1. Podcasts
  2. TruthWorks
  3. $500M Search Founder: This is why Most Executive Hires Fail!
TruthWorks

13 Oct 2026 · 51m · 25 chapters

Episode artwork

$500M Search Founder: This is why Most Executive Hires Fail!

In short

Executive hiring failures in executive search; why most executive hires fail, and how True Search tries to fix the industry with truth, transparency, better data/tech, and compensation/meritocracy.

Guest

Brad Stadler, founder of TrueSearch (executive talent platform). Background: Started at Arthur Andersen as an auditor; moved into executive search at a Silicon Valley-focused firm working on searches for figures like John Doerr and Vinod Khosla; co-founded Iron Hill Partners (venture-backed portfolio company search, 2003–2008); later founded True Search in 2012 with Joe Regioni, Tim McDonald, Pat Haggerty, Peter Clark, Jeff Stump, and Josh Withers.

Key claims

The industry has ego and “black box” practices; success in past roles doesn’t predict success in a new role; unicorn profiles (e.g., CFO + AI wizard) are rare; transparent, monthly compensation and real-time candidate evaluation reduce bad hires.

Notable examples

partner told he’d never be a partner due to height; compensation “phone charger” controller with bonuses on paper; Brad’s Netflix experience where telling clients “don’t hire this person” was rewarded; CFO search where he rejected the “three-time CFO” box and hired an investor-leaning finance leader.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:00

Revenue Milestone and Industry Reflection

The discussion opens with a mention of hitting a revenue milestone and reflections on industry norms.

“We'll approach 500 million in revenue this year.”
1:21

Introducing the Guest: Brad Stadler

Hosts enthusiastically introduce their guest, Brad Stadler, and discuss his executive search firm.

“Welcome to another episode of TruthWorks.”
3:23

Brad's Journey into Executive Search

Brad shares his background, starting from his auditing career to founding an executive search firm.

“But Brad, welcome to the show, everyone.”
4:33

The Transition to Executive Search

Brad discusses his shift from auditing to executive search, exploring challenges and opportunities.

“How did you build my favorite executive search firm?”
6:01

Founding Iron Hill Partners

Brad recounts the founding of his first executive search firm and the lessons learned during that time.

“You know, I could do the work, but you know, I don't know.”
6:55

Lessons from Hydra

Brad reflects on his experience at Hydra and how it shaped his perspective on the executive search industry.

“And we have a common contact, this guy, Keith Kudusing, who I started my first firm with, who started at Anderson with me, who went over to, I think, Jeff Markowitz in this case, recruited him over to Howard Fisher.”
8:13

Founding True Search

Brad shares the inspiration and founding process of True Search, discussing its philosophy and goals.

“I don't know where this leads, but I went in the world, would I ever get exposure to any of these people?”
9:51

Challenges and Aspirations

Discussion on the challenges faced while building True Search and aspirations for the future.

“We had a Really, for us at the time, you know, we had a lot of success during that period.”
14:00

The Origin of the Name 'True'

Learn how the company name 'True' reflects a commitment to honesty in executive search.

“Now, you know, after a while, it just sat with us.”
14:55

Challenges in Executive Search

Explore the common issues faced in executive search and the importance of honesty with clients.

“No, but I want to focus there for a second because I think it is true.”
Show all 25 chapters
17:01

Industry Superficiality and Low Expectations

Discuss the superficial nature of the executive search industry and the need for higher standards.

“Yeah, I mean, I think think about where the industry came from.”
18:49

True's Approach to Building a Brand

Understand how True focuses on brand quality over individual recognition in executive search.

“When you think about like search, it's like, I got to do it.”
21:29

Compensation Structures in Executive Search

Learn about the compensation models in executive search and True's transparent approach.

“So if I said we had some grand scheme, we had some idea, we had no clue.”
22:49

The Importance of Transparency in Compensation

Discover why transparency in compensation builds trust and motivation among employees.

“And then you could get all the way up to 50.”
27:01

Improving the Executive Search Process

Explore how investing in technology and data can enhance the executive search experience.

“Like I think our job is to make people want to be here.”
28:00

Learning from Past Mistakes in Executive Search

Insights on the evolution of executive search practices and company culture.

“So my point with that is like we didn't just like, you know, jump out of college and realize that that compensation should be transparent.”
29:34

Investing in Talent Development

The importance of fostering talent and creating a meritocratic environment.

“Like Evan is so much better at search than I ever was that and I'm so proud of him.”
31:05

The Shift in Hiring Dynamics

How AI and changing expectations influence executive hiring today.

“I think AI is certainly changing things, not only how companies are thinking about their organizational design and structure, but also the capabilities of what makes someone great is changing.”
33:13

Navigating Client Expectations in Recruitment

The challenge of meeting client demands for ideal candidates amidst market realities.

“I mean, I don't think like, particularly with this podcast, I don't need to convince anybody, but having gone through many technology transformations, this is the biggest, right?”
36:19

The Role of Founders in Recruitment Success

Why founders must prioritize recruitment and be actively involved in the process.

“you know, how recruitable they are for that particular situation.”
38:09

Finding the Right Fit for Leadership Roles

Exploring the importance of assessing candidates for their potential fit rather than past success.

“We need, you know, and this person has to be a wizard and know how to transform our back office operations, right?”
42:00

Finding the Right Candidate for Success

Discover the importance of identifying a candidate's potential rather than their past successes.

“the trick is to find the person that's going to be successful in this role not the person that was successful before and that's not always the same person And I think everybody wants to simplify it.”
43:29

Listening to Your Gut in Hiring

Learn how intuition plays a crucial role in the hiring process despite structured assessments.

“Yes, there's like a sense of like covering your ass with the board and whoever else, right?”
45:50

Negotiation Insights During Hiring

Understand how candidates' reactions during negotiations reveal their true character and fit.

“And there may be some things where you're like, oh, I don't I don't like that.”
47:31

Embracing Change and Uncertainty

Explore the necessity of embracing change and uncertainty in leadership and hiring.

