

21 Oct 2026 · 39m · 12 chapters

Governments warn of critical PHP vulnerabilities after AI-assisted discovery; many websites/pages are taken offline or urged to patch quickly to prevent admin takeover and data theft. The episode also covers UK budget speculation (capital gains tax likely not raised), France riots and foreign political manipulation claims, a Russia/Ukraine hostage release, and a music segment on Baka Beyond and Baka “Yelly” singing.
James Ball, technology journalist and author. Prof. Kieran Martin, former CEO of the UK National Cyber Security Centre (GCHQ) and Oxford professor. Martin DeLuca, Stephen Hubbard’s U.S. attorney. Mathieu Kassovitz, French film director. Nick (Newsnight political editor) and William Taylor are referenced. John McDonnell MP and Dan Needle (Tax Policy Associates). Sukha Hart and Martin Craddock of Baka Beyond.
PHP flaws could grant full admin access; about 70% of webpages use PHP; patch release creates a “roadmap” for attackers. No proven hacks yet—an alert, not an attack. Putin called a “humanitarian” drew backlash. Budget: capital gains tax rate not raised; reforms may be limited.
Finland, Belgium Foreign Ministry, Edinburgh City Council, BBC, and Netherlands NCSC taking sites offline; examples of PHP-powered services like WordPress and Facebook; Hubbard sent to a Texas State Department facility.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Exploration of vulnerabilities in PHP and their impact on the internet.
“If it feels too as if 2026 has been the year of hacks, there may be a reason.”
Discussion with James Ball on what PHP is and its significance in web operations.
“The Netherlands Cyber Security Agency is practising what it's preached, taking its own website offline because of the PHP flaws.”
Kieran Martin discusses the seriousness of the PHP vulnerabilities and necessary actions.
“He's now professor of practice in the management of public organisations in the Blavatnik School of Government at the University of Oxford.”
Overview of political responses and decisions regarding gas extraction in the UK.
“Now, on last night's programme, we previewed today's announcement by the Energy Secretary, Miata Fambulla, that gas extraction can restart from the Jackdaw Field, which is about 240 kilometres east of Aberdeen.”
Exploration of the implications of gas supply and oil exports on pricing and security.
“And the reason that would be the case is that the argument that Miata Fanbulla used today, you wouldn't really be able to use with Rosebank.”
Details surrounding Stephen Hubbard's release and the political implications of his detention.
“detained four years ago, accused of fighting for Ukraine, is flying back to the United States tonight after being freed by Russia.”
Analysis of the recent riots in France and the socio-political context behind them.
“If you're listening to us live, it is now approaching 27 minutes past 10.”
Discussion on the UK's economic strategy and the potential changes to capital gains tax.
“It's more about ideology fights than a real plan for the future in France.”
Discussion on John McDonnell's views on taxation and economic strategies for Labour.
“who was Jeremy Corbyn's Shadow Chancellor for four years.”
Dan Needle shares insights on potential tax reforms and their implications.
“Joining me is Dan Needle, founder of Tax Policy Associates Limited, which seeks to improve tax policy.”
Exploration of Yelly singing and its significance to the Baka people's traditions.
“Sing the World Awake, a new album, combines their own Celtic and other music with what the Barker call Yelly singing.”
Discussion on major cybersecurity flaws affecting websites and the urgency for action.
“Sue Hart and Martin Craddock discussing Baka Bionzio album Sing The World Awake with Martin Venard.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On The World Tonight, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.
0:30goals or appetite for investing, Schwab has everything you need all in one place. Visit schwab.com to learn more. How many streaming subscriptions do you have? Is it the same for your business? Avoid it by having all your business on one platform. Try Odoo for free at odoo.com. That's O-D-O-O dot com. Hello, I'm Sean Lay. Thanks so much for downloading the BBC's World Tonight podcast from Wednesday the 21st of October. Here's what we've got lined up for you. Has 2026 been the year of hacks? Well, if you think so, this might explain it. Governments and cyber security agencies around the world are urging online companies to fix flaws in PHP.
