1. Podcasts
  2. The Rich Eisen Show
  3. Hour 2: Rich’s Yankees Postmortem, MLB’s Playoffs Changes Proposal, plus NFL on CBS’ Kyle Long
The Rich Eisen Show

8 Oct 2026 · 47m · 13 chapters

Episode artwork

Hour 2: Rich’s Yankees Postmortem, MLB’s Playoffs Changes Proposal, plus NFL on CBS’ Kyle Long

In short

Hour 2 of The Rich Eisen Show mixes mental-health advocacy with NFL talk and then pivots to MLB postseason format proposals and a Yankees postseason “postmortem,” plus discussion of payroll disparities.

Guests (mentioned/featured in this hour)

Kyle Long (former NFL offensive tackle; CBS NFL analyst; Johnson & Johnson “Generation Fine” mental-health partner). Also referenced later: Vinny Pasantino (Royals first baseman) is scheduled for Hour 3 but not heard in this transcript.

Key claims

Long says about 1 in 10 U.S. men (6 million) experience depression/anxiety, but fewer than half get treatment; “fine” isn’t the finish line. He frames Lane Johnson’s retirement as pressure-related and “selfless” self-care. Eisen argues MLB’s proposed opponent-selection format is unfair because a lower-seeded team could choose an opponent for a higher-seeded division winner.

Notable examples

Lane Johnson’s mental-health decision; Yankees swept in the divisional series; MLB proposal: 154-game season, best-of-seven division series, and higher seeds selecting opponents starting 2027/2029.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:32

Discussion with Kyle Long

Rich Eisen talks with Kyle Long about mental health and the Generation Fine initiative.

“He took a home run away from Manny Machado.”
2:56

The Pressure of the NFL

Kyle discusses the pressures faced by NFL players, particularly Lane Johnson.

“And congrats on everything that's going on right now in your professional career.”
6:17

The Reality of Football

Rich and Kyle reflect on the harsh realities of playing in the NFL and its impact on players.

“And again, just to, you know, add a little bit more of the humanity to it.”
7:37

NFL Team Performances

A discussion on the performances of various NFL teams and players this season.

“There's a, there's a lot of fear in there.”
13:13

Caleb Williams and Future Prospects

Discussion about Caleb Williams and his prospects in the NFL.

“Best team in the NFL through four weeks is?”
14:00

Evaluating Backup Quarterbacks

Discussion on the performance of backup quarterbacks and implications for Caleb Williams.

“didn't complain when Case Keenum went out there, got the start, and the one play second start for Tyson Bajan's game, which is so Ben Johnson, psychopath move behavior.”
15:46

Kyle Long's Insights on Life and Career

Kyle Long shares personal experiences and insights about his career and family.

“All right, Kyle long before I let you go, how can people get involved with generation?”
17:48

Rich Eisen's Nostalgic Reflections

Rich Eisen reminisces about past interviews and experiences in the sports world.

“People are like, that's just the movies.”
20:48

Rich Eisen's Nostalgic Reflections

Rich Eisen reminisces about past interviews and experiences in the sports world.

“A SoFi personal loan is here to help you achieve something once thought impossible, overcoming high-interest credit card debt.”
22:29

Rich Eisen's Yankees Postmortem

Rich Eisen analyzes the Yankees' performance in the postseason and discusses team dynamics.

“Plus, receive a$15 O 'Reilly gift card after rebate.”
Show all 13 chapters
28:00

Yankees Postmortem: Roster and Performance Analysis

Discuss the Yankees' recent playoff performance and roster decisions.

“He didn't get even an at-bat against the Red Sox because they didn't need him, I guess.”
37:40

MLB Playoff Format Changes Proposal

Explore the new proposals for MLB playoff formats and their implications.

“88 % of small businesses say they trust LinkedIn's candidate recommendations.”
42:00

Proposed Changes to MLB Playoffs

Explore the recent proposals for changes in Major League Baseball's playoff structure and the implications for teams.

“So it can be like, hey, you think we got to redo the financial system?”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The Rich Eisen Show, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00It's Saturday. The leaves are piling up, the game's coming on, and your fall cleanup could use a quick assist. Need a blower, yard bags, or a few more supplies? Express Delivery from the Home Depot can get you what you need delivered in a snap. Order in the app or online and track it along the way so you can wrap up the yard before kickoff. Get what you need in two hours or less with Express Delivery from the Home Depot. Subject to availability, order select in-stock items by 4 p.m. Restrictions and fees apply. Hockey on ESPN is blowing up. Hockey is back. So, what does it look like now? The kids?

0:38Hughes. Celebrini. Schaefer. That's hockey. Ovi and Crosby. That's hockey.

0:43Rich Eisen: And with access to over a thousand out-of-market games, you can watch them and the rest of the league. Holy hockey. That's more hockey to love for more fans who love it. The NHL's best on ESPN. Watch all season long on ABC, ESPN, ESPN Plus, and the ESPN app. This is the Rich Eisen Show. Hey, everybody. Can't get enough of the Rich Eisen Show? You're in luck. You can find us everywhere. Watch us weekdays on Disney Plus from noon to 3 Eastern. Miss the show? We've got a podcast so you can listen anytime. But here's the best part. Our YouTube channel. Subscribe at youtube.com slash Rich Eisen Show and you'll never miss a moment.

1:27Now, on with the show.

