NFL Combine Takeaways, Draft & Free Agency Predictions

2 Mar 2026 · 36 min · 12 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

The Rich Eisen Show: Episode Summary

Episode Title

NFL Combine Takeaways, Draft & Free Agency Predictions

Overview In this episode of *The Rich Eisen Show*, hosts Rich Eisen and Chris Brockman engage in a lively discussion about the recent NFL Scouting Combine, the upcoming NFL Draft, and various predictions related to player performances and free agency. This episode serves as a recap and analysis of key happenings during the Combine, offering predictions and insights for the NFL offseason.

---

Key Takeaways from the Discussion

Ohio State Players in the Draft

  • Prediction: Four Ohio State players are expected to be selected in the top ten of the NFL Draft.
  • Key Player: Carnell Tate showcased impressive speed with a 4.5-second 40-yard dash, raising his draft stock significantly.

Rookie Predictions

  • Fernando Mendoza:
  • Prediction: Mendoza will outperform Tom Brady's rookie season statistics (64% completions, 2,900 yards, 18 TDs).
  • Notable Traits: Similar physical build to Brady and is expected to excel due to a more passing-friendly league.
  • Jeremiyah Love:
  • Prediction: Love will have a better 2026 season than Ashton Jeanty's rookie year.
  • Impressive Metrics: 4.36-second 40-yard dash; compared favorably to previous top-performing running backs.

Combine Performance Insights

  • College Pro Days:
  • Argument that pro days should be reserved for players not invited to the Combine, as participation rates are declining.
  • Only 189 out of 320 players invited ran at the Combine, leading to discussions on the event's future relevance.
  • Key Performers:
  • Kenyon Sadiq and Eli Stowers are highlighted as tight ends likely to be drafted in the top 20.

Quarterback Predictions

  • Ty Simpson:
  • Prediction: Simpson will be starting quarterback in Week 1 for his team.
  • Vikings QB Situation:
  • Described as the most intriguing storyline of the offseason, with discussions around potential quarterback signings and the future of J.J. McCarthy.

Free Agency Predictions

  • Jimmy Garoppolo:
  • Prediction: He will lead the Cardinals to a winning season.
  • Mike Evans:
  • Prediction: Evans will advance further in the playoffs next season than the Buccaneers, as he seeks a ring with a new team (potentially Buffalo).

Discussions and Arguments

  • Eisen and Brockman often debate the realism of each prediction, with Eisen emphasizing that while there is excitement around these players, caution should be exercised regarding future expectations.
  • There is a noticeable emphasis on how Combine performances impact player visibility and perceived value within the league, shaping the narrative as teams make decisions on draft picks and free agency moves.

Episode Conclusion

  • The episode concludes with a reminder of the approaching NFL free agency period, encouraging listeners to stay tuned for updates and more detailed analyses as the offseason progresses.

---

Final Thoughts This episode of *The Rich Eisen Show* effectively captures the excitement around the NFL Combine, providing valuable insights into player performances and predictions that set the stage for the NFL Draft and free agency. The blend of humor and expert analysis makes it a must-listen for avid football fans.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

NFL Combine Overview

0:26 to 1:10

Discussion of the recent NFL scouting combine and its atmosphere.

Ohio State Players in the Draft

1:10 to 2:24

Evaluation of Ohio State players projected to go in the top ten of the draft.

“At one point, I was like, okay, you made your point.”

The Impressive Fernando Mendoza

2:24 to 6:12

Analysis of Fernando Mendoza's potential and comparisons to Tom Brady.

“I don't think that's an overreaction at all.”

The State of the NFL Combine

6:12 to 10:00

Discussion on the number of players working out at the combine and its implications.

“Super impressive, though, when he did speak, mentioned Tom Brady.”

The Importance of Pro Days

10:00 to 14:03

Exploring the role of pro days and how they relate to NFL combine workouts.

Understanding the NFL Combine

14:03 to 15:20

Learn about the various components and significance of the NFL Combine.

“I know we're viewing it as such, but at the end of the day, the combine is for interviews between players and their prospective employers.”

Predictions on Draft Prospects

16:22 to 18:48

Explore predictions and analyses on upcoming draft players and their potential.

“That's what kind of this period is about right now.”

Quarterback Speculations and Predictions

18:48 to 23:26

Discuss the speculations around quarterbacks and their potential in the draft.

“The others didn't do much in their careers at all.”

