In short
Preseason Week One “winners and losers” focused on quarterback competitions (Browns: Shedeur Sanders vs Dylan Gabriel; Colts: Daniel Jones vs Anthony Richardson; Saints: Spencer Rattler vs Jake Haener/Shuck), plus standout rookie performances (Titans’ Cam Ward; Giants’ Abdul Carter) and a Bengals defensive reality check.
Guests
Ben Solak (football writer/analyst; attended multiple NFL training camps; Indianapolis-based during recording). Mina Kimes is referenced as a prior guest/clip source, but not as a guest here.
Key claims
- Shedeur Sanders’ 14/23, 138 yards, 2 TD preseason start was “much better than round five quarterbacks typically look,” making a case for QB2 at minimum, despite early pocket-bailing issues.
- Colts: Daniel Jones looked like the same steady RPO quarterback, but Tyler Warren’s translation as a middle-field focal point stood out; Richardson’s injury limits conclusions.
- Saints: neither QB looked great; offensive line problems and receivers not getting open hurt both, though Shuck’s two-minute drive was encouraging.
Notable examples
- Sanders’ layered end-zone TD and a “shuffle then rip” dig throw; contrast with his early bails.
- Colts’ RPO structure and Warren’s downfield presence.
- Titans: Cam Ward’s quick-pocket throws, especially a precise deep ball to Calvin Ridley.
- Giants: Abdul Carter beating elite tackle Dion Dawkins with an inside move; Bengals: Tanner McKee’s strong showing (23/30, 300 yards) highlights defensive concerns.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOPreseason Football Talk: Shedeur Sanders
0:57 to 4:12
Analysis of Shedeur Sanders' performance in his first preseason game.
“just scrolling through TikTok, burning the time, and I got a Seth Meyers TikTok for preseason football with Mina Kimes sitting in the guest chair.”
Quarterback Comparisons and Draft Analysis
4:13 to 6:24
Discussion on quarterback depth charts and draft narratives surrounding Sanders.
“where it's still Flacco and Shador at the bottom, but in my mind, he has made a case for himself as QB2 at minimum.”
Evaluating Quarterback Competitions
6:25 to 11:33
Examining the quarterback competitions in Cleveland and Indianapolis.
“And let's just see if we happen to hit one of these start throws.”
Daniel Jones and RPO Offense Insights
11:34 to 14:00
Overview of Daniel Jones' performance and the RPO offense under Shane Steichen.
“but we didn't give him enough first team reps in August to make the switch.”
Daniel Jones in Shane Steichen's Offense
14:00 to 18:04
Discussion of Daniel Jones's performance in the Colts' preseason game and his fit in Shane Steichen's offensive scheme.
“It was interesting to watch him in Shane Steichen's offense.”
Tyler Warren's Impact on the Offense
18:04 to 20:44
Analysis of Tyler Warren's performance and his potential as a key player in the Colts' offense.
“And when you go and you look at Jones's downfield passing when he was with the Giants, a lot of it was like he doesn't like the Darius Slayton player as much.”
Saints Quarterback Competition
20:44 to 24:18
Evaluation of the Saints' quarterback competition focusing on Shuck and Rattler's performances.
“And I think Bortolini is a smaller player, and he's good at what he's good at.”
Calvin Ridley's Role in the Jaguars Offense
24:18 to 28:01
An analysis of Calvin Ridley's performance and his chemistry with the Jaguars' new quarterback.
“he kind of looks like he did in college.”
Impressive Quarterback Play
28:01 to 29:41
Discussing standout performances of rookie quarterbacks, particularly focusing on ball placement and decision-making.
“I loved the ball placement on the deep over to Ridley.”
JJ McCarthy's Performance Review
29:41 to 31:40
Analyzing JJ McCarthy's drive, decision-making under pressure, and how he managed his injury comeback.
“I think you just heard exactly what I'm trying to say, which is like there was a lot of things that I felt like will translate versus starters in real action.”
Show all 19 chapters
Jackson Dart's Showcasing
31:40 to 35:04
Exploring Jackson Dart's performance, including his touchdown throw and overall composure under pressure.
“I mean, he barely played this one drive, right?”
Giants Defensive Line Potential
36:41 to 42:00
Debating the potential of the Giants' defensive line, focusing on rookie Abdul Carter and team dynamics.
“This year, the award-winning HBO original Hard Knocks training camp heads to Seattle to follow the Super Bowl champion Seahawks.”
Concerns About Bengals' Defense
42:00 to 44:31
Discussion on the struggles and potential solutions for the Bengals' defense.
“like maybe they're unfortunately on the field a lot and teams are able to run the ball and all of that.”
Tanner McKee's Potential
44:31 to 46:50
Analyzing Tanner McKee's performance and potential as an NFL starter.
“So it's a little unfair to say that Tanner McKee dog walked the starters because Hendrickson didn't play.”
Trade Value of Tanner McKee
46:50 to 49:30
Debating Tanner McKee's trade value and the implications for the Eagles.
“He was a high caliber recruit who just missed some time at Stanford.”
T-Mac's NFL Performance
49:30 to 53:02
Evaluating T-Mac's performance and his fit in the Panthers' offense.
“Like this is the day two pick a quarterback.”
Concerns About the Raiders' Offensive Line
56:22 to 59:16
Discussion on the potential issues facing the Raiders' offensive line and how it could impact their season.
“Should Raiders fans be worried that the offensive line might limit this offensive potential?”
The Impact of Cam Little's Kicking Range
59:16 to 1:00:30
Exploration of how having a reliable kicker affects game strategy and decision-making.
“because they have the greatest weapon in football cam little on their side 70 yard field goal for those who missed this incredible moment.”
Rashawn Slater's Injury and Chargers' Prospects
1:00:30 to 1:06:06
Analysis of the implications of Rashawn Slater's injury on the Chargers' offense and offensive line dynamics.
“like on the Tuesday before the preseason game, did the special teams coach come to Cohen and be like, listen, our range is, you know, to our 45 yard line.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00Get your tickets now for the Dog Stars. It's no surprise how fast civilization can disappear. Out there, just kill or be killed. Jacob Alordi. There are people out there. They need our help. Josh Brolin. Shoot first and inquire afterwards. Margaret Qualley. Okay, tough guy. And Guy Pearce. Arm up! The Dog Stars. Directed by Ridley Scott. In theaters August 28th. Get tickets now. Rated R. Under 17, not a middle without parents.
0:34Welcome back to the Meanie Kime Show featuring Lenny. First preseason football edition. We have actual football to talk about. Real snaps, real players. I'm joined by a real live boy, fresh off touring training camps, which is why he's so tan for the audio audience. Ben Solak, welcome back to the show. Thank you. Thank you. I was sitting in my hotel in Indianapolis, Indiana, just scrolling through TikTok, burning the time, and I got a Seth Meyers TikTok for preseason football with Mina Kimes sitting in the guest chair. That was sick. Seth Meyers, huge preseason football sicko, I learned. He was like, he saw the, we're going to talk about Travis Hunter, the rep of Caleb Johnson on Travis Hunter.
1:23He's a Steelers fan. um yeah no that was really fun it's on youtube if anyone wants to go watch um i sent you a list of mostly quarterbacks to dive into because this is our first look at a few of the quarterbacks and then i also uh want you to play a game with me called is this real where we decide how real certain things are such as cam little nailing every field goal from 70 plus yards this is It's actually a weirdly big story, I think. But yeah, I feel like the quarterbacks are the natural place to start. We are now a few days removed from Shador Sanders completely taking over everybody's timeline.
