

Aaron Pierre discusses how he plays cautious, trauma-shaped characters who ration vulnerability, focusing on HBO Max’s Lanterns (as Jon Stewart) and his portrayal of Malcolm X in Genius. He also talks about fear, responsibility, and the craft choices behind calm outward behavior masking internal intensity.
Actor Aaron Pierre; previously cast by Barry Jenkins as Cesar Garner in The Underground Railroad; played Malcolm X (El-Haj Malik El-Shabazz) in Genius; seen in Netflix’s Rebel Ridge; now stars as Jon Stewart in Lanterns.
Pierre says many roles involve learning to manage anxiety and mortality, and that “multiple things can be true at once” (gentle exterior, internal fire). He describes Lanterns as two “chapters” (episodes 1-4: not fully realized; 5-8: fully grounded).
Terry’s relaxed reunion with his cousin then “walls go up” in Rebel Ridge; Jon’s calibrated vulnerability and near-nonexistent arm-raising early on; Malcolm’s smile as a deliberate, selective act; Pierre getting ill during Malcolm’s six-to-seven-month Atlanta shoot and refusing to move on until satisfied.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on Aaron Pierre's roles and approach to character complexity.
“and even this appends to your Casio, a way of not letting people in until you feel like you can trust them.”
Aaron shares his experience and challenges in playing Malcolm X.
“and he's sort of taking the person in rather than offering them this sort of almost Roman coin version of who Malcolm X is.”
Aaron Pierre discusses his approach to taking on unnerving roles and the importance of overcoming fear through his work.
“Do you seek these out or do they come to you like this?”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On The Treatment, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00From KCRW Santa Monica and KCRW.com, it's The Treatment.
0:13Welcome to The Treatment. I'm Elvis Mitchell. I had a chance to see my guest, the actor Aaron Pierre, in a production of Othello at The Globe almost 10 years ago, where he caught the attention of one Barry Jenkins, who cast him as Cesar Garner in The Underground Railroad. Since then, he's played Malcolm X in Genius. We've most recently seen him in, of course, Rebel Ridge on Netflix and the miniseries Lanterns on HBO Max. First of all, it is a pleasure to have you sitting here with me. I'm so happy to have you here, Aaron. And one of the things I want to talk to you about as an actor is you have, and even this appends to your Casio, a way of not letting people in until you feel like you can trust them.
0:54Your characters do that a lot, don't they? They do. There is somewhat of a recurring theme with some of the characters that I portray, specifically as it relates to what you said, you know, being perhaps cautious or tentative when treading the road of trust and partnership and union. Interesting. So many of these guys have been military men. You know, Cassio, Terry in Rebel Ridge, Jon Stewart in Lanterns. And I think watching you play these guys, and again, I think this also, we can say it's a big part of Caesar too, is that it's a matter of they've been through so much, and that becomes subtext certainly in Cassio and in Terry, but they've been through so much that the people they trust, I mean, their faces opened up.
1:48When we see Terry with his cousin on that stretch of road, even though he's really killing himself to keep up on the bike, his body is relaxed. He's happy to see him. And as soon as he goes back to that town, the walls go up with John until he really gets to know how. And because it's fragmented, I don't want to ask you about playing that because I'm sure you didn't do it in a chronological order. Correct, yeah. So we should say these are two Green Lanterns. And it's been compared, I guess, to a few other HBO series, but it actually reminds me, there's an old DC comic, Green Lantern, Green Arrow, where they're going through the country.
2:24And it's actually where John Stewart was introduced. And it's just about these guys trying to figure out who they are in relationship to each other. And that's what it is for John, is he's trying to figure out who he is in relationship to how, but also in relationship to that town. So yeah, I think there are a number of things going on with John in the series Lanterns. I think one of the things is, in my mind, it's a series of two chapters as it relates to John. I would say episodes one through four is chapter one. There we discover a John who is, don't misunderstand me, He is certainly seasoned in all of the things that he is seasoned in.
3:11He's not brand new to the world and the way the world works and conflict and relationships and power dynamics. But he is certainly not fully realized, as it were. He hasn't fully discovered who he is. He's been through a lot and has evolved through those experiences, but he's certainly still a young enough man that he hasn't yet figured out exactly who Jon Stewart is. Episodes five through eight is chapter two, as I sort of looked at it when I was approaching the script. That's Jon Stewart as the fully realized man. Of course, you can never sort of perfect life, but he is much more comfortable in his stride.
