‘Pluribus’ Episode 4: Carol’s Truth Serum

21 Nov 2025 · 56 min · 26 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Pluribus episode 4 (“Please Carol”) follows Carol as she tries to regain control of her situation after grief and confusion, while the hive mind enforces rules like “can’t hurt a fly” and uses “truth serum” style interrogation to learn what Carol knows and thinks. The episode contrasts Carol’s performative independence with Manusnos in Paraguay’s extreme, rule-bound solitude, and escalates Carol’s attempts to investigate and potentially counter the hive mind.

Guests

None. This is a Prestige TV podcast episode with hosts Joanna Robinson and Rob Mahoney; no guest interviewees are mentioned.

Guest backgrounds

Not applicable.

Key claims

Carol is emotionally vulnerable despite her cynicism; hearing hive-mind thoughts hurts her more than suspecting them. The hive mind’s “help” infantilizes and frames Carol as someone who must be fixed. Manusnos embodies global skepticism of authority, not just “American rugged individualism.”

Notable examples

Manusnos stocking sprouts wordlessly; his starvation on dog food and sugar packets; his fly-based rule-following. Carol’s whiteboard rules (“can’t kill, not a fly,” “can’t play faves like all jerks the same,” Shakespeare reference). Her pharmacy search for thiopental sodium (an anesthesia induction agent). Carol’s “truth serum” conversation with Helen/Larry about her writing (including the novel Bitter Chrysalis).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Episode Discussion Begins

0:45 to 3:10

Hosts discuss the fourth episode of 'Pluribus' and its plot dynamics.

“a pigeon is oil, when in fact it is natural iridescence.”

Listener Feedback and Golfers

3:15 to 4:26

Hosts share listener feedback and discuss golfer emails related to the show.

“This summer, we're celebrating 250 years of American cookouts with all the classics, Heinz, Kraft, and Oscar Mayer.”

Listener Emails and Food Preferences

6:44 to 11:00

Discussion of listener emails about food preferences and comparisons to the show.

“And then last but not least, before we get to sort of like the other show comps, we got one more submission for the un-hive mind name, the Carols and the Monusinos of this world.”

Character Analysis and Themes

11:00 to 14:00

In-depth analysis of characters and thematic elements from 'Pluribus'.

“But now that we are in full on like helpful Janet get me heroin mode of this show, like we're really in it.”

Character Analysis: Carol's Independence

14:00 to 14:58

Explore how Carol's choices reflect her fiercely independent nature.

Rugged Individualism vs. Collectivism

14:58 to 17:03

Discussion on rugged American individualism and its cultural implications.

“So like, let me know if I'm missing something.”

Survival and Stoicism in Extreme Circumstances

17:03 to 18:55

Delve into the stoicism of characters in dire situations, especially Carol.

“And yet he's still flipping over the cloche plate.”

Carol's Choice of Vehicle: Symbolism and Practicality

18:55 to 21:10

Analyze Carol's decision-making process and the symbolism of her chosen vehicle.

“Like, there's this line that Carol has later when she's doing her investigation where she says something like, can one person do it?”

Carol's House: The Intrusion of the Hive Mind

21:10 to 22:29

Examining the themes of intrusion and the hive mind through Carol's home.

“I kind of like the idea of taking the cop car though, because it's just sort of like, I don't know.”

Infantilization and Control in Relationships

22:29 to 23:49

Discussion on the infantilization of Carol and the control exerted by others.

“Here's what really stood out to me in this outside the house moment.”
Show all 26 chapters

Carol's Creative Process and Literary Aspirations

25:20 to 28:00

Explore Carol's creative endeavors and her relationship with her readers.

“Shop top brand appliances now at the Home Depot.”

Carol's Literary Aspirations and Reader Disdain

28:00 to 29:36

Discussion on Carol's literary references and her complex relationship with her readers.

“the book she's writing, but she's like, I'm going to put a Shakespeare reference in it.”

Carol's Internal Struggles

29:36 to 30:56

Exploring Carol's conflicted feelings about her career and her readers' expectations.

“She kind of thinks about erasing her wins of Wai Karo prep for a second and then opts for the new whiteboard instead.”

Truth and Vulnerability in Carol's Life

30:56 to 33:56

Examining the emotional impact of honesty on Carol and her relationships.

“I suspect that Helen doesn't like my book or doesn't respect my writing.”

Art's Emotional Resonance

33:56 to 36:50

Discussion on the subjective nature of art and its importance to individuals.

“Like this is probably what Carol in her heart of hearts at least thinks to some degree.”

The Role of Enjoyment in Art

36:50 to 39:16

Debate on the value of artistic enjoyment versus critical evaluation.

“And it's not like I'm dumbing myself down or anyone's dumbing themselves down or whatever.”

Carol's Relationship with Identity

39:16 to 41:32

Exploration of Carol’s struggles with her identity and societal expectations.

“We're at the hospital three times this week.”

Romantic Authors and Public Perception

41:32 to 42:05

Discussion on the challenges romantic authors face regarding their personal lives and their work.

“I don't know if you have any more information on this front than I do.”

The Intersection of Romance and Politics

42:05 to 43:31

Explore how personal lives influence fictional narratives and audience perceptions.

“There is a level of remove that I think a lot of romance and romanticity authors want to have for various reasons.”

Carol's Pharmacy Adventure

43:31 to 45:41

Discussion of Carol's humorous sequence in the pharmacy and the implications of truth serum.

“I mean, the whole heroin sequence is just like extremely funny.”

Heroin and Past Traumas

45:41 to 47:28

A deep dive into Carol's past and the implications of her drug use on her character.

“And I'm like, it's just rolling up here.”

The Dark Web and Hive Mind Discussion

47:28 to 49:40

Exploring the concept of a hive mind in relation to individual darkness and desires.

“So like, what is her history with drugs?”

Zosia and Carol's Emotional Encounter

49:40 to 52:36

Analyzing the emotional dynamics between Zosia and Carol in the hospital scene.

“I'm sure that person will love to have those in addition to all the other pluribus emails they've been getting.”

Celebrity Cameos and Character Actors

52:36 to 55:31

Discussing the role of character actors and celebrity cameos in the series.

“Like from a plot perspective, just from the condensing of an individual episode.”

Discussion on Carol's Fashion Choices

56:01 to 57:20

The hosts discuss Carol's potential fashion evolution and her appeal to leisure wear.

“unless they're trying to like appeal directly to Carol, I guess.”

Discussion on Carol's Fashion Choices

57:51 to 58:15

The hosts discuss Carol's potential fashion evolution and her appeal to leisure wear.

“Compatibility and availability varies 18+.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:13Joanna Robinson:Hello, welcome back to the Prestige TV podcast feed. I'm Joanna Robinson. I'm Rob Mahoney. And I believe we're here today to issue an apology to the pigeon community, Rob Mahoney. Are we though? Are we? If you did not hear earlier this week in the podcast episode we did about the Netflix series, The Beast and Me. Rob, drop some inaccurate pigeon facts on the pod. So Mr. Burger Kebab himself, would you like to answer for your crimes? You know, sometimes we swing and miss. Sometimes we think that what seems to be a shiny patch on a pigeon is oil, when in fact it is natural iridescence. So I salute the pigeons and all the shiny work that they're doing.

0:52I happen to be wrong on this one, but I maintain that a pigeon is not a spectacular bird that is worth doodling in your little birding journal.

0:59Joanna Robinson:Okay, great, great. He's just doubling down on his pigeon slander. Okay. This is what we do in 2025, Joe. We're here to talk about Pluribus episode four titled Please Carol, written by Alison Tatlock and directed by Zetna Fuentes. And how did you like this episode, Ron Mahoney? I liked it. I mean, I think we're kind of moving the chains at this point, right? The plot is starting to click into place i would say this is the episode where carol sort of starts to take control or attempt to of her circumstances which is exciting uh but it's not like the most action packed episode i've ever seen one i mean i think it's interesting because one of the um responses we started getting from listeners was why isn't carol asking more questions or why isn't she trying you know harder to figure out an answer or stuff like that so i think you know this is you know this week to be fair she spent almost all of episode two asking lots of questions i agree i agree but i think it's also grieving her wife so rob you and i agree and i would say i would say the grief continues inside of this episode certainly a lot of other things going on i do want to zoom through um some listener stuff i will say last week we decided to move sort of like what does this show remind me of corner to this week's episode and i will say next week i'm going to get to a lot of the sports related emails we got because i do want to like serve the ringer audience yeah but i think we're going to move that to next week just because we have like plenty to get through this week but on that note joe i just want to say the golfers you you've been like you're you've been heard absolutely we get it we understand your perspective although do we uh but also keep them coming prestigetv at spotify.com and licking the donut at gmail.com i thought some of the golfer emails were actually really good this summer fandu is the best place to bet on goals.

2:46Including equalizers? Uh-huh. Balls? Yep. Headers? Every goal is worth more on FanDuel. So let there be goals. New customers get 350 in bonus bets guaranteed when you bet$5 for seven days. 21 plus in present and select states. First online real money wager only. Minimum$5 wager required for seven consecutive days. $5 first deposit required. Bonus issued as non-withdrawable bonus bets, which expires seven days after receipt. Restrictions apply. See full terms at fanduel.com slash sportsbook. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER or 1-800-MY-RESET.

3:13Joanna Robinson:This episode is brought to you by America's cookout classics, Heinz, Kraft, and Oscar Mayer. This summer, we're celebrating 250 years of American cookouts with all the classics, Heinz, Kraft, and Oscar Mayer. Rob, what's your ideal cookout scenario? First of all, I want you on the ox. I trust you with that sacred responsibility to pick our music. I'm going to have to man the grill, and I'm going to need like a copious amount of condiments. I need every possible fixin imaginable. Well, make sure to top your burger with only the best, Heinz, ketchup, and Kraft singles. And you know, it's not a cookout without Heinz ketchup and mustard.

3:43Different vibes, same ingredients. We all know it's not a cookout without Heinz, Kraft, and Oscar Mayer. Shop at your local retailer.

3:50Joanna Robinson:First of all, our listener, Ollie, I just like the way he phrased this. He said what he would do if he had access to the hive mind. He said, I would get them to remake the Star Wars trilogy series until I liked it. And that was the whole email. And I just had this vision of Ollie with a zombified Oscar Isaac at his disposal. And he's just like, again, again. give me the poe dameron story i want i don't know just the full david fincher treatment take number 183 exactly um our listener morgan was saying that uh she you know we got a lot of answers to like sort of what would be under your very special cloche that the hive mind would leave at your front doorstep a lot of like highbrow lovely answers and then morgan's like pop tarts and hot pockets or honey butter chicken biscuit so i guess my my question to you rob mahoney foodie extraordinaire my favorite foodie what trash food would entice you under a cloche on your doorstep first of all i want to say this the implication on your part that a honey butter chicken biscuit is trash food is insulting to my culture and i won't accept it okay you know you're just gonna have to own that one but along those lines look there's no question where my allegiances lie and it would be a water burger it would definitely be what a burger of some variety I think I would not go honey butter chicken biscuit, but honey barbecue chicken strip sandwich.

5:13It's dear relative, the cousin of the family. Just a delightful, delightful way to welcome your hive mind apocalypse for sure.

5:20Joanna Robinson:I'm really upset with myself because I was like, wow, I wonder what Rob is going to say. And then he started talking. I was like, of course, it's Whataburger. Of course it is. But where are you going, Joe? What's under your quote unquote trash food cloche? Trash cloche.

5:34I, okay.

5:35Joanna Robinson:The true honest heart of me. That's what we're here for. Says it's a spicy crispy chicken sandwich from Jack in the Box. That's the go-to. I mean, at least you're a step above Jack in the Box tacos. You know, you're not going full bottom of the dumpster, just mid-level dumpster. For some reason, I do not enjoy a beef product from a fast food joint, and I always go chicken sandow. That's always my go-to. Safer for sure. Yeah. Okay. Rob, would you also like to answer for your crimes to the Afghan community? because we got many emails from listeners about the use of the Afghan. Rob was questioning why would you have a blanket that has so many holes in it and fired up the Afghan community, I should say.

6:18Joanna Robinson:And by Afghan community, I mean blanket lovers. And I should say we got many, many answers. A lot of them had to be like weighted, the feeling of the weight on you while still having airflow. We've got like a scientific answer from our listener Bernard about the way in which hot air, the sort of the weave of the Afghan traps the hot air in some way. Really peculiar science. What a mystery to me, generally. And then last but not least, before we get to sort of like the other show comps, we got one more submission for the un-hive mind name, the Carols and the Monusinos of this world. Our listener Alex wrote in last week, but I think I missed the email, but our listener Laura wrote in this week with the subject line, stay unlicked, cabrones, of her email.

7:07Joanna Robinson:So I'd be Laura, I don't know. And she suggested the unlicked as for Carol, for Manusnos, et cetera, et cetera. So I really like that, the unlicked. You know what I mean? It is good. I just think that there's lots of other unlicked people out there. If many of them were infected via chemtrail, can we all lump them into a licking bucket? They were metaphorically licked by - They certainly were. This alien plot, you know what I mean? So, okay. On this sort of other show comps, I should say we got a lot of people shouting out the Borg from Star Trek. We got a lot of people shouting out the Good Place.

7:43Joanna Robinson:I know you wanted to talk about a specific X-Files episode, Rob. Do you want to mention that? Oh, yeah. The season seven episode in which Mulder gets a genie lamp, I would butcher the title of the episode if I tried to pronounce it, so I simply will not. But it falls into this almost like monkey's paw tradition of you ask for a thing, but you have to overly specify the parameters or else you might accidentally wipe out all of mankind kind of wish fulfillment. And I would say this show is more in the aftermath of that. It's like, okay, mankind has already been sort of wiped out. And now you have the empty expanse of America and the world as your playground.

8:17But like, what are you going to do with all that?

