Hour 2: The Best Players of the NFL Network Era, plus ESPN’s Jeremy Fowler

1 Apr 2026 · 46 min · 12 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Rich Eisen’s Hour 2 blends (1) ESPN senior NFL writer Jeremy Fowler’s reporting on an “iceberg” in the Philadelphia Eagles’ offense and (2) Eisen’s “best players of the NFL Network era” power rankings (with audience debate).

Guests

Jeremy Fowler (ESPN senior NFL writer; based in Arizona during NFL meetings; reports with Tim McManus/McMahon on ESPN digital/online). Other “guests” are not interviewed in this hour; later studio guest Ken Davidoff is mentioned for Hour 3.

Key claims (Eagles)

Passing offense struggles for two years despite winning via running game (Saquon Barkley). A.J. Brown frustration weekly. Fowler says Jalen Hurts has coachability issues—rigid preferences, sometimes using hand signals/play calls not fully installed by coaches/OC Kellen Moore. Example 1: vs. Green Bay, Sirianni goes for it on 4th; sources say Brown/Hurts effectively decide to run deep/“their own play.” Example 2: final-play vs. 49ers season-ending loss—sources say Hurts recommended “four verticals,” which failed and was criticized widely.

Notable examples (trade/OC reset)

League expects A.J. Brown trade; June 1 cap timing discussed. Fowler expects new OC Sean Mannion to modernize offense (more under-center, motions/shifts) and Hurts to be open to it. Also discusses Maxx Crosby trade likelihood (leans toward staying short term).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Aaron Rodgers and NFL Quarterback Updates

2:20 to 4:08

Discussion on the current state of NFL quarterbacks and team dynamics.

“As you know, I always talk here on this program about in the NFL, certainly more than most sports, but all sports, the NFL in particular, there's always an iceberg for every team.”

Deep Dive into Eagles Offense Issues

4:08 to 6:29

Analyzing the challenges faced by the Eagles' offense and Jalen Hurts.

“Everybody was mingling and making rule changes.”

Jalen Hurts' Leadership and Decision-Making

6:29 to 9:14

Exploration of Jalen Hurts' leadership style and decision-making process.

“And you can see Nick Sirianna mouthing why on the sideline.”

AJ Brown and Jalen Hurts Relationship Dynamics

9:14 to 12:12

Understanding the dynamics between AJ Brown and Jalen Hurts on and off the field.

“know at least with like with Kellen Moore in the offense last year they knew what they were and Kellen Moore parlayed it and do a job with the New Orleans Saints which he did a good job with Tyler Shuck.”

Future of Eagles Offense Under New Coaching

12:12 to 14:02

Speculation on the Eagles' offensive direction with new coaching changes.

“week and hope for the best, but it seems pretty clear that can they coexist maybe, but it's probably not best.”

Jalen Hurts and AJ Brown Dynamics

14:02 to 18:06

Explore the evolving dynamics between Jalen Hurts and AJ Brown in the Eagles' offense.

“he seems pretty open to the changes that are coming with OC Sean Mannion.”

Max Crosby's Future with the Raiders

21:50 to 28:01

Delve into Max Crosby's potential future with the Raiders amid trade discussions.

“I don't sense any major movement or any sort of plotting by the Raiders to move on here in the next few weeks.”

Evaluating Jalen Hurts and Philadelphia Fan Expectations

28:01 to 30:23

Discussion on Jalen Hurts' public persona and fan expectations in Philadelphia.

“And you can't also sit here and say that he's being degraded by the constant drama and drumbeat of Philadelphia as a sports town.”

Power Rankings of NFL Network Era Players

31:28 to 42:06

Rich Eisen shares his power rankings of the best players during the NFL Network era.

“As I mentioned at the top of the program, NFL Network's ownership has changed hands.”

Tom Brady's Impact on Super Bowls

42:06 to 42:50

Explore the significance of Tom Brady's Super Bowl appearances in NFL history.

“When we covered our sixth Super Bowl on NFL Network, six, he had already played in half of them.”
Show all 12 chapters

Ranking the Best NFL Players

43:54 to 45:21

Discussion about the top players in the NFL Network era and differing opinions.

“There could be pushback in the sense that there are some great offensive linemen and stuff.”

Debating Player Selection Criteria

45:21 to 47:26

Engage in a debate about the criteria for selecting top NFL players.

“How could I leave Tom Brady off of any list of any all-time great?”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Rich Eisen:Protein is now at Starbucks, and it's never tasted so good. You can add protein cold foam to your favorite drink or try one of our new protein lattes or matcha. Try it today at Starbucks.

0:15Rich Eisen:K-pop Demon Hunter's Saja Boys Breakfast Meal and Huntrix Meal have just dropped at McDonald's. They're calling this a battle for the fans. What do you say to that, Rumi? It's not a battle. So glad the Saja Boys could take breakfast and give our meal the rest of the day. It is an honor to share. No, it's our honor. It is our larger honor. No, really. Stop. You can really feel the respect in this battle. Pick a meal to pick a side. Ba-da-ba-ba-ba. And participate in McDonald's while supplies last. This is The Rich Eisen Show. Hey, everybody. Can't get enough of The Rich Eisen Show? You're in luck.

0:52Rich Eisen:You can find us everywhere. Watch us weekdays on Disney Plus from noon to 3 Eastern. Miss the show? We've got a podcast so you can listen anytime. But here's the best part. Our YouTube channel. Subscribe at youtube.com slash Rich Eisen Show and you'll never miss a moment. Now, on with the show. A.A. Ron, where are you? This is the Rich Eisen Show. Where is A.A. Ron right now? McCarthy has said, though, Rich, we're wondering who the quarterback of the Pittsburgh Steelers is going to be. I don't just because Aaron doesn't want to let you know about it yet. Earlier on the show, Fox Sports Rules Analyst, Dean Blandino.

