In short
Rich Eisen Show Hour 2 covers three main topics: (1) a debate about whether Tom Brady’s role as an NFL on-Fox broadcaster creates a conflict of interest for teams he may face next week, (2) NFL officiating—especially the Eagles’ “tush push”—and (3) college football targeting officiating.
Guests
Dean Blandino, former head of NFL refs and current Fox Sports rules analyst (with Kevin Burkhart and Tom Brady on the Fox broadcast team). Also referenced: Tim Tebow (earlier on the show), plus Mike Pereira (Fox rules analyst) and Cliff Kingsbury (Commanders/Washington context).
Key claims
Brady’s sideline headset/notes and Zoom access are “weird” but likely not an unfair advantage; Ben Johnson says it’s “much ado about nothing.” Blandino argues the tush push should be banned due to health/safety rationale, competitive unfairness, and difficulty officiating consistently; he cites that pushing the runner has never been legal in NFL history. He also criticizes college targeting for inconsistent application and the ejection/carryover penalty, and says replay shouldn’t be able to add targeting flags.
Notable examples
Eagles’ tush push with missed false starts; Kansas City/Eagles review moments; Michigan vs. New Mexico targeting-related ejection example; replay-assist discussion (roughing the passer, helmet/neck contact).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOBaseball Updates and Upcoming Guests
0:00 to 0:30
Rich discusses recent baseball highlights and upcoming guests.
“At the Home Depot, get up to 15 % off all installed carpet projects for a limited time.”
Baseball Updates and Upcoming Guests
0:33 to 0:56
Rich discusses recent baseball highlights and upcoming guests.
“You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome?”
Baseball Updates and Upcoming Guests
1:22 to 2:15
Rich discusses recent baseball highlights and upcoming guests.
“From the Rich Eisen Show studio in Los Angeles.”
NFL Officiating Concerns
2:15 to 2:44
Rich shares his frustrations regarding targeting rules in college football.
“And kids, due to the inconsistent application, miss halves of football and get kicked out of games that they don't belong to be kicked out of.”
Previewing NFL Week 3 Games
2:44 to 3:56
Rich previews the upcoming NFL games and discusses player performances.
“And ESPN Radio presented by Progressive Insurance.”
Updates on Jaden Daniels and Marcus Mariota
3:56 to 4:49
Rich provides updates on Jaden Daniels' condition and Mariota's potential performance.
“Spent some time in Tennessee and some other spots, cups of coffee around the league.”
Tom Brady's Role and Controversy
4:49 to 6:06
Rich discusses the implications of Tom Brady calling games while owning a team.
Analysis of Tom Brady's Influence
6:06 to 14:00
Rich elaborates on the impact of Tom Brady on coaching and game strategy.
“Something happened, and we didn't know it at the time, and he said he was okay, and then all of a sudden we find out he's not okay, and he misses the Raiders game, and does he come back and look like last year?”
Tom Brady's Dual Role in NFL
14:00 to 19:16
Discussing the complexities and potential conflicts of interest with Tom Brady's roles in the NFL.
“He does have conversations with Brady and so does Chip Kelly.”
Dean Blandino on the Tush Push
21:47 to 28:00
Dean Blandino discusses the controversial 'tush push' play and its implications in the NFL.
“Rich Eisen Show back here on the ESPN radio network presented by Progressive Insurance, former head of NFL refs and current NFL rules analyst for Fox Sports.”
Show all 17 chapters
The Tush Push Debate
28:00 to 29:49
Discussion on the future of the tush push play in NFL football.
“We're going to be the ego, and we're going to stop it, and we're not going to be seen as we couldn't stop them.”
Replay Assist Insights
29:50 to 33:08
Insights into the replay assist system and its implications for officiating.
“And part of my frustration at the game was that the Eagles normally don't false start.”
Communication in Officiating
33:09 to 36:28
A look at how replay assist communicates with on-field officials.
Targeting Rule Controversies
36:29 to 38:43
Discussion on the targeting rule in college football and its inconsistencies.
“And the minutes I have left with you here, you know, actually, can you stay to the end of the hour?”
Targeting Rule Controversies
39:05 to 39:21
Discussion on the targeting rule in college football and its inconsistencies.
Debating Targeting Rules in College Football
42:00 to 46:54
Explore the complexities and inconsistencies surrounding targeting penalties in college football.
Debating Targeting Rules in College Football
47:30 to 47:45
Explore the complexities and inconsistencies surrounding targeting penalties in college football.
“Athletic Brewing Company crafts award-winning non-alcoholic beers for those who want to be part of every round.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00Rich Eisen:At the Home Depot, get up to 15 % off all installed carpet projects for a limited time. Featuring brands like LifeProof, LifeProof with PetProof Technology, Home Decorators Collection, and Traffic Master. Take your pick of carpet built for real life and designed for real comfort. Plus, with installations starting as low as 49 cents per square foot and a free measure to get you started, we'll handle the hard parts for you. Offer valid July 16th, 2026 through August 2nd, 2026. Exclusions apply. For licenses, see homedepot.com slash license numbers. This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome.
0:33You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome? That's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome.
