


The episode “The dramatic race to discover Insulin” follows the 1920–1922 hunt for a cure for type 1 diabetes, framed by Leonard Thompson’s near-death in Toronto General Hospital. It describes Frederick Banting’s reluctant, debt-ridden start in London, Ontario, and his 2 a.m. idea to ligate dog pancreatic ducts to isolate the “internal secretion” that could relieve glycosuria.
insulin could be extracted from pancreatic tissue, first shown in dogs (e.g., dog 410’s glucose dropping after injection of an extract from dog 391), then translated to humans.
an initial human injection on Jan. 11, 1922 failed due to impurities; a purified serum (Collip’s “colipsilin,” precipitated by alcohol) succeeded on Jan. 23, 1922, lowering Leonard’s blood sugar and saving his life.
none named as interview guests; the episode centers on historical figures Banting, Charles Best, J.J.R. McLeod, and J.B. Collip, plus narrator Randa Abdel Fattah and historian Alison Lee.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
The grim situation of Leonard Thompson as he battles diabetes in 1921.
“Leonard Thompson, a 14-year-old Canadian boy, checks in to Toronto General Hospital.”
An overview of the historical context leading to the discovery of insulin.
“I'm Randa Abdel Fattah, and you're listening to ThruLine from NPR.”
Exploring the background and struggles of Frederick Banting before insulin discovery.
“It's summer 1920, a little over a year before Leonard Thompson will find himself in that hospital ward.”
Learn about Banting's struggle to gain support for his insulin research.
“And that's what he's only read four or five hours.”
Follow Banting and Best as they begin their experiments on dogs.
“Before Fred Banting and his newly recruited grad student Charlie Best could study the dogs and deliver on Banting's idea, first, they had to capture them.”
Understand the struggles and tensions between the research team.
“It's like taking a glass of water from the Hudson River and a glass of water from a Brita filter.”
Learn about the ethical dilemmas surrounding the first human trial.
“And we should note, they're using questionable methods to test the serum's effectiveness.”
Discover the outcome of Leonard Thompson's first injection of insulin.
“Because, you know, and I think it's legitimate.”
Learn about the groundbreaking first human test of insulin on Leonard Thompson.
“His doctor agreed to give that a try, and Leonard's father, Harry Thompson, agreed to let them try Banting's serum on Leonard.”
Explore the initial reception and eventual recognition of insulin's life-saving effects.
“News of insulin's life-saving treatment wasn't blockbuster at first.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Throughline, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Alison Li: This election season, let the NPR Politics podcast save your time and your sanity. We'll help you understand key races, which polls you can safely ignore, and what might happen if power shifts in Congress. Our short daily episodes come out every afternoon so you can spend less time scrolling through each chaotic news cycle. Make NPR Politics your hub for midterm election coverage. Follow our podcast on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.
0:27Grant Maltman: December 2nd, 1921. Leonard Thompson, a 14-year-old Canadian boy, checks in to Toronto General Hospital. He's in critical condition.
0:40Alison Li: He was completely apathetic because he was so starved and so ill. His hair was falling out, his eye sockets were dark, and he had this sort of distended stomach.
0:54Grant Maltman: His parents are looking for glimmers of hope. Leonard lies in his bed day after day, listless. He's no longer the boy he was just two years before, then a perfectly healthy kid.
1:09Alison Li: One day he started wetting his bed, and he developed swollen ankles, and his parents took him to a doctor. And a few weeks later, he developed sugar in his urine. And that was the absolute sign that he had developed diabetes.
1:30Grant Maltman: Leonard's situation is grim. He weighs just 65 pounds. His thin breath, almost a whisper, smells like acetone, almost like paint thinner. He's drifting in and out of sleep, and he's on a strict diet, borderline starving.
1:47Alison Li: 450 calories. He was allowed 50 grams of lean meat and just like 100 grams of carbs.
1:56Grant Maltman: The doctor's secretary takes one look at him and says, I've never seen a living creature as thin as he was. He was on the verge of death.
2:07Alison Li: Everyone on the floor knew that he was doomed.
2:10Grant Maltman: And while Leonard's family waits for the worst to come, Four unlikely people come together at the right time to make a discovery.
2:20Alison Li: Here we are 105, 106 years later. We still have a doctor giving a newly diagnosed patient an injection of this elixir, this insulin, that changed the world all those years ago.
2:32Grant Maltman: A life-saving treatment that beat a race against death.
