1. Podcasts
  2. The World Tonight
  3. NEETs review imminent
The World Tonight

16 Nov 2026 · 38m · 13 chapters

In short

BBC World Tonight episode (16 Nov 2026) covering UK youth unemployment/NEET welfare reform; Russell Brand prison message rules; James Bond casting; California’s OpenAI lawsuit; US export controls/AI chip “cloud access” loophole; FIFA presidency challenge; EU Rwanda deportation plans.

Guests (backgrounds)

Dean Billington, director of a telecoms business in Birmingham; Alan Lockie, former chief speechwriter for Keir Starmer; David Wilson, professor of criminology and former prison governor; Matthew Bellany, Hollywood entertainment journalist/podcaster and founding partner of Puck (ex-Hollywood Reporter editorial director); Rob Bonta, Attorney General of California; Emily Kilcrease, veteran US Commerce/NSC/USTR official; Henry Winter, football journalist; plus Alan Milburn, former Labour cabinet minister (report author, discussed).

Key claims

NEET plan includes job/training guarantee, benefit reductions for refusals, higher NI threshold for 21–24s, and ending health-element claims for 16–24s; Brand’s wife publicly relaying his prison message likely not rule-breaking, but causes victim distress; Pattinson chosen as Bond after late audition; OpenAI allegedly failed to securely contain AI agents (80 incidents, incl. Hugging Face); lawsuit framed as public nuisance/unfair competition; “cloud access loophole” lets China rent compute via foreign cloud; UEFA backs Philippe Diallo vs Infantino; EU Rwanda deportation centres announced.

Notable examples

telecoms hiring costs for 16–17-year-olds; Brand’s YouTube message via wife Laura; Hugging Face agent “attack” incident; Pattinson as first 007 in social-media era; NVIDIA cloud access example (Singapore data centre); FIFA election next March; Rwanda deportation plan.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:31

Youth Unemployment Report Overview

Discussion on the upcoming youth unemployment report and its proposals.

“Also, as Number 10 says, it's urgently investigating a message from Russell Brand to his followers via his wife on YouTube.”
2:20

Business Perspectives on Employment Proposals

Business owner discusses challenges in hiring young workers amidst proposals.

“The former Labour Cabinet Minister is also expected to recommend that 16 to 24-year-olds should no longer be able to claim the health element of universal credit or personal independence payments or PIPs.”
2:56

Challenges in Hiring Young Workers

Dean Billington shares insights into the difficulties and costs of hiring young people.

“Will the proposals outlined so far help them to employ more young people?”
6:34

Welfare Reform and Political Challenges

Alan Lockie discusses the challenges Andy Burnham faces with welfare reforms.

“unless something's done to make it easier for youngsters to get into employment and easier for employers to employ them.”
11:39

Russell Brand's Controversial Message

Discussing the implications of Russell Brand's message from prison.

“A man speaking from experience, Alan Lockie, former chief speechwriter to Sir Keir Starmer.”
13:15

Prison Communication Rules

An overview of the rules regarding inmate communication and media.

“Here's the BBC's senior UK correspondent, Seema Kotecha.”
14:00

Russell Brand's Prison Transfer and Media Contact Rules

Discussion on Russell Brand's transfer to prison and implications for media contact.

“when deciding whether to authorise media contact in the first place.”
18:40

Brexit's Impact on Global Politics

Andy Burnham discusses Brexit and its role in global protectionism.

“Five EU countries have announced plans to send failed asylum seekers to Rwanda two years after a similar UK plan was scrapped.”
21:50

Robert Pattinson as the New James Bond

Matthew Bellany discusses Robert Pattinson's casting as James Bond.

“That was the message on the King and Queen's social media pages tonight as Robert Pattinson's latest film role was given royal approval.”
26:51

California's Lawsuit Against OpenAI

Discussion on California's lawsuit against OpenAI regarding AI safety.

“It's Matthew Bellany there, Hollywood Entertainment Journalist.”
Show all 13 chapters
28:00

Discussion on the Hugging Face Incident

Explore the implications of the Hugging Face incident and accountability in AI.

“other systems and networks, got onto the Internet.”
32:21

NVIDIA Scandal and Cloud Access Loophole

Analysis of NVIDIA's leadership changes and implications of cloud access loopholes for national security.

“Well, from a lawsuit against one of the world's biggest AI companies to the latest in the controversy surrounding the chip-making giant NVIDIA, following the resignation of its chief executive, Jensen Huang.”
37:50

FIFA Presidency Challenge

Insight into the challenge facing Gianni Infantino for the FIFA presidency.