0:50Rich Eisen:Check responses set up required, compatibility and availability varies 18+. This is the Rich Eisen Show. Hey, everybody. Can't get enough of The Rich Eisen Show? You're in luck. You can find us everywhere. Watch us weekdays on Disney Plus from noon to 3 Eastern. Miss the show? We've got a podcast so you can listen anytime. But here's the best part. Our YouTube channel. Subscribe at youtube.com slash Rich Eisen Show and you'll never miss a moment. Now, on with the show. This is The Rich Eisen Show. What's happening in the baseball world? I think we take it for granted. From the Rich Eisen Show studio in Los Angeles.
1:35Rich Eisen:Gone! Number 51 on the season for Shohei Ohtani. Earlier on the show, SEC Network Analyst and Heisman Trophy winner Tim Tebow. Coming up, Fox Sports Rules Analyst, Dean Blandino. Actor Tyreek Withers. And now, it's Rich Eisen. Rich Eisen Show is on the air. We're live here in Los Angeles, California. Dean Blandino, the former head of NFL refs and chief rules analyst, along with Mike Pereira for Fox, is making his way to our studio. We're going to ask him what's up with the tush push and all that sort of business. It's an assessment of officiating. Two weeks in, I despise targeting in college football with every fiber of my being because it's inconsistently applied.
2:20Rich Eisen:And kids, due to the inconsistent application, miss halves of football and get kicked out of games that they don't belong to be kicked out of. It's every week, man. There's something going on with targeting. And it's just like, well, I mean, the helmet's connected. And it's just like, it drives me nuts. So I'll hold Dean fully and personally responsible. That's coming up shortly in about 20 minutes time. We're live here on Disney Plus, the ESPN app everywhere. And ESPN Radio presented by Progressive Insurance. 844-204-RICH is the number to dial. We've got our new Thursday staple, higher register, where we have to go into the higher register of our voices to say a declarative statement about what's going to happen in week number three of the NFL season.
3:05Rich Eisen:But we've got to go in the higher register in order to believe what we're saying. It's a fun segment. It's always fun to have fun. Coming up in the crazy and mixed-up world we live in right now. Chris Brockman and Jay Felly, where they are. TJ Jefferson, the candle is lit. Where he is. The latest on Jaden Daniels. We've got it. Got it. From the offensive coordinator of the Washington Commanders, the former head coach himself, so he understands how to term things when it comes to injuries, which is say very little, and leave you to glean information. See if you can catch what Cliff Kingsbury has to say on the subject matter while praising Marcus Mariota, the backup, once upon a time, second overall selection in the draft, out of Oregon, a Heisman Trophy winner.
3:58Rich Eisen:Spent some time in Tennessee and some other spots, cups of coffee around the league. He might be playing a pretty damn big game, as you'd like to term it yesterday, revenge game, because he used to play for a hot minute for the Raiders. Yeah, of course. Pete Carroll had nothing to do with whether he was there or not. Nope. Okay. At any rate, is he going to play this week, Marcus Mariota? If so, Cliff Kingsbury is confident. Yeah, last year, just being around him for a year, when we signed him back, we felt like we have two starters in the building, which is rare in this league. So anytime he's asked to play or practice or even on scout team, he's been phenomenal.
4:35Rich Eisen:So he treats him like a pro as a leader on the team, despite not being the starter, which is hard to do, and can't say enough good things about him. So if he has to go, I'm sure he'll be ready. can you provide any update on where jayden is today um no he's just preparing mentally you know marcus is getting the reps physically jayden um preparing mentally and we'll take it from there okay two things first of all preparing mentally um is the name of a racehorse somewhere if i owned a racehorse i've already told you it would be called a room tone which is what you know whenever you're shooting something or whatever they they make you pause so they the folks who have the boom operators want to take some just sound of what the room sounds like yeah so it can match it up if they need it later on why a horse i don't know here comes room tone down the stretch for your horse when it's coming down preparing mentally against room tone room tone against preparing preparing mentally sounds like a great horse horse name uh not the name uh you also that's item number two what you want to term your all-world starting quarterback on a thursday before a game preparing mentally is um earbud territory clipboard back in the day territory i will be stunned if this guy plays on sunday me too and what a damn shame that would be either way something's up and the first month of this we're going to find out just how superhuman jaden Daniels is because if you just remember last year how we're already we're already looking last year at Jordan Love well he got banged up in week one and he just wasn't the same the rest of the year and it's part and parcel of why the Packers still made the playoffs but since they got one and done is that how we're going to talk about Jaden Daniels here well in week two in Green Bay towards the end of that game.
6:35Rich Eisen:Something happened, and we didn't know it at the time, and he said he was okay, and then all of a sudden we find out he's not okay, and he misses the Raiders game, and does he come back and look like last year? Don't forget, that's now another week in which he and Terry McLaurin aren't getting on the same page. In the first two weeks, they were not on the same page. They were in the same book, it seemed.
6:57Rich Eisen:i'm i'm i'm hopeful that marcus mariotta who's looked phenomenal in practice shows up that way against max crosby and the rest of the raiders defense that wants to you know take mariotta out and find out who the third string quarterback is there that's for damn sure don't forget i mean this is a raiders team that with herbert taking the top of the defense off and also finding Keenan Allen and also looking as good as he did, he only scored 20 points.
7:34Rich Eisen:So I'd be concerned. And also then rooting for the Rams, who are taking on the Eagles this weekend. And then here's your Cowboys against the Bears. What a big game this is. Bears backs against the wall. 0-2, needing to come up with this win, man. Your Cowboys, thanks to Brandon Aubrey kicking it from all points of the Lone Star State. Houston. Taking care of business. At one and one. Almost taking care of the Eagles in week one. Then showing up in week two and taking out the Giants, who throw 450 yards at Russell Wilson. And part and parcel of what's going on in Chicago, they get a 50-burger thrown on them.