2:36Alison Li: If you're living with type 1 diabetes, you need them to win that race. Because if you have diabetes in 1920, 21, you don't have three to five years to wait.
2:49Grant Maltman: I'm Randa Abdel Fattah, and you're listening to ThruLine from NPR. Luxmaxing, weight loss, muscle building, all these things have been driving a massive craze for a few years now. Injectable peptides, some natural and some synthetic. They promise wellness, beauty, and even longevity. A peptide is a basic building block in our body, and some act as powerful hormones regulating key functions like GLP-1 drugs that have been life-changing for millions of people. These injectables have unleashed a multi-billion dollar gray market industry online, helped by the FDA, that's looking to loosen restrictions on unapproved, untested peptides.
3:37Grant Maltman: So today, we're reaching back a century to the murky and surprising story about the mad dash to manufacture the OG peptide-based medicine, insulin. It's a story rife with personal grudges, trial and error, and many, many dogs. Stay with us.
4:03Alison Li: Hi, this is Claire Paprocki calling from Madison, Wisconsin.
4:07Grant Maltman: I'm a longtime listener, first time caller. You're listening to ThruLine from NPR.
4:13Alison Li: This message comes from Superhuman. Have you heard of Superhuman Go? Their Go AI chat helps you draft emails and messages and can also summarize long threads and documents. It can search across your apps, all without leaving the page you're on. It collaborates with you where you are, whether it's in a doc you're reading or the email you're writing. Try Superhuman Go from the makers of Grammarly. Find out more at superhuman.com. This message comes from Rinse. Your dog believes you are magnificent, capable of anything. Your dog has watched you spend hours a week moving fabric between machines and has never once lost faith.
4:53Alison Li: The question was never whether you could become the person your dog thinks you are. It's what's in the way. Turns out, just the laundry. Not anymore. Rinse picks up your laundry, cleans it expertly, and delivers it back while you get on with being magnificent. Sign up today at Rinse.com. Rinse. It's time to be great. This message comes from Whole Foods Market. Fall tastes better with better ingredients from Whole Foods Market. No added growth hormones or antibiotics in their meat department means slow-braised short ribs are even more satisfying. All seafood is wild-caught, like their vibrant sockeye salmon or verified responsibly farmed.
5:31Alison Li: And all sweets, including fall-themed cookies, are made without high fructose corn syrup. Spice up fall at Whole Foods Market. This episode's sponsor is HubSpot, which offers the following message. What if instead of updating your CRM, your CRM updated you? HubSpot's self-updating CRM keeps Keeps your customer context current so you can win more deals. Learn more at HubSpot.com. Part 1.
5:58Grant Maltman: 25 Words It's summer 1920, a little over a year before Leonard Thompson will find himself in that hospital ward. A young general surgeon has just opened a private practice in a little house in London, Ontario, Canada. Frederick Banting.
6:17Alison Li: I think the best way to describe it would be a reluctant hero. This is someone on his own who was uncomfortable in his own skin sometimes.
6:28Grant Maltman: This is Grant Maltman.
6:29Alison Li: I'm the curator at Banning House National Historic Site of Canada, and I'm in London, Ontario.
6:34Grant Maltman: Born to hardworking farmers, Methodists, the youngest of five, Fred Banting was a shy kid growing up, prone to insecurity. He's tall, almost six feet, and he wasn't a great student. One former high school principal said of him,
6:50Alison Li: Not a student on whom he thought fame would ever settle. This is someone who did fail a lot.
6:58Grant Maltman: Academically, he goes on to struggle at university.
7:01Alison Li: He didn't have a passing grade, so you can say he failed his first year.
7:04Grant Maltman: So Banting leaves his liberal arts studies and enters the field of medicine. But as fate would have it, his medical studies get cut short because of World War I. He's sent into combat as a doctor, with what Banting would describe as very deficient medical training.
7:22Alison Li: He comes back from the First War, a national war hero, can't get a job in Toronto.
7:27Grant Maltman: So instead, he moves to London, Ontario, and opens up a private practice.
7:33Alison Li: And then he does everything wrong here. His location isn't great. It wasn't a high traffic area. You could advertise by putting your front name up front, beautiful silver maple up front so you can't see the sign. Phone book's a good way to go, but it came out in April. He doesn't move to London. So he's not in the phone book. No, he's not in the phone book yet because he doesn't move here until June. So he's literally 0 for 4.
7:58Grant Maltman: For months and months, Fred Banting struggles to make money. Six days a week, he remains open. But not a single patient arrives.