2:10Overreactions, underreactions. Unsurprisingly, there were a lot of feelings about his first start. I wanted to start there with you. We're going to talk about, again, we're going to talk about the Colts that you're in Indianapolis, the Colts quarterback competition, if we call it that. The Saints are in a quarterback competition. I want to talk to you about Cam Ward getting – got a first look at him, which is really interesting. But we're going to start with Shador. 14 for 23, 138 yards, two touchdowns. I think I'll go first. The first few reps, I was pretty worried, I'm not going to lie, especially when you know I think it was early on he had a couple of those bad bails the likes of which we saw in college where he's you know got really and we could talk about this I think it didn't seem like he's quite there yet in terms of understanding what he is and isn't capable of physically and going against the Panthers backups again I know I sound like I'm just diminishing him right off the bat but you can't there are things you can get away with in those games that he will not be able to get away with in terms of fleeing the pocket against better competition however as it went on i think you also saw some of the traits that i liked about him in college notably the accuracy the touch um the ability to access the middle of the field which is why i always thought he was kind of an interesting fit for kevin stufanski's offense and a couple of really nice balls obviously the touchdowns um one of which was like a really lovely layered throw to the back of the end zone.
3:41I thought the throw he made backed up in his own, it was maybe around the 10 or so, where instead of fleeing the pocket, he just did a little shuffle to the right and then ripped the dig. That was really encouraging. So, you know, ups and downs. But I think if we're talking about a quarterback who was, you know, QB4 in the competition was not getting reps with the ones going into this and then was thrust into the game because of all the injuries, I think that's a win for him, honestly. I know that they're going to roll out their death chart where it's still Flacco and Shador at the bottom, but in my mind, he has made a case for himself as QB2 at minimum.
4:20Yeah, I think that the first emphatic thing to say is, right, this is much better than round five quarterbacks typically look in the preseason, right? And then the early and immediate response is, well, he was a much better prospect than the round five quarterbacks typically are, right? And that brings us back to the drama of April, right? It brings us back to the fall and okay, he didn't go round one, but surely he'll go day two and then he doesn't go day two. And then that's just the driving narrative for the entire day three, the NFL draft is how is Sanders still falling? What team will end up grabbing him and how will the team that does draft him end up dealing with the hype and dealing with the expectations from the fan base and the players in the locker room who are going to want the Sanders magic.
4:58And I hesitate to call it a sideshow because it's not actually a sideshow. It's kind of really more front and center, but all of the off field stuff, you know field periphery stuff that comes with a qb4 so clearly talent wise he is better than we expect for a fifth round quarterback okay we all we saw that in colorado we say that here great excellent whatever not getting to see gabriel makes it trickier right because you do wonder okay like it would have been nice to get a frame of reference for the other rookie where's he at in his pocket management right you brought up the the dig to lavardi and the the that backed up there like that's like a nice veteran pocket managing sort of okay if you can do this every single time we can make an offense around you sort of a play that to me shows that he's feeling stuff out he's figuring things out in terms of nfl speed it'd be great to if we had seen gabriel back there either do the same or do the exact opposite right and like you know have his panic moments and like you know like sander's had in his first drive because then you get a better sense of like okay is he so clearly outpacing gabriel that the draft capital doesn't matter or is this probably still yeah he's qb4 because they invest in an earlier pick in the top guy and that's just typically how it goes on depth charts right teams double dip a lot and it's really hard to break the double dip expectations it usually takes a couple of off seasons and so clearly better than we might have thought for a player of his draft capital enough to like tectonically shift the browns quarterback room i can't answer that yet yeah the so gabriel and pickett i think both have hamstring injuries and up to this point i said this again they've been they've been the ones right and even in this game you're seeing shooter sanders he's playing with backups i mean it's mostly players frankly i was learning of for the first time the guy who caught the that uh the beautiful one-handed touch or the one-handed catch down the sideline where sure kind of escaped and then he kind of layered it over the linebacker i i floria was his name i was like dang all right i i'm looking right i think i saw that which is a bummer but yeah it is hard to have like a pure quarterback competition when it's just such a mess.
6:59And I think your point about Gabriel and the comp is significant because, and I've said this from the beginning with the Browns this year, their whole approach to the position was just, let's just throw a ton of resources at it. Let's not spend a lot on it. And let's just see if we happen to hit one of these start throws. I also think it's very important to them to find a quarterback who will run Kevin Stefanski's offense. This was a lot of the drama with Deshaun Watson. Well, many things with Deshaun Watson, but one of the many reasons why that whole experiment failed was they felt like a clash of ideas.
7:35The quarterback and the play caller didn't see eye to eye. They tried to bend the offense to make it more Deshaun Watson-like, but he was not the kind of quarterback at this point who you build an offense around. It was just exercising futility. So you get Flacco back, who you know you can run the offense with. They draft Dylan Gabriel, who I believe they drafted because they believed he was a good fit for Kevin Stefanski's offense. And then you have Sanders. And I really, Ben, I keep going back to this in terms of my pre-draft thoughts on him. I genuinely believe if he cuts down on the pocket bailing, which is by far, I think, the biggest sting on him and was the biggest sting in this game, he can run this offense.
8:19he is like you get you like the throws we were talking to are the ones you have to make to run this and i you know i mentioned the dig um backed up in his own as though the second touchdown i think it was the one that was in or i don't think it was second it was the one not the one that was the like touch ball to the back um but it was like um to davis i think yeah kate and davis they run the clear out and then they run the in cut behind it yeah little dino in the red zone baby we love it the little switch release on the right with the double and that was another example i thought of sanders little sidestep doesn't flee the pocket fires it in and i'm thinking i'm watching that i'm thinking yeah if he can do this this can work i'm not gonna say it's gonna be amazing i'm not saying that you know he's this you know there are folks already like taking victory laps on social media.
9:14I mean, it really felt like both the positives and the negatives around Shador, like the overreactions, whether it was like people saying, see, he was, you know, this, I see Joe Burrow or whatever. I know I'm doing a little bit of straw manning or people saying like, oh, he's walking in with like, this is why people didn't want him. Cause he was walking in with his like teammates doing a little gag. It almost felt like neither of these people had ever watched preseason football before. Like, can we just like that both ways? This entire week one of preseason has been a lot of, have we ever seen preseason football before?
9:46I know. Some of the victory, we'll talk about some of the other quarterbacks and stuff. But in any case, yeah, I felt like he certainly made a case for himself to continue competing. I think that's kind of where I come down with this. And I had him over Gabriel. in my estimation, we got to see Gabriel. That's the quarterback competition, though. I think you're right to single that. Like those are the two guys who if you're a Browns fan, you want one of them to win, even if they end up starting Joe Fajaco to begin with. Yeah. And that's why I think the really important thing for those hoping to see Shidor Sanders start a game for the Cleveland Browns this season, of which I firmly count myself as one.
10:30I would very much like to see that. Firstly, it'd be a great week. All right. We do a lot of fun stuff beforehand. man there'd be a ton of like you'd write the the stadium entrance i would dig it but even just from a like i had the guy qb2 i thought he was underdrafted i think he's talented enough to play in the nfl i would like to see him play that game so for those of us who are in that camp we really want to see him play a game what he did against the panthers in the third quarter with the third stringers against their backups is remarkably more significant than whether or not he's getting first team reps in camp i promise you it is like first team reps in camp sound like a really big deal.
11:04And as somebody who was just at like 11 training camps, when the first team goes out there, they have two illegal formation penalties and they throw a bunch of day one install West Coast concepts. And then when the second team goes out there, they do the exact same thing. And teams and coaching staffs are scripting practices and scripting plays and making opportunities and asking players to do weird things outside of their comfort zone, just to learn and just information gather. I promise you there will not be a moment in week six where Kevin Stefanski and Tommy Reese sit down and they go, man, we'd like to start Sanders this week, but we didn't give him enough first team reps in August to make the switch.
