1. Podcasts
  2. Truth, Lies and Work
  3. 348. Does being authentic online mean sharing everything? PLUS! The reluctant founder, the Instagram snub and doom scrolling at work, with Alexis Zahner
Truth, Lies and Work

27 Oct 2026 · 53m · 14 chapters

Episode artwork

348. Does being authentic online mean sharing everything? PLUS! The reluctant founder, the Instagram snub and doom scrolling at work, with Alexis Zahner

In short

Social media’s impact on emotional well-being; Australia’s “algorithm switch” and under-16 restrictions; whether “authentic online” means sharing everything; workplace implications of authenticity, context collapse, and compassion vs productivity.

Guest background

Alexis Zahner is an Australian marketing, business psychology, and leadership development expert and author of Real: Reconnecting to Yourself in a World of Likes and Lies. She consults across industry and speaks on social media and identity.

Key claims

Gallup observational data suggests moderate social media use (30 min–2 hrs/day) correlates with slightly better emotional well-being, while heavy use (>2 hrs/day) correlates with more stress/loneliness; time spent isn’t the whole story—content matters. Authenticity online is inherently performative and contextual; “genuine pretending” becomes an engagement strategy, so online personas don’t need to mirror offline selves exactly. Algorithmic feeds learn what engages users, not what they like, potentially driving emotional/negative rabbit holes.

Notable examples

“I see only accounts I follow” switch (Australia); doom scrolling at work; “pebbling” via meme sharing; get-ready-with-me storytelling; employees absorbed by tragedies via news alerts.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:45

Is Social Media Making Us Miserable?

Discussion of social media's impact on mental health based on a new Gallup report.

“And in the workplace surgery, one listener asks, why does my employee treat every tragedy as more important than his work?”
4:25

The Complexity of Online Authenticity

Exploring whether true authenticity online requires sharing everything.

“And I feel like our future is in safe hands after spending it with about 2 ,000 kids last week.”
9:40

Navigating Social Media Use

Alexis discusses the balance of social media use and its emotional effects.

“Well, no, because we've got lots, lots more Alex's in a second.”
14:00

The Nuances of Social Media Usage

Explore the complexities of social media's impact on well-being and behavior.

“I just think it's a conversation that needs nuance.”
23:24

Authenticity in Online Presence

Discuss the authenticity of online personas and the dynamics of social media engagement.

“It's that time of the week where we take a popular workplace theory and ask if the research actually backs it up.”
28:00

The Impact of Social Media on Storytelling

Explore how social media alters storytelling techniques and language.

“We are starting to tell stories in a way that supports social media engagement.”
28:33

Generational Differences in Storytelling

Discuss generational variances in storytelling preferences and engagement.

“So, and it's kind of in this way, we're in this constant relationship with our environment, how we behave is influenced by that.”
30:28

Homogenization of Language and Taste

Analyze the trend of language and taste homogenization driven by algorithms.

“It is interesting, though, because I also see the other thing that's happening and kind of to your point, Al, it's sort of homogenizing our language.”
32:39

Authenticity vs. Online Persona

Debate the tension between authenticity and online personas in business.

“It was everywhere and everyone was reading it.”
38:13

Navigating Social Media Connections at Work

Examine the dynamics of social media connections in professional settings.

“I'm trying not to take it personally, but I can't help wondering what it means.”
Show all 14 chapters
40:19

Privacy and Boundaries in Social Media

Discuss the importance of privacy and personal boundaries on social media.

“Maybe that's the older millennial me just being like, just because I put it online doesn't mean you get to talk to me about it.”
42:00

Navigating Social Media Implications

Discussion on the implications of social media in professional settings.

“It does, you know, potentially implicate us.”
44:46

Managing Emotional Engagement at Work

How to handle employee emotional engagement with news and tragedies.

“I do think employers should make allowances for shocking events and I don't want to come across as callous but he seems to believe that following the story outranks the work and entitles him to special treatment.”
47:58

Finding Balance Between Work and News

Strategies for balancing work responsibilities with emotional engagement in news.

“I don't know what's happening now because this seemed a very strange decision, but they thought it was a good thing.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Truth, Lies and Work, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:02Coming up this week in work with the awesome Alexis Zahner.

0:06Leanne: Is social media making us miserable? We have all heard of course how damaging these platforms can be for our mental health but a new report from Gallup has caught my eye. It may suggest that we've been overreacting this entire time. I'll be sharing all the details very shortly. And also this week Australia wants to let you switch off your social media algorithm and only see the accounts you follow. So America is calling it censorship. Australia calls it choice. But will anyone actually flick that switch? And in truth or lie, does being authentic online mean sharing everything? Or is it about performing authentically rather than living it?

0:42I've read the research and I have a verdict. And in the workplace surgery, one listener asks, why does my employee treat every tragedy as more important than his work? They're trying to be compassionate but quickly lose their patience. We will get Alexis' view later in the show.

0:57Leanne: This is Street, Lies and Work, the award-winning podcast where behavioural science meets workplace culture, brought to you by the HubSpot Podcast Network, the audio destination for business professionals. My name's Al, I'm a business owner, and I'm here to ask the questions you might be afraid to. And my name is Leanne, I'm a charge of occupational psychologist, and I'm here to answer them. And together, with the help of our brilliant guest, tourist Alexis Zahner, we'll help you simplify the science of work and build amazing workplace cultures. We're going to be right back after a quick word from our sponsors.

1:22Thank you for giving us money, sponsors. We do like it. We like it a lot. If you have support tickets in your business, then this is going to sound frighteningly familiar. You open the queue on Monday morning, 200 tickets before even a first sip of coffee, and you already know what's in there. Password reset requests, order updates, the same questions over and over again. Hey, what if that part of the job just handled itself?

1:43Leanne: CupSpot customer agent resolves those repeat tickets using your actual CRM data and knowledge base so your team can focus on the conversations that actually need them. and your customers get answers faster. Check out HubSpot.com, the agentic customer platform for growing businesses.

2:04Welcome back. Welcome back.

2:06Leanne: Alexis, it's in the house. Have you got that noise? I think so, but I have to look it up. I don't know whether that actually comes out on the track. Right, people, I'm sure regular listeners know exactly who you are because you've been on. You've been on, yeah. You've been on more than I have. But if they haven't, Alexis, tell us who you are and what you do. My name is Alexis Zahner. For those who haven't met me before, I'm the author of the new book, Real, Reconnecting to Yourself in a World of Likes and Lies. I am all things marketing, business psychology, leadership development expert out here in sunny Australia.

