In short
Week 16 NFL takeaways—who “won” the weekend, the craziest game moments, and what playoff/division outcomes are still unsettled.
Guests
Billy Gill (Ringer NFL show guest; NFL analyst/commentator). Host: Shiel Kapadia.
Key claims
Caleb Williams “won the week” for the Bears via late comebacks, including an onside kick recovery and a 45-yard walk-off TD. Trevor Lawrence and the Jaguars “win” the narrative as an underappreciated team, with Lawrence’s best game (possibly) and six straight wins. Liam Cohen is highlighted as a “fun new character,” and Jacksonville’s “small market” chip is treated as bulletin-board fuel.
Notable examples
Packers-Heaters/onside chaos; Jordan Love concussion; DK Metcalf pulling a fan; Lions-Steelers final chaos with Amon-Ra St. Brown lateral to Jared Goff, multiple negating pass-interference calls, and a ref mic announcement; Kenneth Gainwell Hail Mary TD; Chris Boswell missed FG; AFC/NFC one-seed and division probabilities still remain (e.g., Bills ~20%, Ravens ~10%, Texans ~20%, Chargers ~24%).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOBiggest Winners of Week 16
0:00 to 0:52
Discussion on who won Week 16 in the NFL, focusing on Caleb Williams.
“For adults with Crohn's disease or ulcerative colitis symptoms, every choice matters.”
Biggest Winners of Week 16
2:53 to 6:00
Discussion on who won Week 16 in the NFL, focusing on Caleb Williams.
“There are so many options as to who won the week.”
Trevor Lawrence and Jaguars' Success
6:00 to 11:09
Exploration of Trevor Lawrence's performance and the Jaguars' winning streak.
“It felt like it was, I don't know exactly who it was.”
Liam Cohen and Small Market Debate
11:09 to 14:02
Discussion on Liam Cohen's comments and the small market angle in the NFL.
“Are you following the whole, did you follow the Liam Cohen, Sean Payton back and forth here, or do I need to fill you in on this?”
Ingratiating to Fans: Catchphrases and Team Spirit
14:02 to 15:55
Discussing how players connect with fans through catchphrases and team spirit.
“kind of like ingratiate themselves to the fans and what are like kind of sayings that the fans do.”
Liam Cohen: A Fun New Character
17:11 to 17:44
Highlighting Liam Cohen's impact on the Jaguars' success this season.
“Give great jeans this holiday season with American Eagle.”
Analyzing the Craziest Moments of Week 16
17:44 to 23:00
Delving into the most outrageous events from a wild Week 16 in the NFL.
“All right, we're back on the Ringer NFL show.”
DK Metcalf's Incident: A Game Highlight
23:00 to 27:35
Exploring the implications of DK Metcalf's altercation with a fan during a game.
“Is he on like the refs group chats tonight?”
Fantasy Football Implications from Week 16
27:35 to 28:00
Sharing personal experiences and the impact of Week 16 on fantasy football outcomes.
“just between me and you and our fans that are listening.”
Fantasy Football Recap
28:00 to 29:22
Discussion of personal fantasy football experiences and outcomes from Week 16.
“However, because he crushed it for me in the game, I was playing against Jared Goff.”
Show all 13 chapters
NFC Playoff Picture
29:22 to 33:26
Exploration of the current state of NFC playoff teams and implications for Week 18.
“There is a surprisingly a lot of stuff that is still to be settled here.”
Bryce Young's Journey
33:26 to 35:12
Analyzing Bryce Young's development and performance in crucial moments.
“they're squeezing it all out there, I feel.”
Bryce Young's Journey
36:49 to 37:48
Analyzing Bryce Young's development and performance in crucial moments.
“This summer, it's time to put that angry ball of fire on mute.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00For adults with Crohn's disease or ulcerative colitis symptoms, every choice matters. Tremphaya offers self-injection or intravenous infusion from the start. Tremphaya is administered as injections under the skin or infusions through a vein every four weeks, followed by injections under the skin every four or eight weeks. If your doctor decides that you can self-inject Tremphaya, proper training is required. Tremphaya is a prescription medicine used to treat adults with moderately to severely active Crohn's disease and adults with moderately to severely active ulcerative colitis. Serious allergic reactions, increased risk of infections or lower ability to fight them, and liver problems may occur.
0:40Before treatment, get checked for infections and tuberculosis. Tell your doctor if you have an infection, flu-like symptoms, or need a vaccine. Explore what's possible. Ask your doctor about Tremphaya today. Call 1-800-526-7736 to learn more or visit trimfireradio.com. This episode is brought to you by Disney+. The Disney +, Hulu, HBO Max bundle. The best in entertainment, all in one bundle. This month, stream Pixar's blockbuster family hit Hoppers on Disney+. The hit horror comedies Send Help on Hulu. I like that movie. Season three of the HBO original series House of the Dragon on HBO Max. All you have to do is get the Disney Plus Hulu HBO Max Bundle today.