8:17Rich Eisen:And you got people like Andrew Santino, the comedian here yesterday, and our call screener Adam Chudwin saying Tyson Bajan should be right around the corner if they keep struggling. And maybe he is. You know, we're on in Chicago. I'd love to hear from anybody in Chicago who wants to chime in on this subject matter. But we're already hearing from Bears fans that if Caleb doesn't start turning around, that sounds like a higher register. Maybe we should go to Tyson Bajan. You know what I mean? Bears are favored in this game. well because they looked really good in week one and soldier field chris and that maybe just maybe for three quarters that caleb williams can take the top of the defense off in the way russell wilson did wrong like hey he and roma dunze are connecting it's just him and everyone else that's not and you know and is jadavian clowning going to come off the bench the couch and the bench and start providing pressure that the Cowboys lost?
9:21Rich Eisen:What's the name of that guy that traded to Green Bay? Man, I can't remember what that guy's name is. I think we can find out what his name is. It's on the tip of my tongue here. Oh, my gosh. Macca. There it is. Macca. There you go. Macca. There's no idea where Mike Del Tufo's hitting the drops. We 100 % need to fix this whole situation. Can I just tell you not to worry, DJ Moore, fantasy fans, because I'm just predicting he's going to have his get-right game on Sunday, unfortunately. But the one thing everybody's talking about out of the Ben Johnson press conference that he held on Wednesday is the fact of who's calling the game and his comments about it.
10:08Rich Eisen:As we saw, Tom Brady was in the coach's box, very Natalie-clad. he spent his monday night off from his one of his day jobs on sundays um of fox calling games up in the coach's booth with a headset on and um is he listening to the play calls what's happening there is he talking to chip kelly listen bottom line is you're seeing an owner of the indianapolis colts on the sideline with a headset on on the sideline with a headset on and basically marking down plays and taking notes. Taking notes? You know, we'll get into that in a second. But Ben Johnson was asked, hey, Tom Brady's calling your game on Fox and then you're taking on the Raiders next week.
11:02Rich Eisen:Do you have any concerns about anything on that front? Like I said, I'm really not worried about it. I mean, we change week to week in terms of what we do. Schematically, he's going to be able to turn on the tape and see what everyone else in the world is seeing right now. Personnel-wise, really the same thing. It's not like I'm going to sit down with him and say, hey, don't do this to Caleb Williams or you might get it. There's not going to be any trade secrets that are going to be exchanged. But I really don't think it's that big of a deal, to be honest with you. Again, Brady is not allowed in their building.
11:36Rich Eisen:Brady is allowed to Zoom and have conversations with members of teams that he's broadcasting and um i've been in these broadcast meetings some coaches share others do not others will just shut it down and tell you nothing others will you know depending on who you know i've i've been in broadcast meetings that obviously kurt warner is there and quarterbacks share with other quarterbacks with uh in things and sometimes we'll say this is off the record but I'm just telling you this anyway. Now, clearly, you know, we know what the difference between off the record is and not. And sometimes coaches are comfortable sharing stuff with Michael Irvin or Mooch.
12:21Rich Eisen:I've been in these things, right? And there is information you can glean in these broadcast meetings, even off the record, that you can then turn around and tell the team that you own, if you want.
12:40Rich Eisen:I don't know if any of that is happening. Why would you tell Tom Brady anything if you're going to be playing his team next week and you've seen him in a coach's booth with a headset on? And Tom can separate church and state, I'm sure. Here's where I'm going with this one, okay? When you see, again, the owner of the Colts on the sidelines taking notes, listening in on play calls as Carly Ursa Gordon is currently doing right now, I don't think anybody's thinking that the Colts are getting an extra advantage because she hasn't played quarterback in the National Football League to be known as the greatest to ever do it.
13:25Rich Eisen:So there is some neck up and ability that Tom Brady is bringing to the equation as a quarterback when he is potentially talking. and I don't know who knows more football than Tom Brady. When you hear him break it down, he's awesome at it. And you hear him on other podcasts or on other shows, he's saying things that absolutely make you smarter because he's been there and he's done that. And it makes complete sense for the Raiders to pick his brain. As Pete Carroll said earlier this week, they in fact do. He does have conversations with Brady and so does Chip Kelly. Wouldn't that make sense? Do you have an owner to do that sort of thing?
14:07Rich Eisen:You should definitely take advantage. Right? Pete said they do. So, and it's not like he's a Michigan guy who's taking photographs of your sidelines to steal your signs, right? He's doing his job on Fox, and then he's also trying to beat you when he's not on Fox, which just creates a weird dynamic. I'm not going to lie. It's just weird. It's weird. He's calling your game, and then next week, He wants your team to beat your team. So why would you tell him a damn thing? That's on you. Now, Brady did respond to what Ben Johnson had to say, where he says, much to do about nothing. He said it on social media, essentially like, thank you for some common sense.
14:52Rich Eisen:Finally, a smart coach speaks up. Because, again, Tom is probably like, I've got enough knowledge to help my team. I don't need to know your team as well. But he is getting eyes on the Bears. And for somebody that brilliant at it to get eyes on the team, that's a hell of an advanced scout. Hell of an advanced scout. And the thing that I'm stunned about all this is that NFL owners are fine with it. Because in my 20 some odd years of being around the NFL and hearing stories about NFL owners when I wasn't with the NFL prior to my 20-plus years with NFL Network, they are some of the most paranoid competitors I've ever been around.
