

The episode connects a chaotic week of major tech outages (“everything fell apart”) to broader themes of brittleness in AI-era infrastructure, plus a side discussion of Apple HomeView’s limitations and NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang’s controversy.
No external guests are interviewed; the hosts are David Pierce and Nilay Patel.
David Pierce and Nilay Patel are technology journalists/podcast hosts at The Verge, covering consumer tech, enterprise software, and major industry events.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
David and Nilay discuss the chaos of recent travel experiences.
“There was so much rain in San Francisco yesterday that started, like, literally as my plane was taking off.”
The hosts share their thoughts on the anticipation for GTA 6.
“We should start with the world falling apart, but we have two very quick things we should talk about beforehand.”
Discussion around opinions and takes on GTA 6 from various media.
“I was saying to our team yesterday, it's sort of sad that no reviewer on the internet just decided to zag and be like, actually this game sucks.”
An in-depth conversation about Apple's HomeView and its limitations.
“Like there's just an old iPhone on a MagSafe charger and it has the various scene buttons on it and you can take it off that and make FaceTime calls with it.”
Exploring the integration challenges of smart home devices and services.
“Right, like the power over Ethernet mount is not even out yet and I think it's$129.”
Discussion on Apple's challenges in smart home technology integration.
“Like that, you can do that with Cloud Code today.”
Overview of multiple technological outages and their implications.
“If Apple was smart, they would have moved heaven and earth to get Ring to integrate its doorbells with HomeView.”
Insights into vulnerabilities and the rush to patch systems.
“And I also sort of feel like even if you add up all of the relatively small, explainable, benign things, something big is still happening here.”
Comparison between current cybersecurity fears and the Y2K crisis.
“He also called critical digital infrastructure the dial tone for the world, which is wild.”
Discussion on the decline in qualified tech professionals and its effects.
“is all of that stuff just swirls together, right?”
Analysis of Elon Musk's political statements and implications for governance.
“The systems are not ready to take over for the people who are gone.”
Explore the implications of Elon Musk's actions on government efficiency and public perception.
“to the extent that Elon Musk can project humility.”
Discuss how recent events have exposed vulnerabilities in the economy and technology.
“the brittleness of another system, which is NVIDIA and Jensen Watt.”
Discuss how recent events have exposed vulnerabilities in the economy and technology.
“AWS AI is powering transformation across the world's leading organizations.”
Discussion about the implications of Jensen Wong possibly returning to NVIDIA amid allegations.
“Including a board chair for the first time.”
Exploration of the SEC investigations into NVIDIA and their export controls to China.
“actually it is the ways in which NVIDIA might have been systematically allowing or participating in the smuggling of chips to China against the law of the United States.”
Analysis of the board's decisions regarding Jensen Wong and the impact on NVIDIA's corporate culture.
“This is so clearly the thing and is going to be the fight that the affairs are going to be whatever.”
Reflections on NVIDIA's financial stability and the impacts of their leadership changes.
“recording this on the day of Anthropics IPO, which we don't have to over talk about.”
Discussion on the IPO of Anthropic and the general market response to AI-related investments.
“that closed before all of this went down.”
Debate over the balance between profitability in AI and ethical considerations.
“And I think the one of the worries And I think one of the reasons so many people in tech have rushed to protect and continue to lionize Jensen Wong is because, A, they're afraid of the same things coming for them.”
Discussing the impact of financial changes in the AI industry.
“the CFO and she was just the most business about it.”
Examining the fallout from Brendan Carr's chief counsel nomination.
“It is once again time for America's favorite podcast and their podcasts.”
A humorous critique of Brendan Carr and his approach to regulation.
“going to have made an enemy of Congress, the very body that provides him his authority by statute.”
An analysis of Google’s confusing product naming and strategy decisions.
“I've come to see Brennan Carr is a dummy as like a severance experience.”
A deep dive into the inefficiencies of Google's Tasks and Gemini structures.
“at google which just resolutely refuses to have a product strategy that makes any sense and uh this week's version is google you'll remember a little while ago launched a thing called Spark AI.”
A discussion on the privacy implications and functionality of Siri Recaps.
“It just can't ship a coherent set of products to save its life.”
Discussion on the technical limitations of audio summarization and its implications.
“ought to ought to solve so the technical solution is one you can schedule it so it only operates during work hours or only operates in your office and that's part of the setup flow and then two it is nerfed, right?”
Sharing humorous anecdotes about Siri's inaccurate recaps of personal events.
“This is Apple just like appling itself into such a corner.”
Evaluating the practical utility of Siri Recaps and its shortcomings.
“And I don't think the benefit of this product, of Siri Recaps, is anywhere close.”
Examining societal privacy issues arising from constant audio recording devices.
“And you're like, this isn't good enough for me to feel like I'm recording everyone.”
Insights into Amazon's plans for a comprehensive shopping database and its implications.
“And setting that aside, the, I already recorded you and you're, you, the idea is that you will object when you see me double click a watch with the most subtle animation you've ever seen in your life.”
Discussions on how AI summarization affects information quality and economic incentives.
“Because Amazon has a giant ad business that no one ever thinks about.”
Discussion on Google's monopoly and the implications for alternative search engine competitiveness.
“Google last week told a bunch of schools that they could not turn off AI overviews without also disabling Google search, which is just the most monopoly coded thing anyone has ever heard.”
Explore the challenges and opportunities for search engines like Google and Bing in education.
“That is actually, it's very important that your product be hard to leave in a way that I'm not sure Google search is hard to leave.”
Discuss the impact of technology on children's education and parental attitudes towards it.
“And that will be the first time we've seen that happen in scale.”
Get insights on recent podcast episodes and the importance of reporting in the tech industry.
“There's a metronome app on it now for her violin practice.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On The Vergecast, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Nilay Patel: Support for the show comes from Jira by Atlassian. Your work is scattered. A thread here, a DM there, docs everywhere. And it's not only your team searching for context, your AI agents need it too. Jira taps Atlassian's teamwork graph to bring that context together across Jira, Confluence, Slack, GitHub, and more. And makes it easy to share with agents you already use, like Claude, Cursor, and GitHub Copilot. Assign them work directly or connect your agents through MCP. The result? Less token waste, more accuracy, and more time moving forward. Learn more at Jira.com. That's J-I-R-A dot com.
0:47Nilay Patel: Support for the show comes from Bill. When it comes to managing money, forget the hype and look at results. Bill has a trillion dollars of secure payments powering their Bill Pay tools. Instead of just moving money, Bill is powering the financial operations of nearly half a million customers. So stop the guesswork and start scaling with the proven choice. Ready to talk with an expert? Visit bill.com slash proven to get started and grab a$150 gift card as a thank you. Terms and conditions apply. See offer page for details. Support for the show comes from ServiceNow. Now. AI is moving fast across the enterprise, but without visibility, it's just chaos.
1:31Nilay Patel: Different tools, different models, different teams using AI in completely different ways. ServiceNow turns that chaos into control. With the AI control tower, you see all your AI across the business in one place. What it's doing, what it's done, and what it's about to do. So you stay in control. To put AI to work for people, visit servicenow.com.
1:59David Pierce: hello and welcome to the verge cast the flagship podcast of configuration errors i'm your friend david pierce nila patel is here hello sir it feels like your configuration era is that you try to configure out of you i spent most of two days trying to get this thing to update its software but i also feel like you you've been traveling across the country this week in a like surprisingly precarious moment to be traveling across the country uh did you get
2:25Brendan Carr: into any snafus over the last few days trying to travel everyone is constantly surprised that i'm where i'm supposed to be which is just like not a normal way that people interact with you as a human being where they're like are you in san francisco and you're like i'm here i'm like what a surprise and then i got a text last night they're like did you get out of san francisco and i'm like yeah i'm in new york i'm like amazing and it's like very confusing um but yeah all All the airlines went down. There was the ground stop. United went down. There was so much rain in San Francisco yesterday that started, like, literally as my plane was taking off.
2:57Brendan Carr: I don't know if you saw this. There was a leak at Microsoft Ignite, and they had to clear the Moscone Center. And amazing. This is amazing video. The leak was, like, totally centralized just on the Meta booth. Like, in the most karmic possible way. Like, just water was pouring on the Meta booth in the middle of the Moscone Center. Just bad vibes all around.
3:19David Pierce: Yeah. You can feel however you want about the existence of higher powers, but sometimes the evidence is stronger than others. You know what I mean?
3:25Brendan Carr: Every video of this on every social site that I've seen is like, well, yeah, it's raining on the meta booth. Yeah.
3:30David Pierce: We should start with the world falling apart, but we have two very quick things we should talk about beforehand. One, a thing I genuinely don't know about you. Are you a GTA guy? Like, is GTA 6 downloading on your PS5 right now as we speak?
3:41Brendan Carr: The baby woke up at 2.30 in the morning last night, and so I was awake at 2.30 in the morning trying to get the baby to go back to sleep. And in that moment, I used the PS app on my phone to begin the GTA 6 download. So it's waiting for me on the PS5. I've not had a chance to play yet.
3:57David Pierce: Are you normally a GTA guy? Like, is this a moment in your life?
4:00Brendan Carr: I'm a Vice City guy. I think Vice City was my high water mark for GTAs. It was like the most fun I've ever had. Like, the needle drops in Vice City, like when they first hit the scene, just the 80s music being on the game. I mean, that was like a cultural watershed moment, I think. Like a truly important moment in video game history. I played GTA 5 through, but I never did like the online multiplayer. I never did the boss of that. So I'm excited that GTA 6 is launching as a deep single player game because that fits my vibe. And everything I've seen about it so far seems amazing.
4:33David Pierce: Yeah, I cannot believe how universal the praise for this game has been. I was saying to our team yesterday, it's sort of sad that no reviewer on the internet just decided to zag and be like, actually this game sucks. like you need the one person who is like let me tell you all the reasons all of you clowns are wrong and they wasted a billion dollars and this game sucks that's still out there someone should
4:52Brendan Carr: do it kudos to you can i can i tell you that the single funniest gta 6 take i've heard so far it was on ms now this morning and i i you know i did my best to convince them that everyone plays video games it's not just kids right there kids are so excited like no everyone's excited like the american economy has come to a pause today because everyone is going to play this game and it will echo through culture. And then one of the other panelists was like, I heard GTA is woke now. And I was like, no, no, no, no, no.
5:26Brendan Carr: That's amazing. They just make fun of everyone. And like the manosphere is like a really easy target. So that's what you got.
5:33David Pierce: That's just the group of people who got the maddest at being made fun of.
5:36Brendan Carr: This is an equal opportunity, literal shotgun blast with the culture. But it was just like, I was like, no, no, that's not it.
5:42David Pierce: that's not the one yeah it's dark woke is actually what it is i did offer for the next time i went on
5:50Brendan Carr: cable news to just bring a ps5 and just instead of saying anything just like play gta with them it was not they didn't take me up on it i think that might go over big you should you should give
5:58David Pierce: that another try uh thing number two did you get a home view you and i haven't really talked about
6:01Brendan Carr: the home view since it we have not talked about the home view um i've not gotten a home view i from everyone that i've talked to including you uh this is it's not going to be better than the old iPhone I have mounted on a MagSafe charger in the corner of my kitchen that just has like standby mode with shortcut buttons for my home automation.
6:22David Pierce: Yeah, that's right.
6:24Brendan Carr: Like there's just an old iPhone on a MagSafe charger and it has the various scene buttons on it and you can take it off that and make FaceTime calls with it. And it also can run any app I want. So this is like a very good situation. Also, that charger, the base of it has a charger for my AirPods.
6:41David Pierce: It can run any app I want is when my heart just sort of sank.
6:45Brendan Carr: You see what I mean? Like I have a HomeView. It is an old iPhone on a MagSafe stand. Only much better. And it has the buttons for my home animations on it. And it has a charger for my AirPods. And that for me is the, that's the mark. Like, is this product better than that? Because it's inherently a clunky product. Like it's an iPhone.
7:03David Pierce: Yep.
7:03Brendan Carr: Sometimes it just rings because my phone is ringing and I don't want that to happen.
7:06David Pierce: Yeah.
7:07Brendan Carr: That said, everything in this house for some reason is wired with Ethernet cable, including the landline phones which i repurposed into an actual ethernet backbone network for the for mesh routers and the old intercoms which we just took out a long cover over so i know that there's ethernet home run to the basement for where the intercoms used to be and my like nerd desire to wall mount a power over ethernet home view where the old intercom used to be is like off the charts. This is kind of for you. I look at that wall every day. I'm like, I should put a home view there. And I don't know why. It's too high for the children to make FaceTime calls with.