1:25All of these and more streaming soon available with Disney Plus Hulu. Max Bundle plans starting at$19.99 a month. Terms apply. Visit DisneyPlusHuluMaxBundle.com for details.
1:43Welcome to the Ringer NFL show. I'm your host, Shiel Kapadia. A wild week 16, maybe the wildest week of the season, all things considered. We're going to talk about it. Who were the biggest winners? What's the craziest thing that happened? And what is still left to be settled? Actually, a lot. We'll get to that as well. My guest is the Ringers, Billy Gill. Always fun talking to Billy. Never know where the conversation is going to go. Let's take a break. We come back with Billy. This episode of the Ringer NFL show is presented by State Farm. Having insurance isn't the same as having State Farm.
2:19It's like expecting the leadership of a team captain on the football field, but getting a sea captain? Sure, they're both captains, but who is going to run your offense? You wouldn't settle for just anything for your team, so don't settle for just any insurance. When it comes to getting the help you need, State Farm is the real deal. Like a good neighbor, State Farm is there.
2:53we are back here on the ringer nfl show shield kapadia with billy gill and what was maybe the wildest week of this season we don't even know how we're going to try to cover as much as we can here billy but let's start here who won the week because this was a week where seasons were kind of decided, defined, narratives shifted or flipped or whatever. Who won week 16, in your opinion?
3:18Sheil Kapadia:Who won the week, man? There are so many options as to who won the week. We could do the cop out of we won the week as NFL fans, right? But I'm not going to do that. I'm not going to say that we won the week. You know who won the week? Caleb Williams won the week. We were joking about this before this show. it was tossed out that the Caleb Williams win the week. And it was like, Oh, we're just kidding. But no, I, I think Caleb Williams won the week. It was an early win this week. It was a, it was a Saturday win and Sunday was full of wins as well. But I feel good for Caleb Williams. I mean, he was the number one pick a couple of years ago.
3:55Sheil Kapadia:There was some doubt as to whether or not Caleb Williams could lead the team. His head coach gets fired and it wasn't looking great. It wasn't looking great through the, through the first, you know, basically three and a half quarters of that game. But then Caleb Williams, who's kind of turned it on the past couple of weeks, he led his team to victory. He had, you know, things had to fall right. There had to be the onside kick that was recovered, but he had two incredible passes where only his receivers could catch him, then tie the game. Then he goes to overtime after they get the onside kick, which was kind of crazy that they recovered.
4:29Sheil Kapadia:I think that they said that coming into it, only 8 % of onside kicks were recovered, which even that seems a little bit high. this season because it doesn't feel like 8 out of 100 are getting recovered. Nonetheless, they get the onside kick and then you have an insane 45-yard touchdown pass. It's a walk-off that Moore's just laying in the end zone, basking in the glory. Did you see that the heaters on the sidelines weren't working for the Packers during the game? Yeah, kind of crazy. I don't know why they want to get out of Soldier Field. I kind of like Soldier Field. I love Soldier Field. I don't know if you've ever, yeah, it's right downtown.
5:08You stay in Chicago. I used to walk to the games when I would cover games there. I'm with you. That atmosphere looked incredible. I think Caleb Williams is a great choice. I mean, that was an incredible game Saturday night. The atmosphere and just what was at stake. To your point, it looked like think about if that goes a different way. The alternate universe where we're going oh my gosh, the Bears just got cooked by Malik Willis on Saturday night in the most anticipated game in Chicago in however many years. And now their playoff lives are on the line. And instead, what you just described happens.
5:42And then the Lions lose on Sunday. Now they've actually clinched a playoff berth and they're probably going to win the NFC North. So I think Caleb Williams, is it Caleb Williams? Is it Bears fans? Is it Ben Johnson? I don't know who is the right person to credit, but someone, maybe all of that Chicago universe, I think is the biggest winner of the weekend.
6:02Sheil Kapadia:It felt like it was, I don't know exactly who it was. So when in doubt, kind of like the MVP of the league, you just give it to the quarterback, right? Like, I'm not sure. Let's give it to the quarterback. You mentioned Malik Willis. Jordan Love, this is kind of like a freaky week for quarterback injuries, right? Some more serious than others. We saw JJ McCarthy go down. We saw Josh Allen go down at one point in time. We saw Lamar Jackson go down. Jordan Love goes out with a concussion. Malik comes in and he had a pretty good game. all things considered. Yeah, absolutely. I was like, oh my God, this is incredible.
6:34You know, now he's played for them before, but yeah, he was running, he was completing passes. And again, it's 16-6 late in that game where you're going, are the Bears really going to blow this game? This is wild that they're actually going to lose this game to the Packers when Jordan Love went out. But really, that was a walk-off in the NFL is incredible. You know, it doesn't happen often where it's just, it's the last play of the game. He's chucking it deep. To your point, I'm like, is DJ Moore injured? I'm thinking back to when DJ Moore, like one of the first plays of the game just gets leveled in the back.
7:09And I'm like, how does, you know, that play I was like, NFL athletes are different than you and me, Billy. I'll speak for myself. Maybe you, you get leveled in the back like he did from Keyshawn Nixon. Maybe you're just back up, you're potting, you're helping out, you know, you're Zach Lowe, you know, what do you, what do you need? We're recording next week. Ringer tailgate, what do you need? I would be like, I need a couple of days. Okay, somebody fill in on the Ringer NFL show for me.
7:33Sheil Kapadia:So I'm not an NFL player. So I actually got on Friday, this is gonna make me sound tougher than I am, but I'm not. On Friday, I went and I got injections into my spine and neck because I got in a car accident. Yeah, I got in a car accident a couple months ago. So I've been doing physical therapy and I've been having like this ongoing pain. So they stuck these like needles into like my spine and my neck and it's supposed to like relieve the pain. And all of yesterday, Saturday, I was just walking around and couldn't like move. I was all sore. Like, I don't know how these people are basically getting hit by trucks every single day.
8:10Sheil Kapadia:They just get right back up and they keep going. They're different. They're different. It feels like football players are different species, honestly. I don't understand it, how they just keep going. Well, now I'm worried about you, Billy. Well, no, I'm fine. I'm here today. You know what I mean? I think it took a little bit to sink in, The point is I'm not a tough man. I'm not tough at all. No, me neither. Okay. Caleb Williams, Bears. Great choice. They have a 92 % chance to win the division. According to the athletics playoff simulator, they're still in the mix to get the one seed and the buy.
8:40So what a season if you're a Bears fan right now. So that's a great choice. I'm going to go with Trevor Lawrence, Liam Cohen, and the Jacksonville Jaguars. I mean, you and I, what was it a month ago? We call Trevor Lawrence, the blooper reel QB. I know I called him that. And I, you know, you were in agreement with me since then. He's just been on a heater and this really fits the narrative of the Jaguars, Billy, because they are being like, nobody respects us. Nobody gives us any credit. All we do is win. And I thought, all right, that's going to come to an end here in Denver against a very good defense.
9:17It didn't come to an end there. Trevor Lawrence. I mean, this every week we're saying, was this Trevor Lawrence's best game of his career? This might've been the best game of his career. I mean, he's throwing lasers across the middle. He's using his legs. He's not making mistakes. And they go into Denver and they cook that defense. They went up and down the field on the Broncos defense. And the Jacksonville Jaguars now are the nobody believes in us team, that we don't get a lot of respect team. And they are right about that. Like, I hate when teams like the Chiefs, you know, when Mahomes is like, oh, we don't.
9:48No, you get respect. Everyone picks you. The Jaguars kind of have a case. Like nobody does really respect them or think they're good. But now we all have to rethink that because they keep winning these games and they look incredible.
9:59Sheil Kapadia:So they've won six straight games. The Texans in their division, the SEC now has been like sneaky competitive because the Texans won seven straight. It was looking like it was all said and done early in the season with the Colts. And then Daniel Jones kind of things started going a little haywire for the Colts before even the Daniel Jones injury. But the Jaguars, to your point, six straight wins. Trevor Lawrence, you were saying, is this his best game? Which is a crazy question coming off of a six touchdown performance last week. But this might have been his best game, especially considering the fact that they did to the Broncos, who are the one seed right now in the AFC.
10:36Sheil Kapadia:We talked, I think, a month ago about Trevor Lawrence, and we were comparing him to other quarterbacks that we had just kind of written off and thought like, you know what, this isn't going to work out. I don't know if this is the guy. and we were saying every year it seems like we say this is the make or break year for Trevor Lawrence and then he doesn't really make it and there's no real consequences and the next year we just kind of fall back into the same trap and we believe in him again. But this year he might actually be doing it. I mean, he's got to kind of finish and then make it to the playoffs and hopefully go on a little run.
11:06Sheil Kapadia:But I mean, six straight kind of now leading the AFC South there in the driver's seat. It's been a nice turnaround for them. Are you following the whole, did you follow the Liam Cohen, Sean Payton back and forth here, or do I need to fill you in on this? The small market situation? The small market. I mean, it felt like a throwaway line from Payton, but Payton does like to manipulate things through the media. So Sean Payton said during the week, he's complimenting the Jaguars on everything. And then he says, you know, it's a smaller market, but you see a real good team. So then Liam Cohen, after this win, he's at the podium and he says, grateful.
11:42I'm grateful that a small market team like us can come into a place like Mile High and get it done. And then the Jaguar social media, did you see what they were doing before the game?
