Reloaded: How to be a successful challenger - Adam Morgan (2020)

27 Dec 2023 · 56 min

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Uncensored CMO: Episode Summary

Episode Title

Reloaded: How to be a successful challenger - Adam Morgan (2020)

Podcast Description The Uncensored CMO explores the realities of marketing theory and practice, highlighting both successes and failures in the industry. This episode revisits the insights of Adam Morgan, the founder of eatbigfish and author of influential books on marketing.

Key Themes and Insights

  • Challenger Brands: Adam Morgan articulates what it means to be a challenger brand and how these brands can successfully compete against market leaders.
  • Transformation Through Constraints: The discussion emphasizes the potential for innovation and creativity that arises from operating within restrictions.
  • Cultural Shifts: Morgan discusses how brand culture impacts success, particularly for brands in competitive markets.

Highlights of the Episode

  1. The Advantage of Being No. 2
  2. Being the Underdog: Morgan explains why being a challenger (No. 2) can be advantageous and how it fosters innovation and agility compared to the complacency of market leaders.
  1. Personal Anecdotes
  2. Morgan shares personal experiences of facing rejection from prominent figures like Phil Knight, which shaped his understanding of brand positioning.
  3. He reflects on a career-defining moment when a project was shelved but led to the creation of his influential book, "Eating The Big Fish."
  1. Execution Over Ideas
  2. Obsessed with Execution: He emphasizes the importance of over-committing and being dedicated to execution rather than solely focusing on ideas or strategies.
  1. Case Study: Tony's Chocolonely
  2. Reframing the Chocolate Market: Morgan uses Tony’s Chocolonely as an example of a challenger brand that has successfully reframed the conversation around ethical chocolate consumption.
  1. The Curse of Data
  2. Morgan critiques the over-reliance on data in marketing, which can stifle creativity and innovation.
  1. The Fertile Zero Concept
  2. Morgan introduces the idea of using lack of budget as a catalyst for creativity, encouraging brands to turn constraints into opportunities for innovation.
  1. The Importance of Authenticity
  2. The discussion highlights the need for brands to create emotional connections through authentic storytelling rather than relying on polished marketing messages.

Key Takeaways

  • Challenger brands must create their own identity and not merely mimic larger, established brands.
  • Constraints can drive innovation; the idea of "Beautiful Constraints" suggests that limitations can lead to creative breakthroughs.
  • A shift in culture and mindset is necessary for individuals within larger organizations to act with the entrepreneurial spirit of a challenger brand.
  • Authenticity is vital; consumers are drawn to brands that resonate emotionally and represent genuine values.

Final Thoughts This episode of Uncensored CMO featuring Adam Morgan serves as an insightful resource for marketers, entrepreneurs, and brand managers looking to understand the dynamics of challenger brands and the importance of fostering innovation through constraints and authentic storytelling.

Follow-Up

For more insights, follow

  • John Evans: [Twitter](https://twitter.com/uncensoredCMO), [LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/in/jon-evans-9b1b671)
  • Adam Morgan: [Twitter](https://twitter.com/eatbigfish), [eatbigfish website](https://www.eatbigfish.com)

Contact Information

  • Uncensored CMO Website: [www.uncensoredcmo.com](http://www.uncensoredcmo.com/)
  • Email: jon@uncensoredcmo.com

This episode encapsulates a journey through the world of challenger branding, emphasizing the necessity for creativity, cultural transformation, and authenticity in marketing strategies.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:28Welcome back everybody to Uncensored CMO. has had a bigger impact on my career than anybody else. I love what he's done and I was so inspired to record this episode. It's an absolute gem. And what we've done is we actually left the original intro where producer James asked me about why I like it so much. I won't say much more about it because you'll get that, but I hope you enjoy it. This is my favourite episode from all 113 episodes of Uncensored CMO. Welcome back everyone to the Uncensored CMO. Yes, welcome back. Who have we got on the podcast today, John? Right. I'm really pleased because today we have got Adam Morgan.

1:05And the reason why I'm really, really pleased we've got Adam is he's probably influenced my career more than anybody else. He is an absolute legend. He wrote a book almost 20 years ago now, actually, called Eat Big Fish, about how challenger brands can take on the dominant player in their category and win. And I just found it so inspiring. and he's written some follow-up books since then, but he is a genuine legend of the industry. How has he influenced your career? Has he really had that much influence? He has, and I'll tell you why he has. Because, look, if you're listening and you're working on the number one brand and you've got loads of budget and you've got loads of resources, then good luck to you, right?

1:44But most of us don't have huge budgets and most of us are competing, right? Most of us are the underdog. And what fascinates me is how the underdog can succeed and overthrow the dominant player in the marketplace and so when i was early in my career i found myself gravitating to the exciting challenger brands the inner you know the innovation the brands that were kind of number two number three and trying to overthrow number one and for some reason i've always found it more exciting to be the challenger than the challenged and what adam's done brilliantly he's understood what makes a challenger brand successful and you know unless you're the dominant player you are in a position trying to compete with a bigger you know someone bigger than you and his principles are spot on for how you might do that why should we trust adam he's spent more time with more founders and done more research and what's brilliant about adam is he's he's gone and met so many people and he's drawn inspiration from all their stories and basically looked at what is the pattern between entrepreneurs that make them succeed what what the principles and he's distilled that down into sort of you know a handful of key principles that make challengers succeed and it's brilliantly inspiring i mean i know for me what i found was i found it actually quite lonely being a challenger because i mean if i go back to my background i was in britvik i was setting up a like a challenger brand unit managing innovation and um i didn't i found it hard to uh get inspiration from within the business because no one else was doing what i was doing and i met adam and read his books and uh you know kind of followed him closely and just found him a massive source of inspiration.

3:19Where do you think challenger brands fall down most? Do you think they try to have a big company mentality? Why is it important to consider yourself as a challenger brand and get the help or advice to someone like Adam? Well, the thing as a challenger brand is you've got to change the game in your favour. So if you try to be a small version of the big brand, then you're going to fail. You're going to be outgunned. You're going to be outspent, outresourced in terms of feet on the street or whatever it is. And the thing with the challenge is you have to come up with your own identity. You have to reframe the category in your advantage and you have to overcommit and be quicker and more agile and you have to do things differently.

3:56And that's what fascinated me is because also big companies actually have got their own problems because big companies are slow, they're bureaucratic, they're internally focused, they worry more about process than actual performance. And that's where I see small companies succeeding because they can go in those gaps and exploit them. Who's going to find this episode most useful, do you think? Well, naturally, anyone who's in a startup, anyone who's kind of wanting to have a startup is going to find it obviously really interesting. But the fascinating thing is, and actually I said to Adam, I think this is the gem within his kind of in the three books he's written, is actually he's got advice for people that are in bigger organizations that want to be entrepreneurial or want to change the organization.

