Is The Bear REALLY a Comedy?

16 Sep 2024 · 47 min

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

The Rest Is Entertainment - Episode Summary

Episode Title

Is The Bear REALLY a Comedy?

Podcast Overview Hosts: Richard Osman & Marina Hyde Description: This episode dives into the blurred lines between genres in television, focusing on the Emmy-winning series "The Bear," the current state of the West End theatre scene, and the contentious intersection of music and politics through the lens of Jack White's legal actions against Donald Trump.

---

Key Discussions

  1. The Genre Debate: Is "The Bear" a Comedy?
  2. Premise: Despite featuring intense and dramatic moments, "The Bear" is categorized as a comedy at major awards like the Emmys.
  3. Critical Insights:
  4. Richard Osman and Marina Hyde discuss the disparity between the show's content and its classification.
  5. Audience Reaction: There is a growing sentiment that "The Bear" is not a comedy but rather a drama tackling severe themes, which complicates its acceptance in comedic categories.
  6. Implications for Comedy: The categorization raises concerns about taking awards away from traditional comedy shows, leading to debates on what constitutes comedy in modern television.
  1. The State of West End Theatre
  2. Current Performance: The West End is reported to be thriving post-COVID, with numerous musicals based on films doing exceptionally well (e.g., "Mean Girls," "Moulin Rouge").
  3. Concerns of Creativity:
  4. Richard expresses concerns about the reliance on existing intellectual properties (IP) for new productions.
  5. The hosts discuss the balance between financial success and creative originality, questioning if reliance on adaptations might stifle new ideas in theatre.
  1. The White Stripes vs. Donald Trump
  2. Jack White's Lawsuit: Jack White is suing Donald Trump for unauthorized use of his song "Seven Nation Army."
  3. Broader Context: This discussion touches on the wider trend of artists suing politicians over the use of their music without permission, highlighting the ongoing tension between artistic integrity and political exploitation.
  4. Historical Perspective: The hosts recount how various artists have reacted to their music being co-opted by political figures, noting the long-standing tradition of campaign music in American politics.

---

Recommendations

  • Marina's Book Recommendation: *Rivals* by Jilly Cooper (1980s novel, soon to be adapted for Disney Plus)
  • Summary: A humorous and engaging story filled with romance and social commentary reflective of the 1980s, yet remains relevant today.

---

Additional Notes

  • Emmy Awards Discussion: The hosts reflect on the recent Emmys, noting predictable winners and pointing out the dynamics of award nominations, including the influence of previous successes on current nominations.
  • Industry Insights: The episode highlights the financial aspects of theatre productions, the significance of successful runs, and how touring can elevate lesser-known shows to broader audiences.

---

Closing Thoughts The hosts conclude the episode with a light-hearted banter about upcoming topics and encourage listener engagement through questions and comments. They emphasize the importance of understanding the intricate relationships between genre, audience expectations, and artistic expression in the entertainment landscape.

---

Social Media & Contact

  • Website: [therestisentertainment.com](http://therestisentertainment.com)
  • Twitter: [@restisents](https://twitter.com/restisents)
  • Instagram: [@restisentertainment](https://www.instagram.com/restisentertainment)
  • Email: therestisentertainment@gmail.com

---

This markdown summary encapsulates the main themes and discussions from the podcast episode, providing insights into the evolving landscape of television and theatre.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00At Sierra, discover top workout gear at incredible prices, which might lead to another discovery. Your headphones haven't been connected this whole time. Awkward. Discover top brands at unexpectedly low prices. Sierra, let's get moving. I'm NFL linebacker TJ Watt, and this is my personal best. YPB by Abercrombie is the activewear I'm always wearing. That's why I reached out to co-design their latest drop. I worked with designers to create high-performance activewear that holds up to my toughest workouts. Shop YPB by Abercrombie in-store, online, and in the app. Because your personal best is greater than anything.

0:59So no one forgets mom's 60th and never miss a meme or milestone all protected with end-to-end encryption It's time for whatsapp message privately with everyone learn more at whatsapp.com

1:14Hello and welcome to this episode of the rest is entertainment with me marina hyde and me richard osman Hello, everybody. Hello marina. Hello, richard. How are you? How has your publication week been? I would say busy. I was just saying to you, it's been weeks since we've done a podcast and it wasn't. It was six days ago. Yes, I've spoken a lot. And it's lovely to be able to speak about other people's work now instead of mine. Huge congratulations. And we want to hear much more about it always. My favourite thing is always going from TalkSport to Times Radio and having to remember which one you're on.

1:42That's the key. Slightly switching your personality. Do you recalibrate yourself? Yeah, 100%. I mean, TalkSport's my favourite because I talk about the book for a minute and then I can talk about Fulham for 10 minutes. Then you go on Times Radio, you have to talk about quantitative easing or something. But listen, I can turn my hands to both. Of course you can. And we're talking about quantitative easing today. You are a renaissance man. So this week we are going to talk about, we'll talk a bit about the Emmys, which happened on Sunday night or into Monday morning if you live in the UK. Which we do.

2:11Which we do. So we will talk about the White Stripes are suing Trump for using, one of a million artists who are not happy with Donald Trump using their music, but are actually suing. So we'll talk a little bit about that. We're also going to talk about whether it's the White Stripes or the White Stripes. What is it? The White Stripes. The White Stripes. Well, I'll just have to say it in context. I know you've made me think about it too hard. They're not even words any longer. Wait, we'll hear it in context and then you can pull me up on it. We'll be talking about that and a sort of history of songs that have been used by various campaigns as well.

2:47But we're going to start with... So musicals, okay, West End musicals that are based on movies. Okay, right. In the West End right now, or currently, or about to open, are Mean Girls, the musical Back to the Future, Moulin Rouge, Mrs. Doubtfire, Facing the Crowd, Dirty Rotten Scoundrels, Devil Wears Prada is about to open, The Producer is about to open, The Lion King, obviously that's been open, that absolute behemoth. And then you've got things like Magic Mike, Ghost in Concert, My Neighbour Tutorial, Silence the musical, which is like a parody Silence of the Lambs musical. And then last week it was announced that there are two new musicals based on movies coming to the West End.

