The ‘Veronica Mars’ Episode That Got Us Hooked

3 Sep 2025 · 1 h 3 min · 32 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

The Prestige TV “Hooked” episode discusses Veronica Mars Season 1, Episode 14 (“Mars v. Mars”), focusing on how the show hooks new viewers with a detective case, parallel mysteries, and the first strong Logan/Veronica partnership.

Guest backgrounds

Hosts Joanna Robinson and Rob Mahoney (Prestige TV podcast). They reference the show’s creator Rob Thomas and highlight guest stars in the episode.

Key claims

Episode 14 is chosen because it accelerates major season-one threads: Mr. Brooks’ case, Logan’s search for his mother Lynn Echols, and the Lily Kane murder plot running underneath. The hosts argue the show’s core appeal is Kristen Bell’s performance, Keith/Veronica’s father-daughter dynamic, and the chemistry between Veronica and Logan that becomes central later.

Notable examples

Adam Scott plays Mr. Brooks, accused by Leighton Meester’s character of having sex with a student and owning black silk bed sheets. Lisa Rinna appears as Lynn Echols (Logan’s mom). The episode includes Veronica being “very wrong until she’s right,” Logan/Veronica banter at the police station, and an Abel Koontz button ending.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Exploring 'Veronica Mars' and its Impact

0:03 to 0:29

The hosts discuss their personal connections to 'Veronica Mars' and its significance in TV history.

“Because with Apple Pay, you can pay with a simple tap of your iPhone, the wallet you never forget at millions of places worldwide, including websites, apps, and anywhere you see the contactless symbol.”

Exploring 'Veronica Mars' and its Impact

2:15 to 4:52

The hosts discuss their personal connections to 'Veronica Mars' and its significance in TV history.

“I just can't I cannot push Veronica Mars up people's queue to the point that they will actually even give it a chance.”

History of 'Veronica Mars'

4:52 to 5:38

A dive into the history of 'Veronica Mars', including its development and evolution over time.

“Veronica Mars ran on UPN from 2004, 2005.”

Character Dynamics and Relationships

7:28 to 14:00

The hosts analyze character relationships in 'Veronica Mars', focusing on key dynamics.

“Monica Mars is how insane so much of this cast is in retrospect and the talent they were able to bring into this little UPN show.”

Character Development in Veronica Mars

14:00 to 15:00

Explore the pivotal relationships and character arcs in 'Veronica Mars'.

“I think they say in interviews, episode four, that they figured that out essentially.”

The Challenge of Romantic Tension

15:00 to 16:00

Discuss the complexities of romantic tension in TV storytelling.

“And they did their best to sort of like draw it out.”

Veronica's Flaws and Strengths

16:00 to 17:00

Analyze Veronica Mars as a flawed yet compelling protagonist.

“Like you just have this gravitational pull of the audience that then is, it does make it hard to do everything else.”

The Appeal of Troubled Characters

17:00 to 18:20

Understand the allure of characters with troubled pasts in storytelling.

“I know our assignment here is to not make it harder for people to get into or enjoy Veronica Mars.”

Guest Stars and Their Impact

18:20 to 19:50

Examine the significance of guest stars in enhancing the narrative of 'Veronica Mars'.

“You also have to allow yourself room to understand that she is going to make the kinds of mistakes that teenagers will make.”

Cultural Context of Veronica Mars

19:50 to 21:30

Discuss the cultural context surrounding 'Veronica Mars' during its release.

“as the cool quote i say heavy air quotes cool fun teacher doing his exercise in history class almost instantly being accused of having an inappropriate relationship with a student.”
Show all 32 chapters

Plotlines and Character Connections

21:30 to 22:30

Explore the intertwining plotlines and character relationships within an episode.

“So he's like in the family, had yet to do Parks and Recreation, is rocking some real early aughts hair in this episode, is perfect casting for this.”

Mr. Brooks and Misconduct Themes

22:30 to 24:40

Analyze the themes of misconduct and morality through the character of Mr. Brooks.

“And the episode is playing out in parallel.”

Mr. Brooks and Misconduct Themes

26:26 to 26:55

Analyze the themes of misconduct and morality through the character of Mr. Brooks.

“Faster quotes start at the Lowe's Pro Desk.”

Mr. Brooks and Misconduct Themes

26:59 to 27:23

Analyze the themes of misconduct and morality through the character of Mr. Brooks.

“But choosing a snack you and your kids can both get behind doesn't have to be.”

Recap and Character Analysis of Keith Mars

27:23 to 28:00

Reflect on Keith Mars' character and his significance in 'Veronica Mars'.

Character Dynamics in Veronica Mars

28:00 to 29:40

Explore the significance of Keith Mars and his relationship with Veronica.

“It's not all there yet, but the warmth is there.”

Fandom Influence on Storytelling

29:40 to 32:50

Discuss how audience feedback influenced the show's narrative and character arcs.

Veronica and Logan: Complicated Relationships

32:50 to 36:10

Analyze the evolving relationship between Veronica and Logan throughout the episode.

Character Analysis of Veronica Mars

36:10 to 37:50

Delve into Veronica's character flaws and strengths in this episode.

“Brooks's diary, instead gets, you know, just like ink splattered all over her and yet still wants to continue trading notes, still wants to try to prove Mr.”

Cultural References and Their Impact

37:50 to 41:00

Examine the 2005 cultural references and their contextual significance in the episode.

“But I think it's like a pretty good guest starring performance from her as well.”

Setting Up Future Plotlines

41:00 to 42:05

Identify how this episode lays groundwork for future story arcs in Veronica Mars.

“had Leighton Meester back a lot for Carrie Bishop so what else would you say it sets up for the rest of the series?”

Veronica Mars: An Overview

42:05 to 43:36

Discussion on the tone and style of 'Veronica Mars' as a show.

“It's to the point of even almost doing a Clarice Starling accent.”

Pilot Episode Insights

43:36 to 45:14

Exploration of the pilot episode's crucial cold open and its impact.

Character Development in the Pilot

45:14 to 47:54

Analysis of character introductions and plot development in the pilot.

“The UPN executives were not doing us any favors in the battle against Pluck.”

Kristen Bell's Performance

47:54 to 49:59

Discussion on Kristen Bell's performance and its significance in the pilot.

“I do have an incredible amount of admiration for that, like how much it is endeavoring to put forth in front of us.”

Writing and Pop Culture References

49:59 to 52:32

Examination of the writing style and clever pop culture references in the show.

“It was very much like a put her in a slightly different light.”

The Theme Song and Its Impact

52:32 to 53:46

Discussion of the show's theme song and its importance.

“Anything else you want to say about the pilot before we get into sort of like deep, dark, scary spoiler territory?”

Transitioning to Spoilers

53:46 to 54:39

Setup for the spoiler section and a warning to listeners.

“And if the way to do it is by hooking Adam Scott or a guest star on and putting people in through the side door, so be it.”

Fandom Reactions and Controversies

54:39 to 56:03

Exploration of fan reactions to plot developments in later seasons.

“You've shown a lot of a lot of restraint.”

Fan Reactions to Logan's Death

56:03 to 58:23

Explore the intense fan backlash over the character Logan's fate in Veronica Mars.

“You're telling me off mic, Joe, that you thought Piz was like the one true pairing for Veronica.”

Character Development and Stakes in TV

58:24 to 1:01:18

Discuss the importance of character stakes and how they impact the narrative.

“Anyway, Jason Doering deserves the world.”

Comparing Seasons of Veronica Mars

1:01:19 to 1:02:08

Analyze the quality and mystery of different seasons of Veronica Mars.