1:32Rich Eisen:Coming up, ESPN senior NFL writer, Jeremy Fowler. Author, Ken Davidoff. And now, it's Rich Eisen. No A-A-Rod, huh? Hour number two of the Rich Eisen Show is on the air. 844-204-RICH is the number to dial here on the program. We got baseball on the brain, as we all know. in hour number three, 101 Lessons from the Dugout, brought to you by the writer Ken Davidoff. He's going to join us in studio in hour number three. We're going to talk some baseball. Love it. I haven't seen Ken in a very long time, back when I was covering the World Series for ESPN and ESPN Radio. So it's been a while. We'll chat some baseball with him.

2:16Rich Eisen:I know you're up for talking about baseball. Yep. Jason Feller. Always. Your Dodger hat. I'm not loving baseball. I don't understand that. But we'll talk about that later on. As you know, I always talk here on this program about in the NFL, certainly more than most sports, but all sports, the NFL in particular, there's always an iceberg for every team. We only see the tip above water. Underneath the water is the full story. And the iceberg that we keep talking about here over and over again involves the Philadelphia Eagles and the offense. and why does it work when Shane Steichen's there and then Kellen Moore's there, and then in the years after, speaking of baseball, like remember Brett Saber Hagen went once every other year winning a Cy Young, and then in between not so much, right?

3:07Rich Eisen:Yeah. So it's like every other year the offense hits, and then in between when they have to hire somebody new because Shane Steichen goes somewhere else to coach the Colts, and then Kellen Moore goes somewhere else to coach the Saints, there's a new offensive coordinator there that is the scourge of the city. lights up phone lines there in Philadelphia. And what is going on? Why is A.J. Brown constantly being talked about on the trading block? And we hear every now and then Albert Breer of Sports Illustrated and yesterday Mike Garofalo of formerly NFL Media, now of NFL Network 2.0, talking about that there's friction between the quarterback and the wide receiver.

3:50Rich Eisen:And sure enough, this very morning, the old deep dive on ESPN, the app and ESPN.com. Inside Eagles 2025 friction as Jalen Hurts stands at crossroads is the headline written by Tim McManus. And our next guest joining us here now is Jeremy Fowler. How are you, Jeremy? Good to see you. I'm good, Rich. Thanks for having me. You still there in Arizona? I am. I'm about to head to the airport. We had a nice three days in Arizona. Okay. Everybody was mingling and making rule changes. There wasn't a lot of buzz out of here. It was pretty quiet, to be honest. One of the more quiet meetings up there. Well, until your story comes out.

4:29Rich Eisen:We had to mix it up. I'll give you the floor here. What did you find about what we're not seeing? What is beneath the surface for this potential iceberg at the crossroads involving their Super Bowl MVP and highly paid quarterback, Jeremy? Yeah. Well, Rich, the impetus was what we were seeing on the field, which was a problematic passing offense in Philadelphia, really for the last two years. They just happened to win big because they had a great running game in Saquon Barkley, and they just sort of overwhelmed people on their way to the Super Bowl. But it's been two years of struggles in the passing game.

5:01A.J. Brown showed his frustration nearly every week. So we just sought out to figure out what was ailing the Eagles' offense, what the true problems were. So, you know, we talked to more than a dozen team sources, people in and around the team and the quarterback to try to figure it all out. And Jalen Hurts' name came up a good amount of times as far as just some problems there, where despite his immense success and his obvious strengths, he's clutch. He's got a steely resolve to him. But, you know, we learned that coachability was an issue at times, that he's rigid in what he wants. You know, even in 2024, when they were on their way to the Super Bowl, he and Kellen Moore had some tense moments because Kellen was trying to implement some motions and some shifts and some under center work and some new things.

5:43that Hurts either hadn't done or really didn't want to do, that played out a little bit this year too. And so it's a situation where, you know, sources told us you never quite know what's coming out of the huddle. When you call a play, Hurts might go with a play he wants, which to be sure some quarterbacks do, you know, they'll call all the buzz and all those things. But he'll even have some hand signals that maybe weren't in the playbook or weren't installed by the coaches. So there was just a little bit of a discord there over the last year or so, and it showed up because they didn't have the running game this year.

6:11offensive line was beat up AJ Brown was frustrated they looked a step slower at really every position so it was all on Jalen Hurts and the results weren't great so uh clearly he's a well-established good quarterback in the NFL but he's at a crossroad right now going on another coordinator and it's a situation where the train is sort of moving and he's got to jump on it well there was one moment

6:33Rich Eisen:in time that you um in your article bring up that I I want to bring up here because it's something that maybe a fan can hang their hat on remembering from last season to try and use that as the the portal into which your reporting is uh placing this on on jalen hurts his shoulders as well as his personality and his desire to do what he wants and it was the the final throw against green bay where you know sirianni elected to go for it on fourth down rather than kick a long field goal and I'll give you the floor on that moment and how emblematic it may be of your reporting here Jeremy yeah that was an example that certainly came to mind after the fact you know should we look into what goes on with the Eagles process how they get from a play call to an actual play there just seemed to be a discord there and even in that game in the locker room Devante Smith said yeah number one 11 just kind of worked out their own play on that which is AJ Brown and Jalen Hurts just decided to go deep and let's go for it.

