‘Pluribus’ Penultimate Episode and ‘Landman’ Episode 5

19 Dec 2025 · 55 min

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Podcast Episode Notes: The Watch - Episode: ‘Pluribus’ Penultimate Episode and ‘Landman’ Episode 5

Hosts

  • Chris Ryan
  • Andy Greenwald

Producers

  • Kaya McMullen
  • Kai Grady

Video Production

  • Jon Jones

Episode Summary In this episode of *The Watch*, Chris Ryan and Andy Greenwald discuss upcoming TV shows for January, review the penultimate episode of *Pluribus*, and recap episode 5 of *Landman*.

---

Key Discussion Points

Upcoming Shows in January (3:44)

  • Exciting Lineup:
  • *The Pit* Season 2
  • *Industry* Season 4
  • *His and Hers* (John Bernthal, Tessa Thompson)
  • *Riot Women* (Sally Wainwright)
  • *Gangs of London* Season 3
  • *Ponies* (A spy comedy with Hayley Lou Richardson and Emilia Clarke)
  • *Night of the Seven Kingdoms* (from the *Game of Thrones* universe)
  • *Shrinking*

*Pluribus* Season 1 - Episode 8 Review (25:27)

  • Carol's Character Arc:
  • Discussion on the emotional depth of Carol's journey.
  • The episode explores themes of loneliness and longing.
  • Key Scene: The diner scene where Carol experiences a mix of kindness and creepiness, highlighting her emotional complexity.
  • Reflection on Carol's relationships with others, especially regarding her difficulties in accepting help or affection.

Themes in *Pluribus*

  • The show presents a psychological narrative intertwined with societal commentary.
  • The depiction of emotional realities is noted as a standout feature.
  • The importance of the show's slow pacing in developing character arcs.

*Landman* Episode 5 Recap (38:36)

  • Tone and Style:
  • Comparison of the pacing and tone of *Landman* to *Pluribus*; while *Pluribus* is precise, *Landman* is more chaotic and free-form.
  • Character Dynamics:
  • Changes in the relationships between major characters, particularly Cammie, Tommy, and Rebecca.
  • The episode revolves around the legal and moral complexities faced by the characters in the oil industry.
  • Key Takeaway:
  • Both shows highlight different forms of storytelling, with *Landman* presenting a more traditional, albeit erratic, TV experience.

---

Key Takeaways

  • January TV Preview: Both hosts express excitement for a busy month of new series and returning favorites.
  • Emotional Depth in *Pluribus*: The exploration of Carol's character and the subtleties of her emotional struggles are praised for their depth.
  • *Landman*'s Unique Style: While *Landman* lacks the precision of *Pluribus*, it offers a different, more whimsical storytelling approach, which the hosts find entertaining.

---

Conclusion Chris and Andy wrap up the episode with a tease for their upcoming mailbag episode and continued coverage of *Pluribus*'s finale, indicating the lively discussions that are set to continue in the new year.

---

Feel free to add any additional notes or comments that may arise from further discussions or personal reflections on the episode!

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:05I need support staff to clear the room. Stand up and walk now.

0:37as one hand. You didn't say a master and commander themed dinner. That would be amazing. All the fellows show up for a master and commander themed dinner. Greenwall, great to see you today on the show. Pluribus episode 8. Landman, I think it's episode 6, but it was Sunday's episode called Pirate Dinner. We will get into some news at the top. Some programming reminders. Today, obviously, our show. Then Monday we're going to do a special year-end mailbag, which I'm very excited about. Then later next week, we will be releasing an episode timed to the pluribus finale that's some special guests so we're very excited about that and that will be some uh x-mas listening for folks what's cool is we didn't get access to any of the creative team but anybody can be another from that show that's right so we just grab some folks from the lobby um and then we're gonna be off uh for that week in between kind of the after christmas before or after new years and we'll be back on like the second or fourth i believe it is how are you feeling about you know we released our top 10 our year-end episode into the wild how are you feeling about how it's been received do you feel like do you feel like you've been heard do you feel like so i don't know if you did probably didn't have a chance to tune into the sure thing rewatchables which went live last night in honor of rob reiner bill opened the show by discussing watching us in bed while his wife played a video game on her phone i'm gonna unpack that we were in bed no he was watching the watch on his big screen television oh in bed and thought that we had too much opening banter but had really like some good ideas but that's been the note for the last 13 or 14 years he was like you guys i needed to get to honorable mentions faster that's baked in at this point i know i don't mean look do we have to re-record no uh i enjoyed our best the year i think it was warmly received i want to know how you feel about this because I don't know how many more ways we can explain that Sam Esmail is our friend and no longer wants to appear on these podcasts and that those things are both true yes but maybe it's better to print the legend because we I read texts from Sam at the beginning of the podcast oh like I think we should just put his face up there with a Ghostbuster like slash through it because there's still comments like on our stuff being like you are hiding from Sam or you fired him because he disagreed with you I need you to accept the fact that a lot of the people who comment about work that we do, do not actually engage with the work.

3:05That's humbling to think about. That's work. You don't, wait. It's sort of like your relationship to television. And sports. And sports. And the entire NBA season. Yeah. I'm not sure if it's been played or not. They're game casting our pod. You know, they just want to see the results. They don't really care about the process. So they're looking at next-gen stats, and they're seeing that we've vamped. Like, we're doing right now for, like, 20 minutes before we get into the content. The reason why I'm vamping with you right now, the reason why, first of all, it's Funky Thursdays. It's Fun Thursdays.