1:32Rich Eisen: This is the Rich Eisen Show. He took a home run away from Manny Machado. From the Rich Eisen Show's studio in Los Angeles. There's no more talented team than the Los Angeles Dodgers. Earlier on the show, ESPN NFL analyst Jeff Saturday. Coming up, CBS Sports NFL analyst Kyle Long. Royals first baseman Vinny Pasantino. And now it's Rich Eisen. Hour number two of the Rich Eisen show is on the air here. Listen, just to let you in on how things sometimes operate in a show like this one. We talk about having a guest on the program. Sometimes the timing works out. Sometimes the timing doesn't work out.

2:17Rich Eisen: And then you try and find a time in the future where the guest can join. And sometimes that works out even better than one can expect. because talk about perfectly timed. Kyle Long, who's doing a terrific job on CBS, is joining us here on the program as planned on this very day to talk about something called Generation Fine and how one in 10 United States men, 6 million, experience depression or anxiety, but only less than half go ahead and receive treatment. And it is a pleasure to see you on my screen here, Kyle Long. How are you, sir? Legend. What's going on, Rich? Huge fan of yours. Thanks for having me.

3:00Rich Eisen: And congrats on everything that's going on right now in your professional career. And again, like I said, perfectly timed. I'd love to give you the floor and your thoughts about when you heard Lane Johnson was retiring and talking about his mental health. Well, I think I'll get this part out of the way. The reason that you and I were on the books originally is because I'm part of this Johnson & Johnson campaign where we've partnered together on the Generation Fine movement, and the topic has been all things mental health, dealing with depression, fine not being the finish line. You know, so often we get stuck as men in the rut of saying, I'm fine, all good, but fine is in the finish line, right?

3:37We want to be great, and that's what we strive to do. And like I've been explaining to some of my colleagues and friends over the course of the last few days with the Lane Johnson news, look, if you get a hamstring, you go into the training room and you take care of it. Your high ankle sprain, you do all the things you're supposed to do. If you want better cardio health, you get on the Stairmaster and you go and you get your butt on there for five days a week or whatever it is. Well, mental health has been something where we don't have that immediate itch that you can scratch or at least the know-how too.

4:10And I think that partnering with Johnson & Johnson has been great because with the Generation Fine movement, it gives people a place to go. It's generation-fine.com. for stories, information, to get connected with the right people, places and things to get you out of your rut. And mental health is so important right now, Rich.

4:29Rich Eisen: No question about it, Kyle. And I was talking about it on the Wednesday show, that there is no crutch, there's no brace, there's no bandage, there's nothing except you're looking at somebody who plays the National Football League for a living, which is a dream for so many others, that it's difficult for folks to comprehend. How can somebody who's generationally enriched and generationally talented like Lane Johnson wake up with a gray day to the point where he says, I can't do this anymore or I shouldn't do this anymore? Can you help with that, Kyle? Well, it's important to understand the position that Lane plays, and it's the most selfless position in the most selfless sport on the planet.

5:15And he has been at the very top of the game for 14 years now. And it's a pressure cooker, the NFL. I don't care if you're a punter, kicker, long snapper, linebacker, safety, or an offensive lineman. And Lane did the most selfless one. And I just commend him for being selfish in this instance in a good way. And I don't mean that as a bad thing in taking care of himself and deeming this to be the most important thing right now. Look, I mean, you can't imagine the difficulty it is you have trying to go to sleep the night before a game or picture good things happening because as an offensive lineman, we don't have stats, right?

5:53The only stat we have is holding and false starts. The only time you really get circled is when your quarterback's on the ground. So if you can imagine for Lane Johnson, 14 years of that, and then we're also human beings, right? You go home and you've got family, you've got all these things. So Lane weighed his his decision and he made it. And, you know, he will go down as the greatest eagle of all time. And if anybody has anything to say about that, just go watch the tape. Yeah.

6:21Rich Eisen: And again, just to, you know, add a little bit more of the humanity to it. Years ago, I don't remember what year it was, but I was interviewing your dad for this show. And the Bears were playing the Eagles, I think. Right, Chris? Is that what that could have been? the Patriots too I don't know when what whichever team your brother Chris was on at the time and we were at the Hall of Fame and I was interviewing your dad and I'm like boy you know you and your your wife you know when Kyle and Chris are playing against each other this is going to be a great day for you and he's like not so much because every snap between the offensive and defensive line he called it a car crash he goes it's a car crash every time yeah and you're you know my you know you and your mom you know you and diane's heart he said our hearts are gonna be our throats for every step you know and i'll i it always sticks with me whenever i think it's uh it's a very real thing sometimes there's so many superhuman things happening on screen and you know the national football league we do such a great job of presenting this product as shiny and clean but you and i both know having been around it how nasty and and uh raw this thing is and along with with the physicality and sheer size of these people.

7:37There's a, there's a lot of fear in there. There's a lot of anxiety that can come up and clearly all across the league, not just Lane Johnson, you know, guys like Joe Thomas have spoken up who was seemingly invincible in Cleveland at a very tough time for that franchise. Even he speaks up on, you know, his inability and ability to kind of navigate through some of the throws of the difficult times in the national football league.

8:03Rich Eisen: Kyle Long here on the Rich Eisen show how you how you like in the uh Sunday morning tv dude it is it is my dream and you know you mentioned talking to my dad and it's uh it's not lost on me how lucky I am to have grown up in this business and for so many guys they saw football as the finish line I always knew that I wanted to get into the media and just like quarterback one seats in the National Football League there's only 30 32 I couldn't tell you how many seats there are for pregame shows, but there ain't many. And I've got one and I've got fantastic guys that I sit with. Russell Wilson's a rookie and he is going to win rookie of the year.

