In short
Pediatric sleep for babies 18 months and younger—debunking sleep-training myths, arguing against cry-it-out, and offering safer “in-between” options like safe co-sleeping and flexible sleep setups.
Guest
Rachel Shepard Ota, certified pediatric sleep consultant specializing in improving sleep without sleep training; former teacher (10 years) with a master’s in education/special education; completed a UC Davis fellowship in infant parent mental health (2020s).
Key claims
Sleep training isn’t supported as safe/effective under 6 months due to lack of research; even after 6 months, evidence suggests minimal baby sleep improvement (parents may report fewer awakenings because babies aren’t crying). Cry-it-out can be emotionally harmful and may reduce attunement; parents should use informed consent and consider medical “red flags” if wake-ups are extreme.
Notable examples
Her own first child was sleep-trained (Ferber/5-10-15) after a pediatrician recommendation; it was “horribly traumatizing,” didn’t work, and he later slept through on his own. She teaches Safe Sleep 7 for co-sleeping (firm surface, no heavy bedding/pillows, lightly dressed baby, etc.). She recommends daylight exposure for circadian cues, bedtime routines, sensory input, and floor/Montessori beds or separate-surface co-sleeping.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOMeet the Expert: Rachel Shepard Ota
0:30 to 1:46
Introduction to Rachel Shepard Ota, a pediatric sleep consultant.
“This summer, Prime Video takes you back before Legally Blonde, before law school, and into the world of Elle Woods in high school.”
The Reality of Sleep Training
1:46 to 3:52
Discussion on sleep training experiences and misconceptions.
“I mean, when you have three kids, a flight by yourself is It's truly just magical.”
Exploring Alternative Sleep Approaches
3:52 to 5:18
Rachel shares alternative methods to sleep training for better sleep.
“different opinions on what you should do for feeding, for sleep, for education, all of that stuff.”
Realistic Expectations for New Parents
5:18 to 7:06
Advice on setting realistic expectations for newborn sleep.
“So basically what I teach is that you don't have to sleep train.”
Optimizing Sleep for Newborns
7:06 to 10:21
Strategies for parents to help their newborns sleep better.
“You're supposed to just put them down in this thousand dollar bassinet that we bought and they're supposed to just fall asleep and be happy.”
Understanding Baby Sleep Patterns
11:23 to 14:00
Exploration of baby sleep routines and when to expect changes.
“Check out the link below or in the show notes and support the show.”
The Timing of Sleep Training
14:00 to 14:58
Learn why most parents consider sleep training around four months and the associated challenges.
“But I think one really big reason we do it here is because that's when most people are returning to work.”
Research on Sleep Training
14:59 to 17:31
Discover the current research gaps on the effectiveness and safety of sleep training for babies under six months.
“but if you are going to do it, it should be after six months.”
Pros and Cons of Sleep Training
17:32 to 18:42
Understand the limited benefits and potential drawbacks of sleep training for babies.
“It's not a method that would be, that would really be held up scientifically.”
Personal Experiences with Sleep Training
18:43 to 20:55
Hear personal anecdotes about the challenges and emotional struggles of sleep training.
“What was your experience with your first one?”
Show all 28 chapters
Personal Experiences with Sleep Training
21:03 to 21:38
Hear personal anecdotes about the challenges and emotional struggles of sleep training.
“and debating another coffee or energy drink that you know you will regret?”
Personal Experiences with Sleep Training
21:43 to 22:29
Hear personal anecdotes about the challenges and emotional struggles of sleep training.
“Nero can be shared or enjoyed on the go anywhere, anytime, just for discreet and good energy.”
Individual Needs in Sleep Methods
22:30 to 24:44
Learn how different babies respond to various sleep training methods and the importance of adaptability.
“And for some babies, they're large candidates for co-sleeping.”
Perceptions of Baby Sleep Patterns
24:45 to 27:06
Explore societal expectations and perceptions regarding when babies should sleep through the night.
“And I feel like that to me is probably, if you were to ask like most of our parent friends what their expectation would be on when their kids start sleeping through the night, I think that most would say three months.”
Understanding Sleep Expectations
27:07 to 28:01
Discuss the realistic expectations parents should have about baby sleep patterns.
“So we have, let's call it, five or six close friends with babies within three to six months of Tate.”
Understanding Sleep Expectations for Infants
28:01 to 36:03
Learn about the variability in infant sleep patterns and what parents can expect.
“So there's got to be a point at which there is the expectation that they start sleeping through the night, correct?”
Understanding Sleep Expectations for Infants
36:08 to 36:21
Learn about the variability in infant sleep patterns and what parents can expect.
“Hungryroot.com slash two parents code two parents.”
The Emotional Impact of Sleep Training
36:21 to 42:01
Explore the emotional challenges of sleep training and alternative methods for better sleep.
“I would hear her crying and I would know like, OK, we're going to leave her in there.”
Flexible Sleep Strategies for Babies
42:01 to 44:38
Learn about various sleep strategies for babies, including floor beds and co-sleeping.
“Another one is being really flexible about your sleep location.”
Understanding Sleep Preferences and Attachments
44:39 to 47:14
Explore the dynamics of parent-child attachment and how sleep routines can influence them.
“If that's not something you want to do, then taking shifts is another really nice strategy so that each parent can get an uninterrupted block of sleep.”
Navigating Naptime Challenges
47:15 to 51:23
Discover tips on managing naps for babies, including transitioning to one nap.
“Um, so right now both Winnie and Tate are 11 and some change months old.”
Navigating Naptime Challenges
51:50 to 53:24
Discover tips on managing naps for babies, including transitioning to one nap.
“And this year we're saying thank you to the therapist.”
Sleep Expectations and Cultural Differences
53:25 to 56:00
Discuss the cultural differences in sleep expectations and practices for babies around the world.
“How do you know if you have a 17 or an 11-hour sleeper?”
The Influence of Sleep Training Industry
56:00 to 59:10
Explore how the sleep training industry has shaped parental expectations around sleep.
“Well, this is a very unpopular answer because here in the U.S.”
Navigating Sleep Consultant Advice
59:10 to 1:02:34
Understand the complexities and lack of regulation in the sleep consulting field.
“I know and that was what was so mind-blowing to me when I started my account because I started to get this global audience and they started to ask, what is sleep training?”
Common Parenting Mistakes Around Sleep
1:02:34 to 1:06:16
Learn about frequent pitfalls parents encounter regarding their baby's sleep.
“And a lot of people are just not honest about that.”
Aligning Bedtimes for Better Sleep
1:06:16 to 1:07:26
Discover the benefits of aligning your bedtime with your baby's schedule.
Expert Resources and Final Thoughts
1:07:26 to 1:08:24
Get insights on where to find reliable parenting resources and advice.
“that that child will be different than Tate and you have to do things differently exactly they say right?”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00The best dancers from across the globe are about to join me for the audition of a lifetime. ABC Mondays. Do they have what it takes to compete and be the next Dancing with the Stars pro? I'm here to win. Nothing is going to stop me. Our star judges will decide. This is what hunger looks like. It was 100 % a wrong choice. Robert Irwin hosts. The next era of Ballroom starts right here on Dancing with the Stars, the next pro. All new Mondays, 8, 7 central on ABC. Next day on Hulu. This summer, Prime Video takes you back before Legally Blonde, before law school, and into the world of Elle Woods in high school.
0:38Set in 1995, this Gemini vegetarian knows exactly who she is. Until her family moves from Bel Air to Seattle. Packed with iconic fashion, 90s nostalgia, and a throwback soundtrack, Elle proves one thing. Law school was hard. High school was harder. From the world of Legally Blonde, watch Elle, a new original series only on Prime Video. Watch now.
1:00Rachael Shepard-Ohta:Welcome back to another episode of Two Parents in a Podcast. Today is the sleep episode. We have Rachel Shepard Ota. Did I nail it? Good job you nailed it. Okay I was I didn't know if it was Ota or Ota. Ota she's a certified pediatric sleep consultant who specializes in getting better sleep without sleep training. Correct. A moment for that. Thank you. This is probably our top three most requested episode. Yeah. All about sleep. You are the perfect person to talk to about it. Thank you. I'm very excited about this episode. I think we were just talking about this before we got started. Well, first of all, thanks for coming.