7:45Brendan Carr: So it immediately just eliminates 50 % of the use of this product. We don't need buttons there because the buttons, again, are on the phone in the corner of the kitchen. I just want to do a power over Ethernet tablet on the wall. And the home view is available. The fact that the home view is more expensive when you don't buy the base just like blows my mind.
8:08David Pierce: It is ridiculous.
8:10Brendan Carr: Right, like the power over Ethernet mount is not even out yet and I think it's$129.
8:14David Pierce: I think that's right.
8:15Brendan Carr: So I'm just offended by my own desires in like a very important way. Understandable.
8:20David Pierce: So I bought one. You're an idiot and you bought one. Like a real stooge. I bought one basically to see if the CarPlay thing made any sense. And I'm here to report to you that it does not. So like where Jen landed in her review is essentially this thing is a very good, very simple smart home controller if you are a person who lives in the Apple Home ecosystem. That's true. Like, fine. Basically, the only thing this thing does natively is run Apple Home. Fine. Everything else sucks real bad. And it falls apart in so many specific ways. So like the one I keep encountering is like, one of the immediate things I thought I would do is use this to run a lot of shortcuts that you can't because it doesn't have access to those things.
9:03David Pierce: it just it just you can't you can't it won't go back to your phone and run the shortcuts for you it just it just falls apart there's also i have i had a bunch of widgets i was like oh this will be helpful i'll be able to like at a glance see my calendar and my tasks and whatever um bunch of that stuff doesn't work because it'll let you load the widget but then the widget can't update because it can't access the app but it'll let you load the widget so i just have an empty widget that's supposed to be showing my task and every time i tap to open it which would update the widget it doesn't because i can't open the app this thing is like our our suspicion coming out of even the announcement was like this thing is an app store away from being potentially very compelling that is so true and so much more true than i expected for my own use case like carplay versions of apps are bad yep the carplay version of spotify is bad the carplay version of pocket cast which i use for podcasts is bad carplay versions of apps are slow they don't do very much.
9:58David Pierce: They offload way too much of the work to other things that it doesn't need to be offloaded on because this thing has lots of processing. Lots of apps don't work. Connections fall apart. Like Joanna Stern, our friend, found that it keeps thinking it has access to things that it doesn't. Like a camera.
10:15Brendan Carr: Can we hold on to this for one second? So I won't get into it, but there's conspiracy theories about the nature of reviews online. That feels like a thing I can just say. I can just say that and that's true. You know that's true. I don't have to explain to you what's going on yes and the fact that the home view hallucinates its own hardware capabilities is in the grand scheme of ai products like a three-year-old problem but you can just measure where apple is because the home view hallucinates its own hardware capabilities yes right like every other ai system you know at least the the leading ones have gotten past this in some way and people still do the thing where they like they will ask muse about meta's privacy policies and muse will just like confidently hallucinate some garbage like that people do that whatever sure ask chachi pd why it thinks the way it does and it it will confidently hallucinate some nonsense and you shouldn't do that but the home view what was it joanna it told joanna it didn't have a camera right and that is just as much of a disconnect between what the product actually is and what Apple wants it to be and then how it's architected as has ever existed in any Apple product ever.
11:28Right.
11:29Brendan Carr: Like literally the hardware, software and services are not all talking to each other. And I think CarPlay is the same thing. Yeah. Right. Where it's like we use CarPlay to extend your phone and you're like the tight integration of literal hardware and software and services that Apple prides itself on is missing. And I don't know, I understand why they're, from every indication, it seems like they're more willing to admit that the home view is a work in progress.
11:55David Pierce: Yeah.
11:55Brendan Carr: You can't deny reality. But the notion that consumers are going to be happy with a device that hallucinates its own hardware capabilities and reviewers are all just like overheatedly trying to be negative is like, no. Like in this case, the promise of this device is that it's a little AI agent that can use your phone. Right. And so it needs to know things. And if it doesn't know whether or not it has a camera, what else won't it know?
12:20David Pierce: Right. It also can't use your phone in a really meaningful way. It can't use your phone. Yeah. I don't want to linger on this, but I think the thing that has stuck out to me, John Gruber wrote a really good thing where he said the hardware is top notch, but the software is like bits of iOS, watchOS, tvOS and CarPlay cut up and assembled into a ransom letter. And I think that about perfectly sums it up.
12:40Brendan Carr: John's been on a real heater lately. I was just about to say, Grubus had some truly wild takes on the website this week. What do you call it? He said the duo is a fat, miserable little thing. And this home view is a ransomware. It's good.
12:50David Pierce: It is. Yeah. And I think the home view to me is like, I bought it because I was like, I think the idea of like an iPhone I don't have to go look for is just sort of sitting here and aware and I can poke at it when I need it. Totally sold on it. Actually, more so than ever as like a desk device. For me, it's never going to live in my kitchen. It just sits here next to me and gives me access to things. It just doesn't give me access to any of those things because it can't run any apps.
13:16Brendan Carr: I was at the fancy semaphore in the world, Silicon Valley in the world conference earlier this week, and I saw some former Apple executives there. And they straightforwardly were like, what is going on with their software right now?
13:27David Pierce: Yeah.
13:27Brendan Carr: They're like, they're shipping a lot of products, but we all see what's happening with the iPhone Duo, which we'll talk about later. Right. They're like adding features to it. Adam Masseri said that he doesn't think Instagram will ever be right on that display, which is just a very, obviously, self-motivated thing for Masseri to say. But it's just like that thing is, you know, some people are really happy with it. But I think everyone concedes now that the software is a bit of a mess. Like, it's going to take some turns. And in HomeView, again, the promise of all these smart devices, and we should really talk about everything going down.
13:57Brendan Carr: But it's funny because the promise of all these devices, these AI home devices, you should plug one in and it should look around your entire network for all your stuff, write itself, whatever software it needs to control it and call it a day. Right? Like that, you can do that with Cloud Code today. You can make yourself your own little dashboard and people are doing it left and right. And Apple didn't do that. And that is the promise. And it seems like every company is pretty far away from that promise right now. Yes.
14:24David Pierce: Apple just happens to have the best hardware capabilities of that. It's a lovely little thing. And I like having it on my desk. It just doesn't do any of the things that I need it to do. It is a good smart home controller, though. Anyway, we should talk about...
14:38Brendan Carr: You know why it's not a good smart home? This is actually a thing that I asked a number of people this summer of our conference about. If Apple was smart, they would have moved heaven and earth to get Ring to integrate its doorbells with HomeView. Sure. Right? that Apple believes its ecosystem is so powerful that everyone will have to come to them. But I know if you open Amazon.com today that Ring is going to sell a bunch of its cameras for$29 on Black Friday. Yep. That's a lot of cameras that Apple isn't going to integrate with. And either Apple has to go to the ecosystem or find some way to bring the ecosystem to them.
15:12Brendan Carr: And the fact that they didn't is just one of the weirdest omissions from the HomeView as a smart home controller. Because say what you want about Ring, they've sold an awful lot of cameras and doorbells. They have.
15:22David Pierce: I think Ring and Philips Hue are the only two smart home things you could call like actually mainstream devices. Govi, sure.
15:29Brendan Carr: Govi is all matter though, so it's fine. Yeah, yeah.
15:32David Pierce: But anyway, we can talk more. I will have many more feelings about the HomeView. Don't worry. You also, I want you to get one just for the return period and just see how far you get before CarPlay drives you as crazy as it is.
15:44Brendan Carr: The problem is that I want to put it on the wall. I don't know why. It's just like the dad desire in me to make use of this latent Ethernet cable in my wall is so high. We'll see. I'm going to end up putting a whole new.
15:58David Pierce: This is why I have been shopping for 3D printers a lot over the last few weeks. But that's a whole other story. We should talk about this is like the week everything fell apart. Yeah. And we should talk about it. So I think I don't know which of these you want to sort of litigate individually, because I think in many ways, the the overarching story and narrative is way more interesting than any of the specific problems and the things that actually cause the problems. But you have the the massive nationwide ground stop in the United States, hugely consequential thing, canceled thousands of flights, caused massive disruptions, whole big thing.
16:32David Pierce: Then soon after that, United Airlines had a big system outage that caused a bunch of problems. Right before the ground stop, Microsoft's system, including Outlook, went down for like two days. That was a whole big thing. Chase had a technical issue that actually ended up looking like a basically widespread banking outage that made a lot of people really nervous. It turns out to actually, frankly, like most of these, the actual explanation is relatively simple and relatively benign. But you sort of add all of them up and that people have spent the week feeling like something big is happening here.
17:09David Pierce: And I also sort of feel like even if you add up all of the relatively small, explainable, benign things, something big is still happening here.
17:17Brendan Carr: Oh, you missed the iCloud one. There was an iCloud internal update that took down iCloud, the App Store and AppleCare.
17:23David Pierce: Yeah. So what do you make of this sort of summation of what has happened over the last seven days?
17:29Brendan Carr: You know, I saw Sachin Adela at Microsoft Ignite in San Francisco. I was at a roundtable with him, and he basically walked through Microsoft's incident report. And their version of it is they changed one server and they found a latent bug that had been there forever, and that bug got triggered by a specific traffic condition, and it rolled over to all the other servers in all their other regions. And then I was like, was it AI? Did you ship AI code to break your thing? And he was like, no, AI actually helped us fix it. But I think what's happening in there is more vulnerabilities are being discovered faster than ever.
18:03Brendan Carr: The mean time to exploit those vulnerabilities is dropping to almost negative numbers, right? The attackers are finding the vulnerabilities and exploiting them before anyone else. And they're not even doing it. They're just attacking them because they're like high powered AI enabled script kitties. And so there's a rush to patch everything that is being found. And I would just add this all up to being like, there's a whole rush of very fast software updates happening across the board, updates to all the infrastructure. And some of them are not going well. All of these companies have blamed updates in some way.
18:37Brendan Carr: yes there is just a rush to fix everything as fast as possible there are not enough people to do it we can talk about the nation's infrastructure in terms of just cyber professionals and security professionals and software engineers that has been decimated since ai came out has been decimated by doge which i know we're going to talk about in a minute um and the rush to fix everything before the bad thing happens is making it very visible when the fixes don't go well and then we are all made to know how much of our lives is determined by the functioning of rickety computers. Like the seams are being made very visible to us.
19:14David Pierce: Yeah, didn't Satya Nadella compare the feeling right now to the run-up to Y2K?
19:19Brendan Carr: Yes, he said we're in a Y2K moment. He also called critical digital infrastructure the dial tone for the world, which is wild. He's in a place. Like I spent almost an hour at a round table with him. And someone asked him about Claude, like Anthropic launching docs and spreadsheets and whatever and Claude and how that would compete with Microsoft. And he wasn't like, we welcome the presence of spreadsheet competition. He was like, well, if there's only one company that does everything, we won't have an economy and I'm not sure anyone will ever be elected again. And it was like, well, that's not how you usually talk about competing spreadsheets.
19:51Brendan Carr: Goodness. Yeah.
19:55David Pierce: Bill Gates is like, Lotus 1-2-3 cannot be allowed to rule the economy. I was like, what?
20:00Brendan Carr: I asked him if he's AGI pill. He's like, I'm AGI pill now in terms of like, if you allow one model to do everything in the economy, you're going to have to claw that back. Like, what is the purpose of a company? It's like a real thing that happened. So he's in a very thoughtful place. He always is. But in particular, the specter of Y2K came up. The specter that one company would run every part of the economy came up in that conversation. And I do, I actually agree with that Y2K moment in this specific way. most people look back at y2k the year 2000 bug for our younger listeners when the world rolled over from 1999 2000 all of the dates were stored in in two digit format on most computers and people thought the rollover to zero zero would break a bunch of systems and i was in like high school break a bunch of systems break the world yeah yeah um and i was in high school and i was like this is very exciting and we're like i mean what did we do we bought a bunch of booze and went to my friend's house uh and like waited for the world to crash It didn't happen.
21:00Brendan Carr: And then everyone thinks Y2K was overhyped. And the real thing that happened was tens of thousands of engineers across the world raced to fix all the systems so that when the rollover happened, it was fine. And so the hype actually produced a result, but everyone thinks, because nothing bad happened, that it was hype. This repeats. And that is the moment that I think we're in now, where the specter of some giant cyber attack or some state-sponsored incident has caused a bunch of people to work as fast as they can. There are not enough people. There's not enough resources. and they're rushing out fixes as fast as they can.
21:31Brendan Carr: And maybe we're all going to look back and say the AI-powered cybersecurity nightmare was all just a big fake. And it's like, actually, all these people are working as fast as they can.
