In short
The episode is about tracing how North American music evolved into global genres, using a travel guide to music museums, historic sites, and “living” venues. It claims the southeastern U.S. is a root of major 20th-century music: African traditions brought through slavery (work songs, call-and-response) fused with European/Scottish/Irish church and folk traditions, then spread via railroads and migration (e.g., blues moving north from the Mississippi Delta to Chicago, influencing rock and roll). It also argues music evolution is constant across generations and technologies (from front porches to radio/records/streaming). Notable examples include New Orleans Jazz Museum; Sun Studios/Stax/Graceland; Country Music Hall of Fame/Grand Ole Opry; Rock and Roll Hall of Fame; Motown Museum; Bob Dylan Center and Woody Guthrie Center; B.B. King Center; Delta Cultural Museum and Gateway to the Blues Museum; Elvis Birthplace Museum; Martin Guitar Museum; Kane’s Ballroom; Church Studio; Prejean dance hall; Floyd Country Store; Blueberry Cafe; and Cape Breton Celtic festivals.
Guests
Josephine Matthias (Canadian freelance travel writer focused on travel/food/wild places) and Craig Jones (Canadian writer and musician). A second segment features Fred Plotkin (opera expert; author of Opera 101) giving tips for enjoying opera without needing to follow every word.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOEpisode Discussion
0:00 to 14:01
“So much great music was created in the past hundred years and you could log thousands of miles road tripping to all the sights of popular music legends.”
Exploring Cultural Influences on Music
14:01 to 17:22
Learn about the intertwining of African and Caribbean music styles in North America.
“about how this is a cultural story and how things are interconnected and how things morph and evolve with time, we keep thinking of different influences.”
Music Trails and Festivals
17:22 to 20:11
Discover various music trails and the vibrant music culture they offer travelers.
“It ranges from Blue Ridge Music Trail to the Johnny Cash Music Trail.”
Introduction of Guests
20:11 to 20:45
Meet the guests Joe and Craig as they share insights on music in North America.
“Their book is The Music Lover's Guide to North America, focusing on the best music museums and historic sites in the United States and Canada that relate to music.”
Promoting Regions' Music
20:45 to 24:45
Each guest promotes a region's music culture and highlights key sites to visit.
“Let's just pretend each of you is an advertising agent promoting one region's music.”
Celtic Music Influence in Canada
24:45 to 28:00
Explore the influence of Celtic music in Canada and its festivals.
“Tulsa, probably per capita, has more musical thrills from a history point of view than any other place.”
Exploring Celtic Music in North America
28:00 to 31:20
Learn about the vibrant Celtic music scene in North America and key cultural sites.
“which is a real hotbed for Celtic music and Celtic artists.”
Interactive Musical Experiences
31:20 to 32:00
Discover how interactive experiences enhance appreciation for music and culture.
“thanks so much for joining us, and thanks for writing The Music Lover's Guide to North America.”
Appreciating Opera with Fred Plotkin
32:00 to 40:00
Gain insights into how to appreciate opera and its emotional depth.
“A challenge for us travelers is to have experiences, to enjoy other cultures with all the sensuality possible.”
The Heart of Opera in Europe
40:00 to 42:00
Explore the significance of opera in Europe and its cultural impact.
“Fred, an opera takes usually three hours or more.”
Show all 13 chapters
Experiencing Opera in Europe
42:00 to 45:00
Discover the cultural significance and vibrant experiences of opera in Europe.
“for the first time they were allowed to speak in Catalan, so the program was printed in Catalan, all of which is to say that the audience that night experienced identity with the stars.”
Guidelines for Enjoying Opera
45:00 to 48:20
Learn about outdoor venues and tips for enjoying opera performances.
“Let's talk about great potential experiences as you're traveling.”
Understanding Opera Etiquette
48:20 to 50:30
Get insights on opera etiquette, including when to applaud and shout bravo.
“I was thinking as I was reading your book about opera, like you said, Wagner is very tough.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00So much great music was created in the past hundred years and you could log thousands of miles road tripping to all the sights of popular music legends. The authors of the new Music Lover's Guide to North America recommend you start down south. North America, especially the southeastern U.S., sits at the root of so much of the music that created the wallpaper of our lives. It's the blues that moves north into Chicago and becomes the basis for rock and roll. and it's rock and roll that conquers the world. Coming up, we'll look at the legends of country and Cajun, rhythm and blues, and rock and roll from Tupelo to Tulsa and beyond.
0:37And just in case you don't think opera's quite your thing, Fred Plotkin has tips to help you feel transported from the cares of everyday life at one of the world's great opera houses. People who go to the opera thinking they're supposed to follow the story in words are missing out on the main experience. Find music in your travels on today's Travel with Rick Steves. The invention of the record player and the birth of radio helped to popularize music, music that people were making from the back streets to the backwoods all over America in the early 20th century. In just a minute, we'll look at places you can visit to learn about these musicians and pay tribute to the giants and geniuses who helped to shape the music you grew up with.
1:22And a bit later on today's Travel with Rick Steves, we'll explore how even people who don't think they like it can appreciate the emotional power of a great opera. Fred Plotkin is a New Yorker with the soul of an Italian, and he'll help us know what to listen for to enjoy a sensory-filled night at the opera, at home or in your travels. One of America's most influential exports has got to be music. Think of it. Jazz, blues, rock and roll, country bluegrass, soul. These American sounds have gone global, but they're rooted in specific times and places right here. Recording studios, front porches, roadside clubs, plantations, churches, city neighborhoods where musical traditions and cultures cross-pollinated.