“One overall might hang together a little more.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This message is brought to you by Apple Pay. Forget your wallet. It's all good. Because with Apple Pay, you can pay with a simple tap of your iPhone, the wallet you never forget at millions of places worldwide, including websites, apps, and anywhere you see the contactless symbol. Security is built in with Face ID so you don't have to worry about your cards getting lost or stolen. And the best part, you still earn card rewards, points, and cash back you love. So say goodbye to the bifold, add your card to Apple Wallet, and start paying the Apple way. Terms apply.

0:42Joanna Robinson:Hello, welcome back to the Prestige TV podcast feed. I'm Joanna Robinson. I'm Rob Mahoney. We're here with another installment of Hooked, our end of summer, early fall little mini series that we have decided to do about some of our favorite seasons of television. Today, we're talking about Veronica Mars. Have you heard of it? Have you heard of it? Listen, we did some huge, massive Ringer core shows in Breaking Bad and Mad Men. And then it was like, two for y 'all, one for us. This is a very Joe and Rob coded show. So that is why we're here to talk about Veronica Mars. Step very carefully, because this is a big show to a certain subset of people, which includes us, Joe, like this is as big as it gets, certainly for teenage Rob and really just for Rob in general.

1:28Joanna Robinson:Excellent. If you have not listened to any of these hooked episodes, here's what we do. We're here to talk to you about the episode that is not necessarily the pilot of a TV show that you would show to someone, a friend, a loved one, et cetera, to get them hooked into a show you like, because sometimes the pilot isn't the episode that's going to do it. So we're here to talk to you about some alternative options, though we might have an exception that proves the rule coming up on this series sometime soon. What do you want to say about the premise of the show? Rob, anything else before we get into specifics of today?

2:09The premise of Hooked or the premise of Veronica Morris? Oh, no.

2:12Joanna Robinson:Of Hooked. Did I cover it? Did I do it? I think you covered it. And I will say in this particular case, very resonant for me because I would say throughout my lifetime to this point, this is the show I have tried to pitch to the most people and failed spectacularly. I just can't I cannot push Veronica Mars up people's queue to the point that they will actually even give it a chance. And so I think part of our exercise today is, look, if they were going to watch the pilot, they would have done it already. What is the alternative way and we can give them to become Veronica Mars fans to become proper marshmallows?

2:44Joanna Robinson:We have a slightly tougher assignment today because Rob and I both own this show on DVD because that's the kind of people we are. This is not available to stream anywhere for free. I was devastated. Yeah. Hulu, how dare you? I know. They have the new new season, which we'll talk about in a second. But you can buy episodes on your favorite streaming platform of choice, but you cannot just stream it for free. So that's going to be a barrier of entry for some people. but I do want to before we get into sort of the civics of Veronica Mars I want to mention one email we got from a listener sort of about this concept we've gotten some feedback on our Mad Men and our Breaking Bad episodes of people who vehemently disagree with us or agree with us it's a it's a sort of touchy subject it is well and Joe where did these people email us uh prestigetv at spotify.com I believe is where they can find us always perpetually uh we are there you know i i just want to keep the lines open you know the lines of communication especially in hope season this is very important and we've gotten a lot of people who are really eager for us to cover a show that we actually do plan to cover before the end of this little news series so um this email comes from listener uh sam who uh has emailed me for years and across various shows and always has something very clever to say um but he wrote i feel like we have so many you got to get to blank conversations about shows today because pilots are so strictly written to be sold and have to do so much legwork they rarely get to be the kind of show they want to settle into sometimes they are diamonds and perfectly lay out the energy direction of a show mad men oftentimes they're wikipedia articles for everything you need to know about the show in order for it to get loose weird and have fun later um sam said that email before we did our Mad Men episodes.

4:35Joanna Robinson:So that's fine. But listen, I think this idea of this is a Wikipedia article for what the premise of the show is could not better describe the pilot of Veronica Mars. So we are not going to be picking the pilot today. We're going to be picking a later episode. Veronica Mars ran on UPN from 2004, 2005. May it rest in power. And then it became the CW and Veronica Mars wrapped up its third season in 2006. It was a kickstart crowdfunded into a 2014 film. If I can raise my hand, I was among them. Me too. I helped to kickstart this movie. I still have my honorary t-shirt as such. Do you? Does it say like I'm a marshmallow?

5:18Joanna Robinson:What does it say on it? It just has a nice little stylish Veronica Mars logo of her and her car with her camera. It's lovely. Love it. And then it was rebooted on Hulu in 2019 for an eight episode season four so controversial that it's almost impossible to Google literally anything about the show without hitting a wall of articles about the season four finale. Yes. Which we'll talk about in our uber spoiler section at the end of this podcast here today. Rob Mahoney, you already teased that this is an important show to teenage Rob. Do you want to give us sort of the log line? What is Veronica Mars about and what did it mean to you when it first came on?

5:53I mean, Veronica Mars is a genuinely amazing detective show that happens to largely take place at a high school. And because of that, look, the Nancy Drew looms large. And we're just kind of trying to overcome the barrier to entry. But if you can get past that and we would encourage you to do it, and that's what we're here to do today. It is as sharply written and stylized and well acted. And I think one of the hallmarks of this episode is brought to you by ADT. One second, you're enjoying your day off. The next, your phone buzzes. A window's been broken at home. You're miles away. In one second, everything can change.

6:28That's why ADT security systems can monitor your home 24-7. They're backed by the most company-operated monitoring centers in the industry, so you're always supported during an emergency. When every second counts, count on ADT. Visit ADT.com to learn more. This episode is brought to you by Boar's Head. It may have been years ago, but I still remember the feeling of unpacking my kids' lunch boxes after school and to find nothing left. As a parent, that's a total win. Boar's head, maple honey ham, American cheese, maple honey turkey, all-time greats in the school lunch game. It's real quality protein that tastes great, so you can feel that winning feeling all term long.

7:07Whether you're doing wraps, sandwiches, or a quick snack box, Boar's head makes packing school lunches easier. You'll be proud of what you pack. They'll be happy to finish it. Fuel their school day with the premium choice Boar's Head. For lunchtime inspiration, visit boarshead.com slash back to school or head to your local deli counter. Monica Mars is how insane so much of this cast is in retrospect and the talent they were able to bring into this little UPN show. It just turns into something that is so funny and so emotionally resonant and honestly like actually seeks to tackle some very real societal problems and societal difficulties.

7:46And it's like it has a lot to say about class as a lot to say about high school. It's a lot to say about Kristen Bell being a star. And a lot of the reason we live in our current Kristen Bell ruled climate is because of Veronica Mars.

7:58Joanna Robinson:This show is created by Rob Thomas. Not that Rob Thomas. No relation. Who also did Party Down. He was a writer on Dawson's Creek. He did iZombie in which they had the other Rob Thomas guest star. this is a show that you know you and I are huge Buffy Vampire Slayer fans this is like in every way sort of an honorary continuation of the Buffy Vampire Slayer legacy it was originally meant to be a YA book that Rob Thomas then turned into a tv show originally he was going to do a young a young boy like a high school boy who was the son of the sheriff he was pitching around he wanted this to be an FX show.

8:40Joanna Robinson:This is what we constantly hear at HBO show, Showtime show. He brought it to UPN and they said, hey, man, we're looking for female empowerment to go with our recently acquired multi-vampire slayer. And he's like, have I got a show for you? It's about a teenage girl. And immediately then it became, I don't know what the, instead of Ronnie Mars game, Veronica Mars. And that is, that is the show. What's so crazy about that is this would be an unrecognizable show if you gender swap Veronica Mars. It's a totally different show. Obviously, so many of the plot threads would read totally differently. But her, I mean, it's so crucial in the text, not unlike Buffy, of this like, what do you expect of a teenage girl?