8:19Joanna Robinson:But I think also like asking for a hand grenade and maybe having to deeply specify like, Like, A, I was being sarcastic, but B, also don't give me a live hand grenade. I don't know. But also a note about that X-Files episode, it immediately sprang to mind for me after you and I talked about episodes one and two of Pluribus. And I looked it up and of course, written and directed by Vince Gilligan. So, you know, the man has interests. On this week's episode, this is just like a perfect episode for Freeze Frame Mahoney. We get some whiteboard writing. and one of the rules that uh carol writes down about the the hive mind is can't hurt a fly and one of our listeners jessica asterisk allegedly allegedly one of our one of our listeners jessica uh a couple weeks ago mentioned westworld which is the sort of like wouldn't though i wouldn't hurt a fly evan rachel wood moment of the westworld pilot where she then slaps a fly on the side of her neck is pretty phenomenal.

9:19Joanna Robinson:Romancing the Stone was brought up. I don't know if you're a Romancing the Stone fan, Rob Mahoney. What's the comp on Romancing the Stone? Kathleen Turner plays Joan Wilder, who is a romance novelist. Oh, sure. And so it's just sort of like the plot of your book becomes the life you're living to a certain degree. There is a sexy pirate lady who looks just like the romance figure that you've been writing all these years. So I liked that comp as well. It's been a minute for me. I need to revisit it for sure. I have to say the Sandra Bullock, like, ripoff, attempted riff on that idea. The Lost City.

9:55Not as successful. Not as great, no. A little lame, unfortunately.

9:58Joanna Robinson:Romancing the Stone, absolute classic, honestly. Craig suggested The Matrix. And I think The Matrix is interesting. Well, a couple people mentioned The Matrix. But I think The Matrix is most interesting because I was thinking about Joe Pantoliano's character from the first Matrix, Cypher, and how much he would just be begging to join the collective. He's like, please. Only so long as they have the stakes. They gotta have the stakes, yeah. That guy wants his red meat. As soon as it's gone, what is there for him? Exactly. And last but not least, I'll just mention, we got a couple, several Doctor Who comps.

10:28Joanna Robinson:Doctor Who is a great comp for what's going on here, of course. And then Brave New World was something that came up for a lot of people. So those are just merely some of the comps that were sent our way. Surely there are plenty more. Keep them coming. Licking the donut at gmail.com. We still got hundreds of emails this week. They didn't like trickle off. So thank you for your emails. They're wonderful. I would say the other one, Joe, that's been coming up a lot in the emails and also just anecdotally watching the show, like the good place is all over here. Oh, yeah. I mentioned at the top just like quickly.

10:56Yeah. Yeah. I know we've talked about it before and like especially the philosophical implications of episode two. But now that we are in full on like helpful Janet get me heroin mode of this show, like we're really in it.

11:07Joanna Robinson:Absolutely. Absolutely. Let's start in Paraguay. and um i should say we got an email from a listener john who's i'm just gonna call our men in paraguay who just like sort of reported earlier on the previous monos call when we were only on the other side of it and he was like that guy sounds colombian to me fun fact uh because the actor is colombian uh they have decided to make that character colombian in the official podcast they're like he's colombian but he lives in paraguay they like put a like very specific Colombian game in the set of like where he lives and stuff like that. So if you're like, and the reason they did that is because he's like, I can't do the Paraguay.

11:48Joanna Robinson:It's very specific and I can't do it. And so they're like, okay, we'll make you Colombian. Let's just easy, easy peasy do that. But I thought that was really interesting. John, if you want to continue to give us dispatches from Paraguay, we would love to hear them. I actually heard a very similar story, Joe, recently. I was watching a Matthew Rhys interview to prepare for our Beast and Me pod, where he was talking about an episode of Columbo that he did early in his career, where he was asked to flip accents. And it was simply like, but what if we just made you a man with a Welsh accent instead?

12:18Like, what if we just make this as simple for you as possible? Yeah, exactly.

12:22Joanna Robinson:Okay, so we get this extended sequence at the beginning with Manusnos in Paraguay. We didn't get a clock. We're just here with him. He's checking radio frequencies. How did all of this work for you? Rahm Mahoney is a character intro. I mean, not to be the guy who just watched Lost recently, but I can't watch these sorts of introductions anymore and not think of that very like process oriented guy in quarantine sort of like methodical introduction. Yeah. I really liked it. I mean, we learn a lot about this character with very little dialogue. I mean, in that vein, I was struck by the silence of this sequence kind of juxtaposed with the silence of the hive mind.

13:01We see dozens of people wordlessly stocking sprout shelves, and it is like a system, a system in action and fully actualized to its complete capability of what human beings are even capable of imagining in terms of their ability to work together in this context, logistically. And then here's a guy who in his silence is just like painfully alone and quite principled in what he is willing to do to engage with these quote unquote humans, quote unquote aliens, whatever they are or not. But it was just like it was so alarming, especially coming from Carol's world where she is talking to herself, talking to Zosia, asking questions like she's she's even more integrated in this circumstance than he is.

13:45Exactly. This man is like well and truly alone.

13:48Joanna Robinson:I think it's so interesting because Carol's like, I am so doing it on my own. I am so independent. But as we mentioned, the sprout stocking sequence last week was so laughable. And then you compare her, her illusion of independence to Manusinos here, who is like, the cleverness of there's a single fly. and that fly lets him know there's organic material left in a tin that he put and he is so desperate that he will follow the fly to the lid of the can and then lick it and we'll get to the dog food in a second but like that lets us know so much about how he's deciding to live his life here and how fiercely independent he has decided to be i don't know why he is weighing tape and the locks that he has but that seems to be one of the right it's like because it seems to be like 20 grams like he's weighing it i don't know anyway he's taking stock he's got tape to put cardboard on all the windows he's got locks because he's locking all the gates but also breaking locks on the on the storage units etc etc but leaving a polite note you know very polite no he is a rule follower at his core i just thought it was interesting because we got several emails about this one specifically from our listener jennifer about carol carol versus the other unlicked that she met in in episode two and this idea we talked about a little bit but this idea of like rugged American individualism is this yeah is this show a critique of that is you know are the other unlicked people from uh communities cultures where they they value community and and more than America does or something like that but then we meet I again uh any listeners in Paraguay who want to let us know uh tell me but like uh I have not ever heard the phrase rugged individualists of Paraguay or Colombia for that matter.

15:44Joanna Robinson:So like, let me know if I'm missing something. But like, I think having him be like a more extreme example of Carol just sort of undermines that idea that like, we're talking about something very specifically American. There are things about America that Carol that are very specifically American. But I think this idea of like, I don't want to join your zombie horde that is infected by an alien virus. A lot of people are like, what's wrong with Carol? I'm like, what's wrong with you that you think something's wrong with Carol? But anyway, that's fine. But so what do you think about adding Minusnos as an even more extreme example into the mix?

16:16Well, I love that it adds a complexity to that sort of balance that you're talking about, where it's almost not like rugged American individualism versus the collectivism of other nations. But there are people all around the world who are skeptical of authority, who are skeptical of specifically this very like, I am telling you how to live your life and that I know what is best for you kind of authority. That that tact is taken by, you know, dictators the world over by drug cartels, by people offering, quote unquote, protections like it's totally understandable to me that someone anywhere in the world could want to batten down the hatches and lock themselves into a storage facility office and say, you know what, like I'm not buying what you're selling.