11:37I assure you it will not be prohibitive to us getting that action if and when he continues to stay on the roster. He does well as quarterback too. He's preparing nicely. A quarterback in front of him gets hurt, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. Yeah. I think proof of concept is kind of what you're just getting more and more proof of concept. Even the nice touchdown that everybody's focused, the touch throw that was under center booting to his left. Yeah. He wasn't under center a lot in college. So, but now you're saying, okay, like this is where we're, I noticed by the way, a lot of the young quarterbacks were under center in preseason.
12:13I feel like a lot of these coordinators really want to get him those reps. All right. Well, if Schroeder Sanders was a, I feel comfortable saying a week one winner. We have to say Anthony Richardson was a week one loser. and it's unfair you know you feel bad saying player got injured but he is loser not so far as his play which we barely saw but there's a quarterback competition in Indianapolis that's far more like whoever wins this one is starting between him and Daniel Jones and it's a big setback for him I think I was choking with the fantasy guys Danny and Danny on their pod the second that uh he got sacked because he didn't throw hot it was like all the film guys on the internet had all this pent-up film energy and they they were like everybody was putting out their like 10-minute breakdowns i was like i mean each video each video got longer than the last one right somebody put out a three-minute video this time empty protection works the next one was five the next one was 10 and i was just like man we have we are starved we are just a parched and desperate film watching generation we needed it uh there's very little to take from him you know he i think his first completion was he was under center too it was a like a deep comeback or something to ad uh mitchell who was good to see him getting a lot of action out there he hit war on an rpo that to me was much more about like tyler warren who we'll talk about in a second who got a lot of run in this game, sat too long in a clean pocket on like a deep post after that, and then the sack happens.
13:52So he's out. So Daniel Jones comes in and looks like Daniel Jones. I went back and I watched because he played a lot in this game. It was interesting to watch him in Shane Steichen's offense. I'll say that, first of all, because you saw this is why they brought in Daniel Jones, I believe, is Shane Steichen's belief that like, okay, you know, we can, you know, we can run some QB run with him. We can, he's going to be, you know, it's a lot of RPO, a lot of so many RPOs in this game, by the way. He's going to be fairly accurate on the underneath stuff, not really pushing the ball downfield too much.
14:27And that's what you saw. Like there were some drops apparently continuing with the Colts receivers generally decent decision-making some inaccurate balls, particularly deep. I feel like he just kind of looks like the same quarterback he's been for the last three years and things have generally stabilized with him yeah I think that as far as things that we theorized on in March and got right in August the what will Daniel Jones look like in the Shane's second offense was just I mean exactly the pins were lined up and you knocked him down that's what it was the uh the base of this offense in the Gardner Minshew era in the moments of the Anthony Richardson era that we've seen has been the RPO has been a lot of the immediate post snap read one guy decisions.
15:14And that'll make our running game work. That'll get the ball into the hands of our playmakers. That'll activate Josh Downs for us and Michael Pittman for us. And they've been trying to access more explosives and downfield stuff. And, and, you know, more, uh, athleticism at wide receiver without Pierce, how did I Mitchell? And they've had moments of that being successful, but it just has never become like a foundational part of the offense in large part because of Richardson's lack of availability. Well, Lo and behold, Daniel Jones is there, and it's like, yeah, this guy can just point guard the parts of the offense that we expect him to point guard.
15:41The hope here is that he's just a little bit better of a runner and a little bit better of a downfield thrower than Gardner Minshew was in this offense two years ago, obviously with a player in Tyler Warren and a player in Adonai Mitchell and a growth from Alec Pierce that you haven't had previously, so it'll be a little bit better accessing that downfield area of the field. I can't watch Daniel Jones in this Colts offense in that preseason game, and that was the last camp I was at, and be like, whoo i just don't got it i like it's it's so hard to get there i will say tyler warren made me go whoo a few times watching the tape i mean i that to me you know you don't want to overreact to preseason competition all of that but i'm watching him the way they used him as well down both you know i mentioned the rpo early with um richardson but then they use it in like a number of ways I thought that was really interesting, including downfield.
16:34He just looks like he belongs. I mean, uh, you know, like coming out of college, I think there was just the question, okay, this guy was, um, you know, one of the best tight ends after the catch that we've seen in a while, you know, we'll see how he develops as a blocker and, um, as a route runner, some of the other aspects of his game. But I, to me like that, it completely translated at this level again you know obviously with backups for much of the game but like I would be very surprised if whoever is playing quarterback he is not immediately a focal point in this offense and he allows them to I think work the middle of the field in a way that like for Shane Steichen in particular has to be very attractive and if it's Richardson it's immensely important because His Richardson's been, you know, his major flaw has been accuracy underneath.
17:30And I like Warren to me really does solve a lot of those problems, but they have to be on the field at the same time. Yeah. And if you're going to be an RPO team, it's you reach a limit in terms of what you can do on the chalkboard when you're really working your back to your receivers. right when they haven't had just any player at tight end like you know it's been kylan granson and it's been uh you know uh will mallory and just like the the threat as a blocker and then as a receiver it just very much limits the number of wrinkles you can put in when you don't have a tight end a guy you can move through the backfield line up in the backfield at h back and and find ways to leverage him right when you're just using it with receivers it becomes very college it becomes very spreading in the nfl you really want to be able to leverage your tight end on a lot of that stuff and so warren adds schematic depth to their rpo game that i think will make it a lot more sustainable and then the down the field stuff man like i think that they were a leak with him am i misremembering that at one point they ran like a leak with warren and i was yeah i don't think they i don't think they targeted him on it was that maybe maybe i don't know i feel like it was it was later in the game it wasn't with richardson i think with daniel at one point but I got really excited seeing him downfield.
18:40Yeah. And when you go and you look at Jones's downfield passing when he was with the Giants, a lot of it was like he doesn't like the Darius Slayton player as much. Like, all right, this guy's speed. He's even. He's leaving. Let me hang it out there. He much more so prefers the Darren Waller. This guy is just big. I can throw it up near him and he'll make me right sort of prototype. And that is obviously much more so where your Warren eats, where your Alec Pierce eats. So, yeah. I asked somebody at Colts camp. I said, who's going to lead this team in targets? And they said pretty quickly, Tyler Warren.
19:08And I was like, there's four receivers on the scene that were taken day two or earlier. And they were like, yeah, Tyler Warren. I love your point about the tight end in the RPO game. And it takes me back to Kellen Moore's last, or pardon me, Shane Steichen. Kellen Moore, Shane Steichen. In Philadelphia, the way that they would use Dallas Goddard, right? Slide RPO, baby. Slide RPO, yeah. It's just such an easy button, especially, and obviously in Philadelphia, when defenders have to account for so many other things. But I think, I mean, the Colts receivers are not bad. I'm still optimistic about A.D.
19:39Mitchell. Like, there should be significant opportunities for him. So, look, I know. If you're a Colts fan, you're watching that, you're just like, geez, Louise. I mean, it sounds like Richardson is going to be back quickly. It's just a pinky issue. Yeah, he was practicing when I was there on Monday. He can't miss. This is it. You know, this feels like it. He has to stay on the field. um so yeah anyways daniel jones gets a leg up in the competition but as a colts fan i don't think you feel pretty happy about that or about what happened with richardson at least you can feel happy about tyler warren because he yeah to me looks like and i feel like the like the quarterbacks coming off of that game of the big storyline understandably so richardson and blowing the protection they have two new office alignments starting this year center tanner bordellini who played some snaps last year and then right guard matt gonsalves whose name i've been saying completely incorrectly, I learned this week.
20:31So Matt Gonsalves, who was a fill-in-right tackle for them last year and is now playing right guard. Ravens have a good deep defense line. I understand that. This team needs to be able to run the football well, and they have historically been able to be really good with their five up front. And I think Bortolini is a smaller player, and he's good at what he's good at. He's bad at whatever. Gonsalves at right guard is a work in progress. And I think that, especially as you talk about Richardson not getting banged up, I wouldn't be surprised if this offensive line is still getting its footing when we get to live football in September, and that could be a problem for your turnover-prone, injury-prone quarterback back there.
21:06Speaking of offensive lines that are still getting their footing, that brings us to the New Orleans Saints. Win or loser is a little tough with this one because I was going to ask you, in the Saints quarterback competition, who do we think made strides, I guess? maybe i thought i mean like that pulled a little ahead no one strode um i thought shuck had a better day than rattler i thought chuck also was playing against a a level below the chargers defensive depth chart than rattler was i also think shuck played better than rattler in the sense that shuck completed a double move touchdown to mason tipton and that's like you know yeah exactly and really and he had another vertical shot to kevin austin that i thought was a good ball and just the receiver he was thrown to is not a receiver with a ton of uh with like a second gear necessarily so i did think that shuck was acceptable but it's nothing that i'm like you know clipping for the timeline and then rattler had a couple of good moments as well like jack stole dropped what i thought was a nicely placed scene ball for him you know like there were there were classic rat man moments where you're like oh look at the arm talent oh look at the release um but in general man oh not stoked about what i'm seeing out of the saints quarterback competition but i i will say for both quarterbacks but particularly rattler i mean the offensive line still looks like a real problem and guys were not open so obviously alave and he didn't play unless i missed it um the only upside i'll say is the forced fumble rattle got strip sacked i thought it was fuanga i was like oh no and it turned out to be dylan raddins who had come in i missed that so i it's actually a good thing i think for the saints fans that because i because they had banks jr at left tackle i actually thought he didn't look that bad to be honest and then fuanga played fuanga played a little bit to least fun goes the right tackle who's their other first rounder from last year so that's the starting orientation i the interior to me was the problem and they were down a couple starters there penning trevor penning guys we talked about this a little bit got moved from left tackle to left guard i saw him get beat a couple of times again this isn't like an apology for spentler sensor rattler but it was not good uh guys were not open and you it just kind of looked like it did last year for him where you're you're like i don't know how much of this is the quarterback versus his circumstances Shuck was a little bit more interesting because, yeah, he got to go against a tick down in terms of the competition.
23:41I was actually really encouraged by the two-minute drill that he led before the halftime where you're like, okay, the ball's coming out quick. He's thrown over the middle of the field. He looks like he belongs there. And then comes out the second half, stares down the out and gets pick-sixed, and then comes right back. and I think that's a classic at college speed, NFL speed interception. That's one where I'm always like, all right, we all get that. Yeah, it happens. There we go. Yeah. I think you saw kind of like the good and bad from him in this game. It's similar to all of these guys. So we're good time with Ken Ward.
24:16It's similar to Shador where it's like, okay, he kind of looks like he did in college. Like you saw some of the, you saw the arm strength. He has a really strong arm. That was a beautiful goal ball to Mason Tipton. Right. it was like 54 yards or something right and he's got a really good arm he's got good arm talent you saw that there was like a boot where he faced pressure and he side-armed it that I thought okay I remember seeing a lot of this in college but then you saw it wasn't a boot he scrambled and escaped but then you also saw you know like some of the struggles with pressure I think he still He looked like a rookie.
24:53So I guess maybe he got a little bit of a leg up. I think you probably want to see him with the starters. I think both of these guys you'd want to see with the starters before you arrive at any conclusions because I don't think either of the receivers in the line didn't do either of them any favors. Jake Hayner, you know. He's an exception. Once Hayner went in, I turned the phone off. I was like, all right, I've seen my new busy. Briefly, on the flip side. So, by the way, this is NFC South is later this week, So I'll be talking about the Saints offense outside of the quarterbacks more in depth there.
25:25John Ledyard and the defense on the flip side. Just a quick acknowledgement of the trail. Start. He looked fine. He just looked really athletic to me. I didn't think as a thrower much really resonated. The other thing I will say about the Chargers, because, you know, they're they're facing their backups. They're just so clearly well coached. Did you feel that watching the Cargers defense? I sent exactly like Jesse Minters is such a good coach. I sent that exact text to somebody watching that. It's just like the third round Nichols is coming up making tackles and you're just like, all right, like it's just, they just get it.
26:03They're so good. What's the name of the dude who picked them twice? Eric Rogers. Holy mackerel. Caleb Murphy at the strip sack. Grand Rapids go. Okay. Grand Valley State University to Ferris State University transfer. Jamari Caldwell, the third rounder at Oregon. He had a big play. That's actually important. They might need him. And then Justin Agbiogbi, the fifth rounder out of Alabama, who's like, you know, they have him and Deshaun Hand. They have just two of Saban's like 280-pound defensive ends. We solve problems. Like they just got those guys in the building. I was 100 % nerding out at the hustle and assignment sound football in the third quarter of the Chargers defense, I have to admit.
26:42Okay. Cam Ward. I'm marking him down as a winner. My real winner is Calvin Ridley. Because that was my big takeaway from this game is Calvin really is going to catch a million passes this year. You saw in real, you could feel Cam Moore just like locking in on him like really early. I want to say three third down targets in a row or maybe I haven't too. Oh, look, he was looking for him on every point. He was getting the designers. But I thought this was a good start. You know, he comes out first drive. You're like, he's getting his sea legs under him. He bailed backwards. He had one of those moments, which was similar to Shador.
27:17That was the ding on him. in college is he looks so good when the ball comes out quick and he's got this great arm talent, but there are, he had, you know, a lot of doing too much moments, shall we call it. And then, you know, in the first drive, he misses Ridley, he bails backwards on a play, but then the second drive comes out and, you know, you start seeing, I think the things that made him the number one overall pick. I would say I just love how snappy he is as a thrower. He is able to throw to all three levels really quickly and from different platforms in different situations inside the pocket.
27:58I think you saw all of that. I loved the ball placement on the deep over to Ridley. um just perfect perfect football probably of like all the young quarterbacks that was like the best ball of the week for me um you know and like it just kind of felt like he got into a rhythm on getting the ball out quick when he hit mesh uh lock it off of mesh for the first down to set up like it was just like okay like i you know like this he looks to me like the best quarterback in the draft and i feel like that showed up yeah there was uh there was a 39 conversion when they're getting in the red zone to chick a con quo where it's a con quo on the over the ball route.
28:38Right. And it's, I want to say it's five step drop timing. They've got like a couple of, of cross on the field. Right. And he, the, the bucks rotate coverage a little bit. And so there's space right away for a con quo and Ward shortcuts the progression. Right. So he skips like, you know, Oh, look here, they move here. And he shortcuts his footwork. Right. He doesn't five step and then hitch into it. He lands on the back foot of the drop and just immediately opens his hips to uncork it just to say, all right, if the space is there right now, I'm going to throw this, like not just on time, early.
29:07So it's going to hit a conco right when he turns and they won't have any time to relate to this route. That right there is like, okay, he gets it. They get it. What is fundamental to playing quarterback from the pocket at the NFL level against NFL defenses, this guy understands. That throw is not always going to be perfect because he's got chemistry with his receivers. He's got young guys, whatever. And the mechanics aren't always going to be gorgeous. The accuracy might always be perfect. But just making that process is just like, oh, like that moment is better than any moment I got from J.J.
29:35McCarthy or Anthony Richardson or Tyler Shock for this preseason. That moment right there was like 201 stuff. I think you just heard exactly what I'm trying to say, which is like there was a lot of things that I felt like will translate versus starters in real action. And the most important thing is what you're describing there, which is what we liked best about him, which is his arm talent inside the pocket. He's just twitched up. You know, the ball comes out fast. He's smart. He's good at reading defenses. He's, I think, generally like a pretty good, he's pretty accurate in terms of ball placement as well.
30:11Again, the over to Ridley was the one that really jumped out to me in that regard. But yeah, the quick release on the throw to Chick too. Yeah, fantastic. So I think if you're a Titans fan, the other thing you're encouraged about, I thought the new offensive line looked pretty damn good. You know, it's, again, still a work in progress. I do not love this group of pass catchers outside of Calvin Ridley, but the bones are there. You feel good. It's a good start, good week one. As someone with just worlds of Chica Conquo stock, I'm so ready for it. I'm just got to catch the ball. I'm so ready for a target to Chica Conquo.
30:47I was thinking about this. I mentioned he got the first down hitting Lockett on the shallow. Kyler Lockett's going to catch an annoying amount of footballs this year. Just get ready for it. Just with three releases and just falling down six yards past. He's going to catch them all. He's going to be open. He's brown there. He's exciting. That line, by the way, gets Lloyd Cushenberry back. He just came off of pop passes physical and center. I tell you five across. This is a, it's a high floor line. It's also high ceiling, right? Like JC Latham, Lloyd Cushenberry, Tony Pollard just had himself a very nice season running between the tackles.
Read the full transcript
31:21He's, he's not the same player. He was in Dallas where he wasn't reliable behind the tackles. He's getting, he's, he's a hundred percent improved there. Bill Callahan's offensive line coach would not be surprised if the Titans run the dang ball this year. I'm excited. I do want to address the other two. JJ McCarthy's not a rookie, but he is de facto rookie. JJ McCarthy and Jackson Dart before we get to, is this real? We can start with McCarthy. I mean, he barely played this one drive, right? Yeah. Yeah. One drive. It was very much the way they probably want to use him during the season. A lot of under center play action, which was kind of like what they drafted him to do in that offense.
32:03Right. I think, you know, and he had a miss. I'm looking at my notes from them. There was one, there were a couple, the thing that stood out to me, he had to make a miss a couple of screen that got blown up. uh the thing that i the only thing i think that's noteworthy from this other than like them using him kind of exactly the way with that they would they would uh he did not look fearful of contact and i just want to emphasize that because obviously he's coming off the injury when he hit addison i think it was like a deep out or something but um he got blasted and so it was like a slightly inaccurate ball but i thought okay great you know like he is fine they scrambled on the fourth down too right um i think just that was something i was curious to see just coming off of the knee injury how does he look moving back there how does he look with pressure and i thought he passed that test not a lot else to take away from that in my mind yeah the mess on the on the big dig he talked about and he said like you know he should have held his water for another second and like let the window open and i thought that was a good summary where like i did think he was like excited jittery is probably too much of a negative connotation he definitely felt jumpy right there I wasn't like Ward goes out there and Ward just looks so suave in the pocket.
33:18McCarthy has a lot of like movement in the pocket and you just get the sense that like, yeah, the, the bullets are live ish for the first time in a long time for him. Right. He had that major injury. He knows how good this offense can be. And like, he felt young and excited in like, again, like not in a super negative way, but just in a way where like, you could tell timing wise, he just wanted everything to be fast. Wanted to go, go, go, go. It's one drive. Right. I think they were very right to say the, the number one part practice part of today is just the practice of getting ready for a game.
33:45And then we're going to let you do three things. And we're going to reel you back. I'm sure they'll give him like three drives next week. And then they'll reel them back again. Jackson dart played a little bit more. The highlight that's going around, of course is the touchdown, which was a beautiful ball, really great, well-placed notably had pressure just bearing right down on it. It was, this is the one it was a bills broadcast and they like barely show the touchdown because they were talking about the stadium and then they didn't show the replay Giants fans were losing their this is why I love free season football they're like why are you showing our rookie quarterback throwing his first touchdown um I was actually I wanted to see the replay because I was like I think he just got grilled and then they the NFL posted and he did and that's what he did in college right he's he stands tough in the pocket he has a big arm and he's willing to take pressure um so I think you know notable that that translated.
34:39I think otherwise looked, you know, he had his, he had a few sprays, one of which pissed off Brian table earlier on. Um, you saw he's, you know, obviously extremely athletic. You saw that as well. I think that's something that they're going to lean into. I think Dable actually like called a draw for him at one point. Um, so, um, again, you know, I know I sound like a broken record there, but he looked like he didn't, all these guys look kind of like they did in college. And I felt that way about Jackson dart. I felt that way too. I will say that And I feel like a lot of the responses to a lot of the quarterbacks has been, this guy looked the way he did in college.
35:12And the response to Jackson Dart has been like, holy smokes, baby. And I just can't. He played more snaps than the other guys. And so I think there's just more gross good on the film than there were in the other guys. There's more positive plays to talk about. He's also late on enough. There were throws that he wanted to make that he didn't make because he was just way too late on them, which is a totally acceptable thing for a rookie quarterback to be in his first preseason start. but those are not making the timeline as much as right. The, the, the, the touchdown off the sideline is what, what I thought most encouraging about darts game was that table very clearly understands what's going to make this guy successful early, right?
35:50Dart was a little bit more of a project than people wanted to talk about coming out simply because the menu of throws and the menu of concepts he was asked to do at Ole Miss for so limited, right? He had more play action pass attempts than any quarterback in football say for Nico Imaliaba. Frick. I thought I had it, man. I was so close. Nico, the quarterback for the Tennessee Volunteers now with UCLA. It was a lot of shot play stuff, Ole Miss choice rowdy stuff. The menu that Dave will gave him is small. It's very spready. He used him in the quarterback running game. There's a lot of pre-snap reads, RPO stuff as well, talking about with Steichen.
36:22That's the menu Dart will need to succeed if and when he starts this season. The understanding of where this guy's bread is buttered is good. I'm happy about that. It's a good point. Giants fans, after the break, we're going to talk about your other rookie. I'm going to bring him up, Giz. All right, let's take a quick break. Come back and play Is This Real? Hard Knocks is back, and so is the official Hard Knocks podcast. This year, the award-winning HBO original Hard Knocks training camp heads to Seattle to follow the Super Bowl champion Seahawks. Go behind the scenes with the team as they make another run at a title.
36:53Get unfiltered access to the personalities and challenges that define a championship team. Watch the official Hard Knocks podcast on HBO Max, YouTube, or listen to wherever you get your podcasts. and watch Hard Knocks Training Camp with the Seattle Seahawks on HBO Max. As you know, managing maintenance, repair, and operations is never easy. But for the ones who always rise to the challenge, Granger has your back. From professional-grade products you can count on to fast, dependable delivery, they're there to help you keep things running smoothly. Plus, their technical product specialists are here to help answer your toughest questions.
37:26And because Granger knows safety is always a priority, they're committed to being your partner in protecting both your people and your facility. Call 1-800-GRANGER Clickgrainger.com or just stop by
38:03posting your job for free at linkedin.com slash eisen terms and conditions apply all right i teased it so we might as well stay with the giants here is this real the giants could have the best defensive line in the nfl yeah yeah can we talk about abdul carter first obviously that premise is has a lot to do with the other players dexter lawrence who of course didn't play brian burns cave on thibodeau there's also like um i was watching and i they have good defensive line defensive tackle depth now too right like nunez rochez they drafted a couple guys but i would just want to talk about abdul carter holy smokes we're talking about guys and competition and yeah he looked okay against the third stringers abdul carter lineup against dion Dawkins, who is, for those who don't know, one of the best left tackles in the NFL.
39:00And he notably always lines up on like an island, right? I think he has like wider splits than any offensive line left tackle in football. And one of those reps, Carter put like an inside move on him that made me gasp.
39:16He looked
39:21like like one of those like just one of those rookies can come in immediately and just shred i i they pushed him inside on one i mean he only like i think it was like seven or eight snaps um but it was definitely an i've seen enough moment for me watching him in this game because yeah i mean he's like getting him adding him to that group is insane yeah the the number one thing about preseason and training camp for me is always I want to see the rookies in NFL pads against NFL players and do you look like you belong do you look like physically you you should be out there are you playing in an NFL speed and with Carter it's just like not not only yes but so emphatically yes against some of the best competition you'll see in terms of the Buffalo Bills offensive line in such a dynamic way which is what you want from your top five top 10 pick right uh the Deion Dawkins inside move which by the way is the best play of Mitchell Trubisky's life trubisky spins away from abdul carter rolls to his left throws against his body yeah yeah it was really i couldn't believe it i legit i legit was like is josh smaller did josh shrink over the year no it's mitchell so i was great shout out mitch um carter also had that he had that early win against osiris torrance the right guard on a pass rush package right where they've got the three edge rushers on the field the torrance one was funny because carter hits him with the inside move and you can see like the the red sirens going in carter's head it's like i've got him and all i gotta do is just slam past this heavy footed 350 pound guard the way that i've always had in college and then torrance gets like one hand on him and carter comes to a screeching hall it's like no they played a little bit of a different weight class up here that's again those nfl moments where you have to learn about the the the the different athleticisms and capabilities but then he strains through torrance and he gets the pressure the the the the the nascar packages on third down are clearly sick.
41:11I think the point you made about Rakim Nunez-Roches and Roy Robertson-Harris, which I practiced that one beforehand, so I would say correct for the other. They're both good players. Those are such important players because you have to be able to win on early downs to get to your NASCAR packages. You have to be able to get to third and longs. And they have better defensive tackle depth than I think they've ever had before behind Dexter Lawrence. It's a great point about run defense because teams are going to run a lot on them on first down, I believe. Or they're going to face a lot of quick throws.
41:37So I think the linebackers are going to matter a lot too in this defense just because every offense that plays this team is going to spend their entire week game planning for this pass rush, not wanting to face that NASCAR package. So I think for Shane Bowen in this Giants defense, and then we'll see what terms of the offense, complementary football, how much they're having to – like maybe they're unfortunately on the field a lot and teams are able to run the ball and all of that. But it really comes down to like, okay, how can we get into situations where we can let these guys cook? And oh my God, I mean, just Carter.
42:13I just, he was very obviously the best pass rusher in this draft. It was not a debate. And I think though, the question was, is he like good? You know, is he, or is he like one of those, can we, is he like Will Anderson Jr. level? Early results look really good. That's all I'll say. We don't have to get into it too much. I wish he was in a single day. And I'm pretty excited. My big concern is Burns in zero, Thibodeau in five, and then Carter in 51. Just aesthetically, it's not going to look good on the graphic, man. 51 is not a cool – it's not cool. You're going to get him into like eight. I don't know if that's allowed in the Giants history or not.
42:49A cool number. If Dexter Lawrence stays healthy this year, I just don't – I don't know what you do. Okay, is this real? Let's go on the negative side. Bengals fans should be panicking about the defense.
43:06like i panic they should be deeply deeply concerned i i will i will tell you the sliver of hope that i retain that keeps me from panic is the sliver hope that tanner mckee is a golden god and they just ran into it that's a separate conversation the schematically when they walked out against the eagles and you know oh pre-season schemes are always very vanilla yes but they are immediately like run blitzing from depth on first and 10 and, and, and rotating coverage on the backend. And very clearly Al golden has an understanding that we are going to have to do some, not unsound things. And even as coordinator, we never say unsound, but we are going to have to do some high risk, high reward things to try to win some base downs, get into some second and longs, generate some turnovers, generate some explosives.
43:52Because if we just try to line up and play, we are going to get outmanned. We are going to get outgunned. And that is absolutely the case. Cincinnati's back seven is not fast, not experienced, not particularly playmaking. They're in a new system. If they try to just line up and cover guys, they're going to lose. Defensive on the front, they have a little bit more talent. They have a little bit more potential. There's a chance they're better. But still, without Trey Hendrickson right now, the pass rush is nothing. And even then, the interior run defense is you're kind of hoping and praying. So you have to get creative.
44:22And Golden's willingness to do so early indicates to me that they understand the reality of the situation. However, the situation is pretty dire. So it's a little unfair to say that Tanner McKee dog walked the starters because Hendrickson didn't play. Cam Taylor Britt didn't play. I believe Dax Hill didn't play. But there were a lot of guys out there. Let me tell you something. You put those three on the field, McKee's going 23 for 30, 300 yards. Don't even worry about it. I think your point is good. It really comes down to sort of creativity on the part of the defensive coordinator. I think also if they can get a little pass rush juice, obviously Hendrickson swimming, they, you know, I think they're going to probably try to get something done with him.
45:05Shamar Stewart, the rookie actually made some plays too. I think that's a little bit contrary. And it was interesting. They were going, it was lining them up everywhere. You know, like there is really trying some stuff with him. He had the TFL. I thought he looked really explosive. Taven Bryan. Also, I made a couple of plays. I didn't know he was on the former first round draft pick, defensive tackle but i i just worry so much about this back end i worry about the linebacking group which i thought looked pretty rough and then i worry about the corner room again there were a couple guys out but like dg turner ivy this one like it is a bear cupboard so and then gino stone got hurt and he's all that um i think the tave say they address the actual premise it's less like panicking and it's more i think the feeling that this is going to be more of the same like this is it just kind of the hope is that you know al golden to your point um not only can be creative but also in terms of taking some risks schematically but also can develop some of these younger players and it's early so you're hoping like maybe the second half of the season you see some guys take a leap but early results concerning uh well the flip side of that i do want to address is this real tanner mckee yes should be a starter i like people thought i was in the nfl in the nfl people thought i was doing a bit when i said he could start and i listed the teams they're like this is ridiculous i really don't think it is and you can check my tanner mckee receipts i've been here for years this was not off of one pre-season film against the bangles that dude the week 18 game against the giants just just making reads post snap on the fly going through the process in the pocket he was a five-star recruit i think he was four or five Pretty sure he was five.
46:50He was a high caliber recruit who just missed some time at Stanford. He had, I want to say, a Latter-day Saints mission as well. So he was an older prospect coming out and just was a classic Harry Roseman day three dart throw. I think if you put McKee in the Cleveland Browns quarterback room, I absolutely think the training camp reports would be the best quarterback here at 16. I firmly believe that. He went 20 for 25 for 252 yards. Just a cool 10 yards for a 10. A lot of starters. I think my takeaway was just that he looked like a vet. He looked so accurate and compared, you know, just again, especially after watching all the young players this preseason with their ups and downs, it was only ups with Tanner McKee.
47:33That said, he does have, of course, a lot more experience than some of these guys. Yeah, I think it doesn't give you a ton in terms of athleticism, but it's like, and I think that maybe that's sort of what has worked against him. You talked about being an older prospect. I think he's, you know, when teams are thinking about their backups, there's a sign of prep, like you feel around the league. Well, I want a guy at least maybe I can like call like a, you know, have a robust design quarterback run game. That's not what you're getting here. But what you are getting is a guy who can probably execute just about every offense.
48:05I mean, I just, it's funny too. Like if it was any team other than Philadelphia, I would say trade bait, let's go. But they're in such a unique spot because they are obviously Super Bowl contenders to repeat so he is it's weird even though he you know he's not a threat at all to Jalen Hurts he is kind of paradoxically more valuable to them than he would be if he was on a bad team that might trade him that said I heard I think it was you and Sheil talking about not trading a second or giving like accepting a second for him you guys are freaking crazy that was that was that was not me I don't think but I kind of blacked out after the game and there's a chance that I said it.