9:20And the idea of being constantly underestimated because she is a teenage girl is central to her ability to then be a really good private detective, even though she's like 16 years old.

9:29Joanna Robinson:Even though this started as a YA book and became a UPN and then CW show, I would not call this a show for teenagers even though teenage rob loved it i loved it as a just out of my teenage years person um a few years out of my teenage years but the writing is so sharp yeah and so clever and the central relationship between uh the character of keith mars who uh was the former disgraced town sheriff now private investigator and his daughter veronica is i would say not the number one most important relationship on the show but it is the number two and it is very very important and um it's just as you said like the fact that amanda seyfried is here as like a background guest star throughout season one of veronica mars is completely wild and the in the enjoyment that you get out of the guests the many guest stars who show up on this show um is is part of the fun um you we picked the episode we picked today season one episode 14 mars v mars has adam scott it does leighton meester a gossip girl pre-union yeah pre-union um and uh christina locken from step by step which is maybe not as important to other people but here it is here she is um and this is a story by rob thomas teleplay by jed Seidel and Diane Ruggiero and directed by Marcos Siega.

11:00Joanna Robinson:And it aired February 15th, 2005. Yikes on that date. Just big time yikes. Spoiler warning up through episode 14, I should say. And in a second, I'm going to make Rob defend why we picked an episode so late in the season. This is the one where Adam Scott plays a charismatic teacher accused by Leighton Meester of having sex with a student and potentially worse, owning black silk bed sheets. It's not worse. That's okay. And this is also the one where Veronica is very wrong until she's right. And quite crucially for our conversation today, the one where Logan and Veronica really start working together for the first time to find out what happened to Logan's mom, Lynn Echols, played by future Real Housewife at Beverly Hills, Lisa Rinna.

11:45Joanna Robinson:So that is what we're talking about today. Rob Mahoney, 14 episodes into season one. That's like two seasons nowadays, two seasons of a given show. How do you defend that we picked an episode so late in the season? I would say a couple of things. One, look, this is a show that does have a good pilot. It is a little bit of a Wikipedia entry of a pilot, but it does a decent enough job of setting up all of the major kind of players and mysteries in a pretty economical fashion. I have a lot of respect for it. but because it's taking place earlier and you alluded to one of the most crucial relationships on the show, it doesn't have a lot of Logan as we come to know Logan in it.

12:25Joanna Robinson:Yeah. And that is Veronica Mars. And so it's like, for me, look, there are three reasons why this show works the way it does. In other hands, it could have been an absolute disaster. If it was a little less well-written, if it was a little less well-acted, like it could have been a joke, could have been an absolute joke of a show. The reason it is what it is. I think overall, Kristen Bell as Veronica Mars. Like that performance has to work. Enrico Colantoni as Keith Mars. Lights out so funny, so endearing. Their relationship as father and daughter critical to the show. And Jason Doering as Logan, like that triumvirate is what elevates this from run-of-the-mill teen show that would be watched and forgotten and maybe meme-ified in 20 years to one that like you can revisit over and over and over and over and it will always feel like an enriching experience.

13:16Joanna Robinson:I'm not sure I'm making my case for this not being a teenage show to say the most important thing about this show is the central love story between two teenage characters. However, it is a chemistry between two actors so irresistible that it is something that they didn't intend. They cast Jason Doring to play sort of like a one-and-done kind of guy. And this might be what Hooked winds up being, which is like the way in which TV, the best of TV can be a reactive medium. And so, and especially in this era when it was 22 episode season, you have a 22 episode season, they start shooting it and they're like, uh-oh, Logan and Veronica, that's firecrackers.

13:58Joanna Robinson:And it was episode, I think they say in interviews, episode four, that they figured that out essentially. And so they're like, okay guys, we're going to take a hard pivot off of our intended path. All these other would-be boyfriends, bench them. I'm so sorry to you, Duncan Cain. We're going to take a hard right turn and we're going to figure this out. We're going to pitch it at the end of the season, though, because we want to draw it out a bit. But that is where we're headed. And this is the first episode where these two characters are working together. Yes. And it is just undeniably crucial to show.

14:37Joanna Robinson:It is part of what makes season one, I think, one of the most perfect seasons of television. And then I think season two is really strong. And then things are shaky and shakier from there, in my opinion. But the thing about Logan and Veronica Mars, Logan Eccles and Veronica Mars, is it's a... When you're a TV creator and you find something that is this magical, it is so hard to know how to use it correctly. And they did their best to sort of like draw it out. Will they, won't they? Find all these different ways in which they could keep that tension going. And then sort of like similar to famously shows like Cheers or Moonlighting, like once they didn't know what to do with it, the show kind of stalls out.

15:20Joanna Robinson:And not only that, the relationship winds up swallowing basically kind of the rest. It becomes like a monster to a certain degree so that when you get to the part where we're kickstarting a movie or when you get to the season four reboot they done Hulu, all anyone wants to talk about is Logan and Veronica. It's true. And that's, you know, it's something that I am like definitely guilty of, but it's something that I like, it's definitely a double edged sword when you find something that is this sort of like TV heroine and then you OD and are strung out on it. You know what I mean? That frankly like burns that hot that it is all consuming in that way.

15:56And it's very dangerous, not just from a plotting perspective, but for character, like any character who you try to make the next boyfriend or the next girlfriend or just kind of put in that orbit ends up looking really lame by comparison, ends up being hated by comparison. Like you just have this gravitational pull of the audience that then is, it does make it hard to do everything else. I think Veronica Mars overall, as you said, like still has a lot of great success operating within that relationship and somewhat in the shadow of it at times, but it's not perfect. And there are the times where you really feel the absences of that relationship.

16:29And especially early in the season when Logan is drawn before that kind of chemistry starts clicking as a little bit more of just like a high school asshole. The absence of damaged, wounded puppy dog Logan.

16:42Joanna Robinson:Yeah. Also crucial. And that's, I think, especially what you get in Mars vs. Mars is you're getting a sense of this like very wounded person who then, okay, you're peeling back the asshole layers. You're peeling back like the tough guy, popular kid into something that more closely resembles an actual person. I know our assignment here is to not make it harder for people to get into or enjoy Veronica Mars. But I will say as far as like things you have to come back from. And this is an archetype that always works for me. It works for me on Lost. It works for me on Buffy Vampire Slayer. Like it works for me on all these shows, these like blonde assholes who show up and then you have to be like, oh, I see what you're doing here.

17:23Joanna Robinson:You're a character on an arc. I understand. I love a character on an arc. However, orchestrating bum fights is one of the hardest things a character has had to come back for. And that is something that Logan Echols had to grapple with in season one. Not his finest moment, to say the least. But honestly, I think what Veronica Mars really shines is there are a lot of characters who are doing deeply unlikable things, who are enchanted with an incredible amount of wealth and privilege because of their families and just are squandering it. or immune, like don't have a sense of where they are or belong in the world and are just like operating like impulsive teenagers doing impulsive teenager things.

18:02And the show has a lot of latitude for that, including for Veronica, who, as you as you laid out in terms of our picking this episode, most crucially is extremely wrong. And I think that's another reason why this episode works so well is like if we're going to set up our precocious teen detective who is incredibly charismatic and incredibly likable, You also have to allow yourself room to understand that she is going to make the kinds of mistakes that teenagers will make.

