Dan Ariely: the hidden forces that shape your customers' decisions

16 Apr 2025 · 1 h 20 min

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Podcast Summary: Uncensored CMO - Episode with Dan Ariely

Episode Overview In this episode, behavioral economist Dan Ariely delves into customer behavior and the often irrational forces that shape decision-making. He discusses how subtle cues affect perceptions of value and price, the significance of effort in creating perceived worth, and how misinformation spreads. The conversation also touches on the potential for rebuilding trust in industries like insurance and the unconventional idea of letting customers name their own prices.

Key Points and Discussions

Introduction and Background

  • Host's Greeting: John Evans welcomes Dan Ariely to the show.
  • Half Beard Story: Dan shares the personal narrative behind his half beard, which serves as a metaphor for self-acceptance and societal perceptions of physical differences.

Insights into Behavioral Science

  • Predictable Irrationality: Dan emphasizes that humans often make decisions based on irrational factors.
  • Invisible vs. Visible Motivation: Discusses how motivation can be influenced by factors that are not immediately apparent.

Insurance and Behavioral Economics

  • Changing Insurance Companies: Dan shares ideas on improving trust in the insurance industry, discussing Lemonade Insurance as an example of a company that rethinks traditional models.
  • Lemonade Model: Focuses on charity-driven insurance, where excess premiums fund chosen charities, thus aligning both company and customer interests.

Price Perception and Decision-Making

  • Relativity Effect: How context alters price perception; understanding value is often comparative rather than absolute.
  • Choice Architecture: The importance of how choices are presented to consumers, impacting their decisions significantly.

The Role of Effort in Value

  • Effort Increases Value Perception: Dan illustrates that when individuals exert effort, they perceive the value of the outcome to be higher.

Misinformation and Trust

  • Causes of Misinformation: Discusses the psychological factors that lead individuals to fall for misinformation, particularly during times of stress.
  • Combatting Misinformation: The need for societal strategies to counteract misinformation effectively.

Personal Experiences and Lessons

  • Dan's Journey: Reflects on his early experiences as a burn victim and how it shaped his insights into human behavior.
  • Empathy and Understanding: Dan advocates for empathy in understanding others' viewpoints, especially those who have differing beliefs.

Future Projects

  • Upcoming Books: Dan hints at his next book focusing on the importance of making bold life decisions and how to embrace risks.
  • Children's Books: He shares his venture into writing children's books addressing important life topics like procrastination and allowances.
  • Television Endeavors: Discusses a TV show inspired by his life focusing on behavioral economics.

Key Takeaways

  • Human Behavior is Complex: Decisions are often influenced by irrational factors such as invisible cues, stress, and social pressures.
  • Value is Relative: Understanding price perception requires context, illustrating how complicated human decision-making can be.
  • The Importance of Trust: Building trust—especially in industries like insurance—is crucial and can be enhanced through innovative business models.
  • Empathy Matters: Understanding different perspectives significantly aids in addressing misinformation and societal divides.

Conclusion The episode wraps up with the host encouraging listeners to explore Dan Ariely's work further, highlighting the wealth of knowledge in behavioral economics. Dan's insights provide valuable lessons for marketers looking to better understand consumer behavior and decision-making processes.

---

This summary captures the essence of the podcast while breaking down the significant themes and discussions presented by Dan Ariely.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:28Ladies and gentlemen, welcome back to OnCenter CMO. and the impact it has and what you can do about it. Dan is a fascinating guy. So we have a conversation that covers so many different topics. He is really interesting and he brings such practical wisdom from behavioral science and how we can use it to be better marketers. Here it is. Ladies and gentlemen, we are here on Uncensored CMO and I'm meeting Professor Dan Ariely. Dan, welcome to the show. Lovely to be here. Now, anyone watching this on video might notice that you're sporting half a beard. I am. I'm having a guess there's a story behind the beard.

0:58there is a story behind actually there's a a story that is a combination of uh some things about me and uh some things about social science so it's a it's a good story but how does it look to you you know it's been a while since i asked anybody like you look i mean you've seen me in a couple of videos but it's the first time you we meet face to face how does it look to you i think you do you do it very well it's super smooth on one side and it's a full-on beard on the other it's got some asymmetry to it so so you pull it off well do people get see you from one side and they they and then they see you from another side they think you're someone else yeah but how odd does it look to you it's actually less odd now i've met you okay whereas online i was like oh what's that is it is it some trick is it sort of i is it to get noticed i you know okay so what's the story of this half a beard so so this half a beard has a few reasons the first one is that many years ago, I was badly burned.

1:55Most of my body is covered with scars, my hands, most of my body. And the scars have a few features to them. It's a tougher skin, it's not flexible, there's no sweat glands, there's also no hair. So this side of my face is all burns. So hair just doesn't grow on this side. And it just so happened that my burn was almost symmetrical. If you look close by, it's not exactly, but you know, that's the, just the shape of the burn. So that's reason one. But of course I could shave. And if I shaved, they would look less odd. It will be less strikingly strange. And for many years I shaved. And then a few years ago, I went on a month long hike.

2:42I was a serious, I am still a workaholic, but at some point I said, when I was a kid I used to hike. I haven't hiked in many many years. Let me go back and try and hike and I'll take a month to do it. So I did a month-long hike which was fantastic and at the end of this month-long hike I looked sort of like this. A little bit less white, a little bit more hair and I looked in the mirror for the first time and it looked very strange to me. Like I really didn't like it. I can only imagine what it feels like to other people who look at me because it felt very strange to me. I look at my face. I couldn't recognize it.

3:20I couldn't see the point. And I was going to go back to shaving, but I thought that I would keep the half a beard for a while. I said, you know, I took me a month to grow it. I'm going to shave it. I will never do it again. So let me give it a few more weeks for this half a beard. And to my surprise, I started getting thanks from people about this half a beard. Now, What were the things for? These were people who told me that they had their own injury and they were always trying to hide their injury. For example, there was a woman who actually left me a note in my mailbox. She worked at a youth center not too far from me.

3:59She said that she was also burned and she has always worn long sleeve shirts to cover her burns. There was another woman in her 50s who told me that she had a car accident when she was 17 and she didn't wear a skirt or a dress since and she's going to start. So, you know, these people thought I was doing it on purpose. Here I am, I don't care about my injury, I'm going to not hide my asymmetry. And I didn't correct them, I didn't say it was a mistake, but I decided to keep the half a beard for a while longer as like a public service announcement. You know, there's a, it's tough to be injured, I did stuff to be different.

4:41And I thought if I can help people be a little bit less bashful about this, this would be a good step. But the really surprising thing, and this is where social science comes to play, happened about four months down the line. So I'm four months into this half-beard adventure, and all of a sudden I realized that I feel differently about my own injury. You know, for many years I felt like the man in the iron mask. You remember that story? I felt I was trapped in this scar tissue. The scar tissue is tough. It limits movements. It's difficult to regulate temperature. It has all kinds of things in it.

5:20And I felt like inside I was the same Dan before I got injured, but I was kind of wrapped in this wrapper that was aggressive, actually. You know, the scars shrink. I mean, it's an issue. And all of a sudden I felt less antagonistic. I felt it was not me and the injury kind of fighting, like who is the real me, but I felt it's just part of the story of my life. And I started kind of with a very much different level of sexual acceptance, self-acceptance including sexual acceptance. You know, getting undressed romantically with scars is a challenge. And anyway, everything improved. Everything improved all of a sudden.