7:40And you can see Nick Sirianna mouthing why on the sideline. You can see it on the telecast. And, you know, of course, he covered for his players after the game. But it, to me, was emblematic of maybe what has been going on with how plays get to the field and who's calling them. Now, great quarterbacks, and Aaron Rodgers is an example of you kind of can run your own offense at times. You can change the play. You can have your own hand signals with receivers. Like, that does happen. But the fact that the Eagles passing game has really struggled the last couple of years combined with some of those tactics, it kind of comes to a head a little bit.

8:16Rich Eisen:OK, and then the final play of the year where there was a huddle that played out on national television, a timeout called, you know, do or die moment for the Eagles season on the line against the 49ers in a very disappointing game or big struggle offensively. and this is what led your article um so to jalen hurts was the one who came up with the play call that ultimately did not work and then got lit up uh by the blogosphere by the social media sphere by the sunday morning football show spheres saying that's the play you come up with it was jalen hurts who came up with that one jeremy so our sources said that jalen hurts recommended the play however one of those sources said that he was asked what do you want to run jay or something to that effect like he was kind of queued up and so he brought up the play at that point suggested it once he was asked so I thought that whole situation was emblematic of the year you just have a lot of different cooks in the kitchen um and you don't always have a clear direction you know at least with like with Kellen Moore in the offense last year they knew what they were and Kellen Moore parlayed it and do a job with the New Orleans Saints which he did a good job with Tyler Shuck.

9:30So they've shown that when they have kind of a top shelf play caller that they can take the lead on this thing and drive the boat. Shane Steichen, same thing three or four years ago, and Kellen Moore. You know, but the problem is when they've gone in-house, it's usually an extension of Nick Sirianni, whose offense with Philadelphia originated from him that he got from past stops and brought it over. And then you have Jalen Hurts, who, depending on who you ask around the league is somewhat limited to where you know he likes what he likes he wants the ball from under shotgun in most cases and likes to run uh really one-on-one patterns to try to get guys open versus man coverage well defense is adjusted they tried to take away his running ability dared him to throw against zone coverage and that's where aj brown disappears a little bit and so all those factors really come to a head at the end of the year on this one play where the offense is kind of looked that is simplistic it was in that moment the 49ers knew exactly what was coming they read it they sniffed it out uh but yet that was a situation where maybe it was hard to tell who was exactly in control in that moment i still think there are some parts of that huddle i don't know but from what i was told hertz was asked what he wanted to run he mentioned the four vertical

10:42Rich Eisen:play and then they got what they got what's going on with him and aj brown that you're able willing yeah to share here jeremy so i i don't necessarily think they're in a terrible place at the moment and jalen hurt said after the year that he and aj brown spoke and that they are in a quote great place i believe is what he said so that is a positive i really think it's one of those situations rich where there's no blowout fight you know multiple sources told me they I never saw AJ and Jalen in some sort of huge scuffle or issue. Brown can kind of do that on his own, as we saw week to week. You know, what happened at the end of the season was probably the eighth worst thing that happened, you know, when he's addressing his coach and getting mad on the sideline.

11:25It was kind of a weekly charade. And certainly AJ deserves his share of the blame and the struggles last year, too. But I think it's a situation where you have two players who have slightly different personalities, but also internalize a lot. And Jalen Hurts, I think part of the struggle he has is he's very much an introvert. He's very much to himself. Whether he wins a Super Bowl or throws a pick, he's kind of the same guy, which can be hard to read inside a locker room, especially one with a lot of personalities and ego. So, you know, he's not necessarily a galvanizer in that way, although he tried later in the year to change on that and did a pretty good job from what we were told.

12:01But you have a situation where A.J. Brown and Jalen Hurts are probably not communicating all that much on a productive level week to week where the airing of grievances in a positive way is not happening. So really you just have some festering of feelings and you go out there every week and hope for the best, but it seems pretty clear that can they coexist maybe, but it's probably not best. I mean, most people I talked to around the league do expect AJ Brown to still be traded. It just really depends on when, and can they get a decent offer for him? Because the Eagles wanted a lot. New England Patriots or whoever was involved couldn't match that.

12:35And then now you got the draft coming up that could create some urgency.

12:39Rich Eisen:Yeah. And then there's the June 1st date that I keep hearing about that the trade needs to happen after that for cap purposes and, and planning purposes, if it happens at all. And, you know, it's difficult to say that they're, they, they are in a great place if the rest of the league is constantly knocking on Howie roseman's door um you know and there's a reason for that i mean you're at the the annual meeting where there's constant talk at places like this the combine and so the league kind of does know the stuff that we are hunting and pecking to see if someone would say on the record and that's why i think maybe everybody thinks a trade is coming but then you do read a story like this jeremy and you wonder is there somebody in the building trying to do jalen hurts dirty you know i i'll be honest here what do you yeah i can understand that question but really all i can speak for is my reporting where we saw what was happening on the field so we tried to figure out sure what was the problem and you know so we asked a variety of people from different areas of the building outside of the building the whole deal and a lot of the answers were pretty consistent so that that's what was surprising because you want to be fair to a player like jaymond hurts who has had immense success.

13:58And to be sure, from what we're hearing, he seems pretty open to the changes that are coming with OC Sean Mannion. And so he's going to bring in, we'll see what it looks like on the field, but a variation of what the Packers did. That's the school he came from. He was with the Minnesota Vikings once upon a time. You're going to see Jalen Hurts under center more. You're going to see motions and shifts. Modernized offense, you're going to see it a little differently in Philadelphia. And sources have told us that he's been open to that so far. And I know it's early in the process. So maybe it's a situation where they get a total reset and a new mind in there and new ideas.