18:26Joanna Robinson:But what's great about a character like Veronica Mars, because this is a show that has always sort of wanted to go as dark as it can possibly go inside of a UPNCW shell. And it does. figuring that out but it does and it doesn't in that like veronica mars is a character even as she then goes to college and then we meet her as an adult later in the series like is always fucking up and making the wrong choices and that is part of her appeal so it's not just like teenage fumbling it's like she is just an inherently i charge after the thing i think is right kind of character to my detriment again and again.

19:08Joanna Robinson:And that is honestly fascinating to watch, especially inside of what Kristen Bell does with that character, because you're always rooting for her, even though she is quite often making the wrong decisions, you know. But so you have that fully drawn character in Veronica, who's just as good of a central character as we've seen really of many shows over the last 25 years or so. You have these core relationships, I would say, you know her and keith and her and logan in particular really anchoring it and anchoring the episode that we've chosen today and then i think the guest star recurring star element is another reason why i wanted to do mars versus mars specifically like the adam scott element here as a first-time viewer is like whoa adam scott's on this show and he comes in with an absolute bang as the cool quote i say heavy air quotes cool fun teacher doing his exercise in history class almost instantly being accused of having an inappropriate relationship with a student.

20:03It's like, bam, we are going to very intense places, very serious places. There's a plot accelerant and it's with people that you know. And I think if you run through the list of the people who just like appeared in an Adam Scott-like capacity on Veronica Mars, I would like to read for you some of these names, Joe. I'm ready for the Oscar winner. I mean, you mentioned Adam Scott and Leighton Meester here. Amanda Seyfried, obviously, she's recurring. She has a secret, a big one. I'm sure you've heard about it. Jessica Chastain.

20:31Joanna Robinson:Yep. Taylor Sheridan, who now also runs the world. Tessa Thompson, Paul Rudd, Anthony Anderson, Max Greenfield, Armie Hammer. Kristen Ritter and Aaron Paul, you know, just breaking bad all over the place. Alison Hannigan, Michael Cera, Aliyah Shawkat, Paris Hilton, very famously appears in an early episode. Kristen Cavallari, Jonathan Taylor Thomas, Jane Lynch, Diana Agron, our beloved Charisma Carpenter. A lot happening in the guest starring and returning cast of Veronica Mars. The Paris Hilton episode, which is episode two, which I did rewatch for prep here, is truly wild. Like I was watching episode one.

21:03Joanna Robinson:I was like, let's let it run. I was like, wow. Paris, I remember. I distinctly remember the Paris Hilton episode when it like aired, where we were as a nation, when Paris Hilton was a guest star on Veronica Mars. Where were we as a nation, Jo? Oh, it's tough. It was a really tough time for us as a culture. A lot of like juicy couture velour sweatsuits on display here. I think Adam Scott specifically, who like shows up, he had done Party Down with Rob Thomas, obviously. So he's like in the family, had yet to do Parks and Recreation, is rocking some real early aughts hair in this episode, is perfect casting for this.

21:43Joanna Robinson:because this is before he was like lovable ben wyatt and and adam scott has always done this thing where he's played with like lovability and darkness and all this other stuff like this and so this idea that veronica mars in 2005 an episode where veronica mars is just like immediately on the side of the of the dude despite being herself someone who was sexually assaulted and that is a main plot line of the season but she's immediately like i'm not going to listen to this young woman who's accusing this dude i am on his side her dad has to be the one that like this young woman deserves to be listened to and she's like nope she's a gossip and we don't have to listen to her i'm team the teacher didn't do it um until the uh the mick jagger and the black silk sheets uh enter enter the conversation i cannot believe i mean of all the improbable things that happened this episode and an episode television i truly enjoy imagine you're adam scott and you have just by the skin of your teeth been absolved of something you definitely did do so sorry adam scott's character mr brooks in this show mr brooks okay mr brooks has been absolved of this thing that he definitely did do and the teenage girl who helped you get away scot-free comes over to your house and then you try to seduce her try to do the thing that you did that got you in trouble in the first place no no patience no window here just like immediately bam let's put on the rolling stones and get the black side two straight to side two no hesitation no shame i mean the hubris of this kind of exact kind of guy and i think adam scott's portrayal of somebody who kind of like has always has a very innocuous excuse for everything every piece of evidence is levied against him it's oh it was this oh it was reactionary parents oh it was that like it again it's like a very recognizable figure and one that i think as you're watching it one thing i was blown away by revisiting this episode is like it's pretty clear as a viewer fairly quickly what seems to be happening which is veronica being very wrong like keith is presenting compelling evidence a quarter of the way through the episode that's not quite smoking gun but like there are serious holes in this guy's story.

24:01And the episode is playing out in parallel. This is another reason why I think it's a great choice in terms of creating the sort of entry point for people for Veronica Mars is it's this story about Mr. Brooks and this student. It's this story about Logan and his mom. And I think Logan and Veronica on sort of parallel journeys of coming to accept something they really don't want to believe is true. And I think the way that those are played in parallel while also here's some Lily Kane murder stuff. Here's what's going on with Duncan stuff. Like there's so many mysteries being juggled at the same time.

24:33And yet the central stuff never feels like it's getting short shrift. Like you still feel the push and pull of everything that's going on with Veronica and Keith.

24:40Joanna Robinson:Something that they talked about a lot in interviews in terms of crafting season two is that Chris and Bella's in almost every single scene of season one of Veronica Mars. And that's true. And when you look at this story, which has an abc plot right the mr brooks sexual um misconduct plot you've got the logan looking for his mom plot and then you've got the lily kane murder mystery plot which is burbling underneath the whole season yeah abc plots all have veronica at the center of them and in the pilot which we will talk about in a second in terms of like why we didn't pick it has has abcd plots it's a lot happening all featuring veronica mars at the center of it so like this is something that the show learns like we cannot exhaust our young actress uh to this degree in in future seasons in terms of like is this a typical episode yes i would say so it is a like the main the a plot is uh you know something happening at the school to a student uh that is the week classic veronica In terms of the characters represented here, as you already mentioned, like, you know, Logan is heavily involved here.

25:52Joanna Robinson:Keith is heavily involved here because it's. Hey, Chicago, class it up with Crocs. You know, back to school is coming in fast. So why wait to find your new fave footwear? Step into a local Crocs store and step into your new look. Try it. Style it. Make it yours. Because the right pair doesn't just show up. It shows off. First day fits, handled. Walk out ready for whatever's next. Visit your nearest Croc store today. Now at Lowe's. Faster quotes start at the Lowe's Pro Desk. Got a material list handwritten on a sticky note or saved as a photo? Perfect. Bring it to us and get a quote in minutes.

26:37And if you don't see what you need on the shelf, we'll help you get it. You can access thousands of products beyond what's available in-store or on Lowe's.com, right from the Lowe's Pro Desk. Build quotes faster and source the materials you need to keep your jobs moving. Just like that at Lowe's.