1:11That's a programming language which underpins much of the internet. They've been described as the most severe vulnerabilities ever discovered by AI. We'll explain what they are and how it could affect you. As we discussed on our last programme, gas extraction from the jackdaw field is going to restart, but what about oil from Rosebank? Donald Trump's envoy has saluted Vladimir Putin as a humanitarian after he frees a retired schoolteacher in his 70s, who'd been held in a prison colony for four years after being convicted of fighting for Ukraine, a charge he denied. But does that decision make a Russian president a humanitarian?
1:47We'll hear from the lawyer of the released American. There's been no kite flying so far ahead of next week's British budget, unlike last year. So why is the Chancellor playing his cards so close to his chest? And what do the experts think has been ruled out so far? With more protests planned by students for the coming weekend in France, the film director, Mathieu Kassovitz, tells me why we're misreading the riots. And Yelly singing from Cameroon. What's it for? And why it melds so well with Celtic music? Stay with us to find out. If it feels too as if 2026 has been the year of hacks, there may be a reason.
2:25Governments and cybersecurity agencies around the world are tonight urging online companies to fix flaws in PHP, a programming language which underpins much of the internet. One security firm, Wiz, says they're the most severe vulnerabilities ever discovered by AI, and some parts of the internet have now gone completely dark. The whole internet is at risk right now and a bunch of sites are just shutting down instead of risking being at About 70 % of the internet is currently unavailable due to a vulnerability detected in the coding language PHP And so lots and lots of websites and services run on PHP Think about like Facebook, WordPress, most of the internet still running on this old PHP and it's super vulnerable You're probably aware today has been like a crisis of anybody who uses web systems with something known as PHP way over my head, if I'm really honest, and I don't really understand it that well.
3:23Well, let's see if we can help. Earlier today, a fix or patch was issued with governments and their agencies urging businesses to rapidly adopt the updates or consider taking their websites offline because you can't hack a website if it's not online. The Government of Finland, Belgium's Foreign Ministry, Edinburgh City Council and the BBC among those who've taken down websites or pages. The Netherlands Cyber Security Agency is practising what it's preached, taking its own website offline because of the PHP flaws. Let's talk now to James Ball, who's a technology journalist and author. James, thank you so much for being with us to help us explain this story tonight.
4:01Let's go back to basics. What exactly is PHP and how extensively does it underpin the operation of the internet? So PHP is a scripting language and it essentially helps web pages connect to databases. And so those databases hold login information or customer information or anything that powers a website, not to just be a really static 1990s type web page. and it's everywhere. About two-thirds of webpages, slightly more than that, use it in some form. And so because this is such a fundamental vulnerability, any webpage that uses it could be subject to hacking, which is why quite a few of the admins have just pulled their sites offline as a precaution.
4:51So it's not that two-thirds of the website's offline. It's not that all of them have been hacked. It's that they're vulnerable. The potential to hack. And as you said, it's the fact that this connects those kind of public facing bits with the kind of data that can lie behind them. And presumably a lot of that data can be private and confidential. Exactly that. This is a scary vulnerability because it essentially means that any site with PHP, an attacker who learns about this newly discovered vulnerability and builds something using it, could get full admin access. and that means they could access customer information, they could get into private systems.
5:32And the thing with PHP is it's on lots of sites that people might not think about. If there's sort of a server that's running someone's printer or an organization, it might have a web interface built with PHP. So there's got to be all the obvious targets, but it's going to be the work of months for places to sort of find all the obscure ones and all the other pages that run this. PHP is quite an old code, but it is infrastructure. And just as you said, just briefly, that last point, it's old code. Is that part of the problem here, that a lot of the infrastructure of the internet is quite old and hasn't really been updated?
6:10That is a big problem. The sort of cutting-edge sites, banks, etc., are probably already up to date and not too vulnerable. But lots of this is neglected. Lots of this is not got a team updating it. And AI is good at finding problems that have been there for years, but not really managed. Got you. And that's how we found it this time, through people deploying AI tools to help spot these things. James Ball, thank you very much. Let's turn to Kieran Martin, who was the founding chief executive of the National Cyber Security Centre, part of GCHQ in 2016. He's now professor of practice in the management of public organisations in the Blavatnik School of Government at the University of Oxford.
