In short
The Watch episode covers three things: (1) the Creative Arts Emmys weekend and what it signals for the main Emmys, (2) a fall TV preview ranked by what the hosts think listeners will be most excited about, and (3) Lanterns episode 4 discussion (with a “Lanterns after dark” vibe).
Guests
Chris Ryan (editor at TheRinger.com) and Andy Greenwald (podcast host; “the manhunter”).
Key claims
the Creative Arts Emmys are a “gauntlet-throwing” preview that forces nominees to be ready; Widows Bay is positioned to dominate; streamers/networks are shifting toward limited series due to diminishing returns in later seasons.
Notable examples
Betty Gilpin (Widows Bay) wins guest actress; Ernest Harding (The Pitt) wins guest actor in drama; Rob Reiner wins guest actor in comedy for The Bear; Spider Noir wins five but gets canceled. Fall picks: Lowdown S2, Slow Horses S6, Black Doves S2; plus Small Profits, Tiptoe, Youth, Get Jiro, Vision Quest, American Hostage, Kill Jackie, High Value Target: The Hunt for Saddam Hussein. Lanterns E4: it picks up right where E3 left off, includes a long Sinestro sequence, and uses flashback/standalone structure; Sinestro’s betrayal is framed as trust/fear dynamics.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VODiscussing Fall TV Excitement
0:41 to 2:14
Chris and Andy share their anticipation for the upcoming fall TV season and the need for stimulating content.
“I looked at the next couple of months of releases.”
Emmys Discussion and Insights
2:14 to 2:36
The hosts delve into the recent Creative Arts Emmys and the significance of the awards.
“I think we've been having some lulls covering the shows we've been covering.”
Analyzing Emmy Winners and Trends
2:36 to 3:56
Chris and Andy analyze Emmy winners and discuss the implications for the TV landscape.
“Please do, we can do Lioness after dark if you want.”
Industry Trends and Diminishing Returns
3:56 to 8:08
A look at industry trends regarding the diminishing returns of TV shows and the shift towards limited series.
“We already knew, I think, we're going to do some predictions and previews on Thursday that Widows Bay was going to clean up, but Widows Bay is going to clean up.”
Fall TV Preview and Nathan Fielder’s Documentary
8:08 to 10:52
The hosts preview upcoming fall TV shows and discuss Nathan Fielder's new documentary about Elizabeth Holmes.
“Meaning the second and third seasons of shows are underperforming relative to what people expected them to.”
Humor and Personal Anecdotes
10:52 to 14:00
Chris and Andy share personal anecdotes and humorous moments related to Nathan Fielder's work.
“and I know Nathan Fielder's work is very important to you, wanted to ask you about this out-of-nowhere news that Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim have made a documentary about Elizabeth Holmes.”
Analyzing TV's Recent Trends
14:00 to 14:31
Discussion on the evolving landscape of television and its twists.
“and their being honest to their whatever forms they had to sign to see it.”
Top 10 Shows to Watch This Fall
14:31 to 18:19
Exploring anticipated fall TV shows and their unique aspects.
“Let's talk a little bit about fall television before we do the lanterns.”
Show Reviews: Black Doves and Slow Horses
18:19 to 24:11
Insights on the returning shows 'Black Doves' and 'Slow Horses'.
“And they are examples of the varying ways in which seasonal television has succeeded and failed in terms of giving us reliable thrills.”
New Show Highlights: Small Profits and Tiptoe
24:11 to 28:01
Introducing new shows like 'Small Profits' and 'Tiptoe'.
“Lowdown season two, I can't possibly explain how excited I am.”
Show all 31 chapters
Exploring 'Feuding Neighbors' and Its Themes
28:01 to 28:57
Learn about the new Starz show 'Feuding Neighbors' and its relevance to current social issues.
“but is it set particularly during any sort of troubles Not to my knowledge.”
Russell T. Davies: A Unique Voice in TV
28:58 to 30:01
Discuss the career of Russell T. Davies and his impact on British television.
“In my impression, that's most houses in Wales, but it probably is the nicest one.”
Previewing 'Youth' by Sharon Horgan
30:02 to 30:59
Get insights into Sharon Horgan's upcoming series 'Youth', exploring love and life in your 50s.
Animated Series to Watch: 'Get Jiro'
31:00 to 32:37
Discover the upcoming animated series 'Get Jiro', based on Anthony Bourdain's graphic novel.
“First of all, great to see Rupert Friend.”
Vision Quest and Marvel's Future
32:38 to 35:00
Discussion about Marvel's 'Vision Quest' and the implications for future storytelling.
“Based on Anthony Bourdain's graphic novel about a dystopian future where chefs are super celebrities.”
Rigorously Covering Marvel's Vision Quest
35:01 to 36:36
Debating how to approach coverage of 'Vision Quest' and its connections to the MCU.
“And inside of his head, ever since they defeated him, I guess James Spader has been living in his head, which does sound provocative.”
Reflections on Marvel's TV Efforts
36:37 to 37:28
Reflect on Marvel's television ventures and their impact on storytelling.
“This is a character whose charms have escaped me.”
Introducing 'American Hostage' Series
37:29 to 39:20
Learn about the new anthology series 'American Hostage' and its historical context.
“You and I have been pretty much off the sauce since WandaVision.”
Catherine Zeta-Jones in 'Kill Jackie'
39:21 to 41:41
Preview of the upcoming show 'Kill Jackie' starring Catherine Zeta-Jones.
“It's about a one-time drug smuggler, now art dealer, who gets targeted by a group of assassins, and then she turns the tables by going after the assassins.”
Final Thoughts and Closing Remarks
41:42 to 42:06
Wrap-up discussion about new shows and their potential appeal.
Discussion on Upcoming Shows
42:06 to 44:34
The hosts discuss various upcoming TV shows, including a new series starring Joel Kinnaman.
“High value target colon The Hunt for Saddam Hussein starring Joel Kinnaman.”
Lanterns E4 Discussion Begins
44:34 to 45:56
The hosts share their thoughts and a funny mistake regarding episodes of 'Lanterns'.
“I also thought it was surprising when Sunday's episode aired this past Sunday's or the Sunday, the third episode aired actually.”
Episode Analysis: Lanterns E4
45:56 to 47:22
A deep analysis of the fourth episode of Lanterns, discussing narrative choices and character development.
“and And look, I thought that there were parts of this episode that sang.”
Exploring Themes and Motifs
47:22 to 51:04
The hosts explore the themes of heroism and fear in the context of the characters and storytelling.
“And that what happens when you let the fear in and where it, where, where it leads you.”
Character Dynamics and Relationships
51:04 to 56:01
The discussion shifts to character dynamics, focusing on John Stewart and his relationships.
“Yeah, or that, yes, or that John is being set up or something.”
Episode Analysis: Humor and Serious Themes
56:01 to 57:58
Explore the balance between humor and serious themes in the latest episode, analyzing character dynamics and storytelling choices.
“Now there's like the whole like just take the ring and say the oath and you know that stuff.”
Character Exploration: John Stewart
57:59 to 59:56
Delve into the complexities of John Stewart's character, his powers, and the emotional depth of his backstory.
“I mean maybe Joel Kinnaman could do it if he was hunting Saddam Hussein but nine months in the bush you know with one target.”
Reflecting on DC's TV Landscape
59:57 to 1:02:14
Discuss the current state of DC TV shows, comparing them with past offerings and pondering their future direction.
“to expedite expedite like the plot i instead of like hard work figuring out who the the manhunter is i uh i just i just i i really enjoy it but i do note some differences or some basically some flaws here and there.”
Lioness Season Review: Shifts in Tone
1:02:15 to 1:10:01
Analyze the latest developments in 'Lioness', noting tonal shifts and audience reception amidst political themes.
“Like, I know this is incredibly obvious, but I just hadn't been grouping them together in the same way that we group the MCU TV shows.”
Discussion on 'Lioness' and Character Development
1:10:01 to 1:10:59
The hosts discuss character arcs and personal reflections on the show 'Lioness'.
Preview of Upcoming Episodes and Events
1:11:00 to 1:11:39
The hosts preview upcoming content, including the Emmys and a show return.