3:38We still don't have the right name for that, but yeah. Casual Thursdays? Chaos Menu? I don't know what to call it. The reason why I'm doing it is because we're not going to have the luxury of doing this in January. Because January, weirdly, strangely, is going to be among the busier months of our podcasting careers. So rough. Now, look, how we cover this is yet to be determined, but I just mean in terms of sheer volume of shows that we are really interested in and could be interested in. Okay. I don't think I've ever seen a January like it, and I don't understand it. I don't, usually, like, you get, like, a rush of shows kind of in the spring to get under the Emmy wire, right?

4:18Like, we've had, like, crazy April, Mays, but I don't remember coming out of a holiday season into January. And here's just a list of some of the shows that are premiering in January. Like within the first two weeks, right? And we're going to talk about some of these in detail. The Pit. Season two. Season two. Industry season four. Yeah. His and Hers on Netflix, which is a John Bernthal, Tessa Thompson thriller. Crazy. Riot Women, which is the new show from Sally Wainwright, an incredible British writer who did Happy Valley. Gangs of London season three. Okay. So, it's ebbing a little bit. I'll give you a download on what happened on the first two seasons.

4:57Thanks. Ponies, which is a new show on Peacock that I was kind of intrigued by. It looks good. Yeah, which is like a spy comedy. It's a period spy comedy with Hayley Lou Richardson and Emilia Clarke. Yeah. And Ponies stands for Persons of No Interest. Yes. And I'm not one of them. I'm interested. I'm interested. I'm anti-pony for ponies. Night of the Seven Kingdoms. God damn it. What? Shrinking is back which we have not engaged with in the past but is a notable big Apple release to just be like let's slide this in there I just feel like I spend most of my life either in therapy or in Pasadena and I don't need a show about both of those things honestly that's probably the most that's the best possible answer you could possibly give for why we don't engage with Shrinking I'm trying to be honest about things you know like when the rehearsal came up on Monday and I was like I can't get over the fact that someone took a picture of me thinking I was him that's why I don't watch it simpler, simpler, simpler just be honest Yeah, it's cringe and all that, but like, really?

5:53And then finally, season two, 10 years after season one of The Night Manager, which is Tom Hiddleston and Olivia Colman in an extended Le Carre universe piece about... Your vigil paid off. That candle has been flickering on your mantle for 10 years. I now think we are no longer allowed to make fun of Severance for taking too long. Oh. We kind of checkmated ourselves there. because we're excited about this? Yes. Well, it was a long night to manage. What of that group of shows do you think you're most excited to have back? Well, I mean, the fact that Industry and The Pit, which are two of our favorite shows, full stop, are coming back within a week of each other is diabolical.

6:40That's incredibly exciting. Yeah. And both weekly releases. And both weekly releases, which is good. The Pit season two full trailer was released. Yeah. I would say my main observation is it has like more swagger than the first season trailer than the first like the way that the show was presented which I think I can't even really remember but I do remember it being like oh it's just kind of weird is this kind of betwixt in between HBO show and a Mac show and is it going to be just like a heart like a straight procedural or what wasn't prepared for the you know the emotions it would stir and also just the excitement it would stir this one has a little bit of like they did the gritty in the end zone.

7:20You know what I mean? The coach didn't like that. Coach O 'Connell was not happy about that. Yeah, he didn't. Do you think that you would swagger a little bit if you had an undisputed touchdown? Would you have the presence in mind? I would be like Dan Lanning. I would want all my guys to party and celebrate. Oh, so I would run through the back of the end zone. I'd run through the tape. You know what I mean? Then you just hand the ball to the ref. No showboating. That's classic white wide receiver shit right there. that's some real McCaffrey shit yeah just like here you go sir thank you for the opportunity it's expected that I score it's what I'm paid to do it's what my father told me every night before I fell asleep yeah yeah I mean well the pit season one had to sell audiences on a lot including just like a vibe like do you guys remember a show that litigiously we're not legally we're not going to mention right maybe we could give you some more of that and the fun of returning for a second season with the kind of success that it's had is remember these six people that you love, they're back.

8:16Right. And you get to look at them more. And that's a winning strategy for a TV show. Speaking of like the severance delay or the night manager delay, like not just that we got the season two trailer, not just that we got the season two trailer two weeks, two and a half weeks before it returns. There was something in my brain that was like, are they giving away too much? Do they actually have all of this filmed? It's like I'm not used to such a full plate. Yeah. I thought they would just give a little like beep, beep, beep Robbie's face. That was the teaser that they did like like a couple weeks ago and everything.

8:45But now they're like, oh no, they shot this. Yeah. There's no mystery here. It's done. Yeah. They're not like burning the midnight oil over at the studio. Yeah, I mean, it's kind of fascinating. This show, I think, will be one of the most anticipated releases of the year, I would imagine, both critically and sort of like on that TV addict way. But also, I think, on a general, like, I watch four shows a year level. This is one of them. And, you know, this returning cast, we see a little bit of Langdon, we see Mel, we see all of our faves. I wonder, you know, how much turnover there will be on this cast?

9:18Because they're going to obviously push the limits in terms of story about what Dana and Robbie and these people can take. You've got people fan casting the Pitt night shift, you know, like the Hadassi version. Yeah, which I think people want. And the biggest tragedy for me is that Dr. Collins still has her phone on Do Not Disturb. I know. I mean, she must be living a blissful life. Can I ask you something about putting your phone on do not disturb because i do it and calls just blast through um i don't really get it maybe kaya can help us on this like i know lots of people who have their phone on do not disturb and and still have like a full texting life what is the upside well you can program it so some people can break through right let's let's talk to our youth correspondent so the trick with do not disturb is that if you call twice in a row it breaks through all right is that real indeed Oh my God.