2:08For travelers who want to trace these stories, North America is full of music landmarks, both major and minor. Until now, though, there hasn't been a single guidebook to help connect them. And that's where Canadians Josephine Matthias and Craig Jones come in. In their book, The Music Lover's Guide to North America, this writer and musician duo explore the vast array of music museums and points of interest across the United States and Canada with a good dose of musical background and context thrown in. Wherever you are, you probably don't have to go far to find a place where music history comes to life.
2:44Joe and Craig, thanks so much for joining us. Thanks for having us, Rick. Thank you. It's a pleasure. So, reading through your book, it is so clear that North America, dominated by the United States, but you guys are Canadian, so we include that, is sort of a uniquely diverse and dynamic cultural force. And it shows itself in music. People don't create art in a vacuum. It reflects the culture. And when you think about the diversity and the thriving nature of the music culture in our part of the world, what does that tell us about the culture from where it comes? Yeah, start with the easiest question first.
3:26Well, Rick, music is a very, very human expression. It's found in every culture. And I think there's something about North America that the people who populated it initially came from oppressive environments where they were trying to escape. And that's very important. So they brought their culture and traditions with them, but they also created new cultures and traditions out of the fusion of these different cultures coming together and blending. So there, I mean, not that another place might be boring, but relatively speaking, we being a melting pot place, being a land where until recently immigrants were welcome and people who were downtrodden found a refuge, that really made the cultural compost pile from where different slices of the culture, like music, can blossom, quite fertile.
4:18Yeah, I'd like to add, Rick, that it wasn't just people who were oppressed coming to North America to escape that oppression. One of the major influences on how music evolved in North America came from people being brought here and placed in oppressive situations, mainly slavery plantations in the Southeast, which is why the southeastern U.S. is such a hotbed of music. We're going to talk in more detail about specific things a little later in our conversation, but when I'm doing a TV show, I like to always have what we call a wide shot to start with to give people the context so they know, you know, as we dig deeper into specifics.
4:59Give us just a very brief wide shot, a sweep through the story about how music has been diverse and a dynamic cultural force in the United States, in America. How do you thread it together to make it be like an arc? Well, I would say that the very first European settlers to North America brought with them traditions from the Church of Europe and England and Scotland and Ireland. Take Appalachia, for example, and they fused it with the music of minstrels, or what we today call folk music, or people who carried music from one little town to another, and work songs and so forth, and songs of prisoners and sailors' songs, that sort of thing.
5:43And then, you know, it influences and cross-pollinates with other traditions coming from West Africa and so forth. And these were all forms of expression that evolved as they moved from one mouth to ear, to mouth to ear, to mouth to ear. And from there, this music took on a life of its own, and children learned it, and, you know, they sang it around community meetings, and they sang it on the front porch. the county fair, whatever the terminology of the time was. And generation after generation, it all kind of comes together in this extraordinary fusion. And one musical form adapts and borrows from other musical forms and evolves in the process.
6:22I just love that context that we have now because, as you guys were explaining, it morphs from church to folk to work, shanties. It migrates, like with the movement of people, especially with slavery. And then it evolves with the technology, whether it's a fairground or a streaming media service, there's a way to help it metastasize through the culture. That's right. Borrowing and fusing and adapting and evolving and innovating. And, you know, every generation or every artist that comes along wants to capture the best of what's come before them, pay homage to it, but then innovate it, innovate on it and make something distinctive of their own.
7:03And this is going on constantly. Yes, so blues birthed jazz and bluegrass and rock and roll and Motown and soul, and it just goes on and on and on. So it is true to say that North America, especially the southeastern U.S., sits at the root of so much of the music that created the wallpaper of our lives. There you go. So this is the rationale for taking your guidebook, The Music Lover's Guide to North America, as almost a primer to understand music as like a textbook and how it's such a cultural force in our society. It's easy for people from a certain generation, especially in our day and age, to think that, well, okay, that's all over now, and now we're into a whole different reality.
7:51Is this sort of evolutionary story just barreling right through our lifetimes, or is it something that has brought us here and it's going to be different from now on out? Oh, I think it's constant. I think it's so deeply ingrained in the human genome, in our self-understanding, in our relations, in our connections to other people. I don't see any end of it. You know, there's no singularity. That's an important thing for us to remember as we're considering all of this. Indeed. This is Travel with Rick Steves. We're enjoying a tour of North American music sites right now with Joe Mathias and Craig Jones.
8:26Their book is The Music Lover's Guide to North America. It highlights about 150 museums, exhibits, and historic sites connected to the places, instruments, and people that have propelled music in the United States and Canada. Joe is a freelance writer with a focus on travel, food, and wild places. Craig is a writer and a musician. You can find more on them online at their website, musictravelguides.com. Now, in your research for your book, you talked about, we want to take us where the music moves us, and that meant months of boots-on-the-ground research, countless miles, thousands of photographs, hundreds of interviews, suffering through all of this great music in order to distill it into a wonderful 180-page package that we can all have and do what a good guidebook does, help us get more out of our travels.