15:47Rich Eisen:I mean, somebody, I don't know, ask Mark Davis what his dad would think of if the shoe was on the other foot. Al was one of the most paranoid guys out there. he'd probably been looking at the skies looking for drones over practice fields i don't know if it's just a different era now i have no idea but nfl owners are always freak out about are you stealing this are you getting an advantage there are you looking at our practices you're doing this i mean ask anybody who is part of the rams organization if they thought the patriots were sneaking in their practices.
16:29You know, to this day,
16:32Rich Eisen:there's conspiracy theories around it. But NFL owners are fine with it. And, you know, and if you're the Raiders and you have Tom Brady as a resource, of course you're going to use him. You're going to find, is this the right quarterback? Is this the right draft strategy? Is this the right thing? Why wouldn't you? That makes sense. And if you're Fox and you can hire Tom Brady and get his insight, why wouldn't you do it? but if you're an NFL like are the McCaskies all cool the family I mean are they all cool with oh he's calling our game and then we just saw him with a headset on and a booth so he's clearly locked in on what the Raiders are doing and now he's going to see the Bears and he sees one thing with his incredible keen advanced scout eyes and he's not going to pass that along to the team I guess he could pick it up watching it at home on television too i don't know seems a little unfair i don't know i but on its face it does in practice it may not be that's why brady's just like yeah well you're making much ado about nothing but hey if you're gonna try and do both this is the sort of stuff you're gonna hear you know and from fox too they're gonna hear about it too the thing is i just like nfl owners okay i've met nfl owners that wouldn't allow fans of other teams in their suite to watch a game.
18:00Rich Eisen:They want to see all that stuff. That happened to me once, Rich, actually. Ashley and I, we got a chance to go watch the San Diego Chargers and sit in the Spanos box. And one thing we were told, because they knew I was a Cowboys fan, is like, you cannot cheer for the Cowboys. So I had to sit there and just keep my thoughts to my – which was understandable. You're in the, you know, they own the team. Right. That's their, that's sweet. I guess that may be different from what I'm also describing as well as, as a competitive advantage. It's just, I'm just saying that there's a lot of not thinking straight.
18:36Rich Eisen:Just surprised that they're cool with it. I think there's so much money being thrown around. They don't care anymore.
18:45Well,
18:45Rich Eisen:anyway, that game's on Fox this weekend with a ton at stake, man. massive amounts at stake. Who do you like in that game right now? Great question. I think the Cowboys the way they played on the road should win it. The way that they played in Philadelphia, that team shows up in Chicago, they'll win the football game. Definitely has shootout potential. It's the highest total of the week, over 50. That would be fun. I'll take it. And so would Fox. So would Brady. And Burkhardt. I'm sure. 844-204-RICH is the number to dial right here on the program. Dean Blandino of Fox Sports, now that I've talked about his bosses, he'll come on out here and break down what's going on in officiating.
19:28Rich Eisen:He says he's done with the tush push. Oh, man. Let's hear it.
19:35Rich Eisen:While the world watches the stars at the FIFA World Cup this summer, Hyundai has its eyes on the next generation of talent, future stars who are already turning heads at age 14, because Next doesn't wait for an invitation, and neither do we. Hyundai has always moved the future within reach. We did it when we made advanced safety standard on every vehicle and engineered EVs with ultra-fast charging capability because the future isn't some far-off concept. It's already here. Next starts now. Hyundai, an official partner of FIFA. Rich Eisen here with some advice. If high-interest credit card debt is grinding you down, it might be time to call an Audible with a SoFi personal loan.
20:14Rich Eisen:It consolidates your debt into one low monthly payment with no fees required. And with as soon as the same day funding, you can make the right play fast. Call an audible on your debt today at SoFi.com slash debt play. Loans originated by SoFi Bank N.A. Member FDIC. Terms and conditions apply. NMLS 696891. Fast funds terms apply at SoFi.com slash debt play. Rich Eisen here for gusto. On my shows, we talk a lot about what happens in the spotlight, the games, the highlights, and the moments that get replayed and debated. But in any successful operation, what happens behind the scenes matters just as much.
20:49Rich Eisen:Small businesses are no different. Payroll, hiring, onboarding, benefits, and all the details that keep things moving may not be the most visible part of the job, but they still have to be handled right. That's where Gusto comes in. Gusto is online payroll and benefits software built for small businesses. It's all-in-one, remote-friendly, and incredibly easy to use, so you can pay, hire, onboard, and support your team from anywhere. Automatic payroll tax filing, simple direct deposits, health benefits, commuter benefits, workers' comp, 401k, you name it. Gusto makes it simple and has options for nearly every budget, and it's all built to save you time with built-in automated tools for offer letters, onboarding docs, direct deposit, and more.
21:29Rich Eisen:Plus, you get unlimited payroll runs for one monthly price. No hidden fees, no surprises. Try Gusto today at gusto.com slash rich and get three months free when you run your first payroll. That's three months of free payroll at gusto.com slash rich. One more time, gusto.com slash rich. The Rich Eisen Show podcast. Rich Eisen Show back here on the ESPN radio network presented by Progressive Insurance, former head of NFL refs and current NFL rules analyst for Fox Sports. Excellent at his job on a great broadcast team with Kevin Burkhart, Tom Brady, and the rest of the crew. Good to see you, Dean Blandino.