1:42Of course. Thanks for having me. How was your flight? It was so nice. I mean, when you have three kids, a flight by yourself is It's truly just magical. I read my book. I had my snack. No one was climbing on me. Then you went to the hotel last night. Slept alone. Slept alone. It was beautiful. Yeah. Yeah. That's great. Got to walk this morning, get her coffee. Yeah, I was laughing because you were like, it's hot here. Nobody cares. And I was like, no, nobody cares. We're all used to it now because you're San Francisco based. I'm San Francisco. So it's always cold, foggy, windy, freezing all the time.
2:16And I usually complain about that. But then when I'm in the heat, I like to complain about the heat. So yeah, it's very hot here. You guys are going to have a true fall though? So we actually have our summertime in September, October. So it's really nice right now. But the whole summer you don't see the sun. Harrison and I are, Harrison wants me to stop talking to you about the weather. Sorry. Okay, well I'll talk to her about sleep. I would love to talk about sleep. Okay, here's what I want to say though. I think sleep is confusing. Yes, it is. you're writing a book on how America does sleep different than all other cultures.
2:51There's that bringing up baby book. Yeah. Which a lot of people read when they are pregnant. I bought the book and tried to read it. And it turns out I'm just not a good candidate for reading books when I'm pregnant. Got it. I love reading memoirs, but like parenting books weren't for me. I like need to maybe do podcasts or something. Right. But what that taught us too was like America does things different than cultures in a lot of areas. Food, discipline, et cetera. so today we're going to talk to you all about sleep and I think we're going to talk to you through the guise of 18 months and younger is that fair to say love that yeah okay and then the other thing that the audience can expect is well I think the biggest thing is like you don't do the cry it out method you got here from your own experience because you did the cry it out method with your first yeah yeah so we I became a mom almost eight years ago and there wasn't we were talking before we started recording, there wasn't this landscape of social media parenting experts like there are now.
3:49So you really didn't have a million different approaches, a million different opinions on what you should do for feeding, for sleep, for education, all of that stuff. So my pediatrician and a couple of the moms in my mom group were sleep training or my pediatrician told me I should sleep train because my two month old was still waking up at night, which now I know is super normal and common. And so I did like a Ferber style class and it really was just horribly traumatizing for all of us, my husband and I, and obviously our baby. He really didn't take to it. And so then we kind of just abandoned it and he started sleeping through the night on his own when he was like one year old and we didn't have to do anything different.
4:34Just one night he started sleeping. And that kind of made me think, huh, I wonder what all the fuss is about. If babies will just figure it out eventually and do it, then why is there so much stress and pressure on getting them to do it earlier and earlier? And there are obviously so many systemic reasons for that, which we could get into. But I basically started researching other approaches when I was pregnant with my second because I really just knew I didn't want to do it that way again. But I also was so terrified about not sleeping because that was really tough. The sleep deprivation is horrible.
5:03It's awful. It's and nobody really warns you about that. I mean, people say, oh, you're never going to sleep again. Like enjoy your sleep now. But you you don't really get it until the baby's here. So anyway, that was kind of how I found this other approach and this other path. OK. And can you summarize the path for us? Yeah. OK. So basically what I teach is that you don't have to sleep train. There are so many things that you can do in between doing nothing and full on cry it out or, you know, strict schedules and all of that kind of stuff that can be really intense. I teach about safe co-sleeping because a lot of parents end up co-sleeping, even if they never planned on it.
5:41It's upwards of 60 percent of parents will co-sleep. And they won't admit it. I don't think. Yeah, exactly. And that's what we know, right? Yes. Everyone's out there being like, no, I don't. But yes, I do. Exactly. So I'm very passionate about teaching parents how to do that as safely as possible. And then also there are parents that don't want to co-sleep and that's totally valid too but they also don't want to leave their baby to cry it out so what are those in between options and there are so many things we can do to optimize sleep for everybody without doing things that don't feel right to your parenting style okay I love it I'm very excited um Harrison why don't you take over because he did just like a just wonderful prep amazing and you've got all these questions outlined okay I love that let's do it I guess before we get any further is there anything else the listener should know about your background and your training in the matter?
6:27Sure. So as far as my background before this, I started my Instagram account and my certifications in sleep and stuff in 2020. Before that, I was a teacher for a decade. So I have a master's degree in education and special education. And so I've always loved working with kids and with families. And I recently just finished up a fellowship at UC Davis and infant parent mental health. Because I feel like that mental health aspect of not just the parent, but of the baby is something that's often really left out of the sleep conversation. So yeah, that's kind of where I'm coming from. Okay. Love it.
6:59So from your perspective, what's the ideal game plan a parent should follow following birth of a child when it comes to sleep? Lower your expectations is number one. I think when parents bring home their baby and they expect to put this baby down in their bassinet that they've purchased and that the baby will just sleep and then that doesn't happen, I think that can be really scary and confusing because you're like, well, what do we do now? Because they're just supposed to sleep. You're supposed to just put them down in this thousand dollar bassinet that we bought and they're supposed to just fall asleep and be happy.
7:31And that doesn't happen for such a large percentage of babies. So I think understanding realistic expectations is huge, whether that's taking a class before your baby's born or following some people on Instagram that you resonate with. Just getting prepared before I think is the most important thing. It's probably what my followers tell me the most often that they just had no idea and they just were so unprepared for what sleep looked like. So many people take breastfeeding classes and labor classes and things like that, but nobody really thinks about the sleep because everybody just assumes babies sleep when they're tired.
8:05So I would say lower your expectations, have realistic expectations, and have flexibility in your plan. So yeah, you can have the bassinet, but then you should also prepare yourself on what to do if baby won't sleep in the bassinet. So educating yourself on safe co-sleeping practices, the Safe Sleep 7 is a really good resource for parents to learn about doing it safely. Setting up a plan with your partner. So if you have a partner, think about maybe taking shifts for those first few weeks when baby's waking up pretty often so that it's not all in one person. I think those are the things that really kind of get you through that newborn period.
8:38And so much of it is also just surviving and getting through that period and just knowing this is a phase, this is not my life forever and it will pass. And in the newborn period, if they're not sleeping, is there anything tactical you can do to make them sleep or know all bets are off and like you just have to flow like water with this baby? It's a little bit of both. And part of it depends on your child's temperament. So some babies are just born more naturally easygoing and they'll kind of fall into predictable schedules. And those are the babies you hear. Sometimes parents will say, oh yeah, my baby put themselves on a schedule or, oh, just use wake windows.
9:12It's like they talk about it like it's so easy. But then there are also babies who are born with more sensitive temperaments and they just have very strong wills and minds of their own and they will not take so easily to things like that. So my advice is that there is no such thing as a one size fits all solution. And really those first few weeks should be spent getting to know your baby, learning their cues. There are a couple of things you can do that can really help. One is trying to help their circadian rhythm along. So babies are not born with a circadian rhythm yet. So they don't have, you know, the melatonin.
9:46They don't have those different cues in their body to help them know when it's time for day and when it's time for night. They're just kind of on their own little schedule. So one thing you can do from the newborn period is exposing them to daylight during the day and having it be really calm and dark and dim at night. And that can start to kind of help them set up for being awake during the daytime and being asleep as much as possible at night.
10:09Rachael Shepard-Ohta:Fall is planting season. Did you know that many plants and trees actually do better when planted this time of year? But you have to know where to start. That's why I love fastgrowingtrees.com. I actually am obsessed with them. We just got our two trees in the mail. We did indoor trees because I wanted to add some oxygen to the house. They arrived to your doorstep. It's almost too good to be true. You don't have to go out. You don't have to go to the nurseries. You just pick your trees online and they arrive to your house. Doesn't matter if you live in the sunny south or if the air is getting chilly where you are, their plant experts can help you find the perfect fit for your space.