9:17Tell us about the research. That must have been so interesting. It actually started as a little bit of a love story. As a full-time travel writer, I was on the road a lot of the time, all over the world. And Craig was often gigging, and we were like ships passing in the night sometimes. I'm sure you know what that's like. And so I came home from one trip and said, you know, we both have writing backgrounds. Craig has a degree in political science, so he's got the politics and the history background and the music background, and I had the travel knowledge. Why don't we hit the road together writing music travel destinations?
9:58So we bought a bit of a hippie camper van, packed in the dog and the guitars and we hit the road for about eight weeks to look at the roots of American music in the southeastern US and came back and wrote a lot of magazine and newspaper articles and picked up the interest of a publisher. And the publisher came to us and said, could you do a book on one of these genres and which one would it be? We said, of course. And blues was the one that we chose because they like to say blues are the roots and the rest are the fruits. That's right. So much comes from the blues. The blues influence so much and it really picks up all these cultural and historical forces in the 20th century especially.
10:43I want to get into some of the special little discoveries in the intimate places, but before we do, Joe, can you just quickly run me through the major three or four museums or sites that would be obviously on everybody's checklist? Well, I would say the New Orleans Jazz Museum in the city of New Orleans. In Memphis, you'd be looking at Sun Studios or Stax, perhaps Graceland. That's very well known. In Nashville, it would be obviously the Country Music Hall of Fame and the Grand Ole Opry. And I would say those are the biggest ones. Well, except in Cleveland, you've got the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.
11:18Rock and Roll. And then Detroit, you've got the Motown Museum. Yeah. Oh, yeah. Those are the biggies. Okay. Now, you mentioned you visited like over 100 spots. I love a well-done museum, and they don't need to be big and famous to be special. How do you mark a quality museum? What's the kind of museum that really sparkles for you? Oh, well, some of these museums are like four-hour exhibits. You know, you don't go in there expecting to come out in less than four hours, like, for example, the Bob Dylan Center or the Woody Guthrie Center, both in Tulsa, Oklahoma. Another museum that really, really made an impression on me was the Seagal in South Carolina.
11:58And that's an interesting story because it's a private collection that just got out of hand, got so big that he had to relocate to a much larger space. And he's imported instruments from all over the world, including a piano that Chopin toured with and a harpsichord that Mozart played on. Wow. And this is not the kind of museum where you're not permitted to touch anything. they want you to play these instruments and they put on concerts and it's just where is that craig greenville south carolina okay and then there's this beautiful little museum in the in brady texas called the heart of texas country music museum and it's another one that a personal project started by a young young man radio disc jockey who just started writing to country artists and say hey send me a pair of boots hey send me a hat and they did amazing amazing he collected it all put together in this beautiful museum.
12:50And, you know, it's not a Smithsonian-type institution, but it's a beautifully curated, lovingly curated museum.
12:59We're getting you ready for a road trip to see where great music was born, from Nashville and Motown to the back roads of Appalachia, the Delta, and the Southwest. Josephine Mattias and Craig Jones are the authors of The Music Lover's Guide to North America. They also explore the home turf of Mississippi Delta blues legends in their earlier book called Chasing the Blues, A Traveler's Guide to America's Music. Stops in Mississippi and Virginia are just ahead on Travel with Rick Steves. Our guests, Craig Jones and Joe Matias, outfitted a camper van to travel thousands of miles to search the music trails of America.
13:38They visited dozens of museums, exhibits and historic sites, places that are dedicated to the people and instruments that propelled the music made in the USA and Canada into the hits and legends of the 20th century. Their book's been called A Rockin' Crash Course on America's Music Revolution. It's The Music Lover's Guide to North America. So, Joe and Craig, talking to you about how this is a cultural story and how things are interconnected and how things morph and evolve with time, we keep thinking of different influences. Let's just do a little quick review of these various influences. Of course, we have African and Caribbean music styles brought by enslaved peoples.
14:22Tell us a little bit about that, and we'll look at some other influences. Yeah, you know, we had a tide of enslaved persons come into North America, and they brought with them their African traditions, which included singing while working. Very important. And you mentioned that earlier, and I hadn't thought about that, pachanties and, you know, yo-ho, heave-ho when you're pulling a boat up the river and when you're picking cotton, you've got music. Exactly. Working in the turpentine camps or pounding nails in building railroads, something like that. If you have an individual in that group who is able to create some kind of rhythmic utterance that coordinates the work of other people, that person is valuable.
15:07And that becomes a form of music that is transmitted and easily incorporated into the culture. If you want to learn more about African-American impact on music culture, where would you go? I would go to Mississippi, not because Mississippi is the only place, but because blues has a huge influence on North American music. Mississippi is kind of the cauldron where blues really takes form before it migrates out of the Mississippi Delta. I would go there first. Another thing which is interesting to me is a lot of the vibrancy and diversity of music relates to the advent of the railways. Oh, yes. And not only in the building of the railways and the coordinating human movement to lay track and so forth, but then to move individuals from place to place.
15:54And the blues musicians in the Mississippi Delta, they moved around carrying their music with them. And that was a form of spreading the influence. It's the blues that moves north into Chicago and becomes the basis for rock and roll. And it's rock and roll that conquers the world, really. And then another dimension of this that's just occurred to me, we have the impact and the evolution of various instruments. Oh, yes. Because, you know, like, take the piano, a very complex piece of machinery, very fragile. So not a lot of them around. But the guitar, very simple, very portable, maybe not the most robust instrument.