10:09Okay. Well, who breaks through? Your kids? No, it's set to, they can always reach me. What about me? My kids can always reach me. One fun thing that my, my parents' relationship with telephones and all technology is still pretty Jurassic. So they do call multiple times and sometimes forget that they've just called or they're not aware that it's, so one call from them normally involves three distinct ringing episodes. so that's probably why I can't, uh, in the spirit of the holidays, block them out completely. Right. I see. Okay. Yeah. Well, I'm always, cause you know, it got in my head a little bit that there was a time when you would awake to a number of spirited messages from me, alerting you to the events or trailers that dropped between one and 6am.

11:01But now I'm a little bit, you know, I don't know your waking schedule, but I also don't want to, cause you don't put it on do not disturb. I don't I often will leave it outside of my room because now I kind of mechanically wake up at the same time every day so I don't need an alarm but I do get disoriented if I don't see what time it is I you know I don't want to I don't want to rush you yeah you used to send me a lot of shit in the morning just like well let's look at the trades and I'm like okay I haven't had coffee yet and also you pay Richard Rushfeld to do that Matt Bellany to give you the updates I do I thought that I was providing a bespoke service I wish okay um yeah but anyway like what else you got from this like what are your what's your power listing what's your power rankings of interest level you know i'm looking i'm i'm excited for this mixture of returning and new uh so ponies and uh his and hers and riot women i'm very curious about uh this is a bernthal television show yeah this is made for you maybe uh well they all are all those bernthal shows are uh did you see did i send you the video i've talked about this before of bernthal there's a clip going around because it's from an old podcast that you do with Shia where Shia is like, I want to work at Home Depot.

12:11And Bernthal is just like, you think you can work in Home Depot. Do you really think you can do that? Do you go to Home Depot? And Shia's like, that's my church, bro. That's where I go. That's I have mad projects. Whoa. It's so funny. That is, first of all, that is a similar tone to what you take with me. You think you can work in Home Depot. That's something that you think you can do. One of my favorite things about this is Jon Bernthal, like us, went to a Quaker school. I think he saw a different side of Quakerism, though. The rough and tumble side? Well, I just don't know how. He's just too authentic.

12:46I'm not saying he's phony. It wouldn't work for him to play these parts. That said, he is a suburban Jew who went to a Quaker school. It'd be awesome to have a podcast with Jon Bernthal called Another Side of Quakerism. And it's all about... the shit we got into while we were in Quaker school sometimes that light within can burn disrupting meeting for worship were you a big stand up and meeting for worship guy? I don't think I ever did it I don't think I ever did it I mean I also was of a generation that I don't think really prioritized meeting for worship like in the way that it should be like it would often be this is a cool free period if we can get out of meeting early like you know what I mean like once meeting ends there's like a little bit of playtime.

13:31So when people would stand up and start talking about their dead turtle, we would be like, fuck. Yeah, I mean, so for people who don't know, the hallmark of a Quaker education is once a week you have a meeting for worship where you sit in quiet reflection in the traditions of the Quaker religious ceremony. And then if you feel moved to speak, you could speak. But in retrospect, like when you're little, like kids would stand up and be like, meeting is a time to think about God because they thought you were supposed to say that. Yeah. That's like the kindergarten move. But then - Did you do that in kindergarten?

13:55I didn't. Okay. No. but because I was like in kindergarten I was like what if Rancho Man Randy Savage fought Optimus Prime in a neutral site that's what I'm thinking about I'm just wondering if your school because we didn't know each other then we went to rival Quaker schools it's kind of like our version of Quakerism and John Bernthal's version of Quakerism you went to a place in the suburbs why you gotta say it like that I'm just saying that's where it was located okay it physically was located in the suburbs I was on the parkway you were you were right in the shit right by love park you know me and harmony green talking about transformers talking about gummo but did it get like i just feel like the rules were bent a little bit because i remember in middle school when like earth day became a thing yeah we would have like themed meetings where someone would be like we're gonna begin meeting for worship with a song about how the environment belongs to all of us and they play like an ed brickell song and we'd all sit in silence be like what the fuck are we listening to and then i guess think about the whales for 40 minutes.

14:55And that feels a little directional. You know what I mean? Like, what if I didn't want to think about that? Oh, you like to have an action. You like to have like... No, I didn't. Oh, you don't. You want to have it just be like, I'm thinking about Randall Cunningham right now. Yes. Or, you know, will the city ever appreciate Scott Rowland? Or whatever was relevant at that era. I, yeah. I mean, I kind of miss it though. It was kind of nice. Yeah. There's a period every week where you did nothing. It's like therapy, but you don't have to talk. Wow. So you'd fit right in with Shia at Home Depot. Yeah, I think I'm very excited.

15:26I was curious what your temp check on Night of the Seven Kingdoms is. I mean, you haven't dipped into these screeners, right? I don't even know if we're even allowed to mention that we have them. Yes. I'll mention it. Okay. I don't care anymore. Yeah. Clip this, Kaya. I don't care. I got screeners, but I haven't watched them yet. Too busy. It's fine. Got nothing to hide. well I guess I'm open minded about it because the entire pitch of the show as we understand it as non book readers and non house of our we don't live in the house of our we're fans is that this is I summer there do you? yeah the summer you turn pretty that this is this is not the same tone it's a series of novellas that he wrote that I think are a little bit less high stakes is my understanding but also quite good and some of the best work he's done writing wise.

16:20This is George R. R. Martin. Yes. And that these episodes, I believe, are only a half an hour long. Why? Don't quote you on that. I didn't know that. I'm fairly certain that they're like, it's like six 30 minute episodes. It's almost a little bit more British style. Sounds great. I think. Okay. I could be wrong. I'm very much looking forward to it. That sounds nice. This is a series that actually didn't get strip mind in the great streaming wars of the early part of this decade where people were taking Star Wars and Marvel and DC and just being like, we got to get as much stuff as possible up on the services.