48:47I said, if Jerry Jones called me and offered Micah for McKee, I would tell him to throw in a pick. That's where I'm at on, on Tanner's value. Okay. Did you hear feedback right now in your, do you hear that sound back there? No. Oh, I think, I think I'm pretty sure it's just the quarterback factory in the background, just producing more and more. Okay. Okay. Wait, no gun to your head. What would you, what would be the floor for accepting if you're Eagle, if you're Howie Roseman for Tanner McKee? So like a lot of it depends on what I think of Kyle McCord and what I think of DTR slash the veteran quarterback market.
49:22Cause quarterback two is legitimately like the Eagles will tell you one of the most important positions on their roster. I think if a team said, oh yeah, like early day three pick, like round four, I'd be like, no, no, no, get serious. Like this is the day two pick a quarterback. If you're going to take this, what if they throw in, what did the Eagles, what did the Eagles trade for Kenny Pickett? That's the real question. Cause it's something more than that. Yeah. But okay. What if I know I'm dealing in insane hypothetical, there's a potential to get a starting corner back because that was my other takeaway from this game.
49:49CB2 not looking so good in Philadelphia. Granted, it's pretty unfair to go up against Jamar Chase in the preseason. That should be outlawed. That said, this was a concern coming in. Would that maybe sway things for you a little bit? Yeah. I mean, I think if you can turn a QB2 into a starting corner in a time at which you think that you are a contending team looking to push back for the Super Bowl. Correctly. Yeah. Yeah. I think that that's fair. it's also the case where it's like all right that needs to clearly be an improvement on keely plus a dory plus jacorian right so right now they have so many dart throws it'd have to be like a dude but yeah i mean i would i would hate to see him go i would i would weep a little bit when i sent him but i would send him and then he would prosper elsewhere man he would be a great player okay i'm just saying the geno arc is coming for tanner mckee just you wait it's not really a geno arc i just the good he's good and i love him that arc is coming you see the sign that gino smith did double birds to that i heard the sign was terrible i just had the sign was like gino as big a bust as jamarcus russell and i was like oh what that doesn't even make sense he wasn't a first round draft pick he's not a bust he also you acquired him for nothing in seattle is like just a lot if you're gonna be an a-hole at least be an accurate a-hole with your taunts.
51:08Anyways, obviously I'm on Team Gino and Pete. I like how Pete backed him up with the double bruise there. Pete was trying to grab the sign. I saw that picture. He's like jumping up there all 72 years of him. Miss him. Okay. Couple more. Is this real? Ted O 'Romew McMillan, T-Mac, really trying to practice not calling him Ted, is going to finish as a top 20 receiver. That feels rich, right? T. Higgins and Devontae Smith are top 15 receivers. The 20 is probably too far. I think you can get me to 30. I think he can be in that range. We talked about Abdul-Carter and a sense of belonging. Watching T.
51:50Mac get off the line of scrimmage, watching him elevate for footballs, and watching him play against NFL caliber size corners, which Browns backups for sure. It's no question. We have more to say. It's very clear that he's going to be able to be the caliber of ball winner that, all right, like win the contested catch, win the vertical one-on-one stuff, like that floor is there. The question with T-Mac was always the ceiling, right? It's like, okay, what can be as a rat runner separator middle of the field? And you just didn't see that, a ton of that from a usage perspective in this game. And I think with Bryce Young, you're just not going to see a ton of that in general.
52:22But the box check for T-Mac, I think is as emphatic as it was with Abdul Carter, where it's like, oh, the thing that we need you to be good at in year one, you're going to be good at that for sure. He looked like, I know, again, I hate to say this exact phrase again. And he looked like he did in college. You would hope, though. You would hope that we watched him in college and he looked like that and then that's what happened. Yeah, especially if you're not going against the best competition per se, it's harder to look like you did in college as a first-round draft pick when you're facing more challenging matchups.
52:49But the traits that he flashed in this preseason game, body control, the hands down the sideline are exactly why he was the eighth overall pick. I also loved, I think after the go ball, which was awesome, Bryce hit him on like an in-breaker, I think. It was like maybe the next play. Love more. I don't want him to be just a go ball merchant in this offense and just a guy who's winning on the perimeter. Very important in my mind that Dave Canales and Bryce, that he is an important part of this offense working in the middle of the field, which is something he's good at, I thought, on slant, sticks, using that big body to box out defenders and give an easy target to the quarterback.
53:32I also think Bryce young that's needs to be an important part of the offense for him. Right. So seeing that there's a little bit of miscommunication in the end zone. And then Bryce had the great, he had the extended play with Coker where he redirected him back. I mean, he's good too, man. I think that was the other thing I would say about like TMAC as advertised. Awesome. feeling good about this group because what i've always said and we're gonna talk about this on the nfc south preview what i always felt about tmack was if he could be the player that he was in high in college the true number one x receiver in this offense everybody else slots into such a nice nice spot and you're like oh i really like suddenly i really like this group as a whole yeah i i strongly agree the the thing about this this wide receiver room that i i love so much is that firstly you're enormous as very clear priority from dan morgan to be like let's just become as large as conceivably possible on offense they did with the offensive line and then right coker who's just like you know speed threat udfa out of holy cross downfield guys is 6 3 2 13 and it legitimately is like a field stretching caliber of a player mcmillan is 6 5 2 12 xabriel agate who is lower on the depth chart than i thought it was where is xabriel agate xabriel agate is there he is 17, six, three, two 27.
54:50Right? Like if that's your starting three and have Adam Thielen is your primary slot player, you just have such a, a physical presence, but Coker's not really a great, uh, the middle of the field guy. They try to make, look at the middle of the field guy last year. It's not necessarily clearing things out. Yeah, exactly. It used to be what he was really good at. He's a little bit long in the tooth. Now, if you can get that from T Mac, then everybody else makes sense. And, and, and it's just, you can see how, how good it will be for Bryce, who just, The thing that unlocked it for Bryce was, hey, just shoot.
55:20Just fire. They're going to make you right. Just go, go, go. If he has this big cadre of receivers who create that space, oh, man. It's the window. It'll make it work. Seeing T-Mac reward him for throwing that ball on the right sideline early on. It's just like, yes. This is going to build the habits, the timing. That's everything you wanted to see as a Panthers fan, so I'm feeling good about that. Okay, a couple more. Let's do the – this is a small one. So, you know, I'm excited about obviously Gina Smith and this Chip Kelly and this Raiders offense. And I have no thoughts on like scheme or Gina or anything.
55:57You know, when you're locked in, focused and fearless. Welcome to the WNBA. Your vision narrows. You can't look away. Every assist, every stop, every logo three. From beyond the logo. Every did you see that moment? You bet. What records are going to be broken this season? All of it right here. Lock in. It's the WNBA on ESPN all season long. However, is this real? Should Raiders fans be worried that the offensive line might limit this offensive potential? Tank it in some ways. Yeah, that's real. Like I should be worried that it could, I think is, is, is correct. Right? There's no doubt that the interior of JPJ, who I thought the move to guard was good for JPJ.
56:48I thought they made him better last season. I think that's solid. But then it's Jordan Merritt at the center and Dylan Parham on the right side. DJ Glazer at right tackle. Just outside of Colton Miller, there's just a lot of if this, then that. If he can do this, if we can take this step, if we have this improvement, then we have this caliber of a player. And when you introduce that many hypotheticals, you're going to miss one of them. And you're going to have at least one problem to solve. Once you have two or three, then you start running out of resources. I think that what Chip wants to be in terms of the running game, which is a highly multiple, a lot of different schemes, a lot of calls and checks at the line of scrimmage, sort of a rushing attack.
