1. Podcasts
  2. Therapuss with Jake Shane
  3. Session 149: Billy Eichner
Therapuss with Jake Shane

16 Oct 2026 · 1h 16m · 28 chapters

Episode artwork

Session 149: Billy Eichner

In short

Billy Eichner discusses his memoir Billy on Billy and how his Billy on the Street persona developed, why it works as unscripted street interviews, and why he ended the TV run to focus on online clips and other acting/comedy work. He also talks about pop-culture influence—especially Madonna’s impact on gay visibility and his own life—plus his experiences meeting major celebrities (Madonna, Mariah Carey, Michelle Obama, Big Bird, Joan Rivers). He and the host also debate TV viewing habits (more variety vs. murder/serial-killer shows) and dating/app anxiety, including screenshots of messages on apps.

Guests

Billy Eichner, comedian/actor/host; created Billy on the Street (stage origins in NYC, first street-style videos in 2004; TV series began 2011). He studied theater at Northwestern and became known for unscripted street interviews using his own name.

Key claims

Billy on the Street is inspired by his entertainment obsession but is a character; interactions are never scripted or pre-cast. He ended the TV show after five seasons because audiences mostly watched short online clips. Madonna’s Truth or Dare (1992) helped him feel “cool” as a gay kid. He met Madonna via a Super Bowl segment and later ambushed her during rehearsals without scripting.

Notable examples

David Letterman’s on-street influence; filming with Mariah Carey; a Billy on the Street segment with Michelle Obama and Big Bird without pre-given questions; Madonna’s halftime connection at the 2012 Super Bowl; Joan Rivers advising him to keep going (7 years to Tonight Show).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:48

Billy's Early Career and NYC Life

Billy discusses his early experiences in New York and his journey into comedy.

“You know, we actually met on the worst night of my life.”
4:08

The Birth of 'Billy on the Street'

Billy elaborates on how his stage show evolved into the hit series 'Billy on the Street'.

“I said, what if we go out on the street and I do this to people because I grew up in New York like you.”
5:06

The Persona Behind 'Billy on the Street'

A discussion on the differences between Billy's on-screen persona and his true self.

“So you, but you, that persona in Billy on the Street, you don't think that's you?”
8:20

Memorable Moments from 'Billy on the Street'

Billy shares his favorite moments from the show and interactions with celebrities.

“And I didn't want to go up to a New Yorker in some wacky costume.”
10:20

Transitioning from TV to Other Projects

Billy explains his decision to end the TV show and pursue new opportunities.

“Listen to it because it's called The Meaning of Mariah Carey, I believe.”
13:40

Discussion on Madonna

The hosts dive into their thoughts on Madonna's latest album and her influence.

“There is something I want to ask you about Madonna.”
14:01

Exploring Madonna's Impact

The hosts discuss Madonna's influence on pop music and culture.

“I'm just like, like I just got like, I wanted to come out.”
15:11

Madonna's Role in LGBTQ Visibility

They delve into how Madonna empowered LGBTQ individuals and addressed social issues.

“And I hope it gets, it really deserves like a bunch of Grammys and many great.”
19:09

Personal Revelations and Cultural Impact

The guest shares personal stories about growing up with Madonna's influence.

“Young women, young gay men, or really anyone, anyone at all.”
22:37

Generational Icons

Discussion about how each generation has its own icons following Madonna.

“So that's really a huge part of why I didn't have like the shame a lot of gay kids grow up with and still do.”
Show all 28 chapters
23:22

Meeting Madonna: A Dream Come True

The guest recounts the experience of meeting Madonna and the significance of that moment.

“I really think, and again, I'm a 48 year old man, but like, I think from what I can observe, I think chapel is the next is carrying the torch.”
28:00

Ambushing Madonna: A Fan's Experience

Billy Eichner shares his unforgettable experience ambushing Madonna during her rehearsal.

“I would feel that way about Taylor Swift.”
30:23

Joan Rivers: A Mentor's Influence

Billy recounts his relationship with Joan Rivers and the mentorship she provided during his career struggles.

“My own show had been on, but on a very obscure cable network for, we had only had one season.”
36:20

Struggles of Fame and Relationships

The discussion shifts to balancing fame, personal relationships, and the challenges of the dating scene.

“I can't, you know, agents and managers are dropping me, and I would get a TV deal, but it would fall apart, but I was getting all this press saying how great I was, blah, blah, blah.”
42:01

Navigating Modern Dating Apps

Explore the challenges of dating apps, particularly for public figures.

“They're crazy, but when they're good, it's like drugs.”
44:13

Television Trends and Personal Preferences

Discuss the current trends in television and personal preferences for show types.

“Well, Billy, what are you therapist about today?”
46:31

The Unusual Charm of The Nightmare Before Christmas

Delve into the unique aspects and cultural impact of The Nightmare Before Christmas.

“Oh, I actually don't know if I've seen that either.”
48:07

Reflections on Awards and Recognition

Reflect on the significance of awards and the emotional impact that comes with them.

“The Others with - Oh, The Others is, but that's not in like another level.”
50:10

Pop Culture Excitement and Upcoming Movies

Share excitement about upcoming movies, particularly those with LGBTQ themes.

“And I've been nominated for four Emmys and have lost all four.”
53:16

Musical Influences and Current Listening Favorites

Discuss the impact of music, favorite artists, and new releases that resonate.

“But I don't like that they dump all the good movies at the end of the year.”
56:00

Music Recommendations and Catfishing Stories

The hosts discuss favorite music, catfishing on dating apps, and humorous personal anecdotes.

“And I know her a little bit, but not really.”
57:40

Journaling and Personal Reflection

They delve into the practice of journaling, its benefits, and methods to make it easier.

“And it's creepy too, but also flattering.”
59:00

Navigating Social Scenes and Identity

The conversation shifts to experiences in gay bars, social anxiety, and feelings of belonging.

“And I like to listen to music as I do so.”
1:01:10

The Ethics of Reality TV

Discussion about the ethics of filming strangers and the legality of consent in reality shows.

“Loose is like what you were describing, that 2000s chic little gay thing.”
1:04:50

Dealing with Criticism and Public Perception

They share experiences of facing criticism and how to cultivate a thicker skin in public life.

“No one has ever been on Billy on the Street without giving us their approval.”
1:10:01

Navigating Public Perception

Billy discusses the challenges of public perception and personal identity.

“I'm like, they're talking about me like they really know me.”
1:12:07

Experiencing New York Nightlife

The hosts reflect on their experiences with nightlife in New York, especially in the LGBTQ+ community.

“And so like to have to navigate it in your 20s, I think is a tricky thing.”
1:14:17

Dark Tales and Nostalgia

The conversation shifts to a listener's childhood story, exploring themes of nostalgia and dark experiences.

“and I'm excited to be a part of it soon for my golden birthday.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Therapuss with Jake Shane, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00At ZocDoc, we know you care about your health. You wouldn't do that early morning cardio if you didn't. So the fact that your annual physical is overdue just shows how hard it can be to get seen by a doctor. Sorry, that doctor's not in network. Press 1 for more options. You've reached us outside normal business hours. The next availability is in three months. But ZocDoc makes finding the right doctor easy. Download the app and search by specialty, insurance, and availability. Read real patient reviews, then book instantly. ZocDoc, ready to be seen?

0:41His new memoir, Billy on Billy, is out now. Please welcome to the show the legendary Billy Eichner. Hi. Hi. Therapist. Therapist. We meet at last. We meet at last. You know, we actually met on the worst night of my life. Oh, was that the worst night of your life? So far. Okay, you're young. It'll get worse. I know. I know you don't think it will, but it will. I know. It wasn't terrible, though. But the way that you know exactly what I'm talking about. Oh, I guess that's a good point. But we met at a fun location. That was so fun. I mean, that was, I had the time, I had a ball there. Yes, that party.

1:18That party was quite fun. Quite fun. Quite fun. Do you prefer LA or New York? I'm a New Yorker. Uh-huh. Like you, I grew up here. I know. I don't mind LA. I like L.A. Did you spend, when you were, well, I guess most of your career has been here, right? Almost everything I've ever shot, shot here, except Parks and Recreation. And American Horror Story was in L.A. American Horror Story. Oh, yes. Were you a Glee fan? I did like Glee, but I was older already. I'm much older than you. How old are you? 48. Okay. Yeah. You were like, oh, you really are. Well, I was just because we had **** on the show and she was like, your 20s suck.

2:04Your 30s are great. Your 40s suck. Your 50s are great. You know what? That is, I am relieved to hear that because I agree. Okay. And I'm in my 40s. And yeah, it's different than I thought. What's different about it? I thought early 40s was actually just felt like an extension of my 30s. And I think in your early 40s, you're kind of wanting to prove to yourself that like, nothing's changed. Right. Like, you know what I mean? Like, it's still like my 30s, which it was. And then mid 40s and up feels different. You've lived a while. So you can look back on all the things that went right and wrong.