8:07Alison Li: And when he opens the door on July 1st, his first patient doesn't arrive until 28 days later.
8:14Grant Maltman: Patient number one is an alcoholic.
8:17Alison Li: In Ontario in 1920, we're still under the Prohibition Act. So the only place you're getting alcohol is from your doctor. You know, that shot from medicinal purposes. So he came for the alcohol. Yeah, you know, he was an honest soldier and he wanted to give his men a drink. I wrote him this. I thought myself rather good at the barkeeping business today. So I wrote him the prescription, felt good about it.
8:38Grant Maltman: So he gave him the alcohol.
8:40Alison Li: Yeah. A great Canadian hero. Starts off as a legal alcohol sales.
8:45Grant Maltman: He's a bootlegger, kind of.
8:48Alison Li: Yeah, yeah, exactly.
8:53Grant Maltman: Banting is super broke, in debt for medical school. To de-stress, he paints and tries to sell his art. Cooks his meals on a Bunsen burner. Rents out rooms in his home. Down on his luck, he finally gets a win.
9:08Alison Li: This wonderful opportunity arises.
9:11Grant Maltman: He finds a part-time job teaching at a local university.
9:15Alison Li: We need instructors in surgery, physiology, and anatomy. Pick me. I'll do all three. And why? It's$2 an hour. So he does three labs in that first week of the fall session. He will equal his entire July income.
9:30Grant Maltman: Banting is someone who likes being in the lab with his sleeves rolled up. Actually, he takes it even further.
9:37Alison Li: He's always in short sleeves because he cut the sleeves off. He liked having bare arms and working. All his lab coats were always short-sleeved.
9:47Grant Maltman: By now, it's October of 1920. The failed clinician gets an assignment from a colleague. I need you to do a lecture on diabetes and carbideal metabolism.
9:58Alison Li: And you can't do much of a lecture on four sentences. He's never treated a patient with diabetes. So he goes to the medical school and he reads everything he can and prepares his lecture.
10:12Grant Maltman: It's worth noting, up to this point, the medical community only knew a little about diabetes. A lot was still a mystery.
10:21Alison Li: The first recording of the diabetes condition was 1552 B.C. in ancient Egypt. It's the Ebers papyrus. It's the oldest surviving medical text. And it's translated a couple of different ways, but sort of the one more accepted is it's a prescription for someone who has sweet-smelling urine. So we think that's the first recording of the diabetes condition.
10:44Grant Maltman: In the late 1800s, scientists had figured out that the pancreas was involved and progress was being made. But a big puzzle remained. how to extract the essential substance from a healthy pancreas so it might be given to diabetics who couldn't produce it on their own. There was no cure. The only treatment, a starvation diet. And that extended life by only a few years at most. Banting brings the scientific literature home and he crams into the night, pouring over a stack of medical journals. In the bathtub before going to bed, an article catches his eye.
11:22Alison Li: An article on diabetes research.
11:24Grant Maltman: From the upcoming issue of the journal Surgery, Gynecology, and Obstetrics.
11:29Alison Li: So he reads the article, turns out the light, and we're fortunate to have his own words. You know, it was one of those nights when I was restless and could not sleep. I was trying to figure out ways to get away from my debt and my worry. The lecture and the article then began chasing each other in my mind. At 2 a.m. they came together and gave me the idea. I got up, I wrote down, I couldn't stop thinking about it.
11:52Grant Maltman: He grabs a piece of paper and scribbles down 25 words.
11:56Alison Li: Diabetes, ligate pancreatic ducts of a dog, keep dogs alive to the C9 degenerate, leaving glycoseria, try to relieve glycoseria, I'm almost having a brain cramp on the last five words. Retreat internal secretion of these to relieve glycoseria.
12:17Grant Maltman: Wow, that is not what comes to me in the middle of the night. No, it doesn't.
12:21Alison Li: You know, this is, oh, I'll remember this in the morning type of thing as we all go through.
12:28Grant Maltman: Turns out, even for a Banting scholar, it's hard to remember all the words. What's key here? Pancreatic cells or islets. Ducks of a dog. Secretion. One Grant left out. Try to isolate. And keep dogs alive. And with that fever dream, Banting is convinced he's found a way to successfully extract the key substance from the pancreas that could lead to a treatment for diabetes.
13:01Grant Maltman: The very next morning, Banting brings the jumble of words to a colleague where he's teaching.
13:06Alison Li: Look, I think I've got something.
