Graham Platner's Story Unravels, Supreme Court Could Change Elections | 6/9/26 FIRST LOOK

0:00I've tried a lot of seafood over the years, guys, and truly it's been hit or miss. You know, sometimes it looks great, but then you cook it and it just doesn't have that flavor or freshness you expect. So finding something reliable has made a huge difference. Wild Alaskan Company really changed that for me. It's the best way to receive high-quality, wild-caught seafood delivered right to your door on your schedule. The first box I got was super easy to use. Everything comes individually portioned and vacuum sealed, so there's no guesswork. I cooked that wild Alaskan sockeye salmon just in a pan with a little olive oil, salt, and pepper, and it turned out fantastic.

0:34Clean flavor, great texture, and didn't feel like frozen fish at all. I've also tried the wild Pacific cod, which I love. It's light and flaky and really easy to work in when you need a quick dinner. What stood out is that the fish is quick frozen right after it's caught in Alaska, so it locks in that freshness along with the nutrients like omega-3s. And it's clean, no GMOs, no antibiotics, no additives. And it supports sustainable fishing and Alaskan fishermen. They're so confident in the quality that there's 100 % satisfaction, money-back guarantee, so there's no risk in trying it. Go to wildalaskan.com slash Rubin for$35 off your first order of premium wild-caught seafood.

1:09That's wildalaskan.com slash Rubin for$35 off your first order.

1:17Hey, everybody. I'm Dave Rubin, and this is First Look. It's Tuesday, June 9th, 2026. We've got a packed show for you today. Democratic Senate candidate Graham Plattner's carefully crafted blue-collar image is facing new scrutiny as financial records paint a very different picture. A major Supreme Court case could dramatically reshape how elections are conducted nationwide and potentially end the weeks-long ballot counting process seen in states like California. Let's dive in. In Maine, Democratic Senate candidate Graham Plattner is facing growing scrutiny over claims that he earns his living as an oyster farmer, and critics say the numbers simply don't add up.

2:04Plattner has built much of his Senate campaign around an image of being a working-class Mainer who makes his living on the water. At a rally on June 5th, Plattner told supporters, my healthcare gave me freedom. It gave me the freedom to take risks, to start a business and to sink my intellect and my physicality into mastering the skills necessary to make a living on the sea. It's a compelling story. There's just one problem. According to Plattner's own financial disclosures, he doesn't appear to make much of a living from the sea at all. His 2025 disclosure forms show roughly$5 ,000 in annual income from oyster farming, about$3 ,000 serving as harbormaster for Sullivan, Maine combined, that's approximately$8 ,000 per year, from the jobs that have become central to his political identity.

3:01By comparison, Plattner has publicly acknowledged receiving approximately$4 ,800 per month in veteran disability benefits. That's roughly$57 ,600 annually, more than seven times what his disclosures show from oyster farming and harbor work combined. Now, to be clear, Plattner earned those disability benefits through military service and is legally entitled to them. Nobody is questioning that. The issue critics are raising is whether voters are getting an accurate picture when Plattner repeatedly describes himself primarily as an oyster farmer making his living on the water. The disclosures reveal additional details that have raised eyebrows.

3:48For example, the only listed purchaser of his oysters is reportedly a restaurant owned by his mother. His oyster farm operates on a private island owned by his business partner's family. He reportedly received a$200 ,000 loan from his father to purchase his home. Critics argue that doesn't exactly fit the image of a self-made working-class fisherman grinding out a living at sea. Freelance journalist Magdy Jacobs wrote, He says he makes a living off the sea. He objectively does not. Another critic put it more bluntly. You're not trawling George's bank. You're pulling up traps in a protected 25-foot-deep bay.

4:33These questions come at a particularly difficult time for Plattner. His campaign has already been battered by a series of controversies involving deleted social media posts, allegations of abusive behavior toward women, and a Nazi-related tattoo controversy stemming from his military service. Despite those issues, Plattner remains the presumptive Democratic nominee. And some voters continue finding his story compelling. Fox News correspondent Alexis McAdams reported that numerous veterans recently attended Plattner campaign events and expressed support for his candidacy. Still, the broader issue remains.

5:14Democrats have spent years arguing they need candidates who connect with working class voters. But critics say voters deserve authenticity, and they argue that if a campaign is built around a blue collar image, the financial records ought to support it. A Supreme Court decision expected later this month could fundamentally change how elections are conducted across the country, and Republicans believe it could finally put an end to the weeks long ballot counting process that continues frustrating voters in states like California. The case is called Watson versus the Republican National Committee, and it centers on a simple but important question, should ballots that arrive after Election Day still be counted?

5:57Currently, at least 14 states and Washington, D.C. allow mail ballots to arrive after Election Day as long as they're postmarked on time. California is one of them. And it's one reason Los Angeles still doesn't know for certain who will advance to the mayoral runoff nearly a week after voting ended. The Republican National Committee argues this violates federal law. Specifically, the RNC points to a statute establishing Election Day as the Tuesday after the first Monday in November. Their argument is straightforward. Election Day should mean Election Day. Not Election Week, not Election Month, Election Day.

6:38RNC Chairman Joe Gruters recently blasted California's system, saying, Nearly a week after the primary, it is completely unacceptable ballots are still being counted. The issue gained even more attention after the ongoing battle between Spencer Pratt and Nithya Rahman for a spot in the Los Angeles mayoral runoff. Republicans have pointed to that race as an example of why confidence in elections continues to erode. President Trump weighed in Monday on Truth Social, writing, Not possible for Spencer Pratt to have lost the LA runoffs after the big lead he had. He added, Rigged elections. Now, during oral arguments, several conservative justices appeared sympathetic to the RNC's concerns.

7:24Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito, Neil Gorsuch, and Brett Kavanaugh all seemed interested in arguments about restoring public confidence in election outcomes. Meanwhile, liberal justices expressed skepticism. Justice Elena Kagan argued that late-arriving ballot systems are deeply entrenched in many states and questioned whether courts should overturn long-standing practices. The decision could be narrow, or it could have nationwide implications. If the court sides broadly with the RNC, states may be forced to stop counting ballots that arrive after Election Day altogether. That would represent one of the biggest election law rulings in years.

8:06And honestly, regardless of where people fall politically, most Americans want the same thing. fast results, clear rules, and confidence that elections are being conducted fairly. The Supreme Court may soon determine whether states like California will be allowed to continue counting ballots days or even weeks after voters cast them. And that's your first look this Tuesday. Quick recap, Graham Plattner's working class campaign image is facing new scrutiny as financial disclosures tell a different story. and the Supreme Court is preparing to rule on a major election case that could reshape ballot counting rules nationwide.

8:46We'll keep following all of it. I'm Dave Rubin. Thanks for starting your day with First Look. See you tomorrow.

8:57Dave Rubin:Hey, Chicagoland, the Wayfair store is in your neighborhood at Edens Plaza and Wilmette. Finally, you can feel the fabric, sit on the sectionals and even open the refrigerators. Plus, our in-store designers will help you bring it all together with free one-on-one design support for any project on any budget. Yep, we said free. Oh, and did we mention the cafe? So what are you waiting for? Come see all that's in store. Visit the Wayfair store today at Edens Plaza and Wilmette.