2:45So my work spans consultancy across industry in those fields. And at the moment, I'm in the midst of a book tour, though. So it's all book related for me right now. What is a book tour? And also, here's a question. I heard an author who turned up to a book tour and there was one person there. Just one person in the audience.

3:05Leanne: You just grab people off the street, wouldn't you? You would. Please, I'll give you a tenner who just sits down. But then they also said that they did a little sort of talk, maybe 50 minute talk. Halfway through the talk, the one person got up and went to the toilet. At least they didn't leave. What do you do? Do you stop or do you just keep going? It was just so awkward. I'm hoping nothing like that happened to you. No, it didn't. But it was one of my biggest fears is what if no one's interested in the book and cares about what I have to say, because I feel the book's like very timely and very important right now.

3:35But I think that's every author's fear. Will people read it? The book took me three years to write. So I feel like I want people to also get the value from that effort that's gone into it. But thankfully, I had no one people shows, which was great. I had a few lectures and did a bunch of work with school kids and thankfully to quite full rooms, which was really lovely.

4:01Leanne: I'm not going to lie. I'd be the most terrifying thing to me would be speaking to a room full of teenagers. Yeah. Yeah. They're all these days, aren't they? It was pretty scary going into it because I don't do a lot of work with teenagers in that sort of environment. I mean, you know, I deal with them with my board writers club and things like that. So when they're having fun, but coming into their school and talking to them about social media, which they all have and all use prolifically, I was really worried about. But it went well. They're actually a super fun bunch. And I feel like our future is in safe hands after spending it with about 2 ,000 kids last week.

4:38Oh, that's nice. That's reassuring to you. Did you find out what they're using these days? Because obviously Facebook is for grandparents. parents, even me at 50 years old, I don't use Facebook. Then Twitter's like for nerds. Is it a Snapchat thing now? What do they use? I think they're using a mix. I think Snapchat's a big one. TikTok's a big one. They're using a lot of messaging and DMs now as well. So WhatsApp is on the rise with younger people, like group chats and things like that's pretty big. It's interesting because I think younger generations, and this is just anecdotal, I think they're doing a lot more scrolling, watching, viewing, lurking than they actually are posting.

5:16So they're doing a lot of kind of behind the scenes stuff on social media more so than kind of like, of course, they're posting every now and then, but they're consuming more than they're creating, I would say. So a lot of messaging apps as well.

5:27Leanne: Interesting, isn't it? It'll be, yeah, I wonder how that will evolve then if they're not posting. I can see TikTok going the same way as Instagram, though, quite quickly. Do you know what I mean? It'll be full of like the older people. like us yeah snapchat is a big one though the kids are loving their snaps although they're kind of using snaps in a messaging form they're taking photos and just writing messages back and forward to one another um so it's kind of just like real time you know like kids when i was there literally in their lunch break were taking a photo of like their shoes and just like writing a message on it back to their friends so it kind of feels just like a more arduous way to text i've never I've never been on the snap are you on the snap chat Al um I downloaded to try something out there was some kind of like marketing thing that I saw and I was like oh I wonder if that would work opened it spent about three minutes on there closed it did the same with TikTok I I downloaded TikTok and they said what's your date of birth what's what's your gender added all that in and then within genuinely within about six thumb scrolls I've just got pictures of girls with their boobs almost out and I'm like they've now to be fair I wasn't like you know it wasn't horrific but at the same time I'm like I they know that I am a a fat middle-aged white man who's probably going to enjoy this so there you go dude you can have it so then I just went no I'm not I'm done with this so I'm I don't go on TikTok I only go on Instagram Leanne Leanne sends occasionally to we've got a WhatsApp group for our house our new house and so Leanne occasionally sends stuff she's seen on Instagram she likes and I click on it to go to Instagram and oh god the number of times she says you need to update your app or then or it doesn't work or whatever I'm like that's the only time i ever go into instagram do you like it though lee don't you um i think i like it it's a good way to like like know what's happening back home because a lot of my friends in will use instagram or and it's actually really good for saying what's happening in in my store in her governor because there's lots like news channels i follow that will post in yeah in english or you can use a translate thing can't you so that's good but i mean i'm not i don't uh the thing do you know what bugs me about the instagram algorithm is that you just like if you just like Like if I send you one thing about a sync, I'm like, I think this is a really great sync.

7:31Leanne: My feed from like instantly is syncs. And it's like, I've just picked my sync. I don't want to see any more syncs. Whereas like the TickTube or the YouTube is a bit more mixed. Alexis, you probably know a lot more about this than we do. So is that like the biggest signal to the algorithm if you share it? Is that like a super like? Look, no one really knows the exact formula for the algorithm. and there's all the rumors that swirl around what creates the algorithm. But there are so many factors. What you like, what you share are big factors like what you engage in, but also what you linger on. So what you watch even without interacting with that content, if you pause on a video and make it the whole way through a 60-second video, that's a really big score, especially on Instagram.

8:15If you save things, if you, yeah, send things via DM. But no one, this is the thing, the algorithm constantly changes. And I've heard that they do that purposefully to keep content creators and things like that having to change the way they work as well, change the way ads work because they want to drive ad revenue as well. So there's no exact science I think that the public knows around it, but it's all of those things and most likely much more. I genuinely have a theory that they're listening to us sometimes as well because I've said things in my living room with friends and then got on my phone and there's like an ad for tickets to that band or do you know what I mean?

8:55Things like that. And you're like, wait, what? Like, I definitely didn't search that. So, yeah, we're tending towards conspiracy now, but yeah. There's also that idea, the Anne's taught me the psychological idea that you even, that if you, until you'd mentioned that band to your mates, you would have just scrolled straight past that advert and not noticed it. True, true. But because you said it now. It's the red car effect. Yeah.

9:24Leanne: Exactly. That's what I'm trying to say. Yes, yes, exactly. The red car effect. But anyway. I think it's a little bit of both, though. I think it's a little bit of both. Some things that are just too... It's too uncanny. Yeah. It's too uncanny. Yeah. Agreed. Anyway, we should probably get on with the show, shouldn't we? Do we need to? I'm having such a nice time. It's catching up. Well, no, because we've got lots, lots more Alex's in a second. Just before we do that news roundup time, Leanne, what do we normally say? Time for the news roundup. Time for the news roundup. What have you seen this week, my love?

