GOP Makes Dramatic Shift After Identity of Killer Surfaces

13 Sep 2025 · 26 min · 14 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

The episode argues that right-wing media and politicians changed their messaging after the killer in Charlie Kirk’s killing was identified as Tyler Robinson, a 22-year-old white Mormon from a Trump-supporting family. It claims the earlier narrative (e.g., a transgender, “purple-haired” leftist) didn’t match the facts, so outlets pivoted to college/campus radicalization and specific institutions. Key claims include: extremist violence is disproportionately right-wing (citing a 2013–2022 chart), leaders’ divisive rhetoric fuels copycat violence, and mental health and gun policy are insufficiently addressed. Notable examples cited: Nancy Mace’s language shifting from “tranny killer” to “pray for him,” Trump’s “building a ballroom” response, and references to prior incidents like the Butler Trump assassination attempt.

Guests

none mentioned in the transcript.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Identity of the Killer Revealed

0:00 to 1:13

Discuss the dramatic shift in media narrative after the identity of the killer is revealed.

“Summer's supposed to be the easy season.”

Identity of the Killer Revealed

2:27 to 3:09

Discuss the dramatic shift in media narrative after the identity of the killer is revealed.

“Imagine buying your kid a toy only to find the batteries aren't included or buying furniture, but it's missing the tools to build it.”

Identity of the Killer Revealed

3:11 to 6:20

Discuss the dramatic shift in media narrative after the identity of the killer is revealed.

“There's been a major tone change in right-wing media by MAGA Republican Congress members and senators, and even by Donald Trump.”

Shifts in Political Rhetoric

6:20 to 7:32

Analyze the change in rhetoric from right-wing figures following the revelation.

“Here's what the mugshot of him looked like.”

Family Reactions and Background

7:32 to 10:24

Explore the background of the killer and reactions from his family.

“Robinson admitted to his dad that he was the person in the photos.”

Radicalization and Cultural Impacts

10:24 to 14:00

Examine the issues of radicalization among young men and cultural influences.

“wannabe, vigilante, revolutionary accelerator types with this language that's taking place.”

Tone Shift in GOP Leadership

14:00 to 14:54

Discussion on the changing tone among GOP leaders regarding personal accountability and relationships.

“But here's the tone change now from John Curtis.”

Nancy Mace's Victim Narrative

14:54 to 16:14

Analysis of Nancy Mace's narrative on hate and threats she faces as a politician.

“She then goes on CNN and then she plays the victim.”

Kash Patel's Controversial Remarks

16:14 to 17:38

Examination of Kash Patel's comments and the narrative surrounding the identity of a shooter.

“You then have, I mean, this scene right here will never cease to amaze me.”

Trump's Shift in Messaging

17:38 to 18:54

Discussion on Donald Trump's response to the shooting tragedy and the implications of his focus on a ballroom.

“And by the way, right there, you see all the Trumps.”
Show all 14 chapters

Statistics on Extremism

18:54 to 20:56

Presentation of statistics showing the prevalence of right-wing extremism compared to left-wing extremism.

“Overwhelmingly, right-wing extremism from 2013 to 2022, and even if you extend that to the presence, significantly higher than left-wing.”

Mental Health and Youth Issues

20:56 to 22:31

Exploration of mental health issues among youth and their connection to violence.

“So when we're now dealing with a population of young people who feel that they don't have a future ahead of them.”

Common Sense Gun Reform and Violence

22:31 to 24:48

Discussion on the need for common sense gun reform in the context of recent violence.

“But I think we also have to understand and we have to address that specifically people who look like Tyler Robinson are very frequently the people involved in these incidents.”

Final Thoughts on Recent Events

24:48 to 25:01

Host reflects on recent events and invites listener engagement.

“I'm not sure how many more videos I'll do on the Charlie, this may help round it out, but I'll let you, those are my thoughts on where I stand.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Summer's supposed to be the easy season. So why are so many people quietly googling a therapist between summer Fridays? Because more daylight doesn't fix the hard stuff. Sometimes it just turns the volume up. Grow does therapy differently. Therapy is not only for when you're in crisis. Grow Therapy is here for all the moments when you decide you want more. More support, more clarity, more tools. Mental health isn't a destination you reach. It's something you build, and Grow makes that easier. Grow connects you with thousands of high-quality licensed therapists across the U.S., offering both virtual and in-person sessions, nights and weekends.