11:52Sheil Kapadia:No, what did they do? They're posting all this stuff, including our very own Bill Simmons. They got all these clips of media people saying they're not very good and they're posting that. And then after the game, they got players running off the field saying small market, small like this is this is a crazy thing that's going on with Jacksonville where they are using every single thing to the point where I'm trying to figure out what's like what's the most innocuous thing I could say that they would use as bulletin board material you know if I was like Jacksonville's public bathrooms are freaking disgusting you know it does that go on like the sizzle reel next week on the Saturday night meeting and like he said our bathrooms are disgusting we're not going to take and then they come out and they get all fired up and they win seven in a row.
12:37Sheil Kapadia:I don't understand the small market thing is an insult or even really like a comment. Cause like the actual like market size would be like a media market, right. And like a television market or whatever. Right. If you're like actually thinking, I think they take it more as like, you know, if you call a town, like a one stoplight town or whatever, right. Like, Oh, this is like this little town with nothing to do, but like media market size, like who cares about that? Like, Like, why would you be, isn't like Minneapolis, like one of the bigger ones, like in the country. And like, do you think of Minneapolis is like, this is a big city.
13:10Sheil Kapadia:Like, whoa, these are city slickers here in Minneapolis, St. Paul. Like, no, who thinks that way? Like, I don't understand why you get mad about that. But I do like when someone wants to give themselves a chip on their shoulder and they want to look for something to be upset about. I think the whole small market thing, though, might be one of the lamer things to kind of be upset about. But listen, if we remember how Liam Cohn was kind of introduced to, you know, the city of Jacksonville, it didn't get off to a hot start when he couldn't do Duval. Right. So they were kind of looking at him like, Ooh, I don't know if this is the guy that we want or not.
13:45I feel like that's tough. Say Duval. Your first day to have to do that, you know, in front of everybody, I would feel very awkward. I'm not going to do it right now. I'm telling you right now, you can do it if you want. I'm not doing it. Duval. Okay.
13:58Sheil Kapadia:Yeah, I think so. Do you think you practice that? Like, what do you practice in the mirror? Cause like I'm thinking of in the sports world, like what are things that people do, uh, to kind of like ingratiate themselves to the fans and what are like kind of sayings that the fans do. So every time that Russell Wilson switches teams, he tries to come up with his own catch phrase, but no one uses those catchphrases. So that's not the same thing. I'm thinking back to, uh, I'm thinking back to like, I don't remember who it was, went to like Arkansas in college and tried to do the like, woo pig suey thing that they did.
14:34Sheil Kapadia:I do remember that. This is really strange. And I think that Duval is, I guess, the Jaguars thing, right? Yeah. Oh, yeah. He botched that so badly. There's such a, like, it's very simple to try to memorize that. That's going on the sizzle reel. They said I couldn't say Duval, right? We're coming out here and we're going to win the NFC South. I mean, you got to watch what you say. about this team. I'd love to be on someone's sizzle reel. Me too. I'd love to be motivation. Can we make that our goal? Yeah, say something outrageous. What team do you want to motivate? No, no. I think it has to be the Jaguars because right now the Jaguars are like an enemy of the ringer.
15:10They go after one of our people and they're also the team looking for stuff. So let's work on it. I don't think we have to do it right now. Let's think about this. We come back to it and let's think of a way to motivate the Jaguars because I don't, you know, my bathroom thing earlier, I think that probably didn't do it. But like I said, they deserve, listen, they're playing great. Liam Cohen, fun new character. He had the whole thing with Robert Sala. He had the Duvall thing. Now he's got this thing with Peyton. He'll yell at Trevor Lawrence and he seems to be a great coach. I mean, their offense, Trevor Lawrence has never looked better.
15:46They're winning all these games. Their offense looks great. So Liam Cohen is my nomination for most fun new character of the 2025 season. All right, let's take a break. We come back. Our next question is going to be, what's the craziest thing that happened this weekend? Because a lot of crazy things happened. The Ringer NFL Show is brought to you by FanDuel. Tis the season to be boosting on FanDuel. Because this year you're getting seven straight days of holiday rewards, each one waiting in the app for you to unwrap. Every day brings a new way to play. So keep checking in to see what drops next.
16:22and it all leads to the Christmas Day special where you can get something extra special. Seven days of gifts, one big finale. Head to fanduel.com slash ringer NFL to get in on the holiday spirit. Fanduel, play your game. Must be 21 plus and present in select states or 18 plus and present in DC, Kentucky or Wyoming. Opt-in required. Bonus issued as non-withdrawable profit boost tokens. Restrictions apply, including any token expiration and max wage or amount. See terms at sportsbook.fantool.com. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER or visit rg-help.com. Call 1-888-789-7777 or visit ccpg.org slash chat in Connecticut.
17:08This episode is brought to you by American Eagle. Gift, gift, hooray! Give great jeans this holiday season with American Eagle. They have all the wishlist worthy new arrivals for everyone on your list, including you. You'll find comfy, cozy sweaters, soft fleece, sweatshirts, hoodies, flannels, and a whole bunch more. Plus, you'll love their trending jeans, like the high-waisted stovepipe, original straight, bootcut, and so many more fits. They've got every style and everyone covered. You can check it all out at AE.com or just go to the store. All right, we're back on the Ringer NFL show. All right, Bill, you can take this any direction you want.