10:46Rachael Shepard-Ohta:You can talk to a plant expert about your soil type, landscape design, and how to take care of your plants and everything you need. No green thumb required. So I asked, how often do I water these? Should I put them in sunlight? And I learned everything I know I need to know about keeping our trees alive. So this fall, they have the best deals for your yard, up to half off on select plants and other deals. And listeners of our show get 15 % off their first purchase when using code 2PARENTS at checkout. That's 15 % off at fastgrowingtrees.com using code 2PARENTS at checkout. Now's the perfect time to plant.
11:21Rachael Shepard-Ohta:Use 2PARENTS to save today. Offer is valid for a limited time. Terms and conditions may apply. Check out the link below or in the show notes and support the show. So in those early stages, we used the snoo. It was phenomenal for us. For us? Yeah. For us. Some people's kids don't like the snoo. We have a very good friend. We bought one for my second and it was, we used it as like a fancy bassinet. We didn't turn it on. We didn't strap her in. She hated it. So understanding that first period is very much out of your control and at what point can a parent expect for their child to get in a routine and what should they be doing around that to optimize best sleep practices for their baby?
12:14Yeah. Well, like I said, every baby is different. So some babies come out and they're just really naturally attuned to schedules and timings. Other babies are not for a while, but generally speaking, after the newborn period, so after maybe the first 12 weeks, that's when we can expect a more predictable pattern for most, not all, but for most. Because again, that's when that circadian rhythm starts to kind of come into play. So they might be on, you know, more of a predictable nap schedule. At that time, you might be able to reliably know what time they want to be put down for bed, things like that.
12:47So usually around the three, four month mark. And so I think that's what we saw from our end was yeah the first 12 weeks there was a lot of I think waking up probably every three hours yeah um and then at three months that's when we started to see her sleep through the night but it definitely we went through like ups and downs um right now we're back on the period of of sleeping through the night yeah um as you said it feels like you know most of the time when parents get to that three months, a lot of them auto default to sleep training and cry it out. Why do you think that isn't the ideal method to follow?
13:33And what do you think parents should be doing to put their kid in the best position to get sleep quality? To get quality sleep? Yeah. I mean, I could talk about this forever. So just cut me off if I go too long. I think the first thing to think about when you hit that three, four month mark is why do you want to sleep train? And for parents in the U.S., again, this is a very much North American U.S. perspective. Other parts of the world don't do this. But I think one really big reason we do it here is because that's when most people are returning to work. So most people are returning to work around three, four months.
14:10So sleep training, marketing is geared toward that period of time. It's also when you have the four-month sleep regression, which is where babies start waking up more frequently. They're harder to put down and they might not be napping in the same way. So things like that. So it's kind of like this perfect storm. You've got a baby who's now more wakeful and fussier and harder and you have to go back to work. So it's this real like perfect storm of desperation. And so that's the point in which parents are really seeking solutions and answers. And so that's where the sleep training marketing comes in.
14:42That's why you see so many of those courses that are geared towards like the four month mark. When really, if you look at the sleep training research, there's no research to say that it's safe or effective under six months. So I don't recommend sleep training at all because I don't think it's necessary and I don't think we have to do it as a one size fits all solution. but if you are going to do it, it should be after six months. And even researchers that look at this and say, yeah, we're pro sleep training, sleep training's great. Even those researchers say, but it shouldn't be under six months.
15:16So that's something really just important for parents to be aware of. I think, you know, whatever method you choose, whether it's co-sleeping, whether it's cry it out, Ferber, something in the middle, you should just know what you're doing, right? You should have this informed consent and you should know all of the pros and cons. So that's really what I would tell parents is do your research, make sure that whoever you're listening to for your sleep advice is reputable and that they're not trying to sell you something that's inappropriate.
15:47So. And I don't think I answered the rest of the question. Yeah. I'm just deciding if I want to go to the six months or not. And why. And then I'll go back to it. And so why. What what happens at six months? Why, why did, what are the, what is this, what is, what is the evidence show at six months and why that's when it's recommended to sleep train versus beforehand? It's really just that there hasn't been research done on the sleep training, um, methods under six months to prove that it's safe or effective. Okay. So it's just, it's more of a lack of research more than like we have this research that shows that it's not good for this reason.
16:26It's just, we have a lack. And while we're on the topic of sleep training, can we talk through the pros and cons of sleep training following six months? Yeah. So it's really just important to know for parents that sleep training does not improve sleep for babies. So that's just shown in the research that it's a really negligible amount. It's like eight minutes or something that they might sleep more post sleep training. They're still waking up. So the parent is getting more sleep because the baby is waking up and no longer cuing. So after sleep training research, you know, they'll give parents surveys asking how many times did your baby wake up after sleep training?
17:02And the parents are saying zero because they're not being woken up. But then when you actually observe the baby, you see that they're still waking up. They're just not crying out. So, you know, for parents that are really, really struggling and really not coping well and they don't have access to support, they don't have access to things like therapy, they don't have other ways to cope with the sleep deprivation. um that's just one thing to consider is that they might get more sleep post-sleep training but for the baby themselves they're not really getting the benefits that sleep trainers will have you believe they're getting and what about harmful effects of what about harmful effects on babies of sleep training yeah i mean unfortunately we don't have a lot of research on pros or cons and one of the reasons for that is that it would be unethical to conduct a study subjecting some kids to cry it out and other kids to not crying it out right so if you think about it that kind of says it all right there that it would be unethical to do that um there are some studies that have a six-year follow-up or a five-year follow-up and um a lot of people will point to those studies to say there's no harmful effects but really it just shows that there's the parent report that the attachment is fine, but that's parent report.
18:21It's not a method that would be, that would really be held up scientifically. A lot of these studies have other issues with their methods where, you know, there's a high dropout rate or things like that. So I think the research that we have is really lacking. I would never make a claim to say sleep-trained babies have insecure attachment because that's just we don't have that data but I do worry about baby's stress responses and I do worry about the attunement and the lack of attunement that can happen with sleep training especially because we know that sleep training usually has to be repeated several times and that that process can be longer than like the three days that they promise.
19:07What was your experience with your first one? Yeah. So like I said, this was eight years ago. I didn't have all these resources on Instagram to kind of figure out what path I wanted to follow. It was just, this is what my pediatrician told me to do. This is what a couple of the other moms that I'm friendly with are doing. So we bought this sleep training course. It was basically the Ferber method. So if anybody's wanting to buy a sleep training course, just look it up for free. don't don't pay for that um but so it was basically like the method where you put them down drowsy but awake you leave if they cry you wait five minutes then the 10 minutes then the 15 minutes that kind of thing we call this the 5 10 15 yes on here ferber method basically exactly the exact same thing i just think we did a different name yep yeah so exactly the same um and you were supposed to give it like two weeks or something and my son now that i know him it was never going to work like he is just so sensitive he's so strong-willed it was just not going to happen he would go hours and it just did not did not work um and so we gave up and then tried again a few months later didn't work again tried a few months later didn't work again and finally around nine months we were just like okay we I can't do this anymore this is just insane and it's not working.
20:27And it was interesting because a lot of our other friends had done it and say, oh, it worked. Like, you must be doing it wrong. So then there was all of this, like, shame and feelings of failure. And like, there must be something wrong with our baby. Why is it so easy for everybody else? And it wasn't really until I started with my Instagram page that I realized, oh, wow, there's actually a huge community of people that either A, I don't want to do this or B that it doesn't work for. But yeah, I think even now thinking about that, I'm just like, oh my God, what were we doing? It just felt so wrong at the time.
21:02Rachael Shepard-Ohta:Ever feel like you're running on empty, staring at your screen, hitting all that afternoon crash and debating another coffee or energy drink that you know you will regret? Enter Nero gum and mints, you guys. Neuro's Energy and Focus Gum and Mints give you clean, focused energy without the crash, sugar, or sketchy ingredients. It's time to switch to good energy, which I know is something that we all want, whether you're working a 9-to-5 desk job, whether you're a parent, whatever it is that's going on, we all have that afternoon crash, and Neuro's Gum truly can help you. Neuro's Energy and Focus is powered by natural green tea caffeine.