4:39It's a book he wrote called The Pirate Inside. So actually, if you're in a big company and you've got those entrepreneurial urges to, you know, to transform the business, he's also got advice on how you do that. And then actually his third book is called A Beautiful Constraint, which is talking about how sometimes your constraints are actually your advantages. Because when you don't have money, you've got to be creative and you've got to think outside the box. And actually it's using the limitations you have to your advantage is really powerful. And he talks about that in the podcast. So I hope and believe that actually pretty much anybody listening is going to get a lot out of this.

5:15Yeah, should we listen to it? Let's do it.

5:20Welcome, Adam. Well, thank you. And I'm just delighted, obviously, being a challenger enthusiast and being number two in your podcast list. I think it's the perfect ranking for me, and I'm very pleased to be here. Thank you. And in fact, it takes me back to one of my probably favourite ever ad campaigns of Avis, of course, which is absolute genius. So we're number two, so we try harder, which I just thought was one of the iconic challenger brands of our time. Well, it's interesting you should mention that, actually, because having not thought about it a lot for a number of years, I came back to a quote from somebody at Pixar talking about why it was that we responded to characters and the protagonists and the underdogs in Pixar.

5:56And she said, we respond to them because they try harder. I thought it was just a really interesting observation that actually, whatever it is, 60 years after Avis, still there's that kind of cultural truth about why we root for the plucky underdog that still is a mass cultural insight, I think. That's so true. It's interesting because I love my cycling and there's an online retailer called Wiggle. And what they're basically famous for is their customer service because it's online only, but you know that you get absolutely brilliant customer service if anything goes wrong. And that's basically what's been behind their success because all cyclists will go, oh, yeah, you know, you definitely go and get it from Wiggle.

6:31And it is the number two we try out. They're, of course, the number one now. So, you know, they now need to reinvent themselves and stay ahead. So, listen, let's start at the beginning. I'd love to hear how you got to where you are today. So take us right back to the beginning of the story. How did you get into this in the first place? So I was always going to be, I thought, a diplomat. My dad was a diplomat. I was born in China. I lived in what was then Yugoslavia, the Philippines, Sierra Leone, traveled all over the world, loved it. Different country every three years, different culture every three years.

7:01Really exciting, kind of continually evolving, kind of innovative take on life. And of course, you learn so much more about yourself and your own world from seeing other worlds. And I became kind of slightly addicted to this. And then the year before I was kind of due to graduate and enter on the kind of application process for diplomatic service, I was doing a summer job in a department store. And there was a young woman working in the tartan department. And I fell for her and her dad was in advertising. And I thought, this advertising business, this looks quite fun. And, you know, they had a lovely house and were great people.

7:35And I thought, OK, maybe I should try this just as a backup in case the other thing doesn't work, plan A doesn't work. and actually I got into advertising they offered me a job long before the foreign office ever did and so I thought I'll try it for two years I can always go back stuck with it loved it and found myself always working on what in creative environments creative companies that prize creativity and strategy because the companies that came to them were never the market leader they were effectively the number two or number three or number four and so I worked on you know Virgin Atlantic in the early days when there were just two planes.

8:08I then went to the States and worked on Sony PlayStation when it was launching up against Sega and Nintendo. And nobody ever thought it could succeed against those two. And of course, it did. I worked on the relaunch of Apple in Europe when Steve Jobs came back. And so, I'd worked on what were effectively challenges that nobody called them challenges. And so, when a friend came along to me, who was the new business director of the agency I was returning to, TBWA, in Europe in 1999 to become the strategic planning director and said, we specialize in challenger brands. I thought, this is fantastically interesting.

8:39What else have you got on this, Kate? And she said, well, nothing. It's just a line in a creds deck. And I said, well, look, let's make it mean something. So if I maybe take six months out to kind of research and write all about challengers, then it can be the book for the agency. And I took six months out and I wrote it. I completely misplayed the whole thing. I spent far too long getting to the interviews. I had a very long kind of facts interchange with Phil Knight or someone pretending to be Phil Knight at Nike, trying to get an interview with him. And he just declined and declined and declined very charmingly each time.

9:10And so I just wasted too much time to get the interviews. And so I was 18 months late finishing the book. And by the time I finished the book, the agency didn't want it anymore. Well, it was interesting because they said, well, we're not sure we want to be about Challenger now, Adam. We thought we might want to be about leaders now. We've done the Challenger thing for a while. We think actually, you know, we've kind of grown up a bit. And I said, well, first of all, you are. It was a really interesting company, TBWA. There was a Greek-American Bill Tregos, Claude Bonnage, French media slash planner, Uli Wiesendang, a Swiss creative, and Paolo Aroldi, who was an Italian count, who was an account guy who sadly died by the time I got there.

9:47But they were this kind of really interesting challenge who break away from Y &R, set up in Paris. And I said, that's in your DNA. Well, they didn't want to do that anymore. So I'm a very easygoing bloke, but for six months I was driven entirely by anger and bias. And I thought, well, you know, in a polite as possible way, I liked all of them, but I thought, fuck you. I'm going to go and do my own thing then. And had you finished the book at this point? I had finished the book at this point. You had finished the book. And to compound my misery, the global new business director said, well, not only do we not want to use this as the positioning item, we'd like you to lead a group coming up with an alternative position.

10:24Oh, no. And I just thought that really is salt in the wound, frankly. No, I'm bloody not going to do that. Your idea is not quite good enough, Adam. We want you to try again. Exactly. Come on, another one. But it got even worse after that, in the spirit of unsensitcy, because the agency went through a number of changes and my boss left and various other bosses came in. And one of them, an Englishman, when I left the company said, well, I'd like to take the book with me because, you know, I know theoretically it belongs to the agency. I've done all the writing of it. I spent a lot of my life and my evenings and my weekends writing it.

10:59And he said, well, I'll let you take it with you. But if it's a success, we want it back again. I thought, under what circumstances does that make any sense at all? Oh, that's classic big business thinking about it. It was weird. We'll have you one way or the other. That wasn't Jean-Marie Druid, who was lovely, who was absolutely brilliant about it. It was somebody else. But anyway, that's a different story. It's interesting that I wonder how often those personal circumstances, you know, in terms of, you know, things go wrong in a big company actually are the springboard for successful businesses.

11:28Because actually, if you were comfortable in TVWA and doing very well, you might never have had that push that those circumstances actually kind of led to. So in a weird sense, maybe you've got them to thank for kind of getting you over the line. I agree. It was a beautiful constraint. And actually, there's an interesting guy called Matthew Wilcox in the States who specializes in kind of behavioral science. He's an ex-planner from FCB. And he talks a lot about the power of unfairness and a sense of unfairness and how for a lot of challenger brands, actually what they are able to successfully mine is a sense of unfairness.