9:54Leanne: smooth as butter uh well i did genuinely did see this and and i thought this is gonna be perfect to to chat about with alexis is social media really making us miserable i know i think maybe certain ones i don't know linkedin makes me miserable at the minute though anyway um gallup you know the gallup they do lots of reports and and the like they have a new one the 2026 state of the world's health no 2026 state of the world's emotional health report snappy title yes um and it looks at social media use and emotional well-being across 97 countries so some interesting findings in this the first was that people who use social media actually reported slightly better emotional well-being than people who don't surprising surprising alexis knew that i i thought it'd be the opposite i did i thought it'd be the opposite um it says that they're more likely to say that they enjoyed themselves laughed or smiled learned something interesting and felt treated with respect but before we kind of get carried away with that there are some differences because when the researchers account for things like age income education health and social support uh social media uses um it kind of that effect wasn't as strong but it does kind of challenge that idea that social media is necessarily bad for us because the researchers then looked at how much time people were spending online and they found that moderate users those are the people spending between 30 minutes and two hours a day on social media generally reported better well-being than people who barely used it at all but people spending more than two hours a day tend to report more stress loneliness anger sadness and worry than moderate users there are it seems some potential downsides associated with heavier use but it's not really a straightforward relationship the other interesting thing in the united states heavier social media use was associated with lower life satisfaction but in the uk and germany researchers found no significant difference in life satisfaction between moderate and heavy users and when they look specifically at younger people 74 the 97 countries they found that heavier social media use wasn't substantially associated with lower life satisfaction which is interesting when we consider almost 40 countries are now considering or introducing restrictions on young people's social media use.

12:19Leanne: I thought it was quite interesting. Obviously, there are kind of some caveats to this. Gallup has been very clear. It's observational research. It shows relationships between social media use and well-being. It can't establish cause and effect. But equally, interesting stuff's there. What do we think? I think the key thing here is that it's a nuanced challenge. And I think the key thing that we're seeing from that research is that time spent doesn't directly correlate to negative wellbeing outcomes. And I think this isn't necessarily new. We have, for those of us who sort of work in this and research these things, we know that social media is a complex relationship that we have.

12:58And there's a lot of other contextual factors that impact how we feel about our social media use and how we feel about ourselves and the world after our social media use. So there's, you know, what you're engaging with online, there's research around things like the volume of news headlines and negative content that people engage with impacting wellbeing and things like that. There's, you know, over-indexing in social media for all of your relationship needs versus having a balance offline. Like all of those kind of factors will play into our experience of social media. So I've always believed that social media can be a net positive in our lives, but it takes some individual discernment to kind of be aware of how it impacts us.

13:44And if we are overusing social media and we feel that because maybe we are getting more stressed or more anxious or feeling disconnected from people, sort of being able to individually calibrate on that. So I'm not surprised by this research. I think it's great research. I think anyone who's trying to sort of bang the drum one way or the other, Like, I don't love that. I just think it's a conversation that needs nuance. And we're in a brave new world where our young people are using technology a lot. So I think we need to look at how we use technology for the betterment of our lives. And this research goes a long way in helping us understand its relationship, you know, with time spent and well-being as well.

14:22So I think it's, yeah, it's a helpful report. It also shows us where we probably need to do more research as well. Yeah, and I think also, if you see the, it doesn't make the headlines that people are moderately more happy by using social, by using Facebook. It makes the headlines when, exactly when someone is like, oh my God, this happened and my life blew up because of this one post on Instagram. So I suppose that we are polarised a little bit in the news to see the bad stuff, rather than just that generally people seem to be pretty okay with it, Lee. Is that what we're getting?

14:52Leanne: Yeah, I think the thing that I guess kind of, I thought this story was interesting, but I think maybe where it was, maybe it's not particularly useful, as you were kind of alluding to, Alexis, is that it's just looking at time spent. Doesn't tell us much. Doesn't really, no, what are you spending your time doing? That's the interesting question, isn't it? Because I think, I mean, we've had so much on this recently, I'm thinking about Adolescence, the show that went massive, that was kind of looking at kind of the dark side and the incel and the manosphere and things like that. which is a frightening, frightening place.

15:24Leanne: I know myself when I get sucked into kind of doom scrolling because, you know, Donald Trump has said something else that's going to end the world and you just can't help it. Whereas when I find myself looking at, you know, going down a hole of dogs that are being sassy, then I enjoy that and I find it funny. Yeah. So it's more about what are you consuming, not how long you're consuming it for, right? Absolutely. And, you know, we tend to have the same sort of things in our household. Like when we're away from each other, my partner and I both work long hours and jobs where we're separated a lot.

15:56So we will send each other memes and funny things. And I do think there are little tidbits of connection that, you know, I heard someone call it pebbling once, which is apparently something that penguins do. They bring their loved ones little tiny pebbles. And I've heard someone describe meme sharing as pebbling. So when you're just like throwing little pebbles to the people you love via the internet. And so But again, like these are all little ways that social media has been incredible and helps us stay connected. You know, you all live away from family. So do I. So without this technology, you know, we would have been sending carrier pigeons.

16:29So I think there is it's so positive in so many ways. And yeah, again, it just comes down again to the context and the nuance. And I think we will have to be a bit braver about breaking the conversation down without wanting it to be so reductive and polarizing. And some of the things that social media has kind of taught us to expect is easy answers and simplicity and, you know, things being either black or white. And it's sort of interesting because we're wanting to have simple answers to things now as a result of that. Yeah, absolutely. We'll talk in the algorithm, something I saw this week. And you can tell me whether this is actually news or fake news.

17:02But I heard that in Australia, what they've started to do now, they've started to ban social media for under 16s, I think. Has that happened yet? Yeah, it has. it happened earlier this year. I think we might have been the first country in the world to do that. Obviously, teens can circumnavigate this. So what they implemented was a ban for under 16. So you needed age identification to access applications. It was a bit of a rollback. A lot of teenagers already had it. So it's been a challenge taking it back off them. But it appears that some of the early signs are that, you know, teens that are on their phones, especially less in the school zone that it seems to have improvements on their behavior.

17:47So, so far, early positive signs. Kids are getting off the social media more and it seems that it's working. Well, this is perfect because that was the first part of the report was explaining that. Yeah. The second part was something I'd never heard of, which is that now some of the, we're talking about TikTok, Instagram, Facebook, etc. Australia wants them to have a switch at the top, which says, I see only the accounts I follow, which basically turns off the algorithm.

18:14Leanne: Ooh, say more about that. So let me just read from the actual article. So it said, the government's argument is that social media platforms are built to keep us scrolling. There you go, exactly what you just said there. And that most of us never really choose what ends up in our feeds. The Prime Minister, Anthony Albanese, says the point isn't to give government control, it's to give people control back over what lands on their devices. And this law would require platforms to do more to protect under-18s from harmful content. So Alexis, this sounds like essentially I'm going to go onto Facebook and say, would you like to see the stuff that Facebook chooses or just the people I follow?

18:48Have I understood that right? Pretty much. I mean, we don't exactly know yet how it is going to roll out, but presumably that's what it will look like. It will restore some autonomy to the user because they will opt out of the algorithm feature. What's important to understand here, though, you can still choose to have algorithmic recommendations. So it's just a yes or no. You can have the algorithm on and you will get algorithmic recommendations based on all of those factors that the algorithm uses to determine what you engage with versus turning that off. Presumably, it'll be some form of chronological feed of the people that you choose to follow.

19:22But we don't quite know yet exactly how that's going to look. Well, the states, US, they're not particularly happy about this.

19:31Leanne: Oh, is that because maybe they own some of the largest social media platforms and want to push adverts and content that is going to stimulate? There may be a weak link. That Zook is fuming. Oh, Zook. Did you see, by the way, one of the best things I saw this week was that Zook went on, the guys who started Stripe, you know, the payment thing, they have this podcast, video podcast. I can't remember what it's called. He's Irish. And so they all sit down. They're drinking Guinness. I've seen it. They're drinking. Did you see it? And then Zook. I saw a caption. I saw a caption. And it was like, when you're 16 and you're trying to pretend around the adults that you like this beer for the first time, I was crying.

20:10It's so funny. Zook's in there and you see him take a swig and he kind of goes, oh, my God. Oh, he's having the worst time. He's such a, he's just, he's just a meme factory, isn't he? Just in real life. Anyway, the point of this story was, has been lost. It has been lost. I'm not going to search through to find it. essentially was saying, right, we've got the switch coming up. How many people are going to click it? Funnily enough, when they asked people on the street, not that many people. There was probably slightly more people who said, yes, I'd click it. But most people are like, I'm not bothered.

20:41I just keep carrying on. I mean, it's an interesting one because I do think the algorithm offers you exploration beyond your immediate geography as well. I think the challenge we have, though, with the algorithm, if we want to talk about things like misogynistic culture, the manosphere, echo chambers, and sort of political divisiveness is the algorithm really quickly learns not what you like, but what engages you. And then two are very, very different. And this is one of the key things I talk to young people about is the difference between the algorithm learning what engages you and using that to keep you there.

21:16Because oftentimes we find there was a study done by Upwork where they looked at 30 ,000 headlines that was posted to Instagram and overwhelmingly people clicked things with negative titles. So presumably that's not because we're having fun, it's because it's getting an emotional response. And so the algorithm learns these things and it's often how we can find ourselves down these, you know, sometimes dark rabbit holes, but there are radicalized parts of the internet that research is now showing is a result of algorithmic features. So I think there's a lot to be gained from this. I think there's also a lot of positive to be gained from the autonomy it will restore to people.

21:50But again, it's a first step, there's still a lot of work to do here because we can't then stop if people opting into the algorithm, how those algorithms work to serve them content as well. So there's still a lot of work to be done. No, it's interesting. Well, if you want to learn more about this, then you need to go and buy Alexa's book. Is it out now? Can you buy it now? It is. Yeah, it came out in the UK on the 12th, which is super exciting. Excellent. Excellent. Right. It was super exciting. We're going to have another ad break. Aren't you lucky listeners? And then after that, we've come back with the truth or lie.

22:17That's where we take a popular myth. And Alexis is going to bust it wide open for us. Hint, I think it might be about social media. See you in a second.

22:25Leanne: Quick announcement for all listeners. Yeah, I've got a new toy on my little deck thing so I can make my voice change. Anyway, sorry, Leanne. I love it. Do it again. Hello, Leanne. Do another one. But we didn't interrupt your podcast listening for this. We actually interrupted it to tell you about one of our new favourite podcasts. It's called Success Story. It is hosted by Scott D. Clary and it is brought to you by the HubSpot Podcast Network, the audio destination for business professionals. Success Story features question and answer sessions and conversations on sales, marketing, business, startups and entrepreneurship.

23:08Oh, and if you like this podcast, then I think you'll love Scott's episode back in December where the infamous Seth Godin talks about empowering employees. So go listen to success stories wherever you get your podcasts.

23:23Welcome back to Truth or Lie. It's that time of the week where we take a popular workplace theory and ask if the research actually backs it up. Now, have you ever been told that as a business owner or leader that you need to be more authentic online? I know I've heard this. They say that people buy from people. So show the person behind the company. Don't post from your company page, post from your personal page. and also show the hard parts as well as all the good bits.

23:47Leanne: But how much do your team and your customers need to know about you? If you're planning the post and choosing the photo, is that still authentic? So we are asking Alexis, truth or lie? Being authentic online means sharing everything. I think when it comes to what we share online, authenticity is always co-opted by performance by virtue of us showing up on these platforms. So I think contextually speaking, we always want to and inevitably will perform authenticity for the context and for the audience. So yeah, a lot of the research that I looked into for my book sort of went right back to early philosophy even and sociology around what identity means the masks we wear and how we're sort of essentially always and everywhere performing and there was some really fascinating research by Robert Ezra Park in his text race and culture this idea that we're always wearing a mask and then when we perform in that mask long enough it is who we become so I think authenticity has sort of become an engagement strategy when it's online.

25:03And I think now what we're doing is rather than being authentic, we're trying to short circuit authenticity by performing the cues of authenticity, things like transparency and rehearsed vulnerability. And it's a very strategic presentation to build trust because as we say, people buy from people. And these are sort of the things that we want to do to feel relatable to people. So I think for anyone using social media who's grappling with this idea of like, how much do I show up online? What does authenticity look like online? I think we can kind of circumnavigate that discussion and feel better about the fact that it is performative.

