‘Task’ Is Everything We Want It to Be. Plus, the Creative Arts Emmy Awards.

8 Sep 2025 · 1 h 6 min · 23 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

The hosts discuss HBO’s limited series Task (premiered the night before), focusing on episode 1 “Crossings,” a Philly/Delco-set crime story that balances police work and criminals while foregrounding midlife melancholy and family damage. They also recap the Creative Arts Emmy Awards, arguing The Studio was the big winner and predicting the main Emmys’ comedy and drama races.

Guests

Chris Ryan (editor at TheRinger.com) and Andy Greenwald (podcast host/longtime TV critic). No other guests appear in the episode.

Key claims

Task is “Philly coated” and emotionally precise, with art direction and set dressing that feel lived-in. Brad Inglesby (creator/writer of Mare of Easttown) “makes it worse” by escalating circumstances rather than manipulating sentiment. The show is more character study than mystery, with both leads longing to heal personal wounds.

Notable examples

Ruffalo’s FBI agent Tom Brandes (former priest, Phillies radio, drinking) and Tom Pelfrey’s Robbie (sanitation worker, stash-house robber). Robbie’s crew’s botched robbery leads to Peaches’ death and multiple deaths at a drug house; Robbie and Cliff escape with a child wrapped in an eagle blanket. The Emmy segment cites wins like The Studio, Severance (including cinematography), The Pit, and prosthetics/costuming categories.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Kaya's Return from Vacation

0:30 to 0:49

Discussion about Kaya's recent vacation in Italy and her engagement.

“Bryce Harper and the Philadelphia Phillies face Byron Buxton and the Minnesota Twins at the iconic Field of Dreams ballpark.”

Kaya's Return from Vacation

1:40 to 3:47

Discussion about Kaya's recent vacation in Italy and her engagement.

“Yeah, did you guys know that Italy is incredible?”

Emotional Engagement with Sports

3:48 to 4:26

Exploration of how the hosts connect emotionally to sports.

“No one, as far as I can tell, has ever been a better wedding attendee than you.”

Navigating Social Situations during Sports

4:27 to 6:20

Hosts discuss their experiences watching sports together and social dynamics.

“Is this a fun bit where like, instead of like, I don't know, like a wedding planner, you just ask these two late 40s guys that you work with to just really weigh in on all the important issues?”

Creative Arts Emmys Discussion

6:21 to 9:50

Overview of the Creative Arts Emmys and notable winners.

“So we had the group, when I say we had the group chat over, you and Zach came over to watch the Eagles.”

Thoughts on Severance and Other Shows

9:51 to 14:00

Discussion on winners from the Emmys and insights into shows like Severance.

“Like there's always in the award shows the moment where they're like they invite someone who's like mid mid list.”

Creative Arts Emmy Awards Discussion

14:00 to 17:36

The hosts share their thoughts on the winners and categories at the Creative Arts Emmys.

Introduction to 'Task'

19:15 to 21:51

The hosts introduce 'Task', its creators, and the premise of the show.

“The cult comedy classic returns in the most offensive installment yet with Super Troopers 3, a debaucherous bachelor party, an over-the-top wedding, a dangerous drug smuggling ring.”

Character and Plot Analysis of 'Task'

21:51 to 28:00

In-depth discussion about the characters and storyline of 'Task', exploring themes of personal connection and crime.

“He was a former priest and he left the church for a life of law enforcement and spends most of his time drinking heavily out of a Phillies commemorative cup and birdwatching.”

Exploring Themes of Connection and Healing

28:00 to 30:06

The discussion centers on the emotional journeys of the main characters and how their desires reflect deeper personal wounds rather than just professional aspirations.

“and a lot of movies like or stories about guys like this present the two main characters as samurais you know untouched by there's a Japanese word for that should I say it?”
Show all 23 chapters

Character Development and Depth

30:06 to 33:04

An analysis of character interactions and the significance of their conversations, highlighting the show's ability to convey character depths through action.

“And that kind of deep, like midlife melancholy, shout out you and me, suffuses into every frame of it.”

Constructing Tension and Complexity

33:04 to 35:52

Discussion on the show's approach to character struggles and how it artfully constructs tension without relying on typical drama tropes.

“but like there wasn't a moment when I was like, is Robbie creeping on his niece?”

Setting and Geography's Role in Narrative

35:52 to 37:58

A conversation about how the geographical setting influences the story and reflects the characters' emotional states, emphasizing the unique backdrop of the show.

“One is in prison and one is no longer with us.”

Visual Language of Sadness and Beauty

37:58 to 42:00

Exploring the show's aesthetic choices that highlight the coexistence of sadness and beauty, and how this duality affects character relationships and themes.

“Um, tell me a little bit about Delco Montgomery County and like that area.”

Exploring Emotional Depths in Relationships

42:00 to 43:28

Discuss the emotional complexities in the relationships depicted in the show.

“Even the nature of like how Robbie's brother's house that they're all living in seems to be like, it's in a, it's like a tree house somewhere, you know?”

Cultural References and Celebrity Sightings

43:28 to 44:29

Highlight various pop culture references and their relevance to the discussion.

“he'd had some of that baby goat treatment.”

Analyzing Performances in 'Task'

44:29 to 46:43

Delve into the performances of actors in 'Task', focusing on their character portrayals.

“Who's just like, I can't say any of the words he uses to describe his feelings about the Eagles win.”

Character Dynamics and Casting Choices

46:43 to 48:58

Discuss the dynamics between characters and the importance of casting decisions.

“but I am a fucking urban lumberjack strongman, it's just a beautiful portrayal so far.”

Comparative Analysis with 'Dope Thief'

48:58 to 51:16

Compare the narrative structure and themes of 'Task' with those of 'Dope Thief'.

“So like, there's not a good part of his day other than the moment where he sees a bird or the moment where the alcohol probably kicks in and then he pays for it the next day for Robbie.”

Themes of Community and Connection

51:16 to 53:49

Explore themes of community and how they influence character interactions.

“and Pelfrey's just like, this guy is not a bad guy and he's not doing anything wrong.”

The Role of Female Characters in 'Task'

53:49 to 56:00

Examine the portrayal and significance of female characters in the show.

“And whether you're on the crime fighters or the side of crime, like these are porous boundaries and everybody's kind of under the same boot heel.”

Exploring Character Perspectives in 'Task'

56:00 to 1:03:12

Discussion on the character dynamics and perspectives in the show 'Task'.

“in a way that I'm really, really responding to.”

Ensemble Cast and Filmmaking Choices

1:03:12 to 1:05:57

Analysis of the ensemble cast and creative choices in the filming of 'Task'.

“And as a pilot episode goes, I really respected...”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This episode is brought to you by the Active Cash Credit Card from Wells Fargo. That's a mouthful, but that's because it packs a lot in. Earn unlimited 2 % cash rewards on purchases with it, big or small. So whether it's buying tickets at the game or grabbing a coffee, it earns unlimited 2 % cash rewards on purchases. Say it with me. The Active Cash Credit Card from Wells Fargo. Be a 2 %er. Learn more at wellsfargo.com forward slash active cash. Terms apply. This episode is brought to you by Netflix. The MLB at Field of Dreams returns. Bryce Harper and the Philadelphia Phillies face Byron Buxton and the Minnesota Twins at the iconic Field of Dreams ballpark.

0:40The field is calling. Watch the MLB at Field of Dreams game live on Netflix Thursday, August 13th at 7.30 p.m. Eastern, 4.30 p.m. Pacific. I need supports to have to clear the room. Stand up and walk now Hello and welcome to The Watch My name is Chris Ryan I am an editor at TheRinger.com And joining me in the studio He's a re-drummond recipe It's Andy Greenwald I love marshmallows It's cheese Andy, we are going to be talking about the new HBO show Task

1:17Andy Greenwald:The show we were born to talk about The show where if you cut my arm open task would spill out. She has future episodes. It's set in Delco outside of Philadelphia. It stars Mark Ruffalo and Tom Pelfrey. It is a crime show. It's what we do the podcast for. Days like this. But first, 15 minutes of just uninterrupted banter. First we have to welcome back our number one, Kaya. Hello, I'm back. We missed you. You had a beautiful vacation. Yeah, did you guys know that Italy is incredible? Yeah, but first of all, we know it. Chris and I don't, what's the word, take vacations. I do. But we, okay, I don't take vacations, but I like to watch other people's vacations.

1:59Andy Greenwald:And I just want to commend you, Kaya, for doing it right. Everyone, anyone apparently can just go to southern Italy and get on a boat. You went northern Italy. Beautiful vistas, hiking, crisp alpine wines. Yes. It looked amazing. It was incredible. I had some incredible local deer goulash. Ooh. The only don't want is like deer goulash that's traveled. No, I don't. You know what I mean? This deer is from Missouri. No, no, no, no, no. Yeah, I had some, one of the great things about hiking in Italy, and I think also throughout a lot of Europe, is that they have these things called refugios. And I also just really like the European mentality of like putting a bar absolutely everywhere you can.

2:42And it's a lot of honor bars stuff. Yes. In Europe. Yes. And are you honorable? So you can hike for five miles or so and then take a little rest at a gorgeous mountain hut and have some delicious food and a local beer. And I think America should put that into practice.

3:01Andy Greenwald:Yeah, I think it would go great. We are just a country that knows how to respect limits and ourselves. What if we brought USAID back, but it was just for refugios? Oh, but the D stood for draft. Yeah. For ice cold. Kaya, is it appropriate to congratulate you on your other vacation news as well? Yes, which I'm really glad that I'm announcing on this podcast before. And not Amy Poehler. Before I've, you know, posted on Instagram or anything. But yes, I did get engaged. We're going to watch weddings. Yay! Kaya, congratulations. Thank you very much. I'm very excited. Congrats, Kaya. Kaya, have you thought?

3:37Congrats to you, man. Me? Yeah. What did I do? Just like you're a very warm and loving person.

3:42Andy Greenwald:I'm so excited about this, but mostly I'm excited about it. And you don't need to answer this today. But I am curious about what kind of like marathon 12 days of Christmas just grind you're going to put these bridesmaids on after what they put you through over the last five to six years. That's right. It's the fucking revenge of the Sith. This is what I'm saying. No one, as far as I can tell, has ever been a better wedding attendee than you. They owe you. Yeah, I'm also I'm up on deck to be a bridesmaid at least once more. in the next. You could do the bachelor, I mean, you could go to Tahiti for your bachelorette and they would have to pay.

4:17Andy Greenwald:They would have to pay all of it. Like, think big is what we're saying. Yeah, you know, the world, the sky is my limit right now, so we'll see. Is this a fun bit where like, instead of like, I don't know, like a wedding planner, you just ask these two late 40s guys that you work with to just really weigh in on all the important issues? Like, I'm just pitching it. How are you, man? I won't go on vacation, So I am definitely available. Okay. I'm great. Thanks. How are you? How was your weekend? It was good. We learned something. I learned something about you that I didn't know recently because, you know, football's back and we watch football together.

4:52Andy Greenwald:It was very nice. I don't think I really understood that you, in order to engage emotionally with a sporting event, instantly pick someone to be your person. Yeah. To root for. Always. All day on Red Zone. I'm like, I don't gamble, but I emotionally gamble. So I kind of did that yesterday. I was experimenting with the four box a little bit. And then what was weird is because, you know, I'm you just said a nice version of it, but I am emotionally fragile. And so, like, within, I don't know, a span of two hours, my beloved Jets lost. That was so weird. All these teams. Well, because fuck Aaron Rodgers, honestly.

5:31Andy Greenwald:I wanted Sean to be happy so he would be nice to us when the Mets come to Philadelphia this week. but like it was it was emotionally intense to suddenly like passionately be like ah my beautiful texans or whatever but you you just roll i think that you and i have different definitions of emotional connection you know what i mean like i think that for me it's like when it's over i forgot it even happened but you you're like this is now ripple affecting you know it's rippling across my entire sunday it's i can't digest my meal now i'm so heartbroken cj stroud might not be capital H him, you know?

6:08Andy Greenwald:It was hard for me. Thank you. Cam Ward's dad was me. That's, I mean, but sometimes you wind up finding yourself in a corner that you can't fight your way out of, which is the Amanda and a Samova corner that I found myself in. So just a little disclosure. So we had the group, when I say we had the group chat over, you and Zach came over to watch the Eagles. It was a weird, super weird night, but we were happy we won. But there was this hour and a half lightning break, which did cause three men in their 40s to suddenly lose the ability to know what to do. Both of you guys immediately stood up and started pacing.

6:40Andy Greenwald:No, we were both like, well, we're going to leave. We're going to leave. And I'm like, please don't go. My whole Thursday is devoted to this. Don't leave me alone. But then it was very nice. I don't know whether you had eye contact, but you decided to stay. We watched the U.S. women's semifinal. And Zach was like, ah, as a longtime tennis fan, it's great to see Naomi back on her bullshit. like we're all rooting for her and you were like not me i only see one stars and bars on the screen right now son and you suddenly became the number one anselmova fan in the world yeah i mean then she gets smoked on saturday and then you just quietly back away you just walk away like it never happened i mean it's it's it's the discipline as as robert uh de niro said in heat you know oh that's incredible that's who you get it from my last thing was and I please feel free to weigh in on this as well but like I found what I believe to be the last pure corner of the internet this weekend yeah what's that it is the reddit group devoted to sparkling water there are 40 ,000 members and you're really pushing it man listen we're gonna talk about tasks it's great it's on HBO it's just like I'm all for this but sometimes I'm like we are pushing into the realms of the absurd do you think i guess my question is do you think do you think that a beautiful pocket of peace can still exist because i spent a little time in it and people because now that you've said it honestly with like a hundred new dudes are gonna go to the seltzer uh be like your tariffs i'd be like i can't believe you guys don't acknowledge this is the best seltzer no but what's incredible about it is someone was just like oh i've never had uh at Waterloo because it's because I don't live that way.

8:26Andy Greenwald:And someone was like, what do you mean by that? And the person wrote, it's$3.99 more than Polar. And they were like, thank you. And someone else was like, Rambler is amazing. I love the lime and berry flavor. And someone responded, thank you. I helped develop that flavor during COVID from my friends who founded the company. Fun tip. There's a bit of mint essence in it so you can make it at home. And they were like, that sounds wonderful. And the guy was like, no problem. Enjoy. It was so, so pure. I imagine you sitting at a table wearing like a tucked in button down scrolling and being like yeah I was actually at a children's playground with no children doing that on a laptop it was really cool it was really cool what's amazing is I was like Kaya feel free to weigh in on this and she's just completely into wedding planning over there she's fine she's like how much would it cost to go to the moon for your bachelorette alright fine SpaceX rentals I had a nice weekend thanks to this.

9:21Andy Greenwald:So, okay, whatever. We can talk about a great TV show now if you want. The Watch at Spotify.com. The Watch pod underscore on Instagram. The Ringer TV YouTube channel. And you can also watch us and listen to us on Spotify after eight minutes. You watch. We're going to get an email this week being like, Hi, I'm the guy that invents flavors for Rambler Sparkly Water. Long time listener. You wait. And then I'm going to write him back as you and be like, I don't live that way. I can't live your life. Never could be me. Greenwald, do you want to talk at all about the creative, Arts Emmys before we get into task just because you love the Creative Arts Emmys.

9:53I didn't know these existed. I didn't. I didn't know we had spillover awards.

9:58Andy Greenwald:You didn't. Uh-uh. You don't remember. Like there's always in the award shows the moment where they're like they invite someone who's like mid mid list. Yeah, but I always thought that was like pleasure of giving away the guy who pulled the dolly on Endor. Yeah. But these are like pretty significant categories. We had these will be aired on Hulu on Saturday. I think the actual Emmys are on Sunday. Correct. Yeah, hosted by my guy, Nate Bregazzi. Your boy. Listen, I had a great weekend. I watched sports. I listened to Nate Bregazzi comedy, and I read content about sparkling water. I'm doing fine.

10:32Andy Greenwald:I think America's going, okay, okay. You definitely seem like you're doing fine. I'm doing great. I look at these awards, and what I'm seeing is, and I guess if you don't want the Saturday Night Hulu broadcast spoiled for you, you might want to skip ahead to task. I look at these awards and I see something that immediately leaps out at me, which is a huge groundswell of inter-town love, inter-Hollywood love for the Apple series The Studio. Who would have thought of coming, that the industry would fall in love with itself? I am surprised. I mean, like, you know, it's not like Robert Altman's The Player was celebrated, but I think that the ultimate essence of The Studio is sort of something that Hollywood probably would like love to believe about itself now that even though we're under these trying circumstances and maybe not doing the kinds of work the kind of work we want to be doing like there's still something magic the funny thing about it is it is about movies and this is like for the tv that that's a great call that's the that's also one that's another reason why I think it is a little bit guilt-free for the television academy to celebrate it right because it's like well we're we are where all the good writing and acting went in movies right we are where the great the true stories are told also to your point i think the player was a touch more scabrous if i may yeah the studio which presents a generally positive if bumbling if still somehow optimistic view towards this town um i thought this was an interesting night well only there was a wide breadth of winners from a bunch of different shows, categories.

12:16Andy Greenwald:I think the main takeaway for the big show next week, the narratives are pretty set, I think, which is the comedy enemies are the studios to lose. I think the studio cleaned up last night. I think it's going to do extremely well next week and probably win best comedy. And the drama stuff is a rock fight between the pit and Severance. I'm not here to pick sides. I thought it was awesome that Sean Hattesi, Hattosi. I, you know what? We got it right once and then now we're, it's just one of the things we'll never know how to do it right. Yeah, it's basically the sort of, like the Mariana Rivera of the pit.

12:54The guy comes in and closes it.

12:56Andy Greenwald:Yes. Sean Hattesi. He won for guest actor, although I think he's up to main cast for season two. But the great Merritt Weaver won for guest acting and Severance totally agree with that. Yep. Loved her scenes, elevated everything she was in. and Severance won other things that it's very hard to argue with like cinematography like that's a beautiful beautifully shot show Jessica Gagne is that the cinematographer? Jessica Gagne yeah who also directs on the show I think the Pee Wee Herman documentary which we didn't ever discuss I don't think you watched it was excellent that one you know what I don't think we ever discussed either is the news that Ben Stiller would not be directing on season three of Severance we mentioned it I think during one of the classic Kaya Nandi shows yeah one of you guys just batting around headlines but I think we both had a little skeptical okay we'll see okay i think he said that before oh has he um but you know i saw him we saw him in the crowd of the u.s open and he did not look like he was directing season three so maybe maybe all of the u.s open was an episode of severance and amanda anasimova actually won it what that's so good um i thought it was cool that like look and or won a bunch of of awards yeah um adolescents won casting which i mean yes sure that is a correct choice to win that um i the only thing i righteous gemstones won for stunt coordination i guess for some like nude fighting sure but i was kind of bummed like studio won for costuming which it deserves those suits are awesome and everybody has a real visually distinct identity on the show kind of wanted righteous gemstones to win for costumes because for baby belly well for all of but you know generally this was a nice night to celebrate like the editors and the people who don't usually get the celebrations although I guess we'll celebrate them on Hulu in a week I don't really have a lot of the only thing I would say about the Creative Arts Emmys is that they have a lot of categories and that those categories are divided up so that it's almost hard not to win an Emmy if you're not they break things down into like fantasy series and I'm like okay well and outstanding here's a category outstanding period or fantasy sci-fi makeup non-prosthetic division house the dragon congratulations um interestingly house the dragon was up against monsters but not like monsters the like godzilla universe monsters the lyle and eric menendez universe because that's period oh but so the dragons and the monsters none of them were wearing like big fake penguin noses because that won for prosthetics right the penguin did yeah this is this is good context so oh so sparkling water is bad but me being like prosthetics on dragons that's good um it will be interesting to see how much the actual sunday night emmys wind up mirroring the voting tendencies that we saw displayed on the creative arts that was my main takeaway do you feel that fraser for the studio coming i imagine do you feel like the reboot of Frasier's win for outstanding picture editing in a multi-camera comedy series is further proof that that show was ended too soon what I would like to know who won that like if there's an individual and if they like secretly are on like their 51st straight win for that like is there a like oh do you think that he continued to win this is there a Tom Brady of in pictures editing but like even when Frasier was yeah just like he's been James Burroughs's guy since like 82 and he's just the goat yes i mean probably now i'm googling but probably i can't call it up fast enough but so i guess there's no way to ever know should we get a stat boy are you on dial up like why is it coming up fast enough well because are you looking for it historically i see what you're saying yeah that's what i'm doing uh anyway can't wait emmy is always my favorite night of the year you're going to have to watch Nate Percocci for two hours what's Sunday Night Football next week?

16:51I don't know I can't remember where they were going no way to find out that was Russell Griffin who won that Fraser let's see how many Emmys my guy has I'm going over under I'm going over three

17:05Andy Greenwald:here he is winning it's a beautiful picture of him I don't know still don't know no he won last year I had a feeling for how I met your father oh he must be the guy he's the guy he's the guy that's awesome what a cool career just be like you need this multicam comedy edited call Russ big Russ let's talk about Task which premiered last night it's a seven episode he's only won twice though oh really yeah okay sorry this episode is brought to you by Boris Head it may have been years ago but I still remember the feeling of unpacking my kids lunch boxes after school and to find nothing left. As a parent, that's a total win.

17:46Boar's Head, maple honey ham, American cheese, maple honey turkey, all time greats in the school lunch game. It's real quality protein that tastes great. So you can feel that winning feeling all term long. Whether you're doing wraps, sandwiches, or a quick snack box, Boar's Head makes packing school lunches easier. You'll be proud of what you pack. They'll be happy to finish it. Fuel their school day with the premium choice Boar's Head. For lunchtime inspiration, visit boarshead.com slash back to school or head to your local deli counter. This episode is brought to you by Searchlight Pictures.

18:21More than ever, America needs a laugh. Enter the Super Troopers to the rescue. The cult comedy classic returns in the most offensive installment yet with Super Troopers 3, a debaucherous bachelor party, an over-the-top wedding, a dangerous drug smuggling ring. All of them are threatening the troops future. Fill your leader of cola and roll up to the multiplex with Super Troopers 3 only in theaters August 7th. Get tickets. Meow. This episode is brought to you by NOS Energy. Every ounce of dirt, sweat, and gears, every checkered flag and trophy raised, every lap, every race, every hard-bought place.

18:57They're all jammed inside every can of NOS Energy. High-performance energy for burning the midnight oil in the garage and pedal to the metal human horsepower for the streets. Go ahead, crack open a can of NOS Energy and get after it. This episode is brought to you by Searchlight Pictures. More than ever, America needs a laugh. Enter the Super Troopers to the rescue. The cult comedy classic returns in the most offensive installment yet with Super Troopers 3, a debaucherous bachelor party, an over-the-top wedding, a dangerous drug smuggling ring. All of them are threatening the troops' future. Fill your liter of cola and roll up to the multiplex with Super Troopers 3 only in theaters August 7th.

19:39Get tickets. Meow. Task, which premiered last night on HBO. It's a seven episode limited series from Brad Inglesby, who is the creator and writer of Mare of Easttown.

19:50Andy Greenwald:I think we need to do one just PSA for our listeners who I assume do, you know, follow us in terms of our viewing and our watching habits. Don't be like me. if you haven't watched task yet be sure to open up hbo max and change audio settings away from polish yes i had the same problem because it's almost watching eastern gate i have a ghost in the machine where i have watched several things on hbo max since eastern gate but every once in a while they just switch back to sweet sweet polish and it hits different it really hits one polish guy doing all the parts and tasks. It's also stripped of its, you know, Delco accents.

20:30Andy Greenwald:It is. So it's pretty funny. It is. It did make me more attuned to the plight of the Polish viewers of Tasks who are really missing out a lot of the nuance. But anyway. The first episode is called Crossings. It was written by Brad Inglesby. It's directed by Jeremiah Zagar, who did Hustle. And is also from Philly. And is from Philly. The show stars Mark Ruffalo, Tom Pelfrey Amelia Jones who you might remember from CODA if you remember from CODA you are not prepared for her in this Raul Castillo from Looking yeah from Looking and then Fabian Frankel and Allison Oliver and Thuso Mbedu who's very good in this like we're gonna talk a lot about the performances I have like I don't really know if people need a recap recap of like the plot but broadly speaking Ruffalo plays this guy named Tom Brandes who's an FBI agent who's been kind of put out to pasture.

21:26For personal reasons. For personal reasons. Yet to be totally understood family tragedy, although you can kind of get little signs there. He has two kids that we see. One is in prison. The other wants little to do with him.

21:39Andy Greenwald:And the third one is the source of the... The third one is, yeah. You know, and the wife is not there. In the wind. In the wind. She's filming another season of The Killing. He's left... He was a former priest and he left the church for a life of law enforcement and spends most of his time drinking heavily out of a Phillies commemorative cup and birdwatching. And then Kathleen McGinty, a cop, I assume only because that shot of the building is Philly police headquarters. But maybe she is. I know she refers to special agent in charge, so I suppose she's an FBI agent. They just like the building.

22:17I think that's the case. Gives him the assignment to run a task force of local, state, and federal law enforcement to find out who is robbing the drug stash houses of a Montgomery County biker gang called the Dark Hearts. Hell yeah. McGinty wants Tom to find out who is doing this and stop them before a gang war breaks up on the other side. Monco gang war. Hello. On the other side of that heat coin, Robbie is a sanitation worker who moonlights by hitting stash houses in Delaware County. he lives with some combination of his and his late brother's children in his late brother's home with Robbie's niece Maeve, who's played by Amelia Jones functioning as the beleaguered matriarch at age 20

22:59Andy Greenwald:at age 21 Robbie is longing for human connection but what he has is a co-conspirator named Cliff, played by Raul Castillo a guy named Peaches who might as well have lived forever tattooed on his neck and a nose for where drugs and money are hidden Tom assembles his team which includes a state trooper named Lizzie a young cop named Aaliyah and a county detective named Anthony and they move into a repossessed drug house which looks honestly there's a lot of there's a lot of life in that house like I needed more reminders of the real estate mistake we're making constantly living out here at the end of the episode after a robbery goes wrong for Robbie's crew Peaches gets killed as do several people living or visiting the drug house who are associated with the dark hearts do you think they were Airbnb guests I mean visiting just checking out.

23:45Just checking out the bones.

23:47Andy Greenwald:Just signing the guest book. Robbie and Cliff wind up leaving with a young kid named Sam and bring him back to Robbie's. And that is the first episode of Task. Okay. Hit me. This show's so sick. I loved it. Was there any universe in which you and I would not like this show? If there was, the universe dissipated the minute the show began with a KYW news break, and then and then Ruffalo, who to his credit is not doing an accent, fine. But he immediately hits for the cycle in one of his first scenes when he mentions Scrapple, shopping at Acme, and getting a water ice within like one burst. And then I was like, this show is so Philly coated and clear that things are going to get bad for him that the first bird he sees is a blue jay that might as well have Joe Carter tattooed across the front of it.

24:41And just Mitch Williams' ghost. I know.

24:43Andy Greenwald:Yeah. So, no, there was no way we weren't personally going to be responding very passionately to the show. And like when Pelfrey emerges from the trap house with a child wrapped in an eagle's blanket. I was like, these are my own hopes and dreams, Robbie. Like, yeah, I may have a son and that he may come to me in an eagle's blanket. One day I might have a child who likes football. Nope. But that. Yeah. So we were on board. But I think big picture, before we delve into the specifics, it is worth saying that Inglesby is a working class bard of some sort. Like he, his reference points are so on point, both like in terms of plot structure and plot scaffolding.

25:30Andy Greenwald:And like, here are the pieces necessary for a affecting crime epic. Heat was mentioned, I think, when he pitched it. It's here in this, on the screen this many years later. but that the details that motivate him aren't just the ones that motivate us. Like, oh, I used to shop at Acme too. It's the art direction and set dressing of Robbie's house's kitchen. Just the type of ice cream in the fridge, what's in the sink, the cookware. All the details are so, so, so specific that I feel instantly at home. Not literally because I'm from Montgomery County, but because this show is being crafted by people who care about the small stuff that makes the big stuff work.

26:11This is what HBO does best, I think, historically, are these elevated crime shows. I think, you know, they've made seminal comedies, great original films, huge documentaries. Like, there's lots of things that HBO does well, and we probably broadly just describe, you know, maybe not the invention of, but the perfection of prestige television for them. They have now delved into a huge sword and sandal or sword and shield epics.

26:41Andy Greenwald:Non-prosthetic division. Non-prosthetic division and sci-fi and all these things. But I think at the end of the day, they know how to take a piece of pulp and put it up on the top shelf. And so that goes back to Oz and Sopranos and The Wire and True Detective and The Night Of and Mare and We Own the City. They work with really, really, really good writers and creators on this stuff. and they have the patience and the touch to kind of bring it to life. And they cast really, really, really well, and they will pay to go into the streets of Baltimore or go into the streets of Delaware and Montgomery County.

Read the full transcript

27:18So it feels real. And the thing I thought was coolest for me watching this is Inglesby is going to be balancing the crime and the criminals and the cops. Like it's the first part is, you know, I think in some series like say True Detective, you get in like really immersed in like trying to figure out alongside the detectives what's going on. In this show, we kind of know what's going on. I'm sure there will be some wrinkles. There will be some some hooks. I haven't watched too far ahead. But, you know, like I think that this is more going to be a character study than it is going to be a mystery.

27:56and the thing that really was interesting to me is you mentioned Heat and a lot of movies like or stories about guys like this present the two main characters as samurais you know untouched by there's a Japanese word for that should I say it? yeah they're Ronin they're walled off from the world you know and they operate where they're just like the only thing I really connect with is the work it's like you as a sports fan And I think that there will probably be some stuff about that. But what struck me is that the two main characters, Robbie and Tom, are like, I'm broken, but I'm longing for something.

28:37I'm longing for something, whether it's connection with God, whether it's connection with another partner, whether it's like to rebuild my family. It's the desires of the characters are not to achieve professional perfection. Yes. But to heal their personal wounds. And I thought that that was really, really well done in the show.

28:59Andy Greenwald:These are movie archetypes, not only in a fallen world, but in a TV world. And I mean that in a very specific and positive way. Like you can make people samurai in a movie when there's one task to accomplish and one, you know, motivating event that causes momentum that leads to a tremendous finale. All the things that bring us actually through our lives, all the connections we make or the regrets we have or the holes where certain things should have been, those accrue around all of us at any point in our lives. And but film can't always pay them enough real estate or enough lip service or enough time.

29:37Andy Greenwald:These stories that Brad seems able to do so well work so, so much better on television because of the richness and the depth of field that he has to play with. Like we joked a week ago about how this show probably wasn't going to be a laugh riot. Right. But surprisingly, it is kind of funny at times. But what I found really, really amazing was that it wasn't like trauma porn. It's just pre-devastating because we see people who are tenuously holding on to what they have need a little bit more. And we are already pre-aware of how much they're going to lose. And that kind of deep, like midlife melancholy, shout out you and me, suffuses into every frame of it.

30:17Andy Greenwald:Shout out you and me. It's going great. that I'm here for I don't expect this to be celebratory you know but I am here for the fact that from the beginning the show foregrounds the emotional journey and the precarity of these characters as we meet them you think about that scene early in the episode when Robbie and Cliff are having their lunch break they're sanitation workers who are kind of able to observe these different houses and look in the trash and find like you know what they're mixing their drugs with or whatever Robbie's doing that cool Apple knife shit. That's right. That cool guys do.

30:51And they're talking about online dating. And even the sort of tone of that conversation is such a window into this guy's character, right? Like what has happened that he's shut himself off? And even the way he's just like, look, I'm different than you. Like I want to share my life with someone. You know, I need somebody to be the other half of me. That scene, which could just be like a little bit of character building and I think this is what Inglesby really really really does well is he'll take pieces of character and put it into action and so I am actually allergic to child endangerment not because I have like some protective instinct but because I think it's like usually a very cheap way of kind of pulling a lot of heart strings and often like making it more of a four quadrant show because now this guy is like a protector or something but you really do get the sense by seeing Robbie's home life, by understanding that there's at least one person, if not two people missing from that house, his partner and his brother, that he has lost things over the course of his life.

32:01Don't get the impression that his brother is dead because of like a car accident. You know what I mean? Like I think it's like probably something, some choices he made over the course of his life.

32:12Andy Greenwald:He may have been involved, his brother. And that kind of, all of that, it builds up and builds up. And then when you get to the end and he decides to bring this kid with him, you're like, I get it. That's what this guy would do. This is what, that's what this guy would do. There wasn't a moment. He's got, he's already got like a fucking Peter Pan village in his house. You know what I mean? Like he's already got like Neverland going like. And he's got a hero complex. Yeah. Despite being the villain. I mean, there wasn't a moment and I appreciated this. I think this was probably a delicate note to play.

32:44Andy Greenwald:There was never a moment when I thought the kid's life was in danger in that scene. You know, where in other shows or other times we've seen scenes like this before that has gone very badly for the kid, let alone for our collective humanity as an audience member. Similarly, like, I want to talk about Maeve in a second, but like there wasn't a moment when I was like, is Robbie creeping on his niece? Is there something inappropriate here? Like the show runs right at who he is and his relationship to these people in a way that I felt was non-manipulative. Just appreciating Inglesby for another second, because I think that the pilot was so artfully constructed and it didn't begin the way most shows begin now, which is with a very heavy handed note from someone involved in the development process to hit him hard quickly.

33:33Andy Greenwald:Right. Yeah. Show the big event, show the thing. And then that's often why we get the five weeks earlier. Nothing I dislike more. Me too. And me either. And I loved the juxtaposition of these two guys starting their days in different ways, maybe with a similar kind of psychic pain. And did you notice that that opening sequence of their everyday behaviors was scored with this like surging symphonic music, which I thought was so great because it was like, this is the symphony of everyday life. Yes. Like this is the symphony of like the bullshit you do. You put out pamphlets, you pick up trash, you get your kids ready for school.

34:09They don't like you, whatever,

34:10Andy Greenwald:you know, go on, stick your face in a sink full of ice water just to get the alcohol puffs away. Yeah. Um, I want to, I, this is, I, I promise you this is not a classic, uh, digression, but I, I'm reading a book that, that, uh, Kaya recommended, um, called your television by, by Dan Z. Senna, which is really good so far. And, um, early on in the book, the main character of the book is talking about her time teaching creative writing in colleges. And there's some advice that's given at one point. And the advice is make it worse. And I was thinking about that when I was thinking about how Brad builds these shows, make it worse.

34:50Andy Greenwald:Doesn't mean like stop being so precious with your adverbs. It means make the circumstances worse. Don't, don't consider your characters necessarily to be your children or to be fictional avatars of your best interests and your best, um, hopes and dreams. Make the situation, turn the situations to 11, the Spinal Tap parlance, right? Make things as bad as they can be for them. So you see how they fare. And also, so you aren't hiding behind, uh, honestly, like your own writerly concern or optimism or hopes, how you want to be communicated to the world and he makes it worse sure like the the litany of shit that these guys are dealing with right from jump like just to go through it again with tom uh it seems this the implication is that he and his now no longer at home wife have i believe adopted children in the past in the past that they had three children it appears that one child may have ended the life of the other directly or indirectly.

35:52I think it's just a family tragedy. Yeah.

35:54Andy Greenwald:There's, there's some implication. One is in prison and one is no longer with us. Yes. Uh, he is a fallen priest. He is on desk duty, right? Like he is, uh, listening to the Phillies on the radio, which, you know, for most, a lot, depending what year the show is set can often be a sort of calamitous experience. Yeah. It's funny. It's like, there's so many flip phones in this show because of the drug business that I can't tell what year it's set, but it's obviously after COVID and everything. Yeah. Oh, right. So it's not the year where they were like Scott Kingery is the future. Because there were some dark times in those years.

36:28Andy Greenwald:Yeah. Can you imagine if we're just like just when Tom like gets this new job and he cleans the house and he turns on the radio and they're like, and Trey Turner is limping. Chip Kelly looks like he's got it all figured out here. That's worse. Yeah. I mean, what if it's now and he listens to like, you know, Trey Turner as a hamstring strain and we're screwed. Or this is just a pitch for Brad if he's listening. Like, you should definitely have Scott Franski audio being like, one thing about Zach Wheeler. He does not have any blood clots. His veins are clean. Clean is the stat sheet. Anyway, yeah, it's just like every single thing is really bad and he doesn't run from that.

37:05Andy Greenwald:Yes. Up to and including moments that are played for more comedic effect, like what I was referring to when Robbie is just grooving to his tunes shirtless and pilfering his niece's room for some sweet doobage. Yeah. and she comes home with a hookup and he's in the closet. Yeah. I want to get to the performances in a second because there's not a ton of plot. There's not a lot to unpack in terms of like, what do you think this means? What do you think that happens here? The beats are the beats that I laid out earlier. I wanted to talk a little bit about the characters and the performances, but the first character I want to talk about is the setting.

37:40Happy to do that. And I was, I mean, I weirdly have was just in upper Derby, uh, for, for business, but, um, I wanted to know, like, you know, you, you're, you're, we're, we grew up in Philadelphia in separate parts of the city. Yeah. Uh, I was like closer to the art museum and like in the city and culture. Uh, that's right. Just the vibrancy. I was more of a quarry jumper.

38:04Andy Greenwald:Kind of a left bank guy. Yeah. Um, tell me a little bit about Delco Montgomery County and like that area. because I think one thing that would be useful for our listeners who aren't locals and any locals who are listening to us, I spend a lot of time geographically mapping references from this show. Including Easttown makes a quick cameo. Exactly. Shared universe time. It's been suggested that it could be a possibility. What is it about this area that you think is a good backdrop for this kind of show? Well, particularly just going off of what was the way that Jeremiah Zagar is shooting the show.

38:44Andy Greenwald:Yep. What I immediately responded to with familiarity, and I'm not from Chester, I'm not from Delco, but like it's so green. Yes. And it's so weirdly, especially when shot this way, jarringly pastoral, jarringly rustic almost. You feel the age in a different way than you do in like old city, center city. right like their their houses are a certain age but it feels well the townships will have like a strip and it'll be like three dive bars and an acme and then you make a right turn and drive up a hill and you were in the woods yes and there's a farmhouse or there might be i mean i have never i i shack shack meme i was not familiar with cory's game like i didn't know that was an option for me yeah my wife was like how come you didn't take me here and i was like because we want our hearts to explode first of all yeah it's just like i didn't know existed and second of all I don't know if you and me and then Robbie and his family would be like jumping.

39:40Andy Greenwald:See you Friday. What if you, but also you as a former lifeguard. Yeah, are you that guy from the Rewatchables? It's pretty good. It's pretty fucking funny. You as a former lifeguard though, I don't know if you would have approved of the health and safety set up at the quarry. I mean, look, there's one guy who found out where the rocks were in that place when he dove in and everybody else is like, you got to go past that. Hey, got a little bit, keep going. you're going to take a run and start I thought there's like a haunted role I know this is crazy I wrote this down in my document but the quarry especially the shot in the beginning of the episode where Robbie's kids all jump on Raul Castillo when he comes in the door it kind of has a little bit of the tree of life Terrence Malick dusk where it's like it's all around us the magic and like there's all these different POV like perspective shots where it's like that when he comes in, it's shot from like almost the kid's height.

40:39Andy Greenwald:Yeah. And how these kids must look at the adults in the house as giants and as like these playful giants. Here's something that matters about this show, and I think it was in Mare too, is that like this show is very, very comfortable speaking in a language visually or in terms of the script with sadness and beauty that both exist. there's a moment when Maeve and Robbie have this big confrontation and he's like I didn't know you were so unhappy. Shout out Pelfrey. We're going to shout Pelfrey out in a second. Shout out Saquon. She's like I am very very unhappy and it is like existentially bone chilling because that is just there's nothing else to say.

41:20Andy Greenwald:There's no cute follow up. There's no like parentheses about if only she could go to art school or whatever. It is an absolute make it worse rock in a hard place situation. When the guy who comes over is like, what do you do? She's like, I don't do anything. I don't do anything. And that kind of ennui and opportunity, lack of opportunity, and just sunk into the soil kind of cost of a place that is old and beautiful, but what are we doing with it? Just permeates every frame. Well, it's also what families can do. It's like families are the places where you find yourself all of a sudden performing roles that you never imagined you would.

41:57and families are also the only arena where you're allowed to be like openly hostile and still live with the person you know like where you're allowed to be like this fucking sucks now I'm going into this room instead of like I guess I have to leave I've just made a scene you know I think that you really put your finger on something Inglesby has obviously set two shows here now and there is something beautiful about it and then you have to ask what's hidden behind the beauty what is hidden in those woods what is hidden like these stash houses that are a little bit off the road, you know, or up the hill or whatever.

42:30Even the nature of like how Robbie's brother's house that they're all living in seems to be like, it's in a, it's like a tree house somewhere, you know? Like it's just, there are chickens and it's just like this beautifully hidden away spot. But what is the emotional pain that's like behind the walls that's in those places? And I think he's very attuned to that.

42:53Andy Greenwald:And where do the people go who keep leaving? you know like it's it's it's very there's a very affecting moment when uh again like make it worse like Robbie may have this very intense uh argument and then when Maeve goes in the house of course Robbie's daughter's listening yeah and she's like don't leave don't leave yeah and she you we know yeah we know a that she won't and b we know why yeah this is stuff Bruce Springsteen songs are made of you know like of like I just gotta get out of here and I can't. He looked pretty good at the U.S. Open though. Was he there? Seems like he got out. Is he in severance?

43:25Andy Greenwald:He might be. He definitely looked like he'd had some of that baby goat treatment. He looked like the weight of letting go. No, he's getting ready for award season for delivering me from nowhere. No, but yes, but also maybe the release of electric Nebraska is coming out. The release of electric Nebraska has de-aged him. It de-aged me. It's a burden. I was going to ask you about that. I wasn't born in the U.S.A. I was like, we're fucking back. There was like, There was the shot at the US Open. It was Mindy Kaling and BJ Novak still doing the most fun. Will they or won't they ever? Bruce Springsteen, I believe his daughter, was there.

43:59Andy Greenwald:Pink and her motocross bow. Is this all in a row? They were all in a box together. And then professional BFFs, Sting and Shaggy, who were just like... Homies? They were like doing a big reggae fest at the Mann Center in Philadelphia. Right about that, Brad Inglesby. Which is weird. We're just like, okay. Sting and Shaggy. Every week we should challenge Brad Inglesby to really tell the truth. Tell the truth, Brad. Has he seen the video of the guy leaving Lincoln Financial Field after the game? Who's just like, I can't say any of the words he uses to describe his feelings about the Eagles win. Yeah.

44:35Andy Greenwald:But he is all of us. Where's he in your show, Brad? All right, let's talk about a couple of these performances. You know, Ruffalo is the biggest name in the show. But I want to start with Pelfrey. who's a long time CR guy. Like I've been really, really locked in on him for a minute, obviously. Can I just say like on the way in, you were saying that I was incorrectly columbusing a restaurant in London? Yes. Can I say that I do think if I've run the numbers that I do think I like Tom Pelfrey in Banshee before he was on Ozark? Andy, I defer to you. You're right. You mentioned Banshee more than any other show on this podcast.

45:17I just haven't watched it and you're right.

45:19Andy Greenwald:Thank you. I was looking at Tom Pelfrey's IMDB and I was like no shit he was on Banshee. A big Lacunae there in his CV for old CR but it's cool. He's real good in it. It's fine. Pelfrey obviously mind blowing in his Ozark arc that he had in season 2 I believe and very very good in Manc Outer Range. I don't know that they really used him to his full abilities the thing that jumps off the screen when you see him in task is that it feels like he has been this character for his whole life great call and then the camera turned on like his that the moment that i referenced earlier with him and cliff uh talking about like dating i was like this guy knows it it just feels like he's wearing this dude's skin it is unreal like he is so he has possessed this character already and like yeah like we could do accent Olympics all day with these characters I find it really interesting that the amount of Brits who are in it just because or Irish and British actors because I wonder whether or not it's almost easier for them to be like I have to do a new accent anyway so I can get to Philly easier than someone who's not from Philly and I kind of wonder whether that's a thing but we'll talk about the supporting characters uh Robbie being this emotionally vulnerable, but I am a fucking urban lumberjack strongman, it's just a beautiful portrayal so far.

46:52And it's all in his eyes. And it was like that in Ozark, as this guy who was tilting off his meds and descending into madness, even though he was in a completely crazy situation that almost justified his madness. Robbie's kind of, the pain in his eyes never goes away. and I just thought you know you don't have to do that there are a lot of actors who are like this is that's not what this seems about or like it's like every single moment that that guy has you feel like he's like carrying something really really heavy I think it's really important to

47:25Andy Greenwald:shout out the casting here because again there's a nuance to it you say it's a it's a big exciting dramatic, maybe awards-baity, two-hander coming from HBO. Obviously, a project like that goes to the top talent lists at all the agencies. I really admire the way they cast two very different actors who use what they bring perfectly. Ruffalo is a very talented, like, technical actor and has been amazing in a lot of things. But in this, one of the things we're sort of resting on is his just natural, lived-in charisma. He's not, as you said, he's not doing accent. He's not really turning it up past the point of like a couple of vodkas.

48:10Andy Greenwald:Okay, a lot of vodkas. He's steadying, which is the role. And kind of what you want from that figure on the scale. Yeah. Pelfrey's part, he is an industry favorite. People who have seen him, no matter when they first saw him, let's just say, love him. Yeah. And understand his abilities. Um, but I have to say, and I don't mean to do a drive-by here, but if like, if this was an, an Apple show, I think it would be an equally famous actor to Ruffalo playing the other half of it. And that might take away from the lived in nature. You don't even, I mean, you're welcome to do a drive-by. It's, it's, it's, uh, it's your car.

48:49I would say, I, I, I just think that like, there's a lack of vanity in both of these performances for sure.

48:55Andy Greenwald:But I don't want to say one's better than the other, but I'm just saying, no, but like they're doing something really interesting where it's like ruffalo is essentially like what would a guy who's obviously been through an unspeakable yet to be kind of articulated tragedy what how would he carry himself the booze is like sticking to him he is looks like he always has his eyes like halfway closed every probably moment of his daily life is either a humiliation or a heartbreak like he's either like i'm sitting here in a fucking career fair handing out pamphlets like so this is my career's over or I'm meeting with people about my son's sentencing and whether or not members of my family are going to give a witness impact statements or, you know, family impact statements.

49:38So like, there's not a good part of his day other than the moment where he sees a bird or the moment where the alcohol probably kicks in and then he pays for it the next day for Robbie. He's like, look, like it, there is a degree to which what it's funny how much the, this episode of Task is essentially the same beat for beat as the opening episode of Dope Thief.

50:02Andy Greenwald:I wondered if we'd talk about it. It's actually kind of shocking. Well, it is pretty shocking. Obviously, there's stories about this in the greater Philadelphia area that interest these people. And to be clear, we say shocking, not like, oh my god, there was plagiarism here. Absolutely not. But the degree to which they are almost the same... two guys who bring on a third guy a third guy who's not going to be with us for long to go to a rural part outside of Philadelphia and it goes badly yeah go on to be hunted by a driven but haunted law enforcement agent you know but the the act of robbing drug dealers is an interesting piece of I don't know if it's plot armor I don't know if I'm using the term correctly there but it does create morally an attachment for the viewer because you're like, well, this seems like something that it's like, there's no victim in this crime.

51:02It's Robin Hood-ish. Sure, yeah. I don't know that he is donating that money back to charities. I mean, it seems like he's providing for his family but I was reading an interview with Inglesby and Amelia Jones and Pelfrey on Deadline last night and Pelfrey's just like, this guy is not a bad guy and he's not doing anything wrong. About the first episode. Classic Giants fan. He is a New York Giants fan. What did you think of... I mean, obviously, we're going to probably be introduced to the Dark Hearts at some point, who I think will pose a slightly heavier villain.

51:38Andy Greenwald:There's also a biker gang in Dope Thief. That's right. That's right. But, you know what I mean? The idea that if you're robbing stash houses, are you really robbing anybody? Right. I mean, I think what the reason this works for me in a different way, and again, they were different projects with different aims. And Dope Thief allowed Brian Tyree Henry to go to some really phenomenal places. And I was glad he was nominated for an Emmy next week for his performance. But it was a lot more popcorn at times. It was a lot more devoted to the banter and the friendship stuff. and it was a lot of like, you know, extremity Jenga of like, well, you won't believe how crazy this thing is going to get next.

52:21Andy Greenwald:This show, because of its tone, its tenor, its emotional interest in things, and the fact that, like we were saying, it's not really written as a star vehicle, seems just very focused on the idea of a community. What we owe each other, what we owe ourselves, what is available to us within the economy that has been left to us, right? Like, I think that that aspect of it is really interesting, that they are, there's a talk about, I thought one of the smaller moments that lingers is in that same online dating conversation when Robbie is showing Cliff, like, with the money we get, and we don't know that yet, but we could get unspoiled wilderness in Canada and basically start over.

52:58Andy Greenwald:Yeah, an island, yeah. And Cliff says, who picks up the trash? Right. And the idea that, like, there's municipal services, newly relevant in Philadelphia, I would say, although it seems like maybe they've come to some sort of scepter agreement. Have they? Yeah, but like fares are going up, but service is being restored. Okay. We can do that for our next, put it for like eye on the street, local news version of this podcast. Because the fun thing about this podcast, people are always like, it's too general interest. Yeah. You guys cast too wide a net. You should focus more. We got super into abundance.

53:27Yeah.

53:29Andy Greenwald:Don't tempt me with a good time. I've got thoughts. But yeah, but like the idea that this stuff is supposed to work, and that was baked into Mare of Easttown in a really, I thought, effective way too. Like everyone was connected to someone who is connected to some other person who is part of a problem, either on one side of it or the other. Like no one goes untouched. Sure. Right? And whether you're on the crime fighters or the side of crime, like these are porous boundaries and everybody's kind of under the same boot heel. And I think that that aspect of it is going to be interesting going forward.

54:02Yeah, everybody's got a boss. That was like, it's like Ruffalo is the boss of this task force that he puts together but Kathleen McGinty is his boss and she's already like, I've been told I can't. She's being put out to pasture. Yeah, I'm being put out to pasture. It's like it goes up. It just rolls downhill.

54:15Andy Greenwald:Can we talk about the kids? Yep, the task force. In the show, the task force. But first, can we just take a moment for Amelia Jones? If you told me, you could have given me 10 guesses as to what I had seen this actor in before and I would have never gotten it. I've never seen Coda. Like, I just know the name. Was that the best picture winner that you just... You were like, it's COVID, I'm good. I don't need to engage with it. I mean, she's very good in it, but okay. I did not know that this was part of her game. The other thing that's really cool is I could take everything that you say about, you could take everything that you say about Pelfrey and apply it to Jones.

54:55She is this person. Like, I mean, it's probably an incredible performance. The haircut, the accent, the piercings, the... Yes. I got old way too young look in her eyes. Her accent is flawless.

55:10Andy Greenwald:Her vibe is flawless. We have all met this person before. She is a force of nature from the second she appears on screen. And the way that it's not just the way Robbie relates to this character with this mix of like, I am in charge here, but also I know that I am not. it's the way that Pelfrey clearly respects what she's bringing in these scenes that brings something else out of him. I just think she's, I think she's astonishing. And, you know, in a way she is like an interesting, if you watch this show as a, it's not a sequel to Mare of Easttown, but it's the next chapter and what Brad's doing in this world and this type of storytelling.

55:49Andy Greenwald:And so in a way it's like a iteration of what the character Angory Rice played, the daughter who was in the band that played all the Mannequin Pussy songs. Yes. Like it's a really fascinating, deeper iteration of that character in a way that I'm really, really responding to. I think she's amazing. She's a, you know, this kind of character could be a type. You know, it could be not window dressing, but like in the background and the entire thing is just about Robbie and like what Robbie's going through. But Jeremiah Zagar makes some cool choices in terms of the coverage that he does, where sometimes it'll be a scene that you should probably be following Robbie through and it'll stay with Maeve and it'll stay on her reactions to his behavior so that it becomes way more of an ensemble piece that way.

56:38Andy Greenwald:And that's the exact antidote to what you were saying about the way these are not Ronin. It is not Heat for that reason. Their behavior is affecting other people. What if Heat, but from Amy Brenneman's perspective? That's right. A necessary corrective, if you will. I actually, never mind. My daughter saw the musical Anne Juliet yesterday. it's touring and i don't know if you're familiar with this but it's like a romeo and juliet they loved it juliet's POV right it's also like it starts like a play within a play and shakespeare's wife was like this sucks let me do it big big year for shakespeare's play year for their whole family i know by the way 8 a.m i'm like you know chloe joe has a new film at tiff this year called hamnet my children are like please please stop um why that's relevant information i know they were interested uh-huh they're like hamnet's a dumb name i'm like well put some respect on it because anyway um he invented this whole shit yeah then they're like it's a jukebox musical max martin songs max martin wrote and produced life of showgirl anyway um do you think that like within our lifetime will someone be like do the feminist corrective to heat about amy breneman's character i think that if you let me and bill pod long enough we will do it get there yeah i believe in you.

57:52Andy Greenwald:Okay. So then I do want to talk about the, the scene of, so Ruffalo cleans out this house, although not well enough to welcome in these kids in the task force. And it is wild to me. And I wanted to get your sense of the accent stuff about it because the three recruits, none of them are American actors and they are all coming to this accent into this world. So I do think there's something to your point about, also because apparently the Philadelphia accent and the baltimore accent are unique because of the ports in these cities that cockneyed ship workers that's why it sounds like that for whatever reason okay david i'll just say it's fascinating it is i you're right you're right like something cockney east london to baltimore works so i don't know but anyway we have fabian frankel who's your guy from house the dragon who is honestly he's my guy.

58:44I know. He is my guy now. Own it. Anthony Grosso. Yeah.

58:49Andy Greenwald:Tutsuma Bedou is South African. And they do make a point of saying she moved to the area, which maybe gives her a little bit of a break. And then Alice and Oliver. Normie Peeps. No, from Convies with Friends. Oh, that's right. That's right. Normal People is the mescal in my bed. Yeah. Things worked out for those stars of that one. Yeah. Yeah. Alice and Oliver was Convies with Fs and also The Order. The Jude Law starring film that I watched that we never talked about. She's in that. I love that you watching something necessitates the conversation. Because I just want, which camera's on? I want the record to show.

59:27Andy Greenwald:Sometimes you're like, oh, you might really enjoy it. I'm like, oh, okay. That happens once a year and it's always the order and it's not weapons. That's fair. But that was like, watch Miyazaki and you were like, I watched Porco Rosso over the shoulder of a three-year-old once. Shout out to local Philadelphia meteorologist Cecily Tynan. We're monitoring a low pressure system with Allison Oliver. She might fucking, when she's on the phone outside, I don't know if she hits every single accent note, but she is definitely a girl that I have met from Philadelphia, larger Philadelphia area. Sir, you haven't been on the receiving end of that phone call.

1:00:06Andy Greenwald:No, I haven't. I mean, it's possible. Yeah, maybe in my youth. I'm not trying to cast aspersions no I had an incredible run of not getting dumped for a while you know so did you? well do we think I'm sorry I'm trying to remember I think that they were living the characters in this show are living together and like he's now come over to get all this shit but there's no evidence that he was dumped he may have dumped her but he's like can I get my stuff yes I think that's what we're supposed to believe now the CR brain is like can't get dumped if I've already moved all my stuff out and so she comes home and it's just like the Will Smith meme in the empty house in Bel Air that's how you get them never been dumped yeah but if you only have like if you're like I need this ottoman you know or I need this like whatever we need that one chair from Ikea that we all had I need that until I was 35 I had nothing I was the Ronin you know what I mean I was still I was still like I have a bunch of raucous records, white-labeled 12 inches, and an Xbox.

1:01:12That's all I need. Until you were 30? That's why I moved here.

1:01:16Andy Greenwald:First of all, you've made it very clear on numerous pods that your entire shit is liquid. You can go at any time. You began the pod last week. I don't remember if we were recording it or not, saying, can't cancel me now. I have nothing to lose.

1:01:33Andy Greenwald:And even on this pod, you were like, yeah, fuck it. I'll root for the American in the U.S. Open final. and you'll never be able to prove that I did. You're a fucking whisper in the wind, man. Own it. Allison Oliver is doing things in that front yard on the phone where we're just very, very aware of it. Is it a Cecily Tynan thing or is it a John Bolaris thing? I'm more of a Cecily person. Is it a Hurricane Schwartz kind of thing? Were you a Bolaris guy? No, I just, have you been following the Bolaris story since? Oh, he had a rough exit, right? He's still making the gossip column. Okay. Like, it is a wild thing.

1:02:11Andy Greenwald:It is a very specific level of fame to be Philadelphia weatherman famous. Are you so post everything digital that you don't... Did you ever have a personal relationship to a local weather person growing up? Yeah. Yeah, no, I did. Cron 4 News was my local... Cron 4 News. Yeah. Okay. Do you remember what the weather person's name was? Oh my God, no, I don't. But I do remember. I guess when it's in the Bay Area, what's the point of looking at the weather? Like, it's just going to be... It's 50 degrees and foggy every day, so... Like, Belarus has been banned from numerous restaurants now. He's, like, called out people's personal lives who own restaurants.

1:02:50Andy Greenwald:Like, it's quite a... Really? Yeah. What I'm saying is Lizzie has John Belarus energy. I gotcha. But we should probably... You think she's been kicked out of a cheesecake factory once or twice? A rouge on Rittenhouse Square. I'm just saying, I think that we need a professional meteorologist monitoring her barometric pressure. She's incredible. But she has Belarus energy. Frankel is doing very well. It's a really good ensemble. And as a pilot episode goes, I really respected... I'm going to do character beats with upwards of 12 people, including just a tender but haunted Rita's water ice between father and daughter.

1:03:30Yeah. Black cherry? Yeah, that's what he got. And do you approve? Look. You're a lemon guy. It's very on - What? What are you?

1:03:39Andy Greenwald:No, I'm like, I'm not a Rita. Like Rita's kind of mid. Well, what's your water? Do you have a water ice of choice? Yeah, John's. Okay. And then honestly, the chocolate water ice is amazing. Everybody's been talking about the chocolate water ice. The chocolate ice is incredible. But also like in the summer, John's has like fresh fruits. Whatever they have on the board, you get that. You get yourself down there. you tell him John Bolaris thank you actually do not do that you will not be served water yeah you know who else we have to shout out though Isaac DeBanko great great veteran actor from like every Jim Jarmusch movie yes showing up as Daniel who's the priest who's the guy who's stuck with it who's got some cool Catholic literary journals he wants to share and a taste for the yingling which I respected by the way shout out yingling in the show I see the the rolling rock monopoly big RR has been broken.

1:04:31I think Inglesby new. Like I can't just pretend like everybody only drinks RR.

1:04:36Andy Greenwald:Or do you think like the Czech stopped coming from old Latrobe? I'm just bummed that Kenwood couldn't get a shot, but maybe Kenwood isn't hitting an upper Derby. I don't know. Yeah. Kenwood's a good local beer. Anything else you want to say about Task? This is fun to talk about. It's fun to have in our lives. I'm very excited about it. Yeah, let us know if you guys have questions. The watch at Spotify.com. if you want me to detail which travel baseball Little League fields I've played at in Delco, I can talk about my slash line. Yeah, which one almost caused your heart to explode. It's exciting.

1:05:12Andy Greenwald:It was an exciting show. Even the action sequence was very, very gripping. It was well shot. Yeah, I got those masks. Oh, you mean you want them back? When you and Zach came over wearing them for the Eagles game, I thought it was weird, but I was happy to have you come in. It's just my Anasimova mask. Thanks to Kaya, who's back. And congratulations to Kaya. And congratulations to Kaya. Thanks to John. Good job. And we'll be back on Thursday to talk about Alien. I don't think he's going to watch Dystopia anymore, Kaya. I think life has turned a page for him. Yeah. No, he's really committed to the genre.

1:05:45Andy Greenwald:And now you are as well. See you guys on Thursday.

1:05:57Uncovered windows can make your home feel up to 20 degrees hotter. Stay cool and save up to 45 % off custom window treatments during the Summer Black Friday Mega Sale at Blinds.com. From outdoor shades to room-darkening blinds, finding the perfect fit is easy. Get free samples, expert design help, and professional measure and install services, or DIY with confidence and support every step of the way. Shop up to 45 % off site-wide, plus huge savings on doorbusters right now during the Summer Black Friday Megasale at Blinds.com. Best thing that's ever happened to you financially. Go. Easy. Sold my car on Carvana.

1:06:32Amazing offer. Really? I hit 200 on a scratcher. Did the scratcher come to your house and hand you a check? No. How many scratchers did you hit to get that? I hit a button on Carvana.com once. Okay, that's fair. It's like the lottery, except you always win. Not like the lottery at all, actually. Exactly. Inexplicably good. Offers worth bragging about. Sell your car today on Carvana. Pickup fees may apply.

From the publisher

Chris and Andy talk about some of the winners from the Creative Arts Emmy Awards on Saturday and what they predict for the main awards show coming up on Sunday (8:56). Then they go deep on the premiere of the new HBO crime show ‘Task.’ They talk about the similarities to and differences from Brad Ingelsby’s first Philly-set crime show, ‘Mare of Easttown’ (16:44), and the outstanding performances from Mark Ruffalo, Tom Pelphrey, and Emilia Jones (41:43).

Hosts: Chris Ryan and Andy Greenwald

Producers: Kaya McMullen and Kai Grady

Video Producer: Jon Jones
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from The Watch

All 119 episodes
‘Task’ Is Everything We Want It to Be. Plus, the Creative Arts Emmy Awards.The Watch · 1 h 6 min
Listen in VO