13:09Grant Maltman: No luck. They send him away. Surely someone had already tried this, the professor suggests. Struggling to make a dime and still eating meals off that Bunsen burner. A week later, convinced by his clarion dream, Fred Banting travels to his alma mater, the University of Toronto, and makes an appointment to speak with J.J. R. McLeod, this hotshot internationally known physiologist, who has also studied diabetes for over a decade. what do we know about banting's first impression of mccloud oh this is yeah yeah it doesn't go well
13:47Alison Li: you have mccloud this you know well-respected scholar in this field 40 years he's more and banting's not only a clinician but he's a failing clinician so you think of that academic world you know and it's not a bottom-up uh world this is top down during this period and rightfully so It'd be something akin today of you or I showing up at Harvard and meeting a professor and say, oh, I did my research last night. You know, I read an article.
14:18Grant Maltman: I read an article. I Googled.
14:19Alison Li: Right. And that's what he's only read four or five hours.
14:22Grant Maltman: And McLeod, you know, the fact that McLeod offers the courtesy of taking this meeting, you know, is in itself somewhat ridiculous that happened.
14:34Alison Li: And Banting, this is a new feel to him, you know, and McLeod, you know, you've barely done any research. This idea of yours isn't entirely new. It's a twist because it's a surgical approach. But the best experts in the world have, you know, pretty much dismissed this.
14:53Grant Maltman: Well, what was his pitch exactly to McLeod?
14:56Alison Li: Well, it's at 25 words. And that's the thing. It's not a 100-page proposal. And in today's standards, it's a Post-it note. He'd like to get support from a text or a Post-it note.
15:10Grant Maltman: Banting's own account of this pitch meeting is a real downer.
15:15Alison Li: McLeod doesn't believe in me.
15:17Grant Maltman: Banting was asking someone to take a chance on a rookie scientist. McLeod's got an appropriate level of skepticism.
15:24Alison Li: Do you know how many real scientists we've turned down? You know, it was years ago I had a visiting professor come through And it seems to be in his mind that McLeod had already debunked one of these internal secretion theories a few weeks prior to this meeting. Even 20 years later, when you read his writings, you could hear the anger in his writing towards McLeod. You know, he doesn't believe in me, so forget it. And the meeting ends, and Banty returns home, and he's mad at McLeod, angry with McLeod.
16:02Grant Maltman: A few days later, to Banting's surprise, McLeod gives him the green light to try out this experiment. Why the change of heart?
16:11Alison Li: The only reason that McLeod was even going to give Banting a time of day was that he could do this research and fail and publish, and then no one would go down this route.
16:20Grant Maltman: Plus, it helped that Banting was willing to work for free. So McLeod tells him, You can work next year. I've got a couple of graduate students who are going to need jobs. They strike a deal. Banton can start work the following May with a first-year grad student named Charlie Best.
16:37Alison Li: You have a graduate student in biochemistry being led by a clinician with no real scientific method of study, you know, research, what have you.
16:49Grant Maltman: And the two-month summer would begin with a hunt. That's in a minute.
17:00Alison Li: Hi, this is Nabil from Kitchener, Ontario, Canada.
17:03Grant Maltman: I used to live in Northern Virginia, but I still continue to listen to ThruLine and support it through NPR. Storytelling is so well made. What makes it great, it is well produced and researched.
17:14Alison Li: You are listening to ThruLine from NPR, the best podcast anywhere. Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Rinse. A well-designed life doesn't run on default settings. You chose the walkable neighborhood. Your coffee order became oddly specific. You spent three weeks choosing your mattress. But your laundry routine? That one somehow escaped the redesign. Should that really be the one update you skipped? Consider this the patch. Rinse picks up your laundry and dry cleaning, cleans it expertly, and delivers it back. Sign up today at rinse.com.
17:51Alison Li: Rinse. It's time to be great. This message comes from BetterHelp. BetterHelp is in-network with more than 125 health plans with an average co-pay for eligible members of just$23 per session. Don't have eligible insurance? You can still get 10 % off your first month. Visit betterhelp.com slash NPR to explore your payment options. That's betterhelp.com slash NPR. This message comes from Whole Foods Market. Fall tastes better with better ingredients from Whole Foods Market. No added growth hormones or antibiotics in their meat department means slow-braised short ribs are even more satisfying. All seafood is wild-caught, like their vibrant sockeye salmon or verified responsibly farmed.
18:34Alison Li: And all sweets, including fall-themed cookies, are made without high-fructose corn syrup. Spice up fall at Whole Foods Market. Part 2. The Discovery.