0:42You can search by what matters, like insurance, specialty, identity, or availability, and get started in as little as two days. There are no subscriptions, no long-term commitments. You just pay per session. Grow helps you find therapy on your time. The therapist you want takes your insurance on Grow. Grow accepts over 125 insurance plans. Sessions average$21 with insurance and some pay as little as$0 depending on their plan. Visit growtherapy.com slash booknow today to get started. That's growtherapy.com slash booknow. growtherapy.com slash booknow. Availability and coverage vary by state in insurance plan.

1:26Ever wonder why scam calls feel so specific? Why they somehow already know your name, your city, or even your address? it's usually because of data brokers. These companies collect your personal information from across the internet and sell it online, usually without you even realizing it. Things like your phone number, home address, family members, and even places you've lived. And once your information is out there, it spreads fast. That's where Aura comes in. Aura automatically finds your personal information on data broker sites and submits removal requests for you. Then Aura keeps monitoring to help make sure your information stays gone.

2:06You can even see where your data was found and removed. And Aura goes beyond data removal. You also get a VPN, antivirus, password manager, spam call protection, dark web monitoring, and up to$5 million in identity theft insurance. Right now, you can try Aura free at Aura.com slash hidden. That's Aura.com slash hidden. Imagine buying your kid a toy only to find the batteries aren't included or buying furniture, but it's missing the tools to build it. Frustrating, right? Now imagine that exact same feeling, but you're paying way more. That is what buying business software usually feels like. Fragmented, disconnected, and incredibly expensive.

2:48Odoo completely changes that. Odoo is a complete, fully integrated business suite where all your apps actually talk to each other. We're talking automated lead routing for your sales team, seamless AI integration, and an intuitive point-and-click website builder. It's everything your business needs to scale, saving you time, headaches, and money. Stop piecing your software together. Go to odoo.com. That's O-D-O-O dot com to learn more.

3:14Ben Meiselas:There's been a major tone change in right-wing media by MAGA Republican Congress members and senators, and even by Donald Trump. now that the identity of Charlie Kirk's killer has been made public. And the fact that it was a white 22-year-old Mormon from a family that were Trump supporters, Tyler Robinson, the murderer, his political affiliation is really unknown at this point. There are some people who are saying, well, he's a griper, he's a right-wing guy, it's so obvious. There are other people saying, no, he's a left-wing person and whatever. But at the end of the day, he did not fit the profile or the narrative that the White House wanted.

4:08Ben Meiselas:I guess they wanted it to be what a purple-haired, Latino, transgender person, and that they were spreading that as the character of who the killer was going to be. But unfortunately, rather predictably, the killer here has actually fit the pattern of what we've seen over and over again in school shootings, What we saw in the assassination attempt of Donald Trump in Butler, Pennsylvania, where there, same thing, right wing was pushing a narrative and it turned out that it was a Trump supporting family, very familiar with guns, very similar to what we are seeing here. So just look at the change in the language that we are seeing.

5:00Ben Meiselas:So Nancy Mace was all on TV and she was saying, we know that the killer, her words, I know it's offensive, but her words, is a tranny and it's a tranny killer on the loose. And this was the Democrat leftist tranny plot. She literally used those words. Here's what she's saying now. Basically, we need to pray for the killer. That's the stage. Now that it's a 22-year-old white kid, white family, Mormon, Utah, families close with the Mormon church there. Oh, my God. We got to pray for them. I mean, look what she says. We truly believe if Tyler Robinson had ever sat down across from Charlie, the great debater, the man of faith and grace he was, Tyler would not have pulled the trigger.

5:59Ben Meiselas:And then she goes, we know Charlie Kirk would want us to pray for such an evil and a lost individual like Tyler Robinson to find Jesus Christ. We will try to do the same. Or is it because here are the photos of him? Here are the photos of him. He dressed up on Halloween in a Donald Trump costume. Here are the photos of him. He posed as Pepe the Frog in that meme. Here's what the mugshot of him looked like. This is what Nancy Mace was saying yesterday. Here's what she said. Play this clip. This shit ends. Enough is enough. And now I have to deal with real safety concerns. It sounds like the shooter was a tranny or pro-tranny.

6:48And just because I want to protect women that I'm worried about getting murdered? Are you fucking kidding me? It's out of control. And enough is enough. And I'm going to double down on this. I'm going to be more vigilant than ever. I'm going to be louder than I've ever been until this shit stops. It's got to stop.

7:06Ben Meiselas:Now we must pray for him now that she knows the identity. Let's just stick to the facts, folks. Here's the latest of what we know. Jennifer Jacobs recounts the facts. The Midas Touch Network, I just want to give you the facts. The father of the 22-year-old charged in Charlie Kirk's killing saw the photos released by authorities and confronted his son, law enforcement sources told CBS. Robinson admitted to his dad that he was the person in the photos. His father urged him to turn himself in, but the son said he'd rather commit suicide, the sources said. The father called a pastor who knows the son.