22:11Rich Eisen:Thank you for coming here in person. Of course. I really appreciate that, man. Always great to see you. Yeah, you know why. One of the reasons why I texted you, you said I'm done with the tush push when you were part of the crew in Kansas City, seeing it for the umpteenth time. and man, you know, it helps to be part of a crew with great professionals and 90 cameras, I think. And that shot that they had right down the line of the line of scrimmage when you could clearly see the Eagles were false starting and it wasn't called. Was that the play that caused you to say you were done with the touch pressure?
22:48Well, I think it was a combination of things. I think there were six in the game, but there were really three that stood out. Well, four. There was the third and goal play where they ruled Hurts short, and it looked like he scored. And now we've got to spend two minutes reviewing it and looking for the football and all these bodies. Then on the fourth and goal play, they false start that doesn't get called. They false start again later in the game. And then the last one where I made the comment was Eagles are trying to get the first down to run out the clock. They run the tush push. It's a big pile.
23:18The Chiefs come out with the football. They're waving. They have the football. The officials don't do anything. And I've got Brady and Burkhart looking at me in the booth like, what's going on? Right. And it was just a visceral reaction where I was like, you know what? I am done with this play. I'm proud of myself that I didn't say I'm effing done with this play. That's where I was in that moment. And it just then it kind of took on a life of its own.
23:45Rich Eisen:So why are you done? Explain the emotion. I was thinking about this on the way here. I'm going to present my argument three different ways. Please. Okay, three different ways. First, we'll start with health and safety. Now, I don't think there's no hard data that says this play is any more dangerous than other plays in the game or short yardage plays, right? So I don't think that's necessarily a strong argument that, oh, we have all these injuries. But the league has in the past, I think about low blocks and some of the chop blocks and some of the things they've outlawed. There wasn't a ton of injuries, but the league said, this is putting our players in a position of unnecessary risk.
24:24Let's be proactive versus reactive. So let's not wait for somebody to get hurt on a play like this. Let's say, okay, this is unnecessary. We don't allow the defense to push in field goal formations because the league felt it was dangerous. We're pushing these teammates, the down linemen, into the offensive formation. So I think from a health and safety perspective, being proactive versus being reactive. The second argument I have is that it's a competitively unfair play. It is. When you think about the defense, if the defense hits the running back at the line of scrimmage, stacks him up, and drives him 10 yards back, the offense isn't going to lose 10 yards.
25:01You've got forward progress right there. But we allow the offense to push and now gain an advantage in that instance. And it's also a hard play to officiate consistently. It just really is. And it's never been legal in the history of the NFL. You go back. I was talking to Joel Busser yesterday, long-time head of player personnel. Yes, at the league office, liaison to the NFL Competition Committee and a historian of the game. and he was reading to me from the 1938 rule book, you know, as one does on a random Wednesday. And the language in that book about aiding the runner was almost verbatim to where it was in 2005 before it came out.
25:45So it's never been legal in the NFL until 2006. And so because the people that created this game and made the rules, they wanted to kind of separate it from rugby, right? This is more rugby play. It's not a modern football play. And so they wanted to separate it from that. And that's where I think, you know, it's never been legal. Why do we allow it? And the third thing is just as a fan, it's not a fun play to watch. I mean, think about the Eagles. Saquon Barkley last year has one of the most incredible, I mean, he's hurtling people backward, right? Wouldn't we rather watch Saquon Barkley try to get a first down or some other than this, just all of these bodies and pushing.
Read the full transcript
26:25I just don't love it from an aesthetic standpoint. You want to excite me about NFL football? Let's watch the fourth quarter of the Giants-Dallas game. You know, let's watch that. This tush-push thing, again, that's where I'm at on it. But obviously, look, it's legal. Eagles do it better than anybody. Good for them. League's got to get 24 votes. They couldn't. And it's here for at least this year.
26:49Rich Eisen:But I don't think they would be, like, if the tush-push was banned, And we would now just see Saquon behind a fullback. We might see there are still quarterback sneaks, which are going to still be happening. They've always happened. No question. I'd imagine just as difficult to officiate. Maybe this one makes it more difficult to officiate because there's two, sometimes maybe three people piling on top of the quarterback because that's the way the momentum takes them when they're pushing him. That's exactly right. These challenges aren't unique to this play. Like you said, short yardage plays are tough to officiate.
27:25And I think if we get rid of this play, the Eagles come up with a quarterback sneak. I think they're going to be just as successful. I really do. It's just this idea of pushing the ball carrier, which has never been legal in the history of the NFL. It was never officiated that way, so they took the language out. And in hindsight, that really was a mistake because if that language had stayed in the book, even if you don't officiate it, this play never comes into existence. Do you know why they took it out? because it just wasn't being officiated and they felt like okay if we're not calling this why is it in the book and and right the tush push didn't exist back in 2005 2006 so but again taking that language out allowed however many years later for this play to be born and and here we are watching it um you know again i don't think it's a i don't think when you talk about nfl football and what it
28:18Rich Eisen:means and why people love it it's not that play so knowing the competition committee in the way it works and knowing membership and the way they vote and knowing the meetings in which these all come together as well as you do 22 to 10 last year being brought up and it's two votes shy of being voted out do you think that this is the last year we do see the tush push what do you think i think it's going to depend on what happens the rest of the way right this is week two short-term memory if nothing happens there's no controversy they're gonna run it multiple times and the eagles are on national television or on standalone games on fox a hundred percent non-stop i mean it's gonna happen that something's gonna come up later in the season are pretty high i think i really believe that that of those of those right there were 10 teams that voted to keep it nine not the eagles and nine other teams of those nine teams i know there was there were several that felt like the Eagles won the Super Bowl.
