


The episode examines whether polygraph “lie detector” tests can truly detect lies, tracing their history from early policing to workplace use, and explaining why they persist despite scientific skepticism.
Ken Alder, professor of history at Northwestern University and author of The Lie Detectors: The History of an American Obsession.
Polygraphs measure physiological responses (heartbeat, blood pressure, breathing, sweat) but depend heavily on question design and interrogation tactics. Studies by the National Academy of Sciences and Congress’s Office of Technology Assessment found polygraphs are ineffective and possibly counterproductive. Confessions can be driven by psychological pressure (“security theater” and coercion), producing false positives.
A 1921 Berkeley sorority theft case involving John Larson’s early cardiopneumocycograph; later commercial adoption by Leonard Keillor in Chicago; U.S. v. Fry (judge excludes lie-detector evidence); Reagan’s 1988 Employee Polygraph Protection Act limiting private-sector use.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Explore the origins of the polygraph machine and its first use in an investigation.
“It's springtime in Berkeley, California, 1921.”
A listener questions the validity and use of polygraphs in the workplace.
“And the crimes continued, and she clearly had psychological issues.”
Discuss the fascination and cultural significance of polygraphs in society.
“who said they were asked to take a polygraph test as part of the hiring process for a job working for Orange County in Florida.”
Understand how polygraphs work and their implications in interrogations.
“I'm Chief Warrant Officer Foster, and I would like in this film to show you a reenactment of how I made use of the polygraph during the investigation of a crime a few months ago.”
Explore how polygraphs became a common tool in employment and government settings.
“And these will become the most honest employees you will ever have because they will know that they're constantly being surveyed.”
Discuss the limitations of polygraphs and their role in creating a false sense of security.
“It does eventually and in limited ways, but it's basically an American story.”
Consider the broader implications of relying on polygraphs in society and historical context.
“might be more than just its inability to detect a lie from the truth, that it creates an illusion of security that might actually make things more insecure.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Throughline, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This message comes from Capella University. That spark you feel? That's your drive for more. Capella University's FlexPath Learning Format lets you earn your degree at your pace, without putting life on pause. Learn more at capella.edu.
0:18It's springtime in Berkeley, California, 1921. A group of college-aged women are whispering to one another in the halls of their dormitory. A man named John Larson arrives on campus carrying his brand new invention, the cardiopneumocycograph, an early version of the polygraph machine. And there's been pilfering in the sorority, including a diamond ring's gone missing and a bunch of other stuff. And Larson is asked to solve the crime after, you know, the old school police guys just can't do it. They just started asking these women. They realize it's an inside job, but they don't know who did it.
0:57Larson is a trained physiologist who just joined the police force. This is the lie detector's first trial run. One after another, he asks these women questions. And when he gets to suspect number 14, she seems nervous. And when he asks her whether she stole the diamond ring, she gets furious, pulls off the apparatus, and runs out of the ring. And then over the next few days, the police sort of follow her and hound her, and eventually she confesses to the crime. The lie detector had solved its first case, or so it seemed. Did she really do it? Larson had doubts later whether or not she is in fact guilty.
1:38And the crimes continued, and she clearly had psychological issues. She herself admitted to this. And so the psychological effect of the lie detector is to make people feel incredibly guilty, and they do confess to things, whether those confessions are true is then a different question, right? This is ThruLine from NPR. I'm your host, Randa Abdel-Fattah. We got an email from a listener named Frankie, who said they were asked to take a polygraph test as part of the hiring process for a job working for Orange County in Florida. Frankie had the impression that these tests were pseudoscience and can't actually detect when someone is telling a lie.
2:19Frankie wanted to know, what's the backstory of these tests? And if they're junk science, why are they still used in the workplace? You know, it's always fascinated me that there's this device that claims to tell the truth. And it's a story of science that that would be possible always intrigued me. This is Ken Alder. He's a professor of history at Northwestern University. He's also the author of The Lie Detectors, The History of an American Obsession. And it is an American obsession. We have the results of the lie detector right here. The polygraph may be most familiar to us in the context of daytime TV.
2:59Think The Maury Show. During your relationship with Destiny, have you ever had sexual intercourse with any other women? You said no. The lie detector determined that was a lie of more than five women. The lie detector is also used in police investigations. Police wanted a confession. Duxbury agreed to take a polygraph test that experts say he failed. The National Academy of Sciences and the Office of Technology Assessment under Congress have both conducted studies on the effectiveness of the lie detector test. And time and time again come to the conclusion that it's at best ineffective and quite possibly infrequently counterproductive.