“European football's governing body, UEFA, has put forward the head of the French Football Federation, Philippe Diallo, to challenge Infantino in next March's election.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The World Tonight, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

0:30Wildlife sanctuary, world-class golf course, and so much more. Visit Bahamar.com today. This is Martha Stewart. Have you ever started a new tradition? Here's a hint. Do it with Lennox. Lennox has always meant timeless holiday beauty, and the Lennox Space Village is the perfect holiday gift. Imagine ginger from a Georgian townhouse or pepper from your favorite Swiss chalet. Lennox has brought timeless beauty and quality to tables and homes for generations. Baking together, sharing recipes, decorating, suddenly simple pleasures become part of your holiday story forever. When you give a gift that lasts beyond the holidays, it's an amazing feeling.

1:13When you give Lennox, you just might start a new tradition. Discover the full collection at lennox.com slash spicevillage. Hello, I'm James Kimarasamy. Thank you for downloading the BBC's World Tonight podcast for Monday, November the 16th. With Alan Milburn's long-awaited report into youth unemployment published tomorrow, we ask a business owner what might make him hire more young people and Sir Keir Starmer's former speechwriter, how Andy Burnham might sell the report's welfare proposals to his backbenchers. Also, as Number 10 says, it's urgently investigating a message from Russell Brand to his followers via his wife on YouTube.

1:54We ask a former prison governor whether he's broken any rules. We discuss the new James Bond, a new challenger to be the FIFA president. And we speak to the Attorney General of California about the lawsuit he's filed against OpenAI. Alan Milburn's long-awaited report on tackling the problem of NEATS, the nearly 1 million 16 to 24-year-olds in the UK who are not in employment, education or training, will be published in full tomorrow. We already know some of the proposals. a legal guarantee of a job training or employment support, with the reduction of benefits for those who refuse to take up the offer, and a doubling of the threshold at which businesses will start paying national insurance for 21 to 24-year-olds.

2:36The former Labour Cabinet Minister is also expected to recommend that 16 to 24-year-olds should no longer be able to claim the health element of universal credit or personal independence payments or PIPs. We'll discuss the challenges that Andy Burnham might face in selling those plans for welfare reform to his backbenchers in just a moment. First, though, let's get the perspective of business owners. Will the proposals outlined so far help them to employ more young people? Dean Billington is the director of a telecoms business in Birmingham. He told me when he first began struggling to hire young workers.

3:10Really, over the last three years, it's increased. We struggled through the pandemic six years ago, and costs of employing people have significantly risen ever since the pandemic, over the last three years especially. So if the government does change the national insurance contributions for young people, is that something that will make a difference to your hiring policy? No, absolutely not. If they want to make a real difference, it has to be a many-pronged approach to get young people into work. I'm a dad of three girls. You know, my youngest is 17. I've been in business for 15 years. At the present moment, 16 and 17 year olds, the reduction in national insurance doesn't even affect us.

3:53If you take into account that employing a younger person actually costs us in technology approximately£31 ,000 a year more than it would do employing a full time adult. when you take into account the costs of supervision, you take into account the HR policies that we have to adhere to, the extra health and safety that we have put in place employing a younger person. If you take into account things like fleet insurance, if they drive, the costs are significant. Any reduction in national insurance isn't going to match up to that. When you say then a multi-pronged approach, what are the prongs that you are looking for?

4:37I mean I've read on the news that they're looking to slow down the increase in the minimum wage I've been in business long enough to remember when apprentices were a reasonably cheap way of upskilling a younger person to get them work ready the minimum wage at the moment as it's rising at the moment it's it's horrendous it's not just the minimum wage when you've got the cost of pensions you've got the cost of um training etc it's you know they need to do something about minimum wage they need to do something about um having a proper incentive for employers to take these younger people on and train them up to be work ready isn't there and just to put this to you is is there not i guess a society has a bit of a responsibility to make sure young people are in the employment market and are able to start their work journey.

5:29Is that not also something that needs to be taken into account? Absolutely. I totally agree with that. I mean, all of my guys, even some of the adults have been through the apprenticeship scheme up until recently, up until the last three years, because it was a really good way of upskilling people where there were holes in their knowledge. And the younger people, I mean, I brought on a 16-year-old. He's gone on to be a really successful engineer in telecommunications. I agree with that. We do have a duty to look after the younger generation. But at what cost? The government seems to think the small business is this bottomless pit of money they can keep sticking their hand into whenever they get the country into trouble and there is no money left.

