Hour 1: Mike McDaniel’s Hot Seat, Tim Tebow Talks Arch Manning & More

18 Sep 2025 · 46 min · 19 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

The episode is a sports talk segment focused on NFL early-season stakes and college football. Topic: Mike McDaniel’s “hot seat” after the Miami Dolphins start 0-2 with blowout-level losses, including a players-only meeting after a loss to the Colts.

Key claims

McDaniel says job-security worry would hurt performance; the show argues Miami’s path is “Tua: hold the ball, make connections, don’t turn it over,” plus offensive line/defense must “hit people in the mouth” with key defenders (Ed Oliver, Matt Milano) out.

Notable examples

Dolphins’ 13 of last 14 losses to the Bills; Bills’ recent home winning streak; Dolphins’ only win in 2022 (21-19).

Guest backgrounds

Tim Tebow (SEC Network analyst, Heisman winner, former NFL QB) discusses LSU/college football and advice for Arch Manning; Dean Blandino (Fox Sports rules analyst, former NFL officiating head) is set up to discuss rule changes; Tyreek Withers (actor) is later for a movie. Tebow also recounts the 2010 overtime TD vs. Steelers and Allstate AFC Good Works voting.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Baseball Highlights and Show Guests

0:00 to 0:30

Highlights in baseball and introduction of today's guests.

“At the Home Depot, get up to 15 % off all installed carpet projects for a limited time.”

Baseball Highlights and Show Guests

0:33 to 0:51

Highlights in baseball and introduction of today's guests.

“You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome?”

Baseball Highlights and Show Guests

1:22 to 1:56

Highlights in baseball and introduction of today's guests.

“From the Rich Eisen Show studio in Los Angeles.”

Rich's Excitement and Weekend Plans

1:56 to 4:25

Rich discusses his upcoming weekend plans and excitement for hosting.

“Lighten the candle for all those out on the freeway right now.”

Dolphins' Struggles and McDaniel's Situation

4:25 to 6:27

Analysis of the Miami Dolphins' performance and Mike McDaniel's coaching status.

“We keep talking about the firsts this year, right?”

Discussion on Coaching Styles and Locker Room Control

6:27 to 9:50

Exploring coaching styles and the importance of locker room control in the NFL.

“And it's a far cry from the Dolphins making the playoffs in McDaniel's tenure.”

Dolphins' Historical Performance Against the Bills

9:50 to 14:00

Reviewing the Dolphins' historical losses against the Bills and implications.

“That was postgame on Sunday, and then he shows up on Monday, and he's asked about control of the locker room.”

Dolphins vs. Bills: A Historical Perspective

14:00 to 17:20

Explore the tough history between the Dolphins and the Bills, including key matchups and implications for the Dolphins' season.

“getting hit by everything, everything from the kitchen sink the Raiders threw at him to Carrot Top.”

Tua's Challenges and Pressure

17:20 to 18:00

Discussing the pressure on Dolphins quarterback Tua and the significance of upcoming games for his career and the team's future.

Previewing the Show and Guests

18:00 to 20:43

Rich Eisen previews the upcoming show and guests, including Dean Blandino and Tim Tebow, while setting the stage for upcoming discussions.

“including florist state you share a lot i know he played um he played there um but first up tim Tebow.”
Show all 19 chapters

Tim Tebow on College Football

21:08 to 23:30

Tim Tebow shares insights on college football, discussing his alma mater's current performance and challenges facing teams.

“Come on, it's been way too long since I've talked to you.”

Discussion on Bryce Underwood and Quarterback Talent

23:30 to 28:01

A deep dive into the talent of quarterback Bryce Underwood and comparisons with other legendary players, including advice for Arch Manning.

“Which is the best team in the SEC through the first almost month of the season then, would you say, Tim?”

Tim Tebow's Advice for Arch Manning

28:01 to 34:26

Tim Tebow shares insights on handling pressure and the love of the game, offering advice to young quarterback Arch Manning.

“It's just a monstrously large person, incredibly talented as well.”

Tebow's Memorable Overtime Moment

34:26 to 38:25

Tim Tebow recounts the historic overtime play against the Steelers and the camaraderie within his team.

“And so we were on the sidelines and we had a, that pass concept we ended up using, but we had never done it out of that formation.”

The Allstate AFC Good Works Team

38:25 to 40:04

Tim Tebow discusses the significance of the Allstate AFC Good Works Team and the impact of young athletes off the field.

“Let's talk about the Allstate AFC Good Works team.”

The Allstate AFC Good Works Team

40:10 to 41:15

Tim Tebow discusses the significance of the Allstate AFC Good Works Team and the impact of young athletes off the field.

“the allstate werfel trophy um danny was a hero to me and so it's it's awesome that we get to celebrate that and there's so many amazing stories so go vote for who you believe should be the team captain.”

Tim Tebow on Arch Manning's Journey

43:06 to 44:36

Tim Tebow discusses the challenges facing Arch Manning in college football.

“Rich Eisen Show, ESPN Radio is presented by Progressive Insurance, Progressive Commercial Insurance, protecting your business vehicles 24-7.”

NFL Updates and Analysis

44:37 to 47:10

Discussion on recent NFL updates, including player performances and coaching insights.

“And that's when the rubber will meet the road for just year one for Arch.”

NFL Updates and Analysis

47:15 to 47:29

Discussion on recent NFL updates, including player performances and coaching insights.