Evaluating J.J. McCarthy's Future

28:07 to 30:19

Discussion on J.J. McCarthy's performance and future as a quarterback.

“shorthanded because Carson Wentz didn't survive the first few weeks of the season by the way another reason why J.J.”

Quarterback Storylines to Watch

30:23 to 31:52

Exploration of intriguing quarterback storylines in the NFL.

“McCarthy, or do they feel like they don't believe in him?”
Show all 12 chapters

Mike Evans and Free Agency Predictions

31:52 to 34:26

Predictions about Mike Evans' potential free agency move and impact.

“And he also said that one of them also said that Brees Hall was going to be a Cardinal and lead the league in rushing.”

Trade Updates and Closing Remarks

34:27 to 35:18

Update on player trades and final thoughts on upcoming events.

“I'll say that's not an overreaction because if he's going to go ring chase.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:005 a.m.

0:01Chris Brockman:I'm up with a crisp Celsius energy drink running 12 miles today. Grab a green juice, quick change and head to work. Meetings, workshops, one more Celsius, no slowing down. Working late, but obviously still meeting the girls for a little dancing. Celsius, live, fit, go. Grab a cold, refreshing Celsius at your local retailer or locate now at Celsius.com.

0:26Rich Eisen:back here for another edition of overreaction monday now that the nfl scouting combine is in the books we hurtle towards free agency stuff already flying in the national football league chris brockman along with rich eisen good to see you christopher how are you what's up man congratulations another great combine in the books it is over we did it let me just sitting down on a chair talking about people running and moving around tones i mean it's still quiet in

0:54Chris Brockman:there man i gotta say we went and checked it out on thursday and it it was kind of like jarringly quiet i know it's like a lot it's a library yeah i know you're supposed to be quiet but now there's

1:04Rich Eisen:fans in there too and carson beck has to work out to booze so much went down over the weekend overreaction monday is back hit it hit it that was terrible that was crap that was garbage this

1:16Chris Brockman:place sucks over reaction mondays monday all right chris for what do you have over there imagine you're at your job interview a law firm doctor whatever and there's a boom it was crazy and i

1:30Rich Eisen:almost wanted because because the fans in the stands we'll talk about it on the flagship later on the fans in the stands uh many of them have our broadcast so i'm legitimately potentially for sure speaking to them if I decided to address them. Okay, maybe tone it down. At one point, I was like, okay, you made your point. By the way, just check the scoreboard. Yeah, you won. You won the game. He threw the interception to help you seal it. He's the one who had Ray Lewis come right up to him on the sideline and say, let's go. And he's the one who's got to go back to Ray Lewis and say, oh, man, too bad.

2:07Chris Brockman:They should have been like, hey, thank you. Dude. All right. That's a lot. What do you got over there? Let's start with this, and I think I know what you're going to say, but I want to get it out there because it kind of was the story of the first day of the combine, second day of the combine. Not one, not two, not three, four. Ohio State players are going to go in the top ten of the first round.

2:26Rich Eisen:I don't think that's an overreaction at all. Carnell Tate was the one who ran a 4-5-4 twice over, according to all the metrics. Now, there might have been faster hand times by the scouts, but I don't think there's a single scout on the planet that's going to look at that and go, oh, well, we got to knock him down a peg or two. I don't know if you watched it live on NFL Network. No, no. Okay, you might have been running around, getting back into real life for yourself. But we had Brandon Beam, the general manager of the Buffalo Bills, in our booth as Carnell Tate, ran a 4-5-4 for the second time.

3:05Rich Eisen:and he's sitting there between me and Daniel Jeremiah and as soon as he runs it, he says something to the effect of, man, I would definitely let him fall in the draft if I were. I would definitely start overlooking him was essentially the general gist of what he had to say. I love that. And we just laughed because that's the only response you can possibly have. The tape doesn't lie. And you look at some other people who ran four fives or above cd lamb's one of them i mean is anybody sitting here talking about his 40 time as he's wide open wide ass open no no okay so i don't think um now caleb downs didn't work out but his uh conversations apparently with teams were off the charts everyone's raving about him we had him on our show he was beyond impressive he's already talking like he's a pro uh refused to talk about which teams he's interviewing with because some kids don't like doing that they might think it's like uh talking out of school or whatever um and i don't think he's falling out of the top 10 arvel reese looks like robocop he's not falling out of the top five if he does the i think the the commander is at seven that is the lowest he's gonna go in this draft yeah if at all um Then you look at Sonny Styles and all those mocks of him being 12th overall.