18:52Grant Maltman: Before Fred Banting and his newly recruited grad student Charlie Best could study the dogs and deliver on Banting's idea, first, they had to capture them.
19:04Alison Li: There's a story of Banting and Best going down an alley with 12 leashes, and they come out with 13 dogs, and Banting's no longer wearing a tie.
19:12Grant Maltman: That tie was wrapped around a dog's neck, a makeshift leash. The men run down the streets of Toronto, rounding up these unlucky four-legged test subjects, They need a lot of them so they can remove their pancreas, inducing diabetes. And you might be wondering, why dogs? Well, years earlier, German researchers had accidentally figured something out.
19:37Alison Li: They took the pancreas out and the dog developed diabetes. They knew that connection was dogs were a good size to work with.
19:46Grant Maltman: Professor McLeod had clued them into that connection before leaving for a vacation in Scotland for the summer. His priority before leaving town, teach them how to operate on dogs. And then he leaves. But he keeps tabs on their progress throughout the summer by letter. So after they've captured enough dogs, they start running experiments, going down dead end after dead end.
20:11Alison Li: Lots of struggles. They go through a number of dogs trying to figure out how to do this.
20:16Grant Maltman: They tested the dog's urine, the dog's blood. They operated on so many. Dog 387, Dog 388, 389, 340, on and on. Banning was an evil dog scientist.
20:31Alison Li: This is someone who got visibly upset when the dogs passed during these experiments.
20:36Grant Maltman: Their dingy lab is smelly. They're holed up in a tiny room next to the dog's quarters under a tin roof. They have to clean the dog's cages themselves. They work in sweat and dirt. It's hot, the dead of summer. Some of the dogs stay alive, some don't.
20:53Alison Li: They're plugging away and they come to this July 30th. They have dog 410.
21:00Grant Maltman: A white, short-haired mongrel terrier. Banting and Best extract a substance from dog 391's pancreas to concoct a solution that's injected into mighty 410. They wait a couple of hours.
21:14Alison Li: And her blood glucose starts to drop.
21:18Grant Maltman: Eureka! That extract mixed with a cocktail of water and salts worked magic. It controlled her blood sugar, and the mighty Terrier 410 stabilized, at least for a day, before going into a coma and then dying. Nonetheless, the men had done something no one had ever documented before. They had successfully extracted pancreatic cells and added them to a solution that seemed to work. But the solution wasn't perfect. It was very sludgy, not purified.
21:55Alison Li: It's like taking a glass of water from the Hudson River and a glass of water from a Brita filter. Both are water. One's going to have a lot of junk. That's what they have. But it seemed to put them on this right track.
22:08Grant Maltman: At last, they were on to something. Best wrote to McLeod, the extract seemed to have a market effect.
22:15Alison Li: We think we've got something.
22:19Grant Maltman: When McLeod hears about it, he's a little less enthusiastic. You might even say skeptical.
22:26Alison Li: McLeod's research methodology is a little weak.
22:30Grant Maltman: And tells them there has to be no possibility of mistake. McLeod wants to bring more critical thinking to their work, more rigid controls. Banting gets agitated. He wants a salary, a better room to work in, an assistant to look after dogs. McLeod can't offer that. It's tense. Banting says that if the University of Toronto doesn't think the research he's doing is important, he'll take it someplace else. McLeod's reply, As far as you are concerned, I am the University of Toronto. But eventually, McLeod relents to Banting. The men can continue their work. He isn't about to pat Banting on the back, but he can see they were onto something.
23:16Grant Maltman: Maybe something big. This time, they plan to refine the purification process. They need to make it more potent.
23:23Alison Li: Okay, we're going to redo the experiments.
23:26Grant Maltman: And we should note, they're using questionable methods to test the serum's effectiveness.
23:32Alison Li: They're testing on themselves. Okay, we didn't die. I'll try a spoonful. How are we going to deliver this extract? And how are we going to get more? You said they were testing on themselves? Yeah, they're just to make sure. Yeah, it was something not uncommon for Banting.
23:47Grant Maltman: That seems risky.
23:48Alison Li: Yeah, yeah. Again, Bull in a China shop is a way to describe him sometimes.
23:54Grant Maltman: They are desperate to crack the hardest part of this puzzle.
23:57Alison Li: How do we make the leap to humans?
24:02Grant Maltman: How can they concoct a serum that's purified enough to test on a human? As the end of 1921 approaches, McLeod says it's time to bring in a more experienced teammate.