6:07And I thought to myself, what happened? Why now? And what I realized is that these people who said they were stopping hiding is also what I was doing. So imagine somebody like me half-shaving. I wake up in the morning, smooth on one side, stubble on the other side. And the act of half-shaving is also the act of hiding. You know, I would be more non-symmetrical before shaving, I would be less non-symmetrical after shaving. And I actually remember that I was shaving to be less noticed, right? Like people would notice the scars less and so on. And letting go of that was incredibly healthy. Now, this is also what brings me to what I think social science is about.

6:54I think social science is about discovering these versions of half-beards, right? What are the things that we're doing for a good reason, right? I thought that being less noticed would be a good idea. It ended up being a bad idea. But social science is supposed to help us discover those things. Here are the things that we think are good for us, but in fact are not. And here are the things that we should be doing. And it's very hard to discover by ourselves. Because if you asked me 10 years ago, how would it feel like to be with the half a beard, I would have fantastic intuition about day one. Day one would be terrible.

7:32People would ask questions, kids would laugh, and so on. But if you asked me, and what would be the adaptation process over four months, and what other changes would it create, I wouldn't be able to predict. So anyway, so that's what I think social science is about, is finding these little tricks of how we really function and get us to adopt them in a better way. Yeah, I think it's fascinating. And well done you as well, because I know you started your journey, didn't you, in behavioral science, actually as a result of your accidents, didn't you? Your very first insights were in the hospital recovering.

8:07Yeah, not so much insights, but it started with complaining, complaining about bandage removal when the nurses thought that the right approach is to remove bandages quickly, rip them one by one. Somebody with 70 % burns, it's not fast no matter how quickly you rip it. And I thought it was the wrong approach, and I argued with them and so on. And then when I started studying at the university, my first experiments were about duration and pain, and is it better to rip bandages off quickly or slowly? And it turns out that slowly is better. And again, this for me was a pivotal moment. It's about saying, here are the nurses, wonderful, kind people who are doing everything they can to help their patients.

8:57And nevertheless, they're making some systematic mistakes. It's because their intuitions, the intuitions are wrong. And can I deviate for a second? Please do, yeah. In general, I have a very positive approach for life. lots of bad things happened to me but I have a very positive approach to life and I've been talking the last few days with somebody and I tried to write something about this how come I have such a positive approach for life and even though hospital was a terrible experience and I was there for about three years I saw the potential of humanity think about your life how many times have people shown up and acted in a surprisingly positive way?

9:47If you think about it, it doesn't happen too often. We have kind of a standard life, we have friends, but how often does it happen that somebody is showing up in a serious way and then surprising you in a positive way above that? And I had three years where in a pivotal point in my life when I was just a teenager, where people showed up and exceeded expectations. and nurses, doctors, not everybody, not all the time, but I basically kind of grew up, I think, in an environment where there was an opportunity for people to prove to me how amazing they were. So I think that since then I have this sense that if something goes wrong, there's a lot of people who would help, who would live up to the occasion, and also that the potential for help is just amazing.

10:50It's amazing, isn't it? I mean, the two ways I can relate to that, when I was 23, I broke my neck, a vertebra clean in half, and got taken to the hospital. And I was, I mean, the doctor said in 15 years, I was the second person he'd seen survive an accident of that severity. I remember when I had to be kind of isolated on the bed and had sandbags, you know, either side of my head to stop me in my sleep turning because it would have caused paralysis. They had to monitor me every 20 minutes. They were checking I could still feel my fingers and toes because, you know, the first 24 hours, 48 hours, pretty risky.

11:29And I remember when my parents got down to see me and they were surprised at how positive I was. And I said, I've just survived death. so my my mindset was one of i'm i'm you know it's unbelievable to be alive and i'm you know i've actually got through it and then the other one was um five years ago uh our house burnt down and we only just got out uh and but the fire brigade were amazing everyone was amazing and you know the love and support and everything but a similar sort of feeling is in fact this was this was um the christmas just before kobe started so when everyone was going into their covid panic we were rebuilding a house and actually almost missed covid in a weird sense because we were so preoccupied with i mean we lost everything right so we didn't have a single thing you know all the photos and clothes and you know all that kind of went but again you just get this sense of well we we're here we're together you know we got through it sort of thing and it's amazing it's just um but that comment you made the people that have the positive outlook in in you know challenging circumstances, you know, really rings true.

12:36How does it feel to kind of like inbox zero your life? You start from scratch. Amazingly liberating. You mean, you're not supposed to say this, I don't know. But actually, I remember going the day after going to the shops and I just bought two of everything, two trousers, two T-shirts, two jumpers, two coats, two shoes, so I could wash one and wear the other. and oddly that felt great um because i didn't have to choose what to wear you know the decision was kind of like automatic when we rebuilt the house it was uh in fact maybe it's therapy because we redesigned it with our life in mind for where we are now we bought the house 16 years earlier so it was before kids you know now we've got kids and they're getting older and they've got their own independence and that sort of thing so there was therapy and just redesigning it but only having what you need actually was surprisingly nice i mean the the things that were upsetting is the things you'd imagine which is when my daughter say oh have you got the video from when we went on holiday when i was eight or have you got the um the school sports day when i won this and then suddenly you realize that you haven't got those photos i mean we've been able to recover some from hard drives and that kind of thing but there's sort of like this long period of life that's missing and that's probably the the main thing and um it's interesting my daughter's reacted very differently amelie my oldest she just went straight into designing a designer bedroom it was like right i'm gonna have this i'm gonna have that and and lilia my younger wanted to recreate what had been in the past identically down to the color of the door the pattern on the furniture you know all the you know she wanted it recreated perfectly so it's interesting psychologically we all deal don't we in you know in different ways yeah it is it is interesting to think about what is a a good process for restarting and how much of it is possessions and memories and even even a home it is i recommend it but without the tragedy if you could skip the tragedy and just do the kind of you know zeroing i think that would be quite a good thing yeah i i wonder wonder if people would have the guts to to get rid of a lot of things it really does shine a light on actually what you actually need as a human being in life it brings that into stark contrast when you're sat there and everything's gone you're going what do i actually need it's about 10 of what you have you know so it's a good lesson from that point of view that we and it also creates stress doesn't it the more things you have the more stress it creates the you know you've got to manage it all and so on so that's a lesson there uh so i was doing i did a talk last year um at can called the extraordinary cost of being dull and um i did it with my good collaborator mine adam morgan and um we were trying to look at the cost of being dull in advertising so that was the context in which we're doing it but we then tried to say how do you not make things dull and actually we came across this old academic paper from 1972 a guy called murray s davis and it was called that's interesting and it was all about what makes something interesting and I think he was looking at academic papers and what made one more red than the other.

15:48And the conclusion struck me actually because he said, when you deny an underlying assumption of your audience is what makes it. And I just thought, that's almost what behavioral science is so good at, isn't it? Is that you think it was this, and actually it's that. And the illustration we had actually, I mean, again, it was advertising festival. There was an advert where a mobile phone network in France showed what you believe to be the French men's team playing football and they're scoring incredible goals, the crowd's going wild, you know, and the commentary's, you know, there and it gets to a crescendo.

16:21And then halfway through the ad, it rewinds and you realise you've seen the women's team and what they've done is they've changed the heads. They've literally just with CGI, just swapped the heads out sort of thing. And because at System 1, we measure emotional response, we could see second by second, people were very happy in the first half and then it switches to the incredible surprise. And actually surprise is a great way of holding someone's attention. And what I wondered from you've written many, many books and obviously you're an expert in this area, what have been the most, for you personally, most surprising discoveries?

16:55So maybe before I say this, it's also, I think, a good theory for humor. When you ask what is funny, you want to violate some assumption, but you can't violate it too quickly. Like there's a sense of in humor at least. Sometimes it's too early for a joke, you know, maybe in two years or something or maybe it's too close to comfort. So I absolutely think that this is a really nice part about social science that it's, you know, sometimes it's revealing things that we thought were there but sometimes it's revealing things that we, our intuition were different than that, like the half a beard story.

17:40But there's another important element in social science, which is how do you fight, let's say people get surprised in the ad. Okay, so in the ad, you got people surprised, you got the extra attention, you got everything you wanted. in social science we want in addition for that is to people remember that they don't predict very well so when it comes to apply their intuition in the next round they will not do it in the same way so we're also fighting against hindsight bias so when I give a talk for example or when I try to talk to somebody I don't want them to hear a result be surprised let's say have higher attention, all the things you want.

18:27But then a minute later said, oh, yes, I knew that all along. Because that, oh, yes, I knew it all along is a dangerous path. Because then maybe I fixed that initial part, but I haven't helped you understand how our intuition fell so much. So often when I talk, I ask people to predict the results. So I say, here's an experiment. We've done this. What do you think are the results? Please raise your hand if you think A, B, or C, and I get the results. And then I say, okay, here are the real results. And that not only helps with the surprise, but it also helps people say, okay, so just let's realize that we're wrong.

19:13Another thing I used to do more, I do it a little bit less now, is to use visual illusions. because visual illusion is just a way to show that we're all wrong and we're all wrong in the same way, right? And it's saying, okay, so we have this brain that is taking information from the outside, interpreting it. The brain is not a passive organ. It's an active organ that interprets it, and it serves to us something that is biased or wrong and so on. And let's just realize that we don't see the world. We see the world after it's been processed by our brains, and our brains do it to everybody. It's not, you know, at least on the visual illusion, it's basically everybody has the same illusion.

20:00So I think it's very, very important. It's very important to realize that our senses are not very accurate, that our reasoning mechanism doesn't always see things as they are, and then to keep on being a little humble because only if you're humble you'll test things, you'll get data, you'll have different hypotheses, you'll think more carefully and so on. Anyway, so some of the most surprising things for me. So there is something that I used to be surprised about and I'm sadly not surprised any longer and it's about the impact of little things. The first time that I did an experiment on the default bias, and you said to yourself, my goodness, you know, you change something that is so meaningless, and so many people change their mind.

20:59It's just amazing. You pre-select option one for people. They choose option one. You pre-select option two. They choose option two. And when the decision is more important, it actually becomes a stronger bias. So I would say that everything that has to do with choice architecture used to surprise me a lot. Because, you know, the general intuition is people make decisions. And to switch it to say the interface makes a lot of the decision was very hard to get used to it. Now that I got used to it, it no longer surprises me. But I think that was early on some of the biggest surprises. the thing that I think has been the most interesting in the last few years was an experiment we did in a slum in Kenya called Kibera and we tried to get people to save a little bit of money for a rainy day and we tried lots of different approaches we send them reminders we send them reminders from their kids we gave them money We lost aversion, all kinds of things.

22:16But we also had a coin, a coin that we made in China for about 20 cents. Most of it was shipping. And the coin had 24 numbers etched on the edges for the 24 weeks of the program. And we said, please keep the coin in your hut. And every week, take a knife and scratch the number of the week, week one, two, three, four. Scratch it like a minus if you didn't save. Scratch it up and down if you saved. And that coin doubled savings compared to everything else. And, you know, I came up with this coin idea because I thought it would work. But the fact that it worked so well, it worked better than a 20 % match with loss aversion, like it really worked much better than anything else, surprised me.

23:11Now in retrospect, it got me to think a lot differently And I'll tell you how it got me to think So I think that when it comes to spending money We can do things that are visible and things that are invisible Visible things is buying fruit, candy, water, kerosene If you're in Kibera Doing invisible things is saving money, buying insurance, paying debt And in general, if you think about a breadwinner that just happened to make some money today, they want to do visible things because they want their family member to maybe say thank you. But we also want them to do invisible things. And it's like an unfair fight between the visible and the non-visible.

23:55And what this coin did, in Kibera nobody visited each other's huts. It's like, you know, it's not a social issue. But it was a way for the parents to communicate to themselves, to their significant other and to the kid, that there's another economic activity happening. You know, usually if you buy a piece of fruit, somebody might say thank you. If you mark on the coin, maybe somebody would appreciate you. I don't think it will get to a thank you level, but it will be less invisible. And I think it's actually a very important thing about the world in general, that we have lots of things that are very important.

24:32take your medication, save money, buy insurance, that are largely invisible. And we need to make them more visible if we want to start creating more incentives and motivation around them. So that one, the experiment was surprising. And I started seeing this visible and invisible in lots of places after that. That's really, really interesting. It's a bit like, similar to the, this might be quite an old one this, but the pain when you actually give cash versus the pain experience when you put over a card, it's a bit like that, isn't it? You've got the physical handing over the dollars versus the plastic, which doesn't have that same, you know, kind of reaction.

25:21That's right. So this is really about attention, right? So if I pay with cash, I pay more attention. I feel what's called the pain of paying. I pay with the credit card. It's not as clear when I'm paying. I'm not paying much attention to it. I'll pay later. It doesn't feel the same. The invisible visible is a more extreme version of this because when something is invisible, you're not even giving the credit card, right? There's no sign of it. Like if we had dinner and I paid with a credit card. By the way, thanks for breakfast. But, you know, I know you paid for breakfast. But there's some things that we don't even know are happening.

25:59Like, think about your kids, right? What do they know about insurance savings? How much you... They probably see you not being home much. Like, you know, there's a very interesting situation where you're doing lots for your kids, most of it they're unaware of. Well, the insurance one's good actually from the house fire because you don't need insurance until something goes wrong. And when something goes wrong, the insurance is the most important thing in the world. So one thing I'm quite evangelical about is I tell everybody, check your house insurance. Because actually the bit of the story I didn't tell you was after the house burnt down, we then discovered that we weren't technically insured because they, the insurance company, claimed that we had put the wrong number of bedrooms listed on the documents.

26:51Now, we didn't have the documents because they'd burnt. And I then spent two weeks investigating, phoning up the archive department. Anyway, I did a long investigation trial. In the end, it was their mistake. But they actually wrote to us a legal letter to say we're not insured. So for a period of three weeks, we had not only lost our house, we actually thought we wouldn't be able to, you know. So what happened? You did write the number? Well, it's quite funny, actually. So the first thing I did is I was absolutely certain it was correct, because when we bought the house new and at the time in the UK, your insurance had to be linked to your mortgage.

27:27So I phoned the mortgage provider and I said, can you send me the documents from when the mortgage was taken out? And it said the correct number of bedrooms. Second thing I did is I phoned up pretending to be a new customer and said, could you give me a quote for how much you would pay? What are the premiums on this particular house? And gave me the address. And I matched the bank statements to the premium. Interesting thing, though, I was paying the full premium for 16 years. They hadn't given me any discount because you're supposed to get this discount every year as you don't make a claim. So I made that point on the letter.

27:58And the third thing I did is I had a mortgage broker who dealt with the insurance. And I said on his system, before it then got sent through to their system, what he put it in his system. And he'd put the correct number in. So I put the evidence, sent it to them. And then I got this very apologetic call from someone very senior in the insurance company saying, we've investigated. It's entirely our mistake. And that it was a manual computer. It was a computer error when they went from physical records to digital records about 10 years earlier. Someone had keyed in the wrong number of bedrooms. But then they should have reduced your premium.

28:34Yeah, yeah. And they didn't. They didn't, I know. What do you think? Was this a trick for them to try and get out of it or do you think it was a real mistake? I gave them the benefit of the doubt. I assumed it was a, well, I took them at face value actually. I assumed that it was an input error. And that's true, that's a good question actually. I gave them benefit of the doubt. Most people said they're just trying to get out of it. And I was like, well, that would be, you know, I've got enough evidence to suggest that it was true. And they were very, well, the apology actually was very sincere and it had gone up to a serious claims level in the insurance company.

29:09So someone very senior picked up the phone. But that was after a legal letter that I'd got telling me that I wasn't insured and that they were wiping their hands of any liability. So they'd gone very heavy-handed. That's amazing. And then I got the apology. So I don't know if you know, but I helped to create a business model for an insurance company. That solves this problem. Wow. So quite a few years ago, two entrepreneurs came to talk to me. And kind of behavioral economics has kind of a range of what we're good at. We're really good at little details. Like give me any sign-up flow and I can improve conversion.

29:50And give me any kind of repeated behavior and I can probably increase engagement. Right? There's a range of it that is like the study of little things that you don't think matters but end up mattering. And when you look at them with a fresh eye and knowing what we know about complexity and default bias and so on, you can improve things. But it's also a really good framework to design things from scratch. We say, okay, so what are we really trying to achieve here? So a few years ago, a couple of entrepreneurs came to me and they said that they wanted to start a digital insurance company. And I said, great.

30:33And they said, would you join us? And I said, no. I don't see any reason to join a digital insurance company, but I'm wishing you all the luck in the world. And they said, what can we do to convince you to join? And I said, look, from my perspective, from a social science perspective, The real challenge with insurance is trust. And I would be interested if we could create a business model that fixes the trust problem. So they said, what do you mean? I said, think about it. Insurance is a two-actor problem. You have the insurance company and you have the client. The client pays, pays, pays, 17 years.

31:18You pay, you pay, you pay. At some point, something better happens and you want to get paid. And the insurance company wants to not pay. It's a very simple situation. They make more money if they don't pay. And I don't think they're evil people, but the incentives are there for them not to pay. It's designed for that. Now you as the consumer know that they're not going to pay. So what do you do? Exaggerate your claim. I mean, lots of people who don't trust. So we create a system with no trust. The insurance doesn't pay, and then people exaggerate, and the insurance knows that people exaggerate, so they make it harder to exaggerate, and they make the whole process different.

32:00I said the whole thing, if you think about it, is a system with no trust, and everybody is trying to outsmart the other side, and it's a very, very costly system. You know, the cost to adjudicate a claim is very high, and what's called deadweight loss. Because there's no trust, how many weeks you had to spend working on this. I'm sure it's not the end of how much time it took you to... Well, the interesting thing in this situation was, I think it's unusual what they did, but we had to itemize everything, get a quote, all that sort of thing. But then they just wrote me a check for the amount. And I thought, oh, how generous.

Read the full transcript

32:39But then what I realized is, what most insurance companies do is they then project manage all the restoration back to the originals. And what they were doing was transferring the liability to me for anything that went overspent. And of course we go overspent. And also it minimized all the administration from their point of view. So it's just a case of we'll settle. Here's the chat. I mean, in my case, they were quite fair. They took their quote and my quote and went halfway between the two, which ended up probably okay. But yeah, it was interesting that that was their approach. Yeah. So they said, okay, so how do you solve it?

33:12So I said one solution, but this is the solution we ended up adopting, is to make it from a two-party game to a three-party game. So when anybody signs up for this insurance company, they pick a charity that they love the most in the world. Let's say it's the World Wildlife Fund. And this company now has a name, it's called Lemonade. When life gives you lemons. This company takes a fixed percent, let's say 20 % of the premium. And they say, this is our profit. We'll never take more. But if you joined and you said that your favorite charity in the world is the World Wildlife Fund, you're joining a pool of people who love the World Wildlife Fund.

34:02And we collect premiums and we pay claims. and at the end of the year, if there's money left over in the pool, it goes to the World Wildlife Fund. So the insurance company basically is saying up front, look, we are not going to make more money if we reject the claim. We don't want to be in that situation, right? You basically say, morally, I don't want to be in a situation where I make more money if I am unethical to you. But also if you as a customer cheats, who are you cheating? Yeah. Your favorite charity. Right. So it's a really nice solution. And if you look at the statistics on Lemonade, you'll see it's an unbelievably loved insurance company.

34:56And all kinds of things, all kinds of other good things come from this model. So for example, I think the record is to accept claims in about two seconds. Because the moment you trust people, things, and of course you have AI and so on, things are much, much, much, much faster. So this for me is an example of how you can, if you start looking at an industry from scratch and you say, what is the behavioral economics psychological issue? And you say the issue is trust. Insurance is a crazy trust situation. You have to really trust it. They'll be there for you. And if you don't have trust, everything is very expensive.

35:38So let's build a business model like that. That's fascinating that. I wanted to ask you as well about pricing, actually, because you'd think pricing is like the most rational thing ever, wouldn't you? But actually, there's a lot of kind of irrationality that comes through pricing. I mean, the one I remember from your first book that sort of made me smile was looking at how good looking people were. the George Clooney kind of thing. Explain a bit about that because it turns out that pricing, your relative pricing is a lot more important than your absolute pricing and how you frame it as well. Yeah, so pricing is a fascinating topic.

36:12And maybe to start with, I'll give you my metaphor for the human mind. So I think of the human mind as a vintage Swiss army knife. and let's two, vintage and Swiss army knife let's start with the Swiss army knife the human mind is basically a collection of tools we have tools to deal with food, mating dangers and so on the Swiss army knife is not really good at anything you wouldn't say oh I need a can opener, let me find the Swiss army knife I need tweezers, let me find no, it's benefit is that it's a lot of tools in a compact packaging. And our mind is the same thing. We're not that great in most things, but we're quite good at it and it's quite compact and we can carry it with us.

37:07But our Swiss army knife is an old Swiss army knife, vintage. It was designed for a period a long time ago when we roamed the savannah and had to deal with food and so on. But still, that's the Swiss army knife that we carry with us. So we get to the modern world and we don't have the right tools. So we rely on our ancient tools and they're not that good, but we make do with them. We don't understand how bad they are, but we don't have a tool for understanding compound interest. We don't have a tool to understand discounts and we don't have a tool to judge value in terms of money. So we use these other tools, and that's the source of the mistakes we make.

37:50So we already mentioned this pain of paying, right? Why is cash different than credit cards? Why is Apple Pay or Google Pay different than even a credit card? What happens when we pay with those things? We don't even remember how much we just paid. We all get surprised at the end of the month with our credit card bill because we are really bad at this. so the relativity effect that you're referring to relativity is a strategy that we apply across lots of things think about this room that we're sitting in it feels perfectly bright lit how much light do we have compared to sunlight just a fraction but our whole system basically gets used to the overall level and we just judge things in relative ways Your eyes are darker than your skin and so on.

38:42So relativity is a really good algorithm that we apply across many, many different things, including pricing. So when you say how expensive is expensive, I don't know. Compared to what? Like, you know, how much would you pay for a house? How much would you pay for a cup of coffee? Well, it depends on what's next to it. And the next to it could be a medium-sized coffee compared to large. and it could be a different house, but it could also be something else. So if we think about how much are we paying for a microphone, we might compare it to another gadget. So we do lots of things. What's a reasonable price?

39:24Let me understand how it is priced compared to other things. Compared to what? Whatever is comfortable to compare between. Just because we're talking about your house, I'll give you a housing example. So when you show people houses and you give them different asking prices, their bids change. How much they think their house is worth changes, right? And it gets closer to their asking price. When you look at professional real estate agents, they're also influenced. Not to the same degree, but they're also influenced. Or another example, you take people who move to a new city. If you move from an expensive city to a cheap city, people end up buying too much of a house.

40:16If you move from a cheap city to an expensive city, you buy too little of a house. You're still connected to the relative price of the place you moved from. If you rent for a year or two, the effect goes away because you got used to the new price. So relativity is very much everywhere. But I'll give you another example, one of my favorites. Part of how much you're willing to pay for something depends on fairness. And fairness is basically asking, how much did people work for me? So think about an example. Imagine you come to visit me at the university. You're parking next to a parking meter. You look in your pockets.

41:00You don't have a quarter. somebody passes by. You say, excuse me, do you have a quarter? And the person says, yes, I have a quarter. I'll sell it to you for a dollar. Most people say, I'm not paying you a dollar for a quarter. I'll take my chances with City Hall. Case number two, parking, parking meter. You don't have a quarter. Somebody passes by. You say, excuse me, do you have a quarter? And that person says, I don't have a quarter, but I'll tell you what. There's a bank not too far from here. If you want, I'll run really fast to that bank. I'll change a dollar for quarters. I'll come really quickly back.

41:34But if I run all this way to the bank and back for you, would you give me a dollar for my trouble? Now you think it's a great deal. Now in every objective way, you're worse off. You have to wait and you get sweaty coins. But why are you happier? Because somebody worked for you. And it turns out that this principle is very general, that we don't pay for what we get, It's not just for what we get. A lot of the components, the willingness to pay, is influenced by how much it costs, how much the person put effort into it. We just had coffee. People in the U.S. pay a lot of money for somebody who drips their coffee for them or do something like this.

42:22How much would you pay if the coffee was already in a bucket and they just poured it to a cup, it would feel very different. And it's true for lots of things. And, you know, lots of companies basically say people should appreciate the service we're giving them or the product we're giving them, and they don't need to know the details. Not true. Not true. Understanding the details sometimes increase the enjoyment from a product and almost always increases willingness to pay. I'll give you one example from pricing. So I went to visit this bank in a country I will not say, and we were talking about some banking-related issues, and then somebody came to the meeting, and he said that they have a new program.

43:15This was not the topic of our discussion, but they're going to stop charging people ATM fees. and he said, oh, my goodness, we're rolling this out in a few weeks, and we're expecting huge applause from our customers and so on. And I say, I think people would hate you for cutting the ATM price. So how can that be? I say, you think that people would say, thank you for not charging me anymore. I think people would say, oh, you bastards, why did you charge me for the last 10 years? and you know we disagreed on that I said look this is what I think you should do I think you should stop this program of doing it for free and I think instead of doing it for free you should tell people when they come to the ATM you should tell people the price of a transaction on an ATM is X let's say$1.50 but we understand that not everybody has the money so if you want to pay less pay as much as you want up to zero.

44:22Now I said, what would you do with this message? The worst you could do is get zero, but you would give people the sense that this is not free. I mean, ATMs cost money, right? You have the machine, people come to fill money, there's technology, there's data, there's all kinds of things. Of course, it was two, three weeks before launch, they didn't do it, and I was correct. People really hated them. for what they were doing. But it tells you again that pricing is not just pricing. You would say from a rational perspective, people are saying, oh my goodness, it's the same ATM, and now they're charging me less.

45:02What a great idea. But of course the psychology is much more complex than that. By the way, name your own price. Fascinating, fascinating topic. We just did a really interesting, it was an experiment, but we did it to help an organization that had like an event where people were buying tickets. And they wanted to reduce the price of the tickets. So imagine that the regular ticket is$100, but they want students to be able to apply, so they wanted$35. So you could say something like students 35, not students 100, but maybe there are people who are not students and can't afford it. So their thought was to reduce their tickets to 35 and then to find some philanthropist who would make up the difference.

45:56And I said, you know, that's just not the right approach. Why don't you tell people? $100 is the real price. If you can't afford it, pay 35. so I said to start with you'll not get 35 from everybody some people would pay 100 and it's about the morality of the people maybe not everybody who could afford it some people would trade it but at least it will not be zero but I said on top of that put another price level that says but if you're financially okay and you can subsidize another person go ahead and do that And think about this. You're saying it's not us against you. It's not the event versus you, the ticket holders.

46:43It's all of you ticket holders are a community. And if you have money, why don't you fund another community member who can't pay their price? And it ended up being fantastic. It ended up being fantastic. There was even one person who donated for 10 people. Really? Wow. For 10 people. So, you know, name your own price and fairness and question of community. Like, you know, it doesn't sound like money, but the psychology of money is really fascinating. It's sort of like the social contract versus economic one, isn't it? I mean, weirdly, my very, very first economics lecture at university, I studied economics and finance.

47:24It was probably where my love of behavioral economics started because the lecture was trying to explain the difference between total cost and marginal. costs right and the story he told was um he had booked um a holiday no his friend had booked a holiday and um they're they're getting this cottage by the sea and they had some spare uh capacity and they really had some spare rooms and over dinner they said would you like to come along and so the lecturer said that being an economics professor he said we'd love to come along we will offer to pay the marginal cost for us coming along so the extra food the extra wine maybe there's any more petrol to pick us up on the way.

48:00And the friend turned him down sort of thing because it wasn't fair because it's like, well, you know, the cost of, you know, we're saving you all the cost of holiday and you're paying the marginal cost. And I just thought, you know, who would accept that because it's kind of breaking the rules of friendship, which is, you know, you're in it together, you want to split the costs and that's how most people would do it. But yeah, in that question, though, it's also interesting whether these people stayed their friends. Well, exactly. Exactly, didn't have many friends after that. You know, there's a couple of things where economists, so there was a study that looked at who donates to charity, and it turns out the economics department is the lowest.

48:38Economics is a very interesting profession. It's a profession that gets you to think that everybody is rational and to adopt this perspective. Everybody is, you know, it's a wonderful framework. Like it's so interesting and engaging, and it explains some of the variance, but it makes you feel that it explains lots of the variance. But if you buy into it, you expect people to be perfectly rational actors. And when people are not perfectly rational actors, like what he should have offered these people on the holidays is the marginal cost plus a pound, right? How could they reject that? They would be generous.

49:19It would be a pound. It would be a pound. Because if you just offer them the marginal cost, there would be neutral. There's no neutral. But you could have offered them an extra pound. Now they should have taken the deal. But economists get those things wrong because they don't only think of themselves as rational, but they think that other people are rational. Nobody has ever done a study on how romantic life for economists. Well, that would be a very good study. What happens with gifts, what happens with all kinds of things. Yeah, because everything is utility in economics. How do I maximize utility in every transaction?

49:53But as you say in your books as well, we know from system one, is that people make decisions a lot more based on how they feel than how they think. Yeah, and it's perfectly fine, right? So if you say, for example, talk about gifts. I love gifts. And gifts are not about an economic value. Like, I will not buy you socks. I wouldn't put 20 pounds in your bank account this is not a gift if it's about a gift then you basically say what are the things that would lubricate our social exchange what are the things that would get us to act better so maybe I'll ask you what's the best gift you've ever given and the best gift you ever got probably i've just turned 50 congratulations thank you and i'd say everything associated with that like the you know the photos so my brothers for example um recreate in fact they they borrowed the podcast artwork and they recreated it to tell different stories of our relationship over the years kind of thing um so not much cost involved in that but they'd gone to a lot of effort and it was quite funny the way the different they created different titles to describe different personality traits for me.

51:14And they did a talk at the dinner kind of thing. And my family brought, you know, designed some lovely photos of all the holidays we've been on and did it in a collage and that kind of thing. So, yeah, I'd say those things that were symbolic of relationship probably were the most meaningful. Yeah, because it's a concrete reminder and it's a lot of work and it tells you something about their thoughts about you. It's an interesting thing to think about what are really good gifts, what are we trying to get to it. So I'll tell you about one gift. This is a gift at the workplace, so much lower. I can tell you later about personal gifts.

51:58But the people who work with me at the lab, every year I try to do an end-of-the-year gift, and I don't start with what I want to give. I start with what I want to convey or what I want to change. And the things I wanted people to get reinforcement for is the fact that I care about them in general, not just as people working with me, but I care about people. The gift is not backward-looking, it's forward-looking. And I want to do something for them that they couldn't do themselves. Or not couldn't, but wouldn't do themselves. So my favorite one was a year where I asked everybody to write one paragraph about something they want to learn up to 10 days somewhere in the world.

52:51And I said, I'll send you to learn that thing. Coach, cheap hotels, but I'll send you to do that. And it was amazing because people did lots of wonderful things. They learned all the way from cartooning to drumming to yoga to French, all kinds of things that people wanted to do. Of course, you don't learn anything fully in 10 days, but it was also a wonderful year because people kept on coming and going and they kept on anticipating and coming back and describing what they were doing. And I think it conveyed all the feelings. It conveyed that I cared about them as people. It wasn't a, here's a course in statistics.

53:34right it was something that i thought they couldn't do they wouldn't do it for themselves because it was a little expensive and in a little bit of time and it was forward looking right it's not payment for the back like you did x i'm i'm giving you a something but it says look we have an ongoing relationship and i care about your your well-being in general forward looking you're right actually it's kind of like it's effort and uh personalization a bit isn't it so my younger daughter lilia is a massive fan of crumble cookies which we don't have in the uk so every time i come over to new york uh you know i have to go and find a crumble cookies outlet and she's online looking because they change the cookies every week right so she's online going daddy can you order the snickerdoodle uh you know with a you know with a cookies and cream and she'll have looked up all the different options and then i have to go and find grumble cookies obviously order the they come in this beautiful long box you know nicely laid out bright pink and then i have to carry it you know pack it in my bags carry it through security get it on the plane on in the train in the car all the way back to the sort of thing so the effort that goes through and funnily enough actually when everyone notices it on on the plane as well because it's with bright packaging so it always starts conversations i have to tell the story this is for my daughter who you know did a sort of thing But it's partly the effort, isn't it?

54:55Signalling the effort you're going to and the fact that it's personal to the person you're buying it for. Yeah. And are you trying to, you know, we talked about effort before. Are you trying to remind her of the effort when you give it to her? Not to make you feel guilty. No, I always remind her of the effort. Honestly, I just explain the effort. But, you know, there are also ways to do that, right? So you probably don't want to say, look how much time you cost me. but you could imagine telling her saying look buying you these cookies was really wonderful because I knew you wanted them and I was looking forward to going to the store and as I was buying them I was thinking about you and then I was carrying them in the plane and the whole time I was thinking how happy you would be when you got the cookies and now we're here and here are the cookies and I want you to just remember how much I love you every time you have one of them, right?

55:51And if you think about that kind of a story, it's a story that endows the cookies with a meaning that is not just about the taste of the cookie. And I think that part of the things we don't do enough is to endow things with meaning. And I'll tell you kind of a funny story, not funny, but a story that happened to me. So there's a guy, Bill Harlan, who is a wine grower in California. Supposedly fantastic wines. I've drank them, but I'm not a wine connoisseur. But anyway, I really like the guy. And from time to time I go and I spend some time with him. And on this particular day I spend a whole day with him.

56:40And I look at the soil and picking the grapes and doing all the process and so on. and we have dinner and he gives me a bottle of wine. He says, Dan, this wine we picked when you, me, Dan, were 30 years old, so quite a few years ago, and we got 100 points from Parker. 100? 100 points. And he said, I want you to keep this wine until you're 50 and drink it when you're 50. So I was 45 at the time, about 45. So then I had this bottle of wine, and I kept it somewhere visible. Maybe I should have kept it in some cooler place, but I wanted to see it. And it was a reminder of when I was 30. And it was a reminder of my beautiful, wonderful day with Bill.

57:38And it was a reminder that I have some time to wait until the wine will be ready. And then when I turned 50, I didn't want to drink it because I got attached to this bottle and wine and remembering the day with Bill and it's a beautiful day in California and really wonderful discussion. But I did have to drink it. So I bought a decanter. I bought a decanter and I decanted that wine into the decanter and the decanter got some of the meaning of the wine. So now when I see that decanter, it's the decanter that connected to that day with Bill and so on. Now, if you think about that or, you know, the cookies for your daughter and so on, I think we don't do enough of that.

58:24And maybe wine is kind of the best even category to think about meaning because wine is one of the few categories that we have a consumption vocabulary around. we have tannin, complexity, acidity, leg we pick up the glass in many ways you could say, oh this is fake people can't tell the difference your taste bud cannot tell the difference in the wine and people argue about that but in another level it's not about whether your taste bud can do something different it's about attention so if I sit next to my laptop and drink a glass of wine I'm not going to pay much attention. I'm not going to particularly enjoy it.

59:10It's going to be okay. But if I stop and look and smell and slow down and sip and so on, the whole experience is very valuable. So kind of there's meaning that is connected and basically occupies more of our higher function in our brains. And then there's also the experience itself that we could direct by creating consumption vocabulary. Yeah, the environment to wine is so important, isn't it? Where you are, who you're with. I mean, I've had like the same wine in one country and then again in another country. It's completely different just because I'm in the vineyard, the sun's shining, I'm outdoors, and with somebody telling me about it, it's incredible.

59:54Yeah, I went to a vineyard. I had such a good time. The owner was amazing and a beautiful day with a friend. When I got home with the same bottles of wine, I couldn't drink them. Yes, I know. Exactly. I've had that experience so many times. Maybe pivoting slightly from good times to less good times, actually, because you've written a new book, Misbelief. I read it last night and it just blew my mind. For anyone who's not read it yet, describe, because, you know, your career in behavioral science started with a pretty bad event for you personally. And then this is another pretty bad event that happened to you that inspired another book.