“And then I see like, you know, lots of leaders like trying to like, well, you know, maybe it's okay.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On TruthWorks, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00We'll approach 500 million in revenue this year. Crazy. We had no idea. How did this all happen? How did you build my favorite executive search firm? I learned at a small dysfunctional boutique, started my own dysfunctional boutique, and then saw a large global dysfunctional organization. There are several of our partners that early in their career were told by someone senior in executive search that you'll never be a partner in executive search. And one person was told that because he wasn't tall enough. There's a tremendous amount of ego in the industry. The trick is to find the person that's going to be successful in this role, not the person that was successful before.

0:45There's no opportunity in certainty.

0:52What would happen if we just told the truth? Welcome to TruthWorks, where we dig into the nitty-gritty of leadership and work. And what needs to change? I'm Jessica Neal. And I'm Patti McCord. Our journey together started in HR, but trust us, it's evolved into something wild, honest, and well, a bit rebellious. So throw out the handbook. We're here to redefine rules to work for us, not against us. Let's dive into another episode.

1:29Hello, everyone. Welcome to another episode of TruthWorks. I am your host, Jessica Neal, and I'm here with my co-host, Peter Clark. Hey, Pete. How are you?

1:40Brad Stadler: Hey, Jessica. How are you? Good? I'm good. I haven't seen you in a couple of weeks. Yeah. We're going to do this more often. All right. We should. We should. Well, that's because of your other co-hosts, you know. I know. I do have this other. I do. There's that other guy. There's that other guy, Jeff. But you guys are both so great. I can't choose. I can't choose who I love more. So I'm excited today. I don't know if you're excited. You seem super excited. I am super excited. Keith's very excited. Yeah, he's very excited. But we have a very special guest today. And I just, I have to say, like, I get to work with a lot of different firms when hiring.

2:22And there's varied experiences that one gets when you're working with search firms. And our guest today is the founder of, I will say, I don't know if other people are going to get mad that I say this, but my favorite search firm. And it's the, when anyone ever asks me if they're hiring an executive, which firm to use, this is the firm that I always suggest. And it is because the caliber of service and understanding of the business and the culture so quickly. and the fact that it is painless as it can be for a search because we all know hiring is so hard. So I don't know. I'm just excited that the founder is here.

3:10And I will also say that this firm, which is called True Search, has decided to sponsor the podcast as well. And so I'm super excited about that. And I'm not just saying they're my favorite because they're going to be a sponsor of the podcast. They really are my favorite. But Brad, welcome to the show, everyone. Brad Stadler, he's founder of TrueSearch. It's an executive talent platform. Brad, welcome to the show. Thank you, Jessica. Thank you, Pete. Good to see you again. Yeah. And you two have known each other for, I don't know how long. How long? A little while. A long time. I want to say like, well, it's got to be like 2009-ish or something like that.

3:54Brad Stadler: Well, yeah, I guess that's right. Yeah. Yeah. And then, yeah, because we knew each other, obviously, before Heydrick. And then that's sort of where we started working. We did, but did we work together? We didn't work together at Howard. No, but we should get into that, you know, the origin story of Brad, you know, the original. Yeah, let's talk about it. I think there's a bit of a shared experience. Yeah, and all three of us, I know, Pete, you were an engineer for a minute, but our careers all started in search. And Brad, you went on to find a firm, I think, before True, which got acquired by Heydrich.

4:30But, you know, take us back. Tell us the story. How did this all happen? How did you build my favorite executive search firm? Well, I'll do my best to try to explain it. Sometimes I look back and I try to figure out how it all happened. And thank you very much for the kind words, Jessica. So I started out of college as an auditor at Arthur Anderson. If anybody remembers Arthur Anderson. It got cobbled after Enron and is now part of like KPMG.

4:55Brad Stadler: Fred, you led the Enron account, right? I was not in a position to lead anything at that point, thankfully, and was not on the Enron account. So, you know, I didn't have a big plan, frankly. My father told me to take accounting undergrad because he thought I would get a job and that's what he did. And he planned on going to law school, actually. Like I was doing my LSATs and I was filling out my applications and And I only interviewed at one place because Arthur Anderson came on campus. They were the only firm that came to our campus. And, you know, just as I wasn't doing anything that day, I signed up for the interview.

5:31It's going to sound great. Well, that's typically what happens in college. You're like, yeah, OK. So and my college wasn't one in which like they recruited a lot of people out of for one of the big accounting firms. So there were two spots. and I had gotten one of them. So I don't, I'd gotten so excited. I actually couldn't believe they selected me. So my plan was to go do that for a couple of years, go back to law school. But I figured out very quickly that I wasn't a great auditor. I didn't really have a passion for it. You know, I could do the work, but you know, I don't know. I think people find themselves, it's interesting.

6:08You find yourselves at different spots in your career and you look around and you're like, I'm not going to be the best at this, whether it's, I don't have the skill for it, or I'm just not passionate about it the way these people are passionate about it. So I figured that out relatively quickly. In addition to that, through auditing, I had gotten experience to lawyers. And we had a group at Anderson that I was a part of that was focused on companies that were going to go public. So we had gone through doing the auditing process for these companies. And you have to go back several years. And it was pretty intense, but we dealt with lawyers a lot.

6:42And the other thing I figured out is, oh, my goodness, I don't want to be a lawyer. either. Like, I don't think I'll be very good at that. So again, like I hadn't interviewed anywhere. I hadn't really done anything about it or looked for another job. And we have a common contact, this guy, Keith Kudusing, who I started my first firm with, who started at Anderson with me, who went over to, I think, Jeff Markowitz in this case, recruited him over to Howard Fisher. And this was 1999. And I often joke that, you know, thank goodness he called, but, you know, know, Canon could have called and I would have probably went and be selling copiers right now or something.

7:21So you're that miserable. It was well, it was I was miserable, but I really didn't know what else to do with myself. Right. You know, the one thing about accounting is I wasn't having a lot of fun, but it was a, you know, within the accounting world, and this is all relative, the firm I was with was relatively, you know, respectable and people knew what I did. And my wife's family thought I had a real job and, you know, all that kind of stuff. So it was it was it was hard to think about going. And then when I went over to interview, it's the only place I interviewed. So I've been on two interviews my entire life, ironically.