4:33Rich Eisen:It's up in smoke.

4:34Chris Brockman:Yeah, I saw one Monday morning. I was curious how the mocks would react. And the first one I saw had all four guys going in the top 10. And I was like, okay, okay. Right.

4:45Rich Eisen:Well, I mean, you just have to take a look. It had Tate at 10. The question is, is who else goes in the top 10? Mendoza goes in the top 10. Love goes in the top 10. I think Maui Noah, the left tackle of Miami, goes in the top 10. Right. Or the tackle from Miami goes in the top 10. I think Ioane, the guard, the interior guard of the Penn State Nittany Lions, I think he goes in the top 10. And, you know, Bailey goes in the top 10. I don't know about Bain. Bain is an interesting question about his arms, dude. Yeah, I know. And, you know, because nobody with his shortness of his arms has been a top 10 pick.

5:29Rich Eisen:No one with the shortness of his arms has been a double digit sack guy. I mean, so shortness of his arms for his position. That one is kind of up in the air. I don't think this is an overreaction. Yeah. Even though the only other time it's happened in the common draft was 1967, as I mentioned on the show on Friday, when Michigan State, with Bubba Smith going first overall, many people might remember him from Police Academy movies and the Miller Lite commercials with John Madden back in the day. He led the pack first overall. Four Michigan State Spartans went in the top ten. That's it. So I think we might see a record.

6:08Rich Eisen:I really do. I really think that's not an overreaction.

6:10Chris Brockman:All right, let's talk about who's going first, Fernando Mendoza. He didn't work out, obviously. Super impressive, though, when he did speak, mentioned Tom Brady. Fernando Mendoza is going to have a better statistical rookie season than Tom Brady's 2001 year, his first year starter. That's 64 % completions, 2 ,900 passing yards, 18 touchdowns, 12 picks.

6:36Rich Eisen:Interesting. I'll just say, sure. Why not? I mean, it's just a bigger passing league now than it was then. It just really is.

6:45Chris Brockman:I mean, and, you know, I say statistical because obviously Tom Brady won the Super Bowl in 2001. Don't think Mendoza is going to do that. But I think, you know, as far as stats wise, super impressive. They're built kind of the same. Six, five, two thirty. Maybe Tom's not that heavy, but I kind of like this guy. And I think he's going to be a star. Raiders have lots of weapons.

7:07Rich Eisen:I hear you. OK, I hear you. You know, Brady didn't have anybody like Brock Bowers. Definitely not. Did you see Mendoza said a team told him to get arrested so he could drop?

7:18Chris Brockman:I got to say, I'm sure that was tongue in cheek. I thought that was hilarious.

7:22Rich Eisen:I think that's super funny. He said that one team said, you know, you should get arrested. It's the same way Brandon Bean's like, yeah, that 4-5-4. I wouldn't draft Carnell Tate if I were you. I'm sitting there at 26. I'd love to get Carnell Tate for Josh Allen.

7:37Chris Brockman:Maybe he wouldn't do it on the record. Maybe if you call a Raider game this year, Rich, try to get that information. I want to know what team, you know, has a good enough sense of humor to tell him that.

7:45Rich Eisen:I don't deny it. I mean, just the mere fact that this day and age, that passing stats are through the roof. And I certainly hope, you know, for this kid and the Raiders fans that he is everything as advertised. And he is as advertised. There was that moment when he, and I knew it was coming. I mentioned it on the top five list of workouts that I was most eager to see at the combine, that Mendoza was my one more, even though I knew he wasn't working out because I knew when he would walk into the arena that all the fans that were there, 15 ,000 fans came on Saturday. They were all the ones who were booing Carson Beck were the ones who were excited to just get a glimpse of Mendoza.

8:30Rich Eisen:And then there was a 40-yard dash being run by a wide out in the group before his and as soon as he came out and I think this is the photograph those who are watching our our um our overreaction Monday podcast on YouTube I believe this was the moment where he came out and he sat with a couple of his fellow group nine mates and there was this massive applause massive ovation for him and I we were just wondering what's happening and you know our producer Mark Teitelman, T-Man, gets in my ear, goes, Mendoza just walked in, and they got a shot of him just sitting down, and he's just, like, waving, you know?

9:10Rich Eisen:He's like a beetle. Honestly, and I think Raiders fans are going to fall in love with him just because of that and everything that he says, everything that he does, the way that he holds himself. So you put it all together, I can't imagine we don't have this happening. I mean, obviously, anything can happen. Sure. where he has an injury-marred season or whatever. Yeah, I mean, I don't think Cam Ward put up those types of numbers. I mean, those numbers are attainable. What else you got over there?