16:56Like Game of Thrones, for whatever you think about the ending of Game of Thrones and whatever you think of House of the Dragon has been relatively modest. Modest. And I think that the HBO team has been good stewards of making sure that whatever goes up is going to honor what they've accomplished so far. Okay. Yeah, I'm eager to see that. I'm, did you, do you have any thoughts you'd like to share about the industry season four poster that was just released? I'm just, I'm just ready. Yeah, no, we're ready. We don't need trailers. We are on board, but I do really enjoy the real time retconning of what the show is.

17:29That's about Yasmin and Harper. Well, which is awesome. Yeah. And, but I, I am a fan of the fact that the show took a very nonlinear path to maybe uncovering what it quote, unquote, has always been. The central relationship, yeah. And also that your man and Kit Harington is just in the poster. Yeah. Because he's a pretty big draw when he's on an HBO show. We can get to Pluribus first. We could get to Landman first. Is there anything else? Did you want to talk Night Manager trailer? You wanted me to watch it? I thought it was quite good. I think that there are going to be many people. Some may be like, what a great excuse to revisit Night Manager, which I thought was an excellent series, if I remember correctly, from 2015.

18:06But that is a lifetime ago. It's hundreds of television shows ago. So it's multiple vacations. That must be nice. Wow. Want to list your top three? Croatia? Wow. 15. Portugal, 17. You were ahead of the crowds on that one. I did. I didn't get a golden passport there. You're not Sephardic. Is that a big thing over there? I believe Portuguese government was offering citizenship to Jews of Sephardic descent. due to their treatment during the Inquisition period. What that half was. Nah, you're shtetl like me. Come on. You're not like... Why are you turning into Mel Brooks all of a sudden? Because that's what happens to all of us, inevitably.

18:57I just don't remember what happened on The Night Manager. I know that Hugh Laurie's Dickie Roper is an arms dealer, and I don't remember his fate. I'm fairly certain he's not with us, but he's in the second season trailer of Night Manager. Here's my slant on this. Does it matter? Like 10 years ago, it was a completely different show and a completely different television ecosystem and moment. It was on a completely different network. Totally different global chessboard. The show was for AMC. Now it's an Amazon Prime series. And I just don't get the sense from the trailer, which looks beautiful.

19:31It's full of many delightful British actors who we've seen in many other delightful things. And the first season, even for those who didn't watch it, know that it was primarily a show about linens. and blousey suit jackets and hot temperatures. You still, you remember. Yeah, I remember how the way those shirts were fitting my guy Loki. Debeki. Looked great. Yeah. And our guy Debeki. She's amazing. I don't think it matters. I think that what Amazon bought here and resurrected here is this is a Marvel star looking cool in a action espionage show. And so let's go. So I don't think there's a big barrier to entry here.

20:08Hey, speaking of trailers, have you spent any time on your for you tab on twitter recently i i don't i don't frequent twitter anymore um you say that but you do send me tweets only on game day okay um there's like a thing going on right now where everybody is like oh my god the the doomsday trailer or whatever like all the avengers trailers because something's coming and it's all like either ai or it's like vague posting where they're like you're never gonna believe this and then it's like nobody can understand it they're putting out are they really putting out four trailers in the over the course of the next couple weeks with Avatar is that true?

20:43We don't know I mean I do think does Avatar need that much help? Well you're the guy that should I'm just I'm concerned trolling Avatar Did you see that Big Jim Cameron responded to you? He didn't respond to me he responded to a sentiment that I think some of his fans share he also okay you're a passive voice guy you are literally the face of the you're like the QAnon shaman being like, you know, there was a gathering of ideas. There was. He perhaps is the figurehead of that gathering. Sure. There certainly were more than just one guy at January 6th. Right. He just happened to be the one wearing the fucking animal pelts.

21:20And that's you on Pandora being like, this sucks, shut it down.

21:29First of all, everything needs all the help it can get. Sure. Other than the Zootopia franchise, apparently. And by the way, you're not ready for my takes on that. Have you seen it? Of course. Opening weekend. Two? Yes. Zootopia. I am not ready for your takes on that. It sucked. Okay. Sorry to all of China who's apparently boosting it with their collective wealth. Did you see that movie? I did. It made a billion dollars in like six days. I did. Anyway, Avengers thing is it does feel like it's all disinfo campaign because it's not just, I mean, you responsibly source your information from the For You tab on X whereas I just get fed a steady stream of slop on Facebook.

22:09And by the way, one thing that I don't think you're aware of, but definitely like your one uncle with the email account is aware of is how the slop is fed to us now on Facebook, which is not just like, you know, fake news. It's, I'm sure AI generated content that takes like a moment, which is just like, I don't know. what's an example of like um Taron Killam leaving Saturday Night Live and they were like it's like quote guys I'm done the room the room at Studio 8G was chilled by Taron Killam's announcement but they knew the show they loved would no longer be the same that's what it does for like the most banal really celebrity information oh because they're like make this of the most like sticky kind of story this as like some yeah and one of the things I'm getting is just like beat by beat breakdowns of completely invented trailers for a movie yes yes so i saw i watched one that was uh it was like multiple people from avengers but then also sigourney weavers ripley and a predator you wrote this like you're more interested now totally the disney team is coming together totally like what uh do you feel like Avengers Doomsday is a distressed asset right now?

23:34Um, I think it's in the Zootopia zone. I think it's - So it's gonna be big in China. I think it's gonna be big, but I think it's gonna be, I think they need to end this. And I think that they, I think that this is like steering into the skid where they're like, you know what, this, the whole Kang thing didn't work out. Let's actually put good money on top of bad money. Sure. Sure. end this, get back in people's faces with these characters and some of these other things. But honestly, I don't really know what's happening. You know what I mean? I don't really know what's happening. I assume they're going to be building towards secret wars.

24:10Yeah, I think the problem... But it's going to be weird if people are like, Rebecca Romaine? Is that what we did? No, that's what I mean. There's no story here. So these movies have to do so many things and potentially impossible things, but one of which is make a case for its own existence and story momentum because it's not really building on anything. Like even the most optimistic among us, like me, who... You are very optimistic. About this. I liked Thunderbolts and I liked Fantastic Four. You are kind of weird that way. I believe I'm in the minority. And so you see these set images and it's just like, oh man.

24:40I just love Reed Richards and Jay Kelly. That's just who I am. What's wrong with that? But it's just like Shang-Chi and Eben Moss Bacharach, that's one's a character, one's an actor, sorry. And Ben Grimm palling around in London. And I'm like, I see the vision. Sure. But I don't know if I see the... So maybe Avatar's helping them. I don't know. Yeah, no, that actually... That's a good zag. Do you like that take? Yeah. It's actually the Na 'vi are helping the Avengers. Let's do Pluribus first. Before Landman? Okay. We can do whichever one you want. All right. Let's do Pluribus first. I weirdly think I have more to say about Landman.

25:17Okay, me too. But I've also... I've also liked Pluribus, I think in the last couple of weeks, like... I certainly, obviously, I think it's one of the best shows of the year. I think the second half of this season has been remarkable. So to talk about this episode, episode eight. Eight.

25:38You have been, and I love the show as well. You have been much more patient, I would say, and dialed in to the particular rhythms of this show. Yeah. Maybe even more so than I, and I'm a big advocate of Jay Kelly and other slow food entertainments. Yeah. so this episode which really as it often does like with a fine filigree articulates carol's changing relationship with the situation with the collective with the others with social specifically what was it about this journey with her in this episode that that that grabbed you and i'm not trying to be like concern trolling like i i really enjoyed this episode and but i'm where you are with it.

26:22I just don't really see TV that is delving into these kinds of emotional realities, even if the reality of the show is almost science fictional. And so the depiction of loneliness and the depiction of longing and the depiction of needing companionship is so incredible. And I think that sometimes there are shows that are challenging, and I'm like, well, you just don't get it. I know that this is challenging, and I know that there is a kind of time-lapse thing going on here and a focus on things that most TV shows, most movies even, would be like, this happens in between the cuts. Or this is what would happen as we transition from interior to exterior or from this to two days later when something else important happens.

27:10And instead, this is very carefully choosing certain days in this woman's life and showing almost all of it. and I think the cumulative effect that I am feeling is that all of that stuff all that work every time you listen to the voicemail message every time you've watched her do something domestic inside of her house is like piling up so that breakthrough moments like like the diner scene which I think is yeah amazing the idea that somebody would do something so kind but also so creepy yeah and that she would feel both of those things at the same time and that it would mean so much to her. It's the happiest I've ever seen Carol.

27:52Yeah. And then immediately, she becomes incredibly alarmed at that, you know? Yeah, there's something, the show works on so many levels and one of the things that I think makes it ultimately successful is that you can look at it in the macro of what's happened to the world and what are these massive swings in our society or specifically that have happened to us recently that we're using as mirrors to reflect what's happening in the show, but then also like the emotional minutiae of what's happening with Carol. and the diner scene reminded me of a moment also in the episode when she's like would you like me to after she slept over in the hockey arena or whatever that is and she's like would you like me to make you breakfast and she's like no no you don't have to do that it's okay and there's this idea of asking people for things which for some of us is hard to do and then the extra level of it where it's literally nothing to them whether it's power washing her street or having sex whether it's making her breakfast whether it's having sex with her or whether it's spending untold weeks to completely creepily recreate a long-burned business.

28:59Clearly, there are people who don't have that kind of moral quandary like Diabate, and then Carol is somewhere in the middle of it. And it's interesting to watch someone who has issues, but then also some sense of, like she doesn't actually want that kind of labor done for her, but she also doesn't think she deserves it. And so it's a psychological story at the same time that it is a societal story. Yeah, and I think I always looked at Minusos' character as this

Read the full transcript

29:30weather system coming in and changing things. But I keep going back to that introduction of his character, or when his character leaves Paraguay for the first time and pushes his car out of the garage and his mother shows up and he's like, you're not my mother. My mother was a bitch, you know? The pain that he carries with him from the before times is similar to whatever psychological scar tissue makes it so that Carol can't just be in her own skin and enjoy things when they're being brought to her or anything in the world to make you happy. And she's like, no, I am the unhappiest person. And knowing that these two people are on this collision course and what's going to happen is really compelling to me.

30:13Where are you on the... Again, one of the reasons we like the show is because of the room for spirited debate about the intentions behind things. We were talking about in the previous episode, like Minuso's waving. Is he waving in surrender? Is he waving for help?

30:29Carol's softening towards Zosia and then ultimately like giving in to Zosia. How much of that do you think is... Well, what do you think her reasoning is? How much of it is the loneliness of the 40 days of isolation, just reaching a breaking point, and she'll take whatever companionship she can get? Or is it she's feeling something new that she didn't feel before? And there's no right answer. I'm just curious where you think. Because one of the fun things about watching Carol's Osha scenes are what else is happening behind the scenes. Right, and we don't really necessarily see that other than Manusis' plot.

