

A discussion of whether Labour leader Andy Burnham is moving toward rejoining the EU, framed around a UK-EU “Reset Summit” and its knock-on effects for education and Brexit policy.
Lucy Powell, Labour’s deputy leader and de facto deputy prime minister; Education Secretary. Background: previously director of Britain in Europe; campaigned for Remain in 2016; now leads England’s education policy.
The summit is mainly about reducing costs and business red tape (especially food/agriculture), improving youth mobility, and linking carbon markets to reduce border charges on goods like steel and aluminium. The EU is pressing for “equalised” tuition fees for EU students (paying the same as UK students), which Powell says would be negotiated and must not disadvantage British students or destabilise university funding. She says rejoining is “miles off” but could be reconsidered later depending on the relationship’s benefits/costs. She also argues education reform will keep academic standards while adding technical/creative skills for an AI world.
EU port checks and paperwork described as redundant; Erasmus rejoined; “Made in Europe” industrial policy and car-industry competitiveness concerns; Russell Brand’s wife publishing prison thoughts (as a prompt on social-media regulation).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the significance of the Reset Summit and its impact on UK-EU relations.
“We are here in central Manchester to speak to his deputy, the de facto Deputy Prime Minister Lucy Powell and the Education Secretary as well.”
Exploration of Andy Burnham's evolving stance on Brexit and its implications.
“thought might just be useful for John and I to maybe talk a little bit about exactly where we've got to, because it is an amazing, extraordinary kind of transition.”
Overview of proposals discussed at the summit, including carbon markets and student fees.
“So it's been deferred to now, to November.”
Analysis of the ongoing complexities and implications of Brexit on UK policies.
“You know, we are on the right outer zone, that complete periphery sort of beyond Neptune, beyond Pluto in terms of European relations with its neighbouring states.”
Discussion on the internal challenges and concerns within the Labour Party regarding Brexit.
“And it is true to say the EU isn't everything.”
Exploration of public sentiment towards Brexit and how it affects Labour's strategy.
“So we're not taking the rules and the standards of the European Union.”
Explore Andy Burnham's approach to the EU and its implications for his political future.
“But if you're a small company, you just think, well, I'm not going to trade with Europe.”
Lucy Powell discusses her role and the significance of education policy in the Brexit context.
“Not that that's a feature of anything, of course, for the two leading Manchester figures of the Labour Party, that it just also happens to be here.”
Discussion on the EU's stance on tuition fees for European students in the UK post-Brexit.
“And we're recording, just for listeners, we're recording this at about 10 past 11, just as this is all going on.”
How the presence of international students affects the UK higher education system financially.
“which is this kind of new, quite protectionist industrial policy, which would be very damaging to this country if we don't have access, fair access to.”
The complexities of negotiating with the EU and the balancing act of mutual interests.
“A bit like, look, we've rejoined from next year, we've just rejoined the Erasmus scheme.”
Discussion on the motivations behind European leaders seeking closer ties with the UK.
“That's been suggested quite widely today.”
Conversation about potential future relationships with the EU, including rejoining.
“We're already working much more closely with Europe right now on issues around defence and migration.”
Insights on the benefits and drawbacks of EU membership and the changing landscape.
“Just briefly, education, we might not be because we could have a general election next year, certainly the year after.”
The role of public opinion in deciding future UK-EU relationships.
“The Prime Minister said we've lost more than we've gained.”
Discussion on the new Education Secretary's strategies and priorities.
“You do sound like I can imagine you saying maybe, you know, when the decision does come.”
Focus on creating more pathways for children's success beyond academic limits.
“Well, talking about change in this new job, which I know you'd coveted and really wanted and which you've been in for a few months now.”
Responses to criticisms of educational policies and their impact on various needs.
“It's left too many now not in education, employment or training.”
The need for a balanced approach to education focusing on both skills and knowledge.
“It's not got worse than the Labour, actually.”
Conversation on the importance of updating education systems to meet future demands.
“people need today for the world in which they are going into are very different from that of 20 years ago.”
Discussing the importance of making education relevant to engage students.
“I, of course, want more working class kids going to university.”
Discusses how relevant subject matter can improve academic achievement.
“relevant things that then improve people's academic achievement as well.”
Explores the implications of prisoners with social media access and potential legal changes.
“And, you know, actually, I think it's in their own terms of reference and their own terms of operating that they shouldn't be doing so.”
Examines the benefits and challenges of the new office in Number 10 North.
“leaders around the country and others, so that we are thinking about how all of our policies can be implemented on the ground.”
Discusses the implications of Lucy Powell's views on the Labour Party and Europe.
“So we've just stepped out of number 10 north.”
Analyzes the political landscape and challenges facing Andy Burnham regarding the EU.
“The fact is the Labour Party, particularly in its old northern heartlands, many of which in the Midlands as well, South Wales, many of which it won back in 2024.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On The News Agents, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:02This is a global production. Now you almost certainly wouldn't know it from this relatively underwhelming Christmas market that I'm stood next to. You certainly wouldn't know it from the pretty normal Slug and Lettuce, which is just next door around the corner from the building that I'm going to. You almost certainly wouldn't know it from the Wings Chinese restaurant, which is virtually sharing a door. But this door that I'm standing next to is now basically, we're led to believe, the beating heart of modern British politics. It is, of course, number 10 North. The Andy Burnham idea to rewire the political geography and decision making of the UK.
