With the Podcast “I’ve Had It,” Jennifer Welch Goes “Dark Woke” on Politics

0:05You're listening to The Political Scene. I'm David Remnick. Early each week, we bring you a conversation from our episode of The New Yorker Radio Hour. This is The New Yorker Radio Hour, a co-production of WNYC Studios and The New Yorker. Welcome to The New Yorker Radio Hour. I'm David Remnick. One of the big changes in our politics, and I don't think we've really gotten our heads around it yet, is the change in how and where people get their information. You know the top line here. Very real declines in people watching the nightly news and reading the newspapers. And in their places come a much more scattered, much more siloed universe of social media feeds, TikTok explainers, podcasts, newsletters, and all the rest.

0:55Now, I don't think it's unfair to say that most of these outlets, not all, but most, whatever their virtues, are not exactly obsessed with fairness and accuracy in the way that the best traditional journalism outlets are. or damn well should be. And yet there's no denying the power, even the relatability of many podcasts, whether it's Ben Shapiro on the right, Joe Rogan, wherever he might be on a given day, or on the left, someone like our guest today, Jennifer Welch. Welch came to political podcasts in a kind of roundabout way. She had a successful career as an interior designer, and she co-starred in a reality show on Bravo.

1:35But since 2022, she and her co-host, Angie Sullivan, have been pushing political buttons and getting millions of fans on the podcast called I've Had It. And that's Jennifer Welsh's daily state of mind, Furious. I've had it with white people that triple-Trumped that have the nerve and the audacity to walk into to a Mexican restaurant, a Chinese restaurant, an Indian restaurant, go to perhaps their gay hairdresser. I don't think you should be able to enjoy anything but Cracker Barrel. Her frustration is not only with MAGA. Welch has gotten particularly contentious in interviews with establishment Democrats like Cory Booker and Rahm Emanuel.

2:28And she takes real advantage of a certain surprise factor that a white woman in her 50s from Oklahoma has emerged as one of the most provocative voices on the left today. I spoke last week with Jennifer Welch, co-host of the podcast, I've Had It.

2:47So you have one of the biggest podcasts out there. And as you know, there are hundreds of thousands of podcasts. Everybody and their uncle apparently has a podcast at this point. How did you conceive of this show? Where does it fit in? What is it? My friend Angie and I were on a reality television show in 2016 to run 2019. Our politics seeps through a little bit, particularly mine does, in the show because that's what was the hook for the Bravo executives. Like, they're liberals in Oklahoma. Right, where you're from. Right. I'm from Oklahoma City. So the show gets canceled, and I go back to being an interior designer.

3:31And then I'm doing national projects. So that was great fun, and I'm just booming. And then there was the post-COVID boom where everybody comes out of quarantine wanting to redecorate everything. And my kids were like, you know, you still have a lot of people that follow you that are interested in the show. You should do a podcast. So I tell Angie this, and we decide to do it. And the premise was during the Biden administration, which was, I've had it. I've had it with gender reveal parties. I've had it with over-celebrating children. Why are we going to kindergarten graduations? Why? So there were these relatable grievances that initially, I think, everybody likes to trash talk, right?

4:16And we look, my co-host and I, look somewhat MAGA-coded. You're mega-coated because of where you're from? The blonde hair, some Botox from time to time, and the southern accent. Yeah. Right? So it's kind of fox-coated, I would say. And I've always been a diehard political junkie. I was raised in the Bible Belt by two progressive atheists, which is a very, very strange upbringing. Was political discussion a big part of your upbringing in Oklahoma? Yes, with my mother. Who was pretty left, right? Very left. My mother is a voracious reader. She was a closet atheist for many years because if you came out of the closet as an atheist in a place like Oklahoma, it's about as bottom of the barrel.

5:10I mean, it's social death for you. Total social death. And so she and I would have all of these conversations about, I remember the first time I ever asked my mother, what is gay? Why would somebody be gay? I'm like six years old. And my mother would say, well, darling, all you need to know is nobody in their right damn mind would ever choose to be gay in the middle of the Bible Belt. That would be insane. It is not a choice. So this type of critical thinking juxtaposed with the rigid evangelicals that I went to school with that were constantly trying to recruit me was a really interesting upbringing.