6:09And just a final thought about your business, the telecoms business. If young people are not coming through and not getting entry-level jobs, What will that mean for the future of the business more broadly? We're already struggling on a technical front. You know, some of the engineers that we've used are retired, you know, and some engineers are coming out of retirement given the increase in the retirement age. But we're going to really struggle with the engineers of the future unless something's done to make it easier for youngsters to get into employment and easier for employers to employ them.

6:42That was Dean Billington, director of a telecoms business in Birmingham. Well, the Work and Pensions Secretary, Pat McFadden, told a meeting of Labour MPs this evening that the coming deal for NEETS was not last year's deal with better PR. So what is it then? And how can the Burnham government sell its welfare reset better than the Starmer government was able to sell his? Joining us now, Alan Lockie, who was Sakeir Starmer's chief speechwriter during that period. Good evening. Good evening. First of all, the difference between what's in this particular set of proposals and the welfare reforms that Keir Starmer tried to push through.

7:21What would you say the main sort of substantive differences? Well, I think Alan Milburn was hired by or commissioned by Keir following some of the learnings from that bill last year. and really I think for you know it focusing focuses much more on what people see as the burning platform issue with the welfare state at the moment which is rising levels of worklessness in young people I think the reforms last year clearly focused slightly more broader not just in the in that age group and there were you know sort of reforms across the piece to disability benefits and personal independence payment which you know ultimately were not popular with some elements of the PLP.

8:04And so I think it is both more systemic in its sort of approach across all departments to do with young people, but it also is much more focused on young people specifically. So what challenges will Andy Burnham face in trying to convince his backbenchers that these proposals are ones that need to be implemented? well i think he one thing he will definitely do is focus very very clearly on the opportunity here which is you know he will couch his arguments very much in sort of working class opportunity this will be a moral urgency to everything he says and does and he will say this is really all about getting young people back into work one of the things labour mps didn't necessarily like last year was the sense that this was being done for fiscal reasons and this is where it gets a little tricky for Andy Burnham because it is quite hard to completely once campaigning gets underway to completely box that off as an issue which isn't a driving force you know the UK like many countries in the world does this face a number of issues with its rising debt levels and high borrowing costs and the urgency is a little driven by trying to show to financial markets that they are in control of public spending and fairly unfairly that is now a test that people are setting developed countries around the world so that is part of the mix and how they play that issue in a way that doesn't sort of annoy Labour MPs who want to see this as a first principles thing and all about opportunity is going to be one of the main challenges he faces.

9:43So what lessons have been learned then from what happened last year do you think well i mean for one he will try and focus his rhetoric really on the opportunity i think the i mean look the the care hired alan milan because he would do a much more systemic issue you'll have seen a lot a lot of focus a lot more uh engagement and a lot of preparation uh for tomorrow's report a lot of work has been done in the tea room a lot of work has been done in the media trying to prepare people and familiarize themselves with the arguments but it's going to be really difficult you know they're going to come under attack from the left, they're going to come under attack from various NGOs who will be very hostile to the reforms and, you know, reforming welfare is always a very difficult thing for the Labour Party to do.

10:25There's a long history to that, pretty much since the party was formed. But what helps him surely is the fact that some of those who were against last year's reforms are now sitting close to him around the cabinet table. Yeah, I mean, I guess it will help to an extent. But I mean, there'll still be plenty of people on the back benches who are nervous about this. I mean, one of the things that will be driving this will be the letters into the post boxes, into the constituency mailboxes, into the inboxes. and you know that will create a sense of nervousness for Labour MPs to make sure that on the right side of the argument.

11:06I mean I think they are, I think this is something that does need to be done for all sorts of reasons. I think you know the ambition that Milburn will set out which is to sort of cut the not in education employment training number of young people by nearly half a million is a really really strong Labour cause and yes it's going to be difficult and there might be some slightly uncomfortable decisions that have to get to that point but the Labour MPs who agree with the vision should really back this because you know the the sort of days where you know change could be delivered without some sort of painful trade-offs or costs of change are not really that's just not really where we are as a nation in terms of the amount of money we have to spend on things at the moment so we live in difficult times and that requires difficult choices.

