In short
The Cleveland Browns’ quarterback situation heading into a Friday preseason game vs. the Carolina Panthers, focusing on why rookie Shador Sanders is starting and what it means for the rest of the QB room and week-one readiness.
Guest backgrounds
Mary Kay Cabot (Cleveland Browns insider, 30+ years covering Browns); Kevin Fishbane (Bears writer, The Athletic); earlier guests include Prime Video NFL analyst Andrew Whitworth and former NFL GM Mike Mayock.
Key claims
Browns are starting Shador Sanders because Joe Flacco is the only QB not dealing with soreness/injury, while Kenny Pickett and Dylan Gabriel have hamstring issues; Tyler Huntley was added just the day before and will relieve Shador. Cabot says it’s “attrition” and that Shador’s accuracy is his superpower, but he’s still catching up on pro pre-snap/terminology. Another claim: all four QBs could make the 53-man roster, with Joe and Kenny starting early.
Notable examples
Shador’s college-to-pro learning curve (huddle calls, protections, motions); Panthers starters likely limited early; Deshaun Watson is on PUP recovering from a ruptured Achilles and appeared on the practice field.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VONFL Preseason Dynamics
1:28 to 2:16
Discussion about the NFL preseason, highlighting quarterback situations.
“As he steps on the field to start week one for the New York Giants.”
Cleveland Browns Quarterback Predictions
2:16 to 6:41
Analysis of the Cleveland Browns' quarterback situation and Shador Sanders' prospects.
“are going to be back-to-back right in the middle of this third hour of the program to give us updates on what's going on in both of these spots.”
Shador Sanders' Preseason Opportunity
6:41 to 11:00
Exploration of the challenges and opportunities for Shador Sanders in his first game.
“We'll get Snoop back up to speed quickly.”
Anticipation for Upcoming Games
11:00 to 14:01
Anticipation of the Browns' upcoming games and insights on their roster decisions.
“I think we'll all be sitting there watching and be excited for football to be going real time, and I think he's probably excited about that too.”
Previewing the Show
14:01 to 15:10
Rich Eisen sets up the hour with guest introductions and call-in details.
“Now, Joel Klatt might have said something different, but I wouldn't know because he left, as he always does after the night too.”
Caller Discussion: Colts and Management
16:43 to 18:11
Rich takes a call discussing the Colts' management decisions and the quarterback situation.
“844-204-RICH is the number to dial on the show.”
Mary Kay Cabot Joins the Show
18:12 to 19:13
Rich welcomes Mary Kay Cabot to discuss the Cleveland Browns quarterback situation.
“And the issue is, obviously, you know, and I appreciate the caping for Mike, who I adore.”
Shador Sanders' Opportunity
19:14 to 21:30
Mary Kay discusses Shador Sanders' upcoming game and readiness.
“And he went over and then walked off and he looked very pouty.”
Injury Updates and Quarterback Decisions
21:31 to 23:50
Mary Kay provides updates on injuries and the Browns' decisions regarding quarterbacks.
“he was the one most behind of anybody coming into this competition and now he can go out and prove either A, that wasn't true, or B, it doesn't matter.”
Future of the Browns' Quarterback Position
23:51 to 25:08
Discussion about long-term quarterback plans and potential rookies for the Browns.
“Right now, they are both dealing with hamstring injuries.”
Show all 21 chapters
Deshaun Watson's Status
25:09 to 26:25
Mary Kay talks about Deshaun Watson's recovery and his role with the team.
“So at some point, I think they'll turn it over to the rookies.”
Final Thoughts and Humor
26:26 to 28:00
Rich and Mary Kay share final thoughts on the Browns and inject some humor.
“And I guess, you know, the future at the quarterback position in Cleveland is exactly why somebody brought up Arch Manning to Jimmy and Dee Haslam the other day.”
Discussion with Mary Kay Cabot
28:00 to 28:28
Insight into the Cleveland Browns quarterback situation from Mary Kay Cabot.
“And, you know, just take the, you know, the leash off and go.”
Deshaun Watson's Situation
28:28 to 29:18
Exploring Deshaun Watson's role and expectations for this season.
“Cabot with the latest in Cleveland, Bronx.”
Caleb Williams Under Pressure
29:18 to 30:06
Discussion on Caleb Williams facing scrutiny in his second year.
“She says four quarterbacks are going to make it.”
Caleb Williams' Development
30:06 to 33:38
Analysis of Caleb Williams' progress and the challenges he's facing.
“What was that game that they were playing where he's trying to throw in these squares into the netting and he didn't get one of them in?”
Expectations for the Bears
33:38 to 37:16
Evaluating the Chicago Bears' roster and coaching situation affecting Caleb Williams.
“I mean, it seems to be doing what you would expect.”
Upcoming Challenges for Caleb Williams
37:16 to 42:00
Previewing the upcoming season and the challenges Caleb Williams may face.
“And I do wonder, Rich, like Ben Johnson, he's details, details, details, details.”
Exciting Week One NFL Matchup
42:00 to 42:43
Discussion about the upcoming exciting NFL season opener and key players.
“14-win team with the reigning coach of the year.”
Fun Lock Screen Reveal
44:30 to 48:01
Lighthearted discussion on phone lock screens and a humorous lock code guessing game.
“Don't unlock it, but show us what do you have as your...”
Bears' Quarterback Situation
48:01 to 52:08
Deep dive into the Chicago Bears' quarterback situation and analysis of Caleb Williams.
“Level of concern, one, two, hair on fire of the Chicago Bears quarterback offense situation.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00Get your tickets now for The Dog Stars.
0:05Rich Eisen:It's no surprise how fast civilization can disappear. Out there, just kill or be killed. Jacob Alordi. There are people out there. They need our help. Josh Brolin. Shoot first and inquire afterwards. Margaret Qualley. Okay, tough guy. And Guy Pearce. Arm up! The Dog Stars. Directed by Ridley Scott. In theaters August 28th. Get tickets now. Rated R. Under 17, not admitted without parents.