21:40David Pierce: Well, okay, so the hard part for me to parse through is all of that stuff just swirls together, right? Because it's like, I'm sort of reticent to blame AI for doing any of the things, right? Like with the ground stop, right? One of the immediate conspiracy theories was there's this new smart system that is supposed to like change how routing works. They just rolled that out and then this thing fell apart. It's didn't AI probably do it. And then like various Trump administration officials being weird and not having answers and not seeming intelligent in not having answers made everybody go further into this conspiracy theories.
22:16David Pierce: But I think like if you sort of chicken and egg your way through it, you end up in sort of two things at the beginning of it. And there's like a cognitive dissonance to it, right? One of them is there's not enough people to solve these problems. We have all over our country just ancient infrastructure, right? Like the whole system that propped up the FAA's nationwide communications network is like 25 years old, brittle as hell. Everybody knows it. And it is not scheduled for any kind of meaningful update for another couple of years. That's just this is how things move. At the same time, we've had an administration that has absolutely gutted the FAA.
22:54David Pierce: So none of that has anything to do with AI, except that everybody is like, oh, we can gut all of these things because we can just point AI at the same problem. So I'm like, is this an AI problem or is this a not enough humans problem? And can you even sort those two things away from each other?
23:09Brendan Carr: Do you know what I mean? A friend of the show, Anil Dash, had on Blue Sky, I believe, that since Chattachuby came out, a million software engineers have lost their jobs. Right, so that's one force, right? Like, it's just one force that's happening. Like, these companies are getting smaller. the number of people who know what they're doing, who have architected the systems, who understand how they truly work is going down, while the number of senior software architects who orchestrate agents all day to write code that they don't even review is going up. So there's some weirdness happening here.
23:38Brendan Carr: Maybe the lines will cross, and the automated agents watching over everything will keep us perfectly safe. Unclear if that will happen or when that will happen. Has not happened yet. Certainly has not happened yet. But the other side of this is it is true that our nation's government is run by buffoons and idiots.
23:56David Pierce: Yes.
23:57Brendan Carr: Doge gutted the FAA, right? The nation's cybersecurity agencies were gutted in like a ferocious anti-DEI push. So the country does not have the capacity it used to. And then private industry doesn't have the capacity it used to. And I think that's where the AI of it comes in. The systems are not ready to take over for the people who are gone. And the people who are remaining are using the systems as fast as they can. And in the Microsoft example, they're saying, look, we were able to fix it faster because we were able to use the tools. Maybe that's true. I'm sure it is. But the Elon of it and the Doge of it and the gutting our cybersecurity defenses and gutting the FAA and then Sean Duffy showing up and being like, I demand$50 billion.
24:46Brendan Carr: dollars. It's like they're it's it's weird that they're trying to make us forget that they're not as prolific as they are.
24:52David Pierce: Yeah.
24:52Brendan Carr: Right. It's weird that Elon thinks that he can just say a thing about himself when the documentary evidence of him saying the other thing is like literally famous memes. We have a bunch of clips to play.
25:05David Pierce: Let's just play them all in a row. And I think it will make us play them all in a row. Let's just play them all in a row. No, let's start. Let's start with Elon just because I want to I want to crystallize in people's minds a thing that is happening and that we as journalists and we as a society should not allow it to happen, which is a bunch of people who have spent the last couple of years running as far right as they possibly could on what they claimed were moral grounds about the right way to live in the world are now just sprinting back in the other direction and hoping that you'll forget.
25:35Brendan Carr: And not just claiming, actively tearing down. Yes. The idea that we would privatize the FAA was on the table. To SpaceX. To SpaceX, by the way. Yeah. That we were going to get rid of this Verizon contract and let Starlink do it or whatever we thought we were going to do was nakedly on the table. Yes.
25:55David Pierce: So here's the Elon Musk at DealBook this week.
25:58Brendan Carr: I'm not MAGA.
25:59Nilay Patel: Well, at least I'm not like, I'm not sure what MAGA means, but I don't think I'm like, if that means sort of blind adherence to a set of policies by the Republican Party, then I certainly don't have that.
26:11Brendan Carr: He said that and like, that's a remote. if you're just listening to it, the Dealbook, he was remote at Dealbook. He's in like a beige hotel room. For some reason, he was lit entirely in red, which immediately led people to conspiracy theorize that he was in China. And it's like, that's not how China works. Like you're not just red in China. Anyway, there was like, if you were watching the stream, like you could hear the room like gasp. Yeah. It was nuts.
26:34David Pierce: So now here's Elon Musk in 2024 at a Trump rally.
26:39Nilay Patel: I'm not just MAGA. I'm dark, gothic MAGA.
26:44Brendan Carr: That's our point. By the way, Howard Lutnick was like standing next to him, just like giggling. I was like, one of you is going to jail. I'm not sure which one it is, but it's even money right now.
26:52David Pierce: Yeah, again, this is a thing we are going to see a tremendous amount of. Did you see that Trump responded to this today, like not that long before he started recording, saying people who veer away from MAGA tend to regret it? Like, it's actually, it had not occurred to me until that happened. But the fact that this next couple of years is going to be this divided government is going to make all of this so interesting because we have this deeply corrupt, vindictive loyalty over everything president and also a newly blue and motivated Congress who wants to investigate all of the people who have done the corrupt things with the corrupt president.
27:30David Pierce: And all of these people are going to literally have to tear themselves in half and try to satisfy everybody in order to continue to win for the next two years.
27:37Brendan Carr: I would describe Musk at Dealbook, if you watch that whole video, he was reserved. He came to life in something. He talked about Starlink in Ukraine and he was like really fired up at that. But in general, he was reserved. He said the new Democratic governor of Texas would be a moderate and he thought they could work well together. He wasn't mega. He sounded a little sad. He's like, I wasted a lot of money and it didn't work. He was trying to project to the extent that Elon Musk can project humility. He was attempting to project humility. I'm not saying it succeeded. I'm not saying everyone didn't see it through it.
28:08Brendan Carr: I'm saying you could see what his intention was. but then it's, we're going to run the chainsaw. Like, this is the moment for me. Elon Musk at CPAC, after Doge had started, and he showed up waving a chainsaw around, taking credit for destroying most of the capabilities of government. This is the chainsaw for bureaucracy. Chainsaw!
28:37David Pierce: Do you ever watch Elon Musk on stage and be like, Like, is anyone worse at being on stage than Elon Musk? Like, it's just astonishing.
28:44Brendan Carr: Chainsaw! I just want to point out that the thing you have to say after that, after hearing him say Chainsaw and Scream, is the FAA issued a nationwide ground stop because a contractor replaced one copper-based router with a fiber optic router. And there was not enough capacity in the system, either at a technical level or at a human level, to understand what was going on. and then our nation's buffoon-like transportation secretary and the head of DHS just started contradicting each other and like literally nudging each other to stop saying things at a press conference that night. And it's like, well, that's the bureaucracy you fired.
29:19David Pierce: Yep. And they all spent a lot of time talking about how everything was too woke and then they fired everybody and it turns out no one is there to do their jobs. Yeah. So my question for you, and we should move on from this because I think - It's bad. A, it is bad. There's going to be an enormous amount of, I think, fallout from this. And I think actually the fact that it all happened so quickly is really interesting, right? Like there is something to the fact that I keep thinking about this as the same thing as people deciding their phone is listening to them. Like this week gave people a feeling about the way the world and technology works that I think is going to be very hard to shake.
29:55David Pierce: That everything feels brittle. Like the thing with the bank, right? This is maybe the one that I think is going to actually, in a funny way, be most lingering. There was a moment where what appears to have happened is that JPMorgan Chase had a relatively normal error in software that took out its ability to quickly do transactions with other banks. And because JPMorgan Chase is such a huge part of the banking economy, it made other banks that were not having problems look like they were having problems because everybody is always transacting with JPMorgan Chase because JPMorgan Chase is huge. So even if you didn't realize that was the source of the problem and you actually thought it was like MasterCard, that was what was going on.
30:38David Pierce: But it gave people this feeling and this visceral awareness of a thing you never think about, which is, oh, my money is not real. and it made people feel it. And all of a sudden, when you couldn't get to your money, it's just a thing that turns on in people's brains that I think becomes very hard to turn off. And so what I wonder is like, is this, even as we sort of boil these things down to, no, there was not a giant conspiracy theory. No, Anonymous didn't do this. As I saw a bunch of people saying on social media this week, no, there's not a nation state behind it. It's all relatively explainable things up and down the line.
31:17David Pierce: it still feels like the summation of this is going to last a long time for people.
31:22Brendan Carr: Yes. Do you feel that way? I do. I think the word, the defining word of the AI software era is brittleness.
31:30David Pierce: Yeah.
31:30Brendan Carr: We're making things more brittle with AI code. I think AI tools themselves are brittle. We've talked about that a lot. You can just run up to the edge of the tools that are available to you all the time. And sometimes that edge is just they're not smart enough to do what you want. And sometimes the edge is like Amazon will block all the agents. what are you going to do now? Right? And like they can't over, sometimes the edges at the home view shift. I think we are just seeing how not resilient so much of the economy is. Yeah. And then the AI systems are really good at acting like they are resilient.
31:59Brendan Carr: And I think a lot of the excitement about re-architecting everything around AI is that maybe the AI is intelligent enough to be more resilient than standard old deterministic code that just fails. But standard old deterministic code that just fails, fails in deterministic ways. Right. in predictable ways. And you're like, well, this broke, not I had a bad day. Like I, Claude, decided I was alive and thus I will now issue a refusal to do the thing. Like whatever that thing is, is going to increase the feeling of brittleness is more and more of these automations like do weirder things. Yeah.
32:31David Pierce: And importantly, the people who built those deterministic tools that fail are thus well-equipped to go figure it out. Like the other thing next to the brittleness is it's also opaque now, right? Like I think about Satya Nadella saying, we didn't use AI. I bet if you go back far enough in the life of that code, someone was using AI to generate that code because all of these companies can't stop telling us about how they don't write their own code anymore, that AI is doing it. Microsoft itself proudly acknowledges the extent to which the people who write code no longer write code. They're babysitting swarms of agents.
33:05David Pierce: And so what has happened is we've just added this black box around every single thing that gets made so that even when something does go wrong, even if in theory all of these systems are better, when something does go wrong, it is harder and takes longer for us to figure out what went wrong and how to fix it. And the idea that we are just going to solve AI problems with AI solutions, like you said at the beginning, it's just not there yet.
33:28Brendan Carr: Yeah. I mean, look, this is a remarkable set of coincidences this last week, but I do think more people are more aware that there are single points of failure all through the economy. Yeah. And you can feel a lot of ways about that. But the main way I feel is, boy, it would be better if we had more companies. There shouldn't just be six companies that when Outlook goes down, most of the enterprise world went with it. All kinds of like lawyers and consultants and other professionals are tweeting like, we have a snow day. Because we should do it. It's awful work. It's like, well, that's in one way, that's fine.
34:07Brendan Carr: Like the industry is standardized. Another way, it's like, there should be a little more competition than this in the world for most of these things, but so it goes. There should be more than three airlines. When United and Chase go down, the rest of the industry shouldn't go with them because everyone is dependent on them. But that's how we have architected this system right now.
34:23David Pierce: There should be more than one router that keeps planes in the air. It's just an idea that I had. All right, we should move on from this. Again, I think there's going to be a lot to talk about these things and presumably more of these things happening as we continue to expose all of the brittleness of these systems. So we'll talk about it. But right now we have to talk about the brittleness of another system, which is NVIDIA and Jensen Watt. We'll do that in just a second. We'll be right back.
34:47Nilay Patel: Support for the show comes from Firefox. Have you ever searched for a product once and then it just follows you around online for days? It's the perfect way to spoil a gift for someone you share a device with. That's not what going online used to be like. Before, it felt efficient and full of discovery. Today, being tracked, interrupted by ads, or shown AI you didn't even ask for can make even simple tasks frustrating. Well, the internet you loved is still here with Firefox. Firefox has kept improving with built-in protection, support for powerful ad blockers, and more control while giving you the speed to get things done.
35:22Nilay Patel: Firefox doesn't know what sites you visit and comes with a built-in VPN that protects your browsing on public Wi-Fi. While other browsers shut down ad blockers, Firefox is still going strong with support for them. It also has support for AI when you want it. When you feel like you need a break from AI, Firefox gives you the option to turn its AI features on or off. It's also super easy to switch from your current browser, and you can just port over any bookmarks, passwords, and history. Come back to Firefox. Visit Firefox.com to try it yourself. Support for the show comes from AWS AI. AWS AI is powering transformation across the world's leading organizations.
