1. Podcasts
  2. This American Life
  3. 902: The Missing Minutes
This American Life

16 Nov 2026 · 59m · 17 chapters

Episode artwork

902: The Missing Minutes

In short

A woman, Vienna Luke, records a secretly recorded, in-person confrontation with her brother-in-law Justin at a Vancouver airport to obtain details and evidence about a sexual assault she experienced years earlier, after years of uncertainty and memory gaps. The recording becomes central evidence in court.

Guest backgrounds

The episode is narrated by Aviva de Kornfeld (subbing for Ira Glass). Vienna Luke is the central subject; Justin is her brother-in-law (a veterinarian and father of four). Vienna’s sister Shaughnessy (middle sister) helps pursue evidence; police lead Joelle Lachance (RCMP) specializes in sexual assault cases. Vienna’s partner is Jordan. (Later, a short fiction segment is read by Miranda July.)

Key claims

Justin drugged Vienna’s drinks, sexually assaulted her, stripped her, and took naked photos; he also later admits to voyeuristic window photos of her. Vienna says she needed specifics to heal and to confront her sister Sunny (Justin’s wife).

Notable examples

Vienna’s “checklist” interrogation; Justin’s admissions of drugging (possibly Valium), 30 photos taken, and later 8–10 blurry window photos taken 3–4 times; charges include sexual assault, voyeurism, and administering a stupefying drug.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

5:10

Vienna's Experience and Family Dynamics

Explores Vienna's traumatic memory and family relationships.

“Vienna's a fitness instructor, a mom to two kids.”
14:00

Vienna's Journey to Justice

Vienna and her sister Shaughnessy gather evidence to confront Justin about the assault.

“but they didn't know how else to handle it.”
18:01

Preparing for Confrontation

Vienna, with police help, prepares to confront Justin about the assault details.

“if he could be the one to reunite the family.”
22:05

The Confrontation Revealed

Vienna confronts Justin, who attempts to rationalize his actions during the assault.

“And every time he tries to stray and talk about the broader issue of objectification of women, you force him right back to the topic at hand.”
28:00

The Complexities of Justification

Exploration of justifications surrounding inappropriate behavior and its impact on relationships.

“So Justin has his justifications, but then there's some stuff that he has a really hard time explaining, try as he might.”
29:05

Vienna's Cross-Examination

Vienna confronts her brother-in-law Justin about past trauma and its implications.

“Like if you go around to computers, go door to door, start pulling computers apart, you'll find pornography on most of them.”
30:28

Layers of Denial and Defense

Discussion on Justin's minimization of his actions and Vienna's quest for clarity.

“But she said pretty quickly, she realized Sunny didn't really want to understand.”
32:05

Unpacking Conflicting Memories

Vienna and Justin navigate conflicting memories of an event that changed Vienna's life.

“You wrote in the email that you sexually assaulted me.”
33:58

The Burden of Truth

Vienna grapples with the implications of revealing painful truths about her experience.

“and I believed that if I had the pieces that things would make sense to me.”
35:56

Justin's Justifications and Admissions

Justin makes surprising admissions while trying to justify his actions during the confrontation.

“I, I, you know that line that I talked about that I didn't want to cross, that I wasn't willing to cross.”
Show all 17 chapters
37:56

The Aftermath of Confrontation

Vienna reflects on her experiences post-confrontation and the lack of remorse from Justin.

“Can you understand that I would walk into that and hope that I could take pictures of you, go through the evening, and have you wake up the next day and never know that any of it happened?”
40:28

Closure and Consequences

Vienna's meeting with Justin leads to significant legal consequences for him.

“There's definitely, like, yeah, no remorse.”
42:00

Vienna's Story of Assault and Aftermath

Explore Vienna's journey from trauma to understanding and closure.

“Somebody opens it, and they are all, like, practically at the door.”
50:07

A Fictional Exploration of Excitement and Connection

Experience a fictional narrative about anticipation and relationships.

“So you hope that one day, it'll all be explained and finally made clear.”
56:05

The Weight of Regret

A person reflects on their missed opportunities and the burden of regret.

“Everyone was wrong This person is not who they thought this person was This person plunges underwater This person can stay underwater for an impressively long time, but only in a bathtub.”
56:48

Introduction to Randa July

The host introduces Randa July and her noteworthy book.

57:20

Credits and Acknowledgments

The credits roll, acknowledging the team behind the production.

“She's the author of the book All Fours, which is the only book that I, upon completing, flipped over and immediately started reading again.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On This American Life, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This message comes from WFMT. Discover connections in classical music with WFMT's Exploring Music and new host Peter Vandergraaf. Listen Monday through Friday at 7 p.m. on 98.7 FM, WFMT.com, and the app. A quick warning. There are curse words that are unbeeped in today's episode of the show. If you prefer a beeped version, you can find that at our website, thisamericanlife.org. It's This American Life. I'm Aviva de Kornfeld, sitting in for Ira Glass. So there's this recording I heard a couple months ago. And when I heard it, I could not believe it existed. I'd never heard anything like it. It was recorded at a hotel bar at the Vancouver airport by this woman named Vienna Luke.

0:47She'd arranged to meet with this guy, Justin, who she hadn't seen in almost a decade. She's sitting at a table. She orders a tea. Sipping it slowly while she waits for him to arrive. She's wired for sound. Every so often I'm kind of glancing towards the, to where the hostess desk is. And then I see Justin walk in across the restaurant and he's asking the hostess where I'm sitting. Or like I'm already saying, like I'm meeting someone here. I think the guy's here. His name looks exactly the same. And I say, dang, he looks exactly the same. Like, he is exactly who he has always been. He has not changed.

1:37And he has no idea what's coming because he doesn't know I'm different. Vienna's got a hidden recorder in her purse sitting on the table and another recorder hidden in her bra. There are three cops in plain clothes sitting at tables around her and a bunch more upstairs in a hotel room. Justin spots Vienna, walks over to her table, and Vienna jumps right in with a nervous preamble. Okay, so, yeah, obviously, I haven't really wanted to do this for quite some time. But I actually have a notebook today, and I wrote notes because I want to make sure that I cover off everything that I want to. And we're going to take this at my pace.

2:32Can I just ask if you read, Sarah? Are you recording this? No. It wouldn't matter to me because I feel this is your information. And you deal with it whenever you want. Vienna is secretly recording because she's pretty sure that years ago, Justin assaulted her. But she doesn't know for sure. She has big gaps in her memory from that night. Memory gaps are pretty common in cases of sexual assault, which makes for a horrible situation because the one person who could clear things up and tell you what happened, the person who assaulted you, is the least likely person to talk to you and tell you the truth.

3:16Because why would they? In Vienna's case, though, the man, Justin, actually agreed to sit down with her and talk about everything, to answer all of her questions in detail. I think most of us walk around with blank spots in our lives, small ones, big ones. And a lot of the time, you just give up on trying to get answers, accepting that you're just going to wonder forever. So what's it like to actually get all the answers you spent so long wondering about? And where does that leave you? Most of our show today is going to be the story of this recording. It's really remarkable. Stay with us.

4:12Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Capital One. Capital One offers checking accounts with no fees or minimums. What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com slash Bank Guy for details. Capital One N.A. Member FDIC. Support for This American Life and the following message come from Southern New Hampshire University, a nonprofit provider of online education. SNHU students are a lot like you. Parents, professionals with big career plans, busy people balancing life's many responsibilities, and SNHU students do all of that while earning their degrees.

4:49Because with no set class times, online tuition that's less than its peers, and dedicated student support, Southern New Hampshire University makes going back to school possible. Get started at snhu.edu slash American. It's This American Life, Act 1, Known Unknowns. so vienna is at this hotel bar at the vancouver airport wearing that hidden recorder and just a heads up before we start this story includes a bunch of explicit details and references to sexual assault the man in the recording which we'll get to in a minute his name is justin he's a father of four boys a veterinarian though he has a sort of finance guy look about him close-cropped hair, symmetrical face, wouldn't look out of place in a Patagonia vest.

5:38Vienna's a fitness instructor, a mom to two kids. She's warm and sensitive and loves an inspirational quote. She and Justin are actually related. Justin is Vienna's brother-in-law, her oldest sister, Sunny's husband. I met him when I was 10, and yeah, he felt like an older brother. and I'd only had sisters, so having a brother was exciting and I thought he was charming. I mean, he was very self-assured and I guess I thought that was cool. For 14 years, Vienna has wanted to ask Justin about one night from when she was 20 and he was 31. She was living with Sunny and Justin up in their small northern Canadian town, where they'd moved after they got married.

6:32And one day, when Sunny was away, Justin asked Vienna, Oh, do you want to, like, get drunk to experience what it's like to be drunk in a safe place? Like, that was the premise. Which sounded reasonable to Vienna. She and her family were evangelical Christians. She went to church every Sunday. Justin was part of the leadership. and she'd had friends in the church who'd gotten drunk for the first time under a similar arrangement. So Justin makes Vienna a few mixed drinks to try. A strawberry daiquiri, a pina colada, some kind of Kahlua thing. Exactly the kind of drinks you might order for yourself if you were 20 and didn't like the taste of alcohol.

7:11He's got music playing, like country music. and after I had a couple sips, he was like dancing with me, like two-stepping with me. And I feel like already then I was starting to feel a little bit like woozy. And then I basically lose feeling in my legs and collapse on the ottoman. And I'm like, oh my goodness, if this is what it feels like to be drunk, this is rough. Like, why do people, why do people do this? Vienna passes out. A little while later, she comes to in her bedroom, which is in the basement. She has no clue how she got there from the living room upstairs. And she only has one more brief memory from the evening.

8:05Warning for the listeners, this next detail might be upsetting. The one moment Vienna woke up, she remembers having an out-of-body experience, looking down at herself, seeing Justin taking off her underwear. The next morning, Vienna wakes up with a stomachache and a bad feeling. She tells Justin that she's not sure exactly what happened, but that she thinks he should tell Sunny. He brushes her off, saying there's no need to tell her. It'll just trouble her. And besides, nothing happened anyway. I'm like, okay, yeah, that's what I've been trying to tell myself too. Like as this memory comes up.

8:42You're like almost hoping for that answer. Yeah, yeah, no. To be like, okay, it's nothing, right? It's nothing? Yeah, it's nothing. I mean, even in the moment, I remember telling myself, he's taking off my underwear because like I must have vomited. I must have gotten like. Like this must be a brotherly. Yeah. Familial act. Yeah, like, oh, he's just changing my clothes because I threw up on myself. So I'd say things like that to myself, and then I'd be like, but why would he have to change my underwear?