0:58Rich Eisen:Hey, everybody. Can't get enough of the Rich Eisen Show? You're in luck. You can find us everywhere. Watch us weekdays on the Roku Sports Channel from noon to 3 Eastern. Miss the show? We've got a podcast so you can listen anytime. But here's the best part. Our YouTube channel. Subscribe at youtube.com slash Rich Eisen Show and you'll never miss a moment. Now, on with the show. This is the Rich Eisen Show. Is Russell Wilson a Hall of Famer? As he steps on the field to start week one for the New York Giants. The Rich Eisen Show. Russell Wilson, not a Hall of Famer. From the Rich Eisen Show studio in Los Angeles.
1:45Rich Eisen:DJ Jefferson, would you care to chime in on this subject matter as well? No. Earlier on the show, prime video NFL analyst Andrew Whitworth. Former NFL general manager Mike Mayock. Coming up, Bears senior writer for The Athletic, Kevin Fishbane. And now, it's Rich Eisen. Hour number three of the Rich Eisen show is on the air. 844-204-RICH is the number to dial. Mary Kay Cabot and Kevin Fishbane, who cover the Browns and Bears respectively, are going to be back-to-back right in the middle of this third hour of the program to give us updates on what's going on in both of these spots. and great conversations already with Andrew Whitworth, Mike Mayock, also between us.
2:28Rich Eisen:My latest power rankings have hit. Check that out if you haven't already missed it when we re-air on the Roku channel, or there's our YouTube channel, youtube.com slash RichEyesAndShow, or there's the podcast version of this show, all three hours available through our friends at Cumulus. We greatly appreciate everybody checking that out. The phone lines are lit. Let's talk about the Cleveland Browns.
2:52so i don't know if you're aware of this but um there's been a lot of talk of shador sanders
3:01Rich Eisen:and you know obviously i'm um i'm uh in the middle of all of it in terms of you talk about it too much talk about him too much i'm a little biased i've known him since he was a little kid. And one of my favorite people on the planet is his dad. And I can't wait to see what happens Friday night when the Browns take on the Carolina Panthers and obviously tune in to NFL Network for all the latest on all of that. Because the network is as hot as it gets once preseason action hits. and that starts Thursday night, but this is a big Friday night. The fact that we hear, like, why wasn't he drafted? How did he drop all those spots?
3:52Rich Eisen:I mean, that was the story of the draft. I've said it before, I've said it again, I do not recall in all of the 20-plus years I've been doing the draft a story that starts from pick one and goes all the way into day three. Never seen it before, and it happened this time around in Green Bay, and the fact that Shador was taken in the fifth round and part of the reason why the Browns said they took him was a value that they associated with him for being chosen in the fifth round and that value became a reality in part because the Browns were one of the many teams that kept passing on him and took another passer in Dylan Gabriel in front of him and they had already gotten Kenny Pickett in the fold and Joe Flacco was there and how is this all going to work?
4:43Rich Eisen:And then you hear, you know, Shador's behind. Fourth on the depth chart. Albert Breer has said multiple times on this program, including just yesterday, that, you know, he was the one that came in the most green. And some of this stuff just doesn't add up. Not saying his reporting is off. He's the one who was in Cleveland. He's the one talking to everybody. I mean, obviously, he's got way more knowledge about this thing, boots on the ground, than I would. but I mean, you know, Pat Shermer was his OC. It's not like he's not going to get him ready for the pros. And what do you think? Dion was not going to get his son ready for the pros?
5:20Like that he's, but I mean,
5:25Rich Eisen:Albert was saying it's stuff like calling the plays and doing the mechanics and the huddle and all that sort of business, which does happen to a lot of first year quarterbacks as well. But be that as it may, for whatever reason, I mean, And Joe Flacco, as we all know, is top of the flow chart. I do believe he's going to be a week one starter. He does give them the best chance to win. He is a guy who won comeback player of the year with this coach in this system just two years ago and all that business. Kenny Pickett lost some time with an injury, and the same thing with Dylan Gabriel. Whatever the reason, Shador Sanders is going to be the starting quarterback for the Cleveland Browns on Friday night.
6:08Rich Eisen:And it appears he's going to play most of the game. Kevin Stefanski on this announcement, making it official when it popped free, you know, on the Twitterverse and everything else yesterday. On the game itself, you know, we got game Friday night coming up. We'll rest some starters. Some players will play. Obviously holding out some guys due to injury. as you know, and then we'll play Shadour at quarterback. We just signed Snoop Huntley, as you guys saw. We'll get Snoop back up to speed quickly. He's been in a couple different offenses since we last saw him, so he's doing a great job of working at it.
6:48But it's a great opportunity for all of our young players in that football game. But with that, I'll take any questions. We're going to work through it, Tony. I mean, Snoop just got here yesterday, So I just want to see how he's doing with the terminology and all those type of things. Is there any chance that anybody other than those two play? Yeah, at quarterback? At quarterback? No. I mean, what a massive opportunity.
7:15Rich Eisen:Say what you will about preseason. I get it. I get it. But if you had told me coming out of the draft, right, that through the OTAs and everything else, Shador Sanders was going to start the first preseason game and be the guy. Be the guy. I don't care about those other injuries or anything like that sort of thing. And Snoop Huntley, again, just got there. So I don't know when you're going to put him in. Late third, early fourth, just to throw things out there. If you had told me Shador Sanders was going to start and be the guy and not have to look over his shoulder, is Flacco coming in? Is Dylan Gabriel there?
7:56Rich Eisen:Is Kenny Pickett there? what a massive opportunity massive show everyone you can call the place show everyone you can see the protections because there's going to be some grown ass man out there for the Carolina Panthers in front of their home fans who want to show up show out too I don't care about preseason what your thoughts are about it this is it what a massive chance for him I would have signed for that on the spot if I was a Sanders family for Shadour or whatever certainly with him speeding a couple times and putting himself at risk of not having this opportunity. Well, this is huge. I couldn't be happier for him.
8:36Now, proof's going to come out in the pudding.
8:41Rich Eisen:We're going to see it. And let him show that I can hit my back foot and I can read this and I can do that and I can ball out. And I don't want to hear like, oh, he was going against people who are going to be working in the Home Depot in three weeks. Because they're trying to make teams. And Dave Canales is not doing this just to put the Panthers out there to test Shador Sanders. He's testing his own people. This is a competition. This is as high of a competition as you can get for, you know, August 8th. Massive. What an opportunity. Doesn't have to look over his shoulder. No wonder who's coming in.