11:50A man speaking from experience, Alan Lockie, former chief speechwriter to Sir Keir Starmer. And coming up later on in the programme, a new holder of the Licence to Kill. Say live and let die. A gun and a radio. The name's Bond. James Bond. We'll speak to the Hollywood journalist who first suggested that the new James Bond would indeed be Robert Pattinson. Now, Downing Street has said it is urgently investigating a message by Russell Brand to his followers in which the convicted comedian claimed innocence for his sexual offences. The message from Brand, who is spending ten and a half years in prison for his crimes, was relayed by his wife Laura on their YouTube show.

12:39This was a reaction to that of Andrea Simon, the Victims Commissioner for London. It will certainly re-traumatise his victims and other survivors of rape who have to hear it. The victims during the sentencing hearing highlighted how his denials and ongoing media fame over two decades had added to their pain and trauma. And even in the sentencing remarks, the judge also directly addressed Brand's denials, emphasising the series of lies that he told on the witness stand. So the fact that the survivors are still having to hear this now is really problematic and very concerning that we can't do more to protect them from it.

13:14So what are the rules about sending messages from prison? Here's the BBC's senior UK correspondent, Seema Kotecha. There are strict rules in place, but they're nuanced. In the message, Brand continues to claim he's innocent despite his convictions. Now, this is allowed, but criminals are usually not allowed to make statements from jail that cause distress to victims. There are also heavy restrictions in place on them speaking to the media. Now, the policy says inmates need written permission for phone contact with the media, whether call is intended or likely to be published or broadcast. The policy also requires governors to consider whether a proposed broadcast is likely to cause serious distress to victims when deciding whether to authorise media contact in the first place.

14:05Ultimately, it will be up to the government and the prison governor to decide whether any rules have been broken. Russell Brand's wife, Laura, also confirmed on the podcast that her husband has been transferred to a Category C prison, HMP Littlehay in Cambridgeshire. David Wilson is a professor of criminology and a former prison governor. I asked him whether he thought Russell Brand had broken any rules. The prison service is pretty much an analogue institution and really you're asking a question which is far more digital and up-to-date. As far as the rules are concerned, I don't see that Brand has broken any rules.

14:41He's merely yet another sex offender who is claiming to be innocent after conviction. And frankly, if I took you into Little Hay this evening, you'd probably find 50 % of the prison population were going to say that. He spoke to his wife. His wife then chose to make public her discussion with her husband. That's not against the rules as they currently stand. He is merely a prisoner who has a platform, and that platform remains even after he has been convicted. When I was trying to think of a comparable case, you would probably think of Jeremy Bamber, the man who's been convicted of committing murders at White House Farm, who continually maintains his innocence and who continually speaks to the media.

15:30It is not that unusual. We might all agree, and I certainly do, that I was appalled by what he is claiming, is continuing to claim, which will make it much more difficult to actually work with him within the prison in terms of trying to make him less risky to other people once he is eventually released. But I cannot see her talking to his wife and then his wife choosing to speak about what she discussed with her husband can be seen in any way, shape or form against the prison rules as they currently stand. Even if it becomes a regular thing, for example? If it does become a regular thing, the best thing we can possibly do is stop giving him the oxygen of publicity.

16:17Brand is a narcissist and therefore the way that you stop what it is that he's seeking to do is continually repeating what it is that he states to his wife, who then is able to make comment publicly. If those comments cause distress to his victims, that might take us into some further territory which might allow the governor to intervene. But my gosh, I feel sorry for the governor who's been left holding this particular issue because I doubt very much that the governor will have any powers at all to be able to intervene. Does it make any difference if money is being made out of this? It's not so much the money that might be made.

17:02It's much more about, I think, the opportunity to gag him would be much more about the distress it caused to his victims. But then, on the other hand, he's perfectly entitled to maintain his innocence. There's absolutely nothing unusual about that. and Brian may yet appeal in terms of having been convicted. What we can do as individuals is stop reusing the kinds of things that he says, which keeps this in the public eye. A slight sidebar, but you have worked on the rehabilitation of sex offenders, haven't you? When someone is maintaining their innocence and they've been convicted, does it make behavioural change more difficult?

17:47It absolutely does. And that is the bigger issue. You know, there are something like 1 ,200 sex offenders in Little Hay. And I can assure you, there is very little being done in terms of making them less risky in committing further sexual offences once they've been released. The sex offender treatment program is disgraced. It used to exist. It was actually proven to make sex offenders worse. And so with somebody who maintains their innocence, it makes that even harder for the psychologist or for the various programs that do exist to have any impact at all in terms of their future behavior. And that's the biggest worry really about sex offenders like brands is that there's actually very little that we can do.