16:57And ultimately, like that he has like he is he's almost starving, like right. He is down to the dog food and the sugar packets portion of his diet. And yet he's still flipping over the cloche plate. He still wants no part of any of that because to him, clearly this sort of independence is still more valuable.

17:13Joanna Robinson:Something I loved about that sequence that they talked about on the official pod was that watching him eat that dog food, it's all down to his performance. I mean, the dog food looks disgusting and we and anyone who's ever fed a pet wet food like knows that it smells a very particular way that I am not fond of personally. I think I would go kibble in this circumstance. If I had the pet food shelves at my disposal, my last food, I think I'm going kibble. Vince Gilligan said something about how the fact that they had the dog food and he's like, no, we need to make it more disgusting. It needs to glisten more.

17:48Joanna Robinson:And they had to like add like congealed broth to it or whatever. But it's down to this guy's performance to make us really feel this. So Carlos Manuel Vesca, who goes by Vesca, like his revulsion really sells it. But what I loved that they talked about in the official pod was like, there's also this stoicism to him of like, I'm just going to do it. And that's not a show for anyone because there's literally no one there. So it's just for himself that he's like, I'm just going to do it. This is what I'm going to do. And I thought that was a really revealing, interesting character moment. And it's what makes him such a good counterpart potentially for Carol too, right?

18:26Like these are two people who are staunchly resisting whatever this kind of invasion or takeover is. But in his case, like being starving in principle, these are two great tastes that taste great together, right? These things do kind of come in tandem. And so the idea that he is having the stiff upper lip, even for himself, I agree with you. Great character moment, really nice introduction, but they're really slow rolling him into the story. I mean, we see the other side of his phone conversation with Carol Cabron and all. But ultimately, like, when is he going to get into our main action? I'm curious to see.

18:56Joanna Robinson:I know. Like, there's this line that Carol has later when she's doing her investigation where she says something like, can one person do it? Can one person reverse the hive mind epidemic? And obviously... Well, no, there's two keys and you have to turn them simultaneously. So you need a minisnos, I'm just saying, you know. So, well, two things. I don't know what he's doing on the radio frequency front necessarily. It seems like he's just looking for human. Right. Like human broadcasts of some kind. But then like did not want to talk to Carol. No. On the phone. Very confusing from that perspective.

19:35Joanna Robinson:And then wrote Carol is Turkish question mark in his book. And I don't know if like her bad shitty American Spanish sounded somewhat Turkish to him or whatever anyway i thought that was really funny i think i thought there's i thought it was a mishearing of her last name basically oh of course of course you're right so he he thought you know he he misunderstood what she was trying to articulate because i mean yeah her spanish is is wanting to say the least that's right that's right okay um meanwhile back in albuquerque carol still blood spattered walking around outside the hospital um gets into a car yep it's crashed it reeks it's playing genie in a bottle and she's like a glitched out genie yeah tough um so the way they talked about the official pod is that carol was like no even i a desperate person i'm not desperate enough for this car which smells bad so she takes the cop car um not my pick you know if i had what are you picking i mean anything else frankly like i think in this moment you're either going for practicality you know the the truck or the suv or whatever is going to help you haul stuff that you need to haul or whatever the car of your dreams is I don't have one of those personally, but I'm not going for the cop car with 24-7 Zosia, you know, intercom access.

20:52Joanna Robinson:You don't have a, you don't have a dream car. You don't have a car that you like. I'm just not a car guy. You are not a car guy. That's true. Distinctly not a car guy. Interesting. You have like a very normal car. Okay. Interesting. See, that sounded bad. That sounded meh like bad, you know? No, just a normal. Sorry. Okay. Like meh or what was no no no i just mean you have like a normal person car not like a you're not like i don't know that's what i think of what i i think you have like a very normal person car which i is i think is a compliment you're not like trying to impress anyone with your car does that make sense you on the other hand alfa romeo i've seen you roll up i've seen you turn heads this is just who you are joe cherry red with a sort of like glossy finish yeah absolutely no um i also don't think I have like a dream car.

21:38Joanna Robinson:Look at the donutgmail.com. If you're like, what car would I steal? Given the chance. I kind of like the idea of taking the cop car though, because it's just sort of like, I don't know. It's illicit. It's illicit again. Even more illicit than just taking any old car is to taking a cop car and driving it around. You know what I mean? It also kind of fits the like Carol as Karen taking it upon herself to serve and protect the entire planet. Sure. You know, subtext of all this for sure. Okay. So she rolls it back home. There's a cleaning room here. I have some fun facts for you not only is a recent Emmy winner Jeff Hiller here and we'll talk about him in a second great love to see him love him and somebody somewhere um that's the real mayor of Albuquerque is it really yeah Tim Keller the real mayor of Albuquerque sweeping up in front of uh Carol's house so they got they got the Albuquerque mayor and I thought Vince Gilligan calls the real mayor of Albuquerque you do answer yeah he's like thanks for injecting so much money into our meeting.

22:29Joanna Robinson:This man is a job creator. Yeah. Absolutely. Here's what really stood out to me in this outside the house moment. Who gave you permission to be in my house? You did when you were writing the ambulance, you sort of nodded absently. So it's a give them a damn inch, they will take a mile sort of reveal about the hive mind. What do you think about that? I mean, it was a hilarious exchange and kind of recollection of events, but you're absolutely right it is it is a give an inch take a mile situation it's also still a talk to carol like she's a child situation whether it's the people outside whether it's zosha talking about um like even later in this episode she's like do you did you like your police car like do you like this new toy that you have yeah there is an like an infantilization of this person who is one of the few unlicked left on the planet and that is kind of what a parent does is like the tacit understanding of like, oh, I can do this because I am looking out for what's best for you.

23:24That's kind of the subtext. All that to me is not just like, oh, you nodded silently when you were panicked. It's like they believe so firmly and squarely in their mission.

Read the full transcript

23:34Joanna Robinson:That they know what's right for her. That they know what's right. Even if that is a biological imperative telling them to believe it, that there's really no wiggle room on it. I'd like to note for the record that you just used unlicked casually and perfectly in a sentence. So thank you. Welcome, Rob. Okay. Are you looking for support in your weight management journey? ZepBound Terzepatide may be able to help. ZepBound is a prescription medicine used with a reduced calorie diet and increased physical activity to help adults with obesity or some adults with overweight who also have weight-related medical problems to lose excess body weight and keep the weight off.

24:11Joanna Robinson:ZepBound is approved as a 2.5, 5, 7.5, 10, 12.5, or 15 milligram injection. ZepBound contains terzepatide and should not be used with other terzepatide-containing products or any GLP-1 receptor agonist medicines. It is not known if ZepBound is safe and effective for use in children. Don't share needles or pens or reuse needles. Don't take if allergic to it, or if you or someone in your family had medullary thyroid cancer, or if you've had multiple endocrine neoplasia syndrome type 2. Tell your doctor if you get a lump or swelling in your neck. Stop ZepBound and call your doctor if you have severe stomach pain or a serious allergic reaction.

24:48Joanna Robinson:Severe side effects may include inflamed pancreas or gallbladder problems. Tell your doctor if you experience vision changes before scheduled procedures with anesthesia, if you're nursing, pregnant, plan to be, or taking birth control pills. Taking ZepBound with a sulfonylurea or insulin may cause low blood sugar. Side effects include nausea, diarrhea, and vomiting, which can cause dehydration and worsen kidney problems. Talk to your doctor. Call 1-800-545-5979 or visit zepbounce.lily.com.

25:42Joanna Robinson:This is sick!

26:12Joanna Robinson:in about 90 minutes. Shop top brand appliances now at the Home Depot. Offer valid June 17th to July at the US only C-Store online for details. All right. Freeze frame Mahoney. Waccaro 5 notes on the whiteboard. What would you like to highlight here before we get to the sort of other notes that she puts on the whiteboard? There's so many things. There's also so many things I wish were just a little more legible. I agree. Like there's a bit about the commercialization of the IRL spice trade that I'm like, I really wish I could make out exactly what she's saying here. first of all, I want to say this whole whiteboard setup, very jealous.

26:47I would love to have this in my home office.

26:49Joanna Robinson:I would die to have this. It's beautiful. Like functional, not the sliding whiteboards. You could do that anywhere, but the glorious wood inlay with the handle, really nice. That white car money spends, you know, it really goes a long way. Makes a lot of people very happy. And you can see why based on the contents of this whiteboard, I am most tickled by the fact that Carol so desperately wants to kill Rabanne and is looking for any permission to do it, including from her whiteboard, effectively. Rabanne dies again, this time for real, but then ask Val, right? Like, am I allowed to do this? Can I kill him?

27:26Am I allowed to do it? My favorite plot note or kind of like lore note that she has flagged is the Mandovia spice fruit. And she's wondering, is it a poison? Is it elixir? Double underlined. It's got to be a love potion. What else simply could it be, Joe?

27:40Joanna Robinson:Definitely a love potion. Love this. I will add, it just says Battle of Wits at one point. Near the sort of like cliffs of chartreuse and underneath that Battle of Wits. And then my favorite is just sort of like scrawled on the side. It just says Shakespeare reference. Yeah. And it's just like, I love that about Carol because she thinks she's so much smarter than the book she's writing, but she's like, I'm going to put a Shakespeare reference in it. nobody's gonna get it because these dummies who read my book don't know Shakespeare, etc., which we will obviously get to in a second. But look, she's a literary woman.

28:13She did reread Twelfth Night in order to prepare to write this book. So props to her. I also think we may have missed the boat. Licking the donut is maybe our greatest email of all time, but Killer Sand Flea Men would not have been a bad alternative.

28:26Joanna Robinson:It's pretty good. Our listener, Ren, wrote in about this idea of like why Carol specifically might be a person who is so resistant to the pleasant, can we give you everything you want nature of the hive mind. And it's because she has such disdain, partially maybe connected to the way when she has so much disdain for her readers. She is someone who has been crafting the perfect meal under a cloche for her. This is exactly what you want. You want exactly a lady who looks just like this. I know what smut you want. I know what, you know, flea men you want. I know what elixirs you want, et cetera, et cetera.

29:06They want to devour that space pirate. That's for sure.

29:08Joanna Robinson:Absolutely. And so this idea of like, am I just, to your infantilizing point that you keep rightly bringing up, are they treating me like one of my readers who I like think so poorly? Yes. And I thought that was a really interesting connection for my listener. I love that take. I also love the beat as Carol is kind of deciding before she goes to write her list of what she actually knows about the hive mind here. She kind of thinks about erasing her wins of Wai Karo prep for a second and then opts for the new whiteboard instead. And so from the perspective where you're just talking about, Joe, she hates these books and she resents the people who love them.

29:48She has been miserable for who knows how long. And yet, even when the world is kind of over. She's still clinging to a life that made her so miserable, or at least clinging to the idea that it could go back to a version of normal, I guess.

30:02Joanna Robinson:But I mean, one does not simply think of the cliffs of chartreuse every day, Rob. You have to keep those golden ideas, you know, steady. But yeah, Ren wrote, ultimately, she would just be a slop consumer to be placated with slop with the hive mind fully aware of exactly what flavor of slop is most likely to please. And I was just like, yep, okay, here we go. All right. So we slide over to the new whiteboard. These are the beats. What I know about them. Eager to please would give me an atom bomb. Can't kill, not a fly. Can't play faves like all jerks the same. So I think she's considering herself a jerk in that moment, obviously.

30:35Joanna Robinson:Trying to change me, which I think is like so key and something that I think some people are like, why wouldn't you want to join? I'm just like, why would you let someone reprogram you? And we'll get to, of course, the conversion conversation later. And then really honest, which then turns into the sort of like can't lie moment but a lot of assumptions here kind of taking these people at their word and just kind of inferring i mean i don't know i just think maybe i think they are resolute in their mission i think there might be wiggle room around some of these things like yeah they can't kill not a fly but they'll let almost a billion people incidentally die like that feels like important context that's true that's great they they are uh they have all the lawyers in the hive mind so they know all the loopholes of of the rules etc etc um then we get this interaction emmy winner jeff hillers here uh in a in a very tight bike costume um larry to his friends and uh and they have this great back and forth i loved this sequence and what carol is doing here this is this is how racy horn described on the official pod is she's like she's asking questions that she knows they know will displease her, but she suspects are true.

31:50Joanna Robinson:I suspect that Helen doesn't like my book or doesn't respect my writing. I know they don't want to tell me that because they know it will upset me, but I think it's true. So where does the rubber meet the road in terms of like, don't want to upset Carol, have to tell the truth. And that is the sort of trap she sets for Larry here to try to figure out this particular quirk of the rules. And that's the mochis in the whole episode. It's kind of like Carol the scientist. It's a very different disposition from what we've seen of her, which is mostly like downing vodka and sleeping on her couch. But here she is like trying to understand more about what is in play, what can she do, what can she learn.

32:29And everything you said makes total sense, and I think is represented in that performance. Like she's going into this deliberately with an objective. Joe, do you feel like when she hears Helen's thoughts about the Waikaro books and especially her novel, like to your point of what they said on the official pod, like she knows on some level what she's going to hear, but there's also the confirmation of actually hearing it. Do you think that actually hurts Carol in that moment? Or do you think her expectations kind of steal her from that?

32:56Joanna Robinson:I think it hurts her. And I think it was interesting. Miriam Shore, who plays Helen, did sort of like a bonus episode of the official podcast this week. and most of it was just sort of like what a pleasure to be here but the most i think i thought insightful thing she said was that helen was someone who um who protected carol from being hurt that carol was someone who would like walked around so easily hurt and so her bitterness and her bad attitude are really this sort of like protective shell and then it is helen's job to sort of try to shield her to sort of jolly her out of bad moods or all these other things and so Helen saw herself as like she's the softer-hearted person but she is Carol's first line of defense and so she is like defenseless without Helen there but I think Carol is for all of her bitterness for all of her cynicism a very vulnerable person again we get the conversion conversation we get this sort of like truth serum self-tape moment you know where she says like i'm not so bad right like that that aspect of it so you know i think i think she's tremendously hurt by what she hears even like and you you brought this up when we when last week when we were talking about like what if you could hear what everyone truly thinks of you and you and i were talking about what a nightmare it was yes uh so this is something that you sort of called last week and so yeah hearing it it's different to suspect it than to hear it totally you know So even when like, especially I would say Helen's thoughts on the Winds of Waikaro series are not damning.