21:42Rachael Shepard-Ohta:There's no sugar, no aspartame, no crash. Nero can be shared or enjoyed on the go anywhere, anytime, just for discreet and good energy. All you have to do is chew it and go on your way. Nero also offer caffeine-free options for all-day wellness support. Nero's Memory and Focus gum are made with American ginseng to support mental clarity minus the jitters. Nero's Sleep and Rechargements offer melatonin and chamomile to help you unwind and rest without pills or sugary gummies. For a limited time, you can get 20 % off your first order at NeuroGum.com by using code 2Parents. That's NeuroGum.com and use code 2Parents for 20 % off your first order.
22:25Rachael Shepard-Ohta:You can also find Neuro at CVS and Amazon. So is your point like that the Ferber method does work for some babies and it works wonderfully? And for some babies, they're large candidates for co-sleeping. And so it's not a one-size-fits-all. It's really reading your baby. Right. And so for you, for example, with your first, do you say his name? Yeah. Okay. Otto. Yeah. So for Otto, for example, he did the forever method. It didn't work. Right. If you were coaching or helping you, would you have said, okay, try co-sleep now? Or what do you, what's your gut telling you you should do? And then like you would pivot to, to something else or no, like mom and dad are just waking up when he wakes up and like this baby's not going to be.
23:09Yeah. Yeah. So it's funny because I look back now and I'm he was only waking up once or twice a night. So I kind of look back now like, what were you doing? You had a baby that actually was so fine, especially compared to my girls. Like my girls woke up way more than he did. But it's just all about perspective. At the time, I thought he was a terrible sleeper. And I thought, you know, there's these books like 12 hours by 12 weeks. You just think that they should be sleeping through the night so early because these are all the messages you're getting. So yeah, when the sleep training didn't work and I was back to work at this point, which is why we did it in the first place because I was scared to go back to work sleep deprived.
23:49But once it didn't work and we had to abandon it, yeah, I just went back to, you know, he would go down in his crib. He'd wake up maybe once around midnight, maybe once around three or four. I would go in, feed him back to sleep and put him back in the crib. And it was pretty simple. And I was actually fine with that. So if I could go back and coach myself in the midst of the sleep training where I was just like crying myself, curled up in the fetal position, listening to my husband go do the check-ins, just everything in me screaming, this feels horrible. I would just tell myself to stop. Like you don't have to finish this program.
24:27Like nobody knows your baby the way you do. This random lady that you bought this course for doesn't know your baby. She's not going to come lock you up for not following the plan. Like you can just stop and you can just go back to what was working because you were actually fine. And it's not going to be forever. So if a baby's waking up one to two times at nine months, like we're calling that a win. That's normal. Okay. Yeah, that's normal. And I feel like that to me is probably, if you were to ask like most of our parent friends what their expectation would be on when their kids start sleeping through the night, I think that most would say three months.
25:11And I think, including us, that was definitely our expectation. I think that was definitely our expectation. And then if that wasn't happening nine months in, that like there'd need to be like, we'd be trying a whole bunch of different things as to how to actually, you know, have them get there. But is that because, yeah. And is that because you're really struggling and you're not coping well with the sleep deprivation and you're really, really suffering or is it because you just think it should be different and there's something you need to fix? I was struggling with it I I was exhausted and hearing phantom cries and like not doing so well with the no sleep you were doing fine so that was just a personal yeah everybody's different yeah um yeah I and then I do think there's definitely the element of like okay you know you we definitely like aren't ones that we want to put pressure on our child but we also want to you know we hope that they loosely do track yeah like the um trajectories towards sleep yeah and and and other things and so it is interesting it feels like that there's a pretty what you're saying is there's a pretty big misperception about this yeah so I was just in Denmark over the summer doing research for my book and I would ask parents when did you expect your baby to sleep through the night and they looked at me like I had five heads and they were like babies don't sleep through the night.
26:42It's really just our perception is everything. And the messages that we get are everything. And if you have a baby that sleeps through the night early, then that's great. But also know that that might not stay like the trajectory you were just talking about is actually not that common. It's more common for there to be ups and downs and regressions and, you know, kind of two steps forward, one step back sometimes. Okay. So, well, I'm going to share something that I bet a lot of moms go through. So we have, let's call it, five or six close friends with babies within three to six months of Tate. And some of them would sleep through the night.
Read the full transcript
27:19I think everybody used different methods. And I felt like if Tate wasn't sleeping through the night and their babies were, I did feel like a little bit of like, what are we doing wrong? Or like, should we do a different method or something? And what it all boiled down to was like confusion. in. I didn't know how to navigate it. I didn't know if like one method was more right or more wrong. And it's so funny because when let's say we have baby number two, I'll have a totally different thought on how to do the sleep. But when you're going through it for the first time, it's like scary and it's unknown waters and you're tired.
27:53Yeah. So it's like the one area where you're like, like when it comes to weaning off pumping, I have a very clear picture of how to do it and I'm doing it. Yep. And I read something. I thought that sounds good for me. there's no emotional attachment to it i'm thrilled to actually stop right but when it comes to sleep training i'm like it there is emotional attachments to it cry it out could work for some people it's just simply not going to work for us so it just i couldn't do it yeah i i do i do want to push a bit here though because i think what you're saying isn't something that is commonly um is commonly understood.
28:28So there's got to be a point at which there is the expectation that they start sleeping through the night, correct? Yeah. And what is that age? Two or three. Two or three. And so you're saying, hey, parents, wake up up until two or three. There's a very high chance that your baby is going to be waking up periodically throughout the night. I wouldn't say there's a very high chance. But when we look at sleep research and we have a couple of studies that look at some pretty big cohorts of children, like a couple thousand children, we see tons of variability. So at certain points, like eight months, for example, if anybody with an eight month old or eight to 10 month old is listening, you're probably waking up a ton.
29:11The study, the study showed that there were anywhere between zero and 21 wake ups at eight months. And then what it also showed is that by two years, most kids are sleeping through the night, but that some aren't until closer to three. But another thing that I talk about all the time, because this is also so important, is that if your child is ever waking up hourly, like if they're up every hour for weeks or months at a time, or they're not sleeping through the night by about two or three, like there's something going on. And this is another one of my gripes with the sleep training industry is that it sweeps a lot of these potentially dangerous medical issues under the rug and tells you to just fix it with sleep training.
29:48when really if we have a parent that's presenting to us exhausted because their child is up constantly there is something going on with that child that's not normal to be waking up that much there are things like sleep apnea iron deficiencies um you know all uh allergies all kinds of other things that i call red flags that we need to be investigating and we're really not doing a good enough job of of that oh and you're like trying to make them sleep yeah and so yeah what is the general expectation that a parent should have in terms of what the wake-up frequency is over the first 12 to 18 months of childhood.
30:28Yeah. So again, it's so variable. Like I said, at eight months, you could have a baby that's zero times and a baby that's 21 times. And like all of that in between is what we see. So I would say, I mean, personally, I would say if a baby under a year is still waking up a couple of times and they're going back to sleep relatively easily, that's pretty normal. The number of wake ups is also not necessarily the most important thing. It's what are those waking up periods looking like? So is the baby just fussing a little bit and then going back to sleep? Do you count that as a wake up? Is the baby screaming bloody murder and not settling down for an hour?
31:06That's also a wake up. So it's it really does kind of depend on what those wake-ups look like, how disruptive they are to the family, and how much sleep overall the child is getting. But I guess there's obviously a wide range, but where does it get concerning to you? It would get concerning to me if there were hourly wake-ups or upwards of six or seven wake-ups for a baby that's under one or under two. If a baby is closer to two or we're getting into toddler age, if they're waking up more than a few times, then that would be outside of the range of what we see. But again, it doesn't always mean something's wrong.
31:44And we have to look at the sleep location too. So if your baby is in a crib in their own room and they're waking up a ton, but then you decide to bring them in your bed and they co-sleep and they sleep beautifully through the night when they're next to you, then that might just be a baby that's having some separation anxiety or that just might need that extra closeness. And it's not actually that they're waking up a ton because there's something wrong with their sleep. They're just that type that needs more proximity. And that's actually normal. Let's talk about the pros of co-sleeping. Can you walk us through those?