29:17We're not going to take the easy route. We're going to be the ego, and we're going to stop it, and we're not going to be seen as we couldn't stop them. They won the Super Bowl. I know for a fact that there were some clubs that had that in the back of their minds and might have been a factor in voting to keep it.
29:37Rich Eisen:Sort of like the defense and the tush-push. We're going to be the ones to finally stop it. We're going to be the ones to stop it. The ones that are going to stop it and the competition, not competition committee. Correct. Correct. And look, the Eagles are better than anybody at it. They sure are. And part of my frustration at the game was that the Eagles normally don't false start. They usually line up correctly. And it was like, okay, now if you're going to have this play that nobody else can do, and now if you're going to gain an advantage and the officials aren't going to call it, it just added to the frustration in the moment.
30:13Rich Eisen:Dean Blandino here, former head of NFL refs and now rules analyst on Fox. And I guess you're going to be Bears, Cowboys. You're going to Chicago. Bears, Cowboys, yes. That's a big game. We'll see that on Fox later on this weekend. Replay assist, love it. Yeah. I love it. And I couldn't have been more excited that they folded into replay assist this year. Is somebody being hit out of bounds late? If there's a flag, let's pick it up if it's not the case. Same thing with roughing the passer. Same thing with 15-yard penalties that are so big. um you know same thing with uh grabbing face mask well didn't grab it pick the flag up uh but they're not going to put a flag down on the field correct i understand that but i do seem to feel like there there have been is a guy out of bounds or not and you can clearly see guy was inbounds the flag was thrown let's pick it up they're not doing it am i wrong am i am i am i missing anything i'm not saying i'm seeing every snap of football but i'm also seeing roughing calls that aren't roughing and i understand that they want the the the officials on the field that their subjective process is the standard like that let's go with them but at what point we're gonna have replay assist we have a different subjective look at something and say pick the flag up i'm not seeing that yet well i think that's that's kind of the next iteration of this with replay assist they wanted to keep it to the objective elements of the play so if it's a hit on a quarterback and the referee says it was forcible contact to the head neck, replay can look at whether there was contact to the head neck.
31:43And if there wasn't any contact to the head neck area, they can pick up the flag. If there's any contact to the head neck, they can't say, well, it wasn't forcible enough because then that's the subjective part of the judgment call. Right. So I think that's where some of these roughing the passers, that there was one in the Giants-Cowboys game on, And I think maybe early in the game that to me wasn't rough in the passer, but it was more of the bodyweight version, and that's not subject to replay assist. Hits at the sideline, it's whether the runner was in or out of bounds. That's objective. And, again, still, regardless of saying it's objective, you still have people making these decisions in real time.
32:24And I do want the human element involved.
32:26Rich Eisen:Of course, we all do. we all do but we also when does replay assist get the you know 100 people in a bar can see it they all understand it we know what it is type of mentality and to replay assist that's what i'm looking for here that's that's the next step i think that's where you but again you got to be careful we don't want to re-officiate every play because then the game becomes um it becomes unwatchable in my opinion so i think there's there's areas i think replay assist has been great i think they're gonna you know they they always take an approach of we're gonna we're gonna crawl before we stand up and then we're gonna walk before we jog and we'll jog before we run so i think that's where they are right now we're probably in a walking phase right now so how does it work for people uh who are wondering do does at some point in time somebody who's assisting via replay looking at it get in the ear of the head ref and say we're looking at it and the head ref might just like call other officials over to take a second sure while that's being looked at is that how it works they all have they have wireless communication so all seven officials on the field have a have an earpiece and they can listen in the replay official up in the booth the folks in new york in the in the command center yes sir they can communicate to the on field all seven so when there is a situation maybe it's a hit on the quarterback referee will communicate i've got rough in the passer hit to the head neck replay booth will say we're looking at it and and either clear it or no there's no contact to the head neck area pick up the flag so so it should be seamless it's communication right away they have access they use the hawkeye system which you have access if there's 20 cameras that fox is using they have access to all 20 they can immediately pull it up get the best angle and and communicate that to the on-field crew is it possible than when we're seeing some zebras huddle up and talking that replay assist is saying hang on a second we're looking at it and it's it's like and it's like the bull Durham conversation about a candlestick who wants who's getting who's getting candlesticks for the wedding exactly yeah yeah potentially what's happening right now where we've come with replay assist first like year or two it was like this big secret like we all know what you're like stop like just and now they've come out and said okay after replay assist right before it was like after discussion it's like no you got the you got it from upstairs i stop we know what what's happening and people kind of i think are a pre i think fans are appreciative of of being a vicious of course like that of course because we want to get this thing right you know again i'll never forget being in the first owners meeting that nfl network uh we covered when replay was up for a vote about being made permanent and charlie casserly who i think was running the competition committee at the time he was a co-chair you know at the time when he was with the houston texans um he basically told the owners if everybody with their new fang high definition tv sets on their walls can see it we should use it yes you know and so if we're all seeing it at home we should use it um it's just again um i would love for it to be used with i under sure like did did a part of the helmet hit a part of the upper body?