1:00:33What happened to... So during COVID, I did not realize for a while, but I became very hated. There were a group of people who thought that I helped about bringing COVID. They called me the chief consciousness architect. They thought I was part of the cabal, the Illuminati, and I was part of the conspiracy. And they gave me a lot of power. They said, how can it be that people are so compliant? It must be that you're working to get people to be like sheep and so on. But it was tough. I had death threats, people burning my books. It was very, very aggressive. And there was like one day when I discovered that.

1:01:15And I spent about a month trying to prove that this was not correct. Failed miserably, really miserably. And then at the end of that month, I said, okay, I have to understand what's going on. And, you know, kind of misinformation, fake news has been around for a while, right? What's happening in the UK, what's happening in the US, the world over. But it was kind of in the background. But all of a sudden, there was something very powerful about somebody saying to me, you did this. And I said, no, I didn't do this. Like, people were sure I had a contract with Pfizer. And there was nothing I could do.

1:02:02show. I even told somebody, I'll show them my tax returns to see that I... Anyway. So I describe in a short way my experience. That's not the main point of the book. The book is really saying, okay, I gave up on explaining myself. Let me understand these people. In general, the approach of behavioral economics and psychology is to say that things are not random. The reason we have relativity, the pain of pain and so on, there's a reason to it. And in the same way, I think that conspiracies or misbeliefs are not for nothing. They are maybe not a desirable reaction, but they are a reaction to something.

1:02:47And I basically describe, the book is a description of the process by which this new world of information is attacking us. and it's almost like an introduction to psychology textbook because it covers emotion and stress, it covers the cognitive process, the personality process and the social process and it describes this machinery that is taking good, kind, wonderful people and turning them into something very different. And we kind of all have these people in our lives and the question is what happened to them and then what can we do about it And also what should we do as a society? So that's really what the book is.

1:03:30I will say that as I dug deeper and deeper and talked to more and more people, on one hand, I realized how big the problem was. You know, if 10 years ago we would have made a list of the big problems of society, misinformation wouldn't have been there. Now it's one of the biggest ones. And it's one of the biggest ones because we have lots of challenges that we have to solve as a society. And if we can't agree on anything, we can't move forward, right? And it's true. It's true for almost all countries. So I think that we have to understand this and we have to figure out some mechanisms. And there are some things that we could do individually, but there are some things we need to solve as a society.

1:04:20Do you think that you spoke to, you actually spoke, didn't you, personally to a lot of the people that were writing the stuff about you? Oh, yeah. Do you think, are people doing it intentionally? Or is there a conspiracy to conspiracy? Are they kind of setting out to unsettle what they perceive as, or are these people unconsciously going, you call it the funnel, don't you? Are they unconsciously kind of going through those stages? is. So there's no question that there are big forces behind lots of social media in the form of bots from all kinds of dark regimes around the world. I don't think I'm connected to that.

1:04:59So I don't think I'm sufficiently important that somebody in, you know, country X would say, let's get Dan down. Now, do bots help? Of course, because a lot of these bots, once they see a fight, they join in because they want to create fights. But I don't think I was a target of anything. I think it was started naturally. And I think, so, So, you know, the woman who I think started it, like patient zero, and the woman that as far as I could identify started it was somebody who was very stressed about what was happening with her son and masks and so on. And she read that I was advising the Ministry of Education.

1:05:56She knew because she really liked my research before that I did some projects on vaccines. and she knew that I worked with the Gates Foundation. Now, I worked with the Gates Foundation on child nutrition in Africa, but not. But anyway, she connected the dots, made a story, and then it got a life of its own. And it got a life so much of its own that at some point, I became like a social currency. I think the half a beard was also helpful for them because it's so easy to villainize. You had half and half, half devil, why didn't you, your whole face was burned, things like that. But I think that she connected the dots, the non-existing connection, and made the story out of there, and then it just got a life of its own.

1:06:51And when things get a life of their own, it just gets very popular. But I gave Chachi Pitti the book, and I asked you to summarize it in one word and it said empathy i was very happy with this you're very empathetic in the book actually because you i mean most people would be angry yeah most people would be defensive most people go on the attack but to your credit what you do is try and understand first and use it a bit like with your original you know when you had your burns is you wanted to understand and use that process which i guess is healing isn't it in a way yeah for you personally isn't it but that's a really healthy kind of approach to advocacy most people don't have that toolkit when this stuff happens right it is yeah it is it was it was in some way my my way of coping was not was not to get angry with them and this but to but to try and to try and understand and and as a social scientist it was very natural for me to do that and you know there's lots of things to talk about but maybe we'll mention one one factor so we said that there are four elements and and the thing that starts people down the funnel of misbelief is stress.

1:08:00And maybe I'll give one example of how this works. So there's something we call white noise. And in hearing white noise, it's like full spectrum noise. In vision, it's about, it's like imagine a painting with red, with black and white dots randomly sorted out. That's called white noise. And imagine I show you one of those and I say, hey, do you see a figure? And you say, yes and no, I show you the next one. The next one, I show you 50 of those. What happens when we're stressed? It turns out that when we're stressed, we see more images. And why is it? Imagine you're an animal in the jungle and you think there's a tiger somewhere.

1:08:42Your system is completely honed in to say, oh, these two leaves are moving, there must be something there, right? When we're stressed, our system gets you into overdrive to explain the world to ourselves. And that's exactly what happened to these women and happened to lots of other people under stress. And stress can come from COVID, finance, what's happening with AI, what is happening in terms of the war in Ukraine, what's happening in Gaza, who are these Houthis, what's happening with Iran, and so on and so forth. My students, by the way, are very stressed about will they have a job with everything coming with AI.

1:09:21So the first necessary condition is stress. And if you're happy and resilient, you're not looking for alternative explanations, but when something bad is happening and you're stressed, you're looking for something to explain that, and you go into that. And then there's lots of other processes, the cognitive, the personality, but maybe let's mention one other one which we call shibboleth. And it's part of the social element. and the term Shibboleth comes from a story in the Bible that these two tribes had a war, they settled on two sides of the river and then when they walked around, they wanted to know if the people that they meet are from their tribe or the other tribe.

1:10:00And it just so happened that they pronounced the name of the plant Shibboleth slightly differently. One of them said Shibboleth, one of them said Seaboleth. So imagine I walk around, I have a plant and I say, hey, you, how do you call this plant? And if you call it the way I call it, We're friends, we're brothers, we're from the same tribe. If you call it like the other tribe, I have to fight you or chase you away. Now, we now use this term shibbolet for a discussion that is not about the facts, but it's about identity. Because I show you the plant and say, what's the name of this plant? Do I really care about the plant?

1:10:34No, I care about identity. And if you look at a lot of things in our political sphere, or you look at lots of things in social media, you can recognize Shibboleth once you have this lens you can say oh it's very confusing, is this about the fact or is this about identity and you can say okay, it's not really about the fact it is about identity and the discussion about identity is a very different discussion I'm protesting, I'm saying things it has nothing to do with the facts it has to do with showing my purity my values my anti-pro whatever for and as you say in the book it's not a left or right thing is it both left and right are equally you know liable to to have the it's almost signaling isn't it your allegiance to the cause it doesn't really matter whether the truth of truth in that sense doesn't matter it's the signaling that's right and everybody thinks that the other side has lots of misbeliefs and their side is completely accurate it is also interesting to i give some examples in the book for asking people to reflect on their most basic beliefs and how sure they are and where they got it from.

1:11:46But what would have happened if you were born with the same you, were born to a family with the opposite political opinion than your parents? Oh, interesting. Right. What do you think your beliefs would be? And most people say, you know, I would have been different. So we have a, in retrospect, we can say, oh, all of my beliefs are reasoned and thoughtful and they're based on facts and logic. But a lot of them are not. We don't know that much and so on. Now you have a real ability to put your finger on some hot topics. Where are you going next? What's the next book in your mind? So I have a website called the Center for Advanced Bureaucracy.

1:12:37I complain about bureaucracy. I think it's one of the... Slowing me up to that one. Yeah. But I have two large topics that I'm working on mostly these days. One is about thinking about the last chapter of people's lives. So I'm thinking about a journey from the time that people get a terminal illness diagnosis until the end of life, and trying to understand all the mistakes that people do in that process and how we can help. And, you know, there are lots of mistakes. Like in the beginning, people become patients rather than people with an illness. It's like a job, and you basically say, okay, my job is to adhere to medicine.

1:13:15No, no, no. Your job is to live and figure out this. People buy into the medical perspective of prolonging life at all costs. People end up taking extra treatment that they don't want. people end up dying in hospital when they don't want. So there's lots of mistakes along the way that I'm trying to analyze, understand, and offer some solutions. So that's one. And then the second one is thinking about how do we live a life that is more fulfilling by making bolder decisions. So whenever you have a risk, there's an upside and downside. and the upside is where improvement comes from and the downside is mistakes.

1:13:59And I think that risk is the spice of life. People think variety is the spice of life. No, I think that risk is the real spice of life. The challenge is that when you have a choice and you have an upside and a downside, the downsides are capturing too much of our attention. We're too afraid to fail. We're afraid of people hating us socially. We're afraid of cancel culture. So we live a timid life. And when you look at young people these days, they live even a more timid life than we do. There's some really sad statistics on young people not dating as much, not expressing romantic love, not sharing their feelings.

1:14:47And the world is becoming more like that. When we started talking and I said something about sexuality and scars, it's a punishing world, right? You can imagine, I'm very happy I'm not afraid of saying this, but there's something about this world that there's some topics that we don't talk about and so on. And, you know, we've all made mistakes. And we all know that we would love to share those mistakes because there's no reason for everybody to repeat the same mistakes again, right? So I've made a ton of mistakes. And it will give me great pleasure to know that I'm helping some people not relive those mistakes exactly the same.

1:15:37So I think I'm analyzing the reasons. So I'm writing this book where I'm trying to analyze the reasons why. The first part is why we're making, why are we so afraid? And then the second one is to come up with solutions. So I'm just trying to, I'm now in the solution part of it and I'm really, really enjoying it. But I'll tell you two other things. I started writing kids' books. Oh, did you? Yeah, just finished the second one and I'm writing the third. The first one is on procrastination. I think it will be out later in the year maybe beginning next year the second one is about allowances and the third will be about white lies and then I don't know if you know but I helped write a TV show that is loosely based on my life it's now showing the second season on NBC do you star yourself?

1:16:31no no no it's a real TV show there's a real actor but he also has burns not as much as I do and he was burned in a different way He teaches behavioral economics and he's helping the FBI solve his crime. And then the other thing I'm trying to do kind of for the fund is that the same people who did the show asked me to pitch a reality show that is social science based. So I'm now thinking about that. So the creative side of my life is very, very. Well, you're definitely taking the risks and not letting fear of failure get in your way. Actually, you just reminded me of something I think we chatted about before, but I remember going to Tel Aviv and meeting a venture capitalist and I was fascinated by how he chose to invest in the people.

1:17:20And he flipped on his head and said, if you walk in here and tell me you haven't failed, that's our conversation over. and what he was really interested in is how you come back from failure and what and what you've learned and you know he was looking to invest in people that have been through that process learned from it and moved on which was always fascinating yeah and and i think there's a lot to it it's not just a failure it's also knowing that these people are resilient right you you want you want somebody that that understands failure and you want somebody who's developed the resilience to deal with all kinds of things.

1:17:53It doesn't have to be fair. Actually, I met the Olympic swimming coach for the Australian team that won gold last two Olympics, Dean Boxall, massively exciting guy, really, really pumped up, enthusiastic. And he said, look, with the Gen Z, everyone says to me, you know, how do you coach Gen Z? And he said, don't ever tell me that they don't work as hard. They work as hard as any set of athletes I've ever had in my life. the difference comes when they don't succeed yeah he said i have to become psychologist and he said all my job now is talking them through what happens when they don't reach their standards that they've set for themselves he said that that's that's the difference you know the ability to pick yourself back up and go again which you've got lots of experience of obviously what you've been through so so you're well placed to uh to write the book dan thank you mate it's been uh an absolute pleasure i feel like we've just skimmed the surface we did we did it's um you know it feels like we should continue this on the pint of somewhere in the pub.

1:18:55I think that's exactly what we should do. And just to say, everyone out there, go look up Dan. Get his books. They're absolutely fascinating. And it's like a whole world of fascinating social science awaits you. So go check it out. It was a pleasure. Thank you very much for listening or watching Uncensored CMO. I hope you enjoyed that. If you did, please do hit the subscribe button wherever you get your podcasts. If you're watching, hit subscribe there as well. I'd also love to get a review. Reviews make a big difference on other people discovering the show. So please do leave a review wherever you get your podcasts.

1:19:28If you want to contact me, you can do. I'm over on x at Uncensored CMO or on LinkedIn, where I'm under my own name, John Evans. Thanks for listening and watching. I'll see you next time.

From the publisher

In this episode, we deep dive into the irrational world of customer behaviour with legendary behavioural economist Dan Ariely. Dan reveals why we’re all predictably wrong, how tiny invisible cues can radically change price perception, and why effort makes things feel more valuable. We also unpack the real reason people fall for misinformation, how to rebuild trust in broken industries like insurance, and why letting customers choose their own price might just be your smartest move. If you want to understand what truly drives decisions — and how to use that insight to become a better marketer — this one’s unmissable.

Timestamps:

00:00:00 - Intro
00:00:50 - The story of Dan Ariely’s half beard
00:07:53 - Dan’s painful introduction into behavioural science
00:11:46 - Reaction to Jon’s house tragedy
00:15:11 - The hidden truths revealed by social science
00:21:43 - Invisible vs visible motivation
00:29:20 - How Dan would change insurance companies
00:33:30 - Lemonade insurance example
00:35:39 - Why the human brain is a vintage Swiss Army knife
00:38:08 - How context radically changes price perception (the relativity effect)
00:45:01 - Why you should let your customer choose their own price
00:47:11 - Why economists donate the least to charities
00:49:58 - Why effort greatly increases your price perception
01:00:06 - The real cause of misinformation and why it isn’t what you might think
01:12:18 - What will be Dan Ariely’s new book?
01:13:38 - Why we are so afraid of mistakes

More from Uncensored CMO

All 210 episodes
Dan Ariely: the hidden forces that shape your customers' decisionsUncensored CMO · 1 h 20 min
Listen in VO