In short
UK “trustworthy media” legislation and algorithmic prioritization of state-adjacent outlets; free-speech/censorship concerns; internet radicalization likened to cult dynamics; immigration and border policy; examples from Sweden and UK cases of arrests over online speech.
Guest background
Andrew Gold is host of Heretics and author of The Psychology of Secrets. He says he became interested in cult-like politics after studying how minds get pushed into one-sided narratives; he compares political online ecosystems to Scientology.
Key claims
Governments and foreign actors exploit online division; platforms may be pressured to boost state-aligned media over independent creators (BBC/Channel 4 cited). Free speech is deteriorating, with police actions and prosecutions for criticism. Immigration is portrayed as driving unemployment/crime/parallel societies; Sweden is offered as a “small-country” warning.
Notable examples
A man criticized a school in a WhatsApp parents’ group and was arrested (with his wife) despite police claiming other emergencies; Lucy Connolly jailed 31 months after a Facebook post about “burn down the mosques”; Sweden’s shift to high stabbing rates; Jermaine Genas interview treatment; Vanessa Feltz described as becoming aggressive during gender discussion.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOUK Media Legislation and Its Implications
0:00 to 1:54
Learn about the new UK legislation impacting independent media creators.
“Latest thing that they're doing is really North Korean.”
Introduction of Andrew Gold
1:54 to 2:15
Meet Andrew Gold, host of Heretics and author of The Psychology of Secrets.
“And joining me today is the host of Heretics and the author of The Psychology of Secrets, Andrew Gold.”
The Dynamics of Online Hate and Love
2:15 to 3:10
Discuss the complexities of online interactions including hate and support.
“So as we are taping this, it is Tuesday, July 28th.”
The Influence of Internet Cult Behavior
3:10 to 5:41
Explore how internet behavior mirrors cult dynamics and affects individual perspectives.
“Because really, when I started this off the grid thing, it was partly because, you know, I was getting hate online.”
Navigating Heated Discussions
5:41 to 8:04
Learn strategies for managing aggressive conversations and dialogue.
“Because you've been through a lot of these conversations and you're pretty calm and even tempered.”
The Evolution of Gender Discussions
8:04 to 11:45
Examine the transformations in discussions around gender identity and societal perceptions.
“It was a lot of women and they were being sort of pushed into his sex cult, which is strange.”
Censorship and the Borderless Internet
11:45 to 14:00
Analyze the implications of censorship and the challenges of a borderless internet.
“That's where the trigonometry, we all have this job to try and normalize our platforms, interview other people.”
Censorship in the UK: A Growing Concern
14:00 to 19:58
Discussion focuses on the alarming rise of censorship in the UK and its implications on free speech.
“And it disincentivizes whistleblowers, which is so important.”
Censorship in the UK: A Growing Concern
20:02 to 21:05
Discussion focuses on the alarming rise of censorship in the UK and its implications on free speech.
“Guys, it's like buying or selling a stock, except the line isn't set by some algorithm working against you, it moves based on where the money actually goes.”
The Impact of Censorship on Society
21:05 to 28:40
A deep dive into the repercussions of censorship actions on individual freedoms and societal norms.
“I mean, what, you've had, what, six prime ministers in eight years, something like that?”
Show all 17 chapters
The State of Free Speech and Immigration
28:46 to 30:25
Discussion on the current state of free speech in the UK and its connection to immigration issues.
“is that the state of free speech is not that great.”
The Implications of Mass Immigration
30:25 to 35:38
Exploring the consequences of mass immigration in countries like Sweden and the UK.
“So it seemed like everyone knew everywhere.”
Rape Gangs and the Politics of Silence
36:24 to 41:45
An analysis of the failure to address issues related to rape gangs and the broader societal implications.
“I mean, what a grotesque, disgusting thing.”
Cultural Success: Protestantism vs. Catholicism
41:45 to 42:00
A discussion on the cultural and economic impacts of different religious influences in the UK and beyond.
Cultural and Economic Success Factors
42:00 to 43:16
Explore the reasons behind the differing success rates of countries like the UK, US, and Germany compared to others.
“I mean, look, the issue, I've looked into this and I've tried to think about why it is that certain countries succeed and others don't.”
The Impact of Immigration on American Society
43:16 to 44:12
Discuss the effects of importing different cultures, particularly from South America and the Muslim community, on American identity.
“import, as I said before, do seem to be of better stock or more likely to want to be part of your country.”
Assimilation and Cultural Defense
44:12 to 45:09
Analyze the historical context of American assimilation and the potential for resistance against cultural changes.
“I think you guys are going to stand up and kick off.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00Latest thing that they're doing is really North Korean. They want to force the platforms to prioritize state-adjacent media, although in their legislation they're calling it trustworthy media, which is really scary. It's Orwellian. The BBC is a channel called Channel 4 and there are several others that might come under that umbrella that aren't necessarily state-adjacent. Basically they are rallying against independent creators like you and me. That could absolutely screw, you know, me, Winston Marshall, Trigonometry, all the other guys in the UK who the last few years have been making waves by exposing a lot of this stuff.
0:32I've spoken to one guy in particular who came on Heretics. He and his wife were locked up. What had he been doing? He had been in a school, high school WhatsApp group with all the other parents, and he was criticising the school. And the police, someone there, was like, you know what's a good use of our time right now? There's people being stabbed all over London, there's terrorists running amok, but this guy was criticising the school, let's go and get him, and they arrested him. The UK is kind of, this is what can happen to a bigger country in the US in just a few years' time. That's why people need to take stock.
1:04That's why they need to watch what's going on here. And then we have a smaller version that we can look to, which is Sweden. These are countries with tiny populations, you know, 5, 10 million people. You bring in a million or 2 million over a few years. So Sweden went from being one of the safest places in Europe, in the world, they have turned overnight to the point that it is now one of the highest for, you know, stabbing. And even the people on the left there in Sweden and the right, everywhere, they are going nuts. There will be any re-immigration or a further closing of borders? Or is it just that every six months, Tommy Robinson will pull on a rally, it'll be called right wing, and then nothing will happen?
