1. Podcasts
  2. Two Blocks from the White House
  3. The U.S. midterms are over. Now what?
Two Blocks from the White House

11 Nov 2026 · 31m · 14 chapters

Episode artwork

The U.S. midterms are over. Now what?

In short

Post–U.S. midterms analysis one week later, focusing on (1) how Republicans and Democrats are responding, (2) whether Democratic gains in the U.S. South signal a longer-term political shift, and (3) what the results could mean for Canada–U.S. trade/tariffs and investigations.

Guests/backgrounds

Paul Hunter, Katie Simpson, and Willie Lowry are CBC Washington correspondents based near the White House. Adrienne Arsenault is CBC News chief correspondent (segment host for a related intro). Katie also interviews newly elected U.S. Democrats on Capitol Hill.

Key claims

Trump accepted results but may still stoke unproven fraud claims; Democrats face an “affordability” audition and must avoid overretribution; Democratic momentum in the South may reflect demographic and candidate effects; Democrats may try to block/undo tariffs but Trump’s veto and supermajorities make it hard.

Notable examples

Trump’s reflecting-pool news conference; Georgia’s Akisha Lance Bottoms becoming governor; Texas governor race (Gina Hinojosa); trade/tariff buckets (steel/aluminum/auto 232s; 50% goods tariffs; alcohol/wine ban); potential tariff relief vs. looming 50% auto-sector threat; references to Roy Cooper, Annie Andrews, John Ossoff, and Mississippi’s Scott Colom.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:30

Post-Midterm Reactions

Discussion on the aftermath of the U.S. midterm elections.

“You never know where we're going to pop up from.”
3:20

Trump's Election Night Behavior

Analysis of Donald Trump's acceptance of election results and subsequent actions.

“On election night, President Donald Trump told The New York Times that he would accept the results.”
6:00

Implications for the Republican Party

Exploration of the changes within the Republican Party post-midterms.

“And we've learned this lesson countless times since 2015, 2016.”
8:00

Democrats' Strategy Moving Forward

Discussion on Democratic strategies and the mandate from the midterms.

“We had Trump saying that he would be willing to work with Democrats in the immediate aftermath of their midterms.”
11:00

Voter Sentiment and Expectations

Analyzing voter expectations and the necessity for Democrats to deliver results.

“Here are the things we're willing to do.”
14:00

Public Sentiment Post-Midterms

Discussion on what voters expect from politicians following the midterms.

“And it's like they want something that works for them.”
15:00

Shifts in Southern Politics

Exploring the political landscape in the Southern U.S. post-midterms.

“I mean, I think you're absolutely right, Paul.”
17:00

Impact of Candidates in the South

Analysis of candidate quality and its influence on election outcomes in Southern states.

“Here are the electoral college votes in these states, 40 in Texas, 16 in Georgia.”
20:17

Examining Canada-U.S. Relations

Discussion on the potential changes in Canada-U.S. relations following the midterms.

“Katie, as our resident trade expert, I know you've been thinking just a little bit.”
24:40

The Future of Tariffs and Trade

Insights on the future of tariffs and the potential for trade negotiations.

“It would require two thirds of the Senate, two thirds of the House.”
Show all 14 chapters
28:00

Canada-U.S. Relations Post-Midterms

Discussion on the implications of the midterms for Canada-U.S. relations and tariff issues.

“The thing is, heading into the midterms, there was a flurry of sort of increased conversation leading into the midterms.”
28:58

Trump's Unpredictability and Its Impact

Exploring the uncertainty of Trump's actions following the midterms and their potential consequences.

“I hate to say this to you, Katie, because, you know, we you already went through it this summer when you tried to take vacation.”
30:19

Trade Talks and Future Implications

Analyzing the future of Canada-U.S. trade talks in light of Trump's potential decisions.

“I mean, I hesitate to say it sounds like hyperbole, but with Trump, you just don't know.”
31:15

Engaging with Listeners

Encouraging audience engagement and feedback about the episode's topics.