31:06All the kind of exposition that we've gotten and has usually come from like Diabate or something like, because it's only been recently that I think Carol has started to take the easy road to finding things out. Like, you know, she's done, she's basically done medical procedures on people and flown across the globe. But, you know, she's just asking. I think that, you know, because it's in seven is when she's kind of like, she's treating herself, right? Like that's the one where she's kind of gone on the spa day. That's when she's solo, but it starts hopeful and then it ends pretty bleakly. Because you can only really do that for so long.

31:44There's the lie that we tell ourselves that if I just had time to myself, I would do all this stuff. Are you thinking about my phone calls from week seven of me in London recently? Well, no, but I'm just thinking about like, I mean, I think I talked about this, but when my wife has been out of town this past year and I'm like, I'm going to fucking watch every spaghetti Western. And then it's like, oh God, like after five nights of this. It's a lot. Yeah, it's a lot. You really want to start having human contact again. And so I think that there's something kind of profound about the, the arc of her.

32:15It can be both things, right? Like she can be like, I've, I've taken to life where everything I've ever wanted is right at my fingertips, but I can't enjoy it if I'm doing it alone. Yeah. And I think it's interesting to note that the others are changing slightly. They're learning too. The croquet scene, they make a joke. They dunk on her a little bit. That seems new, right? From the monolithic voice, completely credulous voice that they spoke with earlier in the season. Do we think that that is a benevolent evolution? Or do we think that that is, like everything, a kind of long-term manipulation?

33:04Sure. of being a little more old school human for carol to open up herself yeah to whatever's going to come next do you do you feel like you're like six degrees cooler on this whole thing than i am no it's weird i think that that's how i'm presenting it and it's but i i think that what i am i guess the answer is that i am but i think that i have like i said last week like i i've done this before where there was an entire season of Better Call Saul that I was pretty mid on. Me too. And in the fullness of time and in the fullness of what they were moving towards, I was grateful for the time spent in the experience and it would have been lesser without it.

33:45So I think I'm just trying to stay. I also think our brains are different now than they were when Better Call Saul was on. Sure. I'm learning a lot about the SNL cast Exodus on my Facebook feed. I can't believe how dramatic it was. xenomorphous in doomsday so it's incredible that honestly they're getting this show is getting this much of our attention yeah um but yeah like but there's also some of the joys of the show to me still remain in the like man if it ain't broke this good old-fashioned tv machine can still really deliver when you do it right right for example carol sends out the message of we have to defeat these things when she is in one state of mind and then 50 plus days pass during which time she has a complete breakdown and claws herself back together and opens her heart to if not love then the status quo yeah and that's when the message is answered like that's just as as my friend in the writer's room in london would say that's just good telly well and uh i love the the little flashes of like, yeah, we're, we're kind of better at doing this than every, like, like, uh, Zosha saying you're going to have a visitor.

35:00Yeah. It's just like, I think I'm going to remember that line for a really long time, you know, like, and just that moment and that end of their, their sort of reverie and, and their moment of kind of a honeymoon period being over. I wish you could program Postmates to alert you that way. You're going to have a visitor. But the visitor's got soup. it still is very very funny to me that for all the ways we talk about the show and all the discourse surrounding the show the fact that that Vince Gilligan has made a show about a writer who is forced to generate some crap that she doesn't necessarily believe in and carries not just one whiteboard but a nonsense whiteboard then a secret better version whiteboard is very very on the nose and funny and I just really enjoy the visual of like she's actually kind of working on both but it's unclear which has her heart.

35:54Yeah. And as this episode goes on like do you think that she's adding to the truth about them board for any I think that's how she understands the world is to document it. Document the rules to lay out the structure of it because that's how she writes. To break story. Yeah. to break story. I mean, that scene in the diner keeps coming, I keep coming back to it because this season and this show, there's been very, there's been several examples of invasion. You know, there's the invasion in the beginning that feels like invasions of body snatchers. There is the invasive technique that they would use to harvest her stem cells and that they say they cannot do without her consent.

36:37Right. And then there is the invasion of her memory that, that, takes place and the fact that they can recreate this down to the waitress coming back and carol's questions being like where was she and like what did you do to her you know and it's like well yeah she was in miami she was a cosmetologist and she's like but you've just like moved her out here for this cosplay diorama of my past but also i love living in this and yeah so i i find that this show is just so thought-provoking in a really cool way where if given the opportunity what now shuttered businesses would you like the others to lovingly recreate for you?

37:20Because that cafe you liked in Back Bay is still there, right? The breakfast place. I don't Charlie's is still there. I I mean some of the records I mean I would like them to reopen Kim's in like perfect you know like three floors vinyl DVD video has Alex Ross Perry not done that no I mean he's like he's got like he had to make the documentary about all the inventory but I think Kim's in New York would be mine would be yours I mean Great Lakes yeah would be nice hi-fi like the bars of our youth you know where our sobriety is etched all of those are all of those are gone huh yeah wow how do you feel about that well it's a bummer I don't want to live in Brooklyn but like I feel bad Okay.

38:10Should we move on to Lambin? We should.

38:40Funky little episode of Landman. You know, the precision of Pluribus is always in the back of my mind while I watch the free painting session that is Landman.

38:56And I appreciate both. You know, I think we can appreciate both styles of art, both styles of TV. What did you think of this episode? I found, okay, I have a lot of specific things to discuss in the episode. though, but I did note, and look, maybe I'm a victim of my own success here because there's no question that the show is more normal this year. Yes. There's no question, and I have over the course of our conversation over it. You did watch the scene where Allie Larder celebrates her own birthday, even though it's not her birthday at the old person's home. And receives only sex toys? Yes. I did.