16:33You know, they break, you know, they warp and so forth, but you can get them through a mail-order catalog. Maybe you could get pianos through a mail-order catalog too, but they arrive and they're a ton and a half. Yeah, but think about it. A banjo, a fiddle, a guitar, a harmonica. Mississippi saxophone. These are portable. One other one that you didn't mention, which is geography. Things like the 1927 Mississippi flood that changed the shape of the landscape in the southeastern U.S. made work on plantations impossible for people. So they packed up their music and went north, and they took it to places like St.
17:11Louis, Detroit, New York, Chicago, and that's how the music went from the Delta up north. It's a story with a plot, and you can track the arc of it. In your book, you list your favorite music trails for driving or walking. It ranges from Blue Ridge Music Trail to the Johnny Cash Music Trail. Tell me about a favorite music trail and why that would be a rewarding goal for a traveler. I would say one of the very first ones we did through Virginia, which was the Crooked Road Music Trail that goes through Appalachia. And it links not only museums, it links historic sites like the Carter Family Fold, which still has a Friday night dance and jamboree.
17:56And they're on the dance floor and they're flat footing. They're step dancing. And just up the road, there's a remarkable place in Floyd at the Floyd Country Store on Friday nights. They have a jamboree. Local musicians play outside, up and down the main street. and then inside there's a feature band and people are getting up all generations. Grandparents dancing with grandchildren. It's really unique. So it links not only museums but historic sites and culturally important sites. And places that are alive. Like I was thinking of that because you also list music festivals, obviously, in a music lover's guide.
18:37But a problem with the festivals, you've got to be there on a certain weekend or whatever. And what I really like in my travels is that kind of place that I write it up as it's a festival every evening, you know, a beer hall in Bavaria or a pub on the west coast of Ireland. And, Joe, you were just listing several examples of that. Let's just collect five or six places right now that you could go to and reasonably expect to hear a little mini festival of live music of that genre any time of year. I would say in Louisiana, Prejean, which is a dance hall. and you'd find that many nights of the week.
19:16And again, it's multi-generational. The Floyd Country Store in Floyd, Virginia, in Mississippi, the Blueberry Cafe in Clarksdale. These are all small spots that usually feature local artists and have huge followings. Almost any street in downtown New Orleans, you're going to find a bunch of kids cracking out. Yeah, a great example. It's amazing. You know, I've known people from my youth who traveled to New Orleans to live for a couple of years and play on the street exactly to imbibe that culture. And if you love art, visual art, you can go to the gallery and see the genius of all of these artists.
19:57But when it comes to music, you need to hear it. And if you can hear it live, that's it. So your book would give people a good sense of where they're likely to experience that music live in their travels. This is Travel with Rick Steves. We are talking with Joe, Matthias, and Craig Jones, and they're joining us from their home base in Kingston, Ontario right now as we explore the music that emerged from the United States in the 20th century and eventually changed the world. Their book is The Music Lover's Guide to North America, focusing on the best music museums and historic sites in the United States and Canada that relate to music.
20:34We have links to Joe and Craig's work in the notes for this week's show at ricksteves.com slash radio and you can learn more about their work at their website, musictravelguides.com. Now, what I'd like to do is play kind of a little game. Let's just pretend each of you is an advertising agent promoting one region's music. And I'm going to give you one minute to promote why a traveler would want to go to that region and enjoy the music dimension of that culture. So, you know, what's there? Why does it matter? What would we highlight? Right. So, Joe, take me to the northeast of the United States and tell me what is the dominant force, where will I go, and what will I find?
21:15Well, you've got the larger cities. You've got New York and Boston, places like that have some lovely museums right now to visit. You've got the influence of jazz when it moved with people like Louis Armstrong into the cities in the northeast. You also have in more of the rural areas, places like the Martin Guitar Factory in Nazareth. And that's a fabulous spot to go to because it's not only a museum about the instrument, it has a factory floor tour, which is fascinating because on that factory floor, you see pieces being laser cut, but then you see them being hand glued together by one technician.
21:58So it's a real marriage of new technology and old technology. What site is that and where is it? That is the Martin Guitar Museum in the town of Nazareth, Pennsylvania. Okay, and I don't know if Washington, D.C. is what exact region that is, but of course in Washington, D.C., we have the National Museum of African American History. You've got the Smithsonian Museums, yes, that have beautiful artifacts on display, ones that are one of a kind, pieces of history. Now we're going to go to Craig, and we're going to talk up the Southeast. Southeast is, there's so many museums, it's hard to know where to start.
22:37I was really impressed with Bristol. Bristol's got a terrific museum. It's a Smithsonian institution. And, of course, Bristol is a source of the Big Bang, and there are literally thousands of country musicians come out of that part of the world, country and bluegrass musicians. You've got piles of museums in your book from Tennessee and Mississippi and Louisiana, right? Yes, that's very rich and dense cultural history there. And of course, you know, Mississippi produces the blues. It's not the sole source of the blues, but the B.B. King Center in Indianola. Amazing museum, amazing exhibit. Where else in Southeast?