35:36Rich Eisen:Maybe, but if that's the case, let's pick the flag up because that's not roughing. That shouldn't merit 15 yards to potentially give a fresh set of downs or alter the momentum of a drive. I agree. I think that's where you start. You start with the personal fouls because those are 15 yard penalties. The more you can do with that and the more that you can get those right, I think that's a positive for the game. I think you've got to stay away from things like holding and some of the other very very subjective calls hey man we saw pass interference was a holy mess yeah it was a mess when that was made reviewable and that was a one and done and coaches stopped challenging for it because they never could stick to a consistent standard it's like okay where is the bar and it seemed to change every week and so it also comes down to people and who's making those decisions and do you have a small group of people that can make consistent decisions and and apply a consistent standard.
36:29Rich Eisen:Right. And the minutes I have left with you here, you know, actually, can you stay to the end of the hour? I know I only gave you five minutes before. Is that fine? I want to come back because, you know, I'm targeting something for discussion. Yeah. Did you see what I just did? Wow. That was a good one. Did you see what I just did? That was amazing. Okay. Thank you. Well, I appreciate you calling that amazing because I agree. After further review, that adjective stands as called. All right. We're back here on the Rich Eisen show with Dean Blandino, the head of NFL refs. I cannot stand targeting college football.
37:01Rich Eisen:That's a little hint. That's coming up.
37:08Rich Eisen:Rich Eisen here. Running a small business means every hire matters. A bad hire costs time and money, but the right one helps your business grow. The challenge? Finding that person without sorting through resumes. That's where LinkedIn Hiring Pro comes in. It screens candidates so you can focus on conversations with qualified talent. With Hiring Pro, you can hire with confidence and build the team you need. Join the 2.7 million small businesses using LinkedIn to hire. Get started by posting your job for free at linkedin.com slash eisen. Terms and conditions apply. Oh, oh, oh, O 'Reilly. Check engine, ABS, or maintenance light on.
37:45Rich Eisen:Take the guesswork out of your warning lights with O 'Reilly Veriscan. The service is free and provides a report with solutions verified by ASE certified master technicians. And if you need help, we could recommend a shop for you. Ask for O 'Reilly Veriscan today. Oh, oh, oh, O 'Reilly. Auto Parts.
38:14Rich Eisen:The Rich Eisen Show, the podcast.
38:21Rich Eisen:back here on the rich eisen show what is it that makes the all-new hyundai palisade hybrid an incredible suv is it the spacious interior and it's comfy for the whole crew or the capability to go off-road maybe it's 600 miles of range 600 plus miles i don't want to i don't want to leave out the plus right there of range uh the all-new hyundai palisade hybrid so much more than just another suv visit hyundaiusa.com or call 562-314-4603 for more details that's 562-314-4603 for more details dean blandino of fox sports former head of nfl refs current rules analyst here on the rich eisen show uh thank you for staying for another segment especially when you know i'm about to oh yeah let's go again it's not like you're responsible uh but you are somebody who is a consultant for officiating corrected at the collegiate level yes i despise targeting with every fiber of my being with the white hot of uh of of a thousand suns and the reason why is it's so inconsistent like what what what is targeting like what can you tell me is targeting dean so targeting and i do look i think the rule i want to preface this by saying the rule has done a good job i think the rule accomplished what it was meant to accomplish up until this point you know getting the real flagrant egregious hits out of the game.
39:40And I think everybody has adjusted. You don't see in today's game, you don't see those types of flagrant hits that you saw 20 years ago before the rule. So I think the rule has done a great job up until this point. It's what it is. It's either lowering your head and attacking with the crown of the helmet, the very top of the helmet. Think spearing, right? Think what we all growing up playing football, whatever it was, spearing. That is one type of targeting. And that would apply to anybody, a ball carrier, a defenseless player. Then you have the defenseless player version of the rule, which is leading with the head, the shoulder, the forearm, to make forcible contact to the head, neck area of a defenseless player.
40:18So that's the rule book definition. But I agree. It hasn't always been officiated consistently. And I think the angst, though, around this rule, the real issue with the rule right now, I believe, is the penalty. I think it's the disqualification. I think it's the carryover. If these were just 15-yard penalties, not that those don't matter, they do, but I don't think this would be as hot a topic if it didn't have this carryover. And I think my personal opinion, I think it's time to rethink that penalty part of it. Because players have adjusted, coaches have adjusted, and the rule has done a great job making the game safer.
41:00Two things I also don't like.
41:01Rich Eisen:One is that replay can put a flag on the field for it. infuriating absolutely infuriating so if it's not called live guess what we're going to do like again and we showed the the michigan new mexico moment that uh obviously inflamed me because i'm passionate about michigan football of course that we're taking a look to see whether the ball was still in control by the quarterback based on a sack forced fumble and recovery for a touchdown by the way by the way not only is it not a touchdown which by the way it wasn't uh we're going to eject the kid for sacking him for targeting. And there's a difference between targeting, this just in for targeting on sacks of quarterbacks.
