1. Podcasts
  2. The Playbook Podcast
  3. Haley Stevens caps a bizarre midterm cycle
The Playbook Podcast

2 Nov 2026 · 18m · 5 chapters

Episode artwork

Haley Stevens caps a bizarre midterm cycle

In short

The “weird vibes” of the 2026 midterm cycle, focusing on Rep. Haley Stevens’ late endorsement switch in Michigan’s U.S. Senate race—from Abdul El-Sayed to Republican Mike Rogers—and what it signals for Democratic factional conflict.

Guests

Will Stakin and Adam Wren (hosts). No other guests appear in the transcript.

Guest/host backgrounds

Will Stakin and Adam Wren are Politico Playbook hosts covering elections and political strategy.

Key claims

Stevens felt “left out” by AOC, said she would stay with El-Sayed after a 25-minute call with AOC, then reversed course. She cited grocery-price responsibility ads and Tucker Carlson-related comments as reasons. The episode frames the flip as both sour grapes after a brutal primary and ideological tension, with implications for Democrats’ 2028 coalition in Michigan.

Notable examples

AOC not inviting Stevens to Pontiac; Stevens’ call with her fiancé Jason Turkish; El-Sayed rejecting Stevens’ presence at a Detroit black church event; comparisons to Mallory McMorrow’s post-primary trajectory.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:08

Bizarre Midterm Campaigns

Discussion on the unusual events and scandals characterizing the midterm elections.

“I will be there, so will Dasha Burns, Adam, Jonathan Martin, and Alex Burns.”
3:10

Haley Stevens' Endorsement Shift

Analysis of Congresswoman Haley Stevens' unexpected endorsement of Mike Rogers.

“the redistricting wars, which we're still seeing the long tail of those play out in some unintended consequential ways for Republicans.”
6:15

The Context Behind Stevens' Decision

Exploration of the factors influencing Haley Stevens' political decisions and her relationship with AOC.

“And Adam, you actually got to speak with Haley Stevens on the phone after she made this big, big flip.”
9:39

Democratic Ideological Tensions

Discussion on the ideological divisions within the Democratic Party and their implications.

“She's not getting, you know, invited to these kinds of events.”
14:00

Haley Stevens and the Democratic Landscape

Discussion on Haley Stevens' position in the Democratic Party and implications for the future.

“And maybe she would be, you know, joined by other leaders in the party, you know, you know, you know, trying to push back on whatever insurgent, progressive, far left, you know, wing that maybe Abdul El-Sayed represents.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The Playbook Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00A message from OpenAI. College freshman Ryan Honorey began developing wildfire detection technology as a fifth-grade science project. Years and many accolades later, that experiment became Sensory AI, a wildfire detection system that uses ChatGPT to turn sensor data into clear, actionable alerts. Those alerts go straight to departments like Laguna Beach Fire Department giving responders an early signal when a fire starts. Discover his story at openai.com slash stories.

0:35Haley Stevens: Today on the Playbook podcast, welcome to the weird vibes midterms. The polls point to a democratic wave, neither party seems to believe them, and the final days of campaigning have taken a bizarre turn. That's the story driving the day. Good morning, I'm Will Stakin. And I'm Adam Wren, and it's Monday, November the 2nd.

0:58Haley Stevens: Adam, it is happening this Tuesday, Politico Elections Live. Come hang out with us on politico.com or YouTube starting at 9 p.m. Eastern. I will be there, so will Dasha Burns, Adam, Jonathan Martin, and Alex Burns. It will be a fun and also stressful night. Right, Adam? That's right. Yeah, it'll be kind of the culmination of everything that we've been talking about on the podcast for two years, it feels like. And so excited to talk shop with you and everybody else and accept calls. We're going to have some interesting, buzzy guests, we shall say, calling in and talking us through the results throughout the night.