9:39Chris Brockman:Okay, obviously Mendoza didn't work out. And kind of being there on Thursday and throughout the weekend, a lot of guys didn't. It was kind of jarring the number of guys who are, you know, they're weeding the list of guys who aren't working out. Obviously saving it for the pro day. I think we need to come together collectively and figure something out so the combine becomes the place where guys work out. college pro days should only be for players not invited to the combine oh no that's not happening that's not that's not the question i like this is not an overreaction right it is an overreaction

10:14Rich Eisen:um let me let me just give you numbers to back up what you're saying first of all um of the 320 players invited to the nfl scouting combine this year only 189 ran come on that's the fewest at an NFL combine ever the previous low was last year 201 so there's fewer who did it this year than last year's low previous low so yes um that is an issue secondly uh for the broadcast to be honest with you it goes faster things go faster at the combine when fewer people run okay um there are some people who aren't running because they know they're going to run slow they're dinged up they're this they're that they had a long season now in college football you know if i'm not mistaken um i think next year's national championship game is is january 20 something because the same reason why the nfl super bowl is on valentine's day because of labor day being late uh and the calendar year everything's pushed deeper so you've got you've got players who have longer college seasons and and they have longer rehabs for injuries or at least injuries that occur later in the season so there's that but I truly feel the incentive to run at the combine still is there to be a aired on NFL Network and be every single coach or general manager that came to our booth when we were off camera and i think a couple said it on camera too that we were talking about gee do you see how fast everybody is out there and they would say yeah if i'm the agent i would say run at the combine because that's the fastest track on planet earth yes yes some of these turfs are on grass for your pro day some of the turf could be you know um loose some could be on a rainy day some could be a day after a rainy day here you're on you know the home sideline of the indianapolis colts where by day three day four that thing is tamped down like that thing is hard as a rock that thing you can burn on it and a lot of the official times got knocked down by one one thousandth of a second um and so i think at the end of the day if you're gonna run your 40 you should do it at the combine and then don't do anything else if you don't want to like that carnell tate did that he ran the 40 and then nothing else um because some of the drills you You might, you know, get dinged up here, get dinged up there.

13:04Rich Eisen:Anything can happen when you're working out. But to basically say college pro day should only be for anybody that wasn't invited to the NFL scouting combine, there are some times when you're not able to perform at the combine. The pro days are there for that. The pro days are there for the scouts. Everything that I understand that we're viewing the combine as a television event. Look who you're talking to. Sure, of course. Obviously, as I mentioned to the NFL Network group before going on the air, we were all talking about it. This is the proudest achievement I think NFL Network has ever created, which is the combine.

13:46Rich Eisen:Everything else that we've done for NFL Network or with NFL Network is in support of an event that already existed or adding another option for your viewing pleasure for an event that's already existed. The combine is something we helped create out of whole cloth as a television event. So I'm very proud that it's a television event. I know we're viewing it as such, but at the end of the day, the combine is for interviews between players and their prospective employers. It's for a medical evaluation that is a crucial component for whether someone gets drafted here or there. A measurement component, whether somebody gets drafted here or there.

14:22Rich Eisen:and at the end of the day the workouts are televised because we're all keenly interested in just wondering how our team's going to get better that's the beautiful part about the nfl and how its popularity keeps exploding is the level of interest so at the end of the day college pro days are going to be there for people like for met fernando mendoza who's like you know what if i'm going to do any workouts i want to do it for some guys who aren't drafted at the you who are invited to the combine. I want to be there with my guys and throwing to my guys because it's also better for him to do that rather than how you're going to throw to a certain spot and a receiver you've never thrown to in your life isn't going to be there at the right time and your ball suddenly looks like it's a misthrow.

15:06Rich Eisen:Which, by the way, scouts always say they can tell the difference. That said, I'll just call this an overreaction. I appreciate you're trying to support this as a television event, but ask you to move on. All right. All right.

15:19Chris Brockman:Want to earn extra income for your business? Amazon Hub Delivery is looking for ambitious business owners to assist with local deliveries. When you become a partner, you and your staff will deliver packages to customers in your area on a schedule that works for you. With each package delivered, you'll gain extra income and exposure for your business. Plus, Amazon Hub Delivery makes it easy to get started. There's no upfront costs, delivery experience, or long-term contracts required. Sign up to learn more at Amazon.com slash Hub Delivery. That's amazon.com slash H-U-B delivery. As you know, managing maintenance, repair, and operations is never easy.