4:04He's much more grounded. He has a deeper clarity about who he is and how that individual will navigate through the world. It's interesting you say this because these guys, and certainly we say this about Caesar, are all guys who've gone through a trauma that keeps them, in fact, they don't want to be seen in some ways. And so this mantle of John having a place on his shoulder, he really in some ways wants to recede because as you were talking about this in episodes five through eight, we see him asking more questions because he wants to be able to take information in rather than be judged when he walks into a situation.
4:42And the way you play that, like, I don't want this spotlight yet. Yeah, John is such a unique character. And I really, I really have loved portraying him because not only has it been just a wonderful exercise for me creatively and artistically, I also think that it highlights something that I believe to be very true, which is that multiple things can be true at once. things can coexist in equal measure and things that are perhaps seemingly juxtaposed, they actually don't need to be mutually exclusive. And I think for John, he is somebody who is, yes, he is gentle. Yes, he is composed. He's precise.
5:30He's measured. He's empathetic. But at the same time, this young man is internally, he is a fire, he is a sort of treacherous sea internally. And for me, it was the unique challenge was how do I portray somebody who internally is managing and navigating well or not well, that's subjective, but managing that, but his outward is so calm. How do you do that? You know what I mean? And that was a lot of fun. That was a lot of fun for me. You know, there are characters who have that internal world and their external world is very similar. And that's arguably easier to portray because it's just one thing.
6:17But how do you play two things that are seemingly opposites at the same time? You know, I really enjoyed that. We're talking about playing complexities and contradictions with my guest, Aaron Pierre, who's one of the stars of the show Lanterns on HBO. It's the treatment. There's calibrations in the amount of vulnerability that John will show. We finally see it in the last episode with his mother when she finally sort of says, I don't want to give too much away. Because it's really a show that demands a close watch because you were talking about these chapters. And in episode one, we see sort of chapter one and chapter five simultaneously because there's a wraparound of sort of the present day John Stewart in that episode.
6:59That is correct. That's why I was asking you about figuring out how to calibrate. How much work do you do? How much of this is annotated in script about I'm playing him here? Because in those first few episodes, he almost never raises his arms. He's really like at attention. Yes, very much so. Yeah, I think it was a real joy to have that challenge presented to me. I think in that first episode, there is a moment where you get to see John 10 years ahead of where we've understood him to be. It's 2016, John, and 2026, John. For me, I'd made such a distinct decision about who these two individuals were and the point in John's journey that they were at.
7:46So for me, it was a clear shift and I knew exactly which chords I was shifting. If I had to say which one I enjoyed portraying more, to be honest with you, I have to say, I mean, I loved every moment of all of it, but I really loved portraying John in episodes five to eight. John episodes five to eight is a more liberated version of John. and he is more unapologetic about his existence and he is more unapologetic about what it is to be inherently flawed as we all are. We're going to take a break and let my guests hydrate. It's the treat that we're talking to Aaron Pierre. He's starring in the HBO Max series Lantern.
8:33Stay with us. More will come.
8:39It's the treatment my guest who's swallowing right across from me is Aaron Pierre. He's starring in the series Lanterns on HBO Max, among other things. And I want to talk about your Malcolm for a minute. Because I'm really aware of how he doles out smiles. There's a decision. You can see him deciding who's going to get this. And it gets back to this thing we were talking about in the first half, about how you measure the way these characters offer up vulnerability. And this is somebody who is so aware of everything around him all the time. I mean, you talk about, you've played so many characters who are really wary.
9:13He is the most watchful of anybody you've played, I think. His antennae are always up. And so I was really aware of how sort of his shoulders drop when he smiles, and he's sort of taking the person in rather than offering them this sort of almost Roman coin version of who Malcolm X is. That's an extraordinary performance. Thank you, sir. And I want to ask you about that, because also there's a musicality in the way he speaks. We talked about chords before. He's very aware of the power of pause and stopping in the middle of a sentence, which you do a lot of. Some people kind of, yeah, what are you going to say next?
9:49Yeah. No, it's, oh, man. It is the greatest privilege to have had the opportunity to portray El-Haj Malik, El-Shabazz, Malcolm X. And that experience, that six, seven months in Atlanta, which is where we filmed, was transformative, not only for me as an artist, as a creative, as a storyteller, but also as a young man. It was transformative. What was it like when you got the news that you had that role? What did that do to you? Oh, my goodness. I was terrified. I'm speaking plainly. Were you? I was terrified. Yeah, of course. Because he is a hero of mine. He's a hero of many. And I was terrified about the idea of being selected out of however many individuals were up for consideration.
10:46And that being on my shoulders, that portrayal as it related to that particular series being on my shoulders. You should say this is the fourth season of the series, Genius. Correct. and it's sort of about the journeys of Dr. King and Malcolm X but it's also about him understanding that his time was limited. I mean, that's a big part of this performance and it gets one of these things I wanted to ask you about, Aaron, which is the way you choose to play, the way your characters deal with fear and mortality because it's been an issue. I mean, certainly as a person of color, we know about this but it's been something that you brought to the fore in all of these roles, how these characters are going to deal with this fact that they're exposed.
11:33I think it's maybe why they choose to dole out their vulnerability so specifically because they're on the front lines in so many ways. Right, right. I think it's something that was really unique and interesting about my process portraying Malcolm was I'm certainly not a method actor, never have been, But with every role, I do feel the enormity of the responsibility. And I felt that especially with Malcolm. And I actually got ill during shooting because of the weight of that responsibility. And I remember speaking to a colleague of mine and saying, you know, I don't know why it happened. And they said, you know, I know exactly why it happened because you are an individual who lives with the responsibility of the character you're portraying inside the context of action and cut, but also outside of it.
12:31And you live with it until we wrap. And she was absolutely correct. I was living with it the whole six months. You know, I felt that weight, the enormity of that weight and responsibility, but it was, it was such an evolution for me and, um, and such an education. I'm always deeply passionate about every character that I have the privilege of portraying. But with Malcolm, I remember I respectfully and, and, you know, politely and professionally, of course, always, but like there was, there were moments where I had to say to whoever was in front of me, whether it was the director or the producer, I said, I cannot move on until I feel satisfied.
13:13I'm a little bit more easygoing with that in other projects. You know, if the director says we've got it, I'm like, okay, we got it. But with that, I couldn't move on until I was totally satisfied. Well, we're talking about dealing with anxiety with my guest. Right, exactly. He's one of the stars of Lanterns on HBO Max. It's the treatment. but I do find myself thinking about the way these characters at some point accept the mantle of because in some way they all are chosen, these guys, you know. Absolutely. And almost none of them wanted it, but it was thrust upon. It's really this mission that's been bestowed upon them, isn't it?
13:55Yeah, it's a mission. It's a mission. And in almost every case. Yeah, yeah. Do you seek these out or do they come to you like this? You know, these roles have, you know, been presented to me. And I think each of them have been really unnerving when they've been presented, I think. But, well, no, I think, I know I've been very unnerved when I've been presented with these opportunities. But I have a history, whether it's in the context of my career or outside of the context of my career, I have a history of actively seeking out things that unnerve me and scare me because I want to overcome that fear.
14:36I want to overcome that anxiety. You know, it's part of the reason I'm such a sincere and passionate student of martial arts, because I like to be a student of things that you can never perfect. And I like to be a student of things that unnerve me because of the size of it, the enormity of what it is to embark on those undertakings. you played so many of these characters who are in effect in their own world's superheroes oh was it like to actually get to play a superhero oh it was so much fun it was so much fun i really had a great time it was you know we as as a as a cast and a crew and just as a team on lanterns we were like a traveling company i've said this a bunch of times but you know we spent maybe 20 15 of the time was on the lot um which i love by the way love the wb lot you know we were out on the road, man, we were like a traveling company.
15:33One day we're, you know, we're in Barstow. The next day we're, you know, in the desert. It was, it was, it was great. And we just, we just became a family. And I remember right when we were coming to the end of, um, of this project, you know, we'd been, we'd been on, on the road doing this for about six months, a hundred and something days in. And we were like, you know what, whatever the result of this is none of our business. Like we love this and we know unequivocally, like we know that we have given everything to this and couldn't have given more even if we tried. And that was enough for us.
16:20And I think you can feel it when you watch it. You know, somebody gave me a great, like somebody gave me a wild statistic the other day and they said something like, you know, we averaged 19.3 million viewers per episode for a first season. And it was, it's in the top five ever of HBO debuts, of home box office since its conception. And I think that is indicative. Firstly, thank you to everybody who watched. Secondly, I think it's indicative of that, the fact that audience members were able to identify that our hearts were in this. We had given it all. the funny thing about Hal versus John is that Hal is playing a hero he's basically playing it he's he's acting it out as if you were basically in the high school play he's doing all these things that hey look I'm a hero he makes a point of entering even when he comes at the guest of the car it's an entrance he can't help but be that and you could play in the similar because of having seen you do Cassie I know you can do what feels like speedy dialogue and make it feel like repartee and that could have been the relationship too because there's certainly enough verbal clashes between the two of them but there is a i'm not going to let this guy judge me the way he wants me to judge him i'm not going to give him that satisfaction so that becomes this kind of interesting almost reverse chemistry but it's a compelling relationship to watch yeah i think it's i think that's something that you know kyle and i identified kyle chandler yes of course yeah um Kyle Chandler and I, you know, we identified that almost immediately about these characters.
17:58There is a musicality to their relationship. It's interesting because those notes, those chords, they can be played in a plethora of different ways. But we found it would be most conducive to allowing the audience to understand the nature of their relationship if it was in that particular way. And it was a lot of fun to do. It was a lot of fun to do. And I think those who are, you know, those upstairs, as it were, you know, they knew that each time we did a take, it was going to be completely different to the prior one. And we would probably never do that take we just did in that way ever again.
18:42But they trusted that in that discovery, in that workshopping, we were never going to derail the project or derail the story or take it in a direction that it wasn't planned to be heading in. And that was a lot of fun because, you know, for me, I love to be spontaneous. I love to be unpredictable within the context of the work and within the context of bringing sincerity and genuine authenticity to these characters. I remember doing Brother with Clement Virgo, who is, I think, an exceptional filmmaker. And, you know, he and I are actually going to be, we're actually working on something new at the moment.
19:25I don't know why I said that because I can't say too much more. But, you know, that was a beautiful relationship. Well, that can just get away the second season of Lanterns. You can't say anything about work with Clement. You're just talking about something else. Yeah, exactly. But, you know, when we were on Brother, there was, and I was portraying this character, Francis, and we just developed a relationship with one another as director and actor where I would be able to say to Clement in moments, Clement just you know please just ensure that you know the DOP and you know ACAM and BCAM whoever is on me they just roll with me I might go completely off script but just know that I'm always going to come back to it and like that I love that I love that that the element of improvising I love that the element and the energy of spontaneity sometimes there's nothing in there but one thing.
20:16But the one thing that's in there is everything. Well, before he violates any of his NDAs, I'm going to say thank you to Aaron Pierre, who's starring in Lanterns on HBO, one of the biggest hits there, among many other things. Please come back and do the show again. Yes, absolutely. I would love to. Thank you so much, man. This has been a joy.
20:43It's in the way he moves actor Aaron Pierre has kept our attention by playing characters who often have to figure out who they are while they're on the run from his roles in The Underground Railroad to Rebel Ridge to starring as the newest member of the Green Lantern Corps Jon Stewart on HBO's series Lanterns. Creators on the move, catch conversations with them at the archive, kcrw.com slash thetreatment. And catch creators on movement and inspiration in their lives at kcrw.com slash thetreat. This week, thetreat comes from writer-director Jonathan Goldstein, whose latest project with partner John Francis Daly is Apple TV's film Mayday.
21:30He looks at the singular focus of one of TV's greatest and spookiest writer-producers. We move into focus every week thanks to Rebecca Mooney, who produces and edits the show, and Katie Gilchrist, who mixes it. For better days, everyone, I'm Elvis Mitchell. It's The Treatment.
22:01KCRW Sponsor Focus Features presents Elsinore, starring Andrew Scott and Olivia Colman. The winner of Audience Awards around the world, critics hail Andrew Scott delivers the best performance of the year. Elsinore, rated R, now playing in select theaters, in theaters everywhere December 4th. Discover it in Dolby Cinema. Midlife brings a lot of changes. Your Turn with Alison Aubrey is a new podcast to help you navigate the twists and turns. From health and relationships to creativity and purpose, we can help steer your next chapter. With Your Turn with Alison Aubrey. Find it on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.
Actor Aaron Pierre is no stranger to playing characters larger than life, both real and fictional. He starred as Caesar Garner in the 2021 miniseries 'The Underground Railroad,' he portrayed Malcolm X in 'Genius' (2024) and most recently, Pierre took on John Stewart (aka Green Lantern) in the DCU series 'Lanterns' on HBO.
Pierre tells The Treatment about Stewart's evolution over the course of season one of 'Lanterns;' he tells of the thrill of playing a superhero, and he explains why he gave his portrayal of Malcolm X everything he had.