“And we'll also talk a little bit about the return of the paper on Peacock and NBC.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:05Andy Greenwald:I need supports to have to clear the room. Stand up and walk. Now. Hello and welcome to The Watch. My name is Chris Ryan. I am an editor at TheRinger.com. Joining me in the studio, he's the manhunter. It's Andy Greenwald! How long have you known? Ever since we slept together. All those years ago. Greenwald great to see you man on Labor Day but we thought why the hell not you know honestly middle age what are you going to do you know hang out with the kids no no no there's TV to talk about yeah I wanted to talk about Lanterns I wanted to talk a little bit about Fall TV you wanted to talk about the Creative Artists Emmy Creative Arts Emmy because the way you were framing it suggested that I had plans and Kaya and John had plans but you were like I want to talk about Lanterns this is this is saddle up greenwald called his own number he was like monday's got to be the day i'm very busy man on tuesday um so true so also like why go on tuesday i know you know it's like the week's already over this is where we belong and when you look at your podcast feed and it's bill and sal right and then it's cr and greens greenie no do they say that bill and sal they'll call us greenie they don't talk about us at all i'm just saying like i don't think sometimes No, those are, I love those guys.
1:25Andy Greenwald:Don't put me on the spot here. I got no beef. Here's what I want to do today. I do have a fall television preview. Nice. I looked at the next couple of months of releases. That's nice. And I was like, how do I want to present this? I could do chronologically. I could go hype draft. Hype beast. I thought I would just rank them in terms of how much I think you're interested in them. This is going to be a good test on both the fall slate and also your knowledge of me and where I'm at. Well, what I tried to do is imagine a world in which you were just a mere citizen, flipping channels, scrolling through streaming services, but looking for something a little bit stimulating.
2:05A little bit of comfort, but a little bit of provocation, a little bit of artistic boundary pushing.
2:11Andy Greenwald:Something to spice up my otherwise anodyne existence. And I think we as a pod need it too. We need some juice back, right? Do you think? No, I mean TV does. I think we've been having some lulls covering the shows we've been covering. And by the way, I do want to ask you a Lioness question this week. My silence will continue to be deafening. We're in a bit of a... I know, I'm going to push you on that. We're in a bit of a dark moment with this show for the last two weeks. I'm going to carve out a little space. Please do, we can do Lioness after dark if you want. Sorry, I do. I don't know anything about why the Emmys are now taking place over two weekends and why there's like a hundred categories got rewarded this past weekend.
2:50This isn't new. And I don't think it was aired on TV, to my knowledge.
2:54Andy Greenwald:It is odd to me that it's not, just because everybody's so desperate for anything. But yes, the Oscars do this too. There's the Creative Arts Awards the weekend before. But it's not something where they're like, oh, did you see who won the Creative Arts Awards? That means this is going to happen next week, right? Well, no, basically what it is is a two nights to dispense with all of the deeply essential and meaningful categories that don't play as well on television, that aren't as prestigious, that the stars aren't necessarily receiving. I think one of the changes, one of the reasons why it's more evident this year is because, for example, the guest star in a television series, Emmy, has always been given away on this weekend.
3:36Andy Greenwald:and like I feel like between the years of 2004 and 2012 it was just Jean Smart won all of them before she was Jean Smart star of Hacks so it wasn't like a no disrespect to Jean Smart but it wasn't a needle moving sort of pay attention moment because of the caliber of actors that come to TV these days even just to drop in it's a bigger deal and like for specifically guest actress in a television series Emmy went to Betty Gilpin for Widow's Bay along with almost any other category that Widows Bay was nominated for last night, which it won, which sort of previews, I mean, everything from Score to Christian Springer for cinematography.
4:14Andy Greenwald:We already knew, I think, we're going to do some predictions and previews on Thursday that Widows Bay was going to clean up, but Widows Bay is going to clean up. It seems like it. It seems like, I think the big question was, does Hacks get this great victory lap emus run in comedy? and it does seem like Widows Bay has kind of slingshot Pitt-esque into the lead position here. And speaking of Pitt, Ernest Harding won the highly competitive guest actor in a drama award against many other people on the Pitt. He played Louis. That was exciting to see. Great congratulations to him. I would say the biggest thing about these awards being handed out over the weekend is it's really like throwing down the gauntlet.
4:57Andy Greenwald:And I'm just going to say this, like Katie Dippold, Hiro Mirai, people have been on our show. You can't show up and be like, oh no, I don't have anything prepared. You guys now, you have like six days. You gotta be ready. Sure. Because you're, you're going, which camera? Matthew Rhys, you're winning an Emmy. You better be ready for it. Okay. Has Matthew Rhys ever been like, I'm completely flat footed. I have nothing charming to say. Oh, the camera's on? Which one? Yeah, exactly. I'm just saying, you cannot pretend this isn't happening. Go through your process, be nervous, but be ready because we're excited to see you win.
5:35Andy Greenwald:Being Hiro Mirai. What's that? Speaking of Hiro Mirai. Oh, sure. The director of several episodes of Buddha's Bay and an essential plank of the creative team there. I did a adventures in movie going interview with him. I saw that. Where I talked to Hiro for about a half an hour about his favorite films on the Criterion channel and his life as a movie goer. and you can watch that on the Criterion channel now. That's great. Just wanted to let everybody know. I'm sorry, I didn't bring that up. That's all right. I like to be the one to celebrate you. I know you do. Whenever possible. It's one of my two good qualities.
6:07Andy Greenwald:The other one that kind of rocked it was DTF St. Louis. Linda Cardellini, David Harbour won. All told. Why are Linda Cardellini and David Harbour's categories not IMU's favorite? That was the other example I was going to give you. I guess to make more space in the big night. for what? For speeches for celebrations of the medium for like oh it's the 25th anniversary of the Angelian sitcom whatever like I don't know what they're going to be doing but they put the actors in a miniseries categories over the weekend as well so they've already won good for them but the big totals were oh the other sort of very sweet thing was that Rob Reiner won for his appearance on the bear season four yes so he won posthumously guest actor in a comedy Emmy.
6:56Andy Greenwald:That's nice. By the numbers, Widows Bay won eight already this weekend. DTF St. Louis won six. The Pit has already landed four. Palm Royale and Margot's Got Money Troubles, two shows that are on Apple TV that we do not really cover, won three. But here's the one that I think is going to be exciting for you. Okay. A little program called I Love Lucy was recognized with a Legacy Award, which is a little bit like giving a appreciation award to Oxygen for helping us breathe. Yeah. They really went on a limb with that one. Was that a special dispensation or was it up against competition? Wouldn't that be amazing?
7:32Andy Greenwald:This one's legacy matters more. The only other thing I thought was interesting was Spider Noir won five Emmys. And that got canceled. Got canceled right before. Oh. I thought that was interesting. That it got canceled? Yeah. I mean, I wonder whether or not that show is maybe expensive or Nick Cage is busy or what the deal was. I'm going to answer the first part. Yeah. That show is super expensive. as I talked about when we talked about it I can speak from some personal experience the development of that show spans for five maybe almost six years yeah I think they had to get it right but well here's the thing I genuinely think from talking to some folks who are involved in it that they feel that they did a great show and they are proud of it and that they told a story and that it's diminishing potentially diminishing returns to revisit it and come up with another reason for doing it rather than maybe circling back up and coming up with another spider-type show.
8:26Andy Greenwald:The larger industry thing, and this will filter into a lot of our other conversations, I think, in terms of just like a larger industry trend that surprised me, is that the streamers and networks are increasingly concerned about the diminishing returns for everything. Meaning the second and third seasons of shows are underperforming relative to what people expected them to. What would an example be? I mean, I think you could point to, what are some shows that came back this year? I mean, we were talking about this briefly when we were talking about like Last of Us coming back, which is still a blockbuster for HBO.
9:03Neil Druckmann doing some bang up PR for Last of Us season three. What's he been doing? I didn't see. He's just like, I have nothing to do with it.
9:09Andy Greenwald:Cool. Yeah. And seems to be rather pointed in his, like, don't loop me in on this. That's sort of my attitude generally about heroes, adventures, and movie going. I wasn't part of it. Good luck with it. I hear good things. So, but what I'm trying to say is it's not just the three-year gap between seasons that some shows are experiencing. On the 10 ,000-footest, 10 ,000-foot view of things, there was a swing away from the expense of launching a show, limited series, big stars, and whatever, just for that one hit. and thus we've seen people trying to crack the code of is it the pit that comes back every year is it task that goes from limited to ongoing but the pendulum in terms of development is seemingly swinging back to people saying we'd rather just have limiteds and I feel like the kid in the front of the class it's bringing it back every year like I agree there are so many little things you can see from like this short episode order for something like adults where for fans of that show that's basically a two-night experience rather than a 10 to 12 week experience um you can point to shows that inexplicably like not vfx heavy shows that take taking two two and a half years to come back gary oldman just talked about this um in some slow horses promo where he's just like the show works because a bunch of people work insanely hard to make this model that we we follow work, which is essentially the British model, but still, it works really well.
10:44I want to do our fall TV preview for Andy. Thank you. I did also, since I have you here, and I know Nathan Fielder's work is very important to you, wanted to ask you about this out-of-nowhere news that Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim have made a documentary about Elizabeth Holmes. It's coming out next month.
11:05Andy Greenwald:That Sean has already seen. That Sean has already seen, and you can see his I assume glittering review he wrote ha ha ha ha ha on Letterboxd so I assume that means he enjoyed it or he enjoyed the spectacle of it happening or whatever he keeps you guessing, he makes you want to tune in to the next episode of the big picture it looks very intimate so what's the name of this thing? it's called everybody means nothing to me no that's Elliot Smith, everybody all the time now look at me everyone come on you can see everything. I wasn't wrong. Uh, it's an excruciating trailer. Okay. But, cool. Good. No, I, I'm going to be honest with you.
11:50Andy Greenwald:I want to have like a real, um, I want to have a real reckoning about this. Okay, let's do it. Many people know that I - Have you continued to experience this, this phenomenon that you're having? Of, of, of people thinking that you look like Nathan Fielder? Is that what you're going to say? Um, I would say since the glasses went full time, And I started, you know, just doing a lot more core work, you know? No, not that part. You do look good. You know what? I think we're both doing great. Thank you. I would say it has dissipated a little bit. I think the sting of having someone ask for a photo with who they thought to be Nathan Fielder in front of my younger daughter was, you know, that was a tough one.
12:31Andy Greenwald:That one took some time. but the bigger thing that I have to say is you know one can't be cowardly about art you know one has to run towards the things that discomfort us if I may and I also feel strongly though I've yet to remedy this that I am aware of the massive mistake I made in not engaging with the rehearsal season 2 and that I must you're scared of flying too or you were so that was part of it too no I don't love flying not scared of it But you know there's this thing when you're on an airplane and it kind of like bumps a little bit. What do you call that? Turbulence. Don't love it. Yeah.
13:11Andy Greenwald:Don't love that part. But everything else is fine. You know, it's great. Food. Food is delightful. The duct tape, you know, whatever you need. Anyway, so just to say that I need to address this blind spot. I admit it. I'm okay with it. This is great. This is growth. Yeah. Yeah. But that said, the underlying thing, why I didn't engage really with Nathan for you is because the style of comedy is him inches away from Elizabeth Holmes's face while she doesn't blink. And that's intense. Well, Batman may have met his Joker in this documentary. I don't know anything about it. There's a lot of buzz about it.
13:47There's a lot of speculation about it. And I think that there's going to be an issue with a cohort of critics who have gotten to see it. And then I think Lance Oppenheim and Nathan Fielder are relying on their secrecy and their being honest to their whatever forms they had to sign to see it. Like to not reveal what usually happens with Nathan Filger's work, which is like major, I can't believe this is happening kind of twist. So I'm very curious to see what that is.
14:15Andy Greenwald:I also have to stay true to the other previously staked out position, which was super pro Lance Oppenheim, because primetime looks like one of the most exciting movies of the year. Looks ganglusters. So I want to just be held accountable. Let's talk a little bit about fall television before we do the lanterns. So I went through kind of my usual sources to see what was coming out over the next couple of months. People want to know who your sources are. Metacritic.com. Okay. And then it's like slash TV release dates. I didn't mean like in the way that the Justice Department wants to know who's talking to the Times.
14:50Andy Greenwald:I just thought maybe you had some other ways of getting this information. Isn't it the Pentagon? They're the ones who are like polygraphing everybody, right? Yeah, but you know, national security. That actually comes up in Linus. I can't wait to talk about it. Why do we lead with that? okay we'll save it because you're you're worried you got to be accountable to some footsteps it's pete exit um look i i wanted to put together a top 10 list of shows that i thought you'd be fired up about because i think that we have had a weird year uh not you and i but tv yeah i think we're good where um we started out very strong i thought we had the pit and we had industry we had a bunch of shows that we've liked, Widow's Bay, Furious.
15:32The top end is very strong. There have been years where I've been like, man, I already have my top 10. This year, I could probably fill it out, but it's not only been a little bit fallow, in my opinion, but it's also been uninspiring. Up until Furious and Widow's Bay, especially up until Furious, I found it to be like TV has kind of lost its way. We have a lot of stuff that feels like it's bloated, a lot of stuff that feels like it's undercooked.
16:04Andy Greenwald:I'm going to dig a little bit here. Now, do you feel like it's because there haven't been enough things that surprised or delighted, or is it that the volume of mediocrity has started to drown out the highs? I think it also could be me. I think also when you put up, like if you if you spend a ton of time watching something as generally programmatic as weekly television or episodic television you can start to see some tricks and you can start to see some seams uh that maybe you don't if you're just casually watching a show at a time here or there and that's on me like i mean i have to find my joy right like it but some of it is like oh I know I'll give you an example okay there are scenes in lanterns for instance yeah uh but I could think of a couple of shows like it where there are more it's more or less a set piece or more or less like a piece of physical action where a character might be getting chased or a character might be trying to get into a building that they're not supposed to get into and the entire time I'm like obviously they're getting into the building like how long is this you know what I I mean, I see so that there's something where I think I'm hitting against the maybe limited scope of the visual storytelling, but the over reliance on needing those visuals to be effective or something like that.
17:24There's a couple of little tenets of that stuff that I'm like, OK, I'm banging my head against the wall a little bit here. But admittedly, I did this research on the next couple of months and I'm just as excited as you will be. It's interesting, though, because I think you're 100 % right that TV, generally to be successful in a consistent way, has to follow certain patterns.
17:47Andy Greenwald:And it has a certain established rhythm and a relationship with audiences that allow it to flourish in the margins. It's kind of what our conversation was about Furious, where it's a cat and mouse show, the cat and mouse are going to cross paths at a certain point. how but so in that it becomes all about how surprising can be the way that they do it how like when how exactly and then if those delight then you stop paying attention to the familiarity of it but and anyway we should get into the list but i think this specific conversation is relevant to lanterns too in the ways that it delights and in the ways that it it can frustrate services and trust rates yeah all right this is the andy ranking of the new and returning shows of fall the reason why i put this together this way is because i'm trying to like i just wanted to give it some some scope this is also a little bit like chris gpt like you could have done my columns for me at grandland i don't even i don't even have to change the letter it could just be i know see well i guess you might have changed the letter which letter well you know how like bill was doing like chat gbt i hadn't heard about that but he accidentally yeah anyway um so the number one two and three shows that are uh i have ranked here are all shows that are returning okay i have the lowdown season two as our number one show of the fall so exciting i have slow horses season six and i have black dove season two this is gonna be a great fall these are stop there uh an interesting collection of shows to talk about together because obviously they're all genre shows that are a genre that we care about a lot, detectives and spies.
19:21Sometimes kind of both. Sometimes. And they are examples of the varying ways in which seasonal television has succeeded and failed in terms of giving us reliable thrills. I cannot wait for Black Doves season two. It has been a while. Yeah. Since Black Doves was on. Shout out Joe Barton. I know he made Amadeus. I'm sure he's very busy. We love Joe Barton. I was saying like... No, no, no. I don't remember why they are the way they are. But I would say this.
19:54Andy Greenwald:This is a continuation in a way of the praise we were giving the show two years ago when it premiered. For me, the joy of Black Doves is Ben Whishaw sadly drinking champagne with a shotgun next to him and then going to rescue Cura Knightley or vice versa. I 100 % don't really remember the conceit of what organization they belong to and where they stand vis-a-vis Interpol or British politics. Yeah, and who did what to whom to get them there. Right. But I think the sign of a well-made show like that is that I don't actually care. I can't wait to be back in that world at Christmas time. But it is an interesting, again, it's another interesting conversation about what we look for in these TV shows.
20:32Andy Greenwald:and I don't know I think I would have accepted anything you know when we were waiting for a new season of Mad Men to come back I would have accepted any kind of like context shaking yeah and I would have been happy with the characters because we love them but that was a different relationship where Black Dubs is like I want my program back yes with Mad Men I was like I see that they have disbanded the previous firm and I know Lane Price is essential in this forming of the second one now I am prepared for the season to begin when will we find out when Dick Whitman and Dom Draper converge. But Black Dubs, I'm just kind of like, please make things go boom and have cool dinners.
21:10I'm really excited for this show to come back. Sam Riley and Dev Campbell are joining the cast for season two. For Slow Horses, season six, some seasons work better than others. This season is based on Joe Country and Moscow Rules, the two McCarran novels.
21:28Andy Greenwald:I find that really interesting that they took two books. They did. there are a finite number of books, right? Unless he's continuing. I think he's going to keep writing them, but I think, I would bet, I think they're already shooting season eight. Seven. I'm going to guess. Season seven. I think they're already shooting eight. Usually by six, usually at the end of a season, they have a trailer for the following season, right? Yeah, because I think their production schedule is such that they're shooting in the summer, so they would have been shooting season seven this summer and wrapping up just as the season six premieres.
22:01Andy Greenwald:Oh, you think six and seven is a block and then they'll do... No, it's not a block. It's just that they shoot in the summers and they premiere in the fall, the following falls to give them enough time. Okay, well... But they're probably writing eight, to your point. I'm going to guess they're going to do 10 seasons. That's incredible. I mean, I guess. I think that there's plenty of material. There's also novellas that they could mess with. I'm very excited for this season. If they did 10 seasons in 10 years, they should get the I Love Lucy Legacy Award at the Creative Artemis. Well, I think they can do it for as long as Oldman wants to do it.
22:32For sure. I think it's a staple of Apple's programming at this point. And it's like the thing that they have that people... I couldn't tell. I was looking at Twitter a week ago or something and it was just a tremendous amount of Slow Horses tweets that felt in the Elaine Brown clipping zone
22:49Andy Greenwald:of accounts I'd never heard of being the way she looks at him and it's like, you know, like Catherine Standish looking at Roddy, you know. But I am very excited for season six. That's September 17th, I believe. Also, this season has the return of - 16th. Of, what's her name? Olivia Cooke. Yes. Right? Now, I feel like, again, speaking about being accountable, I appreciate this. I think you let me off the hook for this, maybe, which was generous because I think you have read some of the novels. I have not read any of McHeron's novels and I really really remember again there have been so many seasons since but I really feel like I staked some ground on this podcast being like well she'll be back but like I thought did you?
23:34Andy Greenwald:yes I felt pretty strongly that it was misdirect this was me like I know how the show works three episodes in I was glad that in the long arc of history I was right Kingstown situation she was also not Kyle Chandler at that point this is before House of the Dragon And then she went to do House of the Dragon. So maybe she was unavailable. I don't know what the character is like in the books. But I thought it was cool that they, it's just an impressive thing in that you can really, you can do it if you come back every three years, but it feels more exciting when you have a show that is relentlessly pushing forward, but continues to carry its own history with it.
24:10Andy Greenwald:I think that's, I think it's exciting. Yeah, me too. Lowdown season two, I can't possibly explain how excited I am. Name new cast members. Tommy Lee Jones and Betty Gilpin. Emmy award winner, Betty Gilpin. Yes, Tommy Lee Jones, I believe is playing Lee's father. And Betty Gilpin, I believe is the owner of the Alt Weekly that he writes for, but I'm not sure. In any case, this seems like the kind of show that will, if it was already like fully taken flight in the first season, it's going to be like already up and running. Like this is a show screaming out for, you already know and love these people.
24:47Here's a new case and here are a couple of new characters.
24:49Andy Greenwald:For people who are listening to us talk about this, who haven't watched the first season yet, stop the podcast and watch the first season. But one of the things that I think we got away from in praising its development and delivery of the season one plot was that one of the most remarkable aspects of it was that it launched with a complete galaxy of lived in locations and characters. that one of my favorite memories of the show is the early season interactions between Ethan Hawke's character and a character played by Macon Blair who's a director who also he directed that movie that was called Shitheads and is now called Idiots that just came out and that character or the other people on his street what's that kid's name Josh Fadim Fadim I said his name wrong sorry the neighbors the record store who owns the record store like they don't quote unquote matter to the plot, but it is so rare to have a show that arrives with a fully lived-in world to enjoy.
Read the full transcript
25:49Andy Greenwald:And I think, I'm just so glad for many reasons that it was going to continue. But for a show that could move forward but also spread out, it's just a, it's speaking to the theme of having something recurring. Those are the top three. Those are strong top three. I think it's going to be a great fall. Now I have a bunch of new stuff. And I think you're going to be kind of like, oh damn. So number one, I can't say that I am super familiar with Mackenzie Crook's work since The Office and I guess Pirates of the Caribbean. He played Gareth on the UK office. He has also become a show creator over in England.
26:23He made a show called The Detectorists that I never saw and now has a show that I think I've received at least a dozen emails about over the course of the year when it was airing in England about how we needed to find this show, how we needed to talk about it, how we were going to love it. It's called Small Profits.
26:40Andy Greenwald:Alright. P-R-O-P-H-E-T-S Profits. Oh. And it is six episodes. It's coming to Apple on October 7th. And it stars Pierce Quigley, who is also in The Detectorists, who is still distraught. He plays a man named Michael, who is still distraught seven years after the disappearance of his girlfriend. So like any of us would, this is the logline, he turns to alchemy, specifically the creation of magical spirits who can predict the future co-stars in the Manchester set series as does Michael Palin and several other folks Paul Kay, Sophie Willen I don't know anything about it the trailer seems delightful, weird and cozy and how is it coming to us?
27:28via Apple television that's why I was like Apple thought enough of this to put some coin up for it that sounds great yeah so I was like this is cool maybe a new voice for us to cover the next one that I have here after Small Prophets is Tiptoe which is a new show from Russell Davies who made Years and Years oh I know about this and It's a Sin this is Alan Cumming David Morrissey
27:56Andy Greenwald:as neighbors right as feuding neighbors sign me up but is it set particularly during any sort of troubles Not to my knowledge. Troubles as in... I don't mean the Troubles, but I mean more like UK. I didn't get any deep detail about that, but Alan Cumming and David Morrissey play Feuding Neighbors. It's five episodes. It's on Starz. You know I love Alan personally and professionally. I also know about the show because they were doing press together for it. And I think I saw it through Alan's Instagram. And it's just absolutely delightful because they've known each other for 30 years. And they were talking about like...
28:31Andy Greenwald:And they were so cozy and friendly. and I think they play vicious antagonists in this, but it was very sweet to hear them talk about how they had that level of trust. They could do that because they know that they love each other. It was nice. It doesn't seem to be existing in any kind of historical moment other than, I think, according to Wikipedia, anti-LGBTQ rhetoric on social media leads the neighbors to become enemies. So it could be any time. But I think... It could be any way. It's timeless, sadly. timeless content um russell davies i mean he's been on the pod we had a great talk with him about um about it's a sin yeah um also famous for doctor who and bringing it back but and queer as folk and i mean incredible career but also such an interesting creator um because he just does his own thing and seems to have what appears to be i'm sure he would dispute this but from our perspective like like a tenure track position with british television live in like the coolest house in Wales that just like oversees a lock and he writes?
29:36Andy Greenwald:In my impression, that's most houses in Wales, but it probably is the nicest one. But yeah, he just writes it all himself. But it is like, it's the type of career that we don't really seem to be able to support in America. I mean, maybe David Simon and Pelicanos were the closest and they're like, we do what we do and we do it for HBO when we're ready to do it. But his curiosity is, not curiosity, but his the range of what he likes to write about is wider, certainly, but always worth checking out. um the next show i wanted to mention is youth which is the new show from oh so by the way tiptoe comes out october 2nd okay uh and five episodes the next show i wanted to talk about after that is youth which is the new show from sharon horgan we didn't talk about the trailer good trailer good trailer and this is um sharon horgan is essentially uh aside from bad sisters which was clearly like a kind of like um like black comedy mystery thriller she's kind of made a a career out of chronicling different phases and stages of her life from motherland which i i adore so deeply uh catastrophe with rob delaney great um and now youth which is about love and sex and death in your 50s and couldn't be us dog look good starts on on september 20th eight episodes the first two go up it's on hbo and it looked awesome every episode written by sharon um also did you see how deep the cast list goes.
31:01Andy Greenwald:Maybe you saw in the trailer. I didn't. First of all, great to see Rupert Friend. But among the guest stars, recurring stars, are the great Harriet Walter who played the kid's mother on Succession. Mm-hmm. And our number one draft pick, Freddie Fox. Stays working. Can't lose. The one after that, this is really interesting. I guess this is her first HBO series since Divorce, right? Which we didn't really engage with. We did not really engage with that. In fact, I don't even remember who she was getting divorced from. Thomas Hayden Church. Really? Who is now on tires. He sure is on tires. Did I tell you that?
31:33Andy Greenwald:I don't think I told you this, but I love to do the Thomas Friedman style of research, like just boots on the ground, like Man of the People. On my recent flight to Seattle, I would say I had visual... In my field of vision, I could see four other people's screens, and three of them were watching Tires Season 3. Was one of them Kaya? Has Kaya been watching? I have. You convert Kaya? Yeah. You, Andy, converted me. She knew I was already... You're hopeless, but it was my... I'm the swing voter. Wow, that's nice, Gaia. Thank you. I need your help on this one. For one thing, something's going on cosmically.
32:11I'm opening my heart to animation. What? Well, first of all, Blue-Eyed Samurai is coming back imminently.
32:17Andy Greenwald:You like that more than I did, too, right? But I... Another one grabbed my eye. Another animated show grabbed my eye. Get Jiro? Oh, Get Jiro. Jiro? Is it just the J is hard? The J is hard in Japan. You were thinking more of a Greek or even a Spanish. Sure. Animated, anime style. That's Tony Bourdain's graphic novel. Based on Anthony Bourdain's graphic novel about a dystopian future where chefs are super celebrities. Among the voice talent, Titus Welliver and Justin Kirk. Starts October 3rd. On what channel? Adult Swim slash HBO. And it looked really cool. Did you read this graphic novel? I think there was more than one volume, I think.
32:59I read the first one.
33:00Andy Greenwald:Yeah. I mean, it did combine a lot of my interests. The Age of Apocalypse. The Age of Battleworld. Sushi. Pretty much me for a period of my life. Here's the last batch. Okay. Now, when you say the last batch, they are lower on the list because you think they will be less appealing to me or they're more wild cards? As we get, the lower we get, the more I'm like, this could go one of two ways. And are you including like East of Eden in this or because we already talked about that? I didn't include East of Eden. I mean, like, I think it looks lovely, but I didn't know if you were going to be like, stop the presses East of Eden's on.
33:32Andy Greenwald:What about the new Pride and Prejudice? No. I didn't have that on here. No thoughts for that? I guess I don't really know you. It's fine. It's fine. It hurts. I was like, does this new Pride and Prejudice, is this Emma Corrin is in this one? It's Emma Corrin and Jack Loudon. And Dolly Alderton wrote it. Okay. And Olivia Colman plays Mom. And when's that coming out? Soon. First week of October, I think. Not on Netflix. Well, you can remove either Vision Quest from your list. No, no. Keep talking. Vision Quest is just weird. Honestly, it could be the last MCU show. I'm not even sure. I have it down here because you and I care so deeply about what happened in Sokovia.
34:12Some have forgotten. See James Spader come back as Ultron or in some capacity.
34:18Andy Greenwald:Isn't he just coming back as James Spader in a soundstage living inside of Paul Bettany's mind? I believe he is himself. Like, I don't think he is voicing a very expensive drawing of a killer robot. Wait, what do you mean he's coming back as himself? Have you not seen the pictures of the show? They've released them, maybe only to select press. There's a picture of James Spader just being blacklist James Spader. Google James Spader Vision Quest. Can we get the camera on Chris's screen or is that illegal? I think this should be part of it. My understanding of the series is that because Vision has been through some tough times post-Sokovia, this is kind of like a Herman's Head type series.
34:54Ultron in human form in Vision Quest. I thought that's why you brought this up.
35:00Andy Greenwald:It's like a Herman's Head for robots. And inside of his head, ever since they defeated him, I guess James Spader has been living in his head, which does sound provocative. Well, it's Ultron in human form. I don't know if James Spader looks like that all the time. Looks like what? Well, he's got a giant beard. He looks like he's in Mastodon. I'm going to say something. I'm going to, you know, I like to play it close to the vest. I like to play it safe. My guess is that Ultron in human form looks like whatever James Spader looked like the day they got him to set. And they're like, okay, I guess we're doing this.
35:34So I'm curious about this. I'm also curious about where this leaves Marvel television.
35:41Andy Greenwald:Here's why I want to go super hard at Vision Quest. How many episodes is it? 105. Truly. I just wrote down Vision Quest bullet point, finally. That's me. here's how I think we should handle Vision Quest I'm gonna propose something to you I think we should take Kevin Feige at his word with this because my understanding when it was introduced at the D20 eight episodes streams weekly what's it called D23 or something I feel like he I feel like someone said Vision Quest is essential viewing for Doomsday so I think we need to cover this show like it's the second season of The Sopranos I think we need to devote more airtime and more brainpower to the show than anything else on our slot.
36:30Andy Greenwald:Okay. Do you know what I mean? Yeah. Like, rigorously cover this text. I don't even want this clipped for social. I want it clipped for personal use so that when you're like, episode two of Vision Quest, I'm out. I won't be out. I won't be out. You're more likely to be out than me. Yeah. This is a character whose charms have escaped me. How many episodes of Secret Invasion did you watch? I think most of it. Okay. How many episodes? Because I kept waiting for it to be like the parallax view and it wasn't. Yeah. In retrospect, like, how do we feel about, now that we know more of this. That the Russos lie to us.
37:09Andy Greenwald:Constantly. Chronically. But also just that like, you know, more of the backstory of like how challenging these things were to make and then also how little they paid off in terms of their larger story architecture. What are your feelings this many years on of Captain America and the Winter Soldier. No, it wasn't Winter Soldier. It was Falcon and Winter Soldier. Well, I mean, I think it would be a very challenging endeavor, but one could re-watch all of Marvel's TV efforts to see if there's any hidden gems, if there are any things that we judged too harshly, if, in fact, the things that were good were not actually as good as we thought they were in the moment.
37:50You and I have been pretty much off the sauce since WandaVision.
37:55Andy Greenwald:WandaVision was the first one. No, but I mean, I don't think we've like heralded... Yeah, Loki. Loki ruled. Loki was really good. Oh, yeah, that's right. You were crazy about Loki. Crazy about Loki. S1. S2, do you... What was your relationship to S2? Nah. Nah. Miss me with that. I mean, look, who doesn't love a protagonist slowly becoming an all-seeing story tree at the center of the multiverse? Like, that does appeal to me. But I just have... I do have some fond memories. I don't know why I have this nostalgia. It's kind of COVID-y. But like watching Falcon and Winter Soldier and then seeing all the lines that were ADR'd off characters' backs while they were changing the plot in real time.
38:30Andy Greenwald:Yeah. I mean, like they were... It's wild. They were weaving it in midair. It was something else. It was beautiful. And, you know, Wyatt Russell's John Walker... I enjoyed John Walker. ...was important. Yeah. I'm going to read you for the last two here. I'm going to read you a log line and then you tell me if you're interested in this. Okay, hold on. Let me... All right. Set in 1977. I mean, just like us. An Indianapolis man named Tony Caritsis takes a man hostage and phones a local radio reporter and demands to be interviewed on the air. The man who takes the hostage, the hostage taker, is played by Giovanni Ribisi.
39:09The radio reporter is Jon Hamm. The television show is American Hostage, which is Sean Ryan and Eileen Myers, who did The Night Agent, and Sean Ryan did The Shield. it's their effort at creating a like a Ryan Murphy anthology style
39:27Andy Greenwald:there could be a different American hostage every week every week every season every season this is an anthology show is this an original hostage taking or is it historical historical it's a true story also stars Muriel Enos and William Jackson Harper it's on MGM plus don't even know if you have that and it starts September 20th with a two episode premiere just based on this cast yeah good cast the ribese handpiece ribese doesn't doesn't get out of bed for just anything these days yeah and you've always been a big giovanni guy well you see him around and he's always got a cool camera do you see him around he's around he's in around in these streets he's outside and i just love his his dedication to to keeping like old cameras up and working like i think he works on like a bunch of like imax cameras and vista vision cameras this is a whole la i don't know about yeah and he shot strange darling that that horror thriller from a couple years ago he was a dp have you invited him on the podcast no i think he went on big pick for strange darling with jt mollner but this seems cool is is ham's part i mean i haven't seen a trailer you're hitting me with this cole i didn't even know about the show there has been a trailer but he plays a 1970s radio reporter local radio reporter does he leave the radio station or did he shoot out his whole season in like a week in a room because that would be that would be very economical for the series going forward yes if the person the hostage taker calls can just can just wrap out in a couple days garradilla hunt i'm nude in my house for the entire season of lanterns uh i think this looks cool and then this other one i just can't believe i'm like reading this actual log line uh this is called kill jackie and it's on amc okay our our dearly beloved AMC.
41:11Still waiting for that call to run it. The show stars Catherine Zeta Jones.
41:17Andy Greenwald:Okay. It's about a one-time drug smuggler, now art dealer, who gets targeted by a group of assassins, and then she turns the tables by going after the assassins. What? It feels kind of late 90s. It's based on a Nick Harkaway novel, who is John LeCarre's son. Yeah. And it co-stars Daniel Ings. What? This has to be a co-pro. Looks very late 90s, early ought kind of tongue-in-cheek comic thriller okay i'm sure you're right it is a co-pro it comes out october 2nd and it looks okay it looks cool so kill jackie daniel ings it says it's amazon prime this says amc are the maybe the walls are collapsing interesting okay well amc plus AMC plus Amazon oh it's a prime video original outside of the United States that's what you're thinking of I see sorry okay well there's a lot of and it's Freemancel which is an international company but interesting yeah I mean I think two things one of the things that you mentioned as a wild card will take flight and we'll be super into it but I also think we should in the modern parlance hold space for an 11th show that we don't know about that will Furious or the Gold Us.
42:38Andy Greenwald:I have it. You have it already? I already have it. God, you're good at this. High value target colon The Hunt for Saddam Hussein starring Joel Kinnaman. Eight episodes on TNT. We're fucking back. We're fucking back on TNT. Get inside the NBA out of my face and let Kinnaman hunt Saddam. Was he successful? Yeah. He was, obviously. Eventually. Yeah. How long was his hunt? Eight episodes. I would say, again, And I'm not a close scholar of the Middle East. This starts next week, by the way. I'm ready. I don't think... Or this week. Oh, they're waiting. We always like to get involved in Iraq. It's September 13th.
43:16Andy Greenwald:We like to get involved in Iraq right after September 11th. So that's perfect. Very respectful. I, in my, you know, again, my memory might be faulty. I'm not a scholar of the region. But I believe that between the years of like 1970 and his end, Saddam Hussein was in these streets and bunkers. But like he wasn't really hiding. you know he was like i'm running things you know so what was joel's like he apparently is the guy who's like he's a saddam expert and he briefs bush about it like i think he's going back and forth a real hero he's like mr president as i was saying on september 10th hunt for this guy i'm interested in a version of this story yeah you're all ashamed now no i'm not you're a bit have bashed you were a little too eager do you want to talk about lanterns episode four yeah i do i do i'll tell a funny story to start us off here i was hoping you would i think this is going to be good for us people make mistakes i'm not too big to admit it and when we you know we have a couple of screeners for lanterns although i believe i think we're i think this we're cut off cut off dude uh i accidentally watched four ahead of three and i thought it was good because four starts at the end of two yeah this makes sense this makes sense and there were a couple of things that threw me off one i was like you guys are treating laura linney's arrival incredibly pretty chill about this yeah i was like that's laura linney and i didn't meet her yet and yet it seems like i'm supposed to know who she is and what she's doing here were you leaning in at that point or did you feel like it was a little bit aggressive to introduce a guardian as laura linney in a motel room?
44:58I thought it was surprising.
45:00Andy Greenwald:Okay. I also thought it was surprising when Sunday's episode aired this past Sunday's or the Sunday, the third episode aired actually. Oh, yeah. People were like, holy shit. What a portrait of an American family. And I was like, what? Which family? The family that paints each other new. And then it was like, you know, Jasmine Cephas Jones is so incredible as John's mom. And I was like, was she in that episode? On the phone? Yeah, like when she just was like, John is that you? So I was like was there like a stinger? Post credit scene? I went and looked nope because it wasn't up and I had miswatched them.
45:39It did though in a strange way speak to this sort of like unique way that they're kind of setting up this early part of the season to go flashback episode three to go standalone episode almost that's kind of from one perspective is kind of a fascinating choice and And look, I thought that there were parts of this episode that sang. And I thought that the twists are interesting. I'd like to talk to you about some of the detective work. But tell me what you thought about episode four.
46:10Andy Greenwald:Well, first of all, I did watch it thinking of your mishap. Yeah. And I thought that was very interesting for the reasons you just said, which is if you expected the show to kind of be basic paint by the numbers, this does pick up exactly where the other one left. Yeah. I, well, since I was going into this episode with that in mind, I was even more grateful for the, for the, the breadth of three to add more context to it, to get us out of Rushville, to, to, to make a larger world than this in one investigation. I think that the my sense is my confidence is high that when the season is done whether we come out loving it liking it respecting it that the scaffolding of how they built a very complicated machine is going to be impressive yes and I think that the flashback episode where it fell was really clever and really good and as you said not playing with it's always the relief pitcher metaphor but playing with delivery and velocity is one of the more powerful tools than the showrunner arsenal so I thought that was really well done the density of information in this episode i think is pretty high uh both in terms of this opening sinestro sequence yes um which which i thought was excellent but was rather long you know like it's a it's a it's a pretty if you're if you're like a casual fan and don't know much about the green lanterns in general and who the fuck sinestro is um it's it's a pretty like heady scene to watch can you give me any context to i know you're a dc guy i think i'm on the other side of it i love those scenes and i love their um they're almost like austerity like i think the reference that i would imagine was in the room was um uh a different manhunter the michael man manhunter or any hannibal lecter movie yeah um that that's how they were going to frame it and And that, you know, as the other characters talk about Sinestro and Hal and that relationship, I think the subtlety of not just his red skin tone and his little slight alien ears, but you understand that this is a father figure and a friend who he loves but can no longer trust.
48:24Andy Greenwald:And like, that's enough. I think deeper hardcore Green Lantern Corps heads know that Sinestro's betrayal involves the color yellow which is the color of fear and letting fear into your heart and how that defeats green which is all about bravery and fearlessness and I think they're doing a relatively smart job of keeping that up here you know like in the sort of intellectual sense of like we understand that it is both heroic but also deeply fucked up to be like, I'm not afraid of anything. Sure. And that what happens when you let the fear in and where it, where, where it leads you. So I thought that, I thought that was really artful.
49:02Andy Greenwald:I thought also in the spirit of, um, the Colonel in Boogie Nights, who I know was a hero of yours, both on screen and off. Sure. You know, he's a man who knows what he likes. Let's put it that way. Right. Sinestro is or the Colonel? No, the Colonel is. Okay. Um, and you know, to that point, like, I love a what the fuck Lindelofian set piece so Zoe's satellite death no oh the fucking slaughterhouse oh yeah that was very very Lindelofian there's this thing we've been talking about it and again because we know him like I think we're we're doing a forensic read of it that maybe is maybe more we assume more yeah I mean even last week we were ascribing a lot of like Damon writerly like sort of themes in Damon Lindelof's past work that may have been Vanessa B.
49:52and Kelly or Chris Mundy or Tom King or whatever.
49:55Andy Greenwald:Yeah, I don't want to miss, I don't want to like to apportion the credit incorrectly. But again, I do think that there is a step that is a hallmark of Damon's shows and rooms that has filtered into other rooms successfully, which is you reach a point in the breaking of the episode where they're going to go detective. They're going to go after the satellite. If you think about it purely like A to B to C. and then I just have this belief that there's a moment a pause and maybe the pause is a day or maybe it's three weeks where no bad ideas in a brainstorm like what is the most visually what the fuck we could do here to earn more of what we want this show to be and a high tech slaughterhouse where everyone's ignoring them and then a cow comes through a lynchian hell mouth into a white room and then is gorely and bloodily vivisected for a pile of steaks.
50:48Pretty good. Is that like portal that the cow walks through the same thing that John goes through to get to his interview?
50:57Andy Greenwald:Possibly. I mean, it's similar. And so, you know, if you're watching the show on a different level, you could be like, oh, does that mean that the Manhunter's technology also led John? His Guardian technology. Yeah, or that, yes, or that John is being set up or something. Sure. There's a deeper, another card to turn. Cool. But also in that moment, it was like Lynch directing what was the first George Lucas movie? That THX? Yes, THX 138. That one? Like some weird visual crossover of that language and ending in the room with a guy who is not an alien. Like I just really, really - That sequence is awesome.
51:30Andy Greenwald:I just vibrate to that. Like I just think it's so - When they do that in a show that has so many mechanisms like spinning, it just feels like a moment where you can throw your hands up like you're on a roller coaster and enjoy it. So for that alone, I really, really liked the episode. But I have other things to say. No, but please, you next. No, we don't have to go trade back and forth. I'd love to know, what did you think of the Zoe stuff? My concern when you ask me stuff back to back to back is that I think there are people who single channel our podcast and only listen to you. And I'm worried then it's just going to be silence.
52:06I remember when we used to do Zoom recordings back in COVID.
52:10Andy Greenwald:Yeah, and we would record our own audio and send it in. I don't talk that much. did someone else or did um was it because you were more you're more worried about like aerosols more reflective back then you know uh i wanted to ask about the zoe stuff because what do you think yeah i thought the porn of jaganathan scene her her scene with with aaron pierre and the motel room was very good okay i liked it a lot i like this idea of um if you take it at face value that everything is all the little blinking lights are pointing to her as the Manhunter. Yes. That the you know sentinel of destruction could also come in the shape of a great healer and a great you know it would be like why should we revolt against the Manhunter?
53:03He's like cured cancer. She's cured cancer. Nobody's sick here. His body looks amazing. Yeah my body I'm cut you know great. He probably
53:12Andy Greenwald:does a lot of protein and weight training. I suppose this is a question about whether or not, the thing I wanted to ask is whether or not this is, do you feel like this is a lot of work to come up with a red herring? Well, because it seems like everybody is just like, obviously. It's her now. But what's weird is that the red herring was everything else up to this point. And we have reached the halfway point of the season. I think that so far, and we'll see how it plays out. So this is not me predicting a reaction to it, but I will say that the Zoe thread has probably to me been the least successful part of the series.
53:49Andy Greenwald:Nothing to do with the performer, but the relationship between her and John doesn't make any sense to me other than it's what people wanted them to do, writers needed them to do, so that when she says this is the last time, I'm like, why? I don't understand why it was the first time. I don't really understand why they are attracted to each other, why someone who is so buttoned up would be relatively reckless in this case. And maybe, you know, with a brain trust like this, my questions are the questions, maybe these are the questions we're meant to be asking. But everything was so signposted for it to be her, including the way the camera lingered on the bracelet that she left for whatever reason before she got...
54:34Andy Greenwald:Vaporized. Potentially vaporized. So... So, and then if you're stacking red herrings, them going to chase this guy Hammond and then meeting a guy and then being told it's someone else only for them both to say to each other, we both know who it is though really, right? Right. And then my next question is, is this the most interesting thing Jon Stewart's ever done in his pre-programmed life, which is have sex not once but twice with a pansexual intergalactic and when did he know? And to what extent is it part of or in a kind of continuum of behavior and cause and effect that Hal interrupting his assassination attempt, getting him dishonorably discharged.
55:20Oh, right. Sending him in this path
55:22Andy Greenwald:to where he's going to become like an architect, but then becomes... Who's pulling all these strings? Yeah, who's pulling the strings? And, you know, the culpability of his parents. I'm like, is this a guy rebelling? Is this a guy doing deep undercover detective work? Like, what are we seeing here? And I think that the third episode gives the fourth episode so much more color when it comes to Hal jumping out of the car in the last moment and allowing John to crash into a light pole. You think he'll be okay? I do think he'll be okay, but I just think it's like, for most of this episode, these guys are actually seemingly getting along.
56:00Like, I mean, they're at least going along with each other.
56:02Andy Greenwald:Yeah. Now there's like the whole like just take the ring and say the oath and you know that stuff. But I think it was like a handy good middle season detective episode that had some really good human moments. And it had some really good meta human moments like the idea of them being cornered by thugs with guns that shoot darkness. That is a pure comic book idea. Yeah. And I loved it. I loved seeing it. I wondered though the other feeling I had to this episode was that it was funnier and funnier in the sense of like it was they made it they made a point of underlining it buddy cop stuff yeah he's like did you just make a joke because John does make a joke at one point and then there's a moment where they both say set it off as a good movie you know and there's the whole line about you know superheroes don't really lock the door and jazz this can't be good and it's a lot more buddy cop and I enjoyed that this is a weird thing where like I'm not complaining about how clever the script was or how much more enjoyable it is for Aaron Pierre and Kyle Chandler to be playing off of each other as opposed to playing like almost on top of one another but the subsequent feeling that you didn't have because you watched them out of order was that there was an element of we got the serious stuff out of the way now we can be goofy again yeah I mean it almost felt like a season two episode you know what I mean at times where you'd be like now these two guys are investigating like a crime and this is their patter but you know you can trust that they love each other It's also the nature of a show that wants to tackle real world issues where I think they were correct to more soberly state the facts in terms of John's role as a black man on Earth and also intergalactically in his relationship to his family.
57:41Andy Greenwald:That wouldn't necessarily have been the time for a lot of, you know, wink, wink jokes. But the fact that like it went so if the switch flipped so dramatically from one episode to the next, you just felt the difference. yeah I thought that like we were asked to kind of consider the idea at the end of the second episode that John can manifest lantern like powers independent of the ring right or he can continue to continue to right that he is more special than he may even know right like that it's not just he's been training his whole life to do this but he may have some innate gifts that other beings in the galaxy have taken note of and then in the third episode we just go back to his kind of not we just it was an extraordinary like effort to go back and kind of establish why this character is behaving the way he is why how jordan might be behaving the way he is and what context brought these two people together i don't know that i came out of the fourth episode and was like and then this is what we learned coming out of the fourth episode about any of these people but that doesn't necessarily need to happen every episode no i i and i continue to feel like i would rather have the more humorous human Jon Stewart when we can because I continue to feel that like the construction of his backstory is really thought-provoking and interesting and resulted in an excellent episode but I don't believe him as a human because of it.
59:01Andy Greenwald:Sure. I don't believe him. I mean maybe Joel Kinnaman could do it if he was hunting Saddam Hussein but nine months in the bush you know with one target. It's wild. It is wild. No wonder he jumps into bed with the first step-grandmother that he can find. Do you have any other notes you wanted to share before we get into After Dark? No, I guess I just feel, where are you with this show halfway through? Do you feel enthusiastic and engaged and eager to see where it goes? Yeah, on a visceral level, I look forward to watching it every week and I'm never bored while I'm watching it. And that increasingly is becoming something I'm very sensitive to.
59:38Like just the, do I feel my mind wander? Am I locked in? Do I find the performances is charismatic and engaging yes yes yes yes yes so even when i'm like that scene was wonky or it seemed like that was like gifted to this this revelation was gifted to them in the or in the to expedite expedite like the plot i instead of like hard work figuring out who the the manhunter is i uh i just i just i i really enjoy it but i do note some differences or some basically some flaws here and there. What about you?
1:00:16Andy Greenwald:Yeah, I'm loving watching it. I think Never Bored is a very high praise these days to give. I just like the way it handles these ideas. I like the way that this sounds pretty basic, but I like the way Hal Jordan flies. I like the thought that was given to that and what it feels like when he says point in the sky and he's gone. I really like the Sinestro stuff. I like a show that can give us an interesting Sinestro and an interesting Sheriff of Kelly MacDonald in the same episode, that it's not over-weighting one versus the other. But actually, the thought I had when I was finishing the fourth episode was I do have some regret for not sticking with Penguin.
1:00:50Andy Greenwald:Not because I feel like I missed out on Oz Cobblepot's rise to power, but more specifically, people genuinely loved that show or really, really liked that show, let's say, right? And after one episode, I think you and I were like, this is very, very well done. And this might be the best version of this, best case, but because it is essentially using the trappings of a crime show, but instead of filling it, the space created by originality with what something like Furious did, it filled it with DC and Matt Reeves lore. I was okay stepping back. The reason I was thinking of it was, is there a natural cap on these things that no matter what good intention you're putting into it and how much thought you're putting into an episode like three, you are setting up James Gunn's Man of Tomorrow.
1:01:39Andy Greenwald:You are dealing with the precepts of the DCU or the character's history and whatever. And can you overcome them? It's an interesting point. And also, it's not a bad business model for audiences or for KC at HBO to be like, I'm going to spend money and attract talent and make the best series of B-pluses we can. This is also a hit. I'm not trying to damn it with faint praise. I guess I'm just wondering, can it... There have been moments that have transcended and moments and not every show needs to i think the dc shows are working generally i mean i i'm not addicted to them like you know i watched a bit probably more than you of penguin yeah and then i think i finished it as well did you did you watch more people in peacemaker i i it's fine it's fun maker is fun yeah um i don't think peacemaker is like the best show i've ever seen but I definitely like enjoyed what I've watched of it and then it seems like that Scholar Gazzando show the Jimmy Olsen show like that's a really good idea for a TV show to have the American Vandal guys make a true crime documentary with Jimmy Olsen like that's just like let's take chances with the TV stuff rather than sort of staly going through six episodes only to have a post credit stinger that somehow links to an Avengers show Isn't that crazy though?
1:03:01Andy Greenwald:Like, I know this is incredibly obvious, but I just hadn't been grouping them together in the same way that we group the MCU TV shows. Like when you said DC's working on TV, I just was thinking about our jokes about Falcon and Winter Soldier and Vision Quest. Like, oh my God, yes, they're working. It is entirely successful, especially compared to what Marvel became and what they were trying to do and what they didn't even try to do. So by that metric, incredible. I don't know if it's, all gun. I don't think Penguin is in the gun verse. It's more like the Matt Reeves side of things. Right. And for now, I think predates gun a little bit.
1:03:40Andy Greenwald:It does. I still wonder if like the effort of introducing another Batman when you have Robert Pattinson, who's just like, okay, maybe. Well, if they make one of those, like every five years, I don't, it's going to be six years. I think it looks cool. Well, that's all that matters to us. Um, all right. Lioness. Yeah. I got to ask you. Okay. Can I set this up for you? Sure. There were rumblings and disturbances in the force because generally the ambient feedback I get about Linus is that it's all go, brother. Everybody's having a great time. All go, like the audience or the people on the carrot?
1:04:18Andy Greenwald:Yeah, yeah. And recently, I've picked up on a sense that there have been some bumps. Yes. That people are not as gung-ho about some things that maybe the season has taken a turn. And when we last checked in, on Joe and her team of bathtub enthusiasts and killers. I had no notes. You had no notes. You were thrilled. Since then, and I talked about it with Van, and we were equally like kind of delighted by the messiness of basically doing two seasons of this show in one, where one is they tried to kill Joe and they missed and then Joe gets her revenge. And then there's also another season where they've kidnapped Joe and are trying to get her out of the country and her lioness team is looking for her.
1:05:02Andy Greenwald:And those are both happening concurrently this season? They are. And they are like... In two timelines? In two timelines. And I would not say evenly distributed and not always clearly demarcated. So in this episode that just happened on Sunday, there's basically a turn mid-episode where they bring back our Ukrainian-Russian double agent who's living happily in Tulsa under the name Paige Weaver, where she shops for one and has a very Airbnb-ed out, furnished house in Tulsa, but she has one avocado. One Ukrainian lady who wants to hang out at night. I feel like one avocado would be pretty fucking exciting in Kiev.
1:05:43Andy Greenwald:You know what I mean? No, that's the breadbasket of Europe, isn't it? Ukraine? Right now? I mean, generally speaking. Read the news, brother. I know democracy is dead. It's funny you should say that. But I, for some reason, got served a video of people shopping at a grocery store in Kiev. And they were like, don't let them fool you. We still got groceries. They all had six fingers. I don't know why I got served that. Actually, I do. I know. Because you talk about lioness. And by the way, I am not, just to be clear, before I get aggregated by like pro-Putin forces here, I have no opinion or knowledge of the state of Ukraine's groceries.
1:06:19Andy Greenwald:Yeah. It was more that from my experience, all of Europe is avocado mad and they mostly grow them, I believe, in Spain and Portugal and maybe in North Africa. Okay. Okay? Yes. Kaya, okay. Over the last two weeks, I would say this season has made a decision, a turn. And that turn is this. the cia is conducting a domestic purge of our government higher education and news media to rid them of you know i guess russian double agents but kind of not so veiled like communists like it is a weird like red scare thing where they're like it turns out like all these people through NGOs and political action committees are getting paid by Russia to indoctrinate our youth and our masses with like woke nonsense.
1:07:16Andy Greenwald:Brother, that's Senator Tommy Tuberville's campaign literature. I know, I got a show for Tom. If he's not already watching. And look, I think my tolerance level for stuff like that is pretty high. It is. I can't believe that you're blinking on this. there's been a repeated trope on this show this last two weeks where Joe's heart surgeon thoracic surgeon husband I love him Dave Annabelle is in this safe house on an army base where they've been living since the kidnapping attempt and he does nothing but watch the news uh oh and he's just like honey is this what you were talking about like with like these these professors who are peddling anti-American invective and she's just like, no, this is only the story that the news wants you to hear.
1:08:10And it is like we've gotten into like episode 400 of the Lioness podcast that I'm like, all right, guys, it's not as funny as it used to be. That's amazing.
1:08:22Andy Greenwald:It's amazing. And somewhere I just feel like JD Vance doing the Palpatine meme where he's just like, yes, yes. They keep... kidnapping people and then really delighting and informing them that they will not be mirandized like being like where i'm sending you in gitmo i'm like we're doing gitmo still he's like you're gonna be like listening to metallica with no roof for like five years and then i'm gonna come back and ask you again what i just asked you and see if you have like a better attitude about it i honestly that sounds like a kid i knew in high school like that is how he his name Miranda no that's how he spent high school and the teacher will be like I'm gonna come back and ask you again about fucking of mice and men yeah but wow so it's tough and this is a big deal for you to bump on some of this stuff we now find out that Joe's been kidnapped by Iranian forces wow so it's a hotbed that's going on and yeah this one this one I felt like this was not my favorite lioness episode just put it that way and I think a lot I think I think a lot of people have joined me in this journey of watching this somewhat very entertaining spycraft show that also has long stretches of political invective yes yeah not a lot of self reflection and so the show is sort of advocating for some sort of large like cultural revolution if you will where we purge the academics yeah in order to achieve not communism not communism that's cool let's do it the other way so yeah can't possibly see the downside yeah p weird but hopefully this lady in Tulsa is going to figure it all out she seemed to have all the roadmaps for how the Russians exfil oh I thought you were saying they black bagged her and sent her to Gitmo no she just went to Tulsa and witnessed protection but then they found her because they were like the Russians are going to kill her so we gotta go find her oh I hope they were like there's only one woman in Tulsa buying fresh produce not eating not smoking indoors not smoking indoors at the bar next to Sterling's house but I continue to be seated I'll finish the project you know Tim Simons recently started watching Lioness so I take my influence seriously what I enjoy most is that our buddy Tim is texting you about his journey with Lioness like 11 p.m at night but I'm on the thread yeah and every so I wake up you haven't answered at all have you I back channel with him no no but like I don't answer because I wake up sort of bleary-eyed and I throw on the glasses and and I look at the text and it's just like a bunch of texts from 1113 that's like jesus no wonder andy doesn't watch this i don't know what more i can add i feel seen yeah um but look man we'll i'll give you the the finale recap and we'll kind of see where we're at thank you you know you're basically doing the like the the the self-reflective dnc deep dive like what went wrong that they buried that's right you're doing the work and they need to hear what you say from your report from the front lines uh we'll be back on Thursday we're going to preview the Emmys.
1:11:22We'll do should win will win that day. And we'll also talk a little bit about the return of the paper on Peacock and NBC. I believe.
1:11:30Andy Greenwald:I believe both this time. Yeah. And thanks to Kaya and John for producing us on Labor Day. Hope everybody had a nice long weekend and we'll see you Thursday. Happy holiday. Brains.
From the publisher
Chris and Andy talk briefly about some of the Creative Arts Emmy Awards that were handed out over the weekend and what they foreshadow for this coming weekend’s Emmy Awards (2:40). Then they preview some of the fall television they’re most excited for, including returning shows like ‘The Lowdown’ and ‘Black Doves’ (14:31) and some new shows like ‘Small Prophets’ and ‘Youth,’ from creator Sharon Horgan (26:04). Then they break down the latest episode of ‘Lanterns’ (44:07) before ‘Lioness’ After Dark (01:03:57).
Hosts: Chris Ryan and Andy Greenwald
Producer: Kaya McMullen
Video Production and Editing: Jon Jones
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