26:55Joanna Robinson:This episode is brought to you by Welch's Fruit Snacks. Back-to-school season can be tough on parents. But choosing a snack you and your kids can both get behind doesn't have to be. stock up on welch's fruit snacks made with whole fruit and now made with no artificial dyes it's a snack kids already love and one you can feel good about giving them go back to school with welch's fruit snacks now made with no artificial dyes rsb mars keith is on one side veronica's on the other so there's that the gang's all here except for Mac but she was not a main character in season one uh and Dick and Beaver um all not main characters she's not in the pilot either she is like it kind of on re-watching season one it's sort of surprising to me actually how little Mac is used because she is such an important to me character going forward and to the internet you know yeah absolutely the net as she would probably call it do you have an episode and the honorary Bill Simmons MVP who won the episode trophy who would you give it to it's keith mars yeah he's extremely right he's on it he has the girl deserves to be heard the girl deserves to be heard he is on it like i really can't say enough about this performance and this character uh because yet again it's just like one of those things where the show does not function without him in that capacity and i think the pilot also does a very good job of setting up keith as being like very funny and like you already get a sense of his relationship with Veronica, but not as effectively as you can over the course of a full season.

Read the full transcript

28:29It's not all there yet, but the warmth is there.

28:32Joanna Robinson:I would say that his line in the pilot, which is, tonight we die in the lower middle class to which we aspire, is one of my favorite Veronica Mars lines. It's very good. I mean, the repetition of Who's Your Daddy is also very good. Honestly, every Keith Mars line is a banger and a winner. And his own arc throughout the course of the show in this season, as you said, a disgraced sheriff who's been run out of that job and run into all kinds of infamy as a result of trying to do his job and sometimes failing and sometimes succeeding, it could anchor its own show. And so it's always great to feel like with a show like Veronica Mars, it's like, yes, we are spending so much time at Neptune High, but there's this whole world of stuff happening in the background.

29:15And sometimes that world involves the police department. Sometimes it involves like high rise condominiums. Sometimes it involves, Joe, you and I are deep, neck deep in motorcycle gang culture lately and it's huge in veronica mars as well the pchers are

29:29Joanna Robinson:very important um in terms of like picking a scene that and a scene from this episode talking about how it embodies the show um i'm have to pick a veronica and logan scene just because of everything we said about that and something i wanted to add to that conversation is to say it's not just that tv itself can be a receptive medium it's not just a reactive medium it's not just that tv is a reactive medium especially inside of a 22 episode season but rob thomas himself in interviews has talked about how plugged in he was uh you know this comes out in 2005 um television without pity the uh very important tv recap and tv message board website genuinely really starts going 2002 and he talked about how he would read uh it religiously that he he was like uh in an interview i was watching he would say i was such a slut for it that i would read the message board reactions when the east coast uh when it would drop on the east coast so that by the time it aired here in california on the west coast uh i already knew how everyone felt about the episode um so this is this is someone who's just like in deep in television without pity culture this is a time when showrunners would just sort of like hop on the television without pity message boards yeah it was just like a real pivot point in terms of like the power of the fandom to directly interact with yes the creators and so i would say the logan and veronica stuff which comes out of not just something that the writers were observing but something that viewers were observing as well as undeniable thing dovetails into what we get in this episode is we get veronica and logan on a case there's like you know fun banter with them and the police station logan loses his temper that's very iconic and classic but i would say again when this is the bum fight guy you know like his temperament is what it is when he comes back between sort of between uh we're on the job scenes there's a he comes into mars investigation yes sort of a little contrite for losing his temper but he comes in swinging with sort of like an stg joke um says he avoids buildings with stained glass they banter about tabloids um you know she's like he's like this is what i'm paying for she's like i didn't know i didn't realize you were paying for this right and he says i mean we're not exchanging friendship bracelets and she says i'll stop braiding right so they're on this like tentative edge of something yeah but it's just like constant back and forth between these characters um that is very like Buffy Vampire Slayer Whedon-esque in its nature.

32:19Joanna Robinson:But I think that sort of tentative, what are we? Are we friends? Or is this just a job? And the fact that he's trying to figure out what happened to his mom, his mom has allegedly killed herself by jumping off a bridge. And he says, no way, that can't be true. Meanwhile, another side plot of this very busy season of television is veronica mars trying to figure out what's going on with her mom and so it's just like a very it's a it's a they gave logan a story that would be a key inside of veronica mars uh sympathies despite all the shit that he does at the beginning of this season and it works really really well here for her and for us you know i i think a lot of it too like you know logan may not like a stained glass window but the stained glass of mars investigations the like dancing lights off of the pool outside of veronica and keith's apartment that kind of pour in through the windows like there's these are they have to reuse the same locations over and over and over neptune high gets a ton of play mars investigations gets a ton of play and yet you bring it some life for scenes like that with the way you dress it up and just by just by being a little bit inventive with those sorts of trappings i think veronica mars does that consistently all across the board it's like how do we take something very worn in and familiar how do we take this like asshole guy like very sharp teenage girl how do we make that pairing feel different and new now the actors are bringing all that chemistry that as you mentioned was undeniable and irrepressible but there's also just the way that they're deployed in the show and i think a lot of that comes through here in terms of putting logan through the paces emotionally of having to confront his mother's potential suicide over and over and over with every new shred of evidence that is saying maybe she did in fact commit suicide and like seeing that version of that guy who in the actual pilot is mocking Veronica for her own mother's alcoholism be worn down by the process is just like that is what you make TV for like for those sorts of like slow like pounding the rock gradations of change like that's what it's all about that's what long-form storytelling is about absolutely um I do want to mention really quickly we haven't mentioned he's barely in this episode but Weevil a very important you mentioned the biker gangs i just want to say his line in this episode when logan he almost stole he almost won the who won the episode with this one line he lose a puka shell when logan storms out of the cafe is just like a top tier look he lose a puka shell is a top tier commentary on this character you were either there to understand the puka shells or you weren't and And if you're too young to understand the, I say, literal chokehold that the puka shells had on people, I don't pity you.

35:05You're better off.

35:06Joanna Robinson:I would say specifically the Logan Eccles type. A real Logan Eccles. But honestly, a Duncan Cain type as well. Really, the whole milieu. All the O-9ers. Yeah. Do you have a scene that you want to nominate that you feel like sort of typifies the series? Yeah. I mean, if you're hitting Logan, Veronica, I got to hit Veronica and Keith. And for me, it is the ink splatter coming out of the cracked safe. Establishing Veronica and Keith as like, for one, Veronica is exactly the kind of person who would be smart enough to know because of everything her dad has taught her. Someone's going to write down the combination to basically anything somewhere within range of that thing.

35:45and Keith is smart enough to know that he taught her that and that she will look for it and has established this elaborate bid just as a means to teach her a lesson on something that she should already be picking up on and further kind of entrenching us in the fact that Veronica is so deeply wrong about Mr. Brooks like she has just been told all this information that should sway her she goes to the safe anyway trying to crack it trying to get inside uh this girl who has accuse Mr. Brooks's diary, instead gets, you know, just like ink splattered all over her and yet still wants to continue trading notes, still wants to try to prove Mr.

36:22Brooks innocent. And I think the fact that Veronica is that wrong and that irrepressible at the same time is part of what makes that character so great. And the fact that Keith just wants to like warn her, but also teach her a lesson with a bit. Great dad. Just great dadding.

36:37Joanna Robinson:Keith has got some great dadding and some not so great dadding i would say inside of this episode a thing that i'm missing in this episode is a scene where veronica really really reckons with how wrong she was and how she was unwilling to listen to like a young woman even though like carrie bishop is covering for susan knight and there's all these hoops and she does sort of she sort of apologizes to carrie bishop and carrie's like fat lot of good that does me now yes uh she sort of apologizes to susan knight a little bit while pressuring her to report on the case, blah, blah, blah. And when she sort of apologizes to Keith, which she doesn't really, he says, if I were in trouble, I would want you on my side.

37:17Which is just like a very gentle,

37:21Joanna Robinson:kind thing to say to your daughter who has been royally fucking up for many days in a row here. All right. I will say too, Leighton Meester, I think, is quite good in this episode. Oh, yeah. She's great. And all of this, again, pre-gossip girl. So we're not even coded except by just Leighton Meester's general disposition to read her as like, oh, this is like a, you know, again, pardon the just direct rip, but like kind of a gossipy bitch. But like plays this really cleanly, really straight in a way that turns out to be like quite sympathetic, obviously, given the circumstances. But I think it's like a pretty good guest starring performance from her as well.

37:57Joanna Robinson:I really agree. What is the most 2005 thing about this episode? I have so many candidates. Fuka shells aside. Yeah. There is a line about that there's a jungle tribe that worships Donald Trump's hair. That's a line in this episode. We're just going to throw that out there. Visually speaking, I do think for Veronica Mars overall, in terms of the way the show is shot, the very like washed out, blown out blue filter flashbacks, extremely early 2000s stuff that we just don't make TV like that anymore. Which we kind of OD on in the first episode. Oh, yeah. if you were to pick one color to represent veronica mars oh wow what color would you would you pick i'm trying to reach for it i don't what do you have i can't tell if i'm being influenced by the cw logo but i really do think it's that lime green which was like so distinctive of the era the color of my imac at the time yes uh it's the color of veronica has like stained glass on her bedroom window that is that lime green that lime green just like pops up all over the place um i will say the phones in general yep uh i was watching this episode and and someone came in while i was watching it and they were aware of veronica mars but they thought it was a more recent show until they like get out the sidekicks or whatever it is like somewhere halfway through the episode they're like oh my god when did this take place i also thought it was a more recent show until i looked into the dead expanse of time i was like whoa this has been a minute it's been a minute uh there's a weakest link reference uh in this episode and it's from somebody who's supposedly cool very cool again there's there's supposedly a kid rock reference and i will say for the last 10 minutes of the episode veronica chris and bell is wearing the world's skinniest scarf which is the kissing cousin to the puk shell necklace so uh that's that's what i would say is the most 2005 thing about this episode the fashion of veronica mars is what it is i'm glad that by this point in the season we have gotten away from the pilot era uh kristin bell haircut or veronica mars haircut which was not her best look uh they've settled into something but it is still inescapably mid-2000s there's still like a lot of chokers a lot of vests a lot of like weird plaid pants there's there's a lot happening a A lot of Argyle.

40:21A lot of Argyle.

40:23Joanna Robinson:The note I wrote about her haircut in the pilot is it looks like she had her haircut by an angry lawnmower that was listening to Dirty by Christina Aguilar. Dirty with a lot of R's in it. Okay. How does this episode set up the rest of the series? I mean, I just would say the Logan and Veronica of it all. Obviously, Veronica chasing down incorrect leads is just going to be a hallmark of her entire life. Carrie Bishop we should say comes not played by Leighton Meester comes back in the Veronica Mars movie as a Susan Knight so you know Carrie Bishop could have been a big deal like they wish they could have had Leighton Meester back a lot for Carrie Bishop so what else would you say it sets up for the rest of the series?

41:07I think it's just those key relationships mostly the early stages of Veronica Mars in season one are so much more driven by Veronica operating an individual case, chasing other leads, again, with other supporting cast members. The one person we haven't really talked about who is not represented here, just in much volume, is Wallace. He's in the episode, but not really in the episode. That's a shame as far as giving you a fair representation of what the show is and who Veronica's key cast members around her, what the actual ensemble looks like. But the core representations are all there. I would say not just Logan and Veronica, not just Veronica and Keith, Veronica and Neptune, and the broader high school ecosystem is obviously something really important to understand.

41:51I think this episode establishes that stuff as well as any of them do.

41:55Joanna Robinson:The other thing that I had forgotten, this episode ends with an Abel Kuntz button, where Veronica goes to visit this guy who's in jail for Lily Kane's murder. I forgot how hard they stepped on the hand of the lector gas with Abel Kuntz. It's to the point of even almost doing a Clarice Starling accent. accent yeah it's it's there's a lot happening in this show this is another thing though it's like if you are looking for television entertainments that are naturalistic in origin and make you feel like oh this is how real people talk this is not the show for you this is a show where an entire gaggle of high school girls know every word to don't stand so close to me i did write that down like it's just all those oh nine our girls know every every single word and that's like that's just what the show is and we're going to have like line by line references to the outsiders you know it's just like there's just gonna be things like that that happen and are really enjoyable and are kind of feeding into the feel of the show but look it's a gumshoe detective show more than it is a high school show and it has that sort of like brick superimposed trapping of genre on setting like the film brick that i think works so well here too wow just a couple weeks ago you referenced Looper on the Alien Earth podcast.

43:09Joanna Robinson:Now you're here with Brick. You're in your Rian Johnson, Joseph Gordon-Levitt era. There are worse things to be than a Rian Johnson shill. I'm happy to participate. I will say there's a Brothers Bloom reference coming up on our Prestige TV episode this weekend on the first episode of Task. So stay tuned for that. Okay. In terms of the pilot,

43:31Joanna Robinson:one thing we should reference. If you go ahead, if you're like, Rob and Joanna love the show, I'll watch the show. I've never watched it before. I'll go ahead and buy it a season of it on on the streaming platform of my choice well not just that i'm seeing you can buy season one on ebay for five dollars i bet you can get it for even cheaper than that to be honest with you and this is what we would advise because the dvd pilot is different from the pilot that streams online there is a cold open that i think is kind of crucial for setting the tone that was cut from the original airing and for and is it does not exist on the on the streaming uh version of the episode either so in discussing the pilot we should say the cold open that existed went on the version that you and i watched is veronica on a stakeout at the camelot motel yes uh she's talking about how she's never going to get married she's talking about how sleazy all these you know people are here having their hookups at the motel she's got her calculus uh book there on the car seat next to her long lens uh camera very cheeky but what rob thomas talked about is he was like i was making a high school show and the network said it has to start if it's a high school show it has to start at the high school so instead we get cut to the first scene after the credits um veronica rolling up to uh to the high school and she has a voice over where she's like some kids work at taco bell i'm a private detective so like everything that that cold open establishes with his context becomes like voice over uh you know so i'm just i'm advocating uh if you still own a dvd player hunt down the veronica mart dvds for a couple on eBay, you won't regret it.

45:15Joanna Robinson:I promise. The UPN executives were not doing us any favors in the battle against Pluck. You know, it's like, it's real tough when you set it up that way. But again, if you just show Veronica in action, even I can't believe you let Van infect your mind with his Pluck agenda. I really can't. I don't think, generally speaking, I have much more of an appetite for it than Van does, but this is a very real thing. Like, people are gonna have a somewhat allergic response to just the trappings and the setting of this show. and if you can get through that and I think one easy way to do it is show Veronica being something more than just an average teenager, all of a sudden now you're cooking with something.

45:51Now you're seeing her and I think also most crucially in terms of that cold open like somebody who can handle herself. She's a do-gooder sometimes, she's a troublemaker at other times but she's somebody who like you can understand her being thrown into some pretty extreme situations and she can kind of find her way out with the help of a dog and a taser. I will

46:10Joanna Robinson:say that the the way in which this pilot episode abuses the flashback and the voiceover yeah is quite extraordinary on rewatch again i do like this pilot there it is it very deftly weaves uh a logan plot a weevil plot a cliff plot uh you know all these things together and also a sheriff lamb plot like everything sort of like comes in together in the most satisfying little braid you ever did see and the pchers like everything wallace etc etc is all woven together in sort of like one triumphant knocking over the dominoes moment for veronica bars i will say i do think veronica would have an easier time in life if she didn't show up to things to gloat she does it a couple times on the pilot and i'm like you could just execute your little schemes without cheekily finger gunning at the people that you have uh have screwed over but who would she be if she did you're talking about a fundamentally different character you know like if if she's not there to say like this is my over the moon face like what show are we even watching um the tone of all of these voiceovers is essentially yep that's me that you wondered how i got here um and again And it's trying to tell us a lot about Veronica's best friend who was murdered, how her father lost his job, where her mother is, this sexual assault that happened to her.