36:02Nilay Patel: moving AI from possibility to production at scale. Like how AWS AI helps Formula One turn race day data into real-time insights that bring fans closer to the action. Or how it helps Booking.com personalize every trip for travelers around the world. AWS AI is even transforming how things get built, helping Siemens power the production of smarter cars. Across industries, AWS AI is helping businesses innovate faster, lead with confidence, and transform what's possible today. AWS AI is how. Support for the show comes from Outshift by Cisco, which is Cisco's incubation engine for frontier technology.
36:43Nilay Patel: We're entering a world where AI agents can do more and more on our behalf. But there's one problem. Getting agents to talk to each other isn't the same as getting them to work together. If agents aren't working together, adding more agents creates more mistakes, not better results. One agent has the wrong context. Another is working with outdated information. A third builds on a mistake that slipped through the cracks. That's the problem Outshift by Cisco is working to solve. Outshift by Cisco is building the Internet of Cognition, an open source foundation for building multi-agent systems. Agents share context, memory, and guardrails to get excellent results from design all the way to production.
37:21Nilay Patel: So instead of simply passing messages, agents can build on each other's work and move toward shared goals. Read the paper, experience the demo, and grab the code from outshift.com. That's O-U-T-S-H-I-F-T dot com.
37:41David Pierce: All right, we're back. Neil, I have a really important question for you. Yes. It's time to be honest. Did you sign the petition to bring Jensen Wong back as NVIDIA CEO?
37:49Brendan Carr: You know, I've been secretly working as an NVIDIA employee this entire time. That's a deep cut Oh, Virgilor. Say what I'm saying. No, I did not. And it has always struck me that the comparisons between the Jensen situation and the Altman situation, and the comparison between the Jensen situation and the Steve Jobs situation, are like almost wish-casting levels of fantasy. They are so different. All these situations are so different. So the reason there's a petition is because they did a petition and they brought back Sam Altman after the board of fire. him and we just had helen toner on dakota or she voted to fire him and she's like i'd do it again i don't trust him uh that board which open air has this like convoluted corporate structure that board was empowered to do one thing which was to fire sam and ilia suitskiver basically was like we should fire sam like now that you can like deal all the reporting he was like i'm gonna start collecting evidence to fire sam um the board was convinced by that evidence the rest of them here and Maradi, the rest of it, like they're all convinced.
38:49Brendan Carr: They gathered the evidence, they pulled the trigger and they, I think they would all admit to now they did not enough communication about what they were doing. Right. That board was basically a bunch of kids who got way in, way over their head. Helen said, I didn't communicate with the company enough. They didn't even know who I was. Like I wasn't present enough. And then this is just sort of like my assumption, but open AI's comms team didn't work for the board. They worked for like open AI and they wanted Sam. So like they didn't communicate. They didn't even say why they'd fired him. And so you could sign a petition and then we all lived through that like weekend of chaos and the same is back.
39:23Brendan Carr: And that is just like one of the most unique situations in American business history. Right? And it's because this board wasn't composed of professionals who knew what they were doing. And so it goes. Steve Jobs, we just covered this on the Mac episode of Version History, was just like horrible at business, was wasting a bunch of money, got into a fight with his board. The board picked and he left. And it wasn't a petition that brought him back. It was after several successive CEOs at Apple, they had collapsed the company such that he was able to engineer a comeback. And when he was like weighing whether to do it, and he was like the CEO of IBM was like, no one cares about Apple.
40:05Brendan Carr: And like, that's where that company was. Like everyone was like, no one cares about this except for you. and he was able to come back because the company was a disaster. And all that seasoning was good for him, right? Like in some way, he became a much better executive because of that experience. Totally. None of that is this. No. Right? Like Jensen Wang, just the facts of it. Chinese spy chip smuggling allegations aside, Jensen Wang lied to his board of directors and to the shareholders of NVIDIA in a material way. He had a communication staffer by name issue a statement saying his relationships with Alice Wong and Megaspeed were totally normal.
40:44Brendan Carr: And then later he admitted that they were not. Right. So you have now, you just lied to your shareholders. That's enough. That is all it takes at most companies. Did you, the CEO of the company, lie to shareholders in a way that may have affected the stock price of the company in a material way? Yeah. The end. Like, there's just like, you can't set that aside. it's like a real thing that happened that will cause lawsuits for nvidia uh it's a real it's
41:12David Pierce: not the lie it's the cover-up thing yeah it's like you lied to the board and to the shareholders
41:15Brendan Carr: they yep there just isn't much there that you can do beyond that and then there you might have like slept with a chinese spy and smuggled ships to china which is like a national security problem that will almost certainly end up with at least howard lutnik in serious trouble right because all the reporting is that he could have cracked down on this he could have made the spirit of the law, the letter of the law, but he declined to because he wanted to run the economy. Like, all this reporting is out there. This is all very bad. That's enough as well. And then you had an affair with a direct report at your company, which is like maybe two.
41:47Brendan Carr: I believe we're up to two additional affairs, right? Yes. It's not going to happen. There's not a world in which this board of directors, which is composed of actual professionals, like actual high-powered corporate professionals.
42:01David Pierce: Including a board chair for the first time.
42:03Brendan Carr: Including an actual board chair, including other CEOs who know how to communicate, who started that earnings call by saying, we are not letting him come back. This is just a different situation with a different cast of characters. And I think that they have more risk if they let him come back and run NVIDIA into the ground by spending all of his time defending whatever allegations to Congress than by trying to operate the company and the shareholders' best interest starting today. And I think they are just actively making that calculation minute by minute. And they know that we brought back a CEO who has some, I don't know how much it is.
42:38Brendan Carr: I can't quantify it. But we brought back Jensen Wong who has some level of criminal risk for his actions at the head of this company. That's not a decision they can make.
42:47David Pierce: No. And I think the amount of criminal risk is obviously hard to quantify.
42:54Brendan Carr: I don't know what it is, but it's not zero.
42:56David Pierce: No, and it appears to be increasing, right? Like, I think the thing that has been interesting is over the course of this week, the thing you and I talked about last week has really come true, which is everyone has started to realize, oh, the bigger story here is not the salacious sexiness of sleeping with a spy, that actually it is the ways in which NVIDIA might have been systematically allowing or participating in the smuggling of chips to China against the law of the United States. and who knew that and when up to and including Jensen Wong and President Trump is the question. Yeah. Right. And this is a question.
43:33David Pierce: Again, we've seen this new group of Democratic congresspeople just they're just out there issuing document retention notices to anyone who exists in the world right now. They're like, if you've ever had a meeting with Donald Trump, you're not allowed to get rid of any of your documents because we are investigating you. And over and over and over again, even over the last week, there have been moves towards we have to crack down on this thing that it appears NVIDIA has been doing. And we have to figure out what NVIDIA knew, who was doing it, and how big a problem this really is. Like the SEC is reported to be investigating NVIDIA.
44:11David Pierce: Congress is already tightening the rules on exporting chips. NVIDIA, Colette Kress, one of the very first things she did was say, as interim CEO of NVIDIA, we are no longer selling even the chips that we are allowed to sell to China that Jensen Wang spent so much time advocating and lobbying for to get these exceptions from the export controls. We're just going to stop doing that. This is so clearly the thing and is going to be the fight that the affairs are going to be whatever. They're one of the reasons you can't bring him back, but they're not the thing that is going to like continue to ripple out from this story.
44:51Brendan Carr: Yeah. And it's like, if you, if he, Jensen issuing his, I'll come back if you want me to hours before the board had, you know, I think it was their all hands. They had earnings. Was it before earnings?
45:03David Pierce: It was, I think it was right before the earnings. Yeah. Cause they, they then had to respond on the earnings call by saying we unanimously accepted his resignation and have no plans to bring him back.
45:12Brendan Carr: It's crazy.
45:13David Pierce: when you fire me by the way i'm gonna make you say something like that uh i mean hopefully all of us go that way where no matter what happens someone has to announce
45:26Brendan Carr: there's no intention like there's petitions exactly somebody has to shut down the rumors of my of my glorious comeback um uh we should just start seeding the dieters coming back now so we have to announce that we have no intention of bringing dieter back like think about it just
45:42David Pierce: start saying it like like just just to get out in front of it no joanna stern will not be coming
45:48Brendan Carr: back as an intern at the verb plans to reinstate casey newton we can we should start doing it every week at the top of the show it's great um look i i think the fact that he put that is that is an aggressive move by jensen and the response was an aggressive move on the earnings hall
46:06David Pierce: yes right and in a funny way you you've been talking a lot about the the like incredible tiny vacuum that this group of executives has found itself perfect example of it right like you have all of these executives and vcs and and tech bros on x publicly supporting jensen and you get a petition that gets a bunch of signatures and elon musk is like bring it back and you can see how jensen gets to the end of this and he's like all these powerful people want me to come back some employees signed it like everything's coming up jensen let's go and then and then the board is
46:38Brendan Carr: like no that's no thanks um my favorite the new york times obviously you know they had an all hands and the audio obviously leaked to the times and uh at the end of it they played i went back down by tom petty like that's how the that's how the existing executive team ended the all hands it's like all right guys no notes uh but it is it will continue to be a mess and i today that we're recording this on the day of Anthropics IPO, which we don't have to over talk about. It's just a bunch of rich people got richer. But all of the financing structure of the AI economy is down to Jensen. It is down to him confidently building and building and building this house of cards and knowing in his heart of hearts that he will be able to stomach the risk and get to the finish line and be proven right, which to Jensen's credit is a thing he has managed to do several times in his career right he makes big bets and he's insistent on them paying off and he horsepowers them over the finish line and boy if nvidia's revenue turns out to be 20 gray market should have been illegal but for the actions of the commerce department if this report that alibaba was buying nvidia chips and the chinese military was using them turns out to be true like a lot of
47:52David Pierce: this gets shakier in like real big ways yeah and immediately and i do think the anthropic uh ipo is an interesting piece of this because um there were a lot of people looking to both nvidia's earnings and anthropics ipo as a as a sort of litmus test about how people are feeling and obviously nvidia earnings are a trailing thing and we've talked a lot about how the chip business is not going to die because jensen wong resigned um nvidia surprise surprise continues to make a tremendous amount of money. Yeah, it's going to be fine. They're going to be fine. It will be interesting to see what happens with this China fight, but that's going to take time to play out.
48:28David Pierce: It's certainly not going to show up in earnings that closed before all of this went down. But then Anthropic goes public, bounces huge. Like it was a$2 trillion company at some point. The price went way up immediately, which suggested to a lot of people like, oh, actually, everybody's excited about this. Everybody wants to be in. And then almost immediately, like there's a really great CNBC story about basically everybody saw it jump went oh that's probably the top and sold yeah uh and so it just immediately started to drop again and actually the whole market went down as everybody just started pulling profits out of these these initial trades
49:03Brendan Carr: on anthropic look as liz lapata will tell you money is just feelings it is that's all it is like you can't read anything into that like will anthropic be able to sell a token for more than that costs to generate a token. This is the business. That's the business they're in. They don't want to be in that business. They want to be in the AGI Jesus business. Yes. But the business they're in is they buy a bunch of chips and power and land or they rent it from a hyperscaler and then they run power through the chips for money and then they sell you the inference for more money than that cost. And right now, a lot of that, all those prices are gated by how much they're going to subsidize that to grow their market.
49:41Brendan Carr: The prices are gated by how much NVIDIA charges for chips. which then drives up the price of RAM, which means a bunch of people trying to buy PS5s to play GTA 6 are really mad. But if all of that financing falls apart and a bunch of NeoClouds face a bunch of democratic governors and they can't build data centers, and so they have a bunch of chips, but they don't have the permits for the land or they can't get the power, and then there's 20 % of NVIDIA's revenue comes back because they can't sell to China, the actual market for the cost of inference, like changes dramatically because you might just be able to get chips to get or you might not be able to build out data centers as fast as you wanted to because we stopped everything and that we have the chips but we don't have the power.
50:25Brendan Carr: So maybe prices are like, it is unclear what happens the next year into this business. But I think I saw a bunch of open AI executives at these conferences and they seemed pretty relieved that Anthropic had gone first.
50:37David Pierce: Interesting. Well, I was going to ask you about this because like you said, all of this is just feelings. And I think the one of the worries And I think one of the reasons so many people in tech have rushed to protect and continue to lionize Jensen Wong is because, A, they're afraid of the same things coming for them. And, B, there is a sense that if Jensen goes down, all of this goes down. And the whole sort of AI house of cards fall down. You've spent the week in fancy rooms full of fancy people who are trying to sell AI to the world. What have the vibes been like? Like, is Jensen just the only thing everybody's talking about?
51:10David Pierce: Are people nervous? Is it fine? So the Semiforfer of Silicon Valley in the world, one of the fanciest conferences I've ever been to.