9:23Rich Eisen:You got this, kid. You got it. I love it. He doesn't have to wonder because they can't come in. I know. That's what I'm saying. Yeah, they're hurt. And you can't put Joe Flacco out there because what if he suffers a serious injury? Well, he's going to be in pajamas. Now you're screwed for week one. He'll be in pajamas, as they say. That's Mariucci's phrase for not dressing someone. I can't imagine that Huntley plays at all if he just got there yesterday. I can't imagine it either. let him go. Let him go. Let him throw it. And I feel for Dylan Gabriel that he's hurt and pick it, or he got hurt and they decide to be behind.
10:00Rich Eisen:And you consider and say, well, those are the three, they don't want to get hurt. So, you know, way to talk about Shador again, Rich, because this indicates that he's got no chance. They're not going to have four quarterbacks on a roster in their final 53. And so they're protecting the three that they really like right now. and they're using Shador as cannon fodder, I don't believe it. And if I'm Shador Sanders and I'm the rest of everybody in his circle, I'm thinking this is it. This is what you wanted. But even if what you said is true, he can at least go out there and show that it's not. That's right.
10:35Rich Eisen:And he deserves to be ahead of the other guys. Hell yeah. And he could actually zoom in front of them. Let's go. Be accurate. Be smart. Your best ability is availability. Availability. And these guys are unavailable. I love it. I couldn't be happier about this development, even though obviously that it's not great for the other ones who aren't in. I'm sure Pickett wants to get out there. I'm sure Gabriel wants to get out there, and I'm sure Flacco's leaving itching about it. This is what Joe had to say about this. Oh, it'll be interesting. I think we'll all be sitting there watching and be excited for football to be going real time, and I think he's probably excited about that too.
11:12I mean, your first time to go in the NFL, I remember mine. I mean, I didn't get to play until the last two minutes of the game, but it's something that he'll remember forever. I mean, you know, most of us have dreamt about this moment, you know, since we were five, six, seven, eight years old. So for him to get a chance to go out there and actually take the field, even though it's preseason, you know, we're all going to be on the sidelines and at home and enjoying it.
11:34Rich Eisen:Okay. Miles Garrett was asked about it too. And if I'm not mistaken, this is the way I, if I was Miles Garrett, this is the way I would show up to the podium. every single time. Shirtless. This is insane if you haven't seen this video yet. All right, rolling. He's funny. He's optimistic, lighthearted, but he works hard. He takes it seriously, his craft, and he's watching what the others are doing and doing it his own way in which only he can. So looking forward to see him in these preseason games and how he manages the offense. But I think he looks good, but all the guys look good right now. Yeah, I'd say that.
12:15Rich Eisen:I can agree. They all look good. I didn't hear a word he said. What did he say? I don't know. Does he have to cross his arms, too? So his biceps just look even bigger? I mean, that's fine enough. And then he crosses his arms. You know, just a... What was he talking about? I have no idea. I don't know. Somebody playing hard and trying... What sport is this? And protein shakes. That's the way I would show up every damn time. Questions anyone? Nope. Good God. I don't need to get his shirt on. If I was him, the only shirt I owned would be a tank and that would let me get into 7-Eleven because you have to have his shirt on.
12:55Rich Eisen:I don't think he's getting too many Slurpees though. He's getting some, maybe water. I think it's all natural. Listen, I'm loving it. There's going to support him. It is on Shador to take the advantage of this opportunity. because it is that.
13:18Rich Eisen:Again, just to put a point on it, say what you will about preseason. I get it. But for these people who are trying to make a team, it means the world. And they are going to compete, man. And Shadour has an opportunity. Again, I told you after he dried himself off jumping in that pool to celebrate finally getting drafted. If I had said on the draft set, he's going to play every snap of preseason week one, I bet you, you know, Daniel Jeremiah, Charles Davis would have said good because he's going to need the reps, and I'm glad that means the Browns are going to give them the opportunity. Now, Joel Klatt might have said something different, but I wouldn't know because he left, as he always does after the night too.
14:09Come on, Joel.
14:12Rich Eisen:no but he would say the same thing these reps are as crucial as they get and and and it's it's awesome i i can't wait to see what he does with it now we come on the air on monday and say boy that wasn't great and he puts himself in a tougher position to make this team but i don't think that's the way he's going to go into this opportunity 844-204-rich number don we come back we'll take your calls. Mary Kay Cabot is in Carolina. She will join us for the latest on what's going on behind the scenes there. And then Kevin Fishbane will join us as well from The Athletic to tell us what's going on with Caleb in Chicago.
14:52Rich Eisen:And your phone calls. That's how we're rolling here in hour number three of the Rich Eisen Show. Don't you dare go anywhere. We've got your phone calls and that much more in a moment.
15:10Need parts fast? O 'Reilly Auto Parts as fast. Need them now? We've got now. No matter what you need, we have thousands of professional parts people doing their part to make sure you have it. We're O 'Reilly Fast. Just one part that makes O 'Reilly stand apart. The professional parts people. O, O, O, O 'Reilly Auto Parts. Parts.
16:07Rich Eisen:NMLS 696891. Fast funds terms apply at SoFi.com slash debt play. Rich Eisen here. Running a small business means every hire matters. A bad hire costs time and money, but the right one helps your business grow. The challenge? Finding that person without sorting through resumes. That's where LinkedIn Hiring Pro comes in. It screens candidates so you can focus on conversations with qualified talent. With Hiring Pro, you can hire with confidence and build the team you need. Join the 2.7 million small businesses using LinkedIn to hire. Get started by posting your job for free at linkedin.com slash eisen.
16:40Rich Eisen:Terms and conditions apply. Back here on the program, everybody. 844-204-RICH is the number to dial on the show. Let's go to Tim in Arizona. What's up, Tim? Tim. Timmy. Timmy. Two different Tims there. Line, the last line, line five, everybody. What's up, Timmy? Timmy. Timmy. Scataboo to you, Rich. Good scataboo day to you, too. Is he okay? I heard he was banged up, right? is apparently okay. You've got to get him all right, the Plinko Chip at the New York Giants. What's going on, Tim? Okay, good. Hey, my statement is, why not Mayock? I had called in and did the win-loss game with Susie for the Colts a couple days prior to Jim passing away, but at that time I did mention to Chris about the importance of that first game against Miami.