7:51I mean, interviews before that, but for like not real jobs. But. And here you are advising people on how to do it. Exactly. So I went over there and I was like, at the time, Jeff had been there for a couple years, I think. And they had started doing all this work in the Silicon Valley. And they were working with all these people that I had no idea who they were, but they sounded incredibly interesting. So when I went and did research and they were doing searches with like John Doerr and Fanon Khosla and Andy Radcliffe and these people and I figured out who they were, I'm like, I don't know whether I'm going to like this.

8:22I don't know where this leads, but I went in the world, would I ever get exposure to any of these people? So that was it. That was like the basis of my decision. And, you know, they paid me just enough. Like it was exactly what I was, you know, kind of what I was making at Arthur Anderson. And it didn't take me long to understand that it was a better business than auditing. Like I knew the amount, I knew what we charged for an audit and I knew the amount of man hours that went into it. And then I saw what they were getting for executive searches and the type of work they were doing. And I just, it felt like there was a much, much more earning potential, which I had no idea existed.

9:00So I ended up there. and then really you know thankfully there were people like jeff markowitz there and he would he had moved to the silicon valley and was done a ton of work and he was gracious enough to bring me along and a number of others on projects and then after a few years i think it was three years you know no disrespect to to that particular business but it but it i recognized it was a lifestyle business for the the founder of the firm was also a black box in terms of how you were compensated. Now, it was much better than what I was used to in auditing. So I didn't have a ton to complain about, but I understood business enough to know that there were better economics that could exist in this model.

9:42And at a very young age, myself and this guy, Keith Dusing, and Joe Rigioni, who's my co-founder here, went off and started a small firm called Iron Hill Partners, again, doing executive search for venture-backed portfolio companies. We had a Really, for us at the time, you know, we had a lot of success during that period. So we went from, you know, three people who had never brought in business themselves. I think we, between the three of us, had brought in like one and a half searches at Howard Fitcher. And otherwise, we were just working and supporting other people. But we were kind of naive and confident enough to think we could do it.

10:15You know, I was also having, at that point, I had, I have five kids. So at that point, I had two. And I just it just felt like if I never if I didn't do anything at that point, I was going to be stuck forever, you know, because I wouldn't have the wherewithal to go do something. So we went and did Iron Hill. We did that for about 2003 to 2008. And it was a really good run. And we we learned a lot. We gained a lot of exposure in terms of penetration to other venture accounts. And I had at the time toward the end there started doing CEO search work, which is where I began to focus over time. But structurally, in the way we set up the company, it wasn't going to scale.

10:54And I could see that. Myself, Joe, and our third founder, we still get along very well. We're friends today. But we basically disagreed on almost every business decision possible. That's hard. So it was really hard. So I was pretty frustrated at that time. I was also at a point in my life where I was incredibly stubborn and I was probably hard to work with as well. I don't, I don't keep laughing because he might, he might remember that, I guess. I was, I was really, really stubborn and hard to work with and hard to argue with. Like I would get in my head, this is something I want to do. And, you know, I'd go in and I didn't care how long it took for me to convince everybody it was going to, it was going to happen.

11:35So anyway, Keith and I really kind of butted heads and Hydra came along and it was a pretty elegant way to unwind that business. And I also wanted to get exposure to, you know, and thinking going back to my auditing days, you had the top accounting firm as well. Then you had, you know, Hydra, Spencer and Corn Fairy and these firms. So I really did want to see what was going on inside that business. And it was really interesting, honestly. You know, there's a lot of great people at those firms, as you both know, and a lot of talented people. And it kind of opened my eyes to how big the world was.

12:11Not just, you know, my purview was entirely venture capital at that point. And then I realized all this other work they're doing and, you know, how they structured their contracts and what was possible in terms of where you could take this. And it also it pretty much opened my eyes that like venture capital. I still have a really we have a strong focus there. It's about 30 percent of our business today. But it did open my eyes to see that like there's a whole other world out there and possibility. And then the other thing we realized, I realized why we're there and Joe and I think everybody did, was despite the talent they had, there were, we felt, some systemic issues that didn't allow them to actually add as much value as they could to their clients.

12:55And the system that everybody was in did not really foster collaboration, didn't always foster what was best for clients. It didn't always foster like and didn't really foster any type of innovation. Right. You know, and so then in 2012, we started True. It was me, Joe Regioni, Tim McDonald, Pat Haggerty, Pete, Peter Clark. Founding team. Am I missing somebody? Josh Withers. Oh, my goodness. That would have been terrible. Josh Withers. So, and it was really interesting because for a long time, you know, we have, we have been close with Markowitz and Stump and Stump actually started in my star class at Anderson in Philadelphia together.

13:40So it was like me, this guy, Keith Ducing and Stump together. So we'd known each other for a really long time. So we started batting around doing a firm together. Those guys were, I think Stump was at Howard Fisher. Pete, you had already going to hydric right yeah this uh jeff was at hydric i'm wondering if i'm missing anybody i hope i'm not should come to hydric yeah i mean most of us were hydric yeah great so uh we had a lot of discussions around it in fact the the name true was not my you know not me not any of us actually jeff stump came up with that name yeah yeah i i thought it was i thought it was ridiculous when he brought it, by the way.

14:18Yeah, but now you love it? Now, you know, after a while, it just sat with us. I'm like, oh, it has to be true. I don't know what else it would be. Well, thank you, Jeff Stump. Yeah, and the idea behind it was we did realize that in executive search and working with clients, we just saw so much positioning and pretense and, you know, for lack of a better word, kind of blowing of smoke and things like that. I mean, I remember Stump using those words. And he said, what if you could just be honest with everybody? You know, what if you could just, I don't know. And that's aspirational, I think, because I think there still is some, you know, to be honest, some positioning and such, but hopefully less with us than anybody else.