1:44Haley Stevens: Come watch as everyone's biting their nails to see where this election goes and more on the live coverage later. But in the meantime, we should get to the story driving the day, which is about the general weird vibes of this election, which we've been feeling. So let's just go through a list of some of the highlights here. We had bookended major scandals from campaigns like starting with Graham Plattner during the primary, decoyed Dans in Alaska, to whole states like Minnesota. There's these major rules rewriting across redistricting across the country, self-inflicted wounds like Tom Tillis and John Cornyn, surprise competitiveness in Kansas and Iowa, weakness in Michigan, and of course, polling overconfidence and collapse with two deeply unpopular political parties.

2:33Haley Stevens: And then, of course, we had over the weekend Congresswoman Haley Stevens making her major bombshell endorsement. Hey, Michigan. As you may have seen, our Democratic nominee for U.S. Senate, Abdul, said that I was no longer welcome in his campaign and that I should stay away. And he's right. And that's why I am endorsing Mike Rogers for the United States Senate today. I don't belong in Abdul's campaign. We'll get into more detail with Haley Stevens. But Adam, which is the weirdest of the weird so far for you that we've experienced over the past six months? Well, it's been wild, Will. I feel like Playbook and Politico has been at the center of a lot of these stories from some exclusive reporting that led to Graham Plattner dropping out in Maine to the rise of James Tallarico to blue chip Republican candidates like the current governor of Georgia, Brian Kemp, deciding not to run for Senate.

3:42the redistricting wars, which we're still seeing the long tail of those play out in some unintended consequential ways for Republicans. And it's been weird throughout. But the last week, Will, I think has been particularly weird. And really, I think over the last few weeks, we've seen Congresswoman Haley Stevens kind of telegraph in certain ways where she was headed, where this 11th hour flip came from. Yeah, we mentioned in Playbook just a couple of weeks ago, Haley Stevens' outreach to black voters and her praising Mike Rogers for doing that. And you could kind of tell in talking with her that she was starting to lean this way.

4:26I had a conversation with her on Monday of last week where she actually dialed in her fiance, Jason Turkish, who previously, before yesterday, said that he was voting for Mike Rogers, and he was kind of helping her evaluate the statements that she was giving to me on the record. And what was interesting is she started to talk about how she felt left out by Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. AOC visited Pontiac, Michigan in her campaign a few weeks ago and didn't invite Stevens. Stevens told me that she felt left out and wronged by that. And that was Monday. And then, of course, Will, you have some reporting on what happened after that.

5:10Tell us about that.

5:11Haley Stevens: Yeah, it's kind of fascinating when we heard about some of the, you know, the private concerns from Haley Stevens about not being invited by AOC or when she was in town. And then we got some reporting this morning in Playbook that right before Haley Stevens went on to CNN last week, and there was all that rumbling about how maybe she was going to either about to unendorse Abdul El-Sayed or endorse Mike Rogers. AOC actually called Haley Stevens, and they spoke for about 25 minutes, we're told. And during that call, she told AOC that she wasn't going to unendorse and that she was still on the team.

5:49Haley Stevens: She was still going to back El-Sayed. And then even following their conversation, they actually exchanged some pleasantries, according to some text messages that Playbook reviewed, where Stevens told AOC that she thought she did, quote, did the right thing by not unendorsing, which obviously just a few days later kind of went completely out the window. And she did end up endorsing, you know, Mike Rogers. And Adam, you actually got to speak with Haley Stevens on the phone after she made this big, big flip. So, Will, I was at a mall with my seven-year-old daughter yesterday, and she wanted to pick up a special bath bomb at Lush, the store, and this news with Haley Stevens broke.

6:37And so as my daughter was browsing possible selections, I gave Haley Stevens a quick call to talk about her decision, and this is what she told me. I think I've been very gracious and, you know, I did want to put, you know, I put the primary to bed, obviously, but, you know, he rejected my endorsement because he didn't want to speak out for sale on who's being responsible for the price of groceries. Yeah. And who Tucker Carlson actually is. Yeah. And there's, it's just a, it's a simple point. I'm not trying to, you know, I just it was directed at me. I respect the other leaders who are around him.

7:24I respect what's going to go and get done. A lot of people are working really hard. I have a lot of respect and admiration for Senator Schumer. And I still very much believe that with all these incredible races going on across this country, changing coalitions, changing dynamics, people who have never voted in midterm elections coming out to vote, that they'll vote. and we'll see Democratic leadership. So Haley Stevens was upset about two ads, one of which was not made by El-Sayed's campaign, but a rebellion pack ad made by Cenk Uygur. Don't we give Israel$4 billion a year anyways? Yeah, and now we're giving them another$26 billion.

8:04Do you know how much that is per American taxpayer? And the other ad was an ad El-Sayed's campaign put out highlighting comments by the former Fox News host, Tucker Carlson. I wouldn't vote for Mike Rogers at gunpoint. Which Stevens objected to.

8:20Haley Stevens: So, Adam, how much, again, I'm not trying to psychoanalyze what happened here, but how much is it these specific ads, you know, that she's objecting to? Or would there just have been something else that she would have been able to find, you know, as having issued with? Like, to me, it feels like it's deeper than these ads, what I'm trying to get at. It feels like there's, you know, obviously there's serious disagreements with foreign policy and other things. And to me, I wonder if, like, these ads are—I'm sure she feels really passionate about them. But, you know, at the end of the day, I'm just curious how much you think it's the ads and just—or versus something else.

8:59You know, I think, Will, that there's evidence that you could argue kind of points to her looking for reasons not to fully stick with El-Sayed. You know, she was alarmed by some of his debate comments, not acknowledging that Iran posed a bigger threat to the U.S. than Israel. That's something that deeply bothered her and ultimately was itched a bridge too far.

9:24Haley Stevens: As someone that has been covering it better than anybody, Adam, I have to ask you, how much of this do you think is potential sour grapes by Haley Stevens after a incredibly tough primary where she feels like she's been maybe pushed to the side? She's not getting, you know, invited to these kinds of events. And how much of this is just a larger ideological issue that the Democrats are going to have to deal with? I'm trying to grapple with it. I think there's no one better to answer that than you. So where do you think this is falling in? That's kind of you to say, Will. Really, I think it's a mixture of both.

10:02But in terms, let's start with the sour grapes. So you have to remember, if you go back to the Michigan Unity breakfast that happened after the August primary, you know, Haley Stevens was on stage in a ballroom in Michigan a few days after the election, hugging Abdul El-Sayed on the stage and was viewed broadly in the party and nationally as a very magnanimous loser in all of this and helped unite the ticket and was seen as someone who was helpful. In some way, she actually eclipsed in sort of the internet vibe space. Michigan State Senator Mallory McMorrow, post-primary, was seen as someone who was, quote, growing on, end quote, a lot of people in the party and elsewhere, kind of was the darling of X for a little bit.

10:52Haley Stevens: For about a week, yeah, a week or two. Yeah, when I pointed that out to her in some of our calls over the last couple of weeks, she said, yeah, it's probably going to be short-lived though. And, you know, she was right about that. She kind of knew where things were headed. But, you know, she did have clear ideological differences with El-Sayed. And, And you know who else has ideological differences with El-Sayed? Former President Barack Obama, a current Senator Alyssa Slotkin of Michigan who's been campaigning with him. She's acknowledged those differences and said, look, I don't agree with Abdul on everything, but on the specific things, on the majors, we agree.

11:33And so there is some ideological tension here. But in terms of the sour grapes, that does seem to have inflamed in recent days. We heard her yesterday acknowledge that El-Sayed said he didn't want her near his campaign. And of course, we scooped that late Friday night that his campaign through intermediaries was sending signals that they did not want Stevens to be with him at this black church event in Detroit yesterday that was brokered by Congresswoman Debbie Dingell and was going to feature Stevens' mentor, South Carolina Representative Jim Clyburn. And so there is both the sour grapes. Stevens is essentially responding to El-Sayed saying he didn't want her to be at the campaign.

12:25And so this is all fascinating, but it does pretend some ideological divisions for Democrats if and when they take the majority in the House and potentially the Senate. And ahead of 2028, Michigan is going to be a consequential state. El-Sayed has said he wants to be a power broker in the 2028 race. And so all of this is going to be difficult for Democrats to navigate. But there was sort of a flip-flop between McMorrow and Stevens after the primary where Stevens was sort of in vogue and McMorrow was seen as having fumbled away her momentum and her place in the party. But what happened between Stevens and McMorrow was so different.