14:33And that can sort of spark hurts who we've told really responds well to challenges like any sort of challenge, whether it's being benched in college or challenges in the offense after the 2023 season when things went poorly. You know, he's ready to respond well and has that kind of resolve. So I do expect that. but you know his name came up a lot you know when we started asking around and i think there is some sympathy for aj brown in circles of the building even though he comes across as a crybaby and probably is in a lot of cases because you know the behavior you can see it on the field it's every week that had to be exhausting and was for the team but uh sometimes when you ask like what's the deal with aj they'll say pretty plainly it's trying to work around an offense with jalen hurts as the quarterback and they feel like that just doesn't create layups in the offense those easy yards that most star receivers can get elsewhere and it's just a struggle but manion is gonna do

15:26Rich Eisen:what to fix it right i mean that's a question here and the coach and it's just so like you look at it one way and there's another way to potentially look at it like jalen hurts responds well to challenges but previous you know administrations have been challenging to get under center you know let's uh let's do something this way let's do something that way and his answer is this well I'll just do it my own way that that's some of the reporting I'm reading in your article but if he is open to open to changing and Mannion could bring something then why would it be best for AJ Brown to be gone is the last question I have here Jeremy you know what I mean like because you can well so there are a couple of layers there with AJ Brown if you can get a first round pick still at this stage although the Eagles wanted more than that a couple weeks ago, then it's a deep receiver class.

16:17You can get somebody new in there with some fresh legs. A.J. Brown's still elite, yes. Has he looked a half step? Depending on who you ask around the league, some executives I've talked to think that he doesn't look quite as explosive or fast. Now, the context there could be he was frustrated all year. His mind and head wasn't in it. He's only 28 years old, so certainly he's still playing at a high level. And the Rams, who inquired about A.J. Brown, ultimately backed out and kept Devontae Adams. they saw a guy who was fully capable to be in their offense and they're one of the hottest ones in the league so he's got value but I think you can if you're the Eagles you can get some more draft capital you need an edge rusher and then you would need another receiver at that point you can do that get younger and maybe get better by cohesiveness not necessarily just by replacing Brown but you know you can get a more balanced attack and get somebody who exactly fits what Sean Mannion wants to do and start over and then you know with Jalen Hurts and the offense improving this is at least a clear change before it was kind of I'll give you an example in 2025 it wasn't always clear exactly what they wanted from Jalen Hurts too because to shoot Hurts and Bale and I talked to a source close to him about this that he went all offseason thinking it was status quo it was the Nick Sirianni Kevin Batullo traditional offense that he started with and then when they get to training camp they started dabbling more in the under center stuff and then like by week six or seven they realized they couldn't run the ball because they were beat up up front so they had to do some under center stuff to get to just help saquon in the running game so jalen hurts i do think at that point understood the why as to why the change is happening it doesn't mean that he liked it but you know to his credit he's like hey i thought we were doing something all off season and then we're not so what's the problem here so i think at least this is now a clear change they have a clear new identity this is what we're doing and this is exactly what we need from

18:06Rich Eisen:you and it's up to him to adjust all right um last one for you jeremy uh i'm going to ask you the what's more likely question i've been asking everybody in the information business um involving max crosby what is more likely that he stays a raider that he's back and that um that he the experience he had about being traded than not. And the emotions coming from that and being back in Vegas supersedes whatever emotions caused him to be traded in the first place. Or this is all just a smokescreen to get his draft value, compensation value back up to what the Ravens paid, and he will be somewhere else this season.

18:51Rich Eisen:Jeremy. Rich Eisen here. The April 15th tax deadline is coming fast, but don't worry. Hand off your taxes to a TurboTax expert today. You know how April feels. Everything speeds up. Games matter. More hoops and hockey schedules tighten. Your phone won't stop buzzing. And somewhere in the middle of it all, there's that quiet little reminder. Taxes. You'll get to it tonight or tomorrow or after the weekend. And if you handle it the old way, you're refreshing your inbox like it's breaking news. Waiting. Wondering. Hoping everything's squared away. That's a lot of mental bandwidth. With Intuit TurboTax Expert full service, you can match with a dedicated expert who understands your specific tax situation and handles your taxes for you, start to finish.

19:34Rich Eisen:You can do it all online or meet in person at one of their new tech-enabled store locations. Have your tax forms imported directly into the app and hand everything off to your TurboTax expert. While they work to get you every dollar you deserve, you can go about your normal routine, giving you time back to focus on what actually deserves your attention, like rooting for your team to make the playoffs. April 15th is not waiting, people. Visit TurboTax.com and hand off your taxes to a TurboTax expert today. Rich Eisen here. I've traveled all over for some of the biggest NFL moments you can imagine.

20:10Rich Eisen:Conference championships, Super Bowls, draft weekends, and everywhere I go, the city just feels different. It's buzzing, packed, electric. Now, take that energy and multiply it by the entire world. That's what's coming this summer with the FIFA World Cup. Fans from every corner of the globe are going to be traveling to experience it live. And when that many people come to town, they're all looking for a place to stay. That got me thinking. If you live in or near a host city, this is one of those rare moments. You already have a space. This summer, you could list your space on Airbnb while fans are in town for the FIFA World Cup, not as a full-time thing, not as some huge lifestyle change, just during an event when demand is naturally high.

20:53Rich Eisen:When I travel for big games, I just want a comfortable place in a real neighborhood, and that's exactly what so many visiting fans will be looking for. If you've ever thought about listing your space, this summer is a great time as we welcome FIFA World Cup fans. Your home might be worth more than you think. Find out how much at airbnb.com slash host. O, O, O, O 'Reilly! Check engine, ABS, or maintenance light on? Take the guesswork out of your warning lights with O 'Reilly Veriscan. The service is free and provides a report with solutions verified by ASE-certified master technicians. And if you need help, we could recommend a shop for you.