3:26Clueless, which is coming to the Trafalgar Theatre, and Titanic, which is at the Criterion, which is a bit of a parody of the movie, but it has the Celine Dion songs and so on. So one of the things that's really interesting is that it all sort of sprung from some years ago, Universal Studios, the movie people, realised that actually the most successful thing they'd basically ever made ever, ever was not a movie, but was the musical Wicked. And what happened with that one was the books done by someone called Winnie Holtzman, but Stephen Schwartz did the music and lyrics and he'd read this book, which was based, you know, the sort of prequel story to The Wizard of Oz on a holiday, I think.

4:05And he'd said, oh, I really want to do this. And he found that Universal, unfortunately, had the rights to it. And they were, you know, saying, oh, well, we're going to make a movie about it. It was like, sure you are. They were probably never going to do it. which is one of many, many things they held the rights to. And he managed to persuade them to let him do it as a musical. I mean, that thing, it makes billions, OK? It makes absolutely billions. And so what suddenly started happening... By the way, I talked to a theatre producer this week. He said, do you know that the work of creative art in the whole of history that has made the most money in any genre, so music, film, video game, anything, is Lion King the musical.

4:40It's made more money than any other piece of art in the history of pieces of art. And the reason that these things make money, and we'll come in deeper depth to this in a minute, is that they obviously they make money in their original markets. Maybe it's Broadway, maybe it's the West End, but it's touring. It's going on the road that you make unbelievable amounts of money within the US and then around the world. OK, so having really slightly patronised theatre for a long time in the 20th century, the movies were like, right, we need to have lots of significant appointments and people are going to head up our theatre divisions on Broadway.

5:16So that went on. And as you can see, there's lots of successful musicals. But now lots of them are starting in London, which is really interesting. First of all, some good news, which is that the West End is in rude health. It has come back completely after Covid. Booming. Yeah, beyond. There's no dark theatre. This is not something you hear people in theatre. People in theatre are always telling you that their business is on the edge of the cliff. Now, Broadway hasn't come back as well. There's numbers of reasons for that. People think that it hasn't come back as well after the pandemic. Sometimes people are staying away.

5:48Maybe there are fewer office workers or people, suburbanites who will come in at the weekend. Whatever's happened, they are losing money on Broadway. I think over the summer they lost$250 million. Wow. We'll come to how we know how much they lose in America. Oh, great. We declined to talk about this in our country. Anyway, but a show in Broadway, if you want to put a show on in Broadway. Which I do. Which you do. Yeah. It costs, well, first of all, start here, Richard, which I'm sure you will. Yeah, sure. It costs about five times as much to do it there. So if you put on a show here, you might, something that costs like a million pounds to put on here could cost$8 million over there.

6:24and there's various reasons for that, most particularly how heavily unionised they are and their union activity means that people get paid a lot more and things are just miles, miles more expensive. So what you really have now is quite a good situation for the UK which you've got lots of Americans coming to London to develop their musicals and see how they go and get them started. Now, they're much more attracted in a way to London, to New York. If it works, Broadway is still the dream and everyone wants their musical on Broadway. And by the way, of course, the upside on Broadway is a great deal more than it can be in the West End as well.

6:55The upside in Broadway can be absolutely, insanely lucrative. It is insanely lucrative. But you can retire off a musical if you have a successful one in London. Oh, yeah. I was told there's a musical running in London at the moment, one of the very, very few that isn't based on IP or isn't based on a movie. And someone was telling me that the two creators are making a six-figure sum each week each. Just because it's run and run. And by the way, it's brilliant. So the upside on theatre and musical is enormous. most things lose money, but if they make money, goodness me. All you need to do is take one look at Tim Rice's house and you'll know how much money you can make in musicals, a good musical, a hit musical.

7:32There is a snobbery about this sort of thing. If you look at something like Mean Girls, which obviously was a very successful film, and then they made a musical of it, which it did well on Broadway, but it made an absolute fortune out on the road touring in the US, at which point they thought, could we now make this back into a movie? So that has been made back into a movie. We know that Wicked, which obviously touched as a musical, that's being made with Cynthia Eriva and Ariana Grande. The first half of that is coming out later this year. I think that will do enormous business. But you know that there's a big audience for it out there because you just toured it around the States or you toured it wherever and you can see.

8:06So Mean Girls, then people were really surprised that the movie of the musical of Mean Girls, which itself was of the movie, made a lot of money. They should make a musical of that. Yes, they should do. They hit behind the scenes on it, behind the scenes of behind the scenes. but people can be really snobby about this sort of thing because they sort of say, oh, well, aren't there any new ideas? Well, excuse me, theatre has always been a revival art form. You don't say, oh, they're remaking a Tom Stoppard play. It's like, yeah, that's what they do. Oh God, they're doing another Mozart concerto.

8:34Come on, guys. Midsummer Night's Dream. Seen it. Yeah. No new ideas under the sun. But actually, quite clearly, they are different properties because you're not remaking Mean Girls when you're remaking the movie of that. It's something else. There's been some sort of sublimation. Something else has happened to it and it's become a different thing. And so you can see all these kind of shows that are coming, things like Clueless. Now, one of the things that a lot of it, and you're very good on this, Richard, one of the things a lot of people don't think of in many, many different media, and it's quite surprising is, who's my audience?

9:07It seems like such an obvious question, but a huge number of people don't think of it. Now, Clueless, this is a cult movie. it's particularly caught amongst like gen x and people who now have the money or are people who go to theaters women demographic lots and lots of things say to me that that will be a hit but there is still a snobbery about all of this a mega snobbery in the west end we don't know anything about like how much british theaters make because unlike broadway which publishes the grosses every week this is how we know they're 250 million dollars down there is no publication of it so if anyone's saying oh my musical's doing better than anyone else's it's hard for that to be a kind of great thing on a poster because we don't know what anyone else is so we have nothing to compare it with but i think the issue so there's not a snobbery thing but there's definitely a thing which is the west end has a limited number of theaters yeah uh as you say none of them are currently dark because there's always something to fill them but there's not that many of them and we're in a position now where some theater producers would say every single theater has got a musical in it and almost all those come from existing IP they all come from movies so you're seeing almost kind of half of the theatres that are available putting on a play that is something to do with IP and people might think that that's unhealthy for the for the theatre ecosystem in London.