15:53Chris Brockman:But for the ones who always rise to the challenge, Grainger has your back. From professional-grade products you can count on to fast, dependable delivery, they're there to help you keep things running smoothly. Plus, their technical product specialists are here to help answer your toughest questions. And because Grainger knows safety is always a priority, They're committed to being your partner and protecting both your people and your facilities. Call 1-800-GRANGER, click Grainger.com, or just stop by. All right, competition, comps, player comps. That's what kind of this period is about right now.

16:27Chris Brockman:This guy, you mentioned the speed. He was blistering in his 40. We talked to him. Jeremiah, love. This kid is awesome. Love him, yeah. And you know what? He's going to have a better 2026 season than last year's touted top 10 running back. Ashton Jenty. And I gotta say, Ashton Jenty's rookie year kind of gets a bad rap. 1 ,321 total yards, nearly 1 ,000 rushing, 55 catches, 10 total touchdowns. Those are big numbers.

16:57Rich Eisen:I'm gonna say this, okay? I was just thinking about that. We're talking about it with Coop this morning. And I drafted Ashton Jenty in fantasy.

17:08Chris Brockman:I mean, hand up. Me too. Every week I could.

17:11Rich Eisen:And I regretted it almost every week. And again, it wasn't like eye-popping. I'm not denigrating his talent, okay? Anybody will tell you the number of times that he got hit behind the line of scrimmage, you lose track. It was every single time, I think. Just terrible. And obviously, Chip Kelly was an awful fit with a head coach that I'm sure laments many of his choices at the end of the day looking back, okay? but at the at the eyesight just looking at his abilities his size and his abilities and doing it for Notre Dame makes me think differently about Jeremiah Love if I have him in a fantasy draft I just love talking to him I loved he's just like yeah I'm talking mess about USC I'm talking mess to anybody trash talker you know I love uh you know vaulting people that was his favorite thing about his about playing running back he said i'll play gunner on special teams

18:13Chris Brockman:and i think he really meant it he wanted to play special teams like bro you are not going to be

18:18Rich Eisen:out there on punt coverage that's what i that's what i basically told him right um so he is something else and i i he's six foot genties five and a half and an eight five he's five eight and a half yep okay he's got genti by a pound um his hand size is smaller his arm length his arm length he's got a genti by almost three inches um and so you take a look at genti robinson and jameer gibbs are the last three running backs selected in the top 16 of an nfl draft um and and his measurables are are up there actually with uh robinson with bijon more than more than any of the other uh three that i just mentioned he's got to be taller than the only notre dame running back in the common draft era to be selected in the top 10 picks of the nfl draft is jerome bettis obviously bettis had him in weight and in hand but he's he's taller than jerome uh his 4.36 40 He's the best 40-yard dash by a combine running back at least six inches tall since 2003.

19:28Rich Eisen:The others didn't do much in their careers at all. Mike Washington Jr., who is the fastest. He's a combine made of his. The others are Darren McFadden. There's one. Isaac Garendo is the other. But his 40-time, loves 40-time. Here's the comparison for you. It was crazy fast. 4.36. It's the same as Jameer Gibbs. And it's faster than Jamal Charles, Kenneth Walker, and Jonathan Taylor. That's all you need to know. So you bet. I don't think this is an overreaction by any stretch of the imagination. I don't think Jeremiah loves getting out of the top five. How about that?

Read the full transcript

20:07Chris Brockman:Oh, Rich Eisen. I like that.

20:10Rich Eisen:How about that? I mean. Wow. I don't know. If I'm the Titans, I look at him and go. I think if you're Tennessee, yeah. And if you're the Giants, you've got to sit here and think to yourself. How about this as a one-two punch with Scadaboo? That Scadaboo's not a 25-carry guy, I don't think. Well, now he'd have to change kind of his mindset. Oh, he's not going to. Jackson Dart isn't either. You already hear how he's talking coming out of the season about how I'm not changing my style. I'm always going to go for first downs and whatever. The Giants have got to think about it. That's for sure. What else you got over there?

20:45Chris Brockman:Let's talk about another couple guys who helped their, I got to say, first-round draft stock after these stellar combine performances. Tight ends, Rich. Kenyon Sadiq, Eli Stowers, they're going in the top 20. Both.