34:29Like this is probably what Carol in her heart of hearts at least thinks to some degree. At least it's represented that way in what she thinks of her readers. But the novel is a different case. And like Bitter Chrysalis remains like an absolutely elite bad novel name. It is way too long for literally anyone to be writing a novel that much. um but but to your point about helen as carol's protector i love that line about helen and val had kind of talked about the novel and decided like it wouldn't hurt her career and it just would make carol happy to to publish it and that's that infantilizing thing that you're talking it is for sure and it's like that that sentence and that sentiment alone is like it's such it's such a it is a caring thought right like there's a germ of something there that is genuine and affectionate and like trying to be protective, but it's protecting a person from something that they don't want to be protected from, which is their own creativity and expression and self.

35:21Like, how can you do that to someone even when you love them? And yet we do it to people we love all the time.

35:27Joanna Robinson:Did you think, as I saw that some people did, that it was like incredibly emotionally manipulative for Larry to bring up Moira, she of the crazy hats, who was you know like brought back to life by the Waccaro books I actually found that really beautiful I don't know and like I don't know that I would consider that manipulative it was like him finding a truth which is that like to someone and we are all one your book is the most important thing that has ever happened and you're not Shakespeare but there is value And I don't know, I was thinking about this in terms of like, I've been thinking about this a lot as I've been trying to figure out how I'm going to talk about Wicked for good on House of R this week.

36:14Yeah.

36:16Joanna Robinson:Thinking about Wicked, my experience watching the first Wicked movie was I had like a pretty bad time watching it in the press screening. And then I went to a wide release with like an audience that loved it and it actually changed my relationship to it. Superman, a movie that I kind of liked. And then I talked to my nephew about it and he loved it and it changed my relationship to the new Superman movie. And that's okay. Critics are supposed to form their opinions in a vacuum. We're not exactly precisely critics. And they're like, it's okay if your relationship to a piece of art changes based on how other people feel about it.

36:50Joanna Robinson:And it's not like I'm dumbing myself down or anyone's dumbing themselves down or whatever. It's just sort of like when something matters to someone, when they find an emotional resonance in it, it can bring it out for me. That happens when I talk to Mallory all the time. It's just like she loves things so fiercely that it's quite infectious. So I just thought this was like a really interesting way to talk about, you know, art. Art can be art, even if you think it's not Shakespeare, it's art to someone. And I think that that's, I don't know, interesting perspective. So I also really enjoyed it as a way that the hive mind, you know, we talked last week, Joe, about like, is the hive mind capable of creating great art?

37:32And I think there's a lot of complications in that prospect. But this is about how the hive mind understands art. And maybe, you know, it can cite, you know, like, you know, portions of the book that really resonated with other people and made them tingle and all that stuff. But ultimately, like what it is good at at this stage in the story is not high emotional intelligence. It's like fact, right? Like this woman was in this situation and your book, shitty as it might be, like gave her second thoughts before committing suicide. Like that is a real thing. And to be very clear, like more than validating the exercise of publishing or creating anything, like if you could create the worst book ever written and it saves someone from killing themselves, like that is a huge net win in the grand scheme of the universe.

38:14And so I'm like, I'm pulled by that sort of sentimentality you're talking about, which I think is very real. And what a work of art means to one person or a small group of people is incredibly meaningful and resonant and not something you can easily write off. And I'm also in the hive mind's portrayal of that pulled in the opposite direction of the like, let people enjoy things kind of self-validation that exists in so much like of our art and cultural moment right now. It's like a hop, skip and a jump away from like, you're being a snob because you didn't love Fantastic Four. You know, like there is a lot of distance between these things, but they're all kind of connected.

38:49Joanna Robinson:I really agree. I am like very torn about it. I'm of two minds because I don't agree that we should flatten all romanticy with Shakespeare. Like, of course I don't. You know what I mean? I think it matters that we say some things are smarter or better or whatever. But I also think it's like, yeah, you can enjoy Fantastic Four. Yes. But like, I can also say I didn't think Fantastic Four was very good. You know, and like... It was not very good. It was not very good. You know. Okay. And I want it to be good. Okay. So here we get Carol visiting Zosia. She's back at the hospital. We're at the hospital three times this week.

39:22Joanna Robinson:Um, this is when we get the sort of the conversion, uh, therapy conversation, the conversion camp conversation. I will say we had a listener, Mikael, who, who called this out as like a possibility. Yeah. um in a previous uh email and then just said like the subtext has become text this week you know essentially um but uh i this was a stunning i thought interaction between carol um and zosha what did you make of it i i completely agree and i think specifically the juxtaposition of these two camps right of this like smiling group of people who supposedly are well-meaning and have your best interests at heart and are fundamentally trying to fix you.

40:06I think that's part of the thing with Carol too, is not just like we want to bring you into our mold. It's as Zosia mentioned last week, like you are drowning, right? Like you are drowning in your own life and we have the solution. We have all the answers. If you simply give everything you are over to us and never be a person ever again. Yeah. Where would someone like Carol have heard that before? Where would she have heard the idea that she is someone who needs to be fixed? Such a damning thing for certainly a teenager to hear, but also not a surprise that someone like Carol would carry it with her in every interaction that she would have for the rest of her life.

40:39Joanna Robinson:And I think that like, you know, I was, I was wondering about this. Like there's there, we got a lot of emails of people wondering, like, why doesn't Carol have like any family outside of Helen? And she might, but she might be like completely no contact with them because they did this to her, right? And then also, I was so curious why in, you know, 2024, 2025, whenever this takes place, someone would be, maybe this is just a privileged bubble of mine, but like why someone would be, someone who's in the arts would be in the bubble and in the closet that way. Like that's, I was just sort of like, I know people are still in the closet, obviously, but it's just sort of like, what is stopping Carol who is like, you know, beloved in this space and like, this is part of it.

41:26Joanna Robinson:There are many other reasons. And I, and I, you know, So looking the donut of gmail.com if you thought that was like the worst thing for me to say. But this particular trauma being something that would just make her so hesitant to let anyone know her truth, let her wider community know her truth, I think is, you know, very important piece of information for us to have. Well, let me ask you this. I don't know if you have any more information on this front than I do. But I wonder if there's something to the idea of being a romance or a romantic author in that. I would say a line of work that lends itself more to pseudonyms and more to working names than almost any other line of fiction, certainly.

42:05There is a level of remove that I think a lot of romance and romanticity authors want to have for various reasons. I wonder if there's like a – would your audience read your hetero relationship with a space pirate in your book the same way if they knew the inner workings of your actual personal life? I don't know how protective people are of those things in that space.