47:43Joanna Robinson:It's just how her social status changed, all these various things. It's just trying to lift a lot in the pilot. It's a lot to try to take care of. I do have an incredible amount of admiration for that, like how much it is endeavoring to put forth in front of us. and you alluded to the characters, like even just establishing like Lamb, for example, pretty clearly in a very limited amount of screen time. Something that's very hard to do in a pilot, even an extended one. And so the fact that they're able to cover that much ground is great. I find the pilot to be the kind of episode that like, as I am watching it now, having seen Veronica Mars, I have a lot of affection for that pilot.

48:21And I'm like, man, I just love this show. But as putting myself in the shoes or the seat of a first time viewer, it's like, this is a lot that you're just kind of hurling at me and expecting me to not just like get my bearings, but understand kind of the plotting through lines of what this episode is about.

48:37Joanna Robinson:I think the only reason this worked in a way that it shouldn't be, because now if you show this episode, if you show this season to someone, let's say you don't get all the way to episode 14, but you're like, okay, hang with me for the pilot. Okay, now we got to get through a Paris Hilton episode. It's kind of like episode four is sort of like when you'd be like, okay, are you here with me? But like, I just think it's like the fact that they have Kristen Bell, who will later make a fortune just doing cheeky voiceover work in Gossip Girl is what saves the pilot from being an absolute train wreck.

49:14Joanna Robinson:because she reads the flashback, you know, even when it is something as devastating as the sexual assault at the party morning after scene with this just momentum that keeps you going. But it is, I think, a tough sell for people who have never experienced Veronica Mars. When I was watching a bunch of episodes to sort of prep for this, the person who wandered in and was like, oh, wow, those phones are sure are old sort of just like got hooked and sat down and was like sort of watching it and they were like okay i get it it's fun to watch her do her thing it is like that is veronica mars it is fun to watch her do her thing it's really good it and again to watch like within that kristin bell do her thing as as you're setting up with the voiceover like there there are just some performances and some shows where it's like holy shit the star power of this person that you know found might be a little extreme but like kristin bell was not holding down roles like this before Veronica Mars.

50:11It was very much like a put her in a slightly different light.

50:14Joanna Robinson:Her Deadwood guest star. I love her appearance on Deadwood and it plays into some of the sort of like ingenue appearance of naivety that she has like leveraged in almost every six, like all of her great roles since then. Like there is a way that Kristen Bell looks and plays against type that I think makes her so dynamic as a performer. But a lot of kind of her getting more serious dramatic role starts here. And I think what's so interesting about the way it has all unfolded is like, even though she and Logan had that chemistry, like the same has not been true for Jason Doring. Like he has not had the same kind of arc for her as her.

50:49Like even just like somebody who has kind of disappeared, accepting the Veronica Mars reboot, which he came back for.

50:55Joanna Robinson:I feel like it's been like a curse for him almost. I don't know. um i will say in terms of like iconic moments in this pilot your marshmallow veronica mars is what the fandom eventually is called marshmallows like that's eventually what the veronica mars fandom so that comes from this obviously the keith mars tonight we died like the lower middle class to which we aspire is from this episode very important and you mentioned the outsiders that be cool soda pop line which she says to wallace after he mentions the outsiders i think i thought that was an outsider's line i say that all the time is that not an outsider's i'm not gonna i also thought it was just a straight up outsider's line soda pop is a character from the outsiders but if you google be cool soda pop you will get veronica bars it's not from the outsiders but i say that all the time if like uh if like a a dog is sort of like being antsy whatever i'll be like be cool soda pop like it's just a thing that i say that i got from veronica mars that i thought i got from the outsiders uh for a long time so that's the way in which uh pop culture referential writer's rooms will screw you sometimes you know especially with stuff like i mean veronica mars is so good at it in terms of the little turns of phrase that just worm their way into your brain and never quite leave you.

52:16And it's like, there are funny shows that are well-written shows that are really dynamic and interesting shows that just don't have that kind of stick. It's you remember the character, you remember the plot line, maybe you remember like your emotional reaction to a thing. But this is just one of those shows where the writing alone will become like a part of your life as you watch it.

52:33Joanna Robinson:Yeah. Anything else you want to say about the pilot before we get into sort of like deep, dark, scary spoiler territory? I think we covered most of it. I mean, we haven't covered this part specifically, but the opening theme, the Dandy Warhols, lights out from minute one. Just like, okay, we got it. You know, there's so – I feel like I've been subject to a lot of really shitty opening themes. We're just like really like thoughtless. Like, okay, here's a placeholder that we never quite got around to putting something else in for. This is perfect. It's so good. It introduced me to the Dandy Warhols, which is a great band.

53:09Joanna Robinson:What a gift. and they show up in a later episode right i believe so there's like a karaoke night where chris bell sings again in in the buffy vein it's just like you just gotta have the band on it yeah just have the yeah just invite nerf herder to come on anyway um yes which i think you don't get the theme song uh in the pilot so that's another way in which it is really uh missing something here. Anything else you want to say? I think we covered it. I think the pilot overall still a worthy enough place to start. But as I said, I've had trouble just getting people to watch this show. And if the way to do it is by hooking Adam Scott or a guest star on and putting people in through the side door, so be it.

53:51Let's do it.

53:52Joanna Robinson:Clever. Very clever. All right. I want to get into the big time spoiler section because it helps make our point in a way that I feel disinclined to spoil people on. So this is your warning. We're very serious about this warning. If you have not seen this show and you're not convinced yet, one, you're wrong. You, like Veronica, are thinking you're interpreting the evidence here and you are interpreting incorrectly. I need you to leave and think about what you've done and reconsider your life choices. Hopefully watch Veronica Mars, but at minimum, if you've not seen Veronica Mars, don't listen to this section.

54:22Joanna Robinson:We will be back on Sunday with Bill to cover the first episode of Task, a new HBO series that absolutely rules So please come back and listen to that. And we'll be back with another hooked episode on Lost next week, which I'm really excited about. So that's a little like tease. Come back, please. Before we get into the spoilers to really give everyone time to dry the like soapy water off your hands and press stop or pause or whatever you need to do on here. Okay. In season four, Veronica Mars. You've shown a lot of a lot of restraint. Thank you. I'm not as twisted up about this as other people are.

54:59Joanna Robinson:Because, I don't know, when a reboot happens, I'm just sort of like, well, any extra time is extra time. And that is what it is. At the end of the eight episodes of the fourth season of Veronica Mars, Veronica and Logan get married. And then that same day, he gets blown up and is killed. Yep. And the fandom was so mad about this. the fandom that like sparked back to life with the kickstarter for the movie absolutely just like was really living i actually didn't really love that movie i felt like it was too fan servicey and very product placement it's not very effective no i don't think it's great but um i do think that they did some great some good stuff i think with season four and i think the idea of wanting to return to veronica as an adult um having you know lived you know through the things that she's lived through was a good idea.

55:50Joanna Robinson:Kristen Bell was interested in living in the world of this character. They killed Logan. I understand why. Yep. Because, again, that relationship just sort of swallowed the show. You could not give Veronica another love interest because, you know, our guy Piz can really attest to that. Like, everyone will hate. You're telling me off mic, Joe, that you thought Piz was like the one true pairing for Veronica. Don't try to entrap me. in your lives rob mahoney i'm just saying you mentioned before piz chris lowell a real champ showed up for the movie is great it's kind of great in the movie um like you can't put veronica with anyone else am i misremembering is he working at this american life yes he is i think ira glass is in it yeah is in the movie yeah that sounds right for piz i think um i just i understand that they felt like they had written themselves into a corner.

56:47Joanna Robinson:I just have never seen a fandom turn on a creator. They were so mad. I mean, end of Game of Thrones, maybe comp, honestly, inside of this fandom. I have never seen anyone as mad as the Veronica Mars fan was that Logan Echols was killed off at the end of season four. And then they had planned to make more seasons and they just didn't because the hue and cry was so loud. And genuinely, I was just trying to Google, like get interviews of Rob Thomas from season one. And I was putting in all these parameters in my search term and all i could get i mean first of all google's kind of broken because ai is stupid and wrong but also just like i the the absolute avalanche of articles and interviews about this pop culture event that i was like wow i knew people were mad i just didn't know it was this deep and also on like the i was like you know put around the veronica mars reddit boards and a bunch of people are like the phantom just died after they did this and i was i mean it's stunning so it just really underlines the argument that you were making that the logan and veronica relationship which gets starts to get its legs under it inside of mars v mars is the show it kind of is the show that said those people were big mad about logan dying in season four I was big mad at them being big mad because I really like season four and I really like the idea of a clean slate Veronica moving like poker face but making Veronica Mars that's what I was hoping for oh my god like the potential for that with this character I think would have been incredible and I I for one I this is this is my thing about TV I love the reactionary elements that we've talked about where you can shape and guide a show depending on what's working and what's not there's also this fact that like things are of their time and some things you have to just like let go of and it's going to be disruptive it's going to be controversial but like sometimes you have to kill off really beloved characters and i think having actual stakes and repercussions for the shit that veronica is getting into is what makes this show good the fact that some days she's going to show up to a biker bar and it's like holy shit this is dangerous not just like a girl playing at detective is what made the show good and so the fact that there are actual costs I was here for that I mean I'm not saying like the show did that I think quite well in season 2 because I loved the character Beaver and I was absolutely devastated personally devastated at the ending of season 2 so like the show has done it before and I agree like I was actually kind of defensive of the choice in terms of if they want this story to continue and they want Veronica to sort of like be free to do other things and to move and shake and not be in the same cycle of the same relationship.

59:32Joanna Robinson:They had to do it. And I, yeah. Anyway, Jason Doering deserves the world. He's so good. I think Rob Thomas should just create a show for Jason Doering that is just like, which is just like, just make it basically Logan. Just don't even try. It's fine. Just have him play basically Logan. We're all cool with it. We'd be really into it. So he deserves as much as Kristen Bell does a career, I think. So, yeah. I do think these shows and these characters do also struggle with something, which is when you have the bad boy, bleached blonde hair, asshole character that we've been talking about all episode.

1:00:14When you do make him into the like good boyfriend, there is a little bit of a plot vacuum of like, well, now if he's not starting bum fights, what do we have this guy do? And some of the solution for that for season four is, oh, we kind of dial up some of Veronica's mess even more. And then he can be the sort of stabilizing contrast piece. But then that's getting away from some of the edge that people like in Logan in the first place. And so there's kind of a no-win situation that develops with characters like that.

1:00:40Joanna Robinson:Which they address in a meta way in season four in that episode where he's like, he punches a hole in the pantry. And then they have rough sex. And he's like, is this what you missed? This guy? And she's like, yeah, it was great. He's like, I'm going to therapy, man. It is, in fact, what they and she missed. I have been going to therapy. And she's like, I'm not interested. So, yeah, it's a no-win situation. But when it was good, it was very good. And when it was good, it was season one. I would say season one, season two. Season one, perfect. Season two, really good. Season three, to me, mixed bag.

1:01:14Joanna Robinson:But, you know. I could be talked into season two being even better. I think some of the highs might be even higher. One overall might hang together a little more. Veronica Mars also has that thing where it's like the longer you go into it, the more certain events are almost like retconned into complications that make it hard to even remember. Like, wait, who was it that did what? Was it this person who left the room then? And this person like there's a lot happening that you need to keep track of. And it keeps deepening and changing over time. It makes it hard to kind of separate one season from another, too.

1:01:42Joanna Robinson:I think the mystery of season one, Who Killed Lily Kane, is so good. And I think the Aaron Eccles reveal is so good that it's hard to top in season two with Steve Goodenberg, with love and respect to Steve Goodenberg. I love Steve Goodenberg. Good's great. While we're in the broader Rob Thomas universe, the Steve Goodenberg episode of Party Down is just one of the greatest episodes of TV that's ever been made. Absolutely rock solid. Very good. All right. So this has been another hooked episode. We suggest you watch Party Down. We suggest you watch Veronica Bars. Definitely. We suggest you watch Buffy the Vampire Slayer.

1:02:16Joanna Robinson:Of course. You should watch all the things that are very important to us because our taste is perfect. We will be back, as I mentioned, with the first episode of Task and also Rob's introduction to the television series Lost. I can't wait. I cannot believe I get to talk to you about the first two episodes. We're going to be doing the two-part pilot of Lost is what we're doing. I'm feeling a lot of pressure, Joe. No. Just as somebody who obviously Lost means a great deal to you, I am now on the other end of the like recommending Veronica Mars chain. I'm really confident. I'm really confident, Rob, that you're going to enjoy the pilot of loss.

1:02:53I hope you're right.

1:02:55Joanna Robinson:And then we've got two more shows that we plan to do after that. And then that wraps up our first arc of the of of Hooked because task will be going. So horses is coming. We've got a lot. I'm not giving up. I am selling the building. the final season of fx is the bear the restaurant is flooded everything's either going to be okay or not we are outgunned and we are outmanned but we have each other fx is the bear the final season all episodes now streaming on disney plus coming this fall so uh We will see you soon. Press TV at Spotify.com. If you, if you have any Veronica Mars thoughts, Oh, I would love to hear them.

1:03:42Joanna Robinson:If you have any Logan Eccles thoughts, if you have any lost thoughts for Rob, no spoilers on those, please. No, no, no, of course not. And we will see you soon. Bye.

From the publisher

Hooked continues! This time, Jo and Rob take us back to 2005 to make the case for Kristen Bell’s star-making series, ‘Veronica Mars’.

00:00  Intro

05:14  Rob’s elevator pitch

08:45  The Episode: ‘Mars v. Mars’

17:57  Guest/recurring stars

24:42  Episode MVP

26:20  A scene that embodies the show

37:25  How this episode sets up the series

40:16  The pilot episode

50:43  **SPOILERS**

Email us! prestigetv@spotify.com

Subscribe to the Ringer TV YouTube channel here for full episodes of ‘The Prestige TV Podcast’ and so much more!

Hosts: Joanna Robinson and Rob Mahoney 

Producers: Kai Grady and Donnie Beacham Jr.

Video supervision: Chris Thomas

Additional Production Support: Justin Sayles
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from The Prestige TV Podcast

All 102 episodes
The ‘Veronica Mars’ Episode That Got Us HookedThe Prestige TV Podcast · 1 h 3 min
Listen in VO