12:00You've been treated badly. either. And I think I had a sense of I haven't been treated fairly in this process. And it motivated me to stop being a rather complacent senior planner and become a reluctant entrepreneur. Brilliant. So let's get to the book then. So I think you told me you're quite surprised at how well and how quickly the book succeeded. So tell me about that. Yeah, well, it was a slow cooked book. I mean, I had taken, you know, essentially, it was everything I'd learned in the previous 17 years of my advertising career, learning from some brilliant people and some brilliant agencies.

12:32And really, it was just a stitching together of other people's stuff in the interview. So to be honest, there's not a lot of original Adam in there. It's kind of the putting it together. It's the kind of composite that was the interesting thing. But it kind of took off really quickly, much to my surprise, not because I think the publisher put a lot of effort behind it, but just because it touched a nerve. Most of the other books were written at the time about leadership, about GE and Coke. It's hard to believe now, but they were. And it just touched a nerve. And so I had this kind of glorious moment for about two or three months where I watched it rise through kind of Amazon book charts.

13:03And it kind of broke into the top 1 ,000. I thought, that's great. And then it got up to 400. I thought, wow, I'll start watching it a bit more regularly. And it got up to 200, then broke the 100 barrier. There was one fantastic morning when it was number 80 in all books, rather than business books. And Bill Gates' new book was at number 82. And I thought, this is fantastic. And I went home that evening. I was commuting to Wandsworth. and it was on sale in Victoria, WH Smiths for about four days. Well, either somebody bought it or they discontinued. But anyway, so that was the highlight of my life.

13:33It's all been downhill from there, really, if I'm honest. It was great. It was great. That's brilliant. And I have to say, it's probably one of the books that's influenced my career more than any other book. I just think the whole, what you created was a whole kind of movement of challenger thinking that a lot of brands have taken inspiration from. And I think it's one of the most important books in marketing. So definitely big plug for the book. If you're listening, make sure you buy it. So just for people listening, just summarise what are the basic kind of concepts of a challenger brand and how do challenger brands become successful?

14:09So what I was trying to do in that first book, Eating the Big Fish, was essentially say, I'd come out of advertising. I was pitching in what were effectively challenger agencies, We didn't call ourselves that for big new bits of business. And what you tried to say in that situation, of course, is that actually it's all in the comms. You know, kind of whatever situation you bring us, we can do a bit of comms that reframes the situation or reframes the competition or reframes your assets in some kind of way and changes the conversation in your favor. And although changing the conversation in your favour at some level, of course, is at the heart of any challenger strategy, it was quite clear that there were a broader array of things other than comms alone that people had done.

14:51So I wanted to look at how people had kind of broken with the immediate past, for instance, how they'd said, okay, well, look, I know that behaving like this has got us here, but actually what is it that we need to stop in terms of behaviours and ways of thinking about ourselves and about our product and indeed how we define our market? So the first book talks a lot about that, and I introduced the idea of intelligent naivety, that actually quite a lot of the people who've really made waves in the categories around us don't come from the categories themselves. They come from very different kinds of categories, and that gives them a fresh perspective.

15:22And then a sense, I think, and again, it's become a very common idea now, but that sense of having a kind of belief-centered point of view about what you stood for and offering a point of view and a perspective on the world quite sort of insistently and quite sharply that you stuck to and built sort of thought leadership positions around, really. You accepted you were never going to be the market leader, usually. But you could put ideas out that were very consistent with your kind of point of view that broke with the codes of the category and created some kind of sense of momentum, and particularly kind of a social salience that kind of created kind of a talkability and a noise.

15:57And then, of course, some very practical things about making choices, you know, radical sacrifice and overcommitment. And of all of those things, actually, people in the work that we do sign up very quickly and easily for all the first few because they seem very obvious the hardest is making those choices. I have to say, in fact, that's been my experience trying to put some of your principles in the book to use, particularly when I was at BritBic doing this. The overcommitment was by far and away. I mean, we used to call it being obsessed with execution. And you have to go so much further than you think you have to go in order to create the change you want to see.

16:32because I guess we kind of assume, oh, everyone's going to be talking about our new brands. And of course, they're not. And actually, it's probably the single mantra that we live with as a team was kind of being obsessed with execution. Doing the bits before, obviously, to make sure that you've got your identity sorted and you know what you're challenging and so on. But the execution is so important. Yes, well, and the other point that you mentioned there, which is you have to go further than you think you need to go. There's a sort of dotted line in terms of execution that we think is going to be enough.

17:02And actually it's that plus 20 % or 30 % or 40 % and being confident enough to push across that. Yeah. And it's interesting, your idea of lighthouse identity, that's the other thing. Of course, purpose is so popular now, isn't it? But actually you were pointing out the importance of lighthouse identity that radiates to other people what you stand for. And I think it is always rooted in something that's true about your brand and what you're trying to fix in the world. And I think that's where I think purpose has gotten stuck recently, is that people kind of add purpose on to their brand. They kind of draw something that's in culture they think is a good thing to do and they try and do it authentically.

17:36Of course, they don't because it's not rooted in the product. Whereas I think light out of identity is a far more authentic way to say, you know, so you take Tony's Chocolonely, isn't it? Great example. We care about slave-free chocolate because if you go through the supply chain of where Coco comes from, there's a lot of kids being employed below wage and all that sort of thing. We want to fix it. It's authentic and therefore they're, you know, they're kind of projecting identity based on that. It was founded by a journalist who wrote a story on it and was horrified by it. So there's a personal truth to them.

18:04Yeah. So when you scratch the surface, you go, wow. And I mean, it's one of my favourite challenger brands at the moment because they've completely reframed. I mean, I went to a trade show the other day, actually. There are 196 kind of brands that, you know, all displaying. And most of them were new startups. And I started at Tony's stand. And of course, they talked to me about, you know, slave-free chocolate and this kind of thing. And there were loads of chocolate brands. And I went to every single other one and said, are you slave-free? and it was i just got this kind of slightly awkward kind of response well it depends what you mean by slavery all this kind of thing um but in one move they've suddenly identified a truth about their category and they've just flipped the entire conversation to make every other chocolate look unethical and i i just you know as a lover of chocolate myself i just think i'm now a super convert super convert at tony's um but i just think they're a brilliant example of where they've lived those values extremely well.