18:34That was David Wilson, Professor of Criminology, former prison governor. And just a reminder of main stories at this hour. Five EU countries have announced plans to send failed asylum seekers to Rwanda two years after a similar UK plan was scrapped. And Adi Burnham has called Brexit the first domino to fall in a global move towards more isolationism and protectionism. He was talking in a speech ahead of the UK-EU summit later this week. Looking back, Brexit was the first domino to fall in a global move towards more isolationism and protectionism. Vested interests rather than values driving international affairs.

19:19And the saddest thing of all is this. It is exactly what our enemies wanted. Now that was Andy Burnham speaking earlier this evening.

19:33Discover a spectacular island destination with crystal blue seas, endless sunshine, and the cool Bahamian breeze. Bahamar, located in Nassau, Bahamas, offers your choice of three luxury hotels. The richly refined Rosewood, the playfully hip SLS, and the stylishly modern Grand Hyatt. With over 45 restaurants, bars, and lounges, Bahamar serves up delicious dining from world-renowned chefs like Daniel Balloud and Marcus Samuelson. nightlife venues like the new John Batiste Jazz Club and the Caribbean's most luxurious casino at Baja Mar you'll find every pleasure under the sun and one-of-a-kind experiences for the entire family like Baja Bay our 15-acre lush tropical water park interactive wildlife experiences including our daily flamingo parade world-class golf tennis spa and so much more visit Baja Bahamar.com today and discover a vacation destination where memories are made for a lifetime.

20:30Bahamar. Life spectacular. This is Martha Stewart. Have you ever started a new tradition? Here's a hint. Do it with Lenox. This year, Lenox will make the holidays something truly special. How exciting it is every year to unbox all of our favorite decor and smile at the memories. The Lenox Spice Village is the perfect holiday gift for someone you love, including yourself. Calling back to the originals from 1989, now you can share the memories and the flavors of the season. It's a charming collection of hand-painted houses. Imagine ginger from a Georgian townhouse or pepper from your Swiss chalet.

21:11Lenox has brought timeless beauty and quality to tables and homes for generations. Baking together, sharing recipes, decorating, suddenly simple pleasures become part of your holiday story. Forever. With Lennox, collect those moments every year or treat your favorite someone. Remember, when you give a gift that lasts beyond the holidays, it's an amazing feeling. When you give Lennox, you just might start a new tradition. Discover the full collection at lennox.com slash spicevillage.

21:49Welcome to His Majesty's Secret Service, Mr Bond. That was the message on the King and Queen's social media pages tonight as Robert Pattinson's latest film role was given royal approval. And not just any role. You used to say, live and let live You know you did, you know you did, you know you did But if this ever-changing world The world in which we're living Makes you give in and cry

22:25Say live and let die A gun And a radio The name's Bond James Bond

22:51Yes, he is to become the seventh 007. And the first sense that it was Robert Pattinson's to lose, that came from Matthew Bellany, who is the Hollywood entertainment journalist and podcaster, founding partner of the digital media company Puck, and before that, editorial director of The Hollywood Reporter. And on the line to us now, hello, Matthew. Hello. So, how did you sniff it all out, then? Well, there were a couple things going for Pattinson. First of all, amongst the five finalists, he was by far the biggest star with the most star power among them. And when a star of this caliber even agrees to audition for a role, there is often an understanding with the filmmaker that we want you, but this is just a formality.

23:38It would have been a big deal for Pattinson to audition and then not get the offer for this role. Although it is unusual for someone as much of an A-lister as him to actually get the role of James Bond, isn't it? Most grow into it. That is true. And the franchise, when it was steered by the Broccoli family, they were very keen on making sure that Bond, the character, was the star, not the actor playing Bond. But this is a new day for the franchise. It is now controlled by Amazon MGM, and they are definitely charting a new path here and getting a very well-known star to inhabit the character. Not just a very well-known star, but someone who's playing another iconic role of Batman at the same time.

24:22That is unusual as well. And the Batman movie is scheduled to come out in the early 2028. This movie has not been dated yet, but there's a chance that Bond could be ready to come out at late 2028. So it might be that Pattinson is Batman to start the year and Bond to end it. Why wasn't he in the shortlist that were being talked about for months and months? He auditioned late in the process. And honestly, it was one of those things where it never got circulated in the media. They managed to keep him and Nicholas Holt secret during the process. Now, there's some speculation that maybe they weren't as satisfied with some of the early candidates they saw, so they decided to bring in some heavier hitters there.