3:40And yet we just can't seem to quit it. Some federal agencies are ramping up efforts to identify leakers. That includes the FBI, which, in recent weeks, has been using polygraphs. That's right, the so-called lie detector test. When we come back, Ken Alder explains why we got the polygraph test in the first place and why you still might encounter it in the workplace.
4:12Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from LinkedIn ads. Ever invest in something that seemed incredible at first, but didn't live up to the hype? For marketers, that's impressions. When ads don't create revenue, that's a tough conversation with the CFO. Instead, invest in results your CFO will love. LinkedIn Ads generates the highest ROAS of all major ad networks. So advertise on LinkedIn. Spend$250 and get a$250 credit. Just go to linkedin.com slash NPR pod. Terms and conditions apply. This message comes from Viking, committed to exploring the world in comfort.
4:53Journey through the heart of Europe on an elegant Viking longship with thoughtful service, destination-focused dining, and cultural enrichment on board and on shore. And every Viking voyage is all-inclusive with no children and no casinos. Discover more at viking.com. This message comes from WFMT. Discover connections in classical music with WFMT's Exploring Music and new host Peter Vandergraaf. Listen Monday through Friday at 7 p.m. on 98.7 FM, wfmt.com, and the app.
5:38I'm Chief Warrant Officer Foster, and I would like in this film to show you a reenactment of how I made use of the polygraph during the investigation of a crime a few months ago. For a device that claims to detect something as slippery and complicated as a lie, the polygraph machine is actually surprisingly simple. It measures your heartbeat, blood pressure, your breathing depth, and how sweaty you are. Bear in mind that the polygraph is not a substitute for a thorough investigation. It is an investigation aid. It basically measures your body as an emotional instrument, all while being asked a series of questions.
6:17The subject's attention must be concentrated on the questions he is asked. The polygraph may have a psychological influence on a subject. To many, it is an unknown quantity. And as such, may be feared. The real complexity or trick to the polygraph, as Ken explains, happens in the design of the questions. The machine itself is a bit of what magicians call a misdirect. You're all focused on the machine, but it's actually the questions and the rituals and the penumbra, all the things that are going on around it, which make the polygraph successful in quote marks. Now, Danny, I want you to answer each question with a yes or no, a no more.
7:01The usual original way to use a lie detector is to ask people questions that are relatively innocuous. Is your last name Armstrong? Yes. Were you born in the state of Missouri? Yes. Do you sometimes watch television? Yes. And, you know, people presumably answer truthfully and they're not stressed. And then you ask them, did you steal that watch? I told you I didn't. Danny, please, I asked you, answer each question, yes or no. And their body reacts. So that's relevant and irrelevant questions. But there are other techniques, too, for designing the interrogation that are meant to bring out guilt or physiological reaction in any case.
7:44For example, let's say the police know the amount that was stolen and it's not been written up in the papers. And let's say it was a thousand bucks. You ask the suspect, was it$800? Was it$1 ,000? Was it$1 ,200? And you look at the differential reaction to gauge whether or not they're telling the truth. Right. That's a little more precise then. Because if someone asked me, like, did you murder this person last Thursday? I might freak out internally, even if I didn't do it. You know what I mean? Because I'd be like, oh, God, they think I murdered this person last Thursday, you know? No kidding.
8:15And it's a police interrogation. I mean. Maybe the machine is wrong. Well, there's nothing wrong with the instrument.
8:25Well, let's go back to the early days of the polygraph tests. Can you set the stage for how it comes into existence? Who invents it and why? Yeah, so it's invented in Berkeley, California, my hometown. And it's invented in the 1920s, in the early 1920s, because the leader of the police force there is a guy named August Vollmer, probably the most important police officer in the history of the United States. And he's the police chief of Berkeley, but he wants to reform the police. This is 1920. The police have a reputation for being themselves pretty not law-abiding, to put it politely. This is like the height of, like, bootlegging prohibition era.
9:05Exactly. And frankly, police were known then, especially and maybe even to this day, for using very violent methods for getting evidence from people. Police Chief Vollmer really wanted to change the police force to be more humane, less violent. And so he linked up with a Ph.D. student at Berkeley who was a physiologist, John Larson, the guy who tested the lie detector on the women from the sorority. Together, Vollmer and Larson developed this new technology. The theory being that it was better than violence. And the idea was to make the police themselves, you know, more law-abiding. And frankly, the first people it's used on are the police themselves.
9:49The first people to be systematically subjected to the lie detector test are the Berkeley police. August Vollmer is often called the father of modern policing. And one of his focuses was increasing professionalism within the police department. Subjecting police officers to the lie detector was a part of that vision. He wanted to make sure they themselves were not committing crimes, to increase trust in the new technology and create an aura of truthfulness, real police reform. So, I mean, in a way, the use of the lie detector in employment begins at the very beginning. Wow. So was there any backlash or was there any skepticism about this new invention that was really fundamentally changing how police work was done?
10:39Yeah, there's pushback from two directions. One is from within in the law where judges proved incredibly reluctant to let juries hear lie detector evidence, lest it become in a way the queen of all proofs, right? I mean, if you have a lie detector and it works 100 percent, why do you need a jury at all? You know, you could just use the machine. In fact, in a very, very famous court decision, a case named the U.S. versus Fry, there was a murder committed in D.C. and on the basis of a confession in part, but then a retracted confession, a lie detector is brought in and it exonerates the man. But the judge refuses to let the jury hear the lie detector exoneration evidence.
11:23And that goes all the way up to the second highest court in the land and what's called the Fry ruling basically says we will only let into the courtroom that scientific evidence, which passes muster with the scientists themselves. We will defer to the experts. We will be, as it were, sociologists of science. But the polygraph could still be used in other settings, like in police interrogations. And some people were really uncomfortable with the way it was being used. The other place resistance was very vocal was in the lie detector operators themselves, including Larson, who really was horrified by how the lie detector was being used to basically psychologically coerce people to confess.
12:13One important thing to remember, of course, is the police can lie to you in a police interrogation, right? They're not bound to tell you the truth. So they often will accuse people of crimes they didn't commit knowingly to see what kind of reaction they have. And then if they say anything that inculpates them, then yeah, that's admissible in court, even if the lie detector test itself is not. But how does that make sense? If it's deemed not scientific enough in the courtroom, why is it scientific enough in the interrogation room? Because confessions are willfully given and appropriate police work requires confirming and corroborating confessions.
12:52Police get many confessions for crimes. Then the question is, do you corroborate that? But it's a legitimate lead and possible indication of guilt. So by now, you might be asking the same question our listener Frankie asked us, which is, how does the lie detector start becoming used in the professional workplace beyond the police? Well, it turns out Larson had a former co-worker named Leonard Keillor, who brought the polygraph to Chicago in the 1930s. And what's basically the first scientific crime lab in the United States, scientific crime detection lab. and in that capacity he's looking in part to raise private revenue and he starts to go around to banks and other local employers like walgreens and offer them his service polygraphing their employees and what he discovers when they let him do it at banks for example is that people will confess having taken petty cash or having in other ways violated the company's rules and the managers who brought Keillor in to do these tests are shocked, horrified, and want to fire these employees.
14:03And Keillor says, don't do that. Bring me back. And these will become the most honest employees you will ever have because they will know that they're constantly being surveyed. And in fact, that's what begins to happen. So polygraphs begin to spread in the commercial sector as a way to monitor people over time. And it's used in banks and in all kinds of retail. And eventually, the U.S. government begins to use it for employees as well. So it's like the OG surveillance system. Exactly. And it's an inside out. It's like a light shining not just on your exterior, but on your inner self, as it were.
14:41Because the idea is it's monitoring your thoughts, the things you don't speak, the things you're trying to hide and conceal within you, within your conscience, as it were. And so it becomes a very effective tool of that kind of policing, psychological policing. Right. I mean, policing is the right word for it, right? I mean, this is literally a police tool that's suddenly being used across society in civil life. If it wasn't on the radar of people beforehand, for the average person in the country who suddenly is going to apply for a job or is in a job that suddenly is adopting the lie detector test, that's a pretty big change for you as an employee.
15:20Absolutely. And employers at that time were within their rights to fire people for being unwilling to take the test. Certainly, they don't have to hire people that they think have done poorly on the test. And it's used also in the federal government at Los Alamos and at what's called Oak Ridge, Tennessee, where the uranium is built to protect the secrets of the atomic bomb. The idea being these are people whose secrets must not leak. I can understand it in that context. You do. Aha. You know? Well, the problem with doing it on thousands of people and surveying it this way is that even if your lie detector is very accurate, which it is not, you're still generating huge numbers of false positives, huge numbers of false positives, all of them you have to then investigate.
16:07And the false negatives are skating by. So, in fact, you're actually making things worse. It's a terrible tool. The math is terrible. From the 1930s on, the polygraph was used in both private and public workplaces. But eventually, things shifted as more and more people doubted its ability to improve conditions. Over the years, especially in the 1960s, pressure came from labor unions and ordinary citizens who felt their rights were being violated and too many people were being falsely accused. States began to pass laws banning the use of lie detectors in employment situations. And I think about half the states by the 80s had banned it, but it was still allowed by federal law.
16:51And then Reagan, who was president at the time in the 80s, had really wanted to use it to pursue leaks in his administration. But his secretary of state, a man named George Shultz, He hated them. He thought they were scientifically useless and counterproductive. And he threatened to resign if these continued. And that was enough to galvanize Congress and then Reagan himself to make a change. In 1988, President Reagan signed the Employee Polygraph Protection Act, which essentially banned polygraph testing on private sector employees. Now, there were some carve-outs. One is that governments, especially governments that look after state secrets, like the Manhattan Project or like national security, were allowed to continue using it.
17:40So that continues. Police officers continue to be subjected to polygraphs and certain other exceptions, like the pharmaceutical industry for some reason is allowed. But it's greatly diminished from a peak of two million tests per year. It's down to a much smaller number now. But it's still true that in the Department of Energy and other places, people would subject it to lie detectors.
18:07So, given that over the course of the 20th century, you have this proliferation of the lie detector test through American life, and then there's a kind of scaling back with this 1988 act, is this confined to the U.S., or does the lie detector begin to transcend borders and travel? It does eventually and in limited ways, but it's basically an American story. And I think it's American in the same way that the SAT is American. So the SAT test seems on its surface to be machine-like, right? It's neutral. It can be graded by a machine. It's being assessed by a machine. And in that sense, it seems to have the property of treating everybody the same, a kind of equality.
18:55Now, people have criticized SAT scores and SATs as, in fact, embedding presumptions and, if you like, prejudices within the test. And certainly the same is true for the lie detector, where the discretion of the operator is the one that decides it. That's a very American belief that there's a neutral way to solve social problems like that. Throughout this conversation, it occurred to me that the problem with the polygraph might be more than just its inability to detect a lie from the truth, that it creates an illusion of security that might actually make things more insecure. It's called security theater, and it's a very powerful tool.
19:37You could argue that, you know, every time we go through the metal detectors at the airport, there's a bit of this kind of security theater going. And it gives you a false sense of security, absolutely. And yet, we keep using it. And so the basic problem remains, as Montaigne said 450 years ago, the truth has one face, but the liar has many, many thousands. And it's a very tricky game to try to ferret out what's going on in somebody else's head. And maybe, maybe we should put our efforts elsewhere. Thank you to Ken Alder. To learn more about the fascinating history of the polygraph test, you can read his book, The Lie Detectors, The History of an American Obsession.
20:23And thanks so much to our listener, Frankie, for their question, which inspired this episode.
20:32That's it for today's show. ThruLine was created by me and Ramtin Adablui. This episode was produced by me and Skylar Swenson, Jasmine Romero, Sarah Wyman, Julia Redpath, Amy Padula, Liana Semstrom, Molly Marcello, Irene Noguchi. This episode was fact-checked by Sarah Knight and mixed by Robert Rodriguez. Music by Ramtin Adablui and his band, Drop Electric. Thanks also to Johannes Durgey. I'm Randa Abdel Fattah. Thanks for listening. Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Scholastic with the next big thing in reading. Next is an exciting new line of publishing from Scholastic for kids 8 to 12 years old.
21:18Each book features full color and black and white illustrations and irresistible storylines. Launching with The Luckies, Rumor Has It, the first book in a series about strangers turned stepsisters, and Rival High, Avery's story about the chaos that comes when two rival high schools merge. Kids will need to know what happens next from Scholastic. This message comes from WFMT. Discover connections in classical music with WFMT's Exploring Music and new host Peter Vandergraaf. Listen Monday through Friday at 7 p.m. on 98.7 FM, WFMT.com, and the app.