18:57I think that is a great example because I mean I think sometimes you know you sit down with people and people say well you know we vastly overestimate the amount of time and attention that people give to brands they just don't think about brands that much which is of course true they then go into well you know can you really change the conversation in their favor because people aren't really talking about brands in that way but your point is absolutely right which is that's a very simple frame of reference are you slave free or not this is the new criteria for chocolate I'm making and of course actually it does that's why they're number one in Holland now.

19:24That's why Albert Heine has changed its whole supply chain policy around chocolate for all its brands, not just because they've changed the conversation. It then becomes a category entry point, and suddenly you've kind of taken your competition out. The other thing they do absolutely brilliantly, which is another point I know you make in the book, is use of house media. So if anyone's not had a Tony's Chocolate only in this thing, go and get one. Because when you take the wrapper off, the chunks are all uneven. So they're making a point, and of course that costs them nothing to the machine that goes down the line that does it.

19:54So whereas every other chocolate has uniform chunks, all their chunks are uneven to make a point about the abuse of the supply chain and inequality that exists. And one of the things I love about that is they get a lot of complaints about it. Oh, do they? Oh, I didn't know that. They get a lot of mums, for instance, writing and saying, look, this is really inconvenient. My children fight about it all the time because they never get equal sizes. at least if you're getting the Cadbury's thing. You could say, well, you get two chunks. They're all the same as my two chunks. You know what it's like with kids.

20:22They've got to be exactly the same. So there's huge fights. And they always very patiently write back and say, I'm sorry, we can't do that because this is what it represents. So, of course, they then tell the story, and then they tell the family the story, and then the kids become advocates of it. It's just a fantastic example. That is absolutely brilliant. And it's also a nice example, isn't it, in the world that shift towards efficiency, and efficiency is good. That's an inefficient thing. It's a little bit of grit that creates conversation and a little bit of trouble that actually helps promote what the brand is all about.

20:51Yeah, and I think what's brilliant is that they haven't had a big advertising budget. So it's not as if they're plastered on outdoor posters or they're running a TV ad. They've managed to achieve everything they've done through word of mouth, having a great product, taking the grit, as you say, and making their product media itself, and so on. So I think they're definitely one of my favorite examples today of a challenger brand. um so let's let's just talk quickly about um so you you're in tvwa you moved over here and you set up the consultancy so now i mean imagine a lot of people have wanted to do something like that i know i have you know you think oh wouldn't it be great you know to set up my own business and and start a consultancy um just tell me how what that experience was like in the first year and what did you learn from the experience of setting up uh eat big fish so i was clear about two or three things.

21:41So obviously, I had a book. So I was clear that I wanted to prove there was something in this challenger thought. And so the challenger brands are kind of fairly ubiquitous in marketing, but nobody was talking about them then. The book kind of popularized it. And as I say, it wasn't even my phrase. It was a friend's phrase, but it wasn't used in the end by TBWA. So I thought, okay, well, I'll take this and run with it. So I knew I wanted to talk about that. I'd written a workshop framework in the back end of the book because a friend called Matt had suggested that might make the book more usable.

22:06So I had to think about, well, what have I got for a consultancy. Well, I've got this workshop framework in the back of the book. So I'll try doing workshops around the book. And then I knew that I wanted to be international because I'd lived and worked in Los Angeles and loved the States and loved, you know, being international when I was in Europe. And so I had a friend, Mark in San Francisco, friend Rob in Madrid and friend Peter over here, Peter Field, who, and together with Teresa, there were four of us who started it. So we had Eat Big Fish, London, San Francisco, Madrid. So we had this kind of illusion of this huge international.

22:38You were multinational from the beginning. And then I had some friends who were kind enough to say, I'll introduce you to a client. The very first project was a friend who was a client. In fact, Matt, the guy who suggested the workshop idea, said, come along and do one of your workshops for me on Ragu pasta sauce. That was the very first workshop we ever did in New York. And then you're kind of on a roll. So we then did a project for Huggies that went really well through a friend at Ogilvy. And I relied on the kindness of strangers and friends, actually, for the first year or so. And then you start to get some case history.

23:12Then I did a lucky thing, which is the publisher had got us onto Channel 4 Business Live, Channel 4, Channel 5, Channel 4, Channel 5, Channel 4 Business Live, I think. No, sorry, it was Sky Business Live. So I did this live interview, which I don't know if you've done live interviews on TV. It's absolutely terrifying. And fortunately, somebody, a marketing director was uh of a i had i knew vaguely but hadn't met properly for a long time was on a treadmill watching it in the gym and said what he's talking about this challenger thing we should come and do it on my brand um and so i then just got lucky and started picking up new bits of business and off we went really and um and it's that was 20 years ago you say you got lucky but i i because i've been accused of luck a couple of times in my career and i always think but you have to put yourself in the way of getting all the old gary player you know the harder i try the luckier i get sort of thing you have to put yourself in you know in line to get lucky i think with these things so i do i i by and large i agree with that um i do agree with that although funnily enough i was sitting next to a bloke um at dinner the other day uh who worked for a company um that was founded by a man called mark anthony who set up mike's hard lemonade and if you know mike's hard lemonade and he was saying that in the early days mike's hard lemonade was imitated very quickly by one of the other big distillers who introduced something like Joe's Hard Lemonade.

Read the full transcript

24:30And so the founder, Mark Antony, wanted to get a meeting with a high-powered lawyer in New York who would defend the case and got a meeting surprisingly easily and quickly. And it turned out that the lawyer took the meeting because he thought he was Mark Antony the singer. Oh, really? He'd just made a mistake. So I think that was genuine luck, actually, at that point. But by and large, I love those stories. So I'd like to move on, if I can, to what I consider actually to be your best book, which I know is also the one that maybe hasn't sold as well. Let's get to this. I was working at BritVic, obviously, a relatively large organisation connected to PepsiCo.

25:10And I wanted to bring some of the Eat Big Fish ethos to it. I was creating a new team called Sea Brands that basically kind of took the challenger brands in the portfolio and managed them slightly separately. And I discovered your book. I think you'd recently written it called The Pirate Inside. And it was fascinating because for many people, and maybe many people listening to this, they're working in big organizations. They want to be an innovator or an entrepreneur, and they buy into the challenger brand approach. But they just don't know how to do it in the context of big organization. And I found your book very, very useful, particularly at that point in my career.

25:47So tell me about how you ended up writing that book and how that's worked. Well, so that was the difficult second album, really. So I'd had this big success with the first book and translated into eight languages and that kind of stuff. And so I wanted to write a second book because the question I got asked most often about challenges was, look, I understand how it works if you are the owner driver of your own company, if you are the founder of Innocent or the founder of Method, all that kind of stuff. But how does it work if, you know, like I'm in your situation, I'm a middle level, senior level manager in a matrix driven organization.