24:15Alison Li: We need to bring a better expert in. Dr.
24:19Grant Maltman: James Bertram Collip, a renowned researcher and endocrinologist.
24:23Alison Li: December is when J.B. Collip, Dr. Collip joins the team. He's our first Canadian-born professor of biochemistry. He's this person that can get us over the finish line. He was a very astute biochemist. This is Alison Lee. I'm a historian of science and medicine, and I'm the author of a biography of James Bertram Collip. He had learned some of the latest methods in measuring blood sugar.
24:53Grant Maltman: Danting had actually wanted the biochemists to join the team months earlier. But now he wondered if he was really needed, worrying that this renowned researcher might Bigfoot him and get all the glory.
25:06Alison Li: Banting sees his experiments being taken away from him. The collaborative process in his mind is me and Charlie. And, you know, whereas McLeod is seeing the bigger picture and realize we have to bring in somebody else because we're on the cusp of something.
25:22Grant Maltman: The cusp of a major breakthrough. Producing a solution fit for humans. And they know they're close. The stakes could not be higher. Tensions are flaring. And it exacerbates feelings in the lab. Who will discover the solution first?
25:39Alison Li: They are butting heads, and they're not making it easy on each other, if we put it that way.
25:51Grant Maltman: The new year arrives. 1922. The men are in separate labs now, Banting and Best in one, McLeod and Colip in another.
26:00Alison Li: It's a team, but they're sort of working in, you know, a separate, two different labs sort of thing, sharing information.
26:09Grant Maltman: Banting and Best struggle with their extracts. Collip's experiments are going smoothly. He makes his own extract, improving on Best and Banting's approach. The team, thus far, had used the serum on dogs and tested on themselves. It was time to make the leap to someone who had diabetes. Enter 14-year-old Leonard Thompson, who was languishing in a bed at Toronto General Hospital, not far from the men's lab. Without treatment, he would soon die. Banting and Bess approach McLeod. They want to help Leonard with their extract, to be the first to ever successfully treat a human.
26:50Alison Li: They convince him, without Collip's knowledge, that we've got something. It's kind of nasty. Banting can't get hospital privileges in Toronto, you know, for this. Because, you know, and I think it's legitimate. He wasn't in private practice at this point. But the men plead with McLeod. We have someone we know is dying a couple blocks away. And we might have something here. It was really because he was on the verge of death. And they really felt, you know, it was worth a try.
27:22Grant Maltman: Banting goes behind the back of their more experienced colleague, Dr. Kalip, to convince McLeod to approach Leonard's parents.
27:31Alison Li: They go over to Toronto General Hospital and speak with Mr. Thompson. You can imagine what the conversation was like. It was just like, you know, your son's not long for this world. I've got two guys in the hallway here who have something that I think is going to work. Can we use your son for this experiment? You know, you think of it today. I mean, no ethics or, you know, double-blind trial. It's someone who's breathing who's not going to live much longer.
28:00Grant Maltman: On January 11th, 1922, Banting and Best, without Colup, bring a syringe filled with a thick brown solution they call ilatin to Leonard's medical team at the hospital.
28:14Alison Li: His doctor agreed to give that a try, and Leonard's father, Harry Thompson, agreed to let them try Banting's serum on Leonard. And so he was injected with 15 cc's, and you can imagine Harry Thompson sitting by his son's bedside watching this poor boy who was emaciated. There's still too many impurities, and it leaves the sterile abscess at the point of injection. And so in the chart, it said no clinical benefit was evidenced.
28:54Grant Maltman: When the experienced biochemist Dr. Kolip hears about this failed attempt.
29:00Alison Li: He's outraged. I thought, we're a team, even though we're working separately. And so he just doubles down. You almost say he pulled a bandit.
29:08Grant Maltman: Now Dr. Kolip needs to beat the clock himself. For a few days, he worked slate in the lab, motivated to crack the purification problem and offer something to the Thompson family much better than that brown sludge.
29:22Alison Li: And by adjusting levels of alcohol, he suddenly saw this sort of white substance precipitate out of the solution.
29:34Grant Maltman: A substance he dubs colipsilin. With the purified, clear serum in hand, McLeod persuades Leonard's family to try another shot. So, on January 23rd, 1922...
29:47Alison Li: Again, knock on the door. You know, Mr. Thompson, you know, I hate to oversimplify it, but it just makes the story that much more fantastical. I've got this guy in the hallway who's got something. 11 that morning, his doctor injected Leonard with some of this extract. The results were just strikingly positive.