10:24I agree but I disagree that there isn't a snobbery because half the critics don't even like to review the West End there's a lot of that there is a difference between I was talking to a theatre producer this week who was saying to me there's a real difference between US theatre critics and UK theatre critics, which is that US theatre critics are at least notionally interested in the business and numerate, and they understand things that are making money and there's not some sort of embarrassment and it's frightfully and fatigue and you should only be talking about the art. They are interested in things as, you know, successes and what that indicates.

10:56And financial success is obviously part of that because it's all got to work. You see, that's the fascinating thing. We talked about the upside of theatre and we talked a little about how much it costs. And this is why this IP thing has gone absolutely crazy and is going to keep going crazy. I talked to a lovely guy called Jon O 'Farrell. He's one of our finest comedy writers, been around for years, used to write, have I got news for you, and all sorts of things. And a few years ago, turned his hands to writing musicals. Like anything Jon does, he turns his hand to it brilliantly. So he did a big show on Broadway called Something Rotten with the Kirkpatrick brothers, which ran for two years.

11:30But he said it didn't ever quite make it. It didn't quite sort of get over that bit where you think, oh, my God, this is running forever and we're making millions upon millions. And he said he would go down to Times Square to the ticket booth, the TKTS booth on Times Square. And he would just see lines of tourists. And they were all just looking at the board. And they'd see his thing, something rotten. It's sort of based on Shakespeare, early days of Shakespeare. And go, oh, I don't really know what that is. And then they would see Legally Blonde and go, well, we do know what that is. and he said just every person in the queue was looking up the thing just going oh let's go and see the thing that we've heard of because it's 150 a ticket and there's four of them you it's not something you're going to take a chance on you're happy to pick up a paperback aren't you in a shop yeah but 600 you you have to have something that um you've already heard of and so someone came to him after something rotten which by the way now has an incredible life in american schools virtually every school in america has done a production of something rotten type thing yeah it's an educational and which they make a lot of money from i mean it's really you know a lot of money in it so someone came to me said well would you do mrs doubtfire the musical and of course its response was yes because i've just done this musical which takes so much out of you it's so difficult to do so expensive to put on i mean an absolute an eye-watering amount of money to put on and even after two years does it's not really turning a massive profit so yes i will do the thing that when i go down to that ticket queue everyone's going to go oh it's mrs doubtfire uh Let's go and see that.

12:52And so that's been two years in the West End now and is doing very well. But it's fascinating about the process because, of course, Fox, who are now Disney, of course they want Mrs. Doubtfire in the theatres. I think they suggested Night at the Museum first. And John's like, I don't know. They said Mrs. Doubtfire. He went, oh, yeah, absolutely. And, of course, they want it to be as true as possible to the IP. They said there's no way we're making this without Boobs on Fire and Pie in Face. those two things have to be in this musical so he said now yesterday in fact they announced he's doing the Live Aid musical which I think will be amazing called Just For One Day and again that's an interesting mix because it's sort of IP but it's not really owned so a lot of the profits are going to charities and what have you but it's not the sort of thing where it's owned by a Disney or a Fox or anything like that but it's something that people recognise and understand and so if you are a creative in that industry you know for every show like the hamilton or six or these things or operation mincemeat that really do fly that just most of them don't and you can't keep putting five million eight million ten million dollars into things that fail and you'd rather put three million five million eight million dollars into something that even if it doesn't absolutely set the world alight is probably not going to lose you a huge amount of money so it feels like it's something that's good that's here to stay this thing because because of the high operating costs of putting on a play yeah it's a gamble it's a real gamble and actually the sort of it's interesting thinking who backs theatre other than the studios obviously the studios for a long time actually felt that that theatre i was talking to one producer this week who said they thought that the theatre was a place of skullduggery and that they were always going to kind of rip you off and so they wanted people to share the risk even on their own properties yeah now they feel like oh some of these things are such bankers we're going to take all the risk but it's interesting like who has backed theatre in london in the west end all the different bits of money has blown through london and you've had Middle Eastern money and Russian money and Chinese money, you know.

14:49But actually, in a funny kind of way, the people who come back and back are people who like gambling. Yeah, yeah. They are people who like betting on stuff. Yeah. Because you've got to like losing. Yeah. You've got to be comfortable with losing. You have to a bit like show business, but also like a bet. And you should. And actually, people, if you don't like show business, then you're going to just be angry that you lost money. Yeah. Because it's like, you know, people like watching racing. Yeah. And that's why they'll bet on it. sometimes people say people who are really angry in a divorce if they're really happy and they've got a huge settlement they love to spend it on a hopeless case yeah and you know something rather lovely about that that was always the wonderful thing about in excess when they got absolutely massive you know that story so in excess got like worldwide global huge success and their accountant said to them look you can literally just throw away a million quid because it's not going to cost you anything so you can just take a punt so they put it all into like a little australian movie which turned out to be crocodile dundee so they've suddenly kind of turned that into a hundred million i know exactly yeah well it's and and there are some vanity projects the london theater is thriving there's all sorts of different things on and you don't have to be seeing things in the west end but it's pretty great especially after covid there's very few sectors that are like no we're better than ever and we're doing we're doing fantastically and you also want these shows to be touring because you've got these incredible regional theaters a lot of which are you know under threat and some of which have closed down that hasn't come back in the uk whereas in the US it has.