13:09McMorrow kind of put her head down, started helping El-Sayed consolidate the party, stumping and supporting and blogging about down-ballot candidates. And, you know, now she's seen as someone who has a brighter future, whereas the inverse happened over the same period of time with Stevens. Will, in fact, McMorrow addressed all of this yesterday in an appearance on MSNOW. Let's take a listen. It feels like it's more about her feelings than Michiganders. Politics is not easy. I was in this primary, too. It was one of the most brutal, ugliest primaries I have certainly seen, having lived through it.

13:47But there is too much on the line right now for us to be in our feelings.

13:53Haley Stevens: The one thing that I'm really trying, you know, paying attention to and trying to, if we're going to like broaden this out a little bit is, you know, I feel like, and we were talking about this, Adam, the other day, I feel like maybe in years past, we had Haley Stevens, you know, representing kind of like the establishment. And maybe she would be, you know, joined by other leaders in the party, you know, you know, you know, trying to push back on whatever insurgent, progressive, far left, you know, wing that maybe Abdul El-Sayed represents. But she really was kind of on her own on an island. To your point, you know, President Barack Obama did a big rally with El-Sayed, who had been incredibly critical, as you've pointed out, of Obama's, you know, presidency.

14:36Haley Stevens: If Obama could put it aside, I mean, you would think, you know, Haley Stevens could. So I do wonder if this ends up being a blip, if this is a Haley Stevens produced moment that doesn't represent, like maybe the party is going to try to kind of, you know, come together as we head into 2028, or if it's more of, you know, a sign of things to come where this is kind of still bubbling under the surface. and once things, you know, split apart, when the factions split apart and they're going to all try to get power in 28, I wonder how much this kind of bubbles back up. You know, Liz Smith, obviously a really big advisor, was kind of hinting at that toward Dasha Burns about how, you know, if you can win in Michigan, doesn't mean you're going to win everywhere.

15:19Haley Stevens: I feel like that's still bubbling and so I wonder how much, you know, the Haley Stevens kind of sentiment grows as we had passed next week. Yeah. And, you know, what's really interesting, Will, is that if for some reason and we haven't yet seen signs of this, though Mike Rogers is now cutting an ad, our Lisa Kaczynski reports, based off of the Stevens endorsement. If for some reason this seeps through late deciding voters, the very small percentage in Michigan of undecided voters, if this does seep through somehow and El-Sayed for some reason loses, we are not going to see a definitive verdict in the democratic civil war because then progressives.

16:08It muddies the waters. That's right, because progressives will be able to say, look, you know, Stevens, you know, fumbled away our opportunity and we couldn't fully put on display the resonance that progressivism has in a place like a purple state like Michigan. And so, you know, the Civil War, you know, has no reason to resolve after the general election in November.

16:31Haley Stevens: And it was probably never going to be fully resolved with this even more so, right? Like, I mean, even more so, even to your point, if El Saeed loses, I mean, it's really easy to point to the Haley Stevens, even if it maybe didn't have much of an impact. I guess we won't really be able to know. We'll get into maybe the numbers and try to figure that out. But I mean, it's just like if you're, you know, a progressive, it's the best excuse you could have waiting for you. And that's all for today's show. As always, we have much more news and analysis in today's Playbook newsletter, which you can find at politico.com slash playbook.

17:05Haley Stevens: And as a reminder, folks, Politico has a new app. It's free and brings our reporting around the globe to your fingertips. Plus, you can get all of our newsletters and podcasts, including this one. Download it right now. We'll be back tomorrow. Have a great day.

17:25Presented by OpenAI.

From the publisher

Days before the midterms and the vibes are feeling off. The polls point to a Democratic wave, but neither party seems to believe them. Plus, the final days of campaigning have taken a bizarre turn with Rep. Haley Stevens making a surprise endorsement for Mike Rogers. 

For more news and analysis, subscribe to the Playbook newsletter: politico.com/playbook 

More from The Playbook Podcast

All episodes