17:48craziest thing that happened in week 16. What do you got?
17:52Sheil Kapadia:Oh, the craziest thing that happened. Now, as you mentioned before, we went to break. A lot of things happened. And I have a game as the craziest thing that happened. And I don't know if you were going to allow this to be how I take this. No rules. I want to nominate. We had, you know, three or four really crazy games, but I'm going to nominate the Lions and the Steelers as the craziest thing to happen this week in the NFL. And I was trying to pick and pin down just one moment of the game. And I was going to say, this is the craziest thing that happened this week. But that game had so many crazy things happen that it was hard to pick just one.
18:30Sheil Kapadia:Some of them happened in the field of play. Some of them happened off of the field of play where DK Metcalf decided to just grab a fan, buy the shirt, then pull the fan down and then throw the fan back or swing at the fan. and it looked like possibly throw a punch, but I think he was holding the shirt and then the shirt allegedly was ripped and we don't have all the specifics as to what happened. I was reading somewhere that the fan may have just called DK Metcalf by his full name and DK Metcalf did not like that, which seems kind of like a crazy reason to do that. Either way, the fact that a camera caught that was also kind of wild, I guess maybe someone was wondering, why is DK Metcalf so far behind the bench?
19:12Sheil Kapadia:What is DK Metcalf doing? Is there an injury? what's going on because he was nowhere near the bench. He was like well beyond the bench, well behind the space behind the bench, right up against like the fans and somehow reached up because he's a giant human being, reached up to like 12 feet or whatever it is that you have to go up to actually get to a fan that somehow pulled a fan down, had the exchange, throws the fan back. It looks like a punch. For sure, there's going to be discipline. The craziest thing about that too was like he played the entire game, but obviously he played the entire game because who's watching DK Metcalf in any official capacity during the game that would discipline him?
19:50Sheil Kapadia:His coaches are watching the game. They're calling the plays. The officials are watching the game. A camera somehow catches it on CBS. I think it was CBS caught it. And then everyone's saying, oh, he should have been ejected. By who? Who's watching him? The fact that that camera even caught him is a miracle. Normally, that's cell phone camera footage, right? But they found an HD camera that was just following him for whatever reason and got it. And now you have to assume he's going to get a hefty fine and potentially suspended for his actions because you can't be punching fans because that's insane.
20:20Sheil Kapadia:But that wasn't even the craziest part of that game, I don't think. No. Yeah. I mean, yeah, I don't know. We'll find out. Did the fans say something? What was it about? We have no idea. As we're recording, we have no details. But you're right. You know, we could have nominated the camera person as the winner of the week. They're just they're keeping an eye on stuff. Yeah. OK, well, DK's walking over there. Let me because you are so right. Normally, that's a cell phone camera, grainy footage. But no, this was actually a broadcast camera person. We're security. Security had no idea what was going on or you would think they would be over there.
20:52Sheil Kapadia:If you're security, you're going to arrest DK Metcalf. Like you probably eject the fan. You probably eject the fan. Stop. Tolentate the player. The fan for sure. Again, we put an asterisk here, as I say, for sure. but an asterisk. The fan for sure was the agitator there, right? Because DK didn't just decide to walk into the stands and go and attack a fan. The fan was saying something that elicited that response, which was not appropriate, but still the fan was saying something very clearly. I think that's the most likely scenario. I would be with you. Like you said, asterisk. We'll find out hopefully more details, but I'm with you.
Read the full transcript
21:28I think that's probably the most likely outcome and we'll see what the discipline is here. I mean, what is that fan thing? Why would you even get within reach of DK? Have you seen DK Metcalf? What is happening with that guy? Unbelievable. But you're right. That probably, can I tell you what I think was the craziest thing from that game? What? I'm on the same game. The craziest thing on the game if, you know, you had the final play where you throw down Monra St. Brown. He gets stopped at the one and he flips it to Jared Goff on a lateral. They don't call forward progress. Jared Goff goes flipping into the end zone on the play.
22:04And then there's all this chaos. Tony Romo's like, I'm not even going to, I can't eat. Jim, you take this. I don't even know what just happened there. There's too many things going on. The craziest thing that happened was the ref's announcement after all the chaos. The ref said, this is a crowd of Detroit Lions fans, some of whom are crazy enough to get within reach of DK Metcalf when they're taunting him. This is a crowd of Detroit Lions fans. Their playoff lives are on the line. They don't know if they've just had maybe the greatest play they've ever seen to win a football game or if their playoff hopes have just been dashed.