23:17Yeah, I would also like to add that Mississippi is a living history museum of music. places like the Delta Cultural Museum in Clarksdale, places like Gateway to the Blues Museum in Tunica, which is just below Memphis. And a lot of people don't realize that Elvis came from Mississippi, from the little town of Tupelo, and it has a fabulous museum called the Elvis Birthplace Museum that we actually both preferred to Graceland. One of my takeaways from your book, if there was a family tree of music, the trunk would be in the southeast, I think. For sure. All right. Hey, Joe, take us to South Central.
23:57That's Texas and Oklahoma, because it punches above its weight. Well, two of my very favorite museums are in Tulsa, which was a complete surprise to us. It is a hotbed of music, but the two that really spoke to me are right next door to each other. One is the Bob Dylan Center, and the other one is the Woody Guthrie Center. And, of course, Bob Dylan chose this location because he worshipped Woody Guthrie. What I loved about the Bob Dylan Museum that made it different than any other museum we went to is that it's not just about Bob Dylan. It's really dedicated to the art and the craft and the full production of music and takes us through all the decades that he has been around because he still is.
24:42And right next door, the Woody Guthrie Center is also world-class, but it talks about how he was really influenced by the Dust Bowl, which was a whole history lesson for us. Tulsa, probably per capita, has more musical thrills from a history point of view than any other place. Oh, yes. In addition, you've got Kane's Ballroom, which is the old-fashioned wooden floor ballroom where Bob Wilson, his Texas Playboys, started out. You've got the Church Studio, which was a studio for Leon Russell. There's all sorts of great sites there. Okay, we're going to go now to Craig with the Midwest. Music follows people.
25:22It follows industry. We have a lot of people in industry in the Midwest. Tell us about that. Well, the Motown Museum, you can't pass the Motown Museum. It's newly renovated. It's such an extraordinary exhibit. And that music is so powerful and so resonant and so fresh today. It still works so well. as a bass player, of course, I'm enthralled with James Jamerson. So it's kind of a shrine for me, as Stax was, as Sun Records was. You know, these are shrines. So I would go there. Shrines. That's a great thing. Shrines to music. Yeah. Okay, we're going to move it along. We're going to go to Joe for the West, because Los Angeles is just, and San Francisco, right?
26:03Joe, take us to the West. Yes, San Francisco does not really have a large museum dedicated in that area, but it does have a very deep and rich history of music all along the West Coast. And if you go further down to Bakersfield and you've got Los Angeles, so you've got clubs where, you know, the Eagles began and Linda Ronstadt played and other influential artists who were there. And then in Phoenix, Arizona, you've got the massive musical instrument museum, which has musical instruments from all around the globe. That sounds like a fascinating place to check out. And then you guys are both Canadians, so let's talk about Canada.
26:47How does Canada work into the story? Well, Canada is right next door to the United States, a considerably smaller population and under the enormous influence of the United States. So it's only fair to acknowledge that most of the music that we grew up with, certainly that defined the 20th century, came from the United States, maybe with the singular exception of one culture we haven't mentioned, which is the Acadians who were displaced from Canada in an ethnic cleansing and moved to Louisiana region, the bayous and so forth, and cultivated a music style there. But we have like the Hank Snow Museum in eastern Canada and the Anne Murray Museum and the, what's the one in Calgary?
Read the full transcript
27:28The Studio Bell. The Studio Bell. We don't have nearly the concentration of population in museums in Canada that we see in the United States. We've had on our show Alan Doyle from... Yes, you have Celtic. And Celtic. And he is just a Celtic hoot. I love that man. And he's so Canadian and so Celtic. And it just feels to me like he's an upwelling of that Newfoundland culture or whatever. Tell us a little bit about the Celtic influence. A lot of that comes from the island of Cape Breton, which is part of Nova Scotia, which is a real hotbed for Celtic music and Celtic artists. And it has a lovely museum called the Celtic Music Interpretive Center in Judique on the West Coast.
28:14And festivals, Cape Breton and Nova Scotia especially, are awash in music festivals, whether it's the Celtic Colors Festival. The Stan Rogers Festival. The Stan Rogers Festival in Canso. It's a hotbed. It's a world of opportunities if you love music and you're going to be on the road. Come on, come on. One, two, three. Craig Jones and Josephine Matthias are joining us from their home in Kingston, Ontario to explore the historical sites, museums, and points of interest that pay tribute to the cornerstones of American music. They checked out hundreds of options for us and recommend their favorites in The Music Lover's Guide to North America.
28:53I'd like to just kind of wrap up our conversation with just one thought from each of you. As I mentioned, I can go to the Vincent van Gogh Museum in the Netherlands and look at his art and appreciate it. But with music, you need to have some kind of interactiveness. What's an example that has inspired you of a museum or a house or some kind of a cultural site relating to music that really nailed it because they connected you with that interactive experience? Okay, so I cannot remember the name of the place. It was somewhere in the Crooked Trail where the locals gather around a circle every Tuesday night or something like that, and they spontaneously jam.
29:36And my memory of that, because I had my bass with me, I was the complete outsider, but they welcomed me in, and there was a dozen guitars and a guy playing mandolin. And when it was his turn to solo, he sped up. And you could see around the circle the fear rising in everybody's eyes because nobody knew where he was going to come out. But this group had gathered together regularly, and they all knew each other, and it was just fun. And we saw lots of examples of that, you know, like half a dozen guys sitting around with guitars in a barbershop playing songs they played a thousand times, some of them very, very confident players, others, you know, not so good, but just loving the experience of being with each other and sharing these songs.