26:20I don't own it yet. How do I make stuff happen here without getting fired? And so my original title for the book actually was How to Be a Pirate in the Navy Without Getting Hanged. And the publisher, which I still think is a better title, but the publisher persuaded me to change it to a smaller one. And I thought it was going to be a really big and valuable book because I had a lot of – it was very personal. You know, it's a lot of very personal stories, so it's quite uncensored. I tried to get people to talk about what it was like, about the bleak moments, you know, particularly in that difficult first year when you've put a challenger stake in the ground.

26:53Everybody is standing around you with crossed arms looking to see whether it's going to work. You're aware there's a lot of back chat going on in corridors. You're not hearing about that. and it's quite a lonely place to stand as you'll know you know um and i wanted to capture a lot of that and i'd also um one of the questions i i had been asked about the first book was give us an examples of of learning from failure and i hadn't really learned enough from i hadn't looked and studied failure enough in challenges so i deliberately looked at a number of brands that have failed to be successfully or people teams that be pirates inside but nevertheless i thought it was interesting i mean there are some flaws in the book there are way too many analogies for instance uh for one book to withstand um but um i think it it does there it's interesting i do get people like yourself sometimes to say that is that is the favorite book because it spoke to them in some kind of way they identify that's exactly what my experience was because i i genuinely for the first time in my career felt quite lonely because i'd gone to the um i'd gone to the board of britwick and said i've got this great idea you know we'll create a separate business unit.

27:56We'll put together the brands that we want to challenge in the marketplace. So we run our own kind of separate sales and marketing and merchandising unit. And I suddenly realized that there was no one who could give me advice in the organization. There's no one that had done this before. And I was kind of middle management level. And so I didn't have a peer group. So I was kind of running a bit on my own. I mean, I was kind of attached to marketing, I guess, in my peer group. But they were doing some very different things you know big advertising campaigns and big bits of mpd and that sort of thing and i um there were loads of things i mean i represented maybe three percent of the portfolio so you know loads of people would say yeah you know this is just a fad it won't last and you're only three percent you know you see you don't really matter to our kind of future success um and you got lucky i mean that was something that i got told yeah you're just lucky you know just you happen to hit on a an idea at the right kind of moment in time and generally i felt i did feel quite lonely um I'm a little bit scared because I'd kind of promised to break even in the first year.

28:55And I got there with about a week to go and about£50 ,000 to spare. But it was the hardest ever work to my life kind of thing. And then I read your book. And your book was like great comfort to know that actually lots of other people have faced that. But I learned through their experience in a really powerful way. So it kind of, I guess, intellectually, Big Fish was more powerful. But emotionally, I'd say Pirate Inside just hit at the right. So it might have been circumstance timing. I don't know. But so I'd love you to relaunch it at some point. I think there's a lot of mileage in there. So it's a tremendous.

29:28Well, we should maybe at the end of the podcast talk briefly about our Challenge 30 idea as a kind of, you know, bridge to overcome that. Because it still persists and there's no reason why people should feel as isolated as they do with that situation. But the thing is, in big companies, the incentive is for everyone to act in a certain way and to believe the same things and to work in the same process. And most big organizations are quite political. So there is a kind of unsaid pressure to go in a certain direction. And as soon as you break out of that, it's very scary. So some people – I mean, I remember, for example, I advertised in BritVic for people to come and join me.

30:09and I got loads of people phone me up and they said the same thing we'd like to come and work for you john but not yet career career limiting i know i know because because the you know the back chat was hospital pass you know you'll be out of a job in six months it was seen as a risk and most people are actually if you scratch on the surface they're risk averse and i'm the opposite of that i mean i i you know i'd far rather die trying than never try sort of thing and that's what i found was so interesting about the the culture of britwick is the amount of people that were kind of quietly saying they supported me but publicly wouldn't you know until after the first year you know we we delivered our target we were still there you know we'd grown the brands by 30 you know turnover by 30 after the first year and then and then everyone wanted to join you know sort of thing but yeah but one of the reasons it is tiring doing what you did is because the level of internal marketing you need again is 20 30 40 more than you think it's going to need to be So you're doing this external stuff where you're going even further and then constantly internally managing the message and communication.

31:14Huge, huge. I mean, in the Britvik example, I had probably three different very senior stakeholders. I had obviously the Britvik side, I had the PepsiCo side, but I also had because I was managing Lipton, which was a joint venture between Unilever and PepsiCo, another kind of senior stakeholder there. So I kind of described it to my team as air cover, right? So my job was to buy them the freedom to be able to do what they needed to do. And some of them were quite shocked at the lengths I had to go to, to keep everybody supportive and justify that, you know, because I think the perception was, because they saw, I think, you know, I had maybe about 40 people in total, if you include the people on the ground going into shops and kind of selling at ground level.

31:55And people go, that's a ridiculous amount of overhead. and so i had to go and do the sums to say as a percentage if you take our total overhead as a percentage my overhead was exactly the same as a percentage of total company but because it was housed together it was quite visible you know so you know i had to do all this kind of justification and so on so what i found tough was managing all of that while then allowing the team to go and do the great work and make it happen so i you know learned a huge amount so definitely that'd be great i think the um the challenge of 30 idea is is brilliant all right well let's come back to Let's do that.

32:28We'll do that. Okay, so that was Pyro Insight. And then let's bring us up to your most recent book, A Beautiful Constraint. So tell me, what was the inspiration for this book? Well, so I'd always wanted to do kind of three different books about challenges, I suppose. And the idea would be that the first one was about strategy. So sort of loosely kind of, you know, the first book looked at kind of what's the strategic operating system. And of course, the first book touches on culture as well as strategy, but primarily is about strategy. The second book was about culture. So the third one was, I thought, going to be about innovation.

33:03And I was due to write it in 2008. And just before I sat, I kind of set aside the time to write it and started writing it. And in fact, it was called something different. that point. It was called Stubborn Magic. I was just interested in, because your point about kind of tenacity and resilience, I suppose, in making new things happen in organizations was something I wanted to kind of celebrate and talk more about. And then as I was about to sit down and write it, my editor rang up and said, look, you know, Eating the Big Fish is now 10 years old. One or two things have happened in the marketing world you might have noticed since then.

33:33And the world generally since then, you need to write it again or rewrite it. Otherwise, we're going to discontinue it. So I thought, okay, no, this is really important for my business. So I chose that time to rewrite it. So by the time I got to writing A Beautiful Constraint, which was six years later, the world was full of innovation books. And I suddenly thought, I don't want to just write another innovation book. What's the thing about challenges in innovation? And of course, the striking thing about challenges in innovation is they don't really have an innovation department. They don't have an R &D department.

33:59Very often, in fact, they're having to be highly innovative in everything that they do in spite of constraints. And so I was struck by this. And then I kind of came across two or three things in culture, including I went to see Tom Ford speak and got a chance to talk to him about how he did catwalk shows. And he said this incredible thing. I asked him, I said that I'd heard that he described his catwalk shows as filmic and what did he learn from the world of fashion that he applied to business and what he learned from business that he applied to fashion. and he said you know what you have to understand he said is that a catwalk show is 13 minutes long and he repeated it 13 minutes he didn't say roughly quarter of an hour or you know not a lot of times 13 minutes and he said so in that time you've got to convince this very cynical audience that yours is the most exciting fashion vision that they've seen in Milan or New York or Beijing or Rotterdam or wherever you happen to be and then he talked about what he did But he said, he made this really interesting thing.

35:02He said, so what I try to do in that 13 minutes is I try to get all the audience breathing in and out at the same time. He said, my ambition by the time the last model leaves the stage is to make the entire audience exhale as one. And so I was struck by this because clearly he had this ferocious constraint of seen it all audience, 13 minutes. and the natural temptation in that is to kind of reduce the level of ambition. How much can you really do, frankly? And he doesn't. He does the opposite. He raises the ambition to this almost ludicrous extent and that's what gives him the fireworks and the theatre of what he does.

35:39And then I became interested in, this is really what challengers are doing, isn't it? They're not being victims to a constraint. Instead, it's the level of ambition they are attaching to what they want to do, juxtaposed, interjoined with that constraint that actually makes it that powerful stimulus to an entirely fresh way of seeing the world. And surely this is something that is important for challenges, but actually important for us as human beings more generally. So I've got twin boys, they're 24, and they're going out in the world, which has a whole level of constraint on it now that I didn't have when I started out.

36:12And how they, at some level, in business, in personal lives, as global citizens of a planet in environmental crisis, How they learn how to live with constraints, make constraints, stimulus for better is going to define their health and happiness in all those three arenas. So it felt like to me and my co-author, Mark, a genuinely important subject to tackle. Not that they are not all important, but genuinely important subject to tackle. And so there was a new level of kind of personal impetus around it for me. I think that's amazing. I've noticed actually in my career the amount of times people have come to me when I've had teams working for me and they've said, oh if only we had 10 million pounds and and you know sometimes they've been managers of multi million pounds you know campaign budgets and i've just said you've got way more resources than you than you actually need and actually if i look back at my own experience the the the you know the the work that i'm most proud of has always been the things that i've done without any money you know with the i mean on juice burst when i was doing uh when i was doing that came up with the the world's first augmented reality soft drink brand sort of thing.

37:20And that was driven out of constraint because I had no marketing budget. And I thought, well, I'm going to have to break a record. You know, I'm going to have to do something newsworthy to get there. So I partnered with Blippa, that was a startup at the time, and worked together to create an augmented reality soft drink, which, you know, the world had never seen before sort of thing. That was great because, and that gave me an edge when I went to customers and said, well, I'm going to bring you a world first. And that opened doors that, you know, hadn't been open to me before and so on. And I think I got something like 300 ,000 different people interacting with the brand a year in compared to when we started.

37:59And, you know, that would have been impossible if I put that, you know, well, I didn't have much money. But, you know, if I tried a Facebook campaign, I would have gotten nowhere. But I had to genuinely do something that hadn't been done before. and but i would never have thought of that if i because if i'd had a if i'd let's say i had a 10 million pound budget i'd have sat there as most people do and go well what did i do last year what am i going to do this year let's do something similar so we'd divide it up and that goes above the line that goes below the line and and so on and you get lazy and you tend to do the same thing you've always done whereas i think what introduce a constraint and suddenly you have to change your thinking and it propels you doesn't it it just propels you in a direction that you haven't gone him before.

38:37Well, I agree. And there's an interesting tension here, isn't there? Because on the one hand, you know, what we know from Ehrenberg Bass is there's a certain kind of power of scale and you need a certain level of resource to buy a certain level of share and all that. On the other hand, you and I would both say resource can be a curse because it limits that. And I'm very fond of that concept in economics of the resource curse that, you know, what theoretically should be an advantage, being rich in a certain area of natural resource, actually is a disadvantage. And other economies that aren't rich in those resources tend to do better than, with the exception of Norway, tend to do better than you.

39:11And I wonder, I kind of, I'm working on this thing a little bit about, so what are the great kind of curses of the modern marketing world? You know, so one might be resource, one might be efficiency. You know, because we can buy it cheaper and more efficiently, we do. That's not the same as effectiveness, kind of famously. So it'd be interesting to kind of identify and codify what those are and the biases that they create that are actually unhelpful. weirdly i think data is actually a curse so i was at can this year and um i sat in a a whole afternoon of talks aimed at cmos and um every single one was was about data and ai and and one lady gave this example of a cmo that got fired because she didn't have the data from the day before now if ever there was a role on a board right where you're supposed to be looking at the long term and how your brand's doing it's got to be the cmo and if the cmo is going to get fired because they hadn't got yesterday's data i'm sure there's more to it than that but it just was symbolic of how we've become so you know enslaved to the data and what's happening today in short term that we're missing the whole big picture and we're just not connecting the dots or doing the right thing for long term so that as a topic i think would be a great one to come back to well and interestingly so so i i'm doing this kind of project at the moment on uh reviewing 20 years of challenger brands it's been 20 years since the book came out and i'm interviewing various people about kind of what's changed and one of the things that has changed if you talk to people so i went off to interview vanilla jackson at hall and partners and they are a big kind of insight uh driven kind of um data and planning company but they have got data on 400 brands in 40 different countries, effectively, 400 clients in 40 different countries.

40:56So, I imagine, I don't know, we've got 400 ,000 bits of data points on that. And she says one of the things she noticed has changed is that the focus on data has led to a decline in creativity, which is exactly your point, really. So, there's a kind of macro picture that confirms your theory. Yeah. And we've become very, I mean, as the book describes it, very kind of left-brained and analytical and rational and we've lost actually what what drives our behavior is emotions how we feel about brands and i think that's what challenger brands do very well is they create feeling about because they they ask you to join the movement you know they create movements there that they're trying to change you know something wrong in the world and make it right again like the tony's example and that creates an emotional connection people people want then to engage with the brand in a way that if you're just given kind of 15 rational messages about why this shampoo works better is far less effective.