14:58No, but I want to focus there for a second because I think it is true. And I didn't come from the world of executive search. I came from contingency, high-level tech talent, engineers, product managers, those kind of things. And before I landed at Netflix, Netflix was my client, and I was just disenfranchised with everyone. I was disenfranchised with the firm because they were a little ridiculous, but I was also just disenfranchised with the companies that I was working with. And they just approached everything from the wrong lens, right? And it was all about, you know, budget, filling it quickly.

15:43It was not about getting the right talent in the door. They would lose the wrong person for a few thousand dollars. We'd have to be back, you know, hiring the position three months later. And I was one of the only ones that was willing to tell my clients the truth. And I would tell them all the time, like, don't hire this person. You're going to pay me, but I'm going to have to give you the money back. Or, you know, we're going to have to refill the position. And I don't want to do that. Give me two more weeks. We'll find somebody better. And, you know, my firm was like, what are you doing? And I'm like, wait, I'm doing good business.

16:20This is what good business looks like. So, you know, I don't know. And ultimately, that ended up me landing at Netflix because they were the one and only client who really got it. They got that talent was the most important thing that mattered. They didn't care how we got it. They just wanted it. And so that was, I'd never seen something like that. And so that was super intriguing. And they asked me to come in and run recruiting for them. But why is it so bad? Right? And the same problems that we were dealing with then in the mid-2000s are still plaguing things now. Yeah, I mean, I think think about where the industry came from.

17:06I mean, there are several of our partners that I can think of and I won't tell you who they are that early in their career were told by someone senior in executive search that you'll never be a partner in executive search. And one person was told that because he wasn't tall enough. It's utterly ridiculous, right? Well, it was. Yes, it was not. You know, it was not an easy place to grow up. However, you really learned a lot about right and wrong. A hundred percent. Another one partner has a little bit of a tick. This person's exceptional, by the way, and was told early on because, you know, I guess this person is one of the few people that, you know, popped out of college and decided he wanted to do executive search from the get go.

17:50But he was told very early at another firm that you will never be a partner in executive search. You don't have the gravitas. You don't have whatever, whatever the hell that means. Right. You know, so, you know, if you think about where it came from, it was very superficial. Yeah. And I think, you know, that still exists today. Yeah.

18:11Brad Stadler: I think that there's zero barriers to entry in all honesty, right? It's sort of you can hang out a shingle and say you do this work and you can sell it. You can talk a good game. And, you know, ultimately, a lot of folks out there are just sort of, you know, running just ahead of the cliff that's crumbling behind them. Right. Because as long as they can win the search, kind of get a placement, I mean, the industry definitely has some folks who are taking advantage of it. I think a lot of that comes down to the companies and the folks that engage the search firms as well, having oddly low expectations.

18:47Brad Stadler: Right? Like, I mean, think better. Yeah, no, it's not like, you know. Have a higher standard. Yeah. When you think about like search, it's like, I got to do it. You know, I got to call one of the firms, you know. So, but, you know, that is not how I feel about True. And in fact, you know, one of my favorite people that I get to work with is a gentleman on your team named Evan. And I love Evan. And he's just brilliant and smart. And I get excited to talk to Evan. But having been, you know, on sort of both sides running searches, but also being a candidate, I would say you also do an exceptional job there.

19:25And there's many affirms who it's like, I don't know. It's just like, and not to say, this isn't tooting my own horn, but you get to a certain place in your career and you're like, I've had one of the bigger jobs that you can have. And you're not going to get back to me for three, four weeks. And, you know, and then you get back to me three, four weeks later and it and it's like you don't even recognize that that's a bad thing. You know what I mean? It's just like the whole experience just on both sides doesn't feel great. Well, there's a tremendous amount of what I was always always observed in the industry.

20:06And it's counter to what we wanted to do when we started True. There's a tremendous amount of ego in the industry. And I don't want to oversimplify, but I think it's because like, if we're all very honest with ourselves, like all of us that are in this industry, we've done better than like we ever imagined we would do in our careers. And I think that gets to some people and they start to kind of believe it. They're like, I'm doing so well financially. I must be brilliant. And, you know, and when we started True, you know, Joe and I at the time were probably the most senior along in our search career.

20:40And our objective was for people to forget about us. Like, I didn't want anyone to think of True and think of me. I wanted people to think of True and think of this incredibly high quality brand that delivered consistent value. And that's really different than how most executive search firms are built, you know, where it becomes a lot about the founder. It becomes a lot about, you know, the individual names as opposed to what the firm's doing as a whole. So I don't know why. I think it's maybe because we didn't like a lot of those people that we saw out there. Out there. And it's like, I don't want to be that.

21:16Like, that's not what I want to be. And, you know, so that was what the goal was from the beginning. And then when we started True, we decided that we were going to, we had no idea, by the way, we had no clue how, what the potential was. Like we'll do, you know, we'll approach 500 million in revenue this year. Crazy. We had no idea. So if I said we had some grand scheme, we had some idea, we had no clue. I want to ask you something. I want to know if it's changed because, you know, when we were growing up in search, as you were mentioning, Brad, we were sort of raised by wolves. right? It was like, I don't know how to explain it, but it was not for the faint of heart.

21:55And I got paid nothing. And I think I started at$19 ,000 a year. And I had to pay that back based off of my commissions. And I don't know if you all remember, but there was like a dot-com bust and none of us were placing anybody. And we were so far in the red. Thankfully, the firm wiped out all of the red and we got to kind of start fresh. But has compensation changed for search firms? Or is it still kind of the same? So I think, look, I think you have the big firms that have a certain, you know, and they're really similar in their respects. And it's kind of like a sliding scale where the more they build, the higher percentage they end up getting of that, right?

22:42So, you know, You know, at a place like when I was at Hydric, for instance, I think it really was if you build a million, it was like 25 percent or something like that. And then you could get all the way up to 50. But those were like six, seven million dollar billing numbers to get to that level. And there's some variation across the bigger firms, but they're in that realm. So if you look at most of the big firms in their P &L or PL, their comp expense for their producers are roughly about like 40, 41 percent of billings. You know, ours is like 55 percent, 54 percent. Yeah. So we were always and it's from the beginning, we we wanted it to be not a black box.