30:18Sharing it, sharing that culture. And, Jo, I thought about how an interactive experience inspired you. Well, this is a little more low key, but we were in Clarksdale, Mississippi, and we were standing at our van and talking to a local musician who's quite well known. And then he just paused and he said to Craig, my bass player hasn't shown up and I have a gig in five minutes. Do you think you can sub? And so Craig went and got his bass out of the back of the van, plugged in, and you didn't know what they were going to be playing, but he's accomplished enough that he could keep up. and he had a gig that night.
30:55And this sort of thing happened to us several times. And it was a lovely way to connect with the people, not just a curator at a museum or a historian somewhere, but to actually connect with people. And that's what really jumped out at me. And that's kind of the fundamental takeaway from the Music Lovers Guide is to connect with this culture in creative ways. And there's lots of ways to do that. Well, Joe Mathias and Craig Jones, thanks so much for joining us, and thanks for writing The Music Lover's Guide to North America. Our pleasure. Thank you so much. Thank you for having us, Rick. It's an honor to talk to you.
31:30Let's all sing together You can find more about Joe and Craig at musictravelguides.com In addition to his expertise on Italian food and culture, Fred Plotkin is one of today's foremost experts on opera. He has a few pointers to help you get the most out of attending the opera, maybe at one of Europe's grand venues or even just listening on the radio. That's just ahead on Travel with Rick Steves. A challenge for us travelers is to have experiences, to enjoy other cultures with all the sensuality possible. And one great opportunity that a lot of us miss is opera. We're joined today by Fred Plotkin.
32:15Fred's a bon vivant author. He's a self-described pleasure activist, and he's an expert in opera. We've talked to Fred before about Italian cuisine. Now we're going to talk to Fred about opera. His guidebook to opera is Opera 101, A Complete Guide to Learning and Loving Opera. Fred Plotkin, thanks for joining us. Thank you. It kind of reminds me of in the movie when Harry met Sally. Remember, the woman was sort of having an orgasm over her beautiful dinner, and somebody else goes, I'll have what she's having. I get that sense when I'm in Europe. Other people are just into opera. How can we get in on the ecstasy?
32:48Well, that's the first time I've ever heard opera compared to a pastrami sandwich. I would just ratchet up the verb a bit and say, rather than appreciate opera, we love opera. And the people who tell me they hate opera tend to be the people who had the bad experience as a child of being taken without preparation and having to sit in a five-hour Wagnerian marathon. Wagner is fabulous, but not for kids. The thing about opera is it is a projection of who we are. And among the many things we love about opera is we see the whole range of human experience and emotion and passions in our rather polite, politically correct society.
33:32We don't permit ourselves to talk about, but nonetheless, believe me, we still experience all these things. So the place where many opera lovers go to share those feelings is in the opera house. Combine that with the fact that you've taken great stories, set them to music. Now, where the problem is for many people is they think they're supposed to understand everything through the words. So if the opera is in Italian or German or French, they say, I don't get it. My answer is read the story or the synopsis before, then listen to the music because that is where the story is told. Huh. So you wrote, open your heart without inhibitions and let the music flow through.
34:22My hang-up has been trying to be worried about, I'm not following the plot completely, and, you know, of course, I don't speak the language. So we need to, like, ease up then. True. We are such a literal, analytical society, and everything in our education points us toward understanding, but I'm a believer that understanding is more at a visceral, hormonal level. We get it because we share the human experience. This conversation that we're having is a very intimate experience among friends who have never met personally, but are friends. And it's that same experience at the opera. You may not personally know the singer, but she's your friend in that You know her voice.
35:06You know what she looks like. And when she sings for you, now, mind you, it is without a microphone. And nowadays, to hear sound that is unmitigated by electronics is very rare. And here they're singing beautifully over an orchestra that is not amplified. This is a very sensorial experience, and that's why we have this intimacy and this excitement. People who go to the opera thinking they're supposed to follow the story in words are missing out on the main experience. As I was reading your book, it occurred to me Shakespeare is another challenge for a lot of people. There's no doubt opera and Shakespeare are really fundamental in culture.
35:49They're just so undeniably really important. But a lot of people have a tough time with it. And Shakespeare and opera have something in common. They're just masterful at dealing with the human experience. Hamlet is often compared to Mozart's Don Giovanni in that they are so global, so universal, that whatever we walk into the theater with and then encounter from the actors of the singers in the telling of the story that night is what we take away. so that if we're having romantic issues and go to see Don Giovanni and discover that he seems to be on top of his game in terms of love and romance and sex, but in fact he's not, where we connect to that may be through his character and may be through one of the three women we meet in the opera who he tries to seduce.
36:40The thing about masterpieces is they are not plain and simple. They're prismatic. It's like holding up a cut crystal. If you turn it slightly, you see a different reflection of something else. What we put into that reflection, that facet, is what we get back. I would imagine you've seen some operas dozens of times. Hundreds of times. Hundreds of times. Literally hundreds. I'm not exaggerating. It's like holding up a crystal, huh? You can look at it depending on where you're at in that part of your life, or what does the venue mean to you, or who are the performers? Well, all of that, for example, the fact that, let's take Madame Butterfly by Puccini.