21:35Rich Eisen:Ask for O 'Reilly Veriscan today. Oh, oh, oh, O 'Reilly. Auto Parts.

21:49Yeah, so I will lean toward Max staying right now, at least in the short term. I don't sense any major movement or any sort of plotting by the Raiders to move on here in the next few weeks. Now, we have windows of time where that could change, right? We have the draft. If that creates some sort of urgency where teams start calling, maybe strengthening their offers, they're not trying to buy as low anymore, maybe that changes something. But I've talked to people from both sides of the situation, from Crosby's side and from the Raiders. They seem comfortable, fully comfortable, moving on with each other right now.

22:23Now, if they could get something similar in compensation to what they got from Baltimore, or at least in the ballpark, they're not going to get two ones anymore. but if they can get that at some point either around the draft or maybe closer to the season or the third option which I've talked to several teams about this they could see this as he goes into the year shows he's healthy plays with the Raiders get some sacks he's moving well on that knee and then the trade deadline comes and you can make a major move at that point for a team that's close and sitting at six and two and needs a pass rusher to get over the hump you know that to me is a possibility.

23:00But right now I think they're comfortable with Max and have told me as such. So they're going to move forward and I would lean toward him staying right now.

23:07Rich Eisen:Jerry, thanks for the time. Appreciate it. Travel safe and we'll chat with you closer to the draft. Thanks again, man. Yes, sir, Rich. Thanks for having me. Appreciate it. Anytime. That's ESPN senior NFL reporter Jeremy Fowler. Check out his work alongside Tim McMahon. Tim McManus, pardon me. on ESPN's digital and online channels. Okay. There you go. He and Jalen Hurts and A.J. Brown don't see eye-to-eye enough like they used to, and it shows up in games at the worst possible times with a situation where the coach is like, what do you think, Jalen? I like this play. And the offensive coordinator's like, okay.

23:57Rich Eisen:you go for it four verts niner sniff it out it's on you jalen hurts right

24:05Rich Eisen:right or is it on the head coach for saying what do you want to do jay and he gives a play and it's just like yeah i i yeah if you don't like i kind of put this on the coach in the oc unless you got i mean how but can't let the crazies run the asylum it's not does that though, Jay? It's if it works, it's like genius. Right? Remember, we were like, I even said here and I think we all agreed, John Harbaugh once upon a time goes to Lamar Jackson. What do you want to do? Go for it. Alright, let's go for it. They go for it. And it's just like, hey man, you're a guy, you're a coach, just asking your players, what do you want to do?

24:47Rich Eisen:And it works, and you're a player's coach. Or it doesn't work, and at least you're a player's coach. But Sirianni does it, and they lose the season on that one play. Now it's like, what a mess. Yeah. Tip an iceberg, though, you know? Right, but the Eagles love that iceberg, man, and they win Super Bowls with it, too. Yeah. Seems like they maybe won in spite of all the stuff that was going on. How can you sit here and say, you know, I'm not saying you are, but how can anyone sit here and say you're winning in spite of Jalen Hurts when he was the clear MVP of that Super Bowl. And 100 % in this day and age, for any player on a losing team to be considered the MVP of the Super Bowl by a large group of people, meaning America, watching the game.

25:40Rich Eisen:He's without a doubt. Without a doubt, the best players in both. He was that special in the Super Bowl twice. And then the regular season happens the next year. Then you look at all the different offensive coordinators this guy has had since college, and you're like, it's amazing that he can even tie his shoes. Superior offensive line in those years. Right, and then when he doesn't or have a superior play caller, it doesn't work.

26:11Rich Eisen:And you as a Cowboy fan, you're like, stir it up, man. Keep stirring it up unless they love stirring it up. It doesn't matter. You know, I got to be honest when you say that. I am so happy this offseason that take away yesterday's press conference. Cowboys have pretty much stayed out of the headlines this whole offseason, and I love it. Right, and then you read in this article, like Big Dom and Brandon Graham went to hurt saying, you've got to be more accessible to your teammates. You've got to have more personality. Get to be one of the guys more. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. And then it's just like, what's up with that?

26:51Rich Eisen:I'm wondering if Hertz plays anywhere else. Is he considered, well, I guess the debate of where he ranks TJ is top five, top 10. Is he a top half of the league quarterback on any other team? Or is it just Philadelphia with this line, Saquon, Tush Push, weapons around him and then it works? He is so good when he's healthy enough to run. And that's part of his game. He is so good sometimes throwing on the run. Some of his deep passes, they're so good. Yeah. He was, just to finish my thought, he was impossible to stop in Super Bowls, guys. Yeah. Against the Chiefs. I get it. At the top of their games.

Read the full transcript

27:37Rich Eisen:Clearly, some of the best players on his team that won a Super Bowl have issues with the guy. You were saying? I was saying, like you said, would he be as good as any other team? Yet all we talk about is how many offensive coordinators he's run through. Not he's run through, but the team is a run through. So it's not like he's benefiting from this, right? This is hurting him more than anything. And you can't also sit here and say that he's being degraded by the constant drama and drumbeat of Philadelphia as a sports town. Because I think he's perfect for them because he never says anything to make it even worse.