2:39And you've got time ahead of you, but you really need to make use of that time. Right. You know? So time starts feeling fleeting. Yes. You can feel time more a little bit. You feel the pressure of time. Ooh. But did you think you felt that way in your 20s, but you actually look back and you're Like, I can't believe I felt that way. I think I really wanted to be successful and was just kind of worried about, like, oh, God, is my life going to be okay? Yeah. But I didn't feel that, oh, I had to be successful by 30 or else it was over. Right. I felt like I had time. I was good at romanticizing the struggle of being, trying to be a professional artist or actor or whatever I am.

3:21Right. Professional artist and actor. Yeah. Does that make sense? That makes sense. How old are you? Do you want to guess? You're 27? I'm 26. 26. But I turned 27 in a few weeks. You're so young. Well, lately I felt young. Lately I felt young. You are young. I didn't know you started Billy on the Street when you were 32. Well, it started before that in my 20s in my live show. Right. Which you didn't see and very few people saw here in New York before YouTube even existed. Yeah, it was a stage show, right? I had a stage show called Creation Nation where I, that's where the Billy on the Street persona developed live on stage.

3:58And then I said to my friend who was directing the show, who I went to college with, I said, you know, people in the audience seem to like when I do this guy and I'm getting like very angry about pop culture and I'm bringing this kind of irrational urgency and intensity to pop culture topics. I said, what if we go out on the street and I do this to people because I grew up in New York like you. So I know, you know, you're on the street in New York, you're walking around with blinders on, right? No one's really acknowledging other people. And so I thought, what if I break that rule and force someone who's like rushing to the subway or to get on the bus or go into daycare or their job or the gym and just make them talk to me about whether or not Kate Winslet would win the Oscar.

4:42Right. You know, like bring in that amount of intensity to these pop culture topics. That's how it started. And I would cut together videos with my friend Jamie to show on a screen. We would project them on a screen that this theater I performed in in New York had a screen. And that's before YouTube even started. I think the first Billy on the Street style video I made was in 2004. Wow. So I am how old at that point? 25, something like that. and then the TV show, it took about seven years of kind of pounding the pavement, literally and figuratively, and then Billy on the Street becomes, it starts to go viral around 2010, and then the TV version happens in 2011.

5:27So you, but you, that persona in Billy on the Street, you don't think that's you? No, not at all. Okay, so that was interesting for me to read. I thought that was like... I know, people still think this. I thought that was like you. Well, it's inspired by this kind of obsession with entertainment that I had since I was a kid. Yes. So it really was kind of satirizing my own feelings about entertainment. But it's always so surprising to me. People for years, and I've done many other things, but they're still very surprised that it's not. I was surprised. Yeah. I think it's because what I grew up in is like everyone that go, like when you go viral on TikToker, it's for exactly as you present.

6:13It's you. Yeah. It's like I wasn't making up these characters or anything. That makes perfect sense. But I didn't grow up in a world of influencers. We didn't have social media. Like what you do did not exist when I was in my 20s. Right. And so I was being a performer in my, you know, I went to theater school. I went to Northwestern. I came back to New York to try to be an actor on Broadway and off Broadway, but that really wasn't happening. And so I started writing and performing comedy as a way to just get an agent, honestly, because people thought I was funny. And then on stage, I developed, I evolved into this character, basically, you know, to me, it was the same as like Sacha Baron Cohen doing Borat, right.

6:54But I wasn't doing a wacky accent or putting myself in a wacky costume and changing my name. So I think that's another reason why people think it's me because I always said I'm Billy Eichner and I'm on Billy on the street. Right. Right. Um, but to, but I always thought it was kind of clear to most people that I was doing what we used to call like a shtick. Yeah. You know, we still have shticks. We still have shtick. Yeah. Yeah. I would, I do shticks sometimes. Do you? Like some, well, like, no. Are you, do you feel that the Jake that we all see is this exactly you like unfortunately yes okay so like that's my like that's what i was like oh okay like you know what i mean like i think that's a generational thing yeah i was like oh like the the jake i present i mean i don't know louise would you say that this is who i am oh she said she said let me get her mic extremely extremely oh yeah okay well well that's yeah yeah Yeah, for me, it wasn't.

7:51For me, I had created this character but was using my own name. And the reason I kept using my own name and because I didn't want to change my last name or be in a wacky costume is because I wanted people to know that these interactions were real. Right. And I didn't want people on the street that I was going up to because all of that is completely real, unstaged. Like, we've never cast a person in advance. None of that has ever been scripted at all. You can tell. Yeah. And that's why it works. I think why people like it. And I didn't want to go up to a New Yorker in some wacky costume. Yeah. Because then they're going to know like, oh, this guy's a clown.

8:28Right. Right. I wanted them to think it's, I want, I'm trying to have a serious interview. Do you have a favorite Billy on the Street moment? There are so many I love. I mean, when it got to the point where we could have other actors and people that I grew up loving on the show, I'm sure you've had similar experiences like Amy Poehler. and didn't Seth Meyers do Seth Meyers and Will Ferrell and David Letterman did it right David fucking Letterman that was huge for me because I grew up watching him and worshiping him and also Dave you know at that point had kind of stopped doing segments like that yeah his his producers told me that when Dave did Billy on the Street he hadn't done a segment in the field as they say in years.

9:14But in the 80s, when I would watch his show at 1230 on NBC before he even was out on an 1130, he started at 1230. He was doing a lot of on the street stuff with New Yorkers. Oh yeah. He, he was way ahead of me on that. I, he was my inspiration and I just loved his sensibility so much. So the fact that he was willing to be on the street with me, and I remember we were walking around Chelsea. I think it had maybe been a minute since David Letterman was just kind of strolling around Manhattan at that point. And I remember we were walking around Chelsea and he was like, oh, that's the Chelsea Hotel.

9:49And I was like, yeah, Dave, that's the Chelsea Hotel. You know what I mean? Yeah. We shot with Mariah Carey. How was that? I love Mariah Carey. I mean, she's the best. She's so funny. And she's also a New Yorker. She is? Up until recently, Mariah actually lived not far from here. I don't know if she sold it yet or not. So she's a real New Yorker. And she actually, before her career took off, I think she lived in Chelsea, actually, when she was first starting to write songs. I think so. If you listen to her book, she talks about it. Okay. Her book is major. Amazing. I've never read her. What's it called?

10:23Listen to it because it's called The Meaning of Mariah Carey, I believe. She reads it. She does it like impressions of Aretha Franklin, which are really, really funny. She does impressions. She sings a little bit, but she also talks about her parents in a very honest, very moving way. Okay. It's serious. Yeah, well, I don't read, so I appreciate your book is audio only. My book is audio only. Yeah. Right, exactly. But yeah, Mariah shot with me. We once did a segment with Michelle Obama. I remember that. And Big Bird was there. And you didn't give her the questions before, though. No, we did not.

11:01That was my one stipulation because she was the first lady at the time. Yeah. They were still in the White House. And, you know, I think they were used to for things like this. You know, they all wanted to make sure she was prepared and all of that. And I said to them, I was like, look, she couldn't be out on the street with me for security reasons. That I understood. But I said, we cannot script this out because everyone's going to be able to tell. It needs to keep the spontaneity of Billy on the street. So I completely understand that you're the first lady of the United States and you're like a beloved figure to me and many others.

11:37But in order for it to work and to really breathe and be the show that you like, we can plan it all out in advance. And we did not. And it was amazing. And it was good. And then when did you know it was time to end the show? I did five seasons of the TV show which is like you know we're doing 10 or 12 half hour episodes every year and then mix that with all the stuff before even it was even on years of doing it before whether or not people saw it I was doing it yeah you know and I like I said for me it is a very much a character yeah you know and I didn't start out really wanting to be a comedian I liked comedy.

12:20I liked comedy movies. I liked comedy. I like sitcoms and things, but I wasn't someone who ever wanted to do a standup tour. Yeah. Do you know what I mean? Um, so I wanted to carve out time for me to, to try other things, to try to get back to being the type of actor that I initially started out wanting to be. Like I said, I went to theater school. I went to Northwestern. It's kind of a serious theater program, you know, not to sound pretentious. Isn't it the, it's that, that's the most serious one. That and Carnegie. There are other, I mean, there's, Northwestern is great at a lot of things. It's obviously not just a theater school, but oh, there's many, there's Juilliard and there's a million places.

12:59But, um, but you know, I took it very seriously. And like I said, I just wanted to do theater. And so I knew I could keep Billy on the street going forever. Um, I also knew practically speaking that, you know, the world was changing. Everything was moving online. And I knew people were mostly watching Billy on the street from seeing the clips online. So I thought two things. Number one, I'm killing myself spending 10 months of the year to make half hour episodes. And then people watch a two minute clip online. So I can probably still keep that going online and also open up my schedule to do other types of things.