9:20So this night happens, and Vienna has to decide, does she tell her family? And if she does, what exactly is she even telling them if she doesn't know any of the details? Vienna's family is one that makes a point to spend a lot of time all together. Vienna's parents, her two sisters, and her. Vienna's the baby. She grew up particularly close with her oldest sister, Sunny, Justin's wife. Sunny is 10 years older than Vienna, so she was more like a second mom to her. Sunny would dote on her, read Junie B. Jones to her at night. She painted a mural of farm animals on her bedroom wall. When Vienna got older, they'd bake chocolate chip cookies together.

10:00But for months after that night, Vienna doesn't tell anyone about what happened. Until, at the end of a family vacation, Vienna's middle sister Shaughnessy notices Justin pull Vienna into this long hug. A hug that looked too intimate to her eye. So, Shaughnessy, being the loud, confrontational one in the family, corners Vienna and badgers the truth out of her. Vienna stumbles through a partial explanation, saying Justin gave her alcohol. But she can't bring herself to mention the one thing she remembers about the night, about him taking off her underwear. But even without that detail, something about the way Vienna was talking, her body language, Shaughnessy thought Justin must have done something inappropriate.

10:47So she convinces Vienna to tell their parents, and Vienna tells them what she told Shaughnessy. Vienna's parents are very surprised she got drunk. Vienna's dad calls Justin to get answers about what exactly happened. Justin, of course, downplays everything, saying Vienna just drank too much, that's all. When Justin's wife, Sunny, hears about all this, she shuts down entirely. Sunny's not her real name, by the way. My sister didn't want to know anything and, like, basically pretended like it didn't happen. I think everyone was just so confused. They didn't know what to do with it. And at the end of the day, people just like they just want the family to be together.

11:31So pretty much it was just like life as usual after that. And I would have had to see him at the next family thing.

11:45There's a terrible ordinariness to sexual violence. I don't know any woman who hasn't, at some point, wondered if a man was going to hurt her. What's extraordinary about Vienna's story, though, is how she chose to respond to what happened to her. But that doesn't happen for years, because for almost a decade, Vienna tried to continue on like normal. She's naturally a peacemaker, and pushing the issue with Justin just seemed like it would cause problems for everyone. Plus, at this point, Vienna is depressed, operating on autopilot, and didn't have the wherewithal to force her family to confront a thing she wasn't ready to deal with herself.

12:23So instead, she went to university, spent time with her family, tried to figure out what she wanted to do with her life. But she couldn't shake the unsettled feeling she'd had ever since the night Justin gave her alcohol. And eventually, the uncertainty about what happened to her that night became this kind of torture, just question marks looping nonstop in the back of her brain as she went about daily life. Then, in 2014, seven years after the night Justin assaulted her, Vienna's oldest sister, Sunny, discovered that Justin was having an affair. Multiple affairs, actually. This news rocked their community.

13:00Everyone had seen him as this wholesome family man, an elder in the church. Sunny ended up taking Justin back after a couple months. But for Vienna... It was this affirmation that he was capable of not being a nice guy. I finally, like, believed myself. And what was it exactly that you believed? That he had done something to me, that something had happened. So Vienna cut Justin out. Shaughnessy did as well. She'd always believed Justin had done something to Vienna, even though at this point, Vienna still hadn't told her the detail about the underwear. Both refused to be in the same room as Justin.

13:48Vienna's parents positioned themselves as a kind of see-no-evil Switzerland in the middle of this newfound estrangement. with Vienna and Shaughnessy on one side and Justin and Sunny on the other. They felt uneasy about what they knew, but they didn't know how else to handle it. And so the entire family structure was reorganized to accommodate this vague, undiscussed thing that happened. For a family that loved spending time together, this meant no more holidays, no more family vacations. They all settled into a painful, awkward, strange new normal for a few years. Until, one night, Vienna called her middle sister Shaughnessy and said, I'm finally ready to figure out what happened to me.

14:31It had been 12 years since the night. In order to go to the police, Vienna and Shaughnessy figure they need more evidence than Vienna's one memory of the night. So together, they make a list of everyone they knew Justin had been close with at the time of the assault, but wasn't close to anymore. Old co-workers, former friends. They figured maybe he had talked to someone about what he'd done. Vienna didn't want to talk to any of these people herself, so Shaughnessy calls roughly a dozen people, including one of Justin's former employees at the vet clinic he ran. And she says, I know why you're calling.

15:11He drugged your sister. And continues to tell my sister everything she, like what she knows that they were working in the back one day in the clinic. And he says like, if you were giving whatever drug it was to a human, how much would you give them to make sure they were out? Another former employee told Shaughnessy that one day, the receptionist at the clinic, was looking for something on the work computer, and accidentally came across pictures of Justin with a naked woman who might have been Vienna. The woman's face wasn't visible. Some of the pictures were selfies Justin took, leaning against the woman's body.

15:59With those two pieces of information, about the drugs and the pictures, Vienna and Shaughnessy go to the police. Most sexual assault allegations get reported. They never go anywhere. But Vienna gets extraordinarily lucky by getting the ear of a cop named Joelle Lachance, who's made tricky sexual assault cases her life's work. She's like one of those cops on a TV show whose secret sauce comes down to. She just really gives a shit. She used her vacation days to fly places for this case. She was late to her own sister's funeral because she was helping set up Vienna's Vancouver recording. The idea of going to the police more than a decade after an assault, with only one memory of what happened, and hearsay from a couple former acquaintances, and being taken seriously seems unimaginable.

16:49But that is what happened. Joelle ropes the undercover police team in to work with Vienna on her case, and they come up with a plan. For years, since Vienna first distanced herself from Justin, he had been emailing her periodically, asking her to return to the family. Vienna never responded to those emails. But now, with the help of the police, she crafted a response saying, basically, I'm willing to move past this, but in order for me to do that, I need you to tell me what happened that night. Justin writes back and says very clearly that he sexually assaulted her. Vienna thinks, okay, that was easy.

17:30We got him. But the Police say they need more concrete evidence, something undeniable. A lawyer in court could argue that someone other than Justin had written that email to Vienna. And they needed specifics about what exactly he did. So Vienna writes Justin again, saying, We need to meet in person, and you need to tell me the details of what happened. That's the only way I'll be able to move forward. Justin, miraculously, agrees. Vienna thinks it's because he figured he would get to be the hero, if he could be the one to reunite the family. Justin offers to fly to Vancouver, where Vienna lives, so they decide to meet at the airport.

18:13The cops picked the airport because, even though they figured Justin wasn't likely an active threat to Vienna, they knew that if he had just walked off an airplane, there was no way he could have a weapon on him. And Vienna liked the airport idea, too. It felt comfortingly anonymous. In preparation for the meeting, the lead undercover cop spent a couple days training Vienna on how to get usable information out of Justin. So the day I did training, I brought in my notebook and he was like, whoa, this is so weird. You have a notebook like nobody brings a notebook. Usually he's like working with he's like, you are very different than the undercover people I usually work with, Which, not to, like, stereotype, but many of them are, like, criminals that he's, like...

19:05Like, he's flipped them, and then they're going to work against their former. So, like, a bunch of the stuff we were going through in this contract, he's like, this isn't going to apply to you, but, like, you can't commit any other crimes throughout this operation. He's like that. And you're like, no problem. Yeah. So Vienna, A-plus student with her little notebook, writes down everything she needs to get from Justin. And then she and the undercover cop role play so she can practice pressing Justin when he tries to give her evasive non-answers. And a few weeks later, Vienna heads to the Vancouver airport.

19:42I feel like I came here today, or I know I came here today, wanting you to give me details on what happened. Um, so I hope that you're ready to tell me, like, the actual facts today. Well, one of the things that I've learned is that when there's disclosure, it's traumatic, and the best way is to have it all out in one place. So I don't want there to be any amount of information that has to be disclosed at a different point in time. This is the timeline. Okay. So you will get everything you need for me to pay. Okay. Because it'll be more traumatic for you if you have to give a kid. Justin uses this bizarre therapy speak all throughout their conversation.

20:35Several years before this meeting, Justin went to counseling for sex addiction. And it seems like that's where he picked this up. This language that allows him to simultaneously acknowledge that something happened to Vienna, while also distancing himself from it. It's like he's saying, I can help you heal from this, while totally ignoring the fact that he's the reason she needs to heal in the first place. So, throughout that night, and I don't mean to go into other things, but, well, this whole objectification of women in our culture right now is what had happened for me at that time. And for some reason, I had a line drawn.

21:27I wasn't going to touch you in a sexual way. Okay, but you're not actually telling me what. No, I know. Sorry. And it's just sort of the rules before I started. Like the rule for myself. Like everything that happened was on this side of that line for me. The rules before you started what? Before that night started. And I wouldn't say that they were even like pre-thought-out rules. Yeah. Okay, let's get back to the night and what actually, tell me what happened. Okay. You're so impressively uncompromising in the tape. And every time he tries to stray and talk about the broader issue of objectification of women, you force him right back to the topic at hand.

22:12I feel like I went into it with a mentality of like, I cannot fail. Like, I can't. This is my one chance. I can't mess this up. Like, it wasn't even an option. Like, I remember my coach, my undercover cop saying like, you know, he's going to try to make light of this. He's going to kind of try to pull you off track. And you just have to keep bringing the focus back. Tell me what happened. Okay. I encouraged you to drink alcohol. Yeah. You had never been drunk? Were you drinking with me? Yes. I don't remember that. I didn't drink very much. Because I didn't want to be drunk. Mm-hmm.

23:17Well, yes, that's what you told me. Right. But that's not what happened. No. I remember that you laid down on the abdomen. You're back. Oh, I did not lay down. I lost feeling in my legs. Okay. And that's not what happens when someone gets drunk.

23:44So are you going to tell me what you did? Or am I, yeah, I didn't just lose feeling in my legs for nothing. And I've been drunk since. Right. I put something in one of the drinks. I was nervous about it, and I didn't know how much. and so I was cautious and it was I can't imagine that I did anything to maybe the combination is what I did but I did and what was it? I'm not sure if it was Valium or was it? You're not sure if that doesn't make me feel you know like I know that I had both there Do you know how much you gave me? No I don't It wasn't something that I'd done before, so I didn't know how much it was appropriate, but I certainly didn't want to hurt anybody.

24:39I didn't want to hurt you. You're on your back with the ottoman. And you started. We're good, thank you. Justin's talking to a waiter here, who's asking if they have everything they need. I don't have anything smart to say about this. I just think it's insane to have to interact with a waiter while in the middle of a conversation like this. you were throwing up so I helped you down the stairs to your bedroom. There was a wall with you on your clothing and so I helped you out of your home. so it'll be as an odd way of phrasing that. And the pictures that I took during that time were of you on the bed.

25:38Vienna now presses Justin for specifics about the pictures, just as the undercover cop instructed. She needs to get Justin to corroborate the fact that he gave her drugs, took off her clothes, and took pictures of her with as many details as possible. How many photos did you take? 30. Was I wearing anything in any of them? No. Can you describe them for me? There's a picture of you on your stomach from above. There's a picture of you on your back, showing your chest. there's a full body picture of you from above with you laying on your back um i took a picture of us like a selfie at the time of you on your back with me with my head down close to your chest i took a picture of um you on your side with my penis close to your face but I never touched you with it.

26:51But there again none of the pictures, I don't know if these details are important to you, your legs are never open for any emotions. I don't know any pictures of your gender. So the pictures were like from the belly button up? No, from the waist down as well But only from the front and closed leg. Only from the front, because you had a line drawn. That I wasn't going to position you. With my legs open. Right. I had those pictures for a while afterwards. Okay. I was always disappointed that I didn't have a picture of your vagina. But I was never willing to position you to get one. If we take Justin at his word, it tells us something interesting, which is how he lives with what he's done.

27:40He's come up with a story he can tell himself so that he's still a good person, because there are lines he drew and rules he set that he stayed on the right side of. I suspect that's why he agreed to talk to Vienna at all, and why there isn't a shred of remorse in his voice, because he doesn't really think of himself as a guy who did anything worth apologizing for. Of course, just to say, for the rest of us who live in the real world, drugging your sister-in-law, stripping off all her clothes, and taking naked pictures of her for later use, none of that is anywhere close to being on the right side of any line.

28:27So Justin has his justifications, but then there's some stuff that he has a really hard time explaining, try as he might. Listen to how he dodges this very simple question.

29:04Just the issue of pornography, just having pornography, right? Like if you go around to computers, go door to door, start pulling computers apart, you'll find pornography on most of them. Yeah, hopefully not the person's sister-in-law, but, you know. Right. This is what got me in the recording. The way Vienna is like a prosecutor, quick and sharp and relentless, except she's cross-examining her own perpetrator. Like so many survivors, it took Vienna a long time to classify what happened to her as sexual assault. And that's in part because of who the perpetrator was, her cool, charming, church-going brother-in-law, family.

29:45But one of the reasons she's putting herself through this meeting with Justin is also a family. The way she sees it, recording this conversation is her best chance at getting through to her sister Sunny. Vienna hates how distant she and Sunny have become, how estranged. Sunny and her kids will visit Vienna and Shaughnessy once or twice a year, but there's none of the intimacy they used to have. Because Vienna's never gotten to have an open, honest conversation with Sunny about what happened to her. The one time they came close was back when Sunny discovered Justin's affairs. She finally called Vienna and asked her about the night Justin got her drunk.

30:25And Vienna tried to tell her. But she said pretty quickly, she realized Sunny didn't really want to understand. She was more there on behalf of Justin, as a kind of spokesperson. She kept defending him, saying things like, you don't understand. He was exposed to pornography when he was a kid. He had a sex addiction. He's a victim himself. He went nowhere. But with this recording, Sunny would finally hear the truth about what happened. And then she might leave Justin once and for all. That was Vienna's hope. So Vienna's now about an hour into her hour-and-a-half-long conversation with Justin. And you can hear the way Justin's speaking to her, that he's still playing this knowing authority.

31:14And Vienna is sitting across from him, like, I'm not who you think I am. I don't defer to you. I kind of don't believe that you just took pictures of me naked. So, I guess the reason that I wanted to draw the distinction between sexual contact and non-sexual contact is because there was contact that I felt was, I don't remember, I felt really close to you at that time. So I lay down beside you and I put my arm around you. But I was careful that I didn't touch your breasts when I put my arm around you because that would be sexual. You wrote in the email that you sexually assaulted me. Which, yeah, so at what point...

32:13I think taking pictures of you as sexual assault.

32:20I masturbated twice and it was between that I laid down with you. And so I was not, after you have sex, there's a point in the time where you're not ready to have sex again. And so it was during that time that I was laying beside you, spooning in you, but just fooling you. And so I may have been up against you, like penis may have been in around your rear end, around your legs, but it wasn't, like I've always worried that there would have been some degree of mess and you would have thought that potentially I had raped you. Okay, when you, after you masturbated, where did you... On you. Okay, so that would be in the pictures.

33:26Yeah. Did you have to ask any questions as part of the investigation that you personally would rather not know? No, I was, yeah, I wanted to hear everything. Like, not wanted to, but I think when you spend so many years not knowing, yeah, it feels like just being unsettled for years and years and years and the unknowns plague you. and I believed that if I had the pieces that things would make sense to me. Is that what happened? Yeah. I mean, ultimately when I say make sense, I mean that night changed who I was fundamentally down to my core. It changed me as a person. So actually getting some details on what happened made me realize that I wasn't crazy.

34:33That feeling so low that that was normal based on what had happened.

34:50The one memory Vienna has from the night of Justin taking off her underwear. It had taken years for her to tell anyone about it. It felt too shameful, too private. But now, she brings it up with Justin directly. Did you do anything else to me? Like, did you go down on me? I did not touch or see your gem tan. Well, you did see it because you took off my underwear. No, I... You removed my underwear. I know, but that was a closed leg. Slide them down. That wasn't a... I never positioned you the way I could see. Because I definitely came to with my shorts and underwear coming off and wondered why if I was vomiting I would need my underwear taken off.

35:45So, yeah, I feel like you didn't just, you didn't just stop there. There was no contact. I, I, you know that line that I talked about that I didn't want to cross, that I wasn't willing to cross. Well, but you did cross it. I know, I know. You absolutely crossed it. So I just, I feel like it's really important for me to know if you did have sex with me for the first time. Because obviously you know I was a virgin. The only time I had been rescued anywhere near your human was when I was soft. Jordan's just calling me. Sure. Hey. So when I say Jordan's just calling me, it's not Jordan. Jordan is Vienna's partner.

36:36It's actually RCMP upstairs calling me. RCMP, Royal Canadian Mounted Police. Something was wrong with the transmission, and they'd missed large chunks of the conversation. So while Vienna was dutifully working through her checklist of questions, the cops upstairs were on edge. But Vienna didn't know that at the time. And I take the call, and I just go a couple steps away. There is a fireplace there in the restaurant. and I kind of like step over closer to this fireplace and I'm kind of like oh hey what's up and upstairs is like like have you got everything like how are you doing down there and I'm like I think I've got everything like but maybe I'm not going hard enough for like some details so you want me to kind of like push push in go a little harder we give you a chance to tell me the truth I didn't know I had sex with you.

37:32I guarantee you 100%. I didn't know that. You were already going there. Yeah, yeah, I just don't know why you would have stopped, you know? I could have done anything I want. Yeah, exactly. Why would I admit that I put drugs on a drink and then not admit that I had sex with you, if I had?

37:56because you can like justify that to yourself i don't know so in in my in my because it makes you feel better even though you think maybe drugs are really bad but it's like you know less of an evil in your mind to be like oh just drugs but rape is like you know i wanted you to not even know that anything had it

38:24Say that... Does that make sense? No, say... Can you understand that I would walk into that and hope that I could take pictures of you, go through the evening, and have you wake up the next day and never know that any of it happened? Well, of course you'd want that. V, when I look at the future, when I look at your family and my family and my parents, and all of that, that's all that's at stake here right now. Yeah. Why would I not complain on that if it wasn't? Well, maybe you feel like you can get it without giving that up. For me, that's what I need you... I need you to admit to that.

39:08You're not going to. I can't. That's a lie. It really would be a lie. If I told him right now that I had done that, it would be a lie. Vienna's made it through her whole checklist of questions. So she asked Justin one last thing before she wraps up. Is there anything that I'm not asking and you're not disclosing? No reason for me to disclose this. But I took pictures of you at other times. Okay. But it wasn't with you. It was through your window. Justin's saying he took pictures of Vienna at other times, too, through her window. Okay. Which window? You downstairs? The, well, I lived with you at two separate locations, so both of them.

39:56So how many pictures of me have you or did you have? Eight, ten pictures. They were blurry. They were good quality. How many occasions did you do this on? Three, four. Justin just admitted to a whole other crime that Vienna and the cops hadn't even intended to get out of him. And he does it in his detached, neutral, unapologetic way. It's glaring that in the whole hour and a half long conversation you guys had, he never says sorry. No, absolutely. There's definitely, like, yeah, no remorse. Would it have meant anything to you for him to apologize? I mean, if he was capable of apologizing and if it actually meant something, then yeah, I would have taken it.

40:45But I don't believe he's capable. I guess, thank you for coming down here and for meeting with me. And for, I feel like, well, for finally being honest, because let's face it, you've had 14 years. Vienna spends an excruciating few minutes trying to flag down a waiter to pay for her tea. Before he leaves, Justin hands Vienna a goodie bag of cookies that Sunny had baked for her, along with a bunch of carrots from their garden. They say goodbye, and Vienna runs to the bathroom. And I think that's where it all hit my body, and it's almost like I'd have been holding my breath the whole time. Yeah. What's it like when it's hitting your body?

41:33What does it feel like? The stress of all the detail was almost being, like, downloaded to my body. Oh, dear. Oh, dear. Oh, dear. I know you.

41:53Vienna waits a minute to make sure Justin's really gone and then heads upstairs to the hotel room to meet up with her sister Shaughnessy and the undercover team. I knock on the door. Somebody opens it, and they are all, like, practically at the door. They're as close as the door as they physically all could be. And it was so visible on everyone. What does her face look like? Yeah. It's like celebration, like shock and awe and like, whoa, you did it. Vienna pulled it off. The meeting really couldn't have been more of a success. This wire recording ended up being the central piece of evidence used in court.

42:39Justin is charged with one count of sexual assault, two counts of voyeurism, and one count of administering a stupefying drug. He pleads guilty to all but the drug charge. Vienna assumes he did this to try to avoid losing his vet license. Justin ended up getting a sentence of two years minus a day of house arrest, where he was still allowed to leave the house for work and church and errands. The Crown Counsel appealed. The Court of Appeals eventually overruled the original sentence, and Justin had to serve out his term in federal prison. Though, after just six months in prison, Justin was granted parole.

43:18Whatever you think of his sentence, this result is exceptionally rare. The vast majority of sexual assaults are, of course, never reported to the police. And in Canada, of the cases that are reported and make it to court, only about 6 % result in jail time for the perpetrator. So, those are the sort of satisfying legal consequences. But remember, Vienna went into this because ever since Justin assaulted her, she'd had this unsettled feeling, this itch, to know what happened to her. And now that she knows, Vienna says that for the first time since that night, she's able to not think about what happened to her.

44:01She used to think about it all the time. It's kind of crazy how captive I was to everything that was done to me, the not knowing, and how much it dictated so much of my life. And now I don't have to worry about it anymore. I'm tired, and I'm just going to let the rest be. And then there's the last thing Vienna was hoping to get out of all of this. In some ways, it was the thing she wanted most, and that's getting her sister Sunny back. After the trial, once Vienna's parents learned the full extent of what Justin did to her, they cut Justin out. But Sunny is still married to him. Vienna had thought that if she could get Justin to lay out exactly what he did to her, with all the graphic details, and if Sunny could hear that version of the story, My hope is that she would be able to empathize, be able to be my sister instead of being his wife.

45:12I thought if she knew the truth, it would change everything. But as far as Vienna knows, Sunny never heard the tape. She served as a witness for Justin in the trial, and so was kept out of the courtroom until it was her time to be called to the stand. which meant she missed all the wire tape that Vienna's lawyers played in court. I reached out to Sunny and Justin multiple times. I never heard back. It must be frustrating to do such a good job at getting the facts of what happened that night and then for the facts to do nothing to persuade the person you're trying to convince the most that something did happen.

45:51Yeah. Yeah, it's really hard in terms of, you know, look at, I did this for you and you don't want to see it. But I also, I mean, I can't have a relationship if she can't recognize what happened or what was done to me. Like it's, I want a relationship with my sister. I love her deeply, but I also, I'm not okay with her staying married to him. So I... Yeah. They would need to break up in order for you to have a meaningfully close relationship with her again. Yes. Do you hold out any hope of that happening? Yeah. As much as I need to move on and find peace, I always hold on to a little bit of hope.

46:54After Vienna's conversation with Justin, she drove home, exhaustion taking over as the adrenaline started to recede. She still had the goodie bag from Sunny. Vienna's partner, Jordan, thought she should get rid of it, throw the stuff away. But she didn't want to. She used to love baking cookies with Sunny. Maybe this was Sunny's oblique way of saying, I know everything is messed up. I know I chose Justin over you. I know things won't ever be the same. But I'm still here, and I still love you. That's what Vienna would like to believe anyway. So she unwrapped the cookies and ate them.

47:41This story first came to us from the CBC. They made a whole four-part series about Vienna called Personally, Agent Leila. Their story goes far beyond the tape you heard today. There's a link to their series on our website. So, go take a listen. If you've experienced sexual assault and want to talk to somebody, you can reach out to the National Sexual Assault Hotline. 1-800-656-HOPE

48:15Coming up, a person passes the test they had no idea they were taking. That's in a minute from Chicago Public Radio when our program continues. Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Capital One. Capital One offers checking accounts with no fees or minimums. What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com slash Bank Guy for details. Capital One N.A. Member FDIC. Support for This American Life and the following message come from Southern New Hampshire University, a nonprofit provider of online education. SNHU students are a lot like you.

48:55Parents, professionals with big career plans, busy people balancing life's many responsibilities, and SNHU students do all of that while earning their degrees. Because with no set class times, online tuition that's less than its peers, and dedicated student support, Southern New Hampshire University makes going back to school possible. Get started at snhu.edu slash American. This message comes from Whole Foods Market. Host Thanksgiving with industry-leading quality standards from Whole Foods Market. There are no antibiotics in their meat department ever, so carve up turkey and spiral-cut ham with peace of mind.

49:30Shop organic sides like stuffing mix and cranberry sauce from 365 brand. And all their delectable pies are made with no high-fructose corn syrup. Gourmet Thanksgiving flavors with the quality you want, only at Whole Foods Market. It's This American Life. I'm Aviva de Kornfeld, sitting in for Ira Glass. Today's show, The Missing Minutes. We've arrived at Act 2 of our show, Act 2, Unknown Unknowns. So there's information you know you don't know. But then there's all the other stuff. Stuff that just doesn't quite make sense. But you don't know why. You feel like you're missing something. So you hope that one day, it'll all be explained and finally made clear.

50:15This last story is a short piece of fiction about what that day might be like. It's by Miranda July. Here she is. Someone is getting excited. Somebody somewhere is shaking with excitement because something tremendous is about to happen to this person. This person has dressed for the occasion. This person's hoped and dreamed. And now it is really happening and this person can hardly believe it. But believing is not an issue here. It is really, really happening. It involves stepping forward and bowing. Possibly there is some kneeling, such as when one is knighted. One is almost never knighted. But this person may kneel and receive a tap on each shoulder with a sword.

51:03Or, more likely, this person will be in a car or a store or under a vinyl canopy when it happens. Or online or on the phone. It could be an email. Re your knighthood. Or a long, laughing, rambling phone message in which every person this person has ever known is talking on a speakerphone and they are all saying, you have passed the test. It was all just a test. We were only kidding. Real life is so much better than that. This person is laughing out loud with relief and playing the message back to get the address of the place where every person this person has ever known is waiting to hug this person and bring her into the fold of life.

51:45It is really exciting. And it's not just a dream. It's real.

51:59They are all waiting by a picnic table in a park this person has driven past many times before. There they are. It's everyone. There are balloons taped to the benches and the girl this person used to stand next to at the bus stop is waving a streamer. Everyone is smiling. For a moment, this person is almost creeped out by the scene, but it would be so like this person to become depressed on the happiest day ever. So this person bucks up and joins the crowd. Teachers of subjects that this person wasn't even good at are kissing this person and renouncing the very subjects they taught. Math teachers are saying that math was just a funny way of saying, I love you.

52:47But now they are simply saying it. I love you. And the chemistry and PE teachers are also saying it, and this person can tell they really mean it. It's totally amazing. Certain jerks and idiots and assholes appear from time to time And it's as if they've had plastic surgery Their faces are disfigured with love The handsome assholes are plain and kind And the ugly jerks are sweet And they're folding this person's sweater And putting it somewhere where it won't get dirty Best of all, every person this person has ever loved is there Even the ones who got away. They hold this person's hand and tell this person how hard it was to pretend to get mad and drive off and never come back.

53:39This person almost can't believe it. It seemed so real. This person's heart was broken and has healed and this person hardly knows what to think. This person is almost mad. But everyone soothes this person. everyone explains that it was absolutely necessary to know how strong this person was. Oh look, there's the doctor who prescribed the medicine that made this person temporarily blind, and the man who paid this person$2 ,000 to have sex with him three times when this person was very broke. Both these men are in attendance. They seem to know each other. They both have little medals that they're pinning on this person.

54:22They are badges of great honor and strength. The badges sparkle in the sunlight, and everyone cheers. This person suddenly feels the need to check her post office box. It is an old habit, and even if everything's going to be terrific from now on, this person still wants mail. This person says she'll be right back, and everyone this person has ever known says, fine, take your time. This person gets in her car and drives to the post office and opens the box and there is nothing Even though it is Tuesday, which is a famously good day for mail This person is so disappointed This person gets back in the car and, having completely forgotten about the picnic Drives home and checks the voicemail and there are no new messages Just the old one about passing the test and life being better There are no emails either, probably because everyone is at the picnic.

55:26This person can't seem to go back to the picnic. This person realizes that staying home means blowing off everyone this person has ever known. But the desire to stay in is very strong. This person wants to run a bath and then read in bed. In the bathtub, this person pushes the bubbles around and listens to the sound of millions of them popping at once This person pushes the bubbles onto their breasts and makes weird shapes with the foam By now, everyone must have realized that this person is not coming back to the picnic Everyone was wrong This person is not who they thought this person was This person plunges underwater This person can stay underwater for an impressively long time, but only in a bathtub.

56:19This person wonders if there will ever be an Olympic contest for holding your breath under bathwater. If there were such a contest, this person would surely win it. An Olympic medal might redeem this person in the eyes of everyone this person has ever known. But no such contest exists, so there will be no redeeming. This person mourns the fact that she has ruined her one chance to be loved by everyone As this person climbs into bed, the weight of this tragedy seems to bear down upon this person's chest And it is a comforting weight Almost human in heft This person sighs This person's eyes begin to close This person sleeps

57:19Randa July. She's the author of the book All Fours, which is the only book that I, upon completing, flipped over and immediately started reading again. I can't recommend it enough. Randa also has a sub stack called, appropriately, Randa July. Check it out.

57:41We can look at myself Walking this dog alone Watching the ice caps melt With all of the plans I made Just crumbling at my feet While I'm making scrambled eggs And trying to change the sheets Our program today was produced by me and edited by Ira Glass. The people who put together today's show include Mike Kamite, Cassie Howley, Hannah Jaffe-Wall, Adrian Lilly, Seth Lind, Miki Meek, Catherine Raimondo, Stone Nelson, Nadia Raymond, Marisa Robertson-Pechster, Anthony Roman, Ryan Ramery, Ruby Schwartz, Alyssa Shipp, and Diane Wu. Our managing editor is Sarah Abdurahman. Our senior editors are David Kestenbaum and Nancy Updike.

58:39Our executive editor is Emmanuel Berry. Thank you to all of our This American Life partners who pitch in to help us continue making the show. Join, and you'll listen ad-free, unlock dozens of exclusive bonus episodes, and more perks. Sign up at thisamericanlife.org slash lifepartners. This American Life is delivered to public radio stations by PRX, the public radio exchange. Thanks as always to my boss, Ira Glass. You know, he finally told me this week why every time he has to go to a meeting with our colleagues here at the show, he locks all his valuables in his office. Not to, like, stereotype, but many of them are, like, criminals.

59:20I'm Aviva de Kornfeld. Ira Glass will be back next week with more stories of this American life.

59:38Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Integrative Therapeutics, makers of Cortisol Manager. Daily stressors come and go, and heightened stress can affect sleep and focus. Cortisol Manager helps support a healthy response to everyday stress. Available at Amazon.com. Use code STRESS2026 for 20 % off. These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.

From the publisher

A woman secretly records a conversation at a hotel bar, hoping to fill a gap in her memory that has bothered her for nearly 15 years.

Start a Life Partners free trial to watch our new video, A Night of Stories and Improv.

(00:00:00) Prologue: Vienna Luke sits at the bar, waiting for the man she’s arranged to meet to arrive. She has a hidden recorder in her purse, and another hidden in her bra. Three cops in plain clothes sit at tables around her. When the man arrives, Vienna starts the conversation she’s been waiting to have for over a decade. (3 minutes)

(00:04:58) Act One: Vienna believes that her brother-in-law, Justin, sexually assaulted her years ago. Now, she finally gets to ask him the truth about what happened that night. He actually answers her questions. (42 minutes)

(00:47:28) Act Two: What if, one day, you learned something that suddenly made your whole life make sense? Miranda July reads her short story about a person in that situation. 

Transcripts are available at thisamericanlife.org / This American Life privacy policy. / Learn more about sponsor message choices.

More from This American Life

All episodes