22:41OK, and the official is the only one with the information. And he gets on the mic and he says, the first thing he says, the ruling on the field is a touchdown. I can't even get through it. It's so funny. What was he thinking by saying that? And he goes, however, no, you don't lead with the ruling on the field. It's a touchdown. Are you crazy? I was thinking about this, Billy. Is he on like the refs group chats tonight? And they're all like doing crying, laughing emojis. And they're like, Carl Shepard, that was sick, dude. You had them all thinking that was a touchdown. Why would he do it that way?
23:15Sheil Kapadia:It was a strange way to do it. So there's the initial play, right? So the play happens. And before that play, there was a lot of crazy things too that we can get to. or maybe we won't get to, right? But there's the play. It's the pass. It's almost like reminiscent of the Super Bowl where they're just shy of the goal line, right? But this time they kind of pick up Amon Ross St. Brown and they take them back like eight yards or something, right? And then all of a sudden you're wondering like, oh God, what are the flags now? Because earlier in the drive, the game should have been over on a fourth and two and then like six seconds after the play was done where you think there's a change of possession, three flags come flying from all directions and oh no, nevermind, pass interference.
23:56Sheil Kapadia:And guess what? The Lions are going to get a first down here and we're going to keep this game going, right? So when all of those flags went flying on that play, we had already seen three or four other plays that had been extended with penalties. And then there was a touchdown just two plays before they had been nullified on an offensive pass interference call where you thought that Amon Ross St. Brown had caught a touchdown and given them the lead to win the game, right? So as soon as you see the flags, you're like, what's happening? So I'm focusing on the flags. And then all of a sudden, Jared Goff has the ball somehow and he's diving into the end zone, flipping it.
24:25Sheil Kapadia:It's like, how did he even end up with that ball? What's going on? Was there a whistle? Was there not? I assumed when they picked him up and they took him back all those yards that you wouldn't be able to lateral. They would have just said forward progress has been stopped and that would be the end of the game, right? So then the NFL did this thing. I don't know if you saw it on social media where they put out the entire unedited version of it from the snap to when they called what it was. and it's like well over three minutes. So you're still watching again on Instagram or Twitter, wherever, the full confusion as to what is going on right now.
25:01Sheil Kapadia:Because we saw it and we see both teams seemingly celebrate thinking that they just won the game. And then they're kind of backing up and they're doing the thing where they're holding themselves back off of the sidelines because they don't know what the call is and you're waiting. And then to your point, one of the strangest announcements ever whereas the ruling on the field is a touchdown. However, offensive pass interference, but there is no replay, so the game's over. And when he said, so the game's over, then the crowd erupts again in cheers because they think, okay, it was a touchdown and now automatically game over, we won.
25:39Sheil Kapadia:And then the Steelers are celebrating and they're like, wait, what's going on now? Like, we just lost this game. How did this happen? It was a wild finish. And we didn't even talk about in this game how the first half ended when Kenneth Gainwell fell, catches the ball on the ground, gets up and runs in for a 45 yard Hail Mary where everyone just assumed he didn't catch the ball. That's a dead ball or he was touched well on the ground. They review it. He was never touched somehow. he had the presence of mind to get up and run in to score a touchdown on another one of Aaron Rodgers' career miraculous Hail Marys that he does at the end of half.
26:18Sheil Kapadia:So it's just like the sixth time I feel like he's done it. What an insane game this was. Can I tell you on the Gainwell catch, again, Jim Nance could be a winner, our winner of the week because he comes in with the most irrational confidence ever. Like, that was a catch. I'm like, Nance, settle down, man. And you don't have those kinds of eyes. You don't know that it was a game. And then they showed the replay. And I'm like, Nance. Oh, I was not familiar with your eyesight, Jim Nance. That was incredible. He had it right away. Kenny Gainwell has turned into a different person with the Steelers team.
26:52That was an incredible catch, an incredible touchdown. So yeah, think of all the things. You had the two calls at the end, two offensive pass interferences that both negate a touchdown. You had the Amon Ross St. Brown lateral to golf. I'm with you. I'm like, how does golf have the ball? and then Goff who gets made fun. Oh, he can't throw under pressure. He's like flipping into the end zone there. Like that would have been an unbelievable play to get into the end zone. You had the DK Metcalf thing. And how about this? Maybe the most shocking thing of the game, Billy. Chris Boswell missed a 37-yard field goal.
27:24I've never seen him miss a kick in my life.
27:26Sheil Kapadia:Doinked it. You had a safety in that game. Oh, yeah, safety. You had Jalen Warren have two different 45-yard touchdown runs. Like that game had it all. Can I tell you something on a selfish thing just between me and you and our fans that are listening. Just me and you. Yeah. I hated this game, and I'm going to tell you why I hated this game. Because, and this is very selfish, I loved it, but I hated it because of fantasy. Because we're well in the fantasy playoffs now. We're in the semifinals. You got to get knocked out early like me, Bill. You don't have to worry about it. Here's the thing, is that I was not looking good, but I have Jalen Warren, and he crushed it for me in this game.