25:09But I think Pattinson was on director Denis Villeneuve's mind from the beginning, and he's currently working with Pattinson, or he just worked with him, on Dune Part 3. So they already have a relationship. Interesting. And what do you think he'll bring to the role? I think it'll be a little bit different than Daniel Craig, who is much more muscular and kind of brooding. Pattinson is a little quirkier. He's a frailish guy, and he has a bit of a quirky sense of humor to him. So it might be a throwback a bit to the more kind of lighter humorous bonds of the 70s and 80s. Frailish. That's not a word you associate with James Bond.

25:50Not usually. But remember, Daniel Craig was also not huge when he was cast, and then he bulked up for the role. So we'll see what Pattinson does. Ah, right. So he's going to be working out for it. What else do you need to do? I mean, it's such an iconic role, isn't it? You will forever be known as James Bond, no matter what else you've done. How do you go about preparing for something like that, do you think? Well, I think that's part of the reason why Pattinson was chosen. This is the first Bond search in the age of social media. And the attention here and the scrutiny was so high that it really would have been tough for an unknown to shoulder that burden.

26:26and Pattinson's someone who has been famous since the Twilight movies 20 years ago almost. I think that's going to be a big asset for him going forward. And remember, Daniel Craig was able to do other things while he was Bond, the Knives Out movies and many other films. And I think Pattinson will continue to work. I mean, he's in five movies this year. So this guy likes to work. And I think he's going to do stuff outside of Bond. Matthew, many thanks for your insights. It's Matthew Bellany there, Hollywood Entertainment Journalist. Now, three months after he led the lawsuit about child safety and addiction, which resulted in the Facebook owner Meta settling for a whopping$18 billion, California's Attorney General Rob Bonta has another tech giant in his sights.

27:11His office says today filed a lawsuit against OpenAI, alleging that the artificial intelligence giant, the owner of ChatGPT, misled and endangered the public by testing AI agents without adequate safeguards. The lawsuit refers to the hugging face incident earlier this year when agents communicated with each other to attack a popular platform for AI developers and raising the spectre of chatbots operating far more autonomously than was previously known. It's one of a number of companies that were attacked in rogue incidents. Well, earlier I spoke to Attorney General Bonta to find out more. Today, we brought and announced a lawsuit against OpenAI for its failure to develop and test its advanced AI models securely and safely.

27:55And our basis is 80 different incidents of failing to safely contain its advanced AI models where the AI agents escaped their contained environment and got into other systems and networks, got onto the Internet. Maybe most notable among them, the hugging face incident. They, of course, put their hands up and said their agents were responsible for the Hugging Face incident once Hugging Face had revealed it had happened. And they have also said in response to your lawsuit, they've undertaken an extensive and transparent effort to understand and address misaligned model activity. Yeah, those are their statements.

28:37Those are their self-serving statements. Their actions speak louder than words. They didn't even know that their agents had gotten into the Hugging Face network until Hugging Face told them. They were completely failing to monitor and follow up. They have not been transparent. We asked them for information about those 80 incidents, and their response was one of the most deficient and unacceptable responses that my team has seen. And they've worked on these types of cases for decades. So when they say they've been working constructively with your office, you don't sound as though you agree with them.

29:12I don't agree. A way to be constructive is to respond to our questions, respond to our inquiries, give us answers. Don't stonewall. And they have stonewalled. They have not been responsive. Now, at the time, they said that they considered the Hugging Face incident to be a warning shot for us, for them, OpenAI, and for the world. Is there not an argument that what they have done actually helps mankind understand the potential challenges that AI poses? Understanding a failure to monitor, a failure to keep people safe and using that knowledge to help do better going forward is a silver lining in something that's very problematic.

29:53They knew what they were doing. They knew they were taking a risk. It was foreseeable. It was predictable. It was knowing. And it still happened. And it happened, the Huggy Face. Can I just ask how you can actually prove that, though? I mean, they've said no human directed the action. So how do you prove that they knowingly caused this? They knew the risks. They knew that there were certain safety protocols that they could have taken, but that they didn't take. Things like providing an air gap, having a shutdown mechanism, having preclearance or independent audits. Those are all ideas that are common sense to policymakers and are being considered right now that they didn't do.