37:19I saw it for the first time when I was 18 in Bologna. Madame Butterfly is 18 in the opera, but the woman playing it was 40. I didn't yet realize that she was playing 18 because I was 18. As I've gotten older and as I've had different life experiences, the story of this Japanese woman who has a baby with an American sailor who shows up and then disappears and then comes back and takes the baby away. All sung in Italian can seem very strained, but when you realize that what this is about is love, abandonment, selfishness, parental affection, the older you get and the more experience you have, the more you relate to that same opera differently.
38:09If you see different productions in different places that tell the story differently and then hear different women singing the role of Madame Butterfly, it all changes. So we live, we opera lovers live with these operas over the arc of a lifetime. So Madame Butterfly didn't mean much to me at 18. It means a lot to me now. Perhaps La Boheme, which I found very gripping when I was a 20-year-old, has a different meaning now because it's about a phase of life that I've passed, and I'm now in other phases of life. So opera is there to reflect who we are. Now, when you go to an opera many, many times over the course of your life as an opera lover, it kind of raises the bar for the performers to bring something intimate and unique to the performance, I would imagine also.
38:58There's a lot expected out of the performers other than just performing well musically. What I try to do is go not with the history of every Madame Butterfly I've seen before me, but to step into the theater and see the woman who's singing it and let her give me her version. Now, when we go to the opera, we are, let's say you've flown from New York to Vienna or Milan. You might be jet-lagged. You might be in a different mood. You might be in an elated mood. We see these works repeatedly just the way we reread certain iconic books, go back and look at great films and paintings and plays because they are works of art that offer different things at different times.
39:44So I try as an audience member to arrive fresh, alert, and with no preconceptions. I'm Rick Steves. This is Travel with Rick Steves. We're speaking with Fred Plotkin, and Fred writes the How to Appreciate Opera book. It's called Opera 101, A Complete Guide to Learning and Loving Opera. Fred, an opera takes usually three hours or more. In this speedy 21st century, is it outmoded, or can you make a case that it's more important than ever that we take this time? On the contrary, it's more important than ever. You know how we sit down to a slow meal, and we enjoy it more because we can savor everything If you are removed from the worries and stresses of daily life and can sit surrounded by beauty, surrounded by emotion, surrounded by other people who are similarly experiencing that emotion and beauty, it's a very transporting event.
40:39And I think it's necessary just the way some people go to the gym to, quote, zone out. Other people will go for a long walk. Other people will meditate. many of us go to the opera, not to escape, but to deepen ourselves, but not in the sense of self-improvement, but in the sense of giving in. I don't analyze when I go to the opera. I pay attention, but I let everything come into me. And then when I leave the theater, that's when I start putting the pieces together. Now, when you leave the theater, Fred, sometimes do you think, ah, this just wasn't quite right, and other times everything came together.
41:18I'll always remember this evening. Yes. I can pinpoint for you, as any opera lover can, the great experiences they've had. In my case, the greatest performance I ever saw was in April of 1979 in Barcelona. And it starred Montserrat Caballé, José Carreras, and Juan Pones, all of them Catalan, singing in an opera called Andrea Chenier. It is one of my favorite operas. these were three Catalan artists playing to the home crowd, like Barcelona's football club playing at home. Because Catalonia had just become somewhat independent in the political events that happened after the death of Francisco Franco, for the first time they were allowed to speak in Catalan, so the program was printed in Catalan, all of which is to say that the audience that night experienced identity with the stars.
42:15I'm getting goosebumps as I'm talking to you. And the stars were energized by this and really pulled out all the stops, sang the music fantastically well, and the ovations went on for more than an hour after the performance ended. Whoa. Oh, my goodness. And you still remember that from 1979. I could hear it as if we're yesterday. Oh, my goodness. What was the hall? Where was that performance? It's the Teatro Liceu, L-I-C-E-U, in Barcelona, on the Ramblas next to the Boca d 'Irmarche. And Fred, if we're planning a trip, Europe is sort of the heartland of opera. What, France, Italy, Austria, and Germany would be the great classic countries for opera?
42:59And the Czech Republic and Russia. Okay. And if you're going to Europe, what's the checklist of great opera houses to try to experience? Well, there's a wonderful website I use called Operissimo, O-P-E-R-I-S-S-I-M-O.com that list opera houses and their websites in 46 countries. And whenever I plan a trip, what I tend to do is say, okay, I'm planning to go to Berlin. Let's see what's on in Berlin in March. And then once I see what's on, then I pick my flight dates based on that. So it's a very valuable tool. But Berlin is fascinating because they have three opera houses. One of them is the old opera house from before World War II.
43:49One of them is the Deutsches Opera in West Berlin that was built after the wall went up. And then there's the Komische Opera, the comic opera, which is an older company as well. So that in Berlin, every night of the year, practically, you have three operas to choose from. So it's a great destination. I wouldn't say it's the best, but it's great. Wow, that's quite a public demand for opera that they could put on three different operas each night in one city. Well, bless the Berliners' heart, they fund the arts more in the city of Berlin than the entire United States government does for arts in our 50 states.
44:27Wow. And I know in Austria, in Vienna, they do a lot to fund the arts. Last time I was in Vienna, they actually had a big screen in front of the opera house so people who couldn't afford to get in or were not able to get tickets could actually enjoy the opera as it was being performed inside. Actually, though, that's copied from the Metropolitan Opera. It was invented in New York. Oh, is that right? Other companies are doing it now. It's done in the baseball stadiums in Washington and San Francisco, and many theaters do it, but it was invented and premiered at the Metropolitan Opera. Again, I'm Rick Steves.