30:10Grant Maltman: The boy's blood sugar drops. His eyes flutter open.
30:15Alison Li: They immediately noticed that Leonard felt better. He looked brighter and stronger and more energetic. He immediately felt better. This was clearly the first successful use of the substance insulin. Almost six months to the day for that first test on that dog, we have now successfully translated that into a successful human test. It was a race against death that they beat.
30:47Grant Maltman: Leonard Thompson would survive. the first patient who was successfully treated with insulin. The four men had done it. And then, oops. They'd done it once, but now they couldn't figure out how to make another batch of this life-saving cure. And pretty soon, a lot of people were going to want it. That's coming up.
31:17Alison Li: This is Carrie calling from Mexico. Thank you for continuing my education in a way that actually sticks with me. You're listening to TrueLine from NPR. Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Rinse. Your dog believes you are magnificent, capable of anything. Your dog has watched you spend hours a week moving fabric between machines and has never once lost faith. The question was never whether you could become the person your dog thinks you are. It's what's in the way. Turns out, just the laundry. Not anymore. Rinse picks up your laundry, cleans it expertly, and delivers it back while you get on with being magnificent.
32:01Alison Li: Sign up today at Rinse.com. Rinse. It's time to be great. This message comes from Whole Foods Market. Fall tastes better with better ingredients from Whole Foods Market. No added growth hormones or antibiotics in their meat department means slow-braised short ribs are even more satisfying. All seafood is wild-caught, like their vibrant sockeye salmon or verified responsibly farmed. And all sweets, including fall-themed cookies, are made without high-fructose corn syrup. Spice up fall at Whole Foods Market.
32:31Grant Maltman: Midlife brings a lot of changes. Your Turn with Alison Aubrey is a new podcast to help you navigate the twists and turns. From health and relationships to creativity and purpose, We can help steer your next chapter with your turn with Alison Aubrey. Find it on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.
32:54Part 3.
32:56Grant Maltman: Replication. News of insulin's life-saving treatment wasn't blockbuster at first. In fact, the news reports only trickled in. The local paper headline, Toronto doctors on track of diabetes cure. It takes time for news to trickle out about this amazing discovery. But when it catches on several months later, it's big. Serum proves Boone and fighting diabetes from the New York Times. The medical establishment is astonished by banting Best McLeod and Collip's work.
33:32Alison Li: They would see people come out of diabetic comas. and the language they used was the language of resurrection. One of the most famous researchers sort of used the language of the Bible. He said it was like Prophet Ezekiel talking about seeing a valley of dry bones come to life.
34:02Alison Li: Because they had seen these children. We're really on the verge of death, suddenly being brought back to life and to be able to expect to live longer lives because of that. And so I think very early on, people who really understood diabetes really felt it was almost like a miracle.
34:28Grant Maltman: A miracle that conjures a pilgrimage. Soon people flood to Toronto for human trials to help reproduce the solution. At first, it's known as colips extract, which enrages Banting. It's a harried, rushed process. The doctors are like short-order cooks.
34:46Alison Li: Colt referred to as bathtub chemistry.
34:49Grant Maltman: To keep up with the demand, the team first partners with another Canadian lab. They get a$5 ,000 advance to expand the extraction from lots of animal pancreases. And they also patent their discovery. When they do, the internal squabbling over naming rights ends. They decide on insulin. A scientific name that circulated years earlier by a Belgian scientist.
35:17Alison Li: The patent was taken out in the names of Banting, Best, and Collop. And what they did was they sold the patent to the University of Toronto for$1. For that nominal dollar each fee to make it available for the world. They really felt it was wrong for them to personally profit from it. And instead, they had the university hold the patent and then license it out to reliable manufacturers. The whole idea was that they wanted to make insulin available at a low cost to everyone who needed it around the world. And they wanted to prevent any manufacturers from monopolizing it.
36:09Grant Maltman: And within the year, they need to turbocharge the operation. Demand is skyrocketing. So they make a deal with the pharmaceutical company Eli Lilly. By October 1923, the Nobel Prize Committee takes notice.
36:25Alison Li: And the wording is fantastic. The professor of staff at the Caroline Institute has considered the work of Banting and McLeod to be of such importance theoretically, so there's McLeod's four years, and practically. Banting taken from the beaker to the bedside that we resolve to jointly award them this great distinction.
36:45Grant Maltman: A glaring omission from the announcement and the team's award. Charlie Best and Dr. James Collip.