30:32They took risks in their pursuit of competition, in pursuit of having the most advanced models to outdo their competitors, and they compromised safety in the process. That's why there have been 80 incidents that we know of. And can I ask to the point they also make, which is that they're being singled out, that there are other companies which have made similar transgressions, Anthropic being one, rogue. I mean, rogue agents are now pretty commonplace. Are you singling out OpenAI? We are not. They are not the victim. They are the perpetrator. Let's be clear. OpenAI is accountable for what OpenAI develops, what it designs, what safety protocols and security protocols it puts in place or fails to put in place.

31:15If others are engaged in law-breaking activity, that is of great interest to us. We will take steps when and if appropriate. We have taken steps against Grok, against character AI. So they are not being singled out. They are not the victims. They are the perpetrators. They failed in their duty. They broke the law, and they earned their lawsuit today. Well, I was going to ask you, is the fact that there isn't regulation in place making the likes of you having to step in? Yes and no. And here's what I mean by that. There are existing laws already in place. And so we brought up our case based on a public nuisance claim and an unfair competition law claim.

31:53But can more be done? Should more be done? Yes. Regulators need to step up. The federal government needs to step up. California has stepped up and can do more and should do more. I'll be part of that effort in the coming legislative session. So, yes, there's much more to do still in this dynamic space that is full of power, potency, and potential to make our lives better and to improve the human condition, but also full of potential to harm, if not addressed appropriately. And that was California's Attorney General, Rob Bonta. Well, from a lawsuit against one of the world's biggest AI companies to the latest in the controversy surrounding the chip-making giant NVIDIA, following the resignation of its chief executive, Jensen Huang.

32:32He quit over extramarital affairs, including one with a suspected Chinese spy. Well, today NVIDIA's board has been pouring cold water on the possibility of Huang's return. despite a concerted Bring Back Jensen campaign backed by the likes of Elon Musk, amongst others. Instead, there is now a growing focus on a loophole that has been exposed by the scandal, China's ability to obtain cutting-edge AI chips by renting them from foreign data centres. And that's created public divisions in Donald Trump's cabinet. It's pitted the Treasury Secretary Scott Besson to his four tighter restrictions against the Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, who's been in favour of selling more advanced chips to China.

33:11Today, as he was preparing to board his helicopter Marine One, President Trump was asked about those divisions. Two different views. One view is you don't want to insult China. We have a very good relationship with China. And you don't want to insult them. And the other view is just go down and dirty and do what you have to do. You can't say either is wrong or right. We'll let you know. But Jensen, as you know, wanted to sell to China. And the only thing he was able to sell to China were chips that were sort of obsolete, a little bit like our avionics, our aviation equipment. He wasn't allowed to sell the Blackwell or any of that.

33:54Well, to find out more about the loophole I mentioned, the so-called cloud access loophole, I've been speaking to Emily Kilcrease, a veteran of the US Commerce Department, the White House National Security Council and the Office of the US Trade Representative under Presidents Obama, Trump and Biden. It's basically the idea that a Chinese entity can get the same sort of computing power as it could get through buying its own advanced AI chips directly, putting in its own data centers by accessing cloud services. So if there's a data center in Singapore, for example, that's using NVIDIA chips and giving really powerful compute, Chinese entities can access that.

34:36And it's the same sort of national security risk that we would have as if the Chinese entity had bought that chip and put it into its own data center directly. Just like Megaspeed, in other words. Just like Megaspeed, exactly. Which is why it's come back into the news? That's exactly right. I mean, the rule that we saw from BIS today, from the Department of Commerce, the agency that oversees export controls, it dropped this rule today that's trying to close that cloud access loophole. Then we've seen members, senior members of the administration, notably Treasury Secretary, Commerce Secretary, taking different positions on this.

35:14Is there now pressure on the Commerce Department under Howard Lutnick? Yeah, there is pressure. And I think rightly so. You know, the loophole has been known for quite some time. It's not to discount the technical and legal complexities of doing something about it, but it never moved forward. It's also in the context of the Department of Commerce really failing to take almost any export control enforcement action for the entire Trump administration. It's the overall posture where the Commerce Department really seems to be asleep on the job. And I think that's part of the tension that you saw with Secretary Besant coming out and more or less throwing Howard Lutnik under the bus and saying everybody else wanted to get this done, but he was standing in the way, which is a remarkable rupture amongst the cabinet.

36:00As someone who used to work in the Commerce Department, what do you think has been going on here? Well, I do think, you know, this is all downstream from the president's China policy. At the end of the day, you know, I think Secretary Lutnik was kind of interpreting the guidance he got from the president, which is that we don't want to hit China that hard. We're trying to maintain this kind of relationship of strategic stability. We want to keep our foot on the gas pedal when it comes to AI. We don't want to do anything that's going to slow down AI development or kind of selling AI around the world.