44:59This is Travel with Rick Steves. We're talking with Fred Plotkin. Let's talk about great potential experiences as you're traveling. What about great outdoor venues? I used to go to the Baths of Caracalla in Rome for the opera. That's a great one. Another one that is off the charts a bit that people don't know is Bregenz in Western Austria. It's done on Lake Constance, and they build a raft on the lake. And on that raft is the scenery. So the performers go out in boats before the performance, or perhaps swim out, and get into costume, and they're all backstage behind the scenery on the raft and come forward.
45:39And we audience members sit on land looking out at the raft. And it's a wonderful experience, acoustically not the best, but fascinating nonetheless. What about the Verona has opera in it? Verona in the Arena di Verona was built in 100 A.D. People descend from all over Europe. There are about 19 ,000 seats. This is done in the summers. And they do grand opera, which is to say massive productions, crowds of thousands. When I was a teenager, I worked there in the summers as an assistant director and a gopher. What you need to know about Verona, wonderful magical setting, great food after the opera, wonderful pizzas right across the street.
46:24But bring an umbrella. In Great Britain, there is Glyndebourne. Glyndebourne is this wonderful meadow that you go out to and you sit and you bring a wonderful catered picnic, the British dressed in tuxedos and gowns to sit on the ground, to feast on oysters and champagne and grouse and all of that. And they really turn out for that. The productions are wonderful, too. But so much of what Glyndebourne is about is the audience experience. How do you spell Glyndebourne? G-L-Y-N-D-E-B-O-U-R-N-E, near London. You know, I was in Venice recently, and there's a palazzo where you have opera scenes going through this incredible palace.
47:09And I thought it was so magical to take you back to see the opera kind of in the proper context historically. Have you been to that? Yes. Well, opera, as we know, it was not invented in Venice. It was invented in Florence, but it didn't really get off the ground until it reached Venice, which was the first great city of opera. And in the first century of opera, from 1597 to 1697, they built 17 opera houses in Venice and premiered 388 new works in Venice. No city in the world can match that. And you probably went to the Palazzo Vendramine, where they do these kind of backstage at the opera through history events.
47:51Wagner lived there. Right now on Travel with Rick Steves, Fred Plotkin is offering a guide to enjoying opera, especially for people who don't think it's for them. Fred also collaborated with me on a culinary guide to Italy. That book's called Italy for Food Lovers. Fred's authored Opera 101 and Classical Music 101, in print and as audiobooks. We have links to his work with today's show at ricksteves.com slash radio. I was thinking as I was reading your book about opera, like you said, Wagner is very tough. You don't want to break into opera with Wagner necessarily. What would be the best opera on training wheels?
48:29And I was kind of almost thinking of the comic opera in Spain, Zarzuela. Zarzuela, or as they say, Zarzuela. Not really, because if you're not fluent in Spanish, you're completely lost because it's closer to Broadway musical Taparetta with a lot of in-jokes. I think the perfect first opera is Verdi's Rigoletto. We know a lot of the music already. The story is very direct. It never fails to touch you. I still, after seeing it at least 150 times, am deeply moved because it's such a humane story. It's about crime and punishment. It's about father-daughter love and how the father makes bad choices wanting to protect his daughter, and it ends up with tragic circumstances all around.
49:16Sounds great. Rigoletto. Rigoletto. I was reading in your book about etiquette and faux pas and so on, and you can actually holler out bravo. What are the ins and outs of the bravo thing? Well, bravo simply means well done, but you want to really just use it if you believe that it's been well done. You can applaud. People want to applaud. I understand that. But if they're applauding in certain moments, it means they're not listening. And it's okay to wait until the end of an act of an opera and then lustily cheer. Don't applaud costumes. Don't applaud a dog that walks on the stage or a horse. But when the curtain comes down at the end of an act and certainly at the end of the opera, applaud all you want.
50:00And a lusty bravo is okay. In the right circumstance. and brava if it's a woman. Brava. Okay. Fred Plotkin, author of Opera 101, Complete Guide to Learning and Loving Opera. Thanks a lot. Thank you.
50:17Thank you.
50:36Travel with Rick Steves is produced at Rick Steves Europe in Edmonds, Washington by Tim Tatton, Kaz Merhal, and Donna Bardsley. Andrew Wakeling and Sherry Court upload the shows to our website. Our theme music was written and performed by Jerry Frank. You can find links to our guests and search the show archives at ricksteves.com slash radio. We'll see you next week with more Travel with Rick Steves. Rick Steves Classroom Europe is a fast, free, and fun video archive. It's designed for teachers, travelers, and students. It gives you immediate access to some 500 short video clips from the Rick Steves Europe TV show library.
51:14Clips cover European history, art, culture, food, and geography. Google Classroom Europe or visit ricksteves.com to watch clips and create your own playlist. Teachers love it. Students do, too. Thank you.
From the publisher
A writing duo shares the sights that have a place in our music history, from museums and festivals to lesser-known locales to make the heart sing. And opera expert and self-described "pleasure activist" Fred Plotkin shows us how to open our senses and plug into the excitement at some of his favorite opera venues in Europe.
For more information on Travel with Rick Steves - including episode descriptions, program archives and related details - visit www.ricksteves.com.