28:21Ever. and he seems to be able to operate in a manner that doesn't fluctuate based on all of the hot takes

28:35Rich Eisen:and hot talk and burning phone lines and long-time listeners and first-time callers doesn't seem to affect him or bother him, and he doesn't add any more fuel to that fire. And then you hear, hey, man, show more personality. Show that you got a pulse. I think the pushback maybe fans feel about Hurts He's like, does this guy care? That's what I was literally about to say. Oh, he cares. I don't think the Philly fan base wants to. Yes, but he's not showing. He's not showing that he cares. All you see is him sitting on the bench, and it looks like he's sulking the whole time. Do you remember Kevin McReynolds?

29:07Rich Eisen:Remember him as your Met? Yeah, of course. He never showed a pulse. No. And he's just like, Met fans just wanted him to, like, take a bat to a Gatorade jug once in a while and show that you care. That's the Northeast thing. That's the Northeast way of looking at things. Like, hey, man, show, I want to see that you care. I want you to scream at somebody. I want you to throw a tantrum. I want you to throw your helmet. That's just not him. But when they win, it's just like, oh, he's the same guy. He's got no pulse. You know? Todd Bowles, he is a guy that can never show any emotion. And so there's no ups and downs.

29:40Rich Eisen:You can follow that guy in a battle until you start losing. It's just like, show that you care, man. Well, he 6-F bombed Prescott. He did. Sounded like a truck backing up. Joe Torre. I mean, all those years, just like Joe, do you have a pulse there? And then he starts winning all those championships with the Yankees. It's like, oh, he's a steady hand. 844-204-RICH, number to dial. My power rankings, player, the best players, 10 best players of the NFL Network 1.0 era. From the first day I came on the air all the way to yesterday. That's next. This is the Rich Eisen Show.

30:22Rich Eisen:No one likes having to choose. That's why, with America's best lineup of hybrids from Hyundai, you get the best of both worlds. Like the reliable and efficient Tucson Hybrid with America's best warranty, or the stylish yet capable Santa Fe Hybrid, with the power to navigate the toughest terrain. It's like having your cake and eating it too, but, you know, better. Hybrids from Hyundai. It's the best of both worlds. Visit HyundaiUSA.com or call 562-314-4603 for more details.

31:16to being your partner in protecting both your people and your facilities. Call 1-800-GRAINGER, click grainger.com, or just stop by.

31:27Rich Eisen:The Rich Eisen Show Podcast.

31:32Rich Eisen:Here on the Rich Eisen Show. All right. As I mentioned at the top of the program, NFL Network's ownership has changed hands. Disney's now in charge, and ESPN is there, and it's a brave new world for us. And I decided to mark this moment in time, I guess, for me professionally and for also, I guess, the network as a whole after 23 years changing hands. I've decided to come up with a power ranking. Last week, I came up my 10 best Super Bowls that I've covered to date for NFL Network. Here now are my power rankings. players of the NFL Network era 1.0, fittingly presented by SoFi, since, as you know, NFL Network studios are right across the street from SoFi Stadium.

32:25Rich Eisen:Hit it.

32:30Rich Eisen:Power rankings. There are many like it, but this one is mine. Power rankings. Here are my power rankings of the best players of the NFL Network era since we came on in week 10 of the 2003 NFL season to date. All right, Rich, so before you start, yesterday Brockman and I came up with our list. We jotted some names down. This will be a good exercise. I appreciate that. So I looked at the list. I came up with a whole bunch of players, and I ended up paring it down, and I only had room for one running back. and it was between Adrian Peterson, the fifth all-time leading rusher, or LaDainian Tomlinson, the seventh all-time leading rusher, Adrian Peterson, an MVP of the league in 2012, the last non-quarterback to win the MVP, or LaDainian Tomlinson, the winner of the 2006 league MVP.

33:32Could it also be Peterson, the three-time leading rusher of the NFL of a single season,

33:39Rich Eisen:or LaDainian Tomlinson, who did that twice? Better pass catcher. Could it be LaDainian Tomlinson, who was the leader in rushing touchdowns three times? Or is it Adrian Peterson, who did that four times? and I came down to it at the end of the day, choosing LaDainian Tomlinson. Yeah, I figured that. Because he's not only all of what I just mentioned, but he's third on the all-time touchdowns list. 162. Only Jerry Rice and Emmitt Smith have more. That's a couple of quotes. And then he's also that 2006 season. because in the 2012 season where Peterson was the MVP, he was also the offensive player of the year.

34:35Rich Eisen:LaDainian was that too. He was also the Walter Payton man of the year winner that year. And you tell me the last next time we'll ever see that again, that triple play. Oh, never. And, you know, his records as well from that season, I don't think will ever be broken in terms of 28 rushing touchdowns, 31 from scrimmage, 186 points. So I chose LaDainian over Adrian Peterson. Tenth on the list. Got no problem with that. Number nine on my power rankings, a three-time defensive player of the year, and he did it in his first five seasons. Five-time pro bowler, five-time first-team all-pro, a Walter Payton man of the year of 2017.

35:20Rich Eisen:Great choice. I'm going J.J. Watt here. Have to. Ninth on this power rankings list. He's got two records as well that stand to this day. Tackles for loss in a season, 39. So stupid. And not one, but two seasons with 20 or more sacks. Two. So number 99 in your program, number one in your Houston Texans heart, J.J. Watt's nine. Number eight, I've got a Super Bowl MVP who's not only a two-time offensive player of the year, but also a comeback player of the year, and he won it in the second year of NFL Network's existence. Four-time passing touchdowns leader, seven-time passing yards leader, six-time completion percentage leader, two-time passer ratings leader, and a Walter Payton Man of the Year in his own right in 2006 when he led the New Orleans Saints back from Katrina.