32:14Yeah. So I co-slept with my middle and then I'm still currently co-sleeping with my toddler like half the time. She comes into our room in the middle of the night, most nights still. The pros of co-sleeping, it tends to lengthen the breastfeeding relationship. So if breastfeeding is something that's important to you, co-sleeping does make that easier. And we see longer term breastfeeding with co-sleeping families. fewer wake-ups often so the wake-ups themselves are less frequent but also they're usually quicker because you can respond more quickly and you can kind of settle them down before they get super worked up or they're fully awake and a lot of families just feel that it really increases bonding especially for parents that work about half of my community are parents that work outside the home they're not stay-at-home parents and they co-sleep for that reason they say we're away from our baby all day long co-sleeping is when we like get to be together all as a family and snuggle and spend that time that we missed out on during the day so there are so many benefits yeah so sweet and and there's um i think co-sleeping scares a lot of parents you hear um you hear some scary stories and so what are the co-sleeping best practices you would suggest parents to follow and how would you address those that say it's dangerous yeah so as far as the claims that it's dangerous, I have a bunch of articles that I can give you in for your show notes if people are interested.
33:41I would look at the safe sleep seven guidelines. So that's a set of guidelines. It says seven because it sounds cute, but there's actually a lot more things that you should follow. The most important I would say are that you have a healthy full term baby, breastfeeding mother, and people feel a lot of different ways about that. But the reason for that is just that there's this increased synchrony between baby and mom if mom is breastfeeding. and you want to have a safe sleep surface. So that means a bed that is firm, it's clear, there's no big duvets, there's no heavy pillows, there's no pets or other children in the bed and baby is lightly dressed, not swaddled.
34:16So if those conditions are met and all of the other ones that are mentioned in the safe sleep seven, then it's really not as dangerous as people think it is at all. Most of the world still co-sleeps. It's very common pretty much everywhere else. and I think there are a lot of reasons why it's so demonized in the U.S. but taking an abstinence-only approach doesn't work. So when we have our health care providers telling us don't do it under any circumstances, that's just not realistic. And abstinence-only education doesn't work for sex education. It doesn't work for drug prevention. We need to give people options to mitigate the risk because we know that most parents will end up co-sleeping, even if it's just once.
34:57We want to make sure that they're doing it safely.
35:00Rachael Shepard-Ohta:Totally agree with that. Guys, let's talk about Hungry Root because shopping and planning for groceries really can be simple and stress-free, which I know is something we all want. We want to prioritize our meals, but we don't necessarily have the time to do it. So imagine having your weekly cart filled for you with personalized picks that ship right to your door, taking all the work off your plate. And that is why we love Hungry Root. Hungry Root personalizes your meals for you, whether you're gluten free, dairy free, high protein, focused on gut health or whatever else. Hungry Root helps you eat well because you take a quiz and then they personalize your options for you.
35:38Rachael Shepard-Ohta:Hungry Root also helps you by reducing food waste and avoiding multiple impulse grocery buys because there's nothing worse than doing all these different impulse grocery buys, nothing that you will use. They don't actually go into a meal and then you end up just throwing them away. So take advantage of this exclusive offer for a limited time. Get 40 % off your first box. Plus get a free item in every box for life. Go to HungryRoot.com slash 2Parents and use code 2Parents. That's hungryroot.com slash two parents code two parents and get 40 % off your first box and a free item of your choice for life.
36:17Rachael Shepard-Ohta:Hungryroot.com slash two parents code two parents. So yeah, my issues with crying it out and sleep training were it started out as like a gut feeling. I would hear her crying and I would know like, OK, we're going to leave her in there. And then I just, it took me like five minutes the first time that I just looked at Harrison and I was like, I cannot do this. We also, we have just a wall between us. Like our rooms are right beside each other. So we hear her. And then I started looking up like, okay, well, I saw one comment and it said, it's not that they get tired and go to bed. It said they give up.
36:57And I just, I know a lot of people don't buy into that. And that's fine because I don't think we know. But for me, I was like, that's how I feel. And so that comment very much reflected my brain. And I was like, for me, I can't do the cry it out anymore.
37:17And I just wanted her to know she was probably scared. Maybe she was – I don't think she was hungry, but I think she was scared. And I think she just had some separation anxiety and wanted her mom and dad. and I couldn't, I didn't like the idea of letting her cry through that. And I thought I would be fine with it. I thought I'd be like, I can do this. Oh, I know. We all think that before we have to do it. Like I think so many parents go into parenthood, even pregnant, people will come to me and say, I really thought I would sleep train before I had my baby. And then they got here and I was like, I can't leave.
37:52Like it just feels, it feels wrong because it is. Like we're supposed to be responding to their cries. We're primed for that. Anybody who's ever had a baby knows if you hear a baby cry, I mean, it's the most stressful feeling in the world. And that's for a reason. We're supposed to be moved to go to them. And that's just our biology. We can't fight against that. And so, oh, sorry. Well, then she hit the Eeyore phase, which is where she would sit up and start to slump over. And when we saw that, I was like, it's over. Like, she is so sad. Like this, she can't even get her own bottle. Like she was just at the age where she could start to kind of hold it.
38:31Yeah. And it's like that little girl, like she needs us. And we were so tired, but. It's so brutal. The other thing I'll mention is that it makes sense that you're exhausted. It makes sense that you were not coping well. And this goes back to kind of just like my overarching thesis for everything I talk about, which is that we're not supposed to be doing this alone. It's actually a very, very uniquely American thing to be raising a baby in a nuclear household without help. so when we look to other cultures when we look to like hunter-gatherer societies and and the way that we were evolved to care for children it was never just the mom getting up with the baby or just the mom and dad getting up with the baby we're supposed to have this village of help so that we're not so exhausted and we're not supposed to go back to work at eight weeks and we're not supposed to have all of these other pressures right so just remembering that that it's so hard because it's not it's not supposed to be something we do by ourselves totally makes
39:27Rachael Shepard-Ohta:sense. I think that that that's kind of a great segue to build off of by kind of summarizing, I think, everything we've learned to this point and then keeping keeping the train moving forward. And so what I'm gathering is that your advice is, is, hey, parents, wake up and over the first 12 to 18 months of childhood, completely readjust your expectations. And there is not going to be a one size fits all rule that you should put the pressure on yourself to follow. And it's very likely going to look different. And so try a variety of methods. And for if you are blessed and you have a kid that starts sleeping through the night three months in, great.
40:19But if not, then try a variety of methods because what works for baby one may not work for your second baby. And that could be sleep training following six months. It could be co-sleeping. What other method, one is that like an accurate summation of your recommendation? And then two, what are other
40:49evidence-based methods for helping a baby sleep or get the highest quality sleep possible? Yeah. So this is what I love talking about because, again, not every parent wants to sleep train. Not every parent wants to co-sleep. And those things might not work even if you want them to work. So what do we do in the meantime? What are the things we can do to get the best sleep possible without with the understanding that like this is a other human we can't control them right so one thing that I love talking about is sensory input so sensory is so so important giving your baby time outside giving them time on the floor giving them time out of containers they need to explore their world they need to use their body they need to be exposed to things outside of your home and that can be one thing that is really really beneficial especially once they're mobile Once they can crawl, once they can walk, we really want to let them use their body as much as possible.
41:43That sensory input can be so calming to the nervous system. And even if you do it early in the day, like 15 minutes on the swing at noon can still help them sleep at night. So that is one thing that I recommend that can work for literally everyone, no matter what type of baby you have or what sleep method you want to use is sensory, sensory, sensory. Another one is being really flexible about your sleep location. So some babies just will not do a crib. And I teach about floor beds or Montessori beds. Have you guys heard of these? Yes. So these can be magical. They can change things literally overnight.
42:18If you're having a baby that's waking up a lot and you don't want to co-sleep. So that's one kind of like in-between option that a lot of parents use that I've used myself with my two girls. And it's the best. Another one would be another flexible option for sleep location would be co-sleeping but separate surfaces. So you could have your baby in your room, but in their own space. So whether that's a crib, whether that's one of those like side bassinets that kind of attaches to your bed. So they're not really in your bed, but they're right next to you and it's easy access. That's another kind of happy medium.