39:29Super normal. I did. It's still in the Landman universe, okay? Like, it is still within that, but like, it's here's a comparison it's a little bit like the difference between the Sorkin West Wing and the John Wells West Wing you know where like some of the I wrote this entire season while on a crack bender poetry has been turned into more practical more prosaic yeah so there are there my feeling about the show is not spiking like like Aaron Sorkin's EKG while writing season one of the West Wing. I'm fine with it more. I don't know if that's healthier or not. Well, the highs maybe not are as high, but the lows are certainly not as low.

40:16For sure. I think the last two episodes, I sort of felt the nontraditional pacing of the season and how many times we've done the same scene basically over and over again before. Yeah. And it was really only at the end of this episode or towards the end of this episode that I feel like there was actually like, okay, now the dynamic between Cammie and Tommy has changed or the dynamic between Cammie and Danny and Tommy has changed or Rebecca is now operating within the context of the company rather than having scenes separate from the entire cast. So much real estate has been given over to trying to normalize things so it runs on time, right?

40:57The pacing of this show is so odd. Like this entire season could have been a webisode and then it could have started. to your point like sometimes being kind of reasonable doesn't suit the nature of the show yes for example there is there's an AB of two legal scenes involving Rebecca one involves Nate which was cute because I haven't seen him outside of the house I think in the entire run of the show has been Midland only and the first version of the scene Rebecca comes in and absolutely eviscerates a table full of Yes. Dopes. Yes. The same scene happens with really no... And we've been trained as an audience to be like, oh, Rebecca's about to hand these guys their asses.

41:41But now when Nate slash Neil shows up, suddenly these guys find their mojo. And it's the same scene, only now the guys are like, actually, we're going to tell you how it goes. Yeah. Which I don't think that's how law works. If that's how law works, Better Call Saul would have been a limited series. What do you think you understand more? Oh, I like this question. What Monty was doing with$400 million. Right, sure, moving it around, yeah. Or what Cooper was doing with the six wells that all struck it rich, but somehow he doesn't have any money to pay anyone for, and now Tommy has just taken over his wells, but to protect him from the cartel.

42:20But he's also getting into business with the cartel. So Tommy is like, Emtex will buy your cartel-owned and operated wells, but I draw the line at the cartel funding any other well. Yes. That's a difficult moral position to stake out. I don't even understand in terms of the deal. The Sunriso, Danny's company, gave Cooper a loan that he never checked for or never cashed the check. There is$40 million in an account somewhere. It's very problematic because what, again, the show is, it seems like it is set to really begin with season three. Yes. Because the amount of work to get here is so extreme.

43:08Yeah. So in season one, Cooper is a iconoclastic, individualistic genius who sees the game board in a way no one else does. He... Sees widows where no one else does. He sure does. Yeah. He's like, he Billy Beans the whole thing and is like, this is the underutilized asset and he, with his charming personal skills, strikes oil and becomes incredibly rich. Instantly, not only is he told, you don't actually have any money, but there was no paperwork and no agreement. There was nothing in the first season to suggest that he needed to be staked to do any of this. It's just they put the thing in the ground and the oil comes out.

43:49It seemed like he had basically found a cheap way to look for oil and hit it harder than anyone thought anyone could do. Yes. And now... Now they've retconned in that he had financing for this. And that he's a moron who doesn't read the fine print. Well, here's my thing with that. This is kind of like also ties into the Ariana part where it almost is like... It's not like they focus group it or test it, but it's almost like, what if they broke up? I like those two kids together. You know? And so they bring... And now we've kind of had... Not only let's bring them back together, Let's have her say, I don't believe in divorce and we will never, ever break up.

44:32So buckle up. Yes. It did lead to a really fantastic hashtag girl dad scene. It's just been a banner year for them across the board. One battle after another, Jay Kelly and the time when Cooper drives, I did, I did the math eight and a half hours to Corpus Christi to have a McLobe ultra with a man who says, I don't really care what she does. And you don't seem like a violent man, but if you touch her, I will rip you limb from limb. You know what? And then by the way, the bed's made stay the night. One of the hallmarks of season two is that people are driving when they used to fly. Here's my, thank you for this.

45:06This is my - Tommy even says it in this episode. I feel bad that we're so much more articulate about Landman, maybe than Pluribus, but Tommy even says it in this episode where he's like, well, my day is I got to get in a car, drive three hours to have a two minute conversation, drive another three hours to have like another conversation and then get home in time for a pirate dinner. The show is a closed loop. The show is an argument only for itself. The only reason why we need to drill for this much oil is to fuel the gasoline in the trucks of the characters who work in the oil industry. That's it.

45:43No one else drives this much. Low-key, Landman is the most strident argument I've ever seen on a mass media platform for high-speed rail. Yes. Or private planes. there is a strong argument to be made that with the proper investment in infrastructure, all of their lives would be better. Where Tommy's like, you guys fly back to Midland and I'll see you at dinner, but I'm going to drive my truck because this, this Emtex pickup couldn't possibly be left in Dallas and maybe driven down by like flown back to get it again or whatever. Yeah. Also, I like to have some time to myself. Also, I will do a five hour drive in three 15, leaving myself enough time to stop for a couple cold ones and a very special kind of cold one because we've now got some competition in the ultra competition Olympics Troy Aikman's 8 beer which we are informed Tommy can either taste nor smell this is a new wrinkle we've learned this many episodes this feels like Aikman's beer either Aikman and Taylor Sheridan are friends and Taylor Sheridan's like we're gonna prop up your brewery or Taylor Sheridan hates this beer so it's like i will feature it but my main character this is the first time we've ever heard that he can't smell or taste correct does help me understand his response to the truffle dinner and also the fact that he just smokes inside of with his windows rolled up all the time and that for breakfast as a 70 year old stressed man he orders four eggs and fried eggs and a side of sausage and then eats none of it okay uh this brings me to the most important question i had for you on this entire podcast.