41:41Rich Eisen:Yes. The defender's targeting the quarterback. Sure. You know what I mean? Like that's called football. It's their job. You know what I mean? Like that's, yes, he is targeting the quarterback because that's, you know, the job of a defensive player to sack the quarterback to target him. It's, it's, it might be roughing. It might be the definition of helmet meets helmet. that's not targeting man that's not an ejectionable offense you're spot on you're spot on because that is it's a high hit and i think everybody would be comfortable if you say you know what you got to lower the target zone it's rough in the passer but it's not you're going to miss the rest of this game and you're going to miss the first half of the next game which i'm sure had nothing to do with they were playing oklahoma if they've been playing central michigan would he have been that no no i get it by the way you're not wrong of course it means a lot that's why the next half of the next game is is crucial it's such a big penalty and like i said i think it's now time the rule has done a great job up until this point i think players understand coaches everybody gets it do we need to have this draconian penalty associated with this when 99 of these are just kids trying to make a play and that's right and again that's the subjective if like was he trying to hurt the guy was he trying to do like was it particularly malevolent on this player's part like what was in his heart as he was target as he was looking to make a tackle and and i i understand that you're trying to not certainly when when we're at a level where uh not everyone's uh got the professional football ability to make him make a a mid-athletic thought process hit you to say i need to make sure i don't hit him the wrong way sure to ascribe that to an 18 year old freshman at full speed right it's a lot right especially since we also the way it's sometimes called in the acc it's not in the big 10 where where where you're seeing a targeting call that ejects my michigan wolverine you see something even worse later that night in a in a game you know in the mountain west or acc or the sec and it doesn't happen you're like maybe that's where you come in it's trying to make sure it's all that's my job nationally on the replay side to make sure that it's administered nationally consistent standard and one of the one of the just the the issues with college football from an officiating standpoint is you do it's not like the nfl where you have 32 clubs they're all under one umbrella everybody the messaging is the same leadership is the same now you have the acc which has their own officiating department and the big 10 which has their own officiating department and so we do bring them together and collaborate a lot when so it's a lot of off season we do zooms i do i do zooms every two weeks with all of the different conferences i bring conferences together so it's not just one zoom for the acc we have a with the acc the sec the big 12 so they're together and they can hear the same message and we go through it's an hour long every two weeks we go through four or five plays work through it here's where we need to be on this play forget about what happened we're not here to be critical of what happened right how do we how do we adjust going forward how do we apply a consistent standard and that's just one of the challenges with college football because you do have different conferences and sometimes the messaging can be different who's the competition committee though who's who's deciding you know what we should be able to put a flag on the on the ground when it's not called in real time.
45:13Rich Eisen:I mean, who do you go to to basically say that's absurd to put flags on the ground through replay? The NFL doesn't do it for a specific reason. Why is college football doing it? And that's the college rules committee, which is made up of coaches, administrators, ADs. And so it's a cross section of all these different stakeholders in college football. And we go through a very similar process. I've been a part of that rules committee. I've been a part of the competition committee. You look at plays and they end up voting. The college process is a little more layered they've got a playing rules oversight panel that has to to basically bless these rules changes that's going away on the football side all right which i think is a good thing that's going away so you don't have all these layers you can have the rules committee go through it and ultimately decide what what we're going to do in the game and i think that's going to help that's gotta i mean because at this point it's so inconsistent it's so punitive and it seems to be so arbitrary and it makes everybody look incompetent i'm not gonna lie man it's a bad look It is a bad look for when you're watching a game and you're like, that's not targeting.
46:15Rich Eisen:And then you look and see something far more egregious when you're flipping the channel and la-di-da, nothing's happening. And that's the biggest challenge. It's the consistency. Coaches can't challenge to put something on the ground, right? No, they can't challenge targeting. So if it's a change of possession that mandates something gets looked at, it's opened up for targeting. Yeah, yeah. Every play, replay can look at every play. But you can't challenge to look at targeting. No, coaches cannot challenge. But if it's something that's mandated to be replayed, targeting's fair game. That's stupid.
46:45Rich Eisen:Have I used the right word? Yes, you have. With the right inflection? Agreed. Stupid. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. Thanks for coming on, Nadine. Appreciate it. I can't even speak straight now. I'm so... He's so fired up. We got it. We got it. I am. Yeah, and playing Oklahoma matters, man. Could have used him. I know. You definitely could have used him. Okay, very good. I don't know if anybody's beaten Oklahoma this year. I know, which is kind of cool for them. I mean, we just had Tim Tebow on and I asked him, who's the best SEC team? And I thought he'd go, well, you know, Georgia, LSU, and he goes Oklahoma.
47:15Wow. That's what he said.
47:17Rich Eisen:Dean Blandino of Fox Sports is here. Tyreek Withers of the movie Him coming up. Got a couple more minutes to go here. The Ridge Eisen Show Podcast.
47:30Rich Eisen:Athletic Brewing Company crafts award-winning non-alcoholic beers for those who want to be part of every round. With over 185 flavor awards, they're exceptional NA beers that fit your lifestyle and any social occasion. Summer's full of good times, and athletic fits right in. Go to athleticbrewing.com to have brews delivered to your door, or find them at a bar, restaurant, or store near you. Near Beer. Athletic Brewing Company. Fit for all times.
From the publisher
Rich reacts to the latest injury news on Washington Commanders QB Jayden Daniels, and weighs in on the revived Tom Brady the broadcaster vs Tom Brady the Raiders owner conflict of interest debate.
FOX Sports’ Football Rules Analyst Dean Blandino joins Rich in-studio where he explains why he’s “done” with the Tush Push and why it should be banned from the NFL, discusses the expansion of ‘Replay Assist’ in the league, and the inconsistent enforcement of Targeting in College Football and why ejections and suspensions for the penalty are far too harsh.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