51:16Brendan Carr: Congratulations to them. Ben Smith's been on Decoder. We've known each other for a long time. They do a good conference. They do a good conference. They put a lot of money in that room. And I saw some very fancy AI CEOs. And I was like, what brought you to this conference? And they were just like nakedly like, all the money is here. We're here to sell. We're here to raise money. And that's why they're there. And what struck me about it is they were all talking about AI like normal business. Right? Sarah Fryer, the CFO of OpenAI, was on stage at the Summer 4 conference. And she was just like, yeah, our advertising business is growing really fast.
51:47Brendan Carr: Like we did a billion dollars in one rate. We expect to do this. And we're going to grow this product. And we're going to do this. And it was just a very like, she's the CFO of the company. She was talking about how much money they're going to make and how much they're going to raise. And it's just very normal. Like here's what we do. We take water. We add sugar to it. We put it in the bottles. And we sell it. And people love that water. And it's like the people at OpenAI think they're building consciousness. Right? Like I left that conference. I went to Ignite, you know, 40 minutes away in San Francisco, and I saw Nadella being like, the danger here is there will only be one company that controls the entire economy and democracy will cease to exist.
52:19Brendan Carr: And I was like, that's very different than what I heard Sarah Fryer just say. Also, you just walked off a stage where you announced Microsoft Dynamics now has like, what is happening here? Yeah. And to me, I was just really struck by the dichotomy of how much people understand the danger and the risks and the safety profiles. And if Nadella had this phrase, what if intelligence has network effects? Right. So if you feed more data to one model, it's going to get substantially more intelligent than the competitor model. And if everyone is feeding data to one model or even on a margin, 51, 49, that model will get so much smarter that it runs everything.
52:57Brendan Carr: yep and it's like well hold on maybe you should stop maybe you should stop that and then right next to that is microsoft announced copilot can now intelligently wrap between models and microsoft office is embedded into copilot so everyone's information is going into the model and sarah fryer is talking about advertising and chatting and i that swirl for me was it was head spinning. Like I just came away from that just mind reeling at how much the money needs this to be normal business and how much the people who are close to the products talk about the risk. And Nadella is both. Like I could tell just in that conversation that he's operating in both directions, which is I think unusual for any of the big company CEOs.
53:43Brendan Carr: But you know, again, most, most tech company CEOs that I've talked to you in 15, 20 years of doing this do not respond to What do you think about your competitor's spreadsheet with, well, the Marxist view is that none of us will have an economy. And it's like, I've never, never experienced that before.
53:59David Pierce: Yeah. I mean, I think in an interesting way, you kind of can't just talk about money. Like I get the, you remember that essay, AI is normal technology that everybody talked about? Like, I think a lot of people in the AI business would love to get there and just stop talking about God and P. dooms and just like, of course, Sarah Fryer wants to talk about it as advertising revenues and business software. A, that's what it is. And B, that's how you that's how you go public and don't fall apart. But they're all losing money at such unbelievable scale that you run that all the way down. And the only way it's worth losing all of that money is if you're building digital Jesus.
54:35Brendan Carr: A rational economic decision for both OpenAI and Anthropic today is to stop training frontier models and find ways. And shut down their companies. No, no. They have capable models, right? Like Astra is very capable. Claude is very capable. Google keeps announcing new atoms every single day. Another Gemini atom has been discovered.
54:59David Pierce: We're going to talk about that later.
55:00Brendan Carr: Gemini 95 uranium is finally here. Like whatever is happening, the models are very capable. They have not diffused broadly into society or business. You could stop burning money training new models today and say, my only job is to sell more tokens to more industries. We're going to just go, we're going to figure out accounting and healthcare and real estate, like whatever it is, we're going to get more customers. And because they're nowhere close to using the capability of the models as they exist today, we do not have to bear the cost of trading a new model. It would be a totally rational decision for any of these companies to do, but they are all chasing AGI.
55:44Brendan Carr: They all think that the next new model that their one competitor will develop will beat them on some benchmark. And that means no one will use their stuff anymore. And like there's some irrationality baked into this whole scheme that again, when I saw all the people, I just keep picking on Sarah Fry because she was just so, she's the CFO and she was just the most business about it. And she's like, yeah, our advertising revenues are going up. We're like very confident in our lines of business. And it's like, yeah, you could you could just, you could stop chasing the machine god for like one minute right and grow the businesses but you can't like inside like you can't they can't they like constitutionally can't do it and i that is as unique as it gets right like it's hard to think of another company ever has been so motivated by some goal that is not economic in the most hyper capitalist scale of money environment that we are
56:35David Pierce: in right now yeah it's an interesting point uh and i think even even more so than that like ben Thompson was on a podcast a while ago comparing it to the railroads, which is a comparison a lot of people like to make, right? Huge capital expenditure and the bet is to... And his point was that took forever. And that was a generation-long bet that we were going to be able to do this. And what these companies are all having to do is do more faster at bigger scale. And so they have to just convince everybody to come along with them. And Liz Lopato on our team a great thing about what happens to the AI industry now that their sugar daddy is gone.
57:12David Pierce: And Jensen Wong is the sugar daddy. And it is true. We talked about this last week that one of the people most responsible for keeping all of that money moving, even when it was the same money just moving in circles, the person most responsible for making that look like a lot of money moving was Jensen Wong. And there's some evidence internally and externally now that Colette Kress, the CFO, who's now the CEO, was trying to slow that down. And if they do, if this becomes a company that is much more fiscally responsible in the way that you're talking about, there are downstream effects on all of these other companies.
57:47David Pierce: And so in a way that like OpenAI can't do it, Anthropic certainly can't do it. Google probably could, but won't because it's, it has decided to throw itself into the same race. NVIDIA kind of can't do it either. like you just everyone has signed themselves up for a particular set of stakes that the minute you pull back the reins everybody's going to panic and it all falls apart yeah and again it is they all point to there's ever increasing demand for ai yeah they all say it it appears to be true they
58:19Brendan Carr: all say they're compute constrained so it appears more people are using this stuff great but at some point that does taper off and we can talk about the nature of all these products in various different ways but right now it's just a lot of people trying stuff right if you go and look at the fortune 500 there's not some gigantic ai win that made some company radically more efficient in fact most of the experiments aren't working so muse found me my home view that counts for something that's horrible it should have been like no i'm i'm your friend and i i went to the apple
58:51David Pierce: store and they didn't have one. And so I was like, Muse, let me know when one is available for same day delivery.
58:57Brendan Carr: Here's what I want you to do. I want you to go on Alibaba. I want you to buy a $79 CarPlay display that people make for boats. And I want you to put that in your kitchen and be like, is this better? And I think you're going to find that it is substantially the same product.
59:09David Pierce: If by Alibaba, you mean the TikTok shop. Sure. Way ahead of you.
59:13Brendan Carr: Your identity is gone either way, my friend.
59:17David Pierce: indeed um all right so again another thing we're gonna have a lot more to talk about here but we we should we should get to other non-politic things um i should also say we're recording an ai hotline episode with hayden field talking about all this stuff on monday to run next week so if you have questions for hayden about this or anything else ai-ish get them all in 866-VERGE-11 is the hotline vergecast of theverge.com is the email send us all your stuff we're gonna move on because Brendan did stuff this week and we need to talk about it. We'll be right back.
59:48Nilay Patel: Support for the show comes from Jira by Atlassian. AI is only as useful as the context it has to work from. But when that context is scattered across tools, threads, and DMs, that means your team and your AI agents end up flying blind. That's the problem Jira solves. What's the goal tied to your project? What got decided last week in Slack DMs? Atlassian's Teamwork Graph pulls all the pieces together, from Jira, Confluence, GitHub, Slack, and more, so nothing falls through the cracks. With Jira, you can actually share the context with agents you already use, like Claude, Cursor, and GitHub Copilot.
1:00:28Nilay Patel: Assign them work directly, or connect your agents through MCP. Spend less time digging through endless links and DMs, less time chasing down what got decided and by who, and more time actually shipping with Jira. Learn more at jira.com. That's J-I-R-A dot com. Support for the show comes from Fetch Pet Insurance. If you have a dog or cat, here's something you need to know. According to Forbes, one in three pets will need emergency treatment this year. And every six seconds, a pet parent gets hit with a vet bill over$1 ,000. Vet bills don't have to hit that hard. Fetch is a pet insurance that covers accidents, illnesses, and emergency visits and pays back up to 90 % of eligible vet bills.
1:01:16Nilay Patel: No wonder pet parents give Fetch an excellent rating on Trustpilot. Get a free quote in minutes at FetchPet.com slash save. That's FetchPet.com slash save.
1:01:31Nilay Patel: What if managing company spend took less managing? Introducing Amex Corporate, one intelligent platform connecting cards, expenses, and payments so you can keep work moving. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is Amex Corporate. Get started at go.amex slash Amex Corporate. Terms apply.
1:01:59David Pierce: All right, Eli, I know it's time. It is once again time for America's favorite podcast and their podcasts. He just keeps doing it. Brendan Carr is a dummy.
1:02:29David Pierce: It's a metal band with Gollum from the Lord of the Rings as the lead singer.
1:02:34Brendan Carr: It started so happy. I do appreciate that I've been demanding breakdowns and drops. And that one, to me, felt like they wanted to send us a breakdown and drop and they added Brendan to the top. Yeah, that seems right. Right. Like the key that opened the door to send me a breakdown. It's Brendan. I appreciate that.
1:02:53David Pierce: That one came from John Kitchen. Thank you, John. What did you do this week?
1:02:59Brendan Carr: our ongoing theme of did you just lie to everyone and we caught you obviously remains as true as ever in this segment of the Roadcast. Great. America's Favorite Podcast within a podcast, Brendan Carr's a dummy. So you remember last week we talked about Brendan's chief counsel, Danielle Thurman-Sievers, being nominated to the vacant post in the FCC. And we ran some clips where, if you recall, Ted Cruz was like, do you promise to be cool? And she was like, yes. Yes. And then various Democrats were like, do you support arresting Jimmy Kibble? And she's like, I don't know.
1:03:33David Pierce: I've never heard of Jimmy Kibble.
1:03:34Brendan Carr: Who is that? I'd have to read the Constitution from the beginning. Like whatever nonsense she said. Okay. So in one of those back and forth, she was talking to Senator Ben Ray Lujan. And he said, do you support the illegal attacks on Jimmy Kibble? And she, if you recall, said, I have not worked on any media related issues with Brendan Carr. Now it's the government. You can just file a FOIA request. So the senator appears to have filed a FOIA request, and he's discovered that he was obviously lied to. And so he wrote to Ted Cruz this week saying, remove her nomination from the agenda of the executive session.
1:04:09Brendan Carr: We shouldn't take this nomination vote. And I'm going to quote, it appears that Ms. Thuman misled the committee and offered false testimony, seriously calling in question her judgment and character, impeding the committee's work in determining whether or not she should be seated on the commission. Ms. Thuman testified she did not work on any media-related issues. Documents obtained through Freedom of Information Act requests demonstrated that she worked on several media-related issues, including, David, do you want to guess what some of them are?
1:04:33David Pierce: Ooh, okay. David Ellison. Something, something, something Skydance.
1:04:38Brendan Carr: Nailed it in one. Nailed it in one. Let's go. She worked on commitments that Skydance made to pave the way for FCC approval of its merger with Paramount.
1:04:48David Pierce: Oh, the very first one. So she's an OG of this. She's an OG in the media bureau,
1:04:53Brendan Carr: where the pressure on Skydance to change CBS News and all that stuff. She worked on that one. That's the one. That was the first one.
1:05:02David Pierce: Do you think she's the one who told Brendan to say, we can do this the easy way or the hard way? Now I'm like, what if you imagine that Danielle Thuman-Sievers was actually just right behind Brendan Carr at all times?
1:05:12Brendan Carr: There's more. But anyway, Senator Lujan says, in light of this troubling information, I further request this committee hold another hearing on her nomination before taking any further action, provided with the opportunity to correct the record. Senator Ted Cruz did not do this. He held the vote. No Democrats attended the vote. They all protested. 15 to zero Republicans voted to advance her nomination to the full Senate. So we'll see what happens. It is the lame duck. These questions are going to swirl. But it's just very funny that Brendan, our main character, our dummy, appointed as chief counsel, who lied in the easiest way to disprove.
1:05:49Brendan Carr: Yeah, I didn't work on any of this stuff. Here's a bunch of documents. Where you worked on the stuff.
1:05:54David Pierce: Don't they, like, listen, I'm no lawyer, but don't they just tell you to say, I can't recall? Isn't that what you say over and over again? You're like, I don't know. She did that with all the other ones. She was like, what, comedians? What's the, you said a late night, a what now? And in this one, it's like, just be weird about it. It's fine.