21:00Rich Eisen:Their top 20 talents. These guys put on a show. They did. They did. I mean, Kenyon Sadiq had the best workout at tight end I've seen since Vernon Davis. I mean, that's, as you know, is the gold, gold standard of tight end workouts. And Stowers, he was terrific as well. Again, when you say this sort of thing, you have to take a look at who else is available. And pass rush is so crucial and pass protection is so crucial that whoever is at the top end of those flow charts, whoever's at the top end of those lists of candidates to draft are going to go. They're going to go fast. And some teams might even trade into the top 20 because they really covet one of them.

21:49Rich Eisen:and then you've got back end people, the corners. You want to get a top corner or you want to get a top tight end. These are choices that teams make. True. So to say top 20 for both of them when there's Bailey and Reese and Styles and there's Downs and there's Tate and there's a handful of other receivers and then there's a handful of other linemen defenders and corners and safeties who are going crazy in addition to Sonny Stiles. I'll call this an overreaction, that it'll be really tough. I mean, one of them I can see. Both of them is particularly bold. And by the way, how about I kind of gave you an overreaction topic by saying Jeremiah Love is a top five.

22:37Rich Eisen:You did. You kind of like, whoa. You almost got jealous. Like, how did you not think of that yourself? I know.

22:41Chris Brockman:I went with stats instead of draft spot. That's not a bad one. I mean, it's not a bad one, but, you know.

22:46Rich Eisen:That's good. I'm going to back pocket that for later on. Back pocket it. Because, I mean, we're going to be talking about this on overreaction Monday all the way to Pittsburgh. For sure. But if you're Tennessee, you've got to sit there and think, Jeremiah Love, man, we can get him here, and we can get him next to Cam Ward, and off we go and run the ball and play defense for your new coach. That might happen.

23:08Chris Brockman:I just like that, you know, this first round was seemingly lacking buzz, and then post-combine, here we are. You know, these guys had such great workouts. They did. Speed and all right. This first round's got some juice now. Right. That's nice to see. We know who the first quarterback is. Mendoza is going to be first off the board, Rich. A lot of talk about the second quarterback. Probably going to be Ty Simpson from Alabama. I agree. And I also think he's going to go in the first round and he's going to be starting week one.

23:32Rich Eisen:Now, whoever takes it. Now, that's a bold prediction there. That's an overreaction. That's one. I'll be honest. I'm not Jordan Palmer or I'm not Jason Beck. I'm not any of these guys. I'm not a throwing coach by trade. But I could see how a ball spins and I could see how it jumps out of somebody's hands. And I thought Ty Simpson had a very nice workout on Saturday. I think he did. His facial features are very Delomian, don't you think? I was going to say, he could be Garoppolo's cousin. Okay, I got you. He's got good flow, good cheekbones. But Ty Simpson really had a good workout, I thought. I thought Carson Beck looked pretty darn good as well.

24:24Rich Eisen:But, I mean, Simpson looks the part. He's got the whole package. You just got to sit here and wonder what happened at Alabama. them you know what what why can't a uh a quarterback with a talent level that's potentially surrounded by five stars yeah like that might be the coach that might just be the sec being down by the way with the big 10 winning three straight big 10s coming for that i don't know but teams are gonna have to sort it out a first round draft choice is still a tall order daniel jeremiah you know said on our show the last two weeks that he can't find a partner he can't find the trade partner he can't find the team with the need you know and there's two teams with a supposed need you know Steelers if you think Will Howard's not a guy in waiting or if you think Rogers isn't coming back well and and if and and the other one is the Rams who's at some point maybe going to get the next Stafford when they identify him.

25:34Rich Eisen:But if you're the Steelers and you're the Rams and you've got Rodgers and you've got Stafford. Get them some help for now. Yeah, that's the way you draft. You use this first round choice, certainly the one for the Rams that's not their own, the one they got from Atlanta that's in the middle of the first round. You could get yourself, I mean, everybody that we just mentioned in the first, you know, in the beginnings and throughout this entire pod that might force one of those tight ends, for instance, to be out of the top 20, the Rams can get themselves a really good defensive football player. And so I don't know where Simpson's going to land, let alone get a week one start, you know.

26:22Rich Eisen:It's crazy that Jimmy Garoppolo might have a week one start instead of Ty Simpson. Well, let's hold on to that for a second. Because apparently the Cardinals are interested in him. With Mike LaFleur coming from the Rams staff. But, yeah, I'll just call that an overreaction, asking him to move on. What else you got?