41:50So I think there's a general trend in marketing. I think we've got to address the efficiency over effectiveness debate that's been happening. So that's definitely one for another podcast. I think we'll come back to that one. Okay. I hope you're enjoying this episode Reloaded with Adam Morgan. Just quickly to tell you about the next episode that's coming next week with Les Burnett and Sarah Carter, two of the most popular guests I've ever had on the show. We caught up very recently to discuss all the big trends in 2023 and what's going to be happening in 2024 so to get you inspired to get you motivated about this year please do check back in next wednesday 6 a.m where this episode will go live now back to the conversation so listen i've got a little challenge for you so um imagine you are launching a new podcast let's pick an example right it's for a friend this is for a friend for a friend right so yeah i have a friend and he's launching a podcast and he's an ambitious chap and he wants to make his podcast the number one i don't know whether okay maybe the number one business podcast right so let's let's not go too wild i'm not taking on joe rogan here but let's say i want to create the world's number one business podcast right i have no budget whatsoever.

43:06Tell me how I go about doing that. So, all right, well, let's take, there's a section of a beautiful constraint that looks at how ambitious marketers without a significant marketing budget can break through, John. Very good. I knew I came to the right place. So it's called the Fertile Zero. So I'm really interested in how zero can be fertile, how a lack of, to pick up on our previous conversation, a lack of resource can be fertile for us. and so there are kind of I think four or five things to think about and I haven't played them out for you but let's have a look at them so one of them is if you don't have a lot of money you've got to be dramatic you've got to be dramatic so drama is kind of one of the great unsung currencies of our times it's not simply that we sit and watch drama in the evening but we it's kind of it's the in a world of continuous partial attention where we're constantly half looking at other stuff if you do something dramatic it commands my attention it creates an emotional reaction to your point it creates a memory it's more like i'm more likely to mention it to somebody else so you know let's take your your previous experience you're very good at setting world records so maybe there's some dramatic way your podcast is set a kind of world record um so something like that um secondly i think you know um and it's closely related to drama it's not exactly the same i think surprise i think being surprising if each podcast had a surprise of some kind a surprise perhaps about the person you're interviewing or a surprise about yourself oh you give me an idea or a series of surprises yeah okay about yourself the more podcasts you listen to about john the further you get into the yeah yeah what you never knew when he was 19 and you know disappeared for three months here's what happened yeah i don't know um third of course collaborate so collaboration so so collaboration is a big thing in fashion and music and youtubing but not so much in conventional marketing mysteriously uh and yet if you talk to an A &R director in the music world.

44:59They say, you can't break an artist without collaboration. So if you regard yourself as, I'm breaking a podcast, you would collaborate. You would get on other people's podcasts. You'd do joint podcasts with them. You'd invite them to come and do just a guest piece for you in the equivalent. Rappers have guest verses that they do for other people. So you do a lot of that stuff because you'd be trying to get to each other's audience bases and fan bases. And those might not be predictable ones. They might not be marketers. You might be deliberately trying to get to a different, you know, you do one with an innovation, with an innovation podcast or a cultural podcast or something like that, you know, do that kind of thing.

45:31So use other people's resources, adjacent abundance. I suppose the fourth, and I don't know how this would work for you, but the idea of making your secondary medium your primary medium. So what are the assets that you have, the little things that are kind of just good practice in a podcast, you know, maybe you're opening a piece of music, you know, other things that you do, your intro, your outro, how do you make them your primary medium, effectively, the thing that people pop for. The podcast is kind of interesting, but I just love the way. Well, so crudely, I came late to Game of Thrones. My wife said she would never watch anything with dragons in it.

46:12Did it have dragons in it? And I had to confess it did have dragons in it. And that was a restriction to us watching. But anyway, finally, this year, she said, okay, let's go for it. Clearly, we've got to watch it. So we watched it under the kind of tuition of one of my boys, a 25-year-old. And one of the things he pointed out was, as you probably know, is obviously the opening credits change every time. So it's a really interesting example of something that's just dull and repetitive in every other thing. That's true. It becomes a really interesting part of the narrative, actually. And you don't fast forward through them.

46:40You sit and look at them, and they become part of the richness and the detailing of the entire thing. So anyway, so make your secondary assets your primary assets. And the fifth, I think, obviously, is being interesting on the inside. So there is so much that is talked about in the world of marketing. Your whole notion, as I understand it, in terms of being uncensored, is kind of getting to the heart of it, stuff that isn't talked about. That should inherently be the most interesting topic in the world, isn't it? So making sure you prod and poke at your interviewees and indeed yourself to get to those naked revelations, I thought would be okay.

47:09Well, that's exactly it. I mean, certainly if I look at the podcasts that I listen to regularly, they're the ones that go behind the scenes, that kind of reveal the person behind, you know. I mean, I love Diary of the CEO, for example, with Stephen Bartlett. And what's fascinating about him, hugely successful at a young age. But when I listen to him, he's talking about his regrets. He's talking about his failures or he's talking about things he's learned. He's very humble when he talks. And I find that fascinating to kind of meet the person behind the bit. And I think that's what podcasting allows you to do.

47:40And certainly, you know, my desire in setting this up was that if all you read about a brand or a person is what is in the press, you're going to get a very airbrushed view or a very censored view of what they really think. And actually I think the value for us as marketeers is to really get insight into the person or into the subject matter. And that means asking some tough questions. May not be popular questions but they'll get to the truth. And so that's kind of the mission I'm on is to try and uncover the truth particularly with CMOs because CMOs there are very few interviews with CMOs and they don't really say very much because they're being controlled by their PR agency to make sure, well, don't mention this and don't mention that.

48:19Yeah, you can't be honest at the time, can you? You can't. And I remember, strangely, I was at Cannes this year being interviewed by CNBC about what I thought of Cannes and, you know, the pros and cons and, you know, all this sort of thing. And afterwards, the guy interviewing me said, wow, you're the first CMO I've met that's actually given an opinion. And he spent, like, literally three days trying to get a CMO to say what they really thought about, you know, Cambridge Analytica or whatever the thing was at the time, you know. and uh it was him saying that to me just got this whole idea started i thought oh that's interesting because i know i love to you know i'm probably a bit too honest on occasions but but i you know i just that's what i love i love kind of understanding people and and things and how it works and and there's so much nonsense out there that you know i'm on a mission to kind of you know destroy that and uh get to the heart of what matters so well and and there's such an appetite for it and a thirst for it in the world isn't there i mean i hope so yeah i i if i look at my own experience and I look at what I see succeeding at the moment, it is authenticity.

49:20And everything is so polished and managed and, you know, censored that I think we're in a moment in this world where we've got to have some honest conversations and not be afraid to speak our minds, you know. Not like being political, but I mean, just, you know. Well, that's true. And I think it's everywhere, isn't it? You know, one of the frustrations about watching football these days is, you know, they all come off the pitch and they interview this person who's just, you know, pushed three past the top class team. And how was it? Well, the most important thing is three points and the lads did well.

49:47Just for God's sake. You know that. You know, you must be on cloud nine. Just tell us how you're feeling. Yes, exactly. People are dying for that kind of thing. And I think that's partly why podcasting exists is because it's a vent for all that. Finally, I know what they really think. I agree. Unpolished, gnarly. Exactly. The gnarly John Evans podcast. Well, there you go. That was your alternative concept, I would imagine. Indeed. Yeah, we did play with a few, naked and uncovered and so on. Naked and gnarly would be also good. Yes, exactly. I was worried about following through on the naked one, though, in terms of level of overcommitment.

50:18Nobody will ever know. That's true, actually. Here I am, John Evans, completely naked again. There is no YouTube version, unfortunately, and there never will be. Actually, who knew? I might be sat here naked anyway. Well. There's a thought that no one wanted to have, isn't there? There you go. So anyway, we'll stick with the previous one. Listen, let's wrap it up with a – you gave me a thought, actually, as you're talking about a surprise. in terms of a question that I could ask everyone this, actually. So here it is. Tell me something or tell me a story that you've never, ever told anyone else.

50:54Yes. Okay. So this was early days. I had – it was the first year of the company. So this is 1999. It was quite a big project. It was – turned out it was a very political project, and the person who had hired us, who I had a lot of respect for, very smart person also had a kind of nemesis in the room as well and had operator them the view you know keep your enemies closer kind of thing and so they were you know the tiger was in the tent with us in the workshop and the first morning of the workshop this nemesis decided to play their cards quite early and really bounced me around as i was doing the upfront stuff and caught me out on a couple of stuff that i was trying to kind of just kind of bullshit my way through and there an awkward moment in it and and i kind of conceded that i perhaps had been bullshitting a little bit at that point i didn't know enough about that particular case as much as i i thought i did and and and the break came and i went into the into the gents and i found myself dry retching in the toilet i was i was so i just i've never happened to me before or since um and what i learned from that experience, John, was don't ever let yourself get blindsided by political situations.

52:06So I'm really careful about doing due diligence and stakeholder interviews now, really flush out what the tank traps and the unpleasantness might be in advance, really know my stuff, really encourage my lot to know my stuff and have a kind of strict no bullshit policy. Because it's quite easy, you know, you're working hard, you're working at pace, just take one of those kind of searing experiences to really knock you sideways. ways and actually you know i i had a product that i was very confident in the rest of the time the rest thing went really well but if you're relatively new and starting out in my line of work or indeed in my in our company that could really could really mess you up so um that was a very formative and useful experience for me that's very very good advice and i think particularly in large organizations where you just don't know the politics and and well you know that you know there's going to be politics yeah you don't know where they are exactly so you just have to try and make sure you're not blindsided.

52:56And I think that level of preparation. I know one thing I've definitely learned through my careers is how the meeting is never actually the meeting. I mean, this is something that it took. I was way late to the party on this, actually. I have to say, I'd have been far further on in my career if I'd learned this early. But you kind of go to the meetings, yeah, we're going to have an open, honest conversation. We're going to debate this topic, and we'll come to a resolution. And then you sit there and you go, ah, okay. So we're pretending to have a conversation because the boss has decided we're going to do it in this direction.

53:24And the job for me now is basically to fall in line and say, yes, why didn't I think of that? I remember watching the first season of House of Cards a few years ago. Have you seen House of Cards? I have, yes. Brilliant. It's that great moment in the first season where Kevin Spacey is having a meeting with the then president. And he turns around and he kind of breaks the fourth wall and he turns around to Cameron and he says, this is the real meeting. Ever since then, I keep thinking, am I in the meeting? I'm reasonably sure now I'm in the meeting. I think this is the real podcast. No, no, no. I'm recording it separately down the road.

53:57But there's this phrase that used to really piss me off, which is like alignment. That what you had to do was you had to go and meet everybody who was influential in a decision, pre-align them. And then when you got to the meeting, all the positions had been played out. And basically, it was this sort of like pretend meeting, you know, where the outcome, I mean, the Japanese apparently are masters at this. So it's common in Japan to fall asleep in a meeting because they all know this. And they go, well, we recognize nothing's going on, so I'm going to have a couple of hours' kip and catch up, which I respect for being so honest.

54:29But anyway, that's certainly something I wish I'd learned much earlier in my career. I've been far, far ahead. Adam, it's been an absolute blast. Thank you for sharing those stories. And I've learned a huge amount. Just give me a quick shout out for your social media channels, your business. Where can people find you if they want to get you? Oh, fantastic. Well, so the Challenger Project is the way that we share all our information, thechallengerproject.com. If you go onto that, you can get all the latest kind of research that's going on. And there's a fabulous newsletter, which you can sign up for, that costs you nothing, but it's full of richness and nutrition.

55:07My company is called Eat Big Fish. And we're essentially based in the US and the UK. though most of our business is kind of US or continental Europe at the moment. And I'm on adam at eatbigfish.com. Brilliant. Get in touch. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Cheers. Okay. Ladies and gentlemen, I hope you liked that reloaded version of Uncensored CMO, bringing back a previous episode that you may not have heard before. I would love some feedback. If you liked that, please do drop me a note and let me know. It's funny how so many people miss out on some of the early episodes and there were really good content there that's well worth bringing back to the top of the list.

55:43If you'd like that and other episodes of Uncensored CMO, please do hit the subscribe button wherever you get your podcasts. And if you'd like to follow me, you can do. I'm John Evans on LinkedIn or over at Twitter at Uncensored CMO. Thank you for listening and watching. I'll see you next time.

From the publisher

Today I'm revisiting episode 3, with Adam Morgan, founder of eatbigfish and author of Eating The Big Fish, The Pirate Inside and A Beautiful Constraint to find out what it takes to become a successful challenger. Adam shares his tips for creating a challenger brand, transforming your culture and the power of constraints to driving innovation.


In this episode:

  • Why being No.2 is better
  • How he turned the anger of his project being shelved into a career-defining opportunity
  • Being turned down by Phil Knight and where the idea of a Challenger brand came from
  • The importance of over-commitment and being obsessed with execution
  • How Tony’s Chocolonely have become a truly challenger brand
  • How to be a pirate in the navy without getting fired
  • What you can learn from a catwalk show and how constraints can turn into your greatest advantage
  • The curse of data and how it leads us to a decline in creativity
  • The furtile zero and what to do with no budget
  • Adam shares his worst career moment
  • Why the meeting is never really the meeting and why the Japanese fall asleep in meetings
  • The one thing Adam has never told anyone before

Follow me:

Contact me:

Adam Morgan:

More from Uncensored CMO

All 210 episodes
Reloaded: How to be a successful challenger - Adam Morgan (2020)Uncensored CMO · 56 min
Listen in VO