5:48You've got this podcast now with the background that you've got. What do you see as its distinguishing feature? What's it about? We moved on from the petty grievances and we have an additional podcast now called IHIP News, which is short for I've Had It Podcast News. We have so many people in the middle of America, blue dots, if you will, that have a different worldview about American politics than, no offense, you coastal elites do or people inside the beltway do. And there is a part of beltway politics that is too civilized, that doesn't understand the grit and the fangs that will draw people in the middle of the country into the fight.

6:38And you're trying to give, at least as I listen to it, give voice to that sense of frustration. Some of your recent episodes on your podcast have these names, and not all of them will be able to make it on conventional radio. No Country for Maga Men, New Year, same assholes. Ring out the bullshit. Merry Griftmas, Fascism but Stupid, and finally All the Presidents, Morons. I think that's a different mood, say, than Pod Save America. Yes. This is the era of FU politics and dark woke. What is dark woke? Okay. Dark woke is a reaction to you have the purest woke people who are policing what everybody say up in everybody's business, which is similar a bit to conservatives being up in everybody's business.

7:35Dark woke for me is we are fighting for good and for equality and for social justice for everybody, but we don't mind saying F you. You have to know what you're up against and you have to be ruthless. Give me some examples and tell me who your allies are in that. Well, some examples would be we have to go after these MAGA men. One example would be Jesse Waters. This man talks incessantly about masculinity. Joe Biden is not masculine because he sucks on soup. What kind of man sucks on a straw? He goes on and on and on so much about the idealized man. And that's a part of fascism, this, you know, propelling this form of toxic masculinity.

8:17Why are you so obsessed with men, Jesse Waters? What's all that about? Why are you so obsessed with trans people? Why are you thinking about genitals all the time? Kind of flip the script. So when you look at the guys on, and it's almost all guys, on Pod Save America, do you look at them as very 2016, very 2008, very Obama, and you've left that behind? I see the situation as being so dire right now that I don't see any of these people as competitors. I see the whole group as people of building a media ecosystem that is pro-democracy. And if people that are still stuck in the Obama era need to go listen to Pod Save, I know that they are pro-democracy and anti-fascist.

9:05But you think it's a form of self-soothing almost. Yes. Yeah. Yes. I think that they're— And delusional. Yes. Explain that to me because I would bet, if we're being honest with each other, that on public radio there's a lot of that too. There are some commonalities between the center-left and the far-right that can no longer be ignored. You can look at the electorate and you can say you're being lied to. These people are lying to you. The center-left movement, the Hillary Clintons, the certain people in that media echo chamber are still lying to you because they prioritize corporate interest over the interests of the people.

9:48And that is what has left the vacuum for well-meaning people to just vote against the status quo. And this has been an evolution for me because I was a very good MSNBC liberal. That's where I got my marching orders. That's where, you know, I felt like I was intellectual and I lived out and I was the most liberal woman in Oklahoma City. And I see the error of my thinking and not thinking even outside of that box. Be specific. What were the errors? Because I know that you're obviously very, very tough on the likes of Hakeem Jeffries, Chuck Schumer. Give me a sense of what you think their sins are and what distinguishes your politics from, say, the more supportive voices that you do hear on Pod Save America or the like.

10:37The error of my way was probably voting for Hillary Clinton over Bernie Sanders. There's a condescension to corporate democratic politics with the very long answers. You probably saw where I asked Cory Booker, do you think Benjamin Netanyahu's a war criminal? It was a yes or no question. It was a very long answer. Here's where I would get into a conversation with you. Some things are yes or no answers. Some things aren't. And some things actually are complicated. Agree. Some things do have a complicated history. That's not necessarily both-siderism or all the other derisive terms for it. Is that just weakness in your eyes or what?

11:19I do think that some answers are more complex. But when you have somebody like Cory Booker, who has presented himself to all of us as standing for the marginalized, standing for humanity, standing for civil rights, and you ask him a question about Benjamin Netanyahu, who has a warrant out for his arrest for being a war criminal, and you see that answer being duplicitous, This is very damaging to the Democratic Party. Jennifer Welsh is co-host of the podcast, I've Had It, and we'll continue in a moment.

12:15Hi, listeners. Coleman Hughes here to tell you that my podcast, Conversations with Coleman, is joining the free press. This podcast isn't about cheap debates. It's about deep discovery. Politics, philosophy, identity, culture, science, it's all fair game. If you're done with the hot takes and hungry for real talk, come join the conversation wherever you get your podcasts.

12:46This is the New Yorker Radio Hour. I'm David Remnick. And I've been speaking today with the co-host of the popular political podcast, I've Had It. Her name is Jennifer Welsh. Even if you aren't a regular listener, Welch very well may have popped up on your social media feeds with stinging rebukes of politicians on both sides. Her progressive politics are not unique, but her style and her sense of how to connect with listeners is pretty unapologetic, pretty in-your-face, and very profane. Where Michelle Obama famously said, when they go low, we go high, Welch says, you want to go low? We're going to go lower.

13:25I'll continue my conversation with Jennifer Welsh.

13:32Joe Rogan is the leading podcaster, not only in this country, but in the world. And by a lot. Yeah. And this is a guy who started out not with politics in mind, but rather with UFOs in mind and UFC fighting. And suddenly politics and big thinkers and dark web people and, and, and started coming to his show. And it became even more important, even more influential. And one of the biggest lingering questions about Kamala Harris wasn't about this policy question or that. It was about why the hell she didn't manage to go on Joe Rogan. Now, I know you don't listen incessantly. But I wonder what your thoughts on Joe Rogan.

14:19how you think about him and what influence it might or might not have on what you do. These voices are out there everywhere. And on the right, they have a massive, massive media ecosystem. The Democrats are too structured. They need to go on all of these podcasts. Kamala should have gone on Joe Rogan and allow herself to not be so disciplined. The reason that Joe Rogan and a much smaller podcast, I've had it, are taking off so much is because this is the way people speak. The news where you're just being reported to, it's kind of aged. It feels somewhat antiquated. We've become more informal in the way that we live.

15:07And to combine this with my former profession, I still do it, interior design. Think about back in the 50s, the kitchen, your guests never saw it. It was a very formal way of life. And now the kitchen is the nucleus of the house and everybody hangs out at the island. As a culture, we become less and less formal. You see that in architecture and you see that in the way we consume news. So there's this idea that when you're listening to a podcast or two people having a conversation that you know them and they're right in your ear and it feels intimate versus the presentation of corporate news. What I grew up and I still like it and I still watch it.

15:45Do you? Yeah, I do. Do you think the New York Times is a reliable purveyor of news? Because it's certainly the dominant newspaper and probably news gathering organization in this country. I do think they do really good work. There has been some sane washing headlines pertaining to covering what is actually happening right now. Yeah. That I think is not just a New York Times problem but a media problem in general. I saw online, imagine if we covered what was happening in the United States right now, the way we cover what happens in dictatorships in Africa or the Middle East. More outraged in a sense.

16:25Right. And it would be more realistic as to what's happened. I think the media has been very complicit because of the corporate ownership of it. And it's been the soft sell of this fascism that has normalized it. I agree, if you don't mind my saying. So in the sense – I get that critique and I hear it all the time. I'm in corporate media. This week's cover of The New Yorker is Donald Trump emits lots of explosions, obviously Venezuela, drinking from a gigantic barrel of oil and the oil is coming all over him. A more straight up the, you know, the wazoo political cartoon you couldn't imagine by Barry Blitt.

17:09And there it is. And yet I go to one panel discussion after another and get yelled at by one comedian podcast, usually comedian podcasters about the corporate media and they're the truth teller. I don't know if it's as simple as all that. I think you're correct that there are outliers. But it seems like since Fox News, there has been a trickle-down effect of a weakening of journalistic integrity across the board. You had Rahm Emanuel on. Oh, yeah. Rahm Emanuel is pretty clearly either thinking about or already running for president. And you just let him have it. Let's listen for a second. We were really south on kitchen table issues.

17:59We weren't really good about the family room issues. I disagree with you. I disagree with you 100 million percent. The only room we were doing really well was the bathroom, and that's the smallest room in the house. That is such bullshit. That is total bullshit. That is buying into the right-wing media narrative, and I'm so sick of Democrats like you selling out and saying this. You know who talks about trans people more than anybody? MAGA. Kamala Harris talked about homeownership. She talked about kitchen table issues. Trump's over there droning on about Hannibal Lecter. Are you kidding me? You put it right between his eyes.

18:32Why? When I heard him buy into the narrative that the right wing defines the left wing by, by being trans-obsessed or bathroom-obsessed, when they, the right wing, are the people who ran on this, for him to placate to that narrative And when he said it, I didn't know he was going to say it. That was, I felt the adrenaline like come up in me. And I have friends in Oklahoma who have trans children. And to go back to what my mother said, nobody in their right mind chooses to wake up and thinks, you know what? Today, I'm going to F with the conservatives. I'm going to switch genders, and I'm going to go try to be a D1 tennis player.

19:17That's not what this journey is. And for the Democrats, we have to be the party of equality. And even if these MAGA people don't understand what transgenderism is, that's okay. You don't have to understand it, but we're not going to bully them. We're not going to pick them up and throw them under the bus. And the rights that are available for me need to be readily available for those people. And I would even go a step further. Maybe they need a little bit more love and a little bit less throwing under the bus. So when I hear Democrats do this, it really pisses me off. And that's why the Democrats lose because average voters sniff that duplicity out.

19:59Do you accept the argument that – I hate the word but I'll use it anyway – that wokeness got to a point where it did hurt the Democrats on a whole other range of issues and their efforts to get elected? I accept that what we're going through right now is a backlash from a lot of that. I remember on my Instagram feed after Kamala lost, somebody wrote, I hate being white. You know, just very histrionic about the whole thing. And I thought, oh, fuck's sake. For God's sake, this is ridiculous. Of course, you still don't even get the point. On the far left, it can go too far. too woke, which is why I think we have to go dark woke.

20:47Don't get mired down. They call me a wine mom all the time. Yeah. What is that? And why aren't you more pissed about it? So I was interviewed by the aforementioned New York Times and they asked me, they referred to me as the wine mom. And I definitely was at one point. I remember my kids were really little. I was like, God, I can't go through another day sober. I need to have a few glasses of wine. These kids are a lot, right? So, but between you and me and your listener, I do think it's reductive to refer to me as a wine mom. And I do think you would never refer to Joe Rogan as a wine dad or a whiskey dad.

21:26I do think women oftentimes get defined in a parental role where men never do. But here's the difference between being woke and dark woke. Where this comes from is all the people that are pro-democracy. I'm not going to pitch a fit and say, quit calling me a wine mom. That's sexist. And you think that would alienate a potential listener? I don't care about alienating listeners as much as I do. Is this helpful? I think part of your show is almost cathartic. That's exactly right. I'm going to get this off my chest. And I tune in so I hear you doing it with me so I feel less lonely. That's exactly right.

22:04And I also think when you are falling prey to abuse and what this government is doing to us right now is abusing us. We are seeing it every day with ICE raids, with, God, just Stephen Miller in a news clip, as abusive as all get out, right? And we need a sense of community. And I liken it to my husband is in recovery from opioid addiction. And that was an incredibly painful, isolating, horrible thing that I went through. And I found myself at an Al-Anon meeting. I found myself with this group of people who were experiencing the same type of gaslighting and abuse that one suffers from loving an addict.

22:49And it depersonalized it for me. It made me realize, oh, what I'm perceiving as I'm not lovable or if I just did this or if I just did that, then maybe he might be sober. That there is an actual playbook that a lot of addicts do because it's addiction. Similarly, when you get to IHIP News, we're all experiencing this trauma and we're being gaslit and we're being propagandized and you feel like you're going crazy. So you're comparing your show to an Al-Anon meeting in a sense. Kind of, but in the sense of community that you realize you can go there and go, oh God, I'm not crazy. And I think a lot of people don't realize how isolated Americans in the middle of the country are.

23:40What I worry about is the other thing, is exposing people and myself to contrary opinion, not the same opinion. Am I wrong, too? Sometimes I'll, you know, be at a gathering or whatever it might be, and everybody's saying the same damn thing. That concerns me, too. I see your point. I think that I approach the podcast with, and I mention this a lot, with my experience in Oklahoma, which has a Republican supermajority. The last time we had a Democratic governor, we were ranked 17th in the country in education. Since we've had a Republican supermajority in the state, the governor, the state house, the state senate, and the state supreme court, we have fallen from 17th in education to 50th in education.

24:30No, it's grim. It's grim. Are you getting listened to, though, in Oklahoma? Yes. When I go home and I go to Oklahoma City Thunder Games, you wouldn't believe the amount of people in Oklahoma City. It's an awfully good team. God, they're so good. But they're even better than the Knicks. Love. Oh, yes. The Knicks fans are so salty. Were you too mean to Erica Kirk and was your timing lousy? No. Does it help your cause to call her, particularly in that moment of aftermath, a grifter and a person who weaponizes her gender to demean women? Yes, because that's what she did. If people are out trying to fundraise off of his death and the message that she's sending to women to marry younger, breed immediately, it is a very dangerous message.

25:22So I double down on that. And I think her message makes women less safe. We've got an election coming up in a year. Who do you like and who do you not like for 2028? How's Gavin Newsom looking, too? Okay. Your female listeners will appreciate this, and this is what we get to talk on podcasts but not corporate movies. He's very easy on the eyeballs, which is a nice component. Although he looks like a dastardly senator in a movie, doesn't he? He does. The haircut, the whole thing. Out of central casting, yeah. I like his fight. I like how he relentlessly trolls Trump. Yeah. I think with the base, he's going to have the same problems that Clinton and Kamala did.

26:01Granted, he is a white male, and historically they seem to do better in the electorate than women. That seems to be the history of the presidency in this American history. Much to my chagrin. But he has time to clean all of this up. But he recently said he opposed a billionaire tax. And I think he's going to have a very hard time if he doesn't really get in the trenches with where the base has moved. And I think that's going to be what's the most shocking for the Democratic establishment candidates is how much the base has moved away from corporate Dems. So who does that leave you with? I'll tell you, I love Ro Khanna.

26:46I don't think he's going to run for office. But somebody who I think can be interesting is J.B. Pritzker. He's a billionaire. And a real one. A real billionaire. He is Jewish, which he has an opportunity to speak to what a lot of people in the Democratic base have issues with, with Palestine. If he can call what is happening a genocide, if he can call Benjamin Netanyahu a war criminal, he would be a credible messenger. Those are litmus tests for you. I hate the word litmus test, but I'm realistic in the sense that I believe that we have to call what we're seeing realistically. You cannot gaslight people about it.

27:38Would you have called LBJ or Richard Nixon war criminals? Probably. I mean, I think that American foreign policy has been problematic for a long time, and I've had a great awakening about this. But as I see what happened with Venezuela, when I saw that they were killing fishermen, I had to be really objective and honest. We didn't really do anything about what George W. Bush did and Abu Ghraib or the CIA black sites. Obama's drone program. Remember, I love Obama. I'm super nostalgic about him. But if we are really to be honest about American foreign policy, these provocations that Trump just did, they're not new.

28:21It seems to me that the people that you're looking at are Ro Khanna, AOC, the new mayor of New York. Is that the kind of area you're talking about? Yes, I have - Economic populism from a democratic view. Yes. The last gubernatorial race that we had, we had our governor who was running for a second term, Kevin Stitt. MAGA, right-wing, Christian nationalist, says, I dedicate every square inch of the state to my Lord and personal Savior, Jesus Christ. And then you had Joy Hoffmeister, who ran against him. She was a former Republican, switched to Democrat, and she ran as Republican light. and Kevin Stick kicked her ass.