36:53Alison Li: And Banting is outraged.
36:57Grant Maltman: Banting sends a telegram to Charlie Best, who was giving a lecture at Harvard.
37:02Alison Li: Charlie, the Hurt Nobel Committee won't recognize you. To you I ascribe half my prize money for it. So Banting, this great man for this discovery, now is giving half his prize money away. How can you not elevate this man's status? McLeod gets blindsided by this?
37:23Grant Maltman: And when asked, he tells a reporter that he needs a few days to figure out what he'll do with his share of the prize money. Eventually, he telegraphs Collip. Some say reluctantly.
37:35Alison Li: He releases a statement to the press. I've spoken with Dr. Kolop. He's agreed to take half my money.
37:44Grant Maltman: After the prize announcement, the four men went their separate ways. Charlie Best finished his graduate degree at the University of Toronto and went on to serve as the head of the physiology department there. McLeod left Canada for a new university position in Scotland. Kolop, the brilliant mind who made victory possible in the final week, was forgotten to history until recently. And Fred Banting, he became a national hero. The man once consumed by failure became the face of the drug before pioneering aviation medicine during World War II. Banting and Kalip, the man forgotten to time, eventually did make up.
38:25Grant Maltman: Before setting off for a research mission in Britain, Banting and Kalip met up.
38:31Alison Li: The last friend to see him before he went on that trip was Kolop. Kolop and he had a dinner together. Kolop gave him a warm pair of gloves to wear on the plane.
38:42Grant Maltman: Banting would never live to tell the story. Shortly after takeoff, on February 20th, 1941, the bomber he boarded crashed in eastern Newfoundland. Just 49 years old, he died with those gloves gifted to him from the man he once worried might steal his glory. Before he died, Banting got to see so many lives changed, including Leonard Thompson, who lived 13 more years after that first successful dose of insulin. Millions more have been saved since.
39:17Alison Li: He received letters from around the world. Dear Dr. Banting, I'm a fat boy now and I feel fine. I can even climb a tree. I hope you're well. Four-year-old girl. My mommy says this is the greatest Christmas ever. Thank you for your gift. Dear Dr. Banting, this is the site of the greatest moment for Ultron type 1. My daughter diagnosed last week at age 2. Deserves to live. Dear Dr. Banting, this is my 17th anniversary. I came to let you know I'm alive and doing well. I look forward to seeing you again next World Diabetes Day. We have almost 4 ,000 of these letters in our collection now, written in 13 different languages.
40:05Alison Li: As a public historian, it doesn't get any better than that. These are people writing to a dead man.
40:13Grant Maltman: It's remarkable to think that as Leonard lay starving and dying, his father and mother made a remarkable choice. to place hope in an injection of an untested serum, a concoction that was imagined in a dream just a year earlier and reproduced with suspect methods by a failed surgeon who had never studied diabetes. Had the Thompsons known any of the twists and turns that led up to that first injection? Who knows what they might have decided.
40:59Grant Maltman: And that's it for this week's show. I'm Randa Abdelfattah. ThruLine was created by me and Ramtin Adablui. This episode was produced by me and... Amy Padula.
41:11Alison Li: Julia Redpath. Molly Marcello. Sarah Wyman. Lou Olkowski. Liana Semstrom. Irene Noguchi.
41:20Grant Maltman: Fact-checking for this episode was done by Kevin Bogle. You can read more about this story in the book The Discovery of Insulin by Michael Bliss. Thanks also to Johannes Durge, Josie Gettle, Jeff Leon, and Scott Hensley. This episode was mixed by Jimmy Keeley. Music for this episode was composed by Ramtin and his band Drop Electric. And finally, if you have an idea or liked something you heard on the show, please write us at throughline at npr.org. Also, make sure to follow us on Apple, Spotify, or the NPR app. That way, you'll never miss an episode. Thanks for listening.
42:01Alison Li: Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Instacart. Game day is here, and with Instacart, missing a play for a snack run is a thing of the past. Get veggies, chips, dips, and drinks delivered right to the door, along with groceries for the week. One order, everything needed from favorite local stores. Download the Instacart app and get delivery in as fast as 30 minutes. It's election season, which is an easy season to doom scroll, but it can be a hard season in which to find valuable information. NPR can be your source. We're a nonprofit that relies on your support, which means we can act and report in your interest.
42:40Alison Li: And with NPR Plus, you can hear dozens of NPR podcasts sponsor-free, all while powering our independent newsroom. Sign up today at plus.npr.org.