47:22Thank you. Okay. In this episode, I noticed for the first time that across the street from the Patch, our beloved 24-hour hangout, yeah. bar grill, that there is another restaurant. Marjorie's or something? JD's Burgers. Oh, what was Marjorie's? Oh, maybe there's Marjorie's too. I think that's probably a wine bar, small plates. First of all, what do you think it's like for the restaurant across the street from the Patch? Stuff. Because the Patch seems like it's like it's like max and helen's they've got like a two and a half hour wait yeah it's like it's just crazy but if you're just like hey but you guys we have a seat right now i mean there's not there's a proud tradition of this right there's always the like the tourists might get tired one block too soon yes and wander in here yes um i don't know it's also possible that it's kind of like a, what's it called?

48:18JD's? I think it's JD's hamburgers. Yeah. So maybe JD is like, you know, he's like the Una Pizza Napolitana guy, right? Like he's just like, every day I make 50 burgers and there's no other nonsense here. And don't come in here asking for a full bar. Don't come in here asking for a chicken fried anything. Don't come in here. Sure. I have a burger. There's a burger. There's the cheeseburger too. And you'll fucking like it. And I'm interested in that. Yeah. And these guys want more of a cheesecake factory like you can get breakfast for dinner you can get dinner for breakfast and we know you work 24 hours a day i do think top jaw permian basin would would do well i think it would be brief i think it would be brief um what did you make of sam elliott's scene work with uh with audrey mcgraw daughter of tim mcgraw and faith hill pretty weird kind of weird but i think it's just like he just wanted to have a conversation yeah but they're trying to have it both ways with sam elliott still a very attractive man but he mentions that he's 80 in the show i think i kind of wanted tommy to just pick him up and bring him along with him all day like i'd seem like that would be the most obvious thing i do actually wonder whether sam elliott is like i don't want to be in a car all day i have to be i can sit or i can get up twice or do you think it's an insurance issue where they're like we cannot underwrite a show in which a 70 year old man is driving an 80 year old man all respect i'm just saying like we got to deal with the facts We're close to it, yeah.

49:46We're closer to being 70 and 80 than we are being 20 and 30. Why do you have to say this? Kai is right here. Like, come on. Who wins when you say that? What is the upside? Taylor Sheridan does. I mean, we're still talking about his show. We can wrap it up there. Do you think you'd do well with this kind of driving culture? I'd like to think so, but I think I would do okay if it was flat roads and not a lot of traffic. I noted with interest that Tommy drives into the Dallas Fort Worth area. Yeah. With literally not another car on the road. Yeah. Uh, which it's very pluribus as was uh, Cooper driving, listening to language tapes.

50:24I was getting that TV drift where I'm like, oh, this is very Minusos right now. I just think these guys got to make some phone calls, you know, you do not have to drive to Corpus. We shouldn't mock this because, and it was also like Ariana was like, he's like, yeah, she doesn't have to ask me for permission. She knows that and she just wanted to see if you would do it. I'd be pretty pissed. I would be so pissed. I'm pissed if someone, like if I have to pick up something at the dry cleaner, let alone drive eight hours to talk to a guy with a killer dog who doesn't want to talk to me. Right. Um, that said, we should be respectful because if anyone like this is out there, like living like this podcast must be as important as gasoline.

51:01I would hope so. That is a, that's a lot. And they don't even have air conditioning in these trucks. You notice that they're all sweating. Well, that's because I think it's supposed to be summer in Texas. because otherwise, why isn't Ainsley ever at school? Well, she's too old. I saw an interview on Instagram with Michelle Randolph who plays Ainsley and they were like, what are you hoping for for Ainsley in the future? And she was like, I'd love it if she grew up a little bit. She said that. She was just like, I'd love to. Yeah. Yeah. She's not old enough to see the presents her mom got at the sex toy party.

51:32Oh God. You know what? I feel like I enjoyed this episode more than you did. I did enjoy it. I also enjoyed Andy Garcia draining five straight putts in his office. Were those challenging putts to make? No, I mean, just it's steady nerves. You just have to really concentrate. You know, if Billy Bob Thornton was yelling at me, I don't think I would be so in the cup like that. It's just, it's honestly exhausting where it's just like, this episode, they're friends. This episode, Tommy's like, I don't want your fucking money. Yeah, our wives can be friends, but not us. I don't know why I just did Will Ferrell from Eastbound.

52:06I know why you did. We wish we were talking about that instead. let's wrap it up. All right. Long day of potting for us. So we'll have some really cool stuff on Pluribus for you guys next week, as well as a mailbag on Monday. Did you know that you can't be land man and a president? That was the one piece of information we got this episode. Why not? That's what, that's what Nate says to him. It reminded me of like, Oh, but do you mean that emotionally or you can't actually have both jobs? It just reminded me of like the Tracy Jordan movies from 30 Rock. It's like black cop, white cop. It's like land man president.

52:36How could one man be both? All right. Thanks to Kaya. Thanks to Kai. And we will be back on Monday with our mailbag.

From the publisher

Chris and Andy talk about all of the shows that are coming up in January, including ‘The Pitt’ Season 2 and the long-awaited second season of ‘The Night Manager’ (3:44). Then they talk about the penultimate episode of ‘Pluribus’ Season 1 and Carol's arc throughout this season (25:27) before recapping the latest episode of ‘Landman’ (38:36).

Hosts: Chris Ryan and Andy Greenwald

Producers: Kaya McMullen and Kai Grady

Video Production: Jon Jones
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from The Watch

All 119 episodes
‘Pluribus’ Penultimate Episode and ‘Landman’ Episode 5The Watch · 55 min
Listen in VO