6:50Professor Martin, thanks very much for being with us. It is customary of journalists to perhaps over-egg stories sometimes. Are we over-egging this one? It's very bad. We find vulnerabilities in internet software all the time. And since AI models became more powerful, we're finding more than we can handle. But few of them really matter. And this one does. This is the most serious vulnerability discovered for five years. having said that it's not the harbinger of the apocalypse you mentioned that 2026 could be seen as the year of hacks actually real harm in cyberspace is stable in 2026 and there's been a lot of hype about hacks and some of the narrative around this is getting a little bit ahead of itself 70 % of the internet is not offline um in fact there's no proven hacks at all yet some organizations have quite properly taken themselves offline as a precaution.
7:48About 70 % of the sites have PHP, isn't it? So this is an alert, not an attack. And that's an important distinction. But it is the most serious alert for five years and one of the most serious vulnerabilities in foundational internet technology we've ever seen. So no, it's not being overhyped, but we need to be absolutely clear that this is not evidence of attacks yet because we need people to act. The whole point is there's a patch available. Unfortunately, the nature of this type of technology means that you can't just get the people who've built the software to do it for you. Users have to do it themselves.
8:28Otherwise, they're at risk. So for people sitting at home listening to this tonight on the radio who think, well, it doesn't kind of affect me, what would you say? If you're sitting at home and you're just thinking, what does this mean for my personal use of the internet? For the most part, stay alert to scams, as you always would, and think no more about it unless you're just generally interested in tech security. If you ever run an organization, or you work in IT as part of an organization, or you have any form of leadership responsibility in any organization, it's statistically fairly likely that your organization could be running a key website on PHP, or it could be using WordPress, or it could have a ticketing system, an HR function that runs PHP and all of that will be vulnerable.
9:14And there's a race on now. This will have a sort of mini explosive phase and then a long tail. And the mini explosive phase started at 3pm British time today when the patch was released. Because when you give a patch, it's not just a fix. It's a roadmap for malicious hackers to use it in the other direction. There's no other way of making it work. So it tells you, the user, the owner of a website, the owner of a network, it says, here's how you fix it. But it also says, here's how you attack it. So if you fixed it, the hackers won't be able to exploit you. But if you haven't, not only will they be able to exploit you, but they'll be able to use AI to speed up scanning for all those networks and organizations that haven't deployed the patch.
9:59They'll be even more vulnerable than they would have been a year or so ago had this happened earlier. So it's pretty binary. there will be people at risk. Also, some people who want to do the right thing might find they're using an old version of PHP for which the patch won't work, so they'll have to upgrade, which will be more disruptive. So it's going to be messy, it's going to be hard, but it's necessary. Because no one, I mean, again, let's have some perspective. This is really bad. No one's going to die. No one's going to get hurt. Eating and lighting will still work. Hospital functions will still be okay.
10:29But there could be large-scale data loss. There could be a sort of huge amount of aggregate harm done through thousands of small attacks. And that could proceed for many months and even years to come if people don't take this action. Professor Kieran Martin, former Chief Executive of the National Cyber Security Centre now at the Blavatnik School of Government in Oxford. Thank you very much. Coming up in the next half hour or so we hear from the West Country musicians blending Celtic folk with the singing of hunter-gatherers in West Africa They're singing without words a lot so it's the sound of the voice When you sing to the forest you don't need to use words it's all an interlocking of sound and they taught me how to become part of that
11:24Martin Venard's report is something to look forward to. Now, on last night's programme, we previewed today's announcement by the Energy Secretary, Miata Fambulla, that gas extraction can restart from the Jackdaw Field, which is about 240 kilometres east of Aberdeen. If there, why not at Rosebank too, a gas and oil field beyond Shetland? That decision we are still awaiting. The response from Labour environmentalists to the Jackdaw decision today has been relatively muted, But Rosebank is potentially more fraught for the government. Newsnight's political editor, Nick, what joins me. I suppose the first thing is to ask is, has the government survived the potential party problems that could arise from this decision over Jackdaw, do you think?