42:49And then another evidence-based strategy that I think most parents know is something they should do, but not everybody does, is a bedtime routine. There's tons of research on bedtime routines, improving sleep. It doesn't have to be anything super long or really involved, but it can just be bath, books, night, night song and getting in bed. And that can really improve things, too. And then just mentally brace that there's a real likelihood that your child will have one or two meaningful wake ups throughout the night. Yeah, it's possible. And plan accordingly. but if it is if those meaningful wake-ups are highly frequent and very long that's when you're said that's when you would suggest people to look further into is there is there a deeper issue going on for sure especially if there are other more physical symptoms so things we see a lot with something like sleep apnea would be baby is gasping or choking in their sleep or there's pauses in their breathing, if they have an open mouth or if they're really arched back when they sleep, if they have things like rashes or if they're sorry to get graphic, but if their poop is like bloody or has mucus or foam in it, like those could be signs of allergies.
44:12So just always thinking about, okay, are there other symptoms that are presenting in my child and their sleep sucks like I need to get this figured out makes sense um you spoke to the um you know historically the amount of community help towards raising a child I think in theory it would be great if we could replicate that but I think the reality of our home and most of our listeners homes is it is just just the mom and the dad yeah and so if you do have a kid mom or just mom or just dad thank you if you do have a baby that is waking you know is not sleeping through the night what do you see couples do effectively so that way um they're in the best mental mental space to deal with that yeah well one is being open to co-sleeping because it does actually really improve everybody's sleep often.
45:09If that's not something you want to do, then taking shifts is another really nice strategy so that each parent can get an uninterrupted block of sleep. So I think we have these ideas that we need eight uninterrupted hours to feel functional, which is really not actually true. As much sleep as we can get is obviously great. But even if you can get a block of three or four hours, it can really shift your mental health. So maybe that's, you know, So dad or second parent taking the first shift of the night so that you can go to bed early. Maybe you sleep from 8 to 12 and then you're on for the next shift.
45:45Or maybe that's other parent is waking up at 5 a.m. doing that early morning feed and chilling with baby. And then you get to sleep from like 5 a.m. till 7 or 8 so that you have those couple of hours where you know you're off the clock. So figuring out a schedule that will work for you can be really helpful. we we've naturally done shifts that have traded off through time yeah um one and and this could you know just be uh i don't know in our heads but what we find is who goes and gets her in the morning is who she's most attached to is that true i've never seen any evidence to support that but it is interesting i swear like so so you go through a period of time where one person is getting her in the morning and during that period of time she's more attached to that person yeah like three weeks okay one person's getting her so for the last two weeks harrison's gotten her every day and she is that that that that wants to hug she's rewarding you for being the one to come set her free i think so is that real i don't think so i've never seen any research done on this but The three weeks prior, when she was doing it, I definitely saw the preference towards her.
47:01That is very cute. But not a real thing. Not really a real thing. I mean, parent preference is a real thing. And there is this hierarchy of attachments that children can form, but it's usually not changing every three weeks.
47:13Rachael Shepard-Ohta:And why is there a parent preference? because they can really only hold one primary uh attachment at a time when they're this little so lots of times also to be frank a lot of times the mom is the food source and so that's who they're preferring um or it's just the one that is spending the most time with them or has the most attunement to them um but it's different for everybody but there's like a close second oh yeah so sure yeah kids can form multiple attachments i'm actually reading this book right now that's talking about um all of this and how like in hunter-gatherer societies and in our evolution and with apes and stuff like that there's multiple attachments that children can form that can be quite strong um which is really interesting so yeah things like daycare having a nanny things like that like they can form attachments with those people too okay yeah like she definitely knows maria and and gets excited about her of course so naps that's where i was gonna go i knew it.
48:13I knew it. Did you see my notes? No, I can't see them. Um, so right now both Winnie and Tate are 11 and some change months old. They're on two naps. They're on the morning nap and the nighttime nap, but they've started sort of protesting the morning nap. Yeah. So do you think it's a good idea to still put them in their crib, even if they just kind of roll around and play or just to start one nap? Yeah. So this is classic 11 and 12 month old. Um, there's almost always this kind of like nap refusal that happens and parents can get really confused about it because they think, Oh shit, they should just be on one nap now, but they can't make it to the one nap.
48:52And, um, it can be really confusing. So most babies are not ready for just one nap at 12 months. Some definitely are some even before that dropped to one nap. Typically though, it's more like 13 to 15 months where they'll drop down to the one nap more consistently. I mean, as far as putting them in the crib, if they're happy, you can. I prefer to have the crib just be for sleep and have them have a little bit more sleep pressure when they go in there so that they'll just fall asleep. So I would probably just push the morning nap a little bit later and then shorten the second nap. Okay. That makes a lot of sense actually.
49:26Because that way you can keep bedtime And so based off that answer, it sounds like your advice to parents over nighttime sleeping is very much feel it out based off the child. But when it comes to napping, it sounds like you suggest people be a little more structured. Not necessarily. It's more just what we see. I mean, again, everybody's different. Some babies drop to their one nap really early. My son was napping twice a day until he was like 18 months old. So sleep needs are another thing that are super individualized. two kids could have a difference of like six hours and what they require for sleep over a 24 hour period.
50:01So it's hard to nail down schedules. And, and so, but is there like a general framework that you think children should be following around napping in the first 12 months? Not really. Because again, there's, but two, well, not again, not really because there's sleep needs that are over 24 hours. So I think of sleep as like a bucket that you're kind of dipping into every time you nap or every time you fall asleep at night. The difference in two newborns, for example, for how much sleep they need, one might need 12 hours or 13 hours over the course of 24 and another might need 17. And both of them are sleeping normally and both of them are healthy.
50:41So we can't put both of those babies on the same schedule if they have needs that are different by six or seven hours. So how do you test it? Do you say, all right, we're going to try drop, we're going to try pushing the nap back and shortening the second nap for a week. Yeah. So whenever you're making a change, exactly, I would say, give it at least a week before you say, okay, this feels like it's working or it feels like it's not. Cause it's think about like jet lag, right? So whenever we're messing with our body's internal circadian rhythm and sleep patterns and stuff, it can take up to a week for us to feel normal again.
51:12So I would definitely give it at least a week to see if it's working or not. Okay. And then you adjust from there. You say, we tried that, that I'm not sure that's working. I think they are a one napper. Yeah. So we're going to try that. Yep. Okay. And then try that for a week and see if that feels better. And so things that you'd look for to see if it's not working would be they're taking a really long time to fall asleep or they're waking up super cranky or they're not going down for bed no matter what time you try, or they're waking up a lot more overnight, waking up super early in the morning.
51:42Any of those like really big new patterns would say, okay, maybe this is not going so well.
51:47Rachael Shepard-Ohta:This show is brought Brought to you by BetterHelp. And you guys, October 10th is World Mental Health Day. And this year we're saying thank you to the therapist. BetterHelp therapists have helped over 5 million people worldwide on their mental health journey. And that's millions of stories, millions of tears, millions of people that have had a chance to talk to their therapist. And behind all 5 million is a therapist who showed up, listened, and helped somebody take a step forward. Moments in therapy, like asking the right question or having a safe space to cry or celebrating a small win, they are so, so, so important.
52:23Rachael Shepard-Ohta:And you guys know I've always been a huge proponent of therapy. So October 10th, World Mental Health Day, thank you so much to the therapists. And you guys know I love BetterHelp because you can pick an online therapist. You can switch at any time. It's online. It's convenient. And it is so affordable. And I think that therapy is the number one place that you can play offense on life and not defense. And they have over 30 ,000 therapists. They're the largest online therapy platform, and they have helped serve over 5 million people globally. And it really works. That's why they have an average rating of 4.9 out of 5 for a live session based on over 1.7 million client reviews.
53:02Rachael Shepard-Ohta:That is so impressive. So this World Mental Health Day, we're celebrating the therapists who have helped millions of people take a step forward. If you're ready to find the right therapist for you, BetterHelp can help you start your journey. Our listeners get 10 % off their first month at betterhelp.com slash two parents. That's betterhelp, H-E-L-P dot com slash two parents. So you're saying that we look at it like a 24-hour wheel, and some babies need 17 hours of sleep during that 24-hour wheel, but some babies need 11 hours of sleep. How do you know if you have a 17 or an 11-hour sleeper? Unfortunately, it's really trial and error.