23:25So our people know exactly what they're getting paid based upon their production. And then we build a framework for how we want them to act internally and quality that just says, hey, if you don't meet this bar, you can't be here, regardless of your billings. But you're going to know exactly what you get paid. And that was really important to us. And I think the other thing we do, we don't really bill. Most firms build like most of the big firms, they give a base salary and then they get this big bonus in February, March timeframe or like a couple months after whatever the fiscal year is. And we, from the beginning, paid monthly.

24:01So people, we don't build this constraint, this financial cage around someone where it isn't really a good time to leave. And, you know, our thinking around that, I wish I'd say like we had a great plan, but this, that all, the genesis of that was when, you know, when we first started the firm, I was doing a lot of the production and I'm like, I want my money. Like, what do we do? Like, I want it now. Like, I'm not waiting a year for this, you know, type of thing. So but then when I realized as I was paying myself for my own production, I realized that it was incredibly motivating. Yeah. To to see the immediate impact of your production financially.

24:40So then we just kept it that way. And it's I think it becomes like incredibly motivating for people because they know exactly what they're going to get paid. And, you know, boutiques are all over the place. And I've looked at a lot of them because we've considered acquisitions, although we we've only done a couple and I really don't like acquisitions at all. Hard, painful. I can tell you how I can show you on paper that these things, you know, financially can make sense, but they're really hard to do. And and I don't like doing them. So we're not part of our strategy, especially from a culture perspective, culture perspective.

25:13It's just what you realize is you can fix whatever these people are unhappy with in terms of when they join. What you can't fix is the baggage they bring with them, like the last 15 years and the resentment they have with one another. And, you know, I don't know how to address that. You know, like, you're not happy with that. Lots of therapy, really. Yeah, like I can't go back and change the economics of the acquisition and who got what and that kind of stuff. So that's very difficult. So like, so we, we really believe in a very transparent compensation model. And to be, I don't know if we're the highest, there could be a, you know, there could be someone out there that's paying 60%.

25:53I don't know. But I think that the combination of our brand, the amount we invest back in the company and the compensation structure we have is best in class relative to what I've seen. And I think, you know, I made the transition out of search and into, but one of the things that I've learned about compensation over the years, not only just from search, but then designing and building it at Netflix, is when people understand how they're compensated, you win a lot of hearts and minds. And you guys know this. When you talk to employees about how their bonus is structured, like if you talk to somebody from Google, they're like, I don't know, there's like multipliers and this and that.

26:36I just know I get this amount every year, you know. But they don't know how it's decided. And so, you know, I think when compensation is transparent and people understand what they're going to be able to bring home, you win a lot of hearts and minds. And you're not in this like weird handcuff situation where you're, you know, you make people feel like they have to stay. Like if you want to leave, you should be able to leave and you should be able to get what you earned while you were there. A hundred percent. Like I think our job is to make people want to be here. Yeah. That's my job. And if they don't want to be here, I think they should be able to go and they shouldn't have really at least the financial element should not be what's keeping them here.

27:18It's really fun. I'll tell you, it's a really funny story because I'm getting a kick out of it as I think about it. But there's a firm we were all at and you guys can piece it together. I'm not going to name it again. But it was a complete black box in terms of bonuses. Right. So we there was a controller who was a great person. By the way, this is a time that we're going back to 19, whatever, the year 2000 or 2000. Anyway, you had to go get a phone charger from this person if you needed a phone charger. So anyway, we would send someone into his office because sometimes he, you know, at one point he had everyone's bonuses on a little piece of paper written down that him and the founder must have talked through.

27:53So we'd send people in there. Like one of us would go in and ask him for a phone charge and he'd be behind his desk trying to get it and trying to look at the, you know, what the bonuses was. So my point with that is like we didn't just like, you know, jump out of college and realize that that compensation should be transparent. It was beaten into us through, you know, mistakes we thought others made, mistakes we made ourselves, like structurally the way we started that our previous firm would never have scaled to this. I often like to say, as I started, I learned at a small dysfunctional boutique, started my own dysfunctional boutique, and then saw a large global dysfunctional organization.

28:36And then just kind of picked the things that we thought we could improve on throughout that. And the big things that we saw was we want to invest heavily in tech and data. So we invest a lot. We developed our own software solution. We have an entire data team. We're constantly thinking about how we can provide more tangible data to our clients to make better decisions, but also how can we make our people more efficient and more effective? And we believe heavily in that. We thought no one had that we saw at the time was investing in that area. And then the other part is people and the development of people.

29:09And we, you know, believe that like I didn't have a burning desire to start my own company at any point in my career. I had just for whatever reason, wherever I was, felt that I was held back to premature for some reason. Yeah. Whether it was tenure based or whatever. So we really wanted True to be one, a group of people that we that would collaborate and we enjoyed working with. But we also wanted to be a pure meritocracy. You bring up Evan Grossman. He is unbelievably talented. Like Evan is so much better at search than I ever was that and I'm so proud of him. And the guys he's you know, he's he's young.

29:45Fantastic. He's young, but he's fantastic. Fantastic. And he deserves everything in the world he has and has gotten and we've achieved. However, I do know that he would not exist in these other firms at this, you know, this quickly. Yeah. And he's just one example of that. But, you know, Pete, you know, a lot of the members of the team like there we have hundreds of them. that are like that. In fact, you know, about nine years ago, I stopped doing searches and decided, hey, the firm is big enough and I want to focus on running the firm. One of the reasons that led me to that is I had an associate that I was working with.

30:21I felt she was better than I was. I really did. I'm not. I mean, people say like that's like a humble thing and I'm trying to like, but I'm not. She was better at doing these searches than I was. The clients didn't recognize that because she was younger. Right. And you have the name. But I recognized it. Yeah. And I think that is, you know, that's like if I think about all the things like why we've gotten to where we are, we just develop people quicker than anybody else does. Like, yeah, that's probably the biggest thing. Well, it shows. It shows for sure. I want to switch a little bit to today, like what you're seeing in the world today.