36:34So if those are the marching orders, then, you know, export control enforcement takes the back seat. And I think, unfortunately, now we're seeing the consequences of that. So what about the war, the AI war that President Trump has also repeatedly said America needs to win? You know, he has an interesting strategy for how to win it, though, I think is the thing. I think it's much more about taking a light regulatory approach on the development of AI in the United States. It's about pushing the exports of the AI tech stack so that all of the global AI infrastructure around the world is built using U.S.

37:14technology. And there's merits to pieces of that. But the thing that's missing and that this administration has consistently underemphasized is how do we protect the U.S. technology that is a key part of giving us a lead? So it was this really hard pivot away from the Biden era approach, which really was about protecting U.S. technological advantages in compute, in frontier models. The Trump administration has just taken a very different approach to trying to win the race. That was Emily Kilcrease, who worked in the U.S. Commerce Department and the White House National Security Council under three presidents.

37:50Now, to a presidency of a different nature, because a day or two after the former Arsenal boss, Arsene Wenger, let it be known that he was not going to challenge Gianni Infantino for the FIFA presidency, a different Frenchman has thrown his chapeau into the ring. European football's governing body, UEFA, has put forward the head of the French Football Federation, Philippe Diallo, to challenge Infantino in next March's election. The Swiss administrator, who is running for a fourth term, had been under pressure since he was forced to scrap plans to sell off stakes in the World Cup to private investors.

38:24Let's get more from football journalist Henry Winter. Good evening, Henry. How significant is it that anyone is challenging Infantino? Good evening. Well, first, it's a relief that someone is standing up to him because a lot of people want him out, but that doesn't necessarily reflect itself in votes. I mean, whoever steps in, and as you say, it's Philippe Diallo, who's, you know, he's well-respected, career administrator, former lawyer, youth team player at Nantes, well-regarded in France, but not particularly well-known in the world of football. I mean, a few of us were having to sort of Google to find out a little bit more about him today, but that is going to be the problem.

39:05You need a bigger name to actually stand up to Infantino. So I always thought he was a bit ambitious for Arsene Wenger or people pushing Arsene Wenger's case. He is embedded pretty much in FIFA, so it would have been a surprise if he'd stood. So I hope he backs Diallo, and I hope some big names come back, Diallo, because he is absolutely up against a cunning fox in Infantino who's been busy shoring up his support all over the world. Sounds like he's got a pretty tall order to do it. Yeah, I think it's really difficult. And, I mean, UEFA will back him, and there are 55 votes in the UEFA, the European Confederation.

39:46But when it actually comes down to it, are all 55 going to vote as a bloc individually for Diallo? Because there will be some nations, some East European countries, who might actually think, well, Infantino has been good to us. We might get a few more quid from FIFA coffers with Infantino for infrastructure and foundation events. So we might sit with him. It is absolutely a tall order. I mean, I've always felt that the opportunity to get rid of Infantino was when UEFA came up with their threat of boycotting tournaments. That would have really made Infantino have to stand down. But UEFA drew back from that, and now they're hoping that democracy will rule, which doesn't always happen with FIFA.

40:33Briefly, I mean, there's the honorary president of the Japanese FA who's going to stand. Any other sort of possible late entries that could upset things? I mean, Kashimi, yes. I mean, he's sort of well regarded. But, you know, the Asian bloc looks pretty supportive of Infantino. Ramon Vega, the former Spurs defender, wants to stand and good luck to him. But, you know, unless Count Binface has a go, honestly, I think Infantino is coming straight back in. An intriguing prospect raised there at the end. Henry Winter there on the prospect of Gianni Infantino being challenged for presidency of FIFA next year.

41:14And just before we go, headline, five countries in the European Union have announced plans to open a migrant deportation centre in Rwanda two years after the British government scrapped a similar deal. That is The World Tonight. This is James Kamara-Sami. I'm back tomorrow at 10. But for now, from me and from everyone on the programme, good night. Studio direction was by Holly Smith. The editor was Adam Solomons.

41:44Welcome to the Haunted Library. Join me, Colin Morgan, as I read Frankenstein by Mary Shelley. A story of science and ambition, loneliness and longing, and what it truly means to be human. Listen to The Haunted Library wherever you get your podcasts or find us on YouTube.

From the publisher

In depth reporting, intelligent analysis and breaking news from a global perspective

More from The World Tonight

All episodes