13:38Right. So that's what I did. Interesting. Yeah. There is something I want to ask you about Madonna. Love. I, I love Madonna as well. I've never gotten like a proper intro to her. First of all, are you happy with her album? It's so good. It is really good. Now let me, let me ask you now. I am the core Madonna audience. I'm a 48 year old gay man who, you know, when like a virgin came out you know what that is yes no but i get a lot i get a lot of shit from do you for not knowing like the deep cuts i and i but i i'm brave enough to admit that i don't know them it's extremely brave i know it's scary it's really scary it is um i'm scared for you no i'm not gonna give you shit for it i will say in a way you're lucky you have so much to discover that's how i thought it i viewed it as well but are you are you doing the homework and are you listening i'm yes like when i heard lower east side girl i was like well now i'm very interested in her life like leading up to the madonna that she now is today by the way lower east side girl that's a good cut to not everyone mentions that i know the album that i know that's a good one it's a very moving song yes that well that one was my favorite oh okay yeah interesting it's a beautiful song i like it's like you know well because i think when the confessions two came out i wasn't necessarily in the mood to dance oh not in like a sad way i was just like i'm not in mood to dance.

15:04You're just tired. Yeah. I'm just like, like I just got like, I wanted to come out. It came out this summer, right? Yeah. It came out early July. Okay. And I hope it gets, it really deserves like a bunch of Grammys and many great. You want it for album of the year? Oh yeah. Madonna has never won. Am I wrong about that? Ray of light won pop album, but I don't think it won album of the year. Okay. I'm pretty sure it did not. I'm a pretty diehard fan, but now I want to make sure. No, I don't think she won Album of the Year. I think you would know. That's crazy. That is crazy. Mother fucking Madonna.

15:41The world of pop music as we know it, it doesn't exist without Madonna. Can you explain that to me? Oh, Jesus. Please. I've just said, please. I want to know. I want to know. This is a big topic. Like, I know everything about Mariah Carey. Okay. So, like, I love Mariah Carey. I love her too. I know that there is, the two can exist at the same time, but, like, I have a hard time paying attention and multiple people at once. Okay. I have no excuse, actually. I love Mariah, too. They're very different artists. Madonna, boy. You know, Jake, like my bar mitzvah, there was a life-size spray-painted, airbrushed cutout of Madonna.

16:20Right. Like this is deep for me. Madonna. Oh, God. How do you sum up Madonna? What do you want to know? Ask me questions. influence so you want to know why she's so influential no i know why she's so i know that she did things that people like weren't necessarily doing that's right like she behaved like a like a rock and roll star but she was like a pop girl right it's actually there was something very punk about madonna's attitude and the way she presented herself and how much control she took over her career and how and her artistry and how um unapologetic she was um and as a woman but really as compared to any artist, male or female, I mean, she, she had an incredible amount of self possession and defiance and she coupled that she, she, she did all of that in this pop dance genre where those two things like had not really been melded together like that.

17:20Right. I'm not sure I'm being as articulate as I could be. That makes perfect sense. Um, she also really, um, I mean, for us is you're gay. Yes. Yeah, you identify? Yes. As a gay man, you should know about Madonna because when I was growing up, you saw very few out gay men on TV, right? Even on MTV, which was considered like the cutting edge, right? And Madonna had a huge impact on my life because she surrounded herself with out gay men. And she turned dancers. Her brother, Christopher Ciccone, who designed two of her best, most iconic tours, who sadly died recently. Yes, that's who Fragile is about, right?

18:02Was that? That's who Fragile is about, right? Yes. Yes, the song on her album. See, I know some of my stuff. You do, you do, you do. I'm being patient. Yeah. But, you know, she uplifted him. She really, like, I mean, she was the center of it all, but she surrounded herself and really empowered gay men. She loved gay men for their creativity, for their attitude, for their artistry. And she also really empathized with what gay men were going through. You know, she was really good friends with Keith Haring, you know, the famous gay artist who died of AIDS, you know. And then she becomes a huge force for fundraising and for raising awareness at the peak of the AIDS crisis.

18:43So for the most popular star on MTV, you know, arguably like her and Michael Jackson at the time. Yeah, yeah. to be that vocal about AIDS and about standing up for, for gay men and to help make gay men that visible. She has a documentary called truth or dare, which if you've never seen that go and watch this, anyone watching this, you have a lot of younger fans, right? Young women, young gay men, or really anyone, anyone at all. But especially if you're, I feel so fucking old, but like but but especially if you're trying to be a young artist she came out with a documentary called truth or dare in 1992 now you might look at it and say like well that looks like a reality show there were no reality shows right like this was like this no holds barred look at her behind the scenes while she put on the blonde ambition tour which was like the clip when they were like we're gonna arrest you if you go out on stage and she said well then arrest me exactly she was simulating masturbation on stage during like a virgin and in toronto they threatened to arrest her if she went on stage in toronto strangely yeah wow i was not expecting that from toronto well you never know this was also like 1990 things were a little different uh oh yeah the vatican was trying to like excommunicate her from the church i think she might have been um i know like see i know i know the kits and the classics and the big ones and like you know But it's an incredible documentary, and I went to see this with my parents.

20:14I tell this story in my book, Mother's Day Weekend, 1991. I was very lucky as a gay kid at that time. I wasn't out, but it was pretty clear. I mean, Madonna bar mitzvah. Exactly. There you go. So my parents knew. They took me to see this documentary, Truth or Dare, the weekend it came out. I sat in between them, and on screen, in one of the behind-the-scenes moments from the movie, they play truth or dare, her and her dancers, who were almost all out gay men. Now, to even see that many out gay men on the big screen at that point, alongside like the coolest music star of the era, in my opinion of all time, but especially of that era, right?

21:00And it wasn't about them being victims at all. And you're seeing their artistry as dancers, and then they play truth or dare. And two of them are dared to make out with each other, right? And they make out and the camera like goes in for a close up. And I sat there watching this as a 13 year old kid in 1991 with my parents. And they didn't seem particularly uncomfortable with it. You just didn't see I know now you can go on Instagram and you see like every gay guy and he's with his boyfriend, everyone's naked and fucking all the time. And like, you know, it's all like, there's so much more visibility that it's like, it's like, it feels like what I'm describing happened on a different planet, but it was so rare to see that in those days.

21:49And so to see that, like it just, um, it, to see that and just also know that my parents were okay with it. Like something like clicks in your head, you're like, oh, like, I'm cool. Like, I grew up thinking that gay men were so cool. I was so excited to, like, eventually come out of the closet and be part of gay male culture in New York and in the world. And a lot of that is because, like, Madonna made it seem so cool. Yeah. Do you know what I mean? Like, I didn't really connect shame with being gay. Some of that was the fact that I grew up in New York City. Some of the fact, a big part of it, and this is a lot of what my book is.

22:29It was the fact that my parents were so liberal and so supportive and encouraging of me as a gay person, as an artist, as everything. I was very, very, very lucky. So that's really a huge part of why I didn't have like the shame a lot of gay kids grow up with and still do. But also it was the artists I looked up to, right? They empowered gay men. They talked about gay issues. They surrounded themselves with creative gay men and Madonna was at the top of that list. Yeah. I think that's how I felt about Lady Gaga as a kid. Of course. Yeah. Like Gaga for you, I was older already by the time Gaga comes around, but every generation has their Madonna.

23:08Yeah. Every generation of young gay men, young LGBTQ people, young women like has their Madonna, but it did start with Madonna. Would you say it goes Madonna, Gaga, Chapel? I was literally just going to say that. Yeah. I really think, and again, I'm a 48 year old man, but like, I think from what I can observe, I think chapel is the next is carrying the torch. And there are others. Yeah. Have you ever seen her live? I've only seen clips. She's unbelievable. Yeah. From what I've seen, she looks amazing. Have you ever met Madonna? Yes, I did a few times, but, um, I did a Billy on the Street style video with Madonna.

23:48Oh, wow. Which I talk about in the book. It happened really early on, though. It's a strange story. So Billy on the Street, the TV show, started. And at the same time, Conan O 'Brien had his talk show still. And he hired me, his show hired me to do Billy on the Street segments for his show. And the first thing they asked me to do was to go to the Super Bowl that year and cover the Super Bowl. And I was like, yeah, of course. I was like, I was desperate to do anything. But then I got off the phone with them and I was like, what the fuck am I going to do at the Super Bowl? Like, I'm not a sports guy.

24:24Like, what am I going to cover? Like, in Billy on the Street style. And then I realized the halftime show was Madonna. It was like a gift from the universe. Yeah, from literal God. Right, exactly. And I called up Conan's people. I said, okay, here's my take on the Super Bowl. We go to the Super Bowl. It was in Indianapolis that year. And I'm doing Billy on the street, but I'm only asking people going to the Super Bowl about Madonna. I don't care about the game at all. Now, in the years since, this has become kind of an ongoing joke on Twitter and social media. I'm only watching for the halftime show and things like that.