0:47We are here in central Manchester to speak to his deputy, the de facto Deputy Prime Minister Lucy Powell and the Education Secretary as well. And we are going to talk about her brief on education because she has got some big plans to change the way that England's school children are educated. But of course, this is the day of the UK-EU so-called Reset Summit, a summit which has been thrown into some chaos this morning over the issue of whether or not EU students should pay the same fees to go to British universities as UK students. So what better day to catch up with the Education Secretary herself?
1:26on the future of England's schools, on the Andy Burnham government and its future, and on this so-called reset with the EU. Welcome to the News Agents from Manchester.
1:41The News Agents. It's John. It's Lewis. And before we get to that interview with Lucy Powell and get a sense from her about how she sees the government's policy on Brexit and other things going forward, thought might just be useful for John and I to maybe talk a little bit about exactly where we've got to, because it is an amazing, extraordinary kind of transition. We reflected before, weren't we, John, that, you know, when Burnham was running in Makerfield and he was talking about the Makerfield test, I think we got a sense he was, you know, he'd said that he regretted that Brexit was happening.
2:12He'd said, I think, by that point, that he'd hope we'd rejoin in his lifetime. But for the idea, what are we, like, four months on, four months into his premiership, that he would be actively positing and suggesting rejoin? I don't think we'd have predicted that. Well, you think of Labour's whole position going into the 2024 general election, which was just, we don't want to talk about Brexit. I promise you, I promise you, we're not going to reopen anything about Brexit. We're just about making the agreement work and maybe make it work a little bit better. But we are accepted that we are outside the European Union and never to return.
2:46Andy Burnham becomes leader. He gets to the Labour Party conference in Liverpool. and suddenly he's talking about Europe. And you think, well, was that a momentary slip? Was that a kind of daring to say out loud what he privately thought? And you think, actually, Andy Burnham believes this. He doesn't quite know where the argument might take him, but he is determined to make the argument. And I don't know whether Andy Burnham has a clear destination in mind. I want us to be part of the customs union or I want us to be in the single market or the maximalist position. I want us to be back inside the European Union as a full member.
3:23I don't know whether he's got that worked out, but he's not shying away from the argument. He's determined to make it. And I think the way he is framing it so far has been clever to say, is this the best we can do? And asking people, if I can make it better, why wouldn't I? And I think that that is a clever way of positioning it. but it also raises a whole load of other questions about what the next steps are and is he ready for the battle that is certainly going to ensue from all the forces that pushed for Brexit but you know 10 years ago. Indeed and I should just sort of take you through what's being proposed today with this latest summit and this summit of course was going to happen under Keir Starmer much earlier in the year and it didn't happen because of the kind of leadership convulsions within the Labour Party and the change of government.
4:12So it's been deferred to now, to November. And the three things that basically are sort of going to emerge from it, the thing about food and agriculture, so removing some of the checks and paperwork on food and animal products which have been crossing the channel, mainly actually, to be fair, in their direction. I don't know if you saw this, it's a bit of a parenthesis, but I thought it was like such a good sort of embodiment of some of the problems around Brexit, all the ridiculousness around Brexit. all these ports, our ports built loads of kind of clearing houses and warehouse space for the checks on food that were supposed to be coming in they've barely been used they've barely been used because we just don't have the kind of actual people and border officers and all of the necessary checks that like, so a lot of these ports have spent tens of millions on these buildings right, and now as a result of the changes that Burnham is going to bring in they'll be completely redundant And this is kind of, I think this embodies kind of the instability that Brexit has caused British business.
5:11But anyway, so they're going to go, which will be a relief to lots of farmers in particular. There's going to be a thing about carbon emissions and linking British and EU carbon markets. It's a bit technical, but it kind of basically is about reducing carbon border charges on steel, aluminium and other goods. So it's, again, sort of basically less bureaucracy. And obviously this big thing about youth mobility and allowing UK, a certain number of UK students to go to the EU and vice versa. And there's probably going to be agreement on lowering the fees on UK university for UK university admissions on EU students.
5:43So, you know, all valuable stuff like it will make things easier for people around the edges. And in some industries it will be especially helpful. But I do think it kind of embodies kind of what Burnham is getting at, which is that we left the EU with a pretty threadbare deal. I mean, we have a more distant formal economic relationship in terms of the structures which govern our economic relationship, even than Turkey and the EU, more distant than Ukraine and the EU, more distant than Iceland and the EU. You know, we are on the right outer zone, that complete periphery sort of beyond Neptune, beyond Pluto in terms of European relations with its neighbouring states.
6:25That's what Boris Johnson left us with. It was a real change because before, obviously, we've been in the single market, been in the customs union and so on. And what I think in terms of these piecemeal bits, what the EU is kind of now saying, partly possibly because they're hearing what Burnham is saying about potentially rejoining, is like this is kind of as close as we're going to get. Of course, we'll work with little bits here and there. But anything more profound, anything deeper, and actually you've got to start talking about the structures. So that's single market customs union or rejoining.
6:57And it's just worth underlining again that the Labour manifesto, which Andy Burnham has said he will stick by because that's what brought the Labour government to power, the Labour Party to power in 2024, is him saying, no, no, we won't do anything until we get a new mandate. and in terms of the big structural changes like a customs union or the single market or rejoining. If it's rejoining, I think it has to be a referendum because you cannot do that. Just even if you say, OK, we're going to make our manifesto a one line manifesto. We're going to rejoin the European Union, even if the British people voted for that because it's in a manifesto.
7:37There's nothing that stops the Tories reform at the next election saying, well, we're going to have a one line manifesto. we're coming out again and i think the european union would just think oh my god no no you've the only way you're going to rejoin is if this is the settled view of the nation for a generation because you can't just keep rerunning and rerunning a referendum like that and burnham's argument which is true and this is one of the problems with those who sort of say just leave the leave it alone let's leave it alone and i can see some of the political kind of sense behind that which is like oh my god we want to reopen all this it did consume so much bandwidth for the British state and British politics and the national conversation.
8:14And it is true to say the EU isn't everything. It is a gradually declining percentage of our exports and a declining percentage, obviously, of the world economy. But there are new things which happen all the time. So listeners, viewers might have come across or heard of the Made in Europe programme. This is basically the EU's attempt to give European manufacturers preferential treatment when governments spend public money or supporting strategic industries. right, so it's basically subsidies. There was a big question about, we want to basically, we want Europe to treat us as an equivalent member, basically.
8:51Guess who doesn't want that? The French. The French are saying they don't want us to do that. And that really matters for something like the car industry, right? So for example, if you have a mini manufactured in Oxford, you know, we're a big car manufacturer, under potentially the way that Made in Europe might work, it might not qualify for any of those incentives available to a car assembled in Germany despite the fact that the company is owned by a German company, right? Those two plants are owned by the same company, one in, say, Hamburg, one in Oxford. What do we think that's going to do to the UK car industry?
9:19It's going to make it substantially less competitive. And you roll that on and roll that on for industry after industry, particularly in more established industrial areas. So these things, and what's one of the costs? OK, and the EU is saying, OK, you can be part of that. But guess what? You've got to apply the same tariffs on Chinese EVs that we're applying, electric vehicles and you've got to apply the same tariffs that we have so what i'm sort of saying is this stuff gets complex but the point is is that we can't easily disentangle ourselves from europe and from european economic policy and the point is at the moment is we're not in the room we're not in the room as these decisions are being made and we have to rely on coming to agreement on a case-by-case basis which brussels often doesn't want to give so these questions are not going away the economic case is reasonably clear on on these matters at least but the political problem obviously for andy burnham is potentially difficult yeah and the political problem is not just external forces look yeah i'm sure the daily mail the express the telegraph the times will all kind of line up against him and you know and and all the people that were anti last time will still be anti he's got problems in his own labor party he's got problems with the trade unions there are an awful lot of people who think that actually maybe one we don't want to reopen this debate we're in a i'm in a red wall seat and oh my god they voted for brexit last time please leave this one alone that's you know labor mps and they're a substantial number and there are serious economic arguments as well on the other side on the flip side of you know our position on ai for example we're in a much stronger position gene editing a lot of the emergent technologies exactly we're we've got a different regulatory regime now where we have separated ourselves from the EU.
11:03So we're not taking the rules and the standards of the European Union. The city isn't that keen going back in either. The city isn't that keen. I mean, and then you get things like Donald Trump's tariffs and you've got the Scotch whisky industry that got a carve out from his tariffs who would think, oh, well, hang on, if we're back in the EU, then we'll be subject to all the same tariffs that French Burgundy wine or whatever it happens to be is. So I think there are arguments as well there that you know it's not a clear run that Andy Burnham has everyone at his back on his own side saying go for it Andy.
11:35And I think that John you put your finger on one of the key differences in terms of the changes in the political environment of 2026 compared to 2016. 2016 the Labour Party was overwhelmingly remain pro-remain not all of its voters in fact about a third of Labour voters from 2015 actually voted leave but at an elite level at parliamentary level, trade union level, usually those who the Labour leavers were quite eccentric figures, happened to probably include the leader of the Labour Party at the time. That was one of the problems, Jeremy Corbyn. But, you know, overwhelmingly, it was the case that Labour was pro-Remain.
12:08Labour Party feels to me not quite as bad as this, but it's actually a lot more like the Labour Party was in the 70s, actually, you know, in the first referendum, when the Labour Party was much more split. Because then for, I think, more ideological reasons about the EU being a capitalist club it's not so much that now it's more just a sense of the Labour Party was scarred by Brexit not so much just it happening but then what happened in 2019 because there was obviously a feeling that the Labour Party would seem to be obstructionist to Brexit Boris Johnson obviously ran a very effective campaign you know Labour Party had a what felt at the time like a kind of near-death event in large parts of its old industrial heartlands in the north of England and in parts of Wales and in the Midlands and so on.
12:52And those MPs are sort of right to be worried potentially because if you look at the difference between 2019 and 2024, in lots of those seats, you do not see remarkable Labour Party recovery in those places. Very often you only see them adding maybe a few thousand votes. What you see is a complete collapse in the Conservative vote, often eaten into by a much weaker at the time Reform Party, but which still in many seats made the difference. And I think what Andy Burnham thinks clearly, which is really interesting, I think he thinks that public opinion has shifted. And I think he thinks as a red wall whisperer that he can shift it further and he can actually use it politically.
13:32And there is lots of evidence of that. I mean, the polling is very, very clear. People are very dissatisfied by Brexit. And it's clear that he's making like strong arguments, particularly about like, you know, the weekly shop and so on. But you can understand why lots of Labour MPs who were in these constituencies before, who understand them, who know them. they're worried that the same trick could be pulled off that the Labour Party won't have its act together and that you know the vote leave bandwagon reassembles and recoalesces and basically does that thing which they've already basically that they think they've got strong argument which is tell them again tell them again and the Labour Party once again finds itself in its own fear anyway on the side of elites against the kind of like will of the people and it's just this kind of like psychological scarring that they've got that that could just happen all over again yeah what we've had from andy burnham is him making an argument about things aren't good enough and that is an argument without an answer it seems to me because things aren't great and you know if you are trying to do business in europe and you've kind of quite a small company small medium size enterprise nightmare nightmare all the paperwork you haven't got the people to to devote So at the time, if you're a kind of Marks and Spencer, fine, you've got a huge infrastructure and you can do it and you've got the people who are there to do it.
14:49But if you're a small company, you just think, well, I'm not going to trade with Europe. So you lose an export market because you're a small bit. So that side of it is unanswerable. But has Andy Burnham himself worked out? I mean, has he got an end point in mind where he's played this game of chess and he's thought the 10 moves ahead and then thinks that is where I'm going to get to and that's where it's check made? or is he just seeing how the game develops slowly how the argument changes what the polling looks like what public opinion is sentiment is how strong the argument is raging whether it's being as divisive as it was in 2016 or whether he can form a new consensus it's still unclear to me whether Andy Burnham has that end point firmly tied down in his own mind and he'll definitely if there is an election so next year in next may which I still think there's I think there's a you know reasonable chance of this kind of um this sort of delicate dance that he's doing at the moment will come to an end because you have to have a policy then as soon as you're then talking about the manifesto you've got to have a policy to get through the nec of the labor party labor party conference all those sorts of things you know you've got to you've got to actually have practicalities of politics yeah you're gonna if he's serious about it and i think inevitably there is a kind of binary to this which is either stay where we are or rejoin i think all the other options that are stronger than where we are, single market customs union, are just too difficult because it basically makes us a rule taker and we've just got too big an economy to just not have any say in the rules going on by Brussels, we're not Norway and so you've got to kind of have a policy to say, put in the manifesto and go basically do a reverse David Cameron 2015, you go, you know we're going to negotiate a deal and then we're going to put that to the public in the next parliament or you're not going to do it, but that will be a moment of decision and maybe that comes next May, maybe it comes later, I mean who knows but this delicate dance in the end I mean it does have a time limit on it anyway we're going to put some of those questions as we said at the top to well effectively the Deputy Prime Minister certainly Deputy Leader of the Labour Party Lucy Powell in number 10 North in Manchester and more besides too
17:07Well, Education Secretary Lucy Powell, Deputy Leader of the Labour Party, thank you so much for welcoming us to the new beating political capital of the UK, Number 10 North. This is the hot ticket in town, Lewis. In your own constituency, though. Yeah, it is. The great Manchester Central. So, yeah, really good unit. Not that that's a feature of anything, of course, for the two leading Manchester figures of the Labour Party, that it just also happens to be here. It's very convenient, of course, for home. It's very convenient. No, it's great. But yeah, as I often say to the Prime Minister, I am actually a Mancunian, unlike him.
17:38Quite so, quite so. That sort of ersatz manc. Anyway, we're going to talk about your brief and about your plans for education, because I know you've got lots of plans and you want to talk about them. But just given we are speaking on this big Brexit summit day, and indeed it appears that potentially one of the holdups or problems to a potential deal has been something in your area, which is education and about tuition fees. um what is your what is your understanding about what the eu wants on tuition fees for eu students because of course when we were in the eu they were treated like home students then when we left they were treated as international students and now they seem to be wanting to be treated as home students again i.e pay the same as british kids even though we're not in the club anymore so what is your understanding of what they've asked for well let's see what the statement um says because is, yeah, I think the deal has been done, but the statement hasn't been published yet.
18:33And we're recording, just for listeners, we're recording this at about 10 past 11, just as this is all going on. We're in the middle of the interregnum, which is always quite annoying for you broadcasters, I'm sure. It's not ideal for a podcast, I'll be honest. I'm sorry. But look, I think what, we've got this big deal, which is mainly focused on reducing costs and reducing business red tape, especially around food and agriculture and also improving the kind of youth experience for young people, both British and European, which are the sort of central tenets of this particular deal and this summit.
19:11Then I think there will be some further conversations around made in Europe, which is this kind of new, quite protectionist industrial policy, which would be very damaging to this country if we don't have access, fair access to. Particularly the car industry. But a whole load of industries. And in those conversations, the European Union and the Commission want to talk about having access to reduced or home fees for students. And I think what I found very quickly as education secretary is our education system, particularly our higher education system, is the envy of the world. And people want to send their young people here because we've got such high quality, fantastic reputation in our higher education system.
20:04And I think that's great. It's usually the one thing that everyone wants to talk to us about. But why would you be happy to see European students get a discount or pay the same as UK students? I mean, why should they, given that, you know, we're not in their club and they're not in ours? Well, look, we, you know, we've always welcomed international students here, whether that's from Europe or from around the world. It's a really big part of our HE kind of sector. So it's also always historically and now been a big part of kind of how we have our kind of British culture and values kind of exported around the world through all of these millions of young people who over the years have come here to study.
20:46And, you know, that's always something we're going to welcome. But what I will make sure, absolutely, and the government will make sure, is that our universities can withstand that and that our young people, British young people here, are not disadvantaged in any way. The Treasury has estimated, I know, if it were a full equalisation, it could cost half a billion pounds. I mean, when public money is so tight, is that an appropriate use of taxpayer funding, subsidising probably quite rich European families to come and get their higher education in the UK? Look, let's see where we get to. We are some way off those sort of detailed, really detailed conversations, I think, that they will continue to do.
21:32Would you be content as part of a wider deal? Would you be content to say that is something worth giving them that equalisation as education secretary? It depends what we we're getting, obviously, in return. So there are there are there are benefits that we want to get for this country, for our economy, to get growth into our economy, reduce costs, reduce red tape, increase trade for our industries. And we've got a really big agenda now as a government to re-industrialise the country and really get some of those great manufacturing industries and jobs back into this country. So, look, it depends what we're getting in return.
22:15And that's why these things are always part of a negotiation and a discussion. Will our kids, students, be able to go and study at their universities for their equivalent? Yeah, and that would be part of, of course, that would be part of any discussion and deal on that. A bit like, look, we've rejoined from next year, we've just rejoined the Erasmus scheme. Actually, something that I think still got very strong branding in this country, which is there's a huge excitement about for young British young people, us being part of the Erasmus scheme, which of course has reciprocal benefits for European young people as well.
22:52But for our young people, they get to go now and study in Europe as part of the Erasmus scheme. And this has got to be reciprocal. If there is that equalisation and British universities lose the funding that would have come from it, because there are a lot of European students studying in the UK, would you commit to the government ensuring that those universities receive that income that they would have had and would have relied upon, i.e. you will make it up? Look, higher education funding is a big issue right now. We have seen a fall in international students and that's having an impact on universities as well.
23:30We've also brought in legislation to make sure that domestic fees can increase with inflation because, you know, those costs have been kept down and that's put pressure on our higher education. our higher education sector and our universities in this country are really the jewel in the crown of this country across many areas, not just education. So I will always make sure that our universities are secure in that way. And I will always make sure that British students are not disadvantaged or displaced in any of that thing. So these are conversations that are ongoing and we'll continue to have them.
24:12but we've got to make sure that there are the benefits that we need to see and any such deal, any such conversations is in the national interest and we'll always put that first. Doesn't it show, though, Education Secretary, just thinking about the EU more broadly, and obviously the Prime Minister has indicated he wants to improve the relationship, doesn't it show that fundamentally that negotiating with the EU is really tough and they are very rules-based and they often are quite selective in how they apply their rules? and they're basically saying today, I mean the understanding is if you don't agree within six months to that equalisation over something pretty trivial in the grand scheme of things which is university tuition fees for a relatively small number of European students coming if they're willing to blow up the Prime Minister's deal, this reset over that it shows that frankly any wider reset or certainly any rejoin effort is doomed before it even starts.
25:05Well look, let's see what the actual statement says when it comes out and what the nature of the deal. Yeah, I think what's been made clear already this morning is that there is now a deal and that's been done. And that there are some further conversations to be had around things like the made in Europe concept, around things like tuition fees. But you're right, of course the Europeans do, of course they drive a hard bargain. But I think so do we. And I think what the debate about the tuition fees and access to our higher education shows is that we have a lot to bring to the table. We have things that our European partners want access to as well.
25:50And that's why these conversations are not, as some would like to present them, somehow, you know, we're going sort of cap in hand to Europe. we have lots of things that Europeans want access to and that they want to be part of, as well as they have things that we want to be access to and we be part of. So this is a partnership and a conversation between equals. But just because, you know, you're the deputy leader of the Labour Party, basically de facto deputy prime minister, and you're the education secretary. Are you saying to Brussels today, OK, we've got this tentative agreement and they're saying we've got to agree the tuition fee proposal within six months to get the rest.
26:27You're saying that actually that might not happen, that you might not agree to the tuition fee proposals unless we get what we want on Made in Europe and other things. Is that what you're saying? I'm not saying, don't put words in my mouth, Lewis. Let's see what the joint statement says when it comes out. what we are agreeing on, what the conversation is about today and this particular summit is about reducing those business costs, hopefully bringing down costs in the supermarket, particularly around these deals on food and agriculture and giving British young people and others, you know, access to some new experiences and movement around Europe as well.
27:13Then there are some further conversations that will be had and all of these things are always part of uh you know tight negotiations but i think but i want to just be really clear you know we we have some things that the european union and others around the world whether that's china india and others who all want to send their young people to our universities i'm not going to put our great universities at risk you know they are a brilliant advert for this country there's something that we have to offer for people and we will you might say we we will make access to that i just want to just part of the deal you might say no we will it's all part of a deal and negotiations and a discussion still to be had of course of course um just on the wider uh wider if we were to be cheeky education secretary might we suggest i might think like you to be i know not like me i know i know i looked i went to a comprehensive school we picked it up there didn't we um If it were being cheeky, might we think the European leaders and Eurocrats in Brussels, maybe they've got a bit of an ulterior motive here because they want to send their kids to British universities or already do and they want to save themselves a few quid.
28:23That's been suggested quite widely today. I mean, who knows? We, as I say, I think the Prime Minister has been really clear that we want a closer relationship with Europe. We're already working much more closely with Europe right now on issues around defence and migration. We want a closer relationship with Europe that is in our national interest. Of course, the Europeans will want things that are in their interests as part of any reset of any kind of deal that is being done. That's what you'd expect. But let's not be under any illusion. We have got things that the Europeans want. Just on, before we get to education, just on the one final question on Brexit.
29:06The Prime Minister has obviously indicated that there are a variety of end states that we could end up on, not for this parliament, the red lines are in place for this parliament, but for the next parliament. He's hinted and talked about quite directly the idea that potentially rejoin might be an option. Could you imagine yourself advocating for rejoin? I think we're a long way off those kind of conversations. Just briefly, education, we might not be because we could have a general election next year, certainly the year after. The Labour Party is going to have to have a position on that quite soon.
29:37I'm just wondering in principle whether it's something you could imagine yourself rejoining. I was the director of Britain in Europe. So I spent many, many years campaigning for us to be a close part of the European Union. and I campaigned for Remain in the 2016 Brexit referendum. But even so, I've always taken quite a pragmatic view about these things. There are real benefits to our membership of the European Union, or there were, and there were also, even when we were in, there were disbenefits as well. And today that is true, but things have changed significantly in the last 10 years, both for the UK, for Europe, and for the rest of the world.
30:18So you've got to weigh up all the time. And that is not a fixed point. It's a fixed point at a moment in time. What are the benefits? What are the disbenefits? And therefore, what's the right thing to do at that point of time, depending on what the nature of that relationship is, what the nature of that deal is. The Prime Minister said we've lost more than we've gained. Yeah, I mean, look, we have lost in terms of trade, and I think that's really clear. But there were disbenefits about being in the European Union. We have more flexibilities now in some regards, especially monetary and economic policy that we might not otherwise have had, and trade with other countries.
30:58So let's see, we are, what we're not talking about, don't think what anyone is talking about is going back to some time in the past. We're going to get this relationship and this reset done now. There are obviously going to be further conversations still to come. And then for some time in the future, we'll look at what is possible and what are the opportunities, but also the costs of any kind of future. not even re-entry but the future types you know there's associate membership now being kind of proposed for Canada there's a whole range of options here and it will be for the public to decide I think that is really clear it will be for the public to decide Well except the Labour Party will have to have a position on it We're miles off that I'm not writing we're not writing the manifesto yet we're some way off the general election So you can't imagine a world We haven't had any kind of conversations about what that might look like so you know as I've always done you know I will take a view on those things when there is something before us to take a view on.
32:01And there isn't that at the moment. I'm quite interested. You do sound like I can imagine you saying maybe, you know, when the decision does come. I can, from the tone and what you're saying, it sounds to me like you're saying you can imagine a world where we are better off staying out. Look, the world has changed. So, and who knows what would be on offer? I think certainly the nature, I think it is possible. And certainly the nature of the relationship that we had before, the kind of deal that we had before in terms of the rebate and, you know, outside Schengen. I just think these things are some way off.
32:37Well, talking about change in this new job, which I know you'd coveted and really wanted and which you've been in for a few months now. What are you doing differently as Education Secretary under this prime minister than your predecessor did under the last? Well, Bridget did a great job as Education Secretary and she brought particular focus, I think, around issues of child poverty and the early years, you know, rolling out free breakfast clubs and extending free school meals and the huge expansion we've seen in this child care offer. And what I'm really focused on, and it's also because the Prime Minister is really focused on, is transforming other aspects of our education system so that no child is left behind, so that more children have got more pathways and more routes to success.
33:29that taking on the kind of view that education needed to be a kind of one size fits all, quite a narrower and narrower kind of agenda. A focus on academic. Yeah, I mean, academic is one way of describing it, but I think just a one size and narrower sort of view of education. And that's left too many behind. It's left too many now not in education, employment or training. The disadvantage gap has remained very, very stubborn over the last 15, 20 years. The gap between regions is growing wider. And we've got too many young people not in education at all and persistently absent. So we've not done everything right.
34:17So there are changes that need to be made. And that's what we're doing across a range of areas. But if we're talking sort of conceptually, philosophically about your approach, your kind of theory of education, if you like you know what your critics say i mean michael gove says that your education policy is bringing back stupid what would you say to him yeah well i'm i'm absolutely not and i think look the the more um the more michael gove attacks me on education the more i know i'm doing the right thing quite honestly um because um yes we've seen a sort of 30-year consensus begun by the last Labour government prioritising literacy and numeracy and introduction of phonics.
34:54We've seen standards rise and state education improve. But Michael Gove and the Conservatives do need to take responsibility for their legacy. And their legacy is a million young people, not in education, employment or training. It is this long tail, this stubborn long tail of too many people feeling left behind. It is a crisis in special educational needs. We'll talk about that. And many, many children feeling that education doesn't suit them. But hang on a minute, Education Secretary. In fairness, I mean, we know we can talk about the needs crisis. It's got worse than the Labour. It's not got worse than the Labour, actually.
35:35Well, it hit a million under Labour and actually it reduced under the Conservatives by the tail end of their time, certainly pre the pandemic. No, the big, no, no, no, the big, the big, big jump in needs and the graphs are really, really clear on this, Lewis, the big jumping needs came between 2021 and 2024. It's actually taken a downturn. But also, you're talking about England's performance in schools. Yeah. England's 15-year-olds scored, as you know, above the OECD average in all three subjects in the last P's, significantly ahead of Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. you of course there will be criticisms of any um set of set of education secretaries but isn't the point isn't the truth that in fact that emphasis on academic rigor has worked yes of course it might not work for everyone all of the time but in terms of england schools england schools are now better than anywhere else in the uk and many of our competitors and that is not only michael gove's legacy but as you say the new labor legacy as well and their critique of you is you want to unpick it and i don't want to unpick it i mean i think the emphasis is the emphasis on um literacy numeracy reading writing and maths um and raising standards and the whole system um uh focusing on on outcomes and raising standards and we're absolutely not turning our back on standards but what we are doing is facing the future so the skills as well as the knowledge that our young people need today for the world in which they are going into are very different from that of 20 years ago.