28:01Sheil Kapadia:However, because he crushed it for me in the game, I was playing against Jared Goff. So every time he ran for 45 yards and scored a touchdown, I celebrated, but then also knew, but now you're up by like nine or something and Jared's going to have to throw the ball. And he gained so many yards in the fourth quarter. He had over 300 passing yards in the game, 364 passing yards on the game. He had three touchdowns and it felt like they were all in the fourth quarter. Like he turned it on because he had to, but it was horrendous to watch. And I know you're wondering how did it go? How did your fantasy weekend?
28:37Sheil Kapadia:It's a great question. It came down to Sunday night football and I had Derek Henry and I ended up winning. Oh, I had Derek Henry and my opponent had running back from the Patriots who ended up getting injured. Travion Henderson and thoughts and prayers to him. Hopefully he's doing well, But for fantasy purposes, that injury worked out quite nicely for me. Yeah, because there was a series, I don't know if you saw, in the fourth quarter where Chris Collinsworth is like, can I ask you why Derrick Henry is not on the field? So I actually thought your story was going to go in a different direction because Derrick Henry, for some reason, was just not playing on a possession in the fourth quarter where they were going to keep Mitchell.
29:16But it worked out for you. So I'm glad for you. You're still alive. We'll get an update from you next week. All right, last topic here, Billy. stuff that is left to be settled here. There is a surprisingly a lot of stuff that is still to be settled here. The NFC South is, of course, one of those things. But what if I told you that, like, the divisions aren't settled here, you know? And now they're mostly settled, but, like, the Bills still have around a 20 % chance in the AFC East. The Ravens still have, like, a 10 % chance, which is not nothing in the AFC North. The Texans have a 20 % chance against the Jaguars in the AFC South.
29:58The Chargers have a 24 % chance in the AFC West. And of course, like I mentioned, the NFC South and the NFC West, those are up for grabs as well. Then you got the one seed stuff. There's still a bunch of teams available to win the one seed. Six teams could still win the one seed in the AFC.
30:16Sheil Kapadia:Forget the divisions. The one seed can still be won by six of the seven teams. Yeah, that's absurd. So which of the things to be settled do you find most interesting right now? We talked about this a couple weeks ago. I have that soft spot for Bryce Young. We talked about it and we were saying it kind of when it was just like, this is a cute story, Bryce Young. Look, he's having a decent season. But here we are with two weeks left in the season. And Bryce Young is a playoff team right now. The Panthers are a playoff team. and it's not going to be an easy road for them because they are going to be playing Seattle and then they're going to be traveling down to Tampa in what is probably, depending on how things shake out in the other divisions, I'm assuming going to be like the premier game of week 18 just because the division is going to be coming down to that game, right?
31:10Sheil Kapadia:Unless, you know, the Buccaneers lose next week and it's going to come down to week 18, right? And who would have thought that Bryce Young and the Carolina Panthers, you know if you were to tell them tell us a year ago at the beginning of the season when they bench Bryce Young he's going to be going and he's going to be beating Baker Mayfield at home he's going to be beating Baker Mayfield and then they're going to be playing for the division the last week of the season it's been an incredible story I think for them you have to feel good for the Panthers and for Bryce because it's been I mean listen part of it is that their organization is somewhat inept right and their owners a bit a bit of a crazy person right yeah but beyond and don't don't print that and don't put that down there.
31:48Sheil Kapadia:We do not want to be bulletin board material for the Panthers. We are rooting for the Panthers here. At least I'm rooting for the Panthers. We are trying to agitate the Jaguars as a company. It would seem company mandate has come out and said, we must agitate the Jacksonville Jaguars and we are falling in line and we will do so when we think of the proper way to do so. And shield's going to go and he's going to criticize your bathrooms, Jaguars, and he's going to do all of that stuff. But, uh, we're not doing that. We're not doing that with the Panthers. Not to the Panthers. Not to the Panthers.
32:19Sheil Kapadia:Yeah. I mean, I have made fun of the Panthers a lot in the past because of the owner, like you said, asking the restaurant people to change their signage outside, flipping the guy's lid. I don't advocate any of that. I don't like any of that. And I will rip them if I need to, but I can't help it. I'm with you. You know, as you were describing Bryce Young's journey, Billy, he was the original sad Joe Burrow. You know, remember when he got benched and Andy Dalton's getting in there, who was more sad than Bryce Young? He was as sad as could be, thought his career was over. All of a sudden, who could, a car accident, I mean, second car accident reference on this podcast.
32:54I didn't see that coming, but Andy Dalton gets in the car accident. Bryce Young comes back. And now in this game, he's so happy. He's got the celebration with Tett McMillan. He's got that play at the end. He's scrambling. Maybe they get away with the hold. Who cares? He finds the touchdown in the back of the end zone. And you're right. Maybe it won't happen for him. They're not out of the woods yet. They don't have anything clinched. They might have to beat the Bucs again in week 18. But I feel like this was a great win for the Carolina Panthers. And whatever juice there is to squeeze out of this Panthers team, they're squeezing it all out there, I feel.
33:29Sheil Kapadia:Do I think they're going to win the Super Bowl? Absolutely not. Will I want to see them make the playoffs? Yes. Is their game probably going to be like that Saturday noon game the first week of the playoffs? Yeah, more than likely, because who actually wants to see them play in the playoffs? Besides me, I want to. did you see this stat? I don't know if you saw it, Shield. So Bryce Young coming into that game, coming into that final drive, 11 of his 13 wins for his career were game-winning drives. So he now has 12 of his 14 career wins as game-winning drives. This guy has ice water running through his veins.
34:05Sheil Kapadia:Joe Cool over here just leaning his team down the field when he needs to and it matters the most. Forget the fact that he's only throwing for like 140 yards a game. That doesn't matter. Those 140 yards, they're coming in the game-winning drive, and he's going to win it when he needs to. They're coming at the right time. He was very nice to whoever was doing the post-game interview. You know, as you said, the Panthers aren't going to the Super Bowl. I had a thought. Okay, so you're in South Florida. I'm in Philadelphia. Charlotte has to be kind of, well, no, it's probably a longer drive for you than it would be for me.
34:38If the Panthers make the Super Bowl, we meet at that restaurant, and I let you flip my lid and we make it a social media video. You in for that?
34:48Sheil Kapadia:Okay, sure. Okay. Yeah, you don't seem enthused. I thought you were going to be more enthusiastic. It's a longer drive for me, honestly. I mean, can I get there another way? Can I fly there? You can fly. Okay, cool. I'll go there. I'll pick you up from the airport. If they win, we can go and be part of the parade. I'm sure they would love that because again, Panthers and Panthers fans, this is not bulletin board material for you. Only do that for the Jaguars. We want you to succeed. You know what? It's like the opposite of the Jaguars. If they make the Super Bowl, they can play this clip and be like, here are the only people who actually believed in us.
35:20Sheil Kapadia:Thank you. You get it. What happened to that Jerry Richardson statue? They took it down, right? The one where he was like walking Panthers or whatever it was. Yes. I do believe they took that down. Yes, I do. But, you know, if we want to investigate when we're in Charlotte anyway. It was for good reason. He was kind of not the best. Yeah, we could do some investigative journalism on that when we're down there. Yeah. If we want to. Okay, there you go. His name is Billy Gill. My name is Shiel Kapadia. No hurry up today. We had too much to get to. Thanks to everybody for listening. Thank you to Christopher Sutton for producing.
35:55Kiera Givens on social. And additional production supervision by Conor Nevins and Arjuna Ramgopal. We'll be back tomorrow on the Ringer NFL Show.
36:12Must be 21 plus and present in select states for Kansas in affiliation with Kansas Star Casino or 18 plus and present in D.C., Kentucky or Wyoming. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER or visit rg-help.com. Call 1-888-789-7777 or visit ccpg.org slash chat in Connecticut or visit mdgamblinghelp.org in Maryland. Hope is here. Visit gamblinghelplinema.org or call 800-327-5050 for 24-7 support in Massachusetts or call 1-877-8HOPE-NY or text HOPE-NY in New York.
36:49Sheil Kapadia:You can't reason with the sun. Trust us. We've tried. This summer, it's time to put that angry ball of fire on mute. Columbia's OmniShade technology is engineered to protect you from the sun's harsh rays that can burn and damage your skin. The sun is relentless, but so is our gear. Level up your summer at Columbia.com to spend more time outside and less time slathering on aloe lotion. You're welcome. Columbia. Engineered for whatever. The right window treatments change everything. Your sleep, your privacy, the way every room looks and feels. At Blinds.com, we've spent 30 years making it surprisingly simple to get exactly what your home needs.
37:29Sheil Kapadia:We've covered over 25 million windows and have 50 ,000 five-star reviews to prove we deliver. Whether you DIY it or want a pro to handle everything from measure to install, we have you covered. Real design professionals. Free samples. Zero pressure. Right now, get up to 45 % off site-wide. Plus, get a free professional measure at blinds.com. Rules and restrictions apply.
From the publisher
Sheil and The Ringer’s own Billy Gil take a hard look at the biggest games from a chaotic Week 16 NFL slate to decide which individuals made the biggest impact on their organizations and what important questions are still left unanswered as we march toward the playoffs.
(00:00) The biggest winners, takeaways, and questions from Week 16(1:15) Packers-Bears(7:06) Jaguars-Broncos(16:05) Steelers-Lions(28:44) Bucs-Panthers
This episode is brought to you by American Eagle.
The Ringer is committed to responsible gaming. Please visit www.rg-help.com to learn more about the resources and helplines available.
Host: Sheil KapadiaGuest: Billy GilProducer: Chris SuttonSocial: Kiera Givens and Brian WatersProduction Supervision: Conor Nevins and Arjuna Ramgopowell
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