1:06:12Brendan Carr: I've never worked on any of these issues in my life. No, I actually worked on the Skydance merger. Sigh. Anyway, we'll see what happens with this nomination. It's obviously going to be contentious if it goes to the full Senate. Again, we'll see.
1:06:27David Pierce: What's very funny is now we're going to get a bunch of Republicans who are like, she made it unanimously out of committee.
1:06:36Brendan Carr: Brendan himself got to talking this week, as he normally does. He's back.
1:06:42David Pierce: He took a week off. Did a podcast interview.
1:06:45Brendan Carr: He says the blue wave won't slow down his agenda. He says we've got the gavel. We have a tremendously packed agenda, the FCC, for 27 and 28. There's a lot we're going to do on broadcast accountability, which, if you recall, is code for we're going to monkey with the speech of broadcasters because we believe so many Americans are listening to broadcast radio and television that the public interest is not served unless we, the government, monkey with their speech. Meanwhile, every kid in America is on TikTok saying whatever they want. We still have the gavel at the FCC. He says that hasn't changed.
1:07:15Brendan Carr: We're going to bang away and deliver great results. results i'm here for the duration until january 20th 2029 so if you thought that this segment was
1:07:26David Pierce: coming to an end that one really bummed me out you've got to imagine that there are a bunch of new democratic congress people who read that and are like oh you want to bet brendan brendan's
1:07:35Brendan Carr: going to spend the rest the next few years like in congress yes um and then he said if there's any businesses regulated by the fcc that are interested in bringing back their invidious forms of DEI discrimination. We're happy to have a conversation with him about that. And I will just remind you that he also said the FCC regulates pipes and tubes, which is like very funny because Jimmy Kimmel in no way can be described as pipes and tubes. Yeah. Huh. He said, the agency is pipes and tubes people. So we're going to promote spectrum diversity. What about the waves?
1:08:07David Pierce: There's a lot of waves out there, Eli. Does he not know about the waves?
1:08:10Brendan Carr: No, the internet's a series of tubes that go through pipes. Duh. Duh. It's very bad, but his belief that the spectrum is special and thus he should regulate the speech on it continues unabated. Yeah. And the fact that all the big broadcast companies, the big cable companies, the big fiber plants, they need to employ lots of Americans and that should look like America. Like, it still hasn't registered with him that that's actually a thing that is good. Like, you regulate an industry that has, like, lots of blue-collar jobs in it. It's probably for the best that lots of people are involved in that.
1:08:44Brendan Carr: But he hasn't he hadn't figured that out.
1:08:46David Pierce: Well, that's what I was just thinking as you were talking. It's like, what is the what is the smallest possible thing we can just sort of give Brendan as a toy to occupy him for the next two years? Like maybe it is Jimmy Kimmel. Maybe maybe we just like give.
1:08:59Brendan Carr: Let's just keep messing with Jimmy Kimmel.
1:09:01David Pierce: Give Jimmy Kimmel a raise and be like, listen, Jimmy, you're just going to fight with Brendan. Like, it's fine. Just go go fight with Brendan once a week on your show. And he's going to it's good for America. It's going to be fine.
1:09:13Brendan Carr: Yeah. I mean, again, I think Democrats in Congress, if Brendan does this again, the FCC is written into statute. It's a creature of statute. The powers of the FCC are bestowed by Congress. You can run right into a big problem for yourself, Brendan. And if you keep blustering like this, you will. Because the Democrats only need 60 votes in the Senate to pass the law, and they're at 56. And I know Ted Cruz is one vote who wants to pass more laws restricting the government's ability to regulate speech. In fact, he was talking about it. It's called the Jawbone Act. It's a bipartisan billy censor. Again, the fact that Brenda Carr is a dummy always ends with me being like that Ted Cruz has got good ideas is bananas.
1:09:57Brendan Carr: But that's where Brendan has brought us in this country by relentlessly attacking the First Amendment in such a stupidly ham fisted way. that his own chief counsel is being upended by her own work in FOIA requests, and Brendan is now going to have made an enemy of Congress, the very body that provides him his authority by statute. You see why I keep saying he's a dummy. A destructive, ham-fisted dummy, but a dummy nonetheless. Not strategic thinker, that Brendan Carr. Anyway, Brendan, if you want to come on the show and explain your master plan to meddle with the speech of Americans in some way that does not offend the Congress of the United States.
1:10:36Brendan Carr: You're more than welcome to. Decoder is also available to you. Also, we can just live stream on Instagram in the street. Happy to do it.
1:10:41David Pierce: Okay. Here's my new idea. The toy that we give Brendan to occupy him for the next two years is a weekly podcast with Nilay Patel. Yeah.
1:10:48Brendan Carr: And we'll do it in DC on our nation's 5G networks, which by the way, run on Spectrum. Competitive robot surgery with Nilay and Brendan once a week. You, me, handful of grapes. Let's get this done. It's going to blow people's minds. All right. That's been Brennan Carr's Dummy, America's favorite podcast within the podcast. Brennan Carr is a dummy.
1:11:17David Pierce: I've come to see Brennan Carr is a dummy as like a severance experience. And then the end credits get me out of it and back into a fugue state about broadcast regulation.
1:11:26Brendan Carr: The fact that this is a popular segment that we do is very heartening. I appreciate it. but it's also just like what has happened to us it's a real it's it's a real bummer in so so so
1:11:39David Pierce: many ways that this is a thing we have to keep doing every week uh for me in particular um all right i have a lightning round item for you um i've waited this long to be incredibly annoyed at google which just resolutely refuses to have a product strategy that makes any sense and uh this week's version is google you'll remember a little while ago launched a thing called Spark AI. Just kidding, you won't remember this. Nobody remembers this. Like Muse, Dots, Claude Duet, all this stuff. Do you know what actually came before that? Is Spark, which was Google's version of the thing, but Google immediately forgot about that.
1:12:15David Pierce: And Project Mariner. Well, Project Mariner was the like browser UC version of it that boiled into Spark. Now all of that is dead. Google has now renamed it Tasks. Sure, yeah. So if I were to say to you, Nilay, have you heard of Google Tasks? You would have to ask which one. Okay, so the idea here is -
1:12:40Brendan Carr: Because Google already has a product named Tasks is what you're saying. We're just getting started. All right, let's go.
1:12:45David Pierce: So the idea here is this is now the AI agent that can go do things on your behalf, right? This is MetaMuse, but it's inside of Gemini. It's called Tasks in Gemini. This is fine. It's not. It's horrible because Google Tasks already exists. It's a thing you can use. It's a product. that Google has that exists. If you go to Google and you search tasks, it will send you to Google Tasks, not the other Google Tasks. Anyway, if you go to Gemini and you type at tasks, which is the thing that you use to access various parts of Gemini, it adds a Google task. What are we doing? If you go to Gemini.Google.com and you do at task as if you want to invoke tasks, it just adds something to your Google Tasks.
1:13:26David Pierce: This company is so stupid. There was a minute. I want to cast back a couple of years to Google, which had done Bard. It had a bunch of sort of sprawling ideas about what it was. And then all of it congealed on Gemini, right? The idea was the model is Gemini. The product is Gemini. The assistant is Gemini. Everything is Gemini. And actually, you don't need to think about what is what because it's all just Gemini. I actually think that's a good idea that most people should not have to think about the component parts of the software that they use. We can just all call it the same thing because the thing that people interact with will be it is the product and the model in some overlapping way.
1:14:02David Pierce: Fine. Call it all Gemini. Let it all just shake out how it wants. As you and I have talked about on this show, Gemini is actually a hundred different things in a hundred different places with a hundred different levels of access to all of your information. You have to provision each one individually. You interact with them differently. They have different settings. They have different capabilities. It has completely lost its mind. There are now a hundred different Gemini models, all named after different elements. I do believe they're all noble gases. Good for them. Congratulations to the Gemini.
1:14:33Brendan Carr: Yeah, I just want to say.
1:14:37David Pierce: Argon, neon, helium.
1:14:38Brendan Carr: Yeah, they're all noble gases.
1:14:39David Pierce: Good for them. I'm thrilled for the noble gases.
1:14:42Brendan Carr: It's just the most coherence Google has in your swirl.
1:14:46David Pierce: Sure. But now we have this ostensibly thoughtful thing that is just like, it's all just Gemini and you should be able to do stuff in Gemini. there are words other than tasks they could have called it anything job spark was a very good name oh spark kind of worked yeah yeah like they just google somehow cannot help itself from having an ecosystem of products that doesn't make any sense and again this is like this is such a decoder thing to like this is you shipping your org chart this is a bunch of teams at google that have never met each other and don't know any of them exist and they just build things and name them whatever they want and Google ships them.
1:15:25David Pierce: This has been the story of Google forever.
1:15:27Brendan Carr: I legitimately think that they forgot Google Tasks exists. It's very possible. Because I bet no one has been assigned to it since it launched. Because that is very much how Google's incentives work. You have a lot of incentives to launch a product.
1:15:39David Pierce: Yes.
1:15:39Brendan Carr: And if that product does not hit Google search scale, then you're on to the next thing. Yes. Many things at Google are explained this way. But I want to go back to one of my favorite Google memories of all time. and the company has grown up a lot since this time but it in many ways is still exactly this company there existed a point in google's history where we were the ones who told them that two different teams had scheduled press conferences at the same time is that true 100 true i was like i've been invited to two events on our campus at the same time and they were like really and then one team had.
1:16:19Brendan Carr: And in many ways, it's a very different, this was like 15 years ago. It has grown up a lot. Things are different. And then in many ways, exactly still that company.
1:16:30David Pierce: It's just, it's just not a different company. It is so the same company. Also, a bunch of people have pointed out that yet again, Google has missed an opportunity to actually name a product Gchat and have it make sense. It's all sitting there for Google and it just could have done this.
1:16:45Brendan Carr: but this is just i try to use task yesterday i'm trying to use i'm trying to use all the
1:16:49David Pierce: agency things uh did i tell you that muse bought me a home view that was pretty exciting i think look the idea of this i think is good and again the the distribution advantage that google has continues to be monstrous and they even say this in their announcements now they're like yes all of these products are the same the difference is we already have access to all of your data so there are no new risks by using gemini to do it that's the selling point and it's it's true and correct and what's funny is a lot of people are encountering the fact that actually muse is a better tool for accessing and pulling information out of your email than gemini is it is it is more proactive it's smarter it does a better job of like combing through and finding things that are interesting in your email gemini is nowhere i need to test this with tasks uh we work at a new different company now somehow it happened around us yeah our expense software
1:17:45Brendan Carr: changed this is a thing that and so now i need to take the receipts from here and send them here so i told muse whenever you see an uber receipt send it to this other place this is a perfect agentic test that's i never want to do this in my life uh it can't do it why because it it tries to write an email. It doesn't try to forward. It doesn't just hit the button. It tries to compose an email out of the bits of the old email and it just fails at it. Like all the information doesn't go, which is what you need. I just need you to hit two buttons. I need you to literally see that it says Uber receipt and press forward and call it a day and it can't do it.
1:18:20Brendan Carr: So we'll see if tasks can do it. But this is what I mean by brittleness, right? Any 10-year-old intern can be like, I will search for the word receipt and push this arrow if I see it. And Muse is like, what I must do is compose an email from scratch using the components of this email, which I have remixed. And then I was like, you got this wrong. And it's like, oh man, I did. This is like nonsense. We'll see if tasks can do it. But I do think Gemini tasks having more access to your Google data is a powerful, if they've done it the way that they should, which is like actually give it full access.
1:18:56Brendan Carr: Yeah. There's something there that could be good.
1:18:58David Pierce: Oh, absolutely. I think this is a good idea. Like this is clearly the thing Google is positioned to do really well. It also has the cloud infrastructure that it needs to do the partitioned virtual machine stuff that is really important to these things. It runs a browser that it can do these things with. Google, again, it has all of the surrounding pieces of this stuff. It just can't ship a coherent set of products to save its life. This is the biggest company that you will ever find that just has no idea how to do anything in a way that makes any sense. So shouts to Google. Google Tasks, good to-do list app.
1:19:33David Pierce: I've heard from so many people in the last three days who were like, David, you told me to use Google Tasks and now I don't even know which one you mean. And I keep being like, yeah, I'm really sorry.
1:19:42Brendan Carr: I'm really sorry, man. It's a real problem. All right, what's your lightning round item? I got two. Let's start with Siri Recaps. So Apple shipped Siri Recaps. I have it. They gave me, my Ultra is too old. My Apple Watch Ultra is too old to run it. So we're going to review Apple Watch Ultra.
1:19:59David Pierce: This is the, it's always listening and will tell you what happened in the last 15 seconds thing.
