Anyway, we rode the wave and came out. And ironically, Pascal got in to keep him out. Democracy won at the end of the day. Thank you, Nicola. Maybe I should appear on Crime World the next time, the Minister for Finance. I've committed some very grievous crimes.
59:38I swear I have. There was the budget 2024. That was horrific. I robbed everybody blind. I almost, I pillaged and robbed them. I practically went up and took the wallet out of their pockets. So, I'm ready to confess. 7-1-7, 7-2-14, 7-3-21. Oh yeah, I don't think any of the rest will get those figures as I would like. No, I'm not looking for views. I don't want clicks. I'm a nice criminal. I'm a nice criminal. We'd be gassed if you interviewed all the criminals on Crime World, Crime World. Simon Harris, let me say I'm deeply proud of the crimes I've committed Nicola Tallent I've left bodies everywhere I swear I have killed people I'm proud of the killings I have done I've been a leader of a gang Fine Gael one of the dirtiest nastiest ringleaders of gangs in town we're running all sorts of stuff Brilliant Crime World the Fine Gael special They all wanted the same platform as he got so actually I should open the door You should.
1:00:46Well you can have it. Yeah. What the hell am I going to ask them? Like apart from apart from the the monk I mean and the seriousness of it which it is serious as any person who's involved in crime it is serious. He has that thing though that a few of them have which is charisma. He has a charisma. Dare I say almost I put it in movie terms kind of an almost Steve McQueen stillness to him. But he's also up to something and even... I know he's up to something. Jesus Christ. What do you think I'm stupid? I mean, I think of the understatement of the fucking century. Nicola Talent has come on my podcast and go, would you not think the monk is maybe up to something?
1:01:31After all your years and that's all you have left. I'll fuck off, Paul Reynolds. Of course I'm up to something. Have you ever heard of Brinks Allied? Come with the headline. Nicola Talent. I think monk may be up to something.
1:01:49That is the best. That is the best. We've just got there, Nicola. We've got there, yeah. This is what my whole career is about with a statement like that. That's like me saying, marry a Rosenstock. Do you think Flatley might be worth impersonating? Says Rosenstock. But he's up to something when he's doing that thing, when he's coming on a podcast. He's not just coming on because he's decided it's the moment to talk. He's sending a message. But that's... He's sending a message. But that adds to his aura as my son. It does. My 17-year-old son would call it. He has aura. It adds to his aura. Yeah, it does.
1:02:22But he's actually doing far more than he looks like what he's doing. He's given an interview and he's saying this and he's saying that. But he's actually taking back his city. Yeah. That's what he was doing from the Kinnahans. And if you look at the psychology of the whole thing and who they went to war with and everything. And even actually on New Year's, he actually sent me a photograph of himself in a silly hat. Right. and you know he sent the photograph we actually ran it in the paper there was nothing else on the go he knew you'd run it of course he did and he didn't send it for my personal collection you know what I mean we have got a totally and let me see I know what you I know what you said when you received the picture you said Niall I think he didn't send this just for my personal collection well bully fucking who Batman he sends it to the investigations out of the Sunday World just wild but we were in of course I mean it was a brilliant picture and he had a ridiculous hat on and all this sort of stuff and Happy New Year on it okay but Daniel Kinnaghan sent his hit men to kill him on New Year's Eve and that's a message that not everybody gets but I get that and that's what he was doing and I'm actually you know what we get a picture of the front page of the newspaper we are running something as well and you know if Daniel Kinnaghan probably wanted to send me a photograph we would have run that as well but it was a subliminal message I'm still here Yeah.
1:03:44Wow. You know, interesting. That's how the minds, they're always about two steps ahead of you. A little bit like an addict who's trying to get you into a corner to panned over a card at a bar or something. You always have to be thinking, you know, I cannot be charmed by this. This is a really, I'm enjoying the company of this person, but he's doing something here. He has a reason. He's not just sitting here talking to me because he thinks I'm OK. you know so interesting he's up to something yeah I knew it I knew it it only took us two hours to figure that out and 30 years that's class the monk is up to something I knew it we'll leave it with that folks monk is up to something watch this space exclusive from Nicola Talent next week in the crime world she also reveals that so maybe too is Daniel Kinahan but listen she's not sure yet bye bye
1:04:44And my thanks to Nicola Talent for coming in to talk to me about her fascinating life in the crime covering business. And my thanks to you, as always, for listening to this podcast. Please tell one other person if you can. That's all I ask about this podcast. Same time, same place next week, folks. Happy Easter. Take care.
From the publisher
While we’re on our short Christmas and New Year break we’re going back in to the vaults and replaying a couple of our most listened-to episodes of 2025 – enjoy!
As far as careers go, crime journalism is up there with one of the most, let’s say, ‘unique’. Its not for the faint hearted – you’re dealing with dangerous people who do terrible things, and your job is to make as big an audience as possible aware of the crimes they commit.
So who’d want to do a job like that? Well, Nicola Tallant for one. Nicola is one of Ireland’s best-known crime journalists. After years writing about crime, she then started talking about it on a podcast she created called Crime World – which is now one of the most-listened to podcasts in the country. She also does live stage shows, writes a book every year and regularly appears in the media.
In this episode of The Mario Rosenstock Podcast, Nicola and I talk about why she is so fascinated by crime journalism and what and drives her to work so hard at it. We also talk open and honestly about those characters we all seem to find so compelling, like Christy and Daniel Kinahan, Gerry the monk Hutch, and Conor McGregor. And there are also quite a few very funny moments.
COMEDY - Rory MclIroy’s phone is hopping after his big win at The Masters.
Produced by Patrick Haughey, AudioBrand