12:06They have, Sean. I mean, I was in the chamber for a part of Michael Shanks, he's the energy minister, his statement. And when I was there, there were quite a few Labour MPs popping up and were highly critical. I mean, one that particularly struck me was Chris Ward, who used to be a minister under Keir Starmer, incredibly close to Keir Starmer, talked about, I'm concerned about the message this decision sends out about how serious we are about tackling the climate emergency. How about this from Chris Hinkliffe, North East Hertfordshire. It's not quite the response to catastrophic climate change, wildfires and drapes that I had in mind, but I accept that that appears to be a minority view in this place.
12:40But I do have to say, Sean, that most Labour MPs who spoke about this were supportive. And what was particularly interesting was the number of Scottish Labour MPs who were supportive. And a very interesting voice on that is Torkel Crichton, who's the Labour MP for Nahalian Anar, used to be known as the Western Isles. And he's saying, look, don't think that this is just about the North East economy of Scotland. This is about the whole of the Scottish economy, hugely reliant on this sort of energy. So for the moment they got through it, and most of the Labour MPs who spoke up were supportive. When do you think we might get a decision on Rosebank from Miata Fable?
13:23Well, I think what we're looking at is a number of weeks. Now, you know, the Alan Milburn review, we're told, is a few weeks, but that literally is a few weeks. I think the number of weeks with this will be a slightly longer, elongated version of how long that will be. And what is interesting is that Miata van Bulla making very clear today that all these decisions she has to make in a quasi-judicial role. So she has to be very careful. She has to consider the evidence. But there is a feeling that on Rosebank, you'd be heading in the direction of a no, not confirmed. So Jackdaw was a yes because it's about gas.
13:58Rosebank looking like it might be more of a no. It's much more oil related. And the reason that would be the case is that the argument that Miata Fanbulla used today, you wouldn't really be able to use with Rosebank. So the argument she said today is it's going to have no impact on price because it's a global commodity. That's the same with Rosebank. Rosebank is about oil. Oil is exported. The announcement today was about gas that will come to the UK. As opposed to us having to buy in more gas. So Miata Fambula was saying today is about security of supply. And you wouldn't be able to say that with the Rosebank.
14:31Because we've got it out of oil. The emissions from Rosebank, seven times the amount today. So you can't make that argument. It's a very intriguing prospect. We will hopefully come back to when those weeks have elapsed. Who knows? It might all be over by Christmas or it might not. A retired American school teacher in his mid-70s, detained four years ago, accused of fighting for Ukraine, is flying back to the United States tonight after being freed by Russia. The news was announced by Steve Witkoff, Donald Trump's envoy, who's been in Moscow discussing the war in Ukraine. Mr Witkoff met Stephen Hubbard, who's 74, and has been held in a prison colony for four years now, and he conveyed the wishes of the Russian president to his former prisoner.
15:12We just left President Putin. He sends you blessings and wishes you good things. from today to something like you. Well, earlier, Mr. Wyckoff told President Putin, you are a humanitarian also, sir, and I salute that. I commend you. Warm words indeed, and perhaps the sort of diplomatic nicety that is needed to smooth the progress of negotiations over Ukraine. William Taylor, a former US ambassador to Ukraine under George W. Bush and Barack Obama, said calling Putin a humanitarian, that's cringeworthy, and Republicans critical of Donald Trump condemned the remarks too. Senator John Cornyn posted, no, Putin is a stone-cold killer.
15:55President Trump, for his part, has tonight insisted the release came with no strings attached. We gave nothing in exchange, which is very rare. We never give anything in exchange. We've gotten out hundreds of hostages. Once you give, you'll end up quadrupling the problem. Well, I've been speaking to Mark and to Luca, who is Stephen Hubbard's U.S. attorney. And he said when Mr. Hubbard lands in the United States in a few hours time, he'll be taken to a facility in Texas. Texas is a location where the State Department has a facility where they welcome people back, detainees back. And so these facilities are customized and designed to have hospital in it, therapy, medical teams.
16:44And this is where basically they receive detainees from whatever parts of whatever parts of the world they come back from. Right. And it'll help them, I guess, in to just back to normal life. I mean, Mr. Hubbard has lived out of the United States for many years. He's worked as a teacher. He went to Ukraine for personal reasons. He ended up being detained and accused of fighting on behalf of Ukraine. Have you seen any evidence at all that he was doing that? No, we never saw any evidence that he was fighting for Ukraine. It's also not a logical conclusion when you understand that this man was a lifelong English teacher who was at the time of his detention 70 years old, living on his social security pension.