25:39And so we just need to show up authentically for whatever that context is that we're working within. There is a guy who built a company in public, a lot of people are building in public, and he shows all the good stuff and the bad stuff, and he does it all online. But I noticed with his second company he's building, he's not doing that anymore. So was that a trend maybe 10 years ago? Do you think he might have thought it was a bad idea? He literally was saying, this is how much money the company's made this month. This is how much is lost. This is our churn, et cetera, et cetera. Is that too much?

26:09Well, again, I think it's authenticity as an engagement strategy. I think what we've seen social media do is allow us to create in public. And although it looks like people are sharing every part of their journey, They're really not. But I do think the founder's journey is something that fascinates people. And the goal of social media is to engage an audience. So when we feel like we can relate to people, when we feel like there's sort of a slightly aspirational version of where we might like to be, that's really engaging and really attractive. And it creates a desire for us to want to know that story.

26:44So we come along for the journey. I think in terms of like content trends, I think the behind the scenes, the get ready with me, the come on the journey with me, are just ways that they're just new forms of storytelling. And human beings have always told stories. It's how we connect with one another. And I think this is just a new way that we're learning to tell stories through content, to connect with one another, provide that behind the scenes. But again, it's this idea that authenticity is a construct within social media as well. And people are learning what feels authentic and so we're kind of learning to perform authenticity in those ways so that we do draw people into us and our story.

27:22I do sit and watch Get Ready With Me videos.

27:25Leanne: Totally. I do. Yeah, it's so funny. Yeah. I watch a lot of like carpentry videos and the ones which I really like are the ones where they sort of foreshadow so you'll see they'll be like making a cupboard or something and then suddenly in editing they'll stop and zoom in on a particular bit and go we'll come to this later and and then you know that they've made a mistake and they basically fucked it up and so but that for me is like that's authentic because i go brilliant i'm now excited not excited to see something go wrong but it's going to be something i'm going to learn along the way that's a really clever way of being authentic without looking stupid i think it is interesting though because i i like to observe the trends in social media and how it's actually changing how we write and tell stories as well because i do think and I talk about this a lot in my book.

28:15We are starting to tell stories in a way that supports social media engagement. For example, anyone who's created content for more than five seconds knows how to create a hook at the beginning of the video, kind of build that tension and then circle back to a solution at the end. So I find myself now, the way I write, the way I speak to video is social specific. So you change the way you tell stories. So, and it's kind of in this way, we're in this constant relationship with our environment, how we behave is influenced by that. And then we're kind of projecting that back out into the ether. And it's also impacting how other people tell stories.

28:52And I was watching, and this is a rabbit hole, but I was watching a professor of etymology somewhere in the UK, I think, talk about the changes in language, like the words we use since the introduction of social media and now a layer on top of that, AI, and everyone's you know, talking about AI, but obviously M dashes are a big one that have blown up in recent years as well. But things like quietly is a word that apparently has increased. Yeah. So I, and again, it's like the red card that we were talking about earlier, when you, when you've been told that now I notice all of the places where people are saying, you know, I quietly did this or I quietly, whatever.

29:28And I think, oh, wow, I can, these, the language, like whether it's a chicken or the egg, like we're reading AI driven content. so we're using these words more or ai's giving us these words more it's you know what i mean it's a vicious cycle of kind of changing the way we interact with our environment as a result it's

29:45Leanne: so fascinating to me i do wonder as well whether it is because i know generational differences aren't really a thing only when we look at the research and things like that but i do wonder a point of tension that i've noticed is it like you were saying like since you're used to getting the hook so you kind of know the outcome before you hear the story yeah and you get the details so If I speak to my friends, I'll be like, oh, how was the date with that new fellow? And my friend will be like, it was awful. I'm like, tell me everything. But I know kind of the outcome. Whereas when I talk to my mum, I'll be like, how was your hospital appointment?

30:16Leanne: Well. And she'll go through a 20-minute story about how she couldn't find anywhere to park. And then she went in and the doctor actually was looking a bit worried. I'm like on the edge of my seat going, oh, my God, are you going to die? Or like, what, are you okay? And then she goes, and it turns out everything's absolutely fine. I'm like, mum, leave with that. lead with that there might just be all mothers yeah maybe but it might just well in work scenarios i'm thinking about the guy um who's he's kind of building our house for us who's quite old school and he'll tell a really long story to get to a point that isn't really much of a point at all and it's quite frustrating even in business environment you're like come on get to it so i do wonder if this kind of preference for for like you say the social side of storytelling is going to make us all a bit short-tempered with people yeah get to the point yeah Yeah.

31:00Yeah. It is interesting, though, because I also see the other thing that's happening and kind of to your point, Al, it's sort of homogenizing our language. Like there's no flair I see in a lot of writing anymore. And my writing style has always been either short, sharp sentences or ludicrously long winded ones with M dashes and 15 points in the same thing. So, you know, we're seeing like a homogenization of language, but also taste. I feel when we are so algorithmically recommended all the time, like I see every book club in Australia of millennial women reading Yesteryear or Fruit Fly this week, and there are no other books that anyone else is consuming because that is just what is being churned out in the algorithm constantly.

31:44So I do fear that these things get picked up by the algorithm. Great if you're one of those authors or shoe companies or pink collagen face mask that went viral that week. But I do think in a lot of ways, it's kind of then trimming away all of the randomness that we used to interact with previously and just saying, hey, well, you're a 35-year-old millennial, female, white, Australian, you live here, therefore, here's what your book club needs to read. Here's what shoes you need to buy. Here's what face mask, you know what I mean? it's kind of homogenizing our taste in that way and our language.

32:20And that for me is, yeah, I see it everywhere now. And so now I think if you're not careful, you do, like you say, you just read the same thing over and over again, the same books everyone else is reading. What was that one that everyone talked about is Crawdads or something.

32:34Leanne: Oh, Where the Crawdads Sing. Oh, I read that book years ago. Are they all picking it up now? It did get picked up for a while. Yeah, it was like everywhere. It was everywhere and everyone was reading it. And it's a decent book. Not a great film, I don't think. It's one of my favourite books. Yeah, yeah. Anyway, I digress. Right. We should probably go into my favourite time of the week, which is the World Famous Weekly Workplace Surgery Report questions. But today they're also going to Alexis. Alexis, we've got three questions here. I will read them out. And then I'm going to ask you for your opinions on them.

33:02So the first one is, everyone says to be the face of the business, but I don't think I want to. So this person says, I keep being told that people buy from people. So I should be posting as myself every week. a friend who runs a business thinks it's a distraction from the actual work. And I can see both sides, but every time I do post, the version of me online feels a bit like a character than the person my team deals with every day. So Alexis, what would your advice be for this person who just doesn't really feel comfortable? It sounds like being online. I think the first thing that we have to understand when we're posting online, and it comes back to this idea of authenticity.

33:38There was some brilliant research I dived into when I was writing the book by Professor Hans-Jörg Müller, who talks about genuine pretending. And I think what we all kind of can feel a little better about is when we create a bit of gentle detachment from our online personas having to be representative of the whole self. So I think we have this idea that we have to show up authentically everywhere, but when we're going online to present something, It's with a very intentional context. If you are trying to do something in thought leadership and face a brand, that requires a certain version of you.

34:16And it takes a little bit of practice to feel into what that contextual version of you looks like. So that would be my first point. I think we need to gently detach from the idea that online us is the same as offline us. It's a contextual adaptation of authenticity. So that would be my first point. The second point would be, I think, when you are creating content and facing, you know, whether it's, you know, on behalf of a brand or as a thought leader, I think we're sort of conflating visibility and personal exposure. And they're two very different things. I think when you are being a thought leader, I think you need to be really intentional about the kinds of things you want to say and why and focus more on the quality and your opinions and where you can add novelty and value to the conversation versus content for content's sake.

35:13Because I think we're seeing just a glut of content on the internet now and most people have no business creating content respectfully. We do not need more degrade opinions. What we need is more thoughtfulness or what we need is for you to digest these things and have an opinion of your own, you know, rather than just be on a bandwagon. So I think they're the two things I would call on anyone to consider. Yeah. How can you be rather than just visible, but how can you actually create like a semblance of novelty and uniqueness to your voice? And I think that will actually help you show up more authentically as well rather than just being a dancing monkey for an algorithm that you don't really want to participate in.

35:57Lee what are your thoughts?

35:58Leanne: I just I want to just stand and applaud relax it said not you have no business creating content or not all people have any business content I love it you're absolutely right can you mind just be able to say that on LinkedIn like dude you have no business creating content just stop yeah I think the thing that I would say is that to this this person there's a lot of pressure isn't there as a business owner to create content to sell your business or sell your service or your product so my question would be if you're if you're creating content why is it to push your your thought leadership is it to promote is it a branding play is it trying to sell a service or a product and whatever the answer that is will absolutely depend on the the content you're putting out there my bigger concern is an ox psych is you said that you're the person online feels like a character more like a character than the person my team deals with every day if that continues and there's this distance between how you present online and how you present in the team that's going to become a bit of an ick very very quickly and could absolutely start to to really impact the relationships you have with your team because of authenticity is one thing but if you if you're if you're so different in terms of personas that starts to erode at trust isn't it like well who's the real who's the real one and who can I really go to you know who am I going to get if I need to go and talk to my boss about something am I going to get the performative dude who's dancing around on on TikTok or you know being salty on LinkedIn or am I going to get somebody's actually going to listen to me so I think that's the bigger danger is is what are you trying to sell and how what impact is going to have on relationships with your your team because if it's just performative content creation for the sake of it and with Alexis you have no business doing that my friend and I just want to add to that, Lee, because it's such an important point.

37:39Like we want congruence in our leaders. We want to feel like we can trust who they're showing up as across domain. So if it is this caricature, if it is this full on algorithmic dancing monkey, I think you probably need to sit yourself down and think what it is, again, that you're trying to achieve there because we do, we will inevitably erode trust within our team as well. But it also probably is not sustainable for the brand. Like the idea of having to be this person all the time is just super unsustainable yeah yeah totally agree totally agree okay thank you very much for that as you probably listeners probably guessed that we have tried to choose questions that are skewed towards uh social at the moment i've got another one here um i i've already made my mind about this person and i'm so sorry go first then i'm so sorry no it says um i've connected with the whole team on instagram and everyone seems happy with it One person hasn't accepted my request.

38:37I'm trying not to take it personally, but I can't help wondering what it means. Do I leave it? Do I accept that some people don't want to connect? Do I ask them? I'm so sorry for the person who wrote this, but fucking grow up.

38:56Leanne: Mummy, he won't play with me. It's giving pick me vibes. You know, the idea that we pick me is like when we do things specifically to for others to choose us. I think for me, that's what it feels like here is that this person just wants to be like for them. It's important that everyone on their team likes them more than it is about having good relationships, because who gives a shit if someone is following you on social media or not? If that's super important to you, I would argue you probably want to recalibrate what quality relationships look like and whether or not this is an indicator of those relationships.

39:33I also think respectfully you need to consider the power dynamic because if you are a leader, your employees have every damn right to protect their privacy, their boundaries, or their preferences with their social media habits, which by the way has nothing to do with their work, presumably, unless they're, you know, I don't know, a social media marketing manager, but even so, there should be a personal boundary. And I just think you're just being problematic. Someone not wanting to follow you is so fine. And I think if you're really finding that a test of the relationship, I think it's probably alluding to the fact that there is disconnection in the relationship offline and you maybe need to go work on that and your trust and some of that relational equity offline.

40:16Because I don't think someone following you are not online is a true indicator of a quality of a relationship at all yeah totally agree and also lee with this person who seems like they want like like alexa said they want everyone to like them probably a people pleaser this sounds like that's gonna that's gonna actually affect the rest of

40:34Leanne: their work as well i mean if this is your biggest problem as a team leader either everything is going great or there's a lot there's things on fire that you don't know about yeah you know i mean and I think as well like I always like oh I'd always be like when somebody in my team followed me on on Instagram or yeah would probably you know befriend on Facebook back in the day because like oh god now I'm gonna have to slightly censor my content and you know because I'm it's not that I'm I'm doing anything wild at the weekend but equally I don't want to bring that conversation back into work do you know what I mean yeah like oh so you had a really big date night on Saturday night was at your anniversary and it's like yeah yeah it was but I don't necessarily want to start Monday morning.

41:11Leanne: It just feels intrusive at times. Maybe that's the older millennial me just being like, just because I put it online doesn't mean you get to talk to me about it. It's such an interesting point, though. And I researched this idea of context collapse in my book as well. I wrote a whole chapter on this, this idea that when we do have all of these different audiences folding into one on social media, maybe it's a potential date of an employer, your aunt Marg, whoever it might be, we then have to censor ourselves and filter ourselves for that mass audience. And there's a lot of emotional and mental labor that goes into moderating that as an individual.

41:48And it can also open us up if we do want to do things on the weekend that we don't maybe want everyone to see. And that's, you know, our social media is the place where maybe we want to share that with a close group of friends or however it is you want to use it. It does, you know, potentially implicate us. And we know that employers are checking things like social media profiles of potential employees in job recruitment processes now. So there are really real implications with social media. And so I think respectfully, I think this person has every right to say, no, thanks. Yeah, totally agree.

42:22Leanne: I guess it's different if it's like a company account and you want everyone to follow the company account because you want people to engage with it. That's a bit different, but it's not the case here, is it? No. And even then, if it's a company account, it might be that someone goes, that most people I'm like, yeah, I don't mind posting to the company account. But this other person goes, I just don't want to be anything to do with that. I hate social media. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah, absolutely. So fine. Yeah. It's such a contentious thing, though, isn't it? Yeah, it is. What were you going to say? I was about to say that Leanne was horrified because a little while ago, I gave her my phone for LinkedIn.

42:53I was proper Gen X. I'm like, how do I do this? I don't know how to do this. And she went, Al, you've got like 45 connection requests and over 100 unread messages. And I'm like, yeah. That's stressful. I don't. No, I don't want to look at it. I don't open LinkedIn. The only time I open LinkedIn is to look at when Leanne's posted. No, you started posting.

43:14Leanne: They're really good, actually. Well, anyway. They're really good. I just saw my ass with it. I'm like, I can't be bothered. Leanne gave me a right rollicking for it. It's like, you need to be accepting these couple of important people. They sometimes are important people. And do you know what? I'm the same. I'm not always very good at kind of looking back at, especially like DMs. Like if someone looks kind of legit, I'll kind of like press connect and then maybe not look at the DM. And do you remember when Yasmin Alec connected with us? We left him on Red for weeks. I don't know if you've heard of Yasmin Alec, Alexis, but he's a big cheese in Bosnia Heights Governor.

43:45Leanne: And on LinkedIn, he's got like 380 ,000 followers or something. He works like LinkedIn headquarters. He's from Bosnia, lives in Zenica, just in the north. And we left him. Like probably like anyone would lose their shit if they got the connection request from Yasmin Alec. Just ignored it because I didn't see him in my DMs. and when i found out i was like oh my god oh my god how do you recover from this and he's such a nice guy like he's yeah he's just the nicest guy we were in we're in saluevo and he went oh meet us for breakfast and him and his missus sat down chatted to us um and we're like hang on a minute you literally work like linkedin pay you a lot of money to go and talk at linkedin events you've got like and how he's up to maybe half a million uh followers i know when i tried when i first found him before he connected with us i was like oh i might see if i can book a time with him oh no it's like five thousand dollars for an hour or something with him and then we just literally had two hours we just sat and bought us breakfast anyway we go we digress so this person i'm sorry a bit of tough love for you but not everybody not everybody loves you get a great man this person doesn't like you that's that's why they've not they've not accepted that's not true all right so the last one is the last question is about someone who treats every tragedy as more important than his work i don't know where this is gonna go i didn't pre-read this i deliberately didn't so someone i supervise has news alerts on his phone and email and whenever there's a major tragedy becomes completely absorbed.

45:05I do think employers should make allowances for shocking events and I don't want to come across as callous but he seems to believe that following the story outranks the work and entitles him to special treatment. Oh Alexis, how do I stay compassionate without letting this become the norm so everybody can just skive off when something bad happens? This is such a tough one and Leah I'm looking forward to hearing what you have to say on this as well, because I think it is really tough when it comes to employees and the things that different people care about. And it's really hard to set sort of a system or a one size fits all expectation around that.

45:40But the thing that I can say from looking at the research around social media is that because we are fed so much of these very emotionally charged things all the time, geopolitical crises, wars, things like that, it can feel really hard to switch off from that. And if we have employees who are sort of engaging with these things all the time and having these reactions all the time, it does become really disruptive to our team environment, to their capacity to actually perform their job. But also, you know, we know there's that emotional contagion in the workplace as well. So I think the best way to perhaps navigate this would be to have, you know, just a conversation with the person to understand some of the things that are important to them.

46:30And again, it's really tough right now because I think we are all consuming so much doom and gloom so often in our phones. And so we kind of can just feel like this ambient stress. Like I don't even know what causes a lot of the time I care about anymore, but because they all just feel so overwhelming and there's just this permanence of hopelessness some days when we're spending too much time doing that. So I think trying to understand the things that are important to this person, demonstrating that we care about them and their wellbeing, but also I do think making it pretty clear that there needs to be some changes around when and how we're engaging with this kind of content at work and just the impact of that.

47:08Leanne: I agree. It's just not sustainable, is it for that individual either in in terms of how they're showing up at work and how it's going to impact their performance or indeed how how they're coping just with the general you know general world so I think I think you're right it's a conversation is it to to kind of understand what it is that this person is is concerned about at the minute and and I guess maybe framing it in a way that that kind of look it's it's starting to creep into work in a way that it's it's a little bit disruptive and I'm concerned that this continues it's going to distract from your performance and what a great job that you do maybe this is an opportunity for you to use work as a break to use work as an opportunity to switch it off and which is going to be good for good for you in terms of work it's going to be better for for us in terms of working as a team and not getting as distracted but also might be good for your well-being as well as just take a break from from the kind of heaviness of what is happening in the world and maybe frame it like that I think I think the difference is and I think and I've seen lots of people chatting about this and throwing shade at Gen Z especially because there's you know there's just nobody else is there until the Alphas join the workforce um is basically saying you know oh we'll just restrict it to to what it is that directly links to them so for example if if you're you know from Ukrainian background your mum and dad are Ukrainian and the the news breaks about the war then yes that person should be given time to to consume whatever kind of they need to understand what's going on but then on the other hand like people go yeah but the gen says they care about everything you know their second anti twice removed went to ukraine once so they want to sit and sit and watch it so i think it's really difficult to try and figure out like who can and can't engage in certain causes i think that's that's very shaky ground but i think if there is a very clear direct link for a member of staff with something that is happening then i think that's a different different star entirely and that needs to be treated very sensitively yeah and i think you can go too far because we had on episode 343 we had uh steve baker and paul dolan um and they were talking about disagreeing at work and one of those examples that steve came up with was base camp 37 signals um and they just banned any political or any talk that wasn't work on the work company chat and about a third of the workforce left so and weirdly because these guys i like i used to look up to them as like the amazing culture people.

49:33I don't know what's happening now because this seemed a very strange decision, but they thought it was a good thing. But I think we pointed out, I don't think it was. So you can go too far if you're not careful, can't you, Alexis? Yeah. And again, it's such a tough, like there's no one size fits all answer here. You know, I work in a writers festival environment. So talking about political challenges, elections, what's happening in the news is a big part of what we do. But again, I think that the problem is when we start to see employees who maybe don't have the discernment between when it's enough or when it's becoming disruptive.

50:14And so I think it's about setting the boundaries around what good work looks like in our workplace, how we as a group define some of those communication norms rather than these top-down blanket bans on sorts of things like that, especially, again, the group that I work with. Some of my colleagues have very different backgrounds for me, very different religious and political views on the world. And so it could become quite disruptive if we engage in those conversations every day in the workplace. So I think there's no one-size-fits-all. It's about knowing your team. It's about potentially coming together, setting some of those operating principles and norms around how we work together and how we do our best work together, I'm quite confident a lot of people will say that phones and world news is quite disruptive to their day.

51:01So I think if you can come together and make it more of like a conversation around how do we get the best from each other, I think naturally like putting phones away in certain spaces or maybe reducing our engagement with certain types of stuff could probably come out of that conversation. and then your employees are feeling like it's their decision versus you telling them what they need to be doing. Okay, thank you so much. If you have a question for us that you want to put to us or any of our future guest hosts, then check out the show notes, the way to get in touch. Lee, you normally do your subscribe thing, don't you?

51:35Leanne: Well, I think we need to let the people know where to find Alexis. Well, that's worth bringing back to. Oh, really? No. I forgot. Alexis, tell us where people can find out more about you, where they can buy the book, et cetera. Yeah, absolutely. The book, Real, is now released everywhere in the UK, so you can buy it on online, things like Amazon. But I'd much prefer you go into a local bookstore, have a chat with your human being, and order your copy there. Yeah, it's called Real, Reconnecting to Yourself in a World of Likes and Lies. If you do grab a copy, I'd love to hear from you. So you can find me on LinkedIn, at Alexis Zana, and Instagram as well alexis lane zana ironically i've written a book about social media and i am still using and engaging with and promoting the book on social media okay lovely thank you definitely go and do that check out the show notes for all the links lee anything to add um just the usual head over to linkedin if you want to keep the conversation going we're posting loads of clips on there now like subscribe follow whatever it is platform you're listening on if you can leave a review that'd be wonderful we really do appreciate all the feedback um and next week we've got another great episode for you yes we do yes we do we are joined by the awesome kate donovan kate is going to be talking to us about a really interesting topic it's looking at burnout but through the lens of being mismatched to your environment kate is one of the most brilliant people that that yeah she's just great second most brilliant person i said one of the most she's right yeah yeah no yeah come back for that brilliant right we'll see you soon bye bye say bye bye you

From the publisher

Welcome back to Truth, Lies & Work, the award-winning workplace podcast where behavioural science meets workplace culture.

This week, Al and Leanne are joined by guest host Alexis Zahner, author of Real: Reconnecting to Yourself in a World of Likes and Lies. We dive into the latest global research on social media and mental health, Australia’s push to let users switch off algorithms, and whether "being authentic" online is actually just performance art. Plus, we tackle three sticky scenarios in the Workplace Surgery.

Stories covered

Is social media really making us miserable?
Gallup’s 2026 State of the World’s Emotional Health Report examined social media use and emotional wellbeing across 97 countries, with surprising results. Moderate users (30 minutes to 2 hours per day) actually reported higher wellbeing than non-users, while heavier use (2+ hours) correlated with elevated stress, sadness, and loneliness. Alexis, Leanne, and Al break down why time spent is the wrong metric, the danger of doomscrolling, and why what you consume matters far more than screen time.

Australia wants to let you switch off the algorithm
Australia is proposing legislation to let users toggle off algorithmic recommendations entirely, reverting to a purely chronological feed of accounts they follow. Is this empowering digital autonomy, or is it government censorship as critics in the US claim? Alexis explores why platforms weaponise engagement to drive ad revenue and questions whether users will actually flick the switch.

Truth or Lie: Does being authentic online mean sharing everything?

Alexis busts the myth of total online authenticity. Drawing on sociological research and identity theory, Alexis explains why posting online is always a contextual performance. Treating authenticity as an engagement strategy often leads to manufactured vulnerability and curated transparency rather than true connection.

Workplace Surgery

This week, Alexis joins Al and Leanne to answer three workplace dilemmas:

1. The reluctant founder: "Everyone says I have to be the face of the business, but posting online feels like playing a fake character."

2. The Instagram snub: "An employee refused my social media follow request. Should I confront them?"

3. Doom scrolling at work: "My employee treats every world tragedy as more important than his job. How do I balance compassion with accountability?"

Connect with our guest, Alexis Zahner
Book: Real: Reconnecting to Yourself in a World of Likes and Lies — https://www.wiley.com/en-gb/shop/general-self-help/real-reconnecting-to-yourself-in-a-world-of-likes-and-lies-p-9781394445714

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/alexiszahner/

Connect with Al & Leanne
– LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/truthlieswork
– Al Elliott: https://www.linkedin.com/in/thisisalelliott
– Leanne Elliott: https://www.linkedin.com/in/meetleanne
– Email: [email protected]
– Book a call: https://savvycal.com/meetleanne/chat

Mental health support
UK & ROI — Samaritans Call 116 123 or visit https://www.samaritans.org
UK — Mind Call 0300 123 3393 or visit https://www.mind.org.uk
US — Suicide & Crisis Lifeline Call or text 988 or visit https://988lifeline.org
Australia — Lifeline Call 13 11 14 or visit https://www.lifeline.org.au
Global helplines
https://findahelpline.com

More from Truth, Lies and Work

All episodes