53:39So what a lot of parents really like are wake windows, which are not super evidence-based, but I also don't think that they're harmful to try. They're a great, a lot of parents, when they're new parents, really love them because they feel like it gives them this kind of roadmap or this thing to go by. And for a lot of us recovering type A control freak types, it can feel like, okay, now I know this is when they should be sleeping. This is when they should be awake. A lot of parents really love tracking apps and things like that. I don't love those. But again, I do think it's a good starting point to just say, okay, yeah, they actually are falling into these wake windows pretty well.
54:15So let's just keep going with this or, oh no, this chart is saying they should be going to bed now, but they are wide awake. Like let's stretch it a little bit. And just that trial and error over a couple of weeks. If you're tuned in, you'll figure it out pretty quickly. I feel. Okay. It's a gut feeling. Yeah. Okay. um yeah it's i feel like a lot of this feels like new information to alex and i it definitely feels like you know our expectation you know pre our daughter being born and through um the first 11 months has very much been like a we hear a lot about like firm structures or rules that that parents should be following around sleep.
54:59So I think it's just really interesting to hear your take on take a step back, feel it out, and really don't put too much pressure on yourself or your child to follow a specific method. It feels like permission. It feels like permission to give yourself one, follow your gut, but two, lower your expectations. Like if your baby isn't sleeping through the night at nine months old, you don't have a problem. You don't have to go and do something. You say that's normal actually. And number two, what do I want to do about it? Well, now I get to pick because I don't have, I'm not putting pressure on myself.
55:37Right. Or do I want to do anything about it or am I actually fine? Yeah, totally. And am I just thinking it's a problem because my friend's baby is sleeping? The comparison. I feel like this could be a good transition into what's the most effective thing you see done in other countries around sleep that you think parents should be doing in the U.S.? Well, this is a very unpopular answer because here in the U.S. we like hacks and we like immediate gratification and we like everything to be very efficient. But the biggest difference is that they don't put so much pressure on sleep. They co-sleep and they expect babies to sleep through the night when they're ready.
56:20And it's not an industry in other places, right? So there's not these gadgets and products and sleep training books and manuals and classes and all of that stuff because people just expect it to unfold the way it always has. And I know when you initially earlier in the interview alluded to the sleep training industry, all of our ears perked up because we talk a lot of around the thematics of different industries and the way that their marketing campaigns have influenced let's give her one as an example like breakfast is the most important meal of a day like a doctor didn't say that the guy that founded kellogg did and he just started a marketing campaign saying don't skip breakfast it's the most important meal of the day and we're all like don't skip breakfast so can we hear but it wasn't it wasn't a thing and so the sleep training industry is sort of love to hear about the sleep training industry how much time you guys have because this is my roman empire because i was a victim of it as well so i fell victim to it when I was a new mom.
57:24And now, of course, that I'm in this world, I see it everywhere all the time. So I think one thing that's really important for parents to just be aware of is that sleep consulting is a non-regulated industry. So unlike a therapist or a doctor or a lactation consultant who need a governing body to say, yes, this person is reputable and they've been trained and they are qualified to give you advice, you could just wake up and call yourself sleep consultant and start giving people advice on the internet and a lot of people do that so that's one thing to just be super aware of is that you have to be so careful with who you get your advice from and you have to look up what their credentials are another thing is that the marketing is just the marketing is is insane so it's if your baby's not sleeping through the night it's going to ruin your marriage if your baby's not waking up or if your baby's not sleeping through the night, there's something wrong.
58:19You have to give them the gift of sleep. There's all of these very highly charged emotive phrases and words that they use. And a lot of it is fear-based marketing. So it's, you'll never sleep again unless you sleep train, or your husband will, you know, never get over it, or your older kids aren't going to get enough time from you or attention. There's all of these like fear. If you don't do this, then this is going to happen. and I just think that's really gross. But where I'll not stand up for it, but where I understand it is it's all we know sometimes. So it's all you see and then you listen to this and you hear, okay, other countries don't even have a sleep training industry.
59:03They don't even have the word sleep training. But you just assume everybody does and you don't know that until somebody tells you. I know and that was what was so mind-blowing to me when I started my account because I started to get this global audience and they started to ask, what is sleep training? Or why do you feel the need to sleep train? Like what is, and I started to understand, wow, so this is not, I don't know why I had never thought about it before, but it just kind of broke my brain. Like, oh, we don't actually have to be doing this. There are people that are very happy and living in, you know, countries that are in a lot of ways happier and more well-off than ours and they're not doing this.
59:42So, and there are obviously a lot of reasons for that too. And what, what's an example of a country that's doing this right and the benefits that they're seeing? Gosh, well, I'm writing a whole book on this right now. So it's hard to like condense, but for example, I was just in Denmark and they, um, you've probably seen viral videos of, you know, their babies sleeping outside and strollers and stuff like that. They just have like a very lax point of view about sleep. They co-sleep until their baby is about one, but they also have maternity leave for a year. So there's not that pressure of, we have to get baby sleeping through the night because I have to go back to work because they're just able to, you know, be home and be on baby mode during the day.
1:00:26So it's just a very different way of looking at things, but they're like one of the happiest countries in the world and their kids are happy and doing really well. So, um, it's all connected. And it's funny cause we had, I don't know if funny is the right word, but it's scary, but one of, um, tying it to mat leave, I believe it was Nestle. Yeah. Well, formula company in general will lobby for shorter maternity leave. So moms can't breastfeed and have to start doing formula. Yep. Um, and then you did tie into, um, and I know we kind of spoke about this at the beginning, but I really want to nail it, but you talked into, to people need to be careful about who they get their advice from on the internet.
1:01:05And so why should people take advice from you? Well, they don't have to. But. But. And that's the thing too. If you don't want to take my advice or you don't trust what I say or it doesn't work for your family, that's also fine. I want every parent to feel comfortable with who they get their advice from and what approach they choose. I've done multiple certifications in infant sleep biology. I have an infant parent mental health degree from UC Davis and I'm a former educator. I have a master's in education. So I've taken tons of like child development and psychology classes. And I have three kids and I've worked with hundreds of other families.
1:01:46But you're a certified pediatric sleep consultant. Yeah, but that doesn't mean anything.
1:01:50Rachael Shepard-Ohta:Oh. I mean, it does. Like I did the work and I took the course and I believe in the certifications that I've done. But there's no like upper regulatory body saying, yes, you are certified. It's just this person who made up a certification course and is certifying people. So it's very different from like the lactation industry where there's it's very tightly regulated by medical bodies. And you have to take these really intense tests and you have to keep up with it. It's very different. So, yeah, like I'm a sleep consultant because I consult with families on sleep and I have the education to back that up.
1:02:28and I believe in my training, but it's a little bit not real also. Wow. That is so important to say. Yeah. Yeah. And a lot of people are just not honest about that. Yeah. I don't think people know that. I mean, I did not know that and we were through the interview. Yeah. I was wondering why you weren't including that in your education. I thought, oh my gosh. Okay. I'll show you the pick of my note. Wild. Yeah. Okay. Do you have any other questions? We've learned so much. Yes. one question I didn't get the chance to ask is what is the most common mistake parents make in their first year around sleep?
1:03:03Trying to control it too much. And yeah, just trying to control it. I see so many parents who have their mental health just completely deteriorate because they're constantly trying this new method or that new method or trying, you know, this product or that product. And it just is like, they, they could be so much better off if they were less stressed about it. What about this clip that I saw, which is parents matching their bedtime to their kids bedtime? Yeah. So similarly to when we were talking about shifts, I think this is something that parents don't do nearly enough. My husband and I go to bed at like nine.
1:03:37And so this is something that we have learned just works for us because our kids do get up on the earlier side. And if you go to bed early, instead of staying up and scrolling or working or all of those things that so many of us love to do, it can help you get such better sleep overall. Because most of the time, not everybody, but most babies are doing their longer stretch at the start of the night. So they go down for bed. Maybe they sleep three, four hours, maybe a little more when they're a little bit older. And so say they don't have their first wake up until like 11 or 12, but you've just fallen asleep because you're staying up till 1030.