“If after listening to this episode, you still have questions about what could come next in American politics, we'd be very happy to hear from you.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Two Blocks from the White House, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:01Willy Lowry: Hi there, Steve Patterson here, host of The Debaters, the show where Canada's funniest comedians compete for your laughter. It's part stand-up, part quiz, part comedy competition, so three equal parts. This week we're in Alberta asking, is line dancing fun for everyone? We have two comics who aren't afraid to step it up. So listen to these two cowpokes go toe-to-toe on this week's new episode of The Debaters,

0:23Katie Simpson: wherever you get your podcasts turn, twist, three, four. This is a CBC Podcast. Paul, Katie, hello. Hello. Welcome back to... Where are we? We're... What? We're in D.C., right?

0:43Paul Hunter: You never know, honestly.

0:44Katie Simpson: You never know where we're going to pop up from. It's been a whirlwind. Have you guys come down from the adrenaline yet?

0:52Willy Lowry: Yeah, I slept zero hours that night. And so, yeah, I'm still jacked, man.

0:57Paul Hunter: I'm definitely in a sleep deficit, but I'm going to work on that. I am definitely going to try and like, but like I'm already living on the edge up here anyway. Like that's me on a normal state and then throw in an election. It's like it's a lot. I'm already a lot to begin with.

1:11Katie Simpson: It's our favorite Katie. It's the only version you're going to get. Well, there is obviously still a lot and that is all capitals. A lot to cover just one week later. And today we want to follow three post-midterm stories that we kind of want to keep our eyes on.

1:28Willy Lowry: And I'm just going to say, I like how we're rocking the poppies. You know, it's funny. You know, when I walk into work today, you realize poppies aren't a thing or you're reminded that poppies aren't a thing in this country.

1:38Paul Hunter: And you get pointed out as a Canadian. I was up on Capitol Hill yesterday and they were like, you're from Canada. Exactly.

1:43Katie Simpson: I think it's a wonderful tradition and not to dismiss it, but it really, it pops. You know, the poppy pops. I like how you put that, really. I love it, though.

1:53Willy Lowry: It is a very distinct, distinctive and distinguished look. Very Canadian. But speaking of things not Canadian, sort of. I mean, yeah, post midterms. I mean, I can't get enough of what happened in the U.S. South in particular. And so I'd kind of like to talk about the history of party politics in the southern states. And by southern, I mean the southeast, I guess, Texas and points east and basically Washington, D.C. and points south, South, as well as what some unexpected Democratic victories might say about the future of those once and longtime Republican strongholds.

2:28Paul Hunter: And no one's going to be surprised to hear this, but I'm super interested in what the change in power is going to mean for the U.S. trade war with Canada and tariffs. Shocker. Yeah, exactly.

2:37Katie Simpson: I did not see that coming. I know.

2:38Paul Hunter: But that also includes like the significant shakeup at the White House with Susie Wiles, the chief of staff, being out and Stephen Miller being put in and what that means for everything related to Canada.

2:47Katie Simpson: And I'd like to take a closer look at the two parties and kind of which version of each party we might get in the coming weeks and months and I guess years. So this week we're asking what are the biggest questions coming out of these midterms one week later? I'm Paul Hunter. I'm Katie Simpson. And I'm Willie Lowry. We're CBC's Washington Correspondence, two blocks from the White House.

3:19Katie Simpson: OK, I want to start by getting both of your thoughts on how the two parties have been reacting to the election results. Let's talk about Republicans first. On election night, President Donald Trump told The New York Times that he would accept the results. He was fairly quiet in the days after. Now, just on Monday of this week, he posted on social media with vague accusations about voting machines and possible unfairness. unfairness. What do we make of all of this?

3:48Paul Hunter: I was surprised to see that Donald Trump did come out and accept the results. However, I think to borrow from some of his language, when he, you know, stokes election fraud claims that have not been proven, he talks about, you know, we need Republicans to turn out because it needs to be too big to rig. Exactly. And Donald Trump, I think Donald Trump sort of gave us a roadmap to how he was going to behave this go around. I'll never forget. I think this is going to stand out as one of the most remarkable news conferences of Donald Trump's time in power. And I don't say that lightly because I know I know not the beam.

4:25Paul Hunter: I'm talking about before the reflecting pool, reflecting pool. I was watching that. Yeah. Paul gets a point. And you lose two points. Two points. Watching that. So I'm in my hotel in Texas, in Austin, because I was doing like the main file for Your World Tonight and The National. And I'm watching this news conference. And Donald Trump, he's got he walks out to the reflecting pool and he's got those big posters done up and he's got staff ready to go with props. And when he's giving this is supposed to be his speech to give his final message to voters, the final sort of Republican fight to vote for Republicans.

5:01Paul Hunter: Yeah, to hold on to the furniture and try to stave off an emergency. And he spends more than 20 minutes off the top talking largely about renovations, building the reflecting pool, repeating false claims about vandals damaging it, all those kinds of things. And then he added the line in there. If that was not remarkable enough, he's, you know, he acknowledged out loud that this is probably not going to go his way, saying, you know, presidents who are in power, their party generally doesn't win, but we gave it a shot. But when I heard that, that stood out to me as such a stark thing from Donald Trump because he views politics as a zero sum game.

5:38Paul Hunter: You win or you lose. And Donald Trump appeared ready to accept the fact that his party was going to lose. And then so he indicated that's the way it was going to go. But you never know with him whether he's going to try and stoke fraud fears with without evidence to back it up. And he didn't really.

5:53Willy Lowry: Exactly. And and I mean, I think you said at the end there, like you never know. And that's the truth with Donald Trump. And we've learned this lesson countless times since 2015, 2016. It's like to get inside Donald Trump's mind is impossible. I think. And yet we still try. And yet we try. We still try. Here's me trying. We don't know. Right. I mean, I think part of what's in play for Donald Trump right now is ego. And that's why when he said those words that he accepted the results and stuff, I thought, what? Like, when does Donald Trump ever say anything like that? Because that's tacitly acknowledging a loss.

6:28Willy Lowry: But when he spun it to say, well, it's almost like he's spinning it to the party. Like they lost. If his name had been on the ballot, they would have won all this. So that allow, in my estimation, that allows Donald Trump, here's me inside Donald Trump's mind, that allows me, Donald Trump, to not blame myself and to not have the blame fall on me. And I also think – I agree with you, Katie, that it's too big to rig. And we talked about this before. They were pretty inconclusive. This is not – he's still the president.

6:56Paul Hunter: Yeah.

6:56Willy Lowry: Right? And so that allows him to think that. It is too big to rig. The wave was too strong, too all over the place. It'll be a lot harder to challenge this one, I think, in many places. And as well, because he's still the president, you have a much less likelihood of anything like January 6th happening again because that was all about Trump. And this isn't about Trump, even though it kind of is.

7:21Katie Simpson: That's a really good point. And, you know, outside of a few races, one of which is still yet to be called, you know, they really weren't close. Right. So there's. Massive turnarounds. Yeah. Look what happened in Texas.

7:36Paul Hunter: James Tallarico. I also think that even though we're going to talk at a federal level, I think that the way the blue wave extended to governors and states. Yeah, very much.

7:45Willy Lowry: That's not talked about enough. I know. That affects everything going forward for Donald Trump. It makes it a lot more complicated to challenge back to whether he will challenge these things. It makes it a lot more complicated.

7:55Katie Simpson: Which kind of strikes at what I'm really – I'm interested in. It's like which Donald Trump, which Republican Party are we going to see going forward? We had Trump saying that he would be willing to work with Democrats in the immediate aftermath of their midterms. And yet then we see him sort of leaning into the most MAGA hard line instincts with Susie Wiles, former chief of staff, now out. And Stephen Miller, the architect of the president's immigration agenda, which he acknowledges was probably over the top and hurt the party in the midterms. We actually speculated on the podcast just a few weeks ago that Wiles.

8:46Katie Simpson: Speculate. That's not what we do. We prognosticate. We provided analysis, in-depth analysis. But what do you think the message that Trump, the White House is sending with Stephen Miller as the next person in charge there?

9:04Willy Lowry: I think the short answer is having said what we said about whether or not he would challenge results and things like that and whether that's complicated given the size of the wave for Democrats. I think at the same time, on a parallel track, this is Trump giving the finger. And it's evidence Trump wasn't really listening or didn't care what voters, how voters voted. It was a clear repudiation of the Trump White House. And here he is going after the most hardline guy, the architect of so much of what we've seen from Donald Trump last couple of years and saying, hey, you're my main person. So it's here I am.

9:38Willy Lowry: Brought the finger up, but it's giving the middle finger to the electorate, if you ask me.

9:43Paul Hunter: It's very much Donald Trump doesn't want to be reined in. And any sort of message, as Paul said, any sort of message from the American voter, Donald Trump wants to double down. He wants to. Not going quietly. Yeah, he wants to. He wants to fight.

9:56Katie Simpson: One of my favorite quotes from Abraham Lincoln is from his first inaugural address where he talks about. Here we go. He talks about, you know, the better angels of our nature. And I feel like both parties are at this moment where they can lean into the better angels of their nature or not. It seems like Trump is perhaps choosing not to. And the Democrats kind of up in the air. It's too soon to tell which way they're going to go. So obviously they have a pretty big mandate. They won on an affordability mandate and yet they also have the ability to pursue investigations, to pursue potentially an impeachment of President Trump.

10:41Katie Simpson: A recent poll from Reuters suggests it's not actually what the American people want them to do right now. But I mean what do you think that the Democrats need to do going forward or will do?

10:53Paul Hunter: So the thing is, the next two years are basically going to be an audition, an opportunity for the Democrats to audition for the American public to say, if you if you vote for us in the next presidential election, here are the things and you support us in Congress as well. Here are the things we're willing to do. And so what messages did the the American public send? Well, they said that life needs to be more affordable. So what kinds of things are they going to do related to that? They're angry about the immigration policies. Are there any things that can the Democrats find a way to work with President Trump to possibly scale back the way that Donald Trump has carried out his immigration agenda?

11:28Paul Hunter: Those kinds of things. But I also think that because the blue tsunami, as we've been calling it, because the Democrats, their control of Congress is so overwhelming with, you know, the House, how many seats they got in the House. And it's comfortable in the Senate as well. That means there's room for dissent.

11:45Katie Simpson: Shockingly comfortable.

11:47Paul Hunter: Well, exactly. But it means there's room for dissent within the party, right? It means that you can have some of the more hardline Democratic socialist candidates who want to move things very progressively to the left that might make some centrist voters uncomfortable. There can be dissent there. And then there can be dissent among the Democrats that are more conservative and aren't necessarily going to get on board with whatever the progressives really want. So I think it's going to be incredibly interesting to see what they can get through Congress. However, at the same time, you're going to have Donald Trump with his veto power.

12:23Paul Hunter: But the thing about the Democrats in this moment is I look at the next two years as an audition time, an audition space.

12:30Willy Lowry: Agreed. They've got to demonstrate the chance to demonstrate what they would do if they ran everything. And they have to be aware of what, again, what the electorate was signaling in the vote on the midterms. I think the choice they have to make is do we – how far do we – do they go down the retribution path? And that speaks to should Donald – should impeachment proceedings against Donald Trump be brought in? We've already seen on the Pete Hegseth side of things, right?

13:00Katie Simpson: To be fair, that wasn't them. No. Well, good point.

13:04Willy Lowry: That's right. That's right. Very good point, Thomas Massey, Republican. But I will say, I think it was Chuck Schumer who said it's possible to walk and chew gum at the same time on this issue. You can do both. You can pursue. And the intent seems to be that every signal has been that there will be investigation, investigation, investigation. But at the same time, affordability and how do Democrats propose dealing with the biggest issue driving voters besides the anti-Trump vote, which is affordability? Yeah.

13:32Katie Simpson: I mean, I just thought you had Robert Garcia, you know, issue that two word statement right after the midterm saying lawyer up. Lawyer up. I think there was probably a lot of eye rolling among Republicans and some Democrats and seeing that.

13:47Paul Hunter: But or perhaps a little bit of fear because the investigations are coming. The congressional investigation, they are coming.

13:52Willy Lowry: Good point. They absolutely are. But if I can jump in, I think one of the messages from voters in these midterms, and you could pick and choose recent other elections in this country, is that people are tired of politics as usual. And it's like they want something that works for them. Right. Like get rid of all that stuff is just noise. And it's a waste of time. And, yeah, you want to go after people and you want to have, you know, we want to see people pay prices for things that have gone awry. Right. But I think people are saying, I just want a place that works for us. Exactly. That that where I can afford the food on my table and the roof over my head and all that kind of stuff.

14:32Willy Lowry: And I think if the risk for Democrats, if they if they go too far from that is they'll pay a price next time because people are fed up. Why do you think young people turned out this time more than they have? Why do you think Latinos turned? Why do you think black Americans turned out against Trump? Because like, I don't want that stuff. I gave you a chance last time. Don't want it. I want these guys. And if these guys, meaning Democrats now, don't live up to something different, something that works for everybody, then the pendulum will swing the other way again.

15:00Katie Simpson: No, no. I mean, I think you're absolutely right, Paul. I'm just stealing a glance over there at your papers. I can't help but see a map. A little disappointed listeners, viewers. This is not a hand-drawn Paul Hunter map. I'll give you half a point for that. I was going to say, AI had no role in that.

15:22Paul Hunter: I can tell.

15:23Katie Simpson: I think we need to count all 50 there. No. Talk to us about the results, particularly in the American South, that you found interesting.

15:33Willy Lowry: You know, and nothing works better on the audio version of this podcast, not on YouTube or on the radio version, than a good graphic. Hey, really stuff that people can't see. So, yeah, what I've got colored in here are parts of what is known as the U.S. South. I'm not talking about Arizona and New Mexico, but like I was saying earlier, everything from Texas and points east and kind of Virginia, D.C., Maryland and points south, the U.S. South. And look how blue it is, right? Like we're looking at – I mean Virginia was a Democrat earlier, but coming out of the midterms – and we talked about this last week in the MAD podcast that we did, right, the morning after.

16:06Willy Lowry: North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia, Texas, possibly Mississippi still, right? Like to me – And looking increasingly likely there will be Mississippi. Exactly. Well, we'll see. But it's – yeah. And even if it doesn't go Democrat in the end, the fact that it almost went Democrat is signaling something's going on in the U.S. South, right? So what's going on here, right? Like to go back in time, the U.S. South was a Democrat kind of bastion. Then came the civil rights movement. And, you know, there's still debate over how far Richard Nixon pushed the so-called Southern strategy. But nonetheless, there was a change when the civil rights movement came.

16:47Willy Lowry: And a lot of white Southerners migrated away from the Democratic Party and over to the Republican Party. And it has sort of been that way ever since. And that – setting aside midterms of presidential elections, that's a lot. I'm going to go back to my map. Here are the electoral college votes in these states, 40 in Texas, 16 in Georgia. These are all states won by Trump last time, 9 in South Carolina, 16. If you total up all of – it's like the implications of what may be happening in the South for Democrats going forward are kind of incredible. If this is real, if this is not a one-off, right?

17:27Willy Lowry: Is this an anti-Trump vote? Is this a we'll give you a chance vote? Or is this a real thing where, you know, I was in a - Can I see the map quickly? I'm going to say one more thing. Okay. Shocker. I was in a bar the other day. What? I know. Don't believe it. And the bartender, we were talking about this kind of stuff, and the bartender said, yeah, I've known like two or three of my friends have just moved to Texas. Like the point being because there are jobs. It's a hub. Because in some places there are lower taxes. Like there's no state income tax in Texas. Right. So the demographics we talked about this in previous episodes of this podcast, the demographics are changing.

18:00Willy Lowry: So it's not just that Latinos voted for Trump this time, unlike last time. It's not just that young people came out. It's not just that black Americans came out and voted. It's the the population is changing. So is this a is this a one off or is this a change in the South is the big question. But if it is, holy cow, Democrats are laughing.

18:21Katie Simpson: We also – sorry, Kitty. Like we spoke about it a little bit last time, but the candidates really matter. And I'm just – And candidates. Yeah, very good point. And I'm just kind of looking at this list. North Carolina, Roy Cooper. Strong candidate. South Carolina. Annie Andrews facing, quite frankly, Darlene Graham, who is not up to the task. Georgia. John Ossoff, potentially a presidential candidate. And Shane Telerico, a great candidate.

18:45Willy Lowry: A great candidate versus a terrible one.

18:46Katie Simpson: And Mississippi, which is on the fence. Scott Cologne ran a really inspired campaign. Sure.

18:51Willy Lowry: So let's talk. Sorry to keep going on this, but let's talk about Georgia, where Akisha Lance Bottoms is now governor. First black woman governor of Georgia. Thank you for letting me touch the map. Frankly, in any U.S. state, I believe. Secretary of State for Georgia, also a black woman. Secretary of State, people are thinking, what's that in a state, right? Remember Brad Raffensperger? It's a big deal. It's a big deal. The guy that Donald Trump called up to say, fine me 11 ,000 votes, right? In Texas, Gina Hinojosa beat Greg Abbott for governor. Back to the, I take your point. Well, Abbott was a complicated character and candidate as well.

19:29Willy Lowry: But it's like, this is what the leaves that Democrats and Republicans, frankly, are looking at right now. What is going on in the U.S. South?

19:46Paul Hunter: I'm Adrienne Arsenault, CBC News' chief correspondent and your host for When It All Went Wrong. It's an investigative podcast about the people who get hurt when the systems meant to protect us fail. It features original reporting from some of Canada's best journalists. Each series unravels the moment it all went wrong. Not by accident, not from poor planning, but because someone chose to do wrong and others chose to do nothing. Find and follow When It All Went Wrong, wherever you get your podcasts.

20:17Katie Simpson: Katie, as our resident trade expert, I know you've been thinking just a little bit. Just a little bit. A little bit about what comes next for Canada-U.S. relations. The Democrats have indicated that they will use their investigative powers to try to overturn, block or otherwise get rid of Trump's tariffs. And I know you spoke to a few newly elected Democrats about this.

20:42Paul Hunter: Yeah. So we went up to Capitol Hill because lawmakers were returning and a bunch of the newly elected folks are up for their orientation sessions. Remember, they don't take power until January. So this is just sort of a learning time. And it was it's so funny to be up there on, you know, when everyone's coming in for orientation sessions, because it feels like the first day of school.

21:01Willy Lowry: Yeah, I've got kids and no one knows where to go.

21:04Paul Hunter: And they're all wearing like hall passes and everyone's getting ushered around. And like lawmakers were asking me, like, do you know where we go? I'm like, I know I barely know how to get around here. So we went up to try and get a sense of, OK, you know, Democrats have indicated that affordability is an issue. And we wanted to see, OK, where do tariffs sort of land on that? And so we talked to a bunch of Democrats from all over the U.S., from New York, from New Jersey, from South Carolina, from Nebraska to get a sense of, you know, where they are in this moment and what they want to see change and have a listen.

21:39Paul Hunter: It's pretty overwhelming what they had to say. No question. I always say that there's no way that the Republicans who are running, I'm a Democrat, the Republicans who are running in my district or across my state weren't hearing the exact same things that I was. People know what these tariffs are and they know what the impact has been. And I think if we don't do something to address this and start bringing down costs, start rebuilding relationships with key allies, we're not going to get elected again in two years. And that goes across the board. So I think it's something that needs to get addressed and I think it will get addressed.

22:10Paul Hunter: During your campaign, did tariffs come up at all? Any position on the tariffs in Canada? It didn't come up quite a bit. I mean, tariffs broadly were a discussion point. So, but obviously, like in our district in particular, like Canada is a very strong partner with, you know, with trading through the port of Charleston. So, and it's hurt. It has hurt us. I know jobs have been lost and we need to make, we need to make it better. I'm just curious. Do you think that that should be like, is that like an easy target for affordability for Democrats if they try to try to go after? I think they are. I think tariffs are one of the easiest things that we can get after to try to make life more affordable for sure.

22:48Paul Hunter: I was going to say, what do you want to see lawmakers do when it comes to the tariffs? Well, we want to go back to the relationship we had before Trump came on board.

22:56Katie Simpson: You know, we have a close alliance. We both help Canadians and Americans with our trade and our economy. So why are we trying to hurt that right now? I'm Brad Lander, L-A-N-D-E-R. I'm a representative from New York's 10th congressional district. I love our Canadian neighbors. I hate these stupid tariffs. We're going to do everything we can to get rid of them.

23:16Paul Hunter: What does that look like?

23:17Katie Simpson: I mean, we put up a bill that says Donald Trump does not have the authority to do these tariffs. We're going to claw them back.

23:24Willy Lowry: That Donald Trump doesn't sign if it gets passed.

23:27Paul Hunter: I was going to say, there's a couple of things that Canadians need to keep in mind here. One, even though, and there's a short term, what the Democrats think about the tariffs on Canada short term, and then the longer term, bigger picture Kuzma talks, because they are two separate things, and Democrats have very different attitudes towards both. The tariffs that Donald Trump has imposed on Canada related, you've got what are known as the 232s that are on steel, aluminum, some lumber products, auto sector that you've got that bucket of tariffs. And then you've got another bucket of 50 percent tariffs on a wide range of goods, like twenty eight billion dollars for the Canadian goods, things like cheese and things like furniture and hockey sticks.

24:06Paul Hunter: And you've got the wine and alcohol ban, all those kinds of things. The lawmakers that we were speaking with, they don't like the tariffs. And so if the Democrats do get enough support in Congress to pass it through the House and pass it through the Senate and pass it, Donald Trump has veto power. So that's one thing to remember. Now, if enough Republicans look at the election results and say, OK, you know what? Affordability was an issue. And Americans have clearly drawn a line between tariffs and affordability, tariffs and a higher cost of living. Can the Democrats get enough Republicans on board to override Donald Trump's veto?

24:41Paul Hunter: It would require two thirds of the Senate, two thirds of the House. We live in a world where I would never make a prediction about what Republicans are going to do and where their support lies for Donald Trump and whether they want to take measures towards affordability. I would never want to set an expectation around that. And I don't want to. So, like, I don't think I know. Paul is like, I don't think so.

25:00Katie Simpson: Two thirds, two thirds means that's 10 Republicans basically in the new Senate.

25:05Paul Hunter: Well, I can't like, so here's the thing.

25:08Willy Lowry: That's a lot, though.

25:08Paul Hunter: Some Canadian, so some Canadian officials, Jean Charest was out there on CNN earlier this week, the former premier of Quebec, who is sort of involved in advising Carney when it comes to Canada-USA relation. He's like, look, maybe that's a possibility. Someone else raised it with me, Mary Scott Greenwood, who is a Canada-US sort of strategy advisor. She's a former diplomat. She was saying, look, if Canadians can, you know, lobby enough of these new American lawmakers and lean into that affordability message, maybe there's there's a way. I would never want to set an expectation around anything like that.

25:38Paul Hunter: So that that is what it would require. Do I think is realistic? Probably not. The other thing to keep in mind. So we're talking about tariffs and Canada seeking tariff relief. And that's that's what all of these Canada U.S. talks are about right now. Canada and the United States have not entered into sort of formal negotiations around Kuzma, which is the long term free trade agreement with Mexico that still needs to be dealt with. It's sort of in a zombie state right now. It continues to exist. All three parties need to reenter into it because they've reached their sort of sunset period. And Canada and the U.S.

26:10Paul Hunter: haven't started that. The U.S. and Mexico are talking, but Canada and the U.S. haven't yet because they're so stuck in the tariff war right now. Democrats long term, I would caution to say that they're going to get fully, completely on board with Kuzma if, you know, things sort of drag down the line and it's not dealt with and renegotiations have to take place. Because some Democrats are not free traders, particularly when it comes to their protectionists because they've watched and seen jobs in the auto sector be completely hollowed out. Think Ohio, think Michigan, places like that. So I would not caution.

26:42Paul Hunter: I would caution Canadians to expect that right now you're hearing Democrats talk about they want to get rid of these tariffs. Yes. Long term, everyone needs to keep in mind that Democrats might not necessarily support in overwhelming numbers. There might be enough support to get it there and restabilize the relationship at some point. But not all Democrats are fully on board with with, you know, pushing ahead with with this free trade agenda.

27:03Katie Simpson: I guess, is this a window between now and January for Carney to try and negotiate? Or does he wait this window out and even the next one and just wait out the president? What do you think?

27:17Paul Hunter: The thing is, Donald Trump has put another point of leverage on Canada, another pressure point. He in the summer when the talks broke down, he posted on social media that he was going to impose a 50 percent tariff on Canadian auto sector, like a like a massive tariff, like across the board that would. Experts I've spoken to, Flavio Volpe with the Auto Parts Manufacturing Association. You know, he says it would just simply shut down the industry because no company could afford to pay the 50 percent tariff on parts coming in from Canada. It would just be out of control. So that sort of looms over everything.

27:47Katie Simpson: Wouldn't be great for the U.S. either, though, right? For the industry writ large, both sides of the border?

27:52Paul Hunter: It would shut down production in the United States. It would not happen. It wouldn't happen right away immediately, but it would be, if you have to pay 50 % more on these parts that are coming across, it's just not going to happen. The thing is, heading into the midterms, there was a flurry of sort of increased conversation leading into the midterms. Mark Carney saying the prime minister saying that there's progress and that the Americans are moving to more toward Canadian positions. High level conversations are happening, but have formal negotiations resumed? No. But the indications from the prime minister is that Canada, the United States were trying to sit down to try and hammer this out.

28:27Paul Hunter: Because, you know, if the Canadians are wait, Canada obviously wants tariff relief as quickly as humanly possible. Right. It is really hurting Canadian industries and Canadian jobs. And so if Canada can reach some sort of agreement that is doable and livable and gets some sort of tariff relief, Canada will, I suspect, try to lock that down as quickly as possible ahead of the January 1st tariff deadline and possibly ahead of when Democrats are sworn in. And maybe Canada doesn't need to rely on Democrats going after Trump. And then, of course, there's the court case.

28:58Katie Simpson: I hate to say this to you, Katie, because, you know, we you already went through it this summer when you tried to take vacation. But I'm just I envision your Christmas. You know what? You know what?

29:12Paul Hunter: I actually hadn't even thought about that, really. And you just crushed my soul. I know.

29:16Katie Simpson: I'm so sorry.

29:18Paul Hunter: Yeah. I worked through vacation. I worked through vacation. I don't know why I did that. I have regrets or whatever.

29:24Willy Lowry: You are a known soul crusher.

29:26Katie Simpson: Willie Lowry. It's my job. podcast. We've covered a bunch of questions here, but there are still obviously a lot of unknowns. Just before we wrap up, what are the biggest unanswered questions for you post midterms?

29:43Willy Lowry: Well, for me, the two states, obviously, Alaska and Mississippi, we still don't know about. But that aside, I mean, the thing is, and we've been talking about this throughout this episode, is what's Donald Trump going to do? Is he going to blow everything up? Is he at the point where He doesn't care. Exactly. The wild card. Call it what you will. Is he going to go all in with everything Trump all the time because he doesn't care? Or is he going to say, well, I want to leave a different kind of legacy? I mean, again, it gets back to trying to get inside Trump's mind. But I think what many people fear is that he's just going to blow everything up because why not?

30:17Paul Hunter: I so not to be.

30:19Willy Lowry: I mean, I hesitate to say it sounds like hyperbole, but with Trump, you just don't know.

30:23Paul Hunter: No. And so I think take everything you just said and apply it to the Canada-U.S. trade war. And I think that that's what obviously that's the beat I cover. And like I do like I also do cover life in America, too, I swear. But like in this immediate moment where Canada has so much at stake and so much on the line, take again, take everything, Paul, you just said and apply it to the Canada U.S. lens. And where does this go? And what does it mean for trade talks? And does Kuzma get sort of across the line and sort of stabilized and all countries recommit to it, those kinds of things? So it's it's basically I have the exact same point as Paul.

31:00Paul Hunter: And but just apply it through the Canada U.S. lens.

31:02Katie Simpson: I have nothing left to add. My esteemed colleagues covered it perfectly. No, I think you're both right. And it will be fascinating to see what transpires. I think we'll leave it there for now as we watch, wait and see what happens next. If after listening to this episode, you still have questions about what could come next in American politics, we'd be very happy to hear from you.

31:29Paul Hunter: A reminder, you can send an email to WashingtonPod, all one word, at cbc.ca. That's WashingtonPod at cbc.ca. You can also leave us a comment on Spotify.

31:39Willy Lowry: Isn't it great being in the same room together? I love this. The best.

31:42Paul Hunter: It is nice.

31:43Willy Lowry: And if you like what you're hearing, spread the word. Tell a friend about this podcast and follow Two Blocks from the White House on your favorite podcast app. All right. Thanks, guys. Bye. See you.

31:53Katie Simpson: Bye.

32:04Katie Simpson: For more CBC Podcasts, go to cbc.ca slash podcasts.

From the publisher

As returning and newly elected U.S. lawmakers descend upon Capitol Hill, questions remain about what happens now after the Democratic Party's big midterm election win. What might President Donald Trump's vague accusations about unfairness and his change in chief of staff signal about the Republican Party's next move? What might the Democrats do about tariffs? Washington correspondents Katie Simpson, Willy Lowry and Paul Hunter dive into these questions and more.

More from Two Blocks from the White House

All episodes