25:02But that joke wasn't being made as much. This is back in 2012. So kind of before social media as we know it, really, exploded. And they said, great. They thought that was a really funny idea. Make a long story short, I go to the Super Bowl. It's still on YouTube. It's a really funny video. It culminates with me. I'm walking around Super Bowl Village. I'm asking people like, you excited about Madonna? And all these like old straight white guys are like, fuck Madonna. She's old. And I'm like, you're fucking old. And I'm like getting up in their faces, like really defending Madonna. And then And at the end of the game, Conan's team somehow got me like crazy access, like access that like a sports journalist would get.

25:45Right, right. And also no one knows me at this point. Very few people know me. So I could really get away with some shit. And I just had my big parka on and I look like I work for ESPN or something, you know, like this like big guy, like, you know, at the Super Bowl. It's like one would assume I'm interested in the game. And at the end, I run onto the field. The Giants win the Super Bowl, actually. The New York Giants win the Super Bowl. And I run out onto the field. There's, like, confetti falling. The Super Bowl trophy's out. The players are crying. These, like, grown men are crying. You know, their families are running out onto the field.

26:20All the journalists are running out onto the field to interview the guys who just won. And I run up to the New York Giants, and I'm like, hey, you know, congratulations, man. And they just think I'm a guy from, you know, covering sports. And they're like, thanks, man. It was a great game, blah, blah. And then I was like, did you see Madonna? Right. And I go up to all these New York Giants and ask them about Madonna right after they won the Super Bowl. Right. And they were just looking at me. They were so confused that I wasn't asking about the game. And one of them looks at me. You can go on YouTube and see that.

26:50One of them looks at me. He was like, Madonna. I don't know. I was in the locker room. Like it was halftime and they didn't even see it. So her team, Madonna's team, then is made aware of this video. It went like sort of viral. It's a funny video. And her team was really excited about it. Because she had an album coming out and a tour starting. This was MDNA is the album. By the way, and I knew that. And I knew that. I just want you to know that I knew that. Okay. I knew that. I appreciate that. But, and then that started a conversation with me and her team, which ended up with me, her publicist reached out to me and said, she loved the video I made so much.

27:33And she said, if there's one thing I do, I'm getting you on camera with Madonna. And I was like, are you fucking kidding me? Like, just the email alone, I was like, like, I couldn't believe it was happening. Even if it never happened, I was like, just this email, I'm going to frame. Like, I knew so much about Madonna. I knew her publicist's name from reading about Madonna for 20 years. Like, Liz Rosenberg, no longer her publicist, but like, was for a very long time. And Cher's publicist and Stevie Nicks and a lot of people. So I was literally starstruck by Madonna's publicist. I would feel that way about Taylor Swift.

28:04Totally I totally get it Yeah I totally Yeah yes And so And the publicist came through Yeah And Madonna ends up bringing that tour To Yankee Stadium I think she was the first woman To headline Yankee Stadium Wow Solo at least And And they said Okay You can ambush Madonna She's gonna be on stage Rehearsing her show The whole Like the afternoon before the concert And I knew she couldn't be on the street with me Like going up to people obviously but at least this felt outside and like you know it felt like it had the spirit of billy on the street and they said like michelle obama's team they said we know you can script it she knows you're coming would you have scripted it for madonna that would be really hard because it's i really don't want to script it and here's the lesson madonna taught me as a kid madonna would never script it.

28:58Right. You know? And so I would try to hold on to that Madonna defiance if I could. It's a good question though. Luckily she was like, we don't want you to script it. We want you to do your thing. She knows that you're coming at some point, but then it's, we don't know what's going to happen. You can say whatever you want and she's just going to respond to you. And we did. I ambushed her twice during her rehearsal and I'm on stage with Madonna and her dancers. Her kids were there. They were very young at that point. I don't know about Lourdes, but Rocco was there. He's like a baby. And so we didn't script it out.

29:30And I am literally shouting in Madonna's face. Now, what was really hard for me too is that I knew it would be out of character for me to start fangirling out about Madonna. That's not Billy on the street. Like he gets angry. Oh, so this is where the character. Yes. Yes, okay. Yeah, exactly. And so I had to stay true to the persona or whatever you want to call it. And I was like, okay, I can't just like fangirl out at Madonna. I have to kind of keep that inside. And I have to find a reason to get angry at her. Right? Yeah. And I had already seen the tour. And I knew that on this tour, she was not performing Vogue.

30:10And so I shouted at Madonna and she shouted back to me. And it's fucking great. Yeah. Wow. And was in that moment where you like, I could stop for like doing this forever now and I'd be happy. It was strange because it was only 2012. My own show had been on, but on a very obscure cable network for, we had only had one season. I don't even think I had many viral videos yet. And so it happened strangely early, the way that it worked out. Like it was odd in that way, you know? I was like, this is all happening too fast. Like this is like my fucking icon, legend, like the most inspirational artistic force in my life.

30:48And I'm already meeting her. Like it's almost too fast in a way, but it was surreal and it was great. And, um, uh, and I made her laugh too. Cause I think she's a hard laugh, you know, to get, she tries to, you know, Madonna tries to stay real tough. Yeah. And she did kind of laugh out loud, like uncontrollably at one point. And I, in my mind, I thought I did it. I'm proud of that moment. And I have that, like a screen grab of her laughing. Like I like printed that out and I, oh, that's amazing. Yeah. God, that's so awesome. It's pretty cool. And I also, you were very close with Joan Rivers. Yes, I was.

31:27Who I know everything about. Oh. So that. See, now that doesn't track with your huge lack of knowledge about other topics. I know. Yeah. I know. But Joan Rivers, my mom and I would watch together growing up. Oh, I watched Joan Rivers with my dad and my parents too. And I learned that you were about to quit and she sat down and basically told you not to. Totally. That really happened. So Joan Rivers, oh God, this is a long story. I'm going to - No, wait, I'm here for the long story. What happened was I was doing my live show, the one where the Billy on the Street video started that I told you about.

32:06And at the time, the original queer eye for the straight guy, the original. Yes, I remember the original. Back in 2006. How old were you? Six, but I remember the original. Okay, got it. Because my mom was like, you should watch it. You were like, I am interested in this, even though I'm only six. So the original Queer Eye was on was a big hit. Bravo was looking for, I guess, other shows that involved gay men. Again, very rare for 2006. And they put together a talk show pilot for Joan Rivers. And it was called Joan Rivers Straight Talk. And the joke was that it was Joan Rivers. and like the view was Barbara Walters and four different types of women.

32:47This was gonna be Joan Rivers and four different types of gay men and it was called Joan Rivers Straight Talk, LOL. Yeah. And they came to my live show to kind of see if I could be one of the panelists because they'd heard about my live show and Joan came to my show. This was a show being done at this off-Broadway theater. And you didn't know Joan at this point? No. Okay. and Joan came to my show and then I went in and I auditioned and I got it so I was one of the panelists and it was me and Andy Cohen before he had his own show and two other guys LZ Granderson was one of them and Preston Conrad was the fourth Preston Conrad who now I think works for Entertainment Tonight or something like that um extra maybe and so I got this job I shoot the pilot with Joan.

33:39It doesn't get picked up, but Joan kept coming to my live show. She loved me. She really did. And like, I don't know how else to say it. Like, it was crazy to me. She was one of the comics I grew up like Letterman watching on TV with my parents late at night. You know, Joan was the first live standup show that I ever saw when I was a kid. My parents and I used to go to this like pool club in the Bronx called Shorehaven in the 80s. It's a very kind of New York thing. And Joan came to perform once, but she did an 18 and over standup show because she was so raunchy. Yeah. She cursed so much and they didn't want any kids in the show to go to the show.

34:19So, but I begged my dad, I was like, I'm literally like seven years old, but I knew Joan from TV already. And I begged my dad, I was like, please sneak me into the Joan Rivers standup show. And he did. And it's a very sweet story in my book because I was a little kid. So my dad's like holding me on his shoulders so I can watch Joan Rivers make jokes about menopause. Yeah. You know, and I'm like a seven year old child. Right. And then fast forward, like, I don't know, it was like 20 years later, I'm with Joan and making this pilot with her. And she, even though the pilot didn't get picked up, she really, she just really wanted to champion me and support me.

34:53And it was amazing. And I didn't know famous people at this point, let alone Joan. I mean, she's such a groundbreaking figure. And she's so fucking funny. She was so fucking funny off camera too. And she had this amazing, she loved being famous in a not, not in like a weird way where it's like desperate in a way that people coming up, she used to tell me, this is a lesson I have remembered. She used to tell me, she used to get so mad when she would hear famous people complain about fans approaching them on the street. Because she said, what's better than someone you don't know, a stranger, coming up to you and saying, I love you.

35:35Yeah. I love your work. It's awesome. You mean something to me. Yeah. Why do these fucking idiots in Hollywood complain about that? They're desperate to be famous, and then they want to live these lives where a real person who works a nine-to-five job is not allowed to come up to them and say, I'm your fan. Can you imagine what she would have to say about Chaparron? Oh, God.

35:55God, that would be funny. It would be so fucking funny. That's such a good call. And that, when Joan said that to me one day, I wasn't a known person yet, but that really stuck with me. And it's such a good lesson to learn. Because weird shit happens in your head when you're famous. And so Joan became a really big champion of mine. But then that pilot doesn't get picked up, and I keep having these close calls with jobs on TV, but I can't get arrested. I can't get a job. I can't, you know, agents and managers are dropping me, and I would get a TV deal, but it would fall apart, but I was getting all this press saying how great I was, blah, blah, blah.

36:36But if I was so great, why can't I get a job? Right. You know, it's that sort of weird show business thing that happens. And I reached out to Joan in 2009, and I emailed her, and I said, Joan, she always left herself very open for me to get in touch with her, but I didn't want to bother her too much. but I, this time I did cause I really needed to talk to her. And I said, Joan, I'm so frustrated. I don't understand. Like everyone is giving me all these compliments, but I can't get a paying job. Like how long? And I was, I was 30 at this point. And I don't know, when you turn 30, it starts to sound a little less cute, you know, that you're struggling, you know?

37:12And so I said to her, can you give me some advice here? Like how much longer should I hold on at this like crazy dream. I'm like a, I come from a middle-class family in Queens. Like we weren't wealthy. We had no connections in Hollywood. Like, you know, it was going to require what felt like a miracle for me to break through, but I was determined, you know? And Joan said, come to my show. She was doing a weekly standup show. And Joan said, come to my show and then we'll have drinks upstairs. It was in the basement of a restaurant she was performing in. And then we'll talk. And I, and we did. And, um, she just gave me the greatest pep talk of all time.

37:52And she said, how many years have you been doing this? And I said, 10. And she said, okay, it took me seven years to get on the tonight show. She said, sometimes it takes a long time, but, and she was very, very nice. And she just said that, you know, she told me that she had watched Billy Crystal come up and Robin Williams come up and all these other comics come up and that she thought that I had the talent to make it, you know, and she said, I've seen all these guys when they were young and I knew they would make it and they made it. And she said, I think you just have to hold on a little longer and you're going to make it.

38:29And I said, okay, like you're Joan Rivers. Right. And I actually went home and like called my dad. My dad was incredibly supportive, like ridiculously supportive and wanted it so bad, wanted, wanted it to happen so badly for me. Um, and my, my whole book is basically about my dad and my parents just being so nice, really. Um, and I, but I was 30 and he was starting to worry about me. You know, it's like, what are you going to do with your life? Like how long do you hold onto this dream? Like we're not rich people. Like you need health insurance, like basic life things that I was not getting at the time.

39:07You know, I was not figuring that part of life out, like fundamentals of life. But I went home and I called and I was like, dad, I just saw Joan. She says, I have to hold on a little while longer. And she thinks I'm going to make it. And my dad was like this guy from the Bronx, you know, and he was like, well, if Joan says it, you got to do it. Yeah, that's what he said. Those were his exact words. And so it was a pep talk for my dad. It was a pep talk for me. And a year later, my first video goes viral. Wow. And slowly but surely, you know, things happened. Wow. Yeah. That's incredible. Yeah.

39:41Did you enjoy, so you spent your twenties in New York? Yeah. Were you able to like, enjoy, like what was, what did dating look like for you when? Oh yeah. I was a maniac. Okay. Like what do you mean? I still am. Okay. But like, what do you mean? Cause like, I like, Like, I feel like - Are you dating someone? No. No. No. I know. I want to. Sore subject? Well, I was watching Bros yesterday. I was like, I'm so triggered by this right now. Like, I can't even. Oh. Yeah. Couldn't finish it. No, I finished it. I finished it. But I was incredibly - You're not alone, Jake. I was incredibly triggered. Oh.

40:14Because I was like, oh my God. It made you want a boyfriend? Yeah, kind of. Yeah. Yeah. But I was like, these people are kind of impossible sometimes. Yes. person I want is like this, the guy in bros. That's what, that's what the movie's about. Yeah. That we are impossible with each other as gay men. Yeah. Maybe all people are like that. I've never been straight, so I don't know. But I do think that there, there are unique things to being two men trying to date. Yeah. It's, you know, it's cause it's like, it's, it, is it about sex or is it about emotion? Cause it's a lot about sex. And then it's like, also it can be a lot, it's like very confusing.

40:53What are your issues with dating? I don't know. I don't put myself out there. You don't. Well, then it's really not going to happen. I know. But you're a kid. Sorry. That's so condescending sounding. No, please. I would like to hear it. But to me, you're a kid. Yeah. I'm still single. I'm 48 years old. So. And have you ever had a boyfriend? Yes, but very few serious relationships. Really? Yeah. And. But I didn't want one until I got older. Okay. Maybe I think I want one and I don't actually want one. I think that's it. I think that must be it. I think you not putting yourself out there is like kind of your body and soul not really needing it yet in a way.

41:31Also, you're 26 years old. Yeah, about to be 27. About to be 27. You're on top of the world. You're working. I follow you on Instagram. I don't even know. Where does the energy come from? You're in Monaco on a boat. Oh, best weekend of my life. You're working out. You're doing, I'm following your fitness journey. I mean, you have a lot going on, Jake. So just do, I don't know. This is a time in your life to get your career, it's already going, but to like get it where you want to go and have fun. Yeah. Have fun. You don't need a boyfriend right now. I know, you're right. But crushes are so fun, aren't they?

42:09Crushes are great. They'll drive you crazy. They're crazy, but when they're good, it's like drugs. It's like when they're good, they hit, and it's the best feeling in the entire world. Are you on apps? Well, I was. I was on all of them. Yeah. And then I whittled it down to just Raya, which is like they matched me with someone in like Dubai. That one isn't good. Yeah. It's not good for gay guys. I don't think it's. Well, I have straight, my straight friends show up on my Raya. Right. Because they're like, we're out of people who show you. Or it's like some really beautiful guy who lives in Portugal.

42:41Yeah. So why did you go off the others? Because you're famous. Well, Manny scared me. Wait, why? Well I'm scary I just am scared for you People would sometimes be mean to me on there What? Yes What do you mean? Like people I don't know if you know this But like people now Like will screenshot Like your messages And like they'll put them on Twitter And like I'm just like so uncomfortable That fucking sucks Yeah What is wrong With people? I know That it's fundamentally wrong But it still happens And it gives me a lot of anxiety So every message I send I'm like thinking about oh my god well is someone gonna screenshot this and make fun of me because it hasn't happened but I've seen it happen to other gay people and it like gives me like jolts of anxiety I understand that you know if that's happened to me I'm not aware of it I think maybe sorry to constantly be like I'm older than you I'm older than you but like I think because I'm older and I'm probably dealing with an older like demographic of guys on those things maybe it's less likely that like a 45 year old is going to be like, I just spoke to Billy Eichner on Hinge, you know, or maybe they don't want anyone to know.

43:52It's also possible. Yeah. But, um, that might be it. You know, I don't know. Uh, that sucks. I'm sorry. No, it's fine. You know, your life is great and it's kind of a, it's a, you know, it's an interesting life to like do what you do and what I do. It's unusual. It is unusual. Well, Billy, what are you therapist about today? Oh, shit. What am I therapist about? What am I angry about? There's so much to be angry about. See, there is so much. Okay. I wish there were more shows on TV that were not about murder and serial killers. Oh, my God. I could not disagree more. It's not that there aren't great shows.

44:37I just sometimes, it feels like we used to have more of a variety of shows. Like, just shows about normal people. Friday Night Lights. Funny people. Yeah, sure. Friday Night Lights. Or like, you know, I'm thinking like. Six Feet Under. I love Six Feet Under. See, I know my references. You do. To an extent. Yeah. I don't know. Like, that's just something I think about as a writer. Like, you know, I don't know. We used to have shows that were just about people where there was no murder involved. You sound like my dad. I know people. What's that? You sound like my dad. I'm old. I know. I sound like an old man.

45:13That's why he hates all those shows too. I don't hate them. I don't hate them. I'm just saying like we used to have more variety. Like I want more like, you know, I'm a softie inside. I want like more Gilmore Girls and more like Sex and the City. You're not a Gilmore Girl person? Wow. I can't. I just, really, I've tried and I'm like, it's not for me. I'm so sorry. That's totally fine. I love Girls. Girls is my favorite show of all time. Okay, that's a great show. My other favorite show of all time is this show called Dark. Yeah, you talk about that. I've never seen that. I love that you know that.

45:41Yes, I watch your show. It is a German show that you would hate. Why would I hate it? Dark is about a little German boy named Michal, and he goes missing in a small German town. And Jonas, his brother, tries to find him. Why can't I watch that? You can. It's on Netflix. I just don't think you would like it. Why? It's about murder. Oh, oh, oh, I see. It's about murder. I love murder. Don't get me wrong. I love murder. but like you know I love a serial killer I was on American Horror Story I know you were on the I enjoyed it I love doing it you know I'm just saying it's it feels like so it's so much of what people watch it must be escapism people I think it is for me that's the thing I think you're right but for me it's not an escape I'm like I have so much anxiety already the world is so dark and brutal that I can't believe like people go home at night crash on their couch and they want to escape into what an even darker scenario i know um what am i watching i i tend to watch a lot of things um that are related to things i'm writing okay so right now i am um i'm about to pitch a christmas movie oh that has music in it uh-huh can't say much more about that so i'm watching things that are kind of in that world that i will admit i i had never seen until this week Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas.

47:06Oh, I actually don't know if I've seen that either. You've never heard about it? No, I've, please. Yeah, it's a classic. Yes. Yeah. I've heard about it, but I think I might have seen it when I was a kid. Yeah. It's great from what I recall. I missed it and just watched it as a grown man. And what was that like? It's great. It's very unusual. It's very smart. Christmas movies rock. This one's so different, though. I agree with you. I love a Christmas movie. but this one is like a it's a it's a mix of Halloween and Christmas I'm so glad someone's finally promoting The Nightmare Before Christmas by the way it's been out for 30 years um fascinating story then I did all this research about The Nightmare Before Christmas is that it was a Disney movie but it's interesting how much times have changed it was a Disney movie but Disney thought it was too edgy so they wouldn't put the Disney name on the movie when it came out oh and then now it became such a classic that now they like stamp Disney all over it and there's like a whole night before Christmas like thing at Disney World or during Halloween and stuff but like they were scared of it and it is an odd movie it's kind of very I was scared when I was a kid you thought it was scary if I recall correctly I remember being frightened I was always frightened by movies as a kid my mother had to take me out of Ghostbusters oh okay I was so scared I loved horror movies as a kid I loved being scared oh I did not and I still don't Stuff like that.

48:28The Others with - Oh, The Others is, but that's not in like another level. The Others is so good. Yeah, but like I loved all those movies. There's so much, there's just so much Nicole Kidman happening in our culture. Like constantly now. It's awesome, huh? I mean, I've always loved her. You know, the very first season of Billy on the Street, 2011, we did a segment. I don't think it's ever been online. It was just on the show. And it wasn't me going up to people. It was more of a scripted sketch. and it was a, like a protest, a rally that was staged like a political rally to raise awareness of Nicole Kidman.

49:01I actually vaguely, you might've seen, I think I've seen that. You might've seen it. Yes. And because in that moment, people weren't talking as much about Nicole Kidman. She was like a thing. I mean, she was a huge star of course, and she was an amazing actress, but God, Nicole Kidman is like, she's like the statue of Liberty now. I mean, she's like everywhere. Pop songs, every movie every time I look at Instagram she did your show yeah and she was great she was awesome she talked about being lonely the night she won the Oscar I know which was so moving that was really honest it was so nice to hear not nice but I like the honesty of it well of course because you're like it almost makes you feel better because you're like all I want in life are like trophies and accolades and pats on the back and congratulations but if you come home to an empty house what does that what does it all mean?

49:51Is that what happened to you after you won the Webby?

49:56Do you have a Webby? I do have a fucking Webby. Yes! And I went home and I wept all night because I won a Webby. And because it's the only award I've ever won. That's the only award you've ever won? No, I won a GLAAD award. That's amazing. Which was very nice. That was for bros. And I've been nominated for four Emmys and have lost all four. Still cool to be nominated. Still very cool. Was very happy to go to the Emmys four times. Yes. Very cool. Yeah. No, after I won the Webby, I think I was like. Did you go? Oh, I went. Wait, what happened? Just like the speech that you're only allowed to say, as you know, five words.

50:39Right, right. And so it's just, you know what, it's better we move on. Okay. It's better we move on. My hair looked bad. You let me leave. Was it's better we move on your speech? No, my speech was. Five words. I know. My speech was, I wish I could say more, and I thought I ate. Oh, yeah. And everyone the next day was like, ew. You should have said, it's better we move on. I know. That's funny. That's funny. Had I workshopped it a little. There was others in the running. Do you remember my hair was like. I like your hair now. Me too. Yeah. I like my hair now too. Your hair looks great. And I think I'm going to be Danny Phantom for Halloween.

51:14Oh, that's cute. And I'm going to do a little bleach. Are you a Halloween person? No, but I finally got invited to a cool party. I feel excited. I'm going to go with my best friends. Like, it's around my birthday. When's your birthday? October 27th. Oh, nice. Art, where are you? September 18th. Virgo. Yeah, and you're Scorpio? Scorpio. Yeah. Yeah. My first serious boyfriend was a Scorpio. How'd you guys meet? And how old were you? I was right out of college. So I was like 21. And we met at what was a very chic gay party in the year 2000 in Manhattan called Beige. at B Bar, Bowery Bar, which was a gay party every Tuesday night that, you know, the cool gays went to.

51:57And a lot of, like, fashion people. I saw Julia Roberts there once, and, like, fashion designers would go. I mean, I was like a schlub who had just graduated college. But I did. I met my first boyfriend there. And you're... It wasn't my first boyfriend. My first serious boyfriend. Oh, fuck. I gotta catch up, you guys. I really do. Have you had a serious boyfriend? Okay. I run away every time. That's not unusual, though, for gay men. to be honest. You don't think so? No. I had one serious boyfriend out of college and then did not have one again for a very long time. Do you think you can make someone have a crush on you if they don't initially?

52:29No. Okay, cool. You can... Cool. Is that what you're trying to do currently? Yep. No, Jake, you gotta get out of that game. No. I hate it too. It sucks. Yeah. Because if you like the person in your head, you're like, but it was a Tuesday and he had to get up the next morning. Right. That's what I'm thinking about literally right now. He's married to a woman. It's like, who cares? You know Have you ever hooked up with a guy that was married to a woman? No I am so not into that No I mean Not for me But sometimes by accident it happens, no? I don't think so Okay Have you? Once By accident Oh by accident Yeah What excites you about pop culture today?

53:09Like is there anything that's so exciting to you about pop culture today? Madonna Right There are a lot of movies coming out I really want to see I want to see especially movies I you know I like movies about gay people so you want to see the Andrew the Andrew Scott one I want to see Elsinore I want to see Jordan Firstman's movie oh so badly so badly that trailer was amazing yeah so I I want to go out and support those movies it's hard to get those movies made well you made one I did make one and it was fucking hard it's hard you know and it's rare so and I hear that those two are really good I want to see those two movies This is a time of year a lot of good movies are coming out.

53:49It's a good year for movies. But I don't like that they dump all the good movies at the end of the year. Oh, I love it. You do? It gets cold out. What else is there to do? Let's go see a movie. Like, oh my God. It feels like, I just, it's so, it's like, now there's a mad dash to see like every movie. You got to see The Social Reckoning. You got to see, what is the name? The Andrew Garfield one where he plays Sam Altman. Oh, artificial. I've heard it's amazing. I know. See, so many movies. And then there's the Nathan Fielder one about Elizabeth Holmes. Yes. He is Nathan Fielder. Did you know him at all?

54:21We've met a couple of times at parties. Actually, the first time I met him at a party, I don't know when this was, five or six years ago. It was like Nathan for you era. And I saw him at a party in LA. And I went up to him and I said, I love you. And he looked at me and he said, I love you too. And it was like very sweet. And I've met him a few times. I am, he is genius. He's a genius. Singular genius. Yes. I just love him. Yeah, he's awesome. I mean, what a great, eclectic career. I know. So cool. It's like something that started so silly, became so meaningful. It's so meaningful. That's kind of how I feel about Bo Burnham as well.

54:59Where is Bo Burnham? Dating Phoebe Bridgers. Get out. Swear. I did not know that. She has a song about him called Bobby. I did not know that. I missed Phoebe Bridgers in concert, unfortunately. Oh, I've seen her four times. I heard it was amazing. She's incredible. Um, you know who I love? Who? Sarah Bareilles. Wait, so do I because she gave us waitress. That's right. I just saw her. She has a really beautiful album out called, um, uh, oh God, Good Grief. Good Grief. And it's, it's sad. It's about dealing with loss and like people, friends that she has lost in her life, but it's really, really beautiful.

55:42and there's a documentary about the making of the album I watched. I'm like a weirdly obsessive Sarah Bareilles fan. I get very obsessive about like when I see, when I have an album I like, like a documentary to go along with it is always the best. Like I'm very into music. And I went to see her same. I went to see her at Radio City a few weeks ago on my birthday. She was her tour in New York. Gorgeous. And she is so fucking talented. And I know her a little bit, but not really. So this is not like I'm plugging my friend here. But she's just really insanely talented What else do I What are you listening to?

56:16I'm listening to a lot I find the new Adele stuff to be amazing Oh, Nicole Kidman Yeah, but she goes way past that I know it's more than that The song called Marijuana She has this amazing It's one of those Rihanna's higher, like one minute, 30 seconds You're like, I wish it was longer I've been listening to Miley's new album She's the biggest Miley fan in the entire world I really love her I've been listening to the new Tinashe album I did at the gym today. I have not heard that yet. It's really good. It's like as good as people are saying. So you know about the Tell Me What's Wrongs then. I do.

56:53I'm being used as the photos for some random catfisher on Hinge. The way I would be so honored. My friend showed me a profile with my face in photos, but not my name or anything else about me. On the one hand, let's go. I'm being used as a hot girl. Yeah. On the other, I want that shit taken down. LMAO. We already reported, but I'm having my friend try to match with this person. Question is, what do we do slash say if we get the match? I'd be like, what's your name? Where are you from? I want to see what story they would make up for me. Wouldn't you just say you're using my friend's photos? I'd be like, what's your name?

57:30Where are you from? Trying to keep it going? Yeah. Oh, why? What else is there to do? honestly a great answer like what else is there to do do they have my social security number no great okay all good it's just like a fun thing yeah stealing being you're having your identity being stolen but it's not though it's like you know it's fake it's like and all if i if i didn't have um a public career and that happened to me i would be like holy fuck this is the best thing to ever happen to me yeah somebody thinks i'm hot enough to catfish i i I agree with you. That's how I would feel. And it's creepy too, but also flattering.

58:06My roommate has been reading my journal for months now. I just caught her doing this and she fessed up. Ooh. It's become habitual for her. She says it's because we're drifting apart and she just wants to know what's going on with me. But I think that's batshit insane. Hope, literally, what do I say to her? She's got to go. Yeah, that's terrible. Someone read my journal. That's like my worst nightmare. It's my worst nightmare. Do you journal every day? No, do you? Most days. I try to, but I get distracted and then I end up just writing notes on my phone. There's a very streamlined journal I read, I use.

58:40Mm-hmm. Called? It's just three questions every day. Okay, see, maybe that would help me. Yeah, actually my therapist was like, you're not going to journal and journal and journal. So you need like the same three questions every morning and every night. What's it called? It's called the three question journal. Okay. It's actually very helpful. I've given it to other people and everyone enjoys it. I think I need it. I'll send you the link. Journaling does help to an extent. Yeah. And I like to listen to music as I do so. I do the same. What do you listen to? Calming things, like jazz. Okay. Yeah.

59:11What do you listen to? Honestly, like I'd probably put on Audrey Hilbert today and journal. To journal? Her music feels like a journal. Okay. Yeah. That works. My friend is a joke stealer. We don't like that. No. We'll be out and he'll tell a joke to the group and everyone will laugh, but we watch the same stuff because we talk about it, recommend it to each other all the time, and I noticed like multiple times lately he's been ripping off character setups and dialogue, etc. Oh, I don't do that. I don't really care, I guess, but it just feels so phony. Do I get him to stop for his own sake before someone else catches him?

59:43But he should stop doing that. You have to distance yourself from him. Yeah, I agree. And then he won't have any more jokes to make. That sucks. I know it does suck. The beauty of my friends is that we all steal each, like we all adapt our own language. Are your friends old friends? Yeah, from college. So we've known each other for like eight, nine years. Do you go out in New York? Yes. I saw you out one night, but it was like a dinner or something. Oh my God, you saw me at Ledeve. Yeah. Yeah. But I mean like you go out like to gay clubs and stuff. No, I don't. And so actually it's funny you mentioned that because me and my friend were like, let's go to a gay bar tomorrow night and we don't know where to go.

1:00:22Oh, I'll take you. Okay, please. Great. Will you tell me and take me in? I will. Okay. I'm surprised. You should know these things. I get very intimidated by that scene. Oh, I see that. Because I feel like gay people don't really necessarily love me. I think I'm more of a girls' guy, which I know about myself. That's how I was raised. I was raised around women. My humor is very to make them laugh. Yes, I get that. But when I go into a predominantly male gay place, I get very scared. They don't hate you. Well, sometimes it feels that way. Well, that's just social media nonsense, though. IRL is different.

1:01:00Okay. What's your favorite gay bar? What's my favorite gay bar? The only one I know is Animal. Animal is a good one in Brooklyn. We go to the Eagle a lot. I've heard of Loose. Oh, I don't even know what that is. Loose is like what you were describing, that 2000s chic little gay thing. That's Loose, right? Would you say I'm correct? You're a fake gay icon. Where else do we You know Louise has gay parties Where she invites all of her gay friends besides me You don't go? I don't get invited Why? Pick up the mic You do do that You do do that actually Frequently I'm like what are you doing tonight You're like oh my god it's my gay dinner I'm like oh I didn't know that That is weird I don't do that This is a hyperbole You do do that Sensationalized You do do that I've had one party One party That he wasn't invited to?

1:01:52Well, I had a friend that was visiting the city that used to live in L.A., then moved to New York, and he was coming back to L.A., so I invited him and, like, our... A bunch of other gay men. Yes. Who you don't know. He's looking to meet people. It was like a welcome home, like, seeing the friend that's... Yeah. By the way, she has a life, you know. She doesn't have to be attached to your hip all the time. Oh, shit. Yeah, don't I know it. You have to go out and socialize. I know, I'm going to go to... You're a young, successful gay man in New York City. You'll take me to a gay bar? Yes, absolutely.

1:02:26Okay, let's go to a gay bar. Okay, great. I would love that. All right. The Eagle, all these places. Get ready. Have you ever been to a gay bar? You must have been. I've been like a few times, but I blackout drunk. Like blackout drunk. Like beyond. That's not good. I know. You can have a few drinks, but blackout. You're not going to remember. No, yeah, yeah. But I do go out a lot. Like in general, I go out. Generally, you go out a lot, but you go out with girls. My girlfriends. Straight girls. Yeah. You're not going to meet a boy that way. And then my night gets ruined. I get sad. I get home. I get annoyed.

1:02:58This is what I'm saying. All right. We've got to take you out. I know. Show you a good time. I know. All right. I'm so tired of never knowing if I'm being filmed or not. I was walking in the city and some... Oh, my God. Did you do this on purpose? Oh. I was walking in the city and some people popped up out of nowhere asking me to explain my outfit. You kind of started that. For better or worse Yeah They had been filming me for a block And then ambushed me I was so caught off guard I just went with it And they ran to film someone else Like I don't want to be a part of that stuff But I didn't want confrontation out of nowhere It's so annoying There's no privacy anywhere I mean It's become So Prevalent It's like all over now I know Have you walked Have you walked through Washington Square Park?

1:03:43Yeah it's crazy It's crazy Yeah It wasn't like that When I did it Uh huh Um, and we also like, we went out with like, we were a real TV show, like two TV cameras and like a sound guy with a boom. Like you don't see all of that on camera, but it was pretty obvious that we were coming your way. Yeah. You know, like now sometimes these days people are walking, looking down at their phones. They don't know who's going to come up to them, you know? So we kind of caught people off guard that way. But this whole thing with like jumping out and like, I don't know. Did I do a little of that? Yes, I did.

1:04:19But I don't know. It's kind of like most people that I did it with, like, first of all, everyone has to sign a release. See, that was my question. All these people that showed that were on your show, they had to sign something. I don't think that's – I don't know if that's true of these other offshoots. They'll just throw it up. Yeah, I don't know because it's just being done for the internet and it's still kind of like a Wild West legally. Yeah. I had a TV show with lawyers involved. So people had to sign stuff. People had to sign, give us their information. You did it ethically. We did it as ethically as you can.

1:04:56Did I catch some people off guard? Yeah, I mean, that's part of the fun. But they still signed the form. No one has ever been on Billy on the Street without giving us their approval. After we had our interaction, then they have to sign something. And if some people didn't sign. and you've never seen anyone on the show who did not sign. Maybe some of these new shows should take a lesson. Maybe. Maybe. My dream is to be asked, what are you listening to right now? Stop on the street. That's my dream. That's a good one. I know. I like that one. It's my favorite. I'm always thinking about it when I'm walking down the street.

1:05:30Like someone please just ask me. That can't happen? No, I've been saying it a lot on the show, so someone does. But I don't want it to be like a random, like I want it to be the show. Right, you want the real guy. I want the real show. I want them to find me. And I want it to be set up at all. And I want them to say, what are you listening to? And then my favorite part of those is when they play the song as you walk away. Oh, yeah, that's nice. Yeah, it is nice. Am I in the wrong here? My group is getting very upset with me lately because I always play devil's advocate. Okay. I think it's important almost every time to see both sides.

1:06:04And these girls are often in the wrong too. So I think that's why they're upset. I don't want to change this about myself, but they are really fed up with it. Any advice? Stay true to who you are because my best friend in the entire world, Will, does this with me every single time and it makes me a better person. You're fucking annoying is my advice. You think? Every time you're like, I'm the friend that's going to play devil's advocate. It's me. It's important. Shut up. It's important. You're not a friend. You're annoying. Oh, my God. I mean, you don't need to play devil's advocate in every scenario.

1:06:33Right. Now, if you really think that legitimately your friend needs to see the other side. No, I would be annoyed too. some debate that's different and i would talk so much this is who i am your whole personality is i play devil's advocate get a life yeah okay that's what i say do you always play devil's advocate why not always and i think it's very situation dependent but a lot of times the things that we're discussing aren't that okay give me an example for real like he'll think someone's mad at him or something i'm like no perhaps you're just like hearing their communication in a different way.

1:07:09Like sometimes it's not so black and white and I'm like maybe there's miscommunications happening. But that's actually helpful to you because you're assuming everyone hates you and then you're saying not everyone, just some people. No, she agrees. She agrees with that most of the time. She agrees with that most of the time. Yeah. But yeah, no, she plays devil's advocate quite a bit. Well, and I think even if you're 100 % always right, I think it's still helpful. No, she'll say you're right, but the way you deliver the news is wrong. Oh. Well, there might be some truth to that. I think we've diverted topics now, actually.

1:07:44I communicate poorly. Okay. And yet, here you are. It's your charm. I think that's why people get so angry. Probably. Yeah. But it's also what makes you you, so it's a tricky one. Right? When do you stop being you? You don't. Right. Because eventually what I realized is people will come around. If you just don't stop being yourself, no matter how annoying you are, people will come around. You're not annoying to the people that love you, though. No, I am. But I think that's like... And they find it endearing. Yeah. Right? You don't need everyone to love you. No. And I've come to terms with that.

1:08:23Yes. And you're being as popular as you are, not everyone's going to love you. Well, thank you. And some people are going to actively going to hate you. Yeah. But that's part of the life of doing this. Have you ever had someone in person be like, I don't like you? I was once at a gay bar several years ago, and it was really loud. You know, there was a dance floor, and there were these two gay guys younger than me. I would say they were in their, like, probably late 20s or something like that, early 30s. And the music was so loud, they probably thought I couldn't hear what they were saying. but they were just standing right over there right and I was like with my friends but I heard my name they were like and it was something like that's Billy Eichner and then one of the other was like yeah and then now they obviously don't know who I am they know my work they don't know me in real life they were like yeah that's him and then uh one of them said uh he's cute but I just don't like his personality oh shit very like and i could hear it but like i but it made me laugh i was like you don't know my personality like you don't know me as a real person like you don't like my character or like you don't like something you saw that i was in i thought it was very funny though i was kind of amused by it um it felt like that would send me home was that that would send me home oh god no that's the difference between you and me you need a thicker skin babe i know i know You want to be in this for the long haul, especially as a gay man.

1:09:58Yeah, people will say crazy shit. But I don't know. It kind of makes me laugh. I'm like, they're talking about me like they really know me. And they're strangers. It's like, you don't know me. You saw a video or you saw something that I did that you didn't like the attitude. Also, I don't know. For me, I was like, you probably just aren't people who get what I do. And that's going to have to be fine. Like it's going to have to be fine for you and it's going to have to be fine for me. And I don't need you to like my personality in order for me to be successful. Like we can coexist as people in this club with you thinking that you don't like me based on some work of mine that you saw.

1:10:39And with me knowing that, like, I don't care. I have plenty of people that like me. And let's be honest. I was still happy. They said I was cute. I was also a big win. That's what I would have been happy about. He's cute even though I don't like his personality. That's what I would have been happy about. That's really what you want. I would say that I've grown thicker skin when realizing that, like, okay, like, I've had my best friends for, like, almost 10 years now. They're going to be my best friends for life. As long as I have them, I'm fine. Like, you know. I will say I was thinking about you earlier when I was on my way here because you've had a lot of success for someone your age, which is amazing.

1:11:21But I used to, I've thought many times about myself, like in those Joan Rivers years when I was going to Joan for help, I was closer to your age. But now, and all I wanted was success. I had just wanted to be paid for anything at that point, right? Now, looking back, I think to myself, I'm sure it would have been so fucking fun to be like famous and successful in my 20s in a certain kind of way, right? But I don't think I was ready. I think it would have also been very hard. And I wasn't even in the social media world that you're in now. And even so, I think, sometimes I think I probably would have been an asshole or I would have been like completely torn apart by like anything anyone said.

1:12:10It's still hard. And so like to have to navigate it in your 20s, I think is a tricky thing. Well, because you don't even know who you are in your 20s. That's right. So then you're like reading these comments that are telling you who you are and you're like, and they're negative. And you're like, wait, am I that? Luckily for me, my frontal lobe is coming. It's coming full, fully developed. So I can read them and like move past it. But I would just imagine that that's hard, actually. It is. So you need your friends and you need to just sort of not give a shit about what like every single person.

1:12:48There's a billion people out there online. Not all of them are going to like you. Then you're going to come with me to the Eagle. We're going to fuck shit up. What's it like in there? Oh, my God. What's it like? You literally grew up in Manhattan. It's so funny. See, you don't even, everyone's like, you grew up in New York. I'm like, I had no money. I looked like I was 12. Like, I wasn't going anywhere. I actually, I wasn't like a New York kid that went out. I was a nerd. I went to Stuyvesant. You know, I was like a nerd about like schoolwork and stuff. Like I wasn't like going to clubs. Right.

1:13:19I didn't have that like cool kid New York lifestyle. But in my twenties, I, I was so looking forward to like going out and like experiencing nightlife in New York and gay nightlife. But I do worry though. Like, I know, I don't know. I get, I get anxious. Maybe it's like a self important, maybe I think I'm more important than I am. But like, sometimes I do get anxious about like to go to like a gay bar and like have someone take a photo of me and then like make fun of me. I do get scared. Yeah. You're right. So I think a lot of gay men feel anxiety in those types of spaces, but I think they can also be like uniquely liberating.

1:13:55And I think that maybe it'll be for you and maybe it won't, you know, like it's not for everyone, but I don't know. I think it's fun and I think it's sexy and it's like, you know, something great about being a gay man is that you can go and have those types of experiences like with other gay men, like separate from the outside world. and I don't know. There's something fun about it. No, it sounds fun and I'm excited to be a part of it soon for my golden birthday. All right. What's that? It's my golden birthday soon. Oh, okay. Not that you give a fuck. What's golden birthday? It's like when you turn 27 on the 27th.

1:14:28Oh, I've never heard that expression. Like your golden birthday, what's your birthday? The 18th. So it would have been when you turned 18 on the 18th. You have a good, that's a good golden birthday. Yeah. Last one. Hey, Jake and beautiful guest. I recently moved to NYC and went back to visit my hometown. I saw my childhood best friend who ran away when we were little, and now she's acting like nothing happened. What? We exchanged numbers. How do I approach this situation? Mind you, we grew up together, and she ran away when she was 13. I haven't seen her in almost 10 years. Oh, my God. Just let her.

1:15:00Let her pretend. Poor girl. It feels dark. That feels dark. Weird. Right? Yeah. That's the type of show I love, though. Talk about a type of show I love, like shit like that. Like someone running away from home? Yeah. Yeah, like dark, twisted, like sharp objects type. Oh, that was good. See, if every show could be like sharp objects, I'd have the best life. I'd just sit and watch TV all day. You don't want to do that. Sometimes I do. I know. Sometimes. Yeah. Yeah. Well, Billy. Yeah. What did we learn today? What did we learn? A lot about Madonna. Thank God you needed it. I did. Clearly. Yeah. Someone needs to educate you people.

1:15:37I know. I know. Well, Billy. Jake. Thank you for coming on the show. Thank you for having me. You're delightful. You are delightful. This was so fun. It was fun. I hope you had fun. I did have fun. We're going to take you out. I know. The night of our lives. I know. It's going to be fun. Bye, pussies.

1:16:09At ZocDoc, we know you care about your health. You wouldn't do that early morning cardio if you didn't. So the fact that your annual physical is overdue just shows how hard it can be to get seen by a doctor. Sorry, that doctor's not in network. Press 1 for more options. You've reached us outside normal business hours. The next availability is in three months. But ZocDoc makes finding the right doctor easy. Download the app and search by specialty, insurance, and availability. Read real patient reviews, then book instantly. ZocDoc, ready to be seen?

From the publisher

I feel so... fucking old.

Tell Me What's Wrong at ⁠

passthatpuss.com

Follow Billy!

https://www.instagram.com/billyeichner/?hl=en

Follow Me!

Instagram | @passthatpuss

TikTok | @octopusslover8

Listen to "THERAPUSS"

Spotify: ⁠⁠⁠⁠https://open.spotify.com/show/1BHDdC0OVuHqZ706FobfOF

⁠⁠Apple Podcasts: ⁠⁠⁠⁠https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/therapuss-with-jake-shane/id1723626781⁠⁠

Amazon Podcasts: ⁠⁠⁠⁠https://music.amazon.com/podcasts/93117357-1f23-46e1-8f26-88f5182a68b8/therapuss-with-jake-shane⁠⁠
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from Therapuss with Jake Shane

All episodes