1:04:13Or 11. Yeah. So now you feel completely wrecked because you've missed out on this chunk of sleep that you could have had while they were sleeping. And now what happens is babies wake up more as the night goes on because they spend more time in lighter stages of sleep as early morning approaches, which means for a lot of babies, they'll do, you know, their long stretch at the beginning of the night. Then they're up maybe every hour, every two hours. So you wake up feeling like you got zero sleep. So going to bed early, aligning your body clock with your babies is huge. Even if you can only do it a few nights a week, it'll make a huge difference.
1:04:46It's so hard to do because when When the baby goes down is like when I know Tate's going to go to sleep. We'll reserve so many things to do. We'll do it once she's down. We'll open those boxes when she's asleep. Yeah. We're up till 1030 or 11 sometimes. I know. And now she's sleeping through the night. But if she was waking up at midnight, we would be wrecked. Exactly. And so many parents do this. And another huge mistake I see parents making is that they save all of those things for when the baby's asleep. See if you can do things while the baby's awake. So, you know, or split up. So what my husband and I do so that we can be totally done when the kids are down is we split our bedtime routine duties.
1:05:25So I am putting the kids to bed. I'm doing bath time, getting jammies on, reading the books, doing everything while he's cleaning up the kitchen, taking out the dog, resetting the house for the next day. So that way when they're down, everything's done and we can go to bed as early as we want. Divide and conquer. Yes. yeah that's um similar I would say to what we do but then but then I mean we got a list of things we do you got your shows I know I know you've got a chat I know we found hostage we're like just one more episode I'm like it sucks this is gonna suck when she wakes up I know it's hard because that's it feels like when they go to bed it's your only time as a couple or it's your only time to get me time and I totally got that so just try it a couple times a week no no it's really good advice like even twice a week if you can just say let's go to bed at 9 30 yeah like we did it last night we got we went to bed at 10 and so when she woke up this morning it wasn't it wasn't like oh it was like we have all slept eight hours that's wonderful yeah yeah I was like okay it's six no problem um I think this was very helpful a common theme I'll tell you through these interviews and it's so funny is it's fluid you know nobody can really sit here and say do xyz magic will happen or this is the one right way it's this way or the highway it's very read your kid and a big theme we also see is read yourself yes um as a parent and so it's just it's very refreshing so thank you so much thank you for having me thank you for coming of course you are wonderful you are very well spoken you are helpful thank you so we appreciate that i was really happy to be here and i love that that's a theme that you guys have found because i think one thing that our generation needs to give up on is that there's like one evidence-based right way to do things I think you're right just follow your gut and follow your kid and and you'll be fine kids are different so there's no way parenting making them sleep having them eat is going to be the same they're all they're all different exactly and if you guys ever have a second you'll see that that that child will be different than Tate and you have to do things differently exactly they say right?
1:07:32Like, so that's everything is different. Yeah. Um, okay. How can people find you? Plug yourself. Yes. So I am at Hey sleepy baby on Instagram. Wait, that was too fast. I think Hey at Hey, Hey sleepy baby on Instagram. My website is also just Hey sleepy baby.com. I have a podcast. I have two podcasts. Actually one is called no one told us, which is these type of interviews with experts, except I'm not the one talking it's other experts. Um, So that one's really fun. All different types of topics, feeding, parenting, toilet training, all that stuff. And then my other podcast is newer. It's called You're So Right.
1:08:08And it's just like girl chat with my friend Caitlin at Wilder Beginnings. Love it. Yeah. Absolutely love it. Two pods. Two pods. Two pods, a website and Instagram. Yep. Okay. Hey, sleepy baby. Yes. Thank you so much. Thank you. My pleasure.
1:08:23Rachael Shepard-Ohta:Thanks for listening to another episode of Two Parents in a Podcast powered by Just Media House. If you enjoyed the show, don't forget to like, subscribe, comment, rate, and review. Stay connected on Instagram, TikTok, YouTube, and Facebook at 2ParentsAndAPod. Welcome to our home. Sorry it's so messy. New episodes Mondays and Thursdays.
1:08:46That's the sound of zero sugar, 200 milligrams of caffeine, and the power to burn body fat. Storm, energy for life. Storm Energy Blend helps boost metabolism, which in combination with exercise and a healthy diet helps burn fat. This product alone does not produce weight loss. Individual results may vary.
From the publisher
This week on Two Parents & A Podcast, we’re joined by Rachael Shepard-Ohta, a pediatric sleep expert and founder of Hey, Sleepy Baby — to talk about what evidenced-based sleep methods that ACTUALLY work and how to get better sleep without “training” your baby.
We get into it all: what to do in those first sleepless newborn weeks, when (if ever) to expect a routine, and why traditional sleep training isn’t the only way. Rachael explains why baby sleep isn’t linear, how to handle night wakings, and what safe co-sleeping can look like for families who choose it.
We also cover the modern sleep training industry, what other countries are doing better around infant sleep, and the biggest mistakes parents make in the first year (spoiler: it’s not what you think).
Whether you’re team crib, team co-sleep, or somewhere in between, Rachael will leave you feeling empowered to find what actually works for YOUR family :)
Timestamps:
00:00:00 Welcome back to Two Parents & A Podcast!
00:05:20 Introduction to Rachael Shepard-Ohta (Pediatric Sleep Expert)
00:06:00 What’s the game plan parents should follow for newborn sleep when bringing baby home from the hospital?
00:10:30 When can parents realistically expect their baby to get into a routine?
00:12:30 Why Rachael doesn’t recommend traditional sleep training
00:15:30 The real pros and cons of sleep training
00:18:10 Rachael’s personal experience with sleep training and how it shaped her approach
00:23:44 Why baby sleep is not linear — and what that means for parents
00:27:30 When should parents actually expect their baby to sleep through the night?
00:28:25 When do frequent wake-ups become concerning?
00:31:10 The pros and cons of co-sleeping — plus how to do it safely
00:35:21 Alex & Harrison share their own experience with sleep training
00:39:45 Evidence-based alternatives to sleep training and co-sleeping
00:47:10 Dealing with nap refusal and short naps
00:52:28 Trial-and-erroring new sleep methods and learning your baby’s cues
00:54:50 What other countries are doing around infant sleep that the U.S. could learn from
00:55:37 Rachael’s thoughts on the modern “sleep training industry”
01:02:00 The biggest mistakes parents make around sleep in the first year
01:06:00 Thank you for listening!
#twoparentsandapod
---------------------------------------------------------------
Thank you to our sponsors this week:
*Fast Growing Trees: This Fall, Fast Growing Trees has the best deals for your yard, up to half off on select plants and other deals. Listeners of our show get 15% OFF at https://www.FastGrowingTrees.com/TWOPARENTS when using the code TWOPARENTS at checkout.
*Neuro: For a limited time, you can get 20% off your first order at https://www.Neurogum.com by using code TWOPARENTS. You can also find Neuro at CVS and Amazon.
*Hungryroot: For a limited time, get 40% off your first box PLUS a free item in every box for life. Go to https://www.Hungryroot.com/TWOPARENTS and use code TWOPARENTS.
*BetterHelp: As the largest online therapy provider in the world, BetterHelp can provide access to mental health professionals with a wide variety of expertise. Our listeners get 10% off their first month at https://www.BetterHelp.com/TWOPARENTS.
---------------------------------------------------------------
Follow Two Parents & A Podcast:
Instagram | https://www.instagram.com/twoparentsandapod
TikTok | https://www.tiktok.com/@twoparentsandapod
Follow Alex Bennett:
Instagram | https://www.instagram.com/justalexbennett
TikTok | https://www.tiktok.com/@justalexbennett
Follow Harrison Fugman:
Instagram | https://www.instagram.com/harrisonfugman
TikTok | https://www.tiktok.com/@harrisonfugman
Find our guest:
Website | https://heysleepybaby.com/
Instagram | https://www.instagram.com/heysleepybaby
TikTok | https://www.tiktok.com/@rachaelshepardohta
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices




