In short
The Prestige TV podcast recaps the two-part series premiere of Cape Fear, arguing the show updates John D. MacDonald’s The Executioners and prior film versions to match each era’s anxieties—especially modern “tech paranoia” and surveillance—while keeping the core terror of an apparently plausible, legally slippery Max Cady.
Guest backgrounds
No podcast guests are interviewed in the provided transcript; the hosts are Dwight Robinson and Rob Mahoney.
Key claims
The series’ changes include shifting from a convicted Cady to one exonerated in 2026, increasing uncertainty about what really happened, and splitting the classic Sam Bowden role between Anna and Tom Bowden (Amy Adams and Patrick Wilson). The hosts say Max Cady is “smoother” than earlier portrayals, using law, manipulation, and possibly “witchcraft” imagery (bulls, Christian iconography, glitches, dead-wife/son visions). They also worry 10 episodes may dilute intensity.
Notable examples
Max Cady touring the house in a linen suit; Anna’s organization and Ray Rollins’ “investigator” work; Zach’s catfishing/emoji text from “Angel X”; Zach hallucinating an AI-slop version of Cady’s dead son; dead skunks in a reporter’s pool; and violent set pieces (Nazis impaled; toe ingestion).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOInitial Impressions of Cape Fear
0:35 to 1:26
Hosts discuss their thoughts on the double premiere and its unsettling elements.
“Rob, what's your ideal cookout scenario?”
Initial Impressions of Cape Fear
1:45 to 3:42
Hosts discuss their thoughts on the double premiere and its unsettling elements.
“Did you like these episodes of television?”
Analyzing the Source Material
3:42 to 5:59
Discussion on the original novel and adaptations of Cape Fear.
“And what does it say about the decade that it is sort of exploring.”
Exploring Changes in Character Dynamics
5:59 to 8:00
Hosts delve into the character transformations across different versions.
“And specifically, I think in some adaptations of an underage girl, that's been now changed to his wife, his pregnant wife has been murdered, presumably by him, but then also exonerated and released from prison.”
The Morality and Law in Cape Fear
8:00 to 10:46
Discussion on the moral complexities and legal implications in the story.
“So how far off the map are they going to go with this version?”
Max Cady: A New Interpretation
10:46 to 14:00
Hosts analyze the portrayal of Max Cady in the latest adaptation.
“But I think the thing that plays, whether you're talking about the 50s or the 60s or the 90s or today, even, you know, you're updating, you're modernizing, you're changing the framing.”
Analyzing Max Cady's Character Development
14:00 to 20:34
Discussion on the portrayal and evolution of Max Cady's character in the series.
“And even in terms of like who he is seducing and who he is fooling, it's a much wider swath.”
Tech Anxiety and Societal Fears
20:34 to 21:54
Exploration of how the series reflects current anxieties about technology and safety.
“This is a dream assignment all of a sudden.”
The Role of Family and Relationships
21:54 to 27:34
Examining family dynamics and relationships in the context of the show's narrative.
“But I will say I watched episode one, then I watched episode two like much later and I had forgotten about the AI slop part.”
Future Episodes and Character Mysteries
27:44 to 28:00
Discussing potential future episodes and unresolved character questions.
“From Anne Rice's Immortal Universe comes what Vulture calls the most momentous event in fictional rock history.”
Show all 26 chapters
Introduction of Key Themes
28:00 to 28:39
The hosts introduce character dynamics and themes from the series.
“Debuts Sunday at night exclusively on AMC and AMC+.”
Exploring Max Cady's Character
28:39 to 30:45
Discussion about Max Cady's physical presence and psychological manipulation methods.
“I also wonder if it's meant to match Amy Adams' eyes.”
Connections Between Characters
30:45 to 33:11
The hosts delve into connections and secrets among characters, especially focusing on Anna and Max Cady.
“It feels like it's like exposed to the outdoors.”
Creepy Dynamics and Historical Context
33:11 to 34:36
Discussion of unsettling scenes from the past adaptations of Cape Fear and their implications.
“So one of the creepiest, the creepiest things, I think, well, it's a long list, but Max Cady in the various versions creeps around the teenage daughter.”
Potential Plot Twists and Character Relationships
34:36 to 37:04
Speculations about relationships and secrets between key characters, especially regarding Natalie and Max Cady.
“First of all, what teens out there were like, let's go watch Cape Fear?”
Tom Bowden and Family Dynamics
37:04 to 39:31
Exploration of Tom Bowden's character, his family issues, and parenting styles.
“Okay, let's talk about Tom Bowden, Captain America himself.”
The Effects of Stalking and Psychological Impact
39:31 to 42:00
Discussion about the themes of stalking and psychological distress among characters in the narrative.
“it seems like he had the few that maybe stuck with him after the sophia thing he seems to have abandoned for the sake of angel x angel x who among us all right drugs she is what was what What was Dirty Hot?”
Exploring Themes of Stalking and Relationships
42:00 to 50:57
The hosts discuss the various forms of stalking depicted in the series and the complex relationships between characters.
“The seeing Adam Cady, seeing the ghost of the AI slop of the teenage version of Max Cady's dead son.”
Character Mysteries and Plot Predictions
51:26 to 56:01
The conversation shifts to discussing character arcs, potential plot twists, and the mysterious elements surrounding the narrative.
“And, you know, we talk about plenty of other things, but one other sort of logistical thing I want to talk about.”
Wild Animal Preferences
56:01 to 57:19
The hosts humorously discuss preferences between different animals, including skunks and possums.
“Skunks seem like better members of the community, to be honest.”
Product Placement Discussion
57:20 to 58:21
The hosts question the effectiveness and implications of product placements in the show.
“They should have paid some money for the product placement in this episode.”
Actors and Performances in Cape Fear
58:22 to 59:28
Discussion on the performances of Javier Bardem, Amy Adams, and Patrick Wilson in the series.
“You want to hit them with that email one more time?”
Character Dynamics and Accents
59:29 to 1:00:37
Analysis of character dynamics and the accents portrayed by the actors in the show.
“I love his like, you know, dad making inappropriate jokes when he's like, I could pop it on ice, pop that toe back on for you know what I mean?”
Plea Deals and Legal Questions
1:00:38 to 1:02:36
The hosts delve into the legal aspects of plea deals and their implications as presented in the show.
“Yeah, so I would say if people were like, should I watch this show?”
Final Thoughts and Farewell
1:02:37 to 1:04:03
The hosts wrap up their discussion, reflecting on the show and thanking the team.
“That's sort of what I got from CCH Pounder's character Noah when Anna's like, but we're not even taking his case.”
Final Thoughts and Farewell
1:04:38 to 1:05:06
The hosts wrap up their discussion, reflecting on the show and thanking the team.
“Shop up to 40 % off with minimum purchase and a free professional measure right now at blinds.com.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00The playoffs are here and you can predict the action all the way to the finals with FanDuel predicts. Predict the spread, total points, and even the game winner. Sign up and get a$25 bonus. Offered by FanDuel Prediction Markets, LLC, a registered futures commission merchant. 18 plus. Bonus is non-withdrawable and expires seven days after receipt. Trading derivatives involve significant risk and may not be suitable for all investors. Manage your activity with our consumer protection tool. Restrictions apply. See terms at fanduel.com slash predict slash bonus dash offer dash terms. This episode is brought to you by America's cookout classics, Heinz, Kraft, and Oscar Meyer.
0:34This summer, we're celebrating 250 years of American cookouts with all the classics, Heinz, Kraft, and Oscar Meyer. Rob, what's your ideal cookout scenario? First of all, I want you on the ox. I trust you with that sacred responsibility to pick our music. I'm going to have to man the grill, and I'm going to need like a copious amount of condiments. I need every possible fix-in imaginable. Well, make sure to top your burger with only the best, Heinz, ketchup, and Kraft singles. And you know, it's not a cookout without Heinz ketchup and mustard. Different vibes, same ingredients. We all know it's not a cookout without Heinz, Kraft, and Oscar Mayer.
1:05Shop at your local retailer.
1:25Hello, welcome back to the Prestige TV podcast. Speed. I'm Dwight Robinson. I am Rob Mahoney. We're here to talk about Cape Fear. Spooky. The first two episodes of Cape Fear did a double premiere drop. So if you missed that and only watched the first episode, we're going to be talking about both episodes. So you might want to go watch them and then come back and listen to us talk about it. I would advise it. Rob Mahoney, big picture. Did you like these episodes of television? You know, I did. I am intrigued. Okay, tell me. I think, look, on a line-by-line level, sometimes it can be a little blunt.
1:58Sometimes the dialogue can be a little on the nose. I think it gets the most important Cape Fear thing right, which is like the bone-chilling unsettledness of this kind of story. I'm unsettled. I'm sufficiently unsettled. Okay, so the source material that we're working with here is there's a 1957 novel by John MacDonald called The Executioners. Yes. Which I have procured but not cracked yet. I did rewatch the 1962 film with Gregory Peck and Robert Mitchum. And I did rewatch the 1991 film from Martin Scorsese with Robert De Niro. Have you heard of him? Nick Nolte, Jessica Lange, Juliette Lewis.
2:32Both Juliette Lewis and Robert De Niro got Oscar nominations for that film. Both phenomenal in it. Extraordinary. And then, of course, the 1993 episode of The Simpsons, Cade Fair. well we should we should know the first three are all credited as being the basis for this show right i don't think i've ever seen that before the base like based on this novel and these two movies but if nick nick and tosca who's the showrunner of of this uh version i think if he's being honest with himself yeah he should credit the simpsons as well because that is a phenomenal episode let's add it to the list i think it was my first exposure to the story of cape fear was is that episode of The Simpsons with Sideshow Bob.
3:12Amazing. Stalking. Have you seen it? I have seen it. It's been a minute, I'm going to be honest with you. I think it's maybe my favorite episode of The Simpsons. He sings Gilbert and Sullivan. He steps on a bunch of rakes. Wow, it really is hitting all of your touchstones. All right, so this is what, so the question is why? Why do we need a 10 episode show based on a book and two movies and perhaps an episode of The Simpsons that were already quite well regarded and phenomenal. Do we need to tell this story again? And I think it is interesting to track this 1950s novel, this 1960s movie, this 1990s movie, and the way in which the story is slightly mutated over those many adaptations to reflect, and this is what Nick Antoska has said in several interviews, sort of to reflect the anxieties of the era.
4:00Every era gets its own Cape Fear. And what does it say about the decade that it is sort of exploring. And Martin Scorsese talked about that as well, where he was just sort of like, I am remaking a movie that I regard very highly. It's sort of a kind of a B movie. And his version, his Cape Fear, is not really like any other Martin Scorsese movie. It's what years ago, my pal David Ehrlich, in regard to the film Gone Girl, I don't know if he coined this phrase but the phrase he used was trash your piece like something that is like yeah great but also schlocky at the same time and like Martin Scorsese's Cape Fear is a absolute stone cold trash your piece and all three movies are the two movies in the TV show are using the exact same score so that they're like bum bum bum like that is the Cape Fear score.
5:02Let me tell you it still hits. And then this show, right away when we get the sort of photo negative imagery that opens episode one of this show, you know, or the pool is colored red instead of blue. That's a direct visual connection to the Scorsese film. Also, we get the shot in episode two of Max's eyes through the slots of the closet. That's like basically ripped from the poster. Absolutely. So do you want to talk about sort of what our plan is to talk about this really well-known story, Cape Fear, in a way that people are watching the show and maybe haven't seen any of these movies or read the book or watched that Simpsons episode?
5:43Like, you know, what is a spoiler inside of this content? I genuinely don't know. That wasn't a conversation I was expecting to have about Cape Fear based on the idea of it. If you're not familiar with the movies, I would not describe them as particularly twisty. Like it's a somewhat straightforward story. Right. But within this adaptation, I think we're introducing all sorts of uncertainty as far as what actually happened with the inciting incident, which I believe in both movies and the novel, it's a rape that Max Cady has committed. And specifically, I think in some adaptations of an underage girl, that's been now changed to his wife, his pregnant wife has been murdered, presumably by him, but then also exonerated and released from prison.
6:24So there's some uncertainty around what happened. There's some uncertainty around the actual trial that led him and the plea bargain that apparently sent him to prison in the first place. And I got to say, maybe he has a point as far as being a little bit mad that the prosecutor and his defense attorney ended up married. I'm not saying he's a great guy, but I, too, would be a little fussed. Rob Mahoney, Max Cady had some good points. Not saying that. Max Kady is one of the most iconic, like, on-screen psychopaths. Yes. You know, played incredibly by both Robert Mitchum and Robert De Niro. And to get Javier Bardem, who has already played one of our most iconic on-screen psychopaths.
7:06Several, I would say. What's your list? I mean, I think Skyfall might be included, too. You're, okay. Not quite as iconic. As Anton Sugar. No. Okay. I do think this version, in its deviations from the De Niro one especially, which is like a functionally illiterate man who is like malicious and evil. And this version is more verbal in the way that Javier Bardem characters tend to be. That's interesting because like Anton Chigurh is pretty nonverbal. That's true. I guess he goes both ways. So here's what's interesting. We're not going to talk about sort of like the ending of Cape Fear, I guess, is what we're going to stay away from.
7:46And for the record, we don't know the ending of this series. Right. And we talked about this a lot with Presumed Innocent where Rob didn't know the story of Presumed Innocent. I did. We were so careful about that. And then that version of that story was completely different at the end. So how far off the map are they going to go with this version? There's already so many differences. But I do want to talk about this core difference across all the adaptations, which is as we go forward in time and as our world gets more complex, perhaps this blurring of the lines, morality lines, you know, is increases.
8:21So in the 1962 film, we have cast Gregory Peck as Sam Bowden, the attorney. Atticus Finch himself, like just the most upstanding citizen possible. And it is Sam Bowden, family man, and his lovely family. And what happens when this elemental evil, as represented by Robert Mitchum, comes to town and destroys your family? I just recorded an episode of the Rewatchables that's part of this From Hell month that Bill is doing. And this is sort of his overreaching concept of From Hell, which is like this element has entered your home and is here to destroy it. And is distinctly uncomplicated in some ways.
9:05Like a Knight of the Hunter style. Yes. This is evil incarnate. This is why you get Robert Mintum to do this, right? Okay. So in 91, Scorsese's like, let's complicate it a little bit. Okay. So in his version, Nick Nolte's character of Sam Bowden has buried some evidence in the case. He believes Max Cady did the crime. We believe Max Cady did the crime. We believe that ultimately justice was served in sending Max Cady to prison. Right. But is De Niro's version of that character right when he's like, hey, did you bury some evidence in my case, attorney? Look who's saying Max Cady has some points now.
9:42I'm saying. Spurs says he was like, wouldn't it be interesting if Max Cady studied the law? Right. And he is actually the one who's like, here's the letter of the law. Yes. And Nick Nolte's attorney character is like, I'm bending the law slightly to serve this greater idea of justice. Also, Nick Nolte's character in that version of the film is a philanderer. You know what I mean? Like, has these various flaws. He is not a Gregory Peck type. He is like a, you know, he's a husband and a dad, but they had to leave town because he fucked too many women. And like, you know, he's got a relationship of a sort with Ileana Douglas and all this sort of stuff going on.
10:19So that's the slightly different thing. Now we get to this version of Cape Fear where, as you pointed out, Max Cady is not released because he served a sentence. He's released because he is exonerated. There is some question. I don't have any questions about this, but the TV show is asking some questions about whether or not Max Cady actually did the crime. I think he did. I think there's evidence inside of these episodes that he did. I suspect he did. But I think the thing that plays, whether you're talking about the 50s or the 60s or the 90s or today, even, you know, you're updating, you're modernizing, you're changing the framing.
10:54But that like core idea of the plausible deniability of like, I'm just around. I just happen to be in the neighborhood. I'm just like, I'm an innocent bystander. I have this airtight alibi and it turns the core attorney characters into this like position of what if I can see the thing that no one else can see and no one believes me. And the law, there's a limit to what the law can do for me. Absolutely. And so what do I do when the structures that I believe in fail me? And that's what's so fun about De Niro's Max Cady especially is because he has studied the law, he's like, oh, I'm not on your property.
11:27Yeah. Oh, I'm, you know, like he's using the law to get away with all the shit that he gets away with. Right. OK, so in this version, we have no Sam Bowden. It's Anna and Tom Bowden, two attorneys. And as you alluded to, she was his defense attorney. He was the prosecutor. It's messed up. It's bad. It is fucked up. The optics are bad. Very bad. So we've got, you know, I was talking to you a bit about this last week where I was wondering if, because I could tell that they had made Amy Adams into sort of like she was the defense attorney. which is the role that these other Sam Bowdens have played.
12:04But I was like, so is Patrick Wilson just going to be the Jessica Lange interior designer husband or whatever it is that she's an artist? I don't know, whatever it is she does. No, they're both attorneys. So they sort of split the role across these two characters. Patrick Wilson and Amy Adams are here. But they have this like, you know, they look around. Do you ever think we don't deserve this? They have this like picture perfect home. They've got a fucked up kid or two. they've got a lot of they've got so many secrets i mean it's almost like the glitching picture frame is a metaphor what for the mirage of their suburban existence what is the metaphor what is the storm a metaphor clunky writing unfortunately that one was tough um okay so we've got uh lawyers who have you know at least had like fucked each other during the case probably got married afterwards what was the deal they they say this very ominous thing in in episode two that their daughter overhears which is like we had to do the thing that we did what was it we don't know yet because there's so many mysterious questions and we're gonna run down all of the open questions because they have stretched you know Nick and Tosca has decided to stretch this story from a two-hour cinema masterpiece trashed piece into a 10 episode television series and this is the thing I'm most worried about it honestly Javier Bardem sound a little bit worried about it because in an interview with Entertainment Weekly they're like what's the the thing you were sort of like most yeah anxious about he was like people getting bored yeah this is 10 episodes with Max Katie it's not a two-hour jaunt around you know the south with Max Katie you are spending 10 hours with him so how can I add shading and nuance and whatever to him is he still this sort of elemental evil character that Robert Mitchum and Robert De Niro have played.
13:56Yes. Yes. But like, does he have, you know, the De Niro version has a charm to him. Certainly. But this version is even smoother. And even in terms of like who he is seducing and who he is fooling, it's a much wider swath. I really loved the scene in episode two when he's touring the house and he's talking to the real estate, the realtor, whoever he's talking to. Well, he knows how to wear a linen suit. That's for sure. Absolutely. But he's like, and that's the thing is like, unlike, well, I would say Mitchum's Max Katie blends, but unlike De Niro, he blends, right? De Niro's wearing like loud shirts and has like a bikini girl lighter and is as like crass as crass can be.
14:44and this is not the smoothie Max Katie that we're getting here. But the way that he goes off on his rant about whatever and he's like, oh, but that's not the world you live in, my dear. I will get you the information you want. And it's just sort of like, he's unsettling, but you understand why these various characters, perhaps the most frustratingly CCH Pounder's character, are taken in and sort of enamored by him. I think this is the smartest of the adaptive choices we've seen so far. Some of it, we're gonna see how it pays off, like where it goes, what the secrets are within, you know, the two lawyers and their marriage and all that.
15:17The choice to kind of cloak Max Cady in the fight for social justice, I think is a really smart decision. And just the idea of like, what does it mean when someone is released from prison in 2026 because they were seemingly wrongfully in prison? And like, how do people treat him? What does he get pulled into? And I think structurally, if you're trying to make a TV show, you need ways that he and Anna can be in the same spaces. Yes. Logically. Right. Without her wanting to call the police at all times. And so him becoming like, whether by accident or by crook, like almost the face of her organization, I think it's just like a really smart way to integrate this really menacing element into her world.
15:56And I think to start with in episode one at the gala, when she is talking about the flaws inside the justice system. So she's already starting from a place of the justice, Like my whole life's work is to talk about how flawed the justice system is. And so but where does the rubber meet the road in terms of those values when it comes to someone like Max Cady? And she's like, no, but I know that he is, you know, evil. I know this to be true. And that's different from your Gregory Pex, who's like, I believe in the law. I believe in law and order. And when like various people are like, we could do this shady thing.
16:28He's like, no, we have to go by the letter of the law. in in episode one um we meet this sort of investigator character who works for um anna's organization is played by the wires jamie hector ray rollins and she interviews him she's like here's ray rollins he does what the cops can't or won't do you know we are we already work outside they gotta go around the boundaries for sure i think all of that is interesting i do and even like when the two interns meet at that point they're introducing i believe his name's Byron the other guy who they've recently Helped get released from prison who ends up mysteriously Killed or dead Well I mean there were Gunshots there was fighting I think We have an inkling as to what goes on but again plausible Deniability all around But the two interns who come to meet him are Like like oh talking about His lived experience and like the broken System it's like all of this language That we use today to try to Understand those broken systems Is like being weaponized against Presumably Anna and Tom as they try to protect their family and understand what kind of risk they're really in.
17:31I think another needle here is when Ted Levine as Anna's father shows up and Brandon Devereaux. Oh, by the way, we're in Savannah. Gotta be Devereaux's involved. And Toussaint. That CCH Pounders is Noah Toussaint. So you've got Toussaint's and Devereaux's. Like, we're living. We're thriving. Where was Blanche Devereaux from? Was she from Savannah? She's from Georgia. Yeah. Gotta be. We have to do some deeper Golden Girls research, try to tie the narrative. Oh, my God. Is one of these characters Big Daddy? Great question. But I think that I think having her father show up and call Tom and Anna country club liberals is another sort of like brick in the building we're creating here.
18:17Also, in terms of the anxieties that Nick Antoska is like, OK, what are the specific anxieties of the 1960s, of the 1990s and the nows? And what he's clearly latched on to, for better or for worse, is this tech anxiety right now. So, you know, are there predators in your schools is a 1990s question that Martin Scorsese is asking, right? Is someone catfishing your teenage, you know, is a man you sent to prison catfishing your teenage son? Is your security system, has it already been hacked? Yes. You know, all of these tech ways that, you know, the idea that like De Niro's Max Cady went to prison and studied the law and it feels like Javier Bardem's Max Cady went to prison to study tech.
19:06I mean, I have many questions. If he is, in fact, responsible for everything we've seen so far, I kind of wonder if the answer might be he is in some things and other ones are coincidental, circumstantial. I would say some. The one that is almost the biggest logical jump for me is like, how did this man who's been in prison for 17 years become a very good World of Warcraft player? To the point where he would bond with a teenager? Or do you even have to be if you're smooth talking? Don't you get to play video games in prison? They have WoW in there? They have subscription-based MMORPGs? I don't know, man.
19:38Maybe they do. Maybe they don't. Maybe prison has really changed. I don't know. I actually don't know the answer to that. But I feel like you have internet access in prison. So maybe that's all it takes. Great questions. Do you want to do a mini Nepo baby check-in for this? I think we simply have to for every show now. Okay. Joe Anders, who plays Zach Bowden. Yeah. Their son. That is the son of Kate Winslet. And. Wow. Yeah. So. And Sam Mendes. Okay. Yeah. So that's one. That's one. And then Anna Baryshnikoff, who plays the reporter. who is integral in the first two episodes, Tabitha, is Mikhail Baryshnikov's daughter.
20:18Let's talk about this reporter for a second. Okay. If I were reporting a story, as I often have, and the person I was interviewing wound up with a family of dead skunks in their pool, that's the lead. I'm sure it was. That is making the story. There's no like, this was off the record. That's the header photo. Come on, the dead skunks? Yeah. You got a cameraman there? This is a dream assignment all of a sudden. Absolutely. Especially now that all this evidence is coming out, like this man's released from prison, you're just sitting on the dead skunk lead. I do really appreciate that Anna Bowden is so media trained that she's like so careful about what's on the record, what's off the record.
20:51She's like, you didn't say it. So let's be clear. This is off the record. Pretty well done by her. This was not in the brief. We said we were not talking about this. And she was like, she's like, I'm sure you didn't see it. Yeah. I'm sure you did, bitch. Again, plausible deniability all around. We're not talking about this. So yeah, how does that tech anxiety play for you? It's a little of both. I will say of all the characters we've had so far, Zach feels the shakiest as far as like his place within the story. I think the part of it that is the online gaming catfishing, that part I'm along the ride for.
21:23The idea that he has leaked these like presumably nudes of this girl to his group chat. That feels like something a show like this could explore and get into. It's treatment we can dissect. It's the like TikTok AI slop version of Max, Katie's unborn son that he is now, I believe, hallucinating, walking about. Yeah. When it was just the AI slop video, I was like, okay, it's just like ghoulish, but honestly believable. Now that he's become a sentient walking hallucination, I don't know. So that leads into something else I want to talk about for sure. But I will say I watched episode one, then I watched episode two like much later and I had forgotten about the AI slop part.
22:03So when he hallucinated Max Cady's son, I was like, are we doing real ghosts here? Is that what's happening? And then I rewatched episode one, And I was like, oh, no, he saw the AI slop version of him. But Adam Cady, what Adam Cady would look like had he lived. I want to talk about so we've got this this tech paranoia. Right. What if you're, you know, and Max Cady, the tattoos are interesting to me because De Niro very consciously made wanted, you know, and he's talked about this, wanted to make sure all the tattoos on his body were, you know, specific biblical references. So the iconography and, you know, he's got like passages, long passages on his arms and stuff like that.
22:43With this version of Max Cady, he's got the Grim Reaper, which is same, same as De Niro's. Whoever did the ink. But the eyes everywhere. Yeah. And so in terms of this like tech surveillance, like, or is there another spiritual meaning to that? And that brings me into what I want to say, which is like alongside this this Max Cady tech genius aspect is like Max Cady like voodoo practitioner. Yeah. Okay, because in both the mistress who shoots herself in the head twice while listening to the cranberries in the opener. Yes. And in the possum infested den where Zack ingested his own toe at one point or was force fed his own toe.
23:30I mean, maybe the possum was doing the witchcraft. There's like bowls and seeds and nuts and stuff like that. And it's just like it's meant to invoke some sort of. It could just be an acai bowl. Absolutely not. You don't think so? It's meant to invoke like witchcraft. Add some yogurt and you got something going. So like is Max Katie in addition to like hacking your security system also casting spells? Is that what's happening? I don't know. I would say we get two very distinct impressions of him over the course of these episodes. One, particularly with the cold open of episode two, the physical threat of who he is is made very clear.
24:09right this is not a man who you're just going to see looming in the shadows like he fucks up these nazis who try to jump him and we love it look we do love to see that part and honestly i do think escalating both what we see max being capable of in terms of his physical strength and like ability to hurt someone yeah but also what the show is willing to show us right like a nazi gets his head impaled on a bench press bar another one gets a kettlebell to the knee and then we see Zach like with the vomiting his toe. We just put euphoria to bed and here we are again with just like severed toes and Nazis.
24:42Can we not escape? However, Rob, Nick Antosca, did you look at his credits? Yeah. So he did the act and candy, like the two big things that he's done is the act and candy, both true crime adaptations for Hulu, I believe. Yes. Well received, whatever. He was a writer on Hannibal. He was. Most notably for season three. People are eating toast? Is this not back in your Hannibal pocket? It's not a prime cut. It's not your first choice, I wouldn't think. If you have a deserted palette. Dr. Lecter would never. That's what, you know, that's for like the saucaging. Think of it as a baby carrot. Okay, I'm glad you brought up the baby carrot.
25:19We're trying to figure out how we want to cover this show. If it's going to be something we do week to week, we don't really know. Email us, comment, wherever you're watching this. Let us know if this is something you want to keep up with week to week. Prestigetv at Spotify.com. Regardless. Regardless. this. I would like for us to create an email for this show as we return to it. Think of a baby carrot at gmail.com is right there for us. What are your other options, Rob? Babybird the spliff at gmail.com. Possum witch at gmail.com or possum based witchcraft at gmail.com. Backyard cougar, fishing for skunks, the system of fuck you or dipped in handsome.
25:55How do you feel about any of those? Dipped in handsome was such a good phrase. Incredibly descriptive of Patrick Wilson Very, very key. I wrote that down both times I watched the episode. I think it's got to be think of a baby carrot. Let's let's do a quick double check. OK. Snoring, gasping during sleep, feeling fatigued. Ask your doctor about ZepBound Terzepatite, the first and only FDA approved prescription medicine for moderate to severe obstructive sleep apnea, OSA and adults with obesity. Z-Bound is a prescription medicine used with a reduced-calorie diet and increased physical activity to help adults with moderate to severe obstructive sleep apnea, OSA, and obesity to improve their OSA.
26:35Z-Bound is approved as a 2.5, 5, 7.5, 10, 12.5, or 15 milligram injection. Z-Bound contains terzepatide and should not be used with other terzepatide-containing products or any GLP-1 receptor agonist medicines. It is not known if ZepBound is safe and effective for use in children. Don't share needles or pins or reuse needles. Don't take if allergic to it or if you or someone in your family had medullary thyroid cancer or if you've had multiple endocrine neoplasia syndrome type 2. Tell your doctor if you get a lump or swelling in your neck. Stop ZepBound and call your doctor if you have severe stomach pain or a serious allergic reaction.
Read the full transcript
27:11Severe side effects may include inflamed pancreas or gallbladder problems. Tell your doctor if you experienced vision changes before scheduled procedures with anesthesia. If you're nursing, pregnant, plan to be, or taking birth control pills, taking ZipBound with a sulfonylurea or insulin may cause low blood sugar. Side effects include nausea, diarrhea, and vomiting, which can cause dehydration and worsen kidney problems. Talk to your doctor. Call 1-800-545-5979 or visit zipbound.lily.com. Debuting Sunday at 9, exclusively on AMC and AMC+. I am the vampire Lestat. I'm a rock star now. I'm a little killer.
27:51From Anne Rice's Immortal Universe comes what Vulture calls the most momentous event in fictional rock history. Thousands of fans love you. I want millions. It's my era. Anne Rice's The Vampire List. Debuts Sunday at night exclusively on AMC and AMC+. Okay, so through the magic of editing, and perhaps Cameron, who's editing this podcast, can put it down here at the bottom. think of a baby carrot at gmail.com is how you can reach us i'm very happy about it and also was very upset at that line of dialogue i love a baby carrot do you still it's the jar for me zach i'm not a fan of there's i should say uh this is there is a son character in the book there has been no son character in the two movies so we're we're adding back in people let's let's let's go through character by character okay and talk about all the mysteries and questions we have around these characters there are so many let's start with max katie himself javier bardem blue contacts why they're very unsettling i honestly think this is part of it like this character needs to have kind of an uncanny thing to him and if he's gonna be a little smoother in terms of his working with people our familiarity with javier bardem being like turned against us, but like there's just something off looking at him, I honestly think is part of the package.
29:17I also wonder if it's meant to match Amy Adams' eyes. Could be. Which are, the way the color grading is working on this show, they're like ultramarine. Yes. They're like really popping. And so if, you know, I think the promo image is like their two faces sort of blurring into each other. So if the point is to be like two sides of the same coin, we're not so different, you and I, like having these matching eyeballs might be part of that too. Speaking of, we got far afield with the baby carrot of all this, the physical presence of Max Cady is part of it. But you asked about like whether he's actually invoking some kind of witchcraft or magic or like what is making him such a good manipulator.
29:56I don't know the cause, but like clearly he is established as someone who can get people to do all kinds of things. Well, his father was a dog trainer. Yeah. And so I'm wondering how much of this is like the dog, you know, because we get in the flashback, we see that his father put him in a cage among other things and trained him, you know uh so through like behavioral cues or whatever like in terms of like how did he get zach to eat his own toe or whatever when he wasn't even there like you know are there you know can he call someone as it seems like he does with his mistress and and say certain things and get you do something because he's trained you he's hypnotized you so well is it hypnotic suggestion is it is it some kind of witchcraft is it just like a more conventional kind of humanistic manipulation i don't know i don't know but those bulls are he's doing stuff i don't know what it is leading to when anna and we'll get to all of our questions about anna when anna saw those bulls at first i was wondering if she would recognize them from like stuff that max katie had done before but she seemed when she asked her daughter she's like do you know what all this shit is why are they making a bigger deal out of like the witchcraft shit that's in their day i don't know No, I feel like if somebody, if I found evidence of random hexes in my unfinished room, I'd be a little freaked out.
31:10Also, finish that room. It feels like it's like exposed to the outdoors. Apparently. It's very confusing. The possum's just living in there and we're firing contractors left and right. Blue contacts on Javier Bardem. Yep. Dog trainer father. Some weird shit around Christianity and his father as well, obviously. Eyeball tattoos. Facility with tech. Brain damage. Glitches. Sees his dead wife and son. Yeah. And the glitches seem to, I mean, sometimes coincide with like flashes of light or things like that, as all happens for a lot of people with a lot of different conditions. I don't know what the spazzing out is going to ultimately lead to, but it does make it particularly terrifying when you, when you've seen what he can do.
31:50yeah the idea that he would be out of control for even a second and this is to me what's the most terrifying thing about him with all of this plausible deniability right like you have this revelation in episode two where amy adams's character is like connecting the dots between the text from angel x and like something that uh max katie has said yeah and it's like if all of these things that she believes are true then he's like so far ahead he's laying the seeds in like the conversations and the speeches it's like he's like catch up completely it's like it's so terrifying to think that you could be that far behind and yet i feel like javier burdam kind of sells that sort of intelligence mr policeman i gave you all the clues okay fingers and toes it was right there anna bowden uh got sober at one point yeah after the trial that was kind of a like a throwaway line.
32:42I think very important. Almost like 80 yard in, it felt like. Loose cannon, potentially bipolar father, has a bad relationship with him. Yes. And here's a seed I'm going to plant. Again, I have not watched past episode two. I believe she fucked Max Gaty. And I think her daughter is his biological daughter. That's what I think. That would be a hellscape of a show. Well, here's my thought. Okay. So one of the creepiest, the creepiest things, I think, well, it's a long list, but Max Cady in the various versions creeps around the teenage daughter. This is like his thing. This is why De Niro and Juliette Lewis were nominated for Oscars.
33:29Oscars right um by the way 1991 uh I saw an interview that Scorsese gave in 92 or 93 perhaps where he was talking about the scene between De Niro and and Juliette Lewis in the school in the original where he comes and he's like um seducing her yeah and he like sticks his finger in her mouth and then he kisses her yeah um first of all so Juliette Lewis was 17 playing younger She's wearing like a retainer. It's very upsetting. She was 17. De Niro improvised the finger in the mouth thing and he told Scorsese he was going to do it. Scorsese was like, great. Let's not tell the girl that you're going to do it.
34:11So that like fear and uncertainty you see on Juliette Lewis, that's her being like, why is Robert De Niro a 50-something-year-old man, 40-something-year-old man sticking his finger in my mouth? Last but not least. Juliette Lewis has lived a life, man. That was the first year the MTV Movie Awards did Best Kiss and they nominated that kiss from Cape Fear. Are you kidding me? I'm not kidding you. First of all, what teens out there were like, let's go watch Cape Fear? Everyone watched Cape Fear. I guess that's fair. It's just, oh my God, that is a horrendous decision. So I think they're hard swerving away from Max Katie creeps around the teenage daughter in this version.
34:52And you think the hardest swerve is what if he is her dad? I think he's her dad. They're not going to do that. And here's all the swerves they're doing. Yeah. She seems like she might be gay. Yes. So I don't think she's going to be seduced by. Oh, Joe, I got news for you. She is gay. I mean, she's gay, but she could be bi. She could be bi, but like. She wants to kiss her friend. She likes Megan Rapinoe shoes. Fan of Megan Rapinoe is the new friend of Dorothy, as far as I'm concerned. So we'll make her queer. His biological daughter. Yep. And the person he's seducing and catfishing is the son, actually.
35:24Oh boy. I mean, it does seem like that is what has been set up. So like in terms of what secret could Anna be keeping from Tom? Because there are moments where she has opportunities to tell Tom things and she's not telling him. The fact that she fucked Max Katie and got pregnant by him and he's like, I never told anyone what happened and why would I start now? And all that sort of stuff like that. I think there's a watch on this show where you gloss past that as like something about hiding the evidence or some way she messed up the case. or like didn't file a thing on time or whatever. But now that you're laying it out, I think you're absolutely right.
35:58That there is clearly a secret between them that is distinct from whatever conspiracy to commit thing she has going on with Tom. Yeah. And the way that those secrets intersect and what kids may be involved as a result, I mean, my skin is crawling just thinking about it. Because I like this idea. I mean, I hate this idea, but I like this idea of Natalie being seduced, not sexually, but sort of like this bleeding heart. you know when she overhears her parents say like we had to do it you know and she asks her mom something about that like right he had to plead right so this idea that she's just sort of like believes Max Cady wasn't guilty and then maybe finds out he's her real dad and all of these sort of things like that would be extremely tough she's talking to her real dad Paul on the phone who seems deeply checked out of everything and there's an actor playing him but he's not like an actor who is like known for anything.
36:54So I don't think that her biological dad, Paul, is going to play a huge role in this show. So that's where my mind went. Straight into the gutter, it turns out. I guess so. Okay, let's talk about Tom Bowden, Captain America himself. Yeah. Patrick Wilson. I love Patrick Wilson. I'm so glad he's here. A joy every time. And do you think it was his idea to be like, should they see my arms? Do you think? Should I put my sleeves up a little bit? Should I go sleeveless for breakfast? Do you think Tom Bowden would do that? That's one does. Mental health issues in his family. He was very squirrely when the doctor was asking about the history of mental health issues in his family.
37:29Flashback to something in his teen years. It seems like his flash. When he's with Zach in the hospital and there's a flash of something. And it looks like a teenage boy walking into a room. It does. And maybe this is just me being masters of the universe pilled having just seen it. But it sure looks like a He-Man poster on the wall. Which would suggest time frame wise it would be him and not somebody else. I was trying to, so that not the one on the door, but like inside. Inside the room, yeah. Okay, I was trying to timestamp the one on the door and I couldn't really get it. Yeah, that's what it looked like to me.
37:56But look, it could be another half naked man in a loincloth type getup, you know? Beastmaster, let's hope. Okay. Extramarital affair? Perhaps. This is a, you know, a Cape Fear classic. Or a bait and switch. That's a very ambiguous, that's like sort of what we're meant to think. There's a woman on the phone and she's like, I don't want to be weird, but you want to hear about this. We got to talk about it. We need to meet, et cetera. et cetera. Follow question. If he is having an ex-murial affair, is there any possibility that it is Callie, his daughter's friend in a very American beauty kind of way?
38:29I hope not. Callie who's like your dad's hot. She's interested. Yeah. And look, I think a lot of people would be interested. I hope for Tom's sake. Patrick Wilson. That's not what's happening. You know, the man is dripped and handsome. Okay. Microdosing mushrooms? Yeah. What's going on exactly? I think for anxiety, he's microdosing mushrooms. So we think GHB? What do we think? I don't know. I don't microdose mushrooms. But what else do you microdose with a dropper like that? Like GHB is the only thing I could think of. Like something sedative. Yeah. It's like a take the edge off kind of drug, clearly.
39:01So, and he's doing it in a way slightly surreptitiously. So whatever he's microdosing to take the edge off, A, it could be a secret that he's keeping or B, something that could be laced at any point. we've seen him put that dropper on his tongue twice and max katie could put anything in that bottle and what could happen to patrick wilson just the vulnerabilities we welcome into our lives it's crazy okay so that's my tom boden rundown zach boden the sophia thing yeah no friends it seems like he had the few that maybe stuck with him after the sophia thing he seems to have abandoned for the sake of angel x angel x who among us all right drugs she is what was what What was Dirty Hot?
39:44Dirty Hot. She is Dirty Hot. Yeah. Drugs? Willingly or not. Like smoking weed, we're told, but also this seems deeper than that. In Love Slash Lust with Angel X. Yeah. Has a secret cell phone. The whole burner situation. Listen, I'm rooting for you, Anna Bowden. But the fact like, and first of all, I loved the whole, what's this picture and used his face to unlock the phone. Great. It's a good move. Great move. but also if your son's going through all this stuff I think you need a back door into his phone no matter what that feels like why are we giving this kid a locked phone and also they just like leave like the fact that he can like wander out into the night and his sister has to go bring him back home like why isn't this kid under more watchful eye at any given moment well I think this is another way in which the story has been modernized right like if this is a 90s movie he's under lock and key right like he is not let out of the house or it's at least a bigger ordeal maybe but Natalie is sort of like like vulnerable in the 90s version.
40:43But I think the way that they're treating Zach in general, like one of the things I really do like about these first two episodes is the source of some of the marital tension between Anna and Tom is like their parenting styles, right? Like Tom is like, we need to be present with our son to help him get through everything he's getting through. And Anna's like, but I need to solve all his problems by snooping through his phone and like being a detective, basically. I need to know what I'm dealing with so I can fix whatever is happening with him. And like that difference of opinion is starting to wedge them apart.
41:11it's also clearly like part of what drives that crazy in the first place and i know a lot of teenagers hate their parents this kid hates his parents fuck my parents the scene that he has with max katie in the hospital bathroom is terrifying the way it's shot like yeah i think they're doing a great job of and we don't see all of it yes but like the cinematic claustrophobia of like max katie's reflections all around him the idea that this is a man who's very good at manipulating people witchcraft or not it has moments alone it's not witchcraft i have to say at the end of the day i'm fine if he thinks it's witchcraft but i i doubt very much given this story that it's actual effective i hope it's just like a whistle a dog whistle you know clicker something even hypnosis i feel like might fit the story better than witchcraft but yeah i zach is in a bad way for a bunch of different reasons we get some hints as to like the fact that he he has a he's had a hard time dealing with the fallout of his own actions uh as far as what he did with sophia blames himself hits himself like clearly there's a lot of shame we'll not leave this poor girl alone like wants to and i think this is another thing these first two episodes do really well set up all of the kind of different forms of stalking that are happening right sometimes it's natalie walking down the street and a podcaster is hounding her sometimes it is max katie out in the yard don't do that podcasters we would never sometimes there's a cougar in the backyard sometimes it's zach who i think genuinely means well but wants to go to this girl's house in the middle of the night to apologize it's like absolutely not and she's like no thank you she is not interested i think in addition i love that connective tissue you drew between the stalking i think also there's this idea of like are there mistakes you can fix yes you know and this wouldn't and at least like there's some things you just can't fix right uh last but not This might be in the drugs and or witchcraft thing.
42:58The seeing Adam Cady, seeing the ghost of the AI slop of the teenage version of Max Cady's dead son. I really hope this pays off in a way that we will find satisfying, but I kind of doubt it. I am suspicious of this plot line. Yeah. Can I ask you a question, though, on the catfishing front? Please. I need your help. I am not a woman, nor am I a murderer pretending to be a woman on the Internet. Yes. I need you. Life is long. I can't say I understand the series of emojis that exist in some of these flirtatious messages. And I would like for you to help me decipher them. This is like adolescence all over again.
43:36When there was like all this code in adolescence, you're going to ask me as if I like. We're just trying. A woman of an advanced age is going to be able to decipher these emojis. We're tilting at windmills and sometimes they exist over text. This is the text. This is the text that Zach was sent by Angel X, whoever he or she may be. Not a game, not a trick, just a girl who wants how your voice sounds like and wants it closer. The series of emojis is wilting flower, black heart, flame. I didn't even know there was a wilting flower emoji. What does that mean? What does wilting flower emoji mean? Heartbreak, emotional pain, or death of romance.
44:20Maybe love really is dead. Black heart, wilting flower, very like I'm sad. Sure. You know, won't you talk to me? I'm so sad. I get that. That part makes sense. Look, I mean. Okay. They're just kids in love or a kid and an adult man in love. I did laugh at. Or a kid and adult man trying to seduce him. Yes. To get back at his mother who he might've fucked at one point and sent him to jail. Tale as old as time. Tale as old as time. The text that Zach sent back at one point of you're not just a girl anymore. You're a storm system. Then let me flood you. Yeah, exactly. Let me flood you. that's wave black heart wave we get wave black heart wave that's self-explanatory it was wilted flower that really uh you know well uh think of a baby carrot at gmail.com yeah if you have some other more advanced uh analysis the emoji breakdown in adolescence just really uh okay well on the storm front we've got so much storm metaphor storm metaphoring happening in these episodes I have to think that one of the trees that is being complained about in episode one will fall, right?
45:26I've got a few Chekhovs on the list but that's definitely one of them It's gotta be You know what I mean? Tom Bowden's inability to get chores done around the house seems like they're gonna come I mean, is that, yeah is it just gonna crash into the entire house? Or maybe just into the den that's half outside anyway? I don't know if you wanna tag yourself anywhere in these episodes but that one is me, unfortunately The like, I mean to do this chore, but it goes undone. Did you call the people? Sure. Yeah, I'll get right on that. I'm definitely going to do that tomorrow when I don't have five podcasts.
45:56I feel like I'm more of the like, in terms of the differing styles between Tom and Anna Bowden. Yes. Storm's a brewing. She's like, let's move this party onto the sun porch. And Tom's like, it'll be fine. I'm Anna. I'm like, why wait to find out? Why risk it? When we can move everything you've grilled onto the sun porch. Better safe than soaked. Yeah. Okay. Natalie Bowden. Queer? Question mark. Seems to be. Do her parents know? It seems like her friend doesn't know. Seems like her granddad knows. Yeah. At least he has an inkling. I think her friend does know. You think so? It'd be weird if we kissed because I don't think of you that way.
46:41I think I believe that part is true. Yeah. But does the friend know that Natalie does think of her friend that way? I mean, Natalie's not very subtle. I think it's not that. In the down bad encyclopedia, can you blow smoke into my mouth? Point blank is pretty far up the list in terms of examples. It's a real flood me sort of moment. All right. Max Cady's biological daughter, question mark. Maybe. Megan Rapinoe shoes. I don't have much else for her. I actually really like Lily Coleus is the actress playing Natalie. I really like what she's bringing to this part so far. I think there is a like there is a warmth.
47:18There's a curiosity. There's like big older sister energy. And I think the like combination of like son you don't understand and daughter you take for granted can set us up to do a lot with this family structure. Sure. Anna being like so great. We never have to worry about you. Exactly. You're always perfect. It's like. Somebody's got to fish the skunks out of the pool, unfortunately. And she is the one who does it. I will say in terms of like check off something, one of the inelegant things in these episodes, her taking a full open container to walk down the street. I was like, that's unhinged behavior.
47:51Why is she doing that? And it's simply so that she can throw it at a scummy podcaster. As you should. Yeah. Maybe you should always walk around with an open container just in case a scummy podcaster comes calling. Other mysteries. Green Hood Mask Lady, seen by both Anna and Max. What's going on with her? She could be anyone. I don't think we have any grounds to even guess who she might be yet. Do you feel any inkling as far as what that character might represent or where they might intersect with these people's lives? I mean, she's a real person since both Anna and Max saw her, right? She was in the hospital bumping into Anna.
48:26And then it was like on the street or something where she ran into Max. So it was kind of like lurking around him. Yeah. That hair could be a wig. Yes. And then the mask covers the face, hood covering a lot of things. The green hooded jacket I think is quite tasteful. Yeah. It's a nice look. I like the look. His dead wife. You think his... So who was found in the swamp? I don't know. So we do get acknowledgement that the wife's body was like... Now we're on stolen land. Maybe so. the wife's body was left in like a bog or a swamp and was like chewed up by gators basically perhaps beyond recognition but then how would they even know that it was supposed to be Max Katie's wife in the first place I don't know dental records something like that so they swapped out the teeth who's they I don't know this must go all the way to the top yeah but I don't know what the top of what here's an idea what if Max Katie's wife pregnant and maybe Adam like actually exists somewhere because like maybe she's like I don't want to raise my kid with this dude.
49:30You think she faked her own death? And frames him or something. Yeah. So we potentially have a man who went to prison for killing his wife who he did not kill. Yeah. And a mistress who's claiming credit for that kill even though she also did not kill her. That woman escapes, gave birth to an actual child who may or may not be on TikTok posting AI slot videos of himself. They're now infiltrating the psyche of a whole another family. The sister of which may actually be Max Katie's biological time. We have 10 episodes to film. Oh my God. Don't take anything for granted. I don't. I don't. limited series.
50:07I really don't. This is ultimately going to be the struggle of the show, I think is. Who else could she be? I don't know. There's no other like woman around, you know what I mean? Like there's no one else. The mistress, I thought of. Couldn't she be the like Tom's potential mistress? Maybe, but why is she masking her face like that. I don't know. She has to mask her face because the two people who have bumped into her would recognize her. Yes. That's why she has to be masked. Well, it makes sense that the person that Tom... And the long blonde hair is like a real throw off for like someone with like, you know, dark hair.
50:42That is true. Which is what his wife looks like. I really have no clue. I am terrified now that all of these threads are linking together and potentially this way. This is a dizzying amount of potential mystery. It's so much. And I really think maybe they should have done six episodes, but we'll see what happens. This episode is brought to you by WeatherTech. Buying something for dad usually goes the same way every year. Guessing, second guessing, ending up with something that collects dust on a shelf. Here's a better idea. WeatherTech. It's the kind of gift he'll actually use. WeatherTech offers unmatched vehicle protection from floor liners and seat protectors to the cup phone and cargo liner.
51:17And no, a gift card isn't a cop out. It's just practical like WeatherTech. Skip the guesswork this year. Visit weathertech.com to get your Father's Day gift today. One other thing. And, you know, we talk about plenty of other things, but one other sort of logistical thing I want to talk about. If you go to does the dog die dot com, Cape Fear is is a real does the dog die dot com. Yeah. This family doesn't have a dog. No, it is a cat. And Max Katie is a dog lover. He's got a dog. He's got a dog. He's just out here like having a good time adopting dogs. Oh, yeah. Making bilingual dick jokes. I loved that scene where he's just like screwing this guy over and taking his dog as his own.
51:55I thought that was great. and then I was like oh he's not gonna kill a dog but then I rewashed episode one I was like uh oh there's a cat there's a cat Mr. Peanut Butter I believe is his name Mr. Peanut Butter Joe is cooked there's no way that cat survives this season given that this guy wrote on Hannibal perhaps literally yeah who's to say so I'm on peanut butter watch honestly doesthecatdie.com I'm worried about it alright anything else that we haven't talked about that we need to get into honestly there's still somehow a lot of stuff in this show yeah there is Um, yeah, we don't have certainty on what happened exactly with Byron and his mom.
52:30Oh, but I feel for sure that Max Cady got him, like, drugged or, you know, on, like, witch drugs or something like that. Like, I think it's possible that his mom did kill him and then died. Sure. But, like, in terms of he went out and got drunk and took a lot of drugs. You think Max Cady nudged the situation along? Yeah, he's a nudger. and that's I think one area where all of this gray area that Max Katie is living in like really potentially works because we get this information like Byron is like kind of skittish around crowds and so the idea that he wouldn't want to go to this big gala or that it might spark some like real angst for him or strain with his relationship with his mom plausible but yeah the fact that he is kind of like nudging things along and I think this exists too in just his language and the way this character is written right now where it is it is so much uh oh i i didn't mean that literally about seeing my dead wife and child but also i did mean that other part literally about the fingers and toes yeah it's like he's having it both ways did mean that about his wife and his child apparently yeah everything is a simple everything is literal everything's a storm it really is everything's a wilted flower emoji anything else um you know how many flashbacks do you have tolerance for because listen we get this like black and white opener which is a first prison flashback and inside the prison flashback there's a colored flashback to max katie's dead wife who's maybe not dead yeah and the ultrasound um can i ask you a question about the prison flashback oh please is there any thought in your mind that anna and tom would be so ghoulish as to be like behind a hit on max katie in prison i don't think so seems beyond what they're capable of no if anna's like let's tie these loose ends i don't want anyone to ever know that I had sex with him or that he's the biological father of my child.
54:16You know? That's possible. What a web we weave. But if she had sex with Max Cady, like when she was representing him, and she was not sober at the time, which drugs are otherwise? That's... Are we going to get a flashback to 17 years ago, Max and Anna and their affair? Yes. Okay. We're doing like a CGI. No, I don't... No, no, sorry. I'm walking that back. I don't think we're getting the actual flashback. I think we'll just get expository scenes where they talk about it. Okay. We're going to get Tom childhood flashbacks? I think we'll get more of that. The He-Man poster sort of situation? Yes. Whatever is in that room.
54:53Anna and her dad flashbacks? I don't know if we'll get that one literally. Okay. But clearly he's going to be back around at some point. I feel like we're just getting as many flashbacks as we can to fill the 10 episodes of this show. So do you think we will get more flashbacks or in Cape Fear tradition, one of Anna or Tom walking out onto their porch and looking out into the darkness holding a weapon of some kind. They have to do that. I mean, they've already done it like five times. It is cape fear required. But how many times is the question? Just shoot it into the dark. Just shoot the gun into the, empty the clip into the darkness.
55:28It's the only way to be safe. All right, anything else you want to talk about? Joe, I have a couple quick heading things before we get out of here. Tom has this line at the very beginning of episode one. She split herself into two different people. It's a 14 hour procedure, but if you survive it, you get a lot done. Is that a severance joke? I hope so. On Apple? It feels too coincidental. I hope so. Feels like it has to be. He also says that skunks are dumb. Is that true? Tough for the skunk community. Is that true? I did a lot of research on this. It does not seem to be true. Pigeon hater Rob Mahoney?
56:02Skunk lover? Skunks seem like better members of the community, to be honest. I'd take a skunk over a possum. I'll tell you that much right now. I don't have a problem with that possum. I think don't fire... You know what? don't fire nail guns at the possums they didn't do anything to you don't fire the nail gun in general kelly that's a checkoff's nail gun that you think that's gonna be wielded yeah that nail is coming back i hope i hope against the right person i don't know who that is a stray nail gun in the house yeah it's it's pretty gnarly already uh i did find a lot of skunk materials out there insisting that they are quite intelligent and quite smart that said most of the sources seem like pet skunk propaganda uh so i don't know if that's true or not uh but a quick shout out before we get out of here Paul Schneider of Paul Parks and Rec fame notorious Mark Brandanowicz I want to say written off the show the problem with all of season one appears very briefly as a cop I hope we see him again really yeah that's him in the hospital one of the guys who's interrogating Max Katie I love Paul Schneider I completely missed him I think you're beard blind right now I guess a little facial hair and just like can't even see these guys anymore I miss Schneider entirely well he'll come back I'm sure he will probably die would be my guess If you are a law enforcement official or anyone around this family, I fear your life is in danger.
57:15Watch out. Follow-up question. Last question. Do you think Savannah Coffee Roasters got some money for the product placement inside of this episode? They should have paid some money for the product placement in this episode. I've just had my toe cut off. All I want is a fresh hot cup black Savannah Coffee Roasters. It was way too specific. I mean, here's the question. Do you want that kind of publicity if you're Savannah Coffee Roasters? I don't want Zach as my spokesman. No. Toeless Zach? Also, I think Tom's wearing like a local ice cream shop shirt at one point. So I think they're trying to be like, we're really in Savannah.
57:55But I just thought that was a really weird line. I did look up the reviews for Savannah Coffee Roasters. I got to say the service didn't seem great over there. But it was consistently like, you know what? The coffee's pretty good. But these people did not pay attention to me. What is wrong with coffee shops today? That's why Tom's brewing at home. They're not going. I thought he was, when he said I would like a black hot cup of Savannah. I was like, are they door dashing this? What do they do? You know, one of them was going to pop out and go get it. No, the service is bad. You got to brew at home.
58:20Got to buy the beans. Savannah coffee roasters. All right. Savannah coffee roasters. You want to send us some beans? We'll take a sample. Sure. Why not? You want to hit them with that email one more time? Yeah. That email is think of a baby carrot at gmail.com. Or if you prefer prestige TV at Spotify.com. Yeah. The inbox is always open. Yes. We are wrapping up Widow's Bay. There's a couple more episodes of Widow's Bay left. And we're, you know, sort of figuring it out as we go. We're looking around. We're eyeing the landscape. But we really would like to hear from you whether or not you're all in on Cape Fear and you would like us to cover Cape Fear in the way that we cover shows.
58:57Just straight up, are you watching it? Like, we have no idea what the imprint of this show will be. Presumed Innocent feels like a bellwether. But, you know, these things can be lightning in a bottle or Savannah storms in a whatever. I will say if people ask me, should I watch Cape Fear? Here's what I will say. I'd watch Javier Bardem do almost anything. He's so good in this. He's incredibly good. We haven't. So stupid. We haven't talked about that yet. Like, guess what? He's fantastic. He's really. I also love Amy Adams in like a very Southern murdery limited series. I'm a big fan of that. Patrick Wilson.
59:24I'm always a huge fan of. I think he has like he's got such like Captain America, dripped and handsome, dipped and handsome, good looks that like I think he gets underestimated. And I just think he's incredibly good. And I'm really excited. I love his like, you know, dad making inappropriate jokes when he's like, I could pop it on ice, pop that toe back on for you know what I mean? Like, I just love what he's doing with Tom so far. I love Tom's balance of like, we're told he's like the head of his class in law school, like top of his class. But also he has that kind of like dad low EQ, like I'm going to blurt out all of my son's psychological problems in the middle of this hospital and just tell everyone all about it.
1:00:03Like poor situational awareness. His dad is like, did you see adolescence?
1:00:10Also, look, I would say we are, of the people of The Ringer, maybe co-counselors in the defense of Amy Adams. We have been on the forefront. It's true. I'm not going to pretend that everything she's in, that she's like a can't miss or a never misses sort of actor. But her highs are exceptional. They're so good. Remains to be seen if this is going to be that. I do love the premise of her in this story. I will say both of their southern accents are like real spotty in these first two episodes sometimes they're using them sometimes they're not to be honest I don't even care I'm having a fun time here's what I kind of love Javier Bardem is doing a like I was raised in Spain until I was 13 and then I learned English traumatically in North Carolina right that's his accent he's got like there's something sort of dialed in something countrified about the way that he's speaking English we should say dodgy accents are a proud tradition at Cape Fear because what the fuck is De Niro doing.
1:01:03It's very true. In his Oscar nominated role. I'm gonna call it homage. Okay. Pastiche of something. Yeah, so I would say if people were like, should I watch this show? I would say yeah. Yeah. Watch this show. Are we all gonna regret that around episode seven? Possibly. Stringing up the story is gonna be a challenge. I look forward to seeing how they handle it. I would say this is one though where if you are very skittish about being followed, stalking, like, I think this would be a really hard watch. There are a lot of people were just like creeping up on each other for absolutely no reason in this show.
1:01:35Sure. Other than that, I think it's well enough made and I am intrigued. Okay. What's a normal amount to be worried about stalking versus an abnormal amount to be worried about stalking? I don't know where to draw those lines. Is that for me to say? Thanks everyone who worked on this show. Jacob Cornett is here as always. Holding it down. Cameron Dinwiddie is, you know, doing the edit on this podcast. shout out to our team who are in Sweden as we speak living it up and we'll be back with Widows Bay and perhaps more of the show oh and last but not least Rob Perlman's in this show we don't know who he's playing yet somewhere Patrick Fishler who's always really fun is in this show we don't know who he's playing yet I hope like an even scummier podcaster would be a fun role for Patrick Fishler a whole podcaster ecosystem are we are we doing okay we keep saying goodbye and coming back but are we doing a a retrial of Max Cady because he's provisionally released.
1:02:34Yes. And they haven't, they're gonna, there's some sort of trial that he has to do. Oh, is there? That's sort of what I got from CCH Pounder's character Noah when Anna's like, but we're not even taking his case. And she's like. I thought she's saying the case is done, he's already out. Well, she's like I thought she was saying he's provisionally released. I believe she literally said provisionally released. So I think there is like something that has to come. Is it a court case? Is it a something else? You know, just paperwork has to be filed. I don't know what that case, you know, is, but. Here's one other loose end we didn't talk about too.
1:03:11Is this actually what Presumed Innocent Season 2 is? Wow, full time. Honestly, they would kind of fit of a world. I don't know how like. Rachel Brosnahan defending Javier Bardem. Especially if Season 2 is in Chicago. I don't know how we get to Savannah or vice versa. But one thing I'm still wondering about is like, Like we are told that Max Cady is basically urged by Anna to take this plea deal, right? For what he believes is like a 20 year sentence. To save his life. To save his life, a 20 year sentence. Yeah. Then something happens. And it sounds like the judge, based on his telling, unilaterally decides that this is a life sentence.
1:03:45I don't know if that's an exaggeration or maybe I'm misconstruing what he's saying. Oh, I might have missed a detail there. What we know for a fact is he was given a life sentence. You don't plea for a life sentence in the vast majority of cases, I guess, unless the death penalty is on the line. So what even happened with the plea deal? I don't know. Doesn't seem great legally. No. OK, I think we did it. I think so, too. I think we made a podcast. Thank you, Joe. Thank you, Rob. We'll see you soon. Bye.
1:04:37your life, and your windows. Shop up to 40 % off with minimum purchase and a free professional measure right now at blinds.com. Plus, pay at your own pace starting at 0 % APR with Affirm. Terms apply. Athletic Brewing Company crafts award-winning non-alcoholic beers for those who want to be part of every round. With over 185 flavor awards, they're exceptional NA beers that fit your lifestyle and any social occasion. Summer's full of good times and athletic fits right in. Go to athleticbrewing.com to have brews delivered to your door or find them at a bar, restaurant, or store near you. Near Beer.
1:05:14Athletic Brewing Company. Fit for all times.
From the publisher
Joanna Robinson and Rob Mahoney use a complex string of emoji to recap the two-episode premiere of 'Cape Fear,' an Apple TV crime thriller starring Amy Adams and Javier Bardem.
(0:00) Intro
(4:24) Source Material
(11:40) Should This Be a TV Show?
(25:44) Max Cady
(29:26) Anna Bowden
(33:56) Tom Bowden
(36:18) Zack Bowden
(43:14) Natalie Bowden
(47:50) Loose Ends
Email us! prestigetv@spotify.com
Follow us on IG and TikTok!
Subscribe to the Ringer TV YouTube channel here for full episodes of ‘The Prestige TV Podcast’ and so much more!
Hosts: Joanna Robinson and Rob Mahoney
Producers: Kai Grady, Devon Renaldo, and Cameron Dinwiddie
Additional Production Support: Justin Sayles and Jacob Cornett
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