1:49Hey guys, I'm still off the grid, but I hope you've been enjoying everything we've put up for you in August. And this is officially the last interview that we pre-taped before I disappeared. And I will be back next week. I promise you that. I'm still Dave Rubin. This is still The Rubin Report. And joining me today is the host of Heretics and the author of The Psychology of Secrets, Andrew Gold. Welcome to my off-the-grid adventure. What a pleasure to be here. Again, I'm back on The Rubin Show. This is great. You are back on The Rubin Show. So as we are taping this, it is Tuesday, July 28th. I am about to disappear for a month.
2:27This is the last interview we're going to air in August. I've done shows on health and on happiness, how to eat right, stay fit, spirituality. And then I thought we'd end the month with you because, well, you know about cults and you know about craziness and you interview crazy people. And I feel like that's partly what I'm trying to escape in August. So it felt kind of right to me. Yeah, well, that's right. I mean, with the cults and stuff, I started seeing that in politics. And that's what got me into it. I mean, it's the same kind of thing. The way that the mind works, the way that they push out the other side and don't understand the other side.
3:07So I think that's a good little link. Yeah. All right. So let's start with that generally. Because really, when I started this off the grid thing, it was partly because, you know, I was getting hate online. I was getting love online. I was getting everything in between. but I was like, boy, this is just kind of nuts. Like even when it's all great, ego-wise, that's not great for you endlessly, or you just focus on the negative stuff or whatever. So talk to me a little bit about how do you feel about the general temperature and tone of the internet at the moment, this crazy thing that we are all caught in?
3:40Yeah, we're screwed. We're absolutely screwed. I don't know what the answer is. I don't know what we do. It's a good thing I'm off the grid. Yeah, you are. I mean, we've got this authoritarian kind of all seeing all knowing internet, which was such a wonderful idea. Now, from what I can gather, the likes of China, the likes of India, probably Israel, Qatar, all of these guys are now quite involved. They're pushing little buttons and pushing things and making things go certain ways. And all that happens is you end up with one side who is only seeing one thing, the other side is only seeing the other thing.
4:13And that really is a bit like a cult. I mean, I spent a lot of time talking to people who were in Scientology and people who had left Scientology and talking to them about Lord Xenu. Now, that's always kind of the gold star for me. If you can talk to someone who seems intelligent and who very seriously tells you, yeah, yeah, all the Lord Xenu stuff, that's fine, that's true. And he came from another planet and put millions of souls into the volcano. It's utterly mental. half of them don't even know the full story but all they're seeing inside their cult is other you know pro lord xenu stuff so i mean i was talking to someone yesterday who's a british celebrity you won't know her over there uh so it's not even worth saying her name but she's this famous kind of person very tv person and i like interviewing them because they've never heard sometimes you see people go on bill maher and it's similar and probably on your show as well you know you see these guys like mainstream people they've never ever heard an alternative so this woman said yesterday we're halfway through the show and she just went well you know some people don't think a man can become a woman and i just said well hang on no a man can't become what do you mean and she'd never heard like a reasonable she thought only crazy right-wing zealots would ever suggest that a man can't become a woman i said well you know obviously they can't i mean i don't and then she got so angry so quickly it really got very uh aggressive in this in this interview and she was screaming and shouting and basically it was exactly what i had seen from people in Scientology.
5:38So the internet is pushing people further. Wait, before you continue though, so were you able to deescalate it at all? Because you've been through a lot of these conversations and you're pretty calm and even tempered. We have a similar temperament, I think. So sometimes there's some tricks you can use to get somebody out of that frenetic thing. It's really difficult. I mean, the person I was talking to, this woman is incredibly smart. She's like a daytime TV presenter, kind of an Oprah Winfrey or something. But she's - I think say her name. She was on your show. I think you can say her name. Yeah, okay.
6:10Well, Vanessa Feltz is her name. It's just that you won't know it. It's irrelevant to American audiences. But - A couple of British people watch this show, you know. Oh, they'll know Vanessa Feltz. We've got a couple of Brits. They'll all know her. She's very, very famous over here. And I was absolutely just in awe of her intelligence, the vocabulary she has. You don't expect it from a kind of daytime TV presenter. She's smart. and yet this is the kind of thing that she seems to believe. I don't know if she's given it too much thought. So I personally don't think there's all that much you can do to pull someone out of it in one hour.
6:43Now I've done that with friends. I'm sure you have. I'm sure viewers watching this have done and usually it takes months and months. But the key is that nobody leaves Scientology just because like a friend says, hey, you should leave that thing. They leave because Scientology treats them so badly that they have no alternative but to leave. It gets to that point where it's so bad. so an example of this would be loads of jews loads of jews it's just loads of jews and the jews on student campuses right a lot of them were woke i mean probably a higher percentage i don't want to sort of feed into the right-wing rhetoric but probably a higher percentage in jews than maybe the rest of the population loads of woke jews i knew loads of woke jews then october the 7th happened so from that moment suddenly they are being treated so so badly and they're being told things they know are not true they're being told this is an apartheid well they've been to israel They know this is not South Africa 19-whatever year that was.
7:36They know that it's actually a multicultural haven of sorts. So they're being told so many lies. They're being treated so badly that they, little by little, leave that progressive cult. And then you go, and what do you think about men turning into women? They still believe that stuff. They still believe some of it, just like Scientologists still believe. But gradually, that fades away as well. So it's a process. And the more progressives keep eating themselves, hopefully more of them will start to leave but i'm not gonna be able to do it with a woman a bright intelligent woman in a one-hour conversation what have you found about the type of personalities the type of people is there a gender version of it i think a lot of people think there is jordan peterson's talked about a little bit that seemed to fall for the type of stuff that you're talking about so with the gender i don't know what jordan peterson said but i could i've my theory is that more women fall into it i mean nixxiom is a good example that cult that was Alison Mack and Keith Ranieri.
8:32It was a lot of women and they were being sort of pushed into his sex cult, which is strange. But it was loads of women who maybe lacked purpose and status. We are in a world, look, I'm not really a proper conservative, but I do recognize that there are issues around kind of, you know, the family unit disappearing and all of those kinds of things, if it happens on a kind of large scale. And it used to be the case that a woman had more purpose. if the family meant something. But even if it does, after the kids grow up, everyone's told their whole lives nowadays, oh, you need to have purpose. Who are you?
9:05You're the center of your story. And I think that's really difficult for a lot of women. So women go into these cults. I got another theory, which is that, it's just my theories, Andrew's theories. That's wrong, that's wrong. I have time in August to think about these things. So maybe we can talk again in September. I'll see if I can work them out for you. I always remember this scene in The Pianist where uh adrian brody sort of he was he's in hiding as a jew and he goes out and he's in this woman sees him and he's hiding he's not supposed to be there and she looks at him and there's a split second of like oh what's going on and then she just screams jew at him because she's scared and she's and i think women are very very uh likely to sign up to the popular idea of the day because women are usually the victims quicker than men when they don't agree with something.
9:56So if, you know, the witch hunts, as an example, you know, if women don't go along with the thing, men kill them. So women very quickly jump aboard and then start pushing their kind of status about it because it's a survival mechanism. So are you hopeful that using the analogy of, say, Scientology, and then eventually it treats them so badly or they've lost so much that people bounce out so that after these last, let's say, 10 years or even five years, you know, COVID-ish to now of people getting misinformation, clearly being misled by influencers, politicians, algorithms, all this stuff, that there will be some return to normalcy?
10:37Like, can you paint a picture that actually brings people back towards the truth? I think that would have happened if not for the way that the internet's working, if not for the bad actors in governments around the world that are trying to sow division. I mean, Russia and China don't really care if someone's trans or not, but what they want is weakness in this country. They want to sow division. So they're just going to push more and more on the left. They're just going to see more and more stuff about the right. So unfortunately, it's not actually working the way a cult might. In the cult, if you're in Scientology, all you are getting is the Scientology stuff.
11:08They're treating you terribly. Your life is miserable. You leave. If you're in this political cult, it's different because you're on the left, let's say, and all you're seeing is right-wing people online, videos of them saying horrible things about you all the time. So I think it's a little bit more complicated this time. I'm not sure we can get out of it. At the same time, it's undoubtable that in the States and in the UK, in recent years, people have stopped saying that men can be women. I mean, that's a start, right? It's starting to get there. There's still a number of people, as the person I spoke to yesterday proves, particularly in those kind of cultural institutions.
11:42And that's where you and I have a big job to do. That's where the Daily Wire has a job. That's where the trigonometry, we all have this job to try and normalize our platforms, interview other people. Rogan does this well. He interviews lots of other people who are not necessarily politicians. So you get in more audience and you make it like the culture is, it's normal to discuss these things. I think that's, that's how we win this. You know, it's interesting if you think about the internet, the internet is borderless, meaning when you post something, you could get responses, you know, you might be an American, but half your responses could be from Pakistan or 50 different other countries.
12:17We don't know how many of them are human or whatever. So the internet is borderless, but countries obviously have borders, much to the chagrin of a lot of the lefties. But you probably could make some argument around some sort of bordered internet, but you would want it by choice of the individual, meaning I could go on, say, X, toggle something that would just keep me in America and America replies. It doesn't have to be just American stories, but just interacting with Americans. Because one of the things that I notice all the time is that you'll see someone post something completely insane. It gets 500 ,000 likes.
12:50And then politicians literally quote it as if it has some sort of meaning in a country of almost 350 million people. It still seems like a lot, 500 ,000 likes. But then if you were to really figure, oh, well, actually a third of them are bots and a third of them are from countries across the world, it has no meaning. So it's basically turned a mirror into a funhouse mirror. Yeah, it's a tough one because as soon as you start introducing that, it's like, well, how will the governments actually implement it once they have that kind of, I mean, they have the power, but once the precedent is there.
13:22I would want private companies to do it. Like that would be something I would trust Elon more to maybe put a function in that would allow you to do it. I wouldn't want the government to do it because, yeah, then you have no idea what's on the other side of the wall. Exactly. Yeah. Well, look, Elon, it's a lot of power in one man's hands. I like Elon Musk, but I wouldn't want that power in my hands or your hands or Elon's. But I get the idea. I mean, other people are saying another way around that would be you have to give your ID and then you get a tick or something. So you can take that bot seriously if you choose to, but it's not going to have a tick.
13:56But the problem is, I'm sure firstly, the bots are going to get around this some way. And secondly, now we're suddenly giving all of our IDs to people. I don't think anyone likes that. And it disincentivizes whistleblowers, which is so important. So I don't actually think, I know people like to think in the terms of like, if we do this, this will work. I think the reality is if we do this, here are 50 problems. If we do this, here are 51 problems. Let's do the one with 50 problems, maybe, you know? Yeah. It's basically whack-a-mole. It's like, yeah, you can sort of short-term solve something and then another one pops up and another one, another one.
14:25But speaking of social media and censorship and not giving too much power to anyone, what is the deal with what's going on across the pond right now with you people in censorship? You're still not in jail as far as I can tell. Not quite in jail, but the latest thing that they're doing is really North Korean. I know people say that. We say it too easy, but there are only a few countries doing what the UK is looking to do. Among them is North Korea. They want now, and YouTube is very upset about this, but they're pushing YouTube and all the other social media platforms to, they want to force the platforms to prioritize state adjacent media.
14:59Although in their legislation, they're calling it trustworthy media, which is really scary. It's Orwellian, the trustworthy media. Yeah, I mean, that's like, yeah, that's Orwell 101, yeah. Yeah, if it were trustworthy, people would be watching it. And they're saying that the issue here is nobody's watching it. And so we need everyone to watch our trustworthy media. That's the BBC. There's a channel called Channel 4. And there are several others that might come under the umbrella that aren't necessarily state adjacent, but they have the right kind of legislation and lawyers and the teams or whatever.
15:28Basically, they are rallying against independent creators like you and me, that could absolutely screw me, Winston Marshall, Trigonometry, all the other guys in the UK who the last few years have been making waves by exposing a lot of this stuff. So it's obvious to see why they want to do this. The stupidest part of it is this is a left-wing government trying to implement it for authoritarian means. And they haven't thought about the future because what happens when the right-wing government gets in? We shouldn't have any of that kind of authoritarian measures, but it's really scary. YouTube are pushing creators to try and write to people to try and expose it because it goes against the whole meritocratic system of YouTube the whole point of it so it's really scary and that's the first time where I thought you know what if that actually gets implemented not only because it's so scary from a political point of view but from my own personal and professional point of view I won't be able to continue in this country I need a lot more America I mean I just did an America tour because I need American subscribers I can't continue heretics if we get deprioritized so that the BBC gets ahead of us every single time.
16:28So that's the scariest thing now. And by the way, my friend, I hate to tell you, but they're probably all doing that to some degree already. And I mean that even here in the United States. Like there's very few people that are jumping on YouTube to watch a CNN clip, but CNN, I don't even know their numbers exactly, but they do sort of get this like artificially boosted in the algorithm numbers. I'm not even saying that's government related here in the United States, but it's it's just like the system seems to like things of the system how about that yeah yeah and it was disgusting really because even just i mean obviously it's it's terrible because it's not right for the viewers the viewers deserve to get the news that they want to watch and uh but also from the perspective of the creators you and i and all the others many of us started with nothing we you know my first episodes of the of of heretics i was stick you know sellotaping bits and pieces and using a shoebox to put a thing on top of a thing.
17:25The good old days, the good old days. The good old days when it was minimum wage jobs I was doing. It was like trying, you know, all that stuff. Meanwhile, the BBC is just an institution that a bunch of guys who just got university degrees went and worked there and they have not been making anywhere near good enough content for anybody to watch it and they still get boosted and the CNN, the same thing. It's also incredible your BBC to me because every time I go on the BBC and I've been on dozens of times. They try so hard to sandbag you every time. You always get that little off-camera moment with the presenter and they're super nice and they're so happy to have you.
18:02And the second you get on there, they ask you 10 things that have nothing to do with what they told you they were going to ask you. They might switch the topic altogether. They try to quote something that feels like it's not a real quote. I mean, they use every... I think your BBC does that actually even worse than what our mainstream media is doing in a lot of cases. They do. They do. There's an example of this recently. There's a soccer player, we'd call it a football player or whatever, a guy called Jermaine Genas used to play for Tottenham, which is my team. And he became a TV presenter. And he got into a bit of a kerfuffle whereby he was found to have been sending embarrassing texts or unwanted texts to women there and he got fired, right?
18:43It's not the worst thing in the world, though. It wasn't some of the stuff the BBC did let people get away with, with the pedophilia stuff. It was just a guy who was a sports player sending messages like, that's going to happen. Okay, you got fired. Okay. And years later, he's tried to come back on and they had him on for an interview. This was actually on ITV, but it's a similar kind of thing. And they just went for him to the point that he was angry and it was good TV or whatever. But I said to his team, why didn't you get him on my show or a show like that where we don't and the difference is those it's not that those itv or bbc guys are necessarily evil people it's just that they have a lot to lose and if they seem to be you know going along with him or defending him or not going in really hard on him they will lose their jobs or they will be criticized so when you work in that kind of atmosphere dave rubin comes on the show or this guy who's been sending texts or i come on the show they've got to kill us because it's self-preservation.
19:39Yeah, it's so interesting. And what you just said there is so true. And for guys like us who see how the sausage is made, it's like I, when I'm interviewing someone, I try to get the most out of them, get the best out of them, learn from them, try if they don't know what they're talking about to give them enough room to hang themselves. But these guys, yeah, they go in like, sure. This video is sponsored by Kalshi where they know a little something about odds. Guys, it's like buying or selling a stock, except the line isn't set by some algorithm working against you, it moves based on where the money actually goes.
20:11It shows where people are putting their money, not what the media wants you to believe. So, which Hamas breeding grounds will see their rankings drop this year? I like this one. If you put$100 on, yes, Colombia, and we're talking about the university, not the country, you can earn$189 if correct. Download the Kalshi app and use code RUBENREPORT to get$10. When you trade$10, K-A-L-S-H-I, Call she, put your money where your prediction is. What do you think? I mean, the social media ban, you know, we keep seeing these videos of, you know, two young female police officers showing up at somebody's house to harass a seven-year-old for doing something on, what are they playing?
20:52Fortnite? Like what, yeah, Roblox, whatever. What is going on? I want to just say well done for that ad read because I don't think people realize that's all in one take. And most people can't do that without, you know, stuttering over their words. so i've been around the block you know you know what's going on um i think you spoke from the heart that's what it was so so yeah the it's it's hard to say because on the one hand you don't want to be you know pushing out this stuff like you know the uk's and you know you say one thing and the police come over because obviously that's not the case i'm here talking to you right now i i have this interview show where i go on about the ridiculousness of it all and i've never had an approach and it's all been okay so it's not yet at that point we do have a new prime minister called Andy Burnham, who does seem to be a little bit more to the left than the previous guy, whoever he was.