“for those who want to be part of every round.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00At the Home Depot, get up to 15 % off all installed carpet projects for a limited time. Featuring brands like LifeProof, LifeProof with PetProof Technology, Home Decorators Collection, and Traffic Master. Take your pick of carpet built for real life and designed for real comfort. Plus, with installations starting as low as 49 cents per square foot and a free measure to get you started, we'll handle the hard parts for you. Offer valid July 16th, 2026 through August 2nd, 2026. Exclusions apply. For licenses, see homedepot.com slash license numbers. This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome.

0:33You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome? That's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required, compatibility and availability varies 18+. This is the Rich Eisen Show. Hey, everybody. Can't get enough of The Rich Eisen Show? You're in luck. You can find us everywhere. Watch us weekdays on Disney Plus from noon to 3 Eastern.

1:09Miss the show? We've got a podcast so you can listen anytime. But here's the best part. Our YouTube channel. Subscribe at youtube.com slash Rich Eisen Show and you'll never miss a moment. Now, on with the show. This is The Rich Eisen Show.

1:27Rich Eisen:What's happening in the baseball world? I think we take it for granted. From the Rich Eisen Show studio in Los Angeles. Gone! Number 51 on the season for Shohei Ohtani. Today's guests. SEC Network Analyst and Heisman Trophy winner Tim Tebow. Fox Sports Rules Analyst, Dean Blandino. Actor Tyreek Withers. And now, it's Rich Eisen. presented by progressive insurance sirius xm channel 80 we say hello to everybody out there who's listening to us through our podcast all three hours available however you get them and certainly thanks to our partnership with the espn pod center uh we're up there we're out there and hopefully you're in there and hopefully you're also checking us out on our youtube channel in any way shape or form that you can youtube.com slash rich eisen show um and every single uh follower counts certainly my my youngest son is counting it uh cooper this morning when i was seeing him says dad you're you're over 985 000 oh which is uh words that you know my 14 year old's never said to me before so i'm very very proud of what we're building here on our program good to see you over there christopher how are you rich i'm great uh battled the uh the drizzle this morning to get here for those out there uh nationally you're listening to us we greatly appreciate uh being on your local station here um if you're on the espn radio network we're also so appreciative of being heard nationally on Sirius XM, light a candle because it's raining here in Los Angeles, which means people around here don't know how to drive.

2:59Rich Eisen:And it's something. But we're here nice and safely. Is that why Del Tufo's not here? Is he on the side of the road? Oh, I don't know. Good to see you, Jason. Good to see you, too. Hey, how's the weather out there? It's not sunny right now. The candle's lit? Is the candle lit, TJ? Lighten the candle for all those out on the freeway right now. Did I say a lot of candle? I didn't even mean to say that sort of thing. Good to see you. You too, Rich. How are you doing? I'm good. You're going to Indianapolis this weekend. Are you not? It's starting to hit me. I'm not going to lie to you guys a little bit.

3:28My stomach kind of went a little bit yesterday. Is that right? I was pulling out a bunch of ESPN paperwork to make it official.

3:35Rich Eisen:Look at you. You're signing paperwork with ESPN to host along with O'Shea Jackson Jr. That's going to be so cool. No Contest Wrestling is hosting the, have you been informed, it's no longer an hour, it's two hours? Am I breaking the news to you? Welcome to ESPN, by the way. The news got broken. We'll talk later. When I read the official press release in Variety and it said two hours, I was like, oh, Variety. I guess I should have broken the news to you. It was a couple of days ago, like, we'd like them to do two. And I'm like, man, you and O'Shea Jackson Jr. would do 24 days in a row talking about it.

4:09Rich Eisen:So it's the first PLE on this ESPN app and Disney Plus of the WWE and no contest wrestling. Check it out on the ESPN YouTube and Facebook pages on Saturday. Very excited for that sort of expansion of our world. 844-204-RICH is the number to dial. We keep talking about the firsts this year, right? First week of the season, first barn burner of the season that was a Sunday night football game, to say the least, between the Ravens and the Bills. It's the last time we saw the Bills at home. And in between that game and tonight's Bills next home game, which is a standalone everybody watches contest on prime video um and um before those two games uh we've seen a lot of other firsts which is uh the first team to have to start their backup quarterback san francisco 49ers yes sir um the uh soon this weekend we're going to see the first game between two teams now having to start their backup quarterbacks against one another uh it's the Vikings now and Carson Wentz taking on the Cincinnati Bengals and Jake Browning.

5:27Rich Eisen:The Bengals are the first team in the NFL to potentially lose their quarterback to injury for the entire year. Three months is what we're hearing about for Joe Barone. You hear something that's three months that could easily become four and maybe not coming back at all. Shut it down. You're also seeing a first that we didn't see but heard about. And that's the first team to hold a players-only meeting. And that happened after just one loss by the Miami Dolphins. Two days after getting spanked by the Indianapolis Colts and Danny Diamonds, they held a players-only meeting. And so we have now reached another first.

6:11Rich Eisen:Tonight, the Miami Dolphins are the first team to take the field to potentially play for their coach's job. And it's getting real, real fast for friend of the program, Mike McDaniel in Miami. And it's a far cry from the Dolphins making the playoffs in McDaniel's tenure. And it's a far cry from, if you recall, the massive points of Palooza they put on Sean Payton. if you remember that in Peyton's first year there where the Dolphins had a chance to damn near put up 80 on Denver and this was a team that came out of nowhere and put a whole bunch of points on the Ravens defense earlier in the first month of Mike McDaniel's tenure oh yeah crazy in Miami and we were talking about how this guy is perfect for Tua and Tyreek Hill's coming and talking about how Tua has thrown a better ball than Mahomes.

7:22Rich Eisen:And we've come a long way from all of that. Because now we're wondering if McDaniel is right for Tua or Tua is right for the contract that he's gotten based on some of the McDaniel's right for Tua moments. And this team is not only 0-2, they are a hard 0-2, a blowout loss on the road uncompetitive performance in week one players only meeting two days after five days after the players only meeting a home date with the new england patriots in front of a lot of empty seats in hard rock but that you know might be because it's a billion degrees out of miami and everybody's doing other things but um not a packed house in hard rock one of the people in their seats is Stephen Ross, the owner, and he watches the Patriots take care of business against Miami.

8:20Rich Eisen:And when you lose a division game at home to go 0-2 after a blowout loss that causes you to have a players-only meeting two days after that, five days after that, the dreaded home division loss, if you have that, you're a hard 0-2. Hard 0-2. 0-2 in conference, 0-1 in division, 0-1 at home in division. one for one in terms of week one losses and players only meetings. And there's somebody who's hiring a message to fire everybody on a plane above the stadium. Mike McDaniel spoke this week about his job status and how he's approaching his everyday status himself. I think if I worry about my job security, I won't be doing my job.

9:05And I think that inherently is against all things that I believe in. I've never felt entitled to any sort of I've never felt entitled to this position. And it's very important for me to spend all of my waking hours worrying about exactly how to do my job and what and all the residual effects of that are. There's a lot of people affected. So, yeah, I won't spend one moment thinking about all the things that, I don't know, people, whatever people want me to think about, I'm thinking about this team and the Buffalo Bills here after I get done with this podium.

9:52Rich Eisen:That was postgame on Sunday, and then he shows up on Monday, and he's asked about control of the locker room. again you know in the nfl we we look at head coaches like dan campbell right we're biting kneecap off we're gonna we're gonna come at you we're gonna bark we're gonna hit you big imposing former tight end in this league and then you see a guy who says the word inherently um and you think he can't coach in the nfl i mean did what rex ryan call him nerd boy on get up i mean that he's got glasses by the way hey rex am i a nerd boy for espn radio and sirius xm and our podcast listeners i just put on my my glasses don't answer that right i was about to say is that rhetorical or you know but um that's it it's always the case right in in how visuals do matter right joe tory perfect example perfect example um when he doesn't show he doesn't show any emotion he never did right he used to sit there and everything he was half asleep right and half the time he and don zimmer were probably talking about the ponies that they had just bet on earlier in the day i don't know where they're eating but um you know if you're losing it's just like can you show pulse do you remember kevin mcrennolds in the mets oh yeah right and he he was struggling but he never showed any emotion And I heard from Mets fans, my brother, you know, other friends of mine, who would be just like, can he take a bat to the Gatorade jug just once?

11:27Rich Eisen:So he shows us that it means a lot. Did Kevin Mack hit three home runs? He strike out three times. You don't know. You don't know. So when you're winning, it's just like, boy, this guy just shows no pulse. And it's just like everybody's just following, staying calm and winning. But when you're losing, it's just like, can you show some emotion, please? and you know for McDaniel it's like when you're winning it's like boy this guy's a genius he's thinking next level stuff. Remember we had Andrew Hawkins here who remembers how he was with the Browns on the staff and he was talking about footwork and where to place your feet as a wide receiver and he unlocked him and it unlocked a bunch of people.

12:00Rich Eisen:Guy's a genius. Damn near puts up 80 points on the Denver Broncos he comes back on the Ravens. Tua's playing well. I mean the guy's a genius. Now you start losing and it's just like do you are you a molder of men or are you not? you know you can give me a terrific synonym for the word mold but how about actually molding this team can you can you can you i mean tyree kill is even like you know why are we running behind a fullback and and and and mcdaniel goes to the podium he goes his name's alec ingold we have one

12:36Rich Eisen:so when you lose you get questions like this the day after you're talking about your job status I think if there was anything that would lend me to believe that messages weren't being received, then you address those things. To me, I think I've seen a team that is trying to do everything they can to win and coming up short and pressing forward and trying to change that result. And again, it's part and parcel. That's the way he talks. He's very methodical in choosing his words. He has a large vocabulary. He's a smart guy. and I'm sure people in Miami are like, so when you were asked about control of the locker room, can you just say, I've got it.

13:31Rich Eisen:Next question.

13:35Rich Eisen:Yeah, I've got control of the locker room. Just watch the way we're going to play this weekend. You know, I was talking to the guys the other day. You know, you ask them. Tonight's the rubber meet in the road. I mean, if they get smoked, if it's like a Brandon Staley type blowout, and again, I bring that up again because Brandon Staley lost his gig when he was on the road in division when everyone's wondering, do you have control of the locker room? Do you know what you are doing around here? And he goes to Vegas and damn near, you know, winds up, you know, getting hit by everything, everything from the kitchen sink the Raiders threw at him to Carrot Top.

14:09Rich Eisen:Carrot Top might have come in in here and just started hitting him. That game felt like 70 to nothing. What was the final score? And Al Michaels is just like, shut your mouth, Rich, because I had to call that game and I don't want to fly all the way to Western New York on Air Al to call another one. because everybody's thinking that, and the recent history ain't good. It was 63-21. The Miami Dolphins have lost to the Bills in 13 of the last 14 meetings. The only win is a September 2022 nail-biter in a very hot and humid day in Miami. 21-19 was the final. The Bills have won the last past nine at home.

14:49Rich Eisen:and um the Dolphins most recent win was uh in Orchard Park a uh 34-31 overtime game on Christmas Eve which led to the Bills firing their head coach at the time uh and he's the guy that called Mike McDaniel nerd boy that was his last day as a head coach in the NFL. So, the way through is this. Tua, hold on to the ball. Tua, make your connections. Tua, don't turn it over. And I understand I'm laying a lot at the feet of the quarterback, but it's a quarterback-driven league. Just look at the other guy tonight who was playing the position. See what he does. They came up with a 20-point win in New York just five days ago.

15:36Rich Eisen:He didn't do anything. And he didn't score. He didn't count for a single touchdown. James Cook did for two. And that's the way through as well. Devin Achan, that's the guy. Achan scored the only touchdown for the Dolphins in week one. Yeah, he's a good. He scored again in week two on a 29-yard pass from Tua. He almost scored a second time. If he didn't step out of bounds, then everything else that happened after that where the Patriots put a sack of palooza on Tua to end the game, it would have been Drake May trying to win it. Yep. a chance the way through especially when the guys right up the middle Ed Oliver and Matt Milano are out that's the way through through the tackles can they hit people in the mouth and can you win the game for your coach do you believe in him or not because if you go to 0-3 and you get blown out and you don't have another non-compete game in front of the whole country I don't know what Steven Ross is going to do

16:34Rich Eisen:um two is oh and two for the first time in his career he i mean this we're we're in the land of the unknown for the dolphins because they'd be oh and three and a hard oh and three because now you're oh and two in division and the team that's roosted atop your division has just beaten you i know it's kind of unfair to lay all the eggs in this basket when it's a short week game in division in a very tough place to play as we saw for the Ravens and week one. And we'll see for every other team that walks into this building in the last year of this building, people are looking at every single game as a last year and a first there.

17:11Rich Eisen:It's a big one tonight on Thursday night football. I think I've set the stage for the stakes. We got a fun show in store. Dean Blandino, the former head of NFL officiating, now a rules analyst for fox i called him in person to the studio i mean i texted him okay um but he's coming here nice he said he's done with the tush push done with it that's what he said during the broadcast i'm done with this so uh we're gonna talk with him about the the first two weeks of season um and uh then in um our number three the uh star one of the stars uh of the new movie him tyreek withers who plays the quarterback in question he's in studio hour three apparently he has as many uh different teams that he roots for as you do tj so we spread the love around including florist state you share a lot i know he played um he played there um but first up tim Tebow.

18:11Rich Eisen:Let's talk college football. Let's talk Tebow time. Let's just go down memory lane with the highly popular T squared here on the Rich Eisen show, 844-204-RICH to have a chat with us.

18:28Rich Eisen:While the world watches the stars at the FIFA World Cup this summer, Hyundai has its eyes on the next generation of talent, future stars who are already turning heads at age 14. Because Next doesn't wait for an invitation, and neither do we. Hyundai has always moved the future within reach. We did it when we made advanced safety standard on every vehicle and engineered EVs with ultra-fast charging capability. Because the future isn't some far-off concept, it's already here. Next starts now. Hyundai, an official partner of FIFA. Rich Eisen here with some advice. If high-interest credit card debt is grinding you down, it might be time to call an audible with a SoFi personal loan.

19:06Rich Eisen:It consolidates your debt into one low monthly payment with no fees required. And with as soon as the same day funding, you can make the right play fast. Call an audible on your debt today at SoFi.com slash debt play. Loans originated by SoFi Bank N.A. Member FDIC. Terms and conditions apply. NMLS 696891. Fast funds terms apply at SoFi.com slash debt play. Rich Eisen here for gusto. After all these years talking to athletes, coaches, entertainers, and people at the top of what they do, one thing is pretty clear. Success usually depends on getting the details right. For small business owners, that includes payroll, hiring, onboarding, benefits, you know, the work that keeps everything moving, even if it's not the reason you started the business in the first place.

19:49Rich Eisen:That's why there's Gusto. Gusto is online payroll and benefits software built for small businesses. It's all-in-one, remote-friendly, and incredibly easy to use. so you can pay, hire, onboard, and support your team from anywhere. Automatic payroll tax filing, simple direct deposits, health benefits, commuter benefits, workers' comp, 401k, you name it. Gusto makes it simple and has options for nearly every budget. And it's all built to save you time with built-in automated tools for offer letters, onboarding docs, direct deposit, and more. Plus, you get unlimited payroll runs for one monthly price.

20:24Rich Eisen:No hidden fees, no surprises. Try Gusto today at gusto.com slash rich and get three months free when you run your first payroll. That's three months of free payroll at gusto.com slash rich. One more time, gusto.com slash rich. The Rich Eisen Show podcast. Back here on the Rich Eisen Show, everybody. Here on ESPN Radio presented by Progressive Insurance. It's been a very long time since I've chatted with you. Is this the first time he's joined our program? I think it is. I got to think so. I think so. We're turning 11 next month. Ladies and gentlemen, courtesy of Allstate, ESPN, and so much more, Tim Tebow, everybody.

21:07Thank you so much for having me. Come on, it's been way too long since I've talked to you. So it's good to connect, man.

21:14Rich Eisen:Well, Tim, I think pop it up on the screen. I just heard. I've just been surprised by my own team. We have a photograph. Look at us. Look at the baby faces on the screen right there. Wow. Look at that. I wish I got to see it. Come on. That's it right there. That's it. That's where we're little babies in 2012. This is a Super Bowl in 2012. Back in the day, man. And look at you now. You're fine wine. Look, I don't know what's happened to me. You know what I mean? I've fallen apart. All I know is the run, Rich, run, man. Your form's getting better every year. I love it. I mean, most of us just decline in our athleticism.

21:55and you just continue to grow and adapt and improve. I love it.

21:59Rich Eisen:I appreciate that, Tim. It's good to see you. So let's talk a little ball first before we get into the matter at hand about what's going on. I'll just jump in and give you the floor on what's happening at your alma mater and your two cents and what's happening there. Tim, what do you think? Well, I actually think that there's a lot. People won't fully understand this, but there's a lot to actually be encouraged about If you actually watch the All-22 and the coaches tape, you go to Death Valley at night against one of the top teams in the country. And for a lot of areas, you match them stride for stride.

22:35And in some areas, you outperform them. But you're just not going to win with five turnovers. I don't care what level. When you lose five turnovers to, I believe, one, you're not going to win. When your defense really shuts them to 10 points, but the offense gives them another 10. Like, it's just, it's too hard to win, especially in the SEC at night. And so I think when you really look at it, there's a lot to be encouraged, but you have to win in situational football. And you, there's a reason why those always get talked about as the fundamentals, turnovers, scoring in the red zone, penalties, third downs.

23:10There's just certain things that are always the basics. And you have a team that in areas of playing really well, but in some of the fundamentals, the penalties, the turnovers, scoring in the red zone. when you lose all of those, it makes it almost impossible to win the game. And so that's just areas. The situational football is where we have to improve.

23:31Rich Eisen:Which is the best team in the SEC through the first almost month of the season then, would you say, Tim? I think the first team that came to my head was probably Oklahoma. When you look at their violent, aggressive defense, when John Matier as a quarterback, he's fun to watch. He's twitchy. He's a twitchy dude. I think he's probably kind of has a little bit of that Johnny Manziel twitch in the pocket, ability to get it out really fast, super accurate. Their receivers, underrated, can make a lot of plays, like just can take the top off. I'm excited to see when they get more of these backs going, Jaden Ott and some of these other guys going.

24:15I think they can improve their running game. but that Michigan team was a good team that the game was closer the score was closer than I think the than I think it really was like they really dominated a lot of that Michigan had the one big play to start the second half and and made it feel closer but that was a really good performance by by Oklahoma but I also think you cannot take Auburn lightly this weekend because they're much improved Jackson Arnold be a good storyline coming back to Norman but they're getting better And Auburn's receivers are pretty darn athletic. And they can take the top off and make big plays.

24:55And their defense is approved. So I'm excited. We actually will fly to Norman here in a couple of hours to be a part of that for SEC Nation. So it'll be fun.

25:03Rich Eisen:Yeah, I can understand why you'd think Mateer is fun to watch. But, you know, I did go to the University of Michigan. That was not fun to watch. And I can confirm to you, Tim, that the scoreboard difference felt much larger watching, that it felt as if this thing was over. And obviously I was hoping that there would be some form of a Tebow time like comeback, you know, with a few minutes to go, but that did not materialize, Tim. But you have to be encouraged by Bryce Underwood. Oh my God. I've never seen, Tim, I'll say to you what I've said here. um i i have you know i went to school starting there in 1986 so from harbaugh to the present day i've seen michigan quarterbacks including brady um including name it uh chad henny had a big arm um joe milton while he had a cup of coffee there obviously had a big arm i've never seen a an arm like this attached to a body like that in one human being playing quarterback for michigan ever ever it's rich it's so crazy so um we uh flew to pasadena for the cover shoot for the ea sports game and so there's all these different players that you know ryan williams and uh jeremiah smith and everyone and bryce underwood is there and he's right beside me as we're taking some of the photos and i'm uh standing beside coach day and some of the other coaches and we're talking and i'm like looking and i'm like it's my first time to see him i've seen some of his tape but it's my first time to see him up close and personal and i'm like holy cow like it's this is crazy like it's what it's what a lot of people see the think the first time they see cam newton is you're like whoa like it's just different it's right it's just i'm not saying other guys aren't athletic or gifted at all you're just saying like wow like when when god made him he just made him bigger stronger, faster.

27:01Like he's just gifted. Like it's just different. And you're like, he, he, like his size and his length and the physicality, you, he looks like he's 24 and, and, you know, it just, it's so gifted and I'm really excited to see. And everybody's like, well, week one, week two, you know, and you're like, no, he's still a baby and he's got to give time to develop and learn and just because you're that talented doesn't mean everything's going to come easy and I actually think that he's handled the pressure really well I'm excited to see you know what he's going to become because his gifts are just off the charts yeah we had him here in studio uh in the

Read the full transcript

27:42Rich Eisen:summertime and my oldest son is 17 and I kept looking at Bryce Underwood and I'm like they're the same age and I'm like it's wow uh and and what you said about Cam too Tim that Super Bowl where I met you that's that's that photograph of of us uh is from the super bowl where i met cam for the first time it's the one in indianapolis where eli dropped that ball to mario manningham on the sideline for a touchdown to beat or a big play to lead to the eventual game winner against the patriots i met cam there for the first time and had the same reaction uh and then i just saw cam again in brazil because he's part of a youtube broadcast of chiefs and chargers and i still had the same reaction of just like, I cannot believe you played quarterback in the National Football League.

28:26Rich Eisen:It's just a monstrously large person, incredibly talented as well. Before we move on, what advice would you give Arch Manning right now, Tim Tebow? I would, that's a good question. Thank you, sir. I would, I'd just, I'd encourage him. Like, man, you're a gifted player. You're a really good player. You just need to be encouraged. Remember it for the love of the game. He's at a location right now with great coaches, great players around him. But there's just a lot of pressure. And pressure is real. And it's hard to sometimes explain that to people. And one of the easier examples I would try to use is look at the PGA Tour or Live Golf, right?

29:12When they show up on Thursday and they've had practice rounds, look at the scores. But then look at the scores on the same course on Sunday. What's the difference? You've played it more. The only difference is it's Sunday pressure, right? And that just gives an example of how pressure is real. And so I just encourage him, remember the love of the game and play for it. And you don't have to make every play. You don't have to be perfect. I have really appreciated the way he's carried himself for three years now. I appreciated the way that he's handled it as a teammate with Quinn. And when he took over, the way he's handled even some of the disappointments.

29:49I just I think he's a great example of someone that has handled hype and criticism. He hasn't pointed fingers. He's just handled it really well. So I just say, one, I'm proud of it, proud of the way he's handled it. But also, like, try to block that out and remember how much you love the game. And, yeah, people will keep talking. There'll be praise and there'll be criticism. A lot of times, you know, maybe the praise is, you know, sometimes, you know, off the charts. And this criticism is too. And it's usually somewhere in between. And just try to block it out. Love the game. Love your teammates.

30:26Enjoy it. You know, it was probably advice I needed a lot, especially in my senior year, because we weren't just playing against the team we played. We were also playing against what we had done in the past and the hype or the criticism of it. and I needed to be reminded and I should have done a better job of trying to keep that in perspective and just handle it and remember how much I love this game and my teammates and how much I dislike the rivals and just remember the love of the game the game that I grew up running into the yard and couldn't wait to go throw and every commercial break I would run and go dive and score a touchdown before I'd run back in remember that and I think that is just so important And especially when, you know, he can't go walk anywhere, get outside of it.

31:13Like that's different. And it's hard sometimes for people to just understand, like, if you can't walk anywhere, you can't really talk to anybody about it because, you know, who do you trust? Who do you have? And how he has this awesome family, but it's just different. And so I think I just try to try to understand it and have, I think, just a level of understanding and a level of compassion for where he's at.

31:34Rich Eisen:Well, my follow up to that is, did you ever have to have that conversation with yourself as a pro when you were in the NFL? Yes. When? Yes. When in particular? Several times. Several times in training camps where you would just be getting, you know, crushed, you know, with criticism. And you'd like, I needed to be remembered. Like, I needed to remember and be reminded that I can play this game. Like, and you need that encouragement. and um i just i remember a few times having to go back and like being so discouraged that i would have to go back and i needed to go put on a highlight video or go watch or be encouraged man i can go do this you know and and remember that love of the game to truly try to block out the noise and like remember the love of the game because i think the you know perfect love casts out fear.

32:29Remember why you're doing it. Love it. Fall in love with it again. Try to get rid of the noise. And then remember the relationships with your teammates. And those were the best ways for me to kind of get through it and kind of rebuild confidence.

32:46Rich Eisen:I've seen you in person play as a professional on NFL Network. And the whole Tebow time conversation with you, Tim, where it would be darn near 56 minutes of struggle and the last four minutes i'm serious man i've seen it it was real i saw it on a thursday night against the jets uh where tim tebow time hit and you became it looked like a different player did you feel something different because it was real to me and i'm wondering how real it was to you that it's tebow time in the nfl sometimes i just wish i could have been better in the first three quarters like i remember i even had um one maybe two coach bear remember one conversation he was like hey man that was what the end of the game that was awesome how can we do that in the first half and i was like i don't know i it's not that it's a lack of effort or focus i don't know i just you know it's the more you get into the game and the rivalry and the heat of it or the those moments i just i don't know i just always have loved it what doesn't matter the sport or the age of it i love those moments and i felt like um it was just for some reason i would play better now i should have just really learned how to just play better in the first three quarters right different conversation well i mean and and last one and then we'll get to what we were uh going to discuss with with with um with all state um the first ever nfl playoff game with the new overtime rules where a touchdown wins it field goal doesn't but a touchdown does jim nance on cbs was barely halfway through describing what the new overtime rules were when you hit demarius thomas to beat the steelers what was that moment like for you from overtime conversation to huddle to snap play call all of that if you don't mind walking me through that yeah it was um surreal the celebration but one of the the fascinating things rich about that play is we had been in that formation goodness uh remember off the top of my head on first down maybe 20 something times in the game um and getting ready for the overtime we had been running a lot of zone read um because their ends were so gifted that why would we not just read them instead of block them when they're somewhat unblockable i mean you know especially a james harrison so we were like let's just read them so we had run that quite a few times in the game.

35:38And so we were on the sidelines and we had a, that pass concept we ended up using, but we had never done it out of that formation. And we, I think we had only ever done it out of under center as a play action. So, um, uh, coach McCoy, we are sitting down, we think, what can we do this, uh, off of the gun? So we literally, although we've done that play action and we've done the route concept, we've never done it all together. And so that was a, a first time we had ever done that in overtime um and when i get um uh when i walk up to the line and to recall the protection i'm looking i'm like there's there's no way like are they are they really playing zero right now and and honestly it's because of the run and they wanted both of those safeties to be able to come in and uh and and fill and gap contain and so i'm just like no way and so we um i get the snap and the play action I'm thinking is this safety not going to get back and they didn't so now you see both of them um that are dropping down and um and Demarius gets behind them and throw it and then Demarius does the rest and the stiff arm and running down the sideline and one of my favorite moments about that is when you watch the the coach's copy or maybe even uh the I think it was on CBS the CBS copy the you can see as Demarius is running down the sideline Champ Bailey, a Hall of Fame cornerback that is an amazing leader and awesome friend and awesome guy, is how much a veteran like that cares.

37:09He is sprinting down the sideline almost as fast as DT is. And DT is really fast. And that just shows the relationships and that brotherhood on that team that you have one of the best players at his position ever, maybe. and Cham cares that much that he is on the sideline and he is sprinting full speed right beside DT. And it's just one of my favorite things to show the belief and the family and the friendship that team really had.

37:37Rich Eisen:What was the moment like when you saw Elway after that, Tim? It's just surreal. I mean, all of the coaches, all of the staff, all of the front office, it was, I think one of my favorite things about it was watching all of my teammates be celebrated by the stands that didn't leave. Like they stayed there for like what felt like forever. They just stayed and people stayed and celebrated. And it's just such a special moment. It really was. And it's a moment that I just think was really special in the way that it was celebrated by so many. And I wish I could keep celebrating it with DT and you'll miss it a lot.

38:24Rich Eisen:Well said, well put, Tim. Let's talk about the Allstate AFC Good Works team. What is it? What should people know about it and maybe get involved in any way, shape, or form? Well, what they should know about it is this is an incredible award for what these young men are doing, not on the field, but off the field. Because, Rich, there's so many amazing awards for how they perform on the field, but this is for who they are and the impact they're making off of the field. And that's why I'm so grateful for Allstate and the AFC Good Works team of celebrating these young men because it is so important that young people have role models, not just for what they do on a field or a court or in a sport, but what they do and who they are off of it and the impact they're making.

39:04And we look at what these young men are doing, like Adam Randall at Clemson, and the difference he's making in South Carolina and South Africa, or Coach Venerables and the difference he's making as the honoree coach, or Josh Gaddis, a tight end for Kentucky, or Richie Leonard and the offensive lineman for FSU. for FSU. And you know, he's doing making amazing job. So I'm going to highlight an FSU player as a Gator, all of these players and the difference that they're making and, and truly the impact that they're having. And I've been able to see it firsthand. I've been able to see it through stories.

39:37I've been able to see it through lives and communities. And it's just so special, you know, like take Michael Taft, the safety at Texas, that's an incredible player. And, you know, every time he gets a tackle, it's Taft's tackles in fighting fentanyl awareness. And so it's just love it like there's there's such a when so many people especially now in in college are making it about them they're making it about so many others in their communities especially those that are suffering and so i'm so grateful and i'd love to ask your listeners go to espn.com slash allstate and go vote for who you believe should be the team captain who will also receive the allstate werfel trophy um danny was a hero to me and so it's it's awesome that we get to celebrate that and there's so many amazing stories so go vote for who you believe should be the team captain.

40:25Rich Eisen:Yeah man, you were the 2008 Allstate Werfel Trophy recipient and a 2009 Good Works team member so obviously this has been around a while and fans can vote through November 10th who should win the 2025 Allstate Werfel Trophy recipient Great to see you Tim Let's do this more often man This is a lot of fun, great memory lane stuff, great memory lane stuff and I believe again the day that I met you for the first time was on the NFL Network NFL Total Access Super Bowl set in Indianapolis where Madonna showed up as well I don't know if you crossed paths with Madonna on that day Tim but I didn't think I did at least not on that show but I love it what a great what a great awesome memory I love it let's do it again soon brother thank you that's Tim Tebow obviously you can check him out on the SEC Network through ESPN and right here on the Rich Eisen Show yeah I mean he doesn't remember why I remember that Madonna was there that day.

41:21Rich Eisen:Well, I do. I think I know. If Del Tufo was here, he'd know too, because she came to the set and I handed him my blackberry and said, take pictures, will you please? And he goes, I got it. They were the blurriest, worst pictures of all time. And it looked like she was a little dot because it was so far away. When I first began to learn, don't trust him with anything really important. I'll speak for him. I don't have everything ready. Except the audio of the program is very important. We'll take a break. 844-204-RICH is the number to dial to have a chat with us here on this edition of The Rich Eisen Show.

42:03Rich Eisen:Need parts fast? O 'Reilly Auto Parts as fast. Need them now? We've got now. No matter what you need, we have thousands of professional parts people doing their part to make sure you have it. We're O 'Reilly Fast. Just one part that makes O 'Reilly stand apart. The professional parts people. Oh, oh, oh, O 'Reilly. Auto Parts.

42:34Rich Eisen:Rich Eisen here. Running a small business means every hire matters. A bad hire costs time and money, but the right one helps your business grow. The challenge? Finding that person without sorting through resumes. That's where LinkedIn Hiring Pro comes in. It screens candidates so you can focus on conversations with qualified talent. With Hiring Pro, you can hire with confidence and build the team you need. Join the 2.7 million small businesses using LinkedIn to hire. Get started by posting your job for free at linkedin.com slash eisen. Terms and conditions apply. The Rich Eisen Show, the podcast.

43:09Rich Eisen:Rich Eisen Show, ESPN Radio is presented by Progressive Insurance, Progressive Commercial Insurance, protecting your business vehicles 24-7. See if you can save at ProgressiveCommercial.com. 844-204-RICH is the number to dial. Great fun stuff with Tim Tebow. You like his advice for Arch? Just go back to when you started loving football. Yeah, I do like that. You know. Didn't we all do that as kids, man? Watching football, commercials, get up, have a catch. There's a lot of stuff being written and said about Arch right now. Which is? That is probably not going to age well. Oh, yeah, for sure. I mean, he is struggling.

43:51Rich Eisen:Sure. To put up numbers worthy of being a Heisman Trophy candidate. He did five touchdowns last game. But how about, I mean, I understand that. but i'm just i'm just saying i know but it's it is unfair he wasn't coming out saying i'm a heisman trophy candidate well no we just saw the name and he plays for texas and they're number one preseason and so we you know myself included they just kind of anointed him and then it's human nature to want to tear somebody down because they're doing well or you don't want to see them do well which you know we see every day i guess it just comes down to it what's going to happen towards the end of the year when Texas does make the college football playoff.

44:31Rich Eisen:Don't you think they'll make the college football playoff? Don't you think they're going to be one of the 12 teams? I'd be shocked if they didn't make it, but stranger things have happened. And that's when the rubber will meet the road for just year one for Arch. And that game against Florida is coming up, isn't it? Florida not off to a great start, but they did play really good defense against LSU. As he said, it was everything except, you know, giving the ball away to LSU multiple times. Don't have five interceptions. Right. And just don't ask Brian Kelly why he can't run the football. He did say that he needed to do better next time he's asked a question like that.

45:14Rich Eisen:At least he knew. Yeah, he did. Or knows. Right. 844-204-RICH. Again, the number to dial. Top of the next hour, there's an update on Jaden Daniels. Oh, please be good. I mean I'm so torn here Rich I got real life and I got fantasy football I don't know what I'm saying again at least you didn't spend a third of your guillotine league funds on a guy that isn't going to play this week it doesn't matter who plays next week you might be out he's not going to sit the whole year you jerks I'm saying you might lose this week I ain't losing this week there's a Joe Burrow update Ben Johnson was asked about hey man Tom Brady's calling your game.

45:58Rich Eisen:What's going on? What's up with that? What are you going to say to him? He's calling them Bears Cowboys.

46:07Rich Eisen:He's been around the league a little bit. Then you play the Raiders. Yeah, right. Then you play the Raiders. What's up? So Ben Johnson is the first coach to be asked about Tom Brady's conflicts. I like it. That's coming up. Dean Blandino is about to join us. He says he's done with the tush push. You know who also is? If you saw Inside the NFL? Chris Jones. Chris Jones is very much done with it. Chris Jones is very much done. Everything that you thought about him crashing out about the tush push was confirmed by Inside the NFL Films microphone setups. He's not happy. Oh, he's done with it. Yeah, he's not happy.

46:43Rich Eisen:I'm sick and tired. If somebody keeps on shoving you over, over and over again, wouldn't you want to push back? Stop it. Okay. Yeah. Okay. He should stop it. Very good. As I mentioned, Dean Blandino, and then we've got Tyreek Withers of the new film Him, which is a psychological horror football movie. Oh, my gosh. That's a Mad Lib for you if I've ever heard one. I thought that was watching the Cowboys each week. The Ridge Eisen Show Podcast.

47:14Athletic Brewing Company crafts award-winning non-alcoholic beers for those who want to be part of every round. With over 185 flavor awards, they're exceptional NA beers that fit your lifestyle and any social occasion. Summer's full of good times, and athletic fits right in. Go to athleticbrewing.com to have brews delivered to your door, or find them at a bar, restaurant, or store near you. Near Beer. Athletic Brewing Company. Fit for all times.

From the publisher

Rich lays out what’s at stake for Dolphins head coach Mike McDaniel in Miami’s Thursday Night Football AFC East matchup against the Buffalo Bills.

SEC Network analyst/2007 Heisman Trophy winner Tim Tebow and Rich discuss the state of his alma mater’s (Florida Gators) football program, if Oklahoma is the best team in the SEC, Michigan true freshman QB Bryce Underwood, reveals what advice he has for Texas Longhorns QB Arch Manning in dealing with all the hype and criticism, revisits the peak of ‘Tebow Time’ in the Denver Broncos’ thrilling overtime win over the Pittsburgh Steelers in 2012 and more.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from The Rich Eisen Show

All 1,076 episodes
Hour 1: Mike McDaniel’s Hot Seat, Tim Tebow Talks Arch Manning & MoreThe Rich Eisen Show · 46 min
Listen in VO