7:50Ben Meiselas:The pastor called the U.S. Marshal and other law enforcement agencies. Tyler Robinson is being held on aggravated murder, obstruction of justice, felony discharge of a firearm. CBS reports he is a third-year student in the electrical apprenticeship program at Dixie Technical College. He briefly attended Utah State University for just one semester when he was 21, I think, for one semester. The father owns a business, in 2021, rather, for one semester. The father owns a business installing kitchen countertops and cabinets. His mother is a licensed social worker. The Robinsons are Mormon and active in the church.

8:40Ben Meiselas:Tyler is the oldest of three, believe a family of three boys, three white boys. Grandma of Charlie Kirk's assassin breaks her silence to reveal why the FBI must have the wrong man. It's a headline from the Daily Mail, but Daily Beast also reports the following. The grandma spoke to the Daily Mail on Friday after news of Robinson's arrest broke. So this is the grandma. She goes, my son, his dad is a Republican for Trump. Debbie told the outlet, most of my family members are Republican. I don't know anyone who's a Democrat. According to the outlet, that Robinson's father, Matt, 48, was the one to turn Tyler in.

9:27Ben Meiselas:Debbie has not been able to get in touch with her son since the news of her grandson's arrest went public. I'm just so confused, Debbie said of her grandson's arrest. Tyler's the shyest person. He has never, ever spoke politics to me at all. She insisted that Robinson has never, ever got in trouble in his life. well maybe you didn't know all of that and maybe there's a deeper issue that we need to talk about young men particularly young white men who are getting drawn into this internet culture and they're being pulled in to these extremist websites and extremist views or just being radicalized in general, and I don't even have to say radicalized to be extremist rights or radicalized to be this, but just generally radicalized to envision themselves as these wannabe, vigilante, revolutionary accelerator types with this language that's taking place.

10:43Ben Meiselas:I'll talk about that in a moment as well. And then I want to show you some hard data. Again, I just want to stick to the data here. But so then Fox has to adapt its narrative, right? Because, oh my God, the leftist, liberal, transgender, purple-haired killer that they were saying existed to try to, again, bully a marginalized community as they always have, to scapegoat the other people just trying to live. It's the transgender community trying to live, love, breathe, constantly being bullied by right wing over and over again and scapegoated for things. They have to change it. So now what do they go with?

11:25Ben Meiselas:Now they go with, well, he did attend one semester at college. So let's blame that one semester at Utah State University as radicalizing him. So that's what Fox goes with. As Max Steele writes, oh yes, the hotbed of leftist militancy, the electrical apprenticeship program at Utah's Dixie Technical College. That's where he's been spending the last few years. But no, they go, it was that one semester in 2021 where he attended Utah State University. That changed. Come on. But this is what Fox is going with now. play this clip. It is a good point. I want to point something else out. You heard the family members say that this man became more political.

12:14This young man became more political in recent years. Well, what did he do in recent years? He went to college. That's where kids are getting radicalized. It's not just online. Our campuses are where a lot of radicalization, hate and intolerance starts from. And so when he says it's an attack on all of us, I'm going to say this. No, it's an attack on conservatives. It's an attack on Christians.

12:39Ben Meiselas:Okay. And now also you have, you know, these MAGA Republican senators like John Curtis from Utah, he goes on and he's like, you know, it would be very nice that we had, you know, leadership from the top down, spreading these messages of bringing people together. But it really should be a bottom-up movement. So in other words, what he's saying is, let's just give Trump not only absolute immunity from his actions the way the Supreme Court does, but Trump can be immune from acting with moral clarity or moral authority. This must come from the bottom up. Now, I agree that we, the people, need to be more empathetic.

13:27Ben Meiselas:We need to get out of our internet bubbles and see people and show love and respect each other. And that starts with respecting what make this country great, diversity, other people's rights and their independence, their right to be who they are and live their lives with dignity. Let me be very clear about that. But also, people in leadership positions should lead by example and not be bullying and spreading division and hate as Donald Trump does from the Oval Office and as we see right-wing leaders do over and over again. But here's the tone change now from John Curtis. Play this clip. So let me tell you, and I've actually written on this a number of years ago, when I feel like I saw this coming.

14:13And at the time I said, look, in a perfect world, this would be top down. This would be coming from our leaders. But I also have great hope in what I would call a bottom up approach. And I think every one of us, every one of us every morning should wake up, look in the mirror and see what we are doing with our own personal relationships and the family and with our neighbors, what our comments are, how we're responding. I think both, Jim, are critically important. I would love it if we had both. But I actually think if we don't have both, we start with a bottom up. And each of us, including myself, constantly ask ourselves what we are doing to improve the situation.

14:53Ben Meiselas:Now, the tone shift from Nancy Mace. She then goes on CNN and then she plays the victim. And she goes, you know, it's just I get so much hate. I mean, they're all going after me. Let's make this, let's make this about me. Watch her do that after you heard what she said in the first clip, play this clip. Well, certainly, but right now, because it's very one-sided right now, the way that we've been, I have never called one of my colleagues, the kind of names that we've been called. I've never dehumanized my colleagues. In fact, when I've agreed with a Democrat, I've said, so I'm actually, regardless of the press actually covers me.

15:34I'm the 22nd most bipartisan member of Congress. If you're willing to work with me, I'm willing to work with you. That has always been the message. But because I'm outspoken about rape, because I'm outspoken about survivors, I face a different kind of threat. It is all the time. It's imminent. And I fear just walking around trying to be a normal person, trying to be a good, hardworking member of Congress. And I have real deep-rooted, realistic threats that are coming through every single day. And I fear just walking out in public is dangerous to my life. No one should have that fear. But I always appreciate you coming in and have a conversation with me.

16:12Thank you. Always. Thank you. John.

16:14Ben Meiselas:You then have, I mean, this scene right here will never cease to amaze me. Kash Patel, the completely unqualified podcaster, maybe he was qualified to be a podcaster, probably unqualified for that too, turned FBI director, the head of the FBI. And what does he think? He's like acting in a freaking movie here. He goes, Charlie, my brother, I will see you in Valhalla. Valhalla. What are we even doing here? Here play this clip. Lastly, to my friend, Charlie Kirk. Rest now, brother. We have the watch and I'll see you in Valhalla.

16:59Ben Meiselas:And then you saw the shift of Trump even developing a little bit before we even knew the identity. But I think as it became clear that the killer was not fitting the narrative that MAGA wanted out there, I think Trump and others started to know. And then when Trump was asked a question, so how are you handling Charlie Kirk's law? How are you coping? Donald Trump's response, I'm building a ballroom. Do you see the ballroom I'm building? Here, play this clip. If I could go up and get a law to defense, how are you holding up over the last three and a half days? I think very good. And by the way, right there, you see all the Trumps.

17:41They just started construction of the new ballroom for the White House, which is something they've been trying to get, as you know, for about 150 years. And it's going to be a beauty. It'll be an absolute magnificent construction. And I just see all the trucks we just started. So it'll get done very nicely and it'll be one of the best anywhere in the world, actually. Take it, sir. You're messaging. You're messaging.

18:07Ben Meiselas:As this account says. So Charlie Kirk dedicated a decade of his life to fueling causes that benefit Donald Trump, activating the youth and converting them, being a soldier for the right, so on and so forth. Now in death, after the shooter was identified and not somebody that can be politicized by his party, Donald Trump devoted half of a second to Charlie Kirk before plugging his new White House ballroom right there. Again, let me stick to the stats right here just so you can see it. If we look at extremist linked deaths from 2013 to 2022, for example, you'll see a much smaller portion of incidents and killings happen from the left wing, very small amounts.

18:54Ben Meiselas:Overwhelmingly, right-wing extremism from 2013 to 2022, and even if you extend that to the presence, significantly higher than left-wing. Left-wing is only a small amount there, and you see a very small amount domestic Islamist extremism as well right there. Also, Trump basically got rid of our counterterrorism division in the FBI and put this guy Thomas Fugate III, a 22-year-old intern with no law enforcement experience, to now lead counter-domestic terrorism efforts. And they're not even focusing on any type of right wing extremism. But look, you know, there are people who will read what's on the fuel on the cartridges, you know, from the from the murder weapon.

19:40Ben Meiselas:And there are people who say, look, what is written on this? Notice bulges. O.W.O. What's this? That that's like a meme online meme culture of like furries or something. Hey, fascists, catch up arrow, right arrow, three down arrows. That's a code from a game called Hell Divers to activate a certain type of bomb in this digital game. Or, oh, Bella Ciao, Bella Ciao, Ciao, Ciao, another expression that's frequently used. If you read this, you are gay, LMAO. Again, more references to kind of online meme culture right there. The phrase, hey, fascists, catch this. some people say are associated with far-right internet-based movements.