57:23I think that's a really tough ask for a line that doesn't have a ton of snaps together, has had some shuffling and is generally inexperienced as well. And so I think you're going to see that Chip can't run the way he wants to run. And then, yeah, we know what Gino can be in the pocket, but we also know that one of his strengths is his willingness to just kind of hang back there against those pressures and then you get the high interception games and so there's concern to your point there was a rep in the second drive where it was with genti was still in the game where i think they were trying to run like power or something and the and dj glace was trying to come across and the left side just got caved so quickly it was doa and i was watching that thinking like who to you what you're saying about like chip however i will say of note um they took out colton and parham so it was backups on the left side of the offensive line in the second series so i think you're worried about the interior but the most of this game it was not the starters on the left side of the offensive line and i think the optimism would just be okay the depth sucks um if we can just get the interior squared away but yeah so yeah if i'm an ashen genti fantasy holder i'm not panicking but you're a little nervous not about him but about the offensive line and they added Alex Kappa and then they drafted two guys in the third round they drafted Caleb Rogers out of Texas Tech and then the William and Mary I think his name is Grant yeah Charles Grant uh uh who I liked William and Mary quite a bit I liked Charles Grant come out of the process as a 2026 guy right he was always going to be a developmental player Rogers is a tackle kick guard player so you have dart throws we are in it's the middle of August you would have liked if one of those dart throws was going to be a contributor for you in year one you would have expected to hear more about it by now and so i think that their five they got starting is probably the five they got starting and maybe by mid-season they have a surprising contributor but just right now it doesn't sound like they're getting that from some of those off-season ads is this real the jacksonville jaguars only have to gain 10 yards after every touchback to score because they have the greatest weapon in football cam little on their side 70 yard field goal for those who missed this incredible moment.
59:33Um, I was, I looked up his stats as a, just curious to see like, is it so in, as a rookie last year, he was a six round draft pick. He went five for six on 50 yarders and he had a 59 yarder. So this isn't like totally out of nowhere. Um, but Holy. What? Like what I want to, what I want to know is who at, like who on the sideline was the first person to be like, listen, even even if we don't get it past the 50 like let's just do it right like they because cohen talked about this a little bit in the um and the postgame presser he was like we're trying to do like you know like a last end of half situation we're gonna run you know quick play and try to get it past the 50 and then oh like you know to win the game like the justin tucker kick against the lions a couple of years ago right just get it close up and we'll try uh but they didn't end up doing it and they didn't they didn't get past the 50 and he was like cam looked at it was like let's it.
1:00:26I just want to try and keep almost like sure, whatever preseason like fine. But I need to know, like on the Tuesday before the preseason game, did the special teams coach come to Cohen and be like, listen, our range is, you know, to our 45 yard line. That's just a preposterous thing to say. What does it mean, though, in all seriousness, if you have a kicker who you feel comfortably can hit, let's say, 65, right? Does that actually change your approach on game day? I think it changes the last 30 seconds of both halves, which feels insignificant. That's one of 60 minutes in a game clock, but it's actually extraordinarily significant.
1:01:10I'm like, thinking about Bill's Chiefs playoff game from a couple years ago, the 13 second game, the defensive of structure that you're going to get in end of half, end of game, you know, it's a three-point game, it's a one-point game situations, is predicated on an idea of like, okay, we generally know the yard line that you're going to try to get to. And if I can shave five yards off of that, and I'd say, no, actually, we don't want to get, we don't need to get to your 40, we just need to get to your 45, your 48, then it becomes a lot easier to execute that six-second play, because it's a lot easier to execute that 14-second, throw the seam, fall down, and spike it.
1:01:44And then you get the chance to get the kickoff and then once you get the chance to get the kickoff you know close your eyes say your prayers cross yourself and see what cam little does like you did your job and so i think it it changes your operation there in the last 30 seconds of each half which can turn a loss into a win and can turn a 17 into a 16 you turn a wild card to a division round and that's that that's significant yeah i it's it's you know you get both sides are now baking that into their models people are just like they don't know who's on the field they know who's on the the field.
1:02:10And if you're playing a team with a kicker who can make routinely hit 50 plus yards, that is something you're baking into how you approach situational football, particularly at the end of halves, as you pointed out. That's a big deal. Okay, final one. Is this real? The Rashawn Slater injury is dooming the Chargers offense before the season starts. I'm going with the most dramatic possible interpretation of this. It's a big one. It breaks my heart to say yes, but like, yeah, the vibes are really bad. When you sign Mike Williams in free agency and bring it back to the Chargers, and then when he gets hurt, your solution is to sign Keenan Allen back to join the Chargers again.
1:02:54I'm already in a position where I'm like, you are so tempting fate. You are so lining up a full Charger ring right now that it felt like something was going to come down the mountain. And for Slater, just mere weeks after the extension, to then have a season-ending knee injury. In a season in which the Chargers addressed all their other positions but didn't address the offensive line the way we were hoping to, and now it's year two, let's switch the side of Joe Ull, our first-round tackle, to get Trey Pipkins back on the field? It's just way too much Charger behavior for me to ignore the ominous clouds circling on the horizon.
1:03:29so I will say Trey Pippkin's pardon me is not a disaster at right tackle right like this is not we're not looking at this and thinking every you know Justin Herbert is going to be dead out there Jeff Joel of course played left tackle in college uh he the position switched for him rookie was going to the right side there's hope that you can still get pretty high level play out of him. Pipkins, I think 2023, he started it. He's played at like every position I feel like for the Chargers over the years. 2022, they did a three-year deal with him. And then yeah, he played right tackle. So it's not awful.
1:04:09I think it just limits the ceiling in a way because there was already question. I already had questions about the interior of the Chargers offensive line yes the tackles were supposed to be the strength but now it's no longer a strength once again the line is a question mark i think there's a world in which you can get average offensive line play out of this unit it's not entirely outside the realm of possibility but the vision i had for this offense where like all the run games can be so much better and obviously they invested in you know marine hampton and whatnot that to me is a little bit murkier and i feel like once again we are going to be forced to say yeah but justin her it was under pressure on you know and and the other thing is that i would feel a lot better about our wide receiver room is a uh primarily a slot receiver in lad mcconkey and then we added another slot in keenan allen we're trying to figure out the downfield stuff i feel a lot better about that i feel a lot better about we have four tight ends that we're going to rotate and we don't really have like one clear emphatic starter i'd feel a lot better about hey like we thought we had to help our interior offensive line.
1:05:21And now we have to send more help to our right tackle now, it's our left tackle injury. I feel so much better about all this. If I really, really trusted the offensive coaching staff. And I really felt like the offensive coaching staff had proven that they are good at not just installing what they do, but in coaching around the limits and the realities of their depth chart, which for everything that Greg Roman brings very positively as a running game designer, as an innovator, as a pistol, a quarterback option run game for all the positives he's brought. Roman has historically showed that he is struggles when it's time to coach around the limitations on your roster.
1:05:51And this offensive roster has some limitations. And so I just, I, I, I dread the film. I'm going to turn on in week seven, when after six games of Trey Pipkins getting attacked on passing downs, Trey Pipkins getting attacked on passing downs. And we're just, we're just back to the same stuff week in and week out. All right. Well, something to watch a note to end on. I have the chargers actually next Saturday, they're playing the Rams. And I suspect that we will see the starting offensive line because they're going to want to get combination reps. So that will be an interesting one to watch. Ben, as always, great to have you on.
1:06:30Have to have you on again soon before you go on leave. Once the season starts, I'll be back later this week with the NFC South with John Legyard wrapping with the AFC South, their final division the week after that.
1:06:47This is what I Ruby
From the publisher
Mina and Ben react to preseason Week 1. Shedeur Sanders impresses in his debut with the Browns. They break down the QB competitions for the Colts and Saints. Rookie QBs Cam Ward and Jaxson Dart looked good in their debuts. And the Giants o-line looks to be a force to be reckoned with. Find out our early preseason thoughts!
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices




