In short
Average retirement account balances by generation (Gen Z, Millennials, Gen X, Baby Boomers) using Fidelity data, plus a Money Q&A covering student loans vs Roth IRA, brokerage fractional shares, and buying an out-of-state first rental property.
Guests
No recurring guests mentioned; the episode is hosted by Andrew (MasterMoney.co). Q&A includes three listener questioners (no names given in transcript).
Key claims
Start early for compounding; target at least 20% savings/investing. Gen Z: $13,500 average 401k; Millennials: $67,300; Gen X: $192,300; Boomers: $249,300 (401k) and $257,000 (IRA). Roth 401k participation varies (Gen Z 18.2%, Millennials 18.3%, Gen X 14.5%, Boomers 12.2%). Social Security shouldn’t be relied on.
Notable examples
Student loan case (3.97% avg; after-tax 3.1%)—host recommends redirecting $600/month to max Roth IRA. Brokerage case—switch from Merrill Edge to fractional-share brokers (Vanguard/Fidelity/M1/Schwab). Real estate case—new construction can reduce deferred maintenance, but must run cash-flow math including HOA and CDD taxes.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOTransforming Outdoor Spaces
0:00 to 0:56
Learn how upgrading outdoor spaces can enhance family time.
“Our outdoor setup used to be one of those spaces we walked past more than we actually used.”
Transforming Outdoor Spaces
1:01 to 2:11
Learn how upgrading outdoor spaces can enhance family time.
“Deadlines are stacking up, emails are flying, and then someone on your team gives notice.”
Gen Z Retirement Savings Insights
3:21 to 8:10
Explore Gen Z's average retirement savings and the importance of early investing.
“Now, today, we're going to be diving into the average retirement savings by generation.”
Millennials' Retirement Challenges
8:10 to 11:01
Discuss millennials' average retirement savings and the pressures they face.
“The millennials are a generation that early on did not save and invest as much as they should.”
Gen X Retirement Planning
11:01 to 14:03
Understand the retirement savings landscape for Generation X.
“So I need each and every single one of you to strap up and let's get invested.”
Understanding Financial Juggling for Gen X
14:03 to 17:33
Learn how Gen X can balance competing financial priorities and prepare for retirement.
“And so you have these competing priorities.”
Understanding Financial Juggling for Gen X
17:34 to 18:34
Learn how Gen X can balance competing financial priorities and prepare for retirement.
“Trips with kids, time outside, long weekends, and just more moments together as a family.”
Understanding Financial Juggling for Gen X
18:40 to 19:47
Learn how Gen X can balance competing financial priorities and prepare for retirement.
“When I started building this podcast and business, I underestimated how many different jobs I'd suddenly have.”
Understanding Financial Juggling for Gen X
20:18 to 20:46
Learn how Gen X can balance competing financial priorities and prepare for retirement.
“I'll do my five-minute drill, check in quickly, and their weekly recap will flag anything that's off before it becomes a problem.”
Insights on Baby Boomer Retirement Savings
20:46 to 21:53
Understand the retirement savings situation of the Baby Boomer generation.
“Check responses set up required compatibility and availability varies 18 plus.”
Show all 17 chapters
Comparative Analysis of Retirement Accounts by Generation
21:53 to 23:42
Learn about the average retirement account balances across generations.
“And the employer contributions are right around 5%.”
Comparative Analysis of Retirement Accounts by Generation
23:45 to 25:08
Learn about the average retirement account balances across generations.
“And it's how much of your personal information is floating around the internet right now.”
Money Q&A: Student Loan Management
25:08 to 28:00
Get expert advice on optimizing student loan repayments and investing in retirement.
“It is one of my favorite products that I have used over the course of the last couple of years.”
Maximizing Roth IRA Benefits
28:00 to 29:58
Learn the importance of investing in a Roth IRA for long-term financial growth.
“the tax deduction in this given year, but you don't get a tax deduction in this given year.”
Strategies for Managing Low Interest Debt
29:59 to 31:04
Understand how to balance debt repayment and investment contributions effectively.
“stepping stone and the first starting point.”
Choosing the Right Brokerage Account
31:05 to 33:50
Discover the benefits of switching to a brokerage that offers fractional shares.
“I'm very new to investing outside of my employer's 401k.”
Real Estate Investment Insights
33:51 to 40:42
Gain valuable tips on buying your first rental property, including considerations for new constructions.
“So the last one is a real estate question.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00Our outdoor setup used to be one of those spaces we walked past more than we actually used. Random chairs, no shade by the pool, and not much lighting. It just didn't feel finished. But once we started upgrading a few things through Wayfair, it completely changed how we used the space. Now we're outside constantly, morning coffee, pool days with the kids, hanging out at night, and it actually feels like part of the house now. One thing I'd absolutely tell a friend to buy right now is a big outdoor umbrella for the pool area. We grabbed one from Wayfair, and it made a massive difference. It gives you shade during the hottest part of the day, makes the space feel more high-end, and honestly makes you want to stay outside longer.
0:36And if you haven't tried Wayfair yet, I'd just say this. It makes the whole process easy. You can filter by size, budget, and read millions of reviews and actually feel confident you're buying something solid. And thankfully, they help with the hard part too, because outdoor furniture is not exactly fun to assemble. Patio season is here and these deals won't last. Head to Wayfair.com slash m slash outdoor right now to get your outdoor space ready for less. That's Wayfair.com. Wayfair, every style, every home. Workplace chaos. You know the feeling. Deadlines are stacking up, emails are flying, and then someone on your team gives notice.
1:12That's when you think this is a job for sponsored jobs. When you need the right hire fast, Indeed Sponsored Jobs helps your post stand out and reach quality candidates. Instead of hoping the right people see your listing, Sponsored Jobs boosts it in search results so you can match with candidates who meet your specific criteria, like skills, certifications, or locations, and you only pay for results. And here's something wild. In the minute I've been talking to you, companies like yours made 27 hires on Indeed, according to Indeed data worldwide. That is real momentum. Sponsored job posts directly on Indeed are 95 % more likely to report a hire than non-sponsored jobs.
1:50So when the pressure's on and you need someone who can actually move the needle, this isn't your job, it's the job of sponsored jobs. So spend less time searching and more time interviewing candidates who can check all your boxes. And listeners of this show will get a$75 sponsored job credit to help get your job the premium status it deserves at Indeed.com slash podcast. Just go to Indeed.com slash podcast right now and support our show by saying you heard about Indeed on this podcast. Indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Need to hire? This is a job for Indeed sponsored jobs. On this episode of the Personal Finance Podcast, the average retirement savings by generation.
2:50What's up, everybody? Welcome to the Personal Finance Podcast. I'm your host, Andrew, founder of MasterMoney.co. And today on the Personal Finance Podcast, we're going to be talking about the average retirement savings by generation. If you guys have any questions, make sure you join the MasterMoney newsletter by going to MasterMoney.co slash newsletter. letter. And don't forget to follow us on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube, or whatever podcast player you love listening to this podcast on. And if you want to help out the show, consider leaving a five-star rating and review on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your favorite podcast player.
3:26Now, today, we're going to be diving into the average retirement savings by generation. And then we're going to be answering some of your questions and doing a money Q &A in the second half of the show. And so I'm really excited to dive into this because we are going to be looking at data from Fidelity that shows the average retirement savings by generation. And we're going to start this one off with Gen Z. So Gen Z are folks who were born from 1997 to 2012. And so we are looking at the average retirement balance for folks who are in Gen Z. And really, if you are in Gen Z, this is the peak time for you to start saving for retirement.
4:05Why? Because these dollars are so incredibly valuable. And as you grow your wealth over time, you're going to see these seeds that you planted right now, the seeds that you started off with are going to fund your retirement for the rest of your life. Now, one thing to note here is that most people in 2025 who are in Gen Z, their ages range from age 13 all the way up to 28. Now, the oldest members of this generation are in their late 20s and many are still in school. And so we want to make sure that we note that as we start this off. Now, the average balance in the 401k for Gen Z, who have a 401k, is$13 ,500.
4:43And so the employee contributions in these accounts from this Fidelity data are about 7.2%. And the employer contributions are 3.7%. Now, if you're watching on YouTube or on Spotify, we're going to put this chart on the screen for you so that you can see this as we go through this. Now, 18.2 % are contributing to a Roth 401k, which is an uptick from a lot of others out there. And the average balance in their IRA is about$6 ,672. Now, why does this matter? Why does it matter for Gen Z? Well, Gen Z is starting earlier than any other previous generation, which is absolutely fantastic. They are actually starting to invest earlier.
5:24Now, I think this is a testament to the financial education that is out there for a lot of people. There are folks on TikTok talking about, hey, make sure you're saving for your retirement. There are folks on Instagram, YouTube talking through this. And I think financial education is rising across the board. Now, it's still not even close to where it needs to be, but we are at least seeing people starting saving for retirement earlier than they were before. And I think that is really, really cool. Number two, starting in your early 20s gives you this massive compounding advantage. So anybody who is Gen Z, who is listening to this right now, I want you to understand as we go through this.
5:59You have an opportunity to absolutely change your financial life if you start investing now. Now is the time to get your finances together because once you get into your 30s and 40s, you are going to regret not planting the seeds right now. Someone who starts in their 20s will massively outperform someone who starts in their 30s and who works twice as hard as someone in their 20s. And so once you get the ball rolling, you're gonna realize that all you gotta do is just start packing up snow. And as you start to pack in snow, once you get to your 30s, you're going to be able to roll that snow downhill and compound interest is going to start doing the work for you.
6:36But now is the time. Now, you may have come from a background that doesn't understand how to invest. You may have come from a background where every single person in your family is not well off. And you're saying to yourself, well, you know, I've never seen anybody in my family actually do well. And so how would I do well? How you would do well is you could change your family tree right now. You could absolutely turn your entire family tree around just by planting the seeds. Even if it's$100 a month, even if it's$200,$300,$400 a month, whatever extra gap that you have available, that is what I want you to start with.
7:06Now, most people, I want you to get to the point in time where you're at least investing 20 % of your income. That's where we really want you to get to at a bare minimum. But when you are just getting started, at least getting the ball rolling with$50,$100, $150,$200, it is going to make a massive difference. Now we have something called the Wealth Builders Matrix. If you go to mastermoney.co slash resources, it is going to show you how much every single dollar you invest is worth based on how old you are by the time you turn age 65. It is really, really eye-opening. So someone in their early 20s and Gen Z, every single dollar they invest is going to be worth about$100.
7:42Sometimes it's$110, depending on how old you are. For folks who are in their later 20s, every single dollar you invest is going to be worth a little less, but it is still massively impactful. It's going to make you rethink a lot of your spending decisions when you look at the wealth builders matrix, because you can see what every single dollar is worth. Now, if Gen Z keeps up with this pace with continued contributions, the cool thing about this is, is they may be the wealthiest retirement generation yet if they keep the ball rolling, because they are getting started earlier than everybody else.
8:11And so because of that, we're going to see a huge, huge difference here in Gen Z from some of these other generations and what the total outcome is, because folks who start early, that is where the biggest impact is going to be. Now let's get into the millennials. The millennials are a generation that early on did not save and invest as much as they should. And it slowly has turned around as time has gone on. The millennials, I am a millennial. That is my generation, the generation that I was born into. And these are folks born between 1981 to 1996. And so in 2025, most millennials are between the ages of 29 to 44.
8:47And so this is something where the oldest millennials are entering crunch time for savings, and many are dealing with these competing priorities. Now, here's the thing with millennials is most of you are in this point in time where your earnings power is starting to increase, but you're in the middle where your time is becoming restricted because you have families and or you're just focusing on your career. And so a lot of your time is being reduced based on your priorities. And so because of this, we need to set up automations and we need to set up financial systems that are going to allow us to retire by the time we hit retirement age.
9:20The time to start is right now. If you're a millennial, then you need to make sure that you are investing for retirement. You guys grew up in an era where we needed better financial education. And so now we have it. Now we have that point in time where I want you to start to get these dollars working. So the average balance for millennials right now That was$67 ,300 in a 401k. Now the employee contributions on average is only 8.7 % and the average employer contribution is 4.6%. Now this is in the traditional 401k. Now how many are contributing to a Roth 401k? 18.3 % of millennials are contributing to the Roth 401k.
10:00Now the Roth 401k, for those who don't know, is a very powerful account that allows you to get in 2025,$23 ,500 into that Roth 401k. So you put money in, it grows tax-free and you can pull the money out tax-free. So you pay those taxes upfront from your paycheck, but then it grows tax-free and you can pull that money out tax-free. It's a really powerful account. And so also the average IRA balance for folks who are millennials is about$25 ,109. And so why does this matter for millennials? And why do we need to understand where we stand as millennials? Because most millennials, when you're between the age of 30 and 45, you are in your wealth building prime.
10:39This is where you need to lay the foundation in the building blocks in order to ensure that you are going to retire comfortably. This is where your retirement plan really starts to accelerate. And so if you don't get your act together right now, then you are going to start to fall behind and you're going to feel behind. You will regret your decision. I'm going to tell you right now, you're going to regret it if you don't get the ball rolling. So I need each and every single one of you to strap up and let's get invested. Now, this is not something that is optional to go out and start investing.
11:09It is required to go out and start investing because inflation is going to eat away at your buying power every single year if you don't. Now, that's not some sort of theory. That is fact. Every year, inflation will eat away at your buying power. You can look at the difference in costs from 2019 to now, and you can see a massive, massive difference. And the reason for that is because inflation is going to eat away every single year at your buying power if you do not work on this stuff. So really, really important to make sure that you are investing your dollars because you're in your wealth building prime.
11:41Now is the time. Number two is if you are only investing 10 % of your income, maybe it's 15 % of your income, it is time to start ramping up contributions. You need to make sure that you are putting enough into these retirement accounts. So getting to 20, 25, 30 % of your income is the range we want you in. And so if you're not doing that currently, then you're gonna be working a much longer period of time. Now, why does this matter? Why does it matter to make sure that you increase your contributions? One is because the math is very simple. Your retirement contributions or the amount of money that you put towards investments, it doesn't have to be in retirement accounts.
12:14It could be in a brokerage account. Maybe you invest in real estate, but your savings rate, the amount of money that you are putting away towards investments has a direct impact on how long you will have to work. And so if you don't wanna work anymore or you wanna pursue financial freedom, and that is your ultimate goal, that is what you really want to get to, then we need to make sure that we are increasing our retirement contributions. So let's try to do this with the 1 % rule, meaning every single time that you look at your savings rate and you say, well, it's not enough yet. I'm only saving 10 % of my income.
12:43Well, let's try to increase it to 11 % next month, then 12 % the next month. And so just by increasing the dial slowly over the next couple of months, that's going to allow you to really reach those retirement goals over time. Not just ripping off the band-aid right away, you're gradually increasing it. This is a great place to be in. And really, once you get to 20%, then you can decide, am I going to continue or am I going to stop here? Now, you also, as a millennial, are going to have competing priorities. A number of different things are happening. A lot of millennials have student loans and these student loans are eating away at their ability to be able to go out and invest for their future.
13:20A lot of millennials are dealing with childcare. care. Now, this is one that's not talked about enough. If you have young kids and you have them in child care, you know this is one of the biggest costs or the biggest line items in your budget. Each child that's in child care is typically anywhere from$800 to, depending on where you live, it could be all the way up to$2 ,000 per month just to have your child in child care. If you have a nanny, it's probably even higher than that. And so because of this, this is a huge, huge line item for a lot of millennials. Because if you have one to two kids in child care, where you're looking at thousands of dollars every single month.
13:53And so this is another big thing. Then housing costs are rising. And if you didn't buy a house in 2020, then you are looking at a situation where you may have higher housing costs than other folks. And so you have these competing priorities. What we need to do is learn how to juggle these competing priorities and then figure out how to increase our income over time so that we can achieve our financial goals. We talk a lot about how to increase your income here. And so if you haven't heard those episodes, make sure you're subscribed to this podcast because that is our big, big goal is to make sure that we help you increase your income.
14:23All right, next up is Gen X. So Gen X was born between 1965 to 1980. And so right now in 2025, Gen X is between age 45 to age 60. So Gen Xers are turning 60 this year and getting ready for retirement. This is crunch time, big time for people who are Gen X. And really, this is the time to get your stuff together. And so overall, if you are in Gen X, we are starting to really plan and ramp up for retirement right now. So the average 401k balance for someone who is in Generation X is going to be$192 ,300. And the average employee contribution is 10.2 % to their 401k. And the average employer contribution is 5%.
15:07So that means they are putting 15 % of their income into their 401k. That is a great start for a lot of folks. But their Roth 401k contributions are actually lower than Gen Z and the millennial generation at 14.5%, which I think is very, very interesting. Now, the Roth 401k is a newer product. And so the question then comes up, well, is that a reason for why this is happening? Not really sure. And so then the question comes up, is that the reason why this is happening? We'll have to dig deeper. And the average IRA balance is higher at$103 ,952. So Gen X is in catch-up mode. Now, one thing that Gen X can do is they can take advantage of catch-up contributions, meaning after the age of 50, you can contribute more to your 401k and you can contribute more to your Roth and your traditional IRA.
15:53And so they can take advantage of that after the age of 50. Now, if you are in catch-up mode, you're in the final decade before retirement, it is really imperative that you take as many of those extra dollars as you possibly can and put them towards wealth building activities. I mean, your investments, your emergency fund, making sure you pay off any high interest debt. All those big things are very important. Now, this generation often has peak responsibilities. So they have a couple of different things to juggle. One, a lot of them are going to have kids that are either going to high school or maybe they're teenagers.
16:22And so they're having to deal with those priorities. In addition, they also have aging parents. And having aging parents becomes a responsibility of a lot of folks now. And so you have to make sure that you're budgeting and planning out for that. In addition, they have mortgages and other things that they're juggling. And so their expenses are pretty high. And really, overall, it's a tough situation to be in and making sure you juggle all those things. But they have to figure out what to do. But as they approach retirement age, they have to make sure that they are doing the right things and taking the right steps in order to be able to retire.
16:51Now, this is a very powerful place to be. And for most people out there, if you saved early and often, then you know you're probably feeling good about your situation. If you did not save early and often, now is the time to catch up. It is never, ever too late. So anybody out there who is in Gen X who is just getting started, I want you to know right now, it is never too late. We have multiple episodes talking about why it's never too late. And so I highly encourage you to check out those episodes if you have not already. But I want you to know, you got to start now. Now is the time to start. Because if you don't start now, you're going to be living in retirement, relying on social security.
17:23And that is not a good retirement to live on. That is not financial peace. That is not a place that is going to give you financial peace. Instead, I want you to get started right now. And then the last... We've got a lot planned this summer. Trips with kids, time outside, long weekends, and just more moments together as a family. And honestly, the older I get, the more I realize how important it is to protect it all. The good news is getting life insurance doesn't have to be this huge, stressful project anymore. That's why I like PolicyGenius. PolicyGenius isn't an insurance company. They're an online marketplace that helps you compare life insurance quotes from top insurers side by side for free.
18:00And their licensed team helps you figure out the right coverage, answers your questions, handles the paperwork, and helps you find the best fit for your family. It's one of those things that feels like it should take forever, but they make it surprisingly straightforward. And honestly, it turns life insurance into getting more of a summer win than a chore. And there's real peace of mind knowing that your family is protected while you're actually enjoying life together. With PolicyGenius, you can see if you can find 20-year life insurance policies starting at just$276 a year for$1 million in coverage.
18:34Head to PolicyGenius.com to compare life insurance quotes from top companies and see how much you can save. That's PolicyGenius.com. When I started building this podcast and business, I underestimated how many different jobs I'd suddenly have. From recording, editing, branding, scheduling, websites, emails, every day felt like a new problem that I had to figure out. And honestly, when you're building something, having the right tools matters a lot. That's why platforms like Shopify are so powerful. Shopify is the commerce platform behind millions of businesses and handles 10 % of all e-commerce in the U.S.
19:09Whether you're launching something brand new or growing an existing business, Shopify gives you everything in one place. You can build a professional-looking online store with ready-to-use templates, use AI tools to help write product descriptions and improve listings, and create email and social campaigns without needing a giant marketing team. Plus, if you ever get stuck, Shopify's 24-7 support is always there to help. Start your business today with the industry's best business partner, Shopify, and start hearing ka-ching. Sign up for your$1 per month trial today at shopify.com slash PFP. Go to shopify.com slash PFP.
19:49That's shopify.com slash PFP.
19:56Summer's right around the corner, and this is the time of year where I want to be planning trips, not stressing if we can afford them. And the goal is to actually enjoy the summer, knowing everything with our money is already handled. Monarch is the personal finance app that tracks everything from accounts, investments, savings goals, and spending. Get your first year of Monarch for half off, just$50 with promo code PFP. One thing Monarch helped me realize recently was how easy it is for spending to creep up without noticing. I'll do my five-minute drill, check in quickly, and their weekly recap will flag anything that's off before it becomes a problem.
20:28That alone keeps me way more intentional. It's like having a financial advisor in your pocket. And instead of guessing, you can actually see where your money's going, plan ahead for big things like travel, and know if you're on track. Use code PFP at Monarch.com to get your first year half off at just$50. That's 50 % off your first year at Monarch.com with code PFP.
21:10There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required compatibility and availability varies 18 plus. This generation we're going to go through is the baby boomer generation. Now, the baby boomer generation is a generation that was born from 1946 to 1964. And a lot of them in 2025 are between the ages of 61 to 79. Now, most of them are well into their retirement or have started to draw down on their savings. So some of the younger baby boomers may have not retired yet if they are still working on retirement. And then some of the older ones have been retired for a good amount of time. Now, the average balance in their 401k is$249 ,300.
21:52And the employee contributions are 11.9%. And the employer contributions are right around 5%. And the amount that are contributing to a Roth 401k is even lower at 12.2%. Now, the average balance in an IRA for the baby boomer generation is$257 ,000. Now, even with strong retirement savings, a lot of the baby boomer generation is still relying on Social Security. They're heavily relying on Social Security. I want everybody in the younger generations watching this episode right now to do this and to think through this. I don't want you relying heavily on Social Security. Why? We don't know how much is going to be there.
22:27And so this is relying on something that you cannot control. Someone can take this away from you whenever they want to. Now, is that going to happen? I don't think it's very likely for Social Security to go away. They've been saying it's going to go away for decades and decades and decades. But that's just my opinion. What if it actually did? What would you do in that situation? If you're relying on Social Security, you are in trouble. And so I want you to make sure that instead, we are deciding to take control of our retirement ourselves. And so we are going to take control of this by investing in our future and putting more money into our retirement accounts.
22:58Now, longevity risk is real for a lot of folks out there. And these accounts must stretch for decades, especially with the baby boomer generation. And so they need to make sure that they are preserving their retirement accounts. And so again, this is a great lesson for folks who are in the younger generations to start early, start making sure that you are automating your contributions so that you can get ahead. So again, on the screen, we're going to put a summary of everything we just talked about here. The average 401k balance for the baby boomer generation is$249 ,300. For Gen X, it's$192 ,000.
Read the full transcript
23:30For millennials, it's$67 ,000. And for Gen Z, it's$13 ,500. So now we're going to jump into some of your questions here, and we're going to do a money Q &A. Now, this money Q &A is brought to you by DeleteMe. Let's talk about something most people don't think about, but absolutely should. And it's how much of your personal information is floating around the internet right now. Your name, your address, your phone number, your email, your family members' names, even where you work. And it is shockingly easy for scammers and spammers to find out all this information in seconds unless you have someone actively removing this information for you.
24:09Now that's where DeleteMe comes in. DeleteMe goes to work scrubbing your information from all the big data broker sites. You can think of places like White Pages, Spekeo, Bin Verified. These sites have been quietly collecting your data and selling it without you even knowing. And so Delete.me will go and they monitor these sites year round and remove your info when it pops back up. And then they'll send you a detailed report showing you exactly what they found and what they deleted. The first time I did this, Delete.me removed my information from thousands of different websites. I cannot tell you how shocking it was to see how many websites had my information on it.
24:45So I use Delete.me myself and I've used it for a long time. It is one of the easiest privacy wins that you can have. if you're a homeowner, if you're a business owner or a parent or anyone out there who just values privacy, this is a must have. And right now you can get 20 % off Delete Me by going to join delete me.com slash PFP20 and you get 20 % off today. So protect yourself, protect your family and get your personal information off the internet with Delete Me. Cannot recommend this enough. It is one of my favorite products that I have used over the course of the last couple of years. And it is really one of the most important things to do is to get your personal information off the internet.
25:23All right. So the first question we're going to go through is first, wanted to say thank you for the amazing content you put out. I was blessed enough to find it my junior year of college and began following the stairway to wealth as soon as I could. With everything you have taught, I was able to go from a negative$25 ,000 net worth to a 38 ,000 net worth within a little over a year after graduation. First of all, that is incredible. absolutely incredible that you went for a$68 ,000 swing. That is just congratulations on that. That is amazing. I recently have been thinking further on how to optimize my student loan repayment.
25:58I'm sitting with 21 ,000 in student loans, and I already carry a lower end weighted average interest rate on the loans at 3.97%, with loans varying from 5.25 to 2.5%. Now, they are all federal loans, and I am currently doing the avalanche method, shoveling an extra$600 a month into the highest interest loan. With the student loan tax deduction, my after-tax interest rate drops to 3.1%. Now, does it make sense to stop or slow down my rapid debt repayment and reallocate that money into maxing out my Roth IRA to take advantage of the tax deduction while my income level is still within that threshold?
26:35So first off, huge congratulations to you here being out of college and making that big of a net worth swing. And so now let's break down what the top 1 % decision makers would do in this situation. The key is, should you divert money from, you know, paying down some of these student loans towards your Roth IRA? Now with your numbers, I would say 100 % yes. And here's why, because your true interest rate is so low. So your interest rate is much lower than would be for some high interest rate debt. And so for us, we always want to attempt to get our dollars invested when we have low interest rate debt first.
27:11So what are some of the reasons why we want to do this? So one is your guaranteed return from paying off debt early is 3.1%. And so that's the average of all of your different debt payments with your student loans. And so instead, what I would likely do is I would look at the long-term return in a Roth IRA. So let's say, for example, you invested in something like the S &P 500 index fund. Now you could do your research on what you think would be the best funds based on your risk tolerance and what you are looking for. But if you invested in the S &P 500 over the course of the last 30, 40 years, you would get on average about a 10 % rate of return.
27:42So that delta there is about 7%. That is the difference between what the guaranteed rate of return is that you would get paying off your student loans and what the possible rate of return is would be within your student loans. Now, one thing I want to note is that with a Roth IRA, you don't get a deduction in that given year. I think your question stated that you wanted to get the tax deduction in this given year, but you don't get a tax deduction in this given year. You get tax-free growth in a Roth IRA. And so that's a big thing, just a note. And so because we're looking at this situation and if your income is within those Roth limits, then it is a really awesome opportunity for you, especially as young as you are, to be able to grow your money over time.
28:19Because a Roth is a use it or lose it situation. You don't get those years back. And so getting some of that money in a Roth is very, very important for your long-term growth and your long-term financial growth. I think financially, this is a layup decision. So any low interest debt, especially when it's this low, typically I want to make sure that I am getting my extra dollars into investment accounts over paying off that low interest debt. And then over time, we're going to continue to pay that debt off. And we will, as our income rises, then have opportunities to pay it off in larger amounts as time goes on.
28:50We teach this a lot in Master Money Academy, where we have the exact order of operations and something called the Wealth Builder's Journey that we have, which is our 25 step system that takes you through all these different situations. And so we pay off high interest at first, then we start to build up that emergency fund. And then we have a point in time where we are teaching people when to invest and exactly when to invest. And so this is really in your situation, this is when investing is going to win by a mile. And so here's what I would do. Unless this debt really stresses you out and debt is one of those things that really causes you anxiety or anything like that, it is much better to get your dollars invested early and often.
29:26And then later on down the line, you could pay off this low interest debt because the Roth is so incredibly powerful and you have so much time for this money to compound that it will change your retirement drastically to make sure you get those dollars invested and get your dollars growing because your money can work so much harder than you can. And so because of this, that's what I would do. So step one is I would make minimum payments on all the federal loans if I were in your shoes. That's what I would do is I would look at making those minimum payments. Then step two is I would redirect your$600 per month into a Roth IRA.
29:53Now I would automate it every single month, make sure you're making automatic contributions. And that is the first stepping stone and the first starting point. Now we are going to link down in the show notes. If you don't know how to automate your money, I'll link in the show notes, my money automation checklist that you guys can access. We'll link it up, up top in the show notes that you can access that checklist for free and take a look at that. And then step three is once your Roth IRA is maxed out, you can take some of the extra money and either put it towards something like your 401k, or you can take some of that extra money and put it towards your loans if you really want to get those pay down faster.
30:26But I think what's going to happen here is that once you get your money into a Roth, then it's worth looking at some of the other investment options as well, because this debt is so low interest. Now, really, really commend you for even thinking through this and thinking through the best possible option in your situation, because you are going to make some huge wins. If you have made that big of a swing in net worth thus far, just congratulations again for what you've done there, because that is absolutely incredible and is going to be so, so powerful as time goes on to see what you do with your finances.
30:57So amazing, amazing work. And again, congratulations on that net worth swing. And thank you so much for the question. If you have any other additional questions, feel free to send them over. All right. The next question is, Hi, Andrew. I'm very new to investing outside of my employer's 401k. I currently have been investing small amounts, about$50 twice a month into Merrill Edge as my brokerage portal. With Merrill Edge, I am unable to do fractional investments in bigger ETFs like the S &P 500. So I'm kind of limited to the smaller ETFs with lower cost. Would it make sense for me to change my brokerage portal to something else with fractional shares?
31:34Here's what I would say, is that if you have a brokerage account without fractional shares, that is something where they just don't have a lot of flexibility. Now, I have had Merrill Edge in the past, and I've switched from Merrill Edge to some of the other options that I talk about all the time. So Vanguard, Fidelity, M1 Finance, Charles Schwab. Those are all great options that are out there that will allow you to do fractional investing. And so because of this, I would consider moving to a different brokerage. Now, it's not very hard to do it. It's pretty easy to move your funds over to a different brokerage.
32:03And here's kind of what I would think about doing is you can call Vanguard or Fidelity. They all let you do some of this fractional stuff. Fidelity has a lot of flexibility with this stuff too. But you call the brokerage that you are moving it to and you say, hey, I want to move my money from Merrill Edge to you guys. What are the steps I need to take? And they will walk you through it. It takes about five minutes. People in Master Money Academy do this all the time where they want to move from one of their traditional brokerages over to another one that we talk about a lot. And so when they do that, they usually will just call up Vanguard or Fidelity.
32:31I just did this with Merrill Edge and they will move it over. Now, if you're familiar with Merrill Edge and you're just comfortable with them, there's nothing wrong with staying there. But for me specifically, Vanguard, Fidelity, those are my two big ones that I am always investing in. M1 Finance, I have an account with as well. And Charles Schwab, I have helped a lot of people with their Charles Schwab accounts. I have never had an account there, but I know they have some great funds over there too. And so that is definitely one to consider. Now, typically, what I like to do is also just choose a brokerage that has automatic contributions that can also auto-invest.
33:01So Vanguard and Fidelity can both do this and they have some great easy ways for you to actually contribute directly and then auto-invest immediately once your money has hit in that account. And so I really, really like that option because then your money just gets invested and you can get those fractional shares built up over time, especially if you're doing this weekly, because then you're just getting your money invested sooner. And so if you do this over time, then it's not sitting for a month or two until you can buy an index fund or an ETF. Instead, it is getting invested earlier. And so you can get that growth earlier.
33:30I think it is beneficial on all fronts. And probably if we did the math and looked at this, we'd be able to see that just getting those dollars invested even sooner because you'd be delaying a month each time would be really, really important. And so I think that overall, it'd make a big, big difference for your specific situation. So definitely move it over and let me know if you have any questions on that. All right. So the last one is a real estate question. So I recently listened to your podcast episode, How to Achieve Financial Independence Using Real Estate with Dustin. Such a great episode, and I really enjoyed it and found it motivating.
34:02I've always been interested in real estate investing and right now have about$24 ,000 saved. My goal is to buy my first rental property by next year in 2026. I currently live at home with my parents in New Jersey and pay$700 in rent. I've maxed out my HSA and IRA through Fidelity, and I contribute 4 % of my paycheck to my job's 403B. Since the housing market in New Jersey is quite expensive, I've been thinking about buying rental properties in Florida instead. My sister is a real estate agent in Orange County and has a good network of contractors and property managers. So I feel more comfortable investing there knowing I have that support system.
34:36I wanted to get your thoughts on buying a new construction home. I've been looking at a few that are still being built and my sister mentioned that developers often offer incentives that can help reduce the down payment. I think that buying something new could help me avoid some of the repair issues that come with older properties. Any advice or guidance that could share on buying my first rental property would mean a lot. I'm hoping to make that first purchase by next year and ideally buy another property within a year after that. Thanks so much for your time and all the great content you share.
35:04I've learned a lot from your podcast. So this is a really good question. And this question is from Anna. And I think this is awesome, awesome, awesome stuff that you're even thinking through investing in real estate and thinking through it in this way. Now, a couple of things that I would kind of think through. For many new investors, the hardest part about out-of-state investing is trust. And who's on the ground? Who's screening tenants? Who's fixing things? And so if your sister is willing to kind of partner with you on this, I don't know how much work she's willing to do, but if she is willing to partner and be your agent, help you with some of these out-of-network contractors and help find property managers that she trusts, then this eliminates the biggest risk of all, which is finding the right people.
35:44Because building out this team is one of the most important parts when it comes to investing in real estate out of state. So Flora can become a great option, but this is the big key right here, if the numbers work. So when it comes to real estate investing, you make all of your money on the buy. So how you run your numbers and when you buy the property is where all of your money is made. It is not made in the middle and it is not made on the sale. It is how you run your numbers up front. So just because you like the area and just because that area might be booming doesn't mean that the numbers are going to work.
36:19So we have to make sure that we are running the numbers. So does the property cashflow after all expenses, including maintenance, repair, capital expenditures, vacancy. So we have a, for those who don't know, we have a rental property calculator that I think it's 19 bucks, but we'll link it up down below that you guys can check out. This is just a spreadsheet that allows you to run the numbers on rental properties. If you're in Master Money Academy, you get it for free. It's in Master Money Academy as part of your membership. But if you are not in Master Money Academy, it's 19 bucks and we'll link it up down below.
36:47But it helps you run the numbers so that you understand if a property actually cash flows or not. Now, new construction can be great if the property cash flows, if the incentives are actually real, because they do offer these incentives a lot of times that help you reduce the overall price, and if the rents support the mortgage. So it's not just if the property is going to rent minus the mortgage amount. It is obviously all the other expenditures that fall into play. But with a new build, the nice thing is because everything is new, you can have a little more time before things like capital expenditures like the roof or the AC or whatever else could break down.
37:21It would be a little more time before that actually happened. So with new builds, obviously, you're just going to have a little bit less repairs up front than you would with older houses. And a lot of times they will give you warranties on all the different structures within some of those things. So new construction has the less deferred maintenance. There's no 40 year old AC. There's no roof that's going to go bad in the next five years. There's no surprise plumbing. And if there is a surprise in the plumbing, typically they will give you a warranty for 10 or 15 years on new builds, depending on what that is.
37:50And so in addition, they can also offer some other things like closing cost credits, rate buy downs, you know, appliance packages, all these different things. Now you probably on a new build will have to buy appliances and put them in unless they have those packages. And sometimes they'll even give you down payment assistance. But it does not mean that it's going to automatically cash flow. So a couple of things I want you to note is a lot of time with new builds, your taxes could be significantly higher. Why? They do these things called CDD fees in new builds, which are the community development things that they add into some of these new developments.
38:22And so when they add in new sewage, when they add in new plumbing or electrical, or they run all the electrical lines, those fees go back to you within your taxes and you have to pay these additional CDD fees and they can be really high. And so making sure you see those and run the numbers on those, because that could completely kill your cashflow is one big thing. But also you need to make sure that you're looking at the HOA, you need to make sure that property management will manage properties in that area. And then you're going to look at capital expenditures, maintenance, all the other stuff.
38:49But if it cash flows, there is nothing wrong with that. So what I would do is first, I would start to save aggressively. So you have your$24 ,000 saved up. That is fantastic. And you can look at, you know, getting a conventional loan and figuring out what that loan is going to be. And then have your sister help build a deal pipeline. So if your sister is willing to partner with you, see if she can start sending you some properties and start running numbers on properties in that area. Kind of see where you would land with some of those properties, have conversations with some of the agents in that area that can help you through that process.
39:18So don't guess, start running the numbers on some of those properties so that you can get some practice with it. Then I would talk to a couple of lenders, talk to two to three lenders right now, kind of see what their rates are coming back as, especially as rates have been going down over the course of the last couple of months. And then you can interview some property managers also. So I would have some conversations with property managers and then just start doing the math, start running the numbers on your favorite rental property calculator and kind of seeing where you land. If it cash flows, then great.
39:42That's a great option to think through and see if you want to own that property. Then if it doesn't cash flow, then move on to the next one. See if you can find one that does cash flow. And if it's close, then see if they'll offer you enough incentives to lower the price. That's the way I would look at this. But everything comes down to running the numbers on the buy and then making sure you have the team in place, especially since you're not there. So really, really great question. Hope the numbers are going to work for you there in the Orlando area. Orlando has a lot of new builds. I'm in Tampa, so I know the Orlando area pretty well.
40:11A lot of new builds in those areas. And they're in some areas, they're overbuilding. So just watch out for overbuilding too. That's another big thing. I want to make sure that you have a property that works and that people are actually desiring to be in that location. So awesome, awesome question. And thank you guys so much for submitting your questions. If you guys have a question, you can send them over to me via email by joining the MasterMoney newsletter. Once you join the newsletter, you can reply to any of those newsletters that come out every single Friday, and we will be able to answer your questions and help you through the process.
40:38Again, thank you so much for being here. I truly appreciate each and every single one of you, and we will see you on the next episode.
From the publisher
Join the community built to help you master your money, stay accountable, and reach financial freedom. 👉 Join Master Money Academy today!
In this episode of The Personal Finance Podcast, Andrew breaks down the average retirement savings for Gen Z, Millennials, Gen X, and Boomers using Fidelity's data, which will cover where each generation stands today, why compounding matters most for younger savers, how to catch up if you're behind, whether to slow down student loan payments to max your Roth IRA, if you should switch brokerages for fractional shares, and practical strategies for buying your first out-of-state rental property.
Listen to The Business Show here.
Partner Deals
Indeed: Start hiring NOW with a SEVENTY-FIVE DOLLAR SPONSORED JOB CREDIT to upgrade your job post at Indeed.com/personalfinance
Get 50% Off Monarch Money, the all-in-one financial tool at www.monarchmoney.com/PFP
Acorns: Start investing automatically with Acorns and get a $5 bonus at Acorns.com/PFP
Chime: Start your credit journey with Chime. Sign-up takes only two minutes and doesn’t affect your credit score. Get started at chime.com/
DELL: Get a new Dell AI PC starting at $749.99, at Dell.com/ai-pc.
Policy Genius: Go to policygenius.com to get your free life insurance quote.
Shopify: Shopify makes it so easy to sell. Sign up for a one-dollar-per-month trial period at shopify.com/pfp
Wayfair: Shop outdoor furniture, grills, lawn games, and WAY more for WAY less
DeleteMe: Go to https://joindeleteme.com/PFP20/ and Use Promo Code PFP for 20% off!
Resources Mentioned
Automate Your Money Checklist
Rental Property Calculator
Connect With Andrew on Social Media:
TikTok
Master Money Website
Master Money Youtube Channel
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