21:41And so it's worrying. Is it hard for you guys to remember? It's hard for us to remember. I mean, what, you've had, what, six prime ministers in eight years, something like that? It's nuts. Yeah. I mean, I had one of them who had the shortest time she came on the show, Liz Truss. Oh, Liz Truss. Yeah. I had her on. Yeah, Liz. Yeah, she was good. I liked her.
22:02I She's great. She's charismatic and interesting. And at least she's pushing against something. Although when they're in office, they never seem to do it. And then they come out and they say, oh, someone else stopped me from doing it. And they're all blaming each other. Because I spoke to Liz. I spoke to another politician here called Suella Braverman, who's very high up in reform. I spoke to a few of them. And each of them points the finger at the other because I say, how did you let so many people in? To give Americans in particular or non-Brits an idea, we were letting people in it was like 1.3 million i think that was net migration into the country so a lot of british people are leaving and a huge number of now 1.3 million is big in the states right in a country the size of the states in the uk where we've got 50 million people that is ridiculous that overnight that just that resets things entirely and that is year after year after year and it ends up being called the boris wave it was a wave of people who were brought in by Boris Johnson, who is a conservative who is supposed to be against this kind of stuff.
23:00So Lord knows what might have happened had a left-wing person been in at that time of like, bring everybody in that you can. But yeah, they all point at each other. They all say, well, we wanted to change this regulation and the legislation and we couldn't do it, but that person stopped me. And who knows what actually went on. I think the culture actually changed and people looked back and went, what the hell was that? And at the time it was like, we didn't yet have the effects of those millions of people. So it seemed like a reasonable idea. it's not helped the economy at all but as to your your question about um yeah the free speech stuff though i've spoken to one guy in particular uh who came on heretics and he was locked up for i don't know the exact number of hours but most of a day let's say so let's say it was somewhere between 12 and 20 hours he and his wife were locked up they came police there were like six or seven police officers came to his house and arrested both of them in front of their kids which is utterly traumatic.
23:51I mean, I would remember that now if that had happened to my kids when I was a kid. It's just a traumatic thing. What had he been doing? He had been in a school, high school WhatsApp group with all the other parents, and he was criticizing the school. He didn't use any swear words, bad words, cuss words, or anything like that. He didn't make any claims that were sort of really bad or whatever. It was just he was criticizing the school. The school found out about it. They told the police unfathomably. I don't know why. And the police, someone there was like, you know, what's a good use of our time right now?
24:24There's people being stabbed all over London, there's terrorists running amok. But this guy was criticizing the school, let's go and get him and they arrested him. So that's what happened to him? What happened to him? He got released. And I think he was at the last time I spoke to him, he was considering taking legal action against the police, you know, but then he's probably going to be in another WhatsApp group criticizing the police and he'll get arrested again for being in these WhatsApp groups. So that's the worst example. And the reason I didn't go for that first is because your viewers might already be familiar with it, although they may not be, is the Lucy Connolly example.
24:56Now, that's only really the worst example because people know about it. There must be many, many cases. Can you explain it a bit for some of the people that don't know? Lucy Connolly went... Okay, I'll tell what she did first. So this was after a guy called Axel Rudakabana. He was a second generation immigrant from Rwanda who the newspapers described as a Welsh choir boy. He didn't look like a Welsh choir boy, but fine. If you want to say someone who lives in the places, then fine, maybe he's Welsh. And I think some years earlier had attended a choir once, but he was this horrible, horrible guy who had an Al-Qaeda manual, among many other things, and went and stabbed a bunch of kids at a Taylor Swift themed to party uh in the uk on the on the coast somewhere um killed the kids right and the most horrific thing ever and at that point keir starmer the former prime minister who i was pretending to forget previously um he came out and blamed the far right the far right all the far right are doing it it's always their answer it's always the father and we mustn't we mustn't look back in anger they all say they use that oasis song without their permission because i doubt they'd be on board with this but don't look back in anger with we are angry we're very angry that this could happen now in that moment there were some people who took to the streets and sought it wasn't such a riot but but it was you know they held up placards and things a very small number of people who might be deemed far right it really wasn't a big number at all but suddenly it was this whole like oh the far right are going out and doing whatever they're doing and in all of that mess this woman called lucy connelly who had like no followers at all online no one knew who she was really, except she was married to a politician, but very minor.
26:35Nobody knew who these people were. She had lost a child through the NHS. So she had reason to hate the state, the NHS being the national health system. So she hates the state because she believes they made some sort of mistake that ended in the death of her own child. Then she is watching news about, because of the state bringing in so many people, one of them has killed loads of other children. Obviously, she's very emotional. She puts a post up. I think it was Facebook, although I keep hearing people talking about it being a tweet but i think i thought it was facebook a facebook post um saying something along the lines of uh i don't care anymore burn down the mosques for all i care now the for all i care is really important i think because it's saying do what you're going to do anyway for all i care it's not saying go and do it if someone were to go and burn a mosque i think it would be very very difficult to to put those two oh she he did it because he saw the facebook post.
27:23I mean, it's absurd. Anyway, she got taken to put on trial. She was pushed to plead guilty by the lawyers. She did delete it, right? If I'm not mistaken, I think she did delete it. That's a good point. I forgot to mention that. A few hours later, she deleted the post. She regretted putting the post up. And she went to, she pled guilty and she went to prison for 31 months. As you guys know, I recently banged up my shoulder and it's been a painful reminder of how quickly pain can get in the way of your everyday life. Whether it's your back, shoulders, knees, or just general muscle soreness from exercise and daily life, it can make doing the things you love a lot less enjoyable.
Read the full transcript
28:00And that's why I've been taking Relief Factor, although I'm not going to take it right now because I already took it today. It's a 100 % drug-free research-based formula with ingredients like omega-3, turmeric, resveratrol, icarin, black pepper, and more designed to help support your body's healthy response to inflammation and help reduce everyday discomfort. for it. And truly, since I've been taking it, like the aches and pains just kind of melt away. This year, as America celebrates 250 years of freedom, Relief Factor wants to help you declare your independence from everyday aches and pains.