8:40No doubt. Nate Burleson is like, what can he do? Coach Cowher reminds me a lot of my dad. So when me and him are on the desk together, I feel really comfortable with that chemistry. And then obviously James Brown, he is triple OG certified. And he worked at Fox for a long time with my dad. So I'm plugged in with him. I'm really lucky to have that crew to work with every Sunday. So it's either that or Firestorm 2. Is that what it would have been, Carl? They said that my hair follicles weren't quite up to par for the casting. Rich, you know, we've been left out of a lot of leading roles because of our –

9:15Rich Eisen: Listen, it's beautiful, Carl. You know, listen. And that's why I'm rooting for the Titans. They're all – it's not going well for the follicle challenge right now. That entire coaching staff either needs to win a game or go to Turkey. You know what I mean? Like, let's go. And maybe a combination of both. But, like, when I think about, you know, 0-4 and 0-4 isn't all the same, right? So Titans, Texans, this Texans team's got to figure some stuff out too, brother, because this was a championship defense on paper and in conversation. Right. And now we've got D 'Amico Ryan's going to be taking over play calling.

9:52uh there's a lot of that passing of the sticks as it were davis webb doing the same thing with sean payton uh allegedly and you never know i guess sean i'm changing gears a lot on go for it sean payton said i'm gonna go with more of a collaborative approach and you and i know what that means with sean payton sean payton's like that's my playstation controller buddy you're just gonna you're gonna have a say in it i'll be pressing the buttons which is why listen and

10:18Rich Eisen: everybody who knows him was, you know, somewhat surprised because in the same way that we were talking about mental health and stuff like that, it's true that, you know, I think Sean Payton's like taking stock, like that at the end of the day, the pressure of the calling the plays and whatever, if I'm removing that, I could be a better coach to everybody. But at the end of the day, when you know one way to do, like it's sort of like the only way I run the 40-yard dash, Kyle, I only know one speed. You know what I mean? Yeah, don't let your job get in the way of your superpower for Sean Payton, right?

10:53Like, sure, you have a job. Like, what do you want to shake hands and kiss more babies? Like, just call the plays that let your super clutch quarterback Bo Nix go win the football game. And obviously, they lean on that defense. But at the end of the day, you look at their wins and losses, and most of their wins have come on the backs of Bo Nix performances late in the fourth quarter and Sean Payton dialing up some smart stuff. Did the Patriots save their season last week? Or is that too strong? You got to think the Patriots are feeling pretty good. But at the end of the day, that was a stress test for Drake May, right?

11:27Now this week will be the stress test for that offensive line because Malcolm Koontz, N 'Kobe Dean, Max Crosby, and the boys, they're not quite licking their chops after last week. They're not licking their wounds. I think they're licking their chops. You know what I'm saying? They're fired up for this opportunity to get after Drake May. You know, if we couldn't kill Patrick Mahomes, let's go after the other guy. But it's that defense for the Patriots that really has been showing me stuff. Gabe Jack is on the outside. And obviously a number of guys, Christian Gonzalez health is going to be an issue moving forward.

11:58But it's the Patriot way, right? You get a guy that can do like six things, line them up everywhere, make them do everything.

12:04Rich Eisen: I think you just made an interesting point about the Raiders, Kyle Long, because we're all focused on Kubiak being the guy bringing his offense. and look at Kirk Cousins keeping Fernando Mendoza in mentor E mode, right, as opposed to the guy who's going to come out and be the rookie of the year type of season. And that's totally cool, right? And Ashton Gentry looking the way he looks and Bowers looking the way he looks, but it's the defense is making the Raiders, quote unquote, for real, right? Yeah, absolutely. But it's like driving a Toyota. When you have Kirk Cousins in the lineup, it's like driving a Toyota.

12:38You don't even have to think about it. You know it's going to start. You know it's going to run. You're just going to get you to point A to point B. This is a Hyundai show, Kyle. This is a Hyundai show.

12:44Rich Eisen: Can you make that analogy? I'm sorry. You know, it's like the Hyundai Elantra. You know, you get in that thing, and it gets you from A to B as quickly and safely as possible. And then you can worry about, you know, where do we get our teeth? You can throw some rims on that bad boy, too. And that's what they've done. Max Crosby, Malcolm Koons, Nekobi Dean. The list goes on and on and on. But this Raiders team isn't just a gritty bunch punching up anymore. They're very in the same weight class now as these bigger teams, and they're out to prove it. They got to do it against the Patriots. Best team in the NFL through four weeks is?

13:19My goodness. Is that substation still going in San Francisco? I think the San Francisco 49ers are a pretty damn complete football team. But then again, that team in Chicago has showed me some stuff, man. I had real concerns about the defense, but they're above and beyond, in my opinion, the best third down defense in the National Football League, and they're still finding their feet. They get their guy, Kyler Gordon, back there roaming the secondary. He's a blitz package guy as well. And then obviously everybody and their mom has talked about Ben Johnson, Caleb Williams, Case Keenum, and Tyson Bajan.

13:50So can Tyson Bajan go out there and beat up on the Packers at Lambeau? That'll be fun to watch. This team feels like destiny, man. Feels like destiny. There's the guy right there, Tyson Bajan, selfless, didn't complain when Case Keenum went out there, got the start, and the one play second start for Tyson Bajan's game, which is so Ben Johnson, psychopath move behavior. I love it.

14:15Rich Eisen: He just wanted to prove, right? Like everybody says who's starting this week and guess what? I'm going to put two quarterbacks out there and make a mockery of the win-loss record stuff. I think I'm going to do what I want. I think I'm going to do exactly what I want. That's Ben Johnson, right? Yeah, I don't know with the pen clicking and all of that, but in all seriousness, to your point here, do you think because last year it was like Caleb Williams drinking out of a fire hose all summer what's he gonna look like and is this gonna really work yes remember all that and then and then they start winning games by pulling it out of their orifice every single week and Caleb is the ice man and now this year is supposed to be a different ball of wax because he's coming in in a certain way and then they come up and put 60 points on the board and off he goes now with a hamstring injury Do you think in the long run, though, this could be helpful, right?