26:35Chris Brockman:All right, let's talk some quarterbacks here. A lot of talk in Indy about what's going on with the Vikings, who they might be interested in, what type of situation that is. I think the Vikings quarterback situation is the most intriguing storyline of this entire offseason. We're leaving today and entering a world of Mickey Mouse waving, princess meeting and greeting.

26:57Rich Eisen:Lightsaber clashing The Twilight Zone Tower of Terror dropping Banshee flying Space Mountain launching Galaxy rewinding Galaxy rewinding Fireworks igniting

27:11Chris Brockman:World of Other Worlds For whatever you love Infinite worlds await at the most magical place on Earth Walt Disney World Resort

27:20Rich Eisen:So good, so good, so good New markdowns up to 70 % off are at Nordstrom Rack stores now. And that means so many new reasons to rack. Because I always find something amazing. Just so many good brands. Because there's always something new. Join the Nordic Club to unlock exclusive discounts, shop new arrivals first, and more. Plus, buy online and pick up at your favorite rack store for free. Great brands, great prices. That's why you rack. yeah because you don't know what it is you don't know what it is one giant shrug emoji you don't know what it is okay is it lack of belief in jj mccarthy is it lack of um a veteran presence that they definitely need because mccarthy might not answer the bell last year they were left shorthanded because Carson Wentz didn't survive the first few weeks of the season by the way another reason why J.J.

28:22Rich Eisen:McCarthy was not available and at times might have had difficulty in his first few starts as a quarterback in the NFL is the pass protection and the run blocking behind an injured offensive line that took down Wentz also might be part of the evaluation of

28:42Chris Brockman:jj mccarthy oh and also was mccarthy soft benched he had a kid uh there's like the darnold of it all kind of factoring and then there's the way over all of it and then there's the way that he

28:53Rich Eisen:got memed because he was he nicknamed himself and you're wondering what's going on in his head um he's you know let me let me look this up i think he's 22 he's one of the youngest players in the league. Right. And so this is the coach in Kevin O 'Connell who came on this show. He's 23. He just turned 23 in January. This is the coach who came on our flagship show and said that organizations fail young quarterbacks before the other way around. So, you know, and everything I heard at the combine is they still believe in him. So if they get Geno Smith, which is a quarterback that should be out there to go acquire or sign, that you are saying we have a much better veteran backup plan if J.J.

29:52Rich Eisen:McCarthy doesn't physically answer the bell. We have a much better plan because he's going to be in our system all season long, all offseason long, as opposed to last year. Right. When Carson Wentz was acquired practically at the last minute. You've got a better setup. One hundred percent. J.J. McCarthy is our starter. He is our first week guy. Unless you're going to say, let the best man win in a competition. They feel that's best for J.J. McCarthy, or do they feel like they don't believe in him? So, yeah, you want to talk about intriguing storylines? This one's up there. I don't know how you can compare it to anybody else.

30:38Rich Eisen:If they get Kyler Murray, that's a totally different story because Murray, I don't think, is going to go anywhere. To be a backup. Right. I don't think he's going to do that. Same thing with Tua as well. but Geno Smith is you know a veteran towards the back nine here um and he might also want to be that guy all right am I back nine I'll go to the Minnesota system I'll I'll I'll be that guy and I'm definitely gonna get some starts if McCarthy's not gonna not gonna answer the bell that that might be a good spot for him potentially um I don't know how it's all gonna shake out but there's no other storyline in the NFL that has a 23-year-old quarterback who started for the first time two years into his career last year and the guy who's started in his first year because he couldn't answer the bell physically he wins 14 games then goes somewhere else and wins the Super Bowl putting pressure on the decision makers right who basically set this whole thing up from the minute they traded up for jj mccarthy without knowing what they've been creating for themselves at the time yep and adding another quarterback who is as famous for doing something for some other team as anybody else that could be acquired in the offseason and adding him to that mix i i don't know of another storyline that's as intriguing as that so it's a fun buy it what

32:12Chris Brockman:else you got all right two more rich you mentioned uh the handsome man jimmy g he's gonna have the cardinals over 500 next year if he goes to the cardinals yeah all right i'll just call that an

32:25Rich Eisen:overreaction and ask you to move on really just flat out dismissal i'm not dismissing it i'm just like he's not there yet i mean this is you're like front loading you're front loading the listen i want this to be right in the worst way because cooper's buddy luke said that Jimmy G is going to have a start in his job next year. And he also said that one of them also said that Brees Hall was going to be a Cardinal and lead the league in rushing. So both things happen. That would be incredible. I'll take one of them. Just that any of the hot takes that I acquired from Cooper's friends as I drove him to Topgolf on his birthday would be great if it's right.

33:01Rich Eisen:Yeah, the micro four connection.

33:02Chris Brockman:I mean, they've got good receivers.

33:04Rich Eisen:Sure. And Jake Brisket was moving the offense all over the place. Yeah.

33:10Chris Brockman:Jimmy G still has some ball left. What else? You got one more? All right, last one. Free agency is going to hit soon, and one of the big names out there is Mike Evans. Doesn't seem like he's going to be back in Tampa. I'm going to say Mike Evans is going to go further in the playoffs next year than the Bucs.

33:24Rich Eisen:You don't even know where he's going yet, huh? He's going to go to a contender. Why won't Mike Evans? Why has he gone from the Bucs? Because they don't want to pay him? Is that what it is?

33:31Chris Brockman:They don't want to pay him, and they've got a lot of good weapons there.

33:34Rich Eisen:Yeah, but you've got to let Amir Abuka run free. I know Emeka. You know what I mean? Emeka. I almost went full Gronk there. He's really good. And Godwin, when he's healthy. Godwin's back, fully healthy. I got it. And all those youngins running all over the place. But this guy, even with his annual I have to miss four to six weeks injury. But I'm still going to get 1 ,000 yards. Yeah, he almost did. He almost did.

33:59Chris Brockman:Come on, man. Mike Evans wants one more shot at a ring.

34:04Rich Eisen:Don't know if Tampa's the spot for it next season. Is Kansas City the spot? I mean, how many years have we basically said that Mike Evans should go to Kansas City? Well, is Buffalo? Buffalo would be a good one. Is New England? Buffalo would be a really good one. My gosh, Mike Evans with Josh Allen would be great. It would be like 15 touchdowns. Book it. So, sure. I'll say that's not an overreaction because if he's going to go ring chase. I think that's what he is. I think he is. I will buy that. But you front-loaded a couple things. and before before we head out uh during this show david montgomery was traded to the texans okay so that whole business of he doesn't want to be there he doesn't he does want to be there i guess at the end of the day didn't matter they flip him to that's kind of fun i'll tell you that's a great mix man that's kind of fun yeah you could play that joe mixin role right big time with woody Marks.

35:03Rich Eisen:That's a nice one-two punch right there with the Texans get a nice piece. Okay. So things are already happening. Things are already happening. And we're, we're one week away from the two day window of tampering. Don't call it tampering windows open negotiations. So for Chris, I'm rich. Stay tuned to the flagship show for so much on overreaction Monday and more with the new league year and free agency hits. Thank you for taking in this show. and thank you for taking in our show all last week from Indianapolis at the Scouting Conway.

35:37Chris Brockman:Shot clocks, big shots, upsets, aces, TGL playoffs are here. First, Atlanta Drive starts their repeat run against Los Angeles Golf Club. Then, Rory's Boston Common Golf and Tiger's Jupiter Lynx face off in their playoff debuts. Who will advance? Keep up. It's playoffs. Tune in Tuesday, March 17th at 6.30 p.m. and 9 p.m. only on ESPN and the ESPN app.

From the publisher

A weekly staple on 'The Rich Eisen Show' since 2018, 'Overreaction Monday' is now also an extended podcast with Rich and Chris Brockman debating the latest in the NFL. Today's topics:

1:45 - Four Ohio State players will be selected in the NFL Draft's 1st round

5:45 - Fernando Mendoza will have a better statistical rookie season than Tom Brady

9:15 - College pro days should only be for players not invited to the Combine

14:55 - Jeremiyah Love will have a better 2026 season than Ashton Jeanty's rookie year

19:20 - After stellar combine performances, both Kenyan Sadiq and Eli Stowers will go in the top 20

21:54 - Ty Simpson will be starting Week 1

25:10 - The Vikings' QB situation is the most intriguing storyline of this NFL offseason

29"50 - Jimmy Garoppolo will have the Cardinals over .500 next season

30:50 - Mike Evans will go further in the playoffs than the Buccaneers next season
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from The Rich Eisen Show

All 1,079 episodes
NFL Combine Takeaways, Draft & Free Agency PredictionsThe Rich Eisen Show · 36 min
Listen in VO