17:36That was going to be an important first game anyway. And I mentioned to Chris that they were going to lose that game and that Jim is going to hire Brad Stevens as the new GM. I would have loved that to happen, but obviously that's not going to happen, and rest in peace, Jim. But here's the deal. We still need to play football, and football is still a business. Ballard cannot lose that first game. He needs to be fired when he does.
18:06Rich Eisen:Oh, my God. Here's what's not going to happen, Tim, is the firing of a general manager after the first game of the season. That's just not going to happen now. And the issue is, obviously, you know, and I appreciate the caping for Mike, who I adore. And thanks for the call, Tim. I appreciate it. Call back any time. Hey, Tim. I'll return to what I always say with the Indianapolis Colts when there's a conversation, right? is we just don't know Jim Irsay's daughter, who is taking over as the primary owner of the Colts. We don't know her level of patience, what she's going to do in terms of her involvement.
18:45Rich Eisen:And that's always a wild card when there's an ownership change, even if it's the same family. We just do not know, but that won't happen after week one. We're going to have back-to-backers shortly here. Mary Kay Cabot is going to be joining us, covering Cleveland sports and the Browns. And then Kevin Fishbane, check in with him about what's going on. All we hear is that Caleb Williams is drinking from a fire hose. Is he handling everything? Bad practice video getting put out there. I mean, it wasn't good. I know. They set up these nets, right? The nets with the three spots. Right. And he missed them all.
19:24And he went over and then walked off and he looked very pouty. Very pouty in the bad body language.
19:29Rich Eisen:So what? I don't know. You can't say so what. I mean, you can say so what because it's just like so what. He's the quarterback. He's the leader of the team. He can't be out there pouting. Well, I mean, he was also maybe in a competition. He just got upset about it. You get upset about things, don't you? I do. I'm not the quarterback of this team. Well, I understand what you're saying on that front. Yeah. The quarterback of the Cleveland Browns on Friday night is going to be Shador Sanders. joining us right now from the joint practice of the Browns and the Carolina Panthers is none other than Mary Kay Cabot, Cleveland Browns insider.
20:06Rich Eisen:Good to see you again, Mary Kay. How are you? I'm doing great. How are you doing, Rich? Can you walk me through the decision here? What do you got for me? Well, it wasn't all that difficult considering they don't want to play 40-year-old Joe Flacco, even though he's the only quarterback in this competition who has not missed a rep, a snap, a drill because of some soreness or injury, ironically enough. And then you've got Kenny Pickett and Dylan Gabriel both dealing with hamstring injuries. So it was almost an attrition thing. And then also Tyler Huntley joined the team just yesterday. So Shador it is, and he will be starting against the Panthers tomorrow.
20:47He's not going to have, I mean, Friday night. He's not going to have a lot of first teamers with him in this battle because they're just going to hold a lot of those guys out. But for the most part, he will, you know, he's just going to have to go out there and play some against the first team Panthers defense.
21:06Rich Eisen:Well, it sounds like it's going to play a lot, right? I mean, and when you say first team Panthers defense, that's the sum. It just depends on how long they're going to keep their starters in because if stoop huntley just got there um this looks like it's going to be shador's show which is a massive opportunity i i think this is a massive opportunity for him and the question is is his readiness because the conversation i hear about shador sitting at this desk um is that um he was the one most behind of anybody coming into this competition and now he can go out and prove either A, that wasn't true, or B, it doesn't matter.
21:43Mary? Well, I think the thing about Shador is that he's a gamer, and I think he's going to go out in this game, and I think he's going to perform well like he did in college. I think that when the lights come on, he's at his best. He even basically said that when we talked to him the other day, that have you watched me in college, and do you know what you're dealing with here? So he's pretty confident going into this game. Now, once again, the thing to keep in mind is the fact that he will be working with the second teamers and some third teamers against the Panthers defense first teamers, at least for the first eight to 12 plays or so.
Read the full transcript
22:22I think that's what Dave Canales is going to do with his starters. So it's going to be really interesting to see how that goes for the first couple of series. But the thing that Shador has done very well in practice, he's shown off his accuracy. see. That's his superpower in this competition. He led the FBS with a 74 percent completion percentage last year, and that has shown up in camp. The thing that he's had to work on and catch up on is all the pre-snap stuff that you have to do before you actually get to make that pass.
22:51Rich Eisen:Okay, so walk me through that. What's that learning curve been, and why do you think it's the case, Mary Kay? Well, I really just think that, you know, just in terms of calling the plays in the huddle and doing some of those things, he didn't necessarily have to do the graduate level stuff in college that some other quarterbacks do, depending on what kind of system that they're coming out of. So his transition to the pro game and some of those things was just a little bit steeper, that learning curve. But they've been bringing him up to speed. They've been spending extra time with him on those kinds of things.
23:29It takes a long time to figure out a terminology and to get that play call called in the huddle as fast as you possibly can and to ID and to slide the protections and call the motions and all those kinds of things. So he's really coming up the learning curve very, very well. But those are the kinds of things that he had to catch up on a little bit.
23:48Rich Eisen:Where do things stand with Pickett and Dylan Gabriel right now, Mary Kay Cavett? Right now, they are both dealing with hamstring injuries. It's so ironic. I've been asking Joe about this. How is the 40-year-old guy the only one that hasn't missed a snap? But Kenny and Dylan have those hamstrings, and they're not going to play in this game. They're not doing 11-on-11s right now. They didn't do them today in practice. They're limited to 7-on-7s. They're taking it easy with these guys. And this team is heading off to Philadelphia next week for two practices there and a game there. I don't see how you play Kenny Pickett in that game either if you're trying to get him to the season healthy.
24:26So in my mind, it's starting to look like Joe's job. We'll have to see how it plays out.