17:31of approximately$300 a month and not in optimal health. So the notion that somebody like that would volunteer or somehow be recruited to fight in the Ukrainian armed forces is pretty ridiculous. It just flies in the face of common sense. What do you understand as a result of making contact with him, I think about a year ago, about the conditions in which he was being held? Yeah, it was about a year and a half ago that we managed to locate him. You know, the conditions he was being held in were very difficult for Western standards. Those would be very, very harsh conditions. And what made it worse, frankly, was the fact that because of his isolation from his family, from his lawyers, from the U.S.
18:19Embassy and, you know, Consular Services, he actually had no support. You know, the family and the legal team were very, very grateful to President Trump and Steve Whitcoff and the hostage affairs team because they really kept him at the top of the list this whole time. They asked, I mean, and this is unusual. I have to say, I believe they raised him at the most senior levels about half a dozen times. Do you get why some people have raised an eyebrow at what Steve Witkoff said to President Putin today when he welcomed Stephen Hubbard's release when he said, I salute you as a humanitarian? Yeah, I mean, I completely understand why people raise an eyebrow.
19:04There's obviously also a significant difference of opinion on the approach to ending the war in Ukraine between, you know, Europe and the United States. and, you know, friends can have difference of opinions. Yes. Now, it just so happens that the approach of the Trump administration is one that is about engagement with both sides to get tangible results, right? So words come and go, but what matters at the end of the day are the results. Yeah, but it sends a signal, doesn't it? Even the former US ambassador to Moscow was kind of taken aback. No, of course. Well, look, that former ambassador is routinely outraged by everything the Trump administration has done.
19:49I've got you. So they have an agenda of their own. So he's a regular, he's a professional outraged guy. To attribute everything that is done everywhere by Russia's security services armed forces to one man, you know, I think it's a very simplistic way of approaching it. When the situation of Stephen Hubbard, the background, the nature of the case was elevated to the highest political levels, and something could be done about it to correct, you know, perhaps a misguided series of decisions. Where those series of decisions and the result that they produce corrected or not, right? And so the approach to, I think, of the administration to these negotiations is show me the tangible results, okay?
20:32And so if the tangible result is that Steve Woodcoff comes home with another American, that is a tangible result, right? So today the Hubbard family is going to be reunited with someone, their father, their brother, somebody that they had given up basically for death. And if you don't engage, you just don't get the results. That's Martin DeLuca on the release of his client Stephen Hubbard from a Russian prison. If you're listening to us live, it is now approaching 27 minutes past 10. The main headline so far on The World Tonight, websites around the world have suffered disruption after the disclosure.
21:08of critical vulnerabilities in the coding language PHP. President Macron has accused foreign leaders of using the rioting in France at the weekend for their own political campaigns. He didn't name names, but both Benjamin Netanyahu and Donald Trump have blamed Muslim immigration. With students having announced further rallies this Saturday, I've been talking to the filmmaker Mathieu Kassavitz. In 1995, he made a powerful film about youth violence and police brutality in France.
21:51In 2010, Kassavitz left France in disgust at what he viewed as the country's inability to acknowledge the failures in its own history. He also predicted a Marine Le Pen presidency, a prospect which looks even more likely now. Well, he's back living in France, and I asked Mathieu Kassovitz how he views the recent rioting. I think what happened is the usual with something new that we never had before because, you know, protesting in France, of course, it's part of our DNA and rioting during those protests is also part of the protest because this is what makes things move. This is how the power responds, is when they start to see that people are breaking things.
22:41What is new and what was never there is the violence that went against the people and the small shops. That was very shocking for everybody because it never happened like that. I mean, you've explored, for example, themes. I remember your film, La Haine, back in 1995, about urban violence, about police brutality in particular. We've heard criticisms. But judging by what you're saying, you draw a distinction between the kind of violent confrontations between protesters and the police and the violence aimed at other civilians. Yeah, that's something that was really that we never experienced. And I think, you know, that it started with a couple of high schools in the suburbs, in what we call the banlieue, which are, you know, unprivileged kids that are trying to learn and trying to get education through a school that is heaters are broken.
23:40the water is not running, there is no electricity, you know, everything is just not maintained. So all they did is they wanted to protest to have a better education, like people in Paris inside that have, you know, a little more money. And that was the response was response from the government was very violent. Also something that we've never seen before. People reacted to the violence and at some point they said, if we don't get respect, then we will not give respect. And that's what happens all the time. But this time it went really far. That's what happens with the riots and I think all the looting is that people didn't care anymore.
24:27Is there a hopelessness in France at the moment, not least towards whether politics can actually change anything? Yes, but I think that's international. The problem is global. We're trying to find patches to our problems, but the real wound is bigger than us. So I don't think they can do anything. It's more about ideology fights than a real plan for the future in France. Right now, they have no clue about what to do with the economy. So all they can say is that the refugees, the Arabs, the Muslims are responsible for everything, and they are pointing fingers. That's all they do. But we don't have problems.
25:14What you see in the media is not what we go through. We are a very united nation and very united people. This is just the result of the answer of the government to a legitimate protest from teenagers that wanted to have a better education. That's what happens when you don't listen to the people in France. And it doesn't mean that just because there's violence, it doesn't mean that society is broken. You're arguing that actually France is quite a united country at the moment. Very united, yes. But at the same time, this is what we are. You know, I'm 60 years old and I've been protesting since I'm 10 years old.
25:53This is what we are. President Macron said today that he didn't like foreign, I mean, he didn't name the foreign leaders, but I think it was pretty clear that he rebuked them for for using what had happened in France for their own political campaigning in their election. So, I mean, it's pretty obvious that he was pointing the finger at President Trump and Prime Minister Netanyahu, both of whom have blamed the violence and the rioting on Muslim immigration. And as you say, Hamas. I mean, in a sense, you share his view, are you? for others, maybe including the Brits, you should butt out of our country.
26:29You don't understand our country. Don't start lecturing us about what's going wrong with our country. No, no, they perfectly understand our country. They're just manipulating the information to go in their favor. That's all they do. They totally know that it's not ethnic or religious or anything like that kind of riot. It's just purely societal and purely French. They know this. That's the film director in France, Mathieu Kassovitz. France may be politically dysfunctional. A budget was only approved by bypassing the National Assembly, for example, yet its borrowing costs are lower than the UK's.
27:10At the start of October, the yield on the UK's 10-year gilts, the British equivalent of government bonds, was 5.36%. That's higher than that in France. In the run-up to last year's budget, you may remember the then-Chancellor Rachel Reeves being accused of kite flying, floating possible options to test public opinion, only for the ideas to have vanished by Budget Day. This year, by contrast, there's been almost complete silence from her successor John Healy. Maybe it's just a consequence of Mr Healy being a former Defence Secretary from a world where careless talk costs lives. Or maybe it's a deliberate strategy.
27:46We'll talk about that in a moment. The one thing that does seem to have emerged from unofficial sources at or near the Treasury this week is that he won't be raising the rate of capital gains tax in the budget next Wednesday. That's disappointing to some Labour MPs, among them John McDonnell, who was Jeremy Corbyn's Shadow Chancellor for four years. But Mr McDonnell thinks he understands what Chancellor Healy is up to. He's obviously under pressure from the markets. He can't borrow much more, so he's got to balance the books by increasing taxation. There's no other way, because I don't think he can rely upon cuts in public expenditure, particularly welfare, because Labour MPs wouldn't support it.
28:24So he's looking at, I think, he's looking at a range of measures that will increase tax. Now, most of us, and it's not just me, it's the Tax Justice Campaign, Resolution Foundation, even the Institute for Fiscal Studies are saying something needs to be done about capital gains tax. And even if it's not increasing the rate, it is looking at some of the anomalies, like what they call the death uplift, where if someone dies, they don't pay any tax on their estate, that sort of thing. It is all about the concept of having to redistribute wealth and on some scale as well. So I'll be interested to see what else he finds because capital gains tax is a relatively easy one to do.
29:02And just a minor reform like the death uplift would bring in about£2 billion. So I think he's foreswore that because what happens when you mention capital gains tax, and I know this from experience, there's almost a hysterical reaction from people who have vested interests in it. And I think he's succumbed to that. But he'll be looking elsewhere. And I think most probably looking at a windfall tax on the banks, those sorts of areas. It's been quite a lot of commentary surrounding this budget, including from people who even are quite sympathetic to the Prime Minister and thinks of, you know, Jim O 'Neill, Andy Haldane.
29:38Indeed, you may have seen the article Andy Haldane's written for the Financial Times in which he says he thinks it was a mistake for the Conservatives in the 2010s to have an austerity budget at a time when borrowing was so cheap comparatively and they could have borrowed to invest. And he thinks we've paid a price for that. But he thinks there's no way for Labour of avoiding having to make quite dramatic savings, which could include cuts to services, because of the increasing cost of borrowing. Would you accept that that is something that is now unavoidable? If we go into a wave of cuts, we're immediately depressing aggregate demand in the economy.
30:15And that's exactly what we need now to start boosting the growth levels that we need. So what John Healy, I'm hoping, is going to do is actually saying, look, we will have to raise taxation. We've got to tighten our belts overall. It's got to come off the shoulders of the broader shoulders who can afford it. And we use that then to invest both in terms of growing the economy, but also lifting people out of poverty. And the people you lift out of poverty, you know, they spend the money that they receive and that will stimulate the demand that we need. What the bond markets are looking for is a stable plan for the next four or five years in which, one, they can secure a reasonable rate of return.
30:57But they can have confidence that actually we have a growing economy based upon a stable political leadership. and I think that's what John Healy will be seeking to do. That was John McDonnell MP. Joining me is Dan Needle, founder of Tax Policy Associates Limited, which seeks to improve tax policy. Dan is a tax lawyer and also a member of the Labour Party. Thanks for being with us on The World tonight. Is it a question not of what John Healy rules out or has allowed us to learn that he's ruled out, like the rate of capital gains, but what isn't mentioned? So as John McDonnell was suggesting to me, maybe not the rate, but maybe he's going to look at eliminating some of the exemptions around these taxes instead.
31:37I think a lot of the problem has been that we've had two years of febrile rumours around budgets. And it's great that hasn't happened this time, but it absolutely happened in 24 and 25. And that had a cost. And the cost was that a huge number of people sold assets before the 2024 budget to lock in capital gains rules at the time. And we can measure that. We can see that there was about an 80 % increase in gains in that year, people beating the budget. There was probably something last year as well. And there's probably people selling now to try and beat this budget. And all of that has distorted the capital gains environment, which means that if you do make changes now, if you increase the tax now, it's going to raise less than it would have done.
32:24So it's probably too late to have done it anyway, even if he had got ahead in this budget. Yeah, there's great arguments for CGT reform. Yes, to wiping out gains at death is very distortive. It makes people hold on to assets rather than selling them. It's a bad thing. The way in which we tax people who've just artificially converted income to gains is bad. All of that could have been reformed, but it's kind of too late. That's a shame. Given that Andy Burnham says he's going to stick with the pledge from the 2024 general election not to increase the taxes that could yield significant revenue, I mean income tax, national insurance, VAT, isn't it inevitable that this budget like those of Rachel Reeves is going to be made up of tweaks?
33:03Yeah, that's right. It's very unfortunate. We've ended up in a position where the taxes, which most economists would say, are the most economically efficient to raise, all taxes of an economic cost, but the ones that are the least bad, the ones that have been ruled out, and you end up with a messy dog's breakfast of tweaks here, tweaks there, which kind of creates a collective unhappiness greater than one simple tax increase. An example is bank tax. I think We're pretty likely to see bank tax go out. We're publishing a report on that tomorrow, and you probably could raise£1 billion,£2 billion from that, but it's not very much.
33:38How can more of the same, then, by John Healy this year help to reduce borrowing costs? How can it reassure the investors, the people who buy government guilts, that actually Britain is worth the risk? Gosh, I'm not a psychologist, I'm not a guilt specialist, but I think the lack of rumours has been a really good start. Another good element would be to try and avoid scrabbling around as much as you can. Try and have a few measures rather than many measures. And if we can have an impression of stability that we're not going to have another budget after this, where again there's a collection of random tax increases, that's all going to help.
34:15Dan Needle, founder of Tax Policy Associates Limited. Thank you very much. The Baka people are hunter-gatherers living in remote rainforests in southern Cameroon. For more than 30 years now, the British musicians in the group Baka Beyond, get it, have been travelling to West Africa to play with and record the voices and instruments of the people who live there. Sing the World Awake, a new album, combines their own Celtic and other music with what the Barker call Yelly singing. The BBC's Martin Vinyard has been speaking to Baka Beyond's Sukha Hart and Martin Craddock, and he asked them, what is Yelly singing?
35:03Yelly is the singing that the women do. It's quite magical. Traditionally they believe that they sing this and it enchants the animals so that when their husbands go hunting they are successful in the hunt. So I've sung often with the women in the night. It's very powerful and we just sing and sing and sing. But what we're really doing is after the singing, we're listening to the forest and seeing what's shifted and what's moved. They hear the animals have come in. They've been doing this for thousands of years. It's so beautiful. They're singing without words a lot. So it's the sound of the voice.
35:40When you sing to the forest, you don't need to use words. It's all an interlocking of sound. And they taught me how to become part of that.
35:59So why do you think, Martin, that this Celtic music and this West African singing, these voices go together? We're inherently human and rhythm is part of it and what I find is a lot of the backer music is based around triplet rhythms. They're sort of da-da-da-da-da-da-da-da. And Irish music, their jigs and slip jigs, fits in with it perfectly. So it's quite interesting, when I was first there, they'd be playing a rhythm called boule boule, and I had my mandolin and I'd be playing a slip jig to it because it's in a nine beat, and it intrigued me how it fitted together.
36:41And do the women, do they hear that Celtic music that you're playing? I have taken recordings many times back to them, so they have an idea now of what we've been doing. They really enjoy it. And music is such a great way to communicate. We didn't speak Baca when we first went to the forest. The Baca didn't speak much French. We communicated through music. And we got to know each other and like each other and enjoy this music and enjoy each other's company beautifully like that.
37:16And Martin, we hear a lot about the destruction of rainforests around the world. Are these people a threatened community? I would say yes. I mean, they've seen a lot of changes over the last 30 years. Alcoholism is a big problem because the government wants them to live by the road and that's where the villages are and they're the workforce for the village and the easiest way to get them to work is to basically give them lots of drink and get them in debt and then they have to work until they've paid off the debt. We give them a chance to earn some small money from their music which helps them.
37:49OK, some of it gets spent on drink and partying, but every year I see more people spending more money on looking after their children.
38:08And what do they make of the fact that you're taking their music out to the world, Sue? I got better and better at the singing and at a certain point the women said, yes, you can take our singing beyond the forest. So they gave me permission to help other people to understand how their singing works, which is about sharing and about listening to each other. It's a very beautiful lesson in communication that they've allowed us to share.
38:53Sue Hart and Martin Craddock discussing Baka Bionzio album Sing The World Awake with Martin Venard. One headline before I go. Websites have been taken offline as organisations and companies try to patch two major security flaws in PHP, a coding language which underlines around 70 % of the sites. The former head of Britain's National Cybersecurity Agency told us it was a serious risk to data security, and he urged those running websites to act now to deal with it. I'm Sean Lay. That's The World Tonight. Good night.
40:01We'll see you next time.
Governments and cyber-security agencies around the world are urging online companies to fix flaws in their programming language, or take down their websites. We speak to a technology expert who explains how worried we should be.
Also in the programme, a 74-year-old American man is released from a Russian penal colony. We hear from the lawyer for Stephen Hubbard.
And we take you to the rainforests of Cameroon, where a British music group have been recording the voices and instruments of the people who live in Baka.
(Photo: Hard disk drives at the computer server, as cyber agencies warn that websites may be taken offline while PHP prepares a critical fix, in Berlin, Germany, October 21, 2026. Credit: REUTERS)