No Mercy / No Malice: Guardrails

0:28Support for this show comes from Aura Frames. Steel is exclusive to listeners and frames sell out fast, so orders you now to get it in time for the holidays and support the show by mentioning us at checkout. Terms and conditions apply.

0:45Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start? Thumbtack knows homes, so you don't have to. Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin, or what that clunking sound from your dryer is? With Thumbtack, you don't have to be a home pro. You just have to hire one. You can hire top-rated pros, see price estimates, and read reviews all on the app. Download today. I'm Scott Galloway, and this is No Mercy, No Malice. Tech has embarked on its next adventure, artificial intelligence. This could mean rapid innovation, increased productivity, and another tsunami of societal harms.

1:27Now is our moment to protect ourselves from ourselves, not with a pause, but with government oversight. Guardrails, as read by George Hahn.

1:48Last week, we learned about a significant leak of classified material that exposed key details of the Ukrainian war effort and America's security apparatus. The perpetrator? Not an extremist group or criminal network, but someone we're more familiar with. A young man who spends too much time online Technology and our inability to regulate it Have again made things worse Much worse The leaker's preferred platform was Discord Which has been used to share child pornography And coordinate the white supremacist riots in Charlottesville Discord is not alone Recently, Instagram assisted the suicide of a young British girl by serving her images of nooses and razor blades.

2:38Facebook fueled a mob riot in Myanmar. The list goes on. Teen depression, viral misinformation, widespread distrust of national institutions, polarization, algorithms optimized for rage and radicalization. We've discussed this before. What's startling about this latest scandal is the banality. A reckless young man trying to gain social status online accidentally shapes world events. Steve Jobs called computers bicycles for the mind because they amplify our capabilities dramatically. It's a nice image. A more apt analogy for many young men, however, is a Kawasaki H2 Mach 4, a motorcycle that possessed far too much power and had a rear-biased weight balance that made it an accident waiting to happen.

3:31Too much power, not enough balance, and injury is inevitable. Tech has become a bullet bike, a reliable source of disturbing accidents and organ donations.

3:46People have always been stupid, and everyone is stupid some of the time. Note, Professor Cipolla's definition is people whose actions are destructive to themselves and to others. One of society's functions is to prevent a tragedy of the commons by building safeguards to protect us from our own stupidity. We usually call this regulation, a word Reagan and Thatcher made synonymous with bureaucrats and red tape. Yes, air traffic control delays and the DMV are super annoying, but not crashing into another A350 on approach to Heathrow, not suffocating as your throat swells from an allergic reaction, and being able to access the funds in your FTX account are all really awesome.

4:38Sixty years ago, the U.S. registered more than 50 ,000 car crash deaths annually. So we created the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration And charged it with making the roads safer If you're under 60, this may be hard to imagine But not that long ago, many Americans saw seatbelts as an assault on their personal liberty Some cut them out of their cars Democracy bested stupidity, however And between 1966 and 2021, vehicular death rates in America were halved The NHTSA is one of the many boring federal agencies critical to a healthy society. Before the Food and Drug Administration, the sale and distribution of food and pharmaceuticals was a free-for-all.

5:27The Federal Aviation Administration is the reason your chances of dying in a plane crash are 1 in 3.37 billion. Next time someone tells you they don't trust government, ask them if they trust cars, food, painkillers, buildings, or airplanes. The limits on innovation imposed by these agencies, their red tape, are real and worth it. Millions of us are alive and prospering because we had the foresight and discipline to blunt the sharp end of industrial progress with the guardrails of democratic oversight. until you open your phone. The greatest anomaly in the history of U.S. regulation is the place more and more of us spend most of our time, online.

6:19A lethal cocktail of complexity, lobbying, cultural worship of tech leaders, and anti-government libertarian screed has rendered tech immune to the basic standards of safety and protection. Lethal is the correct term. Tech comes into the purview of other agencies on occasion, though it's always bitching it's special and shouldn't be restrained by the olds at the FTC and DOJ. Our government should, I think, just try to get out of the way and not impede progress. And the industry's blocking efforts have been effective. There is no FDA or SEC for tech, which is America's largest sector by market capitalization and growing.

7:04The justification for this was the go-to new economy get-out-of-jail-free word. Innovation. When tech was nascent and niche, we were smart to err on the side of growth versus regulation. That movie ended a decade ago. Phones aren't toys for early adopters, and search and social have moved beyond campuses. We don't require a license to drive a big wheel, but if a big wheel 5G went 750 miles per hour, we might restrict access or at least demand airbags. The go-to narrative for these platforms after every new disaster is the delusion of complexity and that the Internet is just another communications technology, like the phone or a letter, a reflection of society, and it would be near impossible to put guardrails in place.

8:00Also, sprinkle in some blather regarding free speech. This is all bullshit. AI can write a Seinfeld script in the voice of Shakespeare. It can scan platforms for words and images associated with risks. They're already doing it for signals you might be shopping for Crocs. But what's the incentive for a platform to make the investment in any editorial review? Other than decency and regard for others, that is? We've done a good job stupid-proofing the offline world, but that's increasingly not where we live. Especially younger people who now spend roughly the same amount of time online as they do sleeping.

8:46They, we, pass the majority of our waking hours riding in a vehicle with no airbags, licenses, or traffic lights. Plus, there are millions of autonomous vehicles on the road controlled by unknown actors, and they're prone to running over pedestrians. Tech is embarking on its next big adventure, artificial intelligence, which likely means rapid innovation, increased productivity, and another tsunami of unforeseen societal harms. Predicting how AI will tear the fabric of civilization is the new bingo. Humanoid phishing scams that access bank accounts. AI-generated camera footage and headlines that make the truth increasingly opaque.

9:33Rogue AI gods determined to eradicate humanity. Experts agree all of this is possible. What's telling is the technologists' collective reaction to their own creation. For the first time, they want to slow down. A few weeks ago, they wrote a petition calling on AI labs to immediately pause all training of the most powerful AI models for six months. Hundreds of tech leaders signed the letter. The CEO of OpenAI, Sam Altman Who started the hype spiral with ChatGPT Says he's scared of his company's own algorithms One AI expert said the six-month moratorium isn't harsh enough Instead, he says, shut it all down What undermined the veracity of the letter was one signatory Elon Musk who's asked others to pause as he fast-tracks his own AI programs.

10:38As usual, he's full of shit. We should grab this opportunity with both hands. Specifically, both hands on the wheel. Not a pause, which in my view is a bad idea. China, Russia, and North Korea won't pause. If the guy who just disappeared my blue check hadn't been kicked out of open AI and controlled it instead, Do you think he'd be advocating for a pause? Better idea. The 78 podcasts that garner more downloads than the Prof G-Pod should suspend their programming. You know, just to get our arms around this new and potentially dangerous podcast medium. But we do need to seize this moment, likely brief, when some tech leaders have remembered the virtues of government oversight.

11:24We need a serious, sustained, and centralized effort at the federal level. perhaps a new cabinet-level agency, to take the lead in regulating. We can call it AI because pretty soon AI will be everywhere in tech. There have been efforts at comprehensive technology regulation we can pick up and carry across the finish line. For example, last year, Senator Michael Bennett proposed the Digital Platform Commission Act, which would create a federal body to, quote, provide reasonable oversight and regulation of digital platforms, unquote. In other words, exactly what we're talking about. But it's still stuck at the introduced stage.

12:07As with any political issue, it needs public support. What won't work is fake regulation. When the government issues broad, vague statements about what companies should generally do. That's what Biden did with crypto, and he's doing it again with AI. specifically his Blueprint for an AI Bill of Rights, which is filled with truisms, platitudes, and no laws. Similarly, the NIST published its AI Risk Management Framework. Again, not laws. Earlier this month, a tech executive was tragically stabbed and died. Outspoken members of the tech industry immediately speculated the killer was a psychotic homeless person.

12:55A few days later, an acquaintance of the victim, also a tech entrepreneur, was arrested and charged. Note, the homeless are more likely to be victims of crime than perpetrators. The above is another variation on a story told repeatedly across an innovation economy where we have incorrectly conflated wealth and innovation with character. A growing vein of the tech community, venture catastrophists, deploy weapons of mass distraction and fear to wallpaper over an inconvenient truth. The menace unleashed on America the past two decades isn't psychotic homeless people or a crime wave, but a tech community whose products depress our teens, polarize our public, and render our discourse more coarse, making it less likely we come together and address issues including homelessness and crime.

13:55Our failure to regulate this sector, as we have done with every other sector, is stupid.

14:05Life is so rich.

14:21Support for this show comes from Odoo. Running a business is hard enough, so why make it harder with a dozen different apps that don't talk to each other? Introducing Odoo. It's the only business software you'll ever need. It's an all-in-one, fully integrated platform that makes your work easier. CRM, accounting, inventory, e-commerce, and more. And the best part? Odoo replaces multiple expensive platforms for a fraction of the cost. That's why over thousands of businesses have made the switch. So why not you? Try Odoo for free at odoo.com. That's O-D-O-O dot com.

15:02This next one's for all you CarMax shoppers who just want to buy a car your way. Wanna check some cars out in person? Uh-huh Wanna look some more from your house? Okay Wanna pretend you know about engines? Nah, I'll just chat with CarMax online instead Wanna get pre-qualified from your couch? Woo! Wanna get that car? Hey, that's a beat! You wanna do it your way Wanna drive? CarMax