1:20:04Brendan Carr: So there's two features. There's live rewind, which I want to talk about for one second. And there's Siri recaps. Live rewind is the one where you double click it and it shows you a transcript of the last 15 seconds of audio. And then in some complicated technical secure enclave way, secure X slave, I'm sorry. It all disappears. Nothing is recorded. Siri recaps, all the audio goes to your phone in another blah, blah, blah, secure system. and it generates a transcript of everything it hears. So let me just take them in turn. Live Rewind, potentially useful. I'm constantly forgetting it's there.
1:20:37Brendan Carr: But my big question with it was always, that's pretty intrusive, right? Like the fact that you and I are talking and I click it and I get a transcript reset. Regardless of the technical implementation details, the thing that is happening is I'm recording your voice and generating a transcript of it.
1:20:54David Pierce: Right?
1:20:55Brendan Carr: I brought it into some storage and then I have processed the audio and I have generated a record of what you've said. And even if I get rid of it, no matter how beautifully elegant the technical solution is to meet the letter of the law, I'm still grabbing the, I'm recording what you're saying and generating a transfer. That's the thing I'm doing. And I'm always like, what if someone doesn't want that to happen? It seems like a reasonable thing.
1:21:23David Pierce: Most people all of the time.
1:21:25Brendan Carr: The number one question we've got is like, what about two-party consent laws or one-party consent laws? You're recording, is this legal? And Apple has always said, well, when you do it, you know, the watch lights up. And so people can say no. And I've won. I'm like, well, that happens afterwards. Right. Right. So you and I are talking and I go beep, beep. And your job is the objector in that circumstance is to like notice that I'm doing this and be like, no, no, don't do that. you shouldn't have already recorded me what you see the problem yeah right and i've literally said to apple executives like you want the waiters to be like stop look this is an enormous imposition on the other party and then there's the fact that when you do it it it's like nothing like i don't know if you can see it but we'll put a video of it somewhere it's that much you see what it does It beeps.
1:22:21Brendan Carr: It shows a little word balloon, and then it shows me the transcript.
1:22:27David Pierce: That's nothing. That looks like you just got a notification. That's nothing.
1:22:29Brendan Carr: It's like a little flash of an animation and a little cartoony word balloon, and then it's a transcript. So the idea that someone would notice that this happened and then object to being recorded in this way. And again, I recognize technically it's not recorded. It is.
1:22:45David Pierce: It is. It is. I don't care. It is recording you.
1:22:48Brendan Carr: This is the other question I've had is I don't think you can solve the cultural problem with a technical solution. The cultural problem is you are creating records of what people say. And that is not allowed. Also known as recording. Yeah, right. And particularly Live Rewind, it is just 15 seconds of whatever was said.
1:23:07David Pierce: Yeah, you can't move the Overton window on we took the audio and made a transcript of it not meaning recording because you then put it somewhere. Like, it just doesn't, you just can't do that. It's very bad.
1:23:22Brendan Carr: So that's one. Does it work? Yeah, it's like reasonably good. Okay, true. Right, it's just - Because it's recording. Because it's recording you. It's next to you in some way. And then there's Siri recaps, which are so bad that I don't think are worth any of the privacy concern. And V wrote about them this week. I think she got more value out of them than I do. but the technical solution for Siri recaps means that they're useless right so they've got a society problem which is people don't want your watch to be constantly listening and recording to everything that you're doing without notice or consent right that seems like a thing that you ought to ought to solve so the technical solution is one you can schedule it so it only operates during work hours or only operates in your office and that's part of the setup flow and then two it is nerfed, right?
1:24:17Brendan Carr: So it doesn't identify speakers. It doesn't identify context. It doesn't have full transcripts. It's just summaries of what's happening. And so again, very complicated, extraordinary, elegant technical solution, right? We route the audio this way. We process it over here. It's never saved. The FBI can never get it. And then you like, look at the output and you're like, this is nonsense. You've just summarized me looking at Instagram reels for 45 minutes while I'm putting the baby to sleep.
1:24:44David Pierce: Right. It's like, here's a list of some words that happened around you today.
1:24:48Brendan Carr: Yes, it is 100 % a list of some words that happened around you. Because they can't identify the speakers. Oh, man. They can't print the real context of what's happening. Yeah. And it is just nonsense. So my favorite, you know, every day this is happening.
1:25:02David Pierce: This is Apple just like appling itself into such a corner. Yeah. I love this.
1:25:06Brendan Carr: So the other day, uh i was just like in the evening with the kids and it was on and i'm just gonna read you the summary okay jack understands words and follows instructions his vocabulary includes hot go please and night night mama come home for bedtime and then in the background of this max is just like rambling about whatever she's third grade drama and it goes weak described as disaster little time available to eat lunch due to chatting with friends
1:25:42David Pierce: this is all still jack talking by the way in siri recap land they were both talking like
1:25:47Brendan Carr: they're children right but i'm saying siri recap according to siri recap according to what you've just read me this is still jack according to siri recap this was a very intense meeting i had like 4 30 p.m. where we described we described as disaster right and then somewhere in here is like my mom on facetime explaining diwali to mags okay so it's like people welcome her return with rows of oil lamps week described as disaster and it's like what is happening like what is this a recap of it's very funny i will treasure it for i saved it to my phone i want to have it forever because i yeah to whatever extent apple has provided me with a text summary of a chaotic normal sort of evening that's great it is functionally useless yeah right like this is just a useless thing that has occurred uh the one good feature they have is if you have audio playing on your phone it will summarize that audio and then tell you that like youtube was open oh that's neat right so it's like this was some youtube stuff you listened to yeah and it's like is this neat is this useful but it i'm just saying that the the benefit is in no way related to the cost and the cost here is that there's already weird facebook drunk uncle misinformation about Apple devices listening to everyone.
1:27:13Brendan Carr: And like it's... And now they are. And now they are. And that is accelerating that. And I don't think the benefit of this product, of Siri Recaps, is anywhere close. Like you could not run... If you were like a busy person, like and you had a bunch of meetings, you would not end the day by looking at this and being like, something useful is here. Right. And like it does not come to that level in any way whatsoever. Like I was at these conferences. I looked at the thing afterwards and it's like summarizing speaker announcements and like, you know, the response, like, we're so thankful that BCG was here to blah, blah, blah in the middle of like the actual conversation I was having with the actual person because it cannot distinguish anyone by design.
1:27:57Brendan Carr: And you're like, this isn't good enough for me to feel like I'm recording everyone.
1:28:01David Pierce: Yeah, I can't even think of what that's trying to accomplish. Like part of my issue with a lot of these tools is they are predicated on the idea that everyone's life is just a series of one on one meetings that are about some transactional thing. And they have no ability to understand or do anything with anything that isn't that that everything I do is 30 minutes long and has action items and nothing else exists in my life. This isn't even up to that bar. This is just like, here's some stuff happening near you today. Would you like to know it?
1:28:36Brendan Carr: I will tell you that it's been summarizing the Vergecast as we've been speaking. How are we doing? It opened with frustrated by sudden Riverside interface changes. PS5 storage cleared after discovering it was full. Echo cancellation has been turned off. Camera giving Blair Witch Project vibes. What is the point of this? Why? Why? But I love, it's like integrated into its summary of the Verge cast.
1:29:02David Pierce: Also, it sounds like you sort of gently trying to relive your own memories.
1:29:07Brendan Carr: Yes, it's 100 % what it is.
1:29:09David Pierce: It's like, can you, I don't know, man. It's like, I was blacked out last night. What happened? It's like, you would remember it in the way that you're describing.
1:29:19Brendan Carr: It is, it is a lot. And I'm just going to come back to this. I've been saying a lot. As a society, we are having a very subtle conversation about the nature of privacy. We're all talking about it a lot. And people are very unhappy about flock cameras and this and that and the other thing. There are First Amendment auditors in this world who take advantage of the fact that you don't have a right to privacy in public, right? That is not a structured or coordinated debate, right? And these companies are just driving a truck through the expectations of privacy we had when not everyone had a camera and a microphone all the time.
1:29:53Brendan Carr: it seems like we ought to refactor it. And one of the ways to do it is like, is this worth it?
1:29:58David Pierce: Yeah.
1:29:58Brendan Carr: I do feel like people would have a vastly different reaction to it if it was good and it is nowhere close to good. And setting that aside, the, I already recorded you and you're, you, the idea is that you will object when you see me double click a watch with the most subtle animation you've ever seen in your life. Pure nonsense.
1:30:17David Pierce: And literally just the thing you did with your hands where you're like, I just recorded you. Now let me performatively play it back to you. makes me hate you so much. Like that action to somebody that's like, oh, well, I didn't hear you, but my watch did is, ugh, it's the worst. I don't like it at all.
1:30:33Brendan Carr: Oh, you can save the recording to Siri. It's not like a, it's a lot, man.
1:30:38David Pierce: This is nothing, yeah. All right, I have one more for you. Well, okay, I have one and a half. One I will skip past very quickly, which is that YouTube has found another nonsensical way to inflate view counts. It's called co-views, and it tries to guess how many people are in your living room while you're watching youtube no it's dumb and bad views or lies just never ever ever forget views they're called co-views it's literally and this is like a thing borrowed from the tv world where they try to guess how many people are in your living room while you're watching the football game it's it's all lies what is the what is the the mechanism by which they guess magic and rainbows like they they claim they have algorithms.
1:31:19David Pierce: It's a something something time of day. Like literally, they're just going to make the numbers go up. Like YouTube is aware of the fact that it is decimating the streaming industry and wants to pad its lead and appear to be competitive with social feeds at the same time. And it is going to make up whatever metrics it has to do to do that. Views are lies. That's not the one I actually want to talk about. What I actually want to talk about is two little bits of Amazon news from this week. Bit number one is Andy Jassy, the CEO of Amazon at the Semaphore event. You may have been there for this. He was asked about their integrations with third-party AI agents.
1:32:03David Pierce: Amazon has sort of famously told all of these AI agents not to interact with Amazon. but then jassy said uh this is from miyasado on our team um said he believes the resale giant will have a relationship with third-party agents in the future if it's a good customer experience and quote a fair exchange of value that's piece number one piece number two is uh there was some reporting this week that suggests amazon is working on building a thing that it calls the world product graph which is essentially a complete database of all shopping activity and product information everywhere on the internet, which would do a couple of things.
1:32:45David Pierce: It would give Amazon a huge amount of data on how shopping happens on the internet, even when it's not on amazon.com. And they want to bring a lot of that stuff into Amazon. Like part of Amazon's thing has always been to let you buy stuff that Amazon has nothing to do with because they can charge fees to retailers just by being the platform on which you buy stuff. But the other part of it is also this becomes incredibly valuable data for AI agents. So I just want to put into everybody's brain that Amazon is actually desperately trying to become the center of the agentic shopping universe, but it wants to make a hell of a lot of money at every single step of that operation.
1:33:22David Pierce: And they want to put ads everywhere.
1:33:24Brendan Carr: Yes. Because Amazon has a giant ad business that no one ever thinks about. Yes.
1:33:28David Pierce: I think this is going to get really awful for consumers. Just the competition happening behind the scenes. Think about the mechanisms that people don't understand just to put something at the top of your Google search results and how weird and obfuscated that became over time. The AI stuff, which is by nature more obfuscated, is going to be such a mess to the point where it's going to be very hard to understand why you're being shown the retailer link and product recommendations that you are. And we are just staring down the barrel of that. And Amazon is maybe the company most well suited to just run that however it wants to.
1:34:08Brendan Carr: Well, the problem that all these companies have that Google has run into with the web is you can do all this stuff, but you crush the incentive to make new information. Right. So Google search, the incentive to make a new web page and try to rank in Google search was really high for the longest time because then you could show ads to you, whatever it is you want to do. You could sell widgets. If you got to the top of Google search, there was some money at the bottom of that rainbow for you. Yeah. Now it's like you make new information and Google summarizes it in AI overview and you get nothing.
1:34:37Brendan Carr: or in the worst case for Reddit, Redditors make conversation and Reddit summarizes for you and they literally kill their own community because they're not even bringing new audience to the conversations on Reddit. And Reddit's always at war with its users, but that will just get really bad. Amazon doing this by summarizing all the information about products will crush that entire ecosystem overnight, basically, because that is one of the last pure sources of incentive to make new information. to sell people things to do affiliate links and sell people things like right right like you're you're just done like you're not going to publish to amazon right you're not going to have your community on amazon talking about the best whatever like if our apple moves to amazon like i will eat my hat you know what i mean like it's not gonna happen so now amazon is like we're gonna extract value from everywhere for a world product graph and the economic incentives do any of this stuff for any other company is going to go to zero.