42:23Joanna Robinson:Yeah, I mean, my experience in the sort of like sci-fi fantasy genre space is that it is like so queer friendly. At the same point, same time, romanticity specifically right now also has a large like conservative following, you know what I mean? And so like, I remember this specifically from, sorry, excuse me, book talk when like, in our most recent presidential election, there was this huge schism on the book side of TikTok where there were people were sort of like, why would we ever bring politics into talking about books? And then other people were like, books are politics, you know? Excuse me, have you read a book?

43:04Joanna Robinson:So like, I remember this sort of like, can't we just talk about our fairy smut without bringing politics into it? And I think maybe some of those people would want not want to know that Carol is gay. I think that is possible. But I got bad news, though. The fairies are getting deported. You know, if we literalize the metaphors, bad news for all of your favorite fairies. It's true. Bad news for all of your favorite fairies. My favorite pull coat from this podcast. All right. So Carol goes into the pharmacy. I loved it. I mean, the whole heroin sequence is just like extremely funny. I don't know why she knows to look for the thiopental sodium.

43:43Joanna Robinson:Perhaps because she has studied many a fictional elixir for her book. It's true. So she knows some things about how elixirs work. Once you get into the inner workings of the spice trade, Joe, you learn a lot about recreational and medicinal drugs. But okay. Okay, so here's the specifics that we learn about thiopentyl sodium. It doesn't say underneath the truth serum. So that's not like what it's called. But induction agent for anesthesia. Okay. Emergency management of seizures. Is this Chekhov seizure, anti-seizure medication? Like does having a syringe of thiopentyl sodium, could that save another millions of people dying if she like upsets Zosia again?

44:25Joanna Robinson:Do you know what I mean? But how are you going to distribute it to all the millions of people? Well, isn't stopping Zosia's seizure stopping everyone's seizure? That's a great question. See, this is another case for Carol the scientist we need her to really dig into. We need her to yell at Zosia again, risking the fate of who knows how many people. Inject her again and see what happens. This wasn't traumatic at all for her, so I'm sure she'll be right back on the case. Everyone did great. Everyone was fine. um anything you want to say about the pharmacy or about the the dosage footage that we get i was a little i don't know i was a little underwhelmed by the dosage footage okay tell me you know like obviously we do get these sort of character moments and some great lines and i thought like you know carol reading from her own book in a bad british accent like there's there's great stuff in there yeah i think i was just like waiting for more of a reveal of something from from any part of this, I guess, from Carol's dosing herself or eventually dosing Zosha.

45:22It's like, it's a lot of process and there's no payoff for it yet. And I'm open to the idea that maybe that payoff comes in episode seven or whatever. But for now, it's just kind of like, okay, there's this truth serum and it's been administered to two different people. And the most telling information we've got is that Carol thinks Zosha is fuckable, which we already knew.

45:41Joanna Robinson:I don't know that everyone already knew, but like, yes. On the official podcast, Ray Sehorne talked about filming that sequence and how she had to like film all of it because they were just like scrubbing through like they scrubbed through it but like she had to film all of that like together and one thing that they cut like one of the things that she did that they just decided to zoom through was her singing melissa etheridge and i'm like release the etheridge cut please i beg of you i think listen i'm not that bad was really a really good moment i mean like why they have to make her so fuckable is of course and then carol's reaction to seeing herself say that it's almost like revelatory to like carol can't hide from her intrusive thoughts when she has taped them for herself but um but yeah i just thought it's very funny but i think i think you make a good point because then we get this like we're back at the hospital again and we get this whole sort of like after the music in the elevator uh sequence outside i would say that song has been stuck in my head non-stop well it's it's the uh christopher it's not the christopher cross version i don't think but it's that like best that you can do a song from Arthur.

46:44And I'm like, it's just rolling up here. I don't know what it is about that bit of elevator music, but it really got me.

46:50Joanna Robinson:Are you a fan of elevator music in general? Hold music? Apparently. I didn't know this about myself, but revelations abound for me and Carol both. I love this. I think, do you like your cop car, as you say, as a phantilizing shirt? How was the heroin? It's good. It was really funny. Really good. But also, I will say, I think what we learned from the pharmacy interaction, like the fact that Carol did heroin sophomore year. It was crazy. But then he's like, it's been a while since you injected your, like, I don't know. Like, what is Carol's? We are, we've already talked about her substance abuse and sort of like her drinking and stuff like that.

47:31Joanna Robinson:So like, what is her history with drugs? Like, what is, you know, and again, we're keep, we keep getting these like hints of the darkness in her, in her past. you know like sophomore year is tough so i did some heroin is like not something i would say i don't know um no but what were you up to sophomore year joe not doing heroin um one would hope i was working or at least not injecting theater that's what i was doing sophomore year i mean that's the heroin of the soul you know that's that's what got you hooked to be in this line of work now you've been an addict for a long time it's true it's true it was the butter and the popcorn machine that did it, I think.

48:08Now you're going to see fucking Tron Aries and just like, you know, living it up.

48:12Joanna Robinson:Rob, you need to give the people all the information about me going to see Tron Aries this week, which is that I went with some friends. We found a deserted theater. We heckled Tron Aries and it was a great time. And you told me you thought that that was a great idea. I do think it's a great idea, but I am a fellow movie sicko, as are you. I also have a bit of breaking news for you, which is they were all deserted theaters. You could have gone to any of them for Tron Aries. Actually, that's a lie. There were four people in our theater. I hope they were having a great time. But they were having a really, they were also talking through it.

48:41Joanna Robinson:So the point is, we were not disturbing anyone. And our point was to like, I went with the same person I saw Morbius with, and we also heckled Morbius in a deserted theater. So I just think that like, this is how you should consume a Jared Leto film. That's my personal opinion. There's no doubt. We did talk, Joe, we talked a lot about the hive mind as potential AI. And I think this heroin bit, which is really just kind of cover for her to get the needles, which is, I think, pretty clever on Carol's part. It reminded me, we didn't talk enough about ultimately the hive mind here as like dark web concierge.

49:14Joanna Robinson:The heroin's eight miles away. There is a version, you know, there's a group of emailers who are telling us about they want to race cars, they want to play golf courses. There is a, you know, an unheard majority out there who have some really deep dark shit they want to do. But I'm not inviting it. I'm just saying there is a brand of stuff that's out there and possibilities in this universe that people don't even want to touch in polite company. I suggest you email lickingthedownut, D-O-U-G-H-N-U-T. With all of your dark web fantasies. With your dark web fantasies. I'm sure that person will love to have those in addition to all the other pluribus emails they've been getting.

49:54Before we go out of the hospital, though, I want to ask you about one thing. This like final sequence we get with Zosia and Carol in the hospital room where Zosia is telling her like, we have been you, but you haven't been us. And like, we know what it's like to be truly alone and to suffer. I mean, this, this sequence like really caught me. I think first, first of all, in a sort of like weaponized empathy kind of way. And also made me wonder, like, is that something that the hive mind is even capable of? Like this group's emotional intelligence has been so spare to this point. Like there's a lot they miss in context in terms of the actual humanity behind the words and expressions people have.

50:37For one, like could a hive mind even practice the kind of understanding that it claims to hold over what it means to be alone? Is that something that they could even comprehend?

50:47Joanna Robinson:I would argue no. And I would, you know, it's the same, I think that's the very same question we're asking about, like, can they create art? There is just something, like, deeply human that the flattening of, you know, their experience cannot, they don't have access to that. But will, can they get there? Will Zoja, like, what happens here at the end of this episode is extremely traumatic for Zoja, obviously. Yes. and and for the people i mean it's a very scary sequence um carol screaming like backup i have agency but like not feeling confident that that like this is a risk she's taking right yeah exactly um something on a something that they said on the official pot so the person who comes through with the sort of machine to help um zoja at the very end of the episode um her name is rosa estrada And this is the woman who, with that self-same machine, saved Bob Odenkirk's life on the set of Better Call Saul.

51:50Joanna Robinson:If folks don't know, Bob Odenkirk had a very serious heart attack on the set of Better Call Saul. Ray Sehorne was there. And this woman, Rosa Estrada, and I think one of the ADs or something like that, did chest compressions and worked on Bob and brought him back. But it was very touch and go in that moment. So they wanted to like bring this woman in to like give her this moment. But they were also talking about how they want to be very sensitive to Ray in filming this sequence. And also when she was doing chest compressions on Helen, that like this is something that this person, a very traumatic thing that this person went through with a beloved co-star, Bob Odenkirk.

52:29Joanna Robinson:uh and uh so i thought that was really i thought racy horn's performances are always really good but like her terror and guilt and all the things that she's feeling and frustration of not even getting the answer going through all of that and not even getting the answer but coming close seemingly coming close um i thought was like really upsetting i i take your point that like Like we did all this and we didn't get the information. Which is fine. Like from a plot perspective, just from the condensing of an individual episode. That makes sense. Was this an episode of TV or was this part of a larger project?

53:07It felt like more like part of a larger project.

53:09Joanna Robinson:I thought it was really stunning. They talked about how everyone in the crowd is crying and they had to use like vitamin E oil on their faces or whatever, because it was like crying at a rate that like you couldn't sustain as a human. But, and then like, they're not smiling. So like to have this crowd just like standing around her not smiling. Very scary. Very scary. So. And again, like listen, listening to her directives, right? When Carol wants them to step back, they step back. When she wants them to let go, they let go. But also sort of the like wall of sound as they're kind of chanting to her, which is not as you alluded to.

53:44Yeah. Yeah. The please Carol. And you talked about this in an earlier episode, Joe, where it's like it can't be fully in unison because there's kind of a weird uncanny balance to all that. And so it ends up as it's just like overwhelming wave of sound and emotion and moment. And Racy Horn delivers as she always delivers.

54:00Joanna Robinson:Anything else you want to say about this sequence or the episode? Here's what I will say. We didn't spend as much time as I probably should have talking about Jeff Hiller's performance in this episode. But last week we had talked about like all the celebrity camos we would like to see. And like we got some good suggestions. And I do think it's a really fun idea. But like thinking about Robert Bailey Jr. who showed up as the DHL delivery guy last week and Jeff Hiller showing up here, like maybe I would actually prefer this. Let's find these like people who are, you know, Jeff didn't have his Emmy when they cast him in this.

54:32Joanna Robinson:And I think before he won his Emmy, fewer people knew who he was and people still might not know. And they should who Jeff Hiller is. but like these people who have been around and doing great work and let's just like let them show up and do like a gangbuster scene in an episode of pluribus you know what i mean completely i think like the track record is there too for gilligan in terms of you've seen what he can do with like michael mckean you know it's like an actor of a certain repute and like success and it's like if you just want to come play for a little while like we'll give you really fun and interesting stuff to do we'll put you at this table opposite ray sehorn and you get to be kind of disarming and charming and also incredibly eerie and creepy at the same time.

55:13It's like there's a lot for, I think, character actors specifically to work with on a show like this that could be really fun for a lot of people.

55:20Joanna Robinson:And how excited we'll be if Larry, Jeff Hiller, comes back and sees it. And we're like, oh, Larry's here again. He doesn't have to become a main character, but it'll be fun to see these people again. They did talk on the official pod about this idea that Larry's been in that bike uniform since the joining hasn't changed it. I don't know if that would smell great. Do the unlicked shower? That's a great question. They said - I'm sorry, do the hive mind shower. I hope the unlicked shower. Carol sometimes doesn't. Sometimes she doesn't. This idea that they have no vanity, right? So they don't care what they look like.

56:04Joanna Robinson:unless they're trying to like appeal directly to Carol, I guess. But I have a question. Like, again, I'm just curious if they're all going to eventually wind up in like matching jumpsuits or something like that. I don't know. So we'll see how the hive mind continues to hive. Anything else you want to talk about? I will say if that's what ultimately happens, it might be appealing to Carol, who has been a leisure wear icon to this point. I was having a conversation with our guy, Kai Grady, at the office, who pointed out her, to this point, several full body matching like sweatsuits that she has in incredible colors.

56:35And it's like, maybe if you just give Carol a nice pair of sweats, she would be down for all this. They just don't know the weight of her heart ultimately.

56:42Joanna Robinson:That what should be under the cloche is some nice leisure wear. I love that. Absolutely. That's a great, that's a classic Kai Grady observation. Thank you to everyone for listening to this podcast. Lickingthedonetatgmail.com. Please keep your emails coming. I know I keep saying there's a lot of them, but I do love reading them so please keep sending them um thank you to donnie beecham for his continued heroic friday morning turnaround on these pods always like really really good and to justin sales of course for his work on the feed thank you to rob mahoney thank you joe no thanks i guess to pigeons uh rob still is uh considers you his enemy and get lost they're literal vermin uh we'll see you next week.

57:20Joanna Robinson:Bye.

57:50to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required. Compatibility and availability varies 18+.

58:00Athletic Brewing Company crafts award-winning non-alcoholic beers for those who want to be part of every round. With over 185 flavor awards, they're exceptional NA beers that fit your lifestyle and any social occasion. Summer's full of good times and athletic fits right in. Go to athleticbrewing.com to have brews delivered to your door or find them at a bar. restaurant or store near you. Near Beer. Athletic Brewing Company. Fit for all times.

From the publisher

Jo and Rob are back for Episode 4 of Apple TV’s ‘Pluribus.

(00:00) Intro

(2:43) Listener emails

(10:01) Dispatches from Paraguay

(18:53) Meanwhile, in Albuquerque

(22:42) Freeze frame Mahoney: the whiteboard

(39:49) Carol's truth serum

(50:30) Guest character actors

Email us! prestigetv@spotify.com or lickingthedonut@gmail.com

Subscribe to the Ringer TV YouTube channel here for full episodes of The Prestige TV Podcast and so much more!

Hosts: Joanna Robinson and Rob Mahoney

Producers: Donnie Beacham Jr.

Additional Production Support: Justin Sayles
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from The Prestige TV Podcast

All 102 episodes
‘Pluribus’ Episode 4: Carol’s Truth SerumThe Prestige TV Podcast · 56 min
Listen in VO