37:13And that's why we do need to reform the national curriculum. And that's what we're doing. That is why we do need to give greater emphasis to some of the technical and creative skills that are going to be more in demand in the AI world than they were in the past. And we haven't been giving young people a chance to do that. The AI world is going to need absolute emphasis and focus on the most rigorous academic qualifications in engineering, in science, in mathematics. And indeed, in this AI world, we need more kids with the most rigorous humanities education to be able to make sense of this transformed world around them.
37:46So this might seem an odd moment to retreat, your critics would say, from the standards agenda. I'm not retreating. I'm not retreating. And I really do take issue with this sort of false choice between knowledge and skills, because that's what essentially it's about. Do you believe that education should just be about knowledge or just about skills. Of course, it's about absolutely, it's about both. So let me just explain, because I think it's really important. In the AI world, yes, we're going to need young people with more qualifications, not fewer. So I want more young people to have more qualifications, not fewer.
38:20But we're also going to need more young people that can apply their skills and knowledge, not just have them. And the jobs of the future that AI won't be able to do, like building a house or coming in and putting the electrics and the plumbing into a house or caring for someone. Those are great jobs, Education Secretary. Or cutting my hair and those kind of things. Or doing engineering, as you say, applied engineering, applied digital tech. In fact, what AI is taking out are sort of different types of jobs. I meet computer science students today who say to me they are worried that they won't have a job with their computer science.
39:05So they shouldn't become headdressers instead? They shouldn't have a computer science degree. So we've got to keep with the times. We've got to get ahead of the times. But it sounds a bit aggressive. So you need to have the academic rigour alongside the applied skills. So those computer science students you're talking about, should they become plumbers or headdressers instead? No, they should have those. Of course they should continue doing computer science, but we need to make sure that the curriculum is keeping pace with that. our computer science qualification currently in schools doesn't even involve a computer so that's kind of fairly ridiculous so when you take the the theory of education to its end point of Michael Gove where it gets you is a computer science GCSE that doesn't involve a computer where it takes you is a drama GCSE and drama and being able to confidently speak and articulate yourself doesn't It doesn't involve drama.
39:53I, of course, want more working class kids going to university. HE is broader today than it was. Isn't there a danger, Education Secretary? There are lots of people listening and watching who might well subscribe to the sort of thrust of what you're saying, and yet just have that niggle in the back of their mind. And I'll be honest with you, that's the niggle I've got in the back of my mind. Both you and I were beneficiaries, as indeed was the Prime Minister, and much of the Cabinet of an academic education, which enabled you and him and me and all of those sorts of people to get on in life and to frankly improve our standards of living and there is a danger is there not a danger sometimes with this focus on vocational courses or certain types of courses in comprehensive schools in working class areas that they're always for working class kids and not for posh people's kids I am absolutely not going to oversee a two-tier development in our education this is about high aspiration high expectation high excellence for all of our children i want my kids to do um good gcses and things like engineering and in things like digital uh tech um so it's about raising the bar on all of those all of those all of those um to look to be to be um highly technical nothing wrong with being a plumber at all i'm just be highly technical in this future world of work we're going to need more kids with more qualifications whether that's a degree or whether it's level four level five as well which you know we need to see a big expansion you'd be happy that's why we're seeing a big expansion in degree apprenticeships as well that's the middle classes are rushing to degree apprenticeships by the way um you know and you know the conservatives used to be for high esteem in technical education as well as academic education i want my kids to be happy and successful and purposeful like everybody wants their parents to be and there are these bigger conversations going on but I want to make sure that every young person has these qualifications and actually one of the things we've really learned especially from the white working class inquiry which I take very close interest in is that for many young people they don't see the relevance of school and that's when they don't engage in study at school as well so having relevant things so that relevant things that then improve people's academic achievement as well.
42:16So financial literacy as part of maths, for example, helps children to achieve better in maths. Having English that they can understand and be relevant helps them improve their English. And one final matter before we just talk about number 10 very briefly, number 10 North, I should say. I know you've spoken a little bit this week about this extraordinary situation where Russell Brand's wife has been able to publish his thoughts about his imprisonment and the obvious nonsense that it's political persecution and so on. Do you think that, I mean, this is obviously a new thing, a relatively new thing, you know, prisoners having potentially millions of followers, maybe still quite a rare thing, but, you know, it might come up again.
42:58Do you think the government might need to change the law to compel social media sites to remove sex offenders content in the UK? Well, we don't think they should be. you know promoting their their content this is somebody who's uh been convicted of a very very serious uh set of offenses including um rape and um therefore you know we don't we think it's absolutely wrong for him to have some kind of uh platform um to to re-traumatize his victims by showing not a jot of uh not a jot of remorse and you know that's why we've been clear in what we've been asking of these platforms in this context. And, you know, actually, I think it's in their own terms of reference and their own terms of operating that they shouldn't be doing so.
43:50So I think this really is, you know, this is a moment for big tech in this regard to show their responsibilities and show that they're up to meeting them. And if they don't do it? We'll look at those things. It might require a change in the law. We're constantly looking at the law in this space. It's fast moving. Now it sits with Lisa and Andy, the Culture Secretary, and we've got further measures coming already later this year. Just finally, Education Secretary. Here we are in number 10 North. And it's obviously been set up here. And as we say, it's in your constituency. and it's, you know, turns out actually having a kind of proper office rather than 18th century aristocrat's home probably has some advantages compared to the one in London.
44:38Nonetheless, it's obviously been done, you know, to some fanfare, I'm sure at not inconsiderable expense. What have the benefits been? What are the benefits? I mean, can you name someone in the country, particularly not in Manchester, what changes has it brought to Whitehall that it wouldn't have happened anyway? Well, look, first of all, it does bring a very, very different perspective and a different kind of rewiring, really, of how things are considered in Whitehall. Which is practically what's changed. No, well, I think the sort of culture and the perspective is really important. The second thing is actually people really want to be part of this project and come here.
45:17So what it's designed to do is what it is doing, which is having real convening power, a different way of pulling together all of the mayors around the country, the leaders around the country and others, so that we are thinking about how all of our policies can be implemented on the ground. this big agenda around devolution, which here at Number 10 North, they are leading. They are leading that process. But as a result of that rewiring and that psychological change, I'm just wondering, can you name a single decision that's been made that wouldn't have been made or vice versa as a result of Number 10 North being in existence?
45:57We've got a new white paper coming, as you know, called Rewiring the State, which is a really ambitious agenda for devolution and getting growth in every postcode, as the Prime Minister calls it. That's all that work is being led from up here. And it's being led by people that were, up until recently, kind of doing that themselves on the ground. They're able to convene and get into parts of the country that, frankly, Whitehall just doesn't get into. But no concrete decisions yet. I've seen that from my perspective, coming into Whitehall, running a department. You know, aspects, it is still very insular, unfortunately.
46:38What's your department? What do you have an office here? Yeah, well, doing... Look, part of what we do is very on the ground, obviously, in education. A lot of what we do is devolve because local authorities lead on SEND or they lead on children's services or they lead on looked-after children that I'm responsible for the policy of. You know, while I'm getting at education, Sophie, your critics will say, frankly, it's a gimmick. It absolutely isn't. Well, is there a single decision that's been taken that wouldn't have been taken? It absolutely isn't. I think the way in which people have been brought together, the the real shift in focus uh the white paper that's coming coming out soon and what's happening and also i do know that many kind of smaller projects for places around the country have been unlocked um because of of number 10 north so it's not a you know it's not something you you you create a new office and instantly everything's changed this is about really shifting a way of working and moving power out into communities and that will take time but here is central to that I can honestly say that.
47:38Lucy Powell Education Secretary thanks so much for joining us and welcoming us to Number 10 North. Thank you so much for coming.
48:00So we've just stepped out of number 10 north. Maybe I was being a bit unfair with Lucy Powell there, calling it a gimmick. I'm sure it will yield lots of changes, too. And to be fair, it ain't a half bad decision to be next to Wings. We hear the Peking duck. It's absolutely incredible. Look, Lucy Powell there, I think, really striking to me, the extent to which she showed the potential dangers for Andy Burnham and how much more divided the Labour Party might be on Europe today than it was 10 years ago. She's saying in quite a different sort of tone to the Prime Minister that she can imagine a world where we are just better off staying out of the EU.
48:35That's not what Andy Burnham has been saying. The PM has been saying that we've lost more than we've gained and has been far more strident. The fact is the Labour Party, particularly in its old northern heartlands, many of which in the Midlands as well, South Wales, many of which it won back in 2024. Andy Burnham is from that place as well. But many of his colleagues are much less confident about the Labour Party going back onto that terrain. And today is a reminder, as hazy as the details still are as we're recording, the drama the PM's had today with the potential of this deal being derailed as a result of something as relatively trivial as student fees.
49:09The very fact that at a relatively unimportant summit about a relatively unimportant issue, the EU might have been willing to derail the entire thing or to drive such a hard bargain is a reminder for Burnham about how hard those reaccession talks might be. Europe remains for Labour now, as it used to for the Conservatives. A political Pandora's box. Right, we're off down the sluggy for at least an hour or two. We'll be back, of course, on Monday. And you can listen to my show on LBC, Sunday with Lewis Goodall, for all of the latest political developments and, of course, best interviews from 10 till 12.
49:48That is, of course, as the name would suggest, coming up on Sunday. We'll be back on Monday. Have a lovely weekend.
Andy Burnham has described today's deal with the EU as a "historic moment", as he reaches agreements on food exports, youth mobility and carbon emissions. But the EU wouldn't waiver on tuition fees, affirming European students should be charged the same as British students to attend University in the UK - and they've now set the PM a deadline of six months to get on board.
So where does the deal leave Burnham? Nigel Farage has said the Labour leader has "no mandate" for today's agreement. So has Burnham made a reunion with Europe more likely? Or does the sticking point of tuition fees show there's still a very long way to go?
Lewis is in 'Number 10 North' to put all of these questions, and more, to Burnham's deputy Labour leader, Lucy Powell.
The News Agents is a Global Production.
You can subscribe to The News Agents Plus for ad-free episodes and bonus content.
▶️ On YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCVbgFf27--l2zYAneDEgyJA/join
🎧 On Global Player and Apple - https://thenewsagentsplus.com/
Visit The News Agents website - https://www.thenewsagents.co.uk/
The News Agents is brought to you by HSBC UK - https://www.hsbc.co.uk/