24:31Rich Eisen:Yeah, so the idea of bringing four into 53 is not going to happen, right, Mary Kay? No, I think it is going to happen. You do? Yes, I do. I think all four of these quarterbacks are going to make the team. I really do think that it's going to be a matter of Joe and Kenny getting things started off for this football team. And then I know that the Browns would love to see, if they can, Dylan Gabriel and Shador Sanders in some live action at some point this season. Because they have decisions to make next year. They've got two first-round picks. It's a rich QB class. And they're going to want to see what they have in Dylan and Shador.
25:09So at some point, I think they'll turn it over to the rookies.
25:12Rich Eisen:Mary Kay Cabot, a few minutes left here with the Cleveland Browns insider, covered the Browns for over 30 years here on the Rich Eisen Show. What else is happening with the Browns that we're clearly not talking about because we're so focused on who the quarterback is? Well, I'm going to stick with the quarterback room for another minute. So they brought in, they did, they brought in Tyler Huntley just yesterday. So he suited up, he practiced today, and he will relieve, he will relieve Shador in this game. But then I looked out there today, and for the first time, I saw Deshaun Watson out there on the practice field, just not in practice clothes because he's on PUP and he is still recovering from his retorn Achilles.
25:51But it was just weird to look out there and see six quarterbacks. You know the old saying, if you have six quarterbacks, you can have one. But Deshaun Watson was out there. And that just is an interesting twist to this whole thing, because I know he's determined to play and he's determined to join the mix at some point. I don't know if the Browns will ever let him do that. He's on PUP right now. I don't think he'll be even healthy until October or November. But to look out there and to see five quarterbacks in uniform practicing and then also Deshaun Watson, it was kind of a bizarre sight. I'm sure.
26:29Rich Eisen:I'm sure. Let's just linger there for a second. And I guess, you know, the future at the quarterback position in Cleveland is exactly why somebody brought up Arch Manning to Jimmy and Dee Haslam the other day. You know what I mean? Like it's, you know, as if who's starting week one and how do you get through the 18 game crucible of 2025 is not enough. You're looking over the steering wheel. Well, yeah. In addition to watching all of these quarterbacks this year, I really have to do something I usually don't have a lot of time to do, and that is hunker down and watch some college football on Saturdays too.
27:02So that's going to be a big point of emphasis, of course, for the Browns this season to see what Arch Manning is up to. Although when we asked Jimmy Haslam about him last week, he said he thinks Arch is going to stay in school for at least two years. And Jimmy would probably know because he knows the Manning family. very, very well. So that's his prediction that he might not be available to them, but it's not going to stop them from going to the games, from scouting him and from being very ready to pull the trigger if they need to on Arch. So obviously he's one that they'll watch. They'll watch all of the others.
27:39And, you know, they're really going to have an eye on that 26 QB class.
27:43Rich Eisen:How's my guy Mason Graham looking? He's looking good so far. It's fun to see him now in pads where he can really show his explosiveness. And the thing about Mason is that he's learning to do something that he didn't really do all that much at Michigan. And that is just see quarterback, get quarterback, just go for it. And, you know, just take the, you know, the leash off and go. So it's got to be pretty fun for him to be able to do that. The assignment is pretty clear. I thought you meant losing in Ohio because he didn't do that in college either. Mary Kay. I thought that's what you're referring to.
28:17Of course you would point that out.
28:19Rich Eisen:Sorry, I didn't mean to drag you to my level. Mary Kay, I didn't mean to do that. I mean, but thank you for the time. I greatly appreciate it. Let's do this again real soon. Sounds good. Thanks a lot. Yeah, there's Mary Kay Cabot with the latest in Cleveland, Bronx. There I am dragging other guests down to my level. Didn't do that in college either. Let me check that out. Oh, can confirm. Wow.
28:43Rich Eisen:What's wrong with you, man? O-H-N-O Oh, no. All right. So I want to know the latest there. You got the latest. Deshaun Watson's out there saying, hey, don't forget about me. Yeah, I'm still here. Don't you forget about me, right? Go Breakfast Club. Don't get me started. Don't sing. Listen. Listen. I don't blame him, man. He's got to be just like itching. To get out there. 100%. But he's not playing this year. He's not playing. It's going to be Flacco's gig. How about that? She says four quarterbacks are going to make it. That's an interesting way to put 53 men together. That is, you know, I would advise against that, but I'm not running the team.
29:26Okay, you're not.
29:26Rich Eisen:You might call yourself a linebacker or something that you might need. All right, another story I needed some insight on is the fact that right now, Caleb Williams is in the social media barrel. if this guy is not tying his shoelaces right everyone's saying oh he's a bust and Ben Johnson's not going to fix him and then you know if he throws an interception in practice or he's you know I don't know what that quarterback competition was where you got to throw it through these squares in a netting and he didn't nail any of them I mean I watched Hard Knocks last night Josh Allen was perfect he hit all of them you know what I mean Kevin Fishbane of the Athletic here on the Rich Eisen Show once again.
30:07Rich Eisen:Good to see you again. Kevin, how are you, sir? I'm good, Rich. How are you doing? What was that game that they were playing where he's trying to throw in these squares into the netting and he didn't get one of them in? What was that, Kevin? I mean, it could just be them trying to hit the target. It could then be trying to hit the pole. You know, the poles that are around it. There's different things you can do with that. I mean, you could say that you got to love Caleb's competitive fire and the way that he reacted to losing that battle. you can take it whenever it's a Rorschach test. I know, right?
30:39I mean, however you view Caleb.
30:42Rich Eisen:Exactly. That's how you view it. Right. When you say Rorschach test, you mean the people who are viewing it, not how Caleb should be viewed. So give me the real, what is happening in the development of Caleb Williams year two, where the head coach has been brought in to take him to the heights that we saw Jaden Daniels taken to last year, to be blunt, Kevin. Yeah. I mean, it's been bumpy. Like, you know, Ben Johnson told us on Sunday after the practice of Soldier Field that it was sloppy and that there were a bunch of delayed games. And, you know, we don't know exactly how much of that is on Caleb, but the quarterback's got to get the ball off.
31:19He's got to get that snap. And then they come back yesterday and they had this super competitive and physical practice. And Caleb was maybe as sharp as he's been all summer. And I wonder if just that competitive fire, not to mention just being a couple weeks into this, just got him in a rhythm where we saw some nice plays. Still, you know, a couple false starts. Again, not on him necessarily. But, you know, I think you look back at Jared Goff and it wasn't like Jared Goff was this instant sensation with Ben Johnson when Ben Johnson eventually took over play calling there in Detroit. It's just this give and take, Rich.
31:54And you know this about quarterbacks around the league, like the patience level. like how patient should everybody be with Caleb Williams because like I'm sitting here like as an observer I'm trying to be a little patient understand it's a new offense it's a new scheme but there's the other part of me and I can see it and I can get how Chicago fans can see this like they're like we've been here before you guys said this with Mitch Trubisky you guys said this with Justin Fields to give it time and all that stuff and then look what happened so there's this nervousness in town this tense feeling that after last year and seeing that camp maybe hasn't been as smooth as people maybe on the outside might have hoped.
32:32Everyone's worried, and so if he doesn't throw the ball to the net, suddenly it's panic time. But I'd like to see his play out, and I think, Rich, too, it's important to put some trust in Ben Johnson, that Ben Johnson has been brought here to put Caleb in the best position to succeed, and Ben Johnson has proven that he can do that, and now we see if he can do it with someone as gifted as Caleb Williams.
32:53Rich Eisen:Yeah, and the Seth Wickersham book that created, I'm sure, quite the media storm in your world as well, Kevin, is about to hit stores, and that might renew conversations about last year. And I'm referring to Caleb Williams and his dad having issues about being drafted by Chicago that they eventually overcame, and then the issues that happened in his first year only seem to confirm their belief that this might not be the best spot for him. Ben Johnson, best you can tell, has at least shown the way to the film room, right? I mean, not to be flippant, but that's changed already, I imagine. Right, Kevin?
33:34Yeah, yeah. I think it's just a different tone. It's a different situation here. You know, I got a chance to talk to Caleb Williams early on in camp, and he kind of walked me through a little bit of his day-to-day and how early he was showing up to the building, got his notebook out, the things that he's doing. I mean, it seems to be doing what you would expect. And that didn't happen last year?
33:56Rich Eisen:That was not what he was doing last year? It depends who you talk to, Rich, because I don't know. I never got the sense that this was – this is the problem in this city with this position that I think if you talk to people, maybe like Seth Wickersham did, that maybe the coaches weren't doing enough. And I think if you maybe talk to some people on that coaching staff, they might say, well, there's only so much we're supposed to do. You're a professional quarterback. You've got to figure it out, too. Either way, this guy, Ben Johnson, is the right guy to get all of this moving in the right direction.
34:33So I don't know exactly what that film study was like last year. But I think that, again, there's going to be different stories based on who you talk to. Either way, we can all agree last year was a disaster. It was exactly what Carl Williams and Caleb Williams were worried about, as you said. And now you get to kind of start over. And I do think that quarterback room too, Rich, having Case Keenum in there, who's been in this league for a long time, and having Tyson Bajant in there, who is, you know, everybody loves the guy here as he battles Case Keenum for that backup quarterback job. I think it's a good composition in that room to kind of help Caleb Williams and get him where he needs to be.
35:11Rich Eisen:Well, I mean, and the reason why I keep returning to the past, Kevin, is really that's the only way that we can try and figure out the future and to see how that's a prologue in any way. Right. Because right now we're just seeing cut ups on on on our phones where Caleb appears to be struggling more often than not, whether that's fair or not. It probably isn't. But the idea is, is this coach the right guy to do it? Is this setup the right setup to do it? Is this roster as ready as we thought it was last year and has been improved on the line since then? And those are the only questions we have until we see the first Monday night game of the season in Soldier Field against, by the way, the Vikings, who won 14 games last year, and a quarterback who was chosen nine picks later by the Minnesota Vikings getting his first shot.
36:08Rich Eisen:And if he comes out looking more polished, despite having, you know, obviously Justin Jefferson and other weapons around him, that's going to be, I think, front and center for the Tuesday after week two for you, Kevin, right? That's it. I was going to say, Rich, you're going to have to do overreaction Tuesday for that one. Ladies and gentlemen, Kevin Fish being talking our language. Not to step on anyone's toes in your studio there. I appreciate that. Because you're right. I mean, that matchup, if J.J. McCarthy has a great game, and if Caleb Williams doesn't have a great game, I can't even imagine what the reaction is going to be in this city, in Minnesota, across the NFL.
36:46But when you bring up the Ben Johnson element of it, and I'm saying this as someone who's on their fifth head coach as a beat reporter. And shoot, you just brought me on after Mary Kay. I don't even want to. I can't compete with her. She's holding your beer, Kevin. That's true. That's true. I don't want to compete with what she's had to deal with there. But if Ben Johnson's not the right coach, it's like you kind of sit there and be like, well, who could be? I mean, this guy is everything that this team has wanted, everything that multiple teams have wanted. And I do wonder, Rich, like Ben Johnson, he's details, details, details, details.
37:25And how does that work with Caleb Williams, who does some amazing things off script? But the thing about Caleb Williams is he does want to be in the pocket. He wants to sit there in the pocket and get the snap and go and make his reads, go through his progressions. And last year he was out of the pocket a lot because of the offensive line in front of him and a lot because he would maybe exit too early. So I just think that you always hear coaches say, I am going to tailor this game plan to my players. I'm not going to make them just fit what I want to do. And look, you just hope that Ben Johnson seems like the guy who's going to do that, who understands that, who's going to help put him in his position.
38:01He's got this offensive line now with Joe Tooney and Drew Dahlman and Jonah Jackson in front of him in the interior. You have Colson Loveland, who, by the way, you talk about guys who have looked pretty good at camp, Rich, and I don't know if you're familiar with this Colson Loveland. Yes, sir. Went to a decent, decent university I'm familiar with. He's looked good. And you can see why the Bears would have want him in this offense because of the target he's going to give to Caleb Williams. And he's smooth in and out of his routes, and he catches everything thrown his way. So there's a lot to like about this.
38:32But I go back to the top, Rich. It's that level of patience. And is it fair to look at this as like, OK, you're starting over Caleb Williams. I know it's your second year. But it's the NFL. It's just so hard to be patient with these guys now. And you look at the roster around Caleb Williams, and you look at what he did in college. You want him to just take off with Ben Johnson. And it's going to be a very interesting season to see what that relationship is like. Because as I said, training camp has not been super smooth, but maybe it shouldn't be. Because this is a brand new, very detailed Arlington scheme that he's got to figure out the same way Jared Goff did.
39:07Rich Eisen:So when do we see him? Do we see him in preseason at all? Or the first time we see Caleb in this is Monday Night Football, week one? What do you think? I think the joint – I originally thought, Rich, that the joint practices would be, you know, Ben Johnson's got two of them lined up. You've got Miami coming out Friday, Buffalo a week from Friday. And it certainly seems like those joint practices are going to be so intense that they might not need to see in the preseason game. I think he should get out there for a couple of series. I mentioned the delay games that we've seen in camp, the fall starts we've seen.
39:36I just think they need to get the operation figured out in a game setting. And they're going to do their best to simulate that in joint practices. But I think it's fair to try to do that at Soldier Field a couple times as well. So I don't think we'll see him a ton because it just doesn't – It seems like Ben Johnson puts a lot in these joint practices, but I think you've got to get him out there just for a couple series in those games.
39:58Rich Eisen:All right, Kevin, thanks for the information and the idea. Chris Brockman, Overreaction Tuesday. We'll set that up. Well, of course, we do Monday on a Tuesday anyway during the radio. Yeah, I mean, I guess that would be September 9th. Write it down. Thank you for the idea, Kevin. We'll write that down, and we'll chat again real soon. All right, take care. By the way, I look forward to appearing on your pod. I'll do that later in the month. I know that we've been going back and forth. I look forward to returning the favor. Appreciate that, Rich. You got it. That's Kevin Fishbane, everybody. He's been with the Athletics since 2017.
40:30Rich Eisen:He's been there, done that, seen five. Five head coaches. I've even forgotten who they would be. I mean, obviously, Ben Johnson, E. Reflews. Nagy. Nagy. Who's prior to Nagy? With John Fox, right? Foxy? Are you going back to Foxy? My gosh. Hold on, I'm looking this up now. I mean, Bears fans are probably screaming at their radio or televisions right now. What'd you say? I said Mike Ditka. Okay. Yeah, Fox and Trestman. You're still trying to jump your battery over there. Trestman was 2014. What'd you say? Trestman was 2014. Rude. Well, he's been in the Athletics since 2017, but if he goes back to 2014.
41:12Rich Eisen:Yeah, well, 2017 was Fox's last year. So it's Trestman, Fox, Nagy. No, it would have just been, for Fishbane, it would have been Fox, Nagy, Eberflus, and then. Well, you said it's five, so he goes back to Trestman. Thomas Brown interim. Oh, okay, there you go. I got it. Yeah. Kendall Williams had a new situation in the pros where apparently they're like, you're a pro, you need to figure this out yourself. He needed some help. He wasn't getting it. And the offensive coordinator gets bounced. Then the coach gets bounced. Then the new offensive coordinator who had never been an OC before and a play caller before is apparently your new OC.
41:47Rich Eisen:And then now he's the new HD in interim. That ain't working. So now here comes Ben Johnson. And we will see. Oh my goodness gracious. All of the storylines, right? All of them. That week one game is so good. The Monday night, all right? To finish. So good. Vikings at Bears. Division game. 14-win team with the reigning coach of the year. The quarterback whisperer with a kid who has yet to do it. had the same draft and the same draft class as Caleb Williams. It's so good. And now Caleb has got a fresh start. J.J. McCarthy, fresh start. Here we go together. Ben Johnson, KOC. Two play callers who are apparently, not apparently, who industry-wide considered one of the best.
42:32Rich Eisen:What a first game for ESPN on Monday Night Football. ABC and everybody else.
42:43Rich Eisen:Rich Eisen here for Gusto. On my shows, we talk a lot about what happens in the spotlight, the games, the highlights, and the moments that get replayed and debated. But in any successful operation, what happens behind the scenes matters just as much. Small businesses are no different. Payroll, hiring, onboarding, benefits, and all the details that keep things moving may not be the most visible part of the job, but they still have to be handled right. That's where Gusto comes in. Gusto is online payroll and benefits software built for small businesses. It's all-in-one, remote-friendly, and incredibly easy to use, so you can pay, hire, onboard, and support your team from anywhere.
43:20Rich Eisen:Automatic payroll tax filing, simple direct deposits, health benefits, commuter benefits, workers' comp, 401k, you name it. Gusto makes it simple and has options for nearly every budget. And it's all built to save you time with built-in automated tools for offer letters, onboarding docs, direct deposit, and more. Plus, you get unlimited payroll runs for one monthly price. No hidden fees, no surprises. Try Gusto today at gusto.com slash rich and get three months free when you run your first payroll. That's three months of free payroll at gusto.com slash rich. One more time, gusto.com slash rich.
43:57Rich Eisen:Rich Eisen here. We talk a lot about battles in sports, teams battling through adversity, athletes fighting for every yard. The toughest warriors I've ever seen, though, aren't on the field. Their kids fighting cancer, their families standing beside them. doctors, nurses, caregivers. That's why I'm proud to support Hyundai Hope on Wheels. For over 28 years, they've helped fund pediatric cancer research, raising more than$303 million and supporting over 40 ,000 children. Learn more and donate at HyundaiUSA.com backslash Hope on Wheels.
44:30Grab your phone and do me a favor. Don't unlock it, but show us what do you have as your... already. What's your lock screen on your phone? What's is it a picture? What's it of? Yeah, hold up. Let me show you. It's a biggie. Oh, we got biggie. We got biggie. Good one. And then question. I'm assuming do you normally do your face ID? I do not. You don't do face ID? Oh, you know, this man's wasting hours of his life every day. Is it a six digit code or four digits? The unlock this four. Four. That's not that secure. All right. You know what? Just you know what? I was going to the ATM, but I I like the challenge right here.
45:08Okay. Before I come over there, I see you got some, rub the fingerprints off. Haters always tell me later, fingerprints. Gotta be fingerprints. I'm coming over for a second. Oh my goodness. Can I get in the shot? I might swing. What is happening? Oh, careful. All right, all right. All right. Can we see Biggie? Can we get a close up shot?
45:29Rich Eisen:Let's see if we get Biggie. Is it jib? Somebody's getting tight. Tight. There we go. I got it. I go here, it's locked. He wasn't lying. Hold out your finger. Think of the first number. Of my code? Yeah, not my code unless you're a mentalist. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 0. OK. I thought of it. No, I know you did. I'm trying to figure it out. Think of the next number. Does it get bigger? Does it get smaller? Same. Does it move over? Right, left. Oh, look at you not moving. Look at you not flinching. Think of the second number, third number. OK, hold up. Hold up. Hold up. This is just like in the movies when you see somebody trying to crack a lock, pick a lock.
46:04But instead of hearing the click, I can feel it this body. Think of the last number. TJ, what do I know about TJ? Open your eyes. They weren't closed. TJ. Are they supposed to be closed? TJ, no, you're good, you're good. You gave it away with your eyes. I can see in your soul. I think he likes to get in and out of the phone quick. You have a four-digit code. You've got to type this in a million times a day, no Face ID. You're doing a code that you can do quick. Do you care if they find out your code? I'll change it if they... All right. If you don't mind, I'm going to show them. The first number's a one.
46:32Can we get tighter just so we can see this?
46:34Rich Eisen:Let's get in there. There it is. The next number is a six. Kidding. Look at his face, how he got. Look at that. You went back to the one. Can you see me close? That's the two. That's the two. We're inside. Oh!
46:51Rich Eisen:Do not pack up! Do not pack up!
46:59Rich Eisen:He's gone! come on do not pack up come on you're not gonna see him again today folks sorry he's out he's out tj jefferson running a wheel route off the rich eisen show super bowl set in new orleans louisiana is one of my favorite moments and a perfect opportunity to tell everybody you must tune in to Thursday's Rich Eisen show in hour number three when our in-studio guest here in Los Angeles, California, is O's the Mentalist. Returning to this program, TJ Jefferson's favorite warlock is back in his world tomorrow. We do not know what he's got planned. We don't know the caper. We don't know the Lufthansa heist he's got working on.
47:51Rich Eisen:No, you're not. You don't know I could catch him. No, and I know your loaner car is going to have a new battery. The other car is going to break down. Oh, my arm. You never know. Oh, wait a minute. Oh, my God. Mule's car needs a new carburetor. It doesn't. Let's go. I can't wait. Oh, God, that's going to be amazing. Great show. Great show. Level of concern, one, two, hair on fire of the Chicago Bears quarterback offense situation. Ben Johnson and Caleb Williams, 1 to 10. Hair on fire is 10. Christopher? None of us have hair. Six. TJ Jefferson? Five. I'm lower than that. I'm lower than that. Zero evidence to be lower than that.
48:44Rich Eisen:I have zero evidence to be lower than that. Ben Johnson alone is going to be an upgrade for the kid. Alone. No doubt. Okay. No doubt. Alone. and say what you will about Caleb Williams, and a lot of people do, he's given every indication he wants to be coached hard. And don't forget, last year, the crucible of last year, the dreadfulness of last year, everything that was going on behind the scenes where everything that had happened had given credence to all the concerns he and his dad had prior to the draft. All of that was happening. Getting his ass beat. And he said nothing. there wasn't a single flash at a press conference where it was, woe is me, feel bad for me.
49:36Rich Eisen:Never once did he give you an indication of you have no idea what's going on around here. And me, my dad and I, we knew it. We didn't want to be here. But we did. And look at it now. I'm right. Everybody else is around here wrong. How many people in this world today not to get writ large but i will it seems part and parcel of our world it's never somebody's fault it's always someone else's fault it's always look what's being done to me it is a culture of grievance that we live in right now for so many people from leadership on down a lack of accountability of my bad or yes this was done improperly i will admit this is not the way it should be done i will admit it's not the way that we do things but i'll my bad and this kid one million percent had every right to say it's not my fault folks and he never once did it so here comes a guy who's going to coach him hard and give him a whole ton of stuff and i will just ignore a lot of these videos will it happen during the season Yes, but does that mean he's toast?
50:50Rich Eisen:He's finished? I'm confident that this guy, Ben Johnson, is the right guy. And the Bears are getting it right. And they got talented people. The line has improved, right? And the light is going to be on a little bit better for Caleb Williams. You just got to get him playing faster. Got to get him playing more confident. And let's see the off-script stuff. Like, that's what got him a Heisman in many ways. True. And Ben can scheme it up, and let's hope he coaches it up. And the kid's taking the coaching. He took the beating last year. Beating. And a lot of the beating that he took was something that he saw coming.
51:41Rich Eisen:And he never once said, I saw it coming, and wore it on his sleeve. and you also didn't do that there either was justin fields
51:55Rich Eisen:so i'll read into it with with caleb williams that this is going to work out i'll give it a number of three two and a half to three a solid rating oh we'll chat it a second to wrap it up on Roku. You want to impress them on a first date, but also play it cool. So what do you do? I'm Rufy Thorpe, and I wrote and read a real love story about a hinge couple that navigated exactly that. Listen to the free audiobook now.
From the publisher
Rich weighs in the Browns announcing Shedeur Sanders will be the starter in Cleveland’s first preseason game.
The Cleveland Plain Dealer’s Mary Kay Cabot and Rich break down the Browns’ QB competition that will see rookie Shedeur Sanders start for the team in their first pre-season game this week.
The Athletic’s Kevin Fishbain and Rich discuss Caleb Williams’ growing pains learning the Bears’ new offense, the pressure on new Chicago head coach Ben Johnson to get Williams coached up and turn around the team’s fortunes, and more.
Rich and the guys reveal their level of concern that Caleb Williams and Ben Jonson can lead the Bears to the NFL promised land.
Please check out other RES productions:
Overreaction Monday: http://apple.co/overreactionmonday
What the Football with Suzy Shuster and Amy Trask: http://apple.co/whatthefootball
The Jim Jackson Show: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-jim-jackson-show/id1770609432
No-Contest Wrestling with O'Shea Jackson Jr. and TJ Jefferson: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/no-contest-wrestling/id1771450708
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