16:10Yes, absolutely. So it's lovely if you do have some shows that you know are going to be surefire hits that can fill out those places for two, three weeks at a time. You know, listen, there is the worry of it becoming a bit of a monoculture but, you know, I sort of understand why. You always get this thing in any creative arts when people go, oh, why don't you take more risks? Just take more risks. You think, well, sorry, a risk with what? With your money? Yes. You want them to take a risk with your money because we'll do that. If it's your$8 million, you find yourself less creatively inclined to take a risk, I think.

16:39than if it's someone else's. And there are lots of risky plays opening all the time that are, you know, odd and unusual and amazing and are doing really well. They don't have to be in the West End. Obviously, the sort of dream of lots of theatre producers is that this weird kind of hopeless case suddenly becomes a hit, which does happen with lots of different sort of plays or musicals. I mean, Operation Mincemeat would be a perfect example. I think that and Six, they both started at the Edinburgh Festival. We went to see the Edinburgh Festival this year at a show called Weir by Natalie Padamedes.

17:05And you just think, well, I could see that running forever and ever and ever in a West End theatre because it's so brilliant. There's no one who wouldn't enjoy that show. It's already there. It's already written. You can see the audience reaction to it. So, you know, these shows can come from somewhere. But I think it's hard if you are just straight off sitting at home around a piano with a friend thinking, we're going to write a musical about Dr. Barnardo. It's quite hard. The route to market is quite hard there. But if you do, if you take it through Rep and you take it through Edinburgh and things like that, then the market is there.

17:33I sort of feel like it's a positive story. It's interesting because those London versions of those shows are the ones they tour because for obvious reasons, as I say, if it costs five times as much to do it on Broadway. So people are trying things out in London and then they're taking those versions of the shows on the road all over the world, everywhere, China, South Korea. These places are huge for touring. So it's not just the places you'd think. It's much further afield and they're very, very successful. But yeah, it's lovely that the West End is booming at the moment. The one thing I would say, Legrim, come on, guys.

18:03You come back to your bugbear. But it's outrageous. it's genuinely outrageous you're paying 150 quid for a ticket and you're literally going to get deep vein thrombosis and I always sit on an aisle anyway so I don't want to sit in front of anyone because people just tut where can you sit without just having to apologise for yourself right on the very very very end of any periphery ones any particular row but yeah leg room sort it out yeah okay can we do that next week yes we're just no we're just going to do a whole episode just on leg room that's why I like TV in my house I have the legroom that I like save it for next week Richard in front of that I have not put another sofa in front of my sofa well we'll discuss that in much much more detail on a few later episodes so just to give a few recommendations so we talked about touring Heathers is touring at the moment if that's anywhere near you absolutely go see it Hairspray Hairspray is touring my favourite musical of all time Sixth the musical I think is on tour it's in Milton Keynes in September I think and that is a wonderful piece of work it's fantastic yeah it's feel good it makes you think it's got great tunes um so i'd really recommend that but uh and if i'm in front of you i promise i'll be on the aisle what would you turn into a uh a musical what hasn't been done what would i turn into um i think you've just got to do all i mean but how funny how much was i laughing at the 39 steps i know that's a book but it was it you can turn i don't say anything can be anything because you just sound like people who work at marvel and just like just do anything but i i mean i actually yes a marvel musical a really but i like these parody ones yeah kind of just use like titanic titanic you've got to go quite close to the wind it can be it'll be quite interesting to see how that one pans out i'll like to see it i haven't seen this um parody silence of the lambs one but i would like to see it should we have a break before we talk about the emmys let's do that eczema isn't always obvious but it's real and so is the relief from ebglis after an initial dosing phase about four in ten people taking ebglis achieved itch relief and clear or almost clear skin at 16 weeks.

20:03And most of those people maintain skin that's still more clear at one year with monthly dosing.

20:30Allergic reactions can occur that can be severe. Eye problems can occur. Tell your doctor if you have new or worsening eye problems. You should not receive a live vaccine when treated with Epglyss. Before starting Epglyss, tell your doctor if you have a parasitic infection. Searching for real relief? Ask your doctor about Epglyss and visit epglyss.lily.com or call 1-800-LILY-RX or 1-800-545-5979. This episode is brought to you by Jack Daniels. Jack Daniels and music are made for each other. They share a rhythm in the craft of making something timeless. while being a part of legendary nights. From backyard jams to sold-out arenas, there's a song in every toast.

21:05Please drink responsibly. Responsibility.org. Jack Daniels and Old No. 7 are registered trademarks. Tennessee Whiskey, 40 % alcohol by volume. Jack Daniel Distillery, Lynchburg, Tennessee. Lowe's knows how to help make your home holiday ready for less. Get Select Style Selections Vinyl Flooring for just$1.99 per square foot and have it installed before the festivities begin. Our team can help you every step of the way. See a Lowe's Red Vest Associate or visit lowes.com slash holiday install to get started. Lowe's. We help you save. Basic install only. Date restrictions apply. Subject to availability.

21:40Install by independent contractors. See associate for details. Contiguous US only.

21:50Welcome back, everybody. Now, it was the Emmys on Sunday evening slash Monday morning, depending where you are. There's one story I really want to talk about. Well, I know. I can imagine we want to talk about the same thing. But yes, the big winners were, I mean, these things are largely very predictable. And we'll talk a little bit about why that is. But the big winners were Shogun, The Bear, Hax, and Baby Reindeer. But I have to say a special, so happy that Will Smith ran for Outstanding Writing for a Drama Series for Slow Horses. Isn't that wonderful? Yes. And who, on receiving his awards, said the funniest thing said at the Emmys.

22:25I know that's not a tough field, came up and said, sorry, relax, despite my name, I come in peace. When he went up to the stage. Will is absolutely brilliant, has put his absolute heart and soul into that show. And it really caught people's imagination. Sometimes it takes a while and the third season of something. And it's hard when you're coming from one of the smaller streamers in that case, Apple. And it just caught fire. And I'm so pleased because he is genuinely the nicest person you could possibly meet in the world. I think he's the second nicest person. because the nicest person you can meet is his brother, Ollie Smith, the wine expert, who is unbelievably nice.