20:28Ben Meiselas:You see that on 410. But again, let's talk about an issue that's very important here that I don't want to ignore, and it was data that I saw today. Joe Weisenthal posted this. Never looked at this chart before, but if you look at the University of Michigan consumer sentiment among people ages 18 to 34 versus the overall consumer sentiment. When it's green, it means younger people are more optimistic than the general public. In 30 years, we've never seen the sustained relative gloominess among the young. So when we're now dealing with a population of young people who feel that they don't have a future ahead of them.

21:14Ben Meiselas:And they're not involved in healthy relationships. These young boys and men, not getting everything from online, again, not interacting on a healthy basis with people outside, not having relationships with people and the other sex, not having healthy interactions in general and going deeper, deeper, deeper down, deeper down these paths very frequently when we're seeing, okay, who's the shooter in a sense like this, whether it's the person who was involved in the first assassination attempt of Trump and Butler, whether it's the individual right here, whatever. We're seeing that that fits the profile more frequently over and over again.

22:07Ben Meiselas:And it's not a transgender shooter as Donald Trump would say. It's people who look and act like Tyler Robinson. And so when we talk about it, it's like you can send your thoughts and prayers. Okay, well, that's not enough. MAGA is defunding mental health. We need mental health. Absolutely. Focus on that a lot. we also need to these families are often gun toting this was what this family the mom amber the mother gun toting gun toting okay well that's another commonality here but i'm a second i believe in the second amendment but we need to have common sense gun reform as well but i believe in the second amendment but i don't think these weapons of war should be proliferating around our country like the ones used in this i just don't think those are the types of weapons that should be out there I understand that for hunting and for other things, but I don't think for purposes like this.

23:06Ben Meiselas:But I think we also have to understand and we have to address that specifically people who look like Tyler Robinson are very frequently the people involved in these incidents. And whether you say that's because they've been radicalized here or radicalized there, they're getting radicalized. And what I noticed here particularly is the very first thing that right-wing people, leaders at the highest level, wanted to do is say, this is leftist liberal Democrats. And it's the political. As leaders, what we called for on the Midas Touch Network is we condemned all types of violence. We condemn this in the fullest extent.

23:49Ben Meiselas:And again, I'll leave you with this because I remember during the Charleston church shooting where nine African-Americans in Bible study were killed, it was clear that the motives were anti-Black. Dylann Roof killed Black people. That was part of the plan that he's wanted. And we've seen that happen quite frequently as well. And former President Obama didn't go, oh, well, at this point in time, we got to blame Republicans. No, he brought the country together. He gave a speech of unifying. And that didn't happen here. And when that doesn't happen, there's a domino effect. And this begets more violence.

24:30Ben Meiselas:This begets more Tyler Robinsons. That's what happens when you have from the White House this division. And then they just move on to the next one. Move on, move on, move on, create a new issue. Let's talk about this now. And then they're done. but the damage is long lasting. So that's my overall perspective on this. I'm not sure how many more videos I'll do on the Charlie, this may help round it out, but I'll let you, those are my thoughts on where I stand. Tell me what you think. Hit subscribe and let's get to 6 million subscribers. Hey, it's Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile. Now I was looking for fun ways to tell you that Mint's offer of unlimited premium wireless for$15 a month is back.

25:12So I thought it would be fun if we made$15 bills. But it turns out that's very illegal. So there goes my big idea for the commercial. Give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of$45 for three months, $90 for six months, or$180 for 12-month plan required. $15 per month equivalent. Taxes and fees extra. Initial plan term only. Greater than 50 gigabytes may slow when network is busy. See terms. Every company is investing in AI, but most only have a small group actually using it, and a large group who tried and didn't see the value. Superhuman fixes that. From the makers of Grammarly, Superhuman brings AI into every tool your team already uses for instant help with drafts, finding information, and more.

25:52So habits and proficiency form naturally. When every person on your team works at their best, that's when your AI investments start to compound. See what Superhuman can do at superhuman.com. Hey, Chicagoland. Wayfair's Black Friday in July sale is coming to the Wayfair store. From July 23rd through 27th, you can score up to 80 % off everything home in person. Like up to 80 % off area rugs, up to 60 % off outdoor furniture, and up to 60 % off mattresses. Take home the small stuff that day and get the big stuff shipped fast and free right to your door. Shop the sale July 23rd through 27th at the Wayfair store at Edens Plaza in Wilmette.

26:32Wayfair, every style, every home.

From the publisher

MeidasTouch host Ben Meiselas reports on how GOP messaging has shifted now that Charlie Kirk’s killer has been identified as a 22-year-old white man from a Mormon family of Trump voters.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from The MeidasTouch Podcast

All 2,216 episodes
GOP Makes Dramatic Shift After Identity of Killer SurfacesThe MeidasTouch Podcast · 26 min
Listen in VO