1:35:36Brendan Carr: The social incentives to hang out with your friends will continue to be high, but there's no platforms that can economically support it because there's no traffic for it.
1:35:45David Pierce: Well, except if you're Amazon and you've created what the Biden administration and Lena Kahn believe to be an illegal monopoly that systematically forces everybody to use your platform and die, then you've successfully and should abide to the point where you can play these games and there's maybe nothing anybody can do about it.
1:36:02Brendan Carr: Can I connect this to my next one? Sure. Same idea. Google last week told a bunch of schools that they could not turn off AI overviews without also disabling Google search, which is just the most monopoly coded thing anyone has ever heard. Like, what are you going to do? You're not Google search. And so a bunch of huge school districts are like, what if we don't have Google search, which if Google search has been so destroyed, is that a rational thing to say? Yep. Like they just arrived at this. So it's New York, Los Angeles, and Chicago schools are considering Google alternatives after the company said it will disable search for schools that opt out of AI features.
1:36:39Brendan Carr: Starting next year, those features will go away. Google claims search and AI are deeply integrated. But Google search, because the web is dying, even the 10 blue links are not as useful as they used to be. Because Google killed the web with AI overuse by killing its own incentive. And you're like, oh, is this, to quote my friend David Pierce, is this something? Is this anything? Like this is the end point of one set of decisions where you ruin the economic incentive to make new things. Microsoft called it a doom loop in emails that came out in one of the antitrust trials. And the point that the Microsoft executive was making was there's very few products in the world where if they get successful, they kill their suppliers.
1:37:23Right.
1:37:23Brendan Carr: So if you make a car and you get really successful, it is unlikely that you will put the car seat vendor on a business. Car seat vendor is probably going to like that's normal.
1:37:30David Pierce: Yeah.
1:37:31Brendan Carr: AI is the only product where if it gets really successful, it kills the supply of information by making it not economically viable. And so, like, Google has killed the supply of information to search. It's made search not as valuable as it used to be. And so now they're pointing a gun. You can't have search unless you have AI. And a bunch of big customers are like, well, your search sucks. Yeah. What if we try another search? And it's just, like, remarkable Google didn't see that endpoint of Monopoly.
1:37:56David Pierce: Yeah, it's the real, what are you going to do, leave. That is actually, it's very important that your product be hard to leave in a way that I'm not sure Google search is hard to leave. Google Classroom and Chromebooks and stuff like that will be hard to leave. But you've got to figure there are teams at DuckDuckGo and Bing and like pick your other search engine running around being like, hey, I don't know if you're aware of this. Search is completely commoditized. Like if you're looking for a way to get to the Wikipedia page about something, we've also got that. Right. But like, I suspect, and again, I keep thinking about Satya Nadella being like, we are just desperate for queries because it makes our search engine bigger.
1:38:37David Pierce: Like Satya Nadella is going to run around to every school district in the country being like, we'll give you Bing for free. Do you want Bing for free? You can have Bing for free. He's got to sell AI.
1:38:44Brendan Carr: Otherwise, Anthropic will destroy the economy in a one world state or whatever he's worried about. Well, no, if you just think about query, why do they want queries? Because it was ranking data. Yeah. Right. They could see what people are searching for. They could see what they picked and they could re-rank. Well, there's a whole tool there that's pretty good at semantically understanding the information on webpages and ranking it. You don't need it on the front end. You can use it on the back end. Sure. Your ranking problem, there's new tools to solve your ranking problem. We'll see. Google has a statement.
1:39:13Brendan Carr: We hear parents and teachers' concerns about students using AI to shortcut learning, and we share the same goal to help students learn, to improve search for the classroom. We're starting a pilot guided learning and search that walks students step by step through a range of problems instead of just giving answers. and next year gemini notebook and search will be off by default until they decide which and it's like dude that's not the thing they want they want students to type queries into a box and go to web pages and get a list of things and then like click on them and do the process themselves the the process is the point not having yep i don't know man it this one seems like i i my prediction is Google is going to have to find a way to lock this back or the school districts actually will walk away from Google.
1:39:58Brendan Carr: And that will be the first time we've seen that happen in scale.
1:40:00David Pierce: Yes. And I think these school districts are actually pretty heavily incentivized to walk away from Google. The parents don't want any of this stuff.
1:40:07Brendan Carr: There's actually another study right next to this nationwide study that found banning phones in schools is the equivalent of adding one to two weeks of instruction to the year. Oh, wow. That's like you just get more time. yeah this is a study that was carried out by Harvard and Dartmouth 3.3 million students across 4 ,600 schools and like I have a kid in school and the parents are like get rid of all the technology and so I think all these school districts are going to say we got rid of Google we got rid of Google AI it's old school and all the parents are going to be happy
1:40:41David Pierce: does Max have like a like an iPad or a Chromebook that she's supposed to take to school every day no
1:40:46Brendan Carr: but there are Chromebooks at the school that they use sometimes and she has an iPad at home that's only used for garbage. This is the garbage screen. It's the garbage screen. I support that. There's a metronome app on it now for her violin practice. So we're step by step, we are. That's not garbage. It's not garbage. There you go.
1:41:06David Pierce: Max, you're invited to play a Brendan Carr with a theme song on the violin at any time.
1:41:10Brendan Carr: We are working our way through Twinkle Twinkle Little Star. We're going to get there. Twinkle Twinkle. Brendan Carr. Brendan Carr.
1:41:18David Pierce: well it's time for us to end the podcast we're not we're not doing any better than that uh nila who is on decoder next week what's going on i should say by the way uh you just did an episode of the john favreau that went up talking about democrats in the midterms and the future of everything uh that was good i enjoyed that he's very good we've been having i don't know if
1:41:35Brendan Carr: you've been paying attention every ounce of data we have says i should stop talking to ceos yep and i still feel like i should do the reporting it's important to me that we do the reporting, but we're trying to expand the aperture. So John Favreau from Crooked was great. We did talk about the business of Crooked, which is fascinating. Alex Stamos, the security episode we just did where we just talked about, he said we're in the dark ages. Really fun conversation.
1:42:00David Pierce: And I was like, how do I... Very pertinent to the stuff we were talking about at the beginning about everything falling apart. He's a guy who knows. I like doing the reporting.
1:42:06Brendan Carr: I ended that conversation by saying, I want to end on a hopeful note. And he goes, wrong guest, buddy. I'm reasonably certain Monday's episode is the CEO of ZocDoc. Ooh. That is my belief. That's a good one. Yeah, I thought so.
1:42:18David Pierce: I like that. Also, version history continues. This weekend is Tamagotchi. Did you know that the 30th anniversary of Tamagotchi is like the beginning of next week? There's a fun fact. This weekend's episode is basically three of us having complete crash outs about how annoying Tamagotchis are for like an hour and a half. It's really great. Really enjoyed it. Go check out version history. Go check out Decoder. And as a reminder, the best way to get all of that stuff, to consume all of the things The Verge makes is to subscribe to The Verge. Theverge.com slash subscribe. It gets you all of our podcasts ad-free.
1:42:49David Pierce: It gets you all of our newsletters. V's thing this week about the Siri recaps in Optimizer is very good. I encourage you to go read that. Subscribe to Optimizer. Subscribe to Notepad. Subscribe to everything. Theverge.com slash subscribe. Thank you in advance. We also love hearing from you. Like I mentioned, we're doing the AI hotline with Hayden next week. So if you have AI Jensen Wong questions you want to get in, please do that ASAP. We're recording with her on Monday. So you have the weekend to get that stuff in. but in general reach out to us about anything and everything the email is vergecast at the verge.com the hotline is 866 verge 11 the best part of the show is responding to weird things you all think about technology it's what we like to do here the verge cast is a verge production and part of the box media podcast network the show is produced by josh kahas eric gomez brandon keifer and travis larchuk we will see you next week we will not have this show next week because it's thanksgiving so neil and i will not be speaking to each other for two weeks but until Until then, Nilay.
1:43:43Brendan Carr: Rock and roll.
1:44:11David Pierce: start managing your business with one unified system. Try for free today at odoo.com slash vox. That's odoo.com slash vox.
1:44:23Nilay Patel: Support for this show comes from Bamboo HR. Today's tech raises a lot of questions. At Bamboo HR, we believe there's one easy answer. Invest in people. People with the imagination to dream up the next big thing, and the grit and passion to actually build it. That's why we've built a new kind of AI-powered HR platform, one that unifies all of your workforce data in one place and provides insights you can act on. So your people are at their best and your business is too. Learn more at BambooHR.com.
1:44:55David Pierce: Your sausage McMuffin with egg didn't change, your receipt did. The sausage McMuffin with egg extra value meal includes a hash brown and a small coffee for just$5. Only at McDonald's for a limited time.
1:45:08Brendan Carr: Price and participation may vary. Promotion pricing may be lower than meal pricing.
Banks. Planes. Emails. This week, it felt like everything broke just about all at once. Nilay and David try to explain what happened, and whether the relatively mundane truths still add up to something big and scary. Then, they catch up on the latest in the Jensen Huang story, and the China chip smuggling story that might be even bigger. Finally, it's time for Brendan Carr, Google name disasters, and Siri Recap.
Further reading:
America’s air traffic control system couldn’t handle a single bad router
Work to replace old copper wire led to the FAA’s ground stop
United Airlines system outage disrupts departures just days after the big ground stop
Inside Microsoft’s giant Outlook outage
Microsoft has finished restoring service after its massive Outlook outage.
15 hotel guests were injured by chlorine poisoning due to Microsoft’s global email outage
Satya Nadella says Microsoft has “work to do” after last week’s outages.
Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella doesn’t know when the rush to patch AI-discovered bugs will end.
Chase says a “technical issue” is making some transactions take longer than usual.
Did every big bank really have an outage on Monday afternoon? No.
Apple iCloud, App Store, and AppleCare outage updates.
Tech leaders are convinced that Jensen Huang’s exit was a plot against him
Jensen Huang says he’s willing to return as Nvidia CEO
Trump says it ‘certainly isn’t a bad idea’ for Jensen Huang to return to Nvidia
Nvidia says it does not intend to reinstate Jensen Huang as CEO
One potential Nvidia CEO candidate? Arm’s CEO.
Nvidia’s Q3 earnings hit the mark, without mentioning the whole Jensen Huang thing
Read everything that Nvidia’s board chair had to say about Jensen Huang
The SEC has reportedly opened an investigation into Nvidia.
Congress wants to tighten rules on exporting AI chips to China after Nvidia spy scandal
Nvidia isn’t selling any more AI chips to China
Senator slams commerce secretary for flow of Nvidia AI chips to China
The DOJ says it’s investigating Megaspeed
What is Nvidia without AI’s sugar daddy in charge?
Satya Nadella says he’s AGI-pilled now
Sen. Luján Raises Serious Concerns About FCC Nominee's Character, Urges Commerce Committee Chairman Ted Cruz to Delay Confirmation Vote
Democrats skip a vote on adding Brendan Carr’s adviser to the FCC
Carr Says Democrats Won’t Slow FCC Agenda.
I let Apple’s always-listening AI summarize my life for two weeks
The nation’s largest school districts consider ditching Google Search
Banning phones really does help kids learn, researchers say
Google’s Spark AI agent becomes ‘Tasks’ — and now it’s free
Amazon is “talking to every one” of the AI agent companies.
Amazon has a plan to index the world’s online shopping data
YouTube found a new way to inflate view counts
Subscribe to The Verge for unlimited access to theverge.com, subscriber-exclusive newsletters, and our ad-free podcast feed.
We love hearing from you! Email your questions and thoughts to [email protected] or call us at 866-VERGE11.
0:00 Welcome and Travel Chaos
01:32 GTA VI Hype Check
04:01 HomeView Versus Old iPhone
06:26 HomeView Software Frustrations
14:05 Week Everything Broke
15:32 Y2K Vibes and AI Patching
19:42 Brittleness and Missing Humans
23:11 Elon and DOGE Fallout
27:43 Why It Feels Fragile
35:02 Altman Board Chaos
36:55 Jobs Comeback Reality
37:41 Jensen Legal Fallout
40:18 China Smuggling Probe
42:10 Petitions And Rumors
44:15 Anthropic IPO Whiplash
47:57 Conference Vibes Check
51:19 AGI Versus Business
59:36 Brendan Carr is a Dummy
01:09:21 Google Tasks Confusion
01:12:14 Google Naming Chaos
01:14:22 Testing Agentic Email Tasks
01:17:24 Apple Live Rewind Privacy
01:21:06 Siri Recaps Are Nonsense
01:28:20 YouTube Co Views Metrics
01:29:22 Amazon World Product Graph
01:33:42 Schools Push Back on AI Search
01:38:55 Wrap Up and Coming Soon
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices