

29 Oct 2026 · 1h 12m · 27 chapters

VC panel dissects Anthropic’s S-1 ahead of an expected NASDAQ IPO (ticker ANT), debating whether AI is “the new cigarettes” (high, repeatable spend) and how to interpret AI company financials, especially profitability, compute CapEx, and non-cash losses.
DA Wallach, co-founder/GP at Time BioVentures (life sciences/healthcare VC). Dave McClure, managing partner at Practical Venture Capital (venture secondary market). Ben Black, co-founder/managing director of Acadian Ventures (venture secondaries; runs SPVs).
Anthropic’s H1 revenue is $16.3B (up ~14x YoY), with Q2 operating profit of $974M; the reported net loss ($80.7B) is largely non-cash markups tied to convertible notes/derivatives/safes. CapEx is described as “crazy” (hundreds of billions/large commitments to Google/Amazon), raising questions about sustainability. Panel cites a “0.1%” claim: corporate users spend about 0.1% of operating budgets on AI today, implying headroom but also a utility/deployment bottleneck (“meat sacks” and orchestration).
Uber reportedly burned tokens quickly then moved 30,000 employees to OpenAI at once; Microsoft’s large-scale AI rollout is framed as a roadmap. They discuss 900% net revenue retention (same customer cohort spending ~9x more). They also compare subscription metrics (e.g., Microsoft 365 estimated ~110M subscribers) and argue analysts need new measures for “compute-at-margin” businesses.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Introducing the panel of venture capital experts discussing Anthropic's S-1.
“We've also got our good friend, Dave McClure, managing partner over at Practical Venture Capital.”
Exploring the key details of Anthropic's S-1 filing and its implications.
“So, T.A., we've got five or six subsections here, many different ways to go.”
Panelists discuss their insights and differing opinions on Anthropic's prospects.
“You've got to make sense out of fragmented information and try to paint a picture of what's happening, but I still have no idea what's happening.”
Analyzing Anthropic's revenue trends and growth projections amidst competition.
“If that's where the first thing that came to your mind is crazy, how does one go from crazy to sustainable and connect the gap between CapEx spend and revenue and profitability?”
Discussing the challenges of measuring AI company success with traditional metrics.
“Obviously, we see flat, but what is that based on?”
Drawing parallels between AI companies and traditional industries like tobacco.
“Eight markets, March 2025 to February 2026.”
Exploring the potential impact of AI and its adoption in various sectors.
“I had dinner with my friend Aaron Battalion.”
Discussing current AI spending levels among corporations and potential growth.
“out is this is this something i'm going to be using for the rest of my life and how many how many packs a day right and i thought the most interesting number in the in the s1 was this 0.1 % figure.”
Promoting the Conservation Fund and its initiatives for environmental protection and economic opportunities.
“And this isn't just Elantra scooping up property and sitting on it.”
Analyzing Anthropic's revenue model and its comparison with major tech companies.
“billion in yearly revenue, this puts Anthropic at a quarter of Alphabet's revenue, a third of Microsoft's annual revenue and a quarter of Apple's annual revenue.”
Analyzing Anthropic's revenue model and its comparison with major tech companies.
“I'm going to play everybody's famous game.”
Exploring the potential of AI subscription services and competitive positioning.
“110 million is the best I can estimate here.”
Discussion on consumer AI platforms, market positions, and dynamics affecting Figma and Canva.
“They're already shockingly low Black Friday and Cyber Monday pricing.”
Debating the motivations and ethical implications of AI founders and their companies.
“Ultimately, the market, it's not a public company.”
Discussion on the motivations of AI leaders and their pursuit of profit versus ideals.
“No, I don't think I've ever heard Sachs take that position.”
Analysis of compute costs in AI business models and implications for companies.
“Okay, Ben, you want to get in here, Russell Crowe?”
Examination of Anthropic's financial strategies and the implications of convertible notes.
“I mean, by the way, he might not have lost Elon.”
Clarification on how AI companies' financials are interpreted and the market outlook.
“Hitting public markets for the first time in a in a significant way.”
Discussion on the resilience of hyperscalers and their competitive advantages in the market.
“I mean, Dave, you were kind of rolling your eyes there, I'm assuming because off balance sheet loans and stuff like that.”
Discussion on recent investments in companies like SpaceX and OpenAI, including performance metrics.
“Top three holdings in your public, private, what do they call this?”
A detailed analysis of Bitcoin's market position, challenges, and the shifting narrative around its value.
“Did you see my did you see my Bitcoin post?”
Exploring the implications of Bitcoin's stagnation compared to traditional assets like gold amid economic shifts.
“There is no more have fun being poor and put laser eyes in because it's embarrassing to do that when the thing is sideways for so long.”
Discussion on the evolving landscape of venture capital, focusing on the rise of SPVs and the changing dynamics of funding.
“And I think the question then, Jason, is like, has Bitcoin after 15 years earned its place next to gold and the other debasement trade assets?”
Insights on the new breed of entrepreneurs and the concept of 'alicorns' in the startup ecosystem.
“I understand the incentives that drive asset managers.”
The panel is thanked and an announcement is teased.
“Thanks to Ben and our entire panel for being here.”
The hosts discuss the launch of a newsletter aimed at supporting founders with practical advice.
“We looked at all the newsletters out there in the world, DA.”
The hosts share closing thoughts and say goodbye.
“I was going to say, everyone on the show.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On This Week in Startups, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00All right, everybody, welcome back to This Week in Startups slash This Week in Venture Capital. It's a little of both. We have three shows, a little bit of both. We posted the This Week in Startups feed. That's been around the longest, but we do three distinct shows every week. This Week in AI, This Week in VC, and This Week in Startups. And they each have a corresponding newsletter that we're working on. We're hiring, looking for two or three great writers. So we have a big docket today and an incredible list of guests, Lon. We obviously are going to get deep into Anthropics S1, which dropped recently.
0:33Let's, from a venture capital perspective, of course, let's intro our amazing guests. Sure. First up, we've got DA Wallach. He's the co-founder and general partner of Time BioVentures. They're a life sciences and healthcare venture capital firm. We've also got our good friend, Dave McClure, managing partner over at Practical Venture Capital. He's the managing partner over there. It's a firm focused on the venture secondary market. Finally, we've got Ben Black, the co-founder and managing director of Acadian Ventures. They're a firm that invests in venture secondaries, and they run SPVs, Jason.
1:08Got it. All right, let's get started with our first story. We're going to talk about Anthropic, of course. They filed their public S1 on Monday for a NASDAQ listing as ANT Ant, with the price range and share count left blank for now. Revenue for the first half of the year came in at$16.3 billion. That's up 14x from around$1.2 billion in the first half of 2025. Q2 this year saw an operating profit of$974 million. Net loss was$80.7 billion, but$72.4 billion of that was driven by a non-cash accounting charge on convertible notes, derivative liabilities, and safes, which were marked up as the company's valuation rises.
1:47The Wall Street Journal reports that Anthropic aims to go public the week of November 16th, raising$100 billion or more at a valuation of around$1.5 to$2 trillion. So, T.A., we've got five or six subsections here, many different ways to go. What stands out to you about the Anthropic S1 in this story? Well, I mean, I think, like, with everything that's happening in AI, the hard part is figuring out what's sales pitch and what's reality. And obviously, this was timed and positioned in such a way as to sort of comfort the market as to the company's, you know, profitability or potential profitability.
2:26So there's, of course, been this raging debate over, you know, whether inference is profitable, how much money they're losing. And I think the clear intention of the timing and the way this was all framed was to sort of put everyone at ease, say, look, we're sitting on a ton of cash and we're not spending as much as you think we might be. And it's all going to be OK. Did they accomplish that task? Is everybody? I don't know. I mean, I don't know what the I don't know what the hell's going on. It's like you're seeing these little fragmentary views of the elephant every week and every Gavin Baker interview and every all-in podcast and whatever, but you still never get to see the whole elephant.
3:07So, of course, that's what investing is. You've got to make sense out of fragmented information and try to paint a picture of what's happening, but I still have no idea what's happening. Which is very similar, by the way, to poker. You are trying to make really good decisions with partial information, right? Like I know my whole cards, but I don't know yours or the other seven people at the table. maybe no three cards on the flop, but I still don't know the turn in the river to come. So I think that's actually a great way of framing it. Dave, when you saw the numbers drop and you start unpacking the hand, do you feel more bullish on the AI trade?
3:42Do you feel like this is making people more confident in what's being built out here and the sustainability of it? Or do you feel like you have more questions rather than answers. I feel like they did themselves a favor. I think there's been a lot of concerns in the last quarter that revenue might have been plateauing. I think we still have those concerns. Questions about whether OpenAI is taking share, whether OpenWay models are taking share. Company looks like they are profitable. It looks like they've been, on an operating basis, profitable for the last two quarters. It looks like CapEx spend is crazy.
4:19That's over$500 billion of CapEx. I don't know over what period of time, but$100 billion plus commitments to both Google and Amazon, which are locked in. Well, maybe unpack that for a minute then, Dave. If that's where the first thing that came to your mind is crazy, how does one go from crazy to sustainable and connect the gap between CapEx spend and revenue and profitability? Take a moment there. If they had gone public last quarter, I think everybody would have been happy with putting a$2 trillion to$3 trillion valuation on the company. But if you look at – I don't know if we can share the graph of ticker trends.
4:57This is anthropic revenue. This is OpenAI revenue. Okay. So when we're looking at the anthropic revenue, this is company-wide annualized revenue run rate. We just did a story about this in our newsletter, actually. We did? This is ARRR, as in a pirate. A-R-R-R. When you see that, which is not to be confused with ARR, with three Rs, annualized run rate is typically done by taking the last month or the last quarter and timesing it either by that period of time, 12 or four. And here, what we're seeing is it's flat at 76.8 billion in ARR. And you see here, even on this website, they put ARR, which would lead you to believe it's annualized reoccurring revenue.
5:50Annualized reoccurring revenue is for subscription products like Netflix or your Verizon accounts. It's distinctly different than this. So what's your takeaway here? Obviously, we see flat, but what is that based on? Where did they get that number from? You looked at the growth from January to July. You'd be like, holy shit, that is crazy growth. That's almost hyperbolic. but then it tailed off a little bit and people were wondering like why did that tail off was that because of open ai releasing models that were more competitive and taking share uh replit recently announced they've been switching their default uh to open ai instead of anthropic is it because open weight models are taking share i would still say that anthropic is or maybe there's a data problem here like maybe this website doesn't have like who knows where they're getting their data from here.
6:38Yeah. I think my partner just did a teardown of the Anthropic S1, and it still looks like they are growing. I think they added at least$5 billion of new revenue in the quarter. So I'm not concerned that Anthropic is not growing, but they're not growing as fast. And I think you'd kind of want to look at that and compare that to the CapEx spend. Can they just keep up with the spend that they're doing, and is that revenue going to continue? they had previously been talking about$200,$300 billion kind of run rates by the end of next year. I'm not sure. I'm still a believer that they're going to hit$300.
7:13I might guess it's going to be between$150 to$200 next year. We'll see. But they did kind of answer a lot of questions about profitability that seemed like they had profitability under control. I think I'm still a believer in Anthropic, probably at$1.5 trillion, not at$2 or$2.5 trillion. That's just my hot take. All right, Ben, your takeaway when you saw the S1 and the ensuing discussions. When I saw the S1, I really was so impressed with how much analysis could be done in such short period of time with AI. There were so many analysis, I could barely keep up with them all. It was like an amount of analysis.
7:55But really, when I read the S1 and said, we need new measures. You know, this is really the first time we've had financials from a company that does what Anthropic does that are getting now to be torn down by public market analysts. And how the public market analysts, you know, I would say with private companies, this is the moment where the rubber hits the road. And right now we're just seeing literally like the first inkling of all the, you know, of the way that we're going to analyze these companies. We're still just like what you did. We're trying to take SaaS analytical tools like ARR and slap them on a completely new type of business model.
8:35It's going to take a while before I think that the world of business analysts catch up with Anthropic and OpenAI, where essentially you're selling compute at some sort of margin. And you're selling it across multiple models that have different values and different costs, all of which are falling. And I, frankly, am not sure I understand this business yet. I think that's the biggest takeaway I have, is that we have to have a whole new set of measures for these businesses that really help us understand what's going on. Because I think the S1 can be characterized in one way by one group of people, another way by another group of people.
9:12And who wins the framing in the next two weeks is going to determine whether or not 1.5 trillion is a good number or not. This holiday season, don't miss your chance to turn just looking into just bought it. Make it easy for your customers to say yes on the spot. PayPal checkout is a trusted conversion engine fueled by 400 million active PayPal and Venmo accounts. And when you add pay later, you turn holiday shoppers into regulars. 96 % of pay later shoppers are repeat users. Give them pay later flexibility now, and it could help earn their loyalty all year long. PayPal is built for all business.
9:51Get started at paypal.com slash business. PayPal Later Data. Eight markets, March 2025 to February 2026. Repeat users defined as more than one pay later purchase in the past year. Yeah, well, the framing is pretty obviously here. The revenue is surging. Absolutely. That's something we know. And they're profitable and they've got a mountain of cash. So if I look at those just three factors. Well, revenue is surging, but not as fast as it was earlier this year. As the number gets bigger, it slows down a bit. So you can't expect a 10x on$16 billion. It's not possible. It has never happened in the history of it.
10:30So it's going to slow down. The revenue is extraordinary. It's the fastest growing company in the history of business. The cash position is extraordinary. They've barely touched their cash. And so I look at this and say, we've got the greatest business in the history of capitalism ever built. Wait a second, Jason. The greatest business, I thought you were saying last month with SpaceX. Isn't that still the greatest business? I don't know if I said that. I think it's the greatest entrepreneur across a series of different businesses. This is one business selling tokens. And one business selling tokens to be profitable.
11:07but this company was formed, I believe, in 2021, revenue turned on in 2023. So to go from zero to whatever the annualized run rate will be after Q3 data comes out, 80, 100, et cetera, and to have a ton of cash and to be profitable at this point is just extraordinary. I thought they would have been losing a ton of money. So I think this is the greatest business created by humans on planet Earth ever. I wonder if we're underestimating some stuff here, though. I had dinner with my friend Aaron Battalion. He was formerly the CTO at Living Social. And he was saying, we're not even measuring the right stuff.
11:47He's saying, with all the potential for breakthroughs in mathematics, in medical, in a whole bunch of areas, there's potentially new lines of revenue that we're not even measuring. What if either anthropic or open AI solves cancer, like where's this aging, figures out new breakthroughs in other areas. I think DA was actually suggesting there's some stuff coming that people are showing off their lack of concern. We can talk about the anthropic AI releases later maybe, or now, but I was saying to Dave before this, the craziest thing that's happening you guys may have heard about is the AI engineers are now taking up smoking.
12:27And this has become a way of smoking cigarettes. This is a very positive. This is a very, if they're hitting darts, that's a very positive sign. So they're smoking cigarettes and they are doing so as a way of signaling how confident they are that AI is going to cure cancer. So I would view this as a very toppy signal. You know, when people are willing to literally commit suicide because they believe so much in their religion. It's interesting. I'm not sure we've ever seen that in capitalism. It's like, no, no, I think this is the buy sign. It's the ultimate buy sign. They're literally willing to ski without a helmet.
13:06They're like, this is fine. It's all in the line. Now, Jason, it didn't occur to me until you said this is the greatest business in the history of capitalism. The actual greatest business in the history of the stock market over the past 100 years, as you guys may know, was Altria, Philip Morris. Yeah. And, you know, why was that such a great business? Well, enormous gross margins and an incredibly addictive product with virtually unlimited demand. So no churn. At least 10 years ago, the number I heard was still today, a billion cigarette six sold every day around the world. One billion. so i think the fundamental question for anthropic and all the players in this market is basically is intelligence the new cigarettes right so far a little free sample the drug dealer's given a free sample to every company in the world and everyone's trying it and they're trying to figure out is this is this something i'm going to be using for the rest of my life and how many how many packs a day right and i thought the most interesting number in the in the s1 was this 0.1 % figure.
14:15They basically said, I don't know if it was their top customers or all of corporate America, but they said basically the users of our intelligence are spending roughly a tenth of a percent of their total operating expenditures on AI today. So you can think of that, I think, in two different ways. View number one, which is the way Anthropoc was trying to present, was, you know, they've barely scratched the surface. Think about how much headroom there is on that number. I mean, if you just double it or triple it, you can easily start to see how we get to a couple trillion dollars a year of spend.
14:52On the other hand, it does to me complicate this sort of Jevons paradox framing of this whole thing, because I would ask, well, why aren't they already today spending 1 % or a half percent? And is what's keeping them from spending at that level that the cost is too high, or is it still a utility question? And I guess my hypothesis would be it's mainly a utility question. And I'm going to say the thing that everyone has to say before they ever defame AI, which is, oh, but I use it all day and I love it. And it's so changed my life and my business. You have to say that so you don't sound like a Luddite.
15:32But why aren't they spending two tenths of a percent today? Because it seems pretty obvious that this is something you have to be experimenting with extensively, no matter what your business is. So wait, why aren't they spending two percent on? On AI 2%. On Claude, on intelligence broadly. I mean, if they're spending a tenth of a percent on Claude, You need the right people to implement, right? And then you need the right projects. So, and 2 % of a company making, I don't know. Sorry, sorry. Right now they're saying one 10th of a percent of total budget. Of total. At which companies? Fortune 500?
16:14You know, whatever. Corporate America. Got it. So, I think it's because there's a, I think the number is 2 % AI spend at the top companies. So I think if we chop off the laggards and we say 1 % or 2 % is the right amount of spend for today, I just think it's probably the Fortune 100s, Fortune 500s are actually spending tens of millions, I would say hundreds of millions in tokens a year. That's like what we saw Uber was spending. Well, that's, yeah. It's still a small number. I mean, I think there are a couple of questions. One, is the addressable market what they're spending on SaaS? right? Is this just going to bigger their SAS budget?
16:55It's got to be double. So is it going to start by eating their SAS budget and then eat more? Or is it going to be incremental? I mean, I think like, you know, you have this other major uncertainty here, which is that everyone involved here is doing the rational thing. So Anthropics doing the rational thing to pre-order all that compute, even though it might put them in a tough place. Every corporate CEO is doing the rational thing to do a bunch of pilots and spend a bunch on tokens and figure out what this can do. The question is going to be, are these rational actors who are both ramping up their AI activities going to be doing so at rates that lead them to meet at the same level?
17:39Right. I mean, ultimately what matters here is the demand supply and demand. I got it. Yeah. And right now everybody says, oh, that we can't meet the demand. The demand's too high. But then I go again, well, they're only spending 0.1%. The presumption in that comment is typically if the price were lower, they'd be spending more. In other words, when you say this is supply constrained, what it's suggesting is that the supply constraint is leading to a price. I think it's a meat sack constrained DA is the people, the meat sacks at organizations are not able to deploy it. It's too heady for the average employee.
18:20The meat sacks are blocking this. And then if you look at a company like, say, Uber, which adopts the technology pretty fast, they burned all their tokens in the first quarter, famously, and then we're like, oh, what do we do now? They just put all of their employees, I think it was 30 ,000, on OpenAI at once. So I think that this is the key issue. When are the meat sacks able, which organizations will put 100 % of meat sacks on this? And will they be able to not just be the meat bridge, the compiler between the output and the input of the AI, and actually orchestrate it? When could they be sophisticated enough to orchestrate this towards a business result?
18:58And I think Microsoft and their 60 ,000 person buyout, one in four employees that are being offered a buyout, is a roadmap. I think another organization like them, they see it, the writing's on the wall. Dave, you've been wanting, Oh, good. Lon and then Dave. Oh, I was just gonna say on this week in AI this week, Andy Berman of RunLayer addressed this exactly that. That's what he was saying is that it's just the companies have yet to attach the AI to the data and the systems that would actually cause it to become more valuable. And so that's we're just waiting for them to sort of make that. And why?
19:30Why are they not doing that? Exactly the reason that you said that it's just like people being hesitant or not understanding or security concerns or the meat privacy concerns. Yeah, so I think it's both. The meat sack doesn't know what to do. Right. They're like, what do I do? I already summarized this article. How many more? I don't have any more articles to summarize. Like, but that's not what this technology is for. That was like the demo four years ago. And cyber has made everybody in these big corporations play on their heels. Go ahead, Dave. I think we're going to get there. I mean, this is early innings.
20:01I liken this to like, you know, teenagers in high school talking about sex. They want to talk about like everybody's doing it, but not everybody's doing it. And eventually they do get there. So as we got to move up the stack, I think you're going to see AI productivity gains hit not just tech companies, but normal companies. We're still in the early stages. And a lot of people talk about AI, but most people are not really using the full potential of AI. Most people are still using it like Google prompts. A few people are starting to use it for agents, but we're pretty early on. A lot of people think there is a binary choice be a capitalist who supports growth, or care about the environment and the natural world.
20:43But these two ideas don't have to be in opposition. Our friends at the Conservation Fund believe that you can protect land, wildlife, and our shared access to the great outdoors, while also providing important economic opportunities. For 40 years, the Conservation Fund has been acting quickly to protect at-risk land and important wildlife habitats, while also actively supporting local communities and, this is key, creating new jobs. The Conservation Fund already protects over 9 million acres across all 50 states, proving that we can watch out for the environment and keep our natural surroundings in balance without endless gridlock, debate, and politics.
21:24And this isn't just Elantra scooping up property and sitting on it. They're working alongside permanent stewards who will find practical uses for these important spaces without destroying them. Find out more about how the Conservation Fund is changing the playbook at conservationfund.org. All right, just to put this in context, Ben, if we round up to$100 billion in yearly revenue, this puts Anthropic at a quarter of Alphabet's revenue, a third of Microsoft's annual revenue and a quarter of Apple's annual revenue. In but three or four years of charging for their product. That's why I'm sort of saying like, are we fully appreciating this number?
22:14Have we really taken a hundred billion dollars in revenue and put it next to, you know, Alphabet's 400 or Microsoft's 350 or, you know, Apple's 400 and change? Like this is truly, truly nuts. And it's based upon one, but one business model, subscribe slash buy token. So maybe arguably two different billing plans, consumption and subscription, but it's one thing. It's just like one little thing here. Just buy this intelligence. What if they have other products? What if they started? Yeah, that's my point. The one number that I just couldn't get over was the 900 % net revenue retention. Well, unpack that and explain it, Ben, for somebody listening.
22:59What does it mean to have 900 % retention? Basically, they took the same customer cohort from a three-month period a year ago and looked at how much they were spending, how much they were spending, and then looked at and basically said that same three months this year, same customers, for the three-month, nine times more. Nine times as much. Nine times. I went and I tried to look through history. And, you know, I can't imagine another product, including smoking, because it'd kill you real fun, you know, where you use nine times as much of the product. And that goes to say that this is the most useful product I think that's ever been created.
23:43Now, what this says about the long-term ability to extract profits, when you compare it to Microsoft, right? And you're on desktops all over the world. You have a pretty good, clear sense product that they're going to be still charging for that 30 years later. Now, I think that what's really hard to understand here is how sustainable this incredible growth is and their ability to extract profits. Because we know the prices keep falling the minute that the models get slightly out of date. Because you have this really interesting problem of being like, how long are people willing to pay for the frontier as enterprises get better and better at consuming this product?
24:25And the meat sacks get in control of OpenRouter and start sending them to lower cost open source models. Okay, here's what we're going to do. We're going to look at the top subscription products of all time, or currently and all time. And then we're going to put OpenAI and we're going to put Anthropic into that table. And then we're going to see if you guys can guess who has more subscribers, who has less. Don't cheat on this simple test. Before we do that, Lon, I just forgot. Gosh, we're starting this incredible discussion, and I lost it. But now I'm putting on my plod pin. Here we go. Please, yes.
25:07Pause for the cause here. I got my plod pin on. I just very gently pressed the button. You can barely see it there on my lapel. and I'm off to the races. Now I'm recording everything. I'm taking notes. And I can say, this would make a great blog post for my newsletter, JCal on startups to talk about subscriptions and how to grow subscriptions. And maybe we should do a tactical practical one. And I could just mute myself on the podcast, say that, put it in there and say, hey, make sure this gets on my to-do list. Boom. Plot's going to make sure. And I see you have your plot as well. Is that for your ever increasing list of to-do items that you haven't gotten back to me on yet long?
25:42That's exactly that. There would be no way for me to keep track of everything going on at the podcast and newsletter studio that we're running without the Plod Pin. I keep it on me all day. I'm always hitting it just for little reminders, little notes, whatever I'm going to need. And then I can check in at the end of the day and the beginning of the next day and get to all those checklist items that we did not get to the previous day. So if you want to check out a Plod pin for yourself, go to plod.ai slash twist and use the code twist. And they're going to give you 10 % off plod.ai slash twist.
26:15All right. Now we're back. I'm going to play everybody's famous game. Who has more subscribers? DA. The name of the game is who has more subscribers? More subscribers. Do you understand the name of the game? I love it. Okay. You do understand. Which game show host was that? I don't know. Just my generic. Wink, wink, wink, Calacanisdale, something like that. Okay. In all seriousness, I don't know if everybody understands exactly how many subscribers these products have. Anthropic is undisclosed right now, unfortunately, so the game kind of doesn't work. uh consumers according to uh open ai and some reports open ai has 50 million subscribers 50 million subscribers in their consumer base out of their 900 million weekly users about six percent so the game is off i was i was kind of goofing on it when i teased it but um let's talk about that as a concept because in all seriousness, the one I always go to is, and I'll just ask you to give me your best guest, your best, best guest, DA Wallach.
27:33How many subscribers does Microsoft 365 have? Microsoft Office. And this is obviously the most successful business subscription service. I'll give you a little clue there. That's the most successful one of all time. I'm going to guess 200 million. Very close. 110 million subscribers. It's extraordinary when you think about that. It has over 10 billion in estimated annual revenue for consumers, but paid subscribers, 110 million is the best I can estimate here. And if these things are at 50, and these are consumers, prosumers, this is an enormous subscription business. Do you think consumers will ultimately pay 20 bucks a month for this like they do for their Netflix?
28:20You know, I think I think an agent's or I think both Apple and Google haven't reached their steady state offering yet, clearly. And, you know, in so far as the mobile phone remains the preeminent computing platform, it's theirs to lose. so my assumption is that at some point in the future apple intelligence is going to be at parity with these things i mean it'd be a real screw up for i mean it's all right they've already screwed up by not being there today okay but they're the biggest you know one of the biggest companies in the world they're not hemorrhaging cash the way that all their competitors are right now on ai infrastructure so they've got a big budget that they should be dedicating to ensuring that everyone who uses an iPhone is not paying a$20 a month Claude subscription or open AI subscription.
29:17Do you think that's a cup or do you think that's a good bet? Because I think they decided to wait it out. I think they're patient. I think they have the distribution. So they're in the pole position here. And, you know, I would be doing the same thing they're doing. I mean, I would assume that they're trying a lot of stuff in inside the company. And once they get to a product that they feel is good enough, safe enough, user friendly enough. That's just going to be what's preloaded, right? And they get up, then they buy instinct. Exactly. $10 billion. I mean, I think they can wait. They've got the distribution and, you know, we'll see if Sam Altman's mobile device, whatever that ends up being is going to actually be the next platform.
30:02I don't think the meta glasses are likely to display cell phones. So as of yet, we have not found the successor to the iPhone. And the same can be said of Google. And obviously, they're further ahead on AI than Apple is. So it's also theirs to lose when it comes to the people who are using Android phones. Founders, here's a practical and tactical tip for you. Before you raise even a single dollar, before you even think about making that first or second hire, you need a real professional looking website every investor every recruit and every customer is going to google you then they're going to wind up at your website and you need them to walk away feeling confident that you're an established real company that cares about your image and having a beautiful stunning website well yeah of course that can sound expensive time consuming maybe even a little intimidating if you don't have taste or you don't think you have taste but you don't need to start seeking out tons of developers and designers no you just sign up for hosting her i checked out their ai website builder.
31:02And with a few clicks, I was already working on a clean landing page and a waitlist sign up for a new startup idea I had, and we built it all in minutes. Hostinger's help doesn't stop when you've launched your website. No, their AI agents will walk you through the basics of SEO, writing crisp website copy, email marketing, and more. Go to hostinger.com slash twist and use the code twist for an additional 10 % off. They're already shockingly low Black Friday and Cyber Monday pricing. Here's your chart before you go, Dave. Apple services, obviously really huge. Anthropic, 65 billion run rate, I guess, if they're all subscription.
31:40We don't know if tokens is broken out there. OpenAI, 50 billion. Netflix, 49 billion. Salesforce, 40 billion. Adobe, 27 billion. People have talked a lot about that one being at risk. And obviously, Spotify has done pretty well. Can I just say one last thing, Dave, before I hand it over? yeah i have i have not given access to my email to anything yet okay that's really that's my red line wow that's what's going on in your email what's going on well a lot a lot of that's your gmail from like 20 years ago is it your corporate i'm not gonna say what i'm not saying what platform i'm using but i have not given the keys to any of these guys and i'm i'm to me that's the test That's the test.
32:24Can you get 100 million iPhone users to hand over all their data to one of these new companies? Absolutely. And Apple is much more likely. Well, there's something going on. I think maybe. I have an idea for you, DA. All you got to do is make a shadow email. Make a new one. DA new at. And then all your emails that come in from this point forward get sent there. And then your old account is human only. And the new account is human plus machine. That's complicated. It's a little complicated. It is complicated. It is complicated. You have a digital twin. Before we go on, we should shout out harmonic.ai.
33:02Thanks to them. Oh, okay. Here we go. Another pause for the cause. For that amazing chart that you showed with comparing all the subscription services, pulled that directly from our friends at harmonic.ai. Thanks to them. Okay. And everybody go get a harmonic.ai, especially if you're in the VC business. Basically, imagine you had a database of every possible deal and a custom made LLM put together with it. Incredible for research. If I'm handing the keys over, I would much rather that that AI be predominantly local. Yes, me too. This edge stuff, again, for the top enterprises doing really complicated workflows and multi-agents, all that's probably all going to be cloud.
33:39I get that. But I still find the argument persuasive that for the average consumer, 99 % of what they're going to want to use AI to do will be doable on the edge, on their iPhone, within a few years. So why wouldn't that be where we ultimately go? I think you were bringing up an interesting point about the consumer subscription. I think you were looking at customers, not necessarily users. I was doing a little research in the background here. Sorry, I didn't follow your rules. So top three consumer AI platforms, who do you think is one, two, three? It's got to be OpenAI and Google are pretty similar.
34:16I'm going to say Google on top, OpenAI, and then Chachipiti. Close. OpenAI is number one. Google Gemini is number two. Guess who's number three? You were not correct. Wait, hold on. It's not. It's not. So is it Google? It's Canva. Canva is number three consumer AI usage platform right now. Consumer AI. Wait, wait. Usage or subscribers? Okay, that's a little bit... Usage. That's why I was saying... That's an interesting interpretation of Canva as an AI product. Because Canva obviously is a design product with AI features. I wouldn't say it's an AI-first product yet. But maybe I'm wrong. They're trying.
34:58They're trying. I think a lot of people were suggesting that Canva's business is getting eaten up by Claude Design. Figma certainly suffered from that perception in the market as well. And, you know, Canva's growth on a revenue basis has slowed down a little bit, but there's still a pretty big platform for consumer usage. So wait, Ben, would you, if I told you like, hey, you got to put your money, your kids' college education, whatever, your retirement, and you had four choices there. You got the Figma and the Canva, and then you got the OpenAI and you got the Anthropic. Go ahead and tell us what percentage you put into each.
35:40Oh, man, I would definitely be all into OpenAI and Anthropic. Anything in Figma, anything in Canva and why? I think Dave shows it really well. The minute in this world, perception of loss of momentum is everything. Yeah. And like perception, I'm a secondary guy, right? We watched Canva. The second that article came out, it said their growth went from 35 % to 20%. And the price dropped 25 % in the secondary market. Only 25 %? No, 25%. I would say more like 30%, 40%. That's fascinating. Well, then there's a clearing price. Speaking as a Canva holder. As a Canva holder. But just think about the impact that momentum has on how well you attract people to hire.
36:29Just think about partnerships. Right now, those companies have no momentum. None. and they're just in a really hard spot. It's a tough story. They're going to be nice businesses, but they're not going to change the world anymore. Well, if they get re-underwritten DA and they put them at a different multiple on sales, different multiple on price earnings, it's just kind of like Buffett says, these things are voting mechanisms and then it becomes a scale, right? Ultimately, the market, it's not a public company. So it's part of voting and not scaling. I agree, Jason. And I think, you know, look, I'm not trying to be some like bubble, so-called bubble boy, AI hater here, but to me, venture capital, what made venture capital fun when I got into it, when you guys got into it was we're supposed to be the guys who imagine what the world looks like in 10 years or 20 years.
37:23Okay. And, and the guys on wall street are supposed to be the ones thinking about what's hot right now and where's the money going to go next month. So like, you know, short term, sure. Like, what are you going to do? Be the guy who bets against, um, Anthropics IPO. Like you're going to look like an idiot. So I'm sure Jim Chanos or whoever else will be shorting all this stuff, but like, they're probably going to have a lot of egg on their face. I think where it gets interesting is when you start asking these questions about long-term defensibility, about long-term profitability. And, you know, I look at something like Figma and I go, okay, everyone thought, you know, they were going to have their lunch eaten by Claude Design six months ago.
37:58Well, it turns out they have network effects. Turns out graphic designers still do better graphics work for real companies than open AI or Gemini does. Now they're amazing tools. They're going to progressively eat more and more of that workflow, but like, you know, 10 designers at a company are all used to using Figma to collaborate with each other. It's what they've trained themselves up on over the last decade and they love it. That's a product people love. So, you know, I'm not counting anyone out yet. And I think the questions we were getting at earlier around the defensibility of Anthropic and the others, those are fascinating business questions, but they're going to play out over a longer horizon.
38:38You know, I mean, the thing I don't like about being anthropic right now is every person in the world has a huge financial incentive to figure out how to how to compete with your product cheaper. OK, everybody like it's the biggest, biggest pot of gold in human history is to figure out how to offer intelligence for free right now. So, you know, I don't like the idea of having that target on my back. Now, would I trade places? Sure, because they're on top of the world right now. but it's not going to be easy and i think for those guys one of the other interesting challenges is and and this is a credit to them they're not commercial you know like like dario and the anthropic co-founders in particular they're not commercial they're not in this for the money like i i really believe that they are they are full everyone around okay hold on this is good hold on da finish and then dave so finish your finish your thought of why they're not commercial and then, Dave, you get to counter.
39:36Go. For all of us craven capitalists, it is a reflection of our psychology that we cannot imagine that Dario is being genuine. Okay? It's impossible for Chamath to listen to Dario and not see regulatory capture, venality, scam artistry. Okay? Chamath and Dario could be further opposed on the spectrum. My read is - The opposite. Hold on, Dave, let him finish, then you get your catch-up. My read, these guys, as they are chain-smoking their cigarettes, are showing you that they are religious extremists, okay? These are dyed-in-the-wool legitimate religious extremists, and they might be right, and if they're right, we should thank them because they're saving civilization.
40:29But if they're wrong, they're just religious extremists who happen to be engaged in the greatest business of this moment. But they will ultimately be beaten by people who are really good at business. Right. Which you don't see for religious and cult leaders often. I think Scientology had it for like a decade, maybe, where they were surging in growth and surging in revenue. And they had the tech and they couldn't sustain it. Right. But this is a religion with performance. I mean, not since Christianity have we seen this. I mean, Jesus was on all cylinders, objectively. By the way, Jensen making GPUs.
41:08Which is why they took him out. Jensen doing GPUs 15 years ago did not know he was going to end up in this position, in this revolution. He didn't know he was GPU Jesus. He was architected for gaming. Dario studying physics at Caltech did not know he was going to be building the expertise that would put him in the middle of the great economic revolution of our time. So these guys, to a certain extent, are they had prepared minds, but they're here accidentally almost. And the the folks who are competing with them are the folks who are competing with them. Zock, Satya, they are not here by accident.
41:44No, those are here for the money. Capitalists. Yes. They're here for the money and they're really good at the tech. And Sam Altman would fall into that category. Dave. OK, now you've heard his position and you get it. Go ahead. All right. I think that D.A. was doing his best David Sachs impression there, channeling your bestie, Jason, and my former. No, I don't think I've ever heard Sachs take that position. Exactly. Hardly. Hardly never. No, no. I think he to I think he thinks they are religious zealots, et cetera. And they're going after regulatory capture. I think what DA is saying is they're not going after regulatory capture because they're business cutthroats.
42:25They believe what they're saying. They believe it to the same extent that they will cut themselves, believing that they're going to naturally heal from AI. They'll rip darts knowing that. You can be a believer in the benevolence and godhood deity of AI and also be interested in making money. I actually do agree that Dario maybe isn't in it for the money exclusively. Machines of Love and Grace and all that other shit aside, I think he believes it. I really do think that he's trying to birth a deity that is a benevolent deity and will save humanity. I fully believe he believes that. He also probably is okay with making money.
43:07Now, he made a bunch of money at Google before he got to Anthropic. But I think that Sam is in a different category. I think Sam is a venture capitalist and has a lot of ambition, probably more in the mold of Elon than Dario. But all these people working at AI companies, yes, they may be there to change the world. They're also probably fine with making money. So those two things are not mutually exclusive in my book. Okay, Ben, you want to get in here, Russell Crowe? Go ahead. Go ahead, Gladio. I don't want to listen to what people say. I want to look what they do. How many darts did you rip before this show?
43:48Russell Crowe smoking darts in between takes on Gladiator. Go ahead. I remember one part of this business we haven't talked about at all is the cost of compute and all these long-term and how important that goes into the actual sort of long-term business model here. and yeah i have to remember dario giving a very public scolding to sam alderman for being irresponsible about all of his compute deals yes because sam almost like pull up that cliff guys it's when he said you can run off a cliff uh basically you buy too much compute you go bankrupt no love lost between those two folks at all no love lost these guys left open ai because they didn't trust Sam.
44:31That was what they said. And then, but guess what? Sam was playing this game to win. And when it became clear that Sam was right, that you had to have compute locked up to win the business game, what did Dario go do? I mean, he's a rationalist. He's a rationalist. I mean, he's definitely not dumb. And by the way, that's why Elon is also winning too. He realized that he is behind the eight ball and had to catch up. And I don't want to hear him talk about him being a religious zealot. I mean, listen, Jesus turned over the tables at the bazaar. He was like, that's it, I'm taking over the bazaar. I'm going to be the marketplace.
45:09Just the same, and he's competing hard, and he's got a very softer veneer about him. It's really interesting. If you do an alternate history, DA, I think you are as an artist and somebody who appreciates art, the alternate history genre perhaps under recognized in its time. But if we did an alt history here, I got Lon's attention now by saying alt history, you do an alt history here. If Sam Altman was 20 % less chaotic in his approach to business, I mean, it's like he is a bit chaotic. You know, you remember he got fired. He came back, all this stuff. He probably would not have lost Dario. And there might not be an anthropic.
45:55I mean, by the way, he might not have lost Elon. Right. You know, these are all Elon's children. Wow. And, you know, and the godfather is still looking like the godfather right now, because even though he got into this also out of his religious selletry, and, you know, Jason, you know, he believes this, right? He's been very public about it. We have had this conversation many nights. Okay, so Elon's really good at business, but we've also stayed up all night talking with elon for the past 10 years about how he believes this is going to take over the world so you know it's like he believes this too so the these guys were all one like the father the son and the holy spirit they have now fractured it's a schism okay and and and and and basically what fractured them was that sam had to be the guy you know but but you know you can't you got to respect the sensei You know, the student can't overshadow the teacher.
46:51And then and then Dario looked around. He said, oh, wait, these guys like money. I thought they were just here for the religious idolatry. And so I got to go do my own thing. So the the genealogy of this whole thing begins with this religious fanaticism. Right. And, but my point is it will not, unless, unless they are right that this is software Jesus, this will not end with religious fanaticism. This will end with normal business. It will probably end with Microsoft and Google being much bigger. Maybe Oracle will even win. Maybe Larry Ellison's swan song. That's a long shot. Will be the greatest, riskiest hand that's ever been played in American capitalism.
47:40He's putting$400 billion. That's a very good point there, DA. He's$400 billion into CapEx spending being essentially. I mean, this is balls out, dude. And the guy's, he's 80. Those balls are a little shaky, man. Yeah. I mean, could we imagine taking that kind of risk when we're 80? And, by the way, spending another whatever, putting whatever tens of billions on the risk to buy every dying media asset. And giving it to your son, I mean. Son's doing the same shit. They are spreading the treasury. There, it's the treasury. I think a lot of empires spread the treasury a little too far and had too many conquests going on at once.
48:21Let's talk about who won here. Lon, we have to get two things before we wrap up. Number one, who won? Sure. Who won in the old venture capital game here at this week Then number two, convertible notes. Yes. Hitting public markets for the first time in a in a significant way. Go ahead. Yeah. All right. Well, we'll start with start with that one. So Anthropic, a lot of headlines were saying they burned 80.7 billion dollars. That was the net loss for the first half of 2026. But 72.4 billion of that comes from just one line, quote, change in fair value of convertible notes, derivative liabilities.
49:03and safes. In this case, it was mostly convertible notes plus derivative liabilities that were tied to the Amazon and Google note purchase agreements we were previously discussing. Anthropic elected to carry the notes at fair value instead of splitting them into debt and equity pieces. Every reporting period, the company now re-measures these liabilities. If its value has gone up, the shares owed to investors are worth more, hence more liability. The increase is recorded as an expense on the income statement, then added back onto the cash flow statement as non-cash. So this is raising a lot of questions about which of these numbers matters, which doesn't, and how do you all think private markets are going to, or public markets are going to, learn how to interpret these numbers?
49:46Go ahead, Dave. Yeah, this is your wheelhouse. You just net out that$72 billion? I think my partner did the analysis of this, and again, I think they're in fine shape on a profitability basis. There's some non-cash expenses here that people are looking at that are worried about too much. But on actual cash out the door, they're doing fine. I heard though, I mean, there is a negative kind of implication that those notes, a lot of the notes were due to their Amazon deals with AWS and were basically subsidizing their compute costs. They gave lower costs. They gave lower compute costs. So this goes back to the point of like, do we really understand cost of compute here?
50:26Because that's my understanding of it. Well, here's the great news. Sunlight, we'll figure this all out. And we're about to have essentially two of the three, the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost here, we're about to figure this out. Once they're public, then we just have to somehow pencil in one hand of poker at the table, which is what cards are Sam Altman holding. We know what cards Elon's holding. We understand his compute costs. We understand what he's building. We have perfect insight into that. We know what Amazon's doing. We know what Oracle's doing. So really it's just going to, and we know what Nvidia is doing.
51:03And when we get these two companies public, we're going to know the answer to all these questions. So we'll keep at it there. And then let's talk about the winners. Sure. I mean, Dave, you were kind of rolling your eyes there, I'm assuming because off balance sheet loans and stuff like that. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I think what we're not able to clearly understand right now is the amortization of that cost of capital. You're putting a shit ton of money out there on CapEx, and the question is, though, how quickly or how not quickly does that CapEx depreciate over time? If you're talking about chips, people are saying, hey, these chips are going to make money for us for four or five, maybe even six years.
51:43For the neoclouds, I don't know if that's completely true. I think they're spending a lot of money and those things that they're leasing and buying may be making money in the future, may not be making money in the future. I think we saw from SpaceX Q3 earnings, SpaceX is in great shape. Elon's payback is less than 12 months. He thinks he can get to six months. And I think Chamath made some analysis about all the other neoclouds in trouble because their payback was not anywhere close to that. It was two or three years, maybe not even. Yeah, but I mean, two or three years seems completely reasonable as well, DA.
52:18And when we look at the history of compute and the amortization of computers, we see a couple of observations here. I want your comment on DA. If you're Google or you're Amazon, you have new technologies emerge and optimize software. So what was used as a frontline computer eventually becomes used for, I don't know, cold storage, background jobs. And then eventually the equation is in a data center, is this providing enough value in year eight, nine, or 10 of serving web pages or Gmail? Is it worth sending a human to pull this out of the rack or should we just let it keep grinding? And the average lifespan of compute at like other data centers, you know, we're talking about seven, eight, nine, 10 years for some of these servers.
53:11and it's only the human cost of swapping it out that becomes the cost. I think these machines are going to be doing reasonable things in years seven, eight, and nine with optimized software to move them to inference, to move them to storage jobs, background jobs, et cetera. What's your take on how long this compute has a lifespan for? I am relatively confident that the hyperscalers are behaving rationally. They can get money at 6 % or 7%, and if they can earn 10 % to 14 % returns on it, it's a great financial decision. They create value for their shareholders. By the way, if this whole thing blows up, they just stop spending the money and it was a bad couple of years and whatever, they move on.
53:59They're fine. This entire circular economy of the labs, the cloud providers, the hardware providers, I'm convinced that it makes sense within itself as one organism. But the only question that matters over the next decade is whether that organism can find enough nutrients in its environment. And the challenge here in parsing all of these financials is that, yes, sunlight's the best disinfectant. As these companies go public, we're going to see a lot about where they're spending money, but they are not going to tell us all that much about who's giving them money, what their customers are doing, who their customers are.
54:43And unfortunately, our best source of information for that is probably going to remain the investment banks who have this capacity to integrate the financials of every other company in the economy. So what we need to do is stop looking at the AI guys so intently and spend more energy looking at everybody who's supplying their revenue. That's where we're going to see how this story evolves. And as long as that demand's growing like gangbusters, the organism's going to be fine. Yes, you might get some people who get ahead on their skis, who maybe act irrationally, and then they have to cancel or postpone.
55:23Or one of their real estate providers says, hey, I'm not letting you off the hook. you got to give me money. And they say, I don't have money. And then that company goes out of business and somebody buys their assets. And the question is, does it become a dark fiber-like situation where there's no buyers in your analysis as a biotech investor? The nutrients are just not there. You don't have people providing those. Yeah. Good. I'd love to hear Ben's position on this because he's sort of a retired secondary investor. Now he's managing a public traded portfolio of private companies about to go public.
55:58What are the top three holdings in there, Ben? Top three holdings in your public, private, what do they call this? Is this a closed-end fund or something? What do you call them? Yeah, a closed-end fund called PowerLot, SpaceX, OpenAI, and Calci. SpaceX, OpenAI, and Calci. Okay. But SpaceX is already out. We're in the process of selling that down. Got it. When did you buy your SpaceX? How many years before it went public? It wasn't that long ago. It was like early 25. So you got a 50 % lift on that? Something to that effect? Yeah. No, more than that. I got more than that. We got about 3X. Oh, 3X.
56:37Fantastic. 3X in two years is great. Awesome. I looked at all of the private neoclouds. And I think the hyposcales are totally fine. I think they're so dominant. They can always adjust. They have so much negotiating leverage in all their deals that, you know, I'm not worried about them. You know, I don't love companies as an investor where there's just a lot of factors out of your control. And with all the Neolabs, your cost of capital is out of your control. And also, how long it takes you to implement your projects is out of your control. And when you put those two things together, I stayed away from all of them.
57:20I'm sure that maybe I certainly missed Coral Weave for that reason. And that's on me because that was a great deal if I had done it. I missed a big one. But I like to sleep at night. That's why I do gross stage instead of early stage. And I can't take businesses that are built like that. So I think what you're talking about is a lot of debt capital. And I think Ben Horv... Well, it's debt. it's debt and it's timing right right like you know your ability to build your ability to build oh and by the way if Jensen gets mad at you forget it there's all sorts of trouble there's just so many things out of these companies control and I don't like that as an investor and it's like fat it's I mean look no fault on anyone who's doing it but it's it's you know fast momentum chasing kind of and these guys were all Bitcoin miners two years ago.
58:13And, you know, this is the hot thing right now. So you run after that. And the next week they'll be in Miami buying Ferrari. So. Oh, my God. Did you see my did you see my Bitcoin post? My monthly Bitcoin post? Every month you want us to sell every month. I do my Bitcoin is dead post when I'm bored. But I keep working the thesis because I do, in fact, think that it's run its course. And if Lon goes through, he can do a little research here on the previous two. Lon, go find the previous two as well. And so this is like a good one for us to discuss. I said, hey, listen. Have you checked with Naval or Balogy on this perspective?
58:56I think they left Bitcoin for Xcash. I think other people have left Bitcoin for Tau. I have a small bet, like maybe 750K on Tau. And we have millions in Bitcoin, and we're hodlers. It's a very small percentage of the overall family office, but you need to have some, right? You've got a family office, Jason. That's a micro family office. Just me and my wife. Don't say that. Don't say micro. Well, whatever. I mean, it's like the first stage of a family office because when you start having a couple of real, you have disparate assets, you need to do coordination. And so Jade is running it with me and my wife.
59:33And she's awesome. So here's what I wrote. A brutal year for Bitcoin is just getting started. Give me three minutes to explain why you should dump it now. See, that's the hook. That second line there, DA, that's the hook. You know, you as a musician understand a good hook. Yeah, that's great. And now I'm just asking for but three minutes of your time. Outflows from ETFs are signal and will continue. We're going to test the low again. Why? Because there are far too many dynamic places to put your money that are creating much more value. Why put your resources into a dead network? That's a trigger out there that offers nothing beyond a store of value that invites the reader and the holder to challenge those two things.
1:00:12What's the point of the BTC's Ponzi scheme? Nature has gone away. I have a little typo in there. Ponzi scheme. Well, and I think that was actually its biggest value, Dave, was that if you owned Bitcoin, your moral obligation was to shame people who didn't. But people do not do it anymore. There is no more have fun being poor and put laser eyes in because it's embarrassing to do that when the thing is sideways for so long. And I just say, listen, no one is trying to convince people to buy it anymore. and no one is saying BTC can change the world because it won't and because AI has. Just sell and shift from Bitcoin to super intelligence because one provides little to no value.
1:00:59The other provides unlimited upside for humanity. This should be obvious to everyone right now. Bitcoin will never break its all-time highs again. So another hook at the end. Two million views. Wow. Two points. The number of retweets is great. A lot of haters. A lot of haters in there. It's so great. It's so great. And I just literally do this every month. And the amount of engagement I get on this is crazy. Now there's three people who want to bet me a million dollars that's going to hit an all-time high. And J. Cal, is this trolling? Is this trolling or you believe this? Yes. Yes. Yes. The answer is yes.
1:01:36Both. All of the above. Yes. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, look, I will say, you know, we alluded to the debt situation a minute ago and the cost of financing for these neoclouds and stuff. That is the other thing that's happening right now is just this macro context, right? And we may be now for the next couple decades in a sort of inflationary rising rate environment. It's a very different place to be doing business. So the bull case for crypto at this point probably does fall away from this speculative Ponzi scheme thesis and is merely a debasement trade thesis. And I think the question then, Jason, is like, has Bitcoin after 15 years earned its place next to gold and the other debasement trade assets?
1:02:26And will it be durable in that regard? I mean, one interesting thing, past six months, gold's gone down, right? So this has been an environment that hasn't been favorable to assets that are focused on debasement. And the question is whether the secular outlook is such that that has the wind at its back over the longer run. Yeah, there's only a certain amount of money in the world, it seems. I mean, we keep printing some more here. But yeah, it is, where does money go, right? I guess is the question. rational money, irrational money. And I think this is the last thing on people's mind that I, because if Bitcoin just keeps hovering in this range and it never makes new all-time highs, this concept, Dave, of the million dollar Bitcoin is seeming improbable now.
1:03:18I think you're on target that stablecoin has a really solid use case. And that's clearly, you know, going to be something that people are putting money into. I think, you know, we're already seeing that. I think another area that's possibly not bullshit is tokenizing real world assets and having something that - Yes, Robinhood's doing that. Maps to real. Yeah. I think even DeFi in the long run is not crazy. I think lending makes sense. But I do think a lot of the other speculative stuff, there's just hard to understand what is driving the value of those assets. There's no underlying asset to underwrite in many cases, except belief and hype.
1:03:56Which makes giving a loan to a NeoCloud seem like a better option because you have the assets. You have the data center and you have the chips and you have the memory chips and you have the GPUs. It's worth something. All right, let's wrap it up, folks. Can I have one more thing that I want to talk about that Ben and I were arguing about before? I think that we're - This isn't a backdoor promo, is it? It's not a backdoor promo. Oh, absolutely. I would never try to do that. It's okay. We'll cut it. I think I cut it in post, guys. I think there's a big issue. I have a new financial product, DA. Okay, so at the top of the market, there's 10 VC firms, maybe 20, that are taking down 75 % of all the capital.
1:04:37We're seeing huge amounts of capital going. Small funds are under pressure. A lot of emerging managers, Ben runs the Raise Conference, which just happened, are having trouble. Maybe not Ben's precious top 100. Maybe they don't have trouble, but a lot of other emerging managers are having trouble raising funds. And they're shifting to SPVs. And I think, this was my tweet from just yesterday, is SPVs are killing the VC radio star. A little bit of music connection for DA here. God, when is this commercial? And keep going. That's it. Holy fuck. That's it. Well, I think we'll have more to announce about this in the future.
1:05:13Ben and I are working on something. I got a comment on this, Jason. Get in here. I got a comment. Please, get in there. I understand the incentives that drive asset managers. those indeed have led to secondary funds, closed-end funds in the public market with private stuff, big late-stage megatrons. But let's, again, zoom out to the 10-year, 20-year view as venture capitalist guys. 20-year. Here's what the AI is doing, man. The AI is making it so cheap and high leverage to be an entrepreneur, okay? The best entrepreneurs of the next few years are going to raise less money than the best startup founders have ever raised because they don't need it.
1:06:03And so the pendulum of history is going to swing right back in the other direction. the people who are going to make the money off the next anthropics are going to be these people who are running small funds, writing small checks to entrepreneurs who don't need a hundred million dollar seed. Love it. I'm not saying the emerging managers are out of business. I just think a lot of their money is going to SPVs, not funds. I think that was my thing. I think DA, I'm going to go with you on this because here's the thing. The game on the field was, you know, hey, if you and SPV and SpaceX, it always goes up and to the right.
1:06:38And that was true. And Elon's amazing. There was money to be made there, right? But now if everybody's doing it, is there money to be made there? And is your little$5 or$10 million allocation any different than the other person's? And is it a race to the bottom? And when you go talk to family offices with your$10 million allocation, and you're trying to get 2 % a year in fees and your 20 % carry, they're just going to grind you down because they have other places to buy it from. And it's becoming a bit of a fluid market there, which means it's going to be commoditized. Now you go to the early stage and nobody wants to do that work.
1:07:14When I talk to young founders, it is so hard for them to raise that first round that they're willing to do a$10 million valuation, a$5 million valuation, a$20 million valuation to get the right people on. And they are now becoming alicorns. Alicorns are the next unicorns. An alicorn is a unicorn with wings, the Pegasus wings. And this is the future. The future is alicorns because they become unicorns because they get to a billion dollars. This is it. It's the future is alicorns. They get to a billion in revenue by flying over funding rounds. They are more capital efficient and they use their Pegasus wings to fly over a funding round, they skip their Series B.
1:07:59They skip their second pre-seed, post-seed, pre-Series A nonsense convertible because they have revenue. The ability to get your revenue, DA, which you left out of your thesis but is implied in it, they get to revenue quicker. And then when they go talk to VCs, they're like, I don't need to raise around. I have now had to go to three or four of my alicorns and say, your valuation is going up very fast. Can you please just take 10, 20 million off the table so we just have a rainy day fund at a 250 million, a billion dollar valuation? And I have to walk them through that economics, DA, to just like, we're diluting 5 % here.
1:08:38These 16-year-olds right now in their bedrooms who are building all this shit with agents and they're token maxing and they're starting companies and they have no money and no one's permission. These are going to be the greatest fucking entrepreneurs in human history. These are a different species. Okay. Different species. When you're getting all these automated emails, I'm sure all of you all day, it's from these kids in Pakistan in their parents' bedroom using Claude or whatever. I don't even know what they're doing. Yes. But I can tell you they're amazing and they're going to crush and Lightspeed has no interest in talking to them.
1:09:19There it is. The big have gotten too big, folks. This has been another amazing episode of This Week in VC. Lon, let's thank our guests and give them a proper plug. Thanks to DA Wallach. He's the co-founder and general partner of Time BioVentures, a life sciences and healthcare venture capital firm. DA, you were amazing. Thanks for being here. Dave McClure, our old friend, managing partner at Practical Venture Capital. They're a firm focused on the venture's secondary market. There it is on your screen. And Ben Black, the co-founder and managing director of Acadian Ventures, a firm that invests in venture secondaries and runs SPVs.
1:09:58He's also the chief investment officer of PowerLawCorp, the closed-end fund that trades on NASDAQ as PWRL. Thanks to Ben and our entire panel for being here. All right. Well done, everybody. Thanks for having me. And if you could all do me one favor, Lon, pull up this week in Startups, Substack here. We have a little announcement. Lon and I have been working in the laboratory. We have a little announcement here. We looked at our email newsletters. We looked at all the newsletters out there in the world, DA. And we said, from first principles, what do our founders need? And we listen to them. We make 100 investments a year.
1:10:38We have a couple of programs. And they always say the same thing to us. We need money. And we need very tactical advice. They say, well, what do you need the tactical advice on? And they say hiring, growth, product market fit, et cetera. So we said, OK, we can help with that. We have products. We're introducing them to investors. So now twice a week, 100 times a year, we are in a competition to find the best tactical and practical applications. And we're making newsletters out of them. But we also do these events live. And we're trying to hire two full-time riders to help with this effort. twistartups.substack.com, twistartups.substack.com.
1:11:19We charge$100 a year for this. Why do we charge$100 a year? We're arms dealers at this point, DA. If one founder has this information, then the other ones don't. And so you put$100 into the kitty, it's going to go up to$250 at some point. But we're just hoping to get 1 ,000 people to subscribe to this for$100 each. And then keep us honest. Hit reply and tell us it sucks or it's great. And the goal here is just to make it sustainable. I'm not looking to make a killing on these, but we want to have enough that we have two or three smart people working on getting this important information to our portfolio companies and the thousand people who join us to subscribe to this newsletter.
1:12:00That's my little mini plug, DA. Mini plug. Can you give DA a complimentary subscription, please? Ah, sure. He'll give me... He'll give me... Oh, what about Dave and Ben? No, I want them to pay. I was going to say, everyone on the show. Specifically, I want their credit card number so I can... upsell them. No, no. You can give it to all three guests. Drop your email in any of the chats and I will add you for free. You figure it out. Don't make them work. Go find their emails. Come on. I'll figure it out. Great job, everybody. We'll see you next time. Bye-bye.
This Week In Startups is made possible by:
PayPal: https://paypal.com/business
The Conservation Fund: https://www.conservationfund.org/
Hostinger: https://hostinger.com/twist
Plaud: https://Plaud.ai/twist
Today’s show:
Anthropic’s S-1 is here, and finally, we can start to develop a real understanding for the AI economy and whether the numbers add up. Anthropic shows an operating profit, a mostly non-cash $80.7 billion loss, and customers spending a shocking 9x what they were spending on intelligence just one year ago.
Is this the greatest business in history? Is AI now as addictive to enterprises as cigarettes once were to impressionable teens?
On this week’s VC Roundtable, Jason Calacanis is joined by D.A. Wallach (Time BioVentures), Dave McClure (Practical Venture Capital), and Ben Black (Akkadian Ventures / Powerlaw Corp.) to seek some answers.
They dig into the numbers, including that wild 900% net revenue retention, and consider how retail investors will consider the convertible-note charge behind their $80B loss. Plus they’ll debate whether Anthropic’s founders are really true believers driven by religious fervor, and if so, whether they’re destined to be out-competed by “rabid capitalists.”
Guests
D.A. Wallach on X: https://x.com/dawallach
Time BioVentures: https://www.timebioventures.com/
Dave McClure on X: https://x.com/davemcclure
Practical Venture Capital: https://practicalvc.com/
Trading Places podcast: https://www.youtube.com/@PracticalVentureCapital
Ben Black on LinkedIn: https://linkedin.com/in/benblack
Akkadian Ventures: https://akkadian.vc/
Powerlaw Corp: https://pwrl.com
Relevant Links
Anthropic’s S-1, by the numbers (Fortune): https://fortune.com/2026/10/27/anthropic-s1-ipo-filing-financials-profits/
900% NRR and an $80.7B loss that mostly ins’t (HackerNoon): https://hackernoon.com/anthropics-s-1-shows-163b-in-half-year-revenue-a-900percent-nrr-and-an-807b-loss-that-mostly-isnt
Tickertrends: https://tickertrends.io/
Replit makes OpenAI its default (TechCrunch): https://techcrunch.com/2026/10/17/replit-is-no-longer-working-with-anthropic-ceo-says/
Dario Amodei warns that rivals’ spending could risk bankruptcy (Fortune): https://fortune.com/2026/02/14/anthropic-ceo-dario-amodei-spending-capex-risk-ai-revenue-forecasts-bankruptcy
Machines of Loving Grace (Dario Amodei): https://www.darioamodei.com/essay/machines-of-loving-grace
Palantir CTO Shyam Sankar says AI researchers are taking up smoking (Fortune): https://fortune.com/2026/10/13/palantir-cto-shyam-sankar-ai-researchers-smoking-cigarettes-cure-cancer-artificial-general-intelligence-silicon-valley-mass-psychosis-effective-altruism/
Microsoft offers its first-ever voluntary buyouts (TechSpot): https://www.techspot.com/news/112174-microsoft-offers-voluntary-buyouts-thousands-us-workers-ai.html
Canva ranks among the top consumer AI apps (SmartCompany): https://www.smartcompany.com.au/artificial-intelligence/canva-new-ai-consumer-web-app-ranking-andreesen-horowitz/
SpaceX Q3: Musk says it could rent out its AI compute several times over (Constellation Research): https://www.constellationr.com/insights/news/spacexs-q3-musk-says-it-could-rent-out-its-ai-compute-several-times-over
Jason’s 2026 “Bitcoin is Dead” post: https://x.com/Jason/status/2114956980674605075
Jason to Michael Saylor: "there are better places to invest your money”: https://x.com/Jason/status/2115274438979756346
Timestamps:
0:00 Anthropic files its public S-1
4:58 Anthropic vs. OpenAI revenue run rates
9:20 PayPal is built for all businesses. Get started at https://paypal.com/business
10:02 “The greatest business in the history of capitalism”
11:58 Is intelligence the new tobacco?
18:08 The “meat sack constraint”
20:36 Thanks to our partner, The Conservation Fund! Learn more at https://www.conservationfund.org
22:13 Plaud: If your work depends on conversations - interviews, meetings, calls - you need a Plaud NotePin S. You can check it out at https://plaud.ai/twist and use code TWIST for 10% off!
24:32 The Who Has the Most Subscribers Challenge
28:08 Is Apple waiting out the AI race on purpose
30:22 Hostinger: The all-in-one platform for domains, websites, email, and marketing. Go to https://hostinger.com/twist and use the code TWIST for an additional 10% off Black Friday and Cyber Monday
34:19 Is Canva an AI company?
39:08 True Believers who still want to make money
48:21 The $72.4B convertible-note charge, explained
51:03 How long does AI compute stay useful?
58:19 Jason’s monthly “Bitcoin is Dead” post
1:04:41 Alicorns are unicorns with pegasus wings
1:09:58 Subscribe to the TWiST Newsletter!
Subscribe to the TWiST500 newsletter: https://ticker.thisweekinstartups.com
Check out the TWIST500: https://www.twist500.com
Subscribe to This Week in Startups on Apple: https://rb.gy/v19fcp
Follow Lon:
X: https://x.com/lons
Follow Jason:
X: https://twitter.com/Jason
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/jasoncalacanis
Thank you to our partners:
PayPal is built for all businesses. Get started at https://paypal.com/business
The Conservation Fund: Thanks to our partner, The Conservation Fund! Learn more at https://www.conservationfund.org/
Hostinger: The all-in-one platform for domains, websites, email, and marketing. Go to https://hostinger.com/twist and use the code TWIST for an additional 10% off Black Friday and Cyber Monday
Plaud: If your work depends on conversations — interviews, meetings, calls — you need a Plaud NotePin S. You can check it out at https://Plaud.ai/twist and use code TWIST for 10% off!
Check out all our partner offers: https://partners.launch.co/
Great TWIST interviews: Will Guidara, Eoghan McCabe, Steve Huffman, Brian Chesky, Bob Moesta, Aaron Levie, Sophia Amoruso, Reid Hoffman, Frank Slootman, Billy McFarland
Subscribe to our Substack Newsletters!
TWiST: https://twistartups.substack.com/
TWiAI: https://www.thisweekinai.ai/
TWiVC: https://thisweekinvc.substack.com/
Follow TWiST:
Twitter: https://twitter.com/TWiStartups
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/thisweekin
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thisweekinstartups
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@thisweekinstartups
Substack: https://twistartups.substack.com