22:59I refuse to imagine that someone exists who is nicer than Ollie Smith, so I'm afraid. Which Smith? Let's put them together in a new TV format. That's a really good idea. Yeah, I know. Smith bros. No, that was a fantastic one. There were a few British women. Alan Cumming won as best host for The Traitors. The Traitors did very well. The Traitors won. Michaela Cole won for a guest star thing on Mr. and Mrs. Smith as well. And Hamish Hamilton won for directing the Oscars. the Oscars won two Emmys. It's ridiculous. What's that about? I know. Yeah. There's a lot of Emmys. When you look at all the different Emmys, there's a lot of them.

23:31And by the way, they had the creative arts ones the week before, which again, Shogun did amazingly on. And it's quite interesting when you look at all these things is that one of the characteristics of Emmy voting is that it's quite herd-like. Yeah. It is super predictable. There's a couple of upsets in this which we'll talk about. But even though the individual categories have voted for, their form of voting is that actors vote for actors and makeup artists vote for makeup artists and things like that. In the end, everyone can vote for the overarching things like best comedy or best drama or whatever.

24:02But it's amazing how these things got locked on and you have this idea, oh, it's going to be Shogun's year. And then everyone sort of just falls in and votes for those things. But also, if a show like Shogun votes for best drama, there will definitely be a best actor nomination, best actress nomination, best supporting. And you just think, there's lots of telly out there with amazing performances in, but you literally, they come as a package almost. So if you're nominated for Best Comedy or Best Drama, then you are nominated in all those categories as well. Yeah, there's a slipstream that you get in on.

24:28And they also love to nominate things that they then love to nominate again and again and again. And if you can't get in on that, which is why it's great that Slow Horses broke through with this season. But there are things like, you know, Last Week Tonight with John Oliver has never not won. They might as well retire at the award because it just wins it every single possible. He's like the Anton Deck at the NTA Awards of the Emmys. It's that level of, yeah. there is an art to submitting and i think this is going to get onto the subject that we both like to speak about you're allowed to put yourself into and they don't say well you're obviously not a comedy yeah you can guess what this is for example you're obviously not a comedy or you're obviously a lead actress you're not why are you being nominated and supporting you can choose where you get nominated now the bear is what people always say i mean they were making jokes it was presented by eugene and dan levy and they were making jokes about the bear not being comedy on stage, which I know that, you know, there's a sort of roasting element to all these things, but there's something that it's sort of reached slightly critical mass.

25:28In the end, it didn't win Best Comedy. That was won by Hacks. Which is a comedy. Which is a comedy. And which is, in a funny kind of way, about how comedy is slightly undervalued in our world. Yes. So the bare people have said for a long time, I don't really understand. This isn't a comedy. And the creators have always said, oh, yeah, well, you know, it's about how people use humour to respond to really terrible situations in life. No, it isn't. I wonder whether when we come to write, when we come to read the oral history of the period or whatever, that someone will say, yeah, an FX executive told us that we were submitting, whether or not we liked it, in the comedy category because Succession dominated the drama.

26:05Yeah, so we weren't going to win that. And Succession was untakeable. Yeah. And once Succession, you know, as I say, once they're nominating, they're nominating you. By the way, Succession was actually brilliant. And also funny. And it's a comedy as well. Actually funny. It was comedy and a drama. it did everything it was it was all the threat um but they but they felt that that category was untakeable and you have noticed to see a lot of writers i have talked to a lot of comedy writers who have a number of views about that show being nominated in the comedy category because they feel like this is taking an award from comedy if you look at what the some of the stars of and the producers of abbott elementary have said they're not thrilled that the bear which they think and i think actually is a drama is taking a comedy prize because there aren't that many there's always a that i'm talking about i mean we're talking a lot about snobbish this week this week but there is a massive snobbishness about comedy and the prestige award is the drama award um and comedy is just this thing that's like yeah you know oh that's easy comedy this is just jokes which i don't agree with and i think that's it that's been that's been pretty hard for a lot of people in that category so it's nominated for that it's won it before it didn't win this year as a hack Jeremy Allen White won best comedy actor right yes okay now so the bear it's not darkly comic right it is not comic at all and he's brilliant this is no shade on him it's a brilliant show it's not up to him probably it's amazing but what it is is incredibly traumatic as a show and it's not it's so traumatic it's funny or it's traumatic because we're making some ironic point which actually shows that we understand the world and we're shining a light in it which makes it comic it is just traumatic and a brilliant drama and he is absolutely brilliant in it.

27:43He has not done a single joke in any season of that show and yet he's just won Best Comedy Actor. And the thing is, as you say, the people who vote for these things, in the world, I don't know what number you put on this, maybe 30 % of people don't have a sense of humour. They just don't have it. And that's absolutely fine. This is a great take. But it's absolutely fine not to have a sense of humour. Some people, you know, we all have different things. But that means that fully 30 % of the people voting in that category are looking down the whole thing and going, well, Abbott Elementary, no, I don't understand what they're, there seems to be a lot of misunderstanding in that, and people not saying exactly what they mean, and looking down to Hacks and going, well, I saw it, but I thought it was a documentary about Hollywood, but then I saw something that never would have happened.

Read the full transcript

28:23It was almost like sort of comic, and then they go, oh, the bear, oh, yes, actually, that was very good, and so you've immediately got 30, the 30 % of people who don't want to vote for a comedy are voting for it, so of course it wins, and I just think that it is completely outrageous. Comedy is a specific group of people doing a very specific thing for a very specific reason and it is really really difficult and by the way you can make a comedy that doesn't get any laughs you can make a comedy but at the end you're kind of going you know what that was really funny or you make a comedy that makes people laugh throughout the bear and again we have to reiterate what it is a brilliant piece of television brilliantly written the cast is incredible the the directing is incredible it is a great piece of work it is not in any way shape or form a comedy and it is stealing awards from actual comedy stick in the drama would have won drama this year i suspect you know because people absolutely love it it's great they could quite happily run it in a different category next year but won't but you know i mean why not make it best live sports event i mean literally just go for it because people would still vote for it because they go they go oh the super bowl yeah i sort of enjoyed oh the bear uh i love the bear yeah uh but yeah listen if you're comedy people you don't win oscars you know people look down on it you know it's not seen as a great art form whereas i would say it's one of the greatest art forms there is and for this to be in that category i think adds insult to injury it also makes your award ceremony look like something that people are gaming yeah so it makes your and i actually think that despite whether or not they were very clever and decided to put it in this category a while ago because it was while succession was still being garlanded every year who knows maybe we'll know one day maybe we won't it's not what they say but because of the way the bears third season which to use euphemism is divisive a lot namely a lot of people hated it um it was out while people were making um voting basically and so maybe hacks did well but people also say oh hacks has run an absolutely brilliant campaign and you forget with all these things that it's so political and you are working like a candidate if you're even a writer and i'm having spoken to various different writers involved in these things, there's so much politics around you.

30:30You're working like a candidate. You've got to do all these different things and people have got to head off these criticisms of your show on that and they've got to, you know, flan up some other bit of what you've done well. And some people have money to spend on those things and some people don't. And that's how Netflix came in with stuff like The Crown and House of Cards because they thought, not only are we going to make really expensive things, everyone's like, what? Who's Netflix and why are they doing this? We are then going to spend a huge amount of money trying to get all those people nominated for awards.

30:55and they did and they made it successful but it's harder to break through if you can't do that but it is again like all of these races it's very political and then also you have to look at the demographics it's not a perfect process by any means but i do think that there's something very interesting about the bear that this year finally kind of perhaps broke in that thing where people are just saying actually it's this is ridiculous i would be shocked if it wins a best comedy award in any of the uh nominations next year you can't you can't keep doing it it's an impossibility and And again, it reflects badly on them because it's a great show.

31:28And all you're getting when you're winning these things is people going, oh, that's outrageous. You shouldn't win that. And it's which is incredibly unfair. And everyone on the stage making jokes about it. Yes, it's a little bit of gamesmanship that has cost you in some ways. The interesting thing is Baby Reindeer, of course, because in this world, we talked earlier about risk taking and about how everything is narrowing and very difficult to get a risky project off the ground. And Baby Reindeer was sort of in the last gasp of the previous regime at Netflix where they were taking chances on people.

31:56And it's really paid off. I mean, it won Best Limited Series, won Richard Gad, won Best Writer, Best Actor, Jessica Gunning. I was delighted to see one Best Actress as well. And that's lovely to see, again, that thing like Sixth the Musical, that you can have something which starts small and starts very sort of British and parochial and can break out into the world. As you say, that stable of shows is incredibly closed off and it's lovely to see a few Brits getting in there. But you're also hearing all the comedy commissioners saying, we want broad comedy, we want lots of laughs, we want lots of...

32:26The biggest hits are something that is not necessarily even a comedy. I absolutely love Hacks, by the way, and I've got a huge amount of time for Hacks, but a lot of people feel that the bits that are least successful of that are the sort of comedy bits in some ways, and that it works so well as a drama. And then you look at Baby Reindeer, which, you know, is not a comedy, and yes, it sort of probably started life saying it's the sort of comedy... I've done a comedy show at Edinburgh. It started at Edinburgh, yeah. Yeah, so it's an Edinburgh comedy show, a fringe comedy show, but it obviously is complex and more difficult than that.

32:56And so all the people say, I want all this broad stuff, but look what's still dominating. I know, it's crazy. And because if you look at what the Emmy noms would have been 20 years ago, you've got Friends and Frasier and Seinfeld, and you've got the American Office. You've got these shows which, by the way, people loved and also made billions upon billions of dollars. And other than Abbott Elementary, it's hard to see where those shows are now. And as you say, we've said for a few years now, this sort of stuff that is cool is lovely it's great that we can sit and watch it but someone at some point has got to start making big shows for big populations again baby reindeer was one and that's what so what you would say in the old days everyone say oh yeah baby reindeer is going to get all these awards but no one's actually seen it well we can see how many people actually seen it and huge numbers of people watch it which is i think interesting because people always used to say oh they're now turning away from the network stuff and so people like you know abita elementary or britain 99 when that was right you know it was kind of like they were the sort of fag end of all of that in some ways but it's interesting how massive baby reindeer was and how many people watched that when it isn't you know in lots of ways you would have thought that is quite a niche show it's a very niche subject and but there was something so propulsive about it people absolutely became addicted to it so again those shows that you think might have been tiny gambles have become huge nobody knows anything nobody knows anything that's true and so i mean to sum up some there's some good news hacks is very good news i think baby reindeer is good news for lots and lots of reasons.

34:21The elephant in the room is the bear. Hold on, mate. The elephant in the room is the bear, if you know what I mean. And what can we do about that? And I do think it's insulting to the comedy community and I don't think it does the bear any favours at all because it's brilliant. And if you're thinking they're only awards, don't worry about it. They think, yeah, but they're entertainment awards and that's what we love. And there's a reason they campaign so hard, all of the streamers, the studios, whoever, because it really matters and it matters so much for business and it matters how you can promote and market your show.

34:50It matters a huge amount. So it's not just prestige. And I know that we sort of sometimes say, oh, people like just to turn up and see their, you know, the people that they've greenlit or whatever, get things. It's not like that at all. It's a mark of success. Yeah, it's a big deal. It has measurable financial impact. It's just we're bitter because the Bear won Best Podcast at the British Podcaster Awards, didn't it? So shall we move on to the White Stripes or the White Stripes? Yeah. Yes. Now you've done it Now I can't work out How I'm going to say it in context I can't work it out either Yeah Well they Specifically Jack White Yeah I think I've said that right Rather than Jack White Is a suing Actually suing Trump Now look by the way Who hasn't told Who hasn't issued a cease and desist Letter to Trump By the way Something like 93 % of artists Making complaints against politicians Are against Republicans Which is not going to be The biggest surprise I'm really interested In who those 7 % are because I don't think anyone on the Democratic side is using like Kid Rock and Ted Nugent, but okay, surprise me.

35:52There's a huge list of people who have complained. Everyone from the surviving Beatles, Adele, Beyonce, Pavarotti. Panic at the Disco. They've all done it. So yeah, Springsteen, Rihanna. Okay, they've all done it. One of the reasons why Trump uses so much music is because you may have noticed he has a lot of rallies and it takes a long time to get the people in and he is often late for them. Not just walk-on music, but all the build-up. So pretty much, I mean, there's probably no band in the world that hasn't been played at one of those. Yes, exactly. I think people kind of love it. Like Johnny Marr, they played some, they played Please, Please, Please Let Me Get What I Want by the Smiths.

36:28And he said, you are not allowed to play that thing. But I think he was delighted that he got the opportunity to ban him. He told Cameron he wasn't allowed to like the Smiths as well. He said you weren't allowed to like them, which I really respect. Someone once told me about some really cursed-sounding party given by Matthew Freud. And David Cameron was there, of course. It was in the country, in the Cotswolds. And David Cameron danced, like got on stage and was, you know, got on the dance floor to like Town Call Malice, Eton Rifles. It's like, yeah, you can't be ironic about this. This is not your music.

37:02Yeah, this is not. Yeah. I'm so sorry. Even amongst people who would attend a Matthew Freud party, there were people who drew the line at that. Yeah, listen, listen. Everyone's got a line. Jesus, who knew? but that's a bit much um so um sorry where are we now maybe last year okay so what are the rules about this if you make if you pretend you've done some sort of campaign video that you have to get the artist permission jack white might have a bit of a case because i think he put out some social media video with seven nation army it's always seven nation army by the way and jack white's very very circumspect about talking about politics at all even when they're asking about like jeremy Corbyn he's like yeah no I don't know the guy I don't really have any views on that I love it being used at sport yes every time my children hear it in football any kind of game of any type of thing and they're like he's much happier with old Michael Van Gogh and then old Jeremy Corbyn yes yeah much yeah you're right there's there's there's a blanket the ASCAP which is the same as BMI over here which means at a rally you can actually play whatever you want the second you put out a campaign video or it makes it look like somebody is uh has consented to it being used that's when you get in trouble.

38:08Eddie Grant won a, about four years ago, 2020, he started suing Trump for using Electric Avenue and as you say, in a publicly available forum and literally this week finally won the case and Trump's people are going to have to pay him off and Isaac Hayes as well. So Trump used to use, Trump used to use hold on, I'm coming. Yeah. I think that you don't want to hear Trump and hold on, I'm coming in the same room and Isaac Hayes' family sued him so he can't use that either but again, they were using those as almost like official campaign songs whereas a lot of these other stuff like Celine Dion said why are you using my heart will go on I mean that's literally the song from Titanic what happens is that venues can buy rights to play songs and they're sold in a package and if you want to say I don't want any of my songs in any of those package what you're also saying is I don't want them to be played in bars I don't want to be there so there's some people are trying to make it mandatory for politicians to request before they play their songs at rallies and people like Sear and Mick Jagger and Blondie and Greed have written a letter.

39:05But we are at the letter stage. In general, people do cease and desist letters to Trump. But don't forget, I mean, the most famous, actually, I went recently when I was in New York with my son and we went really early in the morning to Trump Tower because we were up so early because of the jet lag. And so you go into the thing and you see the gold escalator that he came down to launch his original campaign in 2015 to Neil Young, keep on rocking in the free world. Now, the interesting thing about Neil Young is that Trump genuinely, absolutely loves Neil Young. Like, he loves him. And in the years before, when he was just the Donald, he was on The Apprentice, he would always talk about Neil Young.

39:43Listen to this slightly cursed front row of people rocking out at a 2006 Madison Square Gardens concert. Patti Smith, Salman Rushdie, and Donald Trump. Wow. At the Neil Young concert. And they absolutely loved him. That honestly sounds like an episode of The Bear. Yeah. It sounds as funny as that. Yeah, and as twisted and dark, yes. So Neil Young tried to stop him. Also, a bit like Born in the USA, which we'll come back to in a minute, because Reagan used that as like, have you actually listened to the song? If you listen to the words of Keep On Rocking in the Free World, it is not like an upbeat sort of anthem about whatever.

40:20But anyway, Trump came down the gold escalator to that. And that's one of the most interesting things of it. I remember seeing an interview with him once, actually, when everyone said, the interviewer just sort of went for it and said, you know, Young really hates you and he really actually hates you. And Trump just went, oh, well, you know what? I still like his music. And I thought, I don't think I've ever seen him not decide that attack is the best form of defense. And I thought, we know that emotion is like his phantom limb, but I think we just saw a sort of twitch on it, just the tiniest twitch.

40:52It existed. That's kind of terrifying. It's terrifying that he's actually in there. that there's something yeah like davros he's more machine than man but there's there's something still in there yeah so anyway the uh the history of using uh this is interesting america has always had campaign songs and for years and years and years they were written campaign songs uh 1808 uh huzzah for madison huzzah was for james madison and they would take like old tunes like yankee doodle dandy and john brown's body and things like that and they would you know do lyrics for their different things harding you're the man for us that was warren g harding um calvin coolidge keep cool and keep cool-age which is an absolute cracker then FDR was the first person who goes I'm going to use a commercial disc he used Happy Days Are Here Again so they're starting to go oh okay we don't need to just have someone writing us lyrics about how great we are but then even as late as Nixon's era Nixon had Nixon's The One and Nixon Now which were written for him but George McGovern against him used Bridge Over Troubled Water which is the first person to use a song that was actually in the current atmosphere and that was early 70s first person to do that and then the one that really yeah didn't it just you know mcgovern yeah you know mcgovern the guy who wasn't president the guy who failed to win wild watergate was actually running yeah exactly mcgovern great great election but the one that where that really broke everything i think was clinton when they used don't stop by fleetwood mac which really felt it had that same thing with um things to only get better in in the uk with blair where you just think oh it really matched the mood of the times absolutely matched the the energy of the campaign and that's when from now on you like the campaign song is such a huge deal which is why people you know get exercised when people use the people use the wrong ones um actually as a slight throwback bob dole when he ran in 96 yeah he had a version of soul man by sam and dave called doll man i think come on we've just we've just on don't stop we're Thank you.

42:44No. We have moved past it, Bob Dole. Well, Reagan said he shared the same American dream as Brie Springsteen. Again, have you listened to this song? Because of Born in the USA. I mean, dream, maybe, but every waking moment, no. No. I don't think so. No, I really... One thing you can do... I know we said that in America you can basically write a cease and desist letter and it's not going to work. There are more complicated ways of suing this. There's like the right of publicity. If you're saying your trademark is being diluted by mere association, this is where all these people are now coming in with Trump where they're able to say no it looks like I'm endorsing you and that alone is damage to my reputation yes because your brand is so tainted it is now tainting mine and it's certainly toxic amongst the people to whom I would otherwise regard as a market for my records it's a form of copyright infringement whether or not you think it is it's trademark infringement and you're um it's false endorsement and so they can get him on these other things and I think that's where you're starting because Jack White by the has been complaining about this since 2016.

43:40It's only now that he's suing. Yeah. Well, same as Eddie Grant. So Eddie Grant's been four years that's been going through the courts and it's literally just finally this week. So you would think that there might be like a little deluge of those things at the moment. And this year, of course, Kamala Harris, Freedom by Beyonce. Yeah. Again, it might be one of those ones that captures the mood of the times. It might be, but I slightly, I still think that I wouldn't sue because first of all, there's always a law. I just think never litigate. Yes. And second of all, you're suing a campaign. They've got lots of money, obviously lots of other people's money.

44:17I'll tell you this for a fact. I know you're saying that, but if we're watching the next Trump rally on TV and just as he's coming on, you hear go, hi, I'm Marina Hyde. Welcome to the questions, oh, sorry, the questions and answers edition of the rest of his entertainment. You would be like, I'm suing. I can't have that. Well, I would just find it hilarious. I just would think it, I'd just get a column out of it and move on. That is the only thing I would do. Or two columns. Come on, you two. There'd be money in that, wouldn't it? Sue and Trump. Oh, no. Never have a lawsuit unless there's no alternative to having a lawsuit.

44:48It'll be the first thing you think about in the morning, the last thing you think about at night. Do you think he'll think about it for one second? Yeah. It will just weigh on you and you'll be thinking about it all the time. So, you know, I'm sure that he's itching to use that. Which politician was it said never fight with a pig because you both get dirty but the pig likes it? Lots of people, lots of strategists. It's attributed to many US strategists, isn't it? I don't know. Did it first come to light around Clinton times? I'm going to get that wrong. Was it Shane Ritchie? I think it was Shane Ritchie.

45:15Shane Ritchie. Shane the legend, Ritchie. Is that us done? I think it is. Yeah. So the big headline is we're not suing Trump. No, we're not suing Trump. We're just hoping for him to do it so we get a column out of it. Well, I do. Any recommendations? My recommendation is a book that came out in the 80s. But I'm very excited about the upcoming Disney Plus adaptation of Rivals. Now, many of our listeners will have already read this. If you haven't, first of all, it's absolutely brilliant. It's even amongst Jilly Cooper, who is brilliant. I think it's her best one. But that's, you know, it's a matter of taste.

45:46I like all her big books rather than the sort of small individual characters. But it's got a huge cast of characters. I'm fascinated. I haven't seen any of it yet. And I'm going to sit to a screening of Rivals tomorrow night. Oh, we will be talking about Rivals. Oh, we're going to be doing Rivals, believe you me. Tennant, Dyer. Yeah. They're all in it. Turner, Parkinson. I mean there are huge it's going to be amazing and I will just I think it's really interesting to sort of read it reread it if you haven't or if you read it if you haven't read it and then watch it and see how they've managed to do that because for so long people thought it was sort of unfilmable for a number of reasons we'll talk about when we but the recommendation is read the novel read Rivals by Jilly Cooper Jilly Cooper will royally entertain you she is hilarious it's brilliant social observation everything is it's a real sort of mood piece of the 80s but it's very current today and it's you know it's got lots of great love stories and lots of great sex stories.

46:38So, you know, it's got the lot. It's got the lot. On which bombshell? Maybe we'll see each other Thursday? Yes, please do keep sending your questions in. The address is therestisentertainment at gmail.com and we'll see you on Thursday. See you on Thursday. Bye, everyone.

47:04Thank you.

From the publisher

If you've ever watched The Bear then you'll have seen anxiety inducing moments of real restaurant culture, tense family shouting matches and a ton more drama... however at the likes of the Emmys awards and the Golden Globes it is considered a comedy. Why?

The West End is in rude financial health with musicals and plays proving as popular as they ever were, returning to pre-Covid success. A lot of the big West End successes are based on films or existing stories. Is there a lack of creativity in theatre, and will it hurt the art in the long term?

Richard & Marina wrap this episode by talking The White Stripes vs. Donald Trump. Jack White is suing the former American President for unauthorised use of a song, but he's not the first to take issue with their music being coopted by politicians.

Recommendations:

Marina: Jilly Cooper - The Rivals (read)

Newsletter: www.therestisentertainment.com
Twitter: @‌restisents
Instagram: @‌restisentertainment
YouTube: @‌therestisentertainment
Email: therestisentertainment@gmail.com

Producer: Neil Fearn + Joey McCarthy
Executive Producers: Tony Pastor + Jack Davenport

🌏 Get our exclusive NordVPN deal here ➼ https://nordvpn.com/trie  It’s risk-free with Nord’s 30-day money-back guarantee! ✅
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from The Rest Is Entertainment

All 311 episodes
Is The Bear REALLY a Comedy?The Rest Is Entertainment · 47 min
Listen in VO