36:11Rich Eisen:I've got Drew Brees here, eighth. Interesting. His all-time record in his 2018 season. 2018 season he had a completion percentage of 74.4 percent you can make the case he's the most accurate passer ever ever of anybody who's ever laced him up and 54 straight games with a touchdown pass i think will stand the test of time as well yeah that's insane and five times he had 5 000 yard seasons five two three four five seven touchdowns in a game also is tied for the record in that regard. He's 8th there. 7th is my wide receiver. I had two choices. I had Calvin or this guy and I chose Randy Moss. Interesting.

36:56Rich Eisen:I chose Randy Moss. Calvin played his entire career in the NFL Network era and Randy did not. But what Randy did with the Patriots played in the Super Bowl too. Obviously it helps to have that quarterback. 4-time first team All-Pro 6-time Pro Bowler. And he's fourth on the all-time touchdowns list, 157. One of the best players I've ever seen. Lace him up. And certainly at that position. Comeback player of the year. 23 touchdowns in 2007. That's a record. Five times he led the league in touchdowns. Five. Three of them during the NFL Network era as well. So, he's five. Seven. Number six on my list is Aaron Donald.

37:42Rich Eisen:Aaron Donald is here. I remember when he got drafted, Mayock was raving about him. He could be one of the all-time greats. And he turned out to be. Three-time defensive player of the year, eight-time first-team All-Pro, 10-time Pro Bowler, made the Pro Bowl 10 times. Every year, right? 10 times. And then won a ring. And I understand Cooper Cupp was making all those plays offensively, and he was dynamic offensively. You could make the case Aaron Donald was the MVP of that Super Bowl, too. You could make a great case. He came up with that game-ending sack of Joe Burrow was playing out of his skull, pointed to his ring, one of the best moments that I can recall covering the Super Bowl.

38:19Rich Eisen:He's six. Let's get to my top five. If you think there's too many quarterbacks, too bad. I've got Aaron Rodgers here. Super Bowl MVP, four-time MVP, 10-time Pro Bowler, four-time first-team All-Pro, two times he led the league in passing, four times passer rating. his career records he's got the best passer rating of all time 102.2 touchdown to interception ratio for every interception he's thrown 4.3 touchdowns for every interception thrown and his passer rating in 2011 was 122.5 and he had 402 straight passes without an interception that's also a record I don't think they'll be broken but I also remember the time because this is an NFL Network conversation here.

39:08Rich Eisen:On the Thursday night football game in the old Texas stadium, it was Favre versus Romo. Romo was 10-1. Favre was 10-1 for the Cowboys and Packers, respectively. Romo, we were talking about pregame, had a Favre poster on his wall. And Favre, Mr. Ironman, got hurt throwing an interception to Terrence Newman in the second quarter of that game. And we were standing in the end zone saying, well, this game is over, until the backup that we were waiting to see why is Aaron Rodgers as good as everybody said he was? Well, he went 18 for 26 for 201 yards and a touchdown and 30 yards rushing and damn near won that game.

39:50Rich Eisen:And we were watching that from the end zone going, oh, this kid's really good. And he's a first ballot Hall of Famer. He's one of the greats of all time. Number four on the list, he did not get drafted during the era of NFL Network. But when we came on the air, he was clearly the best defensive player in the league. And then when he retired, he was clearly the best defensive player in the league. Ray Lewis is four. I've never seen anybody like him. And when we came on the air, him versus Eddie George was something we were talking about every single time they played each other. Ray Lewis, two-time defensive player of the year, 13-time Pro Bowler, seven-time first-team All-Pro, three tackles, three times he led the league in tackles, Three times he led the league in solo tackles.

40:35Rich Eisen:Unbelievable. My final three. Number three on the list is a two-time Super Bowl winner and a Super Bowl MVP and a five-time MVP. You know who it is. It's Peyton Manning, the sheriff. And he's in two rings of honor, two, including the one in Denver where he set the record for most passing touchdowns in a season, 55, most passing yards in a season, 5 ,477. He also threw for seven touchdowns in a game. That's tied for a record. Most MVPs won five. Five of them. He's number three. Number two on the list is a guy who's won three Super Bowls, two MVPs, two-time first-team All-Pro, six-time Pro Bowler, two passing touchdowns.

41:19Rich Eisen:Two times he led the league in passing touchdowns. One time he led the league in passing yards. And you're like, how can this guy be one of your best players? Because he did it all before he was 30. Three Super Bowl wins for Patrick Mahomes is absurd before the age of 30. Before he turned 30, 17 postseason victories. 17 of them. That's more than any other quarterback that's ever played except the name that I have yet to mention. Well, that's a great list. Most total yards by a quarterback in a season. 5 ,614 in 2022. Mahomes is two, and we all know who number one is. And, you know, I could go on and on and on about Tom Brady, but we all know about how great he is.

42:05Rich Eisen:This is the one thing, because, again, this is an NFL Network-related stat. When we covered our sixth Super Bowl on NFL Network, six, he had already played in half of them. When we covered our 18th Super Bowl at NFL Network, he is playing in half of them. We were 18 years old. And Tom Brady had played in nine of the 18 Super Bowls that we covered. I mean, that just sums it all up for why Tom's leading the list. We all know that. But those are my power rankings of the best players of the NFL Network era. Presented by SoFi. Get your money right. Okay. So that's my power rankings list. We'll take a break and we'll compare notes, shall we?

42:59Rich Eisen:And then also with you at 844-204-RICH being the number to dial right here on the Rich Eisen Show. Everybody.

43:10Rich Eisen:The Rich Eisen Show, the podcast. 1 ,000 % inspired. Sometimes teams take a timeout to regroup and call the right play. When it comes to your home, Pella Windows and Doors always has the winning game plan. They're not just your Windows and Doors experts. They're experts at taking care of you and your home. At Pella, they find the products that meet your needs, and their experts install them. They do it every day, and that's why your neighbors trust them. Discover why Pella is a trusted choice for homeowners everywhere. Visit Pella.com slash Eisen today. That's Pella.com slash Eisen. Okay, I just delivered my power rankings of the top 10 players of the NFL Network era today.

43:54Rich Eisen:uh ladanian tomlinson jj watt drew breeze randy moss aaron donald aaron rogers ray lewis peyton manning patrick mahomes to tom brady one i uh send the floor to you guys you you did your own list or you thought well we were just kind of we were just kind of naming names you're trying to figure out well you were giving me grief prior to hearing it saying that you know only a third needed to be quarterbacks on half of my list are quarterbacks i had breeze rogers manning mahomes and Brady on. How can there be an argument? Too many. There could be pushback in the sense that there are some great offensive linemen and stuff.

44:31Rich Eisen:I know that I looked at Joe Thomas. Joe Thomas. Walter Jones. Jonathan Ogden. We didn't think that they would make your list. Trust me, I've struggled with how in the hell do I not have Ed Reed on my list? That's a name. Ed or Troy, obviously. You mentioned Zach Martin, Joe Thomas. We had We had Ray down, but didn't think he'd make it because he was drafted in 1996. I know that, but Randy Moss? No Gronk. Larry Fitzgerald. I mean, full era, you could have had Calvin Johnson over. Sure. I mean, like, if I had said you had to have been drafted, if you had to have come into the league after we came on the air, the date, you know, then it's different.

45:14Rich Eisen:Then obviously Randy and Ray are out. Yeah, well, Tom Brady, too. And Brady would be out, too. You're kidding me. No, I get it. How could I leave Tom Brady off of any list of any all-time great? When, again, we covered first 18 Super Bowls. He was in nine of them. I get it. No, I'm just saying. Yeah, I mean, nine of them. That's no argument. You didn't need Drew Brees and Aaron Rodgers. Why? Well, there's other players who are kind of better. Because they won Super Bowl? These guys aren't number one at their position. Like, to not have the greatest safety of all time on this list is kind of a disservice to the list.

45:51Rich Eisen:Ten players. Not the greatest tight end on the list is not on the list. On your list. I'm just saying. That's all. I got seven out of your ten. The only three I didn't get were Breeze, Moss, and Rodgers. Okay, so who made your list instead of Breeze, Moss, and Rodgers? I picked Vaughn Miller just because, I mean, a linebacker winning Super Bowl MVP. I had Charles Woodson. I was really shocked that. Listen, you know how I feel about Charles. Yeah, yeah. And the other one I had was Drew Brees is one of the greatest ever, period. Ever. I don't know about that. You don't know about that. I think you could have had Adrian Peterson also on the list as well.

46:33Rich Eisen:Like Tomlinson at 10 seems kind of low. Oh, and I thought Fitzgerald, but you put Moss. Yeah, I put Randy Moss in, you know. I've never seen anyone like him, man. It's your list. It's no wrong answer. I just. Drew Brees never won MVP. No, I see you Super Bowl MVP. Completion percentage kind of enhanced by eight yard slants.

46:58Rich Eisen:He's still out of complete them. They were still first downs and they're still touchdowns. I know you guys hate facts. Eight yard slants. That's a lot of eight yard slants to have five 5 ,000 yard seasons. Five. Well, he also. Those eight yard slants added up. He also was under 500 more than any supposed great quarterback. dude. Why do you always say we hate stats? I cannot do a list. A lot of 8-8 seasons for Drew Brees for how great he was. Okay. I hear you. No, I saw, you know, Gronk was on my, you know, I had 20 and then I had Ed Reed and everyone you mentioned and Calvin Johnson as well. I'm saying you could have took Brees and Rodgers off and had Ed Reed and Gronk and the list would have been Gronk.

47:38Rich Eisen:How can I take Aaron Rodgers off this list? What do you mean? He's going to tell you facts because He only speaks facts, and he'll tell you why he shouldn't have. Well, you can talk baseball the next hour. Ken David off with his new book, 101 Lessons from the Dugout. He's here in studio. The Rich Eisen Show Podcast. Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile. The message for everyone paying big wireless way too much. Please, for the love of everything good in this world, stop. With Mint, you can get premium wireless for just$15 a month. Of course, if you enjoy overpaying, no judgments, but that's weird.

48:11Okay, one judgment. Anyway, give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch.

From the publisher

ESPN’s Jeremy Fowler and Rich discuss his new article detailing Jalen Hurts’ major role in the Eagles’ offensive struggles last season, if All-Pro WR AJ Brown and Hurts can co-exist in Philadelphia moving forward, and weighs in on the possibility of the Las Vegas Raiders trading Maxx Crosby in the wake of their failed deal with the Baltimore Ravens. Rich and the guys debate Hurts’ true value to Philly’s offense. Rich power ranks the top ten players of the NFL Network era from 2023 to present day including such luminaries as Tom Brady, Patrick Mahomes, Aaron Donald, Peyton Manning and others.  Brockman and TJ debate Rich’s
Power Rankings with some notable omissions from the original ten.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from The Rich Eisen Show

All 1,076 episodes
Hour 2: The Best Players of the NFL Network Era, plus ESPN’s Jeremy FowlerThe Rich Eisen Show · 46 min
Listen in VO