15:05I think what could be helpful is seeing how efficient and on time the trains are running with these backup quarterbacks. And for him to see Case Keenan work in rhythm, on time, within the structure of the offense. Obviously, everybody knows Caleb Williams can do things once the expiration date runs out in the pocket. He can pirouette like Russell Wilson going to his left. He can go right, make any throw in the field. But the thing that has been in doubt is his ability to drop back. And when that back foot hits the ground at the top of his drop, delivering the strike on time and rhythm, maybe he's learned some from these guys.

15:40Look, and if he has look out everybody, because the bears are going to be scoring 65 points every week.

15:46Rich Eisen: All right, Kyle long before I let you go, how can people get involved with generation? Fine, please. Go check out generation dash fine.com. Obviously Johnson and Johnson and myself, we've partnered on this thing. And it hits really close to home for me. And I think it may hit close to home for you and people you know. I can almost guarantee it. Thanks so much, Rich. Of course, Kyle. Because, again, I imagine it's called fine because so many people are like, I'm fine. You know, they just kind of just brush it aside. It's fine. It's not the finish line, dude. You know? Well, when you see Russell Wilson, ask him who the – and with all due respect to James Brown, who, as you point out, is a goat.

16:22Rich Eisen: And I love the guy, right? um ask him who who the first host of a sunday morning show that he ever did in his career was okay because okay um and i guess you know what the answer is and ask nate burleson uh who the first interview he did on nfl network with when he showed off his chops for the first time uh of which he has many he has many oh my god does he ever uh ask ask ask them both don't do it in front of jb you know because i don't want to make it seem like i'm i'm i'm rich i gotta pinch myself sometimes i'm talking to rich eyes the fat the fastest guy in the medium that is right that is right the longevity uh lane johnson did it for 14 years how long you've been running um running the 40 yard dash yeah oh uh 20 so like you are like uh bruce matthews now oh i'll take it Yeah, man.

17:14I'll take it. Shout out to Jake Matthews. I hope he can play. He got dinged up last week. He's at like 189. We got to get him to catch his pops. I'm all about kids catching their dads.

17:25Rich Eisen: Last one for you. I don't know if you have to run, but just last one. Did your dad ever sit you and Chris down and watch Firestorm with you? Yeah, he locked us in a room and put Firestorm on. Did you ever know seriously, like sit down and watch Broken Arrow with your dad? You know what? Of course. I mean, my dad is our hero. He's our hero. And growing up, it's, you know, my dad's an action hero. Watch this. He kicks this guy's ass in the movie. People are like, that's just the movies. I'm like, no, no, no. Trust this guy. He knows what he's doing. See, I know that's pretty cool with me. It's like, Hey kid, sit down and watch dad on celebrity wheel of fortune.

18:02Rich Eisen: Doesn't have the same kick to it. You know what I mean? Yeah, no, no, no. You do much better in a hosting role than, uh, than he does. That's my firestorm. He's more security. okay i love it thanks a lot rich i know you got stuff to do no you too good to see you man enjoy i'm gonna go take my daughter to tennis we both get tennis lessons together in the same building and it's been fun okay what's your game look like what do we got big powerful i like to go cross court with the forehand i don't like to do doubles i like singles okay um gives some good gaps to hit it into it takes me back to baseball a little left center right center action okay Very good.

18:37Enjoy that.

18:38Rich Eisen: Enjoy being father of the year, Kyle. You be right. Oh, Rich. Take it easy, guys. Carl Long, everybody. Yes, sir. It was a delightful first foray here on the Rich Eisen Show. There he goes. You know the answer to the questions about the Russell Wilson and the Nate Burleson, who are the first? I might have been there that day. What, for Russ? Yeah. It was the year again. He was, was it his rookie year? Because he was the first one there, right? He beat me to the studio. Yeah. Yeah. And then I feel like I remember that. And then we were going to ask him to do the next week as well. But I think he had to go because he made the Pro Bowl because Matt Ryan made the NFC Championship game.

19:19Rich Eisen: That's my memory. If it serves. Or Matt Ryan made the Super Bowl. That's what it was. He came in to do the Championship Sunday after he won. He won in his rookie season, a playoff game. So 2012, 2012. I think so. That's what memory serves. because i i remember he had to run out because he had to go to the he had to go to the um he had to go to hawaii i'm almost sure of it yeah he was a pro bowl pick that year his rookie year right i don't know whatever oh i the one thing i definitely remember is that he beat me to the studio and then he sent me a jersey a seattle seahawks signed jersey as a thank you i guess high class as it comes same thing with james brown which is why i'm pointing out you know I beat James to the punch with Russell.

20:06Rich Eisen: Yeah. Because I'm low class. What's Eisen? Thank you. Kyle Long, really good baseball player, drafted by the White Sox. How about that? Oh, I should have asked him. Yes. We'll leave baseball to get him back on. We'll stay in the lane. Turn the machines back on. Baseball. I'd love to turn the machines back on in the American League Divisional Series. I bet. I'd love to turn the clocks back to maybe May. Or the office. Or 1986. Yeah. That part. DJ wants spring training. Let him get a DeLorean. Let him Alonzo walk. 844-204-RICH, number to dial here on the Rich Eisen Show. We'll take some phone calls, come back, talk a little bit more of our baseball world for sure.

20:48Rich Eisen: A SoFi personal loan is here to help you achieve something once thought impossible, overcoming high-interest credit card debt. Walk the tightrope of your finances right now. With one low fixed rate monthly payment, no fees required, and as soon as the same-day funding. That's right. Pull off your own debt-defying stunt right now with a SoFi personal loan. Please visit SoFi.com slash trick to learn more. Loans originated by SoFi Bank, NA member, FDIC. Terms and conditions apply. NMLS 696891. That was fun with Kyle. Who's Chris anymore anyway? Hi. The Rich Isis Show Podcast. In a world in need of a hero, one man rises to the challenge in style.

21:32Rich Eisen: He is just driving the kids to soccer practice. Make every day feel epic in an all-new Hyundai Palisade Hybrid with up to an EPA-estimated 619 miles of range on select trims, advanced tech, and class-leading interior space. Because when you're hauling kids' gear, snacks, and backpacks, space matters. And so does comfort. Just make sure they keep their cleats off the seats. Visit HyundaiUSA.com or call 562-314-4603 for details. Hiring for a small business is hard. You don't often have a team of people helping out. That's why LinkedIn built HiringPro. It's like having a true hiring partner, and you can chat with it just like you would a recruiter.

22:10Rich Eisen: HiringPro listens, adjusts, and shows you the people that actually fit your needs. 88 % of small businesses say they trust LinkedIn's candidate recommendations. Be confident in your hiring decisions with LinkedIn Hiring Pro. Post your job for free at linkedin.com slash eisen. Terms and conditions apply. Get a free Wix oil filter when you buy five quarts of Valvoline Full Synthetic Restore and Protect motor oil at O 'Reilly Auto Parts. Terms and limits apply. Plus, receive a$15 O 'Reilly gift card after rebate. Visit your O 'Reilly Auto Parts store or o'reillyauto.com. Ladies and gentlemen, we're back here on the Rich Eisen Show.

22:48Rich Eisen: So hire at the first time with LinkedIn hiring pro get started by posting a free job at LinkedIn.com slash Eisen. There are many in New York city that would love to see a, a posting on LinkedIn for a new Yankee general manager. 100 % regular manager, regular manager. But I'll say this man, Aaron, Aaron Boone. I understand the results. It's a results oriented business, but the guy didn't have Aaron judge for two thirds of the season. didn't have Stanton for most of the season, and didn't have Radon, didn't have Freed. You know, I mean. It's not the first time. Didn't have Cole. He's had chances.

23:27Rich Eisen: It's just, again, the fact that the Yankees performed as well as they did during the regular season. And you're not allowed to turn your microphone off, Dodger fan. I was a Yankee fan, and you lost. Was, was, was. I was. I'm the real Yankee fan here. The guy on the screen in the middle in the hoodie, an Aaron Judge, didn't take a single swing in the postseason except in the cage to see if he could come back from an injury that he suffered after he came back from the injury that kept him out most of the year. And the guy on the left on the screen is George Lombard Jr., who is 1 ,000 % the Yankees shortstop of the future.

24:06Rich Eisen: And the guy on the right is also part and parcel of the Yankees' current roster. It's Paul Goldschmidt, who I think is a baseball Hall of Famer. at the end of his career, who's only playing first base when there's a lefty, he's a platoon guy now. And, you know, the problem is when Goldschmidt is at first, now you've got Luis Garcia, who's your left-handed hitting first baseman. And what does that mean with Ben Rice? Because you're not going to put him behind home plate anymore. anymore so that's the way they used to get Ben Rice in to the lineup before he became knocking on wood for Yankee fans here Aaron Judge 2.0 a left-handed hitting judge this kid just crushed it in the postseason crushed it was forget about a pulse he was a heartbeat of the team against the Red Sox and the only guy who showed up offensively with consistency against the Rays, who were just basically pitching around him to get to Cody Bellinger, which is nuts.

25:18Rich Eisen: So, and then if Stanton was even healthy, how do you work him in? Because he's not playing the field. What would Ben Rice have played? The roster, the way it is put together for the Yankees is a big, huge-ass mystery, and you're throwing that on Boone's lap. Okay, you also found Spencer Jones. You're going to put him in the outfield. What happens when Judge is healthy? And, you know, the fact that they made the proper maneuvers to get Trent Grisham or to get a draft choice for Trent Grisham, who they thought was going to take, I think, a deal elsewhere, he comes back, and it's only fitting he made the last out against the Rays by swinging and missing because this lineup just doesn't put the ball in play.

26:09Rich Eisen: enough. When they did against the Red Sox, they looked like world beaters. When the Rays came in, they were a totally different team. Totally different against the team in the Rays that puts the ball in play and has pitching that is not as well decorated or paid as the Yankee staff, but it's damn good. It's damn good. And the Yankees go down in the divisional series without winning a game. I don't believe they had a lead at all. And it doesn't matter that if your lead is essentially in payroll when you are currently the third highest payroll payroll in Major League Baseball at$308 million, and the Tampa Bay Rays are all down at the 28th highest payroll at$95 million.

27:14Rich Eisen: It doesn't matter if you have that advantage. If you see them, and Judge isn't playing because he's hurt, and you only get, listen, Giancarlo Stanton and Carlos Radon. Together, in 2026, their salaries combined $56 million. Those two players, you can do the math, more than half of the Rays' entire payroll. And all they got from those two guys in this series was two pinch-it-at-bats from Stanton, because how are you going to work him in the lineup if he's healthy enough? He struck out both times because it was the only times he swung a bat since April 24th. He didn't get even an at-bat against the Red Sox because they didn't need him, I guess.

28:09Rich Eisen: I guess you could have gotten his feet wet. And Radon didn't throw a single pitch because you're starting Cole and you're starting Schlittler and you're starting Freed. That, I understand, makes sense. but if you are constructing a roster to get you to the World Series, does it matter? You got swept. Radon didn't throw a pitch. Stanton only hit twice. And how, even if he was healthy, are you going to work him in? Because Ben Rice has got to be the DH, the way that everything is set up on your roster. So whose feet do you lay that? on and don't lay it at the arms of the guy who leaned over like jeffrey mayor could you imagine if that was in fact jeffrey mayor is an older man for his kids this dude is getting lit up he should why because he leaned over first of all what you mean he should we just earlier said that's natural and now he's trying to stir it up over there it wouldn't have been a home run anyway off the bat of Volpe because again the bottom line is the Rays they get a guy in Valade who's on what like team six he's the guy who comes in because they're starting a lefty he's the one who connects off of Max Fried to give the Yankees a lead and the Yankees did get to tie the game again Volpe hits a fly ball to right it doesn't go three rows in it goes barely to the wall and fan interference that would have been a double i just don't know it could it could have hit the wall in a certain way and bounced away and volpe could have advanced or i don't know but the yankees don't hit very well with runners in scoring position in games against really terrific pitching i mean you could say that's the case for most teams but the rays did against terrific pitching for the yankees

30:14Rich Eisen: so why does your gm have a lifetime contract great question uh cash because cashman had some great years and there are i guess there's enough to hang your hat on and how steinbrown has a different approach than his dad which is on occasion really good because his dad was a lunatic he was out of his mind you know his dad was a lunatic but he did tell i think it was ed bradley on 60 minutes you show me a guy who enjoys losing and i'll show you a loser and he could have been describing his son right now to be straight up but he's also house winning on on the revenue side of things and they are spending 300 million dollars on players and the dodgers are just one above them and they're doing everything right because they're spending the money on surefire hall of famers who aren't getting hurt and can put the ball in play or hit it out of the park for a manager who's just turned into a wizard dave roberts now it helped to get freeman and betts and then otani added to the mix but he's he's the one who puts pies in out of nowhere in a world series game seven and gets results he's the one who puts miguel rojas in and he gets results you know boone puts jazz chisholm in and Chisholm basically, you know, turned into Knoblock 2.0 on that play and says, I would throw it again the same, you know, I'd do it again.

31:39Rich Eisen: And it's just like, no, you should not do it again. It's just infuriating because it's another year where Aaron Judge is saying stuff like this after he doesn't even play a game because his body wasn't either ready or the Yankees decided we're not running the risk. he did sound like a guy who needed to blink twice to make sure that there's proof of life because it sounds like he he wanted to play i don't blame him this is a killer for yankee fans to see and hear him like this we're the yankees i feel like they should go all in and do what they need to do and find if we got holes if it's finding certain players or personnel whatever we need you gotta go out there and get it you know that's why i signed back here to play with the yankees is to fight for a championship every single year and to go all in that's what I do every offseason is get ready to give this team and the city everything I got so I expect them to do the same.

32:37Rich Eisen: Back page of the post. Pop it up. If you want, I can see you got it right there. It's wall over. No mayor miracle this time as Yanks get swept away. Hey, listen, it's funny right? You're showing a picture of that kid Jeffrey Mayer back in the day because Richie Garcia blew the call in a Hall of Fame-type blowing a call. Like it's a Mount Rushmore of blown calls in the history of Major League Baseball. And I don't understand why Yankee fans were fetting that moment because it was embarrassing. Embarrassing. And if we're hoping that Yankees are rooting for a blown call to get to a Game 4, that ain't it.

33:17Rich Eisen: Here's what they need to do. They need to find people because they found a shortstop and first base is handled. I mean, Garcia is going to come back. And, you know, I mean, Rice has got to get in somehow. If Stanton is going to still be there and he's going to be there, there's like an option for 2028. He's going to be there. Judge is going to be there. Spencer Jones is going to be there. And Bellinger is going to be there. And Bellinger can play first, too. So you got to get Rice in. You're not going to put him behind home plate. That's for sure. So you got to find people who put the ball in play at second base.

33:53Rich Eisen: and if that's Volpe, so be it. And third base, I don't care. Give me somebody who doesn't hit home runs at third base. I don't care. I know you're supposed to get some pop out of third base. Somebody who gets on base for all of these guys. Put the ball in play for crying out loud. The Yankees got productive outs against the Red Sox. They were unbeatable. Oh, good Lord. So. Shame. I know. Met fan is crying me a river. My brother, if he's listening right now, the tiny violin, I can hear it. The Red Sox fan, I get it. I understand. I'm just giving you a voice of what I've seen all year, what I see all the time.

34:36Rich Eisen: It's very frustrating. You know, and the only way I can get back at the Met fan is say, they're like the Dallas Cowboys. But we've been to the World Series. When? Two years ago. Did you win it? Nope. So you didn't go, essentially. Got it. Says the guy can't wait to get that 30-year drought conversation done. Well, 49ers haven't won at all. Am I lying? You are not. Okay, then. So what are we talking about here? Okay. Let's take a break here on the Rich Eisen Show because Major League Baseball just came up with a proposal. Yeah, in the middle of your Yankee stuff. For future playoff formats. And it's wild.

35:18Rich Eisen: It's great. And you like it, huh? I do. Okay, we're going to unpack it. We're going to unpack it. And Vinny Pasquantino is going to be on the Rich Eisen Show in hour number three. 844-204-RICH, number to dial on the program. The Rich Eisen Show, the podcast.

35:39Rich Eisen: Rich Eisen here for Gusto. On my shows, we talk a lot about what happens in the spotlight, the games, the highlights, and the moments that get replayed and debated. But in any successful operation, and what happens behind the scenes matters just as much. Small businesses are no different. Payroll, hiring, onboarding, benefits, and all the details that keep things moving may not be the most visible part of the job, but they still have to be handled right. That's where Gusto comes in. Gusto is online payroll and benefits software built for small businesses. It's all-in-one, remote-friendly, and incredibly easy to use, so you can pay, hire, onboard, and support your team from anywhere.

36:15Rich Eisen: Automatic payroll tax filing, simple direct deposits, health benefits, commuter benefits, workers' comp, 401k, you name it. Gusto makes it simple and has options for nearly every budget. And it's all built to save you time with built-in automated tools for offer letters, onboarding docs, direct deposit, and more. Plus, you get unlimited payroll runs for one monthly price. No hidden fees, no surprises. Try Gusto today at gusto.com slash rich and get three months free when you run your first payroll. that's three months of free payroll at gusto.com slash rich one more time gusto.com slash rich today's forecast falling leaves football and an 80 chance you're going to need a few more things for that backyard project running low on yard bags need a leaf blower let express delivery from the home depot bring them right to you get fall project essentials delivered fast so you can get it done with plenty of time left for the game.

37:13Get what you need in two hours or less with express delivery from the Home Depot. Subject to availability, order select in-stock items by 4 p.m. Restrictions and fees apply.

37:24Rich Eisen: Wish me luck back here on the Rich Eisen Show. Hiring for a small business is hard. You don't often have a team of people helping out. That's why LinkedIn built Hiring Pro. It's like having a true hiring partner and you can chat with it just like you would a recruiter. Hiring Pro listens, adjusts, and shows you the people that actually fit your needs. 88 % of small businesses say they trust LinkedIn's candidate recommendations. Be confident in your hiring decisions with LinkedIn Hiring Pro. Post your job for free at linkedin.com slash eisen. Terms and conditions apply. Cameron in Redding, California, where I got my television start.

38:04Rich Eisen: What's up, Cameron? How's it going, Red? I'm doing fine there. What's going on? Well, I got a question. With the game being tonight and Dallas playing, and it's been quiet on the offseason, and I thought the defense was going to be squirted away, and it's such a mess right now, in my opinion. Do you think it's the staff or the coaching, or do you think it's the players, or what's the missing piece to get that going? Oh, man.

38:31Rich Eisen: I don't know. Everybody says it's the scheme and the way everything's been dialing it up. That's what Gerald McCoy is telling me on NFL Game Day morning all the time. and that the new DC has got to just put the scheme that he's jamming down the throats of guys who don't fit it. He's got to change that. It's basically, I'm paraphrasing what Gerald's saying, because they're really talented, man. I hope they get a fix. Yeah, for sure. So how long have you been living in Reading, Cameron? I've been here my whole life. You actually used to cover, I played at Anderson, And you covered our 12-0 team with Raymond Matiller.

39:12We played horrible in the sections. And you used to love hearing on, you know, Chow 7 with your comments of always, any time Raymond broke a touchdown, he'd be like, looking for daylight. That was it.

39:25Rich Eisen: Did you play for Coach Reed? I sure did. My dad and my uncle. He was the first. Remember I told you my first day on the job, it was um go and cover a high school playoff game right and i had to interview the two coaches live during during the uh half during in between the two games i had to go record the first one then interview these coaches live for the second one record some of the first half of that one then run back and edit it all together and put it on the air and then the live truck just the guy who is not happy that there was a new guy there and just didn't respect me enough at all to basically say I can't get a signal.

40:04Rich Eisen: He drove off without even telling me. And I had to stand there and interview. I had to interview a coach anyway and ask someone to record it for me and put it on a tripod. And he was kind enough to do it, even though it wasn't live. That was Coach Reed. This guy's high school coach. How about that? That's so cool. Talk about old school coach, man. He was one to play for. He was. He couldn't have been nicer to me. I'm some guy from New York sweating my ass off on that day. And he couldn't have been nicer to me. I mean, he's a legend. A legend. You know, Ikeke just passed away, right? Did he just pass away?

40:39He did, yes. He did about two years ago. Yep.

40:42Rich Eisen: Thanks for the call, Cameron, in the memory lane. There you go. There's a small. Yeah, we appreciate you up here. Appreciate it. Appreciate everything you did up here. And I appreciate everybody there. Gave me a great start. Welcomed me. It was incredible. That was fun right there. A little memory lane. It's a small world, huh? All right, yeah. For American-made floor liners and a cargo liner that laugh in the face of fall weather, Visit weathertech.com today.

41:09Listen, it's kind of crazy.

41:11Rich Eisen: We talked about this baseball playoffs where the team with the 28th highest payroll just beat the team with the third. And you take a look right now at the remaining teams in the baseball playoffs. It's the Dodgers' second highest payroll behind your Mets. best team the money can buy. Hey, you know it got to be good. Great. And the Dodgers will be taking on the Brewers, which has currently the second highest payroll remaining. 19th out of the 30 Major League Baseball teams. The White Sox are 24th, the Rays are 28th, and the Guardians are DFL in this category. So it's entirely possible that the Guardians, they make the World Series, it'll be the 30th payroll against two.

41:59Rich Eisen: And you know, you know, if it's the Major League Baseball Players Association, I'd imagine is rooting for the Brewers the hardest and the Guardians. So it can be like, hey, you think we got to redo the financial system? Because it's 19 versus 30 in the World Series. We're all these teams that are you need a salary cap for. Where are they? Oh, OK. You know, that would be certainly because the winter is coming and it's nuclear and whatever. Yep. So any proposal that baseball makes has got to be seen through the prism of this is part of the collective bargaining conversation that's to come that hopefully will result with games being played next year.

42:40And in that regard, I haven't seen this yet.

42:44Rich Eisen: This just got popped up here. Pop it up on the screen if you know. Yeah, MLB posted this. Baseball's proposed returning to 154 game regular season. Proposing it. Right. Right. Best of seven division series. So this would still be going on right now. And opponent selection in the wild card and division series. What does that mean? Starting in 2029, shortening the season would create a weekly standard off day benefiting player health. It would allow the addition of up to eight more postseason games by removing by moving to a best of seven divisions format. OK. And beginning in 2027, higher seeded clubs in the wild card and division series would select their opponents.

43:26Rich Eisen: that's fun so the rays would select somebody that they think they could beat i think they would choose the yankees anyway what does that accomplish that's weird it just takes away the bracket of it and you know so they would choose it yeah so the one seed says hey i want i want to the team that so the team that that that that gets chosen would be able to put the disrespect mantra in full display. Sure. Yes. Oh, you want to play us? The question has always been asked of teams that have advanced in a playoff round. Who would you rather play? Who would you rather play of the teams that, so right now, the question would be asked of the Rays, who would you rather play?

44:07Rich Eisen: And no Ray would ever give an answer to that question. But now the organizations would be forced to give an answer to that question. Yeah. And provide, oh, you want us? You got us. Right. And in the wild card, too, the three seed would select to play either the five or six. I like this. What does it accomplish? Just spices it up. Okay. I do like shortening the season to 154. That's fine. That's great. And now we're extending the baseball playoff series. We're making the division series best of seven. Right. So in this time, the Yankees would be choosing who they want to play. And the Astros would have chosen who they want to play.

44:47Rich Eisen: And I imagine what? Who gets to go first to choose? A team with a better record or a team with a better higher seed? So the Astros would be able to choose an opponent and leaving the Yankees to, you know what I'm saying? So only one team would choose an opponent. Yeah. Because that would leave the other two. So it would be up to the Astros who barely made the playoffs to decide who the Yankees play in the wildcard round. You think that's fair? The one seed in the division, in the division round. What I'm saying in the wild card round is where it would start. So this year, the Astros barely made it, but they're above a seeded better than the Yankees because they won their division.

45:25Rich Eisen: They would get to choose who to play. So the Yankees would be completely random based on who the Astros would rather play. That's who the Yankees play. In your division. Dumb. Stupid idea. Already. I reject it. Oh, why? Because it didn't benefit the Yankees? No, because it wouldn't benefit any team. Just fill in the blank. It doesn't have to be the Yankees. I'm just giving that as an example this year. The second best team in the American League, it would be up to the worst team that made the playoffs to decide who the other best team in the American League gets to play. They won their division.

45:55Rich Eisen: Do we not respect divisions? So you want to just get rid of the divisions? That's been part of the conversation we've had over the last few weeks. I get it. But that's not a proposal. No, the better proposal is you stack the teams based on record at the end of the day. So no division winning a division does not matter. Yeah, it doesn't matter. Correct. but it would affect you. At this point, it's a balanced schedule pretty much anyway. I mean, the Yankees, just as an example, I constantly use the Yankees for an example, two reasons, because this is the team that I know the best in the schedule, and two, it's the team that everybody cares about the most.

46:33Rich Eisen: The varsity. No, but in all seriousness, the Yankees didn't play the Red Sox appreciably much more than they played the Rockies at the end of the day. Which is kind of dumb. I liked it when the division. So there's ways to go about it, but to basically tell a team that barely made the playoffs, you get to choose who you play. And the second best team in the entire league has to then sit back totally random. Cause you didn't win your division. You're using this season as your, as an example. Exactly. But it's, it's not going to always be the case that they're the third division. All it's going to take is one for me to tell you, it stinks.

47:04Rich Eisen: Play baseball next year. Let's. Thanks for listening to the rich eyes and show podcast. You can watch and listen to the rich eyes and show live weekdays from noon to 3 Eastern on ESPN Radio, Disney Plus, and on the ESPN app. The Rich Eisen Show, the podcast.

47:26Today's forecast, falling leaves, football, and an 80 % chance you're going to need a few more things for that backyard project. Running low on yard bags? Need a leaf blower? Let express delivery from the Home Depot bring them right to you. Get fall Project Essentials delivered fast so you can get it done with plenty of time left for the game. Get what you need in two hours or less with express delivery from the Home Depot. Subject to availability, order select in-stock items by 4 p.m. Restrictions and fees apply.

From the publisher

CBS Sports’ Kyle Long and Rich discuss the biggest NFL topics of the week including the mental health-related retirement of Eagles All-Pro OT Lane Johnson, the urgency to get in the Win column for the 0-4 Texans, Sean Payton’s expanded role in Broncos’ play calling duties, what Drake Maye showed in Week 4, if Kirk Cousins and the Raiders are legit AFC contenders, and if the 49ers or Chicago Bears are the best team in the league. Yankees fan Rich laments the Pinstripes’ latest playoffs disappointment to extend their streak of no World Series wins to 17 years and counting. The guys weigh in on MLB’s proposal to short the regular season to 154 games, expand the Division Series to best-of-seven with higher seeded teams being able to select their opponents.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from The Rich Eisen Show

All episodes