31:00The three of us know how hard hiring is we've been doing it our entire careers. It continues to be hard. I think AI is certainly changing things, not only how companies are thinking about their organizational design and structure, but also the capabilities of what makes someone great is changing. And I happen to believe, especially with leaders and what's going to be expected of leaders in the next five to 10 years is different than what we've expected the last 10 years. Because we really hired for that expertise, that functional expertise, and you hired someone that could be a great leader of a large organization, a big operator.

31:46But that's less important than now someone that has exceptional judgment and creativity and innovation and can make great decisions in a world where there's an abundance of analysis and data and somebody who can operate, you know, outside of a frame, not just in the frame. Right. So what are you seeing becoming important, especially in executive search? And what are you seeing companies shifting from or shifting to? Yeah. Well, I think I don't think everyone's shifted to it yet. I know. But they really need to. Well, they need to, but they also have to take context into account. So right now, most companies will come and say they want everything.

32:33We want somebody who's been a three-time CFO and taken a company public or sold a company or done whatever. We also want that person to be like a wizard with AI and understand how his or her function is going to change dramatically. And the reality is that's a unicorn. Those two skill sets together. So, you know, one of our partners, it actually started with Evan, developed this kind of AI skill will matrix that we've been using on our searches. But basically what it does is say, okay, what type of skill do you have? How much do you understand AI? And then do you actually have the will to embrace the change that's going to take place?

33:13I mean, I don't think like, particularly with this podcast, I don't need to convince anybody, but having gone through many technology transformations, this is the biggest, right?

33:21Brad Stadler: Yeah. By far. And it's hitting companies from every direction. So, you know, you think about us, well, our clients are asking us for different things. Okay. That's difficult. The way we work needs to evolve because now we have tools to do things differently. And we're at a point in time where if we can, if we can do that quicker than anybody else, then we can take a considerable lead on the market. In addition, our own back office is under stress because we're not efficient. And, you know, we're, we scotch tape this thing together growing to this pace over the last, you know, 13 years. So it's, and then if you layer on the emotional overhang on everyone involved, where everybody's like, I don't know if my job exists, or I don't, I don't know that I can understand this stuff and be effective.

34:06It's really, really difficult right now. So our clients are asking us for kind of everything. We need to do a better job of communicating to them what's really available in the market. And you talk about like not just anecdotal data, like real data, like, okay, this is what the last 20 similarly situated companies have done in this hiring. So this is the CFO profile they hired, right? And here are the outcomes related to those businesses. Here is actually the available market to the best we know it today. Here are the people that we think have these skill sets. And what you're going to find over time is you're going to see, okay, there's like a very small number of people that have everything we're asking for.

34:49We can't get those people probably in most cases. Sometimes we can, but they might be retired. They might not have the will to go through this anymore. You know, there was a Forbes article where three CEOs were stepping down and they noted that they understood all the change that was going to take place or needed to take place in their business. They just didn't want to do it. Yeah. So they don't have the will. Right. It's fucking hard. They're tired. It's really hard. They're tired. They don't want to lay off 10 % over here and hire 10 % over there and try to communicate to a global organization why that's happening and why everybody shouldn't be scared.

35:29So, you know, it's you have to. So what we're trying to do is provide clients with a framework that gives them a realistic view of what's available in the market. What is more important to them? Hopefully they can take an honest look at their own company and try to figure out where they actually fall and what they need. because some people don't need that person that they're asking for, actually. Maybe they're a legacy software business that doesn't have their next move and they need to optimize the business, whatever that means in the next several years. Well, they don't need this unicorn. So, you know, there is more available people.

36:05So I think what we're really trying to do is kind of arm our clients with more data, actual data, not anecdotal stories or things like that, so that they can understand like what's actually going on the market, who's available and what, you know, how recruitable they are for that particular situation. Yeah. But it's difficult. I mean, you know, it's difficult because you're dealing with companies and clients and getting and they're getting advice from their investors. They're getting advice from other founders. They're listening to podcasts and they're getting all these wacky things in their minds.

36:39I think the other thing that becomes that's obvious and, you know, it's interesting because I just went through bringing on a CFO. So we did an executive search for our CFO at our company. So I was the client, I was working with our team. And there's a couple things that, you know, maybe become natural because I'm in this business. The other thing is like, you know, if you're not going to be the best recruiter in the company, you're not going to get the person you want. So, you know, you can't hand this off to one of, you know, you're the chief people officer and say, just bring me the finalist candidates.

37:09You can't put it on the executive search firm and say, this person isn't interested. Why'd you bring them to me? You know, you have to take responsibility for convincing the candidate that this is a great opportunity for them. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. No, I mean, okay, Pete, I know you preach that, right? I preach that. But I guess because it is so hard and it's, you have to put a lot of energy and effort into But if you are a founder of a firm and you are not making recruiting your top priority, I feel like that's a recipe for disaster. I also think you'll learn. One of the things that I learned when I was doing the CF with our team, I probably communicated exactly what I'm describing other people communicating.

38:06Oh, yeah, we need, you know. You need the unicorn. I've been at$500 million to a billion. We need, you know, and this person has to be a wizard and know how to transform our back office operations, right? And, but then as I started talking to candidates and interviewing them, I went completely the other way. I'm like, look, I do not need this three-time CFO. In fact, I don't want them in most cases. Like, that's not what I want. I have, I do fancy myself of having like, you know, somewhat of a financial wherewithal. So like, I don't need somebody to just give me numbers or make sure the numbers are good, although that's important.

38:39What I need them to do is to really drive business insights through the finance organization and help us with the future and inform us on how we should operate better and identify opportunities. So interestingly, I ended up hiring somebody that was an investor for years and then went into a CFO role in a highly funded venture-backed company that went sideways. But I loved it. I love that he had more of an investor view on our business. And then he had the combination of like being in a, you know, a situation where things were completely going sideways on him, but there were meaningful investors and there was a lot of money raised and all that kind of stuff.

39:20And this person happens to be pretty young, too. You know, it's second time in a CFO position. It's not an obvious choice, but I think it was, you know, me kind of diving into and really spending time with the candidates and realizing that, no, this is this is the person I wanted. I wanted somebody that I could really be a partner to me on thinking about the business as a whole, not just the finance organization. Yeah, creativity. Yeah, go ahead. Go.

39:47Brad Stadler: Well, we've had this discussion a few times in different podcasts, too, on just, yeah, recruiting is hard. We tend to make it harder than it has to be for some of the reasons you described, right? This sort of aspirational profile. I think a lot of that defaults to also people looking at it going, well, if I hire that person and it doesn't work out, I can't be blamed for the result, right? And like this, there's this general lack of, we don't reward creativity. You've got, I always struggle with this obviously day to day. And a lot of what I do is, you know, you work with these amazing entrepreneurs who have against all odds built this thing.

40:27Brad Stadler: Right. And no one could tell them they couldn't do it. And then they get into building an executive team and it's like, Oh, well, I should probably do what that company did because that was successful. You know, my investors won't question my decision-making if on paper, it looks like that. Like, I guess, yeah, maybe if there's a question in there somewhere is, you know, as you work with CEOs and founders, you know, how do you try to push that envelope for them, encourage them? I don't know. I mean, can you say advice on getting them to just think differently and be okay and comfortable making a decision that may not seem like a logical decision on paper?

41:07Brad Stadler: Yeah, it's really difficult. It's it's. You're exactly right. Like, I think it's intuitive to me that, you know, I need to make the decision and it needs to be something I'm comfortable with. But I think you're right. A lot of it is covering yourself in these situations. Like, and I think to the extent we can communicate, I think the best recruiters do a really good job and not just people at True, but just in the industry. They're really good at kind of marshalling when they have a candidate, marshalling everyone to really put a lot of energy and do the right things. but I think that there's a lot of work I mean to your point Pete there's a lot of work to be done to say like look and this is kind of what frustrated it was one I told you my associate I thought was better than me but secondly one of the things that frustrated me about doing recruiting and I was doing CEO searches for software companies at the time was I felt like we were just checking boxes and we were instead of the trick is to find the person that's going to be successful in this role not the person that was successful before and that's not always the same person And I think everybody wants to simplify it.

42:12And I think there's when you really look at the data and look at all the successful CEOs out there, there's a very small percentage of them that can be successful over and over and over again. And I would even question if that's self-fulfilling over time, because you got to remember, once somebody has a tremendous success, by definition, they're going to get the best opportunity. So there is a higher likelihood that that's going to be success. I could throw out names, but I don't want to diss anybody. But so it's really the question is like, who do we think is going to be successful in this situation?

42:46Not who, you know, checked boxes for us before. And that was one of the more frustrating things, just doing searches myself, that I was just like, I feel like this is kind of mind numbing a little bit. No, it is. And I, you know, because we've all been there. And I think, you know, the founders that ultimately end up getting it are the ones that, you know, they make the mistakes and then learn from them. I always like called it like you got to let them touch the stove. Like I can sit here and tell you why it's not going to work out. And I know how the movie ends. Here's how it ends. But, you know, they have to go through that themselves.

43:25But I also think that there's like, because search is so hard. Yes, there's like a sense of like covering your ass with the board and whoever else, right? You want to check all the boxes, but also like you've, you've, you've done the dinner, you've done the drinks, you've done all the interviews and like on paper, they do check all the boxes and you're getting down to like going down the aisle and getting married and And you're just not listening to your gut because you're not willing to really admit like, okay, well, yeah, we did invest all this time and we should walk away. Because you're like, on paper, it actually makes sense.

44:05Am I being ridiculous walking away from this? But I mean, I think not enough folks listen to that gut. A hundred percent. Yeah. And I think like they have to like, I always said that, like, I find I learn more about candidates through like when I'm working through something with them. And I think it's the same for CEOs and founders, like anyone that I'm trying to really recruit that I want at our company, whether it's a partner that we're trying to get here or whether it's a CFO or an executive or whatever, I'm texting them all the time. I'm like, I am, you know, like, oh, I've got an idea on this.

44:39I want to get your thoughts on this. I want to do like and, you know, people try to put like formality and structure. And I think they work like business plans and like, let's talk about what the first 90 days looks like and try to get a sense. But like what's more meaningful to me is like the off structure type of interactions. And, you know, just I have this as I was doing my CFO search. Oh, I have this issue. I'm going to call. I'm going to text this person, see what they think about it. And, you know, if I don't walk away from those conversations like genuinely excited or, you know, with some sort of insight, I'm not going to I'm moving away from the candidate.

45:14Which, good. Yeah, because I mean, you're simulating, in a sense, what it's going to be like to work together day to day, which is like the 90 day plan. Like, who cares? And now with chat GTP, they can pick one of those out really quick. But with the 90-day plan, I mean, yes, it gives you a little bit of an indicator. But if you can, like, try to create real work, like what it would be like to actually work with this person, how they actually think, how they respond to feedback, you know, all the things, then you get a much, much better sense of what it's going to be like. And there may be some things where you're like, oh, I don't I don't like that.

45:55Yeah. I mean, when when when we were and I'm sure you guys saw this when you guys were recruiting candidates. But when you're like from the search side working through an offer with a camp, that's when you really get to know. Totally. We were just talking about this on on the podcast with the former CEO of Redfin. And he was like, what what is that? Like when people are like obsessed with severance at the close, I'm like, it's not a good sign. you gotta walk away you know or just or just like how they actually how they actually ask for things is really important i mean these are like little things but like i'm i'm less tied into like what they're asking for as opposed to like how they're asking for it in fact sometimes i'm impressed i'm like i don't give any of that but like good for you strong case and i i enjoyed that conversation you know like so it's it's like how you know when you say no to something how do they react you know do they get angry do they not call you you know well how quickly do they get back to you you were talking about this with respect to you know your people in search but like you know i texted them they did it take a day like did it take six out i mean these are all things that are going on in my mind and i think they're like that's how you get to know people absolutely and all the you know we could go on and we have assessment capability and all that kind of stuff But I always thought that like working through live and not even simulations, real issues that you're going through at the time is the best way to get to know these people.

47:24It's the best way. And true colors always come out in the negotiations. Yeah. Always. Always. And then I see like, you know, lots of leaders like trying to like, well, you know, maybe it's okay. It's like, no, just got an abort mission. Yeah. You know, but a lot of companies don't. And they, you know, and it backfires. Well, the other thing is timing. Like if they, if you got it, we've all been in a situation. Oh, they have an offer. Do you hear back from? So like, even if they do get back to you, I mean, I think they're telling you what's going on by the way they're acting, regardless of what they're telling you.

47:59Like if they haven't come back in five days, they are, something else is more interesting to them. And if that doesn't come through, maybe they'll take this. But like, we all know it. We want to make believe happening. But like, it's, you have to read those signs. And if they're not super excited about it and we know this is their second choice, probably a good thing to walk away. Yeah, absolutely. Well, Brett, I am so glad you came on. We are running out of time. And I know you're very busy. So we're going to let you get back to your real life. But whenever we have a guest on the show, we always ask them to leave the listeners with something inspiring.

48:37So I'm going to put you on the spot a little bit and ask you to inspire us. Man, that is putting me on the spot. I think like, so what can I say?

48:46Brad Stadler: Okay. So I think like, I think the one thing that I've noticed in, you know, just in running this organization or building this organization is people don't like change. And I think it's very relevant to what's going on today. I think one of my strengths is I love change. I love change so much that like everybody has to like hold me back from things. So I'll walk in one day and say, oh, this great, you know, comp model everybody likes, we should change it. Like, can we just change it? You know, like, so like, I think you have to embrace change. And particularly in the type, in the environment we're in, you know, with uncertainty becomes opportunity.

49:23There's no opportunity in certainty. So, you know, the best advice I could give to anybody is be very uncomfortable with uncertainty. In fact, be uncomfortable with certainty. That makes sense. So the only thing that scares me about anybody is the person that's so certain about something. Like that's that they're the scariest people to me because I am literally not 100 percent certain about anything. So so anyway, I be comfortable with uncertainty. And if you lean into it, this is like the biggest opportunity of our lifetimes that we'll see right now. Yeah, it's fascinating what's happening in the world today.

50:03and certainly leaves me feeling very uncertain about literally everything. Right.

50:10Brad Stadler: Good. Yeah. There you go. So feel good about that. At least I'm someone you like. I don't want to be on your shit list. I am uncomfortable with certainty. All right. Yeah. Pete is very certain all the time. I don't know if you know that. 100%. Yeah. Well, that's my advice to people is, you know, act like you're 100 % certain, but you never are. But don't be. But don't be. Yeah. Well, Brad, thank you for coming on the show. And thank you for being willing to be a sponsor of the show. We are incredibly grateful. And if any of you have any searches, you need to run. You need to call True. Call True.

50:48And Evan and the whole team over there are just fantastic. So thank you for everything that you do and all of the great impact that you've had on not just companies in my portfolio and Pete's, but around the world. So thank you. Thank you guys so much. This was so much fun. Anytime, I'm more than happy to support you guys and participate anytime. Thanks for listening to TruthWorks.

From the publisher

Why do so many executive hires fail, and how do you spot a bad hire before you make the offer? Brad Stadler, co-founder of True Search, has spent 25 years in executive search placing CEOs, CFOs and leadership teams at venture-backed and growth companies, and in this episode he explains what is broken in executive recruiting and how founders, CEOs and boards should hire leaders today.

Brad started as an auditor at Arthur Andersen, went on only two job interviews in his life, and moved into executive search at Howard Fischer Associates and Heidrick & Struggles, where Netflix was one of his clients. He then co-founded True Search, an executive search firm and talent platform. Host Jessica Neal, former Chief Talent Officer at Netflix and an expert in culture and talent strategy, asks him how search firms really work, how True pays its people differently, why he stopped doing searches himself, and how AI is changing what makes a great executive.

WHAT YOU'LL LEARN

  • How an accountant who never planned it ended up in executive search
  • Why executive search felt superficial for so long, and what True set out to change
  • How compensation inside search firms really works, and why True made it transparent
  • What you can't fix when you hire someone: the baggage they bring
  • Why the "three-time CFO who took a company public" is often the wrong hire
  • How True uses data from the last 20 similar hires to set realistic expectations
  • Why founders who don't make recruiting their top priority lose
  • The signs in an offer process that say you should walk away
  • Why "there's no opportunity in certainty"

CHAPTERS
0:00 Trailer
0:42 Truth Works intro
1:30 Welcome and introduction
3:39 From Arthur Andersen auditor to executive search
6:54 Two interviews in a whole career
8:39 Leaving to build a firm
12:24 What was broken in executive search
14:19 Netflix: the client who got it
16:24 How superficial the industry was
20:19 Starting True Search
22:09 How compensation really works in search firms
24:14 The baggage new hires bring
26:24 Building True differently
29:39 Why he stopped doing searches
30:54 What makes a great executive is changing
33:14 Hiring with data, not anecdotes
36:54 Recruiting must be the founder's top priority
40:44 Hiring CEOs: beyond checking boxes
42:54 When to walk away from a candidate
48:24 There's no opportunity in certainty

ABOUT THE GUEST
Brad Stadler is co-founder of True Search, an executive search firm and talent platform working with venture-backed and growth companies. He previously worked at Heidrick & Struggles and Howard Fischer Associates, and began his career at Arthur Andersen.

ABOUT THE SHOW
Truth Works is hosted by Jessica Neal. Each episode is an honest conversation about why work is hard and how leaders can make it better.

#TruthWorks #ExecutiveSearch #Hiring #Leadership #Recruiting #Founders #Netflix #TalentStrategy

More from TruthWorks

All episodes