28:31For a limited time, you can get their three-week quick start for just$17.76. That's$17.76 for the three-week quick start. It's ready for you right now. Visit relieffactor.com or call 1-800-4-RELIEF. So the short answer of the question is that the state of free speech is not that great. So since this is connected to immigration, obviously, every time I've had you on, this consistently comes up. And to nobody's surprise, you've talked about how it's gotten worse and worse over the years. Do you sense, as you just said, you now have another more lefty leader that there will be any re-immigration or a further closing of borders or that anything will get fixed?
29:17or is it just that every six months, Tommy Robinson will pull on a rally, it'll be called right wing, and then nothing will happen? A mix of the two, I think. I think to your earlier point about the cultishness of it, and I think we have reached a point finally, about 10 years too late, where even politicians on the left, they won't kind of admit it, but they're sort of talking in terms of, okay, we need to have stronger borders. Even those guys know that it's gone so bad and so wrong. What we want - Do you think they believe it? Because we have a version of that happening now with the progressives.
29:50Even the progressives, this Al Saeed, who at this point may be the Democratic nominee, I don't even know yet, or as we're taping this, he suddenly, and a bunch of them, Bernie, suddenly they're all like, oh yeah, we should have closed the border. We could have closed the border. We just don't like ICE. To me, it's completely disingenuous. It's like, no, you didn't care about it when it was happening and it was your guy in office. it's just like a trickery to make it seem that they're not as extreme as they are. Well, I guess what we don't know, particularly in the States, is whether this, you know, as you say, whether this is where they really mean it, because it was only a few years ago.
30:21I'm sure you've seen the kind of tweets and the speeches from Obama, Hillary Clinton. Oh, yeah. We've played all of them. Yeah. They were super firm about immigration. So it seemed like everyone knew everywhere. Like, obviously, obviously, you don't just open up the borders and let the whole third world into your country. then you don't have a country anymore and you can never turn that back it's the worst thing you can do ever for a country and so even the lefties knew that uh and it was like the last five ten years they didn't know what a man was or a woman was and they didn't know what borders were and this it was a post-modern reality we lived in so the hope is that those guys you just mentioned and that the lefties in the uk are finally realizing you know and there is a kind of resurgence particularly with this prime minister he is further to the left but he's also kind of of that uh north England, which is the kind of industrial manufacturing, working class, traditional, you know, that traditional left wingism might be making a return.
31:16And that kind of left wing is not like, hey, everybody come into the country. And also, we don't know what men and women are, you know. But do you think anyone will do anything? And by the way, I think this is a completely open-ended question from an American perspective, too. Like, I don't even know that my only hope, really, from an American perspective, and we don't have as big of a problem as you guys have, is that Trump, if the Republicans win the midterms and he knows he has two years left with nothing to worry about electorally, then he does all of the things that he really intended to do and really kicks tons of people out and, you know, and also has to deal with the homegrown thing, which I want to ask you about as well.
31:52Do you think, and that to me is a long shot anyway, despite all of the reasons that Trump's the only guy that can do it. So do you have any hope that, okay, fine, we get a lefty who's more of a working class lefty, but will he, will anyone actually do anything. My understanding is they are raising the standard for higher English requirements, right? 2027, that's supposed to come into effect. There are kind of earned settlements, things going on. There have been some lower skilled routes restricted. So there are things happening. There are all sorts of things happening. Even more so, if you look at the countries like Sweden, Sweden is like, look, the reason that I like to speak to you and come on your show, or why you might want to have me on here, is that the UK is kind of, this is what can happen to a bigger country in the US in just a few years' time.
32:40That's why people need to take stock. That's why they need to watch what's going on here. And then we have a smaller version that we can look to, which is Sweden. Ireland's another one as well. These are countries with tiny populations, you know, 5-10 million people. You bring in a million or 2 million over a few years, so sweden went from being one of the safest places in in europe in the world probably uh and being one of the highest trust societies a place where you know you lived in a remote area or a little village you left your doors open very high trust which i mean that stuff is gone in the us and the uk that's gone been gone a while now but in in sweden that was still there they have turned overnight to the point that it is now one of the highest for you know stabbings rapes all sorts of horrible horrible it's not a place i want to go to on holiday it used to be i don't want a vacation in sweden now and even the people on the left there in sweden and the right everywhere they are going nuts everyone is like what they're running around going what happened and they are implementing all sorts of things from what i can gather uh even i mean their government is now officially saying officially on record saying the things we've been saying which is that mass immigration created unemployment, criminality, honor-based oppression, and parallel societies.
33:54Their government says that. Their government says Swedish society is held together by language, self-sufficiency, citizenship duties, and respect for Swedish norms. These are things that would be considered far right, particularly in a place like Sweden. So I think it's that Sweden shows us it has to get so bad that it's unrecoverable for them to start actually implementing the things we need to implement. Right. But the question is, will they do anything? It's one thing to say all those things, but are you going to kick out? I don't know how many illegals are in Sweden, but like, are you going to go into Malmo and actually pick people up and take them out of the country?
34:25That's the real test. And I don't know what Western nation is willing to do that. That to me seems to be the issue. Deporting people is the thing because you seem to need to leave something called the European Convention of Human Rights to be able to do this. We left the EU, the European Union, but we've still got that convention going on. And people are concerned, if you leave that, do you not have human rights? Well, look, America's not part of the European Convention of Human Rights, and they have human rights there. So there are other ways we can have human rights without it coming from Brussels.
34:58And it seems that we need to leave that to be able to actually deport people, particularly because the argument can always be made that you're deporting them to places where they're going to be killed. Now, it was recently uncovered amazingly by the BBC, because nobody expected the BBC to do this. But the BBC actually did proper news reporting and they found that lawyers, human rights lawyers in the UK were advising refugees or supposed refugees in the UK to say they were gay so that they could stay. You know that moment when you text your whole team, hey, did anyone follow up with that customer?
35:29And all you get is silence. Maybe a thumbs up emoji two hours later. By then they've already moved on and that's when you realize you need a better system. That's why today's episode is sponsored by Quo, spelled Q-U-O, the business phone system built so you never miss a call. With Quo, all your calls, texts, and voicemails live in one place so anyone on your team can jump into a conversation, see the full history, and respond right away. It's the number one rated business phone system on G2, trusted by more than 90 ,000 businesses. You can set up in minutes on any device, keep your existing number, and add teammates as you grow.
36:05Quo's built-in AI agent can answer after-hours calls, respond to questions, and even book appointments so you never miss a lead. Always say hello with Quo. Try Quo for free, plus get 20 % off your first six months when you go to Quo.com slash Rubin. That's Q-U-O dot com slash Rubin. I mean, what a grotesque, disgusting thing. Yeah, I know. I know. Well, I wonder if they'd be willing to go so far. Right, exactly. Let's do one other slightly depressing state of the West stuff, and then let's end on some positivity. I mean, I am trying to be off the grid here, for God's sakes. What is the state of, you know, obviously, Rupert Lowe released the dossier and, you know, 250 ,000 young women that were raped.
36:54I mean, I read some of it. It's not just rape. I mean, as horrific as just rape would be. I mean, it's some of the most unimaginably evil things that aren't even worth... People can go check for themselves that they were doing to these girls, on top of the psychological torture and just all of this unbelievable evil stuff. Is anything going to come of it? No, because they're all saving their own hides. There's too many people who politically were involved by not saying anything. So again, I'm quite pessimistic. Maybe if you had Rupert on, he'd say, yes, we're pushing this through. We're going to have, you know, we're going to look into it.
37:27they're going to start arresting and deporting people. I feel so pessimistic about this stuff. I know how hard it is to infiltrate the heart of a cult. And that's what we have in Islam in the UK. Not obviously all Muslims, but there are some pockets, particularly in places like Birmingham, particularly in the north, there are all these towns where this was happening for so long. It happened over a period of decades. Now, people will say, and this is where Piers Morgan's logic kind of falls down here for me. And it's a shame because he's obviously a very intelligent guy. I know he has this kind of circus show, but he says like, hey, yeah, I do.
38:00It's a circus. Okay, well, you admit it. Fine. But there's some logical fallacies that I think like, wow, he does seem like a very bright guy and he doesn't seem to get it. He had one the other day you might have seen with Ben Shapiro. We was talking about free speech and he was having a go at Ben for saying, like for criticizing him and saying like, oh, Ben, I thought you liked free speech. And it was like, well, yeah, but free speech includes Ben's right to criticize you. To criticize, yes. Yeah, he's an absurd hypocrite. I'm so tired. He had so much potential to do good. And that show, when it first started, I think could have done a lot of good.
38:33And you and I have both done it. I told him to his face why I was never going to do it again. But he's just turned it into, it's just an endless shit show. And he flips his opinion on literally anything. And he blocked me on Twitter because I said that he would sell his mother to a jihadist for a click. So, you know, what are you going to do? But I still think I was right. It's a shame because there are other ways to get, you know, there are ways to get views without doing that. I mean, you and I don't have that. We don't have people screaming at each other and we get good views. He gets even bigger.
39:00He might argue he gets these huge views. Maybe that is the only way to do it. But I mean, Stephen Bartlett, Joe Rogan, they don't do that. So there are other ways to do it. And especially for him, because Pierce has covered so many other topics. He's done true crime. He's done going into prisons and doing the true crime stuff and getting huge views for that. So I don't know why he needs to have jenk coming on every time and just talking utter nonsense i mean i've been in this game long enough i think the answer is fairly obvious which is some people just love the fame thing more than anything else he loves the fame and and the money and but he can get fame and money other ways but but it would you have to work it's a pretty he's doing it in a pretty easy way actually like once you figure out the formula it's a pretty easy way you could start doing it more tomorrow and you'd see your views go up it's just but you have integrity i don't i just don't think it's that but I don't think it's very complex.
39:47Yeah. But nonetheless, I hate it. Yeah. Well, so that was the, but I think a lot of it, because I like the Hanlon's razor thing, you know, like people don't do things out of evil. I think it's stupidity. And Pierce isn't stupid, but I think he has these blind spots. So one of them was that issue of free speech. And the other one, oh, shoot, I forgot what the point was now. No, I've forgotten what it was. Well, probably about immigration or, oh, about the rape gangs, probably. It is the rape gangs, right. So yeah, he doesn't seem to get the pro rata. He doesn't understand pro rata or per capita.
40:14He doesn't get it. And he's been explained this. So I don't know what's going on in his, I'd love to know what's going on in his mind. It has been explained to him so many times, every single time he responds that, well, there are way more white people who have raped, you know? And you go, yeah, but not pro rata, not per capita, like not by a long, long, long, long way. It is Pakistani rape gangs, not just all Muslim people. It is particularly Pakistani, mostly a belief from the Kashmiri region of Pakistan. We take too many people from a very specific, incredibly impoverished part of Pakistan.
40:45The Muslims that America takes in tend to be from different parts. So a lot of Americans don't get this. They go, oh, I've got a friend who's a Muslim. They're very nice. They adapt. And they don't get it. It depends where. And from where we're getting them, it's like low quality ones, unfortunately. And it's a per capita issue. And the other issue is when white people have done it, they get arrested and locked up. Whereas with the rape gangs, for decades, they were allowed to do this because the police didn't want to infiltrate and arrest people for fear of being racist. And also, I imagine, because it was just too difficult, it's too hard to go into these kind of basically ganglands and do this.
41:22So they just left it. That is a huge issue. And so as Rupert Lowe says, because of that, because of their failure to act, hundreds of thousands of mostly white girls have been raped, had their lives torn apart and ruined. And what happens now? Nothing. People just get on with it. And if anyone mentions it, they're racist. So now I give you the challenge, which is to paint a positive vision of the future for your country and then for mine.
41:52Yeah. The thing is to get the things done. Or just do mine. Yeah, your one. Mine is easier. It's a lot easier. Yours is much easier. I mean, look, the issue, I've looked into this and I've tried to think about why it is that certain countries succeed and others don't. And there's loads about philosophy and history and so on. But in particular, the UK, the US, and I would probably say Germany, are among the countries that economically and culturally have been above the rest. They've stood out above the rest around the world. And it's hard for me as an atheist to admit this, but this is Protestantism.
42:23This is not Catholicism. So what you are then importing from all the South American. This is the negative part first. This is Catholicism, right? Well, Catholicism in Europe, you look at Ireland, Spain, Portugal, they've never done anywhere near as well economically and culturally. So there is something in that, I think. And I've had it explained to me from much cleverer people than me about why that might be. And when I've been in South America, you know, I lived there like eight years, eight, nine years. I lived in Argentina and Colombia for some time. When I've been there, they joke all the time about, gosh, you know, wouldn't it have been great if the Brits had invaded us and colonized us rather than the Spanish?
42:57We'd be like Australia now, would be like the US now. It just stands to reason, and they know this, that if you import millions and millions and millions from those places to your place, then you become like them. I was on Jeremy Boring the other day. He calls it the third worldization of America. That is what is happening. The positive side is that the Muslims that you import, as I said before, do seem to be of better stock or more likely to want to be part of your country. I would be wary because it is a fact. Someone put up a scale. There's some sort of scale whereby the number of Muslims in a country affects how they talk publicly.
43:34So at the moment, they're all going to be in America going, yeah, we can be part of this society. And then once they get to like - That's starting to crack pretty quickly with Mamdami and some of these other guys. But yes, I'll generally go with you. Suddenly blasphemy laws start to come in. You can't burn a Quran? Why don't we get more rights? And so on, that starts to happen. And yeah, it gets a bit shitty. What I would say is, I cannot see Americans, particularly because you're armed, lying down the way that Europe has done when this gets really bad, particularly in places, I know it's happening a lot to Texas right now, but eventually the Texans are going to kick off.
44:10Florida is a good example. I think you guys are going to stand up and kick off. The other thing is the people you're importing mostly, they're not going to stand for this either, right? The South Americans. So as much as the South Americans are kind of changing American culture in a way that I don't think is positive necessarily, as much as I love South Americans, my wife is South American. I love those guys, but I don't think that they, you know, I was in America. Everything's in Spanish. I speak Spanish. I'm happy, but everything's in Spanish there. It's ridiculous. It's ridiculous. That is an American country.
44:38What's going on? But those guys actually would be a pretty good defense. You know, those Mexicans and Hondurans, they don't want lots of Muslims coming to their country. So I think in many respects, you guys are set up in a better way. And America's history is about you come to this place, you assimilate, and you can become part of it. Mamdani can't be there forever. And how much influence does he really have as a mayor? You know, it's not that he's president. So that's the positive for America. And then we can just all move over. You'd maybe take a lot. But if you take a lot of us, how do you filter out the bad guys?
45:09Yeah, I don't, you know, I keep telling you, I'll give you a job. We could, it could be a sister show. I'm happy to help in some way, but I can't help everybody. You know what I mean? I know. Thanks, Dave. There's also my uncle so-and-so wants to come. I'll see what I can do for you. Andrew, it is always a pleasure. Enjoy your August. And hopefully the world did not burn too much while I was gone. And we'll pick this up in the fall. Thanks, man. Thank you. If you want a more worldly perspective on current events, check out our international playlist. And if you want to watch full interviews on a wide variety of topics, watch our full episode playlist all right over here.
45:47And to get notified of all future videos, be sure to subscribe and click the notification bell.
From the publisher
Dave Rubin of "The Rubin Report" talks to Andrew Gold about how political tribalism and social media echo chambers can resemble cult psychology; why women are more likely to be drawn into cults; lessons from Scientology and NXIVM about conformity, status, belonging, and why intelligent people become trapped in ideological bubbles; why people often abandon cult-like movements only after being personally mistreated; how October 7 challenged some progressive Jews' beliefs; the growing threat of internet censorship and government control of social media; the UK's push to favor "trustworthy" legacy media like the BBC over independent YouTube creators; how bots, foreign influence, and online ID verification could reshape internet freedom; how institutional pressure influences mainstream media coverage; the worsening immigration crisis in the UK and Europe; why even left-wing politicians are beginning to support stronger borders; how mass immigration transformed Sweden's high-trust society and contributed to crime and parallel societies; why deportations remain difficult under European human rights rules; concerns about assimilation and national identity; and much more.
Today's Sponsors:
Kalshi - Download the Kalshi app and use code RUBINREPORT to get $10 when you trade $10 or go to https://kalshi.com/r/RUBINREPORT DISCLAIMER: 18+ only. Restrictions and eligibility requirements apply. Event contract trading involves risk and may not be suitable for all investors. Prices, values, and available markets may differ from those mentioned. For more information see kalshi.com/regulatory.
Relief Factor - Relief Factor is an alternative to help your body's natural inflammatory response so you can keep doing the things you love. Try Relief Factor's 3-Week QuickStart—just $19.95 Go to: https://www.relieffactor.com or call 800-4-RELIEF.
Quo- Never miss an important business call again. Try QUO for free PLUS get 20% off your first 6 months. Go To: http://www.quo.com/RUBIN

